Sunteți pe pagina 1din 5

Microbiology

Meningitis: A Case Study


Rita A. Krueger, MT(ASCP)

Case History Viral Meningitis other seasons of the year.2


A 1973 CDC surveillance report The clinical presentation of VM
A three-month-old infant was
brought to a clinic for pediatric
evaluation. The infant had had a mild
showed over 8,000 cases of aseptic
meningitis. Eighty to 85% of these
varies with the patient's age, char-
acterized by some or all of the follow-
cases were caused by unidentified ing symptoms: fever, headache, nuchal
fever (101 °F) for the past 24 hours
agents; 15% to 20% of the 8,000 cases stiffness, lethargy, vomiting, and sen-
and was described as very irritable and
were due to the enteroviruses and it sitivity to light. Infants especially tend
fussy by the mother. Physical exam-
is thought that enteroviruses caused to present with nonspecific symptoms
ination results were normal. A lum-
some of the unknown cases but lacked that may only include irritability and
bar puncture was performed, a
the culture confirmation.1 Such re- fever. When a fever of unknown ori-
complete blood cell count and blood
ports have illustrated that enterovi- gin is present, central nervous system
cultures were obtained, and urine was
ruses are the most common agent of infection must be suspected. A lum-
collected for urinalysis and culture.
viral meningitis (VM). Echoviruses, bar puncture is needed to diagnose
The results are given in Table I.
coxsackie, and polio viruses are types meningitis and to clarify further a
of enteroviruses. The mumps virus, viral or bacterial etiology. Table II
Results and Discussion arboviruses, and herpes simplex virus summarizes typical CSF results in VM
The laboratory data for the patient (HSV) types 1 and 2 represent the and BM. CSF pleocytosis with a pre-
are indicative of meningitis, which is other most common viral agents. CDC ponderance of mononuclear cells,
an inflammation of the meninges. reports indicate a prevalence of en- marginally elevated to normal pro-
Meninges is a collective term for the terovirus cases during the summer and tein and normal glucose, represents
layers surrounding the brain and early autumn. However, an entero- the classic profile of VM.
spinal column—the pia mater, arach- viral meningitis can also occur during Studies have shown 20% to 75% of
noid, and dura mater. Meningitis is
further categorized by its pathogenic
agent—bacterial meningitis (BM) and Table 1: Results of Pediatric Evaluation
aseptic meningitis (AM)—which in- Peripheral Blood
cludes viral, fungal, mycobacterial, WBC 12,000
Hemoglobin 12g/dL
amebic, and mycoplasma etiologic Differential
sources. Viral meningitis is the most Band forms 12%
common type of aseptic meningitis. Segmented 70%
Lymphocytes 10%
Defining a viral or bacterial cause can Monocytes 8%
be determined using Gram's stain, CSF
cultures, and a variety of rapid meth- WBC 330 mm 3 (330 x 106'L)
RBC 10 mm 3 (10 x 106/L)
ods for the diagnosis of meningitis. PMN 70%
Monocytes 30%
Protein 50 mg/dL (50 g/L)
Glucose 55 mg/dL (55 g/L)
Gram's stain: no organisms seen
From Riverside Medical Center, Minneapolis, MN.

