Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
LOAN POLICY
I. PURPOSE
The Board of Directors of Sample State Bank believes that sound loans are a
desirable and profitable means of employing funds available for investment.
The board recognizes that lending money necessarily includes reasonable
business risks and thus formulates this policy to provide guidance and to
control the quality of these major earning assets. The guidelines defined by
this policy serve as a basis for sound credit decisions by establishing
systematic underwriting, documentation and approval standards.
Loan policy comes from the Board of Directors. In practice, loan policy
evolves from the officers of the Bank, is drafted and discussed by senior
management, is submitted to the Board of Directors for approval, and
becomes policy after this approval is received or recommended changes by
the Board are implemented in the policy. Through this policy statement the
Board of Directors delegates most of the lending responsibilities to the
Bank’s President and the Loan Committee.
To bring the Bank’s loan portfolio into line with stated policies, the Bank
will follow the guidelines listed below:
The credit committee will meet on a weekly basis to review new and
renewing credits, Bank overdrafts, past-due and non-accrual loans and
2
the credit presentations of any new and renewing credits.
The Bank’s reputation, its image, and community’s high level of public
confidence in the Bank are extremely important, and the Bank will do
whatever is necessary to maintain its image. Each loan officer is
responsible for doing everything possible to help maintain the Bank’s
reputation as a friendly and professional Bank that routinely delivers
quality service to its customers and the communities it serves.
D. Confidentiality
II. ADMINISTRATION
3
A. Loan Management
Although ultimate authority for all lending activities is vested in the Board
of Directors, the Board hereby delegates the administration of these
responsibilities to the Loan committee.
The President manages the day to day functions of the Bank’s lending
functions including implementing loan policy and monitoring adherence to
the policy. The Loan Committee is responsible for assuring that all loans
made by the Bank meet appropriate federal and state legal requirements.
Loan Officers Committee (also known as the Credit
Committee)
Each loan officer of the Bank is responsible for the maintenance of credit
files and documentation sufficient to support the credit and perfect the
Bank’s collateral position for the lending relationships assigned to them.
It is expected that each loan officer will periodically review and monitor
the disbursement and repayment plan, documentation, and general
status of each loan he/she services. If substantial deviations in the
disbursement or repayment plan are noted, or there are substantial
changes to the operation, or problems are detected which affect the
quality of the credit in a negative manner, the lending representative
should determine the cause and develop a plan for correction. Loan
officer is responsible for creating a Problem Loan Detail Report in
FastGrade. These Problem Loan Detail reports will be prepared monthly
by the loan officer and will be presented to the Bank’s Board of Directors
at each Board meeting until they are paid in full, charged off, or the
circumstances of the loan have improved to the point that the loan is not
longer considered a classified credit.
III. EXCEPTIONS
4
3. The officer's recommendation for handling the exception and
rationale for granting the exception.
I. PURPOSE
It is the policy of Sample State Bank to adhere to both the letter and the
spirit of the laws pertaining to fair lending. Fair lending is an integral part of
our financial institution’s plan. We, as the Board of Directors, through this
policy statement take specific action to ensure that negative perceptions,
attitudes, and prejudices do not systematically affect the fair distribution of
credit by our Bank.
II. GUIDELINES
The Board of Directors of this Bank directs management to make sound loans
to all qualified applicants regardless of race, color, religion, national origin,
sex, marital status, age (provided that the applicant has the capacity to
contract), the receipt of public assistance, the borrower’s good faith exercise
of rights under the Consumer Credit Protection Act, familial status (defined
as children under the age of 18 living with a parent or legal custodian,
pregnant women and people securing custody of children under 18) and the
existence of any handicap (collectively referred to as prohibited basis). As
part of this policy, the bank should comply with all of the requirements of the
Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA), the Fair Housing Act (FHA) and all other
federal and state statutes promoting fair lending.
III. ADMINISTRATION
A. This policy should be disseminated to all loan personnel and to any other
individuals who might be in a position to talk with any prospective loan
applicants, receive loan applications, or make credit decisions.
B. General bank staff are reminded of our Bank’s commitment to fair lending
by:
5
E. While the Board of Directors and Bank management have the
responsibility to ensure fair lending for the bank, all Bank personnel are
expected to accept personal responsibility for implementing the
requirements of this policy into their daily job assignments.
I. LAWS
A. The primary trade area served by Sample State Bank will generally
consist of the following counties that are part of the Bank’s CRA area
including Crawford, Carroll, and Sac counties all within the state of Iowa.
The Bank’s Internal Rate Sheet is incorporated into the FastGrade system
and should be utilized by officer’s to determine loan pricing. Any exceptions
to the internal pricing sheet will be approved by the Bank’s President.
A. Consumer/Installment Loans
Residential:
The bank should generate residential real estate loans for its own
portfolio. In addition, the Bank has established secondary market
outlets, giving us the ability to offer competitive, long-term, and fixed-
rate mortgages.
Commercial:
Underwriting Standards:
File documentation and analysis standards for CRE loans are as defined
in Section VIII, Loan Criteria and Terms, and the Credit Criteria section
of Appendix C.
