Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
MAVERICK ENTERTAINMENT )
GROUP, INC. )
)
)
v. ) CA. 1:10-cv-00569-RJL
)
DOES 1 – 4,350 )
)
Defendants. )
_______________________________________)
1. This is a civil action seeking damages and injunctive relief for copyright infringement
under the copyright laws of the United States (17 US.C. § 101 et seq.).
2. This Court has jurisdiction under 17 US.C. §101 et seq.; 28 US.C. § 1331 (federal
3. The manner of the transfer of Plaintiff’s motion pictures among the P2P network users is
called a “BitTorrent protocol” or “torrent” which is different than the standard P2P protocol used
for such networks as Kazaa and Limewire. The BitTorrent protocol makes even small computers
with low bandwidth capable of participating in large data transfers across a P2P network. The
initial file-provider intentionally elects to share a file with a torrent network. This initial file is
called a seed. Other users (“peers”) on the network connect to the seed file to download. As yet
additional peers request the same file each additional user becomes a part of the network from
where the file can be downloaded. However, unlike a traditional peer-to-peer network, each new
file downloader is receiving a different piece of the data from each user who has already
1
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9 Filed 08/10/10 Page 2 of 7
downloaded the file that together comprises the whole. This piecemeal system with multiple
pieces of data coming from peer members is usually referred to as a “swarm.” The effect of this
technology makes every downloader also an uploader of the illegally transferred file(s). This
means that every “node” or peer user who has a copy of the infringing copyrighted material on a
torrent network must necessarily also be a source of download for that infringing file.
4. This distributed nature of BitTorrent leads to a rapid viral spreading of a file throughout
peer users. As more peers join the swarm, the likelihood of a successful download increases.
Because of the nature of a BitTorrent protocol, any seed peer that has downloaded a file prior to
the time a subsequent peer downloads the same file is automatically a source for the subsequent
peer so long as that first seed peer is online at the time the subsequent peer downloads a file.
Essentially, because of the nature of the swarm downloads as described above, every infringer is
simultaneously stealing copyrighted material from many ISPs in numerous jurisdictions around
the country.
5. Venue in this District is proper under 28 US.C. § 1391(b) and/or 28 US.C. §1400(a).
Although the true identity of each Defendant is unknown to the Plaintiff at this time, on
information and belief, each Defendant may be found in this District and/or a substantial part of
the acts of infringement complained of herein occurred in this District. On information and
belief, personal jurisdiction in this District is proper because each Defendant, without consent or
permission of the Plaintiff as exclusive rights owner, distributed and offered to distribute over
the Internet copyrighted works for which the Plaintiff has exclusive rights. Such unlawful
distribution occurred in every jurisdiction in the United States, including this one. In addition,
each Defendant contracted with an Internet Service Provider found in this District to provide
2
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9 Filed 08/10/10 Page 3 of 7
PARTIES
6. Plaintiff Maverick Entertainment Group, Inc. (the “Plaintiff”) is a creator and distributor
of motion pictures. Plaintiff brings this action to stop Defendants from copying and distributing
to others over the Internet unauthorized copies of the Plaintiff’s copyrighted motion pictures.
Defendants’ infringements allow them and others unlawfully to obtain and distribute for free
unauthorized copyrighted works that the Plaintiff spends millions of dollars to create and/or
distribute. Each time a Defendant unlawfully distributes a free copy of the Plaintiff’s
copyrighted motion pictures to others over the Internet, each person who copies that motion
picture can then distribute that unlawful copy to others without any significant degradation in
sound and picture quality. Thus, a Defendant’s distribution of even one unlawful copy of a
motion picture can result in the nearly instantaneous worldwide distribution of that single copy to
a limitless number of people. The Plaintiff now seeks redress for this rampant infringement of
7. Plaintiff Maverick Entertainment Group, Inc. is a Florida Corporation, with its principal
place of business at 1191 East Newport Center Drive, Ste 210, Deerfield Beach, FL 33442.
Plaintiff is engaged in the production, acquisition, and distribution of motion pictures for
theatrical exhibition, home entertainment, and other forms of distribution. Plaintiff is the owner
of the copyrights and/or the pertinent exclusive rights under copyright in the United States in the
motion pictures that have been unlawfully distributed over the Internet by the Defendants.