LABORATORY MEDICINE • VOL. 18, NO. 10, OCTOBER 1987


Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/labmed/article-abstract/18/10/677/2642456 677
by guest
on 03 May 2018
Table II: Summary of CSF Results in Viral and Bacterial Meningitis
had. Unfortunately, lack of a virus
Meningitis
isolate may leave this hit-or-miss ti-
ter analysis as the only recourse.
Viral Bacterial
Gross appearance Clear to hazy Turbid
HSV and arboviruses are rarely de-
WBCx10«/L 10-1,000 >S00 tected in CSF cultures. HSV-1 usu-
Major cell type Lymphocyte PMN ally causes meningoencephalitis (an
Protein Normal or increased Increased
Glucose Normal Decreased
inflammation of both the meninges
CSF/blood glucose 0.6-0.8 <0.6 and the brain), making brain tissue
the best source of isolating the virus.
HSV-2 is more likely to cause aseptic
VM cases to have polymorphonuclear culture data need to be evaluated meningitis and has been found in
(PMN) leukocytosis in their first CSF against clinical presentation and cross- CSF.2 Serology testing of antibody ti-
cell count.2 The chamber differential checked with viral titers. In a study ters for herpes simplex has poor spec-
can be difficult and has poor precision by Mintz and Drew,5 CSF viral cul- ificity. Fifteen to 20% of patients with
when small numbers of cells are ob- tures confirmed 43% of the VM cases. seroconversion do not have HSV.1 The
served. Wright's staining of spun sed- Simultaneous throat and rectal swabs ratio of HSV antibody in the CSF and
iment has the following disadvantages: isolated viruses for 89% and 83% of serum has been used to improve spec-
(1) cell recovery is inconsistent, (2) cell the cases, respectively. Thus, the ificity. This comparison is difficult to
disruption and distortion is common probability of isolating the virus in- evaluate in the early stages of infec-
due to the high rpm, and (3) the qual- creases by culturing the throat and tion.
ity of the smear is generally poor. feces along with the CSF. The appar- Arboviruses require infant mice for
Filtration, sedimentation, and cyto- ent cause-effect relationship between detection, so most laboratories rely on
centrifugation are among the meth- the isolate and the illness must take serologic methods to diagnose them.
ods offering improved cellular into account all relevant clinical and Over 250 types can cause AM. Epi-
concentration with minimal change laboratory results. 56 The Mintz study demiology variables such as vector
in appearance. Cytocentrifugation also found rectal swabs inadequate exposure, geographic location, and
seems the simplest technically, pro- substitutes for fecal specimens. They seasonal infection patterns can re-
viding rapid concentration of cells with concluded CSF and stool cultures pro- duce the range of possible arbo-
good detail.3 Mengel retrospectively vided maximum diagnostic informa- viruses.1 These epidemiology factors,
reviewed 75 cases to determine if cy- tion.5 coupled with the case numbers, show
tocentrifuge data could distinguish BM Primary monkey kidney and a va- that four arboviruses are responsible
from VM. On the basis of 75 cases, he riety of human cell lines can support for most cases of meningitis and en-
developed the following criteria to the growth ofmost enteroviruses. The cephalitis in the United States—St
evaluate the data: (1) greater than 60% cell lines are examined for cytopathic Louis encephalitis virus, Eastern
PMNs is supportive evidence of and effect (CPE), which provides pre- equine encephalitis virus, Western
(2) repeat LPs six to eight hours can sumptive identification. Different vi- equine encephalitis, and the Califor-
show a shift from neutrophils to ruses cause characteristic CPE nia encephalitis group.2
mononuclear cells, distinguishing AM changes. In some circumstances, such The value of doing viral cultures is
from BM.4 Other investigations have as a recognized epidemic of VM, the considered academic by some since the
likewise demonstrated that spinal taps observation of CPE in cell cultures results usually follow bacteria cul-
done six to 48 hours after the initial could be sufficient to substantiate a tures. Chonmaitree et al7 performed
one showed a significant decrease in viral cause. However, if definitive a two-year case review of CSF viral
the percentage of neutrophils, thus identification is desired, neutraliza- cultures. They concluded that viral
establishing a diagnosis of AM. tion tests are necessary. In neutrali- cultures were beneficial since they al-
The diagnosis of VM is based com- zation techniques, the patient's viral lowed for termination of antibiotic
monly on viral isolation from cultures isolate incubates with a battery of therapy and shortened hospitaliza-
or retrospective viral titer analysis. known immune sera. Such a scheme tion. However, they recommended CSF
Isolation of a virus from the CSF pro- represents a "rifle" approach to virus viral culturing only when other di-
vides conclusive evidence of the etiol- typing and is superior to the "shot- agnostic data support a viral etiology.
ogy of the meningitis. In addition to gun" method.6 Viral cultures do not They found spinal fluids were more
CSF viral cultures, stool and throat yield an isolate in the latter. Acute likely to be positive for a virus if the
specimens may yield isolates in pa- and convalescent serum samples are culture was set up immediately after
tients with meningitis. With a fecal- tested with the most probable viral lumbar puncture.
oral route mode of transmission, en- agents for a fourfold titer increase. For To summarize, viral culturing is the
teroviruses are most commonly iso- example, over 60 types of enterovi- best method for diagnosing VM. A vi-
lated from stools. This sensitivity does ruses are known to infect the central rus detected in the CSF has an un-
not provide concurrent specificity, nervous system, but ten types are re- deniable etiologic role. Viral isolates
however. The interpretation of a pos- sponsible for 71% of the cases.1 Neg- only from the stool or nasopharynx
itive viral isolate from the stool or ative viral titers against the ten most need careful consideration before la-
throat when the CSF virus culture is common enteroviruses could mean beling them the etiologic agent. Viral
negative provides only presumptive that the antigen pool did not contain titers are most productive when a vi-
evidence of the causal agent.5 Such the particular virus that the patient rus is isolated. When an isolate is not

