Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Marshall University
LS 626-431
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 2
Table of Contents
I. CASE STATEMENT SUMMARY................................................................................. 6
A. Overview .................................................................................................................... 6
A. Provide Classroom and Creative Arts Resources for Teachers Pre-K through 12 .. 10
C. Leverage the School Box Program as a Vehicle for Corporate Giving ................... 11
A. Provide Classroom and Creative Arts Resources for Teachers Pre-K through 12 .. 11
D. Leverage the School Box Program as a Vehicle for Group Giving ......................... 13
A) Start-up .................................................................................................................... 22
D) Executive Committee............................................................................................... 24
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 4
5. Planned Giving.......................................................................................................... 44
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 5
References ......................................................................................................................... 49
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 6
A. Overview
retail store environment to teachers in the Southern West Virginia region who serve students
from low income families is a fabulous possibility. A frequently-benchmarked “Free Store for
Teachers” is “Crayons to Classrooms” in Cincinnati, Ohio. Some of these stores are operated as
corporate foundations and sponsors who have worked together to distribute over 10,000 student
supply kits for students and families. I propose a “SMART store” charity be created for West
Virginia. SMART is an acronym for “Students Matter: Academic Resources for Teachers.”
My comprehensive Strategic Fundraising Plan and Operating Feasibility Study for the
West Virginia based “SMART Store” is based on the fundraising cycle (Rosso, 2003),
developing and articulating a case for support (Seiler & Aldrich, 2011), and the total
development plan (Seiler, 2011). Therefore, this SMART strategic fundraising plan will include
articulation of:
• Proposed Vision
• Proposed Mission
• Strategic Objectives
• Strategies
• Marketing Requirements
• Staffing Structure
• Funding Partnerships
Of the 38 “Free Stores for Teachers” programs across the United States, all programs
share the same purpose: to collect donations of surplus, close-out, and otherwise available
material and re-distribute them to classroom teachers in schools serving lower income families
C. Core Competencies
Operating “SMART Store” will require several necessary core competencies to establish
and operate a proposed location in Welch, West Virginia. These core competencies are
summarized as follows:
This includes complete knowledge of retail displays and organizing school supplies,
classroom kits, incentive products, and related resources in a creative manner similar to a retail
store. A typical “Free Store for Teachers” requires 25% to 30% of total space in a retail display
area.
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 8
Some “Free Stores for Teachers” demonstrate sophisticated warehouse and inventory
management practices. Warehouse and inventory management competencies include the ability
to organize products in an SKU system and to accept spontaneous inventory deliveries from
donor organizations. Inventory management also includes low cost purchasing of basic school
supplies when donations do not support and sustain demand in the retail store. A typical
management system, as well as 70% of the facility’s total square footage used as a warehouse
area. Loading docks, materials handling equipment, and a warehouse facility adjacent to the
retail space also appear to be a common requirement of the “Free Store for Teachers” enterprise.
All “Free Stores for Teachers” rely totally on a comprehensive strategy for fundraising
and development. Some of the more successful free stores have conducted capital campaigns to
purchase their facilities. Stores also require annual operating campaigns for financial resources to
support staff and material overhead for the program. Acquisition and solicitation of donated
goods are also a core competency in the fundraising and development area.
An effective “Free Stores for Teachers” program will need a comprehensive marketing
strategy and ongoing relationships with local school districts in the target areas. Special event
management and media relations are key marketing competencies needed. Consequently,
marketing leadership and skills will be essential to support a “Free Store for Teachers”
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 9
enterprise. This could be done in combination with professional staff, as well as board members
emotion, reason, and organizational credibility (Seiler & Aldrich, 2011), this document contains
“the ask” script that will be utilized as part of our marketing and fundraising strategy.
All “Free Stores for Teachers” rely heavily on volunteers to be successful. Volunteers
may be teachers who benefit from the store, as well as a wide array of additional volunteers in
successful “Free Store for Teachers” program. SMART will utilize Gattle’s (2011) team
approach throughout donor solicitation, recognition, and involvement, insuring that donors and
volunteers are recognized as important and share compelling testimony about how their support
“Free Store for Teachers” will require administrative and operations leadership. This will
include finance and accounting systems, staff development, program planning, staff scheduling,
D. Target Markets
SMART stores will utilize free and reduced meals as a poverty indicator for necessity of
free resources for students and teachers. Based on the West Virginia Office of Child Nutrition
Scorecard (2015), there are more than 143,000 students in the state of West Virginia that are
living in poverty and utilize free and reduced meals. The potential size and target markets of the
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 10
first “SMART Store” in McDowell County represents those schools in McDowell County of
school aged students (5 to 17 years) eligible for free and reduced lunches. The 2010 Population
Census shows that there are 3,214 school-aged students in McDowell County and West Virginia
Office of Child Nutrition Scorecard (2015) shows that 2,731 students in McDowell County are
Vision
To enhance the readiness to learn for all children in need and their teachers in West
Mission
“SMART Store” collects and distributes, at no cost, the basic tools for classroom learning
into the hands of teachers and school children in need. We help children and their teachers enact
A. Provide Classroom and Creative Arts Resources for Teachers Pre-K through 12
Position “SMART Store” as a resource for classroom and creative arts resources to
teachers, their schools, and school districts, serving populations of children most in need.
professional, community, civic, and educational associations as a preferred mode of operation for
“SMART Store.”
