Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
1. INTRODUCTION
1
The modern trend in interconnected operation of power systems for the purpose of
reliability and in increasing unit size of generators for the purposes of economy has
been mainly, responsible for the evolution of new excitation schemes.
DC Excitation System:
This excitation system utilizes DC generators as source of excitation power. It also
provides current to the rotor of synchronous machine through slip rings. The exciter can
be driven by a motor or shaft of a generator. It can be either self-excited or separately
excited. When it is separately excited, the exciter field current is supplied by a pilot
2
exciter comprising of a permanent magnet generator. DC excitation systems represent
early systems, spanning the years from the 1920s to the 1960s. They lost favor in the
mid1960s and were superseded by ac excitation systems.
AC Excitation System:
These excitation systems utilize alternators as source of generator excitation power.
Usually, the exciter is kept on the same shaft as the turbine generator. The AC output of
the exciter is rectified by either controlled or diode rectifiers to produce the direct
current which is needed for the generator field. The rectifiers can be stationary or
rotating. AC excitation systems can take many forms depending on the rectifier
arrangement, method of exciter output control, and source of excitation for the exciter.
Currently, stationary and rotating AC rectifier systems are widely used in AC excitation
systems. In stationary rectifiers, the DC output is fed to the field winding of the
generator through the slip rings. On the other hand, in rotating rectifiers there is no need
of slip rings and brushes. The DC supply is directly fed to the generator field as the
armature of the exciter and rectifiers rotate with the generator field. Such systems are
known as brush-less systems and were developed to avoid the problems with brushes
when extremely high field currents are applied to large generators.
3
a. Rotating Thyristor Excitation System
The rotor excitation system is shown in the figure below. The rotating portion is being
enclosed by the dashed line. This system consists an AC exciter, stationary field and a
rotating armature. The output of the exciter is rectified by a full wave thyristor bridge
rectifier circuit and is supplied to the main alternator field winding.
The alternator field winding is also supplied through another rectifier circuit. The
exciter voltage can be built up by using it residual flux. The power supply and rectifier
control generate the controlled triggering signal. The alternator voltage signal is
averaged and compare directly with the operator voltage adjustment in the auto mode of
operation. In the manual mode of operation, the excitation current of the alternator is
compared with a separate manual voltage adjustment.
4
b. Brushless Excitation System
This system is shown in the figure below. The rotating portion being enclosed by a
dashed line rectangle. The brushless excitation system consists an alternator, rectifier,
main exciter and a permanent magnet generator alternator. The main and the pilot
exciter are driven by the main shaft. The main exciter has a stationary field and a
rotating armature directly connected, through the silicon rectifiers to the field of the
main alternators.
5
Fig.4 Brushless Excitation System
6
Its excitation parameters are dependent on grip parameters.
7
Figure 6. Block Diagram of Static Excitation system.
In the system DC power source is of rotating type, which in normally coupled to the
main generator rotor.
Brushless Rotating:
8
The excitation requires very large problem of conveying such amount of power through
high speed sliding contacts becomes formidable and at present large synchronous
Generator and motor are using brushless excitation system. Brushless exciter is small
direct coupled ac generator with its field circuit on stator and from circuit on motor the
3 phase output of ac exciter generator is rectified by solid state rectifier. The rectified
output is directly connected to the field winding, thus eliminating the use of brushes
and slip ring. The DC exciter suffered commutation and brush gear problem but also
offered certain advantages. Increased demand for higher excitation currents parallel by
advances in semiconductor technology brought about the introduction of the rectified ac
exciter. These where either static semiconductor diode rectifiers supplying the generator
field winding via slip ring, or brushless system which carry the diode rectifier on shaft .
To maximize the plant availability under black start condition, reliance on
external electrical supplies is kept minimum by using direct driven permanent magnet
pilot exciters. The development of solid state silicon diode with its inherent robustness
and reliability, made possible the design of compact rectifier system that can be rotated
at rated generator speed.
