Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
SUMMARY
Objectives The aim of this study is to review gender differences in elderly suicide in relation to specific social aspects of
the suicidal process and health care contact before death. Such information may have practical value in identifying and
targeting vulnerable elderly in whom suicide may be potentially preventable.
Methods Data were extracted from the records of coroner’s inquests into all reported suicide of persons aged 60 and over,
in Cheshire over a period of 13 years 1989–2001. The Coroner’s office covers the whole county of Cheshire (population
1 000 000).
Results Men were less likely to have been known to psychiatric services (Odds Ratio [OR] 0.4 95% 0.2–0.6) and with less
frequently reported history of previous attempted suicide compared to women (OR 0.5 95% Confidence Intervals [CI] 0.2–
1). All deceased from ethnic minorities were men, none of whom had been known to psychiatric services. There was no
significant difference between women and men in relation to, physical or psychiatric morbidity, GP contact prior to suicide,
intimation of intent or living alone. Of suicide victims not known to services a surprisingly high proportion of 38% and 16%
were found to have psychiatric morbidity in men and women respectively.
Conclusion Suicide is an important problem in the elderly with gender playing an important part in their social behaviour
but a high proportion of the deceased were not known to local services. Primary Care professionals have an important role to
play in reducing elderly suicide as most contact with the health service in elderly suicide seem to be with GPs. Copyright #
2003 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
key words — elderly suicide; sex in elderly suicide; gender in elderly suicide; utilization of psychiatric service in elderly
suicide; primary care in elderly suicide
suicide but very few who consulted family members, of suicide will be referred to in the text: (1) non-vio-
professionals or others regarding this (Ono et al., lent death which included: E950 ¼ Self-poisoning by
2001). GP contact prior to death tends to be relatively solid or liquid; E951 ¼ Gas in domestic use and
high prior to elderly suicide in relation to physical E952 ¼ Other gases and vapour and (2) violent death
complaints or recent ill health but with no overt which included all methods other than self poisoning:
psychiatric difficulties evident in the consultation E953 ¼ Hanging, strangulation and suffocation;
(Barraclough, 1987). Conwell and Duberstein (2001) E954 ¼ Drowning: E955 ¼ Firearms and explosives;
found that another group of elders at high risk of sui- E956 ¼ cutting or piercing instruments; E957 ¼
cide are those with no active contact with primary Jumping from high place; E958 ¼ Other methods.
care at all. Contact with mental health services tends SPSS was used in the statistical analysis and cross
to be low, in particular in elderly male suicide (Con- tabulation to compute odds ratios (OR) and p-values.
well et al., 1996). It may be possible to assume that
elderly women may be at lower risk of suicide than RESULTS
men due to their ability to access the appropriate treat-
ment for psychiatric problems (Canetto, 1992). Males The study included 200 suicide verdicts recorded by
tend to use violent methods compared to women the Cheshire coroner between 1989 and 2001 of per-
(Barraclough, 1971; Lindesay, 1991; Cattell and Jolly, sons aged 60 and above within the County of Che-
1995; Harwood and Jacoby, 2000; Harwood et al., shire. Mean age for the entire sample was 71 years
2001) and are more likely to succeed in their first (SD ¼ 8, range 60–86); 117 (58.5%) of the sample
attempt (Salib et al., 2001b). It has also been demon- were men and 83 (41.5%) were women with mean
strated that method chosen may be influenced by ages of 70 (SD ¼ 7) and 74 (SD ¼ 8) respectively.
familiarity and access to different methods (McIntosh The distribution of the main study variables by gender
and Santos, 1986). The aim of this study is to review are presented in Table 1. Statistically significant asso-
gender differences in elderly suicide in relation to ciation with gender was found in marital status,
specific social aspects of the suicidal process and whether deceased were previously known to local
health care contact before death. psychiatric services and history of DSH.