6 7 8 from
Downloaded LABORATORY MEDICINE • VOL. 18, NO. 10, OCTOBER 1987
https://academic.oup.com/labmed/article-abstract/18/10/677/2642456
by guest
on 03 May 2018
obtained, titers provide "hit or miss" and culture was done to rule out uri- the blood. The normal CSF/blood glu-
information. nary tract infection as the cause of cose ratio is 0.6 to 0.8. The ratio can
fever. be useful when a patient had hyper-
Bacterial Meningitis CSF is normally clear and colorless, glycemia with apparently normal CSF
The spinal fluid testing is the key and any haziness or turbidity indi- glucose. A study by Merritt and Fre-
to differentiating VM from BM. The cates a pathologic condition. A pleo- mont-Smith found glucose levels 10 to
Gram's stain is the simplest tool for cytosis of approximately 400 x 106 cells 40 g/L in 57% of BM and less than 10
diagnosing BM. On the basis of pop- per liter would cause a cloudy ap- g/L in 23% of the 154 cases re-
ulation studies in the United States, pearance. When more than 6,000 x 106 viewed.10 Hypoglycorrhachia in CSF
the following bacteria are the most RBCs per liter are present, the CSF with significant pleocytosis is pre-
frequent cause of BM: Hemophilus in- appears grossly bloody. If traumatic sumptive of BM.
fluenzae, Streptococcus pneumoniae, puncture is a possibility, an approxi- An elevated level of spinal fluid
and Neisseria meningitis. Among mation of the true WBC count is to protein is a key sign of disease. The
neonates, group B streptococci and subtract 1 WBC per 700 RBCs in the elevation indicates a pathologic con-
Escherichia coli are the predominant chamber count. This correction as- dition that has increased permeabil-
pathogens. The overall case fatality sumes that there is a normal number ity at the blood-brain barrier. In the
rate of 26% for pneumococcal menin- of leukocytes and erythrocytes in the study by Merritt and Fremont-Smith,10
gitis ranks it the highest in compar- peripheral blood.10 less than 2% of the cases had normal
ison, with 6% for H influenzae and 10% The rule of thumb, "hundreds of CSF protein levels.
for meningococcal meningitis. In in- WBCs in VM and thousands in BM" Other chemical tests have been ap-
fants younger than one month, a 22% can be applied in most cases, but the plied to the CSF in hopes of differ-
fatality rate is involved with group B exceptions that occur detract from entiating VM from BM. Among these
streptococci.8 With such high risk of using it as the definitive test. Fish- are CSF immunoglobulins, lactate, and
death in lieu of antibiotic therapy, bein et al11 did a retrospective study creatine kinase brain isoenzyme. In-
clearly BM represents a medical of 50 cases of BM and found seven with vestigations have shown that none of
emergency. less than 7 WBCs x 106/L. Organisms these tests consistently discriminate
The clinical presentation of BM is were seen on two of the initial CSF between the two.213
variable and does not have unique Gram's stains, but the nearly normal Spinal fluid specimens should be
features to distinguish it from VM. CSF protein and glucose results were promptly taken to the laboratory. Re-
Fifty to 75% of children have a pro- also in contrast to the "typical" CSF frigeration is contraindicated due to
dromal upper respiratory infection.9 findings in BM. The patients in this the fastidiousness of H influenzae and
