Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
A Research Proposal
Presented to the Graduate School of
Negros Oriental State University
In Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements for the Course
Methodology of Research in
Master of Science in Mathematics
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DEDICATION………………………………………………………………………….....
ACKNOWLEDGMENT .....................................................................................................
ABSTRACT ..........................................................................................................................
Theoretical/Conceptual Framework.................................................................................
Research Design...............................................................................................................
Methodology ....................................................................................................................
Research Instrument.........................................................................................................
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 4
Conclusions ......................................................................................................................
Recommendations ............................................................................................................
BIBLIOGRAPHY ................................................................................................................
APPENDICES ......................................................................................................................
Chapter 1
Introduction
The Philippines was the last country in Asia having a 10-year basic education and pre-
university program (SEAMEO & INNOTECH, 2012). Worldwide, the Philippines were joined
by Djibouti and Angola of Africa having the shortest pre-university education system with other
countries having 13 or 14-year cycles (Senate of the Philippines, 2011). This has always been
seen as a disadvantage for the students who are competing in an increasingly global job
market. Therefore, the longer educational cycle of the K-12 curriculum was implemented with
the main objective which to provide Filipino students a higher quality of education making them
more prepared to enter the labor force. The 12 years or more is in accordance with international
practice as stipulated in the Washington Accord, Bologna Process as well as in the ASEAN and
APEC Mutual Recognition Projects and much more. The much-needed overhaul of the
Philippine basic education system becomes a reality through Republic Act 10533, also known as
the Enhanced Basic Education Act which was passed last May 2013 making the preuniversity
and basic education from 10 to 13 years (Congress of the Philippines, 2011). The enhanced basic
education program encompasses at least one (1) year of kindergarten, six (6) years of elementary,
and six (6) years in secondary education; the secondary education has four (4) years of junior
high school and two (2) years of senior high school education.
Best educational systems are often identified based on the performance of students in the
international standardized examinations. In the world, East Asian countries like Singapore,
Hongkong SAR, Korea, Chinese Taipei and Japan ranks top in the 2015 International
Mathematics Achievement for Grade 4 and Grade 8 (TIMSS & PIRLS 1, 2015).
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 6
But Philippines is still ranks 65th in the world. A Science and Education Institute study
on Trends in Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) in 2003 showed that Philippines’ 8th
grade (2nd year high school) students’ skills and competencies in Math ranked a pitiful 42nd out
of 46 participating countries while the Philippine 4th grade students placed 23rd out of 25
participating countries. The 2004 executive report on Philippine TIMSS showed that in four
years since the Third International Mathematics and Science Study Repeat (TIMSS-R) in 1999,
only seven regions showed improvements in Math competencies among the 8th grade students.
Results of the student achievement test indicate very poor performance in each content domain at
this early education stage. The problem seems to be double-edged, with the students’ lack of
interest to the lack of professionals who can teach Math and Science. Those who teach Math and
Science in public schools are not Math and Science majors, but Education majors that may lack
general. Education, being one of the basic rights of a child, should be given to him in its fullest
The country, being a signatory to the Millenium Development Goal, which states that “by
2015, children everywhere, boys and girls alike, will be able to complete a full course of primary
schooling,” has the responsibility to give each Filipino child the kind of education he deserves.
envision the Philippines to be solving the problems of Reodica which is the first step in
This study aimed to assess and compare Philippine K-12 Mathematics Curriculum
1. What are the standards of the Mathematics, and Mathematics Revised Basic
curriculum in Singapore?
This study will be of greater help for further development and possible revision of
DepEd (PHILIPPINES)
This will help to review and improve educational practice in the department.
Further, this research will also provide suggestions for strengthening the research-to-
practice channel.