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 11
Leverage the ”School Box Program” as a vehicle for corporate donors in West Virginia to
support lower income students and families by contributing school supplies annually to this
program. Because corporations are most interested in supporting causes that form a link between
the company and the nonprofit that benefits the company socially and economically
(Burlingame, 2011), we will show how their company’s SMART sponsorship supports K-12
students by creating a well-educated workforce that will benefit the WV economy and the
sponsor itself. SMART will also leverage the sponsors, such as Massey Energy, into an
improved public image, while also improving Massey Energy employee morale in Southern WV,
thus increasing work productivity and educating their inherent work force (Burlingame, 2011).
Massey Energy’s support of SMART is based on the premise to be good corporate citizens and
that corporate giving and volunteering is a way to demonstrate corporate social responsibility to
IV. STRATEGIES
A. Provide Classroom and Creative Arts Resources for Teachers Pre-K through 12
2. Identify specific desired facility, capacity, location, and a timeline for initial operations
and opening.
3. Develop visitation and free shopping trip policies for teachers, including those from low
6. Expand the services of “SMART stores” to serve all eligible children and schools in the
state of West Virginia as feasible during the first five years of operation.
7. Integrate services of “SMART stores” with WV Public Radio, NPR, and Mountain Stage
to build a strong source for musical instruments and arts supplies for students.
8. Identify WV arts organizations and local retailers to be partners in identifying sources for
Cincinnati as a way for them to gain first-hand experience with the concept.
2. Conduct donor requests from major corporations in the State of West Virginia to benefit
3. Adopt store operating policies and inventory structure of the Crayons to Computers store
1. Engage parents and families in the region, encouraging their leadership as volunteers to
2. Engage the West Virginia Chamber of Commerce as a vehicle for building leadership
support for “SMART stores” in McDowell County and the future state-wide stores.
3. Engage the high-schools as a source for key student volunteers for the “SMART stores”
facility.
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 13
4. Explore the connection of “SMART stores” with the United Way of Southern West
5. Engage major healthcare providers for school district employees to play a leadership role
7. Engage the West Virginia Higher Education Policy Commission as a resource for
“SMART stores.”
1. Designate “founding partner status” for primary corporate funders of the School Box
Program as part of “SMART stores”, acknowledging their contribution to initiating the concept
2. Provide service opportunities for churches in the region to become partners in the
School Box Program and as an introductory vehicle for their long-term support of “SMART
stores.”
developing these relationships for future individual donors to the “SMART stores” facility.
4. Explore collaborations with United Way’s “Stuff the Bus” Program as a “SMART
stores” partner.
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 14
Because total development plans must reach three to five years as part of our
organization’s strategy for addressing mission, goals, and objectives (Seiler, 2011), hereafter are
the SMART details for each year of the strategic fundraising plan as part of the first five years of
operation. SMART is following Seiller’s advice (2011) that organizations must follow
fundraising with pride in mission and boldly invite large gifts from committed donors, to raise
considerably more money through a total development plan, raising funds necessary for program
1. To reach 700 teachers per year or 50% of the potential market of teachers from eligible
2. To support up to 5 shopping trips per year per teacher, leveraging resources to at least
3. To leverage an annual of $1.28 million in donated school supplies per year for the first
five full years of store operations or $6.4 million over five years.
4. To leverage start-up donor support and sponsorships equivalent to $300,000 per year for
the first three years of operation or $900,000 for three years of operating support.
5. To leverage an average of $275,000 per year in additional cash donations toward store
operations and the purchase and transportation of goods to be distributed in the first five
full years.
7. To engage community partners as joint project sponsors for 80% or more of the programs
8. To secure funding for the School Box Program in collaboration with corporate support
9. By 2020, to generate new private funding support from individuals, churches, and
corporations in West Virginia for at least 40% of the School Box Program.
10. To leverage 60% of the philanthropy for “SMART stores” from new sources of
corporate, individual, and community donors by the end of the fourth year of operation.
11. In 2023, to fully participate in and benefit from the national affiliation and branding and
marketing program of the Kids In Need Foundation network of Free Store for Teachers
Street, Welch, WV 24801. This 3,500 sq. ft. of commercial property and upstairs apartment to be
The following lists of improvements and facility requirements are those included in the
improvement cost estimate for renovations in order to accommodate “SMART stores.” These
items are part of a capital project to make the necessary leaseholder improvements for the Free
Store.
