Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41561-018-0209-2
Subduction zones are unique to Earth and fundamental in its evolution, yet we still know little about the causes and mechanisms
of their initiation. Numerical models show that far-field forcing may cause subduction initiation at weak pre-existing structures,
while inferences from modern subduction zones suggest initiation through spontaneous lithospheric gravitational collapse. For
both endmembers, the timing of subduction inception corresponds with initial lower plate burial, whereas coeval or delayed
extension in the upper plate are diagnostic of spontaneous or forced subduction initiation, respectively. In modern systems, the
earliest extension-related upper plate rocks are found in forearcs, but lower plate rocks that recorded initial burial have been
subducted and are inaccessible. Here, we investigate a fossil system, the archetypal Semail Ophiolite of Oman, which exposes
both lower and upper plate relics of incipient subduction stages. We show with Lu–Hf and U–Pb geochronology of the lower and
upper plate material that initial burial of the lower plate occurred before 104 million years ago, predating upper plate extension
and the formation of Semail oceanic crust by at least 8 Myr. Such a time lag reveals far-field forced subduction initiation and
provides unequivocal, direct evidence for a subduction initiation mechanism in the geological record.
T
he sinking of cold lithosphere in the Earth’s mantle along sub- spontaneous in this system7,8,11. Accordingly, the causes and conse-
duction zones is widely recognized as the main driving force quences of subduction initiation are sought for in the tectonic set-
for global plate tectonics1. Despite decades of research, the ting at the time of forearc extension12. To date, the early subduction
processes and mechanisms of subduction initiation remain contro- initiation history remains elusive2, and ISI may have begun millions
versial2. Two main conceptual end-member mechanisms consid- of years before forearc extension.
ered are ‘induced’ and ‘spontaneous’ subduction initiation2,3 (Fig. 1). Research on supra-subduction zone (SSZ) ophiolites and asso-
Induced subduction initiation (ISI) requires a period of forced con- ciated metamorphic soles may yield more comprehensive insights
vergence, presumably accommodated at a pre-existing favourably into subduction initiation, because these provide a rock record of
orientated weak structure, until subduction eventually becomes both upper plate extension and lower plate burial2, respectively. SSZ
self-sustained4–6. Alternatively, gravitational instability across oce- ophiolites13,14 are interpreted as relic forearc oceanic lithosphere—
anic transform faults or passive continental margins has been pro- similar in composition to the Izu–Bonin–Marianna forearc—that
posed to trigger lithospheric collapse and spontaneous subduction formed during subduction initiation7–9 and was subsequently
initiation (SSI) without net plate convergence3,7. Whether only one uplifted above sea level15. Many SSZ ophiolites rest on thin (<500 m)
of ISI or SSI is the active subduction initiation mode on Earth, or sheets of metamorphosed oceanic crust termed metamorphic soles.
both modes can be activated depending on the tectonic setting, is These metamorphic soles derive from the uppermost crust of the
a matter of debate2,3. A fundamental criterion that would discern subducting lower plate16–19 that was preserved from further subduc-
between ISI and SSI is the time lag between initial lower plate burial tion by ‘welding’ to the mantle section of the upper plate during
and the ensuing upper plate extension (Fig. 1). During SSI, the area subduction zone infancy20,21. Garnet–clinopyroxene amphibolites
consumed by subduction must simultaneously be balanced by area found at the top of many metamorphic soles indicate high-pressure
gained through upper plate extension7,8. In contrast, upper plate granulite facies22,23 peak metamorphic conditions (11–13 kbar and
extension following ISI must be generated by the growing slab after 850 °C). Metamorphism of oceanic crust to such conditions requires
a period of forced underthrusting4,5,9, resulting in a time lag of sev- subduction along an anomalously hot geothermal gradient that is
eral millions of years. Constraining the magnitude of this time lag restricted to the initiation stage of a subduction zone20,21,24. These
requires specific geochronological methods applied to a rock record amphibolites probably represent the leading edge of the nascent slab
of both the formation of the incipient subduction thrust and the and may therefore have directly recorded the initial burial of the
onset of upper plate extension. lower plate during nucleation of a subduction interface18,20,21.
Models for subduction initiation are based on studies of earli- The age of extension and crustal accretion in ophiolites is
est extension and magmatism in the forearc of modern subduc- commonly estimated using U–Pb dating of zircon from gabbros
tions such as the Izu–Bonin–Marianna system7,10, where rocks and plagiogranites, interpreted to have formed in magma cham-
that directly recorded formation of the subduction interface are bers below a spreading ridge25,26. Dating of the earliest history
not exposed. Subduction initiation is widely assumed to have been of the subduction interface requires an estimation of the age of
1
E4m, Département de Géologie et de Génie Géologique, Université Laval, Québec, Québec, Canada. 2PCIGR, Department of Earth, Ocean and
Atmospheric Sciences, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. 3Department of Earth Sciences, Utrecht University, Utrecht,
the Netherlands. 4Department of Geosciences and CEED, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway. 5Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of
Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada. 6School of Geography, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, United Kingdom.