Practitioners have to comply with policies, and teachers are accountable for what
learners learn. This research gives teachers the tools to analyze and make informed
decisions about their practice. This will guide them on what competencies or learning
Researchers
Future Researchers
This study will serve as future reference in enhancing their research regarding
The research aims to identify the most significant differences and similarities
between the Mathematics Philippine revised curriculum (RBEC) and the Mathematics K-
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 9
12 Curriculum with Singapores. Without claiming a direct causal link between the nature
of the intended curriculum and student outcomes, the research uses student performance
various countries. The crucial issue of classroom practices and the quality and nature of
the schooling system in general is not taken into account in the research. However, we do
provide some context below regarding the countries involved in the study and their
schooling systems. The duration of this study is intended only for seven months –
There are few factors that are beyond the control of the researchers such as: lack
of available and/or reliable data on the curriculum of other countries, conflicting business
C. Definition of Terms
school or in a specific course or program. It also refers to the knowledge and skills
students are expected to learn, which includes the learning standards or learning
objectives they are expected to meet; the units and lessons that teachers teach; the
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 10
assignments and projects given to students; the books, materials, videos, presentations,
and readings used in a course; and the tests, assessments, and other methods used to
CONTENT – are the specific subject areas such as Algebra, Trigonometry, Calculus and
etc.
by the learners.
D. Conceptual Framework
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 11
Singapore has a superior education system. It has earned the title of being the best
education system in the world because of its success in international academic competitions in
science and mathematics. Currently, Singapore ranks first in the world while Philippines ranks
65th (Carballo,2009). It is the Department of Education which oversees the basic education in the
Philippines while it’s the Ministry of Education for Singapore. As compared to the Philippines
15% budget allocation, Singapore allots 17% of the national budget to its education spending. In
terms of educational structure Singapore has a very different but very effective system. In the
Philippines graduates of the primary education undergo the national achievement test, the result
of which is but used to see whether the student has learned the needed competencies. In
Singapore, graduates of primary level have to sit for the Primary School Leaving Examination
(PSLE) the result of which is used to determine which type of secondary school the student will
have to pursue his education. The result will tell whether the student will be accommodated in
the Integrated program which leads directly to University, or the Secondary express course, the
Secondary normal academic course, secondary normal technical, or in the technical and
vocational courses. There are two levels of qualification for admission in the University, the
GCE “O” level which is taken at around age of 17 or 18, and the GCE “A” level which is taken
after taking Junior Colleges or Polytechnics. This system is not present in the Philippine
education or in any other educational system in the world. The teacher-student ratio in Singapore
is 1:22, another reason why the country has an excellent education structure. In the Philippines,
the typical ratio is 1:50, the worst scenario is 1:55 or even 1:60. Teachers in Singapore are hired
and employed based on meritocracy. This entails hiring the teacher based on her capability and
intellect. The same process is being followed here in the Philippines. The Philippine
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 13
education system’s priority programs are multi-grade program, alternative delivery modes,
Conditional Cash transfer, GASTPE and Child Protection Policy, Mother Tongue
education act, focus on Science, English, and Mathematics, “Teach Less, Learn More”, ICT
Integration, and Internationalization of Education. The “Teach Less, Learn More” program is
Singapore has Standards, Productivity, and Innovation Board (SPRING), Higher Education
Division, Council for Private Education, Singapore Quality Class for Private Education
Organization, and Singapore Pre-School Accreditation Framework. It’s worthy to note that
Singapore is the only Asian country which has an accreditation framework for pre-school. On
critical issues and concerns the “superior” Singapore is not an exception to have them. If the
education the Singaporean education has issues like Over-focus on examination and grades,
the primary school leaving examination is too early. Unlike the Philippines which have already
established a system for the education of the children with special needs, Singapore has only
started focusing their concern on the issue. Nevertheless, there is no objection that Singapore has
the best educational system in the world. It has the best practices that make them number one
like the Compulsory education act, gifted education program, primary school leaving
examination, special, express, and normal secondary schools, two years of pre-college education
, and GCE “O” and “A” levels exam as qualifications for admission in universities (Ramos, n.d.).