9
Fig.8 Brushless Exciter
10
CHAPTER-2
2. LITERATURE SURVEY
11
enables to improve the rated capacity limits of the synchronous machines. The main
components of an excitation system are automatic voltage regulator (AVR), exciter,
measuring elements, power system stabilizer (PSS) and protection unit. The excitation
systems can be divided into different categories. In the following section, the detail
discussion of the different categories of the excitation systems is provided.
2.3 Digital Excitation System for Synchronous Generator Manish PrajapatiA, Jigar
Patel B, Dr Hina ChandwaniC and Mr Vinod Patel D, Journal of Electrical Engineering.
Automatic voltage controllers for synchronous generators have traditionally utilized
analog electronics. Modern voltage control systems are beginning to utilize the power,
flexibility, and cost advantages of Digital Signal Processor for control. Digital
excitation systems is a DSP based controlled devices. Digital excitation systems play a
significant role in providing fast and accurate voltage control to the power system. In
12
order to maintain system stability in interconnected system network it is necessary to
have fast acting excitation system for large synchronous machines which means the
field current must be adjusted extremely fast to the changing operational conditions.
This paper deals with the design and simulation of a Digital excitation system for
Synchronous generator excitation systems to improve the steady-state and transient
stabilities. The performance of the proposed system is examined for voltage control
application of synchronous Generator through simulation studies using the Psim
software package.
2.4 Excitation systems: the current state of the art, Power Engineering Society
General Meeting, 2006. IEEE Synchronous machine excitation systems have advanced
significantly in the past few years. Digital technology has made a major impact on these
systems, allowing new and improved features and functionality. This paper reviews the
current state of the art in excitation systems and address the progress made in the
industry on improving these systems
CHAPTER-3
3. EXISTING SYSTEM
13
produces an additional signal into control loop and in that way compensates voltage
oscillations. The typical range of oscillation frequencies, given is of 0.1 to 3.0 Hz and
insufficient damping of these oscillations may limit the ability to transmit power. PSS
input quantities may be speed deviation, generator active power, frequency deviation,
transient electromotive force and generator current. Usually two of these input
quantities are chosen to get optimal regulation. Measuring elements are used to obtain
excitation system input values. Generator armature voltage is always measured and
measurements of armature current and the excitation current and voltage are optional.
Limitation and protection unit contains larger number of circuits which ensure that
certain physical values (e.g. generator armature voltage, excitation current, etc.) are
limited.
14
of these systems, inability of generator deexcitation. Another disadvantage is slower
response of system, especially in case of low excitation. Self-excitation system
advantages are simplicity and low costs. Thyristor or transistor bridge is supplied from
generator terminals via transformer. The main disadvantage is that excitation supply
voltage, and thereby excitation current, depends directly on generator output voltage.
Brushless self-excitation systems with diode bridge also exist.
To examine the operation of synchronous generator and its excitation system and to
determine how synchronous generator affects electric power system stability
mathematical models of generator and excitation system are developed. Changes of
reference values and disturbances that are typical for real systems are also modeled.
Since a large number of excitation systems for synchronous generators exist in practice,
classification of excitation system models was necessary. IEEE issued Recommended
Practice for Excitation System Models for Power Stability Studies, document which
classifies excitation systems introduced in engineering practice so far. There are three
major groups of generator excitation systems, with nineteen different excitation system
models altogether: Direct Current Commutator Exciters (type DC), Alternator Supplied
Rectifier Excitation Systems (type AC) and Static Excitation Systems (type ST).
15
There are three main properties of excitation systems that must be considered in
regulation: speed of system operation, autonomy of excitation system and maximal
drive security. Speed of operation is important to maintain stability of electric power
system in the meaning of reactive power transmitting and receiving, fast deexcitation in
case of internal failure and overvoltage limitation in case of sudden unloading.