8. The true names of Defendants are unknown to the Plaintiff at this time. Each Defendant
is known to Plaintiff only by the Internet Protocol (“IP”) address assigned to that Defendant by
his or her Internet Service Provider on the date and at the time at which the infringing activity of
each Defendant was observed. The IP address of each Defendant thus far identified, together
3
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9 Filed 08/10/10 Page 4 of 7
with the date and time at which his or her infringing activity was observed, is included on
Exhibit A hereto. Plaintiff believes that information obtained in discovery will lead to the
identification of each Defendant’s true name and permit the Plaintiff to amend this First
Amended Complaint to state the same. Plaintiff further believes that the information obtained in
discovery will lead to the identification of additional infringing parties to be added to this First
picture is ongoing.
COUNT I
INFRINGEMENT OF COPYRIGHTS
9. The Plaintiff is responsible for the creation, development, production, and distribution of
the commercially released motion picture titles listed below that have significant value and have
been produced and created at considerable expense. At all relevant times the Plaintiff has been
the holder of the pertinent exclusive rights infringed by Defendants, as alleged hereunder, for
certain copyrighted works, including but not limited to the screenplays and films (collectively,
including registered derivative works, the “Copyrighted Motion Pictures”) which are the subject
REGISTRATION
TITLE NUMBER(S)
PAu003446529
13 Hours in a Warehouse
PAu003446513
A Numbers Game PAu003441629
Border Town 2009 PAu003377551
Deceitful Storm PAu003029940
Fast Track No Limits PA0001669961
He Who Finds a Wife PA0001215498
Hellbinders PAu003334408
Locator 2 PAu003352028
Smile Pretty (aka Nasty) PAu002920820
Stripper Academy PAu003146949
4
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9 Filed 08/10/10 Page 5 of 7
PA0001608017
The Casino Job
PAu003361207
The Clique (aka Death Clique) PAu003023078
Trunk PAu003400325
10. The Copyrighted Motion Pictures contain a copyright notice advising the viewer that the
11. The Plaintiff is informed and believes that each Defendant, without the permission or
consent of the Plaintiff, has used, and continues to use, an online media distribution system to
reproduce and distribute to the public, including by making available for distribution to others,
the Copyrighted Motion Pictures. The Plaintiff has identified each Defendant by the IP address
assigned to that Defendant by his or her ISP on the date and at the time at which the infringing
activity of each Defendant was observed. In doing so, each Defendant has violated the
Plaintiff’s exclusive rights of reproduction and distribution. Each Defendant’s actions constitute
infringement of the Plaintiff’s exclusive rights protected under the Copyright Act of 1976 (17
12. The foregoing acts of infringement have been willful, intentional, and in disregard of and
13. As a result of each Defendant’s infringement of the Plaintiff’s exclusive rights under
copyright, the Plaintiff is entitled to relief pursuant to 17 US.C. § 504 and to its attorneys’ fees
14. The conduct of each Defendant is causing and, unless enjoined and restrained by this
Court, will continue to cause the Plaintiff great and irreparable injury that cannot fully be
compensated or measured in money. The Plaintiff has no adequate remedy at law. Pursuant to
17 U.S.C. §§ 502 and 503, the Plaintiff is entitled to injunctive relief prohibiting each Defendant
5
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9 Filed 08/10/10 Page 6 of 7
from further infringing the Plaintiff’s copyright and ordering that each Defendant destroy all
copies of the Copyrighted Motion Pictures made in violation of the Plaintiff’s copyrights.
WHEREFORE, the Plaintiff prays for judgment against each Defendant as follows:
1. For entry of preliminary and permanent injunctions providing that each Defendant shall
be enjoined from directly or indirectly infringing the Plaintiff’s rights in the Copyrighted Motion
Pictures and any motion picture, whether now in existence or later created, that is owned or
controlled by the Plaintiff (“the Plaintiff’s Motion Pictures”), including without limitation by
using the Internet to reproduce or copy the Plaintiff’s Motion Pictures, to distribute the Plaintiff’s
Motion Picture, or to make the Plaintiff’s Motion Pictures available for distribution to the public,
except pursuant to a lawful license or with the express authority of the Plaintiff. Defendant also
shall destroy all copies of the Plaintiff’s Motion Pictures that Defendant has downloaded onto
any computer hard drive or server without the Plaintiff’s authorization and shall destroy all
copies of those downloaded motion pictures transferred onto any physical medium or device in
2. For actual damages or statutory damages pursuant to 17 U.S.C. § 504, at the election of
the Plaintiff.
