Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
No. Action Ref. Node Reference Deviation Follow Up Notes P&ID Status Date
Provide double check valves instead of a single check valve 3.2 Reverse/ Misdirected 122A 121A
1 3 YES P&Id Updated Accordingly closed 26/10/2007
at 1" TEAL start-up line Flow 123A
Provide interlock to trip 2P1204 on loss of open condition for P&Id & Interlock Description Updated
2 4 4.1 No/ Less Flow YES 121B closed 26/10/2007
2HV-12110 Accordingly
Provide interlock to trip 2P1205 on loss of open condition for P&Id & Interlock Description Updated
3 6 6.1 No/ Less Flow YES 122B closed 26/10/2007
2HV-12210 Accordingly
Ensure correct labelling on site of the alignment valves and
7.1 Reverse/ Misdirected
4 reactor catalyst lines in order to avoid mis-alignment during 7 YES Instruction for labeling provided to site 111A closed 9/8/2008
Flow
changeover.
Operating procedure should highlight the consequence of 7.1 Reverse/ Misdirected
5 7 YES Operating manual updated accordingly 111A closed 9/8/2008
mis-direction of catalyst feeds. Flow
P&ID to include note indicating the requirement of elevating
6 the alignment valves relative to the upstream/downstream 7 7.2 Others YES P&Id Updated Accordingly from process part. 111A closed 26/11/2007
piping in order to avoid sedimentation inside the valves.
Provide interlock to trip 2P1302A/B on loss of open condition P&Id & Interlock Description Updated
7 10 10.1 No/ Less Flow YES 131 closed 26/10/2007
for 2HV-13103 Accordingly
Provide interlock to close each reactor outlet feed to 3rd flash
vessel on closed condition of 2HV-12310B depending on the P&Id & Interlock Description Updated 121B 122B
8 8 8.1 No/ Less Flow YES closed 26/10/2007
mode of operation. This can be implemented through Accordingly 123B
feedback from manual bypass valves at flash vessel inlet.
In case of 2PIC-12315 malfunctions to close
2PV-12315, the scenario is the same as
defined by Basell in the data sheet for 2PSV-
12303: "Discharge of 3000 kg/h of Ethylene
and 2500 kg/h of hexane in case of feeding
9 Verify 2PSV-12303-S is sized for 2PIC-12315 failure case. 8 9.4 High Pressure YES 123B closed 26/10/2007
C2 saturated hexane (12 barg, 85°C) to an
isolated vessel D1203 at safety valve set
pressure of 6 barg". 2PSV-12303 discharge
capacity of 28145 kg/hr covers this relief
case.
Provide interlock to trip 2P2101A/B on loss of open condition P&Id & Interlock Description Updated
10 14 14.1 No/ Less Flow YES 212 closed 26/10/2007
for 2HV-21204 Accordingly
Provide interlock to trip 2P3102A/B on loss of open condition P&Id & Interlock Description Updated
11 33 33.1 No/ Less Flow YES 311B closed 26/10/2007
for 2HV-31103 Accordingly
Interlock 2S-33303A is indicated on P&ID but this cause is not
20.6 Reverse/ Misdirected
12 included in the interlock description for 2S-33303A. Interlock 20 YES Interlock Description updated accordingly 331 333B 333D closed 30/11/2007
Flow
description to be revised.
Operating procedure to mention the requirement of
20.6 Reverse/ Misdirected
13 repeating the distillation step in case of accidental opening of 20 YES Operating manual updated accordingly 331 333B 333D closed 9/8/2008
Flow
2H/Y-33101/ 33102
No. Action Ref. Node Reference Deviation Follow Up Notes P&ID Status Date
No. Action Ref. Node Reference Deviation Follow Up Notes P&ID Status Date
Delete check valve in pump 2P6211 suction line as it will not
32.1 No/ Less Flow of soda
provide protection in case 2PSV-62203-R actuates (will
28 32 from IBCs to soda process YES P&Id Updated Accordingly 622 closed 26/10/2007
restrict relief of pressure since PSV is routed to pump suction
tank
and joins the section between check valve and pump)
Provide overflow line for soda process tank 2D6210 routed to 32.6 More Flow of DM
29 32 YES P&Id Updated Accordingly 622 closed 26/10/2007
safe location. water
Provide check valve in the caustic dosing line to distillation 32.7 Reverse/ Misdirected
30 32 YES P&Id Updated Accordingly 333B closed 26/10/2007
vessel 2D3303A. Flow
Check the possibility of reverse flow from membrane unit 32.7 Reverse/ Misdirected
31 32 YES P&Id Updated Accordingly 232 closed 26/10/2007
2PK2301 and provide protection measures if required. Flow
Provide high pressure alarm at pump 2P6210A/B discharge
32 32 32.8 High Pressure YES P&Id Updated Accordingly 622 closed 26/10/2007
independent from 2PIC-62201.
Temperature Gauge 2TI-62251 provided.
Installation at the selected location
downstream jacketed pipe was the envisaged
re-closed after
Provide a local temperature gauge in the caustic circulation solution during HAZOP meeting. Control
33 32 32.11 Low temperature YES 622 PSI PSSR Sep-2009
line upstream of 2PV-62201. valve 2PV-62201 was relocated later on due
<04>
to layout restrictions. For this reason the
description "upstream 2PV-62201" is
misleading.
