Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
2 .1 Int ro du c t i on 1
2 .2 R at i ona le 2
4 . 0 L ite r atu re R e v ie w 4
5 . 0 Fr ame work 9
6 . 0 R e s e arch C onc e pt s 11
6.1.3 S e cond ar y D at a 11
6.1.4 Pr imar y D at a 11
6.1.6 Va lidit y 12
6.2.4 Access 14
8 . 0 R e fe re nc e s 16
9 .0 App e nd i ce s
1 .0 Abst r ac t
This proposal is designed to investigate the successful attributes and environment for the female gender to succeed in the
This proposal is necessary because even though there is more women in the workforce than ever before there is still a
hegemony of men even in female dominated industries like the fashion and textile industry. Women are still expected to
be the ‘homemaker’ therefore forcing women to take on less demanding roles at work so they can raise their children this
Power and leadership are deemed to be a masculine term. There is also the expectation for men to be leaders because
women cannot control their emotions. This is a barrier for women to become leaders in their industry because they are
not being given the chance because they are being compared to male norms instead of actual leadership.
There are internal barriers facing women from getting leadership roles as men are more likely to go for raises and
promotions as women. Women acting confident is seen as a negative which is a further reason for them not to go for
leadership roles because they don’t want people to look down on them.
The literature review has been conducted by collecting books, journals and articles to understand the extent gender bias
still has within the industry and how it has changed over time.
2 .0 Int ro du c t ion & R at iona le
2.1 Introduction
The aim of this proposal is to determine the successful attributes and environment for the female gender to succeed in the
fashion and textile industry in Australia. This proposal explores the industry broadly by showing it is not just a fashion
and textile industry it is worldwide. It explores the history of feminism and how the workforce has changed over the
decades for women. It presents the current barriers facing women in the workforce today including fairness, the wage
The major issues discussed in this proposal are equality, fairness, gender roles and internal barriers.
The major inequality facing women today is unequal pay. Currently the wage gap in Australia is 15.3% (WGEA n.d.), for
retail trade in Australia it is at 8.1% (WGEA n.d.). Reasons for the wage gap include women and men working in different
industries with the more ‘feminine’ industries paying less, discrimination in hiring and disportionate share of household
The unfairness women are exposed to at work involves sexual harassment. According to ABS (2016) 1 in 2 women has
been sexually harassed. Sexual harassment tends to occur towards women more because they are usually inferior in the
power structure at work and women are left to feel powerless and intimidated and prevents advancements in their career
Despite how far our society has come there are still internalised gender roles at play. This gets taught at a young age
through media and interactions with people. The words ‘power’, ‘dominance’ and ‘leadership’ are considered masculine
terms (Pike 2016). If women were associated with these words it is seem as a negative. Leadership throughout history
has been men, therefore these are a generalised stereotype for what a leader should be and this is associated with male
norms. When women are in leadership roles they get compared to the male norm of leadership and not for what women
The major internal barrier facing women is lack of confidence. Confidence is negatively correlated for women (Sandberg
2010). Therefore they are less likely to ask for a raise or a promotion (Babcock & Laschever 2007). Sandberg (2010) stated
women are more likely to put themselves down if they do well using terms like “i got lucky” or “i got help” this is a further
example of showing the lack of confidence women have because they don’t want people to look negatively at them.