Loan to Value:
7
Loan to Value Ratios should not exceed the guidelines established in
Appendix C.
Agricultural:
8
The Bank should provide conventional financing for the acquisition and
refinancing of farmland. The bank should also use the Farm Service
Agency guarantee loan program whenever deemed necessary. The
bank also offers the outlet of doing secondary market loans direct with
Farmer Mac for long term fixed rate loans that need consideration for
lending limit purposes.
Construction Loans:
See the sample site inspection form for construction loans at Exhibit F.
C. Agricultural Loans
Loans that are short term for the purpose of financing crop and livestock
production, provided that adequate collateral is obtained within
9
acceptable margins for that type of collateral or guaranteed by the Farm
Service Agency or another federal governmental agency.
Loans for the purpose of purchasing, and secured by, farm machinery,
equipment and implements, with appropriate margins, adequate
insurance and a repayment schedule to insure the borrower’s continuing
equity position.
D.Commercial Loans
10
exceed 80% of the appraised value or of the cost, whichever is
lower.
E. Participation Loans
From time to time, this Bank may purchase participation loans from other
banks. When we do so, we should exercise all the precautions we use
when we originate a loan in-house, including performing our own
independent site inspection of the collateral pledged on the loan. Sample
State Bank will do an in-house independent credit analysis and require the
same documentation that we would require of one of our own loans. The
Bank will analyze the collateral and satisfy ourselves that the lien status is
acceptable. A complete credit file on each purchased participation should
be maintained and sufficient credit information be obtained to monitor the
status of the credit through maturity. If multiple entities are involved in
the credit, a global debt service coverage ratio will be performed to
ensure that all debt payments can be met.
F. Overdrafts/Uncollected Funds
Overdrafts are unsecured loans that unless properly addressed will result
in losses to the bank. The loan officers will monitor the overdrafts on a
daily basis. Credit extension is not to be accomplished by overdrawing a
checking account. Overdrafts will be paid using an automated overdraft
program when experience dictates that the customer will repay quickly
and in the ordinary course of business. Abuse of checking account
privilege and long term overdrafts are no to be tolerated on a regular
basis.
WSB plans to take “meaningful and effective follow-up
action” on overdrawn accounts that have been charged an overdraft fee
on more than six occasions in a rolling twelve month period. Meaningful
and effective being described as contacting the customer to discuss less
costly alternatives to the automated overdraft payment system such as a
linked savings account, a more reasonably priced line of credit consistent
with safe and sound banking practices, or a safe and affordable small
11
loan; and giving the customer a reasonable opportunity to decide whether
to continue fee-based overdraft coverage or choose another available
alternative.
G.Letter of Credit
The Bank does on occasion offer its customer’s letters of credit. Letter of
credit requirement and procedures are listed in Exhibit S.
A. The Bank intends to comply with the legal lending limits described by the
law. The Board of Directors plans to quarterly review and establish bank
lending limit guidelines. Quarterly lending limit computation is approved
in the Bank’s Board Minutes.
12
G. Release of collateral should normally be authorized only by an officer
whose loan authority is such that the loan could have been made with the
reduced collateral or by proper committee approval if a loan officer’s
authorization would have been exceeded.
H. Annual Review Form: All credits that will or already have an aggregate
loan total of $150,000 or more must be presented to the Credit
Committee on an annual basis for approval. The annual review should be
completed on a template provided by the FastGrade software. (Permanent
first mortgage debt secured by the borrower’s primary residence may be
excluded.) Approval of the Credit Committee will be received before any
new loans are funded or any existing loans are extended, renewed, or
modified. A simple majority vote by the Credit committee or special
approval obtained from the bank president is required for approval of
funding of all new and existing loans. Copies of these annual review forms
should be supplied to the Board of Directors at their next regularly
scheduled meeting.
Annual Review Forms will include, but are not limited to: Current Sample
State Bank loan totals, current requests, purpose of credit, source of
repayment, schedule and interest rate, ownership structure & history,
capital and debt structure, cash flow and debt service coverage ratio,
collateral description, credit bureau report with beacon score, current
balance sheet with historical trend on balance sheets, risk rating with
justification, copy of complete Federal Tax Return, explanation of loan
classification, background information on the borrowers relationship with
the financial information as needed to support the request.
13
Senior Management may require an inspection more often if there has
been a decline in the repayment ability of the borrower as evidenced by
the annual financial statement analysis, a delinquency problem with the
loan, or if previous inspections were unsatisfactory.
All Agricultural and Commercial lines with aggregate loan total of $150,000
or more, excluding first mortgage residential real estate, will have the risk
rating re-affirmed at least on an annual basis.
Any time a change to the risk rating is being proposed, the loan officer is
responsible for completing a risk rating change in FastGrade.
It is expected that the bank will extend credit in four principal areas in the
following portfolio mix:
Concentrations:
14
In conforming with the December 2006 Interagency Statement on
Guidance on Concentrations in Commercial Real Estate Lending and Risk
Management Practices the bank will monitor the levels and keep the
following concentrations below the following percentage of the banks
capital:
1. The Bank’s total loans for construction, land development and other
land will be less than 100% of the Bank’s total capital.