The findings are interpreted and compared to the The low rate of widowed men at 30% compared to
available literature on suicide in the elderly. 54% widowed women may simply reflect the longer
survival of women and have no other specific signifi-
METHOD cance. Men were less likely to have been known to
psychiatric services (OR ¼ 0.4 95% 0.2–0.6
Data were extracted from the records of coroner’s p < 0.05) and less likely to have attempted suicide
inquests into all unexpected deaths of persons aged before compared to women (OR ¼ 0.5 95%
60 and over, in Cheshire over a period of 13 years: CI ¼ 0.2–1 p ¼ 0.06). All deceased from ethnic mino-
1989–2001. rities were men. There was no significant difference
The Coroner’s office of Cheshire is based at War- between women and men in respect of; physical or
rington and covers the whole county of Cheshire psychiatric morbidity, GP contact prior to suicide,
(population 1,000,000). intimation of intent or living alone. The positive asso-
As a proportion of open verdicts may be wrongly ciation between male sex and using violent means as
included in suicide rate data (Salib et al., 2001a), defined in the methods section is in keeping with
inclusion of all non-suicide verdicts, such as open ver- other studies. However, the unexpected higher rate
dicts, or to selectively include some verdicts other of violent suicide in women (48%) in this sample
than suicide (Harwood et al., 2001) may result in may have resulted from the inclusion of suicide ver-
selection bias. In order to avoid this selection bias this dicts only.
study included suicide verdicts only. Verdicts of acci- Table 2 deals with gender difference in deceased
dental death, misadventure and open verdicts were elderly in respect of history of DSH. 80% of suicides
excluded. A standard form was designed and used succeeded at the first attempt. Those succeeding at
to extract the data from the inquests’ files consistently second or subsequent attempts were more likely to
for the whole sample. Information recorded for all have suffered enduring physical illness prior to death
cases included: demographic details; method of and this especially applied to men. In this study living
death; circumstances leading to the death; previous alone and being widowed prior to death at first
history of psychiatric and physical morbidity; social attempt especially applied to women. More men
isolation and evidence of intent. Two main categories saw their GP prior to death if they had attempted self
Copyright # 2003 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 2003; 18: 1082–1087.
1084 e. salib and l. green
Table 1. Sex in elderly suicide elderly suicide victims with a history of previous
Male n ¼ 117 Female n ¼ 83 attempts. However, those who were known were more
(58.5%) n (%) (41.5%) n (%) often women, especially those who succeeded on first
attempt, perhaps because they are more likely to seek
Intimation of intent help than men. Table 3 also shows that of those not
Yes 61 (52%) 40 (48%)
No 56 (48%) 43 (82%) known to the local service, 55% of men and 74% of
OR 1.2 95% CI 0.7–2 women were living alone. Considerably fewer
Marital status widowed elderly were known to local services prior
Widowed 35 (30%) 45 (54%) to suicide compared to the married group regardless
Other 82 (70%) 38 (46%)
OR 0.4 95% CI 0.2–0.6
of their gender. Nearly half of those not known to
Living alone the local service did not have GP contact during the
Yes 58 (50%) 48 (58%) 3 months prior to committing suicide. Of the elderly
No 59 (50%) 35 (42%) deceased who were not known to local services, 38%
OR 0.7 95% CI 0.7–1.3 of men and 16% of women were reported by family
Children
No 43 (37%) 27 (33%) members and friends to have displayed some evi-
Yes 74 (63%) 56 (67%) dence of psychiatric morbidity before suicide. Of
OR 1.2 95% CI 0.6–2.2 those known to the local service, significantly more
Known to services men saw their GPs prior to death and overall those
Yes 23 (20%) 34 (41%)
No 94 (80%) 49 (59%)
known to services were more likely to use a violent
OR 0.4 95% CI 0.2–0.7 method of death than those not known. A history of
Method of suicide DSH was more common in those known to services
Violent suicide 69 (59%) 40 (48%) overall but of those not known to services more
Non-violent suicide 48 (41%) 43 (52%) women had evidence of previous self harm. Table 4
OR 1.5 95% CI 0.9–2.7
Previous attempts reiterates that men known to services were more
Yes 18 (15%) 21 (25%) likely to see their GP, have previous psychiatric mor-
No 99 (85%) 62 (75%) bidity and evidence of DSH prior to death. Those not
OR 0.5 95% CI 0.2–1 known to services were more likely to live alone, be
History of recent ill
health & GP contact
widowed and show evidence of intent. Known women
Yes 56 (48%) 44 (53%) were more likely to use a violent method, have psy-
No 61 (52%) 39 (47%) chiatric morbidity and previous DSH than those not
OR 0.8 95% CI 0.8–1.4 known to services. Those not known were more likely
Ethnic origin to live alone, be widowed, have no children and show
White 111 (95%) 83 (100%)
Other 6 (5%) evidence of intent.