Several of the following factors have study were elderly or had other de- N meningitidis. Spun sediment is ex-
been identified as prognosticators: (1) bilitating conditions. 11 Thus, the amined after gram staining; 2,500 rpm
state of consciousness, (2) age of pa- screening ability of CSF cell counts, for 15 minutes is commonly used.
tient, (3) seizures, and (4) another su- glucose, and protein determinations Higher spin rates and membrane fil-
perimposed disease process. Upon in compromised individuals can be di- ters can be used to enhance the con-
hospital admission, a comatose pre- minished. PMNs, an abnormal con- centration of smaller numbers of
sentation is more likely to result in stituent of spinal fluid, are usually the bacteria. Even with centrifugation,
abnormal neurologic sequelae than an major type of leukocyte seen in the extensive examination of the smear is
irritable or lethargic state. Patients differential count. This aspect of BM, necessary. Bacteria counts below 105/
younger than 1 year or older than 40 too, has noteworthy exceptions. In a mL (108/L) are common and would re-
years are at higher risk of mortality retrospective chart review of 103 doc- sult in less than one organism per oil
and morbidity. Seizures caused by umented cases of BM, Powers12 found filed. The skill of the observer is crit-
bacterial toxins or brain damage are lymphocytosis in 14% of them. When ical to accuracy.
associated with increased chance of the total white cells counted was less Rapid diagnostic methods have be-
hearing handicap or other neurologic than 1,000 x 106/L, thirty-two percent come available in an effort to aug-
abnormality. Seizures in children oc- of the reviewed patients had more than ment the Gram's stain and to preempt
cur more frequently in H influenzae 50% lymphocytes. Previous studies had culture results. The rapid techniques
and pneumococcal cases than in those shown that lymphocytic responses include countercurrent Immunoelec-
caused by meningococci. Any under- were most commonly caused by Lis- trophoresis (CIE), latex particle ag-
lying disease process weakens the pa- teria monocytogenes or previous an- glutination (LPA), coagglutination
tient's immune response and may tibiotic therapy. Of the 14 cases testing (CAT), and the limulus lysate
lengthen the recovery time as well as reviewed, only one had Listeria iso- test. In addition to enhancing diag-
increase the chance of post-recovery lated.12 The role of the Gram's stain nostic speed, these tests are generally
sequelae.9 and culture in these situations is fur- not influenced by prior antibiotic
In the peripheral blood, an elevated ther stressed. treatment. CIE, LPA, and CAT may
white count is characteristically seen. Hypoglycorrhachia, defined as an also be performed on serum and urine
A left shift on the differential count abnormally low CSF glucose level, is specimens. Despite their potential for
is another common feature. Blood cul- usually present in BM. In order to best a speedy diagnosis, the reliability of
tures are drawn because bacteremia assess the CSF glucose, a serum glu- the rapid methods is subject to the
usually accompanies BM. For the in- cose sample should also be obtained specificity and sensitivity of the re-
fant in the case study, a urinalysis since all CSF glucose is derived from agents. Available antisera are not

