Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Laser-Cut Slot
Laser-Cut Spiral
.0015" Wide
Swiss-Turn
ID Chamfer
Swiss-Turn
U-Cut
Laser-Cut
Windows For Tubes .050" to .625" OD
Swiss-Type Turning • Laser Cut Tubes • CNC Machining • Automated Assembly • Laser Welding & Marking • Precision Metal Stamping
Accu-Blade ® Scissors & Blades • Production Proven Prototyping ® • Award-Winning Product Development
Other locations: Medical Products Manufacturing: Berlin, CT USA • Medical Precision Components Manufacturing: Alajuela, Costa Rica
CASES | INSTRUMENTS | IMPLANTS | INNOVATION
Greater capabilities than ever before, the capacity to deliver on the most demanding
challenges and unparalleled industry expertise are now at your fingertips.
888.287.0400 ■ tecomet.com
Features July/August 2015
Volume 11, No. 5
Orthopedic Design & Technology (ISSN # 2157-1449) is published bi-monthly with an additional issue in July by Rodman Publishing Co., 70 Hilltop Rd., Ramsey,
NJ 07446-1150, USA. Phone (201) 825-2552. Periodical postage paid at Ramsey, NJ 07446 and additional mailing offices.
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to: Orthopedic Design & Technology, 70 Hilltop Rd., Ramsey, NJ 07446-1150, USA.
Canadian Publications Mail Agreement No: 40028970 Return Undeliverable Canadian Addresses to Circulation Dept. or P.O. Box 1051 Fort Erie, ON. L2A6C7
Free subscriptions are available to qualified recipients. Others are as follows: U.S. one-year subscription $95; Canada and Mexico one-year subscription $120
(GST required on Canadian orders. GST #134451756. Foreign airmail: one-year $195. Make checks payable to in U.S. dollars through a U.S. bank. American
Express accepted.
(517) 694-2300
©2015 Orchid Orthopedic Solutions LLC REG-1-1 www.orchid-ortho.com
Departments & Columns July/August 2015
Volume 11, No. 5
Editor’s Letter........................................................................... 8
How do you measure medtech success?
GROUP PUBLISHER
Howard A. Revitch, hrevitch@rodmanmedia.com
Editorial Advisory Board........................................................10
Listing of Orthopedic Design & Technology Editorial EDITORIAL DIRECTOR, MEDICAL DEVICES
Advisory Board members. Christopher Delporte,
cdelporte@rodmanmedia.com
News Front..............................................................................12 MANAGING EDITOR
Integra LifeSciences spins off orthobiologics business.
Michael Barbella,
mbarbella@rodmanmedia.com
Financial Reports...................................................................16
The Dodd-Frank Act at 5: Nary a nay to exorbitant CEO pay. ASSOCIATE EDITOR
Ranica Arrowsmith,
rarrowsmith@rodmanmedia.com
Washington Roundup............................................................20
Senate bill aims to speed up FDA’s medical device review ART ASSOCIATE
process. Tyler Natale, tnatale@rodmanmedia.com
ASSOCIATE PUBLISHER
Risk Management ................................................................22 Mark Weeks, mweeks@rodmanmedia.com
How to bulletproof your firm from expensive employment
liability risks. SALES MANAGER
Patrick Browne, pbrowne@rodmanmedia.com
New Technology Update........................................................24
ChoiceSpine launches Blackbird posterior cervical system SALES MANAGER
Julie Steinkrauss Fuhrer,
in the U.S.
jfuhrer@rodmanmedia.com
ART DIRECTOR
People News ..........................................................................83 Michael Del Purgatorio,
Senior nanotechnology specialist hired by Titan Spine. mdelpurgatorio@rodmanmedia.com
PRODUCTION MANAGER
Calendar..................................................................................85 Lisa St. Charles, lstcharles@rodmanmedia.com
MPO Summit returns to Utah.
Audience Development Manager
Classifieds...............................................................................86 Joe DiMaulo, jdimaulo@rodmanmedia.com
A listing of advertiser services.
CIRCULATION DIRECTOR
Richard DeVoto, rdevoto@rodmanmedia.com
Ad Index..................................................................................89
A listing of advertisers in this issue. CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS
70 Hilltop Rd. • Third Floor
Ramsey, NJ 07446 USA
The Last Word........................................................................90 Phone: (201) 825-2552
A look outside the Top 10: Orthopedic startups making a Fax: (201) 825-0553
mark.
H
ow is success measured? How’s that for a broad topic for purchasing decision-makers they once were. Hospital chains are
discussion? Let’s narrow it down a bit. How is success in making more centralized procurement decisions. As such, there is
business evaluated? A little more focused, but still a wide- pressure on orthopedic manufacturers not only to establish clinical
open question. Is it by profit? That’s certainly one easy measurement. efficacy, but also to combine it with improved economics.
Perhaps it is by customer satisfaction—very important. Maybe it’s by According to a recent blog post by Sharon Fong, a brand strate-
employee satisfaction (three cheers to the forward-thinking firm that gist with Level Brand, a Minneapolis, Minn.-based healthcare-fo-
charts success by this). In today’s social-media obsessed world, suc- cused advertising, marketing and communications firm that works
cess could be how many“likes”something you’ve posted to Facebook with companies such as 3M, Beckman Coulter Inc. and Medtronic
receives or the number of Twitter fol- plc, orthopedic device companies need to change their game be-
lowers you have. Is it the page views, cause there’s no longer a“cookie-cutter formula”for success.
page visits or click-through rates “Every aspect of the healthcare industry has to rethink their
your website gets? Lots of people way of doing business. And, because healthcare today is so fluid,
hang their hats on the strength of most healthcare and related industries are still figuring it out, in-
those metrics to be sure. cluding the medical device marketing community,” Fong wrote.
No matter what the combina- “Technical and clinical features of the device alone will not drive
tion of factors, success is fleeting sales. Instead, hospital administrators, clinicians and payers will
in a fast-paced world. Heaven all be part of the equation in the selection and purchase of prod-
forfend your online numbers dip, ucts that combine devices and services built around delivering
for example (not as successful to- solutions for everyone—patient, provider and payer.”
day as you were last month?). The She writes that successful companies are the ones that un-
winning formula—if there is such derstand and anticipate the continuous changes and trends in
a thing—is an amalgam of vari- healthcare; know the competition; are category leaders with
ables, and most of them are out of our direct control. What we depth in the largest categories in which they operate, versus
can control, however, is how hard and how smart we work. breadth across multiple categories without clear leadership posi-
The July/August issue is our annual Top Company report, in tions in any; understand the individual motives for purchasing;
which we examine 10 of the world’s largest orthopedic firms. Just and develop flexible marketing and sales models that solve for
as in years past, we categorize the list based on reported financial the different ways physicians and procurement officers approach
data. While that gives us a starting point for a discussion, it’s only a purchasing decisions in different geographic locations.
small part of what makes these companies—and the orthopedic de- To give orthopedic firms and their supplier partners the tools to
vice industry as a whole—tick. Accomplishment, of course, doesn’t meet this mandate, Medical Product Outsourcing (the sister publication
just come from billion-dollar revenue streams. If the U.S. Food and of Orthopedic Design & Technology) is returning to Utah for the MPO
Drug Administration just approved a startup’s first implant that also Summit (www.mposummit.com), held Sept. 29-30 at the Stein Erik-
happens to have a solid reimbursement pathway, the executive team sen Lodge in Park City. At the heart of the education and networking
of the small firm is feeling pretty well-off—though there hasn’t yet event are sessions designed to: address the changing healthcare land-
been a single sale. Money is a byproduct of success. scape and how it is reshaping medtech innovation pathways; provide
In compiling all of the data required to create this year’s Top resources and skills for developing market-leading technologies; and
Company installment, I continued to think about the topic of suc- demonstrate the best manufacturing, R&D, regulatory and business
cess, the factors that drive it in today’s medtech marketplace, and strategies to help firms compete and—yes, you guessed it—succeed. v
what its recipe really is. Increasingly, companies with the resources
and foresight are going beyond the outmoded model of claiming
market share with one type of technology and its clinical benefit
alone. Today, the winning mixture is technology that moves past im-
proved clinical outcomes at one point along the value chain, but also
helps healthcare systems manage costs, keeps patients from return-
ing to the hospital with complications, can track a patient’s progress
remotely and ultimately saves the entire system time and money in Christopher Delporte
the long term. Savvy companies know that doctors aren’t the sole Editorial Director, Medical Devices
Make a breakthrough
in medical devices.
Siemens PLM Software.
Realize innovation.
Editorial Advisory Board
Linda Braddon, Ph.D. Dave Neal
President Plant Manager
Secure BioMed Evaluations IHI Ionbond Inc.
I
ntegra LifeSciences Holdings Corpora- focused structure from which to oper- and approximately $60 million in cash,
tion has completed the tax-free spin-off ate, which should improve our ability subject to customary working capital ad-
of its orthobiologics and spinal fusion to achieve our longer-term growth and justments, and including the extinguish-
hardware business, now known as SeaSpine margin improvement objectives. Further, ment of approximately $13 million of X-
Holdings Corporation. we believe these moves create exciting spine debt.
Integra stockholders received one opportunities for our shareholders and Once the deal closes, Bacterin will
share of SeaSpine common stock for ev- both organizations.” change its name to Xtant Medical Hold-
ery three shares of Integra common stock Integra officials said the separation ings Inc.
they held on June 19, the record date for will provide both companies with a According to Bacterin officials, the
the spin-off. SeaSpine shares began “reg- faster top-line growth profile; allow the transaction will position the combined
ular way” trading on the Nasdaq Global new SeaSpine to invest more in top-line company as a “comprehensive supplier for
Select Market on July 2. growth initiatives such as sales, market- spine surgery procedures”that offers hard-
“[This] marks a meaningful mile- ing and research and development, and ware and biologics through a “more sub-
stone for SeaSpine, as we reposition the to access the capital markets; accelerate stantial” national distribution footprint.
company for innovation and growth,” Integra’s operating margin expansion “This transaction joins two strong and
said Keith Valentine, president/CEO of plans; and unlock equity value for In- growing organizations and reinforces the
SeaSpine. “We are well-positioned in tegra’s shareholders. strategic initiatives outlined earlier this
the spine market with an orthobiologics The new SeaSpine consists of a port- year to expand our product offerings,
platform, an R&D pipeline with several folio of spinal hardware solutions, in- strengthen customer relationships and
product launches expected this calendar cluding unique interbody devices, mini- expand our distribution capabilities. We
year, and a strong balance sheet with $47 mally invasive surgery solutions, and are excited to leverage further our com-
million of cash and no debt post-spin to deformity correction products, as well as bined operating platform and exceptional
fund growth initiatives. We are confident IsoTis, a leading brand in orthobiolog- talent to drive, significant and ongoing
in our ability to deliver long-term growth ics, including a range of osteoconductive value for our stockholders. With the ad-
and value creation to our shareholders as and osteoinductive solutions using de- dition of X-spine, we will have a stronger
an independent company.” mineralized bone and synthetic matri- financial profile with over $80 million of
The spinoff occurred seven months ces. The company will operate out of its revenue and positive EBITDA (earnings
after Integra announced its intentions current locations in southern California. before interest, taxes, depreciation and
and four years after it acquired the Vis- SeaSpine offers a portfolio of ortho- amortization),” said Dan Goldberger,
ta, Calif.-based firm for $89 million in biologics and spinal fusion hardware Bacterin’s CEO.
cash. The move allows Integra to focus solutions that help neurosurgeons and X-spine has numerous products for
on specialty surgical solutions, orthope- orthopedic spine surgeons perform fu- the treatment of spinal disease, with an
dics and tissue technologies. The portfo- sion procedures on the lumbar, thoracic emphasis on less-invasive treatments for
lio realignment, according to company and cervical spine. the degenerative spine, X-spine’s spinal
brass, is part of a larger transformation implants and instrumentation are highly
strategy that began in 2012 and centers Bacterin International to Become complementary to Bacterin’s leading or-
on “optimizing the business and acceler- Xtant Medical Holdings Following thobiologics portfolio. The great majority
ating growth,” according to a news re- X-spine Systems Buy of spinal procedures using X-spine’s prod-
lease from the company. Publicly traded Bacterin International uct portfolio could use an orthobiologic
“These strategic changes create a Holdings Inc., a developer of bone graft that Bacterin currently offers, officials said.
much stronger platform for organic material, is purchasing the outstanding “This transaction will increase the
growth and execution, and we believe shares of privately held X-spine Systems scope of our organization with a new, di-
both companies will grow faster sepa- Inc., a medical device manufacturer of versified portfolio of products focused on
rately than together,” Peter Arduini, In- products for spinal surgery, headquartered the orthopedic and spine markets. Fur-
tegra’s president/CEO, said when the in Miamisburg, Ohio. thermore, we will be able to offer those
spinoff was announced. “Moving for- The deal calls for approximately 4.24 diversified products to our established
ward, Integra will have a simpler, more million shares of Bacterin common stock customer base, representing an accessible
Solutions
Tegra Medical is on the ball
Manufacturing devices for sports medicine and other The growth path of your device might start with our
orthopaedic needs can be complicated, but the GENESIS Tech Center, where we help nurture your
®
experts at Tegra Medical love the challenge. We’re designs with prototyping and pilot production, then
innovative problem solvers who have successfully progress to full-scale production, and end with final
provided solutions to challenges like yours. assembly, packaging and sterilization.
Whether you need PEEK or titanium implants, instru- Providing ingenious solutions for orthopaedic
ments, or complex assembled devices, we offer broad and other medical-device challenges is just one
machining capabilities, laser processing and insert of the hallmarks of Tegra Medical, along with
molding. All are manufactured to exacting quality speed, service and quality.
standards in facilities that are ISO and FDA registered.
Tegra Medical and GENESIS Tech Center are trademarks of Tegra Medical. Copyright © 2015 Tegra Medical. All rights reserved.
News Front
revenue growth opportunity for the com- CEO and president of Flower Ortho- Infection control is a critical concern
bined business. I look forward to working pedics. “We are committed to providing in healthcare. Nowhere is that more evi-
with Dan and his team to open the next our customers in the United States and dent than with surgical implants, where
chapter of our mutual success,” said David Europe cost-effective, safe and efficient the body’s own defense mechanism will
Kirschman, X-spine Systems’ president Ready-for-Surgery treatment solutions coat an implant with a “biofilm” layer.
and CEO. that bring true quantifiable value into to Biofilm is known to resist antibiotic ther-
Kirschman will join the management the O.R.” apy, the primary treatment option in in-
team and serve as executive vice president Flower Orthopedics currently is seek- fection control.
and chief scientific officer of Xtant Medi- ing distribution partners in Europe, and As a result, the cost impact of biofilm
cal. He also will be president of X-spine is hoping to start selling products in the is significant. In fact, hospital-associated
Systems, the hardware subsidiary; and will region next year. infections caused from biofilm on medi-
serve on Xtant’s board of directors. Flower Orthopedics’ “Ready-for-Sur- cal devices is estimated to cost the U.S.
gery” concept provides surgery-specific healthcare system $35.7 billion to $45
Flower Orthopedics applications in individual sterile packag- billion annually, according to the Cen-
Receives CE Mark ing, which eliminates the need for pre- ters for Disease Control and Prevention
Horsham, Pa.-based Flower Orthopedics, op sterilization and, compared to current (CDC). Recent information released by
creator of the standardized, procedure- practices, considerably reduces the num- the CDC shows that surgical site infec-
based, bone fixation concept the Flow- ber of implants and instruments brought tion rates accounted for 31 percent of all
erCube, has received the CE mark. The into the operating room. healthcare-associated infections among
approval, according to company officials, All instruments in the FlowerCube are hospitalized patients. In part, this is due
opens the opportunity for significant ex- single-use, removing the need to repro- to the widespread production, use and
pansion of the FlowerCube concept in the cess surgical tools post-op. This single- misuse of antibiotics, which have con-
European Union. use feature also decreases the risk of in- tributed to the next generation of drug
The approval encompasses Flower Or- fection stemming from reusable devices resistant infectious organisms, commonly
thopedics’ entire product line, which con- and expedites valuable operating room called “superbugs.”
sists of complete bone fixation solutions turnaround time, the company claims. Tyber Medical’s BioTy Antimicrobial
for upper and lower extremities. Consist- With these efficiencies, the firm expects surface coating features technology
ing of more than 400 implants, including hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers that exhibits surface characteristics on
a full portfolio of cannulated screws, each to save as much as 30 percent of the com- a nanoscale that potentially can sig-
implant has been engineered with a clear bined implant and instrument costs cur- nificantly reduce infections. Company
surgical strategy in mind to provide the ul- rently spent on each surgical case. executives said the BioTy process can
timate in secure bone fixation. be applied to various implant materi-
Flower Orthopedics’ single-use instru- Tyber Medical Acquires Licensing als, including titanium, stainless steel,
ments are standardized and multifunc- Agreement for Antimicrobial cobalt chrome and PEEK (polyether
tional, expediting case completion and Surface Coating Technology ether ketone).
driving surgical efficiency in the operating Tyber Medical LLC, a private-label man- “New research suggests that implant
room (O.R.). ufacturer of spine and orthopedic im- nanoscale features alone, without using
Tailored for specific surgical indications, plants, has acquired an exclusive licens- pharmaceutical agents, can inhibit bacte-
the FlowerCube houses all of the requi- ing agreement for its BioTy antimicrobial ria and virus functions to improve medi-
site bone fixation implants and instru- surface coating technology. cal device performance,” said Thomas J.
ments; they are sterile packaged, made for The company offered few specifics Webster, Ph.D., Art Zafiropoulo chairman
single-use and always ready for Surgery. of the deal, naming neither its licensing and a chemical engineering professor at
The FlowerCube is delivered ready for use, partner nor the applications best suited Northeastern University (Boston, Mass.),
eliminating set drop off and preoperative for the technology. In a news release and a new advisory board member at Tyber
on-site sterilization. Tyber executives only would identify Medical. “I’m pleased to be working with
“Receiving CE marking approval is a the licensing partner as “a prestigious Tyber Medical to further develop the Bio-
significant milestone for Flower Orthope- biomaterial research institution,” and Ty technology for use on a wide range of
dics. The market response to the Flower- said the technology would be used in surgical implants.”
Cube concept, to our anatomic implants “certain orthopedic applications.” The “We see three significant benefits re-
and to the single-use instruments in the agreement also includes allowance for sulting from our BioTy technology,” said
United States has been positive, and we refining the manufacturing process, as Jeff Tyber, company founder and presi-
are excited to bring this concept to the well as ongoing funding for additional dent. “Initially, it may enable us to be
European market,” said Oliver Burckhardt, scientific studies. first to market with implants that exhibit
exceptional infection control proper- Approximately 350 new employees total, 1,923 units were sold in the United
ties. Second, by tailoring implant surface have joined Smith & Nephew. States, representing 52 percent of total
characteristics, we can optimize certain Terms of the transaction were units sold globally.
qualities of the implant, such as bony not disclosed. SpineGuard has offices in Paris,
ingrowth and attachment, to meet the France, and San Francisco, Calif. The
needs of specific clinical applications. SpineGuard’s First-Half company was founded in 2009.
Lastly, the potential inherent antimicro- Revenue Climbs 41 Percent
bial properties of the BioTy process may Disposable medical device firm Spine- OrthoSpace Begins U.S. IDE Trial
negate the need and expense of phar- Guard has grown its half-year revenue by Caesarea, Israel-based OrthoSpace Ltd.
maceutical agents. As a result, cost ef- 41 percent to nearly 3 million euros ($3.3 has enrolled the first three patients in its
fective infection control may be within million) Global revenue in the year’s first U.S. investigational device exemption (IDE)
our reach.” half, ended June 30, increased 860,000 pivotal study. The study is a 184- patient
Based in Morristown, N.J., Tyber euros to 2.97 million euros, compared randomized, single blinded control study
Medical designs and develops Class II with 2.11 million euros in the first half that compares the company’s Inspace bio-
orthopedic systems. Its BioTy technology of 2014. At a constant exchange rate, the degradable balloon system to conventional
is the latest addition to a product portfo- growth rate is 21 percent, the company repair or partial repair for the treatment of
lio in spine and orthopedics that includes noted in a news release. full thickness massive rotator cuff tears.
headless compression trauma screws, an “We are very pleased with the strong While Inspace currently is commercially
anterior cervical plating system, and a full growth that the company delivered in the available outside of the United States and
line of spinal interbody spacers. first half of 2015. Sales momentum is par- has been implanted in more than 5,000
ticularly solid in the U.S. and France, our patients in 15 countries, the trial will be
Smith & Nephew Acquires two direct markets which had new re- the first time the device is implanted in the
Russian Orthopedic Manufacturer cord months in June,” SpineGuard CEO United States.
Smith & Nephew plc has acquired the Pierre Jérôme said. “Looking forward, Edwin J. Rogusky, M.D., and Paul R.
trauma and orthopedics business of De- we are really excited about the upcom- Sensiba, M.D., performed the proce-
Ost LLC and DC LLC, a manufacturing ing launch of DSG (Dynamic Surgical dures at University Orthopedics Center
company in the DeOst group. DeOst has Guidance) screws in collaboration with in State College, Pa.
distributed Smith & Nephew’s products in our partners.” “We are honored to be a part of this
Russia since 2009. Revenue in the United States increased study and to initiate clinical study en-
According to a statement issued by 52 percent (23 percent in constant cur- rollment,” they said following the first
Smith & Nephew executives, the ac- rency) to 2.27 million euros ($2.5 million) three procedures. “The data to date has
quisition brings the company closer to in the first half of 2015, compared with 1.5 demonstrated Inspace’s safety and effi-
customers through well-established million euros in the first half of 2014, and cacy, and we look forward to contribut-
commercial channels, allowing the represented 77 percent of global revenue. ing to the U.S. data set to facilitate Ins-
London-based orthopedics behemoth In the rest of the world, revenue increased pace’s entry into the U.S. market.”