5. For such other and further relief as the Court deems proper.
6
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9 Filed 08/10/10 Page 7 of 7
Respectfully Submitted,
7
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document
Ex. A
9-1 Filed 08/10/10 Page 1 of 65
1
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document
Ex. A
9-1 Filed 08/10/10 Page 2 of 65
2
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document
Ex. A
9-1 Filed 08/10/10 Page 3 of 65
3
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document
Ex. A
9-1 Filed 08/10/10 Page 4 of 65
4
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document
Ex. A
9-1 Filed 08/10/10 Page 5 of 65
5
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document
Ex. A
9-1 Filed 08/10/10 Page 6 of 65
6
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document
Ex. A
9-1 Filed 08/10/10 Page 7 of 65
7
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document
Ex. A
9-1 Filed 08/10/10 Page 8 of 65
8
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document
Ex. A
9-1 Filed 08/10/10 Page 9 of 65
9
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 10 of 65
10
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 11 of 65
11
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 12 of 65
69.134.182.226 4/2/10 04:05:33 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
70.160.77.111 4/2/10 06:21:46 PM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications Inc.
68.191.209.75 4/2/10 10:25:04 PM Fast Track No Limits Charter Communications
75.80.34.149 4/3/10 09:29:20 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
173.52.250.131 4/3/10 04:54:34 PM Fast Track No Limits Verizon Internet Services Inc.
97.113.47.174 4/3/10 10:49:53 PM Fast Track No Limits Qwest Communications Company, LLC
72.199.176.114 4/4/10 12:30:18 AM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications
24.179.237.116 4/4/10 01:22:02 AM Fast Track No Limits Charter Communications
68.226.24.203 4/4/10 07:36:08 AM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications
67.242.95.154 4/4/10 11:07:17 PM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
65.35.224.114 4/5/10 02:10:49 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
68.112.136.131 4/5/10 02:16:12 AM Fast Track No Limits Charter Communications
72.66.230.56 4/5/10 11:15:58 AM Fast Track No Limits Verizon Internet Services Inc.
24.250.253.106 4/5/10 09:52:24 PM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications
138.89.29.221 4/6/10 12:06:12 AM Fast Track No Limits Verizon Internet Services Inc.
71.209.177.123 4/6/10 01:57:06 AM Fast Track No Limits Qwest Communications Company, LLC
97.102.238.227 4/6/10 05:05:07 PM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
68.161.211.182 4/6/10 09:14:35 PM Fast Track No Limits Verizon Internet Services Inc.
24.196.81.156 4/8/10 12:24:58 AM Fast Track No Limits Charter Communications
97.82.161.239 4/8/10 01:47:59 AM Fast Track No Limits Charter Communications
74.170.50.160 4/8/10 10:34:30 AM Fast Track No Limits BellSouth.net Inc.
67.35.255.232 4/8/10 10:40:19 PM Fast Track No Limits BellSouth.net Inc.
173.69.66.250 4/9/10 12:42:56 PM Fast Track No Limits Verizon Internet Services Inc.
68.0.222.164 4/9/10 09:48:10 PM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications Inc.
68.102.237.180 4/10/10 10:04:23 PM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications Inc.
66.157.57.20 4/11/10 03:57:53 AM Fast Track No Limits BellSouth.net Inc.
98.179.14.246 4/11/10 09:10:34 PM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications Inc.
71.112.227.58 4/12/10 06:13:55 AM Fast Track No Limits Verizon Internet Services Inc.
72.83.195.137 4/13/10 09:48:39 AM Fast Track No Limits Verizon Internet Services Inc.
65.33.85.232 4/13/10 04:04:13 PM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
70.172.242.75 4/14/10 01:19:47 AM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications
76.187.20.13 4/14/10 02:41:49 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
72.211.150.105 4/14/10 02:53:55 AM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications
75.170.65.4 4/14/10 06:45:31 AM Fast Track No Limits Qwest Communications Company, LLC
96.36.85.241 4/14/10 06:21:42 PM Fast Track No Limits Charter Communications
24.193.182.54 4/15/10 01:35:48 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
70.190.65.90 4/15/10 07:45:59 AM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications
68.104.209.54 4/15/10 08:51:51 AM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications Inc.
71.173.7.113 4/16/10 12:14:54 AM Fast Track No Limits Verizon Internet Services Inc.
