Against Liberalism - John Kekes

Copy rig hted m ateri al
.......

......


.iii ,J,i;I<i~~,jij: ...... I,ii' ...... ",I' ,I'),\-;li,i: .. ,"",,~iI'u, aJl~!Il~i.:~W.-{-:f. V:;j .L\III_'~II~;I

T:M/ N~#.·._ ,,,,,f,im.~;&.<,"""L..

- '--~~ - '~~.~~~!I!'~ '-rJ' l'--~~t'"'-I'!fI:J.1

Z~ Fiw.' "ned' Ufo' ~,~

::; ,,;,.-~. ,_' ',": ,:;:",

,l-._ •. __ J. ....... - .. ,-_,

Ml?ml 'fmdilWn ,and i1Uli'mdu~, Fidlitfig Evil'

TIM MM:_'t;,1 Qj.PlUfaJilm M-_'W~,;jJM ~~ ,It Cau'for' ~~fi4~,


· 'L~'~' lii-BI'····'E' -'-····:R ":', A'-\ 'L' -I '1-' s MI\ \1

.' '._ . '-j. I" 1 .. ' •.•• 1 .' .. _-1 ,.1 ~ ... ' •...•....... _ .. ,',,"""_ .' ,_.'-j .11., ~ •.• '.")' •••• , .. 1,'>. _.

- - --

I HIW]III !I D

"WI\-,:~~[L;I-f:5. ',~'''nm,¥ rig

A .... I·11 ~ fiN _ ~~ ~

,;1;,111 (igIi.h;, ................... [!l':_cepl A..w;. [~rn~oi.I ..... ", j~ .. rfi. ,;ia..,'t~, lJ'lII_ '.' '_ .... 1~I!Clr~1 ~_ .': '. ~MU' '~ln:;.ll '~rr-"'-_U\lI-Y' ~ • l I.--~l .-~~~_,-J U_lIIl

'~ ,'. . ... ['111' _ .,., ., '..... 'od.-.:ll !h- ' .. ,L--

' ............... ' _ pu!U 11ll!f:-:< IIIIIUII: DCn: PI: ~U_ iUl, m..y ,I,UI);IU

Mtmut ,_'I..t- In 'Wl'liIi'_',&om iIhri' NJ'hIb'bm: For

l ' _' - .• - ',~'~~II!!J __ -- - -~ _~. -__ ~_- It-,__ - _-~. '~. __

:F:I .. ~, 11m ~ ~ll 'liTmYelilht:PftM

1"!i , ~""-iII!'. ~~-!U '~_~~~. jliAi"iA[

,£.U_, II',.,,_.·U:II,O' .......... nnc, .. T""" ~ ,iI,""_

I~['''' 'lit.;"';! "00'1

J.J-~ -.~~":F;Ij [1 __ '-

'!ft.!5il~


1: !iN' :Lov~'Ni!lj 'M'EiM:OI:A:,Y Ofl M:Y' ifA'WHER :l{rftltE.s J:H:NO

,ltN:D OiF :U'\!" :FUI:ST TiliA/(;,M:!IUI, FE'N'VO' ,~~'I}OR



1..,1 !lift,v Lfullieranmm ',Ie~ ,2 L'2 :~itit~ ft~, 4

,"',a'

:2 Tte~gJ ,~fl:fii~' 23,

:2-'~ Th~' PtcEWDeiilm' fl!f'm~Z4

:2.J!! 'IIi1.fIDd.~,'iifllIdUJ- ~libC!, ~,~c!i1iic.C!, iDf]mli:"~1 ,261

~ _ ~_ ~ ~ _ __ _ g .~ ~ ~L _ _ ~ ~ iL ~ 'ML ~

,~,l~~viA~'~mW$ti~' ·46,

~J ThJB' UEM :Strnli5PY ,41

'i,;i';u TlIl. 'ri_ii.'Ii - -m _I:' '1:').'::;-1 Aft

~"I:~ A l~_iel ~ll~ex_M:&w1 IW: [~'~t~_ , 7-,7'

;",~, The' f,t1liligftp[1;e1: "'O~,agihrt;' :~'g:Dl~;di~~ ,1)~Om:" 12 !!Uli ~'O V~E.o:n;s, oJ '('h~' hincip:l!e j:7

~c5 ~.tl'I~ ~'~'~'~n~ 62'

,A,' ,""",~J,'~ ... ~, _ _..:ip ......" ....... ,.,.':~..i:J.\!'~

~ lIkItf~-~~IlV~ ,J;ta.!!!!~II~!Il'~2

6-11"

, '

i .. <:-.'


[el J~~' ~nd,lk$m~ ~,20

[6~'[ nll~ ,())~tl~p~ ~!JI jJ'~ti~ ,~',2,1 l&ik:! 'Dis 'Nj\liIll1tie [pf ne~FII: 1:2'4: [i.~ .1~ce and D'e~~t 1,'2;'

'i/~: .wb',':~ Concqti~ I~_l~e ,fJf)[

91 n~',~~~~,d·~~h~ n~1

9' 'm ilrnnaro'I!"llllfel[JU

I!!lL;!}; ~.--,"n-c ~-~~I' -:. -~[ ~:a:-~, 1'~ ~-;'fi C_-;.'--, ,,.J',~,·I:;."·"_··;IL_~;[ !:!!' ... ' ...... ,t.'l .............. U_ (0 ~m.c::~tf aI l~~ ;l!!i!.!iDI~Ga1ilOIil! !oM ,I.l~';!IlII~

'9~3 hi, [~~I,~ m~ '"rg~t.1bi~~~ ,~8fJ

9[.4: 'Ge'W!~ .m:~~t:il!'~ as 'like Jmamkiliu@1l'I. Qf' Ubernfum.

1,M

,1:.91'


c' 1tIii$ ~k, Q :il, ,,,riJti¢i$im! of :IjM~iisf:il., :1:'(.5 p~5i~ ~~, Ih~t I~'be~~ :b Imea:;paiM~ (Jf' ad'li'erlng' i~ ~lVll arilnS' ooca~ lit ~~ riddled 'M~, ilftO:():n-_~s.tIo, .'~IiI(:ie~, ,&mle '01 ,tb;es;e' inrom_!!ittM:eIld:es, IfeJldt :fmm, 'Ih,e ~iHnill '(:~mmltm,~nlt 'm 'MQ illloom:parfribJe ;aios" ene neptlve':r. ~,e' ()'tn~1i pOlbi,~~, "'ItI,C:l n'"Plti,~ aim is 'tn 3,midl ,mijis" ~uClh. as, di~tatDf5hip~ 'iO:f:D.IFC'" :~~rty!' ~iltolte~~'C:,~ :U'ifC'ssl~g!, ,d!~rlm.initioOj' 'taw1:ePQ;~ ,md ,50 f:o:dit, The' :posiil1ve a1Jm~ ~ 't'O ·Cirea~ cnnditi'ons:in. 'w'hilt:h indl~dIJ~Jd~ ,t_ ~ ~,:m.~~ :WF '.~mii' ;se~.

:[jb~nill'lh~Il]{ Ith3Jt. f:irr.!~ r;i!l1lo:m_g' ,tlh~, (::omd~tl\o:m8; is, :irD,OOi~uatl, ~~~ti,o~y~

~ cj,," eh • ~ i£'~ ~ii"" " "d! if' ~ ,;;j;.q.iii... " iii..... t'il., .' 'II.~. ,,"'. ,.iI'" .,.1 ~ Ii"", 'II!.,.

W~!iL~J :~ '~o!il~m~ :,.:.,;' ;a ~~ i~JlI1~~!!!I me :ng'lwl 10,1; In~\lVI,!:Jlu.al!S w' mi!il;i£

:r-ro@li:' ,cbo:i£~ ,3!bO'll!t how' 'lh~~c Wi~~.~ -n~'iaill;-nn: -m :and! :~"~:Hct f,~r tIit'~"r'

"" . " "H" HH H ~ H" H ~.. H~~ey ~~vel' e'l~"~ c~~~ce.~,",", H~~~ ~",,",\peo .. ,"".~ ,~L~

I~m.thiam~ ,aJu!ut I~' of ~~ r,~Ui~~S dtot~ n~edJ. ~d, ~.:pm:~ro~ :p:l~nil-' :~lf of 'Q_mH,

l11c' ,erills '-all; :llt 15, u.,e' :111.~ aim, of ~ij~F3iUi~nI tU 3iliUid are 1~1]s, '~, ,cai~' t'h,~' ~n:_geF pod, :r-i~" "['be ~~ of :3!\!I~fiDrny, 'ij:~dQ\m~, '~gh~" '~~ilI31~"L~ diilimlrrlll:tlve ';m~R~-, 31Dd ":-~"n"'1";ii"m ,iii[r. ... ,~ ;i";o :;;~, ~,'i-.", :", "";'. ':;' :~~, ~~~~_~~!' _H~~'~~_~H~ ~_~tL._..'"C~~~~~, p.~!rI!t,~_!!il= u~t u; g ti;Ue ~I!n,ve mml U.I,

~I"iIJ =s lJ!i!. r..~~

'IT'''"":''"r,''~''m~' 'itA '~,~~i,..,_ .. !~ '~',:-~III""'Ii1-'I"" [L-,",,:j'f'"'ll~~ 't!'r'~ '""if'i'" ~:""~~IHi"'rit: i"~1 'I..=; '-;-:;-::---(C::-~' ~~,dJ.t"'_Ql_~= iii""" ,I;I~~ """,I'",," ¥14iI_JIl!I, ,,,,," I~~ .11_,o!' .. ~ Ib U],'U,~u, ILiD uc ,noo~

:fnr ,~, ~~I., :Lii~~ is ilii~:Qm;sis.te~U, 'kcit~, ~c r.eal1U.1lJl'A ~f these 'IL~kmJ, 'gllle5 ~!i.I!'ld inaeaw; ,~!: I~~lls! liJba~alls, ~t '~D muid ,and, Kml.l~ '.e d~~~ ,~f these le¥j_b, '~p¢'n6 O~ c~a~n,1 oond)i;tion~, c:on~ ItDI tlli;e 'Ii!bc~, vaiW;ch

,An,o~er r-espcct In W!bith libeFa1'i'Sm :I'S incO:IiI15is.teot :~llllr.s :froml 'tile in,,,,

, ... ~.-r;t""'J'ft::Ii·"'~:b"ili'~fV ,....f:., ~,: ... "'" :j}·IL,":'~iII .. o:~ n;iNP:plli~"fo''''''; .... £.' ;i"i!'!I~,·-Il~,tu'" "·'Ii'..,t~:"3-:::; ''''i?~ '0''liJ~IIC=I'I:~-:-;-;-1 ""'~nr~~- . II!U,..., 'V' , IU],'!I. ~_ ,~I,~, '!I..!" _~, .!II.iII'-ZlcL'<l! UJ._!I!~I .. ;" J ....... U'lJiEi,~, alIIilu' ,p'JiI)iIll-!tlU!al!

Mltb'loOO li,Yn" 'bl i!!i, ,d~~~' (If good. ]~ roo, (1f~~ 'c-olfldiJti(Xn:s, till wbJidl, g,~ ,and I~~ :~fl:c:' ~' ~~d, 'with, eqiuaJ! 1~'G:m,~~'rn and fe!5.,;e<m, in wb~¢h jl)j;$~e is ~e:QI '~ 1~¥Q!l¥c' the !f~:!ilb'ijbl!ltlo~ @j relOWCei ~'Ni!th@I.:IJt :~ to 'w'hetner' '~c:i'[' ',[lescot, holders ,and mlDf~ '~ipl~ll1!l1!!i; I~~ ,~,~~;!~~~~~,H~'~ '~'~~~:~n'I'~:'~~';.~'I.~: '~~~~~~~~ iI~~' om~~~'~ [~;~:~j~" ;=("~'~;:~~I ,~~

1IiJ!iII"",,,,,I_, ....... _~,'!j)I ,~_U 'nlilu,l_iI Fiuiliillil.'iP.n.. ,iii' iI ~i:I!II.iII",I""!I!~, I!'OJ' -[f,"~,(j!\n.:lI! Utili" ~~jlnlinFln ",0

:m~, ~P'~i)Ili~"mJ$.


,[,itt\ tnm.$ ,of 'fAils boot 'is develo,ed, '~Il ten C'~-p,teH, Chapter' 1. descriibejS 'tlbe po]'i,ticai~ p~m~ ~,e bMic wiI11Ul!S, U];~{~~oml ~,u3illilty~ Dlh:t~ ptuDlilil:m" and ooririlbu~' jlIU.ti:(l~)I!, ,a!I1d 'rD~ IO~ ,(;(ij~iWI~~Plt, [(auro~, 'O:ID¥'~ ,of 1i~Ol!lbm" [Oha,iteF 2; ;~:e5 that. ,evil, i~ p:r~CHt, &at it ~I~ maillliy rn'O:m, n(!(oout'Ol1io;~,O:M ac~O]]'5j, ; .. ,d, that tbe' p:zd,iJlicrtIJ p~5,[ 'basit; wiUu., Md, C:€rR' 'Co~iittnoElDlt. 'Dfn~f'Q!lism :mat~' ilt m~~ :qther ~, 'tess p:reva.l1eIl:t. The tlu:., oJ Clmpte'l' S :~ ~art 'Ille refluaJlr.)' bold indMd~ ,a]s Fespo'DsJ1blc' :f'@F Ute' evil, tb~F :nO'lliI~~noQmO'udy' (lnl'K' I,ea~, likwBm, 'W,iirl'iOU~, ,ntora1J ,rt'SOlliUJ~ t:o [oo;,c' M~, 'lhiC :m()'!lt f~,ueQt :kind of [~~, [()hat,,~er 4 ::!iih~, ~ 'man}" 'Ilibecral :poilli'Call :P~' pR!!Ui~ tiO:I11ec:." ~ Fe-:~ni!.ibi!li·[~': l'!Jiilitrne' 'the. (jere' 'I~L",,:,~;' [cc·'rnmi· i~· ·ii~ ,.[ i~i(·,<':,·' , .. _

~~' ~L~ ~~J'j, ._' __ ~_ ~ .Al __ ,=.J~~ijg (lO:ITL~!jtme!rnt (0 3N.a!t.'G:noIn,Y ex.

, ..... ~.ll.IIIo . ..;JI~.~_., I. 'it. " ;j'""!1..'''''n .• ,''''' '~if ,l~, , :,....,,·I!Ij..;"f'i~.""'.iEi ~:l.. ..... ,. ~;;-r':'"l ...... ~ .,...rL .... ~ . ...,<:,...jI'i_ .... , t.:i ~1l!.~1 :;-·.r·· filti.~ ···.:n:a;I~ftj,: ,~~,= I·~ ,}",'flt

Lh;.~ ~~. ",,"L~~I!' i\;II ~,,'[~~'I;;C!'!IIUl~ !I!I!~1I~4!,I! .... ~~;I!~.,..r,yQL Q= ..... , _~~:I oILu.F m_~_!1-

,ag,nosiml' dle . pro'bleml it ;a.IDl'S l~, ;am~lio:ml~J prom;,ti1ng' l.ii'~urd and lifi~~r;mis~filt, :~ti¢ie~ :f1;):F de:;diIng' 'wUh it, and ,d.eti~nl dJe' p'W~ :ma d ~raIJ :i_Qe~~i3I~tf, ;amo:ng h.UiOO~, bei'n__g5. 'CJlai,~en, 16, ;~~, " oo~side.T' :an,d, ,uje~t 'tJi~ lilxnl ;()ourepti,on of]usti.~~ an [rae ~oDnd, 'tliiatt ~Lt. ~X(J];ud~ tb.~

, .. 'n" of " In\rle' .0:1.~ . ..t' [iIf"'h' .'t. I" iIi:i: 'ari..:l~srit:" ,·f ~'I:. . ,', ' :. .

~~,-c.e '_"., J~--'-" ~se~""" ..... LII!ia!,p!l!e= ~ pI"_. _Y!I1;i_ a_lu,(:_SMs, CL [,uC' ,lniOO:Il~l~

t'e~c:r' 'lbe~@'n 'tlu~ H~JAd, ,cQmmirt.m.~n:l~ to pluraJii$m! aJii,(i, ,~~, ,t~g~, ,lib-,

~1 1-..-1: f .. Ii .. t, Wb ~h 'i-.~~' 't·be~·l' ._:i\'".~ ..:il t..... ,0" t " .. ,\..

[e~,!IY ~e,.: '~~!iIf~ '.:,_;c:en I~~~t:' ~1¢ ~~ .. ,IJ,!d)t ~~~S[ iili.m;u ;ialUJruno:m,y oon~;I'I}C: 'M!.l&iI.

"'.' ,,,,,":,,,'I,~i~·, .... ,";""'iI '~';"""~'I~~ ~: ...... , '1~1i-- ..... .-,.-~ "':-~il.~ ,;o;'If""",,~'II""1 ~~-m.t--:l ..... '"I';''' ~::I;IliiL..~,......['1 •. ~ .,,-_~.~,.,._ ,.11ll'C',1, '1IIlI. '!'tidilJIl!IIAii-llI!, [LUIG ,IIJi.JIIC 1I.!iIIJI VHllll~., ",_lllu,uL'U 'U'~'G., .u.., 1!lI1I!IE I1Inn [uc'1 :l1l.I, onc!.

,eha(p,:t~r' '9 ~:'.il;;J!m.b1J;e"s· ;~d s.h~ 'the :r-ai'liw:oe' 0:1: 'the ~1it~\Pt 'to base likMd:i.8:m, [00. ~11~l~ilii~':, :[Q!th~' than, o.~ ~~ :l1l()~ ~luJ1 bn!~. :If.-o.,~~dl!ij:.

Tilt '" '~!'b~ 'I" '" • -..:I '" r'!L. '11;ii1i;

-,b:~~e case agil!l~_d: ~IJ~nl~ lliS m:mmM,I~~], n~ '--!Ii~apter' ,!i.U,.

:Liibem:b~' :1liI~. Un~ of dde.il!~ ~~t i)!h~se (;rij'tic~ 'Wln 'be' tOl de~' ~~t

iibiP.1i" l~oI'1i;l~ :i"i!.-1ri~ ;~t<tor'l~~":"~ i",,", ''''''"''m. 1i~, ;'!iC'. i"'If.',.,r,..,,4:'"~I'\"" lI">oIIir\P~1i'V :t'~, 'p'l"n,"'!i..1":,,, =r=r ~~~Q [~l~ .. ,=,~L!,,!!~ M!MIr~b!~yt~!\:II!II'I!.lI' ~~"' __ Jr. I'll: ~_Q 1._ljl~'ill~I}lu\llL'_ ~.~-~1' ¥.IJ.II L. -tIIV-III!·""~

[~~~:ll'JJ.~ dJtamnfllS. 'Th~' :~m adopt'Gd ~5, ~ Ic~tatiuns In di~' 'text ad::r. van~e the deKripllve 'M tdti:cd iEWc,otiin'tS, ,()fwhi~b !thq aJtie pam, They au' 'tmi~rn as st~,PS :io, [th~ ~~n~ ,31Ild ,th~ir' ;SQUr(::U ~p'~alf in ~i1Jf:i~~.s. Ci!t.a!tiQ~s ooU!e-(:ted ;M :notes at dl't: end [Ocr tbe' 'boo!l;, suppon: it'he ~urilmlion of ~~l)Jl'~' v1I.~ '00 :,ankuilaw h~Q:FS., :b-ad~, 'geed 'm [OO:~lt 'l1!he :nOle~ 'therewre':! [Q:n]y H' d\'Cf '~i't. ,~den{de 'thllt the ~triblUlo:.OiI, iu ~lC' 'le:-:lCi; H~' ,aoG~mte.


(!P'Fii~~c'Crog~ PPJ1c~l)Qn. 'U'[i~ty :Pf1~ 1993); ~d. 'Oh3i'~' '9.1 ~!il, PQrilionl, of: ,u:Benm'!Ol!e'nc~' A 'MlimO'r ·Viirm.u~ .", ~ PlIii:,runNI~ [anti Aili~ 4,

~~_-_._. __ '_, ' __ ._. __ .....'!J. __ ._~_~_t_.~[!!1 ,,', ,_--~ .. _' .. __ ~._,., .~.~. . __ ' '_._.~rl';/'. - ._.i~Jr.. ,

< l"[1):: :2[1,,-..., 3Ddl. 'i.\~'&i¥' _d U:be:wlsm~ 'c! RtM ll6 0:006):. ·g,34.'CC4Ht WBl1~~ Mailo50U- 'LolLIits Po~maill- and ,SDen Qa1u~ uad .~£ [entire __ ft-

.". _ _ ,'. _ _. _ .' . _ -J11 '.. - - I ~"'- !!II' .. _ _ .••.•. _,. _ _, _. ,. ,'. _ _ . _ . • _ 1. _ .. _ _ _ . _ J _ 1

~~p,i'_ "i"'1!:-~.~!"". ,""oi'"foo'~'1'1"""""'"""' L-f"llped. ~"i"'. '""....,~ ... ~o ~~~'m-, ,-,...~[~ ... ~ .. '1"F""4'_'_ 'I' "'~

~.ll.J . !liP. .1 II~~ _';I] '1.!_Ut.J.I_II_II_II_ ...... !I~.j!ftJI ll::bl..1 . .. _. ~ ~-~.],I! ~~-~ !ll.}!110!1 __ ,""!llY.,!IIoI!il! "~8_M~I~~~.. l] !RoII_~_.l

~ ,_:

e~hlI!ly ind~bood '00 ~~n.i$! de~led.! ,~.~the,tie 'yet w~gb~_nded crimcisms.. ·Ij.;,:maitiian ·hj·;w;diLe'. · ... 0011' Silmon. and "'~~6 Il~iba (l0'~

. - • • - _. - - • I ...r-' - - -. - - " ,'- - - _. [!i , . - .. -. . .... ..- - , _. - ~ . - ~-II-I.'. -. . - - I . 1 • - ., - - ,

_ _

:~en~dJ ,0:11 ,parts, 'of' the· :q~.iW!(:rlpl. It ~. gl~atdbll. f:b-T liheb' ge~em~ :lelf.· Nnn~ ofdl~m~ h"~il'~ ,~'hm:lld be ,sllIIppoKd, [to ~du~ my vi~'ws:, In. :ract~ 'they' ~IDorr* d.isa~: 'wi~ ~l' of melin, It is 'eve.~ moore' W, ·.e~1I [creclJt;. th~~ro~!. W ~. ·b~lc~dI. [tQ '~pr~ 'm~m, '~,'bt;,

V;i!W'I' .r' U'~"""n h .. !fl,. _. 'i;:.~n [i;~ ,_..:Ii'"" r"ffi ~ • ...,....,' iii, ... .' iL-"1''l''''~\'': 'jI"'i;., [ '. i,," .,' ~~~e= =~,~ __ =M ~OW ~e __ U~e '!O;'.,I,b,iQ_ 0:1, !l.1~·'I''''''' o:~. ,m,~~~" ,I, .Ijl;e;re ~

0'1-= - • ..Ji~"'-"--- iL.:"',~-.--_ .i.'b.-. -. 'iIb..-_ L_._.·.·,- . ·-··:itA 1-. .... ~h· .. ,-A ',-,.' . -, -" "" u'- .. ""':

~. el;.l!!~~' lpt:u..e:r IYI!~. lile\,. I;H!I!t ]It 'W'Q1lI1Q Y'Il; [Litglll. to .Im.~e om;c., ~ ~e;,

wit- ,in:t- .... I~i'lH!n.....".,- . .,.-fij;o-o-!l"'-I1;ni!'_ :!:I;II1'o~ ""-~nP'.-Ij' li'Ii!!;~d\"~i"\ia;", '",~, .IM;~.~,~, "lit ;i!!i!lli>ll'lJ' ~m·...:I1

~._.~-~ =cJ~~"""D~==~:1! ~~-'!m\'J~~-~-t ~I ~!I~' "Ir-~""'~".J iii. .'_L_.~I~. _jW'll_~~~ J l[l~i~'!IwJ ll~I::._~~ l !I .. ~_._..).' ~nJ.U

·1l'ii'1~a.sant Ito 'tr:aa1lfhrm arll! irm.'5um.'fi'fm'iJ'!Il ~1JsftI 'fnili:ll<-r-M""--:"'n:t "n!t(jl dttl: 'i:'U\~ .

. ~' ",' .. ... . . . ,'. - - . .. - .; .. - . - . -- -, - , . -} 'J' ,. , , . - ,0 ,.D(l-. .1 ) - - ., ,t"""'"

,e;nt '~k. 'MlCtrher ·~t :~ ",ow' 'WC'll ,e:m;Oo~h :[OC!iMd. ~. '0.1' the Iiead!e:r 'm sa¥.~

'iff : t ·;I,i~"t-·· :"~ .. ': ! l.."':"iIi,... ... -- ":'lr-: 'I ' 'l~", -', ' , ,', , !t,'-': ;: " ',-",,': ',..;I ~- , :-;')1,-_ ,,~- - ,~"'!!' ",,~, 'u',- ,"~",.,., ,'?: " --:1'-,- .• ~;.' _.

~U ,",,~iI h,. ,1_iS !.[II!;1Iii!IA.[ 1;iI1Ian ~" was .IS ,'0 a OOfUI-~:n.lJlJ',I.Cl: ~x'll.lG.n!ll. .n:i';J'U.o:n ,S uum8'I"

'!i;l'v .i~~'_ 'Li;_";i:'Ol Y 1L"' ... 'b,~,_ ' ...... dl 'nro~ .... ,::_. "i--,,",~ ~ - ~~t,. .~ - ,..'-r- ~'I' ~ I'~, ~:-:,_C\~~. --c-,~ ~'-l;-~.-: ,m'l ,",'liI~.r''''''lilJ :1;. ~.......,~ ,IJG - Uillml~ W]I~ WOFIK DJ], 'OlIE m3)liUSCr:ljp'" ~E!'J_.e

.~. -', . -, ''. 'iiin . " , , ,': ','.: [~';:' ~}i.." , ", --- ['d--'lit-;': .'. :'[ [ ,- :b- _ '!"". lb-" .' t :', '," : l]'~ ii..-- [..;11 . _:. .1" .o:iI '''~_:l

~l c.reia,l'L",R ,ma!.l'l:Y U'A, !liUC oonh ... QnS lin. W, [I.e,. rt OOUL'!JI, .~ none, iilillu llIi.Iit.U!

:!iitite he·ILf¥I!d. 'W! dOl :it ~ 'lbten~nB' '~li.e n a~ to Dl!\!' 'I'uouib.ratu,o~s· I' arm '~mnt~aF

-~-- -- ··-.r--- .... - ... JJ .. ~/T ~ ... - ~. i!!l!' ,r--:..-·-, _l -1,'" ... - -.,'- lI._ ... __ .1 _. I •• __ •• 1 •• - - - .•. _J

:$W$bty lnd~b~ t-Ol :b~r love·l, lIUPp.li1!, ,aru!I, 1000 sense ,Glt this ,~on"

~n .",. .. [ ..... p .... ;t '!:Iin,A '~j~·ii.l ]u .... :t. :·1· ... 1H'a"- ·!IiU"t· .................. ",., ~ j'.~~~ L~.~'-jl IAIIllr'tllLj! '!rIU al ~ }y~~ l _~11. 'j.'~. __ .~t.J!1 l·vlIi. ~ ~1I,~_L~lil

JTH~ ~ lWwffnt



CH,A,:~TR:R :~

'WIui'''': ~ 1'" /1;' i~1 >. ",

I _', ", r V.- I,'.: .' :'ir. .'.' I::~" ~ - .":: I, . -l(~" - . : '>;'

_·l_:I.t_~.~·_,_~, . ~,.r ,_._ .. ~ ' ..• J .. _._~ .-'_' ',' •. : ,II

,A -d~i:sruM1o:n of" :tiJbem1lism, ous"h!t b~)i begin 'whih, a, d!efi'Dlj;tm~ mat identiilia a ,set o£ imOOeJ&ilIl' and luf~ici:@m)t oond~tiu;ml Ihait WlI, '~m:i:on5, of Ult~:ra1!iMn ,m,1Dt meet, ht IiJJO ~s!iJC'b :se1;, ,eXists" wbtiJ¢hl :makcs Ube.raUm elu~,~ Thb l~l.';k u, ,~'moWl~d 'by nbent.h d~e~'lVe~.,'!" :hl 'gC ,~~~C of' 2, 5atkf~ory' '~nirlie:n~ il1u~w~r~ no ,~ri.d~iDD fir j,u~iiifljj;;3iti.Dfi" ,€31D; 'b~~' to

~j~"lU' 't""': ~1'liI '~_i ..... ~ .. ,~f" '1,~II.,"".."...liiiiE~, Th",~' i'iM~;oo.~~ 'p" ~~ii: .. iii;li'D" 1itrin'Ii:'i.i'"fo;O!'Io;i!!''L. ,l':I;f~'!Ii_, 1III1F'\rlJ'f !Ij.u .... lll ·~~.JI"'L-~._~~ Ul" ,lll~l,dLliiiJlL~I'._'J [ - [~ ~_.L-'!U!i:Hi. l.·1J UIJIJUABIJ_~ ",-,rli"u.":IIiI!.w_lIil, .... IF"lr...,l.Ii,IJ ...

~"f"l '",,~,_ ~'''''~'''~'O.<I'''''_ ''''''I" -P"':'r'nosI" "'"'1010 'i'I'I_'jj,~IITII"i"""~"'lit,'~'1" ~iL... ... ~~ ,"'m- - b- ~'-"~I ,i">.! 1'jI;'>"'~~' '''h!>'~, I"" ~~ IIJ~l""l, 1[3)Y.,I,'~J' ~ L .'!Ur~~ _iI. ,~ - i! .... ,,,., r~ ""' __ ""'0121, U]_g)j. ..... - - - ,~,~~ ga ~~"""ill ""- ..... ~=

~~Jl! oflibemli'Sm as :poujWe:, 'wbiil~' :[~~tJiy, ;aekllowledpn_g' *3'£ mttre' ver~g.n~ may iti;1II, 'be' '1m 'out, gd, [that. olihe!f' iQk~ti~M' are ;aII~ ~ble'., '1111F1-'- ~~'n :-I-~:C'-- ;-'_ :-- "'1~ '1;:-7"' '"iI1r ;-cc-- ',- cL 'if;.."I'I'- ~--1 '1[-- --- _

=-~3i1;. ~_, M¥ ease, Wl_~~ I!J!!: IllII,C ap"liiOaCu, "',U,_!JWe.u, nere,

'he ~'bjee~ ,of' tbiS! (l~~,te\f' ~9~, tben~ _ ~~teqtt-etaCio:n i!lf UbercaUsni. lit

-~>---'·n." ,...;; ... 'i.1 "'" -~cd~"""''''II''II'I''ri',"' "I'Ii~,;i;'1.._, !"~~":,,","'Wj'''' ,~t:"~·I'I'i..~ ....... ;if·I-"!I"I!'I1 '-I~,;;ij"_ '."""mC,C;O;' 't'un'I- , l~6.~ili3! !1'!lrIIJU;1J ai, lUIJ ~_C:IJ idI_._,!Ioo ...... ~_I"II!L. ~IL !ULI~I~ __ IILI_UI,~!U.'!u.·-.IUI_~ OJ: 1_ ~IJ idI_t_a-'il,IJ_IJ~, , ~I_i:l~ ~ - ,"!I;;I ~t ,r ~

QIJ f~bc~ :p~"I~b.~" :pr~,,~ tOE, !~~" ~nbiiat [~riptiQn. CllFdt~ '~k; va!lj'U~" tIINtt ~nl"im th~, 'P:~5~1 ,aJl~jl di~n d,ii.KIJj~ th~, 'C-O~ of' 1~'I:ie~ ~sm:J 'w.hi~b iP-~d~s, 'thE ~lll~m3itl!i :RiDOn :FOF m'C lKW.c 'v.1!IjJj~5, mJid, the po:l'I!ti? mIJ 'p:~5. :lil1, :Iakr c!tmp~~ :iindii,Yiih:miIJ :liioom. dlinHn 'w.I], be ~n.ppd -.d pe~t~r' ~pth. ''!QU. 'be pr-Q¥i~d, I~ .m, 'be ,em!phii~"21ed ~ 'gat Wtin 'Ent~~ :~ only on,e' poWJbl~' Injt~i:3!ti.on., To' amid :FepefitiDn 31!td '~r' _Iify" 'iii?~ibenill8nlJ~'~ :ft(Jm U'OW Oil ~i!u :f:i\leiUi, tbis :~ll!~i?~t31tion" 1'I;:i8; 'f~ to th~ r~da' 'm '~ar' :m, m.in-dJ tih~t, lQothel" :m.'t~t:p~tartiDn~ ~ :,u$5~bI\e. The


prCK~U Olile~ 'h~r~, is me-a,t. ·to 'be' broad. ·efiDUlb '00 include mOM. Wr-' 81 ow· oJ [c'O'Dlem:po:~' ibera)~ ..