“to better understand needs and offer a 14 percent during the first half of 2015 to “Having heard about promising results
fuller range of products and services.” 696,000 euros ($772,000) compared with with the use of this technology from our
DC’s local capability to manufacture 610,000 euros in the same period in 2014, colleagues abroad and having seen the
mid-tier trauma products will allow and represented 23 percent of global rev- procedure in Europe, I am looking for-
Smith & Nephew to reach more custom- enue. France, the company’s second direct ward to leading this group of U.S. surgeons
ers following recent changes relating to market after the United States, reported in completing this pivotal study that will
state tenders supporting Russian pro- a 42 percent growth in the second quar- hopefully allow us to bring this innovation
duced products, officials noted. ter of 2015 after 36 percent in the first to the United States,” said Nikhil N. Verma,
“Smith & Nephew has grown its quarter, and represents 5 percent of the M.D., of Rush University Medical Center,
business in Russia since 2005. This in- global revenue. First-quarter sales jumped the primary investigator of the study. “In-
vestment, in-line with our strategy to 47 percent to 1.51 million euros ($1.63 space addresses a current unmet medical
build our platform in the emerging million), while second-quarter revenue need for my patient population: a simple,
markets, significantly boosts our local climbed 35 percent to 1.45 million euros minimally invasive way to treat massive ro-
presence and prospects and will enable ($1.61 million), according to the company’s tator cuff pathology, with limited recovery
us to take advantage of market dynam- financial data. time for the patient.”
ics and better serve Russian custom- The company sold 3,716 PediGuard Enrollment in the study is ongoing, and
ers,” said Olivier Bohuon, CEO of Smith units in the first half of 2015 compared patients are being recruited at multiple
& Nephew. with 3,008 in the first half of 2014. Of that sites across the country. v
T
he controversy is not at all surprising.
In fact, the global debate is pre-
cisely the kind of fallout Daniel
Price expected from his groundbreak-
ing decision this past spring. The Gravity
Payments CEO reopened old pay dispar-
ity wounds and exacerbated the long-
standing war between the haves and
have-nots when he decided in April to
cut his million-dollar salary by more than
90 percent to give each of his employees
a raise.
Price set a $70,000 “minimum wage” at
his credit card processing firm, convinced
by research the total would boost workers’
emotional well-being ($75,000 is the re-
puted going rate for happiness, according
to a Princeton University study). The sal-
ary hike is set to accrue over the next three
years, enabling roughly 30 of the com-
pany’s 120 employees to double their pay.
Price is subsidizing the raises by reduc-
ing his stipend to employee levels (achiev-
ing minimum wage after two years) and Far from it. Price, in fact, is quite a savvy cades, their salaries rising 937 percent
using 75-80 percent of the company’s $2.2 businessman. By setting a company-wide between 1978 and 2013, according to the
million in anticipated 2015 profit. minimum wage, the CEO generated in- Washington, D.C.-based Economic Policy
Naturally, the company-wide sal- valuable publicity that ultimately will Institute. The rise is more than double
ary hike garnered global headlines, turn- boost sales, and also provided workers stock market growth and substantially
ing Price into an anti-establishment hero/ with an incentive to attract more business greater than the 10.2 percent hike in the
income equality poster boy hybrid. It also trig- and better handle clients. average worker’s stipend over that period.
gered a war of words in traditional and social Moreover, in cutting his own salary, The CEO-to-worker ratio is even more
media outlets between business leaders, aca- Price bucked tradition in generously com- telling. Fifty years ago, chief executives
demics and journalists deliberating the raises’ pensating himself for his work. earned 20 times more than their workers;
merits. Critics called the move“pure, unadul- “The market rate for me as a CEO com- the gap grew to 30:1 in 1978 and 58.7:1
terated socialism” that eventually will hurt pared to a regular person was ridiculous, by 1989 before surging in the 1990s to hit
Gravity employees; Forbes boldly predicted a it’s absurd,” he told The New York Times. 383.4:1 at the turn of the millennium. The
bad or“quiet”ending for the higher compen- “My salary wasn’t $1 million because I Great Recession narrowed the chasm a
sation, contending a $70,000 minimum wage need that much to live, but that’s what it bit in 2008 and 2009, but the ratios have
will be a “difficult sell” in the capital markets. would cost to replace me as a CEO. I think nearly returned to their 2000 levels, reach-
Supporters, however, argued the move will CEO pay is way out of whack...I want to ing 373:1 last year, up from 331:1 in 2013,
reduce turnover, increase morale and help be part of the solution to inequality in this AFL-CIO statistics indicate.
Price build a better company. country. If corporate America also wants Corporate America clearly has no in-
Some remained neutral but questioned to be a part of that solution, that would terest in following Price’s lead. And why
Price’s mindset. During an appearance on make me real happy.” would it? Annual pay for CEOs jumped
MSNBC’s “Morning Joe,” Huffington Post Price, however, is destined for disap- 12.1 percent last year, the fastest surge
editor Sam Stein bluntly asked the CEO, pointment. CEOs have enjoyed steadily since 2010 and up from a median increase
“Are you crazy?” rising paychecks over the last three de- of just 1.6 percent in 2013, a Towers Wat-
** Bradley R. Mason
2014 $610,769 0 $1,714,625 $486,332 $638,283 $3,450,009
President/CEO
2013 452,846 0 388,200 2,150,250 21,900 3,013,197
Orthofix
Source: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filings, 2014/2015. ** Recently appointed CEO
son & Co. analysis found. CEOs at small- compensation earnings” to boost his total base pay, a $149,000 gain in his stock
cap companies ($300 million-$2 billion) 2014 earnings to $37.2 million. holdings, and a $2.4 million increase to
received the largest raise—13.7 percent— Gorsky’s increase—like many in the his pension/other compensation.
compared with the 10.6 percent hike at industry—was based on the company’s Orthofix Holdings Inc. President/
mid-cap firms ($2 billion-$10 billion) and fiscal performance in 2014. Despite suf- CEO Bradley R. Mason and former Nu-
11.6 percent boost at large-cap organiza- fering declines in its Medical Devices Vasive Board Chairman/CEO Alexis V.
tions (more than $10 billion). and Consumers segments, the multina- Lukianov and reaped similar rewards
Shareholders aren’t helping Price’s tional still grew sales 4.2 percent (though from their respective firms’ surging
cause, either. Since being given the right it was less than the 6.1 percent surge re- stocks. Lukianov, who helped lead a to-
to vote on executive pay through passage corded in 2013) and grew stockholder tal shareholder return of 46 percent last
of the Dodd-Frank in 2010, investors gen- returns by 17 percent. Consequently, 96 year (a result achieved only by those in
erally have sanctioned top management percent of JNJ shareholders approved of the 93rd percentile of the S&P 500, the
compensation. In 2014, roughly 95 per- Gorsky’s $8 million raise and $24.9 mil- company claims in a U.S. Securities and
cent of shareholders at 500 of the largest lion total pay package. Exchange Commission filing), earned an
companies approved administrative sal- Other considerable salary hikes additional $1.2 million in stock; Mason
ary plans, up slightly from 93.8 percent in went to Medtronic plc Chairman and was awarded a $157,923 base pay raise,
2011, according to data from compensa- CEO Omar Ishrak, who added $4.7 $1.3 million in additional stock and a
tion analysis firm Equilar. million to his pension value, non-eq- $616,383 increase to his pension/other
“Most of these votes are pretty perfunc- uity incentive plan compensation and compensation in appreciation of the
tory,” said Matthew Semadeni, associate deferred compensation earnings; 3M firm’s 30 percent rise in stock price (from
management professor at Arizona State Board Chairman/President/CEO Inge $23.11 to $30.06).
University’s W.P. Carey School of Business. G. Thulin, given $1.6 million in addi- Corporate capital, however, can be a
“People really aren’t using it for what I think tional stock/options, and a $4.6 million double-edged sword. When it falls, share-
both Dodd and Frank intended, which was increase to his pension and non-equity holder support tumbles with it. Case in
to try to discipline management.” incentive plan/deferred compensa- point: Hologic Inc. stock slipped 4.2 per-
Punishment has been few and far be- tion earnings; Becton Dickinson Board cent in fiscal 2013 (ended Sept. 28, 2013)
tween, with failed “say-on-pay” votes de- Chairman/President/CEO Vincent A. amid slumping profits and multiple man-
clining steadily from 2.6 percent in 2012 Forlenza, who received an extra $1.6 agement changes. As a result, only 34 per-
to 1.5 percent in 2013 and 1.1 percent last million in stock/options and increased cent of investors supported the diagnostic
year. Such dissent is rare in the medtech his pension value by $1.3 million; and giant’s executive compensation plan in
industry, where shareholder approval for Jabil Circuit CEO Mark T. Mondello, fiscal 2014. (Regardless, President/CEO
executive pay averaged 90 percent in 2014. awarded a $75,000 base salary boost Stephen P. MacMillan earned $24.4 mil-
Such complacency likely is tied to the and $2 million more in stock. lion, more than half of which he received
rising stock market. Research that Semad- “As the public cried for executives’ in stock.)
eni conducted concluded that investors pay to be tied to performance, that “This was an obvious signal that
care more about stock performance than trend has very much happened,” said there were significant stockholder
the size of a CEO’s paycheck. Kevin Scott, co-founder/CEO of the concerns we needed to address,” Ho-
“It’s a very human thing,” Semadeni ADDO Institute, a branding consulting logic’s 2015 proxy statement read. “In
noted.“If you’re doing fine, even if someone firm. “And now, as their stocks are per- response to stockholder feedback we
else is maybe not, you’re going to not care as forming at very high levels, those CEOs introduced performance stock units tied
much as when you’re not doing fine.” are reaping the benefits.” to ROIC [return on invested capital] as
Perhaps that explains the very fine In more ways than one: Rising stock a significant component of fiscal 2014
88.3 percent salary hike approved for GE prices not only increase executives’ in- long-term equity awards...Understand-
CEO/Board Chairman Jeffrey R. Immelt dividual share value (most, if not all, ably, however, the biggest concern we
and the 47.7 percent raise given to JNJ own stock in their own companies), heard was about our approach to suc-
CEO Board Chairman Alex Gorsky last they also can warrant considerable cession planning during a time of un-
year. Though Immelt twice requested that bumps in base pay, stock, options and/ precedented change in leadership and
he not receive a bonus and declined an or 401(k) funds. disappointing company performance.
$11.7 million payout under the company’s Zimmer Holdings Inc. President/ Accordingly, getting our leadership
Long-Term Performance Awards program, CEO David C. Dvorak, for example, structure right was a key focus during
94 percent of shareholders nonetheless profited substantially from his compa- fiscal 2014. There was nothing more im-
approved a $20.7 million increase in his ny’s 21.7 percent rise in stock price last portant than stabilizing a new team as
pension value and“non-qualified deferred year, receiving a $30,000 boost to his quickly as possible.” v
T
here apparently are limits to human opulence, even in Attempts to narrow that chasm have fallen short, prompting
America. Incredibly, the nation that long flaunted its “big- legislative reform throughout the European Union and Austra-
ger is better” tenet with mile-high skyscrapers, gas-guzzling lia. Laws regulating executive pay gradually are gaining traction
SUVs, McMansions, megamalls and giant superstores may finally and support for both the visibility they afford the general public
have reached its limit. and the enhanced powers they give to shareholders, whose tra-
The tipping point? CEO salaries. ditional non-binding votes have done little—if anything—to curb
Historically, executive pay was never a big concern in the Land runaway salaries over the last half-decade. Employment analysts
of Opportunity, having risen steadily and mostly inconspicuously for believe government mandates may be the best way to level the
nearly three decades to help the top 1 percent and 0.1 percent of all CEO-worker playing field, although they have yet to catch on in
U.S. households double their income shares through 2007. Then the the United States.
Great Recession struck, and CEOs—especially those in the financial “Politicians need to do more to stand up to big business and the
industry—became Public Enemy No. 1 for the big bonuses and ex- super-rich,”Deborah Hargreaves, director of the British independent
orbitant salaries they collected in the wake of their failings (former think tank High Pay Centre, told a London-based business daily
A.I.G. Financial Products executive Joseph Cassano, for instance, earlier this year.“We must also give workers the power to force em-
pocketed a $34 million bonus in 2008 despite costing the insurance ployers to share pay more fairly throughout their organization.”
giant $99 billion). U.K. workers have had that power for more than 18 months now.
Such handsome rewards for the leaders of taxpayer-funded bail- New laws implemented in the fall of 2013 require British companies
outs like A.I.G., Citigroup Inc., Bank of America Corporation and to publish exit payments for directors who are fired or resign as well
JPMorgan Chase spawned public outrage as well as a groundswell as the salary totals of all top directors. More importantly, however,
of political support for financial reform. Congress appeased the an- the legislation gives shareholders a binding vote on executive pay
gry masses (and itself) in 2010 with the Dodd-Frank Act, a sweeping schemes, and mandates the packages be approved by more than 50
set of laws designed to better regulate the U.S. financial industry. percent of investors. Companies that fail to muster enough share-
Among the Dodd-Frank bill’s numerous provisos is a“say-on- holder support must abide by its last approved salary plan. Approved
pay” clause that requires public companies to put their executive compensation packages are valid for three years.
pay practices to a non-binding shareholder vote at least once The rules are tougher in Switzerland, where publicly traded
every three years. Another provision—yet to be implemented— firms also are beholden to investors but additionally are forbidden to
commands corporations disclose the salary ratio between their award golden handshakes, signing bonuses and golden parachutes
CEOs and their employees. Neither one, however, has had much to top management. Violators face a three-year jail term and fines
effect on executive pay: Salaries jumped 9.1 percent in 2014 to a equivalent to six years of pay.
nine-year high of $22.6 million, and the average S&P 500 CEO- Executives, though, can still earn big bucks. Swiss voters rejected
to-worker ratio swelled to 373:1, up from 331:1 in 2013, AFL-CIO a proposal in November 2013 to cap administrative salaries at 12
statistics show. times the amount of the lowest-paid employee, thus ensuring the
“Today’s CEO-to-worker pay ratios are simply unconscionable,” CEOs of Swiss-based multinationals such as Novartis AG, UBS AG
the AFL-CIO said in the latest installment of its compensation re- and Glencore plc continue to make more in a month than most
port, Executive Paywatch.“America is supposed to be the land of op- workers earn in a year.
portunity, a country where hard work and playing by the rules would Emboldened by the legislative victories in Britain and Switzer-
provide working families a middle-class standard of living. But in land, the European Commission now is considering increasing
recent decades, corporate CEOs have been taking a greater share of shareholder power throughout the continent. If adopted, all remu-
the economic pie while workers’ wages have stagnated.” neration policies by E.U.-listed companies will be subject to binding
The gluttony, though, is not confined to the United States. Pie investor votes very three years.
lovers exist on nearly every continent, with Australians and Euro- Australia has perhaps been most empowering to shareholders
peans among the most hungry (Americans, naturally, still have the with its“two strikes”policy, implemented in July 2011.The law requires
biggest appetites). Germany, Spain and France boast some of the company boards be “spilled” if 25 percent or more of a firm’s inves-
highest CEO-to-worker pay ratios in the European Union (147:1, tors reject its remuneration plans at two consecutive annual meetings.
128:1 and 104:1, respectively), while Australian chief executives earn Once the second resolution is passed, all board directors (except the
93 times the average worker’s salary. In the United Kingdom, the managing director) must be re-elected to their positions within a 90-
earnings gap—estimated at 84:1—is wider than at any point since day timespan. Experts contend the legislation—among the world’s
Queen Victoria’s rule (1837-1901), according to a British commis- strictest—has helped shareholders find their voices and effectively
sion’s findings. fight for salary equity. — M.B.
U
.S. Sens. Richard Burr (R-N.C.) The Device Act also will allow spon- Can Device Tax Repeal Pass in
and Al Franken (D-Minn.) have sors of device trials to seek approval using the Senate? Republicans Say
introduced bipartisan legislation either a local or a centralized institutional They’ve Got the Votes
designed to expedite the medical device review board (IRB), much like the FDA al- Congressional Republicans see a repeal
approval process. lows for drug clinical trials. Specifically, the of a 2.3 percent tax on medical devices
According to a news release from act calls for the use of centralized IRBs to as their best opportunity to chip away at
Burr’s office, the FDA Device Account- hasten multi-center clinical trials, as these the Affordable Care Act after the U.S. Su-
ability Act (The Device Act) seeks a more studies have been noted to bog down the preme Court’s decision earlier this sum-
consistent and meaningful application of current approval process. mer turning away a challenge to a key
the “least burdensome” principles speci- “America is a global leader in medi- component of the law.
fied in the FDA Modernization Act of 1997 cal research, development, and inno- The U.S. House of Representatives
(FDAMA), enabling device manufacturers vation,” Burr said in prepared remarks. voted in June to repeal the tax, and U.S.
to bring their innovative and life-saving “Ensuring that safe medical devices are Senate Republicans now are weighing
products to patients more quickly. developed and reviewed quickly will the best timing for a vote to undo the
The release claims the FDAMA did help get them to patients faster, which levy, which helps underwrite the health-
not change the statutory requirements for will improve and save lives. This legisla- care law. Legislators believe they may
the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s tion will also help cut down on the total be close to securing the necessary votes
(FDA) medical device review and approval time it takes for patients to benefit from to override a presidential veto, or insist
standards, but only required the process approved medical devices by permitting the tax be rolled back as part of a grand
be conducted in the “least burdensome” more efficient clinical trials.” bargain on spending bills later this year.
manner, which the Device Act seeks to The legislation also requires the FDA Senate Majority Leader Mitch McCon-
ensure by: update its guidance on waiving Clinical nell (R-Ken.) took the first procedural
• Requiring the secretary of Health Laboratory Improvements Act (CLIA) re- step toward bringing a repeal to the floor
and Human Services to ensure that quirements. Specifically, guidance should after the House voted overwhelmingly to
FDA reviewers receive training on indicate that point-of-care diagnostic quash the levy.
the intent and application of the tests that perform the “same in the hands “That House vote was a big deal,” said
least burdensome requirements; of untrained users as… in the hands of Sen. Pat Toomey (R-Pa.), who is leading
laboratory professionals” may be admin- the repeal effort in the Senate.
• Requiring an audit by the FDA istered in CLIA-waived labs (e.g., a doc- Many in the device industry have been
ombudsman, as well as an assess- tor’s office). fighting to overturn the 2.3 percent tax
ment of the measurement used to The Advanced Medical Technology since it was conceived as part of Presi-
track implementation of the least Association (AdvaMed) issued a formal dent Obama’s Affordable Care Act (ACA),
burdensome requirements; statement praising the filing of the new claiming it stifles the industry’s ability to
Senate bill: “AdvaMed commends Sens. create new jobs and fund innovation.
• Requiring FDA reviewers to Richard Burr and Al Franken for intro- The Washington Times published a scath-
consider the least burdensome ap- ducing the FDA Device Accountability ing editorial in early July, which referred to
propriate means necessary for dem- Act, which will make improvements to the ACA as “Obama’s scheme” and called
onstrating a reasonable assurance FDA’s medical technology review pro- the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision to up-
of safety and effectiveness when cess and help ensure more timely pa- hold the ACA a “little artful abuse of the
requesting additional information tient access to the latest medical inno- language.” The editorial claims the device
from manufacturers during the vations. Taken together, these reforms tax takes a bite out of gross sales, rather
premarket approval process; and will greatly improve the efficiency of than profits, and it risks shutting down
FDA’s medical technology review pro- companies that are operating in the red.
• Requiring the FDA to disclose how cess and eliminate redundant regulatory Citing the Advanced Medical Technology
it considered and applied the least obstacles that impact the timeliness of Association (AdvaMed), the piece claims
burdensome requirements in its American patients’ access to life-saving the tax has killed 14,000 jobs and blocked
rationale for significant decisions. and life-enhancing innovations.” the creation of nearly 19,000 positions.
Its proponents argue the tax is a fair several standards. Repealing the tax could cellator should never be allowed to
fee for medical device manufacturers widen the deficit, she warned. happen again.”
that have seen their markets expand Kingsdale agreed, saying a repeal Supporters of the bill say informa-
as more Americans have signed up for could lead to the unwinding of other tion such as the make or model number
health coverage. Other industries, such financing mechanisms. “It would be the of devices used in treatment should be
as the pharmaceutical industry, made first major chink in the armor of the included in medical records so patient
financial concessions to help augment ACA being scored as deficit reduction,” harm can be closely tracked. Currently,
health benefits, Jon Kingsdale, former he said. the identifiers are not incorporated into
executive director of the Massachusetts all electronic health records, “which
health exchange and now a director Medical Device Safety Part of makes it difficult to fully achieve the
at Wakely Consulting Group in Bos- 21st Century Cures Act Passed benefits to patient safety,” Fitzpatrick’s
ton, told The Wall Street Journal (WSJ). by House of Representatives office said in a formal statement.
“Medical device companies were pretty As part of the 21st Century Cures bill that There is no parallel bill in the U.S.
much the only major group that re- passed the U.S. House of Representatives on Senate, but Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-
fused,” he said. July 10, the legislation included a provision Tenn.), chairman of the Senate’s health,
Senator Amy Klobuchar is from to improve the safety monitoring of medi- education and labor committee, has said
Minnesota, home of two of the big- cal devices. The house passed the act by a he hopes to get a measure through his
gest names in the U.S. device indus- 344-77 vote. panel by year-end and bring it to the
try—Medtronic plc and St. Jude Medical The 21st Century Cures Act con- Senate floor for a vote next year. It is
Inc.—and is one of five Democrats to co- tained multiple health IT-related provi- uncertain whether it would contain simi-
sponsor the Senate bill to repeal the tax. sions, particularly in the areas of U.S. lar language.