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 14
Philippine education is patterned after the American system, with English as the
medium of instruction. Schools are classified into public (government) or private (non-
government). The general pattern of formal education follows four stages: Pre-primary
level (nursery and kindergarten) offered in most private schools; six years of primary
takes four, sometimes five and in some cases as in medical and law schools, as long as
eight years. Graduate schooling is an additional two or more years. Metro Manila has a
Philippine schools start in June and end in March. Colleges and universities follow the
Basic education in the Philippines intended to meet basic learning needs, lays the
1). English
2). Science
3). Filipino
5). Mathematics
- Mathematics II - Mathematics IV
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 3
- Mathemetics V - Mathematics VI
BASIC SECONDARY EDUCATION, BSE (4 years) First year to Fourth year • Stage of
free formal education following the elementary level below college level corresponding
to four (4) years of high school • Can be attained through alternative learning system
(Florido,
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 3
In the case of Philippines, Filipinos have a deep point of view of education, in which it is
treated as the main street of further social and economic mobility. This was materialized
from the Americans due to their colonial rule, where the ideal of democratic society in
which individuals could get ahead through good educational attainment (Country Studies,
n.d.).
under the various DepEd secretaries (Lourdes Quisumbing, Isidro Cariño, and Bro.
Andrew Gonzalez). Starting 1995, intensive consultations were held with various
stakeholders – the schools, parents, students, business, trade and industry, NGOs and the
people in the Education Department who administer the education system on ground
level. Almost immediately the consultations started on March 2001. The DepEd people
consulted included experts, public and private school teachers, the 16 regional directors,
different subject areas in different and year levels. The Philippine Commission on
Educational Reforms (PCER), created on Dec. 7, 1998 through Executive Order No. 46,
recommended the adoption of the restructured BEC and its implementation starting 2002.
The BEC focuses on the basics of reading, writing, arithmetic, science and patriotism.
Values is integral to all the subject areas. Students can then be ready for lifelong learning.
It seeks to cure the inability of students who cannot read with comprehension at grade 3
and worse, at grade 6. The BEC decongests the overcrowded curriculum. Integrative and
learning and sharing of knowledge and experiences between teachers, between teachers
and students and among students. For instance, under the old curriculum, English
teachers prepared lesson plans for English and values teachers prepared for values
education. Under the BEC, the English and Values Education teachers work together on
their lesson plans. High school math shifts from the spiral system which introduced all
math subjects in every level to the linear, sequential approach where only Elementary
Algebra is taught in 1st year, Intermediate Algebra in the 2nd year and Geometry in
3rd year.
TIMSS 2003 is the third in a continuing cycle of international mathematics and science
around the world and collects a rich array of information about the educational contexts
for learning mathematics and science, with TIMSS 2003 involving more than 50
participants. At both the eighth and fourth grades, Singapore was the top-performing
country having significantly higher average achievement in mathematics than the rest of
the participating countries. At the eighth grade, several countries showed significantly
higher average achievement in 2003 compared to the previous assessments in 1995 and
1999. Korea, Hong Kong SAR, Latvia (LSS), Lithuania, and the United States, as well as
assessment to assessment with significant change over 8-year period from 1995 to 2003.