• Lighting Improvements for the warehouse area and retail store area
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 16
• Painting scheme and design for store branding colors, store and warehouse floor, and
• Office equipment, including desks, chairs, and file cabinets (possible in- kind donation)
• Sorting tables
• Check-out tables
• Four computers, two printers, a server, and monitors (possible in-kind donation)
While each of the national Free Stores has a product or inventory structure related to their
product donors, the following Product/Inventory Structure for “SMART stores” in McDowell is
The Product/Inventory Structure for McDowell would offer three brands of supplies and
materials, including:
One of the key attributes of the feasibility study for “SMART stores” in McDowell has
been determining the committed partners and potential collaborators leveraging other community
resources to achieve the store’s mission. The following confirmed partnerships are committed to
the Free Store project and the specific points of shared resources and collaboration which follow.
The Kids in Need Foundation will play an integral role in developing and implementing
“SMART stores” in West Virginia. The Foundation maintains a network of Free Stores
throughout the United States with members paying a modest annual fee for participation.
• Use of the national branding strategy for Free Stores associated with the Kids in Need
• Participation in major national, regional, and state donations of products for Free Stores
the “SMART Store”. The Cincinnati-based store is a national model with best practices
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 19
replicated by other stores throughout the country. Specific, unique synergies between the
Cincinnati-based “Crayons to Computers” and the McDowell -based “SMART stores” include
the following:
One of the major clients for “SMART stores” will be the teachers serving McDowell
Public Schools. Recent difficulties with school district funding will only accelerate the problem
of inadequate resources for teaching and learning in the classroom. The partnership with
community resource
Charleston, WV operates a material re-use facility that could provide furnishings and
equipment through the re-use of recycled and donated products, including furniture, lumber,
office equipment, and recycled goods. The following collaborations have not been formally
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 20
committed; however, they remain potential prospects, particularly in the area of volunteer
The following concepts are considered helpful to establishing the identity and
relationship of the free store to other educational services and needs within the community.
bono basis.
2. Marketing and Community Identity Strategy to guide the greater McDowell area with the
concept of a free store for teachers, the needs in the community, and “SMART stores”.
3. Develop a series of feature articles on teachers who go the extra mile to support students
and the level of need for classroom supplies and learning tools for students with the
4. Schedule a news conference event featuring teachers and students as a main focus of
5. Work with United Way Industries to develop a series of articles featuring the unique
6. Feature students in the free store who are exceptional student achievers through a follow-
up special event which highlights a link between adequate resources in the classroom and
student success.
7. Create a joint campaign featuring the United Way “Stuff the Bus” Program and a unique
articles which focus on the community’s voluntary response to meeting the needs of rural
The following governance and advisory structure would initiate “SMART stores” in West
Virginia as a 501(c)(3) organization within the State of West Virginia . This is the most common
model for teacher free stores among the network of those entities throughout the United States.
Executive
Committee
Board of Trustees
Finance and Operating
Committee
Governance and
Nominating Committee
A) Start-up
organization, the following key activities are anticipated as part of a 90-day start-up to launch
1. Submit an IRS 1023 application to establish a 501(c)(3) status for “SMART stores”. This
designation will be achieved between six weeks and 120 days from application.
2. Establish a fund for “SMART stores” to accept and acknowledge gifts parallel to the IRS
4. Form a Transition Team, including initial sponsors and the Executive Committee.
5. Secure Board Member and Founding commitment to actively lead the fundraising and
development effort for “SMART stores” establishing the organization within the
community.
7. Recruit the Executive Director after pledges have been received for the first three years of
stores” including teachers, civic and community groups, corporate donors, and local
businesses.
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 23
B) Board of Trustees
A Board of Trustees should be constituted to begin “SMART stores” by the fall of 2018.
The Board of Trustees have no less than 10 members and no more than 20 members and should be
elected for a period of two years with the possibility of renewal for two additional two-year terms
or a total of six years of service on behalf of “SMART stores.” The principle responsibilities of the
Board of Trustees will be further elaborated upon in a Code of Regulations and will include the
following:
• To serve as the chief fiduciary agent for “SMART stores” according to the laws of the State
• To promote the purposes and advocate on behalf of “SMART stores” throughout the state.
• To oversee strategic plans, operating plans, and fundraising and development plans as
• To approve the use and management of endowment funds and other charitable funds of
• To engage the community and various agencies in a common mission to serve children in
• To review the monthly, quarterly, and annual financial statements and balance sheets of
“SMART stores”.
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 24
• To approve annual operating and capital budgets developed by the Executive Director.
• To review and approve reports of the Finance and Operations Committee, the Executive
Committee, the Governance and Nominating Committee, the Fundraising and Development
Committee, the School and Community Relations Committee, and the Retail Donations
• To approve individual expenditure items outside the budget recommended by the Executive
Director.
• To hire, evaluate, and terminate the Executive Director in conjunction with good business
practices.
• To annually assess the mission effectiveness and stakeholder satisfaction with “SMART
stores”.
The Board of Trustees for “SMART stores” should have three formal committees,
including an Executive Committee, a Finance and Operations Committee, and a Governance and
D) Executive Committee
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 25
The Executive Committee consist of a Chairperson, Vice Chair, Secretary, and Treasurer
elected by their peers annually. Responsibilities of the Executive Committee may consist of the
following:
• To facilitate communication among the trustees, their board committees, and advisory
• To act on behalf of the Board of Trustees on those items that cannot be deferred to a regular
trustee meeting in those months in which trustees do not have plenary meetings.
an initial review of challenges, plans, and financial matters facing the organization.