Klobuchar told the WSJ, “This is a tax on Food and Drug Administration (FDA) The FDA issued a rule in 2013 requiring
manufacturing and I’ve always been in regulation, telehealth, and interoper- all medical device labels to include unique
favor of eliminating it.” ability. It also would boost federal fund- device identifiers and said it would phase
Though the $30 billion the tax would ing for medical research and changes in the system over several years, focusing
collect over the next 10 years is a small part drug approvals. first on high-risk products. Fitzpatrick’s
of the ACA’s expanded coverage, many are The medical device amendment from office said his action “adds pressure.”
concerned there is no plan to replace the Rep. Mike Fitzpatrick, (R-Pa.) was in- Fitzpatrick has used the morcellator
funds, and some allege the repeal is just an spired by controversial gynecological issue to open a larger debate about how
attempt to chip away at the ACA. devices called power morcellators, which devices are regulated and tracked. Sev-
While many Democrats could sup- were used in thousands of minimally in- eral other amendments offered by Fitz-
port the repeal in theory, the WSJ asserts vasive procedures a year—mostly hys- patrick and prompted by the morcellator
they will be unlikely to do so unless the terectomies—to cut up benign uterine issue didn’t make it through the rules
ACA’s funds can be replaced from another fibroids. Last year, however, the FDA committee. One amendment would
source. To overcome a filibuster, 60 sena- warned that women undergoing the have directed the Government Account-
tors must support bringing the bill to the procedure have an estimated 1 in 350 ability Office to investigate FDA medical
floor for a vote. chance of harboring a dangerous hid- device safety reporting regulations, “fo-
Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), who den cancer that power morcellators can cusing on reporting problems involving
voted to undo the levy in 2013, will only spread and worsen. Johnson & Johnson, power morcellators.”
back the present repeal measure if there is which was the largest manufacturer of A voice of opposition was rules com-
a funding offset, a spokeswoman for her the device, pulled its product off the mittee member Rep. Michael Burgess,
office said. market a year ago. Most hospitals have a Texas Republican and a doctor who
It is unlikely there will be one. Sen. Or- halted or limited use of morcellators. formerly practiced obstetrics and gyne-
rin Hatch (R-Utah), chairman of the Sen- Morcellators made by other companies cology. Burgess, who said he left active
ate Finance Committee, said, “It’s pretty remain on the market. practice more than 10 years ago and
hard to come up with a $30 billion offset.” Fitzpatrick’s amendment calls for didn’t use power morcellators, argued
The Obama administration has said unique device identifiers to be included in that doctors, rather than regulations,
the tax is a key component of funding electronic health records. were to blame for problems resulting
and not an undue burden on the industry. “Unfortunately, it is becoming clear from the device, according to The Wall
U.S. Health and Human Services Secre- that the reporting system for faulty Street Journal.
tary Sylvia Burwell said the administra- and deadly devices is broken,” Fitzpat- “In this instance, I think that it was
tion would insist that any changes to the rick said in the Congressional Record. clinical judgment that was at fault, not
health law improve the economy, among “What happened with the power mor- the FDA approval process,” he said. v
A
grandmotherly figure with white These include:
hair peers benignly over her read- • Wrongful termination claims
ing glasses in a magazine ad. The and lawsuits from those who feel
caption: “Her smile seemed to light up the they were unjustly let go. Even
office.” The ad’s small print reveals that groundless claims consume hours
“granny” cost her employer $425,000 due and thousands of dollars in legal
to an age discrimination suit, citing the defense fees;
need for financial protection in the form of • Spike in workers compensation
employment practices liability insurance. claims from employees who allege
Medical device and life-science firms— they were hurt on the job, seeking
much like many other businesses—face workers compensation benefits to
employment practices liability from a host replace lost wages;
of situations. These include allegations of • Cost of unemployment benefits;
not just age discrimination, but also gender • Lowered morale on the part of
discrimination, sexual harassment, wrong- the “remaining” workers if they
ful termination, hostile work environment feel those laid off were dealt with
or violating fair labor practices. Despite in- unfairly. Even if such a perception
creased automation of manufacturing pro- does not exist, the “lucky” survivors
cesses, the medical device and life-science may have low morale as workloads
industry is labor-intensive. Whenever you increase with fewer resources and
have employees, a company risks employ- no comparable pay jump; and
ment practices liability claims and lawsuits. • Negative public relations and a
Prime sources of such claims are layoffs tainted public image spurred by
and terminations. “malcontents” who claim they were
Life-science firms are vulnerable to lay- treated unfairly.
offs, employee terminations or employee
complaints. A myriad of factors drive and While layoffs and terminations are un-
accentuate this trend. Sometimes, employ- pleasant but often necessary realities for
ee performance—or lack thereof—is an is- life-science firms, there are ways to handle
sue. Other, larger financial factors dictate these steps to minimize employment liabil-
cost-cutting and reducing headcount. Eco- ity risks. Fortunately, life-science profes-
nomic downturns and recessions slow de- sionals can manage this risk just like any
mand. Long waits for U.S. Food and Drug other. Let’s look at tools and strategies for
Administration approvals diminish output. life-science leaders to consider when man-
Many pharma firms face “patent cliffs,” aging the risks of layoffs and terminations.
where blockbuster drugs will soon lose Many insurance companies offer coverage
their patent exclusivity, lowering demand for employment practices liability. Exam-
for branded drugs. Increasingly, sales reps ples are Monitor Liability Managers, Chubb
have difficulty getting to doctors, reducing and XL Catlin. (Caveat: These are examples,
the need for field sales personnel. Global not rankings or recommendations.)
competition is another factor. Bottom line: Work with your insurance agent or bro-
Layoffs are unfortunate but often finan- ker to identify promising candidates from
cially necessary steps for life-science firms. whom to obtain coverage quotes. Prepare
for the process by anticipating the ques-
Sources of Claims and Risk tions that insurance companies will pose.
Kevin M. Quinley Bungling these situations can create needless Life-science firms that show the greatest
and expensive risks for a device company. readiness to provide cogent answers to
these questions and demonstrate strong the agreement and when does the that may minimize headaches.
internal risk management procedures agreement expire? Moral: Collective Second, update all management, su-
have the leverage to get the broadest cov- bargaining agreements can fore- pervisory employees and nonsupervisory
erage at the lowest cost. shadow aggrieved employees filing employees on amendments to the compa-
employment practice claims or suits. ny’s human resources manual or written
Anticipate Insurer Questions • Do any employees have writ- guidelines. Have employees acknowledge
Questions that an insurance company asks ten employment contracts? If so, in writing that they received such manuals
on its coverage application reveal areas it how many? Suggestion: Contracts or guidelines.
views as risky. They also offer a road map may be a good idea, but they risk Third, establish a toll-free number
for the company’s risk management pro- breach-of-contract suits if relation- for reporting allegations of and claimant
gram addressing employment practices. ships sour. practices violations. Some insurers may
Expect to face questions like the fol- • In the past three years, what offer to provide one or help offset the cost.
lowing in an insurance application: has been the annual percentage Fourth, consider hiring a full-time risk
• Do you plan a merger, acquisi- turnover rate of employees, both manager, human resources manager and
tion or consolidation for you or domestic and foreign? Takeaway: general counsel. Tip: insurers like to see
any subsidiaries? Comment: Such Many see turnover rate as a ba- seasoned, full-time risk managers, human
corporate maneuvers often spawn rometer portending employment resource specialists and general counsel at
layoffs for the sake of “synergies” liability claims. the helm.
and efficiencies. A strong business • What percentage of employees Fifth, prepare essential documents and
rationale may exist for layoffs, but have salaries larger than $50,000, have them ready, since insurers often re-
an expected result will be claims $500,000, $200,000 or above? Tip: quest the following materials as part of the
and suits from wrongful termina- The higher the pay scale, the higher underwriting process:
tion or discrimination. the stakes in employment litigation. • Latest annual report or audited
• Are you undergoing or contem- financial statement;
plating employee layoffs or early With answers to such questions pre- • Employee handbook;
retirements in the next 12 months, pared, medical device and life-science • Human resources manual/guidelines;
including those resulting from firms can craft strong internal programs to • Procedures regarding job appli-
company restructuring or office or minimize the risk of employment practice cants, employee discipline, termi-
manufacturing plant closings? liability and claims. nation, harassment or discrimina-
• What is the total number of em- tion allegations; and
ployees, broken down amongst Risk Management Strategies • Latest EEO-1 report (a government
full-time, part-time, seasonal, First, maintain an updated/amended hu- form requiring many employers to
temporary, leased, domestic within man resources manual or equivalent risk provide a count of their employees
the United States, and foreign? management guidelines addressing: by job category and then by ethnic-
Comment: Employment claims • Legally prohibited discrimination; ity, race and gender).
are more common in the United • Sexual harassment;
States, so the mix of foreign versus • Compliance with the Americans Which strategy is better—buying in-
domestic labor force is a risk factor. with Disabilities Act; surance or implementing risk manage-
• What percentage of employees • Compliance with the 1991 Civil ment? It’s not an either/or choice. Life-
are union versus nonunion? Tip: Rights Act; science firms capturing the best coverage
Insurers correlate a unionized • Compliance with the Family Medi- deals blend management practices with
workforce with a higher risk of cal Leave Act; savvy shopping strategies in the insurance
claims and litigation. • Employee disciplinary procedures; marketplace. Companies that combine
• What percentage of employees are • Employee appraisals/reviews; and these two approaches will have nothing to
in Texas or California? Caution: • Terminations, layoffs and fear from a vindictive grandmotherly em-
These states are perceived as “hot early retirement. ployee or from business-driven reductions
houses” for employment practices in force. v
claims due to laws congenial to Insurers writing this coverage want to
such actions. make sure the company has its house in Kevin M. Quinley, CPCU, ARM, is the
• Is the device firm or any of its order and represents a safe risk. None of principal of Quinley Risk Associates LLC,
subsidiaries subject to a collective these features guarantees that a medical a risk management consulting firm. He can
bargaining agreement? If so, how firm will not have a claim, but they reflect be reached at kevin@kevinquinley.com or at
many employees are subject to a systematic human resource approach (804) 796-1939.
C
hoiceSpine, a Knoxville, Tenn.- FDA Clears EVOS System Invibio´s Peek-Optima HA Enhanced
based spinal implant company, has From Cutting Edge Spine polymer has demonstrated its perfor-
launched its Blackbird posterior The U.S. Food and Drug Administration mance in pre-clinical studies, with supe-
cervical system in the United States. The (FDA) has cleared Cutting Edge Spine’s rior new bone formation and quality of
system was designed by a surgeon panel EVOS system, an array of interbody im- new bone bridging compared with PEEK-
with the goal of improving upon current plants manufactured in Peek-Optima Nat- Optima Natural at early time points.1 A
designs available in the market, simplify- ural and Peek-Optima HA Enhanced, both further study that evaluated the bone on-
ing instrumentation and improving pa- offered by Invibio Biomaterial Solutions. growth of the two implantable polymers
tient outcomes. “With the approval of the EVOS sys- in a bone defect model in sheep revealed
“After over 150 successful surgeries, we tem, we are proud to be first-to-market in that PEEK-Optima HA Enhanced resulted
are excited to announce the commercial the U.S. with an HA enhanced Peek Lum- in approximately 75 percent direct bone
launch of our Blackbird posterior cervi- bar Interbody system,” said Randy Roof, apposition as early as four weeks follow-
cal system,” said Steve Ainsworth, Ph.D., Cutting Edge president and co-founder. ing implantation.2
ChoiceSpine’s vice president of research “Invibio’s Peek-Optima HA Enhanced “Our goal is to provide today’s market
and development. “The Blackbird poste- has been compounded with hydroxyapa- with tomorrow’s technology,” said John
rior cervical system is the result of hard tite (HA), an osteoconductive material, to Souza Sr., director of Research and Devel-
work between our internal team, distribu- enhance bone apposition. The integration opment at Cutting Edge Spine. “To that ef-
tion partners and physician partners.” of two proven Invibio biomaterials com- fect, we have taken a no-excuse approach,
“Blackbird extends the portfolio of bined with cutting-edge designs and the providing surgeons with 3,714 lumbar im-
products we offer,” said Anderson Collins, largest range of footprints in the market plant options, and hospitals with single use,
director of business development. “This is truly a game changer. Our partnership bar coded, and pre-sterilized packaging.”
system and what we have in the product with Invibio made it possible, and was key Cutting Edge Spine currently is in
pipeline will continue to fuel the double- to obtaining FDA clearance. We look for- the process of commercializing the new
digit growth we have experienced over the ward to the impact that the EVOS system technology and establishing distribution
past few years.” will have on fusion rates, and ultimately, throughout the United States.
The company received U.S. Food and patient care.” Founded in 2009, Cutting Edge Spine
Drug Administration 510(k) clearance for Peek-Optima HA Enhanced shares all develops and distributes spinal technolo-
the system more than a year ago. of the material properties that originally gies. The privately owned company is
Blackbird is a comprehensive system for made PEEK-Optima Natural an ideal ma- headquartered in Waxhaw, N.C.
posterior fixation of the cervical and upper terial for spinal interbody fusion devices,
thoracic spine. It offers a variety of screws, including a modulus similar to that of References:
hooks and rods that can accommodate any cortical bone and radiolucency, allowing 1. Study evaluated the in-vivo response in
surgeon’s needs, company officials claim. visualization of the fusion mass, accord- a cervical spine fusion model in sheep. Study
Blackbird is the first of three commercial ing to a Cutting Edge Spine news release. did not use Cutting Edge Spine products.
product launches the privately held Choic- Hydroxyapatite is fully integrated into the Data on file at Invibio. This has not been cor-
eSpine plans in 2015. PEEK-Optima Natural Grade, provid- related with human clinical experience.
ing a complete homogeneous compound 2. Study evaluated bone ongrowth in a
that ensures HA is present on all surfaces bone defect model in sheep. Study did not use
of a device. Cutting Edge Spine products. Data on file at
“Supporting Cutting Edge Spine in ev- Invibio. This has not been correlated with hu-
ery phase of the development of the new man clinical experience.
EVOS system now entering the U.S. mar-
ket allowed us to contribute to a solution Medtronic Debuts
that we believe will have positive impact New Spinal System
on the quality of life of patients with clini- Medtronic plc’s spine division launched
The Blackbird posterior cervical system. cal conditions,” said John Devine, Ph.D., the CD Horizon Solera Voyager spinal sys-
Image courtesy of ChoiceSpine. director of Invibio Biomaterial Solutions. tem for minimally invasive procedures.
The technology now is available in spinal, neurological, orthopedic and oral nium alloy produced with electron beam
countries around the world. The system maxillofacial conditions. melt technology. The cage displays a po-
expands upon the transforaminal lumbar Medtronic plc is headquartered in rous surface with a diamond cell structure
interbody fusion procedure by offering Dublin, Ireland. providing a base for cell proliferation and
multiple, minimally invasive rod insertion bone growth. Two large openings, which
options and enabling a seamless 3-D-nav- Rivanna Medical Gets FDA OK may be filled with autogenous bone, are
igated surgical experience. The announce- for Ultrasound Device to Guide meant to support the creation of a straight
ment was made during the 22nd annual Spinal Anesthesia column for fusion.
international Meeting on Advanced Spine Charlottesville, Va.-based Rivanna Medi- The EndoLIF implant allows sur-
Techniques in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. cal LLC has earned U.S. Food and Drug geons to use an inter-muscular approach,
According to the company, with the Administration 510(k) clearance for Ac- similar to a mini transforaminal lumbar
curo, a handheld and untethered smart interbody fusion, into the intervertebral
phone-sized ultrasound device designed disc, enabling endoscopic-assisted fu-
to guide spinal anesthesia with automat- sion. Ralf Wagner, M.D., of the Ligamenta
ed 3-D navigation technology in addi- Spine Center in Frankfurt, Germany, and
tion to ultrasound imaging of abdominal, Bernd Illerhaus, M.D., of Orthopädisch-
musculoskeletal, cardiac and peripheral Neurochirurgisches Zentrum in Datteln/
vascular anatomies. Recklinghausen, Germany, two German
The CD Horizon Solera Voyager spinal According to the company, the Accuro spine specialists, have performed more
system for minimally invasive procedures. platform is designed to provide automat- than 200 out of 600 EndoLIF procedures
Image courtesy of Medtronic ed navigation to an anatomical target so in Europe.
a clinician may avoid guesswork when “The access is dura and nerve-gentle,
CD Horizon Solera Voyager, surgeons finding the target. The initial commer- preserves the dorsal bony structures and
have the flexibility to use either a percu- cial application of Rivanna’s Accuro plat- we can avoid scar tissue because of the
taneous or Wiltse minimally invasive ap- form is designed for guiding clinicians to stepwise tissue dilation,” said Illerhaus.
proach for rod insertion depending upon a first-attempt success in administering The EndoLIF on-cage is designed to be
their preference. The system also features spinal anesthesia. used with supplemental posterior fixation,
a low-profile, extended-tab screw with “There are multiple clinical uses for such as Joimax’s Percusys percutaneous
inner threading, which eases rod inser- Accuro, a disruptive, game-changing de- pedicle screw-rod system. Cage implan-
tion and facilitates rod reduction. In ad- vice platform technology,” said John A. tation can be performed with a posterior
dition, the system is part of Medtronic`s Williams, president and CEO of Rivanna or postero-lateral approach, either using
Surgical Synergy spinal platform—the Medical. “The Accuro platform, which is an open or endoscopic-assisted method,
most integrated portfolio of navigated based on automated superior imaging company officials report.
surgical technologies—which seeks to technology, has an addressable $1 billion
minimize the operating room from inter- U.S. market today. Because of the consid-
ruption and constraints and gives sur- erable unmet clinical need for automated
geons the freedom to focus wholly on image guidance in general, and in the spi-
their patients. nal anesthesia market especially, we are
“Medtronic is known for our life- looking forward to launching Accuro at
changing innovations and groundbreak- the upcoming annual scientific meeting of
ing technologies. That legacy—along with the American Society of Anesthesiologist The EndoLIF on-cage implant.
our broad portfolio and collaborative part- in San Diego in just three months.” Image courtesy of Joimax.
nerships—enables us to truly make an
impact on patient care,” said Doug King, Joimax Gets FDA Clearance for “With the EndoLIF program, Joimax
president of the Spinal business and se- Endoscopic Lumbar Interbody offers a complete endoscopic-assisted so-
nior vice president at Medtronic. This Fusion Implant lution for spinal stabilization and fusion.
system represents our commitment to German company Joimax, which makes In the future, we will be able to treat pa-
take minimally invasive techniques and minimally invasive technology for endo- tients with even more gentle techniques,”
3-D-navigated surgery even further and scopic spinal surgery, has earned 510(k) said Wolfgang Ries, CEO and founder of
develop solutions with clinical and eco- U.S. Food and Drug Administration clear- Joimax. “Our next development will be an
nomic value.” ance for its EndoLIF (endoscopic lumbar EndoLIF cage on the basis of our Ilessys
Medtronic’s Spinal business is based in interbody fusion) on-cage implant. Delta system for posterior lumbar inter-
Memphis, Tenn., and offers therapies for The EndoLIF on-cage consists of tita- body fusion.” v
T
he orthopedic industry is seeking
new methods to drive innovation
as greater attention is given to
improving patient outcomes and con-
trolling healthcare costs. One method
that has been embraced by many com-
panies over the past few years is the use
of population analysis based on com-
puted tomography (CT) or magnetic
resonance imaging (MRI) to determine
new implant shapes and sizes.1 This
technology promises to reduce design
iterations, the number of cadaver labs
and the risks associated with design er-
rors. Population analysis also can be a
powerful argument in convincing regu-
latory bodies, hospital management and
surgeons of the thorough sizing ratio-
nale and good performance of a new
implant system.
This column examines how the DJO
Surgical division of orthopedic device
company DJO Global Inc. and medical
ADaM models represent the sample population of femurs as population-representative discrete geom-
etries. The femur in the middle represents the population average, with the -1 and +1 standard devia-
tion models of the first mode of variation on the left and right, respectively. Image courtesy of DJO.
Risk
Execution
Seeing
Your Product
Value
As You Do...
At SMC Ltd. we share your passion for success.
We oversee every aspect of your finished device.
From intial design engagment through packaging
and delivery, our contract manufacturing services
consistently meet your expectations.