Of the countries participating only in the 1999 and 2003 assessments, Israel and the
Philippines showed significant improvement. The girls had significantly higher average
achievement than the boys in Serbia, Macedonia, Armenia, Maldovia, Singapore Cyprus,
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 5
Jordan, Bahrain, and the Philippines. Mathematics achievement was also positively
related to computer usage particularly at the eighth grade, with average achievement
highest among students reporting using computers at home but not school, followed by
students using computers at school but not home, and then those using computers at other
places or not using them at all. Mathematics teachers reported considerable teaching
experiences. At both the eighth and fourth grade, on average, students were taught by
Medium of Instruction:
Pursuant to the DepEd Bilingual Policy (Dep.Ed Order No. 52, s,1987), the media of
K-12 CURRICULUM
The CORE SUBJECTS: Filipino; English; Math; Science (Science and Health for Elem.);
English shall be used in the following learning areas: English; Science; Mathematics
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 6
Mother-Tongue-Based
The additional languages are Ybanag for pupils in Tuguegarao City, Cagayan, and
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 7
Isabela; Ivatan for the Batanes Group; Sambal in Zambales; Aklanon in Aklan, Capiz;
for mathematics, science and literacy. For mathematics around 3 hours per week
was the most common time al. Furthuer,location, but Singapore gave more time to
mathematics, rising to 5.5 hours by the end of the primary years. Science allocations
allocations tended to be higher than those for mathematics, but this was sometimes
because pupils were not being taught in their native languages. Interestingly, no
consistency was found in whether the time allocated to subjects increased with time,
Turkish and Indonesian Secondary Mathematics curricula wherein they focus only on the
approaches. The main data collection tools are the curricula and mathematics textbooks
of both countries and was analyze by coding and presented by descriptive statistic
Also on one early work by Graham Ruddock and Sainsburry, M. (2008), six
Chinese Taipei, Hong Kong, Singapore, the Netherlands, Ontario andLatvia. The
comparisons have revealed a range of similarities and differences.At the most general
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 8
level the Chinese Taipei, Hong Kong, Singapore and Ontariomathematics curricula can,
students but with little ethos projected. TheNetherlands, on the other hand, can be
these two approaches. The Netherlandsalso differs in being much shorter, with all
In another work of Zarina Bibi Ibrahim and Khairil Iskandar Othman (2010), they
with the Singapore Secondary Mathematics (SSM) implemented in 2007. Their aimed to
examined the math content and level at which the content is introduced between the two
countries. The results from their study indicated that there is a need for Malaysian
Mathematics and ability to apply mathematics into other disciplines at higher level.
Meanwhile, the present researcher will use documentary analysis with the aim of
examining the math content and learning competencies of the Philippines, Singapore,
Korea and Hong Kong but not the level at which the content is introduced.
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 9
Chapter II
Research Methodology
A. Research Design
The paper is all based on secondary information using the literature review protocol.
The literature review stated planning a review protocol, then searching for potentially
relevant literature and snowballing (backward and forward) to exhaust all available literature,
selecting the relevant articles, analyzing and synthesizing then writing this manuscript
(Myllarniemi, 2015). The paper uses official publication of each government, specifically the
agencies that have authority over the delivery of the basic education, such as their respective
conducting researches on education were also considered as sources of data. On the other
hand, the paper has also used literature published in other agencies including news articles to
enrich discussions about the issues regarding the subject under assessment.
The researcher will gather all the Mathematics curricula of the Philippines,
Singapore, and the learning areas focused by TIMSS. Then they will analyze and
CHAPTER IV
KINDERGARTEN
Kindergarten is mandatory and
compulsory for five-year-old
learners with public schools
offering it for free. The
Kindergarten is the first stage of
the basic education and is
delivered using mother tongue
(SEAMEO INNOTECH, 2012).
ELEMENTARY
Elementary level is completed
within six (6) years. The first 3
grade is conducted using mother
tongue and succeeding levels are
bilingual using English and
Filipino as medium of
instruction. (SEAMEO
INNOTECH, 2012)
JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL (JHS)
Grades 7 to 10 (four years) are
the first part of the secondary
education. Grades 7 and 8
students are exposed to core
learning areas and TLE
exploratory courses are
introduced. On the other hand,
Grades 9 and 10 will be based on
the preferred learning areas of
the student. (DepEd)
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL (SHS)
The career pathway
specialization started in JHS
continues in the SHS. Grades 11
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 11
Singapore
4.74
Primary education, teachers 3.39
Ranked 67th. 40%
per 1000 Ranked 107th.
more than Singapore
31.44
17.44
Pupil-teacher ratio, primary Ranked 38th. 80%
Ranked 81st.
more than Singapore
34.81
14.91
Pupil-teacher ratio, secondary Ranked 6th. 2 times
Ranked 47th.
more than Singapore
3.83 per 1,000 people
Secondary education 2.06 per 1,000 people
Ranked 66th. 86% more than
(Teachers > Per capita) Ranked 108th.