7
LabMaTer, Département de Génie Géologique, Université du Québec à Chicoutimi, Chicoutimi, Québec, Canada. *e-mail: carl.guilmette@ggl.ulaval.ca
Favourably orientated
Lithosphere in the overlying ophiolite constrains a minimum time lag between
weak zone
Crust initial subducting plate burial and incipient upper plate extension.
SSZ crust
Metamorphic
sole
The Semail Ophiolite. The Semail Ophiolite (Fig. 2a) exposes over
20,000 km2 of oceanic crust and upper mantle rocks underlain by a
Spontaneous Induced discontinuous thin sheet of metamorphic sole. The ophiolite–sole
couple is thought to have been emplaced in Late Cretaceous time as
a giant thrust sheet36 over the Hawasina complex comprising distal
oceanic rocks, and carbonates of the Arabian passive margin37. The
Spreading Retreating Semail Ophiolite exposes a section of oceanic lithosphere includ-
(proto-forearc) hinge Metamorphic Forced ing residual upper mantle rocks made of harzburgite and dunite,
sole
(lower plate)
convergence plutonic lower and middle crust comprising cumulates and gabbros,
and an upper crustal sheeted dyke complex underlying pillowed to
Spreading Retreating massive submarine basalts and abyssal sediments38 (Fig. 2). High-
Metamorphic
(proto-forearc) hinge precision U–Pb dating of the plutonic section across the ophiolite
sole Sinking showed that the oceanic crust of the ophiolite was generated during
(lower plate) rapid spreading between 96.1–95.5 million years ago (Ma)25,26.
The ophiolite has been classically interpreted as a relic fast-
Metamorphic spreading mid-ocean ridge38,39. However, recent evidence clearly
sole shows that the ophiolite formed above an active subduction
(upper plate)
Sinking zone29,40,41. Similarities in the chemostratigraphy of the Semail
Ophiolite and the Philippine Sea Plate forearc strengthened the
inference that the ophiolite formed during subduction initiation2,13
Δtsole – forearc = 0 Δtsole – forearc > 0 (either spontaneous3,8,42 or induced43,44).
The sole of the Semail Ophiolite comprises amphibolites that are
Forearc notably garnet- and clinopyroxene-bearing near the contact with
Arc volcano
(ophiolite) mantle rocks. Garnet–clinopyroxene sole amphibolites represent
oceanic upper crustal mid-ocean ridge basalt (MORB)-like basaltic
sequences40 of unknown age, which were metamorphosed to peak
Metamorphic conditions of 11–13 kbar and 850 °C21,45,46. U–Pb dating of zircon
sole from melt segregations suggests solidification of the melt fraction
(upper plate) Steady-state
subduction by 96.16–94.5 Ma26,29,30, followed by rapid cooling below the closure
temperature of the 40Ar/39Ar system in hornblende (500–550 °C)
Fig. 1 | Conceptual lithospheric sections representing SSI versus ISI. between 95.7 and 92.6 Ma28. The available data support the hypoth-
The time lag between initial lower plate burial and incipient upper plate esis that the upper crustal protolith of the sole was subducted to
extension is diagnostic of the subduction initiation mode. mantle depths in excess of 35 km along an incipient hot subduction
plane before being transferred to the upper plate20,21.
This study focuses on two main Omani metamorphic sole
prograde metamorphism in the garnet–clinopyroxene amphibolites localities: Wadi Tayin and Wadi Sumeini (Fig. 2). The Wadi Tayin
of metamorphic soles. Previous chronological studies of soles used locality21,45 (Fig. 2b) exposes amphibolites interlayered with thin
40
Ar/39Ar hornblende or mica dating9,18,20,27,28 and, more recently, quartz- and calc-silicate-rich layers, overlain by a middle quartz-
U–Pb dating of zircons from melt segregations29,30. These ages typi- ite-dominated interval, and again an amphibolite layer with gar-
cally coincide or slightly post-date the ages of the magmatic crust of net- and clinopyroxene-bearing amphibolites present in the top
the overlying ophiolite9,18,28. Coinciding 40Ar/39Ar and U–Pb dates 5 m (Fig. 2e). The Sumeini sole locality45,46 (Fig. 2c) also exposes
from sole rocks, and age data for ophiolitic crustal spreading have amphibolites, which become garnet- and clinopyroxene-bearing
been taken to provide evidence for synchronous sole formation and in the upper 10 m (Fig. 2d), whereas the lower section of the sole
upper plate spreading28,29. The meaning of this coincidence in terms consists of epidote amphibolite with more abundant quartzite and
of sole formation is nevertheless debated9. Both methods date post- marble. We collected samples WT-150 and WT-151 from the Wadi
peak conditions rather than burial31, and thus underestimate the age Tayin locality and SU-03A from the Sumeini sole locality (Fig. 2b–e)
of sole formation by a yet-unknown amount of time. from garnet- and clinopyroxene-bearing amphibolites that occur
It is clear that rigorously constraining the chronology of sub- as metre-scale coherent levels (Fig. 2d) or as boudins embedded
duction initiation requires new approaches in dating the earliest in garnet-free amphibolite (Fig. 2e) immediately below the contact
metamorphic minerals in soles. A promising technique is Lu–Hf with the overlying mantle section.