2. The Bank’s total commercial real estate loans will be less than 200%
of the banks total capital. These real estate loans would include
commercial, agricultural, multi family and other non 1-4 family
residential real estate.
Policy:
In providing for the ALLL, the Bank shall be consistent with FFIEC
Interagency Policy Statement on the ALLL and OCC Bulletin 2001-37 and
shall include in the analysis procedures for determining loan impairment
per FASB 114 and for segmenting the loan portfolio and estimating loss on
groups of loans consistent with FASB 5. In addition, the Bank shall
consider the relevant qualitative and environmental factors including
trends in the internal risk ratings and delinquent and nonaccrual loans,
results of external loan reviews, concentrations of credit considering both
15
present and prospective economic conditions, and applicable lending staff
experience.
Following the analysis, management shall summarize the ALLL for the
Board’s review. Any deficiencies on the ALLL shall be remedied in the
quarter of discovery prior to Call Report filing.
Procedures:
The President along with the Loan Committee utilized the FastGrade
software system to analyze the loan portfolio to calculate and maintain an
appropriate ALLL level. The software shall be consistent with the ALLL
policy provisions within the Loan Policy, specifically the direction given by
the FFIEC statement and OCC Bulletin 2001-37 and FASB 5 and 114.
The starting point shall be determining impairment on the FASB 114 loans
and the impact to the financial statement of the bank and the
collectability of these loans in determination of the amount of allowance
required to adequately provide for these loans.
The remainder of the loan portfolio, excluding the impaired loans, will
have a historical loss percentage applied to determine the FASB 5
allocation to the allowance. The historical loss percentages should
include a proper level of detailed segmentation. Management will identify
the “buckets” within the portfolio that are truly causing the increase in
delinquencies and non-performing loans and apply their FASB 5 allocation
based on the segmentation to the loan portfolio. Historical loss
percentages will be reviewed to determine if the most recent data
indicates a further trend. If it does, the Bank will use only the most recent
data. The historical loss percentages will be adjusted for changes in
trends, conditions, and other relevant factors. If negative trends in a
“bucket” are seen, then an action plan to reduce the banks risk will be
devised and presented to Credit Committee and the Board of Directors to
implement.
1. Purpose
2. Financial Statements
16
Current financial statements must support loans for the borrower, co-
maker, endorser, and/or guarantor. The statements must be signed by
the borrower or shall be prepared by a well-regarded independent
certified public accountant. (The only exception to this requirement is
when loans to well-known borrowers are secured, within margin, by
highly liquid, well-diversified collateral, such as listed stocks, savings
accounts, or certificates of deposit. It is recommended that financial
statements be obtained to ascertain possible secondary sources of
repayment in the event of a decline in the value of the pledged
collateral and signed by the borrower stating the accuracy of the
financial statement.)
Tax Returns: Tax returns are generally required for loans where
the bank receives CPA-compilations or in-house financial
statements.
B. Loan Agreements
Loan Agreements are required for any extension of credit when additional
terms, conditions, and agreements not contained in Sample State Bank’s
standard documentation are required to provide safeguards for the Bank.
17
Size and complexity of the loan agreement will commensurate with the
size and complexity of the transaction.
C. Repayments
2. Collateral
3. Guarantees
Where the credit line of the borrower will be strengthened by the use of
a guarantee of a financially responsible party, then a guarantee may
be used. In cases where a loan is made with heavy reliance on the
strength of the guarantor, strong consideration should be given to the
guarantor’s ability to pay out of income and not on the liquidation of
assets. The guarantors major assets and liabilities should be verified
to help determine their liquidity to support the debt payments and for
the period of time that they can support the payments.
D. Secured/Unsecured Lending
1. Unsecured Lending
18
It is expected in certain situations, loans will be made by the bank on
an unsecured basis. Unsecured lending is appropriate only when a
borrower’s capital, liquidity, historical operating performance, and
management indicate that such an extension of credit is proper. The
repayment of an unsecured loan should be tied to the purpose of the
loan and anticipated source of repayment. Such an extension of credit
should normally not exceed one year. Generally, unsecured loans
should be limited to 10% of the borrower’s net worth with a maximum
unsecured amount of $500,000.
2. Secured Lending
Loans are considered unsecured unless the bank has legally perfected
its security interest in the collateral. UCC and title searches must be
performed, collateral documents properly executed and liens properly
recorded. The lending officer is responsible for perfecting the bank’s
security interest as well as for ongoing maintenance of collateral
documentation.
E. Collateral Standards
19
It may be appropriate in individual cases to originate or purchase
loans with loan-to-value ratios that do not comply with policy or
the supervisor limits established by banking regulation. The
approval of any such loan should be supported by written
justification that clearly sets forth all the relevant credit factors
that support the underwriting decision. The justification and
Loan Committee approval documentation should be maintained in
the credit file. Exceptions are reported to the Board of Directors.
F. Lien Perfection
G. Appraisals
Appendix E establishes the guidelines for our appraisal processes and sets
out the appraiser list.