Passion
United States • Costa Rica • India
www. smcltd.com
Design Viewpoint
Using the model femurs, standardized cross sections were located and then used to design
and verify the optimal shape for the TaperFill hip stem proximal body. Image courtesy of DJO.
veloped ADaM technology—an image- “In traditional population analysis, produced at standardized locations
based population analysis method.2 In the designer may have to a priori choose and used as input to interactively drive
the project for DJO, Materialise used a few discrete parameters to measure the best implant shape for maximizing
its expertise in segmentation and sta- from the available anatomical data sets, congruency and minimizing interfer-
tistical population analysis to combine often ignoring a significant amount of ence. The results could be directly vi-
3-D geometrical bone shapes from a the rich geometric data available,” said sualized, quantified and shared among
database of male and female femur CT Bryan Kirking, engineer at DJO. “Now the design team. Moreover, surgeons
scans into an average 3-D shape of the that we use the evidence brought by particularly liked the ability to directly
entire femur. This average shape con- this new technology in our design pro- visualize the cut femur as seen during
tains features, trends and population- cess, we feel much more confident that surgery, which helped evaluate inser-
specific shape information that best we are doing everything we can to op- tion and positioning characteristics that
represent those of the entire popula- timize implant geometry to the natural previously could only be evaluated at
tion, thereby forming a good starting anatomy. We are also able to reduce the later stages of the design process. Engi-
point for virtually assessing the fit of an number of design iterations and ca- neers were pleased to be able to use the
implant design. daver labs, thereby saving the company femur models in the same CAD soft-
Besides the average femur, varia- significant costs.” ware already being used to design the
tion models also were created to reflect The team proceeded with virtually implants and the ability to interactively
the 3-D geometry of typical larger and fitting their concept design into the visualize design geometries against the
smaller patients. These variation models femur models, with the aim of better model femurs. The final TaperFill hip
are not just larger or smaller versions of understanding the interaction of bone stem shares the same medial-lateral ta-
the average model; they are able to cap- and implant at key anatomical land- pered profile of DJO’s Linear hip stem,
ture how other aspects (e.g., offset and marks. After importing the femur mod- which has more than 17 years of clini-
neck angle) change together with size els into their computer-aided design cal success, and also, thanks to ADaM,
as well. (CAD) software, cross sections were has an optimized congruency with the
With increasing regulatory requirements, cost pressure and the need for evidence of
techniques that sounded like a thing of the future only a few years ago now are being used
N
ew advances in whole–body tive energy doses delivered during long driver of a 20 percent to 25 percent de-
magnetic resonance imaging exam times. Patient comfort in long ex- cline in reimbursement for MRI, affecting
(MRI) technology have cre- ams, as is the case with those typically providers, payers and patients that have
ated a powerful diagnostic tool for the performed on the spine, also is an issue. high-deductible plans.2 Even with this
entire musculoskeletal system—for the strong emphasis on cost cutting, the most
knee, spine and shoulder, in particular. Why It’s Important recent data shows that the U.S. healthcare
Whole-body MRI is a valuable tool that Like robotics, the average selling price system still generates the highest ASP.3
allows non-invasive evaluation of the (ASP) for an MRI system is expensive. In High-field and very-high-field
spine and the spinal cord to evaluate in- 2010, the ASP for a whole body MRI sys- whole-body scanners lead the market,
tervertebral discs, nerves, trauma to the tem was estimated at $1.2 million. Prices supplied by major international com-
spine and ligaments. However, there are are expected to decline as the market panies including GE Healthcare, Sie-
implications for patient safety. A high lo- becomes more competitive, declining to mens, Philips, Toshiba and Hitachi.
cal specific absorption rate carries risk an estimated $1.13 million in 2015. U.S. Very-high-field whole-body systems
of patient injury, as does large cumula- healthcare reform is reported to be the provide additional applications previ-
Chart 1
Chart 2
vascular structures, and re-
gions of the brain affected
by stroke.5 The MRI industry
is driven by the demand to
provide high-quality service
to patients in a competitive
environment. High-volume
production of MRI magnets
has led to efficient magnet
designs. Still, there are many
opportunities for improve-
ment to enable this diagnostic
tool to be available to patients
around the world. v
References
1 . M a r k e t s a n d M a r k e t s ,
2010 MRI Imaging
2. Ibid
3. www.itnonline.com/arti-
cle/advances-mri-market-tech-
nology-trend-analysis
4. Op. cit. 1
5. Op. cit. 3
Chart 3
Editor’s note: Readers are invit-
ed to submit their market data
and trend questions to Maria
Shepherd. Periodically, selected
questions will be presented in
this column along with answers
from Maria.
B
y now, the orthopedic device industry has had ample time to adjust to its “new normal.” Implant firms have had years, really,
to revamp their business models to jumpstart growth, but progress has been tortoise-like—hampered by lingering Affordable
Care Act uncertainty, new federal regulations, hospital consolidations, purchasing decision instability, fickle reimbursement rates
and demands for values-based solutions. Nevertheless, medtech manufacturers realize that future profits depend on their ability to
evolve with the market, and many have begun their metamorphoses, whether it be through acquisition (Medtronic-Covidien, Zimmer-
Biomet, Smith & Nephew-ArthroCare), partnerships (Novartis-Google[x]), restructuring or redefining innovation. As one healthcare
CEO noted, “Innovation is broader than delivering the next breakthrough product. It is about partnering with physicians, hospitals,
payers, patients and our communities to challenge conventional thinking and create medical solutions that save and improve millions
of lives worldwide—while reducing healthcare costs for all.”
The key to success, of course, lies in the industry’s ability to buck tradition—which historically, has been a virtual sacrilege among
implant manufacturers. But disruptive change is underway. Companies no longer will be able to earn premium margins by simply sell-
ing clinical features and new products into established market spaces. Rather, they will need to look at new segments and, particularly,
new end-to-end solutions to secure additional revenue and maintain margins, contends an A.T. Kearney report on forces currently
shaping the medical device industry.
“While the future contours of the medical device industry remain to be defined, radical change is inevitable, and the companies
who embrace it will both shape the industry and profit from it,” said Dave Powell, A.T. Kearney partner and study co-author.“Execu-
tives should urgently be evaluating the impact of disruptors and using this information to determine what capabilities and resources
they will need to build a distinctive business model that will enable them to compete in the future.”
Time is wasting.
1. DePuy Synthes
A survey by branding firm Landor Associates concluded that 77
percent of consumers believe it is important for companies to be
socially responsible.“There’s a heightened awareness of the need
to be, and to be seen as, a good corporate citizen,” noted Rob-
(a division of Johnson & Johnson)
ert Grosshandler, CEO of iGive.com, which allows consumers to
$9.67 Billion ($74.3B total) support their favorite charities through shopping.
Johnson & Johnson realized the value of good corporate
KEY EXECUTIVES: citizenship quite some time ago. The company bible, a.k.a. its
Alex Gorsky, Chairman & CEO 72-year-old Credo, pledges responsibility to the “world com-
Dominic J. Caruso, VP, Finance & Chief Financial Officer munity” as well as those in which the diversified healthcare firm
Stephen J. Cosgrove, Corporate Controller & Chief Accounting Officer operates. “We must be good citizens—support good works and
Michel Orsinger, Worldwide Chairman, Global Orthopaedics charities and bear our fair share of taxes,” the Credo reads. “We
Gary J. Pruden, Worldwide Chairman, Medical Devices Group must encourage civic improvements and better health and edu-
Karen Licitra, Worldwide Chairman, Global Medical Solutions cation. We must maintain in good order the property we are priv-
Kathryn E. Wengel, VP, Johnson & Johnson Supply Chain ileged to use, protecting the environment and natural resources.”
Charles Austin, Corporate VP, Global Supply Chain Like many companies, JNJ has refined its approach to CSR
Jesse J. Wu, Chairman, Johnson & Johnson China over the years by closely relating social causes to its core busi-
nesses, an approach scholars have dubbed “socially responsible
NO. of EMPLOYEES: 23,000 capitalism.” Last year, for example, the company eliminated PVC
(polyvinyl chloride) in its Enseal G2 Articulating Tissue sealers,
HEADQUARTERS: Warsaw, Ind.; Raynham, Mass; and and cut its energy and water consumption by 44 percent and 43
West Chester, Pa. percent respectively, in disinfecting/sterilizing the DePuy Syn-
thes TruMatch personalized Sigma Knee implants.
“Creating a strong business and building a better world are not con- By embodying CSR initiatives into its business strategy, JNJ is
flicting goals—they are both essential ingredients for long-term success.” both a good corporate citizen and a savvy investor—a combination
— William Clay Ford Jr., executive chairman, Ford Motor Co. that has helped the company continually boost its bottom line.
“Our credo is absolutely central to our culture and impacts
M
ilton Friedman remains as controversial a figure in everything we do. It reminds us that we are responsible to pa-
death as he was in life. tients, medical professionals, consumers, families and communi-
Renowned for his free-market ideology and con- ties worldwide, and it motivates our employees to come to work
servatism, Friedman’s antistatist views—mainly, the belief that every day with the passion to make a difference in the world...”
unimpeded private competition produces better results than CEO/Board Chairman Alex Gorsky told Leaders Magazine last
government—are still contentious subjects, nearly nine years af- spring. “We share a belief that if we take care of those responsi-
ter his demise. Yet the most fervent debates continue to revolve bilities, then everything else will take care of itself. Throughout
around his stance on corporate social responsibility, a concept he our history, this has been true.”
labeled“nonsensical”and harmful to the foundations of a free so- And it was true last year as well. The New Brunswick, N.J.-
ciety. Writing in The New York Times Magazine in September 1970, based company grew net sales 4.2 percent in 2014 to $74.3 billion,
the Nobel Prize laureate impenitently proclaimed that business bolstered mainly by a 15 percent jump in global pharmaceutical
has “only one social responsibility—to use its resources and en- revenue ($32.3 billion). The increase in drug sales offset a 1.3 per-
gage in activities designed to increase its profits so long as it stays cent slide in worldwide Consumer sales ($14.5 billion) and a 3.4
within the rules of the game, which is to say, engages in open and percent decrease in Medical Devices proceeds ($27.5 billion). Ex-
free competition without deception or fraud.” cluding the net impact of M&A activity, including the June 2014
Friedman believed corporations are inhuman entities that divestiture of Ortho Clinical Diagnostics, the medical devices
cannot possibly have real responsibilities. In the ideal free mar- segment had underlying operational growth of 1.5 percent.
ket, he contended,“all cooperation is voluntary...There are no val- JNJ’s Pharmaceutical segment traditionally has outperformed
ues, no ‘social’ responsibilities in any sense other than the shared its brethren, but executives are planning to even the score a bit by
values and responsibilities of individuals.” seeking approval of more than 30 major products in its Medical
Friedman’s unconventional business strategy initially resound- Devices division by the end of 2016 while also focusing on fast-
ed with Americans (journalist/author George Will called him “the growing emerging markets. Much of that focus will be centered
most consequential public intellectual of the 20th century”) but on China and Russia, where the medtech sector is growing three
support for the doctrine has dwindled considerably as companies to four times faster than in developed markets.
respond to consumer demands for reputational excellence. “China is important to every medical device company given
Numerous studies have shown that corporate social respon- the number of people and the size of the market opportunity,”
sibility (CSR) policies influence consumer purchasing decisions. Glenn Novarro, an analyst with RBC Capital Markets in New
www.sterigenics.com
curing hyaluronan found in healthy joint fluid, and to cushion, latter (and five former sales team employees) of breach of
protect and lubricate the knee joint. contract. A complaint filed in a New Jersey federal court al-
Monovisc is specifically for patients who have failed to re- leged the five Stryker sales reps resigned en masse in April
spond adequately to conservative non-pharmacologic therapy (2014) and immediately began soliciting customers in North
and simple analgesics such as acetaminophen. Carolina, and promoting DePuy products among area doctors,
The Peak Platelet-Rich Plasma (PRP) system works by separat- moves that reportedly cost the firm roughly $3.4 million. The
ing PRP from a sample of a patient’s own blood. The device con- five accused were key members of the Stryker Howmedica
sistently produces 3 mL of high-quality PRP from 27 mL of whole team assigned to promote and sell orthopedic reconstruc-
blood in two-and-a-half minutes, yielding up to seven times the tive and trauma products to physicians and surgeons in the
normal concentration of platelets, according to DePuy Synthes. Fresno and Bakersfield, CA areas, according to the complaint.
The company’s Codman Neuro unit experienced a busy sec- Stryker claims their illegal actions will cost the company up
ond half of 2014, releasing two catheters and a disposable for- to 90 percent of its reconstructive devices sales and between
ceps, and securing approval in China, South Korea and Taiwan 60 and 70 percent of its trauma parts sales in the region. The
for its Revive SE Thrombectomy device, a next-generation self- suit alleges that the five company defectors submitted almost
expanding clot removal product intended to restore blood flow identical resignation letters simultaneously in April and did
in patients with acute ischemic stroke secondary to intracranial not respond to phone calls, emails, or text messages.
occlusive vessel disease. • In August, Stryker extended an olive branch (of sorts) to
The Revive SE device is designed to ease navigation through DePuy Synthes, dismissing the company from a patent
small and tortuous blood vessels and arteries in the cerebral vas- infringement lawsuit over its hip implant acetabular cup,
culature. The product enables rapid restoration of blood flow to which features a“dual-locking mechanism and is capable
the brain during an acute ischemic stroke. of accommodating a plurality of bearings with different
DePuy Synthes debuted its catheters during the Society of characteristics.”
NeuroInterventional Surgery 11th Annual Meeting last summer • Bonutti Skeletal Innovations LLC rang in a merry holiday
in Colorado. The Envoy DA XB Guiding Catheter enables access season with its federal lawsuit (in December) claiming
to more distal anatomy and is designed to provide additional DePuy Synthes’ product line of spinal devices infringes
proximal support of the catheter when more stability is required. six patents owned by Bonutti, generally covering wedge
It features end-to-end braided construction, a distal 10 centi- implants and their methods of implantation.
meter hydrophilic coating, soft distal tip with a recessed metal
marker, and Brite Tip Technology for enhanced visibility.
The 7F Envoy Guiding Catheter is the largest-diameter guiding
1. Stryker
catheter the company has ever offered, expanding upon its 6F Envoy
line. With stainless steel end-to-end hybrid braid technology and
soft distal Brite Tip Technology, the new catheters are offered in mul-
tiple shape configurations to navigate and treat different anatomy.
$9.67 Billion
Courtroom Drama
JNJ is no stranger to the judicial system. As the world’s largest and KEY EXECUTIVES:
most diversified healthcare firm, it spends a considerable amount Kevin A. Lobo, President & CEO
of time in the courtroom fending off legal challenges from rivals, Lonny J. Carpenter, Group President, Global Quality and Operations
defending its integrity and protecting its proprietary technology. Ramesh Subrahmanian, Group President, International
A summary of the more notable cases in 2014 follows: David K. Floyd, Group President, Orthopaedics
Timothy J. Scannell, Group President, MedSurg & Neurotechnology
• Baxter International lodged a patent infringement com- J. Andrew Pierce, President, Endoscopy
plaint against JNJ in January 2014, accusing its rival of vio- James N. Heath, President, Instruments
lating six patents protecting Baxter’s biosurgery products, William J. Huffnagle, President, Reconstructive
including Floseal, used to control bleeding during surgery. Vivian Masson, President, Trauma & Extremities
The suit contends JNJ’s hemostasis delivery devices, includ- Mark H. Paul, President, Neurovascular
ing its SurgiFlo product line, directly compete with Baxter’s Bradford L. Saar, President, Medical
biosurgery products. Floseal and SurgiFlo are indicated Spencer S. Stiles, President, Spine
for use in surgical procedures as an adjunct to hemostasis Wayne D. Dahlberg, President, Performance Solutions
when control of bleeding by ligature or other conventional
methods is ineffective or impractical, according to the suit. NO. of EMPLOYEES: 26,000
• The rivalry between Stryker Corp. and DePuy Synthes reached
a boiling point last summer, when the former accused the HEADQUARTERS: Kalamazoo, Mich.
38 • ODT odtmag.com July/August 2015
Top Companies
N
ever let it be said that medical technology is uninspiring. for it—not only for inspiring me to pursue medicine, but also for
Meet Tadashi Kikuchi, M.D., and Galina Gheihman, making it physically possible for me to do so.”
two rather ordinary individuals driven to magnificence Perhaps even more inspiring than Stryker’s Xia 3 system is
by Stryker Corp. innovations. Kikuchi, a surgeon at Bange Ko- the Customized Mandible Reconstruction Plate, used last year to
sei General Hospital in Fukushima, Japan, is the company’s rebuild the lower jaw of a Kazakhstanian woman grievously dis-
6,000-knee-man, having reached that procedural milestone in figured by a misdiagnosis of terminal cancer. Based on anatomi-
January with the help of sales representative Toshikazu Shimazu cal data and a clinical analysis, the customized plate is designed
(and Stryker’s lineup of artificial joints, of course). specifically for the patient (indeed, the number and position of
Gheihman is a Harvard Medical School
student inspired to pursue her dream career
after suffering from a debilitating childhood
spinal condition. The Toronto, Canada, na-
tive was an active youngster, participating in
basketball, springboard diving and ballroom
dancing, but developed lower back pain at
14—an age of tremendous physical change.
The pain eventually affected her ability to
play youth sports.
“What had been a dull, aching pain
stretching across my lower back was soon
joined by shooting, sharp nerve pain running
down the backs of my legs and a tingling
numbness in my calves,” Gheihman recalled
in Stryker’s 2014 annual report.
In 2008, Gheihman was diagnosed with
spondylolisthesis, a condition in which a verte-
bra in the spine moves forward out of its prop-
er position onto the bone below. In children,
spondylolisthesis usually occurs between the
fifth bone in the lower back (lumbar vertebra)
and the first bone in the pelvis area; the condi-
tion often can be traced to a birth defect in that
area of the spine or a sudden injury.
Two years after her diagnosis, Gheihman
underwent surgery at Toronto Hospital for
Sick Children, receiving Stryker’s Xia 3 im-
plant to correct the vertebral misplacement
and stabilize her lower back. The spinal sys-
tem, used in more than 500,000 cases globally,
features a buttress thread blocker that helps
eliminate cross-threading, prevents screw
head splaying and ensures secure closure.
Gheihman resumed her active lifestyle
several months after the surgery with hikes
and camping trips, and she put Stryker’s
hardware to the test in 2011 by completing a
50-mile sea kayaking trip in Vancouver, Brit-
ish Columbia. Her back problems are now a
distant memory.
“It’s been a dream come true,” Gheihman
said, “and I have my surgeon, Dr. [Stephen]
Lewis; the Toronto Hospital for Sick Chil-
dren; and Stryker’s products, technology and
physician technical support team to thank
3. Zimmer
ability products (reprocessed and remanufactured devices) fell
out of favor as sales slid 1.8 percent to $209 million.
Stryker’s Orthopaedics segment (formerly its Reconstructive
unit) ended the year with a perfect growth record, boosting to-
tal revenue 5.1 percent to $4.1 billion. All four product divisions $4.67 Billion
contributed to the upswing, with orthobiologics, biosurgery and
performance solution products leading the charge by way of a KEY EXECUTIVES:
24.2 percent revenue hike (to $236 million). Trauma and Extremi- David C. Dvorak, President & CEO
ties pitched in with a 10.2 percent sales increase ($1.23 billion), James T. Crines, Exec. VP of Finance & Chief Financial Officer
followed by Knees with a 1.8 percent gain ($1.4 billion) and Hips Joseph A. Cucolo, President, Americas
with a 1.5 percent spike ($1.29 billion). Kataryna Mazur-Hofsaess, M.D., Ph.D., President, Europe,
Hip sales likely were stunted to some extent by Stryker’s deci- Middle East and Africa
sion last fall to settle thousands of patient lawsuits over its recalled Stephen H.L. Ooi, President of Asia Pacific
metal-on-metal Rejuvenate Modular-Neck and ABG II Modular Matt E. Monaghan, Sr. VP, Global Hips &
Neck hip implants for $1.42 billion. Cleared by the FDA in 2008 and Reconstructive Research
2009 respectively, the devices were pulled from the market in July Stephen E. White, Sr. VP & General Manager, Knees
2012 after dozens of patients reported problems with the artificial David J. Kunz, VP, Global Quality, Regulatory and Clinical Affairs
implants (among them: pain, inflammation, infection, loosening, Richard C. Stair, Sr. VP, Global Operations and Logistics
compromised mobility, and in extreme cases, failure). Stryker ex-
ecutives expected the settlement to have a minimal impact on 2014 NO. of EMPLOYEES: 10,000
earnings since most of the payments would be dispersed in 2015.
Likewise, fiscal fallout from the company’s OtisKnee settlement HEADQUARTERS: Warsaw, Ind.
had a minimal impact on Knee revenue. In early December, Stryk-
K
er agreed to pay the U.S. government $79.5 million to settle crimi- en Watson’s pain typically followed the same daily pattern.
nal and civil charges that its OtisMed Corp. subsidiary sold devices It would start in his shoulder blade and then intensify,
used in knee replacement surgery without approval from the FDA. the dull ache suddenly turning into a white-hot lightning
Such legal drama was lacking in Stryker’s Neurotechnol- bolt that radiated to his neck. Once there, it sat like a pool of mol-
ogy and Spine segment, which posted an overall 5 percent sales ten lava, aggravating the muscles and nerves already strained by
increase to $1.7 billion. Neurotechnology product proceeds hours of sedentary computer use. Every so often, the pain would
climbed 9.4 percent to $1 billion, bolstered undoubtedly by the cut a fresh swath down his left arm. Relief was next to impossible.
February launch of the Trevo XP ProVue Retriever, an expansion “I would just come home and feel like going straight to bed
of the firm’s ProVue Retriever line for acute ischemic stroke treat- because that’s the only way I could get comfortable,” he recalled.
ment. The addition provides additional size and shape options for Thinking his rotator cuff was torn or—worse—detached, Wat-
doctors. Spine sales slipped 0.4 percent to $740 million despite son sought help (and relief) from an orthopedic shoulder special-
(or perhaps on account of) the March acquisition of CoAlign In- ist. But after reviewing Watson’s X-rays and magnetic resonance
novations Inc., a manufacturer of implants for lower lumbar pro- imaging films, the specialist determined his shoulder was beyond
cedures, and the November debuts of the LITe TLIF Procedural repair and recommended replacement surgery.