Philippines
4
Secondary education, duration 4
Ranked 197th. The same as
(years) Ranked 196th.
Singapore
Table 1 showa the compared educational statistics of Philippines and Singapore.
Whole numbers, fractions, and decimals, Negative numbers, integers, rational numbers,
and the four arithmetic operations (addition, and real numbers, and the four arithmetic
subtraction, multiplication, and division) operations (addition, subtraction, multiplication,
Calculation with calculators and division)
Factors and multiples Calculation with calculators
Ordering of numbers Prime numbers, highest common factor, and
Approximation and estimation lowest common multiple
Percentage Ordering of numbers
Ratio Use of symbols including <, >, ≤, ≥
Speed Approximation and estimation
Algebraic expressions in one variable Percentage
Ratio, and direct and inverse proportion
Map scales
Rate and speed
Algebraic expressions and formulas
Algebraic manipulation (linear and quadratic)
Functions and graphs (linear and quadratic)
Linear equations with one unknown
Simultaneous linear equations with two
unknowns
Quadratic equations
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 13
Table 1 shows that that the Singapore express learning strand is consistent from
Singapore
The Singapore primary school system is organized in key stages: Primary 2, Primary 4,
and Primary 6. The Singaporean curriculum is organized around subject syllabi, each one a self-
contained entity. The content, concepts, and skills specific to that subject area are used as the
basis for organization. Content is specified per level in detail. Aims for the subjects curriculum
for that particular subject. These vary across subjects, as does the presentation of content. In
Social Studies themes are used as an organizing principle, in Health Education objectives are
used, in Mathematics topics and in English Language required learning is specified in terms of
learning outcomes (language skills, strategies, and attitudes), text types, and grammar focus. The
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 14
single document per subject is concise, comprehensive, and clear. The following subjects make
• English
• Mother tongue
• Mathematics
• Music
• Social Studies
• Health Education
• Physical education.
The Singapore MoE develops the curriculum and at the end of primary education, pupils sit
Since the 1980’s Singapore secondary pupils have been doing the Syllabus D. The
Ministry of Education issues the syllabus for the Lower Secondary levels.
•For each topic, the syllabus describes the instructional objectives, lists the main concepts
and learning outcomes. These topics are a subset of the syllabus for the “Ordinary” level
Chapter V
This study aimed to assess and compare Philippine K-12 Mathematics Curriculum
3. What are the standards of the Mathematics, and Mathematics Revised Basic
curriculum in Singapore?
1. What are the percentage distributions of the content areas used by TIMSS in
evaluating?
REFERENCES
Budy Sugandi and Ali Delice (2014). Comparison of turkish and indonesia secondary
Zarina Bibi Ibrahim and Khairil Iskandar Othman (2010). Comparative study of secondary
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.sbspro.2010.12.049.
education-curriculum-subject-areas-units-and-mg/
http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/Philippines/Singapore/Education
http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/stats/Education/Compulsary-
educationduration
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 17
https://www.scribd.com/document/327993066/Philippines-vs-Singapore
http://countrystudies.us/philippines/53.htm
Congress of the Philippines (2013). RA 10533, an act enhancing the philippine basic
Education system by strengthening its curriculum and increasing the number of years
For basic education, appropriating funds therefore, and for other purposes. Retrieved
from http://www.gov.ph/2013/05/15/republic-act-no-10533/ (Accessed May 28, 2016)
Senate of the Philippines (2011). K to 12: The Key to Quality Education?, Policy Brief. Senate
Southeast Asian Ministers of Education Organization (SEAMEO) and Regional Center for
TIMSS & PIRLS (1), International Mathematics Achievement for Grade 4 and Grade 8. TIMSS
http://timss2015.org/timss2015/science/student-achievement/(Accessed September 2,
2016)
Senior High School Curriculum in the Philippines, USA, and Japan (PDF Download Available).
Retrieved fromhttps://www.researchgate.net/publication/318494693_
MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM AND TIMSS 18
Senior_High_School_Curriculum_in_the_Philippines_USA_and_Japan