• To serve as the agent of the Board of Trustees in evaluating and hiring the Exec. Director.
• To decide upon the compensation of the Executive Director in consultation with the Board
of Trustees.
• To act as the personnel committee reviewing personnel practices, policies, handbooks, etc.
The Finance and Operations Committee may be responsible for the following:
• To provide review and analysis of financial statements, budgets, and other financial reports.
• To provide oversight of findings in the annual audit to be performed by third party auditors.
• To provide a source for review and evaluation of recommended capital improvements for
• To provide recommendations to the Board of Trustees for the selection and evaluation of
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 26
• To provide recommendations to the Board of Trustees for fiscal policies of the organization
The Governance and Nominating Committee may be responsible for the following:
• To research and cultivate a pool of potential candidates for balanced composition and
• To annually recommend a slate of candidates for the trustees and trustee committees for
• To provide ongoing trustee development for the roles, responsibilities, and governance
development of policies such as, but not limited to, whistle-blowers and probations and
dismissal policies to be utilized in the event that professionalism, trust, morals, or ethics
The purpose of an advisory committees will be to engage community leaders in the mission
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 27
of the organization and to cultivate a future pool of prospective trustees. Members of advisory
committees are appointed for one year of service by the Board of Trustees. Each advisory
consultative role only to the trustees and would not constitute part of the governance structure.
The Fundraising and Development Advisory Committee will be responsible for providing
advice and expertise to the Board of Trustees and Executive Director on the fundraising and
• Donor intent
• Donor relations
• Annual gifts
• Based on individual ability, to participate in major gifts and capital campaign programs of
• To review and evaluate all fundraising processes of the organization, including case
statements, campaign timetables, gift schedules, etc. for the reasonableness and potential
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 28
success.
The School and Community Relations Advisory Committee will be responsible for the
following:
• To provide counsel and advice to the Board of Trustees and Executive Director regarding
• To provide guidance to the Board of Trustees and Executive Director on the institutional
• To review and evaluate key marketing and public relations materials of the organization,
• To provide guidance and access to key community organizations who are likely partners for
“SMART stores”.
• To provide guidance and access to school districts who may be key clients of “SMART
stores”.
• To provide general public relations and communications advice regarding the positioning
process. Since the major product lines of “SMART stores” are donated products, this advisory
committee is considered important for effective leadership of the organization. Members of the
• To provide access to major corporations and businesses capable of donating goods and
• To provide feedback and advice to the Executive Director on the various product lines
• To identify major contributors of products and services to “SMART stores” who may
• To provide assistance to the Executive Director in working with other stores and
entities who rely on donated products and goods for joint purchases or receipt of large
• To provide a source of advice and expertise on the appeal, attractiveness, layout, and
The following staffing structure for “SMART stores” in West Virginia is based upon a
review of staffing models of other Free Store organizations. The following staffing structure will
likely take “SMART stores” in West Virginia through a five-year operating period without
substantial change.
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 30
Board of Trustees
Volunteer and
Executive Director
Administrative
Coordinator
A) Executive Director
“SMART stores” will require the full-time services of an Executive Director. This position
will serve as the chief administrator of the operation. He/she will specifically be responsible for:
• Soliciting ongoing corporate gifts in support of “SMART stores”, including cash and
donated goods.
• Soliciting ongoing individual gifts in support of “SMART stores”, including cash and
donated goods.
• Managing and overseeing all special programs for collecting and distributing donated
• Participating in meetings of the Board of Trustees and preparing materials for the trustees
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 31
• Approving and overseeing the purchase of basic school supplies from major national chains
• Approving the participation of “SMART stores” in major acquisition programs with other
stores in the Kids in Need network and other recycling entities of the community.
• Overseeing all budget operations, including budget development, financial statements, and
balance sheets.
• Coordinating all activities as appropriate to assure smooth operation working with sponsors
and partners.
• Working with local school districts to increase outreach and knowledge of “SMART
• Serving as the major strategic partner with other charitable organizations having similar
A Retail Program Manager is envisioned for “SMART stores”. This position will serve as
the major “out front” role inside the retail store during the hours of operation and during re-
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 32
• Organizing all display layouts at the direction and supervision of the Executive Director.
• Organizing special store promotional and sponsored areas working with donors.
• Overseeing all input to the inventory and customer database system of “SMART stores”.
• Training and coordinating all volunteers serving in the retail operation of “SMART stores”.
• Working with the Warehouse Manager on inventory and re-stocking supplies on a daily
basis.
• Qualifying schools and teachers for their eligibility to participate in “SMART stores”
programs.
“SMART stores”.