70.162.90.169 4/16/10 01:18:26 AM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications
173.170.124.241 4/16/10 01:17:08 PM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
70.174.79.154 4/17/10 03:27:51 AM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications
76.175.107.188 4/17/10 03:56:50 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
76.178.69.106 4/17/10 08:34:29 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
96.236.73.78 4/17/10 02:13:27 PM Fast Track No Limits Verizon Internet Services Inc.
174.100.99.37 4/17/10 03:34:13 PM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
75.169.226.89 4/18/10 12:02:03 AM Fast Track No Limits Qwest Communications Company, LLC
75.130.185.187 4/18/10 12:54:48 AM Fast Track No Limits Charter Communications
68.225.142.243 4/18/10 02:04:24 PM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications
24.205.42.195 4/18/10 02:55:36 PM Fast Track No Limits Charter Communications
71.208.93.41 4/18/10 04:09:14 PM Fast Track No Limits Qwest Communications Company, LLC
74.79.115.203 4/19/10 03:40:12 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
66.75.32.129 4/19/10 07:55:19 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
173.58.34.157 4/19/10 06:58:37 PM Fast Track No Limits Verizon Internet Services Inc.
96.36.137.255 4/19/10 07:03:29 PM Fast Track No Limits Charter Communications
24.209.161.146 4/19/10 10:25:55 PM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
72.181.181.56 4/20/10 02:47:12 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
69.205.75.48 4/20/10 03:33:38 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
68.12.192.174 4/20/10 09:47:01 PM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications Inc.
76.94.153.153 4/20/10 10:14:03 PM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
70.16.1.236 4/21/10 02:46:03 AM Fast Track No Limits Verizon Internet Services Inc.
72.68.226.211 4/21/10 06:37:36 AM Fast Track No Limits Verizon Internet Services Inc.
74.77.195.187 4/21/10 10:57:25 PM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
66.91.9.164 4/22/10 03:59:25 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
98.67.213.8 4/23/10 04:19:44 AM Fast Track No Limits BellSouth.net Inc.
75.84.108.148 4/23/10 06:09:46 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
75.80.255.162 4/24/10 07:35:41 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
12
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 13 of 65
13
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 14 of 65
14
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 15 of 65
98.211.40.223 6/3/10 02:26:15 AM Fast Track No Limits Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
98.64.77.244 6/3/10 07:17:26 AM Fast Track No Limits BellSouth.net Inc.
24.19.81.166 6/3/10 07:33:23 AM Fast Track No Limits Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
67.8.1.243 6/3/10 08:20:24 PM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
68.117.138.108 6/4/10 12:57:12 AM Fast Track No Limits Charter Communications
72.147.183.225 6/4/10 02:28:19 AM Fast Track No Limits BellSouth.net Inc.
71.220.181.223 6/4/10 06:46:37 AM Fast Track No Limits Qwest Communications Company, LLC
76.89.97.44 6/4/10 07:45:22 PM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
24.209.216.138 6/5/10 02:10:39 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
24.243.38.190 6/5/10 05:58:07 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
76.115.4.191 6/5/10 07:16:21 AM Fast Track No Limits Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
72.219.137.168 6/5/10 08:15:41 AM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications
76.122.58.240 6/5/10 08:06:40 PM Fast Track No Limits Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
97.78.209.171 6/6/10 12:00:23 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
74.65.109.182 6/6/10 03:41:00 PM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
67.185.146.220 6/7/10 12:01:14 AM Fast Track No Limits Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
98.149.86.156 6/7/10 12:02:25 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
72.68.230.157 6/7/10 12:16:20 AM Fast Track No Limits Verizon Internet Services Inc.