Psychiatric morbidity
Yes 57 (49%) 42 (51%)
No 60 (51%) 41 (49%) DISCUSSION
OR 1 95% CI 0.5–1.6
1. Interpretation of findings
In this study, the proportion of male suicides was
harm before than either women or men who suc- higher than the female suicides but only by approxi-
ceeded at first attempt. Men who succeeded on first mately 17%. This may be, at least partly, due to the
attempt were more likely to use violent means, in effect of excluding verdicts other than suicide in the
keeping with previous literature, compared with data collection. Henriksson et al. (1995) and Conwell
women succeeding at first attempt. Of those succeed- et al. (1996) have shown that suicide rates for elderly
ing on second or subsequent attempt, more women men are twice those for women. Harwood et al.
used violent methods, perhaps reflecting increased (2001) also demonstrated this marked male predomi-
levels of mental ill health. nance of two to one amongst older suicide victims.
Gender differences in relation to whether the However, other British studies by Cattell (1988) and
deceased were known or not to local psychiatric ser- Cattell and Jolley (1995) showed similar proportions
vices are presented in Table 3. Of those not known to for the two sexes. This may be partly explained by the
the local service 89% of men and 80% of women had changing rates of suicide in men and women, with a
no previous suicide attempt which may be indicative greater fall in rates of suicide in older women than
of the lethality of attempts hence the low number of older men during the last 15 years (Kelly and Bunting,
Copyright # 2003 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 2003; 18: 1082–1087.
gender in elderly suicide 1085
Living alone
Yes 8 (44%) 9 (43%) 0.01 0.92 50 (50%) 39 (63%) 2.14 0.14
Marital status
Widowed 5 (28%) 9 (43%) 0.96 0.34 30 (30%) 36 (58%) 12.14 <0.001
Children
No children 6 (33%) 2 (10%) 2.33 0.13 37 (37%) 25 (40%) 0.14 0.71
GP contact
Yes 14 (78%) 12 (57%) 1.86 0.17 42 (42%) 32 (52%) 1.30 0.23
Method
Violent 10 (56%) 13 (62%) 0.16 0.67 59 (60%) 27 (43%) 3.95 0.05
Evidence of intent
Yes 8 (44%) 8 (38%) 0.16 0.67 53 (53%) 32 (52%) 0.01 0.91
Psychiatric morbidity
Yes 13 (72%) 16 (76%) 0.05 0.83 62 (63%) 36 (58%) 0.33 0.56
Physical morbidity of
Yes 14 (78%) 13 (62%) 1.15 0.28 43 (43%) 29 (46%) 0.17 0.68
Known to services
Yes 8 (44%) 11 (52%) 0.24 0.62 15 (15%) 23 (37%) 10.18 0.001
Table 3. Gender differences in elderly suicide who were known and unknown to local psychiatric services in Cheshire 1989–2001
Known to services 57 (28.5%) Not known to services 143 (71.5%)
mean age 69 (SD 7) mean age 74 (SD 9)
Living alone
Yes 6 (26%) 12 (35%) 0.54 0.46 52 (55%) 36 (74%) 4.48 0.03
Marital status
Widowed 2 (9%) 33 (35%) 5.24 0.02 11 (12%) 34 (69%) 18.29 <0.001
Children
No children 10 (44%) 5 (15%) 5.86 0.02 33 (35%) 22 (45%) 1.30 0.25
GP contact
Yes 18 (78%) 19 (56%) 3.02 0.08 38 (40%) 25 (51%) 1.47 0.23
Method
Violent 15 (65%) 22 (65%) — — 54 (57%) 18 (37%) 5.53 0.02
Evidence of intent
Yes 6 (26%) 12 (35%) 0.54 0.46 55 (58%) 28 (57%) 0.02 0.88
Psychiatric morbidity
Yes 21 (91%) 34 (100%) — — 36 (38%) 8 (16%) 7.30 0.001
History of DSH
Yes 8 (35%) 11 (32%) 0.04 0.85 10 (11%) 10 (20%) 2.56 0.11
1998). Women have a greater ability to cope with men are thought to gain less experience of change
changes ageing may bring and their increased flexibil- with their development though adult life following a
ity to cope is due to experience of changing circum- more stable course. As a result, they may be less able
stances during life, e.g. the changes experienced to cope with the age-related mental, physical and
during child bearing and the different stages of child social changes and thus are at higher risk of suicide
development. In contrast (Breed and Huffine, 1979), (Breed and Huffine, 1979). The study found that a
Copyright # 2003 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 2003; 18: 1082–1087.