dating of garnet—a petrological indicator of burial and heating
in metamorphosed oceanic rocks. Owing to the robustness of the Occurrence, composition and age of garnet, zircon and titanite.
chronometer at high temperatures (900–950 °C)32–34, prograde age The samples show a hornblende-dominated nematoblastic fabric
records of garnet growth are typically well preserved even in cases of that wraps around boudinaged bands of garnet–clinopyroxene-rich
long-lived supra-solidus conditions35. Here, we apply this approach granulite (Fig. 3a–c). Garnet occurs as subhedral centimetre-scale
to garnet from the metamorphic sole of the archetypal Semail porphyroblasts with abundant inclusions (Fig. 3). Mineral composi-
Ophiolite of Oman to date the early stages of sole development. tions are consistent with those of similar samples used in previous
The results, supported by textural observations and trace element petrological studies21,45,46 and with high-pressure granulite facies
mineral chemistry, are then combined with new U–Pb zircon and metamorphic conditions22,23. The strongly foliated matrix is defined
titanite data, and existing dates for the sole and overlying ophiolitic by subhedral hornblende and subordinate anhedral diopside with
crust, to investigate the complete history of the sole, from burial abundant pseudomorphed anhedral plagioclase and fine-grained
and heating to exhumation and cooling. The comparison of garnet ilmenite–titanite symplectites. The granulite assemblage is variably
growth ages in the metamorphic sole and published extension ages overprinted by dynamic amphibolite–facies metamorphism. Sample
Sem
Sheeted dykes sediments
Longitude
UAE Amphibolite
a
Saudi UAE 23° 03′45′′
il Th
Kharz
Arabia Plutonic
Oman Kharz Quartzite
rus t
crust Mantle
25° 00′ Ksqz harzburgite
N WT-151
WT-150 0 0.25 0.5
Mhhc Distance (km)
Sumeini Mantle 23° 03′15′′ 58° 36′00′′ 23° 03′30′′
harzburgite
Latitude
Sole Se
Gulf of ma
il T
24° 00′ Oman 24° 42′ hr
us SU-03A
t
Muscat
Oman Q
Ksgs Mantle
Amphi-
Longitude
harzburgite
Mhhc bolite
Wadi 24° 41′ Green-
N Tayin schist
Ksa
23° 00′ Hawasina–
0 20 40 Haybi
Distance (km) complexes
d e Garnet–
Peridotite clinopyroxene
amphibolite
Garnet–clinopyroxene Peridotite
amphibolite
Amphibolite
Amphibolite
Peridotite
Fig. 2 | Geological maps, sample locations and field relationships. a, Geological map of Oman. b,c, Geological maps and sample locations at Wadi Tayin
(b) and Sumeini (c). d,e, Field relationships for samples SU-03 (d) and WT-151 (e). Scale bar on the peridotite outcrop of e, 10 cm. Panels a–c adapted
from ref. 29, Elsevier. Red stars are sampling sites. Kharz, Cretaceous harzburgite; Ksqz, Cretaceous sole – quartzite; Ksa, Cretaceous sole – amphibolite; Ksgs,
Cretaceous sole – greenschist; Q, Quaternary; Mhhc, Hawasina and Haybi complexes.
SU-03A best preserves the granulite assemblage, whereas sample negative shapes and very low dihedral angles (Figs. 3f,g), suggest-
WT-150 shows the strongest amphibolite overprint. A lower-grade ing that they represent the solidification product of trapped melt.
assemblage with epidote, prehnite and albite is found in fractures Grt-1a shows distinctly lower chondrite-normalized gadolinium/
and veins, and as pseudomorphic replacements of plagioclase; the ytterbium (GdN/YbN) than grt-1b. Grt-2 is defined by a textural and
mafic minerals of the granulite assemblages are not substantially compositional mantle that encloses anhedral grt-1 cores. Grt-2 has
affected by such replacement. fewer inclusions, is magnesium-rich and calcium-poor relative to
Garnet shows complex zoning and inclusion patterns that dif- grt-1, has high GdN/YbN, and shows strong and locally very well-
fer between samples. Two garnet zones (grt-1 and grt-2) are nev- defined oscillatory zoning for HREE (Fig. 4).