Solution and Aero-AL anchor-based ALIF technology. Watson was stunned at the prognosis but jumped at the
The LITe (less-invasive technology) TLIF system combines chance to lead a pain-free existence.“He [the orthopedist] said, ‘I
several innovations, including the LITe Pedical Based Refractor, know we can take care of your pain,’”Watson fondly reminisced.
the ES2 Percutaneous Spinal System, and the AccuLIF Expand- “The decision to have [the surgery] was an easy one to make once
able Lumbar Interbody Fusion technology. The LITe Pedical Based I got home and talked with my wife ... even there in the office, I
Refractor allows for direct visualization and a less invasive work- said, ‘Let’s go ahead with this.’”
www.HDSurgical.com
(putty) bone void filler products to its biologics portfolio, enhanc- Extreme-Angle screw technology allowing for 112 degrees of
ing Zimmer’s ability to treat early-stage joint disease. conical range of motion and simple rod alignment. The Virage
Surgical product proceeds fell back to earth in 2014 after skyrock- system also includes a proprietary friction-fit screw head that
eting 18 percent the previous year. Revenue slid 5 percent to $410 holds the desired rod in position.
million as Zimmer’s temporary edge in the fluid waste management
market ended with the commercial return of a competitor’s capital “These new products reflect our vision to introduce solutions
equipment part (used with a single-use disposable manifold com- that make a meaningful difference for our surgeon customers and
ponent in its own fluid waste management system). their patients,” Dvorak wrote in his letter to shareholders at the
Spine sales bounced back from a five-year downward spiral start of the firm’s 2014 annual report.“Technologies such as these
with a 2 percent growth rate owing to solid demand for the Path- also advance our objective to become the single-solution pro-
Finder NXT minimally invasive pedicle screw system and trabec- vider at every stage of the continuum of care, offering the most
ular metal technology products. Revenue totaled $207.2 million; personalized and appropriate therapies for every condition and
gains were highest in Asia and Europe. The company helped en- patient. Our results in 2014 are evidence of Zimmer’s sustained
sure future growth in this notoriously difficult segment with 12 focus on our strategic growth platform.”
new product launches, including: That platform delivered constant currency net sales growth of
• Puros Demineralized Bone Matrix (DBM) block and strip, 2.4 percent (1 percent reported, to $4.67 billion) and a 5.4 per-
bone graft substitutes used to stimulate natural bone cent increase in adjusted earnings per share (to $6.06). Operat-
formation processes in spinal surgeries. Used alone or ing profit climbed 5 percent (adjusted) to $1.43 billion, and gross
as a bone graft extender, Puros DBM allografts provide profit rose 2.5 percent to $3.42 billion. Net earnings, however,
osteoconductive and osteoinductive properties, improved declined 5.3 percent due to increased spending on the company’s
handling and excellent graft containment. operational excellence initiatives, a $70 million legal fee and in-
• Puros DBM Reverse Phase medium putty, putty with tegration planning/debt issuance costs associated with its block-
chips, gel and paste—products designed to stimulate buster $13.35 billion bid for Biomet Inc.
natural bone formation processes in
which mesenchymal cells differentiate
into bone-forming cells. Puros DBM
with reverse phase medium items
allow the allograft to be malleable at
operating room temperatures while
causing the product to stiffen when
placed into the body.
• The Optio-C Anterior Cervical System,
a modular, stand-alone cervical device
that offers allograft/autograft and PEEK
(polyether ether ketone) options and
delivers the strength, stability and fu-
sion potential of a traditional anterior
cervical discectomy and fusion. Offering
secure fixation with no profile, the
system comprises an anterior cervical
plate, three bone screws and either a
PEEK intervertebral body fusion device
or structural allograft/autograft. The
system is designed to maximize fusion
with a load-sharing interface and mul-
tiple implant footprints.
• The Virage OCT Spinal Fixation System,
an occipital-cervico-thoracic spinal
fixation solution that uses Zimmer’s
360 decrees Omnidirectional Extreme-
Angle screw to bring a new experience
to posterior fixation surgery. All Virage
System polyaxial dual-lead screws incor-
porate the 360 degrees Omnidirectional
surgery without the Verasense technology. surrounding soft tissues. Because there is less soft tissue that needs
In February, the company launched its Polarstem cementless stem to heal, patients undergoing direct anterior hip surgery reported
for total hip replacement in the United States. Available outside the less postoperative pain. Additionally, because the gluteal muscles
United States since 2002, the implant is one of the company’s most and other natural stabilizers are left undisturbed during the direct
popular stems globally and features a unique geometry and surface anterior approach, it is possible for patients to regain mobility more
texture. Polarstem earned 510(k) clearance from the U.S. Food and quickly and ultimately go home from the hospital sooner.
Drug Administration (FDA) in October of 2013. Polarstem implant of-
fers several design features that assist with muscle sparing approaches Financial Details
for U.S. surgeons who use the direct anterior approach for total hip For fiscal 2014 (ended Dec. 31), revenue was $4.62 billion, an in-
replacement. For example, the proximal portion of the stem is wider crease of 2 percent on an underlying basis and 6 percent on a
to help reduce the possibility of movement downward into the bone. reported basis (2013: $4.35 million). Acquisitions added 5 percent
The distal portion of the stem is shorter and features a narrower tip, to the reported growth rate, while currency was responsible for a
making it easier to implant through the smaller incision used in the 1 percent negative impact on growth.
direct anterior approach. Lastly, the stem features an advanced surface “Our 2014 performance reflects the choices we have made to
texture of titanium plasma and a hydroxyapatite layer. invest in transforming the growth profile of Smith & Nephew,”
Verilast technology is a low-friction bearing couple combining noted CEO Bohuon in a prepared statement. “We improved our
Oxinium oxidized zirconium, a patented ceramicized metal alloy existing businesses, driving a sustained improvement in U.S. hip
for the femoral head, and a cross-linked polyethylene (XLPE) cup and knee implants and building rapidly in the emerging markets.
liner for the acetabulum. During lab testing, Verilast technology We strengthened our higher growth platforms, acquiring Arthro-
demonstrated 67 percent less wear than the combination of cobalt Care to give us a broader sports medicine portfolio. We created
chrome and XLPE. With the direct anterior approach, an incision new growth platforms with the mid-tier portfolio and Syncera
is made on the front of the hip rather than the side or back. As a disruptive models that fulfill unmet customer needs, and ad-
result, the surgeon can follow the natural spaces between the hip vanced wound bioactives again delivered double-digit growth.”
joint’s muscles and tendons, thereby minimizing the damage to the The Advanced Surgical Devices (ASD) division delivered 2014
5. Biomet
The Advanced Wound Management segment is grouped into
disposable wound care products (Advanced Wound Care), elec-
trical equipment for wound therapy (Advanced Wound Devices),
and bioactives (Advanced Wound Bioactives). Sales for Advanced
Wound Management delivered 2014 revenue of $1.32 billion, $3.22 Billion
down 1 percent on an underlying basis (2013: $1.35 billion). For
A
Advanced Wound Management, revenue was down 4 percent in nd then there were four.
the United States ($454 million) and 2 percent in other estab- It’s become survival of the fittest in the orthopedic
lished markets ($699 million), and up 14 percent in the emerging world, or quite literally, survival of the richest, as multi-
and international markets ($166 million). Advanced Wound Care national implant manufacturers exploit their fiscal clout to gain
revenue was down 4 percent ($805 million). Sales of Advanced market supremacy. Responding to a shifting healthcare land-
Wound Devices were down 9 percent ($192 million), impacted scape defined by cost pressures, shrinking reimbursement rates
by the U.S. Renasys hold. Sales of Advanced Wound Bioactives, and customer demands for fewer product choices, orthopedic
however, delivered strong growth, up 15 percent ($322 million). device firms are transforming themselves into “one-stop shops”
Smith & Nephew temporarily ceased commercial distribution to boost their appeal to hospital clients.
A
pril 24, 2014: Zimmer announces plan to purchase some European assets.
Biomet for $13.35 billion, including the assumption of March 25, 2015: Japan Fair Trade Commission clears the
net debt. Upon its closing, the deal would create the Zimmer-Biomet deal.
industry’s second-largest manufacturer/provider of orthopedic March 30, 2015: The European Commission gives its bless-
implants. ing to the acquisition provided that Zimmer divests a knee
May 2014: Zimmer and Biomet boards approve the pend- implant business in the European Economic Area and Biomet
ing purchase. sells an elbow implant unit in the region as well as a knee im-
June 12, 2014: The European Commission halts review of plant business in Denmark and Sweden.
the Zimmer-Biomet union, claiming the company’s submis- April 17, 2015: Zimmer sells its Unicompartmental High
sion lacked some details. Flex Knee and Biomet unloads its Discovery Elbow System and
July 2, 2014: The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission Vanguard Complete Knee System to Lima Corporate to sat-
issues a subpoena requiring Biomet produce documents relating isfy European regulators’ conditions for merger approval. The
to “certain alleged improprieties” in the company’s Brazilian and agreement with Lima becomes effective upon the Zimmer-
Mexican operations. Biomet apparently had become aware of those Biomet deal’s closing.
“improprieties”in October 2013 and had retained lawyers and“oth- June 24, 2015: Zimmer receives U.S. Federal Trade Com-
er experts”to investigate.“Based on the results of the investigation, mission clearance for its merger with Biomet after agreeing to
Biomet terminated, suspended or otherwise disciplined certain sell its Unicompartmental High Flex Knee system in the U.S.
employees and executives involved in the matters, and took certain market to rival Smith & Nephew plc. The acquisition officially
other remedial measures,”according to a regulatory filing. closes, and Zimmer Biomet Holdings Inc. is born.
February 2015: Zimmer submits a revised plan to Europe- June 29, 2015: Zimmer Biomet Holdings Inc. begins trading
an regulators on the Biomet deal. The company contends the on the New York Stock Exchange under the ticker symbol ZBH.
revised proposal is “generally consistent” with one it submitted The company’s new tagline is “Your progress. Our promise.”
in December (2014), which included plans to divest itself of — ODT
Such metamorphoses have become quite common in the last de- Zimmer’s Chief Financial Officer (CFO) James Crines and
cade, with major players like Smith & Nephew plc buying Plus Ortho- Asia Pacific President Stephen Ooi both retired following the
paedics and ArthroCare Corp., Stryker Corp. merging with Orthovita deal’s closing, but Crines continues to serve in an advisory role.
Inc., Tornier N.V. purchasing Wright Medical Group, and Johnson & Dvorak now is president/CEO of the combined company,
Johnson (through its DePuy subsidiary) snagging Synthes Inc. which is organized around three business units led by 12 ex-
Zimmer Holdings Inc. finally jumped on the mega-merger band- ecutives who report directly to him. These include the heads of
wagon last spring, offering $13.35 billion for Biomet Inc.“We believe business units, geographic regions and functional areas. Two of
that current demographic and macroeconomic trends affecting the the three business heads reporting to Dvorak come from Biom-
healthcare industry will reward companies that successfully partner et: Adam Johnson, group president for the Spine, Microfixation,
with other key stakeholders to improve patient care in a cost-effec- Bone Healing and Dental businesses; David Nolan, group presi-
tive manner. Together with Biomet we will expand the scope of our dent for the Sports Medicine, Extremities, Trauma, Biologics and
innovation programs and will enhance our efforts to provide inte- Surgical businesses; and Daniel Williamson, group president for
grated services and comprehensive solutions that address the needs the Knee, Hip and Bone Cement businesses.
of our customers. At the same time, we believe that this merger will Among the three geographical leaders named, two hail from
further support our long-term growth and stockholder value cre- Zimmer and one from Biomet. Of the six functional area heads,
ation strategies,” Zimmer President and CEO David C. Dvorak said four are from Zimmer and two are from Biomet. These include
when the merger was announced in April 2014. David Florin as senior vice president and CFO; he was previously
It took Zimmer more than a year to officially close the deal, Biomet’s CFO.
having been forced to satisfy American and European regulators Biomet’s final earnings report was a crowd-pleaser, as con-
with several product line divestitures. In late June 2015, however, solidated net sales rose 5 percent to $3.2 billion in the fiscal year
the two separate companies became one, and the newly named ended May 31, 2014.
Zimmer Biomet began trading on the New York Stock Exchange U.S. net revenue increased 5.8 percent to $1.97 billion, while Eu-
on June 29. (For more details on the merger’s logic, turn to the Zim- ropean proceeds jumped 8.7 percent (4.8 percent in constant cur-
mer listing on page 42). rency) to $772.0 million. International sales (comprising primarily
Spine
during FY14, compared to $964.1 million during FY13.
Operating income was $313.2 million compared to an operating
loss of $164.5 million during the previous fiscal year. Excluding spe-
cial items, adjusted operating income totaled $863.8 million during
FY14, compared to $837.6 million during the prior year period. $3.04 Billion ($17B total)
Net income was $36.8 million, compared to a net loss of
$623.4 million during the prior year. Excluding special items, ad- KEY EXECUTIVES:
justed net income totaled $420.1 million. Omar Ishrak, Chairman & CEO
Excluding special items, adjusted EBITDA (earnings before Gary Ellis, Exec. VP & Chief Financial Officer, Medtronic
interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization) during fiscal 2014 Mike Genau, Sr. VP & President, Americas Region, Medtronic
totaled $1.078 billion compared to $1.03 billion in 2013. Richard E. Kuntz, M.D., Sr. VP & Chief Scientific, Clinical and
Preliminary reported cash flow from operations came to $529.0 Regulatory Officer, Medtronic
million. Free cash flow (operating cash flow minus capital expen- Chris Lee, Sr. VP & President, Greater China Region, Medtronic
ditures) was $300.3 million, which included $347.4 million of cash Stephen N. Oesterle, M.D., Sr.VP, Medicine & Technology, Medtronic
interest paid during the year, compared to a free cash flow of $264.5 Luann Pendy, Sr. VP, Global Quality, Medtronic
million during FY13, including $388.6 million of cash interest paid. Rob Ten Hoedt, Exec. VP & President, Europe, Middle East and
Biomet briefly experienced a role reversal, having acquired Africa Region, Medtronic
Lanx Inc., a full-service spine company roughly six months be- Bob White, Sr. VP & President, Asia Pacific Region, Medtronic
fore it was purchased itself. At the time, the merger expanded Geoff Martha, Exec. VP & President, Medtronic Restorative
Biomet’s spine technology portfolio through the addition of such Therapies Group
products as the Timberline Lateral Approach Fusion System and Doug King, President, Medtronic Spine
the Aspen Minimally Invasive Fusion System. Both items com-
plemented Biomet’s spine offerings, including the Lineum OCT NO. of EMPLOYEES: 5,000
Spine System, Maxan Anterior Cervical Plate system, Cellentra
VCBM and the Polaris Translation Screw System. HEADQUARTERS: Memphis, Tenn.
“This is an exciting opportunity for Biomet to improve its
W
competitiveness in the spine market by leveraging the best as- ithout a doubt, Medtronic is a company of firsts.
pects of each company and adding strategically important tech- Most of its milestones, of course, are breakthroughs in
nologies to our product portfolio,” former Biomet president/CEO healthcare technology—the first battery-operated exter-
Jeff Binder said. nal pacemaker (1957); the first commercially produced implantable
Some of Biomet’s final product releases included the ePAK Sin- pacemaker (1960); the first implantable, programmable neurostimu-
gle-Use Delivery system and the Juggerknotless Soft Anchor Device. lation device for chronic pain (1983); the first implantable cardioverter
Biomet released the ePAK single-use delivery system, an in- defibrillator (1993); the first insulin pump with real-time glucose
novation for internal fracture fixation, in July 2013. The system is a monitoring (2006); and there are many other examples, in innovation
pre-sterilized, single-use procedure pack that aims to add value by as well as in the company’s far-reaching philanthropic work.
addressing the productivity needs of the operating room by helping But 2014 saw another—and perhaps less auspicious, depend-
to save time, reduce cost, improve efficiency, and ultimately increase ing upon your point of view—first for the world’s largest stand-
productivity. The ePAK system addresses distal radius fractures and alone medical device company. With its nearly $50 billion pur-
features the DVR Crosslock implant and instrumentation. chase of Dublin, Ireland-based Covidien plc, Medtronic pulled
In July 2014, Biomet’s sports medicine subsidiary launched the off the largest-ever “inversion” deal (at the time) in U.S. history.
Juggerknotless soft anchor device, an innovation the company Medtronic Inc., once headquartered just outside Minneapolis in
claimed was the first all-suture, knotless product on the market. Fridley, Minn., became Medtronic plc, now rooted in its acqui-
Used for labral repair surgery in the shoulder, the Juggerknotless sition’s base in Dublin. Inversion deals are structured to reduce
Soft Anchor Features: U.S. income taxes and typically involve a U.S.-based company
• The benefits of all-suture anchor technology, which acquiring a foreign firm and relocating there for tax purposes.
eliminates the use of a hard implant that can fracture and The deal for Covidien was announced in June 2014, just after
cause loose bodies in the joint. the start of Medtronic’s 2015 fiscal year. The deal was completed
• A small, 2,1 millimeter drill hole that preserves bone and in January this year. The cash-and-stock transaction was valued
allows more freedom in anchor placement. at approximately $49.9 billion, based on Medtronic’s closing
• Technology that allows the surgeon to control the tension stock price of $75.59 per share on Jan. 26. Under the terms of the
of the construct without tying a surgical knot. transaction, each ordinary share of Covidien outstanding as of
ing, investing in and delivering therapy and procedural Officials noted the combination would also result in the diver-
innovations to address the major disease states impacting sification of Medtronic’s revenue base due to a stronger founda-
patients and healthcare costs in the United States and tion in emerging-market R&D and manufacturing and the addi-
around the world; tion of industry-leading capabilities and expertise in general and
• Globalization: With a presence in more than 150 coun- advanced surgery and patient monitoring.
tries, the combined entity would be better able to serve Medtronic also revealed the proposed management structure
global market needs. Medtronic and Covidien have of the new company. The new Medtronic is composed of four
combined pro forma revenues of approximately $27 bil- major business segments, headed by Medtronic’s three existing
lion including approximately $13 billion from outside the group presidents plus Covidien group president Bryan Hanson.
U.S., of which $3.7 billion comes from emerging markets. The four segments are Medtronic’s Cardiac and Vascular Group,
Covidien’s capabilities in emerging market research and valued at $8.8 billion; its Restorative Therapies Group (which
development (R&D) and manufacturing, joined with includes the company’s spine business) worth $6.5 billion; its
Medtronic’s clinical expertise across a much broader Diabetes Group, worth $1.7 billion; and the fourth, the Covidien
product offering, significantly increases the number of at- Group (which was quickly renamed the Minimally Invasive Ther-
tractive solutions the new company would be able to offer apies Group not long after the merger closed), currently valued
globally; and at $10.4 billion. Covidien’s neurovascular business will function
• Economic value: Medtronic has adopted an intense focus on as an independent business under the umbrella of Medtronic’s
aligning with its customers to create more value in health- restorative therapies group. The company also announced four
care systems around the world by combining products, ser- geographic regions around which the combined company will
vices and insights into solutions aimed at expanding access operate: Asia Pacific, the Americas, EMEA (Europe, the Middle
and reducing healthcare costs. With Covidien, Medtronic East and Africa) and Greater China—down from Medtronic’s
would be able to provide a broader array of complementary present seven regions.
therapies and solutions that can be packaged to drive more “While we will move to four regions in the future—versus the
value and efficiency in healthcare systems. seven regions represented in the Medtronic structure today—this is
and $140 million in fiscal years 2015 and 2014, respectively, re-
lated to InFuse. In addition, investors have filed lawsuits claiming
that the company harmed its value with the handling of InFuse.
On top of that, last summer, health insurance company Humana
filed a racketeering lawsuit alleging Medtronic had promoted
InFuse for uses not approved by the FDA. The lawsuit cites the
Racketeer Influenced & Corrupt Organizations statute, com-
monly called RICO, and was filed in Tennessee Western District
Court. “Defendants paid for and sponsored publication of aca-
demic and peer-reviewed literature that falsely represented In-
Fuse and [recombinant bone morphogenetic protein-2] as safe
and effective for uses not approved by the Food & Drug Admin-
istration. Defendants knew or should have known that Humana
would rely on the fraudulent literature to pay for Infuse and/or
BMP,” according to text from the suit.
For the third quarter of 2015 (ended Jan. 23), BMP revenue
was $122 million, up 9 percent. For the final quarter of the com-
pany’s fiscal 2015 (ended April 24), BMP revenue was up mid-
single digits, though overall spine sales for the year continued
their slide (see overall company results for the most recent fiscal
year below).
VITAL STATISTICS
Year Founded: 1979
Number of Employees: 70 Our expertise includes:
Number of Facilities: 1 • Multi-axis CNC Milling
Annual Sales: > $10 Million • CNC Turning — Bar feed capacity from .030 to 3.000”
diameter
WHO WE ARE • EDM Wire — Both CNC Wire EDM with 4-and 5-axis
capability and Sinker type EDM.
• Heat Treating — In-house heat treating capability up to 1100
deg. for most preceptive hardening materials. Chart recordings
and hardness testing are archived as required by our customers.
• Laser Etching
• Precision Welding — TIG welding processes complying with
AWS standards free of all surface and subsurface defects. Weld
processes inspected by dye penetrate and magnified visual
inspection.
• Metal Finishing — Automated, multi-media vibratory finishing
processing. Proven to be an extremely economic process for
fulfilling many surface finish and cosmetic requirements.
• CMM Inspection
• Passivation — Nitric and citric passivation
• Belting, Polishing, and Cosmetic Finishes — A full range of
belting and polishing equipment with grit and shot peening
Founded in 1979, Centex has evolved with the medical-device capability. Cosmetic anodize, hard chrome, electro-polishing,
industry, serving customers in the early years of double-digit and other chemical or electrical finishes are well understood at
growth and expansion, as well as the dynamic periods of Centex. Centex can easily comply with all surface texturing and
corporate mergers and acquisitions. As the healthcare industry finish call outs.
advanced, we proved our ability to work proactively with • Simple to Complex Assemblies — Centex has built some of the
customers to address the ongoing pressures of reduced costs most complex assembled products in the business – experience
and new standards. that sets us apart from the competition.