1086 e. salib and l. green
Living alone
Yes 6 (26%) 52 (55%) 6.32 0.01 12 (35%) 36 (74%) 12.0 <0.001
Marital status
Widowed 2 (9%) 11 (12%) 5.01 <0.05 12 (35%) 34 (69%) 9.44 <0.001
Children
No children 10 (44%) 33 (35%) 0.56 0.05 5 (15%) 22 (45%) 8.34 <0.01
GP contact
Yes 18 (78%) 38 (40%) 10.6 <0.01 15 (56%) 25 (51%) 0.19 0.66
Method
Violent 15 (65%) 54 (57%) 0.46 0.48 22 (65%) 18 (37%) 6.29 0.01
Evidence of intent
Yes 6 (26%) 55 (58%) 7.78 <0.01 12 (35%) 28 (57%) 3.84 0.05
Psychiatric morbidity
Yes 21 (91%) 36 (38%) 20.78 <0.001 34 (100%) 8 (16%) 56.22 <0.001
History of DSH
Yes 8 (35%) 10 (11%) 7.08 <0.001 11 (32%) 10 (20%) 1.52 0.22
significantly higher proportion of widowed men were and friends during coroner’s inquest. This is an unex-
not previously known to the services. The risk of sui- pectedly high percentage considering the fact that
cide has been reported to be high in widowed men depression is one of risk factors of suicide in the
(Bock and Webber, 1972; Cattell and Jolly, 1995; Li, elderly (Cattell and Jolley, 1995; Conwell et al.,
1995; Harwood and Jacob, 2000) but also as an equal 1996; Shah and De, 1998). The only effective way to
factor risk for men and women (Meehan et al., 1991; reduce suicide rates is to actively take the health ser-
Karipo et al., 1987; Kreitman, 1988). It may be of vice to those people, e.g. by using of outreach pro-
interest, in light of this study, that widowhood in grammes. Reaching vulnerable elderly people who
elderly suicide as a risk factor is revisited in relation do not use local services and are at risk of suicidal
to whether they were known to psychiatric services behaviour must be given high priority, as it appears
and not just as a social risk factor. The study found they are likely to succeed at a first suicide attempt.
no significant gender difference in childlessness in GPs have an important role to play in reducing elderly
elderly suicide victims which may imply that the pro- suicide as most contact with the health service by the
tective effect of having children appears to diminish in elderly is with GPs (Vassilas and Morgan, 1994). Spe-
old age. The lack of evidence for the protective effect cific postgraduate teaching designed to help detection
of child bearing for elderly women in terms of suicide and treatment of depression has been shown to reduce
risk (Appleby, 1996; Catalan, 2000; Quin, 2000) is not elderly suicide (Rutz et al., 1992) and may be of use in
surprising and could be explained by loss of maternal elderly suicide prevention.
role due to children growing up and moving away
from home. Of those not known to service, nearly half LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
of men and women did not have GP contact in the 3
months prior to committing suicide. A large propor- The main limitations of this study include the small
tion of suicide victims having no contact with any sample size and limited duration of data collection,
health services prior to the event. Consequently it will which may reduce its statistical impact. It was also
be impossible to reduce suicide rates without active difficult to collect information about the circum-
identification and targeting of these people. It is evi- stances surrounding elderly suicide and to obtain
dent that men in particular are an important target GP psychiatric records.
group with half not being seen by the health services The collected suicide data came from one county,
prior to suicide. Of suicide victims not known to ser- Cheshire, which may not be representative of the
vices, a surprisingly high proportion of 38% and 16% whole elderly population of the UK. The study did
in men and women respectively were found to have not also exclude the interaction between age, cohort
psychiatric morbidity as reported by family members and period effect.
Copyright # 2003 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 2003; 18: 1082–1087.
gender in elderly suicide 1087
Copyright # 2003 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 2003; 18: 1082–1087.