ertheless consistently observed. Grt-1 is defined by anhedral cores All three samples yielded garnet–whole rock Lu–Hf isochrons
that are generally richer in calcium, manganese and heavy rare (Fig. 5a–c) with mean square weighted deviation (MSWD)
earth elements (HREE) (Figs. 3 and 4). These cores are typically between 0.32 and 0.79, and uncertainties of 0.8% relative standard
poikiloblastic with inclusions of titanite and apatite in the inner- deviation or better. The samples from Wadi Tayin yielded ages of
most domains (grt-1a) and mono- and polymineralic inclusions of 104.1 ± 1.1 Ma (MSWD = 0.79; sample 150A) and 103.2 ± 1.2 Ma
diopside, hornblende, plagioclase, ilmenite, titanite and apatite in (MSWD = 0.32; sample 151A), and sample SU-03A from Sumeini
the outer domains (grt-1b). Polymineralic inclusions locally show yielded an age of 103.5 ± 1.6 Ma (MSWD = 0.62). All Lu–Hf age data
h
a Garnet d 2 mm 50
Fig. 3d Diopside Alm
A′ Hornblende
Titanite + Ilmenite 10
Mn Ti Fe P Symplectite Sp
0
e 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500
Mn Ti Fe P 5 mm A Distance across profile (µm) A′
i
b 50 Alm
Ilmenite
Fig. 4c B′ 10
f Sp
0
0
0
00
50
00
50
00
50
50
10 mm
Mn Ti Fe P B
1,
1,
2,
2,
3,
3,
B Distance across profile (µm) B′
c j
50 Alm
200 µm
30
at
Gr
Ap
500
467
Plagioclase 434
Py
C′ 400 20
367
334
C 300
x
Cp
10
Ilm
267
Fig. 4e T 234
Sp
en
200
ite
167
134
100 0
5 mm Mn Ti Fe P Titanite Garnet
67
34 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500
0
C Distance across profile (µm) C′
Fig. 3 | Petrography of the investigated samples. a–c, Micro-X-ray fluorescence chemical maps of thin sections for the samples SU-03A (a), WT-150
(b) and WT-151 (c). d, Magnified view of the solid boxed area in a. e, Magnified view of the solid boxed area in c. f,g, Back-scatter detector image (f)
and composite Ca map +schematic (g) of a melt pseudomorph inclusion in garnet from SU-03A. The colour scale in garnet in g represents Ca relative
abundance. h–j, Electron probe microanalyser chemical profiles for the samples SU-03A (h), WT-150 (i) and WT-151 (j), showing almandine (Alm),
grossular (Gr), pyrope (Py) and spessartine (Sp) mole fractions and Mg# = Mg2+/(Mg2+ + Fe2+). The locations of the A–A′, B–B′and C–C′profiles in h–j are
indicated by dashed lines in a–c, respectively. Plag., plagioclase; Cpx, clinopyroxene.
are identical within uncertainty. Taking a weighted mean of these indicated by its oscillatory zoning. This zoning is interpreted to
ages yielded 103.7 ± 0.7 Ma (MSWD = 0.63), indicating no resolv- reflect the competition between the rates of HREE uptake by grow-
able age scatter among the samples. ing garnet and diffusive HREE supply within the melt. Such a garnet
Zircon and titanite grains were recovered from sample WT-151. growth sequence is consistent with phase equilibria modelling and
The zircon population consists largely of colourless, subequant and experiments for MORB-like protoliths that predict supra-solidus
anhedral grains (Fig. 5d). Five analyses of such grains are clustered grt-2 growth21,23 from 9 kbar and 650 °C to 11 kbar and 850 °C across
to the right of the concordia curve. The slight discordance and the titanite–ilmenite transition48.
spread in 207Pb/235U is a common feature of young zircon popula- The robustness of the Lu–Hf geochronometer33,34 is largely gov-
tions, reflecting in part the probable bias in the decay constants used erned by the low diffusivity of hafnium49. The closure tempera-
and initial 231Pa excess47. All five 206Pb/238U ages overlap within error, tures of diffusive hafnium loss for the grains analysed were at least
yielding a robust average age of 96.19 ± 0.14 Ma for the crystalliza- 900 °C33 and hence exceed peak temperatures that the Omani sole
tion of zircon. A fraction of four titanite grains provides a 206Pb/238U samples were subjected to. Lutetium is more mobile, and modelled
age of 95.60 ± 0.27 Ma. mechanisms of age skewing by diffusive lutetium redistribution49
must be considered. However, these are clearly not applicable here.