Autonomy of excitation systems means that excitation system supply must be ensured
in every condition of a drive. Drive security is function of reliabilities of all
incorporated components. To insure maximal drive security, components are
overdimensioned. All of excitation system models given above include linear
controllers. Linear controllers are made of combination of three basic elements:
proportional (P), integral (I) and derivative (D). Types of linear regulators in common
use are: P, PI and PID controller. Lead-lag is also a type of linear controller which
improves an undesirable frequency respond by introducing pole-zero pair. P controller
is the simplest controller for it has only one parameter. Main disadvantage of this
controller is divergence in stationary state. The increase of gain (i.e. increase of
regulator parameter value) reduces this divergence, but also decreases stability of the
system. PI controller eliminates divergence in stationary state. Disadvantage of this
controller is that integral gain decreases system dynamics and increases phase delay,
which also decreases system stability. PID controller has additional derivative element
which responds to divergence change speed, increases system dynamics and
compensates system deceleration caused by integral element. Parameters of linear
controllers may be adjusted using analytical or experimental methods. Analytical
methods for parameter adjustment require mathematical model of the whole regulation
system. Synchronous generator model is nonlinear system, hence system linearization
is needed. Parameters adjusted this way are valid in the operation point region. If the
synchronous generator operating point is changed, parameters must be readjusted.
Experimental methods do not require knowledge of system mathematical model, but
also give optimal parameters only in the region of operation point in which experiment
was performed.
16
Linear controllers yield good regulation properties of synchronous generator operation
in stationary state, i.e. in one operating point. In practice, it is important to maintain
system stability in transition state of synchronous generator or electric power system,
e.g. synchronous generator synchronization, short circuit in electric power system, etc.
To achieve stability during transition state, operation with nonlinear models and
controllers is required. Methods for construction such controllers are newly developed
and are not widely used in practice. Three of these methods will be explained in this
chapter: neural networks, fuzzy control and adaptive control. The operational value
which provides virtually direct information about the generator working point position
in relation to the stability limit is the load angle of the operating synchronous generator
on the electric power system. Transition from one to another steady operating condition
is often accompanied by significant changes in the dynamic load angle [6]. Information
about change of the load angle can be used in implementation of the PSS stabilizer, as
an input signal. Load angle can be measured or estimated. Direct measurement requires
implementation of special measuring elements, and is rarely used solution. More often,
load angle is determined from values that can be measured more easily, e.g. rotor
mechanical angle and electrical angle of the base harmonic of rotating magnetic field,
or electrical values together with parameters of system model.
The most novel method for load angle estimation is use of neural networks. In [6]
double dynamic neural network is used. Estimation results show high accuracy in the
process of load angle estimation. The network learned in such a way can be
implemented into the digitized excitation as software extension. It is also concluded
that another dynamic neural networks can be applied in the realization of additional
excitation system regulator functions whereat additional measurements are not
necessary. Another type of nonlinear regulation is Fuzzy controller. Fuzzy controller
uses fuzzy sets, linguistic variables, possibility distributions and fuzzy rules, thus has a
very simple structure. An example of simple fuzzy logic excitation control of a
synchronous generator is explained in [4]. Introduced controller type is used for voltage
control and generator stabilization. The main advantage is that there is no need of
knowing electric power system mathematical model, which is highly nonlinear. The
fuzzy controller has two control loops: voltage control loop and damping control loop,
and in that way unifies AVR and PSS. Simulation and experiment indicated that,
17
compared to linear PI voltage controller and conventional PSS, fuzzy controller shows
improved static as well as dynamic operating conditions. Adaptive control is special
form of regulation in which system parameter information are acquired in operation
cycle, i.e. on-line. Adaptive regulator compensates influence of disturbance (input value
in system, parameter or structural change). It consists of two closed loops: negative
feedback and adaptive feedback. Negative feedback ensures process stability with
classic linear regulator (e.g. PI regulator). Adaptive feedback is nonlinear mechanism
that consists of algorithm for compensation of parameter changes in regulated system.
