Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
To cite this article: Maria de Fátima de Campos Françozo & Roosevelt Moisés Smeke Cassorla
(2004) REWARDS AND FRUSTRATIONS OF BEING A SOCIAL WORKER: A QUALITATIVE
STUDY, Journal of Social Work Practice, 18:2, 211-221, DOI: 10.1080/0265053042000231025
This paper deals with aspects of actual professional experience of social workers, in order
to grasp a framework for professional rewards and frustrations. A qualitative research
tool was chosen, life histories, and ten social workers were interviewed. The subjects were
women who graduated between the 1950s and the 1990s from schools of social work in
Brazil, and whose practice, present or past, involves direct contact with clients. The
reasons explaining satisfying professional situations are rooted in professional experiences
which were translated into personal development, the establishment of personal ties and
the acquisition of skills. Perceptions of having contributed towards solving a difficult
situation and recognition from their clients were positively appraised. These are
rewarding situations from which social workers derive the feeling of having created
something which is positive for the clients and for themselves. Unpleasant situations were
described as unfair situations experienced by clients, poor working conditions and
difficulties concerning inter-professional relationships. Inferences on the feminine role as
influencing social workers’ rewards and frustrations with the profession, as well as
inferences on possible unconscious configurations underlying some of the data were drawn
in the conclusions.
Keywords social workers; professional rewards and frustrations
Introduction
Social workers in Brazil are hired to deal with trying aspects of clients’ lives in a
very broad range of situations: from poverty and illness to unemployment and lack
of education; from domestic violence to homelessness. The fragility of the country’s
social policies, however, significantly interferes with the efforts of social workers. In
this sense, social workers’ desire to help people is not always easily accomplished. In
addition, social workers claim that the profession is seldom well recognized as far as
salaries, fringe benefits and social status are concerned. We may thus wonder how
social workers deal with such a limiting reality. It seems that such situations are very
frustrating. How do social workers fulfill their desires and goals under such
circumstances? What keeps social workers in the profession?
To answer such questions one has to look into the real lives of social workers,
Journal of Social Work Practice Vol. 18, No. 2, July 2004, pp. 211–221
ISSN 0265-0533 print/ISSN 1465-3885 online # 2004 GAPS
http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals DOI: 10.1080/0265053042000231025
212 JOURNAL OF SOCIAL WORK PRACTICE
searching for subjective experiences common to the professional group that may be
the reasons for remaining in the profession. In this sense, our study aimed at
describing, in terms of social workers’ own views, the significance of their
professional experience.
A question similar to ours was raised by Vincent (1996), who investigated the
unconscious motivation related to choosing social work as a profession. She focused
on ‘compulsive care-giving’ and ‘parentification’, as well as early parenting experiences,
and discussed possible implications of these in relation to professional choice. Csikai
and Rozensky (1997) studied ‘social work idealism’ and factors influencing career
choice among beginning BSW and MSW students. They found that idealism ran high
among all students, and altruistic reasons were reported as more important than
professional reasons in career choice. Reynolds (1963) describes her journey as a
social worker, discussing the close interchange between personal and professional
experience. The questions raised by the authors above, as well as Salzberger-
Wittenberg’s (1970) views on psychoanalytic theory and social work, encouraged us
to listen to social workers’ stories on their professional journey, searching for their
reasons to remain in the profession. First, however, it is important to draw an
overview of the context of social work in Brazil.
In Brazil, the emergence of social work is associated with the appearance of the
‘social issue’, understood as the expression of the relation between capital and labor.
At the beginning of the nineteenth century, the State, the Church and dominant
sectors in society were forced to take a position concerning the clash between the
increasing number of urban proletarians and entrepreneurs (Iamamoto & Carvalho,
1982).
The Catholic Church, as a way of expanding its social doctrine, mobilized the lay
apostleship to work with the proletariat, stimulating philanthropy initiatives.
Associations for Catholic young women were organized, aimed at finding agents for
the Church’s social action. Courses focusing on the education of young women
originated the profession of social worker in 1936. It is important to notice that,
since its birth, the profession has borne a feminine mark, carrying with it the
stereotypes of the so-called feminine professions: the idea that this kind of work
is transitory, discontinuous — due to motherhood and childcare — and
complementary to men’s work. It was associated with care providing and teaching
activities which were seen as an extension of those carried out at home; therefore,
they could be better developed by women in view of their ‘natural’ skills. Due to
those characteristics, women should not assume command posts, but service posts
(Safiotti, 1979).
Faced with the social issue, the State began to interfere in the relations between
entrepreneurs and the working class, searching for legal regulation of the labor
market and for the management of social services organization and rendering
(Iamamoto & Carvalho, 1982). It expanded its social agencies network, which
absorbed many of the first social workers that graduated in the 1940s, hiring them to
execute the social policies. It centralized and rationalized social work and the
REWARDS AND FRUSTRATIONS OF BEING A SOCIAL WORKER 213
Methodology
The aim of the study was to investigate what Brazilian social workers think and feel
about their professional activity. A qualitative investigation, using life histories as a
tool to collect data, was carried out. We asked social workers to give us an account
of their professional experience, from the moment they chose to be a social worker
to their current job. There was a list of topics to help the interviewer fill any gap left
in the subject’s narrative.