Garnet growth in the Omani Ophiolite soles. The microtextures The dated samples show exceptional preservation of the fine growth
and major and trace element distributions described above indicate zoning in the distributions of lutetium, which precludes any sig-
the following growth history (Fig. 6). Grt-1 nucleated and initially nificant diffusive homogenization of lutetium after garnet growth.
grew at sub-solidus conditions in the titanite stability field. The The dates, which were determined for bulk-grain garnet popula-
transition from grt-1a to grt-1b marks the prograde stabilization tions, therefore represent an estimate of the average age of garnet
of ilmenite and the formation of inclusions indicative of the first growth weighted according to lutetium distribution. The Lu–Hf
occurrence of melt. Peritectic garnet growth at those conditions is dates for all three samples are identical, yet show different lutetium
further supported by evidence of melt segregations at the outcrop distributions. This shows that the weighing of ages was insignifi-
scale29,30 and by phase equilibria modelling21,23. The distinct increase cant. Our data are thus best explained by a single, fast garnet growth
in GdN/YbN could relate to the dehydration melting of horn- event at sub- to supra-solidus conditions from roughly 550 °C and
blende or titanite breakdown. Grt-2 represents peritectic garnet, as 8 kbar to peak conditions of 850 °C and 11–13 kbar (Fig. 6). Zircon
Garnet/chondrite
Grt-2 3 10
Spot 1
Lu (ppm)
Grt-1b 2 1
Ilmenite
Titanite
1 0.1
Spot 27
0.01
0
e
La
o
Tb
Yb
Sm
Tm
Eu
Lu
y
Pr
Er
d
d
C
H
D
N
G
c d
1,000
15
1 mm
100
12
Spot 29
Garnet/chondrite
10
Lu (ppm)
9
6
1
Spot 1
3
0.1
0
0.01
o
La
Tb
Yb
Sm
Tm
Eu
Lu
y
e
Pr
Er
d
d
C
H
D
N
G
1 mm
f
Ilmenite 4 1,000
Titanite
Spot 1 100
3
Garnet/chondrite
10
Lu (ppm)
Ilmenite
Titanite
2
1
1 0.1
Spot 25
0.01
0
e
La
o
Tb
Yb
Sm
Tm
Eu
Lu
y
Pr
Er
d
d
C
H
D
N
Fig. 4 | Trace element content of representative garnet from samples SU-03A, WT-150 and WT-151. a,c,e, Lutetium maps for SU-03A (a), WT-150 (c)
and WT-151 (e), the locations of which are indicated by the dashed squares in Fig. 3a–c, respectively. b,d,f, Rare earth element (REE) profiles normalized to
chondrites51. The locations of the spot analyses are shown a, c and e, respectively.
(96.19 ± 0.14 Ma) may have crystallized from late, highly fraction- U–Pb age, whereas cooling to ~550 °C and below was constrained
ated solidifying trapped melt29,31 when the rocks cooled from peak by hornblende 40Ar/39Ar dating between ~95.5 Ma and ~92 Ma28.
conditions to sub-solidus conditions of 700 °C. The U–Pb dates of The onset of cooling in the sole thus coincided with the formation
titanite (95.60 ± 0.27 Ma) represent cooling below 650–600 °C31. of SSZ oceanic crust (96.12–95.50 Ma25,26). In the Semail Ophiolite,
sole formation, or lower plate burial, started >8 Myr before upper
Implications for subduction initiation. Rheological studies indi- plate extension occurred. The inference that underthrusting below
cate that the upper part of a subducting oceanic plate will be trans- the mantle section predated formation of the ophiolitic crust by at
ferred to the upper plate when conditions of 850 °C and 11–13 kbar least 8 Myr confirms a SSZ origin for the Semail ophiolitic crust, set-
are reached at the interface, forming a metamorphic sole20,21. We tling the long discussion regarding its origin29,38,39,41,50.
now show that garnet growth in the sole under the Semail Ophiolite The Semail Ophiolite, preserving a ~50-km-wide forearc litho-
occurred at 104 Ma. This age provides a timing for burial, decoupling sphere8 measured perpendicular to its spreading direction38, is
from the lower plate and transfer to the upper plate. Between peri- 8 Myr younger than the sole age, and thus does not preserve the
tectic garnet growth at 104 Ma and zircon crystallization at 96 Ma, crust of the pre-subduction initiation lithosphere. Therefore, we
the welded sole did not record any major thermal or dynamic per- cannot conclude with certainty that this is the oldest SSZ crust that
turbation, probably staying at supra-solidus peak conditions while formed after subduction initiation. However, during SSZ spreading,
underthrusting progressed. Around 96 Ma, extension in the upper the ridge must have moved away from the trench at half-spreading
plate led to oceanic lithosphere accretion along a spreading centre. rate9, which was >10 cm yr−1 (ref. 25). At these rates, if upper plate
From 96.2–94.5 Ma, zircon crystallized from the segregated melt spreading had started even 1 million years earlier, the ophiolite
fractions29,30 in the underlying metamorphic sole, marking cool- should have been ~50–100 km wider than today to preserve the
ing to sub-solidus conditions29,31 from >850 °C to ∼700 °C. Cooling 96–95.5-Myr-old crust. We therefore conclude that the oldest crust
to 600–650 °C31 occurred ~0.5 Myr later, as shown by our titanite of the Semail Ophiolite formed at the onset of upper plate extension.
a 0.287
Our new results imply that SSZ ophiolite formation is not
unequivocal evidence for SSI, as is often assumed for Semail and
0.286 other large and well-preserved ophiolites3,8,42. In fact, SSZ ophiolite
formation indicates the onset of upper plate extension, which does
Grt1
not date subduction initiation in ISI.