SERVICES OFFERED
Centex offers a complete integrated manufacturing facility for
your fabrication project. Just as the medical industry has always
been an innovator in product design, Centex Machining’s
dedication to staying on the cutting edge of manufacturing
technology and supplier controls reinforces our reputation as an
innovator in product fabrication.
7. DJO Global
out an entire shoulder product portfolio.
“We are very pleased to now offer our e-plus vitamin E tech-
nology within the Reverse Shoulder product line. Through our
e-plus offering, we seek to enhance the clinical success across our
$1.23 Billion shoulder portfolio, including the Turon Anatomic Total Shoulder
and Reverse Shoulder implant families. We now proudly offer e-
KEY EXECUTIVES: plus technology throughout our entire surgical product portfolio,
Michael P. Mogul, President, CEO & Director including knee, hip and shoulder,”said Bryan Monroe, senior vice
Toby Bost, President, DJO Global Consumer Business president for DJO Surgical.
Susan Crawford, Exec. VP & Chief Financial Officer Unique formulations of e-plus have been optimized to reduce
Steven Ingel, President, Global Bracing and Supports wear, eliminate oxidation and maintain mechanical properties
Joe McClung, Sr. VP & General Manager, DJO Global Vascular in DJO Surgical’s knee, hip and shoulder products as compared
Gerry McDonnell, Exec. VP, Global Operations with conventional polyethylene. The e-plus formulation, opti-
Stephen J. Murphy, President, Sales and Marketing, Interna- mized for DJO Surgical’s reverse shoulder prosthesis, reduces
tional Commercial Business wear rates by 92 percent while maintaining the yield strength of
Mike Peters, Exec. VP, Chief Information Officer conventional polyethylene, according to the company. Officials
Brady R. Shirley, President, DJO Surgical say that together, the advancements potentially can lead to un-
Sharon Wolfington, President, Global Recovery Sciences paralleled implant longevity.
In 2015, DJO got off to a strong start with new product intro-
NO. of EMPLOYEES: 5,200 ductions and strategic technology acquisitions.
During the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons
HEADQUARTERS: Vista, Calif. (AAOS) annual meeting in March, DJO launched its Exprt Preci-
sion System for knee revision procedures. According to company
T
here are so many examples of how the medical device officials, the Exprt system “redefines” total-knee revision arthro-
industry represents the best of American ingenuity. Who plasty. DJO claims the system’s compact design reduces turn
doesn’t love the proverbial story of the big idea that started times, minimizes waste, and has proven implant design technol-
in a garage and ended up a billion-dollar business? DJO Global ogy for 40 to 70 percent of the cost of comparable knee revision
is the result of just such a humble beginning. The company got systems. A simple, comprehensive two-tray system replaces the
its start in a garage in Carlsbad, Calif., in 1978—founded by the traditional eight-tray setup used during complex, total-knee revi-
Philadelphia Eagles’ offensive line captain and a local attorney. sions, which is intended to reduce prep time and eliminate un-
Mark Nordquist and Ken Reed named their new company af- necessary surgical steps.
ter their wives, Donna and Joy; DonJoy was born. The firm’s first “The Exprt system offers experienced revision surgeons a
products were simple sleeves made of neoprene that were sewn toolkit that matches their skill set,”said Mike Mogul, CEO of DJO
together and designed to be pulled over the knee, ankle and/or Global.“The makeup of this revision knee allows for streamlined
elbow for support. Thirty-seven years may have passed, the name simplicity at a dramatically lower cost.”
may have changed a little, and a few different owners have come DJO Surgical worked closely with a group of experienced re-
and gone, but the company’s innovative roots are still intact, sell- vision surgeons to develop the technology. “The Exprt approach
leads to efficient operations that save both time and money, while the U.S. marketplace.
providing excellent early results,” said C. Lowry Barnes, M.D., “These product acquisitions are a part of a broader strategy
chairman of orthopedics at the University of Arkansas for Medi- to invest in our fast growing implant business,” said Mogul. “We
cal Sciences. “My operating team especially appreciates the fact believe our surgical division is poised to continue its position as
that only two pans of instruments are opened. I believe that I can the fastest growing orthopedic implant company. I have always
speak for the entire Exprt design team when I say that we have admired Cobalt bone cement’s color features, which offer bet-
met our goals in offering a high-value, high-quality revision knee ter visualization and much simpler packaging and the Discovery
system for the accomplished surgeon.” elbow is extremely well-regarded.”
In addition to Barnes, other early adopter surgeons have tout- The Cobalt bone cement is used with hip, knee, shoulder, el-
ed Exprt’s cost. bow and other orthopedic implant technologies. Cobalt offers a
“In today’s value driven health care environment, cost effec- complete range of viscosities as well as antibiotic solutions for
tiveness is crucial in order to provide stakeholders with a high- enhanced performance and patient safety, according to DJO. The
quality result at a reasonable cost,” said Richard Iorio, M.D., a unique Softpac packaging technology creates a “safer, glassless
New York, N.Y.-based joint replacement specialist. “Putting the environment and the user-friendly Optivac system provide the
patient ahead of profits, the Exprt System allows skilled surgeons best in modern cementing techniques for Cobalt as well as other
to provide TKA (total knee arthroplasty) patients with a function- cement technologies,” company officials said in a release.
al knee at a fraction of traditional costs.” The Discovery elbow will be DJO’s first elbow technology and
DJO Surgical also played a role in the Zimmer-Biomet merger. adds to the company’s upper extremity portfolio and shoulder ar-
The agreement for Zimmer Biomet Holdings Inc. to divest throplasty products. The Discovery elbow has more than 12 years
certain assets was part of U.S. Federal Trade Commission require- of successful clinical outcomes.
ments prior to Zimmer Holdings Inc. completing its purchase of “This acquisition is very timely for us based on our disruptive
Biomet Inc. entrance into the revision market with our Exprt revision knee
DJO Surgical purchased the Biomet Cobalt bone cement, Op- launched at AAOS this year and the Discovery elbow provides great
tivac cement mixing accessories and Discovery elbow system for breadth to our strong upper extremity portfolio,” said Brady Shir-
8. Integra
Stryker, which include the president of Stryker Communications
and senior vice president of Stryker Endoscopy. At Stryker Com-
munications and Stryker Endoscopy, Shirley was responsible for
all domestic operations and profit and loss for the Communica-
LifeSciences
tions division, as well as global product development and sales
and marketing for Endoscopy, representing approximately $1
billion worldwide. “With DJO Surgical’s current market position
and growth potential; brand momentum, innovation and market
leadership are our most urgent priorities,” said Mike Mogul, DJO $928 Million
Global’s president and CEO. “Brady’s strong Orthopedic back-
ground and proven track record and ability to develop and lead KEY EMPLOYEES:
top performing teams, drive shareholder value and innovation Peter J. Arduini, President, CEO & Director
will support the outstanding team we already have in place to Glenn G. Coleman, Corp. VP & Chief Financial Officer
transition DJO Surgical to the next level.” Mark Augusti, Corp. VP & President, Orthopedics and
The company also appointed Susan Crawford as the com- Tissue Technologies
pany’s new chief financial officer. Crawford joined DJO from Kenneth Burhop, Corp. VP & Chief Scientific Officer
Life Technologies Corp., where she most recently served as vice Robert T. Davis Jr., Corp. VP & President,
president of business transformation, responsible for integrating Specialty Surgical Solutions
newly acquired companies and engineering business processes John Mooradian, Corp. VP, Global Operations and Supply Chain
throughout the broader organization. Crawford also assisted the Dan Reuvers, Corp. VP & President, International
Life Technologies board of directors with evaluating strategic Joseph Vinhais, Corp. VP, Global Quality Assurance
options for the company. Prior to her stint as business transfor- Judith E. O’Grady, Corp. VP, Global Regulatory Affairs
mation vice president, Crawford was vice president of corporate
finance planning and analysis at Life Technologies, providing fi- NO. of EMPLOYEES: 3,400
nance leadership on the company’s growth strategy, forecasting
and analysis, supply chain productivity and financial modeling HEADQUARTERS: Plainsboro, N.J.
for mergers and acquisitions. Before being hired by Life Technol-
I
ogies in 2005, Crawford was chief financial officer for RealNames ntegra LifeSciences Holdings Corp. certainly is no newcomer
and PowerTV, as well as head of investor relations and financial to the orthopedic business. It may not have as much “history”
planning at Covad Communications. Crawford received a bach- as some of the more venerable firms with which it competes
elor’s degree in accounting from Rollins College in Winter Park, (DePuy Synthes, Stryker Corp., Zimmer-Biomet Holdings Inc.,
Fla., and an MBA from the University of Central Florida. Medtronic plc), but that hasn’t stopped the 26-year-old company
from charting a successful growth course through this industry’s
Dollars and Cents all-too-often complicated and competitive waters.
DJO recorded sales of $1.23 billion for FY14 (ended Dec. 31), up As was the case for so many firms in the medical device sec-
4.6 percent year over year. Despite the gain, the company report- tor, 2014 was a year of transition for Integra. The company may
ed a net loss $90.5 million, an improvement compared to a net have reported solid top- and bottom-line gains for its fiscal year
loss of $203.5 million in FY13. (ended Dec. 31), but officials with the Plainsboro, N.J.-based firm
“We are pleased to end 2014 with full year constant currency chose a path for their company that they claimed would be more
growth in net sales of 4.8 percent and leveraged adjusted EBITDA streamlined and profitable.
(earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization) “During 2014, we made significant progress … and I believe
we are at an exciting and pivotal point in our transformation,” which to operate, which should improve our ability to achieve
said Peter Arduini, president and CEO. our longer-term growth and margin improvement objectives.
What transformation you ask? Further, we believe these moves create exciting opportunities for
In November, the company announced plans to spin off its our shareholders and both organizations.”
spine business and realign its portfolio. Specifically, in 2014, the Integra officials said the separation would provide both com-
company chose to consolidate its five business divisions into panies with a faster top-line growth profile; allow the new Sea-
three. Following the spinoff, the company would have a sim- Spine to invest more in top-line growth initiatives such as sales,
plified, two-division global structure. Neurosurgery and Instru- marketing and research and development (R&D), and to access
ments were combined worldwide to create a new division called the capital markets; accelerate Integra’s operating margin expan-
Specialty Surgical Solutions. Orthopedics and Tissue Technolo- sion plans; and unlock equity value for Integra’s shareholders.
gies were consolidated globally and include the extremities busi- SeaSpine’s portfolio consists of spinal hardware solutions,
ness, comprising small bone orthopedics and wound care. The including unique interbody devices, minimally invasive surgery
portfolio realignment, according to company brass, is part of a solutions, and deformity correction products, as well as IsoTis, a
larger transformation strategy that began in 2012 and centers on leading brand in orthobiologics, including a range of osteocon-
“optimizing the business and accelerating growth.” ductive and osteoinductive solutions using demineralized bone
The spinoff created a new publicly traded company (which and synthetic matrices.
went public on July 1 this year). SeaSpine—the name of a former Integra’s board of directors named Kirt Stephenson, former
Integra acquisition—focuses on spine hardware and orthobiolog- CEO and co-founder of SeaSpine, as board chairman of the
ics. Integra acquired Vista, Calif.-based SeaSpine in 2011 for $89 new SeaSpine.
million in cash. The company is still based in Vista. “I’m excited about the opportunity to create another company
“These strategic changes create a much stronger platform for focused on growth through new product development, strategic
organic growth and execution, and we believe both companies acquisitions and partnerships,” said Stuart Essig, Integra’s board
will grow faster separately than together,” said Arduini. “Moving chairman.“As a public company, SeaSpine will have a host of op-
forward, Integra will have a simpler, more focused structure from tions to accelerate its growth and effectively invest in new busi-
KEY EXECUTIVES:
Gregory T. Lucier, Chairman & CEO
Patrick Miles, President & Chief Operating Officer
Matt Link, President, U.S. Commercial
Quentin Blackford, Exec. VP & Chief Financial Officer
Carol Cox, Exec. VP, Strategy, Corporate Development &
External Affairs
Russell Powers, Exec. VP (with focus on China expansion)
T
alk about a shakeup. The current executive team at NuVa-
sive looks distinctly different than the leadership team that
finished up fiscal 2014. The changes came in 2015 when
an independent investigation uncovered still-unclear below-
the-board practices in relation to expense reimbursement and
personnel practices by ex-CEO Alex Lukianov. He resigned on
April 1 (not, unfortunately, a joke) without comment, leaving it
to Independent Board Director Jack R. Blair to make a diplomatic
statement in his wake.
“The results of an independent investigation overseen by
the board of directors revealed that Alex had not complied with
certain of the company’s expense reimbursement and personnel
policies,” Blair said.“Although the amounts involved appear to be
immaterial to the company’s financial results, his actions in this
regard were not representative of the high standards by which
NuVasive operates.”
At the time, Greg Lucier, a member of the company’s board
of directors since 2013, was appointed interim CEO; he has since
been instated permanently in the office.
But the executive changes didn’t begin and end with Luki-
anov. His departure came three months after Chief Operating
Officer (COO) Keith C. Valentine unexpectedly left the company
after a 14 year career with NuVasive. He left, according to Luki-
anov, to “explore different career options” and “fulfill long-held
professional aspirations.” At this time, then-president of Global
Products and Services Pat Miles took over the role of COO.
In July, the company announced a major restructuring of the
10. Globus
than doubled since 2011 and the Foundation is on track to ex-
pand its program development, NuVasive reported.
Finally, NuVasive also received a favorable settlement in one
of its ongoing lawsuits in 2014. The company filed a lawsuit
Medical
against Kennewick, Wash.-based Cadwell Laboratories Inc. in
2012 regarding one of NuVasive’s neuromonitoring technology
patents. It asserted that Cadwell infringed on certain parts of the
patent, including the integration of nerve monitoring technology
during lateral approach spine surgery. As part of the settlement $474.3 Million
reached between the parties, Cadwell agreed to exit the lateral
spine surgery market, and to no longer provide products, services, KEY EXECUTIVES:
or support for lateral approach spine fusion surgeries. In addition, David C. Paul, Chairman & CEO
certain of Cadwell’s future products that rely on NuVasive pat- David M. Demski, President & Chief Operating Officer
ented technology may be required to openly attribute intellectual Daniel T. Scavilla, Sr. VP & Chief Financial Officer
property ownership to NuVasive and may require a 5 percent fee A. Brett Murphy, Exec. VP, U.S. Sales
paid to NuVasive. David D. Davidar, Sr. VP, Operations
The neuromonitoring technology in question was previously Anthony L. Williams, Sr. VP, Business Development
validated in litigation between NuVasive and Medtronic plc. In and General Counsel
2011 a jury awarded monetary damages and back royalty pay-
ments to NuVasive in favor of the company’s claim that Medtron- NO. of EMPLOYEES: 900
ic’s NIM-Eclipse System infringed upon NuVasive’s neuromoni-
toring technology patent. HEADQUARTERS: Audubon, Pa.
LATEST IN SWISS CNC MACHINING Swiss-Med Technologies is the medical division of Swissline Precision
Mfg. Inc. We are a custom contract manufacturer of precision medical
CNC Swiss Laser Technology components holding tolerances of +/-.0001. Swiss-Med was created
to focus exclusively on the manufacture of complex medical components,
Key Advantages Include:
instrumentation and implants. From prototype to production, we offer
• Integrated/horizontally mounted laser capability on the Swiss platform
capabilities to produce precision product consistently to specification.
• Metal removal & deburring becomes much more efficient and accurate
To support our operation, we have state of the art CNC-Swiss
• Produce intricate geometries with no Secondary Laser Operation style machines with 13 axis capability. These machines are able to
• Direct drive rotary guide bushing provides accuracy within 50-millionths produce highly complex components complete off the machine with
• Complex medical components made easier with Swiss-Laser Technology minimal burrs. Swiss-Med has a full Micro-Deburr department trained
in the art of precise deburring. Each technician uses a 20x or better
MAJOR MARKETS magnification for the review of any burrs relative to the components
they are working on.
• Endoscopy: To include Bronchoscopy, In addition, Swiss-Med uses a top of the line Trumpf Laser machine for
Gastrocopy, Enterscopy marking of the components per customer requirements. This laser marking
• Colonoscopy operation is used extensively for many of our Medical customers.
We also provide our customers with the option of full turn-key
• Medical Instrumentation and Devices
solution. We utilize only certified suppliers who have a high quality
• Biotechnology Instrumentation
rating with Swiss-Med. We combine our extensive machine knowledge
• Analytical Instrumentation
with their specialty service to give you a component that exceeds your
• Orthopedics and Pulmonology needs. To complete our turn-key solution we also offer full assembly
• Endomechanical Instrumentation capability using our experience and talent to take the frustration of
• Pharmaceutical Laboratory Components seeking multiple vendors to a stop turn-key solution.
• Thermal Analysis and Rheometry
Instrument Components
www.swiss-medtech.com
• Ultrasonic Surgery
H
istorically, the automobile industry has been the dence program, one of my primary jobs was to develop
American industry of record. But given the explo- a road map so anyone—individual surgeon, inventor or
sion of technology and focus on patient care, the med- international medical device conglomerate—would have a
ical device industry is positioned to emerge as American Auto guide to help them get their devices to market.
version 2.0. U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) accep- Here’s some of what I learned about what it takes to make it
tance and clearance are the gold standard worldwide when it through the long haul.
comes to marketing medical devices. Even if the device is not
released in the United States, FDA clearance provides “street Parts is Parts
cred” and marketing mojo for products from foreign countries Because every medical device is somehow unique, there really
because of the high value manufacturers and patients place on is no standard assembly line or single starting point to get
the blessing of our primary regulatory agency. a device on the road toward market approval. But there are
So what does it take to earn that internationally sought common features and parameters that apply to just about any
clearance or approval? It’s rarely a smooth, straight road to device to help you minimize road hazards and other obstacles
market, particularly for first timers or innovators who don’t to give you reproducible, successful results.
have the backing of a major international corporation. When You have an extraordinary idea that will revolutionize pa-
I worked with the FDA as part of its Entrepreneurs in Resi- tient care. That’s why we are in this industry; we work to make
people’s lives better. To make your journey easier, faster costs of development? Factor in engineering, prototypes,
and better, you need to figure out how to make that idea testing, building inventory, etc.
a reality. You ask yourself a seemingly endless stream of And the most critical concern from a long-term stand-
questions. How long will it take to get to market? How point, is if the device can receive reimbursement. You may
big is the market? How long will it take to make a return design and garner clearance for the most revolutionary
on my investment? Do I have the resources to make it all technology since Capt. Steve Austin from “The Six Million
the way to market? The answers to those questions will Dollar Man,” but if no sponsor can get paid for rebuild-
depend on your specific device as well as circumstances. ing him within our current health insurance and medical
Be honest. If you don’t know, find someone who can reimbursement system, Capt. Austin is terminal.
help you. A reliable, knowledgeable navigator will make If your brainchild is a disruptive technology, make sure
all the difference in how well and quickly you travel the you have a plan for reimbursement at the time you receive
road to market. your approval. Shareholders can be fickle folks; they don’t
want to have a game-changing device with no way to
Know Your Make and Model get paid.
In the United States, there are three classes of medical de-
vices: Class I, Class II and Class III.1 There are significant Know the Rules of the Road
differences in requirements and time to clearance or ap- Because the FDA is an evolving organization much like
proval. the evolving technologies it evaluates, the landscape will
Class I medical devices have the least amount change with each submission. New clinical data, medi-
of regulatory control because they present mini- cal device reporting and new ASTM standards lay the
mal harm to the user. Such devices include wheel- path for future submissions.2 Just because you included
chairs, crutches and other external products. It is re- something in a previous submission, that doesn’t mean
quired that the manufacturing facility for a Class I the same rules still apply. Per the 2015 Strategic Priorities
device is registered and the device be listed in the Document, the FDA Innovation Pathway 2.0 is a stream-
FDA database. lined route to regulatory approval.3
For Class II devices, general controls aren’t a high The goals of this new approach are to strengthen the
enough standard; they require more scrutiny, typically a clinical trials enterprise, strike the right balance between
premarket clearance through the 510(k) process before premarket and postmarket data collection and provide
they make it to market. They’re typically an improvement excellent customer service. The FDA also is actively up-
to an existing device, usually one that goes into the body dating tools to facilitate collaboration with clients. You
such as a new pedicle screw or hip joint. can now even request a presubmission meeting to help
Class III devices require the most stringent standards mitigate any regulatory pathway risks and make sure you
because these are considered a completely new technology and reviewers are headed in the right direction.4
for the body. As far as the FDA is concerned, they pres-
ent significant risk to the patient and/or require significant What Drives Your Plot?
scientific review of the safety and effectiveness of the medi- I tell clients that the road to regulatory approval is really
cal device prior to commercial introduction. Most Class III the chance to write your own story for your medical de-
medical devices require a premarket approval application vice. Although there is no standard form for submissions,
(PMA). there is a right and wrong way to submit your informa-
Once you know which class your product falls into, tion. So be sure you lay out the plot with precise detail.
you’ll have a much clearer idea of how to proceed. If your submission is well-written and easy to follow, it’s
the foundation for productive, positive dialog with your
Know the Lay of the Land reviewer.
Before you hit the road, check out the forecast and the As the author, you’ve been working on your project for
terrain you’re traveling through. Does the market cur- months, maybe even years. You know all aspects of the
rently exist for this product? Is it a $300,000 market or a design history and every painstaking decision of the pro-
$300 million market? If this is a disruptive technology (for cess. But your reviewer is a new reader who can only go
example, intervertebral body fusion devices), what is the off what you provide. The FDA reviewers are responsible
potential market value of this device? Based on the regu- for making sure our parents, friends and family all have
latory path, what is the timeline to get to market? A Class safe and effective products for better health. The more in-
II device may be a year or less, but a Class III device could depth, clear and vetted information you can provide, the
be two to five years or longer for PMA alone. What are the quicker you can travel the road to market.