ThE bistory af II'Mn.lJiMn has, b:iJm£t:'tO ~n .. 3. ;stnry of Sllmt"D. :~t be:pn, durri.n.g ~te' :h~c':e as a -reactiun m· :re1ligjiotiS o:rtbodJoxyll' pined ~tre~gth. dl!mqgh(J;l)iI~ the hWH!Aat1o:nt :and! '~C3!jjtJc:' (i):m:e of dL-e :main, poUMc!ll :fu~s, brl. 'tl~e Hn1j,lhJMnm~llit. ['n m~ [OGrtH:'H' of' '~M, d~]o,,..

'm.""»~· ~ii~"",I!"!'I;'lliiC'~ 1I1"i'~.~.:I ;!liUl,a.I!' :"lIo-r;lm' be "l[nD 'm .. ",,~Iiu:!:I; 'n~t;~ ..... , '1'I~.~~tI· 'l'li1l1!; ~11\'1 • ..:i1 , __ r'?l.r.II_1I11I,;1I I_II~II HI_I.:UUIJIii, IIJI_.~-IIQU Mi~nr _ t ~_.lLV-i __ , "l -I-"ID . __ r'!lrll ~II'" 0& l.~Ij-~'Di""W1'!~ l.lL ... ~_ }'~IUI !PIII_.u

.~. ~. :posi!~' :I~"~itkail ~~~ that oo~ll(l; be 3ippeaJed 'm ,~ an aJ.l!e~~ ~, to ,aliI [~S, m- a'Mo:I'Il!hli: :aIlJthor.:iJtJ", It Ite.adily @xpatIld~d, h~ 0pposltii,on to the di.rine :Ftgbt Qf nt{Jp~b" to ~t~~.c ~. dwved. :I1r(lm. fe-udal timesj. aDd. 'then to ;a1I~ fOr..ms [of' o:,pr.~o;n, whe~er it be :in ~t .~ja ... OWlnmm T~F-b'y·!. l;ihe Comm~ ~c:~ tJol():FiJ![ :F~~, s~ pd .

. iI' ... ~[~~. ·N·'~~·I ~~rm··i<liniV. [ .... l" '''i~'' [i!l""\~~ ....... ~ ri.. ... ' "..\i'i,;it.-., .... ""'~ .. _ U~"i''i-. ~'ir-e ·~..,.m[tl..,.,. 'iIJioji:'

JilLdLlI1 C!i l,"_ &.£:I. I ~ ,[ .; .; _iAl-I~.I,r:r. Y"i I ...wl~ 11! •. JtIJ·~~,~-~· v..:IL IU~I!Iir. ~"VlV"lll!I~'!I.Imr. "1!'~/~::Il IUll' .. , ~ ~ ~l

'~!' :~t ~, biroOM~ &tli· dom~lt. :i~ology' ·of ~_ tiim~~ [i)jl(i' :Sign ,of whim h that: ~n ib [D:p~~gJll!i. g~' oo~c'h ·theiJr defeg~J of 'the :~JIle!il' they :ra~r in ,~~~ .. ~ ·~~t ~~~~ :h~ ~~~d. ~~ po'l~ do..

[CO'Ur:5e.

l.JbemlliMm. ttan~nds na~o:na!l·bon1.e." and. !historical. ~rlo&~. dr:aw;s .liB

r~iI,.;o;>iIi":""~-' r~m' . 'm, "'"';'>~' ]a.t1i'Q'lIMIIQl'PA:_ 'l":"'"i'i)Q'I· "I'io.~;OO.. i<>ID -'I .... ]i<>II ... ""'";oo,.. i<>\':'"·dl :1·'0' ·iI'\"'D·.I~, ~..ii"'[

iUiiI_n,'!I:r~ !!I.,~_~J!I.i:J 1;ll'V'i __ , . IAI ...... ,.. l _Y-Io~~,_Ior.~1 .. !!Iir.1_~ IVilj"_~~1 ai, _ U ~ -~.Q!l!i !AI-II~II ._ [ __ iu.;-, _ ~ i~


immc~K~Y 'l\PJH'idiim;g' ideil :~ tb~t :~~mC;il'U, Q~gbt t~, be' aJble '00. j~' "'"il' dt" ;, " '"k ,;, d"I' "d"1 '"b 'h;"1 th"I" 'bj"1 • d" b" b"' iIy"

,t ,·· .... 1,'"" ,",,"~; ; "",.".-Ii!U' 't"?: [I' '.~. i"1;1i( 11'"1" "1'" . I '~ ,,'~ "l~ I: 1·· .... 1'"" iI',~~ ": '_";00; i"'i""'J .: ~ J' .. it 'iii .. "" ,...-1 . ':'

... "" ,I, !U!!I!I" "'V.~ ~"'j!' !I,Al!! III. J '" InOIO ."''!!'~ . !I.M'I .. " ''I'I!' , ,V' ""'""""" ~,", !It!l!l. '. ~!t.;J AiI!I, .. , ~ ... QO. !Ii I I!ii' villi"

K~~le' j;udI_Ieation. i5, 'that. th~ rl..ghts, of iDd!i~d!na'!ls, ~ 'ktt« :~'O-'

't, .... ,""..:I1 .~ '~':'Ir-, ' . ''''. 11m : f " " ' iii':" [l'hilr: ,,'. " , I , ,'." , ~ '. " " "t,,..iiillll : ,",'i!-:-I .' 'irr-. ,~'t Q,.-~'IiI!r.'~'- ~,r lJI!~e ~",e~ oem J;m!",,(le ,~.I'lel!.'! ~emDle!lb,. ~1'l1_~:S ~~ialIl ~,~"~ ~Jih,

'.~' co~ 'hi of fQi" 'UiIlIllIer dJifFere:ort :~pHlenib,

The' ,cceH!~ il.~~c.'e' 'tlh~l, 6~ralJism iIi~inil~s, 'to irtd)iwd'!Jai~ i~, at"e:a!tI~ ~nhatll£M I ..... , ,tii~ ~fk3l of:8i1l~DFU1~m"" 'f'o:rmtl!]3i~~ ,~, 'l"mm:mUlrdl '~l]Jt

~~ ~ . ':J .. ... ",. '" ,. ,u,! . . .., ., ., .. , . ... I' .",.. . ".., ur ' , . J", , " :J

wb I ,,", ' ,'in i""i;..;i " ... '. " ··t"irO'fI) f " .. ~ '~JI . " " ,.Ii , ." ': .... " '~.? I, " ,'." 'It"~"i':'lili~: '1 .' . '.' ..

~"ltQ 'was ~ 'M;!L_S1 resp« . ~~~UlCn«~, ~]"ean;-J:avqu,e5 ,1:'!oU~3iU,. ,DoIU~'liilan, au

'~n:Qr~'Y' may' 'i!)e, '~l'Ident~ ,~ '~e <::Qmd!iiti,Q~ :in wbj~b. im;diridt!iails ;~' free :Fr.--onlJ ex!tefOaI! detefrn!h:la~~n! mch ,~ ,c:oer.-cl'O~", fQj-¢~t. ~F ~O:Ul9i :f0'~ ,of

illhr-:--";"'~' :- ",-;li, 'O!n<i --:-"II'iL ... ~~ il~ '~Ilr- ~iIr"'C ~ ',' :", ," c "" ,~: "yO, : ~. ," --", ,"~ ,ti[r "", .',<b.: .' "

_="C~ _~ =!iI[t~~i!i~,O:~~" ~~e= ac.~OD_8 ate e.xe€:UJuOllILS 0.. !I. lilli eu' !!1:uOtCe!!,

llheJ' are aiI!KJ1 :fir-ee from, i~{(eO)aiI: 'C3JUgj iQf]fuemc-e:s IIllat. .ec~ dI~irn' ,chm€.'CiS

~fLii'--:"'di1\.' '"'-I--:-·--:·---:-·iF~'I~'·=·..J, .4i.-'-:~---' "" -.--">.">", ,C"" .," -'"'"II'.:I~·"·";, - c . .:I .. :1-..";;' c 'C-~"': ' ... UbOu'I:!!IIII, UIJ.~--onIUiU'f I.~ llI.e;s][[~~ p~QnSf~ OF .p:r~~U!I~S; i!J(O;U. 1~: • .c~F 'C.uQ.l~~

,Be ,c-O:li1itJtoU,~d by rea.w.fll,. 'U'r:id~Bt~, :as, c:o:oJ:o:rn1iiJty '~,O Dlf;iliKrnalI~~'b:I~

'.' ~.

prinQipl~s.., :~t 'lxiti~, ~tlilI3!t. ran :htlllimm 'K~Iti,g$' ,ai)C ~q'lla~1 ~~ *e~f ¢'a~lty

r~r :a,'_uu~omy;.; ~t :mt;x~, :~~PQmIsib1iUlty md hu~ 4,~ty oofb 'rest: all this ca:pac:ii'~ and [that .fiW~t;y rnqjuiiif.-CcS :~,~ct :Q.F '~~ne' ,c~~ble of ,aill!to:m~m,~'~ :H~' !lJlius ;arti(;Ul'I3I~ tJb~ ~d.ea, tlilJ8!t '~fidhvi.du~s ~' c:nrtiifled t'4ll'

- - .... '1 'Ii...~ ,,"' ,.,:1:.., • ..JJ'..' ilk, 'b '" 'b '"

PflI!U:l!l, RSil'~1! ~c._a1~ 'OJ: ly~eD' a~t~m-'V" '1!mt'C~,I}~re:tl()e 'Mt~!1 W 'Ie, 1:5, ~

'''!''''!'~I --·-r·~-- _. -- .. ~.- .. -" .. !"'!l .~-. ._._ •••• ··-_JtI~ l_.l .. - ,[1. I. _I."- •• , l __ • _l l __ ._1

~'OJ~ti,Q~ Qf'.~ ~'~I)ute, :m~F3!l, proli.jbiltiO<Jl,

j'O:hn, St.ltWlln. Mi!lI~1 ~nUtu:~.m;cGd 't,' ,klEljam~D, Coill!9i!airtt ,and, '\WUhe:lm V!ll)~ H!tlnlbQld!t~ furF1lh~r· ~tfl~gtheD,~d, :lil~ism. '~ '~.1rgYi~g ~t :~t :~ Hlorallly im:n.P.fmlsSU,'lc· to irllle:Ili'Cu' 'wi!tD 'tJ.i~ aClUOmiS, ofindmdWl!ls, '~n if ~~~ ~-~,-::_,

, ... J:"'_ '" ..... - "' ,. ..,., I. '" "....., .. , ,'. . . . , . ,. ",' '" . "., '" '" y !il1fti

Din":""" teA }ru,"if . liii:;:n~:I, ·..It.,...,,~; ;<oil.·.;1 "'! ""~~' ' ." ·; .... I~ i;: ..•

~~__: _ ,~q~~!Ill!. ~'t ..1l'a~(L=--~, ~e5W! I!I.iI!O!Oil,'f,e, 0"Ii!UPI,ujl o:r em.oU!I!f:' oonSlU'Gtrih:;"QI115,

-rnVided iIl-o Iv ;i.'k,,,,, .. ';"\..i.'r' . ,,"':n ,..:I~ '.', ' '''', L .;Il;~, '~."]~' '''', b" ., p__; .':"'~"...:.,.:.. ''::t'!:...c'!'t IMi~ ~~e= ac~o~s !y!!J iIiIot u:.a.m1 Olllll.eIiS., ni:I! .~l!(dill 1m Ilu I; . ,a:ve-

p~t itJ ~l~~I~m, ~ O'.PO~ tOI dte ooeOOt'Uil! ,eve~ 0:1 ~o:m,'~U.!l~Jl;O'~OU_S ae[i,OM" ,jIBt :50" ~fi1].g :U, ;i£utliiJ ,adl'OIl'$, ,ar~ oompatJ'hle lrith the ,il!uJm~O'mo~ :m n.eti-on ifill' of OrghEf ~nd:t~dJlJa'I" :M:iU ,th~ CiJ,,o$iC"d 'paWmraJl~ti~ blllwder-!. '.n :inile ded m" '~,,~ fh' ,., ,d~' "~dmd H:' ~"':--"---c"'""~"'l ,~";-, '~ ,-:; - [[b-::_,

e~~~e ~~~ il:L ... ... ~ lt~! j, U1M, ,~. .~ U.P,PfiS-IJUUIl! was .., on , . ~

'Wide'ih..' ;ac~:ntedi '~iL""-rl'l Vi~ '~''iri!lift ~n-..:ILi,w..:lL.;.~'II~, :~~, '1~1L;~'I:v ,t,~ kn w' '~""'i"'''i' .... b~,.·

.·.'~~·~~l' ~~·~-~-F·--·~' ~~IJ~ __ -~'Jl!! ~~Ai!l.' ~~~-~~~-~:_,~ 9!"Ir '~.-~~JJ' ~-~ l. __ ~"· ~~ Ul __ g!l.l

iii:, g~ :[01' th.em .. , ,~d, ,eve:rn, 'if 'lJihey' atre :rnistake~~ j~ i$· be~r iQ ~,e. :oo~g' rtm, w ~I.O"W' them tQ :ma'ke; ~id"~ ~UJ !~O '~Q;ve ~, ~fn:me.~t i'mpose

"'(Il~ .. ;I~""1iffIl .... .,.._-riJf'-~ .... m, >t>t! ~lb •• a'--"":"-~ '''''0"', ,.:L"",.,..,. 0_ ~ I Dlll~1I11 '!Id-U'i.o.'~~F""~.".J ~IL l!LI~l~ Dt~1 IIJ.!", 0 , IU"l"-"~'~.

~ tb,el¢ 'h"rld' blt1!~ii'i:tal :iJiemtik5, mK@' ~vi.d@iiltJ ~5Sej],tiBI 1.0, :li~iHlIDiDm i~,

th,@, m,OD~ oCFiltj-cism of ,(I)i£t3!t,grihilf~' '~I~ ~F~ :~Il;'~Je:~~e.. FelP're~ ,si:OJII~ pe~~tlIO'Jl, bwleg_IlI;e~ and dL'f:' mpp:[\ess1!};1l, o:f irnd'i,viil;uails 'by eni)lf.~lrl~h.~d, (xMliildoxlie:!!l, ke~1'I1 ;_d, ~orailiity~, QmJ ~e. side, n{ 6kmh ~d, ,~t. [tha' o.~~e'Iii;'U, j~. '~g, mm;:all, c___~'d,m", lndect;, one ~f the aW5ie[S1 ,Ott:' it'lltil: mlump:b ,of likmIJi;sm i!l, 'that. ~~ 'has atl:J'a£mn ~c Wl~an~· ,oof'm_y 'of thore :idi, tOQ H!.wmem~ ,pe~,ple 'who balve S-!d{~red aJtul ,ax,e ~uff~rning' '!Wfiodei: rep~ut~ r-c,_m.es.,., M ,adequarlle poIiticaJ :mi;J_mjj~'j' :I!tow,ever, m'ml:


offer mote' WM ~r,aI [criddml, ~!:'i, :if~t,[Ij~nli~~njtly,~s 'w:bat ou:rb1t '00 be ~,po~.

:U'ben:liMn, ,al.so :almll! to develop[ a, ~g.w, ID~O:~' thru; ~1)n,e~n:tra'm en ,po!li!dcSl---Q~ '!J!he ~U~ ~at 'cm.ght '~O ~D'iJ [th£ :po:lilti'Call, :iil'lstil"Duons 01;3; ,000.""lt);iI!o '~'::;~~-r"~illim :!l;II1'~ ,+ .... ~ ,i,'i;-.~n~lI![ nf n(iIIUti)r •• ;I] iilM)WIKr d~Wcr' m'a' 'lh""

[~~L_IW.. JL.i.I~LI.m_1.iI! __ , ttlillllIIt~l IJ Ilvm UJ_'-~l1!..!IJ! L.I~~ y~ lr·~'=='Iir.'~ ~-~ __ ~ -~-~1 _.~. ~ _ ~ ~ - c~

v:;d~l9i th~ fa,VOE. Th~~ dilfF~l'ien(lcs!, h~~ reflJect u~ ,evc~ deeper eae 'oonc;erni~g ;~~.t):n~, a'lt~).l!Irt :hrl!llmm :lljil!1iur~ ,and c-~n(ieElnin:n8 [~.d" a 1''OOdl, ~ilf:c 1m, .aG'O(Zlillance' wl!'tb 'which. lihe ~.~ gd plUrticaJ! ·values, rat(:l' m.~fi to be :fgm~l\a~d, ~d.j~ult~.

T~e relleva!n:t iliiberail ~Uim~~~~ ;u-e' :wane' exp'~u;;ilt. :~n ~E 'wtl:owilng :MP

. . '" ",'air '. "'. ti..-..... ~'l._ '1i.SiL.~,='1 '1[=,,"-, 'I'~'L 'n~ 'Ii 11] ntl.'O,

r~ntli~' ist.a:t£:ment!h" l~fl!tJji)K ~i,y,g me l!Ii~tcid!l, ,..e~~ .J!wiin ~W!lS, ~.Ii.'~O;'!;

~C"'~c'\ '·'d'. iOlicilli.'.-";ii!!,_, ~i'[.''''_'' 1'Ji1'Y'i;'L.'Iii"",...-.; n""' '1~;I·ii..-~l;;jI!m."ii; ~II! !~H!io'Wll' i:jjj ,ii;;' '~Iij";l"''b,!I!,~, ,."'l.."",," Xl';'V.I 1I_:__ ~LIlUIL~~ U_I~ rIILUW,IU.II~I=ll ~I, l _ )~Illm_li_ .. _ ~ ~ ~jJ ft'IYi!,,~r~, ~Ib ,F -:b--~~;gcfe ~~-~

,thl!!R: e.~uts, over Cilm--e1 ,a. ,~ta;blc and jTIst. S(Ki~q of :rr.~' ;an,d, ~!f~al c~tirtens :profollll'itd!I,y di~ded by le~nablc' rcngiol!U~ p'l1nto~hkaiJj~, and maw, dOCtill~~i' ,And, speaki[1il,g :[wm '.e' 6be~ rig;bt! Wt1liiam GWi!t(ln, {I ~lb l~-ln ~! i'Th~ 'Ii!bera,l, 'cDnoe,tiOl], o:f ~"e ~' •• ' '. mlOwtl, f.oJ:' a l'ride .' ' .. 'n:]llLFa't~ ,~O:!'l1it wa~ 0:[ Iffe. lit ;~l)l!rnl~!!I, ~31t iudiiIWil)md\5, :hraft :5lmiPdi_3il '. .' .,

r' m ;1·~ ,r-~

:iln~lBbt. '~_flit:o tbeilr 0'WlI, g'OOd. '. '. '" [T'Jhc :ll:be'nlI, >aGOOlllfIJ~ (if IrIi(i: h'~m.a:o ,good, . '" . ui1id.e~rds, ttt~, :t!ufJidaim,enlal cQ!fi~de:mwtu'~s[ , '. " o:f dbilrlJbtwtJ;ve',jl;L$~

'. -. ,~-. - ~ ~ ~ '-ib .. ~-=1i·'· • dl .,.~'Il· b" -. _.it..,

wJItbm ,lliJilel"1l!l, Qx-o:e!ffi. '. ,. '" L]IOO:f.:uilSm :1S [CGmml'tt~ , to, ~'1~uJ.', ]~~n lit ne~

[tt'X.'(l~la~Ji1;r.(i:, '['t ~ c~m:QljY:ed, '~O :Il:reed.o:w,! bl)l~ itt, :l'tf:eds, 'viinu,~, .. !i!

Tb~' aml~,tiQlll$ ~ba;t ~~njt'e. ,dJi!lfere~~ 've~i'Q:m~ gf :tilbemU~m ~'" 'tbt'!l1IJ~ ~~t ~ l~betaIJ ~ ~te' i!!~G!wd, 'k' pidEd 'by 'W\l)u@s ~at :reileot. a pl~~~' of' re~~iJ!blte c:o~ce,tion~ 'm- a .lood li(~,~ ,pmmnJt'tt' die' :rre~d1o;m ;md. [eq~a1., W,' of :iJ~ ,dti~efJ_'5, ,lind m;aJI·~tdn, a j\l.9t dlsttilbtiU'fifii, ,0£ 'I]b,lii B'oods, :iJt5 CiJ1Bj!,Iil'!,

=!7~ ~~~=:~I!~'~ilm:::::::~~

,(~£b~ :Ol)'t. o:mily esn 'burt alse ,mould, :ma;ke'.decisi;an~ [m' them~lves, ,about,

!tth,c' ooncep~O'~ ofa ~, Uf~' ~~' 'will, m~' th~ir oWn as dIe]' aot. 4illilmno-' !lnUl!lS'~ w,jlthii'o, the' '~rilYare filJlI.eFe' tb3it. tllliEi[t, dif;h!u, p-. ro~ot. T,lle' ~it; ~ij.

~l ,[r' llf" ~i _,

::=lm~==::t~:~::;.~~·::~~:

e~aiblc ,~ndi,QdilJ;~d!; tn :Ili,~ ,aumn0:ml,(nliSl~'., The mm [0£ iberaitisg :i;s, W 'C~~

~~ m:~=:n::=::~~~:~r;=:D:~~==

disalf-ec' a'bo~n th~ :in"~~Rta'tiun, of tne basK '"ables, aoo!!l!t Utm' :feill,~ ili~ :i[m,porta;nce~ b:l' ,!aiUlto~Q:m.yl' and :aiknwt 'how ;aiUJt'Um;o:m,~' ~'hOllld be pw--

... ,,~~ ... [ ~.~.


be :re:sl1rlclioo ,to a ~peciLfi'C oo~ne~~ :IF~f 'the fJ~~:S' '00 ,1tl,g~.Qll" lit. Win be r-emi£'ted here to lite' t:-(rm~mI~~!~il Ame:rll:m, 'C01]~]U ~d '~thi~ lriJa;t.

,r~1Ii~1-

to d,o;m,esmc ratber '~arn :lntcir.ll1:lI!ltonail aif[airs. ''1ibeK: 'pl'~ are tb~, re-

Cilbirilb~iin:ri. ofweaUh :hm 'i:h,e flI,ch. 'fu) 'ifie pDO:t[; I'iad.fuat~ laxaCi,o:o:, man,·, ~~' :pa1ti.d~ti:OJll, i~ ~e' ,~hd ~ouriit:f p~; ~tfm:n__g' S~Hllm~n,t ~QiJltFO~ of !)!be' '~O]ljQ.y~ in,d~d!iiDg' ibQ'iness, ~d, 6~~:e;; the eJ(ten$lnu, of rl-'ihib, :,ml:ectl~B' 'Fn:ed!om to in¢lude -:,rotutiIlfIg' we lf3ifiej, :~arler 'radial

,,,,~-:I ,~O;1'''''l.o.r :""i"li.' .... ,'I'.· fti'" ~;I:--~ ~~,...~ :"!''"1":''+~~,~":','....t:: ~~i~~;::':'i"":"'I' "I"'i".I~I'I'~,:'""'UI'llh:.l .. !,o; M.III~U, ,~I~II_.U-..;;r~ I ~~!lMiII1J r"'.}, U!lr'Eol lI .... ~dl ~lIl1_~IU~JII L-'till_lI_"'IIi:F.I~IJll !\.I,I. lI_lI_lIJL'''''',~r-,'_rU~,.;IJ~, [1,lI_lI}";II_IJu-~. _ll_UII

raJI~~ ,aftiJrmau;ve action, ·,~s~; 'me preur--e:nJtiaiIJ k~tm.~,t, of '~en

md ihb.cb· ---;;:~:-rn'm~i1Jt-sui'~.'~.""i .... ,,··I. '1lI!Ii1!i::::-r .. ;1 '1rteaJ)"~ .-:_ CI-~ ~i;' ~k~, w1I~:~ - -,c,--';:

~~ ' __ ~ __ ~,! ~_,= __ e ~1P,pg"'~'Y-!l_!j-_ve.~~ '~ __ ~~b! ~-e." II-tle. . "1!~e&t ~

ble .~m, of ~C;)ub.r' pu'ltJnr; Mj'uca!tiun~ 'the majll!!5M~itID~~g' of pen;pl1E w.ll[h :,h~t"~, _d :m~nt1il di8a!bi'lilti~~\!, ~5,~d~ly ,(;hnldreo,: :ltr~my' 3!~'~'ble ,jOO[-!.. m;(m;; tb~' OP-PO::!firtion, i1.~1 ith~, I~, ,~.nrel!m,fl;nlt. of' :m(.l:r.a1I~.,,!, ~m~3!f:~f IOfiO;;---:--=--,)·~Ilt~' '0' m:- - -=-a,ualJ.- -x~lla1. --:--,c-c_~;;c-es, ,amDn~: ad!~:~;It5~ sin C-", :~~ -c ~I,;~d·~n.

__ ~~(iem~1I ~cc~_ ~~_~ ~~!!L_~ p~fJJI "'"-g ~_UL" aql ~~Q __

'of,c;lbm¢111 ,31i1d, $mtei~ 'ilflCfCalCd, ,fUn __ dtll;g :wt we'~ue ,and, decr--elUed, fbndin:1 fur d!ef.eTIse~ _on!; proc,eduitail :,[tot'f:cti!On '~f ac()ue<i cr.:imilllia!l~ ,aIDd It'tte' '~~' p~~.wiit. oJ these p~ 'by ~ fedm,alIQ'~'e.rnJJH1en~,

'~h :,aUtkal pn),~ r~t1~t d~~F aluiI'ud~ 'tb~l, ~I~~, ~iwly '~.)I,(t POF ex~pl~'~~ with. r~pect tfil' i)!he :rcd!btribUltio:n ,~f"weaildL~ tihcy CM-.e' DUlU' ia!oout ~,e' needs of '~,~ :ri~'e:~pi~llJts 'dwan, ,8;ootl!l, tb~, :.b~ of fh~' I[to.., n~~' ~Iili atltrma:Urve. aOUfili1J ~d! nN[~r~filli~1 itRMMi!tIi1!~'- tC:h'!a'~ ~R 'i'm!l:m Ci;:~

~~ •• ~.~J~~~~~ •• ~.~~., -· •• ~~I!J~'~~'-r~":I [_..~. .. ~. _, , J.~ __ r,.}}.J. __ J. [ __ , .• 1 •• ~

,~emed, with dIe '~ctiOJiS 0:1' pet ii~juslia' ~ham 'widll d~;e :presenl: 'wi,-ctims 'of 'tlb~5e ipom~i~Si, ~~ 'e~~n~ jl~cet they :foo~, mere iOJi), 3!VQidil~QK dte

. h .. ...xJ!"' . ~'ii.. • ~' ... , co, 'Ii., ~ ~'Ii., '" I .

pl!limr~e~~ y~' iLDnOOentt't 'Y!~iiIlD Oi,li), iIIiM'Ult'lOg !gli:e :puDllS1ili:m,C!A~, 0,,: '!:.I!ii;e SU'.~,,~;

iLQ ed~ati:o~,. they pr-et'Cr ~;pec.ilaI :p~dII [OF 'tih03e' WJidJ l{Jw' iUI('C1miJen£;-t, tID s~LaI! 'n~fms '£1""1' the taiI"""n ...... ...J·' 'in ' ...... D'11~1'---ilii;nlJ' nfiilmflK'J'I""'p"L\f ,~'ii.pv .~': -r .... ..:..,.,~~ ,F~';'~~'~~' ,-,~- _:__;'-~ ~,. ~~~,-I",,!!;~," ,_'__;., ,~"",,~.":'JilI""'----"c.~. lr·,J.~~~,J.~'!8! ,~!I'Jrj' ~~~,

:~lIS, on, tb,(l' ~~p<i~c:e gf tree e~P'~l$io~ ,Father W~ lOlli, O'!,t~g tlh~

p~lmg':5ml~jhiiUty;; :10: tW~ SCpamMOj], 'Df,c:h.w~'1iiJ ,:lIi:f:id iSialli', m,ey' the

:fri~~'dI():. ,1ii00t 'lin '\iiJ:Gl1'$'b'ip :aJt. tth~ ~~~~' 'uf tbe :ti~dJJm, to '~'h!ip:~ :in

'~'I''''i"''''!i' '1~,''' ... I,...d''l'<'f'1 ~;I.., ""IU' :'I" ..... '"1" .... '"!!'"1"t"'ri\O!!, ,¥ .... , '!I£!'If"I"<i' ..v;,nn"~ ~"-;""'I ~~:L._ ,"",' ~;""'~iffi! 1-:--," L~"r~U_" .. ~ ~~fl_l::I_iIi-i1I)I.JIVIJ_~~1 UJ,.~,. ~U"_lI""'~lI_lIJU,[II1!L~ UiI,I. ·"·IHIJ~L [1r..s--=~rlJlIi:Ii 1IL1,~~ 1I,a!li .. tl,~'[' lUI_6IIJ~ 0.-.11,1.

'..-illat. 't1l;~ d~~~; :in, _uiLticuillt~bm~ dtq ,e_Q1-P~~C [the be:neil,'b, of dlwm!tf~ '\\iiI,hn~, d~phwing me' ,b~ ,oo]a~k, OfiiLIi1i~".

lj~mI~, ~' tm,ot alene, ,0{ 'C(jllrH', :iIll. fl;11U.litul':'SiIng' ,th~, p~s ,!lfid

11--..,.'1 ~~ima ~:I..~i<''''''' :"' .... iIo:ft·I~..:I~: ~eoi"1"·~ iI;1io'foit :"",iI~ 1'.·iL."", __ 'I .. ,~,~ ~~, ,~.,.. ..... ~'I'i"''''. ,"'~ -fl. [L-'.,. 11d: I ,-.llil

!lIb,,!', }!i,"" ... "I~, 11".u~_, !lAiU":. ~:.'!I\.!o iII:LiIId,iI, .liil~." ,idlJiI, ,I! JLK;i',I;,iiJa ,IJ~_ '" ,I~~ ~nllu ... ~ ..... ,.0 11>1 1]. iilUll

'"'1'If ~'t""':";'"l" 'i'::;Ii- ..... .."...~ .. iI;~'. ""0;- ~·.~Irl~ ,'"' ..... ":":"',.,...;ft~""'d' 1 'iI<". m-,i: .,..,~ ~j""'""fti!il , .. ,....d:

~ W_lb,:r.~_IJ_.,r. .1...iII~ll.m_IJ!!I' lI_ltv."~'1!~IJl!i "_IJ~ ~'.r I~~~.ItlJ~' 1Iw-'\A1l_1;.1I,1I_~_1J. _~. ~.1l:I.! 1I_1I_~~". u.IL 1i1I;I~lI_.tlJl!' ~=I, ..

moo nonlberalb, ,.e 'Or~d, w, a, ;~, _alII)" (lillhem" Ylibl1l. is, ,sigJl~jltiCDlt :fOr th~, PI"e'Soe-;Q't ,p~s\!, b~::ri is, nol, ~ :m~c.h, ~~ ~l~beraib typi~fy' d.Q :faWOf ~~4n Ti:rUJt; mth~][' the' j~flcarOOl1i, '!)!hey' ,P' :rQ:F oo~ng' so: that i~ in :rD@ ,c~rnI~miro:n\l'y ,~rlum, ,c()'nr~J{~ ~~~ 3itM~lJ.u:l~ and ~~ :pr~

.. !L·;O:O;iIi' :~fiI",,~;i, ~""''''m ""_, '~i'~ eenerete '~~, ~o,:;; :-- :'b~""h.· ~;1.- .... 'I:-="'~:c ~~I'L.-:-.,.".,'Il -7~Y·--' ~~'R1!i, ~ "'"d! .... ""'~ I'·n,,,,,,,~ ~... ~~""" ...... v"lI!""" ,,,",,!Ii';" .!I"I!' ..... ,.~ 1.~iI W, _ c,''''' _, 'liiU,,,," ~_IC: IIiUl!1i'IIO ""'. ¥1diI~m

,~ .~t lill:i_dy to be [eaJ)~od,


BeUll5e '~e ·~git.e.retatiiO'J], [o,f"lllle 'hsk ~~es of':~lI>e;r:a!luml :is OOD-'

,- [',,:--[_-'· ... ;i ,:- -11\1;- -,.c,<"·-_' libe~ ... ;jl ... [i"'ir-,-_,e-'-:l<:!:_ :-,:.',' ,e, o:e,,-'-d 'm'-l:_;-[---; lili-n'

~fS:J~ eVtL amo:...lJI ~ ~~~~ ,y!~em__SC.~,,!!·tL., ~,y ,~_~_, ,=l!erpretaJ_OOl

must. :~~p' ltD 'the middl~ M~m, '.,¢ p6llJ ,of ~(lldl1i,l th,¢ OOn~Jll!~: of' ~'I;-, ... iV1i.nif-,Arifl~1I'fIi1lt- ~IFt;"'"''"'' ~ '1T:----~l'jiiT ~o'j;o '~gll':" ",In.!l, 'l'>'if iHfi'w'i~rl1li'" ... ,AI~'_:l-I\;P~_

IU.~, ~"¥JI:_~Jp..i:I~I~_!I!!II'''1 ~l ~r'!P.-1iI MI.' 1K"_K~l~ ~ '!"!'~ __ '!IiIIIoII~ltU v.I. lr.. _. .. ~.rW_.~~, MI' ~t.AoI_ I"'~-LI!

raU;!Eiiil partisan" ,aooo.11Dlt. ]n uymg to ~~p, tu ,3, ;e--6urK' mat amid5 ooth~ 'flIt!. ~Dt'eIFMUIJ!i0:mJ 'will aim to be sperlic ufI!til it ~0DiI~ 'OUll!tnJ~ia1J" at 'WhIOh, pGin,t i,t d, i[u:lim~ tbe K~ :for m.~, ,co:nr~Qf'.