LABORATORY MEDICINE • VOL. 18, NO. 10, OCTOBER 1987 6 7 9


Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/labmed/article-abstract/18/10/677/2642456
by guest
on 03 May 2018
Test and found it more sensitive in
detecting the diminishing antigen
levels following antibiotic therapy
than CIE. Antigen persistence was
detected an average of 6.3 days with
CAT versus 5.1 days with CIE.
The limulus lysate test is one not
HIB N routinely available, although it was
first demonstrated as a detector of
endotoxins by Bang in 1946. Since
then, many other investigators have
documented its usefulness. As applied
in BM, it assays the CSF for the li-

V7
popolysaccharide endotoxin found in
the cell walls of gram-negative bac-
teria. A lysate made from horseshoe
F
crab amebocytes is gelatinized when
.b bacterial endotoxin is present in the
- \
CSF. Tubes containing the lysate and
CSF are observed and graded for al-
tered appearance at 30-minute inter-
vals with a maximum two-hour
incubation. A positive result must be
at least 2+ (increased turbidity and
viscosity) or a 3+ (solidified mass).15
The test is negative in AM and pos-
itive with toxin concentrations ex-
ceeding 0.05 ng from N meningitidis
or H influenzae type B. Dyson and
F Cassady15 evaluated the test on 208
c CSF specimens collected from new-
borns with suspected meningitis. Pos-
itive Limulus results were obtained
• • • • Protein A only from the six infants with gram-
negative CSF isolates. The initial
Anti-H influenzae type B with protein A of S aureus coagglutinates with homologous Gram's stain revealed the causative
antigen. organism in three of the six positive
standardized and vary considerably. homologous antigen, strong aggluti- Limulus specimens. The gram-pos-
Thus, a negative result cannot be con- nation occurs. The size of the clumps itive bacteria of four infants were
sidered conclusive since it could be and the speed of their development negative at the two-hour readout.
caused by low antigen levels or poor correlate with the quantity of antigen Candida and Aspergillus can cause
antisera reactivity. Even a positive present. The detection of the polyri- false-positive results due to their sim-
result should have culture confirma- bose-phosphate (PRP) capsule of H ilar endotoxins.10 The usefulness of the
tion since cross-reactions may hap- influenzae type B with LPA is supe- limulus test with blood has been less
pen. Clinicians use rapid methods to rior to CIE; levels as low as 1 ng of clear-cut and remains difficult to in-
complement the smear and culture, PRP are positive in LPA, whereas CIE terpret.
though the decision to admit a patient requires at least 10 ng/mL of anti- After culture confirmation of bac-
and the antibiotics chosen for treat- gen.9 terial meningitis, additional labora-
ment are usually independent of the Staphylococcal CAT is another rapid tory testing may be indicated. The
rapid method result. test available. In this test, the protein need for repeat lumbar punctures to
CIE was formerly one of the few A antigen in the Staphylococcus au- ensure effective antibiotic therapy has
rapid methods available but is now reus cell wall is bound to the Fc por- been debated. The bulk of available
used less frequently. Newer, simpler tion of an antibody to a specific evidence suggests subsequent taps are
methods such as LPA and CAT offer bacteria. The Fab portion of the an- not necessary in most cases unless the
comparable or improved sensitivity tibody is thus unoccupied and free to sensitivity pattern of the pathogen is
and specificity. CIE remains as the unite with homologous antigen (Fig- unusual. Children with meningitis
basis for evaluating the performance ure). When bacterial antigen is pres- may develop a syndrome of inappro-
of the newer methods. ent in the CSF, agglutination occurs. priate antidiuretic hormone secre-
In latex particle agglutination kits, Comparisons of CAT and CIE indi- tion. When this happens, the kidneys
latex particles are coated with anti- cate very similar sensitivities and retain water leading to serum elec-
bodies to the bacteria commonly as- specificities. Webb and associates14 trolyte dilution and hypoosmolality.
sociated with BM. In the presence of tested the Phadebact Streptococcus Due to the patient's risk of cerebral