Interlock 2I-62202 should also close DM water inlet to soda 32.6 More Flow of DM P&Id & Interlock Description Updated
34 32 YES 622 closed 26/10/2007
process tank 2D6210. water Accordingly
Provide suction strainer for pump 2P6211. Consider
35 relocating strainer provided upstream of 2HV-62201 to 32 32.18 Others YES P&Id Updated Accordingly 622 closed 26/10/2007
2P6211 suction.
Provide interlock to trip 2P3301A/B on loss of open condition P&Id & Interlock Description Updated
36 34 34.1 No/ Less Flow YES 311A 331 closed 26/10/2007
for 2HV-31101 Accordingly
Provide interlock to trip 2P3101A/B on loss of open condition P&Id & Interlock Description Updated
37 35 35.1 No/ Less Flow YES 311A closed 26/10/2007
for 2HV-31102 Accordingly
The function of control unit 2FV22304 is to
Consider control of 2PIC-22305 through pressure transmitter keep a constant discharge flow and is
38 located downstream of take-off point for 2FV-22304. To be 16 16.2 More Flow NO controlled by 2FT22304; hence 2FV22304 223 closed 15/06/2008
confirmed with conveying system vendor. cannot be controlled by a PIC. Low-pressure
alarm will be provided with 2PI22307
Provide interlock to trip 2P2201A/B on loss of open condition P&Id & Interlock Description Updated
39 39 39.1 No/ Less Flow YES 222 closed 26/10/2007
for 2HV-22201 Accordingly
HDPE SPEEDBIRD PLANT SAFETY REPORT
ATTACHMENT 13 - HAZOP & SIL RECOMMENDATIONS FOLLOW UP
No. Action Ref. SIF Reference Scenario Follow Up Notes P&ID Status Date
Check for protections inside the extruder package. In case No additional protections are present in
independent protections are provided inside the package, W2 To prevent very high
extruder package. W2 has been considered
1 can be reduced to W1 for extruder damage. However, W2 1 temperature in HP steam NO 621 CLOSED Jan-09
for both piping and extruder damage in the
can still be considered for piping damage. header;
SIL assignment of SIF N.1 (SIL 1)
Check if there is any other independent safeguards for plate Independent safeguard has been provided
heat exchanger for dryer 2D2201 inside the package and if To prevent very high with 2TAHH22113 closing steam supply valve
present, W2 can be reduced to W1. However, for piping temperature in LP steam 2XV22106 on high steam temperature (P&ID
2 damage W2 is still valid. 3 header (2TIC-62103 YES sheet 221A). W1 has been considered 621 CLOSED Jan-09
malfunctions to close 2TV- therefore for dryer damage and W2 for
62103) piping damage in the SIL assignment for SIF
3 (SIL 1)
As per HAZOP Recommendation 17, in case an interlock is
provided inside the recycle gas compressor package to trip Interlock 2IS32102 stops recycle gas
To prevent damage to
the compressor on high level in suction damper 2D3206, the compressor on high level in suction dampner
3 5 compressor 2C3201 due to YES 123B CLOSED Jan-09
interlock 2I-12312 can be deleted and a DCS alarm can be 2D3206. Interlock 2I-12312 has been
liquid carry over
retained. therefore deleted
Check if there is any other independent safeguards for plate Independent safeguard has been provided
heat exchanger for dryer 2D2201 inside the package and if To prevent very high with 2TAHH22113 closing steam supply valve
present, W2 can be reduced to W1 for plate type heat temperature in LP steam 2XV22106 on high steam temperature (P&ID
4 exchanger damage. However, for piping damage W2 is still 3 header (DM water supply YES sheet 221A). W1 has been considered 621 CLOSED Jan-09
valid. failure due to condensate therefore for dryer damage and W2 for
pump 2P6201A/B trip) piping damage in the SIL assignment for SIF
3 (SIL 1)
HDPE SPEEDBIRD PLANT SAFETY REPORT
ATTACHMENT 13 - HAZOP & SIL RECOMMENDATIONS FOLLOW UP
Reference Follow
Package Action Ref. Node Notes P&ID Status Date
Deviation Up
2PSV22114 and 2PSV22115 on expansion vessel 2D2207A/B
are sized adequately for inadvertant opening of 2PCV22126 re-closed
1.Provide a relief valve on each expansion vessel 2D2207A/B
Dryer 1 4. High Pressure YES or 2PCV22127 (N2 fully open case is 50 kg/hr). PSV 221,221A after PSI Dec-2009
sized for N2 fully open case.
datasheets for 2PSV22114 and 2PSV22115 are showing also PSSR <04>
Cv of 2PCV22126 or 2PCV22127.
P&ID Updated Accordingly - RPI RV-069. PSV areadequate for
re-closed
2.Provide a relief valve at the hot water inlet of each set of the sizing case: 100% closed panels with pump full flowrate of
Dryer 1 4. High Pressure YES 221,221A after PSI Sep-2009
dryer panel sized for pump flow case and set at 6barg. 325000kg/hr. PSV22122 and PSV 22123 sized is for
PSSR <04>
434321kg/hr.