These issues highlight the glass ceiling in the industry and how there is still several barriers facing women in the
1
advancements in the career. It further projects the need to understand what the attributes and environment was for
women that have been able to beat the glass ceiling and how the fashion and textile industry can implement these
2.2 Rationale
The aim for the second part of this proposal is to find out what the ideal attributes and environment are for the female
gender to succeed in the Australian fashion and textile industry. This will be through conducting expert interviews and
giving out a questionnaire to approximately 100-200 people. The purpose of this is to analyse what the key attributes are
for leadership roles and whether these are gendered. How the fashion and textile industry in Australia can overcome this
barrier to make leadership roles more available to the female gender. How they can overcome this barrier will be done by
It is a important proposal because despite how far the industry and women have come there is still a glass ceiling in
Australia. Society still has internalised gender roles these being that women should still be the one’s raising the children
and leadership is for men as women cannot handle the pressure. The wage gap is of major discussion today and two of
the major reasons it occurs is because women have to take on more part-time or more flexible hours at work to take
care of the family. Another reason is the more feminine industries like health and education pay less. A barrier towards
the female genders advancement is sexual harassment. Sexual harassment still occurs regularly at work but often goes
unreported in fear of losing their job. This is a key work environment issue that needs to be focused on.
2
3 .0 R e s e arch Aims & O bj e c t ives
Aim: To determine the successful attributes and environment for the female gender to succeed in the Australian fashion
Objectives:
Objective 1: To identify the barriers for the female gender to succeed in industry.
Objective 2: To analyse the attributes and environments for females to succeed in the Australian fashion and textile
industry.
Objective 3: To evaluate the attributes and environments for females to succeed in the Australian fashion and textile
industry.
3
5 .0 Frame work
WHO WHAT WHY HOW
Females in the F&T -Their experience -Directly associated with Face to Face,
industry (Buyers, -What makes them the F&T industry Skype, Phone
designers etc) who different to other -What attributes they think Call, Email. The
have been in the candidates for their role makes a successful leader question that will
of their gender
Female and male -Their Experience -What attributes they think Face to Face,
tutors/lecturers that -What makes them makes a successful leader Skype, Phone Call,
the fashion and textile candidates for their role The questions
industry and teach it. -Have they personally that will asked
of their gender
Government -Their Experience -What attributes they think Face to Face,
an opportunity because
of their gender
9
Employment -Knowledge of the -What is the ideal candidate Face to Face,
ended. Focus
Groups
General Public What attributes do they Are these masculine/ Survey. The
mixture between
questions
10
6 .0 R e s e arch C oncepts
6.1 Research Methodology
Research methodology describes the actions to be taken to investigate a research problem for the application of specific
procedures or techniques therefore identifying and analysing information to understand the problem therefore being
able to critically evaluate the validity and reliability of the study. (USC, n.d.).
Qualitative Research is a research methodology that emphasizes words rather than the quantification in the collection
and analysis of data. (Bryman 2008a: 366) According to Sandelowski (2004) qualitative research is a term for a array
of attitudes and strategies towards conducting an inquiry aimed at discovering how humans understand, experience,
Quantitative research focuses on gathering numerical data and generalising it across groups of people or to explain a
particular phenomenon (Babbie, E 2010). Zikmund, Babin & Carr (2012, p 655) defines quantitative research as research
that addresses objectives through empirical awareness that involves numerical measurement and analysis.
Secondary data according to Doyle (2016) is data that has been collected through a third party. It can also be referred
to as existing data available through researchers who aren’t involved in the original data acquisition (Trzesniewski et al
2011).
Primary data is the numerical and non-numerical information that is obtained directly by a researcher through surveys,
observations or experimentations and it has not been previously published (Duignan, 2016). According to Sylvia &
Terhaar (2018) data is considered primary when it has been collected specifically for the purposes of measuring the
Hussein (2009) defines data triangulation as the use of multiple methods mainly qualitative and quantitative methods
in studying the same phenomenon for the purpose of increasing study credibility. According to Thurmond (2001)
triangulation is the combination of at least 2 or more theoretical perspectives, methodological approaches, data sources,
11
investigators or data analysis methods.
6.1.6 Validity
Validity according to Oxford Dictionary is the quality of being logically or factually sound. To Cambridge Dictionary it
is the state of being acceptable or reasonable. There are twelve types these are;
Statistical conclusion validity: The validity of inferences about the correlation between cause and effect (Landrum 2015)
Internal validity: The validity of inferences about whether covariation between A and B reflects a casual relationship
Construct validity: higher order constructs that represent sampling particulars (Landrum 2015).