Hf/177Hf
0.284
of convergence convey critical, previously unavailable information
103.5 ± 1.6 Ma
0.283 176
Hf/177Hfinitial = 0.288569 ± 23
on subduction initiation. The magnitude of the time lag should
WR1
MSWD = 0.62 reflect the balance between forces driving and resisting upper plate
extension, depending on the nature, geometry and kinematics of
b 0.287 the intervening plates, as indicated by numerical models2,4–6. Longer
time lags could indicate a strong upper plate, long subduction inter-
0.286 face or slow convergence rate. Models of ISI at transform faults
Grt2 Grt3
involving a very young upper plate4–6 predict time lags of the order
Hf/177Hf
0.284
record in the pre-104 Ma configuration. Accordingly, the absolute
0.283 104.1 ± 1.1 Ma
176
Hf/177Hfinitial = 0.282377 ± 21
timing of initial lower plate burial is also of utmost importance. The
WR1
MSWD = 0.79 plate configuration and kinematics in which new subduction zones
were initiated in the geological past might have significantly pre-
c dated the earliest expression of upper plate spreading represented by
0.287
ophiolitic or modern forearc crust. Such new insights into subduc-
Grt3 Grt1
0.286 tion initiation processes open new avenues for reconceptualization
Grt2
of the initiation and processes of global plate tectonics.
Grt4
Hf/177Hf
0.285
Methods
176
0.284
Methods, including statements of data availability and any asso-
103.2 ± 1.2 Ma
ciated accession codes and references, are available at https://doi.
0.283
WR1
176
Hf/177Hfinitial = 0.282499 ± 24 org/10.1038/s41561-018-0209-2.
MSWD = 0.32
0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 Received: 18 January 2018; Accepted: 18 July 2018;
176
Lu/177Hf Published: xx xx xxxx
d 0.0152
97 References
1. Lithgow-Bertelloni, C. Encyclopedia of Marine Geosciences (eds Harff, J.,
0.0151 Meschede, M., Petersen, S. & Thiede, J.) 193–196 (Springer, Dordrecht, 2016).
96.6
2. Stern, R. J. & Gerya, T. Subduction initiation in nature and models: a review.
Tectonophysics https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tecto.2017.10.014 (2017).
Pb/238U
96.2
3. Stern, R. J. Subduction initiation: spontaneous and induced. Earth Planet. Sci.
0.0150 Lett. 226, 275–292 (2004).
95.8
4. Gurnis, M., Hall, C. & Lavier, L. Evolving force balance during incipient
206
Titanite
Ilmenite
Zircon crystallization with melt solidification Initial lower plate burial
Titanite cooling below 650–600 °C
Hornblende cooling below 550–500 °C ii
Ma
4.1
–10
10 .2 Sole burial Lithosphere
3
10
and garnet Crust
growth Metamorphic
sole
ii 104–96 Ma
i iii Forced convergence
Pressure (kbar)
Solidu
8
a
M
s
t-in .5
rne – 94 Sole welded
Ga .2 to the upper
96
plate
lting
iii 96–95.5 Ma
.60
rtial me
95 Ma Upper plate extension
6 7
0.2
±
10% pa
.7 a
95 6 M
9 2.
to
4
400 500 600 700 800 900
Temperature (°C)
Fig. 6 | Pressure–temperature–time evolution of the Semail metamorphic sole. The pressure–temperature trajectory and hornblende ages are from Soret
et al.21. The supra-solidus garnet growth ages and titanite ages are from this study. The zircon ages are from this study and Rioux et al.29. The 10% partial
melting isomodes and solidus for MORB-like protoliths are from Palin et al.23. The garnet-in boundary and titanite–ilmenite transition are from Liu et al.48.
i–iii, lithospheric section diagrams synthesizing our results. In iii, the spreading ages are from Rioux et al.25,26. See main text for details.
15. Dewey, J. F. Ophiolite obduction. Tectonophysics 31, 93–120 (1976). 30. Warren, C. J., Parrish, R. R., Waters, D. J. & Searle, M. P. Dating the geologic
16. Jamieson, R. A. P–T paths from high temperature shear zones beneath history of Oman’s Semail Ophiolite: insights from U/Pb geochronology.
ophiolites. J. Metamorph. Geol. 4, 3–22 (1986). Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 150, 403–422 (2005).