Relief valves 2PSV -22113-S and 2PSV22114-S are adequately
sized for Demineralized Water full open case. This can be
demonstrated by a pressure drop calculation on the DM water re-closed
3.2PSV-22113S/ 22114S should be sized for DM water full
Dryer 1 4. High Pressure YES supply lines to the Hot Water Expansion Vessels 2D 2207A/B. 221,221A after PSI Dec-2009
open case.
The maximum flow possible at PSV set pressure (17972 kg/hr) PSSR <04>
is well covered by the discharge capacity of the relief valves
(27145 kg/hr).
Nitrogen blanketing line is sized 1". Line length approx. 30
meters. For nitrogen at 8.8bar(g) and 10°C the critical flow at re-closed
Off Gas 1. Consider sizing 2PSV-34104S on separator 2D-3404 for N2
1 1. High Pressure YES PSV set pressure (6 barg) is reached at approx. 850kg/hr. 341A,341B after PSI Sep-2009
Compresor valve full open case.
2PSV-34104 on 2D3404 is sized for 860kg/hr and has a relief PSSR <04>
capacity of 1362 kg/hr. P&ID Updated Accordingly by Vendor
DM water make-up flow to offgas compressor package
2PK3402 is controlled by 2FV34102 (Cv=0.32). In case of
2. Consider providing a PSV on the DM water make up line
valve full opening the maximum flow is approx. 480kg/hr of re-closed
Off Gas (inside package battery limit and downstream of isolation
1 2. High Level YES water. 341A,341B after PSI Dec-2009
Compresor valve), sized for DM water valve full open case and set at
The safety valve 2PSV34120-S (orifice diameter 10mm) is PSSR <04>
6barg.
adequately sized for this case. The relief capacity at set
pressure of 6 barg is 3600kg/hr of water.
Reference Follow
Package Action Ref. Node Notes P&ID Status Date
Deviation Up
N Action Ref. Node Ref. MOC Form. Reference Deviation Follow Up Notes P&ID Status Date
1. Consider closing the 2HV-12104 on close condition of 2HV- P&ID Updated Accordingly - RPI 121A,122A,
1 1 3443-T-MF-0045 1. No/Less Flow YES closed Apr-08
12106 (through 2S-12107) RV-069 123A
2. Consider an interlock/ permissive to inhibit starting of
P&ID Updated Accordingly - RPI
2 hexane unloading pump 2P-4104 on loss of open 2 3443-T-MF-0051 1. No/Less Flow YES 38,411,412 closed Apr-08
RV-069
condition of 2XV-41201
3. Check that design pressure of pump seal pot is equal Design pressure of seal pot of
or more than design pressure of N2 system (8.5barg). If existing unloading pump 2P4104 is
3 2 3443-T-MF-0051 4. High Pressure YES 38,411,412 closed Feb-09
not pressure protection system like a relief valve, need about 32 barg. No Further
to be provided for pump seal pot protection are necessary.
4. Confirm hexane truck tank is designed for full vacuum P&ID Updated Accordingly - RPI
4 2 3443-T-MF-0051 5. Low Pressure YES 38,411,412 closed May-08
condition RV-069 and letter E-BM-TM-01086
5. Provide a selector switch for selecting the 2HV-41103/
P&ID Updated Accordingly with RPI
41105 in line that will trip the mother liquid feed pump
RV-069 - Interlock description
5 2P-4102A/B on loss of open condition. This is required 3 3443-T-MF-0052 1. No Flow YES 111A closed Jun-08
updated accordingly with Issue 03
considering only one of the HVs will be in open condition
of 3443-VZ-SG-221
at a time
6. Provide a selector switch for selecting the 2HV-41102/
P&ID Updated Accordingly with RPI
41104 in line that will trip the distilled hexane feed pump
RV-069 - Interlock description
6 2P-4101A/B on loss of open condition. This is required 3 3443-T-MF-0052 1. No Flow YES 111A closed Jun-08
updated accordingly with Issue 03
considering only one of the HVs will be in open condition
of 3443-VZ-SG-221
at a time
7. Consider tripping the hexane feed pumps and flushing
P&ID Updated Accordingly with RPI
hexane pump 2P-1104A/B and 2P-1105 also on loss of
RV-069 - Interlock description
7 open condition of 2HV-41102/ 41104. Also provide a 3 3443-T-MF-0052 1. No Flow YES 111A closed Jun-08
updated accordingly with Issue 03
selector switch for selecting the 2HV-41102/ 41104 in
of 3443-VZ-SG-221
line that will trip the pumps
8. Provide a note on P&ID (3443-XZ-DM-001_241) to P&ID Updated Accordingly - RPI
8 4 3443-T-MF-0053 1. Others YES 241 closed Apr-08
route the outlet of 2PSV-24101 to safe location RV-069
HDPE SPEEDBIRD PLANT SAFETY REPORT
ATTACHMENT 13 - HAZOP & SIL RECOMMENDATIONS FOLLOW UP