External validity: whether the cause-effect relationship hold over variables (Landrum 2015).
Face validity: Occurs when something appears to be valid. It is not a sufficient validity because there needs to be more
solid evidence. Researchers start off with face validity to prove a point (Changing minds n.d.).
Content validity occurs when the experiment provides adequate coverage of the subject being studied. It is related to
having a good experiment design as to have content validity the experiment must have a wide sample size and measuring
Criterion-Related validity: The ability of the measure to predict a variable that is designated as a criterion. It is related to
Predictive Validity: Measures the extent to which a future level of a variable can be predicted from a current measurement
Concurrent Validity: Measures the relationship between measures made with existing tests. The existing tests are the
Convergent Validity occurs where measures of constructs that are expected to correlate do so (Changing minds n.d.).
Discriminant Validity occurs where constructs that are expected to correlate do not (Changing minds n.d.).
Conclusion validity occurs when there is a definite relationship between two variables. Can have a positive or negative
12
6.2 Proposed Research Design
6.2.1 Information Required
The research design will be conducted through primary and secondary sources. The primary sources will be conducted
The expert interviews will be directed at women with either a long or short history working in the fashion and textile
industry; these include buyers, designers and allocators. The point of interviewing these women is to see whether they
have dealt with the ‘glass ceiling’ and whether gender has influenced their job opportunities. These will be conducted
through face to face interviews or through email or phone call. The type of questions that will be asked refer to appendix
C.
To go broad with the research interviews will also be conducted to females in different industries including tutors,
lecturers and government regulators. This is to show how it isn’t just the fashion and textile industry facing this problem.
A survey will be conducted through QUALTRICS. It will be taken by the general public therefore ‘no experts’ in the area.
The survey will be conducted to further present the issues with the glass ceiling. It will showcase what the ideal attributes
are for a leader and whether this is more masculine, neutral or feminine.
This proposal is directed at the broad audience being RMIT University, government regulators & academics. This
audience will find the proposal of interest because it highlights the barriers the female gender are still facing today in the
workforce. In the next part of the proposal that will be conducted next semester it will present how to overcome these
barriers.
The surveys will be done through QUALTRICS and will be distributed through RMIT University Brunswick through
emails and Facebook. The sample size of the survey will be to 100-150 people and because of where the survey will be
distributed the characteristics of the sample size is adults in between the ages of 18-60 all from Melbourne and Perth
To analyse the survey I will cross-tabulate the answers so group the respondents based on age and gender. I will filter the
results to focus on one major sub-group being females. I will further compares females by the age groups to see how they
differ.
13
For the expert interviews data will be collected through face-to-face interviews, through emails and phone calls. The
expert interviews will be females in the fashion & textile industry. The jobs in the industry being buyers, designers
and allocators. Other expert interviews will be from tutors and lecturers who have background in the fashion and
textile industry. Government regulators including a former politician will be interviewed to show how this isn’t just a
problem facing the fashion and textile industry, it is worldwide. Employment consultants will also be interviewed to give
6.2.3 Limitations
The limitations to this research proposal were sample size, time frame and working around the availability of the experts.
The sample size was small as there will be only 100-150 surveys collected. The scope of surveys is small as it was delivered
to students at RMIT Brunswick campus and to Facebook friends of the author. Therefore majority of the sample would
be from Perth and Melbourne ranging from 18-60. The time frame to collect the data and research was limited to four
months. Finding a time to talk to the multiple expert interviews is another limitation as not all were available to speak to
Another limitation is the limited financial resources as a student writing the research there was a very small budget to
6.2.4 Access
The surveys will reach the intended audience by being given out face-to-face at RMIT Brunswick campus. They will be
distributed through email to former and current tutors of the author to their current students. By being uploaded on the
To get into contact to each of the expert interviewees the author will be contacting businesses in the fashion industry,
employment consultant agencies and government bodies through phone calls and emails to see if they are interested and
available to be interviewed.
