Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
The following cars were used for a realistic simulation of the various fire
scenarios:
1-Renault 19 with opened bottom engine: this scenario was used to simulating
big cars of old models.
2- Renault 19 with closed bottom engine: this scenario was used to simulating big
cars of new models and also medium size car of old models.
3- Mitsubishi Colt with opened bottom engine: this scenario was used to
simulating small cars of old models and also medium size cars of new models.
4- Mitsubishi Colt with closed bottom engine: this scenario was used to
simulating small cars of new models.
FP Fire Protect Car Ltd
R&D
WORK CONSIDERATIONS
Further considerations were made regarding the fuel to be used for the fire tests.
Indications from various specialized sources in relation to the fuel pump, its capacity
and fuel injection with the time gave some guidelines as following:
- a leak in the pipes or joints taking the fuel to the injection unit may cause a fire in
case the fuel spreads on top of very hot engine components; the amount of fuel
necessary to ignite is quite difficult to estimate
- a leak due to a malfunctioning in the injection point, due to the high temperature
in that position, should cause a prompt ignition therefore not a large quantity of fuel
should be ejected before the fire starts
- an electrical failure may cause a warming up of the component or wire and its
ignition, without the presence of liquid fuel
an accident may cause a damage to the fuel pipes or injection device and some fuel may
leak and get ignited a few seconds after the crash; also in this case it is difficult to
estimate the amount of fuel; new models have got a system for the fire protection in case
of accidents, which consists of an electronic device which cuts off the flow of the fuel,
after a crash or impact of the vehicle
FP Fire Protect Car Ltd
R&D
WORK CONSIDERATIONS
The quantity rate at which the fuel will be lost is directly depended on the fuel pump. In
the most recent models the ECU of the engine cuts off the fuel supply from the fuel pump,
in occurrences of big pressure drop (big fuel leakage) and also a safety device is installed
into the vehicles, which cuts off the fuel supply into the engine in case of an accident. The
fuel pump deliverance quantity depends from the revolution of the engine (rpm), the
torque, temperature etc.
Taking into consideration the above factors and collecting information, we calculated that
the fuel pump could supply 0.08 ml/sec per hp. This is the figure that has been used for
our simulated fuel leakage scenario. An average engine size was estimated at 115 hp, and
the leak time before ignition 12 seconds. Thus the quantity of fuel, which will ignite is the
result of the following calculation:
0.08 x 115 x 12 = 110,4 ml.
It was decided to run various tests using different quantities of petrol, in order to
simulate more challenging fires (between 3 to 5 times the calculated quantity). Therefore
we have run tests using 300, 400 and 500 ml. of liquid fuel (petrol unleaded 95).
FP Fire Protect Car Ltd
R&D
METHODOLOGY
working package 1, a number of tests were aimed to assess the extinguishing
concentration to be used. We have defined 4 types of vehicles fire scenario, in order to
cover the widest range of cars, as following:
1- Big old models
2- Big new models, equivalent to medium old models
3- Medium new models, equivalent to small old models
4- Small new models
During some preliminary tests the fuel was ignited manually; later on an automatic
ignition system was engineered, consisting of a pyrotechnic igniter, which functioned
through an electrical current impulse supplied by a battery/ power supply unit. The
pyrotechnic igniter was placed inside the engine at direct contact with the fuel and was
actuated from the control panel, at a safe distance from the car.
FP Fire Protect Car Ltd
R&D
METHODOLOGY
working package 2, various detectors were tested as following:
- the detectors were installed inside the engine compartments
- the electronic detectors working with smoke and heat, were used in combination
(double knock mode)
- the linear heat cable was used alone
- a standard fire panel was used during this phase
- the fire was ignited, and the quantity of fuel used was always 300 ml.
- the fuel specification was the same
- the detection time in seconds was registered for each test
working package 3, various tests were run using the 3 system components interfaced, i.e.
the detection system, the control panel and the extinguishing generators. The tests
methodology applied was the same as described above and a different control panel was
tested, after it was identified from an English manufacturer. This panel has been
developed mainly for marine application and could also be used for vehicles
applications. Some modifications though are under discussion with the Manufacturer, to
suit better the purpose and to reduce its cost.