We tried to create a pleasing atmosphere during the interviews, so that the
subjects could talk freely about facts, memories and feelings of their professional
experiences. The order of events and the chronology of facts were not rigorously
controlled. The subject should tell the events according to the associations she
established. Life histories become close to psychoanalytic free associations when
chronology is left aside, opening the possibility for the researcher to go deeper inside
the interviewee’s mind (Bosi, 1979).
The subjects were ten social workers who worked directly with the population
in public or private organizations, in a broad range of fields. We selected those who
had graduated in different decades (from the 1950s to the 1990s), since during this
period three different curriculums were implemented in the schools of social work.
Only women social workers were chosen because they comprise the vast majority of
professionals.
214 JOURNAL OF SOCIAL WORK PRACTICE
Results
The social workers’ accounts of their professional lives were rich and complex, as
they cope with factors related to professional choice, to insertion in the labor
market, to labor crises and successes, to personal, family, institutional and political
aspects — all of them were interconnected in a way that was peculiar to each
interviewee, but revealed aspects that were common to all. In this study we will
present only what we call the ‘rewards and frustrations’ of being a social worker.
I learned a lot with the clients, their problems taught me a lot (…) I graduated
from college at the age of 21 and at that age you just start to understand the
world, the way people live.
In addition, since different feelings are present in human relationships, they give
the professional an opportunity to deal with them and, sometimes, to modify them,
as shown in the example below:
Contact with the population was greatly valued, as well as the population’s
approval of the social worker’s job. The population was frequently mentioned in a
positive way by the social workers, who valued the opinion that the clients have of
their work and attitude:
REWARDS AND FRUSTRATIONS OF BEING A SOCIAL WORKER 215
I was very struck by two situations. The first one was when a client came to me
and said: you are on our side. So, when he feels I’m on his side, it’s very
important. The second one happened when an employee asked why I fight so
much for the population’s rights. It’s stimulating when people recognize which
side you are on, because they also see that my work with the people is not
founded on pity, but on their rights.
Sometimes, fighting for the people’s rights may bring the professional into conflict
with the status quo. Even so, the social worker seems to feel rewarded for acting as
an adequate mediator, usually speaking on behalf of the client in situations of conflict
or difficulty.
Human contacts, the possibility of meeting new people, making new friends
were valued:
I made good friends, I have friends that now live abroad and send me Christmas
cards. It was worth working as a social worker.
The acquisition of skills in dealing with the public was viewed as a form of
personal development:
Facing new and challenging situations may cause fear, but at the same time it is a
stimulus to remain in the profession, as it brings growth to the professional and gives
a dynamic aspect to her daily routine:
This is not a boring job. No day is like the other, I’ve never heard anyone
saying: nothing happened today! There’s always something happening.
The government created the program for teenagers. It was a very small
program. But we worked with the community and today (the program was
extended due to the pressure of the community) the program’s coordinators are
the teens of yesterday. So, you can always give a personal touch.
Sometimes you don’t have direct contact with the client, but, if you know there
is someone who will be helped, then you feel your fight is worthwhile. That is
what makes social workers go ahead — knowing there’s someone out there who
will benefit from what you’re doing.
216 JOURNAL OF SOCIAL WORK PRACTICE
The fragments above perhaps summarize the social worker’s ideal: to help
someone, even if she does not know this person.
In addition to rewarding situations, however, there are frustrating ones. They
can be grouped into unfair situations experienced by the population, unfavorable
working conditions and problems concerning inter-professional relationships.
Rewarding and frustrating situations co-exist, and sometimes the predominance of
one of them can mask the other.
This kind of situation relates to how social workers or other professionals understand
and perform the objectives of their work, how they see the service user. And how the
agencies see the community and the service provided — as ‘a favour’, not a right.
The social workers also questioned the way they attend to the community. This
derives from difficulties referring to material resources, but, sometimes, personal
difficulties also interfere, such as insecurity about being helpful or fear of being
invasive:
I was very disappointed: you don’t earn a good salary, and you must think about
the salary too — I’m not a philanthropic person. If you develop a good work,
you must be well paid; you must have good working conditions.
Associating bad salaries with philanthropy is not fortuitous, for, as we have seen,
the profession originated in charity towards the poor.
One of the social workers explained the reasons why she keeps the job in spite
of the bad conditions:
REWARDS AND FRUSTRATIONS OF BEING A SOCIAL WORKER 217
If you talk to the professionals, you can’t understand why they’re here. The
salary is low, there are political problems. Some of them are young, committed
to the profession and politically engaged — and still, they are here. It’s karmic!
It’s the only explanation: it’s karmic! Or you get the bug.
The speech fragment above suggests that some social workers feel frustrated due
to the bad working conditions, but seem to feel rewarded for their involvement with
the population and for their political engagement, which suggests a healthy rebellion
against the status quo, mixed with situations of personal sacrifice. It would be necessary
to investigate to what extent many of these professionals work moved by guilt and
maniac reparation, and which professionals are performing actual reparations.