• Working with teachers individually and collectively to better understand their needs for
• Coordinating educational programs which occur in “SMART stores” with other common
• Speaking to teacher groups, volunteer groups, and parent groups on behalf of “SMART
C) Warehouse Manager
“SMART stores” will also be served by a Warehouse Manager. He/she will specifically be
responsible for:
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 33
• Overseeing all safety policies, guidelines, and warehouse compliance with safety and
• Coordinating shared inventory management and exchange programs with other stores and
• Determining the acceptability of large donated lots of contributed goods from corporate
• Identifying and recommending major purchases of inventory items within the budget for
• Setting recorded values of all donated goods for the purpose of determining their income
“SMART stores” will also be served by a Volunteer and Administrative Coordinator who
primarily works for the Executive Director, but also supports the Retail Program Manager and
• Providing all clerical support to the Executive Director and management staff.
• Overseeing the purchasing of promotional items and services as directed by the Executive
Director.
• Implementing all direct mail programs and overseeing their distribution to a third party
mailer as appropriate, as direct mail is the most effective and efficient way to build a donor
• Providing all data entry to the inventory and customer data system established for the store.
• Coordinating all meetings as requested with staff, donors, volunteers, and members of the
Board of Trustees.
campaign of $1.9 million to support the organization during its first three years of operation
and provide adequate time for “ramp-up” to full leadership by the Executive Director and
the Board of Trustees. Of the estimated $1.9 million for start-up costs, $300,000 per year for
three years is anticipated for operational expenses which include some purchase of goods to
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 35
be distributed through the store to fill the gaps for items that may not be received through donations.
In addition to the $1.9 million of financial support for “SMART stores” in the first three
years of operation, it is expected that the store will generate approximately $7.4 million in donated
goods and supplies during the first five full years of store operation. These goods and supplies will
be available for direct distribution to teachers in eligible schools and school districts throughout the
state of West Virginia, as SMART expands from McDowell County into Southern WV.
The following companies show interest in their representatives being Board Members and
also contributing a three-year pledge toward the $1.9 million goal of establishing “SMART stores”.
• Alcon
• Chesapeake Energy
• Intuit
• Nippon-Tungsten
• Ramaco Development
• Massey Energy
• Mylan Pharmaceuticals
• Toyota
The School Box Program will be expanded to include individual donors by establishing a
system for donations through this network of pick-up and drop-off sites. Additionally, individual
donors will be solicited for cash donations to the Free Store, especially through churches, youth
serving organizations, and seeking partnerships between businesses and civic organization
members. The individual donor strategy is likely to begin with an expansion of the School Box
Program by the end of the second year which will lead to further cash donation strategies for
individuals to “SMART stores” in successive years of store operation. Intuit, led by CEO Brad
Smith, will sponsor the STEM boxes created by 7 Degrees at Marshall University (2017) for
distribution to WV schools. Brad Smith is a major donor who has quickly caught the SMART
mission and vision and recognizes the importance of education and technology in West Virginia
“Education is like a baseball game; it needs all its players: parents, teachers, students, and
community (unknown, n.d.).” This will be our motto and theme for our 5-year strategic fundraising
plan. There are many lessons in baseball. Lessons of cause and effect, motive and result, sweat and
sacrifice, teamwork and collaboration, mentorship, community engagement, or how statistics are
increasingly used to make decisions (Beard, 2016). All of this can apply to our charity. Baseball
teaches us to take risks, since you can’t steal second base unless you take your foot off first. It
teaches us that every day is a new day and a new opportunity. It teaches us to keep swinging. This
is how we will approach donor involvement, fundraising, and operations. This is why baseball will
be our theme. The comprehensive fundraising program with strategies and tactics can be
categorized as follows:
2. Donor events
3. Online fundraising
5. Planned giving
“The Ask” Script can be used to prepare a specific ask for each initiative, such as
businesses, individuals, capital support vs. program support, etc. SMART’s ask is as follows:
Students Matter: Academic Resources for Teachers [SMART] has given the children of West
Virginia/McDowell County the support they need to achieve success since 2017. In West Virginia,
Right now the SMART store is starting an exciting adventure. At the same time, our
community has a growing need reflected by long waiting lists for our programs. Teachers see the
opportunities available by utilizing our programs and they want to ensure that WV children have
their basic needs met, while also learning how to help themselves. In order to change the future of
That is why we are coming to you right now. Your contribution of $ would make a
significant difference in our ability to support teacher academic resource donations, expand our
reach to more students and schools, and meet the needs of our impoverished communities. Can I
Donors are most likely to renew if they are promptly thanked for every gift they make, and
frequently contacted by staff with news about programs and giving opportunities and asked to give.
Therefore:
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 38
• We will respect generational giving differences by utilizing language in donor solicitation that
speaks about SMART programs meeting basic needs, helping the poor help themselves,
making their community better, changing the world, and statistical significance (Brown &
Kou, 2011).
• We will track all gifts that are received using Paradox, an inter-relational database program
• We will send thank you letters within 48 hours of a gift being received, with those letters
• We will track contacts with donors and potential donors of using ACT software program.
• We will send a weekly donor newsletter by email to all donors for whom we have email
contribute.