'.'m:' "I'l~,~ '1"1 '~"'O;'O'O"'I ~"" ..... '_,c .... , ~~ Il-~-''''' '~.~~~_~ ',"I ~,.~ ..... ','.(',. '1:I·L .... ~,iII ~"'m.~:i!: . .t_.'I"~ .... ..:I '; ;~·n. i(I ,~ ...... ~~, ~I""'L. ,,'~~ .. ~ .• :", ,"'I""

~ lu_I;,iIlJ_:I_lJ!III_ILIJ 1I:il! U,"_I...-;r lJd3_~ ~di.lJu"", u.1, ,IL ~~ll[IIlI_II:IJI Po ,.muGLulI,Ul 'DI ~ II~ IU_[~, ~ .11i:I! 01.1=11

iaeduclbie plUtailiIt)', (If ~~~OJa)ble' valUes .d r-euonable ,eoDcepii(>;TIs of' a ~, Ufe., ]'1lI. a, Ubenit iJQci.::,·" il~di;Vid~~al~[ [DUfht. 'W be 'fr.-cc' to ,adapt gyQ.n~' ,0-1' ,any OOmib~H!il!tion ~ ~(i5e v~IJ~~~ ~d, '~~' (J<urh~ t.o, ~ ~~il.Jy' f~~ '~O ,c~nlis~t; O!ilt ,of th~m, t\tu~l.r own. ,co:lito~,,'tion~ ,of' a, pod nr~ alut, 'to :l!ive :at:Cilt-dl~1 'W them" 'One 'paUillfatJ :bnpl~~n IO'f' :,1'Uta1li;tm, b, that the

g' .... :>.iII;"'1'Il"~m~, ","",":""t, '"'i'!"'g' I",,,, .,,,,, 1"I"~i'!"""""~"""" ~"L."!i' eq "",,,,,'11 '·"i""" ... I·"i"'i"' .... ~t: · .... f' ~-Il"" ,.,...,. ... ~';1i, ... JL.i1i~

.'U7.'!li:r.11 ~_~ ~'ii,.,. OJ UU _ ri=liL !IL'-I.!. IUrtIiI.IIIi 81j1l~1II:I! tlII~ !\:r.'. ~_IJ U !!e'OU_IJ_I,~II!.JL "U' I L1I.:;.,,"-~\ I IJ ~,~ .... ",i[N!IY-

- - . ...:_. = :.

o@n~.,ollJ fif ii, good, iif~,. wh:ieb :mmms ~ait 'th~ ~mm,@:mlt O'ugbit :IlO't

'tJj favor gr' ~c)ldar' r.-c-~na'blc ~OJ]eeptiOg ~r Qthen.

This:is ofw~ '*[[1, W' ]mp'~, ~a.t '~e 8~rnHlent ~o~dd '~, neYitralJ aJbou!, dl~ (JOOiCi-.epti,O;ifi5, [oof tit ,good, ~U~ :~t5, 'Ci~f;ii ITtu·~~" [bat jll ilb(f'wiL~ M

.,~~iih . 'il~, Ii; .;ik ~~\.. . '. ~'iI.. r'· f' 't·i-..-l!'a!Il '. r11

~,~~1' WiCmillt. o:~' 'g~em,. ~Ji '~~a;t: m 'U~e poa~c~ 0:": a JJ~_!~'!'" :5OCleq '~C:e

:F&g'ht ~hoOliIll:d 'it)e' a('C'Omed priQrity' over' '~e ,~, 'Th~ 'lJa&t :imf'~karl()~~, :m.ay' be :li~ 'eblOO~t;cd l$ tb~, 'vi.:ew that m-e ~in.e~, 'I)f g,~m_ell!i; 'bl' 'h} fibir;mJuiJa;te and :main'taln i~lle' miles, that ena'ble :iu· cimens[ '1l'O :maike 'What theY' '~h of .eiF :ti"ve;5. l(b:nfO:rnUlty w tn~, :m'~~ ~$, 'w-hart :~ ri,lhil~ Whe;r~~,

,~ii;"!,! 'D',~t'''''1 h """b. , """L m:i~""l,",::",,: -tl~t='"\""if""" in 'tN"'~' "i"f" 'III'~ ,"'''i''_..,''''" ....... 'I·~(7 :t~ :iI"Ii:-'""'I',,,,, 1"''"JiIIl''"''""'~ 1lI11..,.; ~U'UU ,..., n ,'11111 ,~,~,,~ .... , 1u£""~.L<I! .. " .... ]' .. '11) IIl!U' I ,'!!' .... ~'lLI,U,~,.~[ 'IIV ,lil"';'JI, 'l..!1!.l!'< - I!U .... ,J"-

,tton.s m '~~t ~eiir 'Ive~, IO'ugbJt 'to be. Dc' lifbcnd 'W~ b~ dlat pnliiJtiea1

,--~ ~ -~ 'l~iIV db ~ ",,1.~ ~'- .. ~~., ~~. -~, ~ ~ --=,.dI =- ~' .. ,'b, ;i'b. ... ~a'h't'. 'i!ion·..!I ;i'Ib,=j' ~;i ,.;'LHi'iIi'll..!l, 'L.,= 'Il~~ •• """ ,m,o:nlll~:'r :!l.lIIDww IIX' ![;"OJiI,C~i[]li~, WliUIi. lLen,.,. ~;,~ ~ -, '1I1I.:I~.)1iII, [",IiM •• ,h· ~,U~'1i!.LU ~ ,&~J,L. W'

. d" . d 'I . de '. d abo- ~ DOd Pt~·, -, .' - dJJ tb '~'beniIJ ~

:lnlV'1i.iWIi'8 bl' e u et,~e-':U!l:Le' :g, _< ,_gm 'g, I _IUS l:rle' _lIL~1 ':'_Iue

'.a!l. ~~I~,C~ tb.e right :poliitital ;aldhld!e hlWitrd, d1,e, I'oodj.

Cu:ml~m~ a!oout :PliUralbim. Mg;iu beeause i,t is 'Im,d~a:r 'wb~lhu dl~ '~'ir~: '!ii"l',.:I1 '~iL~, ~ can ''--1·.- ~ ~' ,..,L""mnil.~ ' ....... U:li~ .. ,-)j _ ·w·.'i:'- .... 'i[-,;ro;[' ~.L;IfII' iI:'""'l'jIi"i--r-~:ihl!, • .,."" , .. ~_Ial~ !IiiU_I.U 11I!1,~ ,15.1~IAILIJ l~ M~I_ .. _.lf.r..:,· ~r-' .. -~.~~ ... I~lb!llJ~ I U],~ ll"l~luW'!II:I.I_ .. ~Jl 13.1

,th~ I-Qve:m~r; :is me:miy p~:cd~. (IF w'h~~ ,~t ,~I'I!ViQ~s 'p.~dln:g' I()m~ ,!ubstaj,y~ ,good!!l, 'rI.i:n aJ~ oonuptians of ~, gC0dJ nf~' :Rqt!liR'~

h ~iL. .~~:I}· ,A~, "iI"I/,,~~_'11 - • Ii! .~~~..:I I"i"

W, .; )eui,Cr. He-uu !UIJty eX!'k:illj:g :lQ :antl~~K~m ,co:n'Ce_pu'OJ[s! 01£ a 8~ ~~:C'[r

'wb~llh,rer' :pliUr.3!1ii~' 'ils am, iimtrllll!i]£ pmperiy.' of'm'ues 0:1' melrtdly a, sy:mptoml of" th~ 'il~ iH;capac~ly 'o:r- '~Il!WillI~np;e-s; tt~1 r«~~' ti\le valu-e~ wh.e the t, 'OOile~'Qj], I" ~ted by le:n!t1in~' equaiJity' ao'unr2\g ;c-.o:m,~nltl' M:3, good liI'f:' '~lUI by' pruden~ail :rcaso:nl! aplnst. pa'tema'l'ian" aud 'wh,em,er' 'tie ,exclu-. slo:~ ,of' :so~e (lO'n~.Qns, IOf' a ,good Iif':e ,3$ umr'easQJlulible d'(J, [!Ui)il ~m{pi1y' Fd~t :~ibe:~ prtj1:J:dj.¢,:$$. Th('. ,(:o:ntt~~iu" h~~, ~1)tl,C~ 'tj;.i~ ~XF'

't)"",Ii'IiI.' ,'"Jilt" ~"""'I"IIIi;o!'I'~n'~ :~;I"'Ilii'I"~~"";f:i~ft1Io _ ''''~~''i' ,t'Il-~~ .... .,.."'rilt' ~".' ...... LI"I'I· '~i1,."", ~'I'~~_'il [c,O'lii ...... ,

!l.~11. !11l Vi J .. _Ii_ ..... JJt'UiJl_ 1'P.'~ ~,~ U.ll r' JY_I, __ W!I~._"~ U-llIlI. '.1(...,.". UrV ,"_~V.!11l W1;tIIIi~'i :: J !WI~bw· lI_ ~I_ .-"v.".I::I::1l


m~tm.e!mlt ~I :,liU.raIliml iilmcilf {K.~ Gal)slio:n, 1:9~!:n~ H'amps'h~~ 1.988:; :~h5, ~;99!(; U1TmlU'l~ 1981;; !4a'V~1 1_;, :Moon :1998;1 ,~d :~, i186l.

"'""i[l .'t.;,;;, lbasi'"' ~ .... ;iiil._ .... ~ 'i;::L""' ...... ~;·.,m··' ' .. ,.. .... '!I",.,. __ .';";';,oi;,ll 'L,·,t 'fNi!I'~1..""m .... ""ft,oi; ~" IU:l~ ._ ~ _IIO.L 'Y~~:a! IU-.I JlI~_J~~I.oI:JI_ .. , I&.I,;,I,~ 1.~~ .. ,II.-;'I"!II!lI~,~~U~, UU OJ ~Ii--' :1~611I- __ ' ,.o.r"UhIiJI~

m~e ~, '6310 :pJ~~SiH gd, ft-eednm. If 'J"i~~, ~s' [the ~opitli(i):~ 'lhi,\[ the[\e arc mal[ll,f dUlere;n;l, ·w.b.!lC'5, ,and '(co;n-vecpti:oO''S, or: a B'ood I_i_fe" '.en fn,edo:.:~ the ~limcait lS,~e ~n w:brkih ili;dfi,\!idIjJ"~ ,can: ,(:'b(M)$t ,~J):ng iJiem.

U!Dre-·..:Ii~ !'~ ""'f' 'U:IL1'L",":,rfiIU' 'Ii!< i;D' .1'....... nn]~IIi" .... ~;I, 1"""'i'""'!I';!!o I~~' .1''1,.",,",,,, ,1UI1!i .......... /VIMIi.-r;. .. ' •. .,.,!

lrJ! ,'1;;I~~(J.u.,.LI,LI~ ~ . ,11 ~~"~,,"l ... I 1lI1~ r-.o.r.,LI~""'-W .'I.~;JI_Ll~ UI IllIII,.._._Ini..· ~l.-l..!U"'I"IJ.I· .. -- .. -L.uu;a

te;rm.s~ is tJbe idea 1lih3!i: the dtaeliU, of: a :lKJCle~' O~I'ht 'to 'be aiJ.ilowed. to (;'hoo~ dt~iF va1!iU!~ ~d, ()oill(epi)ilI):tQ ,of ~,:~, :~, 'WiithQ~t 'exlt-eI'lllal1. :iDi~e[1r. felfcnce. f:[\ealo:m oonc:eirved, 'iiDJ '6_u, waf' expresses a, 'h~m_l ;upntmn mat :m~~" ,~ '~nr~Ld f-),\lBl",r 'of ~ple' In, '~th. tdl~ We5fte:~, 'wo:ri\d! ;and.

.... l!"'~.~"L.""~,.~';iI;.i"""~&~~I'I .. ,q'.'.-r;:.,"!' I·p .. ~ e- I"w 'I':-~':~'I!-- ~,-:dll·ln·. (".1'96910:-. 11'11)' ;I".i!liiP'~

""'1i:!Kiin;U~~.~,. .1.'!ilI1. U.I;l ...... _ I .... ~""Ui,. .. , . il~'IU!',I'I'.I., i3oIIlI.iIU.1 ~" ., .. .. ..~ • .11."-'11 ... """""\ .

~ ~ ·2' _'

'~~S, th~ ~~tion as 1~!'tI~e ~h (kg the pm m w.£, indlilid\na~ m' be' :h!~

own :ma"t~;, J. '.'11 my' liif~ ,a.ild ,~o.n~ '00 de.~~,d. ;(J~, :~lf~ not l(ln, ,exteL~~l fbrces of 'wha~ever ikJind;, :':'M!ilJi to 'be' th~ :ioltrumenl: o:f: llnJ' own~ :not (IF: otlltu' m~n~';s .. , aoll5 of W1i.~t. l Wih. m be ii, !!llbjut,~ !mot mJi, Oiqj~c:!t: 'W bE :m~d, by' :rreUD:l'ltS" OOIlSCIU"Wi!, p~!ipOS'ei" 'whit_h .. are m~y O\m" Il0't be causes which el"kd, mc-" as, it, ~re',; ~ O'~wdc·" I wilh It.V be '. '. '. d~ddl(ng'" ~DiO:t.

' ..... '01 ..... d: - -" ...:Ii,_~' ifij- - - -11.f:"~~.- - -~"",..1 __ A - - t - -;t..a..Ji 1I'i:- - - In; . - -;j;..a·C - ..,11 . - - i:i>;;" - !'~

~LQ;R' [~e!I!:iJ~~ ::.,'01'" ;~..y][ig!!I!::~ ,~ ~D' _: ao",~, ~pon '~i e.x.~rn~ na~'""_l"e',.

or 'OQ1U~, alii :mkr.ab, :~ogoQe that the ~bimu:, 'Of: ~m. ~ :nQ:t.

UH;C'O:fid'iJlie:l1iwt .An. ,omlio.l!U fC~lri,Cti:on, ,oil &Ci' :~~dDm o:f 'iiu~ i1i~!Dal1, ,lis that its te.le«be mn1lJ!ld iO,j)t ink:n~t'C' 'wiillh, the' f~.0m of o~er btcl)i,Vid'u-, als, 'T'!hi5 :mJllch, is, IlJmoo.n~~[5~ .. Bllit a, .rth~if' f.~tti:cdnn, ma~' .1 'be' .lin ,o;r:de:r~ The absence ,of',e:Jlttemal,oOleuion :may be ,aooe:ptOO, :as, n~(j~' (hr.· :~~do:m~, In.u:, (j(J(:j[..cioi1J m.aJ. ,~8Q be intemal If' itulliv.id~~iJl~, ~ :~ed by ,c'O:mp\d5ioll~ ;addkliQ11l,~ ir:ra1ioDJa!l. pmJjIll.dI£~S~1 01' ulil(inn,tn"lU~d ,31I],d, ,mii5di? u~, :pa.uiunos, ,and :if ~,~, ~nrD~Ifl~ 'ch~,H!! th~ mati' ~ infOnnm by

iItrn"1i'.,..iIJ"..,....,~ Gh;.'pi..,:i;ih.iL m' ,"IfiI';:m .. ~~g~;'oll1'., ""'''1"'d'~1 'nTl.'!\'n~I~Ili'Ii..i~. ,j:i!r'e"1' [i.:il:-,.. ~9""k~' r~,

~-Q'~~Vtll[~l."""'[!! filI'~ ; .~IU_IJ~l ~I ~jl-lj;r!~-~_ilill.:UrVIL~l!i !H.lll! . ,rr.~11LVr~--.UAJ. t_.at ... I~IJ U_I_,' I_~ _ I~.JI"""'"

de ...... ", .. , ' ..... ~~ I1;-- ""'"'I !l-'~ rli;~ h ~,...:II '''''':'';.'"1" :'"'.:.:~t, .... :~ ,t,o.: ~~.\i"'m·· '~'I,"',~;;o;~""'''i", rr- ... .,.,n' ...

. _ ~,I~IJ.ll ~ ,1~1~.J!VI JJ1Il !M&J! U, IU_I!II.i!'$"- __ d'U ~~IJ_.J IlI-U_~:~l-D.II1 ~. . ~oI'L~ .1 __ W .... -I' •.• ~~~;JJlb~_."U._~£r. 1:"'~U~rlJ~

o{l:e~ cheese 'to ado:pt, vallucs< lbat 'they' wo:wld, :not, ad!o:p,t, ,if ~bey' 'Were rea ... mrna.bl~'" :lemg' f~~ rn;Im (!lx~m~ :inlt-ene:~nc~ '.l~S, {dh:, ;$'l:t1)n 'of beiing· 'free' to m_Ue' [~aable cbol¢es", And 'p1'e81UIIU;1y :6;eedo-m. D,;3. baMe 'gjrL!le ~a~ 'iit~ ena;blm hldii,vidljjil5 'to mdie re~nablie 'chm:oo ~ng va1\l.e$. and cnnct:,tiQ:i1iS of' a :good, :tite'" O:uu:;[lQVe(;jl~ a!oout :Fr.'Ccdom bqin 'When dlc' 'q.llICKiaml ;~s 1m- '~' (~ it iis, 'l\eIi'~ to .~sm,ct ~~ :f;t~dmml. ,mindlYlidllidis w, •• ' unr.~na'.Wc ,clu~l:ces, These 'ii::o:mr~nles, R!DJtcir ~und, !tie' relati~,n 'ktwec~ oegati,ve alu;I. :posilti:vt:, :r-rc:cdnm~, be:hVCel1l 'til,¢ ,extent. to 'w:hriih. fRMuml ,lis me' ~nu of ,c~..cmfi. :_,d, 'th~ ~xMl1Jt m Whii.'(:'h lit, is 'Illhe Qjlpl.rmmilty· m' :m3ik~' re~~~ble ch»~ (1e-r:liiQ, ·UiJ69'C,~ lW'bthas, :1,OO~i, 4Illd, :lptIll l '~')'"

:U_raI 'oontr.rw~Bt~s aiR'ut; ~.o:m" b~~ ,mtl~fid '~1iI ~~r; lit

D, ".', Im,·n .', ,'.' ".~. : ", ,' •.......... ii'L..,..,.,..;i., "il"i,. (> ,.;ll::-. ',;1'. " ...•. ~,~ ·d"'·.," " :." I····· ,", .:.

_ oom~u~~ grolm~ amOllR _U'!;.:~~iM8 W'1a:t, Uile \\3. !ue Oil: ,1I1Tf:e o;m. etme~


A . "u'~'"

an::I-,"" .l :' .. , • '- ," \ ; ~ "

, ~'_"'I-II-a!I, . . __ . . _ ,..

on1, 'lu:uder cl~ILbed (joJ[.~OOI_s" If 8tanrd:tion~ d'isease:o p:werqr-:,. iln~1:'ii1q'~ iSUpe:~H~():f;t~. :ip.(JO~¢~.~ ~n~mrriity~ ..... d ~ :filmtb ~. :~pau;tl iI11.cQ. :~ , dum ~ an ·~.nla:lfQIdab1e' b:Qu~'~~ The :mai!A,rtcnal~ee of Iitt' ci~t~ed lo~ndi-· IriOOSi r:iiM~ :f':o:r :~Dm. M-m,g 3. :~~gftI.I. '~Ue:I' h~~ :fi~m.,

""ili;li1·i~ ·lI".;Inll·l~res C-_~"",,;niT ·;i.,;,"'i'I'·-':::.:i .. ~~:iL.., 1",-" Im~ ~3ike' , ... ii-. ..... ·I)·~I .~ • .-.~'~i;iii . ...,._, ·'I!ii', ~~1.J1 II ~.""I~- ,'. . ;-~Il'~-~.-~I;;J IIIJ,LU_ 1"'~ua.&3. I!U'! _ _ _ _. !IY_LllJ.IUI. 'Ii.i!l;;l~ .I-.¥U-.I~~I~ ~~ '~I

.wrlm.g dtfi: CDliu1lido:nil o:f ~Onl th~Rfor-e dr;~nds (TJn :~tJ, :Fe!!lmmUD" ,And, ii, mMl, cDntf~w.ii:aJ ''r~O:Dl :fuf'lliJ~; ~ 'by how' Q1Jl1('Q .taQ .~ dom; be' legiitiJma:tel,,' :~hi.cted. lu: orner w :imp:1i'm!'e :heal!t.h~ ~'j. ~. ual(h~n~, ;~url~~ and. ~'oo~1I:r [(';@:nmlti(J~!!1' ;of ~~

.t ,f:1i11i-',·1..· ..... [' ""·_""'II[I'iIi~".~-I·-·111 ,"'~ I"". 10,'11-:-'3.'1 ·if':,~I·_~·~-..1·,,"'1'm ,i .. , 0:''''''1 ~,- r ' ."1i' ... .@ ... ~I!' "I'1..""!, ' ... ~--'.: ... ,n ,lull iLl].'!!... ....'!.:.!'.~~!I'II.'U"1iO.1,1ilI_ 1&1! 1lII0I'''''''' ~,~ !!.1iI ".iI1I;I~!!.l!'. _ . ,Ia iI~~.:r "",".M.'!IY· UrI. !llU,~ 1JId:lU!Ii.

..... ;11.;,..... If rL,"""""ii" 'Ii' ]-IA 'l._ '" . ".,,11 • ~·iI..·;nil ..... 11';' .

'~w~i OJ ~~'~_gm., ~t ~u .~, ~ LQe:O'mpall~e 'WIY!! r-!iJi_'J,ilumJ!l; ·w ,.,pose

o1hcen¥ii~. 'Odlttf' bule '~hj~ of li~mIlWn~1 ih~t oi~. c:qnilllii~t WJltn freedom. J\nd ([Teed.o:p'I, Olaf' be jl!Sl1:liHJhl;y :re!lm£Jtcd, 'by ·the lleaMr imJp0,fJ"-'talltt lmat iii R:atOoa'bk Ito m(p. in .sam~ (;-nlllt~a ito dt~, c'la!bmIi5, of' o th.(; r' vaJ)UCl., No Ubetal),C'();lIlKlIiIi\d· ,exist; aooul: 'hOW' suc'b >0 D:mrflkUI are to be :resO!lRd.,~

·Yi:Jt.liicm1s. p1lleralJl;y ,apee tbat (maioml is a ibask MLm' ~ iJt. is a :fi~~' iGon.cjjo:n or ind~d~s~ .ntdi!m.g' fO:F .e-~_, what dtey ~, pm ,as ,aJ ,pxi, :lliIc'" Dis ~e.mCDJt exknm, tD ·tdI,e· :1!C(iogn;~1iOD :tm3.t; th~ dai_ of f~ed-iQ- :ra~:Y' be 'Iegi)timat~ly ~!iitriQ:ed~e d)~emeni!.$ ~ Q¥C1t ,the ,qiuedions of' how fa.r a::nd ·~~.r' 'wn!a!t: ·ci~~ and. [Qr w:furat

.ij\i"' ... oifi>'!" .... j,t. .. , ~1Ii~.....-.~,..._"'7",..: ~"''!iII'-- .... ' '1~~~..,.,.L"'iIi .... , I~_~ ,~~-~'":"'IIt ..... '!"1 l:.~~· ~:...or ,~';~ .:If~.~II_" IJ ""~,llliiil! 1I!1iiil! .. ,~~,.l-~Y.V-!l£I_ .. ll-II-IIMI ILK; ,l~;!jI~!WI_Ii_II_~Mii ~~~ g-W __ I~,IJ_IJ ~~~ lUll UliAir! .1.tUIL-!lY'Ii:I!Ll

M.d, 'M!U: ,~~ntl,

:1U,1~1B1 .~ uO'lh~r 'basi£; 'm1I1.U,~ of li_raIIiml. Th~ fml,~~nblll Id~il :Qi, that. ~~:iLmdivi.dlgl~ h~' righu~, ~d. thc:r-c' ~. dliinp 1101 PC~H 'Dr :BTO~' :m~ d!o t~ dt~m hrithnuJt; 'YioJlati'llg th~l.r .rip8) ,,~. (NOliel!;;, 1. fit:. ix;,;, n~

:I'QQ:~' :im~t b d1~ f~~~ In w.briih ipr-w.~ b Q.e~'ed~ th'e .~ 'baI.i,c is< ~e' ri;b!t '(ibalt: .mtay. be ,dallnred. fbi' prov.imn;g it. 11'1.4:' most. !impona.nJt :p:J-QtC¢.ti'O~~ ~ I!llu:;ua:glirt Ito' 'be· ,th~, ~t i~dhddl~~al!!l!' ~~ed. Ibcca!g~ I)lb~ .

. "."",", 'h'l'''"'''''''''''' o"",t· [b-~~,.,,~ .. ib;p.v' :i. . .,..,.,... ~-.:II~p-t-·d·1 ''''I'''-V H.:iI1r1iil u·II~_, ._'_·Il.,,,-~ .. ""''''' ..........,.

H'!.~ ";_j.~~~±' ~~¥'!i, I~~, "",,~_~. !I!~!I'I;~-"",, i«YU .. ''''''''' . 'l'I;U.,f' 1r-, MLlIII. '!I!!IN~1Ii 'flAil oIA#.~ .• '

~~pti.-OP.!5, of ,~ :~. :li~, Th~l ~.~ed :ftIr ;~~·b pr-wmig~1 iii '~ive~Iy' :hiUiman, .. nd im:dliridua'!!, ;ar~ I~,~. bo'lh in ~nl .~~ n~~ ~d i~. 'bemg' ~1ililtitlted. '00 ib ~kli():ti." Th~' 'm""-e-~PQ~~I :rig'hu are' ~FeR-ed, 'W g

' ... ·.'''m ... - ."I'io"j L_,~~: ... ~r' ~"~.;I~-'II!!~~,,.·IL .;11;'1'1 ~~I.iMi'""';O;< ·I!- .... ~n~ :""'"':"'!' , ..... ~-:I 't."": ~-~~"'. ~;L""m-,'I 11~lJw~ ... "':11 ~IJ ~ 'U". ~W:I,Udl.L[I:.~~iI_lIj~_. ft.! J lI;li!LlIU._., ..... _lI. ~1I._~~ ... MI.I,~ ~.u, ~.u IJ.II~ U:;L~ _-

and WI [1-0 ........ , the.,.;;; !ii!mljc~ilhr-. ·beQ.~' thllli!V' :tliH"'J('ih 't,n 'F~~h"'_"'" of 'h!'illm~lI[Ijiih;o'

~~.-' -~. i~o~~ ~_._ ~ ~·~.~~~lr:J! ~.~~.~ ~~-~.I B'~~ ~ ,-,~~~_~I~~ ~-~ ~-~~-- ~~~"t:".l'

wihh, U5.p«t 'to 'w:hri:Ch :liIillma!ll: MiB,(p ;U~ .iaJUt~i

UrUmH :f,i,pu.~ not l~ rights, beea~ ta, l~.l ~em. :may ~.I~til!-· aib1),' ailti\c~d, for' 'wlilllg m'l~teot hj~, :rig'hb., A legal], ~m ·c;cr.tidnif

",' I" .:i!-I~' 1""'""1'. "",it.~ e h ~; , ,- ...... 1,..'it ... _ b" I.t "111..·., , ·1IJIJr;rI", ... ':'! t· :'! ,.,011.,. .. ,_: , ........... ,.,'110 .,.~: .. " ,. O.IIi~, I"" prn~c .... ,. ;UmaIIlI, .ng1U!Io1!" llI. w:I.e n.l!!!I)llIJ!Io1! ~Xl!" IIl~nUEn,u, 0:11: m,

suoh. ~~m. UitmlDJ. :fij~~, may be _dJ to ~ :m~Fa:l~ in dt~ ~.11I1e ~ they'

nwu~'.~: j.~'~""" [1----:1"0. !i:I!'iiIi," I ~.". ~''I; .... [~Hjjll·~~'!"iil!' ,~~'Ir-~O;'I' ... ¢ .• iI', : ... ~~. ~'-L ... ;"'''-'"'foil'~"·",,,,,,,,,, ~~ Ir,"LI'!"~-'!I.l"!II ll] ~'_~_~~Il l~ __ ~ __ "_IJ_1Ii Wi.,,,, ... 1~.4J!'!IE.l-~~_.~ll~~1 Utl ~~~~[IUI 'MII_~IU Wlby; &,!F~, .t!.hU]r'~Ir.L ~IL

!harml, [hat OOm1!t as lwih sitnl(Ply' ~~ of '~l;l' :'bpi~l~oIJ .. , ·~h,@L.


e ~ 1"1: i .""~-:I '~~I'I. """i'"'1",.,'1)".:""'"i"" ··:';;];It· 'h.J'OIul ~--ualIL,c .~:;,."i" .;i!;'ii .... ~ ... ~. '.'~:'i'i~.,,(... Ihii!t'h . .''''''', .1I;';:d.I.\, IMl.I_lI.l.11 ~---:-.Iid.1l ~1J_.U_IJUO.lI_~ lJI_lI_OLOl . _ u-JU .,..", _ _try .1J,u'1J 1Ii:i'!f.~ .. ,:!"v..,J;L-'!Gi," ,D!I.o.UlIlilOLI,l. ""~I' Ia

;i<kii'i;ii' AI~" ~ ~ ""~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ..... ~ ~ ~ .",;'j;~. II ~ +i ~ "~. i'll' " :o-o'l;~rl' ,;, "'I'!iiP "." '.ii..]~" 'i'. .. " ~ "" ;>,\;."

~I,'~ '"~unf:' ,~ WnOse '''IOlilw.on :.;;J HlO .. :lIIiili if [Jmr~f01'L!S8l,'IIi!'. e ~c.ause '1ilI)I}q~i'

'COltsti1.W miinimiUilill re.quir.ements, lof 'liI!U'man 'wellfa!l'e. There are, 'of 'c:o~~, L~ and moral. rig'hi~, o.~r lhUJ hrllm.31fi ftgPJU~, 'limit. mq' wry

'i"ft· , : .', ifV 't""r' :' "hi' .. ,·d·1 " ", -'. 't;"-r- " , ','" c1'-~~ .. ," ,. " .. 1L..rp, '"'i'li"., I 'e "1 'I!>-~~:.-

~=o:_m 8IOCl.'Ci":1 II/,V! !SOCle ... ] an ... pe[:lO:D. ~ ,pelnon., .Iile n.1f,lIIJ.., Ulla" am 31, ~

'.jUt or l~bei'l!lum ,~ b~"

~t :is g,~rle.mill'y ;~d by' tiibeFdh [that tb~' jU5~liic3:tiun of b,~man ir.t-g:Irut5, ~~, ~, '!;!bey' 'p~~t ~cQlltd~lll)n$ :n~~ {Q:T the' &ne.tiiO:Oim.g ,m 'h~nlan

i'--~I'I"'!Q'!':: :"'4': 4'.'Ii~ ... :'Ij'", ·iI:!Ii'U". [':'1..'1'''': Q.-.·;o;o'!"Il"I"11 ;t:Ii~i'(>;">~'n' t ili'"i"m,'"' ';'":,,,'tl'i''': ,;o;'b"","!'ift: d, ' 'I"U~~~":",lt It.,.;", _I::I!I)-"I.'!" ~ !iJI!II-I!"'-~ll~ W _"' l~tl __ ~ ~-...l.ll~'!I.r1j g_ ~r-' ~'!U'~_IUJIIi..J. _ 1. 'lUUI_ l __ ~ ~_.~Ill~ fi:J_I~~,l". __ ~.l-_~~_"_"G-..~Il. ~

as, ~:n, g an a:ttempl ~Sl made. 'm spe¢lfy ~c' (loJldhilo;n~ ,s.wp:posed ty, uec.-es-SWl' for- hutmMl :m:mmOJ'll~.','~

n ... jo"ii;' ,,,,,&' 't;i!-~ r~ .. n"i'" l'~'i;..I·y· ~'"i..~iI'~ .~~~, .. 1 : ~oiI!!~'ii",,!i'"1"rpl i"""'ia~t\~." ';4': '"' .... a't' 'l'l'j!L,."",..,..iI 'po' ',' iI,\.""