97.122.176.101 6/7/10 01:32:14 AM Fast Track No Limits Qwest Communications Company, LLC
76.189.147.195 6/7/10 01:33:01 AM Fast Track No Limits Road Runner HoldCo LLC
98.236.183.216 6/7/10 04:20:31 AM Fast Track No Limits Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
68.113.46.47 6/7/10 05:45:53 AM Fast Track No Limits Charter Communications
76.25.209.244 6/7/10 07:47:53 AM Fast Track No Limits Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
66.190.49.195 6/8/10 11:15:57 PM Fast Track No Limits Charter Communications
24.158.35.155 6/9/10 04:35:22 PM Fast Track No Limits Charter Communications
68.231.59.201 6/10/10 06:26:03 AM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications
68.0.223.197 6/10/10 01:01:49 PM Fast Track No Limits Cox Communications
98.28.120.26 2/23/10 04:34:42 PM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
76.116.50.4 2/24/10 02:17:38 AM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
76.181.144.147 2/24/10 08:46:27 PM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
98.216.47.4 2/25/10 12:06:20 AM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
71.72.21.65 2/27/10 05:42:38 PM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
72.178.14.28 2/28/10 03:17:39 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
74.65.242.128 2/28/10 04:26:26 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
98.226.9.217 3/1/10 12:41:35 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
76.105.86.224 3/3/10 01:50:05 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
76.169.147.64 3/6/10 06:53:48 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
67.246.107.120 3/12/10 04:43:07 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
98.220.17.146 3/13/10 07:17:24 AM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
71.72.115.49 3/13/10 10:39:45 PM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
69.242.51.135 3/14/10 12:56:16 AM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
67.174.175.13 3/17/10 09:58:26 AM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
76.186.174.250 3/20/10 12:30:56 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
68.205.177.232 3/23/10 12:36:18 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
24.166.31.154 3/23/10 08:36:55 PM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
66.108.114.75 3/24/10 08:01:28 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
98.252.194.216 3/24/10 10:24:10 AM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
98.202.235.50 3/27/10 12:37:10 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
97.100.183.24 3/28/10 12:59:00 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
67.8.225.40 3/28/10 03:12:16 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
76.189.19.85 3/28/10 03:21:17 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
75.179.15.120 3/28/10 05:51:16 PM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
98.239.62.68 3/30/10 06:52:50 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
98.239.1.28 3/31/10 12:04:57 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
24.88.111.247 4/2/10 11:48:43 PM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
70.92.141.156 4/3/10 06:02:48 PM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
76.108.216.73 4/4/10 10:50:49 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
69.207.3.73 4/10/10 06:45:36 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
76.189.96.189 4/10/10 10:09:11 PM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
68.56.10.72 4/13/10 03:22:48 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
68.56.243.46 4/13/10 06:44:26 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
68.203.159.234 4/14/10 06:45:28 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
67.191.142.89 4/15/10 06:42:34 AM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
98.200.127.144 4/16/10 02:22:48 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
65.191.131.21 4/17/10 10:21:05 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
75.178.10.47 4/18/10 05:57:10 PM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
65.28.101.155 4/19/10 11:42:38 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
15
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 16 of 65
68.204.52.175 4/22/10 12:01:42 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
98.227.17.11 4/25/10 05:46:42 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
76.31.98.252 4/30/10 05:28:01 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
69.206.234.77 5/2/10 01:09:37 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
76.177.33.236 5/6/10 03:35:08 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
76.108.46.216 5/6/10 05:58:20 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
68.51.255.45 5/7/10 11:26:51 AM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
65.24.61.251 5/13/10 08:40:45 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
98.195.110.202 5/13/10 11:43:19 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
174.97.16.215 5/15/10 12:00:06 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
76.30.164.3 5/15/10 05:01:28 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
76.107.93.223 5/19/10 09:30:06 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
65.29.251.5 5/20/10 02:58:23 PM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
69.207.15.173 5/23/10 04:13:58 PM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
174.48.142.61 5/24/10 01:20:02 AM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
98.204.173.249 5/24/10 01:55:36 AM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
69.255.116.146 5/25/10 01:56:32 AM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
67.9.3.241 5/26/10 01:05:54 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
68.49.250.196 5/27/10 06:44:37 AM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
68.51.16.25 5/28/10 05:33:12 AM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
24.211.104.34 5/28/10 11:00:20 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
69.242.212.163 5/28/10 12:25:14 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
98.242.114.186 5/31/10 03:32:36 AM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
174.48.104.45 5/31/10 04:15:38 PM He who finds a wife Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
65.24.62.228 6/1/10 01:16:48 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
65.184.120.202 6/1/10 02:52:55 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
24.209.120.187 6/1/10 03:51:17 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
24.161.235.93 6/4/10 04:48:31 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
76.168.72.3 6/5/10 07:43:57 AM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
66.57.210.150 6/6/10 09:26:53 PM He who finds a wife Road Runner HoldCo LLC
72.230.212.37 2/19/10 10:36:52 PM Hellbinders Road Runner HoldCo LLC
76.17.16.177 2/21/10 03:46:59 AM Hellbinders Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
71.229.214.125 2/22/10 05:51:09 AM Hellbinders Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
68.45.199.42 2/22/10 07:34:01 AM Hellbinders Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
70.18.58.120 2/23/10 12:01:07 AM Hellbinders Verizon Internet Services Inc.