• We will send Quarterly Progress Reports by email or regular mail to donors of $1,000 or
• We will maintain a Development Progress Report that tracks what gifts have come in, which
are pledged, and which need to be secured in each quarter. That report is continuously updated
• We will maintain calendars of dates and deadlines for corporate and foundation donors.
• A first renewal letter will be automatically generated three months prior to the one year
“anniversary” of a donor’s last gift. If the donor doesn’t renew, another letter is sent a month
later, and a third letter is sent two months later. Those letters are updated once a quarter.
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 39
• Donors will be approached before their renewal date by phone or email to discuss their
• “Expired donors” going back three years will get invitations to events and end of the year
solicitations to give. Notes about major past donors will stay in the ACT database for five
years or longer.
• We will continuously conduct research on current donors, even small donors, to discover
people with high net worth or positions on foundation boards who we might be able to up-sell.
That information is put into the ACT database so that all fundraisers can see what information
• Highlights of planned renewal efforts in 2021 include significantly increasing the amount of
development staff travel, meeting with corporate and foundation donors who we did not see in
2020, as we expect to have volunteers to help do background research on current and new
donors.
a wide top and narrow bottom or shoot. The wide top represents reaching a large number of
potential donors, and the narrow bottom is the actual number of donors that will result from that
outreach. SMART needs to identify about 10 potential donors for every actual gift we receive. We
will utilize the LAI principle (linkage, ability, interest) in our donor research (Martin, 2011).
Table 1 describes four categories of potential donors we will regularly search for prospects,
where we get the names of prospects, and how we make solicitations. The LAI principle will be
further utilized for implementation of our Direct Mail marketing (Warwick, 2011) as direct mail is
Table 1
Target Groups for Potential Major Donors
Group Name Description Sources Solicitation Method
Friends and Individuals Board members Current “Crowd source” the prospecting
colleagues of introduced to donors SMART staff process by asking all SMART staff,
current donors SMART by a Senior fellows directors, and donors more than
and staff friend or once a year to recommend
colleague who individuals who might give.
already
supports us. Add to temporary comp mailing list
and event invitation lists.
Table 1 (continued)
Target Groups for Potential Major Donors
Group Description Sources Solicitation Method
Name
Individual Individuals who Public lists of donors and Add contacts and background info to
prospects give to other sponsors to events ACT and Paradox, code to receive
groups or publications.
candidates;
letter writers to Sympathetic civic and Write, call, schedule meetings,
daily business leaders submit proposals, and follow up.
newspapers. Try to bring senior fellows or
current donors to meetings.
2. Donor Events
Face-to-face meetings are necessary to get larger gifts (Rosso, 2011). They can occur
pursue both. Group meetings can be hosted specifically for SMART donors or for elected
officials and other audiences at which SMART development staff can make presentations and
Events hosted by sponsors, education allies, or business and civic groups, in which case
SMART is an exhibitor, presenter, or just sends people to attend, all of these are potential for
making connections and recruiting volunteers and donors. The inaugural SMART solicitation
benefit (Donahue, 2011) will take place on the same day as the WV Student Success Summit,
in order to get more than 500 education administrators, teachers, students, military leaders and
community group members, as well as legislators, to attend both events and create
opportunities for donors to mingle with legislators. This Summit benefit is expected to happen
every July.
Furthermore, to stay true with our “Education is like baseball; it needs all its players”
fundraising theme, we will host events with the WV Power Minor League Baseball team at
Appalachian Power Park in Charleston, WV. These events will vary from taking donors to
games and hosting them in the Legends Club suite as our stewardship event (Donahue, 2011),
to taking our low-income students, parents, and volunteers to our WV Power Field of Dreams
motivation, community building, and thank-you events. Baseball games happen April through
September, which beautifully lines up with the end and beginning of the academic years for
our students and would assist students, parents, volunteers, and teachers in meeting up with
Our inaugural Field of Dreams event will be hosted in 2020, where each SMART youth
guest will participate in an on-field catch and meet the Power starting line-up team. Guests will
have their name announced and run to position on the field with a Power team member, be
gifted their own souvenir baseball, and then have a pizza party while watching the baseball
game. As part of our corporate giving and funding structure, sponsors will have tickets and
hospitality to Field of Dreams, as part of their second-order benefit from their sponsorship and
3. Online fundraising
Our website and social media presence will have ads and requests for contributions on
the homepage and an exciting “donate” feature on every page (Stanger, 2011) that will utilize
instant personalized thank-you feedback, student and volunteer testimonials, and statistics
about how their donation benefits student’s education (Brown & Kou, 2011). We will utilize
this presence to respect and utilize generational differences in giving, as well as utilization of
the trend that forty-one percent of organizations are using blogging, text, instant messaging,
Donors will then be asked if they would like to join our e-newsletter, which also
contains promotional language requesting contributions. We are steadily expanding the list of
people receiving the newsletter to include potential as well as actual donors. Donating online