This proposal will be conducted following the principles in the National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human
Research (2007). This will be done by getting written consent by all participants involved and knowledge that they will
be recorded. Information revealed by participants will not be released without their consent. This proposal is represented
by RMIT University and will be taken seriously and done in a professional manner.
14
7 .0 G an nt C har t and Budget
7.1 Gantt chart for Research Project
This is a gantt chart that details the project schedule that will take place during the second half of the year.
TASK July August September October November
Survey Design X
Survey X
Conduction
Mentor X X X X X
Meetings
Expert X
Interview
Design
Expert X X
Interview
Conduction
Digital X
Presentation
Secondary X X X X
Research
Draft X
Submission X
15
8 .0 R e fe re nces
Australian Bureau of Statistics 2017, Characteristics of Employment, cat. No. 6333.0, ABS, Canberra, viewed 21 April
2018, <http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/0/A8CAED8E5F9FB2E1CA257F1F00044E8C?Opendocument>
Australian Bureau of Statistics 2017, Gender Indicators - Work and Family Balance, cat. No. 4125.0, ABS, Canberra,
Features~Work%20and%20Family%20Balance~7>
Australian Bureau of Statistics 2016, Personal Safety, cat. No. 4906.0, ABS, Canberra, viewed 21 April 2018, <http://www.
abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/mf/4906.0>
Australian Human Rights Commission n.d., Sexual Harassment, Australian Human Rights Commission, viewed 30 April
2018, <https://www.humanrights.gov.au/our-work/sex-discrimination/guides/sexual-harassment>
Babbie, E. R 2010. The practice of social research, 12eds, Belmont, CA, Wadsworth.
Babcock, L & Laschever, S 2007, Women Don’t Ask: The High Cost of Avoiding Negotiation - And Positive Strategies for
Banks, R, Dransfield, J, Willmott, N & Legalwise Seminars 2004, Harassment & Discrimination in the workplace: papers
presented at a seminar held in Sydney on Thursday 26 February 2004, Legalwise Seminars, Sydney, Australia
Belasen, A.T. & Belason, A. T 2012, Developing Women Leaders in Corporate America: Balancing Competing Demands,
Transceding Traditional Boundaries, ABC-CLIO, Santa Barbara, USA, viewed 4 April 2018, <https://ebookcentral.
proquest.com/lib/RMIT/reader.action?docID=871419&query=>
Bolsø, A, Svendsen, SHB, & Sørensen, SØ (eds) 2017, Bodies, Symbols and Organizational Practice : The Gendered
Bryman, A 2008a, ‘The end of the paradigm wars?’, in Alasuutari, P., Bickman, L., and Brannen, J. (eds.) The Sage
Handbook of Social Research Methods, London, Sage. viewed 20 April 2018. <http://sk.sagepub.com.ezproxy.lib.rmit.edu.
au/reference/the-sage-handbook-of-social-research-methods/n2.xml>
Cambridge Dictionary n.d., Validity, Cambridge Dictionary, viewed 20 April 2018, <https://dictionary.cambridge.org/
dictionary/english/validity>
Changing Minds n.d., Types of Validity, Changing Minds, viewed 20 April 2018, <http://changingminds.org/explanations/
research/design/types_validity.htm>
Chung, H 2017, Want more women in top positions? Provide them with more flexibility at work, The Conversation, viewed
at-work-82188>
Clements, P, Spinks, T & Phillips, E 2009, ‘Equal Opportunities Handbook: How to Recognise Diversity, Encourage Fairness
16
reader.action?docID=433144&ppg=86>
Doyle, C. (2016). Dictionary of Marketing. In: Oxford, 4th ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Duignan, J, 2016, A Dictionary of Business Research Methods, Oxford, 1st ed, Oxford University Press, viewed 16 April
2018
Fielden, S.L., Davidson, M.J., Woolnough, H. & Hunt, C. 2010, “A Model of Racialized Sexual Harassment of Women in
the UK Workplace”, Sex Roles, vol. 62, no. 1-2, pp. 20-34. Viewed 18 April 2018, <https://search-proquest-com.ezproxy.