I. Environmental
20
On commercial real estate loans and commercial loans secured by real
estate, when applicable, the following will be required of a borrower at the
inception of a loan:
The Bank or any agent of the Bank will not participate in facility
management, or take any action that would put the bank in the position
of “owner operator”. Any property subject to potential contamination
shall be held only as a security interest or the bank should acquire
ownership only in the course of protecting a security interest.
J. Site Inspection
Exhibit E is a site inspection form for real estate, and can be utilized for
commercial and residential properties.
21
The loan officer is responsible for completing a site visit and
completing Exhibit F, the Construction Loan Inspection Card, prior to
funding the initial draw request and for any subsequent significant
draw requests during the construction process. Additionally, each
advance request must be supported by copies of third party invoices
and an updated construction budget prepared by the general
contractor and signed by the borrower. This budget should break out
the expenditures to date and what is expected to be spent in the future
to complete the project by category. The total expected cost of the
project should then be compared to the amount of the loan to
determine if there is a potential overage or shortage in the amount of
the loan. Properly executed lien waivers from previous advances
funded should also be obtained before funding a new advance so that
Bank can ensure that the borrower / general contractor used the funds
to pay suppliers, the general contractor, and subcontractors.
K. Non-Desirable Loans
Loans of the following types are not desirable loans by the Bank and
should normally be denied.
The Bank utilizes DigiDoc for its loan documentation function and utilizes
FastGrade for its loan portfolio management function.
A. Credit File Requirements
To ensure that the Bank maintains useful and adequate credit files, the
following minimal elements should be included in all credit files:
1. Comments
c. Correspondence
2. Financial Information
a. Consumer Loans
Installment Loans
o completed application, signed and dated
o credit report
o consumer worksheet
Real Estate Loans
o financial statements (or application) for the borrower,
guarantors and co-makers, as appropriate
o income tax returns as appropriate
o financial statements (signed and dated)
o cash flows (commercial/agricultural) as appropriate
b. Commercial/Agricultural Loans
Balance sheet (or application), which is signed and dated and
current within a year for borrower, guarantors and co-makers,
as appropriate.
Balance sheet trend analysis.
A profit and loss statement. This information is to be
accumulated in a comparative analysis of prior periods to
establish trends as appropriate.
Cash flow analysis as appropriate.
23
Complete tax returns as appropriate.
Risk rating
Annual reports the business is required to file.
Borrowing resolution
Other financial data, including interim statements,
projections, etc. should be maintained when appropriate.
Copy of Annual Review Form presentation.
3. Collateral
a. Consumer Loans
Installment Loans
o Title of item financed or other security document when
applicable
o Assignment
o Life insurance assignments as appropriate
o Evidence of insurance on collateral with bank listed as loss
payee
Real Estate Loans
o Guarantees/co-signers
o Appraisal or assessment
o Attorney’s title opinion/title insurance or title search
o Perfected mortgage and riders
o Evidence of insurance with bank as listed as mortgagee
o Flood report
b. Commercial/Agricultural
Lien searches showing the banks lien position
Perfected lien documents
o Security agreements and schedules
o Financing statements and titles
Collateral verification, floor plan checks, etc.
Collateral analysis should be completed on lines greater than
$100,000 on an annual basis.
Life insurance assignments as appropriate
Evidence of insurance on collateral with bank listed as loss
payee
Loan Agreements and Amendments
o Loan documents
Business Arrangements
o Partnership agreements
o Corporate resolutions
o Personal guarantees
o Collateral agreements supporting personal guarantees
o Completed Loan Documentation Checklist
X. LOANS TO “INSIDERS”/EMPLOYEES
A. Loans to “Insiders”
1. All directors.
2. Shareholders owning 10% or more of the bank, its holding company, or
affiliates.
3. Officers of this bank that are designated annually by the Board of
Directors as Executive Officers.
4. Related business interests.
B. Loans to Personnel
1. Executive Officers
25
A majority of the Board of Directors, voting in the absence of the
applying officer, whether or not the officer is also a director, should
give its prior approval to any obligation of an executive officer.
2. Other employees
A. Administration
2. Credit Committee
26
e. Semi-annually the Credit Committee reviews loans charged off to
determine the course of action for any potential recoveries. No
charged off asset will be rebooked by the bank.
3. Board of Directors
a. The board receives a past due report for their monthly review.
b. The problem loan list, nonaccrual loan report and other repossessed
assets
It is the policy of this Bank to hold past due loans to an absolute minimum
by applying aggressive correction and/or collection efforts. Loan officers
are responsible for collecting on the loans they made. Loan officers meet
weekly to discuss collection efforts on all loans past due. As loans
become progressively past due, action plans become directed more
toward collection than correction.
B. Problem Loans
Problem loans are generally those that meet the definitions noted below:
27
b. Loans classified by the regulators.
A problem loan list should be established using the above criteria for
guidelines in identifying potential problem credits. The list should be
updated monthly. To ensure proper control, the Credit Committee
monitors the progress of each loan and makes recommendations to loan
officers regarding corrective action strategies.