W
ith multiple cost stressors on the orthopedic rapid prototyping. By manufacturing proto-
market—including the medical device tax—or- types quickly and inexpensively via additive man-
thopedic OEMs are intent on saving time and ufacturing methods, engineers can hold, examine, and test
money. This means adding value whenever they can to ex- these products very early in the design process. This makes it
isting products to improve performance and make them much easier to identify flaws and inconsistencies, which can
stand out from the competition—usually by using meth- then be “designed out” and retested with a minimum number
ods and materials that already have regulatory approval of iterations.
and validated by a large body of testing and performance
data. For many orthopedic manufacturers, the research- Top R&D Trends
and-development mission has become enhancing exist- Orthopedic engineers continue to improve advanced-bearing
ing products and getting them to market quickly, while surfaces in implants with the goal of reducing wear debris
still meeting or exceeding regulatory requirements and and implant loosening, as well as extending implant longev-
keeping costs down. ity. This includes testing engineered plastics for articulating
Achieving these goals can be a challenge for the contract devices like hips and knees, including biological reaction to
manufacturer and depends on a number of factors, includ- wear debris. Research continues in cross-linked polyethylene
ing the type and size of the project and whether the contract and vitamin E cross-linked polyethylene. Although vitamin
manufacturer must be fully integrated into the customer’s E-cross-linked polyethylene laboratory in-vitro testing has
quality and design system. Understanding user needs early shown positive results for controlling oxidation, longer term
in the design process also is essential for speeding up prod- follow-up testing is required to prove the clinical benefits of
uct development—especially through the efficient use of vitamin E materials.
Polyether ether ketone (PEEK), which has cant breakthroughs that can reduce overall production costs.
proven itself in the spinal market for many For example, using casting, additive manufacturing, or metal
years, is strong, biocompatible, radio- injection molding to join multiple parts in an assembly into
lucent, and easily adaptable for ma- one part that would otherwise be too complicated to machine
chining and molding. As a bearing as a single piece reduces the number of parts and eliminates
surface, however, PEEK is sup- some assembly steps. Engineers also are always looking for
optimal in high load-bearing ways to optimize production—machine programs, operation
applications (such as hip order, process type, and other elements can be experimented
and knee implants) un- within the prototype environment to achieve a process that
less additives such as easily can be transferred into a production environment.
carbon fiber are used
to increase strength. Rapid Additive Manufacturing
Although some com- Design for manufacturability studies can greatly benefit from
panies market car- rapid additive manufacturing (AM) technologies for mak-
bon-fiber-reinforced ing prototypes. Rapid additive manufacturing eliminates the
PEEK materials as time-consuming steps and delays that come with standard
acceptable wear sur- prototyping. What used to take weeks or months can now be
faces for acetabular done in a few hours, saving time and materials and driving
liners, most device down costs. Popular additive manufacturing technologies are
manufacturers avoid direct metal laser sintering and 3-D printing in plastics. Both
PEEK for these ap- of these processes have revolutionized the way engineers ap-
plications while they proach the concept and design stages. Within hours, parts
wait for more clinical can be manufactured, held, and closely examined, making it
data confirming its re- much easier to identify errors and flaws, and design them out
liability as a high load- of the process.
bearing surface. Occasionally, additive manufacturing methods can be
The U.S. Food and used to create production-ready metal parts from steel and
Drug Administration (FDA) titanium, which saves considerable time and money. Difficult
is placing increased scru- geometries easily can be achieved using AM. Porous coatings
tiny on new materials—espe- also can potentially be printed directly on the part. Making
cially for bearing couples—and fully functional parts with AM methods, however, currently is
is asking more questions related to only practical for low-volume runs because of the post-pro-
the wear performance of these materi- cessing that is required. For example, gross geometries easily
als. Standard cross-linked polyethylene, are accomplished with AM but tight tolerances often cannot
vitamin-E cross-linked polyethylene, carbon fi- be reliably held—as a result, some post-process machining of-
ber PEEK, and titanium carbide all are new materials ten is required for features like locking mechanisms, articulat-
that require additional tests such as third-body wear testing, ing surfaces, and assembly features requiring extremely tight
particulate analysis, particle counts, morphology, and leach- fits. Some companies use AM technologies to mass-produce
ing studies (traditional polyethylene bearing surfaces do not parts that are simple in design and require minimal post-build
require these tests). Also, since many of these types of tests machining because the process has been optimized and vali-
are relatively new, there are no ASTM or ISO standards that dated. Overall, however, high-volume AM production still is
specify how to run these tests, which can be a challenge when cost-prohibitive. Current research is targeting process im-
trying to find a predicate device/test for comparing results— provements and cost-reduction strategies.
which can drive up costs. Therefore, considerable R&D is be-
ing directed toward justifying these new testing parameters, Sterile Packaging and Product Delivery Systems
acceptance criteria, worst-case samples, appropriate loading More complex products also create more packaging and ster-
regimes, etc., to provide data that is acceptable to the FDA. ilization challenges. The FDA also is becoming more con-
cerned about sterilization requirements, especially in light of
Design for Manufacturability recent patient deaths associated with serious illnesses trans-
More complexity means more cost. OEMs are looking for mitted via imperfectly sterilized instruments.
ways to reduce costs through simpler design strategies—for As a result of these concerns (as well as another way to
example, assembly simplification. Finding ways to maintain reduce costs), more companies and healthcare end users are
or improve functionality by using designs that have fewer using disposable instruments with pre-packed “peel and dis-
pieces and/or less complex modes of operation are signifi- pose” types of packaging, instead of more expensive instru-
needs.
is greatly enhanced by rapid prototyping
and 3-D printing. Getting the designs off
the computer screen and into people’s
hands is critical for initiating thoughtful
11DAYS
dialogue about how the products can be
READY IN improved—especially how they are held
and used in the working environment.
These improvements are best identified
and tested through several rounds of
Assemble your individual maxon
DC drive: You can configure the
rapid prototyping.
gear stages, the motor bearings, Depending on the size of the project,
the shafts, the encoder and much getting the contract manufacturer in-
more. Design your custom drive volved in the concept stage can save up
online today and your finished
drive will ship from Switzerland in
to one-third of total production cost. This
11 working days. also includes the CM’s help in determin-
ing the best way to invest funds during the
dcx.maxonmotor.com
R&D phase of the project. When properly
targeted, R&D dollars can provide a sig-
nificant return on investment during the
design, production, and packaging stages.
When looking for a contract manufac-
turing partner, evaluate how the CM will
assist you through the entire process, from
conception to production and delivery.
Contract manufacturers should be eager
to be fully engaged in the concept and de-
velopment stages and bring considerable
medical device experience to the table. On-
site prototype capabilities are critical for
enabling engineers and fabricators to have
daily interaction regarding things that are
learned during prototype manufacturing,
so changes made to the design and key as-
pects of what makes the prototype work are
properly documented. It also is important
that the CM uses the same computer-aided design software as cal dynamic stabilization systems and semi-rigid tumor/trauma
the customer so that all files are compatible, streamlining the technologies. Scifert is a certified Lean Sigma green belt and
exchange process. supported the continuing improvement efforts during his tenure
Cost goals typically drive every medical device project and at Medtronic. Scifert’s additional experience includes managing
are best attained when the CM and the customer collaborate. engineering projects as a senior engineer and project manager at
It’s hard for OEM engineers and design teams to keep up with Smith & Nephew, focusing on early intervention knee and shoul-
the latest in advanced materials, improved prototyping and in- der systems. Scifert received his bachelor’s degree in engineering
jection molding technologies, additive manufacturing and 3-D sciences and mechanics at the University of Tennessee and his
printing capabilities, and sterilization and product delivery sys- Ph.D. in biomedical engineering at the University of Iowa with
tems—all of which are evolving very quickly. The experts who his doctoral dissertation titled, “A Finite Element Investigation
do have this up-to-date knowledge, however, are CMs and oth- into the Biomechanics of Total Artificial Hip Dislocation.” Scifert
er vendors who work with a variety of clients and project types is based at Orchid’s facility in Memphis, Tenn.
across the medical device industry. By teaming up with CMs Litke’s expertise is in the design and development of mechani-
during the concept and design stages to allow them to share cal systems and mechanisms. He has strong computer-aided
their industry-wide knowledge and experience, OEMs improve engineering experience coupled with solid manufacturing pro-
their odds of developing a better product that meets or exceeds cess expertise including welding, forging, extrusion, casting and
their initial expectations, at a lower cost. v machining. He also is certified through the American Society of
Mechanical Engineers as a Senior Level GD&T (geometric di-
Ron Litke and Chris Scifert, Ph.D., are engineering managers mensioning and tolerancing) Professional. He was employed by
with Holt, Mich.-based Orchid Orthopedic Solutions Inc. Cannondale and NextRnd, a contract engineering firm. Litke has
Scifert has more than 12 years of experience including serv- 15 years of engineering experience, and received his bachelor’s
ing as senior manager of product development at Medtronic Spi- and master’s degrees in mechanical engineering from the Uni-
nal and Biologics, where he executed engineering projects and versity of Connecticut. He holds 11 patents or patent applica-
group management responsibilities for intradiscal and extradis- tions. Litke is based at Orchid’s facility in Shelton, Conn.
800.343.4111
www.bostoncenterless.com
ISO 9001:2008 & ISO 13485 Certified
July/August 2015 odtmag.com ODT • 79
Industry News
Single-Procedure Ratchet Developed by ECA Medical
E
CA Medical Instruments, a designer
and manufacturer of single-pro-
cedure torque-limiting and fixed-
driver surgical instruments and sterile-
packed procedural kits, has developed
what the company calls the “industry’s
first single-procedure surgical ratchet for
use by surgeons to secure orthopedic and
spine implants.”
The proprietary Model 300 Secure-Fast
ratcheting system is designed to reduce
surgical costs by more than $1,000 per pro-
cedure and to provide a pristine ratcheting ECA Medical’s new single-procedure surgical
capability for securing screws, fasteners ratchet. Image courtesy of ECA Medical.
and connectors used in demanding proce-
dures including spine, trauma and extrem-
ity implants. The ratchet is bi-directional “We’re helping implant designers and pany, there are more than 9 million frac-
and fully cannulated. This, according to surgeons transform healthcare econom- ture repair and spine procedures globally
the company, makes it well suited for ics by providing robust disposable instru- each year that require a surgical implant
minimally invasive surgeries where speed, ments and kits as alternatives to tradition- and more than 80 percent can benefit
safety and implant fixation are critical. al and costly reusable tools,” said James from use of a versatile, single-use ratch-
“The Secure-Fast single-procedure Schultz, ECA’s executive vice president. eting instrument. More than $4 billion
ratchet is a novel first of its kind instrument “The Secure-Fast ratchet complements in healthcare industry savings could be
that will become every surgeon’s instru- our family of disposable instruments achieved annually with widespread adop-
ment of choice for hospital and outpatient and procedural kits and underscores the tion of disposable surgical fixation instru-
ortho and spine implants,” said John Nino, broader adoption of disposable instru- ments and kits.
president and CEO of ECA Medical Instru- ments and kits across hospitals and am- ECA Medical Instruments, an Ameri-
ments.“The ease of use, versatility and abil- bulatory surgical centers.” can Capital company, was founded in
ity to speed surgeries across the full range According to Schultz, surgeons and 1979 and is based in Thousand Oaks, Ca-
of implants will make this ratchet a popular healthcare professionals—including pay- lif. ECA’s products are developed for key
and value-packed alternative to expensive ers—are focused on gaining the best pos- industry OEM implant makers and come
re-usable ratchets that require cleaning, re- sible outpatient outcomes at the best price both sterile-ready and sterile-packed,
processing and re-sterilization.” point or value. making them easy to inventory and ready
The ECA Secure-Fast ratchet comes “Our single-use instruments and to use. The firm has manufactured and
configured with either an industry-stan- kits and our new Secure-Fast ratchet delivered more than 30 million precision
dard AO or quarter-of-an-inch square are cost-effective productivity tools for torque instruments to manufacturers of
hub connector that can mate with legacy orthopedic and neurosurgeons and im- cardiac rhythm management, neuromod-
stainless steel drivers and shafts used prove patient safety as every instrument is ulation, cardiovascular and orthopedic
across all types of surgeries. The instru- new out of the box, sterile and ready for and spine implants, resulting in more than
ment is bi-directional, making it ideal for surgery,” he said. 500 million precision surgical actuations.
fixation, implant adjustments and extrac- The new Model 300 series Secure-Fast
tions, company officials noted. ratchet, which has worldwide patents Anniversary Wishes in
Unlike existing reusable ratchets, the Se- pending, will be available for sampling Order for Cadence Inc.
cure-Fast ratchet is new for every procedure, in the coming weeks, ECA officials said. Staunton, Va.-based Cadence Inc., a con-
eliminating performance concerns, and can OEM implant firms should contact their tract manufacturer of advanced products,
be sterile-packed ready for surgery, thus re- ECA strategic account director for details. technologies and services to the medical,
ducing the risk of surgical-site infection. According to figures cited by the com- life-science, and industrial markets, is
celebrating a milestone anniversary—30 Altman, a partner at Arlington Capital. Founded in France in 2000, In’Tech
years in business. “Recognized across the industry for its Medical is a privately held company
The company, originally founded as engineering and manufacturing capabili- that manufactures orthopedic surgi-
Specialty Blades in 1985 by engineer ties, Avalign provides significant value to cal instruments and implants. Prior to
Martin Lightsey, was developed with the its [original equipment manufacturer] the acquisition, the company employed
concept of combining computer numeri- partners through design improvement, 300, and had offices and production
cal control and razor-blade sharpening speed to market acceleration and cost facilities in Europe and the United
technologies to address the needs of com- reductions. We look forward to partner- States. The company’s U.S. site is in
panies that required high-performance, ing with the Avalign management team Memphis, Tenn.
custom-made blades. to support the company through its next “In’Tech Medical’s demonstrated
“It’s the people and the culture that phase of growth.” leadership in contract manufacturing
have made this company a success,” said “We are extremely pleased to be part- and proprietary orthopedic instrument
Lightsey. “This has been the realization of nering with Arlington Capital,” said For- design is greatly enhanced with the ad-
a dream 30 years in the making.” rest Whittaker, CEO of Avalign. “Avalign dition of Turner Medical, as we continue
Since the company’s inception, its ca- is committed to improving patient out- to constantly strive to better serve our
pabilities and services have expanded comes by providing best-in-class medi- customers,” said Laurent Pruvost, pres-
beyond its original scope. Cadence has cal devices through our end to end capa- ident of In’Tech Medical. “If increasing
experienced substantial growth since bilities. We believe that Arlington Capital, our market share and product line are
2003, company bigwigs said, with a fo- which has deep expertise and an impres- great news, what I most value is the
cus on serving the medical device and sive track record in healthcare and preci- unique talent that Turner Medical has
life-science markets, adding precision sion manufacturing, is the ideal partner developed over the past 35 years. The
metal process capabilities, injection mold- to help us achieve our goals. We would management’s know-how, combined
ing and clean-room assembly to its list of also like to thank RoundTable Healthcare with that of In’Tech Medical’s, turns the
current capabilities. Partners for all of their support and part- group into a creative engineering and
Cadence now employs nearly 500 nership to date.” problem-solving powerhouse; a serious
people worldwide. In addition to its head- RoundTable Healthcare Partners asset for our clients and a tangible com-
quarters in Staunton, the company has founded Avalign in October 2005 through petitive advantage.”
other facilities in Massachusetts, Pennsyl- the purchase of Instrumed International, a “At Turner Medical, we are all about
vania, Rhode Island, Wisconsin, and the German instrument manufacturer. Since customer satisfaction and family val-
Dominican Republic. entering the industry in 2005, RoundTable ues,” said Bill Turner, president. “The
“We have a defined culture in a set of built Avalign from a niche, family-owned company was founded by my father
values at Cadence where doing the right business into a platform with a complete John Turner in 1985. We took it from a
things for our employees, customers and suite of high-precision manufacturing local machine shop to a nationally rec-
shareholders matters,” said CEO Alan capabilities and a reputation-building ognized organization with the highest
Connor. “It’s what has allowed us to have strategy consisting of organic growth and quality standards, latest technologies,
30 successful years and what will allow us strategic acquisitions. RoundTable Health- and most efficient processes, always
to have 30 more.” care Partners was founded in 2001. designed to meet and exceed our cli-
ent’s needs, as well as save them time
Arlington Partners Buys In’Tech Medical Expands U.S. Biz and money. Merging with In’Tech Med-
Avalign Technologies With Turner Medical Purchase ical allows Turner Medical to further de-
Washington, D.C.-based private equity In’Tech Medical SAS, a developer and velop and provide the services that are
firm Arlington Capital Partners is buy- contract manufacturer of orthope- most beneficial to our clients, both in
ing Lake Forest, Ill.-based Avalign Tech- dic surgical instruments, has acquired the U.S. and internationally.”
nologies Holdings Inc. from Roundtable Turner Medical Inc. In’Tech Medical’s 2015 consolidated
Healthcare Partners. Avalign is a full-ser- According to officials with In’Tech, sales forecast now is $65 million, equal-
vice precision manufacturer of implants the acquisition of Turner Medical im- ly balanced between Europe and the
and instruments, specialty instrumenta- proves In’Tech’s manufacturing ex- United States, produced by close to 500
tion, cutting tools, and cases and trays to pertise, expands its U.S. business employees globally. As a wholly owned
the orthopedic medical device and spe- and global capacity, and adds the subsidiary of In’Tech Medical, Turner
cialty surgical markets. manufacturing of orthopedic implants Medical will continue to operate out of
“Avalign is an established leader in to its core business. its headquarters in Athens, Ala., under
the large and growing orthopedic preci- Financial details of the deal were its current name, becoming the U.S.
sion manufacturing market,” said Matt not disclosed. platform for the newly formed group.
TransPerfect Establishes of their multilingual labeling by over 50 methods for other joints, such as ankles
New Device Division percent,” Miller said. and shoulders,” Budd added.
TransPerfect, one of the world’s largest TransPerfect has global headquarters Lucideon offers a range of tribology
providers of language services and content in New York, N.Y., with regional head- services for orthopedic implant manufac-
management technology to the medical quarters in London, United Kingdom, and turers, including failure, debris and wear
device industry, has created a new busi- Hong Kong, China. pattern analysis, in addition to other ana-
ness division called TransPerfect Medical lytical capabilities, such as surface analysis
Device Solutions. The division combines Lucideon’s Orthopedic and materials characterization.
the ISO 13485- and ISO 14971-certified Implant Services Now Offers Lucideon provides materials develop-
systems and patented risk management Impingement Testing ment, testing and assurance to custom-
processes of TransPerfect’s Crimson Life United Kingdom-based Lucideon, an in- ers in a wide range of sectors, including
Sciences division with a range of integrat- ternational materials technology compa- healthcare, construction, ceramics and
ed services and technologies across the ny, has added impingement testing to its power engineering.
TransPerfect family of companies. range of services for orthopedic implant
“Over the past 10 years, TransPerfect manufacturers. Materialise and Consensus
has pursued a strategy that creates value Impingement testing assesses wear Orthopedics Expand Partnership
for life-sciences clients by combining caused by motion beyond the joint’s nat- Materialise N.V., a Belgium-based pro-
validated automation technology with ural limit, mimicking in-vivo conditions. vider of 3-D software and printing solu-
compliant processes,” said Marc Miller, Such testing can help manufacturers to tions, and Consensus Orthopedics Inc. are
division president for TransPerfect Medical approximate the longevity of an implant, expanding their association.
Device Solutions. “Now, we’ve success- but more importantly, predict its ability to El Dorado Hills, Calif.-based Consen-
fully completed the integration and spe- withstand abnormal conditions; as such, sus plans to use the Acetabular Cup Ori-
cialization effort necessary to produce the impingement testing often is included at entation (ACO) Hip Guide System from
first set of core solutions for device mak- the design stage of prosthetic development. Materialise. In June, the companies an-
ers—this is the basis of TransPerfect Medi- The new method for impingement nounced a partnership using knee-imag-
cal Device Solutions.” wear testing of hip implants has been vali- ing technology from Materialise.