17. Spray, J. G. Possible causes and consequences of upper mantle decoupling and 31. Yakymchuk, C., Clark, C. & White, R. W. Phase relations, reaction sequences
ophiolite displacement. Geol. Soc. Lond. Spec. Publ. 13, 255–268 (1984). and petrochronology. Rev. Mineral. Geochem. 83, 13–53 (2017).
18. Wakabayashi, J. & Dilek, Y. Spatial and temporal relationships between 32. Baxter, E. F. & Scherer, E. E. Garnet geochronology: timekeeper of
ophiolites and their metamorphic soles: a test of models of forearc ophiolite tectonometamorphic processes. Elements 9, 433–438 (2013).
genesis. Geol. Soc. Am. Spec. Pap. 349, 53–64 (2000). 33. Scherer, E. E., Cameron, K. L. & Blichert-Toft, J. Lu–Hf garnet
19. Williams, H. & Smyth, W. R. Metamorphic aureoles beneath ophiolite suites geochronology: closure temperature relative to the Sm–Nd system
and alpine peridotites: tectonic implications with west Newfoundland and the effects of trace mineral inclusions. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 64,
examples. Am. J. Sci. 273, 594–621 (1973). 3413–3432 (2000).
20. Agard, P. et al. Plate interface rheological switches during subduction infancy: 34. Smit, M. A., Scherer, E. E. & Mezger, K. Lu–Hf and Sm–Nd garnet
control on slab penetration and metamorphic sole formation. Earth Planet. geochronology: chronometric closure and implications for dating petrological
Sci. Lett. 451, 208–220 (2016). processes. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 381, 222–233 (2013).
21. Soret, M., Agard, P., Dubacq, B., Plunder, A. & Yamato, P. Petrological 35. Anczkiewicz, R. et al. Lu–Hf geochronology and trace element
evidence for stepwise accretion of metamorphic soles during subduction distribution in garnet: implications for uplift and exhumation
infancy (Semail Ophiolite, Oman and UAE). J. Metamorph. Geol. 35, of ultra-high pressure granulites in the Sudetes, SW Poland. Lithos 95,
1051–1080 (2017). 363–380 (2007).
22. Pattison, D. R. M. Petrogenetic significance of orthopyroxene‐free 36. Hacker, B. R. & Gnos, E. The conundrum of Samail: explaining the
garnet + clinopyroxene + plagioclase ± quartz‐bearing metabasites with respect metamorphic history. Tectonophysics 279, 215–226 (1997).
to the amphibolite and granulite facies. J. Metamorph. Geol. 21, 21–34 (2003). 37. Searle, M. P., Warren, C. J., Waters, D. J. & Parrish, R. R. Structural evolution,
23. Palin, R. M. et al. High-grade metamorphism and partial melting of basic metamorphism and restoration of the Arabian continental margin, Saih Hatat
and intermediate rocks. J. Metamorph. Geol. 34, 871–892 (2016). region, Oman Mountains. J. Struct. Geol. 26, 451–473 (2004).
24. Peacock, S. M., Rushmer, T. & Thompson, A. B. Partial melting of subducting 38. Nicolas, A., Boudier, F., Ildefonse, B. & Ball, E. Accretion of Oman and
oceanic crust. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 121, 227–244 (1994). United Arab Emirates ophiolite—discussion of a new structural map.
25. Rioux, M. et al. Rapid crustal accretion and magma assimilation in the Mar. Geophys. Res. 21, 147–180 (2000).
Oman-U.A.E. ophiolite: High precision U–Pb zircon geochronology of the 39. Boudier, F., Ceuleneer, G. & Nicolas, A. Shear zones, thrusts and related
gabbroic crust. J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth 117, B07201 (2012). magmatism in the Oman Ophiolite: initiation of thrusting on an oceanic
26. Rioux, M. et al. Tectonic development of the Samail Ophiolite: high-precision ridge. Tectonophysics 151, 275–296 (1988).
U–Pb zircon geochronology and Sm–Nd isotopic constraints on crustal 40. Ishikawa, T., Nagaishi, K. & Umino, S. Boninitic volcanism in the Oman
growth and emplacement. J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth 118, 2085–2101 (2013). Ophiolite: implications for thermal condition during transition from
27. Hacker, B. R. Rapid emplacement of young oceanic lithosphere: argon spreading ridge to arc. Geology 30, 899–902 (2002).
geochronology of the Oman Ophiolite. Science 265, 1563–1565 (1994). 41. MacLeod, C. J., Lissenberg, L. & Bibby, L. E. “Moist MORB” axial magmatism
28. Hacker, B. R., Mosenfelder, J. L. & Gnos, E. Rapid emplacement of the in the Oman Ophiolite: the evidence against a mid-ocean ridge origin.
Oman Ophiolite: thermal and geochronologic constraints. Tectonics 15, Geology 41, 459–462 (2013).