,1:"""'1, !Ii, UJ, llll .... I ""'AOI!U".iI '!I"I!',U U,I,,,,,,,_,_ !!I.h ." .""'~IJL-""'iliIIJ"" iI~UI!tl"""', ,Ia t!!IillLIL" ,I l~I,:idlI, .. h!t!F

, . :... . ~

eM. :Pf~ :af-e ;sl.UJn,gIf' :~gfl)I!l~~, by the: ~mlte:qnl:=~tioIil, '00 bl!l~

rl_g'hi~l *art [O];UU dtej1r bad~.gl"O'uud;, If:' ·~e Uberall. :slait.~ o.~bl: !l~, 'pmt~l: ,th~ :hi~;111 ttg;hits, IQf' :indM.d,~, '(;~~i$! 'me~ :~t :~~ ~, gH':at. deal of dUier.en(lc whelJiher dIe' rlgh;l:!!:, are: i~terprelte'd, m,er.e~' ;U, pm~tiOOls ifro:m OO~Md :inltme:renoe WiIW, the exeF(ol8e (If :btdmdil!~!iJj :fr.eed~~. ~r ,~

,,.'L ... ",.;i .. il:~~""n~' ~""" n~;::;AI ni.,., .... ,,",I'lj4 .. ~ .. , ... ,t·:,",,, ik_'n"~~" ''';iII. ~'"""'d' ':.';::..11·,··_'1_ m:::ni" '~~,

U_~"'_j ~~-r.o.-----,IU", .. ~ F'IJ ....... ~u_ i.:p.!U.III."I;1l [.:II~~~,.,UT"'-' l~, it;1I],'~ [~~,~_~.:__'_~~~g~ ~~'~'" ~

thGrtJg;hit, m, ~_uiIlIe ,u :~. ,of tb~' :mi.niimli.Utl :teqJnir-em'Mlu 'Q\f tth~)1' weU-~, Sr;tm~ of ,tlh~ !$~5t (20fi,:~nl~ ,wm@:p__g'ln~~ OOH;oeftll .e' questions

~f·"~'L."'I'"""'''"r' ''rllll'm .• al'"'" ,~~,,\-"i:OO al~ ''1'''''I'!iI i"I""'U'il!IIli::~:-=- 1;i"fW" ,-~,-=- '1'In~"i="C'7~' ,~.~. ~:::.UI' ~~ [.;~.::.-:; 'U. H,U~ILI]!!I,.". ,I!II ..... _1111.,1,1, ,,. '1~iliI~ Mil' .... u\u 'l iliI~~ .. Uve ....... ~ 1I-:!iluJVC;:: a::[Ii 'W(i1!1!~, D, Ule;¥

~-e' ~Pe~ what 'iihe' requiir-ed, 'benmu, ;im::'~ and :how' broad~' :iJt. is 'reaso:mi'" ablf~' t\(jl d~fiIn~ 'lh>~ ~.Eflt5 t4J1 14li1riih :iIfidmdu!1J~ ~ 'i)!lJu;rugl1lt '00 'be ,e-Q. d!ed,

Uil!il;..:Ile:r'~niIJI' 't'-r·~, ew~4>, .... ..:II""""1f'i ,..Ili;~~.:_ I~' ~""""'if"IIIi)l:· ~~ .... ~ ,,~: ,,,:,t;;:. ~_ :' ~ ~~,:; --;:Ii,(

uU. '~,111.'1~ .l!l iiI!!lo. u.lIll"l..,u. ~"'r u......,.~ ~ ..... I,I' .. ,IE;IlIl~ U!Ll'U"'''''''''[[" ,U; 1!lI!I.c;: ~_ ..,.~Hjl~n!lio

ilfI ",._'t... .' L i: "" '. .;11"'6:' d ih..:. iii-. "" '" iii:'

'~~a!t iUlem! g, a.I~'C iP'tOWObJ~J.nj' ~. ,IO,cd 1~,1 ~I,e' :mlnllmJlUn rn'l!UlRme;I'l'~' !!fb'

'i;-llIllIlm: .• ,,,.,. ~ ... iI~'"r.~,'". ,,,,""" 'Iil.·b.,~ ... :b 'I'J"'~~l'II. '~J_'II";no~iI', a1re' ,;O;>""I~~~'''''''' ,a, n'l';O'lIJ."_",._.i",,ioIio "'Il-,ali' '". ~!"L _ .... ' 1l·~~_@rI~ ·~~1I~cUl~[f ~ gl_~I~[ll l_I!IW_Ml'1!ldJIIJiUI!.I_1iI! g_ 1. ~.j~~I11~~ 10 rll·~~.~~U-U.l_;I, UI_IIIl-L !Il2f],~

l$taJte' 'Q f~po:~Ib'I!e' for :~dJj_Qg! gd theM. UUc' s~~, 'by 'whJch il1he'

, ...... ~"..I'I : .. t"'I"'-!I~nD' ~f:'" :al,",,!,!, ~a:iI' .. t"'!L m' a(V' '1i1-~, 'i'lIlh"~ " .. : ''t-~, ·=c:~;:.'111 '~Ji ~4i::.~, rili-_' r~: ,1~'!'.i!'1! w, !J!W1!lU,uJI.'11!!i! 'U, MU,.i!' iil!U1I!I'L .. _ -QO:f ~ .J',n.~", .... , ,Ia .liIu!l'l' we . l.. !r- ~~,,}Wl:e!ii u:l!l:S

:pro't~ti'o:lii." ,1m of~ni ad~hJc~d .j~titlcauo:n, of [the ~~be-rail ;state g, that. ~t; c-o:m~ eleser [to :m,@l~ting' 'rilil statr1d)ard, ~.31n dCJ.m ;3fif om~!i" ~ ([f ;star~e,

Of ~.~, bulc ~IU~ I()f ,~~k~~lm! ,e,q,il~aJI~ty i~, th~, DlI~t. ,difftc~'~t w' pt~ OOW,1l gdJ OOf!i_~,~¢Jlrtlr ~J~' ·O't05t {lQ;nj~nliat '11u~ :~t 'ida, j~, 'the ~'1J;m-., binati:OH of' 'tJii~ ~,b:ve .claim ~at; 'ihe:re 'i:!li ,mlfme :ilUnd!l1JDcnta!l :res,pe:ot ~n 'wh~cb. alii: :buma;o, be~nfP are o'lluail and] O'u.lJht'tt} be tlrearten fiJ,l1Iallry and ~iu:~' :nq,ane' ,claim dwat W"hitt1'il:ry iimeq~ty :amQng hrwn~, ·.hlp, 15 ,m.o.~ly :~pu,p-b The ~~ ('(!aiM,! h~ve'I:"i! i!!;, VtaCiU~US Qin'lea, dIe' '1"espeol m -whICh. eflimJi:Iy' ;j4' ;a'lii>n~~~A ' .. t .... bnil!dl ; ... [Q:t"W'\i"""':L,"~" ,; ... , ...... i'":"'l"~ n ... ~~jIio'';';' ..,...'I;];c'~ ~ ~

_~ __ . __ . ·~_~~,'I· ~q. !;iI!I!I.i!!I!~·,r·--"~ ~ ~I _, l~ ~_'WIo'l- .. _DI~-JI! iAI_I::lrOJ UIl~ .1"-lt'Wo'l-~""~YIf!G ~ .G_I_I::I;I, tl_S

'1""1' ~ ,";'m~ll;-i'""nft;o;I'J·:"l'"1jIi; ~:O"""i~~ i,. -i';o; ~"'~~'--,~'~·',:.If·a;i 'il ... ~";;-ilii8l;lfiii'-L =(~\iTIlIln'. ~~~~~ii l~iI. "", .. ~. iillildJI. cr--"- U)U.u 'LiiI~iiI!II.iII.1 ,lll,.1a -lr-.,.L.UleQ W,E~ ""'~, ,I!I.L-~." ~" I"':l 15 ~-1!l,J1J""'""""1" Y~1I:iiIJI

oonjt[love~ WXnljt eCfluati!t'f are 'caiUSied 'by d~~i2m~RJ~ a'hu.llt m~ (ion,. [t~n,t !O:f th~, mq;mRd, l,~da:C:aJti-o~"

U"~d ~ ~l"" "" it. " ~ ~ ~"""." h .1.." 'I.. d 'II ",.

__::n~"eT:'~,)1IIi1__g"_Il__~ese OOIilI~m~,~ ..;c:owevefj, rine.re :IS a 8.[1:M'e mnm W810l'L


~ .. lu-:···~~~"

~ 1;·; ,'~.~ - .. . \-,:;' J

, _ m" .


.Wh_kh oqht to 'be' 'favomd ,u-e' ~t the' ~-e~t~' of (~liIt d1$t~O:fI!S' aJbout

sre:~e~'t=-::~==~~.orn ,d~ly aI6Ed ~d1i, a, :![~nlb~ ddm!k¢r 'iilan jlDtiu i5 w1!lb JObr:i: Rawl~. 'Hil ,~ is, d,~o:ped in. ,A, T_~, iOjp.lia.' (i 97l) ~d. ~caJ .l.i~~ (1[998,). S111~' the afpe~(je of' ~e 11f51. book.~ imme~se inrere~t :~ £,Qi(:~d! (Ii]! '~e cc(Jm:pl~, i~u~ :~~d by bw:l$., b'~ R5pOn~ m' cri:ti,ci:s:nB" b~, rev.ised 'hi\!!! :po5_~ti'On~ :a.rnd, hils lai~:c8t.

""~ ;00< ..... ' eut ,1f'''''''~'_''~-fI :;_ ;i;l1.,,,,,, .,_;tjLn..:l ~~:.,",", .":.o.c "' 'i~, D~OUirl .. ",iio ,~'!il- ...... n;. ~., 'n.,.,; ' .... ~'J"~~.,,.i ... iIii; ~-,!!!_~L~i121 ~ ~ F .. ~.~' ,~~~-"¥.f."~Q. lI!,~lI ~]~ ~y~ .. ~. I~LIIJ ~,"Ql I~ ~[)j~_,} 1I~1 ,IJ.~~, uJ ... ;~UL!~

~1'I1 WtGieral but O{I]~' af dIe -di:8tribu~' ,~t at' '~t.. 'b; is a :pmvelffU.l. 00 ... ' "lc~ ,and, :mblll~ ~,(',()ry," Cr:ttiw, f~J?Qn~~, w' ilt :~. :in!lt)' 'tmm~ Il~t 'RI)" ;!!l'h~,y ,d~tin~l!!iha!bl~' ~l3ines, (Ke'~ rOlf' ,~pie~ :Danioeb, l:975~ KymillkJ"a, '.1[fU"Lfi~: ,i'Ol":"~ ,~~I~-lI",,'11 '11'r-a~i\ ''11.... i""It~, '~I""i"t', '~ .. ji"'1i'na ~ii~':"'!Il"'I;jl.., '~'i;,o~ I '~ :"'iI1"~ ]~!:Im)!>

~~l!i R.i!IJi.J] ~nI~)J 11J.~~'.1 ~l .I.v. [Uil~ I:I_I ~ L~b .. !I.'': _ G lb.llM::~ ~_CIi ·!r~'I!',Il_1 ~J" ~_lI~U I - ...... j,!).;~

,OO;.,.. ........ iM' , .. ~.., '''~''''''''1''V. :i"'"~"iL"""ila"h. ''''-ri'!li m!W' djif'ff"T" ~iL.;-:O~ii: "Ii,.,:-iIi..,.iIo"'ii~;o; ,'Wt~ '~ifii'dl

~~!I;;r,Ir-'!" lJIl_lI~ UUI~V"'I';1i .~J~~ 0 U'[-J -'-~Il· ~-.I, ~_UU'IJI~ ]~I.a U1i:OlD.IlIiI • .JJ,I_lI~ ~~---,'U~lIi

.' 'I!""'_~I I .... ~ • . ,..'In. .. '1-. wh Ie Th .. !b"'_A '. if

'C:O:D!taillDSi 1i1~'~I;~S w.!~, :rej;Cclt. IIDe' weo:ry' alS, a,·"--,lOOJ~'" "="~.te' mlili~, 'WDJnSt81 i)~

,'!I;!P:liI.ill'1"1I..'·"..,...~iI', ~ •• 'L. ..... '~i~ ... "i: ~"","i;1.. Di"'."~",~',;o; ~;I...@:"'li-'~' ~~"dl 'Ii~~"'""r~."~", ''1il''-'..,. ,,-..,.~~~~~ ... ~ &U"Ii~_ll~ll~ __ '" nLllbw~ .11L~;J~!I.l-~ l~U::1 ~wa ~ IU::l'~V~"l !tIiiIII_1II ,_ .. _~I. __ IiiP_.il_~_. oiL Ill,,... 'rUj-'!Ul"IIU:~LI~_w.=-

~"n-lif 1D\~··i!.o,i'", orb" ,,<'wj;O.'i!-1 liiif:.-n·- .. ·;jlj- ~~I i~ ,",', [li:i'~I'1"~' i""'~''-'ii- ~11-. " . ""." "";;", '~I'"'€ ~11-." """,O'~ (til !I'IiIA,""" s: ~I,eo:.ry _".I!y;~ l!iI!~!I!iP_MD ~S ~ ",,~..J.ng 'Y!ml. !!I!He .trt;J,eCi~{~]J1! iQ~ ~e

moo:FY' b ;Qi!t(!D, ImM :110' mlOI!lIf:i.t m ' • .e :~Eaim:n 'of' 1iM:ra!l~, '!itself, • iID,e·

';'..:iJ' "'. f • 'D~, 1; 't'i.~~ii

LQ\,l--JP..atLO'J] !OJ ;ialDI11·~:w~s~ ,JIJ,,"=,!i;iMS ..

,Raw:bi ,e;KpUdlJy :id~~~~~5, m~' pr.(fhl~m t~) wb.icih, b;ii$ 'tJ1ooq of di:sml'bu. tti~ j~tme :~_ iflil' 'be' 31, :mllJlitl'On ~ 'i!'illb.e p~'bIe'm,' of '~~~ism'''': "i,:~ is

~"i: 'n;i'\ft".:'I,.'I\o:I;, ~;b"'''I' ~:I:~¥.>;I;' "'i"",i,;o<"",, ~[' '''I~m''''''' ""I .,-iI'i'" L..'I "'i' "'"I";""_": J""I,,;o;t ,~~~, , .... £' ,'"'I;"iD .... i"''"I"-:I

1I/~ ,F·~~ lU I~ lli. g_~1 IU~l~.~ ~~_IIil!L:J. 'U'-'I!-1Ii:r._ I !I.LlI ~ 0 !i:l!l4I~ll I~ ~11tU _:._ ~. a .~--:-.I~Pfi;.' ..,.J. tt_ .. ~1Ii:r a:.IJIU.

~qliail: [(~~filS [pnlF':t;fllDdiIy d)i~dted, bY' :re:~n:ablc 1!eUIgl(JlQ,!, :pbj~(J$)pbii.ca1!, ad .orail, doomn~?!;~ (bwb 't998;' ,XX"l). Th~' :t\~e' ud. ,ttl,QiI. ,d~~$ are ,~med. to be re~.mIaJbte, and 'W '~t '00 :ti¥e ac:€~ni~n_:g' '~ 'tbe:ir een.....,,~ii"'1i'n~ ,"r':e. ~iL.,!!, ~" '1"'-r~ '~ll~, ~'i""''i''''!'~ ...... Pi"'' ~oo'~""""~- ,~i .. jl .... if"'"" 'i'OfO'!Io'l'""i''i''!!Oj ~~~~~, - I Uti W,I,.~ 1t!i1~_'I1 ,~,1j_1~1 '!I!'I'.~ rllll lilII_lI~IJ~IJ .. V.~"'IlW:.~' ~ .... ,r-,..,lI,a!t~ ·nJ~IJIHI. u.1J"~ [~_~/ulill_lI~IJII'

lbN:aiuse th.~ :mo.lze bo-th ~t they d];emse:~!i £;(Ji)lild ~Dt H,ve • thq ,,~ti!ib '.thout. ~c.h, ~OO,~~"h ;.4, 'tbat the ~e is; '~e gf 'Gther;S"

~ Q.·"~'f ..... "'t""1i'''" ""iI':. ~.'" •. OL.I '!I;,t 'tl!f, .. ~1~\A ~~iI'l :O"iof' 1"./'1.._ 'Ii!':;;"',' , .... ~.~~.1"ii!"'--,; ~,'F.'''('io''ll" ;;otL..'i'"'.n'i,'ll~ 'Ij:o.,,:," '~".·'I"~'it·

,;I iliI ,""""IltU!!,l!',.,.1 ,~Ilt ,",1111'1110., . I iii .... I .... ~".'U" ~, !I':'U&.~IJ ""''U'V!r~'''IAO~ ,,,",,"iii !i)_U"",,u_ ,U, ~"' ,Du.,

'whatever 'tlbcY' ~ out Ito, 'k', tbef' 'wiJU. have to< ,~n~'lUde :p;rl;n¢:iplC"!l tha~ ~m: the di_~tribu~(1in, of :primatl:Y socia'l: :g:oo&~ looib ~ait: dtiml: 11 S' :may tr~lulJbl~' '~tJl '\lihat~~r' ml@i.F (ion,c~ptlO:l1 (~f d:t~ pOO, :may be, :stl~h ,BS rlg;hts~, Ube'me!!l~, ~~cQ:mej, ~c.grityj, a;nd ~ [on., Th~ :g,~, ~~t: 'be' pFQ~:hu~:ed ;md "m~ted~ iQf 'co~'~ and doil1(g'·s.o provides, beln.cfiJ~ ;m.d, 'jim~s ihlHldten.8 aD! ~.e ,c~~r:aJtirng ~~dz¢n!li" Th~ p:ri!\1.-e~'I~!!l' ,of di$triJ1,~~ ,jlllSti£e ,;sUre 'the te:nns :irn 'ni'C'h '.ese be;Jlefi.~ ,lind 'b'wrdems o~ghJt to 'be,

dilmiiJU!l-M, :amollg dl,~' [~~~n!.,

Th~ft aR' ,~, rsu.ch prind,ple~: '~'~, Each. :pelSQ~ 'has ;., 'e<:I:uill,elJaim bl' a ifo1,' ,a(t~q)uat'e scbem.e.' of'.~uail basie :.h~ ud I~OOru,l@!!I,!, w:hiclll ;sch~m.c :is (:.(Jtn:pa'ti~le w;ilm the ~e :5(:'kerrne for ;alll;, ~d b~, tbJSI ;sc'he:me '.e ,~,.~;d iI1oi1ii'I':t': ...... 'I] ]~II1-~-: .... iI!: ;";'I"dJ'"1 "l"'I'I'~ "i'';;r;.- ~iil..":"IjiI"::""iI'" ,""I~ [t,o •. 'If.~, 'ilnil!i.l nUlJ "i"", __ .:I. r'1::-8r r->".i.'i' 1-=-,..,.IlIJU1i..,W l _Ml~I, u.'L.~ !IiiUJ_. ~1J-~-1J1 W]~ lI,~U&1J lU~_i:l"1 IIiiILI.L!II;I, l. t.K [~~.,_ __ ~~ IUl~;,J lI~1J

valrut. b, ~W, ,and, eoo:nomric ine,ua'l~ties, ;at-e' tOI ~&:fy.' ~ 'O:O:f;I,diitii.o:~; f.ir:sl;i, they ~ 'to be ,a;ttadt~d, ~, ~iOJ;ls and Qftic~ are~, 'f)O. ail~ ~der


,clln.dii;t.iUD!!; of :&~II e-q,~i~' u:£ oppal1Jtrlni~ ;an,d ;~Ji.U,~~ ~~ W"t;i.' 'lQ ~ t~, ~~, ~at~t, be!J1;~t or (he, leg ;ad,~,~ mem~, oF: ;~e~'" (Rawls,

1~,iiVli~';' c~=ij!)-"I_ Th-I C -~""', ,-,-,~,.,._ ... i;~,,-,~ .. ' .... ~""·n-'L.- "'""" 'I,~,,,,":~:I T-"'~' 'po" ·~ii.'i ... ~:1 'p,,,~:-,,--. ,- -: '-- -,' -'1 ,-~~

~~Ii,;J~1 ~-u ,. , '.! ~-~ 1 .. .s"L'1-1l ~~I u.~~ ,,1lKS i •• HIIi ,L~iIII.I.,. ,,tl'l:; ' .. ·).I"UL-itlJ .. _ I ._ I I _' . Uti

- - - - ~ ',' - - ,r "~', r ~ ~ - - ~ ~~. ~ ~ ~~~. - ~ - ~ '_ - '_ - - ,- - - - _'-- ';- - .. '_ -- _'-- - --

'I!"L...~~,'I\!: _..I' _-..iI ~-_iL,._ .'10., '~~~I" ~ ~itif:· "" oJ! .. 'I

I(lUieiiiiiri5nli ~ i!I.iI~h!~"-m 'to; illi~ luii~ ,a-c~Nhu !5tabli' 0": ,_liaID, U1i 'lml'ii""u~c.uw'

,I - . - . . . - -~.",. . ,. - .. - . - .. . -- , . . ,,- - - ... -, - _. , . -r~ H . -- '1

'li;benil ~i~ltie~ ;O~QnIl. 'mo:r~' ,md fIlQJ.-e '~I~Iy' toOl 'il!b~ ide:all..

Num~n:nB, liibHa'l:t [~i~d: 'RaWlsts dI-mt;"\,!' whirl';: <lD:n'tiiIl'UJlna IllO ~ti"ii'riI~iU'

• ., • __ • ,_.. __ , l 1 ~-.. l t. _ 1. 1 _ _ t. • •• ,.. ~l " __ ., • ,- "' I. - I. - _ - -~I _ . ' .... r--.-~

libe:~. Su-ch 'criJtia H~ >O~m!lJttcd 'm J;~tiice a::nd to tlte, other 'bask: 'W~~~ but th~ ~~,y Ith!l!t. 1b-Wls,!',S, ('ct)n(:~nwtiOQn, [00 di~u'-jblltive jlUtffie ,ex,'~SSie8 what. '~, es.sentitil to ~;_Kmll5:m., Or~, ,even, g. 'dtq' ~ o~ the imjpo~c.e' ,0£ dbtribtke j,lWii_t)e~ 'they' di~-e' 'wJith iIllIC' 'e<iO:f1omic [cpli.~ ~._~ ~at\ .Raw, ~lmms ,ddmiultlw'JIJ!!l~o-c :linm~iII, ,(~~ tor :In:mmm'!~

~-11;a .......... 11,~11'" , ''r'''''p-·!I'- .... r' [~~ M--'9fi; ..... ..,. 11~,1iI'~ '~l "!·I~'i'., '~n_",:.t::~ i"Ifmd'- 'iii ... .., jI~liu;;. ,""~i"Ilm..

~ctI_~-~~ IlJiiil!;~IIJ~1 __I_f&:_, \M;., U~I I _, _iAI~_!_ll IIJI:~~ ,l· - .. _r'!lr_ .. 111~/V.~ !PII_I_oII __ " I~ 111:~1'l U11_iAl;r·

mr' ,5,) .. 8'uI, [h.~fe is :110 dii~£nt am-on,g U~, ,about m-eti~ '~in,g ,SOc_rne bale~ politiicaitlJ ptOOura'ble .jnIiIIh~m :requiiJed, rO:~t 'Ililwt., acJoord.iQ;i' to, a-n~ [c'UIitOtl:~tiOJn [of a ,~, nf~ ail1ld, a'b'ii)'llt it '~iitiHl' ~~l 'R-cSN'i~gmn~' [of

... _- I,;: , .. ,j ."- r·- - -, .. I - ~-~ - .. _-- .: _ ... -,.~ .. _ -.-=-~ _I. I -_ ·Ir-,_.; - - - . - - .:~ ..

.. ,'i,. ~"L.._ 'II 'L. ~'",.~,' • a,

1~1,t'!' ~~m _te 'to ,SOC!J.H"e W!Ha~!f I~~t. Dlilnllm!llil'in 1i!Ii.

:h 'wlI~1 ,d~n 'll!bi5' aoc:QQ!n!t of' dt~, '~i1;; .~~~ ~ :I:i~~iu!n to' ro~sider ~m.-e' i1):f' ~e D'llilin ,di:ff-erenc:c:s, 'beDi',Hn. '~ni'O:ms: of' :nbenlii!m,. 11J'~r'it-~nJI:, ~1..""" 'L~III!~' .p~~'!'~' :i-,n ~iml ~II!, ~fi;'iI-~ ~'if.·~'t~:::n.r '~""" 'iIJ"...I_ ... ,j;;'G,_..1_ ;!:I;iII, '!!I[C:;~iII"'Ct,. ~-!l!l;;i~ [I~M!~ ... l~tl"'" ~.~.~ L, -~ !II-v. ~1!I!~1~1l ...... ·~·,IlYI ·n·.l~. 1I_1I_1_"rIl;" ~ l ~~ll!l.tlll~ MQi JI_~

c-;;d'" '~~beFaiti9mJ. 'Di~, is ch~,~, 'tlbart '~~ :~st basi~ l~berm, valru-c' i~, he-

...i""m- I"""[I~.·I-·,_.ll ""'" iii'h- .... ,"iii..~·~"", ....... A~ ... -.iii><>m-'il ,i,[I,i;_...l' ... __ "' ... ,..m:~'L, ~.,.d-'iHld-··I··~~ u-~ _ .; -i!! '1...!-v .. ; ~ ... ~ It,cu ;~ 'IiI_ .; ~I !R~~~~,..I ,~,.l, ~~_ l;:.u ,~; 1~~I~ilJ;-'_MI !!i..~~",-I '~IlU_.LI, ~_I_~.' I_.F~~ :_~,

u~tie~, F::~wQm ~~t be' IlQl~~d, o[ oo-:-~ne" '~~, o~e PC~~~;~I m~~ ,K~ti~!!i, 'rna"!' iri~rfu-::, 'wii~ ;Dor:h~r' iV~n!'!5 siMilar' acuwoo- 'Th~' [d~

_.-J •• 11 I r."- , !J-' __ .. , ., lEi ,J • _, _I •• _ r., • lr--:IoI::o , .. , _I •. ,,_ l". -. - _r. [_.,. _ _ _ _.

,c-aiJ :ti[be-m ~~ w tlhc: q,ueJti"01'l, of' :h,-ow these iiimijg ~, be ,jtl$tilfiab:tr dFa~, ~~, dl~~~ 'by :£m~dQ~, ij~iJf: ~n'l:r ,.~, li-~u, .n jfii,di-v-idlual, ~ti~ de~, tha~ :prQt~t the' iQp.portul1!h.i~ ;Of an 'iin-di;ri,d1Jal~ 'W :~' fme ;~ti~

.~~III!, ;!:Io1fO'"'J·,.jI"'iiI" • .:IL n· .. , .. ..-..1. n'f' 1""1,;. ... , ,~-!- .. f~' ' • .:11 "'JfI;IAI'i"1 w: .... ;o'L'~, i.~Ii, n ... \tIutI,'i"I!" 'iii\ll'lo, ~-'!r.o!i! ~~ ~~.~~_II~U~ II. I~-~, lll¥ilr'!ir ¥. I IY~~, I~F~·~'·~!lll::I_I~I~~~Il~,~ t.V UU "[1::14:.." .... 11::lr'!lr.-.__-'!tr.-~,)J ¥.W!I

:~[te-e' tib-e' moOd e~OOndVe' lP~k' ,sp'he:r;e wiii!hin, w:l1rre'fIJ :lindj,v.idna'lS ,~

'-I~' ,~ - --' . ·t..,. , .'i'.,~~:t' I~'i.l.· '1' ]-, •..• ' W'L,~. f""'~ '1 .....

. !;U, ,1I_fCe ro [IDa"' [UI; Ui!:!:cl)[, ,nvcs_._',~;lIM, 1~""1 ,PU!~ase"

:Rig:h!u, d~fini!i' 'di1li :~,~~U ~n which jfiimVJd~s, o,ug'ht not 'w be ~~~f:;r. f-ered, '\ri~~ [!:qluaJitr b)!)ll(b ;iUDong :iLndi,MlJail'S :m, ,re!!l,pe:ot. t() their :[reedlo:m, oil 'ri'a;h~ J"ilwc'e OO~Wt1l:, in tb,@, ]~,l [nM{'@otio:n o:f f~edo..- ~llaititv-

- ,. , '~'IC< ' "-_ . . - . -- ... ... - - .. - ''''''is .... ' ,1;"'- ._, . - .-. .., -, - ..- ,I' -'";II 'L'l~

,and rirh;bi;, and plQtailumtl g, the ~JtJji~1iIJ dlat. fR\e iQmvid~..a_b, \WIiU puF-' ;$~ [diff~~~t ~-o:-m.~~ptiQn~, 0:£ fa,,~ :~if~" ~~h ,~fwhicJil, ~a;, ~ f~a'bl(!i

;' ' - ,.~ 'VP)'t • - -'.- ':,,-',,- -' ,,-, [ """'~"]- ,,' . . ,".1.. i"i,., ~Ilj. " . ,-! "i""i,o.i"," , ~'i!- . ~ :"~ ......... 'iii· • .' [~#' '.iI:' ~ il iiUl-!OJl, 1""'" l!~O'mmc.n3U_1I! ~ e 'W;tYIi me o W'I,en., ,I, ulS: B ',"ue ;11~iI,dlLl5m, Uol ,_lilli

i"l-n~aii. IB...._._'~l~= tlll'9Ght '~'~d·l~~ ... "b- I~H~~~-~"\o' ijl~iI1fut!~1i ~-..Ji 'fi=I..=~, r-liirI.'~'= __ ' ~'I\o.

\.,",,'/[1;11'1'" .Q!I;;'lI:,~", ~.Ik~;~ -~:h- ,!f'J]~: [~~iI!I, ' are., [\'~'~i:~ any, ,~,n" ,!,""!!U~I;;.