In addition to traditional à la carte dated to ASTM F2582-14 and is comple- The Materialise ACO Hip Guide System,
services, such as labeling and market- mentary to Lucideon’s other wear-testing a platform consisting of 3-D surgical plan-
ing translations, TransPerfect Medical services, which include hip testing to ISO ning software and patient-specific surgical
Device Solutions includes a range of 14242 and knee testing to ISO 14243, both guides for hip surgery, allows surgeons to
integrated technologies and services for of which are ISO 17025 accredited. predictably plan hip procedures based on
manufacturers’ emerging content needs, “Impingement testing uses differ- the patient’s unique anatomy and structural
including: translation process automa- ent setup, load and motion profiles than damage. Based on that pre-operative plan,
tion technology; labeling automation standard wear testing, reflecting the fact patient-specific guides are designed and
solutions; Validated XML publishing that a joint in-vivo would very rarely be 3-D printed for use during surgery.
systems; guided authoring/author auto- under maximum force whilst impinging Jeroen Dille, director of Materialise’s
mation; automated website localization; but accounting for the additional stresses Clinical Unit, said: “Through this grow-
software translation, verification, and the implant would be under if it did,” said ing partnership, more surgeons will have
testing; formatting/layout services and Gemma Budd, healthcare business man- access to 3-D planning and printing solu-
technology; e-learning development ager at Lucideon.“By performing this test- tions, which ultimately means that more
and localization; vigilance and e-clinical ing we are able to help manufacturers see patients can benefit from this technology.
technology solutions; multilingual digi- how their product will perform in-vivo, Since the start of Materialise 25 years ago,
tal media services; and patent, litigation enabling them to assess its longevity and our mission has been to create meaningful
and contract support. foresee potential failure modes.” 3-D printing applications for a better and
The division’s flagship solution is the Budd said the company is “committed” healthier world. This partnership is per-
EnCompass System for labeling automa- to developing centers of excellence for hip fectly in line with that mission statement.”
tion. The EnCompass System combines and knee wear testing in the United States “Surgical outcomes have a higher rate
guided authoring, advanced XML content and in the United Kingdom, adding that of predictability once our surgeons have
management, and GlobalLink process au- Lucideon has invested 1 million British access to preoperative planning and are
tomation technology for maximum label- pounds (approximately $1.57 million) in able to use patient-specific guides based
ing automation and effectiveness. state-of-the-art facilities on both sides of on a patient’s CT (computed tomography
“With the EnCompass System, device the Atlantic. imaging),” said Colleen Gray, president
makers can reduce both the cost and risk “We also plan to develop and validate and CEO of Consensus. v
M
equon, Wis.-based Titan Spine, Jim is the right person to lead these ef- optimal host-bone response and actively
a medical device surface tech- forts. One of Jim’s initial tasks will be to participate in the fusion process by pro-
nology company focused on clearly differentiate the science of our moting the up-regulation of osteogenic
developing spinal interbody fusion im- nanotechnology platform from those that and angiogenic factors necessary for bone
plants, has named Jim Sevey as its new claim to have nanotechnology but have growth, encouraging natural production
senior nanotechnology specialist. The ap- not been cleared by the FDA to do so. We of bone morphogenetic proteins, down-
pointment follows the company’s receipt are proud to add Jim to our ever-growing regulating inflammatory factors, and cre-
of 510(k) clearance from the U.S. Food scientific team.” ating the potential for a faster and more
and Drug Administration (FDA) to mar- “The spine industry is beginning to robust fusion.
ket the Endoskeleton line of interbody recognize ‘nanotechnology’ as more than
fusion implants featuring its next gen- a marketing concept and now as a design NuVasive Revamps Executive Team
eration Nanolock surface technology and approach that has the potential to im- San Diego, Calif.-based spine firm NuVa-
precedes the company’s full commercial- prove spinal fusion results for patients,” sive Inc. continues to make changes in its
ization of the new line, planned for the commented Barbara Boyan, Ph.D., dean executive ranks.
fourth quarter of this year. The Nanolock of the School of Engineering at Virginia In May, the company named a new
surface represents the only FDA-cleared Commonwealth University, and lead au- chairman and CEO following the depar-
nanotechnology for spinal implant appli- thor of several studies supporting Titan ture of long-time head Alex Lukianov,
cations, the company reports. Spine surfaces. “Titan Spine has been at who stepped down earlier in the year after
Sevey’s role the forefront of this charge for nearly a he failed to comply with company reim-
will include lead- decade, conducting studies to evaluate bursement and personnel policies.
ing the educational and refine the benefits of nanotechnol- According to the company, the latest
initiatives to fur- ogy for interbody fusions. I look forward changes will create a “world-class leader-
ther demonstrate to working closely with Jim to further ship team to drive
and communicate these efforts.” NuVasive’s next
the scientific evi- Before joining Titan Spine, Sevey held phase of growth and
dence supporting several positions at DePuy Synthes Bio- success as the in-
the advantages of materials, including most recently, man- novation pioneer in
Sevey Titan Spine’s unique ager, biomaterials technical specialist. In spine.” The new ap-
Nanolock surface this role, he generated multidivisional pointments include
technology. The surface features an in- sales of osteobiologic product lines by current NuVasive ex-
creased amount of nano-scaled textures providing clinical and technical consult- ecutives along with
that result in the up-regulation of a great- ing, training, and education for surgeons, Lucier recent hires.
er amount of osteogenic and angiogenic residents, operating room personnel, and “Our abil-
growth factors critical for bone growth sales consultants. Prior to DePuy Synthes ity to accelerate our
and fusion as compared to PEEK (poly- Biomaterials, Sevey was part of the found- growth, continue to take market share in
ether ether ketone) and the company’s ing team of Skeletal Kinetics LLC, (Cu- the global spine market, meet the needs of
current surface. pertino, Calif.) as director of marketing. our customers and generate value for our
“As our body of science continues to Sevey holds a bachelor of science degree shareholders has never been stronger,”
grow, we identified the need to bring on- in health science from St. Mary’s College said Gregory T. Lucier, chairman and CEO
board someone of Jim’s caliber to educate of California in Moraga. of NuVasive.“With this incredibly dynamic
the spinal surgeon community and our The full line of Endoskeleton devices leadership team and new roles and re-
sales force on the science and associat- features Titan Spine’s proprietary implant sponsibilities defined, we can move even
ed benefits of our current and Nanolock surface technology, which consists of a faster to deliver game-changing innova-
proprietary surface technologies,” said unique combination of roughened to- tion, expand globally, drive operational ef-
Kevin Gemas, president of Titan Spine. pographies at the macro, micro, and cel- ficiencies and inspire our ‘A-Player’ share
“With more than 22 years of experience lular levels. This combination of surface owners to be the best they can be.”
with medical devices and biomaterials, topographies is designed to create an NuVasive’s executive leadership team,
reporting directly to Lucier, includes: vice president and a member of the execu- NuVasive offers a spine portfolio of more
• Pat Miles, president and chief oper- tive leadership team at NuVasive and will than 90 products developed to improve
ating officer (COO): Miles has been with focus on NuVasive’s expansion into greater spine surgery and patient outcomes. The
NuVasive for 14 years. In 2015, he was China. Hannon has extensive experience at company’s principal procedural solution is
appointed president and COO, respon- NuVasive in the areas of corporate develop- its Maximum Access Surgery, or MAS, plat-
sible for leadership and management of ment, mergers and acquisitions, and regu- form for lateral spine fusion
NuVasive’s global products and services, latory and legal. He joined the company in For more details on NuVasive’s restruc-
as well as operational duties, includ- 2005, most recently serving as executive vice turing, see its write-up in the Top 10 com-
ing customer fulfillment, manufacturing, president, corporate development and gen- panies listing.
supply chain management and quality eral counsel. In his new role, Hannon will
engineering. As COO, Miles leads NuVa- be responsible for NuVasive’s business and Mazor Robotics Creates VP of
sive’s Global Operations, Product Devel- commercial operations outside of the Unit- Product Management Position
opment and Marketing Services teams, ed States, including leading the company’s Mazor Robotics Ltd., a Caesarea, Israel-
which combine the company’s develop- international expansion opportunities. based developer of innovative guidance
ment and operational expertise within • Carol Cox, executive vice president, systems and complementary products, has
one organization. Most recently, he has strategy, corporate development and exter- added Anat Kaphan to the company’s ex-
overseen the launch of Integrated Global nal affairs: Cox has more than 20 years of ecutive ranks as vice president of marketing
Alignment, or iGAT, a proprietary, pro- senior level experience in cross-functional and product management, a newly estab-
cedurally integrated, digital platform of corporate roles in the healthcare sector. lished role with product development and
specialized products designed to help She joined the company in 2014, most re- corporate marketing being the primary re-
surgeons achieve more precise spinal cently serving as executive vice president sponsibilities. Kaphan will be based at the
column alignment. of corporate affairs and human resources. company’s global headquarters in Israel and
• Matt Link, president, U.S. Commer- In her new role, Cox will be responsible report directly to Ori Hadomi, Mazor’s CEO,
cial: Link joined NuVasive in 2006. He most for leading NuVasive’s corporate develop- and will be a member of the company’s ex-
recently served as the company’s president, ment and mergers and acquisitions strat- ecutive leadership team.
U.S. Sales and Service. In this role, he led egy, leveraging communications, investor Kaphan has more than 15 years of ex-
the strategic integration of the U.S. sales relations and government affairs channels perience in product development and
and service functions. With that integration in support of the company’s strategic priori- strategy and previously has held several
complete, the company is renaming its U.S. ties, and creating a corporate marketing and product, marketing and business devel-
Sales and Service division U.S. Commercial brand team. opment positions in leading medical de-
to better reflect NuVasive’s broad efforts to • Pete Leddy, Ph.D., executive vice vice companies, such as Philips Medical
integrate sales, service and specialized cus- president, human resources and corporate Systems and Lumenis Ltd. She holds a
tomer marketing programs. Link now will integrity: Leddy assumes leadership of the bachelor’s degree in economics and ac-
focus on driving greater sales force efficien- company’s human resources, compliance, counting from Haifa University and an
cies and the further development of NuVa- regulatory and facilities functions after M.B.A. in international marketing from
sive’s commercial strategies. serving as a member of NuVasive’s board Tel Aviv University.
• Quentin Blackford, executive vice of directors since 2011, from which he has “I am excited to have Anat join Mazor
president and chief financial officer: Black- resigned. Leddy brings to this newly cre- and I look forward to her being a valued
ford has served as chief financial officer of ated role more than 25 years of senior level member of the executive team. She has de-
NuVasive since 2014. He joined the com- global human resources experience with veloped and successfully executed strategic
pany in 2009 as corporate controller and Dell, Taylor Made, PepsiCo, Life Technolo- business plans for new products throughout
has more than 15 years of experience in gies and Doubletree Hotels. Leddy’s exten- her career and we are looking forward to the
the healthcare industry. During his tenure, sive experience includes successfully imple- contributions she will make to the corporate
Blackford has been responsible for all ele- menting and leading best-in-class human team,”said Hadomi.“Mazor is an innovative
ments of the company’s finance, accounting resources strategies that drove operational company and our objective is to continually
and investor relation functions, including excellence and several major employee and deliver product enhancements. Anat will
the development of the company’s financial cultural transformation initiatives. ensure that we are proactively addressing
strategic planning and analysis. In addition, NuVasive has begun a the market’s evolving needs and maintain-
• Jason Hannon, executive vice presi- search for a chief information officer, a new- ing a high level of surgeon satisfaction.”
dent, international and general counsel: ly created role, and a new general counsel to Mazor Robotics develops robotic-based
Hannon assumes the role of executive vice replace Hannon, both of whom would also technology. The company’s Renaissance
president, international, from Russell Pow- be part of the executive leadership team and Guidance System currently is used for spine
ers, who continues to serve as an executive report to Lucier. and brain procedures. v
September
MPO Summit Returns to Utah
Sept. 3-4: Eurospine, Bella Center,
F
Copenhagen, Denmark. More info: +49 or 10 years, in U.S. and international medtech manufacturing hubs, Orthopedic
3641 311 63 15; www.eurospine2015.eu Design & Technology’s sister publication, Medical Product Outsourcing’s conference
series has provided the medical device industry with the most comprehensive
Sept. 9: MedtechVision 2015: Women in programs, addressing critical medical device outsourcing and manufacturing issues.
Health, Four Seasons Palo Alto, Palo Alto, This year, MPO returns to Utah. The MPO Summit-Utah will tap into the state’s grow-
Calif. More info: jacque@medtechwomen. ing medical device market. Utah’s life-sciences industry boasts more than 26,800 em-
org; www.medtechwomen.org ployees, making it a leader among Western states for life-science businesses per capita
and second for overall industry growth. In addition, state universities bring in more
Sept. 17-19: 36th SICOT Orthopaedic World than $400 million annually in research grants. Building from such statistics, this inter-
Congress, Baiyun International Convention active networking and educational event will gather local and out-of-state industry
Center, Guangzhou, China. More info: +32 experts for a forum to discuss timely industry topics and provide tools to compete and
2 648 68 23; www.sicot.org/guangzhou grow in today’s challenging business climate.
The conference will open with a keynote address delivered by Robert Grajew-
Sept. 21-23: World Congress and Expo on ski, M.P.A., M.B.A., president of Edison Nation Medical. More than an incubator,
Medical Devices, Hyatt Regency Orlando Edison Nation takes product ideas from any stage of development and helps the
International Airport, Orlando, Fla. More inventor make the idea a reality. Grajewski will address bringing open innovation
info: (650) 268-9744; medicaldevices. to healthcare invention.
omicsgroup.com The sessions featured at this year’s event include a panel discussion with and
about women in medtech hosted by Maria Shepherd, founder of Data Decision
Sept. 25: 2015 Medical Technology Executive Group. John Langell, M.D., Ph.D., M.P.H., surgeon, assistant professor, and execu-
Forum, Crowne Plaza Cabana Hotel, Palo tive director of the Center for Medical Innovation at the University of Utah, will
Alto, Calif. More info: (202) 354-7171; present a discussion on engaging universities and medical device companies in
www.medicaldevices.org new product creation. His forum will be followed by an address by Secure BioMed
Evaluations President Linda Braddon, Ph.D., on getting medical devices to market
Sept. 29-30: MPO Summit, Stein Eriksen faster. The day will wrap up with a talk on the MedAccred accreditation process
Lodge, Park City, Utah. More info: (201) and a case study presentation on the long-term impact of supplier consolidation. A
880-2243; www.mposummit.com reception—including entertainment—will end the day.
The second day of the conference features an in-depth tour of Nelson Labo-
Sept. 30-Oct. 3: International Society for ratories Inc.’s facilities in Salt Lake City. Company President/CEO Jeffery Nelson
Technology in Arthroplasty 28th Annual will introduce the experience. The tour will include views into several of Nelson
Congress, Hilton Hotel, Vienna, Austria. Labs’ capabilities, including biocompatibility, sterility, protective barriers, package
More info: (916) 432-3550; www. testing and validations, and bioburden and radiation sterilization. Two interactive
istaonline.org workshops on the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s unique device identification
mandate and offshoring guidance will complete the final day.
October The MPO Summit will take place Sept. 29-30 at the Stein Eriksen Lodge in Park
City, Utah. For more information, call (201) 880-2243 or visit www.mposummit.com.
Oct. 5-7: AdvaMed 2015, San Diego
Convention Center, San Diego, Calif. More
info: (202) 434-7213; www.advamed.org Oct. 21-22: Southern California Design-2- Oct. 25-28: Cleveland Clinic 2015 Medical
Part Show, Pasadena Center, Pasadena, Calif. Innovation Summit, Cleveland, Ohio. More
Oct. 6-8: S.M.A.R.T. Medical Devices More info: (800) 225-4535; www.D2P.com info: (216) 444-0141; clevelandclinic.org v
Conference, Berlin, Germany. More
info: +421-2-3220-2200; www.ebcg.com Have a Meeting to Announce?
Send all meeting announcements to:
Oct. 14-17: North American Spine Society Orthopedic Design & Technology
30th Annual Meeting, Chicago, Ill. More 70 Hilltop Road, Third Floor • Ramsey, N.J. 07446
info: (630) 230-3600; www.spine.org Phone: (201) 880-2273 • Fax: (201) 825-0553
E-mail: rarrowsmith@rodmanmedia.com
One Component UV10TKMed 6280 South Redwood Rd., Salt Lake City, UT 84123
OKAY Industries, Inc.......................................................... 860-225-8707
200 Ellis St., New Britain, CT 06050
Withstands Repeated Sterilization Cycles Orchid Orthopedic Solutions............................................ 517-694-2300
1489 Cedar St., Holt, MI 48842
• USP Class VI certified Triangle.................................................................................. 201-825-1212
• Meets ISO 10993-5 25 Park Way, Upper Saddle River, NJ 07458
for cytotoxicity
• High glass transition
temperature CONTRACT MANUFACTURING SERVICES
• Optically clear
maxon precision motors, inc............................................. 508-677-0520
101 Waldron Rd., Fall River, MA 02720
Paragon Medical.................................................................. 574-594-2140
8 Matchett Industrial Park Dr., Pierceton, IN 46562
www.masterbond.com | +1 201.343.8983 SMC Ltd................................................................................ 715-247-3500
ANALYSIS/TESTING 330 SMC Dr., Somerset, WI 54025
Swiss-MedTech.................................................................... 401-333-8888
Cadence, Inc......................................................................... 800-252-3371 23-A Ashton Parkway, Cumberland, RI 02684
9 Technology Dr., Staunton, VA 24401
Orchid Orthopedic Solutions............................................ 517-694-2300
1489 Cedar St., Holt, MI 48842
Paragon Medical
8 Matchett Industrial Park Dr., Pierceton, IN 46562 DELIVERY SYSTEMS
COMPONENT PARTS
fiNANCIAL ADVISORS
Cadence, Inc......................................................................... 800-252-3371
9 Technology Dr., Staunton, VA 24401 P&M Corporate Finance, LLC.......................................... 312-602-3636
Centex Machining, Inc....................................................... 512-255-1477 225 W. Washington St., Ste. 2700, Chicago, IL 60606
1513 Sam Bass Rd., Roundrock, TX 78681
Marox Corporation............................................................. 413-536-1300
373 Whitney Ave., Holyoke, MA 01040
Orchid Orthopedic Solutions............................................ 517-694-2300 FORGING
1489 Cedar St., Holt, MI 48842
Paragon Medical ................................................................. 574-594-2140 Orchid Orthopedic Solutions............................................ 517-694-2300
8 Matchett Industrial Park Dr., Pierceton, IN 46562 1489 Cedar St., Holt, MI 48842
Tegra Medical....................................................................... 508-541-4200 Paragon Medical.................................................................. 574-594-2140
9 Forge Park, Franklin, MA 02038 8 Matchett Industrial Park Dr., Pierceton, IN 46562
Triangle.................................................................................. 201-825-1212 Tecomet................................................................................. 978-642-2400
25 Park Way, Upper Saddle River, NJ 07458 115 Eames St., Wilmington, MA 01887
STERILIZATION
Huron Tool & Cutter Grinding Co. Inc....................................... 11....................................... 631-420-7000.............................................. www.hurontool.com
O
rthopedic Design & Technology’s Top the perfect blend of traditional techniques
10 issue highlights giants in the to form a plastic covered with carbon fiber.
industry, providing insight into the “The process has this interesting blend
successes and pitfalls experienced by the of human and machine labor,” he told
companies in orthopedic technology that TechCrunch in February. “What’s interest-
bring in the most money. On the oppo- ing is how the machines help us print the
site end of the spectrum are the emerg- legs. But the machines couldn’t design this
ing companies that are revolutionizing on their own.”
their own fields in numerous small and All of Standard Cyborg’s prosthetics
not-so-small ways. With an aging popu- are custom-made; the final lamination
lation and new technology that allows process takes two hours and is done by Inventor Jeff Huber’s walking leg prosthesis (left)
for more customizable, niche products, hand. Even with the more labor-intensive and Standard Cyborg’s Water Leg prosthesis
more people that need specialized medi- portion, Huber’s techniques allow him to (right). Image courtesy of Standard Cyborg.
cal technology now are able to receive sell these prosthetics at just $799 a piece.
good care to solve unique problems from The company is backed by the seed fund Inspired by his daughter who runs
startups catering to specific needs. For in- Y Combinator. Huber remains the founder a dance studio, serial Rochester, N.Y.,
stance, San Francisco, Calif.-based startup and currently is the sole employee. entrepreneur Jack Schickler started
Standard Cyborg is making a 3-D printed, Intellirod Spine (formerly Ortho- Balance Engineering in 2009 to cre-
customized waterproof leg for amputees Data Inc.), which received its first round ate software that can measure human
that’s reportedly 28 times cheaper than a of funding in 2008, was founded by spine balance. Six years later, the company is
normal walking prosthetic leg; and Roch- surgeon Rolando M. Puno, M.D., and pro- now starting a funding round to expand
ester, N.Y.-based Balance Engineering Inc. fessors from the University of Louisville in sales of a product that can diagnose
is commercializing a technology that has Kentucky. The company is developing a and treat people with concussions and
already helped football players and college wireless implantable microelectronic spi- other balance issues.
athletes improve their balance after con- nal rod strain sensor meant to allow spine The tool, Equilibrate, has been in de-
cussive trauma. surgeons to objectively assess the strain on velopment since the company’s found-
Let’s take a look at some of the small implanted spinal fusion rods postopera- ing, and has been used to treat pro-
companies making big splashes: tively. After years of work and funding, the fessional football players, orthopedic
Standard Cyborg was founded by en- company received $1.9 million last year to surgery patients and college athletes.
gineer Jeff Huber, who also is an ampu- accelerate commercialization of the sen- The software tool combines real time
tee. For most of his life, Huber has used sor and related lumbar fusion implants. objective upper and lower body mea-
a prosthetic leg. He was born with a con- The company has now submitted a 510(k) sures with the judgment and experience
genital birth defect that left him without clearance application to the U.S. Food of a clinical professional to improve
a fully formed fibula. As a growing child, and Drug Administration for the Loadpro patient outcomes. A patient stands on
Huber would get a new leg every nine intra-operative sensor for use in achiev- adjustable, static force plates while
months or so, a familiar and expensive ing rod strain balance during surgery. The wearing a lightweight vest with imag-
problem for children who need prosthet- system gives the surgeon new informa- ing targets placed at specific anatomi-
ics. Once he became an adult, insurance tion for improving surgical technique and cal landmarks. Receiving input from
only would cover a new leg every three to avoiding post-operative adverse hardware the force plates and cameras, Equili-
five years. His current leg costs $23,000; related events. The company currently is brate senses minute shifts in central
for patients who are above-the-leg ampu- establishing alpha clinical sites for Load- body force, positions, directions and
tees, it can cost double. In his own Em- pro in Louisville, Ky.; and in Cincinnati, frequencies of motion from individual
eryville, Calif., work space, Huber started Columbus and Cleveland, Ohio. Not only areas of the body and provides quanti-
tinkering with 3-D printers and various does the technology promise to help sur- tative scores of dynamic alignment and
different plastics including ABS and PLA. geons do their job better; it also holds the sway, as well as the integration of com-
One of the materials was promising, but promise of reducing costs associated with bined effects across the whole body in
wasn’t quite strong enough until he found postoperative complications. an overall score for total balance. v