will be made by use of Kimbia, an online donation and reservation processing system that is
easy to use, secure, allows us to receive funds immediately, keeps donors on our Web page,
While ideologically motivated individual donors are apt to contribute for general
operating, corporations and foundations want project-specific proposals. We will tailor our
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 44
programs to meet both the requirements of our mission while also exciting new donors to make
the contributions needed to fund our programs. Therefore, donors such as Intuit will focus on
STEM box funding (7 Degrees, 2017), and foundations such as the Mary Reynolds Babock
Foundation, WK Kellogg Foundation, and the Claude Worthington Benedum Foundation will
have grants written and provide to them as part of specific programing and ranging from
5. Planned Giving
life insurance companies and charitable remainder trusts. As baby boomers retire, planned
giving is rising. SMART realizes that most new organizations do not have the financial
resources and personnel to allow for a comprehensive planned giving program, but as SMART
has a strategic plan that outlines our first five years of operation with clear goals and an
accurate mission statement, why services provided are important to the community, and a case
statement that clearly and concisely describes how and what the organization does
(Regenovich, 2011). Because planned gifts are sometimes twenty to thirty years later, we will
ensure that our organization exudes growth and stability and that we will be a responsible
In 2023, SMART will launch a planned giving program with the following parts:
• A Planned Giving Board consisting of estate planning and planned giving professionals
• Advertisements in our publications and newsletters and on our Web, and a brochure
making the case for including SMART in your will and estate planning. Furthermore,
when an individual requests information, we will personally call them and invite them for
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 45
a SMART tour, meet with them personally to begin a long term relationship, and engage
• A document that provides more detailed guidance to planned giving, explaining the tax
100k
Field of
Letters Radio Spots/
Mailing Mail all Dreams
Founders Event June 15 and SMART site Jersey Order
List items Event
Invites Tour
Held
Hand- 100k
Follow
written
up Friendsgiving Holiday
Founders Event June 15 Thank Meetings Retreat
phone Dinner Cards
You
calls
letters
The five-year financial forecast which follows is based on the following set of
A. Income-related Assumptions
A founder’s campaign will be established to raise 300,000 for three years or a total of
$900,000 for operating expenses to launch “SMART stores”. As part of the founder’s
campaign, an additional $300,000 will be raised for capital improvements for future stores and
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 47
warehouse facilities. The School Box Program partnership with Cincinnati, Ohio may be
managed by “SMART stores” beginning in fiscal year 2023. This will contribute potentially a
break-even or positive cash flow taking into account related income and expenses. In the
accounting for many Free Stores, donated goods are booked as income (value) annually related
to their valuation by the store to determine the real size of the financial impact of the store in
local communities.
At the end of five years of operation, at the close of FY 2023, the financial model
illustrates “SMART stores” with a possible cash reserve of $419,576. This is approximately
3.8% of the total income, including in-kind donations. Since the project is the start-up of a new
organization, a possible margin of error is helpful to assure the stability of “SMART stores”.
This reserve could be designated to endowment in 2023 to further secure the store’s future.
B. Expense-related Assumptions
Net operating costs for “SMART stores” are anticipated to be approximately $371,500
per year based on a full fiscal year of operations in 2019. In many Free Store operations, the
cost of goods distributed (given away for free to teachers) are booked as an expense offsetting
their corresponding donated value which appears as income on their financial statements. This
is done to determine the true size and scope of Free Store operations and the value of goods
References
http://www.marshall.edu/ucomm/2017/04/27/marshall-students-work-solve-west-
virginias-biggest-challenges/
Barton, Noelle., & Wasley, Paula. (2008). Online Giving Survey. Chronicle of
Philanthropy.
Bate, Sandra. (2011). Marketing and Communications for Fundrasing. In E.R. Tempel, T.L.
Seiler, & E.E. Aldrich (3rd Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising (pp 362-374).
Beard, Laura. (2016, October 27). Put Me In, Coach: nine lessons those who work in higher
education can learn from baseball. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved from:
https://www.insidehighered.com/advice/2016/10/27/career-lessons-higher-education-
can-learn-baseball-essay
https://behappy.me/education-is-like-a-baseball-game-it-needs-all-of-its-players-
parent-teacher-community-student-285169
Brown, Melissa S., & Kou, Xiaonan. (2011). Giving differences among the generations. In
E.R. Tempel, T.L. Seiler, & E.E. Aldrich (3rd Edition), Achieving Excellence in
Fundraising (pp 199-210). San Francisco, CA: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Burlingame, Dwight F. (2011). Corporate Giving and Fundraising. In E.R. Tempel, T.L.
Seiler, & E.E. Aldrich (3rd Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising (pp 138-
Census Viewer. (2010). Population of McDowell County, West Virginia. Retrieved from:
http://censusviewer.com/county/WV/McDowell
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 50
Davis, Gwendolyn Perry. (2011). Foundation Fundraising. In E.R. Tempel, T.L. Seiler, &
E.E. Aldrich (3rd Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising (pp 150-161). San
Gattle, Kim. (2011). Personal Solicitation. In E.R. Tempel, T.L. Seiler, & E.E. Aldrich (3rd
Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising (pp 213-222). San Francisco, CA: John
Huehls, Frances. (2011). Resources for Strengthening Fundraising. In E.R. Tempel, T.L.