There are three types of adaptive control: Gain Scheduling, Model Reference Adaptive
Control and Self Tuning Control. This is effective regulation method for systems with
slow but significant parameter changes.
CHAPTER-4
4. PROPOSED SYSTEM
18
auxiliary control, limiting and protection functions. Limiting function generally have no
role under normal operating condition. It is only when the synchronous machine is
pushed beyond its operating capability that these limiters are brought in to play. In
addition the Digital excitation performs control and protective function essential to the
satisfactory performance of the power system by controlling the field voltage and field
current.
Many researchers are worked in the design and optimized of the AVR. The objective is
to maintain the terminal voltage as a constant at the operating points. The main
19
requirements for designing the AVR are fast response, small overshoot and zero steady-
state error to the deviation of the reference voltage.
Digital voltage regulator regulates the generator voltage by controlling the firing angle
of thyristor. It is designed for synchronous generator utilizing anti windup PI controller,
to keep the terminal voltage of the generator to the rated value. In DVR a reference
Voltage “Vref” is compare with a sensed terminal voltage Vt. If it determines that the
generator voltage is incorrect, it produces an error signal, this error signal passes to the
firing circuit. There, it overrides the control signal and causes the firing angle of
thyristor rectifier to restore generator voltage to a desired level.
security of the parallel operation but makes operation of the system easier. However
limiters do not replace the protection system but only prevent the protection system
from tripping unnecessarily under extreme transient conditions. The static excitation
system is equipped with three limiters which act in conjunction with the AVR. These
limiters are as under;
The excitation limiter tested as a summing point type device acting upon the set-pint of
the automatic voltage regulator to provide restrictive control of the machine.
The maximum excitation limiter senses the field current of the generator and similarly
acts upon the set-point of the voltage regulator to restrict control of the machine where
operation is undesirable. The capability of the generator in the overexcited region is
limited by the capability of cooling the field winding and the overall MVA output
(stator current) of the machine. The overexcited region of the machine is referred to as
lagging power factor, where VAR are being supplied from the machine. Over excitation
Limiter or Maximum Excitation Limiter senses the field current output of static exciter
and limits the field current to prevent field overheating. Two OEL current levels are
defined for off line operation. They are high and low as shown in the Fig. 2. The
generator can operate continuously at the low OEL current level and for a programmed
time at the high OEL current level. Over excitation limiter avoids thermal overloading
21
of the rotor winding and is provided to protect the generator rotor against excessively
long duration over loads.
FIELDCURRENT
High current
Level
High
Low current
Current Continuous
Level
Time
TIME IN SECONDS
The purpose of over excitation limiter is to protect the generator from overheating due
to the prolonged field current. The generator field winding is designed to operate
continuously at a value corresponding to rated load condition. The over excitation
limiting function typically detects the high field current condition and after a time
delay, acts through the regulator to ramp down the excitation to a present value.
(typically 100 % to 110 % of rated field current). If this is unsuccessful, it trips the
breaker and a unit trip. Two types of time delay are used: (a) fixed time and (b) inverse
time. The fixed time limiter operates when the field current exceeds the pickup value
for a fixed set time, irrespective of the degree of over excitation. The inverse time
limiter operates with the time delay matching the field thermal capability. The OEL
controller is normally implemented as either “Take over” or a “summing” type
controller. The summing type controller is considered here. The OEL make up the inner
loop of the voltage regulator and use a PI controller. The actual exciter field current in
Amperes is used for the OEL models and the OEL output is added to the summing point
of the voltage regulator. When it is above the limit, the OEL limiter output becomes less
than the AVR output and the OEL takes over to control at a proper excitation level.
When the OEL is active, the AVR loop stops integration and compares its output with
the OEL output to get out of the OEL loop.