J"l 9'1'4,~ ,31mO:~Q' [()I~['S. Th~rn' ,aim m~raUl!' ,and radi:Gd '~mions of' diaS5~

\,' .... 1 !!I' I .. IJ~ __ - ..• 11__ _ _. _ i I __ .... -.... _r. I I. _-._ , •. I _r •• __ • -l. _

[~aJ, I~be~,., ,an.-d dl-e ~l!~ ~~, ve~nO!~, ~:bad!e ~nW' Ube~i~ [-(,uo-e' 'iI''''f'm~III!'k,'v '}n8,"_ 1i;·'''"~'h!:l;'I1Ii ][gr:l~- '!:ll1II'I'd'-1 N~~III!oin'l1li ]n88,~_

"~.~ '~~~~<I ~~~ w[l! ~ .... ~-~~ =- w~ ~.~.~ ~w~,,!,~~~ .~~."~.,~,



EpIlitmati, :f~be:~ ha '_e:n crilU;~d, ~' t~iU1, U~, :fQr 'N~n,g ~~-(Iiv~' :lin :~tI, ,niqr '~:Rdli$tribu)tiO:fII~ by' ~i\a.li)n :IJiMEah :mr not 'ixin,g

~~ift:; .. " .. ~-]" [e'n' '0,110\'1;0- ""'1IfI'd-l, ~ ""n'l1O~~'~i.!"!", ]~:;i,.~~-, .i"o. ... ~'~":"d- - Oiniino ii"''-',",:"",ii

'1U-IS .... - .. IAII[~_Ll. - U~,.LIl.!! ~-. ""r ~i.r'V'tI_::I_~ .. ""'AY~,... 1_~lb'~ll~ 11J~1 ~~ •. -.~.__:III-Di ~1UA1~_j

:5taiQd~ '~~def '~e' :~ of neu~rtlf'~, 'but ,.~, ,c;:riti~'ism, chat has, '~CD: :H1O:d :m4l!~nitiail, in, ,mapin:g ' • .e' de¥tJ.o:,w.tnt lOf' I iberaJiw, :~ roo.m~' ffO:m ~O'miiDllI1fi!j~$" :Some '~~rL1l·iJ~~,,~ '~~~~ UMra!ls" ~~ I(unc:

, u .. ,·.t' '1"·' . ..-..An -- - - - . - ,A,:tt::,c -1100, ....... ,~~~:-" • .4.. - ,.ii.. ~ -,c ,- ,.4;'- -~ ~ c ii\iio, 'i.. ..... ~ .- n;ri11;'if;i:jj,o::-,

are illO'!IJ.;, - '1Ii., I!J """'LKim, very ulilc!l'CmLI. 1!IoV gy"l!le~ef a y_~U~ ~!!J,~I!;~H ~ _ _j-r-

am, 11be_ml1s[ ad [c'O'LmiOnl!.([ltamms[ g, '~eg two vcmO'M, 'm-libcrall~, '~F 'be~e~ its ~~nd~l':'S, ,and len,tiics" :h oomplk:ams, mal!mu, :£ufilll~r that, (iU.' ~iU1D'i~i8,m, :itMJif':bg ;~raJJ ~on!L ,qnpg':hm, the ~ol~lalbt I~i, 8)[ ~e' (i'i):pi~~,~ :rlg'hrt., ~ r~nlla~ [of :this, position. ,a!['i@ :Ronal~ iD";' .' ('llntlitlii\ A'I _~'. ~ \;ii'~ ~'[ ~ -~ - - "}~'iii DifiiiliGIl) 'Uo.ii __ - 'Moo-- '(:'HJ9S"" ~l!ller:~""i\JI~,'tI! ,::,-,;UiLLIJ[' ,I;"",acl 'III!~ ,=~! =~,'" '~~!15~""'~ , __ ~~r.-e,c_;~_:c ''It<

Mkhael, ~de] l( 19.8~n~, Chtil~" [T~lQF I~ IMh~ :l99!) ~[ aJiid, M~£"bHl

"'iIi~;".l!!11'''''' ,("~ nl)!IiII'~ ~ ft·ld.I_~"'ll .' .11 ~-~ l' ~

The :fOws, of CO~Ufli~~, ;eritidsnu U, the waf' in which ,ep!lj~ U'berah, ~~de~d ~u:ron,Qrny., 'Dc' Wl.It'O:fiQlDOm :ti1~ :b1 ~!l:utrug'ht 'by 'th~m t;-, be ,-~~- ~ Itiailt':: :~,d:V,i.jih'aiJl!t.k' 'Hi:!~Il!~m5.md mtio:nfa!J- ;a!lmed at 'f:'M!I~inQ' }O ~ .. ~ ~Q,_ . _ , UiI iii, ;u. ..~,. _, ... - .. ~ , . . . .. i!' ..... ,. "__~

a, :ptiwt;e l~o:1t~e,ptWH, 'M a :~, :~if~J ,and one ~F yi~' (Jdt~f' ~~~~' :and dt~' own mci~tv' fmm the' WHt~Q'''e 'DiOiint of't;'tle m're ~'h~ n'IMr :iim dt.at

. _ , --" ..... "";l .,., ...... ~ ,r-~-'-' - ,.-- ,,- - ' ... ,..--/' ,r'~'l 1., .. ___

oon.cepd.0]lJ. Thee ~!j.lble 'with, thill '~~de~dii~g m;auroH~iiIiI,rt ,ac~or.-dlkig

- - n, twoil·, M· ru ... 'Ik. ~I a, 'Ill f'

;1;--:" '-::-~---"""~I~r"'('~",,,,,,,,,",ii1'it,_, "'-," :- '_"\Ij'i; ;~ '.f. ''''''fO''~·p .. ·II''"'i!'-.nrl''l> IU~ mOr,diI, '~',lIl0~~" 0:' 'LD ~o.m'.' •. ~1lIi~ .. h,Qi.',MiIlII!I"'l" I • ., . i~. _ iliA ._ • ..,,, c!' ...... __ '!W. _ """"'_(I!~'~ __ ~, _~ _ _ _ __, _ __ _ _ _ , ~.~

" l 1 ~ '.-_ ~j

:r,ati:mud .ntsJ; ailtd ilt :m:,p1I~~~,t at 'be.s~ ,only a, paniet~l\ar '~~ne~"tion

of a :g~, life" 'wbJcb, e,pltnii~ l~,~~ ~ham!piQI1! :~Q ~~Ijaition 'm dleil: (::Qmmiiltm~n~ ('O, :n~1.:1Jt17an~'.,

O~ !Lhc int, ~OUJllll" oo111i_uni~an~ ~e 'ilihat the t~,~ifCnten*, of ~J.f;.

:'",j;--: --:--t~. 'C-,jI;.~~,...;ll~iIV ""'~''''I ~~""""!ip r- ,.~~ .... ,4'£: ""' ~ 'IL:~.,., ;""~." ~"'1i't'.J~~iI"","~, ~, Inl~~~.~, ,['!1u-'U'ulilll!l.~:,!' ~~ &IJ.U """"" .. 11 ........ _ !IliI'-'!'U,O;:]! UI g, ~I"""""'" ,nil;", II!IOI,~ U""", ~i[iI.nJ""'YI l~l

aAWbJ:l'lomo-w; ;¥nU but. :ar~' tlte pFOO.iI,1e:t.5, on'me' mend 'ndliti'Olii, linw 'wbkllt, indiwd!llails, are' oorn ~d, whose ideail:s~, 'v,ah~~~, [OO:ilve~lti([~~l[ and, pt.ID(~pJe-s, '6e~f 'nlond ;tl.thJtIUnn, fll'DUk3ttft ~n, dl,@m. M@u~rf ~~n~r" cit g, ~ly ,c.Q:R:Q~i~d! ~lsti~Wy:. N'~~aJl'f'~, ,a_pHIU 'd\~Jl'tlfy mlth dt~r'

£..= -'I~ ~ ., .... L~ 'I!I .. :L.. • ~.'. '" ~ ]] • -.

iUIlIliIIiU-" -, i1.n~n~ ,Q'o. )ti;':Iili!J!ln(l!S Cli.i:uUI£ ~un.c.-. OOrCdlnnJUiSh;;, Qr' :IJeJlOW CI'UIo.

__ I! ~!ii!' . . -.!I' -, -""'QI-· '!,. - . - - .. lei·' ~'. r~~" -" _. ~~~ . -- --". -- - ,u. . ~ ~ ..~.-

:z£~s., Tlteiir. 'iind!iJwd)na'tlty~ iihudoJ\e, is[ H!O't formed, 'by ~lf<~ation b~t by'

[""Iir"'" '_}~~~~i~,p'IL·I'I"iilv,,nf·: '·lln;.ne.I._nO':'li!lOll' "',n;'!I:Ji.'b~ ... ib ~:i;.,p"v '!:II~ ,i:I.r.I~u.r.t,Ari~ii-nn .... ntV.,n,n ,i;'~~, 1IJ_1 ... · ,LLLLI'!I;iI_I""_" I. I'!I.r_IJ~:, ~ 1 ,_I::I~I~I""'~'iI::I~IIr.~ ~A!I' 'I!T~~I_~~I::Il Yl~'J !WIl ~ !iI!-¥i!~~-_!IrI' ~}Ir~l!I"¥:~~~~.__J.J.';t! ¥~ ~~

,,'; - .. , ... ,', .-, ,". ,it:, 'd-" -' ~,-:-,,,,_ ............. ~.~ "t'b.,~"~c ~-c·-!Ii"'~c"4i~·,=,1"'--~~ -1-;-,-1 ,-:--:- .. :-:=;1 ,~-.=,..:J"_

VlIew~ OO~!!!li!JlS, I!IiIJ liil~:_,_I!H,K ,a nt ~'~lE;len iljJJ.eill' ,ln~!IVI,(lIilhl1l~ ,a!lJu ,mOIfItll, u:anl,.,'

11- - i'k'k~- 1989[\

. con, \': i, .. ' ~~ , '.~ .. '. " -J.

~ .:L.· I' .. _ ." :: .. ,..;i __ .. _' :: ,":- :. -. _ ~ - - -_ II r - ~-" - -=-~:-. ~. -, ,_~ .. ~.'i'_~I·"·· .-:- - ,- .a. ~'i1..'''''~1 ... '~-- .. :-::_ -;-:-c-,.:-::_ -:-1" "l.:·- -,"

""'~!I!, !!I't!e ,~Q'J)~ 'CQ'UlQ~ CJi)nlfIiQ~nrl!~5 "O;]n~ out. UNlIl. IUl~ c:onC:clipllo:n

.,~tf' -,~; ~fiif~, '~-:::'I'~ '~r ,~i'I\i:!i. ;.~i~~';o;i~"i'7' ~ii~",;""",,,II ... ~ iii .... , ... ~'r-""'m. '!I;f.'.ft-,j'io_~~~'V Ii;oo, _~nl~~;ol;,1 __ ~I, !J, ~~ liU!:C;; 1i1.~,l'IiJI, ruJ' e.s"'"'"~- _II, h~\liiill':li~, !IiI!w!' nill.'!W!', .. , MM!liu'"' •• v ..... JI .:iP. ""'-':".l~""M J'

is O:D'~y one aim.Olll.g' mao,y" The :i:nsls.remee' on indlwd'ualis;m, :rati:oItudjty,,, aJfid ~1rlyjAg :fOF w~, ,.nJQ~ ooIlC~!ptjP:_lli of a 1''OOdj ~I':cll Is ~.~, :p:i:'Od'll£:L of t'u:t~ stmn_d i~ ~e W(}~m, ~~~ 'ii1ait: :~ ~e~dl ~m, ~jbe' ,rE1nU,gb~if¥' menL, It iI, ;~u'Im'~, vo:I)jj(umis~c~ atomi:sti~~, and 'tingitd, WI., a, ,strong dose of P:f(),rnetihean, m~~Qi9m (Ram~ UJ92~ ~d, Ta~l~r 19891)., lE~pitiJw;.


iiiiN.~~'if:~ .. f ,~","":",,_j;.:',._,, '1. l~

!rP,,,," ,.r:.iJi ~1!11!. Ji iJl

~ '~~be~ fJBiIta!ke· this [t();n~eption 'm a·l~ life' ·f.of du! good life ibeLf ..