Some social workers revealed dissatisfaction at political interference in their
professional action:
We were able to humanize that place. But I saw it being destroyed. When
things there started to come out right, outsiders started to come and interfere.
The state governor put one of his relatives as the agency coordinator. He didn’t
have any experience and the things we had built deteriorated.
Finally, some social workers take the situation personally, considering themselves
responsible not for political interferences, but for the consequences they bring to service
rendering. In the account below, the social worker warns her colleagues of this problem.
I say to my colleagues: don’t feel suffocated, don’t blame yourself for something
that is not your fault. You did what was possible, what you could do.
This interviewee told us that social workers tend to feel responsible when they
are unable to find solutions for users’ problems. What is viable is seldom taken as a
good reason to soothe the professional. At the same time, the difficulties seem to
attract professionals:
I think that, to be a social worker, you must wish to deal with the impossible.
I see challenges in the profession; I think that we like challenging situations.
What frustrates me is team work, because people are different, have different
knowledge and experiences. They could help one another, but the interchange
of experiences doesn’t happen. There is insecurity — if I’m doing something
different, my colleague gets worried because I may be better than her.
218 JOURNAL OF SOCIAL WORK PRACTICE
The atmosphere is hostile, there is a lot of struggle, so if it’s not alright, if you
don’t like my temperament, there is no ethics. I may disagree with your
opinion, but I should respect it. But this doesn’t happen, it’s an emotional
instability (…) suddenly you become a threat, a nuisance.
This social worker talked about the difficulties in promoting an objective relationship
with her colleagues, without arousing anxieties and feelings of persecution.
Other interviews also revealed aspects of the problems in inter-professional
relationships, such as self-devaluation, competition and envy:
It’s complicated, because I don’t know what happens with our professionals that
they think that whoever is close to you isn’t good. Those who come from
outside are better. They don’t take the opportunities that appear. You know,
they miss the train and cry afterwards.
Discussion
The method used provided complex, interconnected data on each social worker’s
perception of her work and its effect on her personal life. Deep investigation of each
individual situation would only be possible if we reported each interview
completely, but, in doing so, we would be carrying out case studies. Although it
loses track of individual dynamics, partitioning the whole data set into categories
allows us to notice factors that are common to the interviewees.
One way to understand many of the feelings of frustration and reward in the
data is by seeing them in the context of feminine work, that is, by relating them to
the situation of women’s work in Brazil.
For instance, low salaries, as well as lack of professional recognition can be
related to the devaluation of the so-called feminine professions. Feminine work is
viewed as subsidiary, and a woman’s salary is considered to be complementary in the
couple’s earnings. These ideas, together with that of lower qualification of the
feminine workforce, favour salaries that are not as high as men’s, and are responsible
for the fact that women perform those functions that receive the lowest pay (Safiotti,
1979). Despite conquering new spaces, women are still discriminated against, have
more difficulty in assuming leading positions and earn less than their male colleagues
in all professions, even those in which women’s participation is higher (Bruschini,
1994), as is the case with social work.
Social workers are frustrated when their work is not recognized by the
institution — either because it does not pay them well, or because it interferes in
their activities and does not provide growth opportunities, or even because it
considers their work as secondary (a professional says: ‘you’re good to carry the
piano, but when it’s time to plan things together, they don’t call you’).
REWARDS AND FRUSTRATIONS OF BEING A SOCIAL WORKER 219
Conclusion
It is important to emphasize that the feminine question is one of the strings that ties
the different aspects of the social worker’s professional experience, conditioning the
different situations viewed both as frustrating and rewarding.
The interviewees mentioned the huge difficulties that they face in the profession,
such as lack of social recognition, low salaries and the fragility of social policies,
which influence the daily working routine. The frustrating aspects are related to
social injustice, bad working conditions and problems concerning inter-professional
relationships. That is, situations in which they are prevented from accomplishing
something, from solving a problematic situation, from contributing to bringing about
some positive change for someone else.
When we examined the rewards of social workers’ professional experiences, we
were impressed by the countless ways in which they describe situations that
influence their own lives. Inspired by ideals of justice, citizenship and solidarity, they
get involved in dynamic and instigating situations, seeing themselves as helping to
solve them. The pleasant aspects of the profession are described by the subjects as
situations from which they get the feeling of having created something positive for
the clients and for themselves. When they recognize that they can create good things
for themselves, the social workers feel that these life aspects are predominant in
their inner world.
Finally, the data showed that, in the population studied, with some exceptions,
the subjects are generally conscious of the good and bad aspects of the profession,
which seems to reveal a good capacity for integration.
References
Bion, W. R. (1961) Experiences in Groups and Other Papers, Tavistock, London.
Bosi, E. (1979) Memória e sociedade: lembranças de velhos, T.A.Queiroz, São Paulo.
REWARDS AND FRUSTRATIONS OF BEING A SOCIAL WORKER 221