Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
for
Alloy Selection
choose the correct grade for the chloride content of the water;
avoid crevices when possible by good design;
follow good fabrication practices, particularly removing weld heat tint;
drain promptly after hydrotesting.
Waters
Stainless steels do not suffer uniform corrosion when exposed to water environments. On the other
hand, they can be susceptible to localised corrosion under certain circumstances which designers and
end users need to recognise and avoid. Such attack, if it occurs in water environments, is usually
localised as pits or in creviced areas. Design and good fabrication can minimise such corrosion sites
but this needs to be combined with correct alloy selection.
Pitting and crevice corrosion requires the presence of chlorides and, for a given chloride level, the
more highly alloyed stainless steels are more resistant. In general, the higher the chromium,
molybdenum and nitrogen contents of the steel, the better the corrosion resistance. While there are
other factors that have an effect on corrosion rate in waters, chloride content is a major factor for
selection of an appropriate grade and is easily measurable. As crevice corrosion tends to occur at
lower chloride levels and temperatures than pitting, it is normally the parameter used to guide
selection. The guidelines in Table 4 are based on laboratory tests and service experience over many
years.
Machining grades of stainless steel contain high levels of non-metallic stringers which significantly
lower their resistance to pitting in waters. Therefore, free-cutting high sulphur or selenium bearing
grades such as alloy 303 and 303Se should not be used.
Chemical Additions
Care must be taken when adding chlorine compounds to various process streams. Serious
consideration needs to be given to ensuring that chlorine and aggressive chemicals, such as ferric
chloride (added for flocculation purposes), are added centrally into the stream for good dispersion.
Concentrated forms of these chemicals directed at or down the side of stainless steel piping or
equipment can result in localised attack.
Bacterial control and management is often achieved by chlorine dosing. Type 316L(1.4404) stainless
steel performs well and the molybdenum additions in this alloy provide greater pitting and crevice
corrosion resistance than its Type 304L(1.4307) counterpart. Data to evaluate acceptable free
chlorine levels is limited but that available for raw waters suggest up to 2ppm for type 304L(1.4307)
and 5ppm for type 316L(1.4404). However, stainless steel can tolerate considerably higher levels of
chlorine for short periods of time, as would be the case during disinfection treatments e.g. AWWA
Standards C651/652 where 25-50 ppm chlorine are held for 24-48 hours. It is important however that
such levels are well flushed through the system immediately after treatment.
Useful reference: Effect of Chlorine on Common Materials in Fresh Water. NI Publication 14049
Ozonation has increased in popularity. This is a powerful oxidant with limited retention life. It does
not create ions or compounds which are as aggressive to stainless steel. However, a good filter is
preferred to remove sediment from the cooling water before it enters the generator to avoid deposit
build up on the tubes. Type 316L(1.4404) stainless steel is a standard material used in ozone
generation and for the handling of the ozonated water streams.
Prompt removal of stagnant water after hydrotesting requires particular attention. It is very important
to drain and dry stainless steel systems after hydrotesting, if the equipment is not going into service
directly. Alternatively, if this is not possible, maintaining regular flushing or water recirculation of
the system is good practice. Potable waters, steam condensates (where available) or filtered waters
should be used for hydrotesting rather than raw waters.
The above practices avoid long term stagnant conditions that occasionally can produce colonisation
of certain unsuitable types of bacteria as biomounds and tubercles which can lead to
microbiologically influenced corrosion (MIC). The bacteria causing MIC are more likely to colonise
in the area of welds that have not been cleaned of heat tint. Therefore, good fabrication procedures
which remove or avoid heat tint also greatly improve resistance.
Useful Reference: Microbiologically Influenced Corrosion of Stainless Steel by Water used for
Cooling and Hydrostatic Testing, NI Publication 10085
Plant Atmospheres
In enclosed plant atmospheres, where wet chlorine vapours collect and concentrate, acid condensates
can begin to stain and pit stainless steel. Good venting or regular washing down is recommended in
pipe galleries and other areas where chlorine gases can collect. However, where this is not possible, a
higher grade of stainless such as alloy 2205(1.4462) or super stainless alloys may be required.