Th~' f,~jl. '110 RIi<~Iize, 'illh::l!t: 'lhe'~ '!II~ :reti~A"'la', ~~~-,'IL ~··iI!-·Ili;\I" _ ;~:U':r~:rti!llfnl_

- ~~~l ~~". ~.~ ~ ~~}":"":'·[rIi~-~~~ ~ ~~-~-~ ~~~ w ~.~ ~~ ~ -~-~~~!~;II! l~!!!;~ ~~_-~~.J ~p~~g_!1_IIl;lJ

' ... ·i"""'"""'!I"i'i"hfi":"I .. ·'I- :"'i"1"~. ~1;'>;'O!~lllI'l;'>ti"'~ :'1""""IiIi ....... plli~;i'"fo;.,.·;I; ,...£.: .... a~'1"'" 'If\~"" ["'-:-: ~ .. i"':li1'"!b.· ··i"~> .~ .. .. ]!~ ..... ~ oR"! ~~II!".iA!I~, oA'I!!II~ ~~~I_I'!'I"",,_..,~d!I ... "V~[h .• '!Iiii~. IliilI!U!'.Uo;:]I v.l, A g:UY'U .lliI"" 'Ii.O 'JJ'lub2 _, 1!JI!l15~. o.

:W~ed ~" ~~~tP:'i.di~g of ,raultQIlIO'rny 'i;.s DiOt. illg~~' tfOrt::~gn 'but iIlbn'i:a.i1,.

'1("D""'ll~IIi""or:::i'li'''' 'I'I"~~'-r"'~" _ iI"If.-"-"'~- _ ...... '''""f"IOjO·O')oi.i' [(''''1".,.., 'f';I~"'i""'"i"";'~ ·~'~~ijOl."'iiii<io l~'~c", ii' .... '; - '-.':; .--,=. [-"';D'!III~~ ~~Il I _ ~lll~~J 1'_'L~~.I,""IJUt., '""~ ~-HlJ_IJ_II"'Ul'J ,-V,lll_iJl __ ~1I_LlJU1$' U_UiiU_IJ_lJt.a.lLI". U_I_IIIILl U!J_lI~ [I~

~rn.~~lt. Q"gb~. ~gl ~ :fiwtt:al iI1l1l():Jt._g· [co.nee-pwms, ,0£ '.,e :~~ ~O:I' 'they' ·the~llve~ are ,mythi~g ltnJ,t ~e!JJ!tJrfd a.l~)!!H: MdUltEn'~ oonc~pnnll&,

lJi~r.m ~f. d. bn~ :~ itPw 'tihcsc' c(Jmm~~~~ ·Cc_ri'lk~s. tiD biC!i'Mt ['n ,th~ m.gf~ :FG.C~mJ~ .R!!I.po:m~$. m~~ ;teenu to' be Ciln~m;JW!' '~at ·th~ 1~lmlm'Cnit: [caJntn.ot be :aJ)t:oget'ltli£lf' :n;m:ljtrn.l~ that :tiibeJ."aUsm. tis, :not 3, ~nl!llYe!f'" ; •. hr'um:~. ideall·bu!t. ,o.nc' :~iiitriot-ed. tJ) ·lite ~iliilk'X)t 'm"Westem~, "IiMperousj ll'1d!ustrSl~dj, 3~d d~mD(;rati:(: ;!lun~: dun ~~ditu1id\,;a'b ,M-.e f'Oornledl 'm 'iC'~

,~n, .. ~:.~iI ''''''''''''. t' ''IO!!II:.-.t ,'if-, ... l~'i!-- [ .... _O'liiI'l·lil!;Iii ... 't ~1;1'1Ii. i'''''', ". 'M''i-',o'oi;''''1,.1 ~;L .. ii"'U r ' 'hi' ..... ·~r·. -::.' ''''7~ '--1.,11 :i-;-l .~ ~'I;-r ~ .. 'Ih ~i- -~,:, _ll~l!'!!t!l'll.J."~ ~J' I.n'"" 'Io!"""', ,!II ..... ,.. .. .. ~'IW.!'!I"I!.II!~"""II! U.I,~~. 'I'!I!"" .'t!i lKlI' ... iIO~. aFtg ~n W.uL1;:u I;:Ilq'

have '~en m~; ~art; RimJl1a;bl~ ~-DfiC~p~I;Itq of a .~. '~ile '~n~llude ~es·

,of .~etian ,an~ Sllfi~~ilihll.· i!IIlnd··I·~iL. .. ,..it· ~"I,. , : ... """iI'ii~;o;.I.or;-£.'·~f·.· ... '"i";];I'11 !!:iD'j!f11il!";4i:; '1':;:[-

~ _ ~_'""""' .. _ ~ ~II _!,y _ ~ ~~~ ~",n ~~~._. ~lU-'lln, I,U ~"_"I,''IiillI! UI'J. .IJ L'IOuu.~dOl ~._"n!1!3 liIIil' .IIID .

'by dte;mse:h,~s. d)mn,c' dlo£ gO<ld$ (If'dl~ i~~b 'w;b,o 'b:ave OCIn, Mm-c' IieCen'i. 6bend ,t&in'l~. tD~l:c.tpR:~: .a!ttlOlllom,y .and plnrdiljsmJ :f:[~dom~ rig;furu" eq~Jail-' ~.!I and di,mbuti~ jW!lIi'CIe in. ~~. ng'ill of ldt~· (ritiCi5~ SOHl,C' ,e;-umples, iHCi~de' GalSJ~~ [19911)., Stt.l.aI't. "'al1m,~jR (l989') '-I cMW~ .KJmiIiiDu. (I.mh 'Ohafil~ ~me (l'98') ~ M~of:ie (l99S) ~ hwbi, [~llft!):. u:d Iaiz (l19861).


(If ,a. ,~, Uf~ but ra$, Wi.i. idEal .0£ wh~t :irndl',viduab O'qhit; '~Q! d~ t>QI :V~~

'~'r!'l;it'~r 1"·n:n·"".i!li ... t-:i ..... ;'1dlf, [~"" 'I':,,"~ '"i:'L.~ ~Q'[i!lilPd' . I :~;jI' .~ _ii[ A:' ··:.I.;"oi'1ifn-;r;.m .. '" ,i., '~~':-!'l;i. :",'L."" 'nl_I_Ml~,""'J!'!!UI '!IwJ-Vl. _ ~rr.--"'J~II.J!I! U,I] I_n .. !llW_1~,l-' .J ~D.'''''''l . MiiJi ,&.f~_'Il _U-!II~ _ ~l __ ,,.. lL-i:ll 'nll.&!11I ilI~m

b~c ~]jli(iaJJ ~~!!i, of likm.l~ ~~ ]~IMf:i,d~.d '~Q :f{)~~ gd :pr.-Qt~t:.. A~· tq:m.o:my ~~, c1ie' ~nd. ,~w'hri~b ,th_~K' om« vail'ues,.~ ~Qjl"ti!'nl~j'ts or t~ ww¢b they :al-c: ·mc~-. GoH!~MK!, :if !1N.(tO'1ilomy· were: '~mp<mlblc' :(too; Mlm.e· :inift., '¥idJi~Uii't~ ~ had I, mental [d~Fd~~, 'we_~ ~·'in.'R;py :~'llI" ~F

b,g,d-l [L-'~ .~~. ~'"1" .i'~IlI3!'-I·b- S1.,' "-'·'·r~O:~~~ ~~'n ~"""l' i··~"""'-"'i' ["""'1"-:" .:I'I··:i"1"l("- ~:~<I;I;~ ~!i;"" ~ ..... _... _.g, l~1I21, .IL.I,1i ~"'~I~ ,_ ' •. " 1l.f-.l1.lJ.1iiiIlI_~Ul L!liI __ JII.IILIJ IiUJIl~ •. ~ !I."J-~,I"I,U_ jU;.~,IJ,.~Y! •. WlI~ !\r_.A'"r

[le'f'Jjt W whi~!i. the :~c ·~~~tu~ Oli.ljht w' ·be· pn:M.d~d! (QJ' '~~m ·~d. '~, dmlnJ$hcd. by' am. amDU[!)lt :pmportiunal ·to ~e~F (ljmiw:utidl a~~,,, Itt:) atit.ai~ :alllwno;liB¥',

'lluli' [~ntlaJi :f£3itUR of ill!lli!an,omy' 15, ;a, rsroific :(0:~ of £:cOD)mol dlat :indil.Vcidua11 age:Oit!i e,,:eKise 0YeJ:" ·.efJi :~ti'Ons.. '!!:By ,a!U,wDcrxm,y,,'" lSlate; ,Stan-, l~ knID" i"1. ulu:IEnmnd a. ~h~~f' niit( am.()~flltj~r I~D a apa:ci:t¥' hJ[ IiKt alii. prine'~ple"l " , .. , flIt ,at-c; one":s, ~ 'because' ~ne lla! .~ ,them, :SQ by :a

'j;'U'1~- .. ~I!' ~~~")i''''''-~ ,~n .. ..-~~.ryn.· ..... """1 ~:-:--''''' ~'m-[ -'n:'~"" 'nri,n. #"-1 ..... 1 ...... ""'"!"d·l ,~~I·liIi~ .. ; ....... ~~ Jj-.ll'~~~ OJ: ~ .• _u'uiIJ.tiIJI IIIL!Ii:I~IT.~~!ILI'u, _ I ~~_IJ IlH!Ii:r ~jU _ -1Ii1J_1Ii:NI'IIr. r-.l. __ I~_ ~_III:L_-i:II RllII. rdu_.u._'iJ! ![JJ.:4IX

OIlC' hg =tQ~ilJated. from lon,e:',!!j[ :~i.aI! e1D.vii~H!mcnlt·t (U~8fk .");. .and 3I1?' ~oJ.\d'ilng to 'Gemld, ~r'lun" '~!'A, peliSOIJ; ~. :a;uJWno;m.0'1iJ5 :if"he idJeutll1cs'w[ijtb :ilIis de~reL g~! ·a:od mUe~ ~d. ruche iden~6cltiotll. :iJ :fiot, :~~1iC :~liIIt1l.· ~~_(=N. in '~y!' wbich .~ [fh-e p~~u d b:il~~dfi~~cm, in tQft\'e' wa~' iIli~ll 'm the' in;d_ivijd)!Ila~;'~ (H~I88b:; 6l )1., (Sec: ,ai~ Ch~UtIDg 1m,;, G·. DwQtPl: it ~1l!IiD." . 11 ~~~. ~""Iiji;~ ~~~Tii'i\;- '~(Ii.~e' ')"

J.l·~-l!i lli.~3!1 ~11I.IIUl tU_8i"'Y"lII !Ii.IL-t lIl'~y~ e-

. .tilil~~\i;'Ol;'Ii<oi'1ifm· ,\I' ~'I •. i1i~", iil(l;~'''',~;jI': [;OOI1.. .... i"" ... ,~ [k-.'.Jt· ["~;jI', '1I-f~!IJ,'I"1iiI"li~ l'I'~"~'~ '1l-":~jI-~~\'UJl' ~I c. L.oiii'l·;ONI>, n_IIJI~-II.V~ : .; II ~I}~ 1I_li.II'!f!~I~·~ ~I~IIV~~'!I IU.K.· 1D.~1iiI! ~l ~I~.~' -'1ri ~~~~Il'-' Mi· . IL~~ I'!Ir'~'

mar ~fal.mo:n [Of'lIe-a) CQ:nJl:mld 'be.~ th~, ,chQice' ma~' be be'tw«IiI. ,aillterna-' 't.i~i!!' :th;a;t. ~ t'"@:~~d Q:ml ,th~ •. ent, .~ ,~nit ma~' n(it Ih~~' :~~I.1l!a!h~ ~Wlt-ed 'the :av,all_lla!bl~' ai~maltl~~ 91' 'il1bc' .agCIiJit_ :tacbd :~dell1!t u~deV'-' ~d~.' (If:' ,~~. ~plfic3lit<l~ .0£ [[he ·dh.o.iic~. ,AltlJtoll'-ijl)m,~' il'h~ljieJm,e u:q.U'~rle;s. 'the kjgd. of (}otF~llJbat in.VO:lves .m uDm~~. chDi~e' ~o:m,g :a!I~mab.~ 'that Itb~ agCllit b~as rca5QD~alAy e~ab~a!led i!n the Ishit. of' ~de~t g~dC:f-'" ~~.d~.' Qf W(l' :!!i.:iiJjE'Dt"~· of.',~h,oo:s.ln.g Of;l~ among ~~ a\!laiib;hl!c' ,ai]Jmr:ma-.· hive!,.

'Dc' :Q!aMe of'rob ~nd. of (;nn.llnl~ may ~@n. 'M; s~ifim, by fi.~ tD:Dd~· d:on~.U); ftC'; :I~n.t oogd.ition. [s ~ ~na ,~ '~e' :agcnig. :poc:ift.',nn acti€Xn;iii. Aoti(Jm;~, :U~l ,~m~~~J!i,g clh~t q;~lts do :Ff~--r a m~lii" wbl~h u5Uall1y :in,VO:lve! bolD :11 :HtQ~ lind a. pal. 1'hoe' m'Q~ may ·be· :said. 'm M' a .• ,~" pr-Q.vi~d. ilt. is. undef,S~. bf-(J~'. The ~lnal! ~.5, d1~ :5a!~ti.~n ~f: ,tIi~ d~· 5ii~'i' .5i)re .. ~, 'm[oadll,y 'Ullldl~::ntoOOj are' [exlrclTilC~' '~d~ ph-,~rololi.ca11 aad :~,(;·h.ol~a1~ ~niJ!iatei .d! ~qlm~d~ pl~umJllLI(f ;and, :paif(llt.d~[ '_D~fildail: md htu"m"uj~, :;oti~' :and. :n~!. :~mpo.N.ttt ~d. tri\l'iia1, e!fld!!u'liH,1; :gd.

[i'_r;n(n''''-'ii;---:--:--: ii'""-"iI\iI'iOiiji;",,:""1i~ .",(.,.-'11 '''.i'''I~'''''''''1""",Ji'Ioik'I\,;,;'_ ~. !'l;i"I··,dl [ .. ~~~ :;O>i"'~ "'~. , .... ~t·If:o~. "1"'1;..1""'" IU'I!I'Jlcla.liLDIY, iI."-...lIilIIIIOW ..... IIIIL1U,U M_.'._.,''li.iIIIOlI'!U!',.,._a'U .~~ ,~"""""'" 0l1I0.1.. . _ .... '!!1~I~, IA'IU.'!<iI, !ill'!.:;!! Ilvii .. 1', ,I, ,Ill ...

. " ...- ,i! 1 _ •. - 1- .~, F-'i...,- ~in - ,i;'~ . :~ I~ -'nnS +L~n i!I·WU'l.:--; tn:: '~~ier tih:a(' ...... ~~l!Iit.s rc~, .I:O~ ClllQOI g U~e. aru_~~_ !!l-!tl~~~. ~~ __ \l.",,,, _~e ~ ~~~- _~~~t ~,'1'

,",'il.,~"'--:: .. ---;;-.--;J--.,.~, ... i!ji; ........ "1'1; ..... [Q',.~~'II .... ~ "''''I.'~.:·-I·i(!JJ !II' : ... ~, ~ ... ·I"""".'_ -·J.:-n,_'Q" .. ..:1.: ~;jI'i;~ '·1-' ~:",,~. IUII~1.r .~:J~l~'lrll_II""'_II!ko~ '.!ll~ ~-lMIJ u;IL ~~,1"l._.ll;~1 Il_I~I,~ LI_il_~._ J~\MI-Wl __ • ~I...-.:J_l!_ljllM l _oi:II !IHI_.u"!IIliti

l~tie:ly t'O he ac1h[leved, 'mall'll !06.e~,


'Th~ .t:0:l1:d ~Qlldhll(.'n i$, du' diei~ ~~;; Ith~ q~l~ (!h~' .' :~r" fQ:Uil ,~ti1ln~ 'lvm ~(!):fit__g' ~. DJ~'beF of aI~~i!ItirW!~ :th_~t. mq :~~~ly klli~ ue' awJilla'hle. :MdJjng' .e' ,eho:i.:c~ :in,V(lI~ 'ilhe :ag;eo!t$" :fe~n~'le bellicfs :in ha¥l~n,B 'dle Y1pwty uel, [th~ op,P'llnllJn~,ty '~:O 'pe:d'O:rm! ~nlJ ~£ ,th~ a,.la!bl~ ailt«.nau,ms. ~t i~, iSllI1lici~.t :f:ur nt'HMn.g ~!§; ,Ctm-diJtl,01!lJ ~~t 'the '3pfilm jbo~ltQ lii)l,d, th~, '~~i:e& :m:~n.abl~ :~t hi, iilIo:t !t-eqQ'iIDed 'mat. me' be.'ti,er-, be :tlmt; M,d'6ci~Iil!~: 'c-un~J '~K~B fhr' ~~tnn;Omy if 'fh~ ~[I,enjt.5, 'Uffli? lcn~ngty d'toose' the' ~lI~ity' ,ubj~l~y ;a~IJa!bl'e' :a:ll~rna~',!, '~t :m~u:e~ :~ ,th~ ;.n~'~ :il~Jt~n!I:aJl, ntnu.wtlolilJ t'O, ~rrfirm the ,actifil1ii!l~ :fitit wb£~.t;j[' 'm:ey ~b:ave me ,cap.a.cit)?, :and, o.,po~n'l1J w, periibnu ;:5Qme other ;acu,ons.

,A, fi;lIFthillr (~n$id~QtiQ:JiiJ 'be~ng [gn dl>Qke ~ '.~1. '''~!!l' (lQ:D<U~(!JJl [of' :a .. 'mllUmy' does[ :l1Iot d.epen,d, on '~e' qilllantirLJ' iinn 011 '~tll :~lfKIrtaim~' [m th~ [[;'hllic~~ .mrm ~m, m~~'", U'a:WiilI,g ~ple ,~'(J<pc:' fur ~h.Qlcc!!l, in triVI~;d: :m~t·· ters does, D.ot (lUmpe:ns.al:e ~Of' laekiiog ~r; :i!l:l, ~mportmt ot!u~_:s, lihat ,~OOm'ly : .. ~~ ,hi)W .~ rag'~fil!~' U~ (l'ayJ~F l~~, "[,,he r-.e,!;I!i!t-emCint gf'.aiU!toJ\lomy~

'''i'~''"~iffi'''l!'"'i"- ~ .. , ~'Ii..,~ -~ ·'t','t:Ii(lN> .. ·..,.~\II' ,;oo'Ii:r~""~dl '[[ ......... A'"1""'I'~I!I:!, i""'-'~ ·.·"'I~~"_ '·'~ml·", .... ·lb:-::_"" ~\oi~l ''i-l~.~- 1":""-:; lIIlI,I"",,,, !!Ir~," "'"i!' iI-il! [,IIMI ,!~"I.[1011 ",lilV'uil "!Io,,'IAiJ!U" .. ~""'UJ,, 1IJC. iI ..... '!I'~ 1!lI1~""""II\i~_iJ IL'I,I! liilioi"'-!IO;O iU;l~

'c~p3!d", ,.d, th'C Q,~~'i:tY' '~JJ :maike' ~BHi'c3!l'Ift C~,OOe8. Md s:ipUli,··

[ ..... f ... ~e :4'l!r~ .. I.ildl i"'-~ ~:Olfri'd--t,4'~ .... 1 ~iO]i' 't!""""'1'1'''' [~i?' ot'L.. ;:-~i""i~ ~!I.;-,..,t; ' ... _F'=-~=,--:_, ,"I ,I(:;;-;-,,-,;:i:.':-;--=""'''''HJ.... ,d!lu!IIII!I... I~ IILUii . ""'.,r.J!!II.!.l!'U'Ui 1.lIiI l!lUo..,101J1.a UJ. ",-_I,I,tJl~'IiO!iI! !li!lcll:IIi_ U.<II,'!t!E Hi ,lfD:nnJa_'la,m

:i;fi!IIJ~,~em.;de Olii, th~ life tihe' agMIM'lo o:n ro :l!ive, }k'(jIiQUS! aftimiatil,GJl, ,emJploy-' m,CillIJt" ,sexual (lUndilu:t" poiliMCail, :a]ll~ajl(:-fi', :M],{[i, pl~' of fC~d~n("~ ~i~WlIy' ,~avt ,~U'C'h :ro:~ i1pflue(!lc'e'~ wbere~ (;ult~~' ~dl, 'onl~F IPrererc11lC-cs~, ~e' [c\ho:i~' ,~" 'l:e~ t-Q' n,}Q;t J-br" 'ox' b-ow' Ito :~,pend a '~do:n, typ:i:UlJUy do :oot.

:M__;d~n---l' ehelees '~l1dcr these ,o1KU1nSaul{;ai; h~r.~[ ,may' ;st.iiU, fall, mun

,"'ti?' i~ii~IIi";-:~"'~' b=; .... a~:u~~Iii .... ,~~~"il"'tr .... :r.,. ''W!i!~: 'il""ii""'iTIIofioC-~l·~ • .;I1 .t'''''oii'''i-jil''r<'""'''' n..--,a;a-"I"'I"', ~1Ii1'[ .. ,'i.. ... , ... ::;."._.

"''tIl H!U!~.~.IJlj •. _. __ ::': ~- _. :~ ,I,iJu_1J 1 .. _ILI,'!b~ •. l!'l r'l -!II. !II.II.IJ.l.:iI:I!..r-"" _ ,[Illl ~U ,[i..H...!l.ti!", •. ~ [1f.'.I.!!IL.F~IJ_IIJ!l!; ~_IIHII ~]~ !I.;.o_~I.i--

CU~ ...... S .rO.lill.il 'ATPvPl"lliii' ~D',.., ... b 't:....."m.·1 ..... , , .. p'i:.ai·I''''''Q' ' .... '. iDi::: ""·1"" "'" t, "" ....... jt- ....... 'Il Li .....

'.e --'~~, '_ ~_~.,;.'I',U '~"-,~ .... , ,r""~'...-,"-....._.l~!Ii, ~~.~.,~' ,lill,v,' _, [",~i.,~_IiiJI~ '.!.t:II' ;i]!uU,I~ ,~lIilJL ~U",.,.ui'(l!', _. I!,~

'ex~lUde these ~Ylo:rJ,om~ej'ea;'ti!flg f'~~~ ~t 'is nc«u.uy I~O 'ilmpose 00('11, ,1l~pJti,~ ,3ID,d, :~5~t1V(l"~=<xn~QiimrM' o:n ch.Qi.'(i~ :so' as, w' be, able' :10 diim~p~ 'between; lDr<loautolil,o;m,Q'W and aD~J}!Jlo.mi!lJm, ~lnu~·s. TI!t~ n~xtt d:lr~' [o~1:l(li,· ~,(iIJlj awe bliltended toOl :s,peeifj 'these' 'c_Q~b"ai_n'b,

The' [",1I.11•I"d··-1 'N"Io~4II·rt,iie.,.,. ~;oo, :ii',i.C.,~, ~J<",!,'~' , .. il..d,~, .-:==,JI'i[j.'-'~~~I. :"'l""" .~~'L..~'\",=.--c-=-, ''f--.-. ==. IYlt __ .i ., !!IrV!IOIiU !i&"U,.,., IIII! d·j.Ci ' .... ;r,~ ........... !l:-'rRiJ\1!!L\iIli' «nJail"rm'\ UI~ ~n.Ql'l;,o!lq_!Ii ~ ~

tw~n, ,a\lte~~ tb~t ar-e' '~Qot f-arced, 'on dJ,c' ;.e~~, ''"IDleS, oo~dijtio:m ~~. ,~' two :n~tii,\,,~ [(l~Il$~IU ,W), tQh~, ciboi:(le ,oo:ndiillOQ by ~'I:udbt_g' ,d~·, ,~m!j.~'C5, i~ 'whie!h :iii, ;{::b;oi£~' :is :mad~ iblWt tis, :niOnaUJtcOao:m~UiBi" On,e 'way :in which, dil!ls [CalIl, h~~n :is :if dl~ ,aJlt~~ti,~ [~Gng ,,:hkh th~ 'cb~~' :.~ 'M' made ~' :(o~d, lpn, tlil.~ .en:U~, ,~ b~ :baviln_.g' 'm ch~' be;~eg perse[Ci;ir~o:n rand, 'oo:nveRio:n, 'nc .~u[ 'ch~j' burt: ~q' >ColW, hamly be ~tlP"" pased ~o 'have sldlid,ent ,c:O:ll1Jtn:iill.

A" choi€e' lt~t i:$ :r:O:K~d 'iifill tbis mD.inc4" d~~ :Il(:\t ~fidi('~re d~m~filhih:e(l [oO'ntF6~ :mer-cJY' boca~ it ~~t. 'be' maie 'benvee:n 'u-nd,(!si'ra!bl!e aJt,¢Im8!t.i~~.,

~ :~~~ .. , ..,.f' ~.A'~ ... -~'I '1i'iiYI~,,~I;'\iI'!o;E, ~' ... ,'li;IIi: '.Ii:f';IO ,,,,,'Ij'--:_;rn,<!io~~' ''ir---., 1r.~,,~-=-~'L"Cib'il'-" .,_-.,~.~: ",~~, = ~_~ -,~tM ""'" ..... y-,n!!d,''!U!\, ,.1 ~"'1'!1;1-'II" '!oLil! 'liiH_ .. _", ll~.... diJ!LJfiil,'H'M!U;!I!~--ca ~ un""'~i!Ii~l;u~ n,QII!;, }lI8J1!.

:fur ~3it a,p.nt ~n tQh3it ;s~tna'nll: burt ,also f'Or ~l" ag,e:ll!t ill ,th~t. ~rlt, o:f i~itua-


'i':'~(f;I. Thc-~ ~,-~:; ;-, ffit"iihIS, ,'-, ~'i!-'-jo '~i"~ ; .. ~,;i..am';:;;~ [b"""~n lWii!-":'L. '"11.. '" 'Ifo'~' y-Q~~_ '~'~~~ re~ ~~~, _~~~ ,I!!JIIY!~a!l" ~~e ~'""~.~",,",o:;!Il~!I:i''!I~,,,",~~ __ UOC!l!!! ~ey lJ_mYe

'to ~~ Dm"" 'M' ,[-o~ ,0:0 ~~nl.1 'Manse: oJ the: ~nklllllar· 'n1'd~Rln~§,

• _. -, .• ~ ... c. .,. I .. ,i. ,f •. J .,. ~I""'·· .. -. - . _-. ,1_ ,,_ r-J_-'Ii"I"_ ~-., Irr-"~- .~- .~- .. ~-~-~

,,;iir- " '.,..,~~ .' c - 'l~'~; ~ '~""",AI '~,- ·~4 ,,', -j' bee --, '. ~ '~Ir ~. rJi~.' , ,~- :.~: ~ ,-~' I~'L ~ - ,- ,- .. -- :'L.·-~l • " . y_~ey c'_M~ (:J)I__1U-W'u;:Qi ~~, !mol ~ ~~e iUjU:~ U_ile,ng;el~ .iCl!R

• ~ " __ ill:¥ ...lI,==" iL.1_. ,. ,...li.~ .1I1~=dJ .~i!! ,",I.. "I::.. '.'~ ,",b,= '

''C'mn-~~·UQlln~UKi mHi!V'ntmim~ '-C'lliil{wlie::'1!' ififiIiIlJi:rtm ~ U"~~' --- -m"

,mc-'.~~~.c' ::,; c __ - ~' __ c~ 1, __ c-·c __ ', -'--~",r"'" :~ I_lc~,':' .'-_1 ,_~~--,,~ lF~'''''~~~'''~c_~~,~-,,---,--, ,_.~~-,ag~)_:_,

'D1"~~~II[I""~IE, m,~'~,~ ,~m' , '"i" ,"'I'I"'........,.., .. ~:"'1'"'" .. , i"jIi~-"iI~·I~'I,.'I\io:I;," .. ''L.;iIII!~ ,":'I:--~' 'm:ud 'm""" 'I!--"~~ l~_I~!Ii:ri.jLIIYi.~~_~filI! __ ~...:r ~, __ ,., !AI. r~ll,lJ~yl"'~ lU_._~U.~-~ __ lldU. I'!G~ IIJ: .. ;o UJI ..... l,' , c. -. ". I ,.~LU ... ,I_I:IIII!'J."-IIUI

m8e~ a I~ ~ ,(i:OfiitfO:I~, p~ed, 'iJbq;' ~ ¢Otillool: ~ 'iheiir 'prt:fef-' oc-aa''''~nl! mav ihavtll' tOI ~IltOOK Mtwftn [hanar D;d mnibiilio:n, 'but if

• _ I. I •. _II ~ _,. _ . _ ~ _ •• __ • - •• -, .• .".. - •••• -. _ I. ~. _.. _. ~ ) I. _ ~ • _ ,

'~-'- --'b]iI"':"'-"- -, ,;,~ iii"""", ,~..-. , ,..'i..-.' , -- 'iii~" 1,- ,;.t!- --- -,ii-n,"- ,"'i'~ , .. b. ", ,':''Iil'--'' - .• ' 'd'-'· ..

~'.Le ,~-"J~~ nil ~ ~!I~,....J1g" 1Y!~eJl _,l__~e ~g,P~ __ Jtg:~~~1 w, ~~e CILwce ULJ

:I"~'iI",_' [0''''''.' I~ ,~:I"~'W1',"'"'i"'1"1 [I-·rl"'iIi' 1"'1.,; .... , ::.-Q', ... mj.iI',~ ,;e.':I]"jIi11"""' i'".n: ........... 11'"",. ..... 0;'". ... , .....,..~~,_,.II :"" .... f'!V

~1I!I,u;.~ _ /WI!!!" L_,'!;OI',i]OiJ YI, '!Iru-,J!~!!l.JI,.\!P-= '"",,iii. IU~ ,,,",,11,,,_ ,. I!I.'I_~ .... 1!Ii,"" "'"'~'""., I!;"ll_~· !lion,,,", '!U'!I..!I"~U,~, iLU,_,

:ba'!'c:, On 'Ilhe 'O'dlc:r hand" d~e 'chO'ice be.~ !~f8iC-ouJliag ;a1rJd tOan~nlo;n: ('ann~, iM :attril:niuail [to [rl1.~ .1i'I!~~' :fiUllU'~ flo ~"~m~ 'nG:n!lJ"¢)~!, ~~ :~t :g, a ,fo~ (~home 'be,~elJJ :iil':lit;rin.~' '.rnu1~~F3i'ble ;a!l.temad,~. U:mf~~ed, [oh():k~ ,~tu;nilild, m~D, M 1iU1&mr(K)(ll as ,ch(iJl(a ~t ~' n(()~ :ful!'(:fi, oFiJ :apm,u 'by :~nr~sit1ll1y ~d,tsiJJ;fa!hlte, ,wt~atiN('5.

T.1It~ ,o:d1l~F :Ilt.~ ,c:Qn!l!tnUDt on, i1h~ ,c'tto:i£l'; ,c:o:u:dii:rion:iI dbat dI,~' ;aiI)t~ir" ,nadve!, nb1l:I:c::' tn the ,agCDJt. aq'llt :no1. ro ·be, 'Fesllictmrd 'by' -round and

,~ ~ ,1" -.;' ~ ..... 1 _='jL,- - - .. ,'b. ~ -. ,"'I!.. - - - - ,~ ~ - 1Ii - -~ - -. - - - - _. ,~, fill' ~,'b. - - wlla'bit - -,'b - , - ~ - --

:roll~C~ l!~"ll.e!il' ~U.~ lUil'C' ~O!~, ~Q n~t ,~~e,pt. !JI. '~1IC: ,a" . ~_i__ _:we IQ~l.U:[:U,(:~ ~-,

d~' mEre '[\etirious,. sexuWJ, md aes1lleti~ ~Citic,eS 01' can~n ,31Ild' life.-

• _" -.. ."L __ ~ [ I. ;~~ .. -l_!. \ - - -~ - _. . _. •• c... . lr-'- . I. • •• I . _ •... .. _. J

;Sty-:tel o.:~ dl--e: :p0lltnd 'that they ge ine0:mpatible w;j~tb ;1(t1DC WI~ w~bi(:l~ ,ar~ :ng.1. ch~, ~mr~" (tWD, .. men, 'lh~ ,dh([~~ ;arBt'mg' ,~~, ~!mWnjn:g a1i~m~ ~ ~ 'not :i:u'll:y acUitall0nl0!J.l5. &W' la:rr ,:u~ldll leK:ll1.WOO'.j acm.aillf ,cuftalil ,aUiwnJ~:mrdoc! not depend o~ me: me~_, of the c_ 'Wl 'their,elc'l~n

'Ii-., . . 'll.,. - ". c ..... -. , .,':. ru " ... 1;.... . -. , • ,",'i..~;i;. ;i;ii ... · .. ,. 'I ..I_.:il -:I' -, m' , .' . -.. 'L-.-~

~ul. 0,0 ,n'OW' ,Impo;rta:nt, [IJt!lS W me ;ageDJt8 IU_m.!l, W-,l,e ex'C1U"",~ w,leL~a:tweS, U'!l;

,·it iL.1_, :l!;t," 1::--. .L, ' ... --= ' ... -~, ..... , _I., 1·-1 IL._ ' ... ·1

,~v.lh~'~ iUr'iI:uf.' '111'0 '~uIiiEF I~ hli~j;i t~_t. 1u_JC'i! ~!:ii:fj'!nts ,Mi~U ALiI ~ au Ii: tF,

.:it _." ",..,' ~ ,_ . ... i[.... ~ , .. _ , ...,. .,,~ . . _.. .. , ~ ., . _ .,. )0

'reject: 'th~m, ~Jf" ''nJs :Je¢:ogd, :kind of ~~ptivc' >O():~t. 00, di.-oe ~hoic:~

_.:if· • _~'i., 'O~':.A . ,",'i:.~ 'b '" - ik- Ii _.:II ik~+.'i:.. ~ 'h .,

IC'O']'IMIJttiQ'~ ',,-,jiM;/.e5, :lit, ii;;;~~ent, I~Mt ¢.:_d)lC'¢!I!, leg ee : .. ;'O]\(:lw Iwu~ ~] ~~a~~Q,1J

:1ip!tri~sJc~· 'Ulild~rniliJle ;ajlte~~ to ~b.~, k~n ,and 'by [depriving

;.. .__:' [ t~l ,.,,-,jr,' '~'~'e ",- , ,,' -.,.-- j - , ".'I'U' f '-'1 ~..:Il~:., - •. ~ , " .. ·.b· '~' ;"~iIi"~ ," "iIi~'~' ,I . ~ .~ e • , b'il __ .o)1O'lIi OJ. Uilt!: iOppo",,',lLIil'llf~;, Il-O U'[;€lI!llJIen! ,3iJi. iIIi.I,,"",ma]lll,!II1i;;!;Ji ia:[\f:: '!I.lImua_ LGo

Th~' :fillIfrntb oond~ilofi, b, du' I~ ~i_ dl~ .~n;~, ~ 'favor~

;~Ltv' ~;-IJiiI;il'iI"i~AI '~l'ij. .. l'i,;j'oiiiil~r'iI!1i '~I'ij.c§lI~' i""l;-J!i.V' .o!""i!-,;n.,n;1i.iji, 't,"'1' ~rifoiRi\l'il'~ ~'iiiiJ ;iI'In:"fI~~t:;\'lIiil MiYI,1 ""!J."'!IiIfI_ L~~ IIl.,,,, R.1I.-~:!W!"il"l~ W~I_@~ 1UJ_j;'!Ir.·,I" "'IiIIlI:ll~w."Ir.· ~ ~~'i J[ I. ~ tIL~_.-~ III [[IJ_19 ~-~~d~il,,_jU,'!i:I.',Io~

:i!m~s a, ~dve c:o:nstndElit on the 'cbo~ .oG:pd:ition by' :~u.ir:m,g 'tibe

'L.-_ ·._,.11 !Wo,;:: (Ill .~.J: /:' _:1\,,: .. '...." ' ... , '" ·if' .. ' ....

'ilIi~:m~ '~O lim"-'~ 'a '~Fitluwar' il;J(R· 'lii RaKlH JtOl' 'miO:lif;1:Q" w;iCl:ilF £l!l'OlC~S - ' ., w!iii"'U'

I~I~ . ) __ " _ .... _- .. ~ [_ lr~ . -' - - - ..... .. , . -, , - - - ._"--0' - , .. - _- - .~. _. - ,I' . - ~l

are to 'be' ;iliu.tQ~o:rn@~. If' 'illhe qCrI:t,s, ,~h~' toOl pcdQ~, ~tio~~i ~)tl1!i:n:kr.:~ng;ly~, wilmout, ~:()nii(kt~ng tilE DID KfIPj,e,OGM, md without, wei,lhin,g 'thCll :re~n!!l' "f-()f th~, vario~ alIkmJ~ lh~. ~ey ha~' aiD. g~' ;c'hQl(e~ 'b'nt.

.o,t... £: '"'~ '1!":L."''' ...I~ .: ... "~ .,'Ii." 'I..~,

'!IliI.d~~~' '~ 'Il~1 Uia.son 1;01' wllti!m, 'Jl !I'I~51 iI.!, Ilo:t tD, ,~mv [YMit. 'w~~u· mal'!' 1!X: '~,

· , . _. .. l _ r.. • _ ,". _. . •• t. - . _ _ _ _ or. • • _. _.. _ 1 .-.. . _. _ ~l . ,". . _ .. .. _ : __ l(l _-. I l. _.

KJ~I 'fiJI' ~nta:na:u~, ;aoti;(J~!l., ,A,(;OOD8I gay ibc ~gWl«J~, c~~~~, th~' .IiiU 'haft d~ne all a~, :R"qj"llirnd dir.ilm;lUng'" (!onl'id1!':IiiIll'~ :arlld ~Ib'fn,g 'llill '.e' :palt, ;so they ~ :now db:r-d ::S,pli'lltageity:. :It: i~ :pogi!bl~.! !tb~~O.fe~, M,

'-r"i"'~ ~"""n .• ,l:'.,..."I" ,"'~t-:_~! ,~"1' if·c 'O:'i,"q":' ""'"i!"!" [D.oili", r-~"i .. ~,;,,~~~ :~,j;, ,.,~ .. iI":~mj'"i"' of.-:-':' ,1J_m"'-~l ill'!li:l'~, _ ~ ,l:jU" ~_UU-.lJJIiJi ~1'1!-!!E"_"., tI_lI 1IIiiUJ'1III.r _!UIILI. 1,!EJJJ,'!Ir.'iU~~l A-'_ Llltl", Iy __ -'I.r - ,

.:

!~--~nq--~;--:: 1:~n;.."'iF i'C"; ':~d·· .... -iII. ~ .. , '~~r- ~'I; .... :!li~,.,.iF ~-I '-r-,-~ i"":""'""......_'"i"~. ,~I!--L-.I:- :"",;o;._"['~d' I ~~_ ~__ • "!I',I.~~,!li;!! ,n-,..~, __ ~ ~iI iI,UiI U;[~ ~~~~)." Il"U ,11iiII'IIJiD ~,~ma!U'n""i!! '!I"I!',Un.1.iI "",U'-!!.iI1 IIJ€i

.. ~

~~'::~L_.i ,of:' ithoilO"lJ' . - - -- ,;, ~IL ~. - - ,0 -...i ..

:P:[\U~1IU!~;~;i' e¥el!l! ]i; 1!H'-~",,' ate' D(]Il: :p.res;elm1t m '~eJlF :m!lQ~",


n.~' re~ru!, h~iI'~, WltSt. be of: a c'eroiln l~n_D to q,iHiJU[f' fQ:t a!l,UQ:Q;-r.

O'mIY" Ii£" the m,uo:m, :fOr ,(ib.~~g ,an ~~oo, ~ ~t ~~, .nt is ;a.n iaddi'cl and! ~1teeds a :6tx" 'then the' ;qe~t '~ a :[leasq,1l 'but. ~t :~ ng,1. ,~e~eJJ't ,{Qr .e' oolilif1ml that ,a1!ljto:mo:m,~' req,u:iJr.es. '']i)lu: aippropriate 'kiI_nd 'of" re~H de~ rF~xm, the a&m'uI" 'beLidJ ~baut th~ kii~.1 ,0{ d~Fe$, .~t '~~it to 'be' :~tb-,

,iIi::,~~AI A' Ii' I'" nr.; ~;;- ,. ;:.ii",."'" iiL -". ,.:1:." - - - .-"""iIli;;.,,," ",;' -" -:f ii-''''~", un" i, ", !l~IIClbJUS ~' [w; exp:rcstln,g: 'ullS '1.8 !!ilI.alt rae ;sabM~Hn o(~~ l~~'

.~g~ flqt-oFdeF d~Fe!ii' di~gld [~OTIfQrm, M dt~lf' ~,~t):Q,d~rd~F I~U' 't'Q

'I'· ,.,'L. i:.:.:il iii" 'jl:~' • ~ • .4..'" L t::, _A.... d"[ - "'. "" -"" - - .e.' .. G"",A - - d ,I,ve ute iIoJimiU! o( ,IIlI,e 'llll! 'riouK~lI, !Omc~ :1~nt!"O,I~F '·~l_reS are :SMtiM~!;iy ~.:_;

~m'C' oWn are not (~Cj, Ib:f' ~gmfl.c:'t F"Fami~A, 198& gd!, 'taylor 'l:9r1i)., It :~ :t11cM, be wd, iIhd th~, ,m.lJu..atiion, oondiiiti'ou mqjWRS, ,.nts to 'hare :ide gili led, wi;th~, ae:¢'epood., gd, ~p;~ the d.~r-e$. dlt~f:' ,eb~n, ~,tI~n$, ,aim !to :sati~'.,

Th" .. ~' '~i"f'i:L.. """"rIo~~~il:;i'"f>"" .:;0; ,.J.,"": ,,-·"c=..I[=:-:-.-=·.It~'~.' [7=,':IL'[~~L ~!L.."", ~Q',,,,,, ... 'it,.,!' :t'~II"""~1W'"i" , "~ IllJI! UJI 'J..!-Ulol,IUlI,'II.!.I'u,I,,11 Iril! IJIC' gNIM'J·~lMi-~.~, ~J.H.#.'ln~ t.iI!II~ ~~I::ll"-"l! ,1_WFI!U .. ·gJllJ,.."

,eva1~tiO:J:1, o:F: their ~h.Q;sen ac;iti~g, :m~t 'be' ~ Ofll :iSuS:ci~O!t '~def-'" ;!!!~ding of .~, ~[pUttan¢'~' of' ~.(ll~ :a¢iti:()~$., Th"'$! (li)n.di~j):n, :S~Zlj[p-.~1ii5 ~C' :~si)t1ve CQnl1imi~~~ OB '.e uokie oond)itio~ '~' req,u-iJrinl ~a!t Ith'C ,evaJ,1. 'oatiOO:!!,lIl1lUUJle !by' ,agcni'P :!hOll~d me ,acc()001ii1lIt ,of a!~n fe-~~s of tt..e cJh,((~n, ;kti:onl., [One ,O'f dJes.e :€ea~ :~ that. the' a,ent.s, :dlOuild, ,~ their actinn5 nn~r tlh,Ii.' as~c;)t of ()bj~t1'wiy ,ac~p1'2ii'b:I~ d~ri,pl:imii5., A d~KI'ip' . ti~Q :~ ,(I\i;eClti~ly :ac~~p~'ble ill" r-e~~!Jible peo!Fite 'w'ho ,~ :f.amjl~ 'wiIth th~ [oal:1i~~l; 'wO'Il~d ~ 'with ~,~, ~,~n't.s,![ d~S('rl,ri:01i.i of' ill, Ag~Jl:t.s!' d~ S(riptiom;s, ~' .1. 'w. 'be ()'bjettiivc' ~ause ,of ,~If~'C(;'CiP~Oit, l~Il:.te~iilon,

~ '1'''' ... :::,' .'. '" . ,'. 'I~ ~', ,,[~"!" , " ·d· I " "_ f;l :" '. ·liI"i~· ~ ,,'1" '~'" ,t!Zli~'_ ti :t~ I ";'!dl"'tv- .' '~d' I, ~'-rt:L,.1_ ~eti~on1!:,~ se~,,~<e~~re .. _ness:~ ~:IUlia,""I~" ,dID'-T" ~. U,p.l .. 1~:1" an ... so ~:OI[lYL,

'Th$~ ~, ~f. fdimrg' In ([)'~~Ii~~' ~' '1JI~~lVe'5i, cll(J8ep", u.fD~'h~FiJ~, 0.1" ~me-wher.-e ~n be.~e~" 'De e~~nt to ,~tc'h tbey ;~-e' w~'t];~~ :1s i)!bc

~""~\iIIi~~' ,it)~ '~~iijo;'~, ~;L.~ ~«~Holi';O;!' '1"",;o;!'L, '''1"£.',''fo:b,i''''''''ii:i~IN' 'i;'\i"'.,..;,";!I-,",,,,,,,", '.~~~r.' :i!Io"!ji~;oj!i;~,;!E, '~';i'ioii'Ioi':!il~fi'_ ~ft~lIIlIllij;. !l~ ·nj._~_.~I~ U~I~ -,'1iFl1~.1!liiJ! ,~,II..l-~l U-.I ~ ;JJ~"''''i'l!J,IJ~ll .IJ ~lj .. lU[[I.E3! u_I.w1 , ~~UrV;lJ_il_'" .1J.~,I"I_".u=

An th fl' '" ~ t1b 'Il; Id t1h. h . fI

;;·:-,~O'·.~U' R:3'hu·(l: Ui, I~j.;: 'i~(l: ag~t.5, S!!:O'UlI .• ·.1 see ~ i !~Iir' c .; .o~1l ,aotl'of!i!5, ;mm

Dl'C '~~cj'ti~ ,of m~iF past pa'tte:ms, of 3Dbfi:fiJ. De' :ag.e['u;s ,~Ihou!ld 'I!HJ. abl,!f:' lQ[ s.ay:! 'if m~' D.eed! ;~!il~, 'whcillber dteiir (:'h~~ acu'OnS! oogti~!l.te Of. de~t'e ftQ:l[!I, 6t~r ~, ~QiiI.d~ct. ~, the' actiiO'IJ~ (;h~terlMi~ rOT ~e' age'f;I.'h.

d! ",. & . ..1.. ,;'" .. 'i-. ~ii-. " .. ,,,,"" 'j.,. b" 'I

a::n.:__ lL" [~Loey ;iiU'e,r :~ ~re![f pat~ ene ~iII!t ~~e. .n~ '~!tUI!~, ~'8 feiiJ.8iO'niiIJ_. e ttl,

'oon~niUC!i? ,If :it, is;a d!eW~ti;j!)n {mill, the :~teirJJJ~, wha~ q dt~, ~~n {tif' :llt. b;d! [S !tlh,~, reason, :3, I{lOO, IQn.e~' It, i$, nGt!, oJ course, ~i!lii!: i!le~Qln:a: [C:jUl, 'be' aiUiW'.f'I.1!lg}J1Jms on~' :if the ;ageg~ ~~ve 'llaOOrllj'YS!I~' ;~~..ed ~d Qswered, Ii'll th~ q,iIJ~tit)ns., '~t ,arUill)m;(J~' :r[~'ld'~ ~5i, th~t. th~ age[!il~ .<ifulld, be aU~ to Ih,~' .li'Ca!l],4t~, of 'g~ilr ,CJhn~m, E)[J,Qmrs· ,an,d, be ,~adli' t~, ftloe th(i'

q~n1io:m IF .Cfe.' ,~ re.awI~ 'to ibe1ieve 'tb!9it. ~b;@y can f.or mr;;O'Il'[ :1:'ittf:1)K~~Il,.

Oee ~ut :f~atuiri£ '~a!t n~~'~ '~m~l'liu:m~d iill this (::(i~fiI~C~n:Il, ~ ~.e' ag~n,li:.ili" ;8iWta!t-en.e:s.s, of me' :mo:taJ1, iSitaRdirng of .e~[' ~Iu~s.en. ;i,Wti'O~s. The' re'qj~ll';elmell:t lis, not that autono;m,ijJU1S actions lJiliUS-t be :mo;mny prari:seworthf' WI' il1mn~~ 'blJJanl~111b", ;:ihjb,orfi)ii, ',can, aIlm, bE' aru}~o:no:rn.o:lBi" The rGrijl,~~~


n't~f;iit ~~, :1'1,0:'(, even tba,t the· :ln0'rall :s!)g,ding 'of the 'c'hg~n ,~i)iIO:f;q ~(JUiI.d, 'be , I ,,' , ., ',' :, ,,' ~ : ~ '~' ;i ~ ~ c., 'C'; ~ ,~:t :~;c, 'irlh~ ,- --; ~~nlS'! mim;~-' fOT' thti: : y ,~ll!flS uppermmt on ('ur even Impo:~~ W _~~ :age~~_ ~~~_~~ ~.~~' ~~~~ • ,~~

~' s'U'bordim~u m~, ~~n~di~r3!n'O:ns W ()tb~r&, 'Tb(l:' :req~[umen)t Iii 'dliaiL agenJt! !lh,o,\11!d :reCiogrrilc '6~ re~~ce lof':m,oFaiIJ ;Oonsldet:aunJil5 .' mel'~ gti'QfIIS of dtorir' ac~~I1lI. Thiili rmJ~ 'aprii15, to ;acce:p1, ,~, ,and ,~I ;e O:n~ oJ th,~ ;~l5 'llIindcit', whkb, .e.' :!Si:gfli~ee' '00" 'tbe~r (:'~n :~tiQjljS met. be 'ri~d" I~~ :if the ,qenlU,!' ehesen a.C~io:UiS tunlJ iilJ.U!t 'to 00 ~¥:H 'Wbc:g ~' vii~l!t

:I ..... , ., vu .. ~ •. , ·f;·j.'ii..·~ """J!lAi";'- ~,~ "-I 'fi;~-~----"' and 'Ili--" '-~ '~Ci):in'd~ lin 5l.!1Hl!ma[}!", ;eaCilili 0:' iYlleK' !~XLU)l--'-~~1'Q ,~ ,~~~~"~ ,~~~~:'_. 'e.' q at ~ J""' .. , IJ

~tdH,{;i~mlt :fur ',an, ,actiU\D, to, M ,a;Il)tollom,O'WI. ~~Its, ,~' 'be' :sa1dl, ~Q ~, a. 't:on0mu~, to the lextent to which '~~iF :aotio:ns ~ !Jfllt(tl1():nl()m. ,A1nd :~~, faIr· m), [they ~ ~~u:i51n:g' '~,e :kind oJ eerurel over' thelr a£ltiQm;S, that. [dle~ !OOlldiitll,@j]S, deiPiict;. '.e¥' :ma;y' be uid 'W 'be '~.' ,aIU)Wno:m,(.nll$ ;c'h;o:i~iS,;, :Sm,~~ ~i)n(gl'l1ii~t)" tn dI~· last 'd..r~ oond~tiun8 i_s a, ll'Ulitter- of' •• u'~ 'be-' Ica'l.lR Ithe 'WKe! :iLQiI~~Il{;iLn-!' ~:hoic:e$, aE!d W$ exmnt 'of dte aIEDIt.s,~' ~,~ 'lion, nd ~nder-s&1:fiding of'tl1i£m CWl 'M lOO3!kit" or leMieli'j' ,age.~I~" choioo~ aud, ;aclion:s can be m;QJ'c '!J'J"' :1!e~1 4llld,O'd;ClBilOU$."

1b,cse Bve >CODmdO'lJis, r~,~~r~ thrat a:Ui~Qj],ontn,l!J5, ac~nM M bam fR~ :an.d, '~, on thc@' ,ageoJu' jlld,gnt~nt. ~t ,may' 'be ,wd~ ~,eref~j-e'~ that. aJutOi],·' lamy bM a 'fl',~~o;m. ;~d, a j~dgnte~t 'C.(1JroPlJiL~,t The 'petfD:~.c~~ ,c~Jo:i~',. ~nd fifjn_fu~d. c'hoi«, (jO'nditi.o:n5"joln~' 'fku:ttil, the '~dD:m, ~Q(mP.O""

,".', j~' '"'JiL" ,:_ ...... :ll~·,-ii-i","i· ,- ,-, .. ~ "'ii~'.dI ::,·c,-i\ .. ;n."-:iIi~I·j)i.·.,, :""'''"'''-, ~~~~;i')iI",",;o; , ... ..,.If" ... t.i~~iO'~"'" ,~'~~ j"ll1I...'IQ.' ,~e:QJ~ .Ii, u.e i(!!lo't¢,llUa!u.Of!) aln,'liI, unU,itinlo<lllOl;I,'!l.illln:~ ",",'V',u"'hlli'll'!.O!',u~ """"'c"'~Q!~,,"l"!~ U~""'.;J! -~-

',~ ~. - ':l~' ;c: ;:-;-,~ jn.n'lf" ... .,.I·' A···iO~~"'i"';li''1"m· 1''1"1'1''', i""i"t;iO'l'lo, iC'1 11"1"1"0. ·'IIliIIi.n-1jl;;!l;,,,,,,4.1V '-:nn;£O~' 'l[; .... , 'II-~ r"'"', ~nl ~ oom,Ii"''''''~''''''~~!I!.' ,,' '1iI1l"nll.lU!',. U'UiII! "",",",UU .. ,I", ...,""'" - -'""'''':Ii....,_~Y,].' ,!'H)!I;I!_ ~ =~ ~ .... ~ I~

'ca~ th~ .1)L~t be Ic~~n, ud, di;fl: [c'~,0iu:s iDlEt: D,ot be :[0rc:ed~, 'but, :&-ee ,~Ii:~~i5 mav 'n~t be ,auwnO'~M~ bec.au.s.e ilihe :::HJ"J)!".;Ili(S, m!Snii' :ilDt iIJIa:w: '~r:-.

." 011_ ,-- J ,- ,~ ... ,-i, .. ~~.. . __ .. , - --~~- - ~ - ~-.~~- ~·_"f . .

,aibly' evalluiated, t~em. '~F oodef$tood dt~r' slpi1l[alIl(l~.ln

:It [SI cDdaJ. 'to ~nd!e'n;taiIl,di~g the 1~_!I'aI OOi!U~~pMo:n, ,of an~nnfimy:, b~ ,eve\f~, ~t it :~ OOH't1[!l~AD~, ~j)'t ,.~riJ.y m '~~ need [(JI 'C(U~;oill the :freedom, ait1:d 'tile j~l.uflm,enJt, compone~~ 'burt: :aJl~ Ito a, :~ ... v.i~w 'Qf :h~' ~~

Jwis)me:n:t ,~, m' ~ ,e~~f~~d.., Thi!l: jlll~,~. ,Must 'be· me ;~~ts'~ meal!, ud, they mrlUl. M' '~d, un th~ .nl5" cri,~.r.aiJ1 ~~Ieoti~.n 'Og dtcit ~ choices" ,acuo:ns; ;H),d oo~ce,ptian~ of: ,3), g~ Ufe'" Tb:is ~Cill)Ldes I!h~. Sti'lt>snllll!ti'Oft of ttU~jlJ.U:lgmOO)t of some' po~iitial~ n:i~giUlU" 'm'ornl, (:'~~ati<;~, ot wb~t~~ .': tlt·····'tu.' f:l .... m" .~ '~.' ts' "' .... :." And "t ,~!('i'ud~!I!, as w¢'II ,th~ ;t:liru'!n~~ J'ud1aia:Ui ~~ ~Q{r]",:;!' Qi,f .. e agen D"WiIiI",.. I. , . . . ., '. ... .~. = ~ - ""'1:Iii-~~ _ .~ ~

;'IT ", '1.."";.' ...•. , L_~ .... ~ ,,'.' ,·,:A ........ ·il~i,.·~.,:':Il!~:,:mr-c;'"F"~ .. i:ofi, 'U!fl.e~nr,dl '~,:,~ •• nI~,Il,r:.s ~I"I ~IJI, on ,11luv\"mnatl(L~, oo~p~~ ~ ~~,! ~.~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~. ~'. ~~. ,~J ~

,4!.'"~ ,,"~ .~: ·,i''''''f'o'liW-:..Ji naDi;iCfo<'" ,~~-:I '''11::-"", ~~il\.,,,,,~.A.jl:I~,;n'"i"''''".·.c'm' ''101'.': '"',PAi";II:;.".. ..•• , ..... ::L~.·I_ .,.' i" '"'.";!( .... 'o!I!'

ul'(iC,. un,t;;'1)nl~'I;lI", !I.c!iu Ir~,U"cU!, ;fUIiU Uih ... liIOl!i.~. ft~!liV,l!!I!'V'~].' ,I!,'_~,'!iI!~ ..... !!I ~~ !!!Ill ...

,agCf:iJlS ~bOlllld, jud,ge' 'hmv ilief' ~~lil~d e.~eroi~ theif' ri'e~dnm, ~d, tQhat th.~~f ,jUd,g~n¢llits, mou'I~, ~m!voWe' '.ti,e' ;iaJpp],i,~,QII; of ;$Qine: 8'~du& dtat

.. i~"".'IO!' ' .... ~o;l .................... , ~""" ""''''c~n~' "".:11 .;, ~;iiii!~·iJ,., ,.-..f"· tfJ~n"·~~·"", .. l ,~#i"," .... ~i;o;"i\'" '"""" .. ~'1.."'·m·' ""lfI<d· I '?io"'1i' IY~i ,~I}.A'!!I'~ !Iiw~"~~~~ ~'~~<.'~lF·~ I~'~ LI,~~II.IIIIJ!I1 ~, IU, I rUi.d1l.. IJ~ZI,~~u,~II. 'U"JI"ll W!bl:P. ,'_. !W:ltlf. _. U~

how ~ $lhiQ~lld n~,,,

J~:nl'l" ;~iIIl liii;,.-:"';"'~!il, ,4~~_"Ele ~. NBLt: '~i'um , 50, aiI:w, do !t!h~U' d~'~~e ahomi~:

"M9.I!;,. ~ =~~I~- ~~~~ - ~ - . ~~ ~~..." -II! 1 -~ •. ~

... j...~, :~= ~;I·c.-~ -'7~~~~,i;-:;_;:-"",:: '~I!ta·t ";0;. ~ni.,.il·i"."":~ '~'I" ;!lIi(U'~*",'" , ... b~;i_"'_~ ,,.,.'nd'~i :"''I''lt.lons Y:I,e ~,~~ ""'_I a:1)l~O:I.I}Ou .. y UI l,"" ,~"'-i"1u<l,~, 11u., ~f~iI!!I'!Io":!\~ 1!<.-1f!."!.i!'~""!0!1,~ ~.~ ,""""'"'_~ ~~~


t~) [q~u_allY ;!U amfig.mQ'US". Th~iif' 'ri~, ~gt from. whM ts .~:bi3J~s, 'the .iflihnail :~,uireHl~iI)Jt. d~f~iIlded .t,' ;Raw1:s: (I ~ffitm: 72[ .... 88) to 3J :ftrlner one· eJil(loEsed by Ubexal pe~eotkJ~~ts such ~l ~ n 986~ :869-[99,), 'De 1Wea~er 'dle :requ~~menit. j~~ the I~~ jil j~:!!b'~. o~ i!1h~' ,(;o.1l!fi~U'Om. 1ixi~e:D. a~to:lJ? ..... mlV~ .... 1;'1;1 ~'L.~, ,non"" hf"l,l!1i·d·t ~d rPl'.'111i! '!Io1;'I;·d··· [Q\.,.......d· H",,"lR. on .I:ih;lilo ~i:lb;l>'I!':. I~' 'i:!l! i!tuffi..

Y.~~.I~ """,~~ [y~~ ~~~"'" ~~~.~~, ~~.~ [~~~~ ~~.~ o'!c""""'~""""4I' '~",d ~~'!'r ""'~~~~." ~['" .~. ~ =~~

d~ul for' _~Qimall .. a'Ult(Jno:wy :if me .• ~~ ~a~ :m:~j]s t'O bel1~· ~:aJr 'thek' 'bele(s are tme ainu ~he~F ·ai_~· a!IIe gooo,. '']1)e l'eq.~i!I1em,e~~ of fuller ~'Ulwm;QlnY' ~. nt(l~' .~trinp[!)iT!;; .~~ ~nt5,l' 'be~i~& ~'OO:l;Iit. ·itie 'lrult£b. oF: it~&F 'L.~~i"""f~ ;ol;ud' I ~,''''~, ~n""'!"'~ tl'F Iiih~irr' i:lo~m"': m!~~~"'''i'. ~~, ~iIi'~~nIM_. n;<o,f .... nd~J~. af

~="t!rr-~~ ~~.~ l~~~ ~,~~~~~.~ _1= ~=.j-~= ~ __ ~ ~~~~~!r. ll..~ ~.~~_ ==~~ ~ ~~=~~~~~ ~-~

:mU;er. 3!UWllIr!Jmy 'be'~leve '~31t there are o~j:eoti,'re ~sta'lldarr.W. t\'o wbk:b be'Uef-s :a!oouJt. tFUim p;dJ [g,oodlfi~ q~lt 'W IOGltf:Orm .• td [th~t ~U!to'j],;Qm.:r i~'{~l~ ;a;t the very least a ~~Q'Jl~ [df'@'rt ItlO[ oo~__f'O~ '~n 'them,. :Deofcntae~ '00 ~ju:i.m.aJj i8!tllUnnmy' do not r[~.!i.!'iIm (lO:i~foi'm~ty [l1) o'bj~lirve :S'ta1'i,durds: !Or ilhat liIe' [eff(!K~ ~ be J:;~iti.o:mrail :!!ihiO:~ll(l ·w~cee~l!.

T.fu!is ~I" betw~~[W the m;i!D:irmt~ ~f~d, tbe :iJlJIn~r :f;'iiYI~~rem~~ts of ,8!trlj'l~~

~~r --,

·o;m.~· :leaves, !Open ~l~"c:h o17M,uus. ~.~eS1iol]Js, as, t~e eXJlent :to whii£b a'1LI!~Dn&

.~U.S' aoti,ons, :mriljst 'be' nl~O:tiai!;. !1i.ow ,dlfferel'tces· ~T '''e: :t:aLtiona1l~t)'· ~r variAilw de~FeSl' ~'~o-jC'e$\I' ~d. ev~ua'Q:Jj~ ~ be ,selde4:,;; what eff~ct the '~ID(iDg p:robl~m [of d~t~nmi~ll!i.s:m has o~ ;aJM~;O:f10:m:y: buw m!ltc~ (lulltrol ~s ~~oo~d. befOf~' 3!Ui~Ofi~m.y C;;aD ~. ~FiJbed. w .iInd'iri.du~b;; :h;ow ,~riu~i5, .mu~t ilire' l~ {If a!u~O{I1~m:y be '~O 'WM~JJ;'t dirm~miihjng 'the righa. [of :in.dlMl1al~ w'h:!lit. ~5' w~· ;app:m,ri.aW· g~:t:W. amd. PQJb~cal'Feuli'(Jn '10 !fie ep:~i~ ~d w· die' ~t(emaltJh.: md~us.e [Qf' ;~l!I~tto;rn,1i'.; how ~uUvidfe!Jl;a~Js· ~ho:!ltd!d be ~~~d H: thq cboo~' 1)0 ~~!];de!r .t!be:i:r a!Y!toI')i):my;, ~d so [uxtih,. 1'.h~ 'qjue.~(ID~~ 'w.IU. be 'n'umued Iml .su1u!¥~,emJr\ iC'b:anl~~, h)J 'w·h.kh ~,¢. aeiOOitlif~lt. Of;iUJlf'Ullu:-m!i1l'

,Ij' ~/!Ij_] r l

,~~]I 'i!:-.,.. ,iV.Ii>":""'· .... erdev ... iliNr1iiP~I.

'~'[I~ ~.l ~ lLu.llU]I'1arl. UI~·"-"'ll,.vrr.-~~~

"'rlt:-.-""i' '~'in","f"",~_--:l1 [ii"Ilr- .... ~t~;i'fo; ... f'I': ~.-:~ .. ~~,~:- 'I ~."':-:::. 111["T1~ .. -:",r-·,·'1;..·'-'·1 I·,' .... ·~· ~-:.-. 'I'~:::.I:- ~T~' .il 1.iL'~ ..... ~~":iIi~L"iJ!U ... iIi ... U ,u",suU<U'.lIlJl !I:I,~~r;.[ ,,~ave iIliIin~[l~uE\!l. Ule ~Cim~i1iI[~

·ru·L~ '1 ';"il. U h L~)~,. h'h . t1I '1'

!a11]1o:n-1:' lrI!~m:sl 'Y!!liat ;;ar..1 LID'UOC~ IL~QgJ[ Lave ~=~e' capaotr :1)0',[" ,!iI!l!IIW~O:my', ~t

iii~ [i"t..."" iIl'IIo .... ;o;t· ,ii."i'~l.,.. . ..Il,~~.-- .... [.,~i1i ~~~,~~, ~'i'io =.~t.." _'b. ~,'L ~w -~."""", ~'~fi'i-~'II '1', .. "'oil [~'b. ~ "-~'~·~~·Fu. ill.,.' .. Iii"" ~.~.,~"-l' ,L'Ii!iI~~Uil.il:n~., •. YiI!I ,.;'"Sr~Q~ ru WUiUL";n iLcU£l ar.~,...; (liqu:ail •.. l, Iii' Ul!ti· '~i:llr_Gilll'r

:f:or w:hoO~ d~~op:ment Q;dJ e:Xi.e:r.o]m 'ii.ey .m;~d. fmMl()ml. 'the proi:eCtlQlIl:

,~. [,iii' iI'·L.I· 'e.I·I' ~n\b.·-'. ""'~'dJ' I ·.i''b :'""", 'nl'i ......... "':"'[.\O~ ..,....:If' o,~~~"'~ ·tJ"\-;!>it. Ai ;~, ... t,~"",.u· J":"""".',. ~'U·""lil·""~' 'I·"'" '1"1"" .. · '!<lI'<1 'till .. iIi.I •. ~)" )!I;;II, g.liI<. !li,:Ui!b r-.JIiil!!I.,~· v ... ~ 'YI. ~uy!u'i) tili!lo. lIJIiIo"iJ!U ~!I}. u,'I!' .... .!JI.""~ )',-""" '.o:t ,~, •.

!iiI ;,.,.. ''(!I;J..A ,; ~""I .i..... n ............ · ., ..... ·'~~l,;:;. :~!lil ;" is 'tl~. ·1-'I'''''O'ii"i'''''.· .. ' ~~~,. Ai;' ~ ..... -:: .~I''il.1"i''''1" ... ~ .. [i' ,"'-'-" fi '. esereise ,"'Ii" fi 'i·-:;. [""iIoi.WAlU IIi.V r.1 '!Li!'""~.!JIi",,,. Ii[~ . ~ t'-" .. '.iiI!r'"~ "'" !Ri:I !l:I ..... """"'"u1r..IIJL1b!l, •. L, ml.,'<!!, t:.~,'b..IJ "" .. ""'" 0101,"", !lD

provide ~~ w1ith ,S.deQl~ ~[pe dl~t '&ey :n;eed. '~g :have a.Yalilalbie ,It p;l'yp!}~tr '0'1' oolu::epliilo;D_s of ill -. rood. ElITe 10 [eu,(low ~be~r: e(f;ule~,,,,,o:rs 'w.i;tb m~~lilli:lilg' oond pl!l!~'" .And. iii: b, ·iJle fooi~rlng tI):[ ~,e' ,a;lJIt1!lRO([liU;)US :~nQti;Qn~ng' 'Di' a!Jl[

.... ~~;.0:1\".",1!l It·II..;!>,1i' 'I·"" [t:"'."" ,~,.I~,wlm~iIi_' 'p.l!r~ ,a'I:~~ ~.'."'ii£!""~4i'I~""~ ,....;f 'I:I~~"'~~~:"'~. l·'i';:O; '!o,,!L'Ii'I.:o""".,L'iP. !IoIJ~"",!Io, il' lll!;"", !!.'I[I'" .'IIl1iH'1!"- I 'Il.'I' .• ' W,r~~ .. "",U • ..j,U-lI'!l.],l'!o.'A"" ,,,,,,,, •. 1; 'v.',Ii. ,I: ~ • .'Alli'iJluJ.,~ . !IQ!

'basi:£; ~UC~J~~ and ~t!S, :p¢I~~Ii:{'alI. :(?f.~.

"['.he :im.por<om,cc' IJiber3Jlls a~trib~w t\l ~JJl!t~110n1rfj! h~,eveli~ ~s, .11;0t ~ol~"liy ~~t :~i.virng· ~. :~. nl~ d~~n. on. :~t: :iit. ji5, ~ dt~~,g~t ·to '~. a :fiooe~'

[;o''.oi!liln'd···It':-r:01(il; ,nif' ~.or'io'l!'!'l'·11 ~ ... ~ftffl"''''~~'·lii~iru'~ 'P-r-tf ·t~· ... ~~i~"",~;11 '~·I""'~' ~iI', li; .... ~iIi' ~ffli·11.,. [;O;;ol;il'~ ~-u~ ... __ lY~!Iltl! ~ 1 ,1!:1~.I~lII ~_ ~'~-~~ll::I_~.l_IJJ.I, ~I_~"fil'" r. ,1Ii~1l _lIllt'!M- ll_II~III!A_ "To", r"I:.!"n" ll_~ !IJ;IJe!~J' r-~'='r I~ ~MI_ -,I,

._. hEM f~spofisibl~ [G:fily fGf' a;ct1ilDD'~ that .at\e bill ·iJElJmr· ~~;mitrOi];:: act1ofi$ ~t fefl~ot. the ,age~b' il!I~f.o·F~d. chQicc~,. l~fl~~ti~~;S~, ~d u!l'lcleF8:~~dImg of


~ft.·.- .. :. Ji ....... ~ ... , ... ;jI ;~ . .:,iL __ ·~\if.i:·~,

~~, ~ir.-:.;~,IH,r,.a11 JL.I1iBT,~~m

The 'bit o'bseFmltioJU 'Will. 'coHtpiete ·.ilSI :iLQ!~qn"etaig.u of' li~m~~ YLfJ~ th~ c-o:r-e gdJ ,th~ '~ vaL~~ i(~,f :liil~bm. '~~O'I, 'h' w~~d :ro ~50'liI'UOll, fmml Olll~ ;atl,od'ter. •. 'T:be~' .aJ[,e iB[tc;rd!epe~*n:t ill! ;;1. [liug'd:~el' .g.f' '~ys.. :PtlJ\tmlL~ reQjUires; ltbaI. g~l'I;q.g-m: lQdlv!idt~b, ::dlould be ·able '00 djlOO~ fme~f ~on,g th~ man,y :a~labl~ ¢Dlluip~jh:nu, of a good Ji&;~

'I!'·'~'-I;--;-.· riO"_'l;liI< .. , ''''~_'''~""ii1fi? ... ..:I1 : ... ~~ 'qlJ[!Ii"'--.' ;1,_.,1] '~'~nd~"i'''''''_ ;''Il:01'~ ,~'L."~' "'II':"" ~~ ,n,'U1J))aIJ ,.,,~III!1,1.':!1 ,!!D.""" ~"",IIIi1i1""'Ui ;QOIiI~, ,!).~IIU'"Il1.U)"""_'!tiU, =r ,J---~~ ;QOIilU, Wil'-l iAOI.'!IO; r'~~

sessed e~uail[y by' aU~i'1,Qmou.s ,hldJi~d~.aILs. Eq,l!laU" dW~, hm [tb~ ~~ pac~ty :ilr a~MiitDmy ~at\ alit :binmm 'Min.p b ave'., JuMi£'e' is th.e diis.trilxui.o:ml of :11,00&· 'reqUi~, by' ,autQ~,o:m,.~ and '~U, ,aiim. 19, to' pr®de' dl~ '~Q:Qdilti(JQS :111, whlch il'me and, ,~ual citiz;c~'S, ,can ;!iI;uwmtmlQ~' ,ch~ ;iml:ong een.c~;"'cm!-, :~f-~:"F"7-~ ~iEe

(le.ptl__jJ_~~ Q~ a. g'UVY ~~~o.

'Th.!: i:lltemepe-ncl.e~[_'e' ,of' ~Ql~omr ed th~ 'b;:uk; 6~, valrueillail. QgC~' r:;e~o£l}:re~s, Uibemi.ti9iD ,an,d ;m~ lit :mom' 'N'Iln~mbl'@; ro fDilldamMJtalI. ,crir~ elsm, Tilt'@: :reiJAiftm(jemc~~.~· 'be~~' if' one' of ~ ,~~j'tial ;OI)~~ u:enlt$ :b i$uc(:ad1.lnr ,~:ilefemded, m~n, l'O,gic ,e-o:mpelJ. 'that 'Ih~· ,O'dii~r& !l!i;n.ned, '~' :IJt Must ai\5o, 'be ;acooptcd .. :lUlt [the oontmlry :also ttO~ !jl,!l__.Cc:esdLd crilicmn. of "if' of' the '~n)tia'il (2OOl:s:ti'~.'ts, '~n& 'liD w~ :m:m (j,ilIt'SWlil. :rliOH' otllt«' '~flI)tia'~ 'CD:l1'5tilU.le":l1ft!i, tn3.t depend on ill" UJbemJilsm :!iIttOldd 'be' vi.ewed~ ~3!r.efbr.e'i as, a, ooherent. ou11oo,k .hose j~'Cailwn or' ,cQ\kism. is

,-,~--;-"'I~~--:IL: ..... ~ ..... ~.~. ni:~~~-~. ,iii ..... ";" '''IM;~ 'rl- .. _,I" '''"'"''I'' ... ~~.,.I~, :-...:i.;ln .... ~.,:il, ~o':· .. , ........ Ilinl1lllliEil!y ~ lDe rL~~~ ... A...----::iIJI~ ,1l .. \.I.',1J (l([I'-U .~~ll~._~ fil!~~;W-":r iIUI.lJ!IdI""~U W "1 V.ll

~in8t. sam.c' 'pan: d teLl1d w' :reve:r'beRli:e thro~hO-UJt me' wh,;Qle ;of ~t.,

'Th~' ~c~l1id o'bKl'\\ad.on :15 't1!tat !ibcraliiMll ii, ,a, 1e:IlC!mJ1 O'~~oo'l~;, tnat. :fi~ :i't.s, adherent9, .dO • .o:~ ~lQ~~r ~~ ,to:~ti5m" OOCIUD.I (1h.rhUD~"I' d@mocraq, [1@im~ni8]n~ ,or :mti.on:a'illsm 'it 'm.eiirs., Ad:h.erellce to, one ,of diese' lellcnlll Q,tUiloob imliicates, a, ~, ,~f fJlJ~Q;dJ" ;a :flow (l)f ~pth¥,! a. dIi~'

. • • ..• '" '~.)!. " '''Ij'! 'iL.... .:L - - - -" ".".". ..:ii - - - - ~

'UU1l W, 'Vlew' Hl.llUte:['[5, nl. a ,ceFitaJn __Ilpd:', -~,il 1,!I!Ii;;' ;Sw!_R~, [Y;~J~ ,aUUjl!lu~ are'

g~med! by' dI,~' l~n~aI, 'GOi:tstiill.lC;Ilri,5, o.f tlb.~ Im~Dd O'Oid'oo.l;" But [th~·

... ttl' - . 1 . '-. ~.~-~. '~.'~'~. ~ to - -- ~,;, ~ -,'.-, ';--~te-~- -~~tati -~~- -I-d 'fViI-m-]are' [,e;mse,ve,!J, (loml:U:~ lopen .I~' lI31"iIOUS m~1IPT-cl~_Wn!!il~, g_:__ ,r";;','~~'

(/DmmlttM to th.~m m;1.ullD~ly (liisagifee :aJOOtut. '~eir[' h~tcrprletadO:I}SI aiud reti~Jti,\',e hnportan£e, Ir is not b), 'be e"'pectedJ therefore [that: the 'ul'ilerpret:t-

'Fi< ":;:~ ~~;~",,~llioil;~ ~'-'-~ct. ""_"'_~irii'I\Olit""_-:I '~"~i1ili ~~\iIio"'!'i!l!IJ' '~,rili' ~~I!Ii_,~ w~:b:''''''l ~~!IJ' '~:uon, 'Oil. II!U'I:liil.;Wo.,;;..IiIiI JJU" ""'1U'JI'.liI;r' .~I"~U. W,I!I!l. r-I;,Ii,"" .... 'II.!I.,I!' ,1;1'10, ",,"'!I''!IiiL •. .,!'.~.I~'''' .. , ~.V ....... ,;1' ~

id.e~~iled as a [lijberaJ], The leese 'fit is. ;a oo~seq.~cn~e of' the' fI~~Fe' 'Qof tile

""--.'.ii..' .... '"ii' "I";i"foii' ,,", '(",];(".11"1: ,~i: , .. iL-I··..,. '1·'I-."jit~nri~iIi·"'fit:~'~ ...... __ ~"'~~Jf~""J"I!' ,1J_"lU!ll QI ,1-_o-u_lI}"II. ~-.l UII11 ...... l _ ..':1 !ll)j"J~.1 FI1·~~-U-~1I!1_r.

This;" ilie.~,~ ~, Ure.' :m,tferp:Fe~til)n. 'm- U~~i~ ~ ~n be '~e tafget,~ criud!!ims ,ruj,VaiIl(;M, u.'['iOugihDl[I!l: 'lite 'bi:w(k.


';~!ENi~" U [(tot :3. t~l 'dial !il::u, ~l :p:rolfi'in~Jlit :in O@j];tl!m.~ piI~-phrleall ~1jJ]~ ,~ ~ ~ [n~ ~-o.~. d ~ g, liih.~ ~, Q-r[~, '~ '" " ". :~; mft~Iy'mA~' t~ all tM~; a: p~'hy .aBd :Hniira1iie ad. [des'irall .. le :in itullman li£~, lwl:a fD:ml: ~bkh b! a.C!uvel~ '~kinK - ~'ITii~' aU m~t 531. iii:fIjF,'i\"~~ -,d. admimr'iiil-·_ ._ ... _. '~f'fHliiii!!! fftll'c::rws.

~- ,- ._iiI -It''~~--,,.,, ...... -"'~'"",,, ,-!,.' aIII. __ . .H!!!.!I~_I.Ci!~ ~ , ~ - --- --~----

'libe' 'i~~ ~iu((DJ ,of Min\, Sidgwik·~. G. E, .M~~~ amd JQhrn

D~ •• t_ ,. I",,-L'I .. '~- '~~;F' Lr ._,. fi'il'

,N~l!-2!. OM ~,._gw~i!: W '-i"i_'~ i01; :gI:ea1; :p!I-IQru:: 'ewt~ ,~,!iIi. ~~ mg away

hmo 'the :~t. ,Qf j~ [Of' QJ' 'Iih~ ~!' .••• ne UQMl. $~'

"11 ~~' 'i:-- 'k1'''''''-I' Imoi;>1l- n·.· ,il'i'fIPi'lf.~·~"", '1.:--·-·,,.lL,.,,;o~1 ~:o:' '"