lib.rmit.edu.au/docview/225366910?accountid=13552&rfr_id=info%3Axri%2Fsid%3Aprimo>
Griffin, G 2017, ‘Second-wave feminism’, Dictionary of Gender Studies, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, viewed
acref-9780191834837-e-343>
action?docID=1356320&query=>
Horyn, C 2017, Phoebe Philo and the Death of Leisure Time Philo is a designer for a Slower Era’, The Cut, viewed 1 April
2018, <https://www.thecut.com/2017/12/phoebe-philo-leaving-celine-cathy-horyn.html>
Hussein, A 2015, ‘The use of Triangulation in Social Sciences Research : Can qualitative and quantitative methods be
combined?’. Journal of Comparative Social Work, North America, 4,viewed 24 April 2018, <http://journal.uia.no/index.
php/JCSW/article/view/212>
Landrum, E 2015, 12 Types of Validity, Youtube, 30 November, Boise State University, viewed 20 April 2018, <https://
www.youtube.com/watch?v=52aoo1p2mL0>
Liddy, M & Hanrahan 2017, ‘Fewer women run top Australian companies than men called John - or Peter, or David ’, The
john/8327938>
Mandel, H, & Semyonov, M 2005, ‘Family Policies, Wage Structures, and Gender Gaps: Sources of Earnings Inequality in
20 Countries’. American Sociological Review, vol. 70, no.6, pp. 949-967, viewed 20 April 2018, <http://journals.sagepub.
com.ezproxy.lib.rmit.edu.au/doi/pdf/10.1177/000312240507000604>
McCann, J 2013, Electoral quotas for women: an international overview, APH, viewed 18 April 2018 <https://www.aph.
gov.au/About_Parliament/Parliamentary_Departments/Parliamentary_Library/pubs/rp/rp1314/ElectoralQuotas>
McLaughlin, H, Uggen, C, & Blackstone, A 2012, ‘Sexual Harassment, Workplace Authority, and the
Paradox of Power’, American Sociological Review, vol. 77, no.4, 625-647, viewed 16 April 2018, <https://
ap01-a.alma.exlibrisgroup.com/view/action/uresolver.do?operation=resolveService&package_service_
id=16423196040001341&institutionId=1341&customerId=1330>
Oxford Living Dictionary n.d., Fairness, Oxford Living Dictionary, viewed 8 April 2018, <https://en.oxforddictionaries.
17
com/definition/fairness>
Oxford Living Dictionary n.d., Feminism, Oxford Living Dictionary, viewed 15 April 2018, <https://en.oxforddictionaries.
com/definition/feminism>
Oxford Living Dictionary n.d., Validity, Oxford Living Dictionary, viewed 20 April 2018, <https://en.oxforddictionaries.
com/definition/validity>
Palestini, R 2013, Feminist Theory and Educational Leadership: Much Ado About Something, R&L Education, Maryland,
USA
Pike, H 2016, Female Fashion Designers Are Still in the Minority, The Business of Fashion, viewed 20 March 2018,
https://www.businessoffashion.com/community/voices/discussions/how-can-fashion-develop-more-women-leaders/
less-female-fashion-designers-more-male-designers
Ruderman, E.G. 2005, ‘When Loss Becomes Gain: Transforming Women’s Internal Saboteur’, Clinical Social Work
Journal, vol. 33, no.4, pp. 455-471, viewed 17 April 2018, <https://link-springer-com.ezproxy.lib.rmit.edu.au/content/
pdf/10.1007%2Fs10615-005-7038-7.pdf>
Sandberg, S 2010, Why we have too few women leaders, podcast, December 2010, viewed 20 March 2018, <https://www.