WORKING SHEET
RESULTS 1
WORKING SHEET
RESULTS 2
FP Fire Protect Car Ltd
VECHICLE CLASS TESTS FIREPRO AEROSOL GENERETORS RESULTS
FP80 FP100 FP200
4 1 1 EXTINGUISHED
2 1 1 EXTINGUISHED
1 2 EXTINGUISHED
BIG OLD MODELS 2 1 NOT EXTINGUISHEDED
1 1 NOT EXTINGUISHEDED
1 2 NOT EXTINGUISHEDED
2 2 NOT EXTINGUISHEDED
1 2 NOT EXTINGUISHEDED
1 2 NOT EXTINGUISHEDED
2 1 NOT EXTINGUISHEDED
4 2 EXTINGUISHED
2 1 1 EXTINGUISHED
1 1 NOT EXTINGUISHEDED
1 2 NOT EXTINGUISHEDED
5 2 EXTINGUISHED
3 2 EXTINGUISHED
2 1 1 EXTINGUISHED
SMALL NEW MODELS
2 1 NOT EXTINGUISHEDED
3 1 NOT EXTINGUISHEDED
3 2 NOT EXTINGUISHEDED
FP Fire Protect Car Ltd
R&D
CONCLUSIONS
Working package 1 & 3: extinguishing concentration assessment
Big old models: the results indicated that for this type of vehicle, open at the bottom, the
selection of the FirePro models should be: 1 x FP-200 and 1 x FP-100, for a total
extinguishing concentration of 300 grams.
Some tests were giving positive results with less concentration, but were not ensuring
consistent results.
Big new models & medium old models: the results indicated that for this type of vehicle,
closed at the bottom, the selection of the FirePro models should be: 2 x FP-100, for a total
extinguishing concentration of 200 grams.
Some tests were giving positive results with less concentration, but were not ensuring
consistent results.
FP Fire Protect Car Ltd
R&D
CONCLUSIONS
Working package 1 & 3: extinguishing concentration assessment
Medium new models & small old models: the results indicated that for this type of vehicle,
opened at the bottom, the selection of the FirePro models should be: 2 x FP-100, for a total
extinguishing concentration of 200 grams.
Some tests were giving positive results with less concentration, but were not ensuring
consistent results.
Small new models: the results indicated that for this type of vehicle, closed at the bottom,
the selection of the FirePro models should be: 2 x FP-100 , for a total extinguishing
concentration of 200 grams., and also 2 x FP-80, for a total extinguishing concentration of
160 grams, or a combination of 1 x FP-100 and 1 x FP-80, for a total extinguishing
concentration of 180 grams.
The difference in the total mass is very small and the selection will be based by the space
available inside the engine compartment.
We have also noticed that whenever we have used the nozzle applied at the outlet of the
generators, better results were achieved. This confirmed that an important factor is the
uniform distribution of the extinguishing aerosol
FP Fire Protect Car Ltd
R&D
CONCLUSIONS
Working package 2: test different detectors and development of the control panel
The electronic smoke and heat detectors have shown during the tests to be very sensitive
and at risk of malfunctioning in environments such as an engine compartment. The
electronic detectors have given a detection time of average 5-6 seconds for the smoke
detection and 7-8 seconds for the heat detection.
On the contrary the linear heat detection cables rated at different temperatures have
demonstrated during the whole testing program, to be heavy duty. They have given
longer detection times, from 9-10 seconds up to 18-20 seconds.
These types of detectors are much less sensitive to environments such as the engine
compartments and are therefore more suitable for our scope, considering that the
difference in the detection time for the lower temperature rated cable is only of 3-5
seconds from the electronic heat detectors.
FPX106a AUTOMOBILE FIRE PANEL
FPX106a AUTOMOBILE FIRE PANEL
MOVIE 1 MOVIE 2
WORKING PACKAGE 4
BUSES
FIRE ON BUSES
BUSES ENGINE COMPARTMENT
RTA – Dubai Buses
BUS ENGINE COMPARTMENT
SIMULATOR
FirePro®
Fire Extinguishing Aerosol Generators
MODEL FP-500
Mass of extinguishing mat 500 gr
Activation mode/s Electrical ( 6/12/24V D/C, min. 0.8A for 3-4 secs)
Thermocord at 1720 C
Activator Heating element with 2.3 Ohm Resistance
Testing current max. 5mA
Weight Gross 2670 gr Tol. +/- 5%
Net 500 gr
Operation (Discharge) time 5 - 10 seconds
Discharge outlets 1
Dimensions 260mm x 88mm (diameter)
Self activation temp. 3000 C
Classes of fire A, B, C.
Bus Engine Compartment
Fire Extinguishing Tests
MOVIE 1 MOVIE 2
BUS TEST RESULTS
BUS TEST RESULTS
BUS TEST RESULTS
FirePro®