C. Nonaccrual Loans
General rule – The Bank shall not accrue interest, amortize deferred net
loan fees or costs, or accrete discount on any asset (1) which is
maintained on cash basis because of deterioration in the financial
condition of the borrower, (2) for which payment in full or principal or
interest is not expected, or (3) upon which principal or interest has been
in default for a period of 90 days or more unless the asset is both well
secured and in the process of collection.
a. An asset is “well secured” if it is secured (1) by collateral in the form of
liens on or pledges of real personal property, including securities, that
have a value sufficient to discharge the debt (including accrued
interest) in full, or (2) by the guarantee of a financially responsible
party. An asset is “in the process of collection” if collection of the asset
is preceding in due course either (1) through legal action, including
judgment enforcement of the debt or (2) in its restoration to a
"current" status described below.
b. For purpose of applying the third test for non-accrual status listed
above, the date on which an asset reaches non-accrual status
determined by its contractual terms. If the principal or interest on an
asset becomes due and unpaid for 90 days or more on a date that falls
between report dates, the asset should be placed in non-accrual status
as of the date it becomes 90 days past due and it should remain in
non-accrual status until it meets the criteria for restoration to accrual
status described below.
28
The asset upon which principal or interest is due and unpaid for 90
days or more is a consumer loan secured by a 1-4 family residential
property. Nevertheless, such loans should be subject to other
alternative methods of evaluation to assure the bank’s net income
is not materially overstated.
D. Loan Charge-Offs
Loan losses should be recognized in a timely manner to properly reflect
bank Capital and earnings. The recognition of the losses should occur as
soon as there is a reasonable probability of loss.
Repossessed Assets
29
b. Consumer Loans - typical as outlined in 4a except:
In order to properly monitor the status and action items of all OREO
property, the Bank should complete the OREO Workout Plan Template on a
monthly basis for all OREO properties held by the Bank. This form
includes information regarding marking of the property, any action items
that need to be completed or are in process for the property, and also the
current operation of the property if it is an income-producing property.
The OREO Workout Plan Template is made a part of this loan policy at
Exhibit D.
30
XIII. REQUIRED BOARD OF DIRECTOR APPROVAL FOR
CLASSIFIED LOANS
The Bank will not extend, directly or indirectly, any additional credit or modify the
terms of any loan that is classified as: Substandard, Doubtful, or Loss or for a
borrower with a previous charge-off without prior Board of Director Approval.
In order to ensure that this procedure is followed, the Bank’s loan processors are to
complete the following steps before a request from a classified or previously
charged-off borrower is processed:
1) Processor is to check the Bank’s classified loan listing as of the most recent
month-end to determine if the borrower is on the classified list. If the
borrower is not on the list, the processor can continue with processing the
loan. If the borrower is on the classified list, continue on to Step 2;
3) The loan processor should verify that all terms of the additional loan or
modification of the existing loan match the terms that were presented in the
Loan Workout Plan Form that was approved by the Board of Directors. If all
terms do not match what was approved by the Board of Directors, the loan
processor is required to STOP processing the loan until the terms are
changed to match what was approved or the terms that are being submitted
to the loan processor are approved by the Board of Directors. In no
instance should any terms that were not approved by the Bank’s
Board of Directors be granted to a borrower. If all terms of the new
loan or loan modification match the terms approved by the Bank’s Board of
Directors, then the loan processor can continue with processing the loan.
31
APPENDIXES TO LOAN POLICY
I. GENERAL
The Bank's Risk Rating system is the cornerstone of its Allowance for Loan
Loss Reserve adequacy. In order to effectively quantify and analyze the risk
in the Bank's loan portfolio, it is important that the appropriate risk ratings
are assigned to each relationship within the portfolio based upon credit
characteristics and potential loss exposure. These criteria are established in
32
this policy. The designated Risk Ratings are used to identify measure and
monitor the risk associated with the loan portfolio.
II. PROCEDURES
All loans will be assigned a Risk Rating by the originating officer and
entered on to the loan systems at the time the loan is originated.
Ultimately, credit judgment and experience will be incorporated to assign a
final risk rating to commercial relationships.
The account officer has the primary responsibility for providing the first line
of defense against deteriorating credit quality and should continue to
monitor the credit during the life of the loan, making adjustments to the
Risk Rating as necessary. In addition, periodically the quality of the credit
and accuracy of the Risk Rating will be independently verified through the
loan review process. Normally any upgrade of a credit in the 1-5 rating
would occur at the time of renewal or annual review. Any downgrades are to
be addressed immediately.
33
loss basis, would be considered above average. This is due to “average”
financial condition but strong collateral coverage.
Risk Rating #8 - Doubtful - Strong potential for some loss with clear
inferior financial and collateral coverage conditions.
Risk Rating #9 - Loss - Highest risk of loss. Very weak in both financial
condition and collateral values. Any loan rated in this category would
likely be a loss at least to the extent that the total loan amount exceeds
the collectable value of collateral.
34
Appendix B - Credit Criteria
36
5. Financial Flexibility includes assessing the borrower’s access to other
sources of financing including the money and capital markets, non-bank
financial institutions (life insurance companies, commercial finance
companies, etc.). Borrowers that have three additional channels of
financing are generally strong companies. The ability to reduce or
eliminate capital expenditures in relationship to cash adequacy should
also be considered. Borrowers without a significant investment in fixed
assets relative to total assets generally exhibit more flexibility.