22
4.5. UNDER EXCITATION LIMITERS
Under excitation limiters are included in most modern voltage regulators
applied on large synchronous generators. An under excitation limiter (UEL) acts to
boost excitation whenever it senses a condition in which generator excitation level is
determined to be too low. The UEL typically senses either a combination of voltage and
current of the synchronous machine or a combination of real and reactive power. The
limits are determined by machine operating point crossing a reference level or
characteristic. When the reference level or characteristic is crossed, the UEL output
signal acts to become a part of the control of the excitation system. The UEL output is
applied in the voltage regulator either to a summing junction to add the normal voltage
control or to a high value (HV) gate to override the normal action of the voltage
regulator. Depending upon the implementation of the UEL function to control
excitation, the action of the UEL could take the voltage regulator out of service and/or
cause interactions which may not normally occur during normal operation when the
UEL characteristic is not reached.
23
Summing junction point of AVR.
vars P6, Q6
in (-)
P4, Q4
P3, Q3 UEL
P1, Q1 P2, Q2 LIMITING
REFERENCE STATOR
CURRENT
HIGH
CUT DOWN
FOR RESET
LOW
SCT 1 SCT 2
The SCL current reference is generated based on a two-step waveform with a high
current level and a low current level as shown in Fig. 4. For excessive inductive current
24
it acts over the AVR after a certain time lag and decreases the excitation current to limit
the inductive current to the limit value. But for excessive capacitive current it acts on
the AVR without time delay to increase the Excitation and thereby reduce the capacitive
loading. This is necessary as there is a risk for the machine failing out of step during
under excited mode of operation.
25
Figure 15: Excitation system control and protective circuits
AC Regulator:
Its basic function is to maintain generator stator voltage. In addition, other auxiliaries
act through the ac regulator.
DC Regulator:
It holds constant generator field voltage (manual control). It is used for testing and
startup, and when ac regulator is faulty
Excitation System Stabilizing Circuits:
Excitation systems with significant time delays have poor inherent dynamic
performance unless very low steady-state regulator gain is used, the control action is
unstable when generator is on open-circuit. Series or feedback compensation is used to
26
improve the dynamic response. The most commonly used form of compensation is a
derivative feedback.
Load Compensator:
It is used to regulate a voltage at a point either within or external to the generator
achieved by building additional circuitry into the AVR loop with RC and XC positive,
the compensator regulates a voltage at a point within the generator and used to ensure
proper sharing VARs between generators bussed together at their terminals.
It is commonly used with hydro units and cross-compound thermal units with RC and
XC negative, the compensator regulates voltage at a point beyond the generator
terminals and to compensate for voltage drop across step-up transformer when
generators are connected through individual transformers.
27
Fig.17 Load compensator
COOLING OF EXCITER:
The exciter is air cooled. The cooling air is circulated in a close circuit and re-cooled
in two cooler sections arranged alongside the exciter. The complete exciter is house in
an enclosure through which the cooling air circulates. The rectifier wheels, house in
their own enclosure, draw the cool air in at both ends and expel the warmed air to the
compartment beneath the base plate. The main exciter enclosure receives cool air
from the fan after it passes over the pilot exciter. The air enters the main exciter from
both ends and is passed into ducts below the rotor body and discharged through radial
slots in the rotor core to the lower compartment. The warm air is then returned to the
main enclosure via the cooler sections.
Hydrogen cooling:
Hydrogen cooled synchronous condensers operating at speed up to 900 r.p.m. have
been furnished with direct connected main exciter located in hydrogen filled
compartment which can be isolated from the main condenser compartment when
maintenance is to be done on the exciter. It has been found that hydrogen cooling of
exciter not only reduces the temperature rise of exciter but also decreases the wear of
the commutator and brushes. Hydrogen cooling has been proposed for the exciters of
28
turbo generator.