ted.com/talks/sheryl_sandberg_why_we_have_too_few_women_leaders>
Sanelowsk,. M 2004, ‘Qualitative Research’, in Lewis-Beck, M., Bryman, A., and Liao, T. (eds) The Sage Encyclopedia of
Social Science Research Methods, Thousand Oaks CA, Sage, viewed 20 April 2018
<http://www.jstor.org.ezproxy.lib.rmit.edu.au/stable/pdf/41723052.
pdf?refreqid=excelsior:b89f9c4da0eccc459c9f2b563375ecad>
Sherwin, B 2014, ‘Study: Women are More Effective Leaders Than Men, Business Insider, 24 January, viewed 17 May
2018, <http://www.businessinsider.com/study-women-are-better-leaders-2014-1?IR=T>
Stefanovici, S 2016, “Why Do We Need Feminism”, Studia Universitatis Petru Maior.Philologia, , no. 21, pp. 105-110, viewed
id=info%3Axri%2Fsid%3Aprimo>
Sylvia, M, Terhaar, M.F. 2018, ‘Primary Data’ in Syliva M, Clinical Analytics and Data Management for the DNP, 2nd eds,
The Economist 2009, The Glass Ceiling, The Economist, viewed 18 April 2018 <https://www.economist.com/
node/13604240>
Thurmond, V 2001, The Point of Triangulation. Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 33(3), pp.253-258.
Trzesniewski, K.H, Donnellan, M.B, Lucas, R.E, & American Psychological Association 2011, Secondary data analysis :
An introduction for psychologists (1st ed.). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women n.d., Concepts and Definitions, United
18
Nations, viewed 18 April 2018 <http://www.un.org/womenwatch/osagi/conceptsandefinitions.htm>
University of Southern California 2018, Organizing Your Social Sciences Research Paper: 6. The Methodology, USC,
Vaillancourt, T 2013, ‘Do human females use indirect aggression as an intrasexual competition strategy’, Philosophical
Transactions of the Royal Society, vol. 368, no. 1631, viewed 30 April 2018, <http://rstb.royalsocietypublishing.org/
content/368/1631/20130080>
Valerio, A 2009, Developing women leaders : A guide for men and women in organizations, Chichester, West Sussex,
England: Wiley-Blackwell.
Willis, M & Jozkowski, K.N. 2017, ‘Ladies First? Not So Fast: Linguistic Sexism in Peer-Reviewed Research’, The Journal
of Sex Research, vol. 55, no. 2, pp. 137-145, viewed 18 April 2018 <https://www-tandfonline-com.ezproxy.lib.rmit.edu.
au/doi/full/10.1080/00224499.2017.1346058?scroll=top&needAccess=true>
Workplace Gender Equality Agency n.d., About workplace gender equality, WGEA, viewed 18 April 2018 <https://www.
wgea.gov.au/learn/about-workplace-gender-equality>
Zikmund, William G, Babin, Barry., & Carr, J, author. (2012). Business research methods (9th ed.). Mason, OH: South-
Western.
19
9 .0 App e ndices
A
20
C
Do you think the me too campaign has impacted the fashion retail industry?
How has your company changed to be more accessible for growth in the workplace for women
Why do you believe there isn’t many female fashion designers for major fashion brands?
Have you had any experiences that may have been contributed to your gender as to why you didn’t/did get the job
What strategies has your company implemented to lessen the wage gap?
Do you believe the Australian Fashion & Textile Industry has a glass ceiling problem and if so what strategies has
Women are underrepresented in the workplace Why do you believe this is - do you have any policies
How are you addressing the wage gap for women - do you have any policies
How has the experienced changed over the years/journey - did they have to leave a company
21