7. Other Relevant Factors include but are not limited to, (a) unstable
ownership, (b) collateral dependency (those situations when the borrower
may have to liquidate assets not in ordinary course of business) to repay
debt, (c) bankruptcy, (d) non-accrual status, and (e) asset/liquidation
values under the relative loan outstanding must also be considered in the
assignment of a risk classification.
37
Appendix C - Recommended Loan Terms and Collateral Margin
Requirements
Commercial Loans
Recommended
Recommended Percent of Maximum
Type of Loan Loan to Collateral Value Maturity
Unsecured or secured working
capital loan N/A 12 months
Not to exceed 80 %
(Depends on borrower and market ability
Equipment and other, includes and condition and age of collateral;
autos keeping bank in good equity position) 60 months
Not to exceed 60%
(Depends on borrower and marketability
and condition and age of collateral; Not to exceed 12
Inventory keeping bank in good equity position) months
Not to exceed 60%
(Generally accounts may not be past due
more than 90 days to be eligible for Not to exceed 12
Accounts receivable financing) months
Farm Loans
Recommended
Percent of Loan to Maximum
Type of Loan Collateral Value Maturity
100% of purchase price if borrower has
feed on hand; otherwise, we should
finance 80% of the purchase price plus
Livestock- feeders feeding costs Due at market
100% of slaughter price if borrower has
feed on hand; any amount exceeding
this should be specifically approved by
Livestock-breeding Loan Committee 2-5 years
Crops/operating loans for
expenses for growing crops 100% of actual spring costs 6-18 months
80% of dealer invoice on new; 80% of
Farm equipment selling price on used 3-7 years
Land 70% of appraised value 25 years*
To be paid when
Grain stored in bin on the farm 80% of current cash price marketed or 1 year
Recommended
LTV ( Loan advance as of % Maximum
Loan Category of appraised value) Maturity
38
Land Development (being
developed prior to the erection of
structures) 75% 2 years
Construction: Commercial, multi- 1 year**
family and nonresidential 80%
Construction: 1-4 family,
residential 80% 1 year**
Improved property (commercial,
farmland, and non-owner
occupied income producing
property) 80% 25 years
Owner-occupied 1-4 family 80% 25 years***
Raw land 65% 3 years
*Collateral for real estate loans should normally be that of a first lien. However, it should be recognized that in
certain cases, a subordinate lien may be appropriate and the use of such approved. In the case where a
subordinate lien is procured, this subordinate debt, along with all senior debt, should not exceed the loan to
value ratios designated by this chart
**Construction loans should not be made for more than 12 months unless the size of the project clearly
demonstrates a need for a longer construction period.
Consumer Lending
Home Equity
Real Estate** Consumer
Persona Overdra
l ft
Purchas Refinan Closed- Open- Automob Automob Unsecur Protecti
e ce end end ile (new) ile (used) ed on
Gross Debt/Income
% (payment
amount)* 28 28 38 38 38 38 38 38
Gross Debt/Income
%
(total debt)* 38 38 38 38 38 38 38 38
Length of
employment
FT or PT 6 mo. 6 mo. 6 mo. 6 mo. 6 mo. 6 mo. 6 mo. 6 mo.
LTV% 80% 80% 90% 90% 90% 90% N/A N/A
Minimum Credit 625 625 625 625 625 625 650 625
score
Minimum $ amount $5,000 $5,000 N/A $5,000 $3,000 N/A N/A $500
Maximum $ amount N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A $ 1,500
*When computing the income of the applicant consideration should be given to reliability of this income.
Bonus, self-employed, commission, part-time, cyclical, or similar income should generally be averaged over a
two-year period in order to be deemed reliable absent other circumstances.
39
Appendix D - Real Estate Lending Repayment Guidelines
I. Guidelines
41
The appraisal must:
3. Disclose the appraiser's opinion of Market Value (Fee Simple Value) based
upon the definition of Market Value set forth in the regulations.
4. Provide detail and depth of analysis that reflect the complexity of the real
estate, and be written and presented in a narrative format or on forms
that are sufficiently descriptive to reveal the estimated market value and
rationale for the estimate.
5. Report, and use as a basis for valuation, the area sales history for the last
year for 1-4 family transactions, or the last 3 years for all other types of
property.
II. GENERAL
III. APPRAISERS
A fee appraiser that is independent of the bank must complete all regulated
appraisals. If the only qualified person(s) available to perform an appraisal is
not independent of the bank, the bank must ensure the appraiser exercise
independent judgment by:
IV. ENGAGEMENT
All appraisers shall be engaged directly by the Bank and have no direct or
indirect interest, financial or otherwise, in the property or transaction. The
Bank cannot use an appraisal prepared by an individual who was selected or
engaged by the borrower. The Bank cannot use "readdressed appraisals",
which are appraisal reports that are altered by the appraiser to replace any
references to the original client with the Bank's name. The Bank may accept
an appraisal that was prepared by an appraiser engaged directly by another
institution, subject to title XI of FIRREA, if the regulated institution that
accepts the appraisal has:
V. SELECTION
The Bank will maintain a current list of all approved appraisers. Appraisers
must be approved in advance by the Board of Directors to be used for these
purposes.