Emergency Cooling of Exciter:
Emergency cooling is provided to permit continued operation in the event of cooler
failure. In such an emergency, flaps in the hot and cold air compartments are
automatically operated by actuators admitting cold air from outside the exciter
enclosure and discharging the hot air through openings in base frame.
29
Fuse monitoring system
Ground fault detection system
Excitation current measuring device
Temperature monitoring system:
The exciter is provided with devices for monitoring the temperature of the cold air after
the exciter cooler and the hot air leaving the rectifier wheels and main exciter.
Fuse monitoring system: The indicator flags of the fuses on the rectifier wheels may
be checked during operation with the built in stroboscope.
Ground fault detection system:
Two slip rings are installed on the shaft between the main exciter and the bearing. One
is connected to the star point of the three phases winding of the main exciter and the
other to the Frame. These slip rings permit ground fault detection. The field ground
fault detection system detects high resistance and low resistance ground faults in the
exciter field circuit. It is very important for safe operation of a generator, because a
double fault causes magnetic unbalance with very high currents flowing through the
faulted part, resulting in its destruction within a very short time. If the field ground fault
detection system detects a ground faults, an alarm is activated at Resistance < 80kΏ
(1st stage).if the insulation resistance between the exciter field circuit and ground
either suddenly or slowly drops to Resistance < 5kΏ the generator electrical protection
is tripped (2nd stage).The generator is thus automatically disconnected from the system
and deexcited.
Excitation current measuring device:
The excitation current is measured indirectly through a coil arranged between two poles
of the main exciter. The voltage induced in this coil is proportional to the main
excitation current thus enabling a determination of the excitation current.
Advantages of a Digital Excitation System
Features of the new "Digital" Static Excitation and Voltage Regulator interface that we
enjoy working with include the Data Logging (Oscillography), Sequence Events
Recording, Trending and Real-Time Dynamic System Analyzers. These can be set up
and accessed easily by a laptop and greatly aid in system testing and in the
troubleshooting and analyzing of System problems, such as caused by System
disturbances. We can now record the performance of the System both before and after
any System disturbance.
30
Generator Voltage Softstart that will prevent voltage overshoot during machine
startup.
Automatic Nulling to prevent bumps in Voltage and VARs when transferring
between Automatic Voltage Regulator and the Manual Voltage Regulator
control.
Automatic Voltage Matching between the Generator and the Bus Voltage to
prevent VAR exchange / bumps when paralleling.
VAR / Power Factor Controller, to be utilized if VAR control or PF Control can
be utilized within this Generating System, selectable by the Operator whenever
it is needed.
Summing-Point Type or Takeover Type Offline & Online Maximum Excitation
Limiting to prevent rotor damage due to excessively long overexcitation
periods.
Under Excitation Limiting to prevent too little excitation to be applied into the
Field based upon the kWs being exported.
Stator Current Limiting to prevent sustained overheating of the Stator Windings.
Generator Protection including Loss of Field, Under/Overvoltage, Field Over
current, Field Overvoltage, Field Over temperature, and Loss of PT Voltage
Sensing, Volts Per Hertz.
Under frequency or selectable Volts/Hertz Ratio Limiting to prevent the
machine from being over flux at low operating frequency.
Modbus Communication Port available to interface to existing Plant DCS
Systems for both control and monitoring of the new "Digital" Control System.
As an option, the Modbus TMCommunication Port could be connected directly
to a Remote Display Panel, such as the {E2ROIP Remote Operator Interface
Panel} for remote control and monitoring of the new "Digital" Control System
and all of the associated devices.
31
CONCLUSION
In this paper Digital excitation system using thyristor rectifier converter is discussed. In
order to improve the generator stability under unbalanced conditions, this generator
excitation system is proposed. This excitation system gives better stability than a
conventional excitation system. The performance of the proposed excitation system has
been verified through computer simulation. The over excitation, under excitation and
32
stator current limiter allows operating for a period of time within the machine or
equipment limits until corrective measures can be taken, even when failure. For these
reasons, limiters used on generation provide both performance and economic benefits
to the user, to insure reliable power generation.