71.57.214.195 2/23/10 02:51:32 AM Hellbinders Comcast Cable Communications Holdings, In
24.193.49.13 2/23/10 03:40:42 AM Hellbinders Road Runner HoldCo LLC
69.180.127.138 2/23/10 04:02:24 AM Hellbinders Comcast Cable Communications Holdings, In
24.31.171.50 2/25/10 04:54:06 AM Hellbinders Road Runner HoldCo LLC
72.94.118.237 2/25/10 04:57:07 AM Hellbinders Verizon Internet Services Inc.
75.72.235.83 2/27/10 05:09:38 AM Hellbinders Comcast Cable Communications Holdings, In
173.88.228.169 2/27/10 11:43:37 AM Hellbinders Road Runner HoldCo LLC
98.165.164.22 2/28/10 08:51:54 AM Hellbinders Cox Communications
24.19.161.207 3/2/10 04:09:32 AM Hellbinders Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
72.187.120.106 3/2/10 10:46:45 PM Hellbinders Road Runner HoldCo LLC
70.188.189.109 3/3/10 10:13:31 PM Hellbinders Cox Communications
71.76.239.225 3/4/10 03:42:45 AM Hellbinders Road Runner HoldCo LLC
76.184.215.89 3/4/10 04:35:23 AM Hellbinders Road Runner HoldCo LLC
68.3.65.85 3/4/10 05:16:37 PM Hellbinders Cox Communications Inc.
76.189.143.206 3/6/10 03:28:54 PM Hellbinders Road Runner HoldCo LLC
71.63.72.51 3/7/10 02:51:01 AM Hellbinders Comcast Cable Communications Holdings, In
72.95.158.117 3/7/10 09:12:20 AM Hellbinders Verizon Internet Services Inc.
98.218.61.93 3/7/10 03:24:32 PM Hellbinders Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
76.177.106.49 3/8/10 12:11:54 AM Hellbinders Road Runner HoldCo LLC
76.110.133.208 3/8/10 12:56:44 AM Hellbinders Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
96.236.169.53 3/8/10 07:29:00 AM Hellbinders Verizon Internet Services Inc.
71.164.76.13 3/8/10 09:43:26 AM Hellbinders Verizon Internet Services Inc.
72.200.7.103 3/9/10 01:11:01 AM Hellbinders Cox Communications
98.224.104.206 3/9/10 01:36:06 AM Hellbinders Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
68.33.213.42 3/10/10 02:29:23 AM Hellbinders Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
68.34.74.231 3/11/10 03:42:17 AM Hellbinders Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
69.123.182.72 3/12/10 05:30:42 AM Hellbinders Optimum Online (Cablevision Systems)
76.88.43.173 3/12/10 09:23:05 PM Hellbinders Road Runner HoldCo LLC
76.183.7.220 3/13/10 05:40:43 AM Hellbinders Road Runner HoldCo LLC
98.156.8.212 3/13/10 09:14:59 PM Hellbinders Road Runner HoldCo LLC
98.30.72.40 3/13/10 10:58:19 PM Hellbinders Road Runner HoldCo LLC
98.204.221.12 3/14/10 02:21:35 AM Hellbinders Comcast Cable Communications, Inc.
16
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 17 of 65
17
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 18 of 65
18
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 19 of 65
19
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 20 of 65
20
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 21 of 65
21
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 22 of 65
22
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 23 of 65
23
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 24 of 65
24
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 25 of 65
25
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 26 of 65
26
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 27 of 65
27
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 28 of 65
28
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 29 of 65
29
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 30 of 65
30
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 31 of 65
31
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 32 of 65
32
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 33 of 65
33
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 34 of 65
34
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 35 of 65
35
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 36 of 65
36
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 37 of 65
37
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 38 of 65
38
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 39 of 65
39
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 40 of 65
40
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 41 of 65
41
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 42 of 65
42
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 43 of 65
43
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 44 of 65
44
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 45 of 65
45
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 46 of 65
46
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 47 of 65
47
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 48 of 65
48
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 49 of 65
49
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 50 of 65
50
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 51 of 65
51
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 52 of 65
52
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 53 of 65
53
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 54 of 65
54
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 55 of 65
55
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 56 of 65
56
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 57 of 65
57
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 58 of 65
58
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 59 of 65
59
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 60 of 65
60
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 61 of 65
61
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 62 of 65
62
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 63 of 65
63
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 64 of 65
64
Case 1:10-cv-00569-RJL Document 9-1
Ex. A
Filed 08/10/10 Page 65 of 65
65