6 8 0 LABORATORY MEDICINE • VOL. 18, NO. 10, OCTOBER 1987


Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/labmed/article-abstract/18/10/677/2642456
by guest
on 03 May 2018
or pulmonary edema, the clinician may References M, Smith A, Root R (eds): New York, Churchill
Livingstone, 1985, pp 83-94.
closely monitor serum sodium and os- 1. Rubin S: Detection of viruses in spinal fluid. Am
10. Fishman R: Cerebrospinal Fluid in Diseases of
molality levels. 16 J Med 1983;74:124-128.
the Nervous System. Philadelphia, WB Saun-
2. Ratzan K: Viral meningitis. Med Clin North Am
For the patient in the case study, 1985;69:399-413.
ders Co, 1980.
negative CSF and blood cultures ruled 11. Fishbein D, Palmer D, Porter K, et al; Bacterial
3. Krieg A: Clinical Diagnosis and Management, meningitis in the absence of CSF pleocytosis.
out BM. A virus culture was not per- ed 16. Henry J (ed). Philadelphia, WB Saunders Arch Intern Med 1981;141:1369-1372.
Co, 1979, pp 641-642.
formed, but the infant's clinical course 12. Powers W: Cerebrospinal fluid lymphocytosis in
4. Mengel M: The use of the cytocentrifuge in the acute bacterial meningitis. Am J Med
was uncomplicated so a virus was the diagnosis of meningitis. Am J Clin Pathol 1985;79:216-220.
most probable cause. Serology testing 1985;84:212-216.
13. Rutledge J, Benjamin D, Hood L, et al: Is the
for virus identification is most effi- 5. Mintz L, Drew W: Relation of culture site to the CSF lactate measurement useful in the man-
recovery of nonpolio enteroviruses. Am J Clin agement of children with suspected bacterial
cacious when cultures are done in Pathol 1980;74:324-326. meningitis? J Pediatr 1981;98:20-24.
parallel. BM can be diagnosed on 6. Pearson G, Valdmanis A, Mann J, et al: The 14. Webb B, Edwards M, Baker C: Comparison of
spinal fluid gram stains with good ac- impact of viral diagnostic studies on medical slide coagglutination test and counter-current
practice: A report of the years' experience with Immunoelectrophoresis for detection of group B
curacy. Rapid techniques such as LPA enterovirus isolation in a hospital laboratory. streptococcal antigen in cerebrospinal fluid from
and CAT are useful adjuncts to the Am J Clin Pathol 1972;58:349-357. infants with meningitis. J Clin Microbiol
7. Chonmaitree T, Menegus M, Powell K: The clin- 1980;11:263-265.
bacterial culture and Gram's stain. ical relevance of 'CSF viral culture.' JAMA 15. Dyson D, Cassady G: Use of limulus lysate for
The variability of CSF cell counts, 1982;247:1843-1847. detecting gram-negative neonatal meningitis.
differential, glucose, and protein lev- 8. Broome C, Schlech W: Bacterial Meningitis. Pediatrics 1976;58:105-109.
Sande M, Smith A, Root R (eds). New York, 16. Shann F, Germer S: Hyponatremia associated
els limits their reliability in differ- Churchill Livingstone, 1985, pp 1-10. with pneumonia or bacterial meningitis. Arch
entiating VM from BM. 9. Kaplan S, Feigin R: Bacterial Meningitis. Sande Dis Child 1985;60:963-966.

In the October issue of the


American Journal of Clinical Pathology

Estrogen Receptor Immunocytochemistry for Preoperative Determination of Estrogen Recep-


tor Status on Fine-Needle Aspirates of Breast Cancer
Angelika Reiner, Georg Reiner, Jurgen Spona, Bela Tekley, Roland Kolb, and Johann H. Holzner
Hepatitis B Virus-Related Glomerulopathy in Patients With Systemic Lupus Erythematosus
Fernard Mac-Moune Lai, Kar-Neng Lai, Joseph C. K. Lee, and Ben Lin Horn
Identification of Neutrophils With an Oxazine Blue
Lawrence Kass
A Novel Whole Blood Capillary Technique for Measuring the Prothrombin Time
Fred V. Lucas, Alexander Duncan, Richard Jay, Robert Coleman, Paula Craft, Beatrice Chan, Laura
Winfrey, Dennis R. Mungall, and Jack Hirsch
Fluorescence Intensity as a Quality Control Parameter in Clinical Flow Cytometry
Charles W. Caldwell, Joyce Maggi, Louise B. Henry, and Henry M. Taylor
A Panel Approach to the Evaluation of the Sensitivity and Specificity of Antibodies for the Diagnosis
of Routinely Processed Histologically Undifferentiated Human Neoplasms
Sara A. Michie, Dominic V. Spagnolo, Kathleen A. Dunn, Roger A. Warnke, and Robert V. Rouse
Large Intracytoplasmic Body in Lung Cancer Compared With Clara Cell Granule
Kuniaki Nakanishi, Toshiaki Kawai, and Minoru Suzuki
The Effect of Melanin Pigment Removal of the Pap Immunoperoxidase Technique
Jule McGovern and John Crocker
Evaluation of Dipstick Urine Studies Using a Scoring System Based on Test Performance Character-
istics
Gifford Lum and Mary C. Morrison
Basal Cells of Prostate in Fine-Needle Aspiration
Daniel M. Jacobs and Mark A. Weiss
Special Report: The Clinical Significance of Eosinophiluria
Howard L. Corwin and Meryl H. Haber

LABORATORY MEDICINE • VOL. 18, NO. 10, OCTOBER 1987 681


Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/labmed/article-abstract/18/10/677/2642456
by guest
on 03 May 2018

S-ar putea să vă placă și