A copy of the current approved appraiser list is kept with the Bank’s loan
processor.
VI. REVIEW
Bank lenders should become familiar with related federal regulatory agency
regulations. The objective of an appraisal report is to communicate an
44
appraiser's reasoning and conclusions in a reasonable manner so that the
reader is led to the appraiser's estimation of market value. The contents of
an appraisal report must conform to the accepted and established
professional standards of nationally recognized professional appraisal
organizations. The form, length and content of appraisal reports may vary,
depending on the type of property being appraised and the nature of the
appraisal assignment.
When an Environmental Risk Study is required on a subject property, it
should be completed prior to engaging an appraiser.
For transactions that are not subject to the minimum level or approved by
the appropriate parties, as exceptions to the appraisal policy, the Bank will
obtain an evaluation that is appropriate for the circumstances. The
evaluation need not meet all of the detailed requirements of an appraisal set
forth by policy or regulations; however, any evaluation must fully support the
estimated value of the collateral. Therefore, the greater the bank's risk, the
more detailed the evaluation should be.
The Bank may accept an appraisal for a loan request less than $100,001
from a non-approved appraiser and will not require the appraiser to be
approved as a single use exception. If this valuation method is used the
lender should complete the applicable appraisal checklist to ensure that
adequate valuation steps have been taken.
45
5) A real estate loan that is insured or guaranteed by an agency of the US
Government, provided that the transaction is supported by an
appraisal that conforms to appraisal rules or other written
requirements of the Federal agency providing the insurance or
guaranty.
4) The evaluation must be written, signed and dated, and include the
preparer's name and address.
For transactions requiring less detailed analysis, such as certain home equity
loans of less than $100,001, the evaluation may be based upon comparable
property sales information from a multiple listing service, current tax
assessed value, or a combination thereof provided by a widely recognized
and reliable property value estimator service.
APPRAISAL REVIEW
For each certified appraisal the Bank officer will review each appraisal to ensure
compliance with the Bank's appraisal policies and ensure appraisals are in
compliance with minimum appraisal standards in 12 C.F.R. 34 as well as Uniform
Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP). This review of the appraisal
will be made by an individual independent of the loan in question.
The officer must attest that the 14 minimum appraisal requirements have been met
prior to acceptance of the appraisal and payment for services. This review needs to
verify that the appraisal is complete and that the assumptions used in the appraisals
are reasonable and documented.
46
For land development projects where the loan amount exceeds $1 million and
commercial real estate loans where the loan amount exceeds $2 million, an
independent party must complete an additional Appraisal Review. Generally, the
Credit Department will conduct the secondary review but an experienced commercial
loan officer not associated with the credit will be allowed to be an alternate source of
review.
Sample appraisal checklist forms are included as part of this policy at Exhibit L for
residential appraisals, and at Exhibit M for commercial appraisals.
VALID APPRAISALS
The bank will have loans that mature with a balloon and will need to extend the
balloon loan for another length of time. When the loan is to be extended the bank
will review the old appraisal to determine the value of the property. The value of
the property can be affected by the period of time since the old appraisal, volatility
of the market, inventory of like properties in the area, condition and maintenance
of the property, rezoning of the property, and environmental factors. The bank will
evaluate the old value based upon these factors and document the file that the
value is sufficient or the value is determined to be greater than the old apprised
value. If the bank determines that the value has decreased, a new appraisal will
be ordered and analyzed prior to the loan being extended.
Sample State Bank will automatically provide a copy of the appraisal report to
applicants for credit secured by a lien on a residential structure containing a one-
to-four family home.
Appraisals will be accepted only from the listing of appraisers approved by the
Board of Directors.
Appraisals are not required for loans of $15,000 or less. Loan officer to determine
value by obtaining taxed assessed value and evaluation of local market.
Annually, the Bank’s Board of Directors will approve the list of appraisers to be
used by the Bank.
ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY
The purpose of the Environmental Policy is to establish safeguards and controls to
limit the Bank's exposure to potential environmental liability that can be
associated with real property held as collateral or acquired by the Bank. The Bank
recognizes that environmental contamination and the liability associated with that
contamination may negatively impact the value of real estate collateral and, in
instances where the bank is an owner or operator of contaminated property, the
Bank may incur significant direct liability. Further, the Bank recognizes that, in
addition to impairing the value of the collateral, the borrower's liability for
contamination may threaten the ability of the borrower to service the debt.
47
Procedures for Identifying and Evaluating Environmental Risk
In cases where the property offered as collateral may pose a higher degree of risk,
the Bank shall employ the following approach to analysis of environmental risk.
Step 4: After completing step three, the Bank may choose to conduct a
historical records review to determine, from public documents and, where
appropriate, historical aerial photographs, the former uses of the subject
property and adjacent properties.
Step 6: Where the amount of the loan is large and the Bank believes the
initial steps outlined above do not sufficiently guard against risk of potential
environmental liability, the Bank may require a Phase I environmental site
assessment as defined in the ASTM subcommittee Phase I Environmental
Assessment Standards. A loan is deemed large when it exceeds $500,000.