~~~Q! ~ l.U.-'!v 1~~aiI:I_l __ I'!U!-!!~I_I_I'V_ _ III III III I'! ~-~!b.~U;'IIJ!L~ IU~t!f.1b ~-iH,;J·U~~ l~J- .•. ~!f.IIIr::.l

:a! ff~ brn.oce'aC¢' h~ :m~ ,bf~hy: iUl. ~lTiin~oe w·t.i:ch

[n~a ~~~: m wtt'~l ~~ ·r~l ~ -~ MrlI~·" 't t" "gfil'"'~ "" -""

~ II: I" ,em I .. " '~_\ i1 .. ~'" • '" , :u. .. ":1, ~ 1 ,'~" ,{"I.cn.' ,:0 ,e '.,~, 'I ,1Q1]1C!

nih :~hgu't Gle :~~ ~ fiJI:" ma.m~g~ ~d. m¢fiI dcd~~ :hm ~ '~au:. '~ :~~~ !h~mm vlfi1!~e~ .' '1' " :~d ~.e· !i!'i~t~~' :W!ti31 plUm. 1;1; ~, 'om ~"'timD!t,

......... :9,'W'U;l!;.R,W ,HI!.'r.t~stU~!E .• li1~ [~P1d,~

I

"'. [' [ .: .' . .I! ~ I [ •

t :1'5, aJ, tr~ar.brDI~' :t"~8!turiill: ,of ]~_mIJ thfi:m)lih~ ~at :lit ~ :a)most

'_'rJl Ir~,J"''''

ItO 3!tw~dO:fil 'to ·.C' ,~en,¢e' iO'f ,evit The' tQpil(; 'bi i~JlFed 'or' '~'lr

'OOuthed, o.lii, 'by m'C ;aJu.th,on Qr~C gap,r boo'u, an.dl ,wcl~ :s~ '~fil dl~' '1iX['t-ecledilmD' ii!:'fuaft'teF~ '1beu' [tIn'SO'me rare aJu:em'p"!l8 hu' '~iibeliails '~O (J',mpn'l!e'

ri: J. ..- • - - - ;D' . - - - r,... • 1 -~. • • - ,-. -, •• - - • • - - •• • - -, _.. - - 1 • _. ~., - •• l ! - - - .. ~ J - _' r' .

w1Il\b, th~, pw'ltrl(;.m~ 'bu~ du:!f are' [dth~' :~n~d1e~ ~' ,t;ol.r' lead hlJ ,ao ,d~IiOCtJO'I:l

d~3!t :ilI, inoo~p'ble' wirth 'Ibe~~sm,m :Fot' d~c :mnst p~ howevef"j; lijbe~ 'Ifiioor' 'I1t{Qihlti'l~ tol ~"p'llain 'Wi:b~' l~' 'is r,[~;ma'bl~ b) -i'n£'M~ :a.llil'Ono-m~' b.~'

l .. ,--fl.~r-I.--1J.' - .. ' , .. ~._l!,' .ll_. ll .. __ .· .. l .•.. - .. 1 __ 0.,1. __ .-. _ .. _ ... - .. -.l .. ~ __ I~ __ ,j-

:~afli_p"g (h~ir' ~'i(; ·vait~5, :~~. pol~~c~, p~~ 'btlIt. ,Ilt~ ~ :GiQi ac_"

f:,,,,'ik. g.._ ,.,'iI... "1 '" --'. '" 't"ik~~.1 "'. 'Th'" "

~Ounlt. m IUi,ce '!tAlt, [U~at. CVI!~ g, :p'J:1!;¥:'«e.~t. eve~, L~ .J;~~,~ ,SoOClCl'Clle!!!. '=ldS, 01D1~'

"i!lID WO'!lJl~ be J"u5m6!ahlte on; ....... 0:0 ~.e: ,as501m~O'D ~at ~be ,ann!lCluO'D'5 o:f

, _ I.", •• __ • "- '::._/ _ -, _ _ _ _ -., • __ II." ." _ _ ., _ _ _ __ ~-'IIi;;.It. "~ _ J , OJ , _ t., -. _ ,. _ t. "~ __ ". ,

:I!iMmU!~m, ~ ~ufti[l~n,[t t~) iiDd~FiiIt pitOpl~ to ,C~ll,du:~t m~;m~I,~ :aor:-omt· mg' W i~ p~~riiJ14iiQ:~. I~t th~l :~~miPtio:n, :i)j :Fl!l~: :lnl~oh, h~m, ;Ql)u,duot. is ~ll ,even illIo~I'f~ ill.lJ, .,m'u, 'unDen.tutd 'whart 'tiJbe.::a1Ls te'lllJ tb~ .. J'it H.ree&

fiG' [~~.i:.J.


°4"~

~I'~.'

i":o 1-._ ~xn·.i, .. ~Ij'iI .... ~, ~;~Jii!;r ..... ~ii''''''., ~Jb.N '~"'i;lii'I"""· ·iUiiJ"\' ..... '1;lfH;..:I~!PoC!;"~i"'~ ~'i~--~·I:a;m "'i'WiIi"+-~n

1!Ii__ ~ ~~-~F-~~,~!I;i-u.J! ~,.~~,~Llf\.l!'" ~~ "R,IJ.l.,. ,Ir'~vlf' r~ ·1I!"!f~IHIt'!J.! u_.~I~l.,"'!l4Yll!tll, ll_~~~ m_ ~ q~l~~~,

,_ I', ',.:"1 ,., :' ..•.• ' iW. '.',,' [~:i" itt ' ' ,'. c ,&cilI, "tio-ns"

iil:'aN5e e¥]11 . .In '!YK},Iiilitl,'O~ U'.t 1I~ p:Fe~ ~ ~~, _ ~ ~ .~.