1230–1247 (1996). 42. Whattam, S. A. & Stern, R. J. The “subduction initiation rule”: a key
29. Rioux, M. et al. Synchronous formation of the metamorphic sole and igneous for linking ophiolites, intra-oceanic fore-arcs, and subduction initiation.
crust of the Semail Ophiolite: new constraints on the tectonic evolution Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 162, 1031–1045 (2011).
during ophiolite formation from high-precision U–Pb zircon geochronology. 43. Agard, P., Jolivet, L., Vrielynck, B., Burov, E. & Monié, P. Plate acceleration:
Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 451, 185–195 (2016). the obduction trigger? Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 258, 428–441 (2007).
Table 3 : Lu-Hf isotopic dilution analysis of garnet and whole fractions from the Semail metamorphic sole.
Lu-Hf age
Sample Aliquot Lu (ppm) Hf (ppm) 176
Lu/177Hf 2SD 176
Hf/177Hf 2SD (Ma) 2SD 176
Hf/177Hfinitial 2SD MSWD
Grt-1 4.06 0.554 1.038 0.003 0.284388 0.000036
Grt-2 5.35 0.553 1.371 0.003 0.285051 0.000035
WT-150 Grt-3 4.88 0.454 1.523 0.004 0.285329 0.000027
Grt-4 5.52 0.714 1.096 0.003 0.284526 0.000028
WR-1 0.193 4.20 0.006516 0.000016 0.282388 0.000022
104.1 1.1 0.282377 0.000021 0.79
Grt-1 4.81 0.380 1.794 0.004 0.285975 0.000056
Grt-2 5.01 0.475 1.495 0.004 0.285381 0.000047
WT-151 Grt-3 5.08 0.405 1.777 0.004 0.285926 0.000053
Grt-4 4.97 0.573 1.231 0.003 0.284854 0.000049
WR-1 0.0888 1.20 0.01049 0.00003 0.282521 0.000025
103.2 1.2 0.282499 0.000024 0.32
Grt-1 2.29 0.273 1.192 0.003 0.284910 0.000059
Grt-2 2.29 0.298 1.091 0.003 0.284652 0.000059
Grt-3 3.01 0.398 1.070 0.003 0.284635 0.000068
SU-03 Grt-4 1.07 0.127 1.196 0.003 0.284886 0.000048
Grt-5 2.82 0.435 0.917 0.002 0.284336 0.000031
WR-1 0.565 2.97 0.02692 0.00007 0.282622 0.000023
103.5 1.6 0.282569 0.000023 0.62
Table 4 : U-Pb data for zircon and titanite of sample WT-151
Properties Weight U Th/U Pbc 206/204 207/235 2 sigma 206/238 2 sigma rho 207/206 2 sigma 206/238 2 sigma 207/235 2 sigma
[ug] [ppm] [pg] [abs] [abs] [abs] [Ma] [abs] [Ma] [abs]
(a) (b) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (f) (f, g) (f) (f) (f,g) (f) (f,g) (f) (f) (f)
Z eq [1] 10 17 0.46 1.9 102 0.10889 0.00447 0.015038 0.000082 0.19 0.05252 0.00212 96.22 0.52 104.95 4.09
Z eq [1] 25 73 0.01 0.8 2100 0.10185 0.00090 0.015011 0.000123 0.94 0.04921 0.00014 96.05 0.78 98.48 0.83
Z eq [1] 18 10 0.39 1.3 152 0.10411 0.00298 0.015027 0.000063 0.26 0.05025 0.00140 96.15 0.40 100.56 2.74
Z eq [3] 15 73 0.09 1.5 671 0.10164 0.00069 0.015054 0.000036 0.51 0.04897 0.00029 96.32 0.23 98.29 0.63
Z eq [2] 13 117 0.02 0.9 1558 0.10015 0.00046 0.015014 0.000036 0.68 0.04838 0.00017 96.07 0.23 96.92 0.43
TIT [4] 45 111 0.10 8.6 550 0.09887 0.00071 0.014940 0.000042 0.55 0.04799 0.00029 95.60 0.27 95.73 0.65
a) Z = zircon; TIT = titanite; eq = equant; zircon treated with chemical abrasion (Mattinson, 2005), titanite not abraded
b) weight and concentrations are known to better than 10%.
c) Th/U model ratio inferred from 208/206 ratio and age of sample
d) Pbc = total common Pb in sample (initial + blank)
e) raw data, corrected for fractionation and spike
f) corrected for fractionation, spike, blank (206/204=18.59; 207/204=15.24) and initial common Pb (based on Stacey and Kramers, 1975); error calculated by
propagating the main sources of uncertainty; The U-Pb ratio of the spike used for this work is adapted to 206Pb/238U = 0.015660 for the ET100 solution as
obtained with the ET2535 spike at NIGL.
g) corrected for 230Th disequilibrium according to Schärer (1984) and assuming Th/U magma = 4