Step 7: Following review of the results of the Phase I Site Assessment, the
Bank may determine the potential risk to be sufficiently small to warrant the
making of the loan, the Bank may deem it necessary to turn down the loan
request or the offer of the property as collateral security, or the Bank may
conclude that a Phase U Site Assessment is appropriate.
DOCUMENTATION
Where the Bank has determined that a piece of real estate being taken as
collateral poses a potential environmental risk, or where the amount of the loan
is large, the Bank shall consider utilizing covenants in its loan documents which'
safeguard the Bank against potential environmental losses and liabilities.
Possible contractual clauses include:
49
Requirement that the borrower comply with environmental laws;
Requirement that the borrower disclose information about the environmental
status of the real property collateral;
Requirement that the borrower grant the institution the right to acquire
additional information about potential hazardous contamination by
inspecting the collateral for environmental concerns;
Provision which enables the Bank to call the loan, refuse to extend funds
under a line of credit, or foreclose if the hazardous contamination is
discovered in the real property collateral;
Provision which requires the borrower and/or guarantors to indemnify the
Bank for environmental liability associated with the real property collateral.
TRAINING
MONITORING
During the life of the loan, the Bank shall monitor the borrower and the real
property collateral for potential environmental concerns. The Bank should be
notified of any changes in the borrower's business which may result in a
significant increased risk of environmental liability and should exercise its rights
under the loan agreement to either call the loan, refuse to extend funds under a
line of credit, require the borrower to ameliorate the environmental problem or
cease the risky activity, or take such other steps as may be necessary to protect
the value of the real property and the interests of the bank.
The Bank is mindful of the fact that under CERCLA, the Bank can incur
environmental liability if it goes beyond the status of mere holder of a security
interest in real property and becomes an owner or operator of the property. The
Bank shall therefore exercise caution in its actions to guard against actions
which may be deemed to constitute "participating in the management" of the
business located on the real property collateral.
Further, the Bank understands that it may incur direct liability if it takes title to
real property held as collateral. Therefore, prior to acquiring ownership of real
property collateral either through foreclosure, deed in lieu of foreclosure, or
other similar means, the Bank will evaluate the potential for environmental
liability risk associated with the property or, if the degree of risk is determined
50
to be significant after an appropriate level of inquiry, the Bank shall abandon
the collateral.
The bank or any agent of the bank will not participate in facility management,
or take any action that would put the bank in the position of “owner operator”.
Any property subject to potential contamination shall be held only as a security
interest or the bank should acquire ownership only in the course of protecting a
security interest.
RESIDENTIAL LOANS
Review the comments and bank reservations made by the appraiser. If the
property has no evidence of existing or potential environmental hazards sufficient
to the soundness of the loan, and the loan officer has no knowledge of any no
further action is needed. If there is evidence of environmental hazards, then
proper action would be required to determine the risk and reported to loan
committee and or the Board of Directors for recommendation of further actions
needed.
EDR LOANCHECK
EDR (Environmental Data Resources Inc.) is the innovator of the largest and most
accurate database of environmental and historical land use information in the
world. With over 23 million records compiled from over 1,200 federal, state, local,
tribal and proprietary databases, EDR maintains the world's largest repository of
environmental information.
51
EDR provides data that is often utilized for the underlying information found in
Phase I environmental assessments.
An EDR Loancheck provides this underlying data in report format that can reveal
background information on a property and surrounding property within a 1/8 mile
radius. This can be used to assist in assessment of the possible environmental risk
associated with a property. The EDR Loancheck is not intended to replace a Phase
I assessment and should be utilized to assist in determining if additional
environmental investigation is necessary.
A. “Construction loans” are loans made for the purpose of building on vacant
land or construction additions to existing structures. Because the incomplete
structure and the land represent the security for the loan, funds are
disbursed in installments as work progresses. One of three methods, or
variants thereof, is used to ensure a lien free, and an adequately
collateralized loan throughout construction. A current site visit should be
documented for each disbursement in excess of $5,000 that also includes
52
the projects current percentage of completion and calculated current loan to
value. These three basic methods are:
B. Construction loans usually involve a higher degree of risk than other types of
loans. A high degree of expertise is necessary to assure that construction
results in a structure or structures that comply with plans and specifications.
Procedural controls must be sophisticated to the degree necessary to assure
that disbursements are made in such a way that precludes intervening liens
and which prevents misappropriation of relative loans-in-process balances.
A log of all expenses, loan advances and lien waivers is required for each
project.
54
Exhibit A - Loan Approval System and Committee
Responsibility
A. LOAN OFFICER AUTHORITIES
Each individual loan officer has the authority to grant unsecured and secured
credit loans within their authorized limit as listed below:
Comments:
55
A. The Loan Officer Committee (also known as the Loan Committee)
consists of the President, all loan officers and head of loan processing
department.,
B. The Loan Officer Committee meetings will be held on an as-needed
basis but, at a minimum, monthly.
D. Approval Functions:
56
3. Reviews and approves all actions requiring Board approval prior to
their submission to the Board.
A. Approval Functions
6. Review and approval of all new loans made the previous month.
57