Seiler, & E.E. Aldrich (3rd Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising (pp 453-461).
https://archive.ama.org/archive/ResourceLibrary/documents/Spending_Forecast_Gro
wth_Rate.pdf
Klein, Kim. (2011). Fundraising for Grassroots Nonprofits. In E.R. Tempel, T.L. Seiler, & E.E.
content/uploads/2013/08/StrategicBusiness&OperatingFeasibilityStudy7.23.07
http://www.crayons2computers.org/about
https://static1.squarespace.com/static/576d20679de4bb8477fa4306/t/59656fda03596e
3fa1142828/1499820012830/AnnualReport_2016_Final.pdf
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 51
ry6f.squarespace.com/mission-history-2#mission-history-3
http://www.crayons2computers.org/programs
Donahue, Roberta L. (2011). Special Events. In E.R. Tempel, T.L. Seiler, & E.E. Aldrich (3rd
Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising (pp 247-255). San Francisco, CA: John
Tempel, T.L. Seiler, & E.E. Aldrich (3rd Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising
(pp 349-361). San Francisco, CA: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
https://www.desmogblog.com/sites/beta.desmogblog.com/files/%281-15-
2012%29%202012%20Fundraising%20Plan.pdf
Hodge, James A. (2011). Major Gifts. In E.R. Tempel, T.L. Seiler, & E.E. Aldrich (3rd
Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising (pp 64-80). San Francisco, CA: John
Kids in Need Foundation. (n.d.) Starting a Resource Center or Teacher Free Store Part I
Kids in Need Foundation. (n.d.) Starting a Resource Center or Teacher Free Store Part II
Martin, Vicky. (2011). Prospect Research. In E.R. Tempel, T.L. Seiler, & E.E. Aldrich (3rd
Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising (pp 125-137). San Francisco, CA: John
http://www.northlandfdn.org/convening/keeley1009/fundraising.pdf
http://www.oldcolony.com/s/wv/mc-dowell-county/welch/24801/21-mc-dowell-
street/dmgid_115480494.html
Quinn, Ryan. (2016, February 16). WV extends national lead in school breakfast
http://www.wvgazettemail.com/news/20160216/wv-extends-national-lead-in-school-
breakfast-participation
Regenovich, Dean. (2011). Establishing a Planned Giving Program. In E.R. Tempel, T.L.
Seiler, & E.E. Aldrich (3rd Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising (pp 92-114).
http://www.tamariskcoalition.org/sites/default/files/resource-center-
documents/Fundraising%20Plan%20Model%20-Spring%202014.pdf
Rosso, Henry A. (2003). The Fundraising Cycle. In E.R. Tempel, T.L. Seiler, & E.E.
Aldrich (2nd Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising (pp 24). San Francisco,
Rosso, Henry A. (2011). The Annual Fund. In E.R. Tempel, T.L. Seiler, & E.E. Aldrich (3rd
Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising (pp 51-63). San Francisco, CA: John
Sanders, Bernie. (n.d.) The Great Divide: Life in McDowell County. Retrieved from:
https://www.sanders.senate.gov/life-in-mcdowell-county
STRATEGIC FUNDRAISING PLAN Artayet Shepherd 53
Seiler, Timothy L. (2011). Plan to Succeed. In E.R. Tempel, T.L. Seiler, & E.E. Aldrich (3rd
Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising (pp 10-17). San Francisco, CA: John
Seiler, Timothy L., & Aldrich, Eva E. (2011). Developing and Articulating a Case for
Support. In E.R. Tempel, T.L. Seiler, & E.E. Aldrich (3rd Edition), Achieving
Excellence in Fundraising (pp 27-38). San Francisco, CA: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Seiler, Timothy L. (2011). The Total Development Plan. In E.R. Tempel, T.L. Seiler, & E.E.
Aldrich (3rd Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising (pp 41-50). San Francisco,
Stanger, Jeff. (2011). E-mail and internet solicitation. In E.R. Tempel, T.L. Seiler, & E.E.
United States Census Bureau. (2016). QuickFacts West Virginia. Retrieved from:
https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/WV
Warwick, Mal. (2011). Direct Mail Marketing. In E.R. Tempel, T.L. Seiler, & E.E. Aldrich
(3rd Edition), Achieving Excellence in Fundraising (pp 223-234). San Francisco, CA:
West Virginia Healthy Kids and Families Coalition. (2013). Child Poverty in West Virginia:
http://www.legis.state.wv.us/senate1/majority/poverty/WV%20Child%20Poverty%20
Report%20February%2019%202013%20WVCBP%20-%20Ted%20Boettner.pdf
West Virginia Higher Education Policy Commission. (2017, July 25). Student Success
http://www.wvhepc.edu/student-success-summit-to-focus-on-collaboration-across-
education-systems/
http://wvde.state.wv.us/ocn-download/Forms/NSLP/Scorecard/2016Scorecard.pdf
https://www.worldvision.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/2016-annual-report-
brochure.pdf
http://www.worldvisionusprograms.org/appalachia_trc.php