REFERENCES
33
2. Chan-Ki Kim, Hong-Woo Rhew and Yoon Ho Kim, “Stability performance of
new static excitation system with boost-buck converter” Korea Electric Power
Research Institute (KEPRI) 103-12 Munji-Dong, Yusung-Gu, Daejon, KOREA.
6. P. Kundur, Power System Stability and Control, McGraw-Hill, Inc., New York,
1993, pp. 333-369.
8. A. Murdoch, and G.E. Boukarim, M.J. D „Antonio and RA. Lawson “Generator
Over Excitation Capability And Excitation System Limiters” Panel Session
Summary for the JEEE/PES 2001 WPM, CoIumbus, OH
9. A. Godhwani, K. Kim, M.J. Basler, “An Under and Over Excitation Limiter
Implementation in a Digital Excitation System for Synchronous Generators” 0-
7803-4403-0/98/-1998 IEEE
10. Joseph D. Hurley, “Under excitation Limiter Models for Power System Stability
Studies” 0-7803-9156-X/05-2005-IEEE
34
11. M. Rabiul Alam, Rajib Baran Roy, S.M. Jahangir Alam , Dewan Juel Rahman
“Single Phase Automatic Voltage Regulator Design for Synchronous Generator”
International Journal of Electrical & Computer Sciences IJECS-IJENS Vol 11
year 2011.
12. Gaing, Z. L., “A Particle Swarm Optimization Approach for Optimum Design
of PID Controller in AVR System,” IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion,
Volume 19, pp. 384-394 year 2004.
14. S.Panda,B.K. Sahu ,P.K. Mohanty “Design And Performance Analysis Of PID
Controller for An Automatic Voltage Regulator System Using Simplified
Particle Swarm Optimization” Volume 349, Issue 8, Page 2609–2625 October
2012.
17. Yinggan Tang, Liheng Zhao, Zhenzhen Han, Xiangwei Bi, Xinping Guan
“Optimal gray PID controller design for automatic voltage regulator system via
imperialist competitive algorithm” International Journal of Machine Learning
and Cybernetics Volume 7, Issue 2, pp 229–240 year April 2016.
35
18. J. Kennedy and R. Eberhart, “Particle Swarm Optimization” in Proceding IEEE
International Conference Neural Networks, vol. IV, Perth, Australia, , pp. 1942–
1948 year 1995
25. S.-R. Qi , D.-F. Wang , P. Han and Y.-H. Li, "Grey Prediction Based RBF
Neural Networkself-Tuning PID Control For Turning Process",in Proceding
IEEE International Conference pp. 802-805, 2004
36
An Integrated Environment for Rapid Control Prototyping", IEEE Transaction
Industrial Applications, vol. 44, no. 4, 1090-1098, 2008
31. D. Devaraj and B. Selvabala, "Real-coded genetic algorithm and fuzzy logic
approach for real-timetuning of proportional-integral-derivative controller in
automatic voltage regulator system", IET Generation Transmission Distribution,
vol. 3, no. 7, pp. 641-649, 2009
37
34. V. Mukherjee and S. P. Ghoshal, "Intelligent particle swarm optimizedfuzzy PID
controller for AVR system", Electr. Power Syst. Res., vol. 77, no. 12, pp. 1689-
1698, 2007
35. J. S. Chiou and M.-T. Liu, "Numerical simulation for fuzzy-PIDcontrollers and
helping EP reproduction with PSO hybrid algorithm", Simulation
ModelingPractice Theory, vol. 17, no. 10, pp. 1555-1565, 2009
37. C.-C. Hwang , L.-Y. Lyu , C.-T. Liu and P.-L. Li, "Optimal design of an SPM
motor using geneticalgorithms and Taguchi method", IEEE Trans. Magn., vol.
44, pp. 4325-4328, 2008
38