Galvanic Behaviour
It is often necessary to use a number of different alloys to construct a treatment plant or processing
system and the galvanic compatibility of these materials must be considered. Galvanic corrosion can
occur when 2 different alloys are in contact in a common electrolyte (e.g. rain, condensation, fresh
and treated waters and waste water) forming a galvanic corrosion cell. If current flows between the
two, the less noble alloy (the anode) corrodes at a faster rate than it otherwise would if the alloys
were not in contact.
Prediction of corrosion rates can be complicated by area ratios of the metals, temperature, surface
films and the electrical conductivity of the electrolyte and are not always easy to accurately assess.
Galvanic series are available to indicate which alloy is the least noble in a metal couple but these are
usually based on sea water as the electrolyte. Less information is available about other waters but
Galvanic Corrosion-A Practical Guide for Engineers by Roger Francis published by NACE Press
goes some way to assembling existing information.
ANODIC—LEAST NOBLE
Magnesium
Zinc
Aluminium
Carbon steel and cast iron
Copper Alloys
Stainless steels
Graphite
CATHODIC—MOST NOBLE
The greater the potential difference or, put more simply the vertical separation, between two metals
in the series, the greater the driving force for corrosion. Stainless steels are noble alloys in this
ranking and they are the protected component of the combination.
When the stainless steel is active such that the passive film is damaged or removed by localised
corrosion attack, its position in the series can change to between copper alloys and carbon steel and
thus become less noble.
In practice galvanic corrosion is particularly relevant when considering joining stainless steel and
carbon or low alloy steels. The risk of deep attack is greater if the stainless steel area is large
compared to the steel; for example, galvanised or steel fasteners in a stainless steel flange.
Design to ensure the more noble area is small in comparison with the less noble area
Insulate the Joint e.g. insulating gaskets, sleeves and washers, paint and tapes.
Use of Isolation spools
Cathodic protection
Coating the joint region ensuring adequate coverage either side. If this is difficult coat only the
more noble metal. If the less noble metal alone is protected, then attack at any coating defects
will be severe.
Galvanic corrosion is also a reason why it is important to select a weld consumable that is at
least as noble as the parent metal.
In fresh waters as opposed to sea water, copper base alloys are compatible with stainless steel unless
extreme stainless steel to copper area ratios exist for example copper alloy valves can be used in
stainless steel piping. However, steel, zinc and aluminium are significantly less noble that stainless
steel and generally should be insulated from stainless steel.
Useful Information: Stainless Steel in Waters: Galvanic Corrosion and its Prevention, A.E. Bauer
Soils
Soil corrosivity towards stainless steels depends on many factors the more important of which are
soil resistivity, pH, chloride content and soil drainage. Resistivity provides a guideline to the soil’s
water retentiveness e.g clay; sand; loam. and the higher the resistivity, the better is the drainage.
Chlorides are affected by location; the more aggressive being coastal sites or near roads salted for
deicing. Selection of bedding can help with drainage away from piping, especially in aggressive
acidic and/or high chloride soils.
Coating protection, cathodic protection or both is often suggested for type 300 stainless steels in
conditions where the resistivity is less than 2,000 ohm.cm, pH is less than 4.5 and drainage is poor.
Between resistivities of 2000-5000 ohm.cm, stainless steels may require protection or consideration
given to higher alloys if the chloride level is high or soil acidity is of concern. In the EuroInox
paper, Stainless steels in Soils and Concrete, recommendations are given in more precise terms and
provides guidance for material selection vs chloride levels in the absence of coatings and or cathodic
protection. A summary is given in table 5.
Chloride <500ppm
304L
Resistivity>1000 ohm.cm
316L
pH.>4.5
316L Chloride<1,500ppm
Resistivity>1,000 ohm.cm
pH.>4.5
Chloride<6,000ppm
Super duplex
Resistivity>500 ohm.cm
Super austenitic
pH>4.5
Related Information
Articles
Type 316L
Well pressed with SS
Sewage treatment
News
Publications
Corrugated Stainless Steel Pipes are part of the solution to water loss
Infographic: Nickel Recycling
Infographic: Waste no water - the essential role of nickel
Knowledge Base
FAQs
Nigel Ward at NiCoMo 2014
An Introduction to Environmental Quality Standards for Metals
Press Releases
Nickel Compounds - the inside story
Press Releases
Presentations