'The ~mu~sl o:b¥i~~ leJ;pJ~ti.o:n ~a ·tlh3!1. In, b,tlman 'oo~up, :m.O:Fall~' ~ dls.posiniD:n~ <lH.Xist; 'wII •. m,o;m1iy I~~ di:5po!~u_n~s" 1f alU!t'O:m.o:my ~~I f~fed~ 'th~Jl, both ,~, and, mil di5pm1tio~s, ate efi(.~;l)jn.g~" Li~ra1~sm, must 'thereF'O:I'<'e have' '[W.O, enii:u'drlv hll1Witlnftant 9Iim!l!" th,e ~ii(h{e 'G:I1'c' [of 'p. U'r5!Jl!irnv

~~~~ ~~~' '~~~'. ~".'~' ~"iIi"" .J' 1""'-' '" ..... Ir'~~-"" ... - ... = 1 ... = .... D

'~e good, Wiiid m~' .fii~JtJ.'i'.\,'i; on.e' of ;aVO'ldi~g' evil., Eacb. :is g~~,wly' .(fefi~i~nlt. Mlth£J'~t( dtL'f; o:ritte;r:;, ,A, t'bJOO'ry of po.'liLti€td .ll:rall~ty :rolU8t ra~t~nd, :t-o '00., aims;: :11[; :m,tlsi; ~"~J m~d :ill, Eml, say ~~" ~LikraJJ [lhirrd~,e~! h.~f'i roo-n.c=mltf'3lie

". '. .•. , '. . "..1 L,~ ~~ ~ ,~,~ ~.-. 'I["~·~·"l~. ,,....... ...... .. ik~· .• ' , ... '. '~,;:!I "!, . "', ". . ·:!I·I.aJIu·

en 8afIng :yes, ,~.g U~' very ,IUU'£ UJI' ~ :3!UUtlll UiO'. ,lLi~,I;J. IIS[ [Oo.UlS,PIOl!lO,_..,z

b fi h . 'I d"j .. i. h' ottl~

,II Sill::nt rrem t ,e ;iM1IJC!II! 'a~_ :YJ~ou.gL~!t ~ -' .-,--1 ~~c :;.:-.~~ ..

Tl:tn[~ :i$' a nknJ 'view' of eri:l;; but i~ is no!!. explk~t Th'C :Il!~t '~ of :~U!, ,olllti£ m.~t. be to, :maike' ~t $0., Thiis ·wiJU '" dune: by d)mm~g' O'~I; mme ~m.piiicadi~f;i~ of'~ePi~Lf ~n1po~~t lib@w 'oolild's" :ilm:pl~c3lti!oDS t:hat. :OOTI~~~cr re.~rl!J!i'l!es 'I Ibeir,aJIs' to ~o~~t. 'ttds, ~mn.ned \!\i.~ Mn 'dtiC.1il1 'k' a~mblu;e.d, WI

.~ ,If lIT'

I~bemb,~ Ibl!llt ilt :s'hO'lIld :not 'be supposed that lilbe'J:31s, HI!~t. 'c~~$Clnl,l~jly :~Jll.d.

~,t. 'f~e.y au Ilevortiheres:51 'co:mQl!jtted. W ~t, '~,ar~' m~y hold olh.er bciliefs

&" 'L- 'i. ~'l.. _. - £' ·'1 ""_.n..... '1'..... '1).·'1 "" ii"'il..~ ..... ;il .. , ,;, .. iL . ~!L ;

Imm, W:1~1!l¢11! '~u 'Vi~ [GJ tfv.li, muuW,s. ~,I~Il~e pro~ .. e.m !tor lb~!Ii~ ~S '~~:art '~1eI!F

~iltive ,aim,., as, Id\cfIn~d, boy t~.e.i![' pnUJucaili :pJ1~,. ·~c ~A[l~,! ,and ~lI:t'O([Ulnny" ~II :LQoon.teo't: w1IdI, iIh~ir iiIJr:,,~tive ~~m~ wlruk'h :is ~D amid evil

Th~rt ~ ;$(tm~ f~idimc ti:H.tm~ll[l5 of ,evij_~ ~i'll, ehe 'h~hm:J' of West·, flim' 'l'W'IilitiiCa~ 31!l!d 'm~. 'lh.ouQ'bt: tlh.oR!!· ,o.f "I'bu~li~:ile5, Arist:O'~ ,A:nQ!lli~C~

" ,,_l r--"-'" I. --- .--~.-. = ... -~ ~~-~i~~~ ~~. _ .. ~- .. ~}-~' ,. - . -;~i~

ine'~ H\Q'ltrJbrJ5i~, M~hij,a,,'~Ui,., and :Nietz'Si!l:'b~' C'-awe :read~tr '00; ~iLm:d. They' d)~, .:ree aOO~~. ~~' dl!~IiF,~ bu.t Ulq' ,~tlJld :Ilta,,,",'t,: been ~n;an:i-olUl :m. :Ilam!b~oog" eaeh in :tlis OWl'll :f-ashtirO.~~, blil~ naivete.' o:f 6berailium" Th~ w:ou~dJ 'b;a¥e :ftli<:us;ed, [(>jl the ;~~m!pti():ll 'thaJt informs ]~~rWJ lW]lOugh:t 'd1a:t autQJl.·' IlYMy m.a:lbes tile strugl,e f'Of 'pb.~'ail~~, t~oo..o~, fig;bt.5" ~"s~~I¥:~ udJ dii5-, tribuuve J'·~ti\Qe ·wOIrthw:hUc·., T~ey W<J~1~ '~ave fu~m;d. ilbs~rd, ,tli~ ~ibemiIJ

,.

;:5u:p~rti(()FIJ lIlmrt if [b~' IOo(l1rlil,tl,QU'S, we~rc' (;n!;a;ted. LIlI, wbich irlu:li~.dua'l$ ~o'jjldl

;Ht ;~~~~Q\mQt:tdy'~, t:h(itm [h,@~ :m!i:f,tiduaJ5 'woldid oooperat'e with ODe an- 100lh(IT' :iIn a rffilSO::mable :maiDiner:, U each ,is ,e:n_g,¥d in. pUnfuiimg' ;SOlili.i~ ;CUll .. , Ic,C'nti;nn, of 'il ~ 'lif~. 1'b;i"'V WDllfd h3H' ~:Id, 'tba:t ;aJ)oJ]Q90ide 're~ ad!

';-r"~--= '_"_ I~- ~I~"_· •. ~ .. , ,-.~!- .... _. -- I ••• r .. _.l ... 1 __ ,. •• "L~""'_r._ .• ~. -- ------

dl£~r OOAC~iPtlIo;IlS o:f :the ~r b\!lmrul be]o,g! 81f\ti :MSI) :mO't1'w~ '~' ~nrea-. :~Jl ~d evU; tb~t 're~n d:~s, net atwa:ys ,dli£taite :ri&bil. Wl:JtOO~!ili' gd that ,anr[~o:n, batred~, prejudi.c:e" ~tR'iiihH;~'i ;cru~tlf~ '~~Il'tn'l~nlt~, '~Il!"", :gweed~, f:e~~ .d d<l,~iJjsml au' al5t), !afm.O:I1g 'h!~m~ m»~~, They 'would!. !barR io:!§iinoo, '~a1l, '\it:h:etne[' ilul'O'n.orn.1V l! ~ Of' I~~ ,"'l~n-d)s, '0:1\1 ~~ use

It I !ll~ ~l~

dlat ;~,~c;;'I6£ :ifU~IMIh.mI!!![ :i,n, ~(~ic [(l~J]'texts· :mab' 'm :i1t. hld, '.~' '~d.

iL"~ ~~,::: 'L..~ ""'.... 'ri«'btL. !Ill_ave ~~.~ ='";CiP~ ~~


A :mo:ltu::~t ~f:' :[\eftunOjlj, o:n Utf;:i' mQ~itf ~d!, plt~ile$' ,of' ,QUii' ,age b:lio:gs m mind ~ m'llTd@r;, UInj~n 'W3fIll" VI.olO'llS diC!ta:t'(:ujsh~ps~ oo~c~~U8!tiO:[I!

''''''''Im- C'n,;; ~~i'i'\tV_ ... c.:.;i\o;o, n_ .... :iifI;ii! .. ;!.:-i'i... "'~'''~'''''b'" Jfo"",, ,;;;n4 ,..:i:!:"'-as.e [ .... nn--r,;;"I .... ,.,.' ri"""-_' !Io.._U 00 r-ii:l,-, l[_,~~~_iI:iIIl~ r.I-Il:ry.~lIILlllLilSU.J~ i::2LdJ1J''If'd. - ,'!I.;IIiiJlIl [II.J,;,ILlUIL. [l.U~ - . '-' !LJ!'rrlJ~~ .'!J.oIIlJlIltlJ lIgaJ".r

paIlllt 'cri~e •• ttema:u'(; W~llU'1e',. ~d ;a:I], e~L~' a~ubbL~' H~ of" :~u~~'f'

'.~ n" ].AI~· L~. ~~ hu '11·Jik~,~~ 'b . . 'f" "b .... 1·· • '£ .

,ev,I~.:5" ,.~ OW'[(;()U .~,!IIt: I~ sup~~~~ ~·f'.II!.iGI,,~!5, Itt ,at !Ii' t o.c' OOIiruYiI;ll;ofilS,:IC'Of 3!U~O:I:l.~'

'~Wf 'wete made :mG:ki f~I~lble 'than, ~ey' !ha.ve' been hi!Swric~llF'" then ~.~~ ~ri]s would. d)imiInrish FiI.~r .iIlfi nwu'lltipif ~iroldff

One D~~F th3!t. fiberab ~Y' ~' ts that: 'tkey su;ppose. ne sueh itbiln~;, 'Th~ ~~ idlen, r-eadily' a;(;lQ];~l~d,ge '~t 'e¥l~ i~ :pt\~~t ,md '~rat ~~\(.h

:. f iit, " , .o1i I" r""'", ,;" I,' ... ~. 'I'~>r< .., i ' . '.'. ' . , .~ ~il.. . ' . ." "'·';1'] ,,',",', f 'd' :'~. ·It)· '. ,t' ..... " '-,:b, .' ,:', ,.,,'1.., 'It o:~ ~!Io, ~ ~~e: I""" mJ_:s~~, ,lI!u"""""n;o(lnY, ,aJD!!l)I, ~ll,e.y M •. repu ·.Iale lU(: C ,arg:e t!lllat,

tbey awe ~aive aibo:ut evile, Tbts ~S\We:rj' 'h~,~r, b, belled 'by iUiberaJ,~ (i.;Qt,,;, '1'£ ~ib~r;als did, ~nd~d ,aooE:pl t~e pf.~vRlern;c'fij [o.f [ml Md ,il mey' did, rbi.n'k m.~t 'm.uClh [of it i,s car~dJ by' 3IU"ln:mo:motLS! ,ac.ti'OiUls" ith,e~ 'ii.ey' could niOt ,~31te :poo~i,ti~ :priO,~~ and 'balk 'VtaJri,ile~ tb.at ail!e deMr~ed, lo ms-iter aJllu:o.lilomry. Mld 'ye' t, [da1lm '~n be' n~"'r ~;h"'frli '-li'·~~'\U' ".;~;--~~t'· "1"- .. : '-p;'·'~"""~.k"~'I-:.'

__ .~ . _ ~ ~~ _ ~~~. __ ~~~ .. ' '" __ ~~_~~ ~ __ ~ ~ _~"""~ I!L~""~L ~.~", ""~u I'me .,I,'~d.o!L4lli!JJ',,(l!

, ~

~~cr~ ~FIJ i(i~l roa~ \Vin be me' ,o.utoom.ce' 'm the pf~~ they 'bvor.

IJiJbe;~5, m2f,~ u~pollid i)filJ O:Il~' uf two wa15. r:i:r:si,[ ,t1Wcy :may h.()td tn tt..e~r' pQliJti.miJ 'p:~s ,and, b~c 'vailIUe'!il ;ancl, c~n~~!!re W re,gaxd ;a;uwn~my ,~

the; ""or,""' afl!1i;.~~:jlia;m 'i;."'~'i~ Q£:i[:O<"'" If .... [;-o'!l;-o.tm·, ,t'II.·;o> Ii' i •• 'p·t'\......,rwl·;O;I.'''!! ,~;n-~O!ililfiliii.,. ... I..1_, , ..... , ;'~I~Ct· -~ ~ "'" ~ ~ ~ - = =~JII;;~l3I!_~~ ~'I;I!'!I,. D= '!<;!"~~I !I;,V I!o..MlI - . , !Io1J~1I'I!l- A ~ . r" U.r"." :oR]:,., ~~~;~ .. ~. DIS u~~s.,

be pllit mlO e~'¢Ol as :pro:t~oti.O:IlJ ,apirn.n ~~, evil ~-on~q,ii)l~fiO~.s ~~t f~lJi~t tf'r·'@m the [mi'.Su!Se of aAllllo:nom'!ll·, ~il-e"",er' tibt'H' iSWl~-r-"lrd~ :-C--.-::". 'h;DW':"~~:'~IC =--==~ '"-'-_ .. _ ... , .. , .. c ••• "'J' ... 1 ,. ,. - .... ~Q"U:li5 H~l~ ... evc;;.ir,

[dt~ DUt. c,unan aUlto~o:mJ\ f~t bow e~' (;-o;~ll(i its ml~~~' be a:voided!~' :B.wi:

'l"I'ITit""'.~~m·!' :"'.ljIi~""""". A~IV ~~"'I""'''' ..,.l'.'r.· ... II·~~'i1i"."n'I'I~Iif"":I~~ .. if"i'i' ,~~.-::. --11;---;;--1 -;';'m.~~"".-=- ;;~

... ~ _.., .,' 'IIII!!O!I!IIi,Vt.i,,'V', •• n,1 n.",::"u"iI! "'"' .~., I>R. Ih •• '"'Q; T." JIO!IOIJ IR lillJlJ~.!I ,1iJ'"!I!!!:IG{l{)m!, n,~!I!II~Ji !Ill 'I.

ity~ :anlli1, th~ ~uiPposedl,~Joo ~~ibyd:Q~ of goods[ ~h.Att pmreot actual ;alfld

'IVl't'-llfdaii ,.....m~dio...-F8~, 'Ii'" al:w.., m e " ' ...... ' ... 'I~II'\'n.i"ii"i'i.n· Q!' irHJI,'I~"i1:: ... ",;['1 p·ro'.·'.··~I-m.iI': iiI"""(lil.~:"~r ... -:I

,F~I!!'I;,o.- ~ -~- ""'~~~~. - ""'~ --- ='~ --~ - _"""Q"!~9 ~,r,r""""'~ I~_L, iI!I!' !r~ '.!w",",,,,,,, [, .. ,I!)'.I~. " -.~ ~ ""'''1' ,.1 .'!EIiJI,

[iQf. 'the ;a,wldJajm.c~ ,of ~~! ,Sll(]l as, ,s~~,gtbeim~~g' :lJaw' ruwd 10 r-derj, ef!lj"Q:Ki~1 mC\rnII~iJ'" Mid i!li!iiistiIng O~ die HlO~ ~d~eati~~ W [d~~s., e~'IiI,~' 'Vf1iI'I'IIDC:1 ;O~"''''_ . ;iIL~.~ i"'Ir--~r<'''!'' in'rno'",:",,'r:o]i';o' 'fi'i "i"h~I~[iji<'''' ~,~U5ii~i:'--;i' ~ib. -=-, 'li~:"_=:~~1 ,----;--;--t.- . ~~'~~iO[ V;l;~'!;.,(.JI_ l"1IilI11!Y, '!IoI;I,-...,-.. !r.' ._~."A.L.ilil!" 'U.1l "'"''U'1L'Ii1J ~" ~i~ ~~n5i!l' lliJ,l~ ,!t~!Ii iilIJI! ,gr"dlln.

'Ii' d 'b 1 'L '1"iIl..=,=iW ""L .'j.. AI it u,

,liit: ,QeS, 11tOt; , ; iti':IP' tl;i~' , IlLi&I.,i!I, ~~ to ~ l!.!lart. iui~' :neelit: ~,():r ,SI1'£n pr--o,gF31lll:S

:is, ;smdl~ :and, ;SQ[ ~be' (Q:r'e 'Of likrnJl~ ;~d, ~e '~ic IkmJI ~'hu~5, :a,m' not seFii!l"u.str ,eo:mpr(lm!liiseil, '~' dlese pro,~s., H)I" i!h~s, ~m.e~~ 'iteWies, Q~ d.e:n.ryiifig th4!:' pFCi;mJlen.¢c of: evil, wh~db ,!lJO:l1e' oo~l\d render ~ 'tiie need (-Or the pOlitic-a] p~m:s tb~t; ti.1x:rn1s, Jj;nd tlDa£ic~PtlJhL~'", If' HI\)elr:aJl:s, '~fe llO[ fo¢~pond i~ ~h_is, ~'. ~h,(iy' wo~I,d, ~f:i~D.bten. [dru~' cb:a.-e' 0:£ I1;a!Ive~:e., 'whi!Ch their !felSpanse ~ Du::anll: to '~,eake:ll..

The seeond ~ ~ib;;lFi.dSi ~ f..espo-~d, is; 'by d~jIJ,yi'ng tlh:a~ the :P(i:\~~~ce

o~ ,tWI~ i;s due 'm :a-ilIIi1m'IlOniO'I~,1i:l '!fIi"',"';""''''a' Ti;.,pv <gI.l"'jl.",·.·,,-uci1l;a;ADI"" ,t!li.~" 'il";oo 'r1ii1'l~""= '.: ~ .;. ".-~ ~~ ''':_ ww-:':' ~..:. w~_~wr~'w=!t~'~~!i_'~' ~~v.L_I8I-r. ~ ~~_) M."I.::~_~IIV"-n!·Ir~~~~ !ldlll'~\.~IJ IJliI! .r.I"~~lF

lem:oe bU1l. attrilb~te lJ't to Ilito:n:iallU,D:Ilti}'mOUS, arm,ons .. 'w~k~ i'll\';l~l"",~ c:():m,plil~ MOIl .. :['01"C~d 'ohoi~~$~ oodi, :fa:iiiuFCs, ,~!l '~U:i!ti:o~ @:!:"' il!I~de'~ta-'-Qm~g'., The~'

..... ,,""".'i"I" , ede "'1~L:-,."",iI" ;<0 .. ,"",", rEi: ,e e' ',.".n.,·'11 ~i'E., 'I"!""I~_~.·,A, '~ ... tt;V.' · ....... n'l.;:;. ~.~,:L,. 'C'[ "",~ .. Iii\;:--;--·~ --;-,~ -;-;:iIf!;,,'. ~~::. '~, ~'-.'"

... """"!!' "" --""" iY~", ~J",~~. ~ .~.,~ ~,~ ~~ .,;..r r·~""",~'.'!Yo W,uo MiUJIO.UlJ,alliUJUaoo,' \!I.O WJiIH!l,

i'"'bA'!l!' kn~' '''I' ~~. '~,,~"i ~fI-., ~',",'I'!Q'IU';' 'it'i~'''[i' i<"I~, ... II!;, '~'foJipiW ... ,J;I~ ii:"'---;-:' ~. ~~"'F~[_' ,:;-1--;-., I~ ..... J _","",'~!I';JI '!;..~, •. ~~, ~!I.'I!" ~U'~.l IAOLiO;-= l~!IA"" o::IU!I.,f!Ii ,r-U,', .iJIl> ""L'Il> ~~. !L.iIJ!iI"{;lI~ C!10

rn.~n. ~c Walt tbe' :po:Urdc.aJ :,:r~ :m()uwted 'by ~he' basi\( liibenl w'IF


utc~ne$ d~ped, tQ ~ :~p'lIe nt;Qf~' a\:Jron~~,,~~,lt, rth-e ben toope oj d;e£[I~~n-8' ,th~ iHf:I:uen~~' 'of' fl.o~!lillt<J,nQ:mow, ~~O:lU .. 'to 'whJch, ;50 'Hl,lW~'h evil ~iIl, d~~.

"'i'i-::. ,~~_;- ~:0:1 ~";b.",",.,,} :r,...,..nnijO'~ i"iI', :;f;~_"'l"0"I!'"i ~il,..!"'"ff ~;'",~, ;C:J :~t,. ""':""~d' i ""' [Q'1!'if""'I~ :~I~~.'I,11 .' u~ ,~;(}n.tlll, 11!LK:iIi'it!IlI CII'~"',Ii-~~"""" Ii!! i!I!Ii!I,Uilll,~,~~ U:lW.l, ,,_n.,_, 11111,!<I!,![ IIliU, R ~_ ~""", 1,U;JIIi

'willi 'be' ~ aoolU, it, ;~ the ~ment. d~i~,.,.. l.wt ~ pr-abltegu, l'ri'th it:

-,1... ~-I~'II..:I 'I:;- ,,",- ~~""'~ ~'~j ....... -:llti ... ~,,",'~ 1i~ a,~ , ,·'';' .. ..,.,rv''':"I!' 'no!'~~~ .. "'I] 'm~ ~ ;ro"':':"'I'I',":ry ~"I' :"".n.n_

~Q!IIlD I[1!IE DI'iJI~U, iI ... ~.,u""'U""~",:r'" 11.1" 1lIlIA:i<u\.",. OJ; r~III!IiiI""""" ,_ - I!i.drdlli '-1 ,_ """,,,",,1,1,

~ ...... _.;i' ""';"'ii..1 .,.i_ ...... , .. ;jj~1IiI;17 ~iil .".,;; !iii' m~i'\_1\i' iniji..-:t be :and ~f' 'm!i:'I.H'h ,~~ i!!l du~

~I!""., .. ,",~ ",.IUlI '!JI!""" .... -~"""~_~-If.I), ~'!!'!Il_~" _' C_!J, o:;!I~~=i !_I_c_ '~-' _~.~.:__. 6 ,_!~~-,- cc_·_' ,-",,_._~, ~_[ -'-'~_-':"

'00 :nO'~WJitQmO~ ~~O:~! men, :tilber:al~ ,cgnot bc:1 :ng'ltrt ~11i ~dcnr~ng' ,th~ d.n~Q ,of :nto:raJ] :~U!s~mtil" 'wi~, th~, ,domain. 0:( aut'OllUllmlY., lit, can,~

L~ ..:il~~.iI ~:il1u ,._~,1 "' dlR . "] ~ ram •.

:I!lO't, ee ,re;pr.[~, ,as: ai, :m}o:I!~:o!'J' 'neuQ~1 Q'I! Lll_'_~:eFe~!t Qf L~~~,t ~-::: e- '_~~at:

:ntmlry' ~o,le :hilbit~lial~f ,~d p~di1;;.'b~' ~~ ~" ai_it :no:mt1!lkm;~ 'm .... ·I"·!lv TiOo[ """'"PIl"iO!IiI!'! 'b~1r i";I;-.~iI: 'lmiPA'm;te, mav 'be beJd morailllu' '-rwnsi:..

- _ ""'!!OII-'iII_,~" =""" !L!o!l;l!i:· .r'~~-"'j' ,~"1!00!1'!!"!!~,!!,,,,,,_!,, IY;~L ,r--~=""",r~~' C_C_~--'i I",~· ,_:~ ~ ~~_:__, ~'~~'- ~,:_ ~~:l '~''''o;!I,Ii'".,.;..' _ ,

''1:-1;-: r-;; -:: '~I'f':-~j-:C 'iIO-'?~fi'iI<ljo'-;-~~'O'!t~;f;, !~"'':''I'';o;< .. , ' ... ' ;\"""'i..,.,nsj:U'ri'"i"41: ,~,~;*:- ,·?'t.o;!! 'iC:ji:,..~-rii '.1.'0;0,'",

~.~ .1;01" t!J!I.eu ,nv-!~~Q~,[l'o,;Jl-!~!Io __ '~ ~U'li,;U.lli!I ,"_' iIOn~""" ,IIIIIL!I'I',~UI, llII!1AlO .ul~I,'iI1I, uu

d~t.alIl_i6~g ~I: both ·m,QraJ :[le&,o~siibn~tr, and, :aru~n~~J11}t" Dl~\lS$iQn, Qf:

.. ''br~PfOit,..'I~c;~ ::-'-"~II [L- ... :""-;' .... ~ft_p~: t: ""f'~:I,.., .... i"1"..,. .... ~: , .. IL.j ~i",·:t)""r' II!UiIS ".Ule:m, WilIII! ILH:li u!1_~ [L'lJI ,L"- U. , iU:l~ 1111"'1110"- ... lJlld .t_"" .ru

~-~-~,l-~~ ~ - -~ ~ -~- - ~J

"I'h'(; ,O'ther :prOibl~!m 'Mt!h, the ~cQ:H:d fe8,p;>nlWi' i$ [th!JJt. If.' the pf~~I!i~' 'n£ ,~~ wcr-e (::<I~l!ly' rattfibult~, t.o, ifi,o:nauikln,o:E11U!il5, aol1ofli5j, ~t1tt.e q.~e"l.if)n wo:u'ld ,!!in :remaiJl'l", 'Yihy are' DWnOmD1JS ~o:m,;~~~d, ~Q ~ '~~ li~l¥' m' ~us.e ml ~ ~' :m;~~rofi~,()'"~ [i)jl~$<? 'YI'b.lf" I'lloult(l: 'vOO~, be ~.ess lil~ly ['0, :~lh:),llIIliis'b '1 .. n11mr' [oo]ldiilttOIl:5[ (!Ill widch autonomy :~ fOMe~, by' :,11'0:'" mlb:m<p. rr~$du:m;, ri-g;Ii1!t5., cqnla'll;ily" ,aIJ:td dismb]i,[ltil,~ j~ti~c 'thai", '~ey W(tulld M: ull,d~r (;onditilo:n'.! iin, 'w'bi\(l~ v:i'r1!~e8 are e~eo~d, aad '.~S ~' pr-e~ by pllilti~ :pf.~ di.a~~ ~~k~ worud fUnd unapc~pta;bI~? 'Wh,~' 5t1Pp;i~ 'Dilit m a£~llill Oli' pot£:Flima1. mldKif8 were' pro¥i:d,ed, Wci!m ·du:::' ,(rj'PfJ~-'

iiir, .... :'ifij ,;s, .... ,._jl ' .... "''''''"'i:r!Ii'(_ ,~"'i" !~,;o;i ,"",.' .,' ... ~ W'~;!I''''' '""~-~ '!I'iII","~,"i1id',1 ~I~"'!in !I!U'j;, !:Ii~illi"il;!l'~' ,",'i;c.'''''::r.' l~~~'!!:,. ~~U"~ ~~~,~~~ ~ ~~, [~ IU;IJ~ I IF;.I~~, IUIJ~ 1 'n~ULI_ - 1lI,It'wIlJI, itI;- '~ __ II_III_""" IU,~_ .

@ri], d~s:i:ti.'ons and, rs:taI1: :actiing' beDi.in;I:y~

'Be.sc' questions, are' dle 'ilOpl.((; of ~i!!!, (;'hapta~, 'Tblii ;5ii[.:i6~c~' [of d!~~ :pm\!,tlelic~ of: [e¥I~ ~n the present (lODJiaJi. g, ~t. :Ilibcnill~ ,arppem, toO' be driven to 'rtoioi!ilMlidl to it ,e~&ef' in ~ dial:; ~' jnmfi~tei1Jt ~ili '~t.s ~jfi~

_~~_- . ...:..::,___;~ l __ .l.~.~~,[p"!""!"___;~.__:_'~ l~_.l ,J~, .:__=;~ ~~[~-.__:_ _. ~~~, .• '!''!'!'''!!''~'~ . '~_~ .... ~_ ,~, I I ~ ._..[ ' __ •. "_-' 1,L .... - -, Ilfr. __ - r - I.: ..

aim, [G'f' '~' de~ng' the ilIudeHiLatdA:' :fa-ct ,ot :i!'t8 p~eLfi'Ve.

<iF:wl ,is [lk .... 'm""'s( s.evere '!'\AnrlemnaJiilon ,e:o:ll!ternlVlllil!J"1i" 'iElond voca'~

_._l = ~~~, ,__;~- _ __: ~-~ _,- __ ,-_- ~_~ :__·~< ~~ __ L~o ~:_: ~ ' .:__-:_:_ '_" __ -:__ [[ [F~,..J~l_" [,..:_. ' ._ ... .:_ .. -_ ,1_"

~~~ ,=,tliil 'I. ,Iii =.111 Il~ 'I dl 'll., "'iii"" ~II

'UlI~' :aiil~" lt1iIUI'~¢I'\ Wrtl)l!m" iE.fl)Sm~m~m:tl pf(), :o~~ ,lilllllml~l!3tU:UIl!![ anu

pT~H!~ble ~~tiI)T:I, ~ ;Ktme ~'x.am:ple$ (JF' it, E~, m:-Uj, w,~:l~ :ba.nm:J

'IiiiJi\.'~;i"i'\.' ~,~, ... ,t, 'L.~ "' .... ..:tl ..... ' ... , ... u~;O";O/~,.,,: .... iIi\l'io .Al~n'Ii,!:Ii_ ""jt,. '"~iIi;"!UI;~' capac',":tv iii"", ;ti.'''-.!H .. iiilIlI''ifn, 1I!'I'1IL1~_~_1IL1, ,IJIJ."!I,;,I~~. UtI[. ~IJ oItV!Io.IIi:I! 1IW:i1J_"UU; ... ~~I, 'lL-vl [....,..._~_~I~ [ y' ·'I!J.~_""_II_~_~ '._" , __ :". _,_" J." ~I lllU.:lllf...,__1.!Ij-V,:llll

- - ~

~nor.:ma'llly, F~_n:hcrmore.'ii' tlne.' :~, :lillI!lW: 'be lm.j~iirfi~.! ~~ not ~"

~ri.01D harm is 'in '~tKilf '~~~llo:.' [m~ u[ It: 'may 'be IU5t lIlH'mli.8himent, f(}:Ii'

. _" ...'." " ", , , I.r ,', , " ',J ,J, , 11:-, , ., J

e.RrEUeS i()O;mmll~ 0:1' the ge~~ ,of p:r.~41!tl~__g ~H g~~~a.t'Cr h~. Wh~t ~, lean, be J~.'6:abl!v IIlOiu_, is, ~nu~ of dt-e ,fim,Om,ClinJtal ~tlmtinms ,O'f

_,' l!' ''ill

'm,"'li'p;"''1 n"ir",il'l'"iUWI!'L.c\!,· but :O'~ "1""" '.;~i'I'"' n""""~ 'n .... ~ i'-" ... """""nsid"~-~ ibeft'.

l _, ~lllAt r,rl'- _ !V'Ior.~rllllJ ~ ~" _._ 1 ,_ JI~"'~ U~Q" =,~~"Ir.:!liI, ,~_~" l~ !Iir~ , _ ~.~~ __ - __ . _~'


:!Vill nl!af' 'k' [Ilt~ :,rrodJtlot of :hl!llli'tl_ '0:[' nnn'h'llilinim ;~fIjq. lfl€l'$nt~fl,[t ~ath~r '(hart ca~ ~ro;p :~J~' ;~,d, 'w.id~5prl~, $~li~~, i:s, ~ [~pl~

~~' r,'~~ ~i"'Jt-.~II'_ !0!10~~ 'lit ,,· .. 1 "I;E·I·~·IiI'lil. [d' ~"""'''';iL~d·1 !'!i<;!E, '~i1''''lIiili~"",",'11 ~;I'_ 'I.'\~I' [,;o;;o:J;I·~·:",~"iI1 ' ......

\til IU_l~ m._~'i.j~ ~~Ul Il.l [_-ill lHil!~_l}' ._.~~ll.lJ~ __ ~ 1 __ ~U_.!AI ~'!I!'~ __ r. lE..fII!-111] IIIwlMl~ UJ.:

:1i1r~mm 'btt~RF, .. ' ~c'h, 3jj M$~ of ,"_ :m.'noc~nrl pe~n,-, I~' mo~ ~~. 'T!lJiI!5'

,.~ . .:II· . • _,1 . ..i::: . ,', '. 'L~' . ~~ ..:II ~'il "'II .' ~'·'1' b . ~,'i... 1~..i 'y "'-U_.!UO~!dlt ~_d.lIDc1ilo:n .ltween ~!ill1!.Iil,'dlJ" Uu moJ.dI! [eviI,- 115, '~U;"J_, _Irrt snou ,i!:lI,

:IlU~t, 'K' draMm, ~'OO, :!IiIl!ar,pl)",-, ~ :lruuman, '~iinp imay'~ ag'~ltir.s, of':_turai ~I~, ;g [c.am~~, .gf' ,[I, dbc~"i f;ot i~s~(le" ;.d, evil g!Med, by M~hJ\I_rmuJj iagei1i~ ,~ ~t nt-ond QlPp~briu.m,-, if ~t,~ p~lm;bl~' ,~d [i:h1B :~~,pofi~b'l~ :&;.F do~ng',~ R~ ne,gng~lt. MQ.mJ, ,!l1I'ld :p<J:I~~ tthii[!lkii~1: n~ ,¢;f:1!h,~I~ 'mlllm '00 foclD 0111, ;m.o:ral twiitJ 5lftC(i it is ;m,~1ti mof...e :libfy' '00 '~, wJrdliUJ, hrUnl;3i1l ~g.nunt CJbg ~ :m;a;~ eri1.

The :primail'J ,!SII'i~~, {~, cwbk;'b, ~()j~ll ~Ail (i"~~,n :OCilIn ~QW Oilil~ ~~l~ 'o:lilerWi:!!e :i1ndlicaitrd) ma~' 'be ;aKrl!bed ail'C 'Ilia:ma:n, ad.lI,~nl. :~nrtall, ,~tG5I ,~hoi~~,~ :¥~~ :Uiid, ~[!i~~Aiilo:P~ :l1IiIa¥ aha, 'be' eriI,. 'tnilt on_~' :i_~, a ,dedw~' senee, fb:r :m,ental State5, and c'il)Ol.C'e5, aR' [evi~ if they au' :lilk~1Y t~1 l~ad t~1 ,eVil ,aI;wns;; .nts,~ m~ n:mID:!it ,of i!ljU~~F ~i)iIo:iU ~ ,~~ ~d, iin!5tibwtiQIlI:S ,~ ,~J, [if 'tbq' ~'luJy' ftlmJ1filPt q,~nl't5, rcprnmorUiml' (h,mo m, ~~iliD ~l ,acitOIll!!t, ~Q i. :primaJf:')!" ,sen'K'~ ttu:ref'Ore'~ nil, ~Si a.senirSlt ;(;Dnn,~c~d, ~~, bum.an aCJti,~m:5, Dl.i3it ,ca.~ ~rlOIJ1$ .. 'UlJlj~stifie:d, 'hi ann, ~ human 'kin;p.

Th'C [~J at: tiM 8 lof b\!i~ ageoillSl may be rare' episodeJ ,iFIJ 'the ~l~S, o:f 'o:tDerwiK' d~tm;t: ~P:l~'" 'o:r ~Il~)" ~'Y-' be p~di1:;table ~ (d"a .~,~S~ti'(Ul that is; ch.:a:n.tte.ri,~c' of th~ .o:u1 ¥ih0lSe at:tion.i!ji they 3,(K, III 'tihe lallier'

, .... "",""'"'. :",'1;., .. , ,d'-I=,g;~,·"'-i""'lII'Il ;,."":",, ... , ..... ""' .. !l'11., ... 1i::-1 ,"";0;, ",~lli1i'l!iIIi~f"'~oit. ",,",,",.,~IIifi:!ti' ,d· •. l~-ii:ii'i,ft!iol .~ --;-,,~ ~.~kr. UiL-~ . --~r..~-- JY,V.,.i~ l _1iJi ~I '¥l A.c~l!i ~uL_Il_W ~ ~ln'amJI;"~-~ 1Ii..:-.I. ~LI~r"l "_ ~"r- .. , .. ~_ua.J~IJ'J [atD~,

~mrvy., AgfHl.1l$ with vii~i!i, ~' 'I)r ~' ~~t be erili f~f 'they m_~y a&o, ha\Ve' viI~e-s., udJ their ldl~OOSI aotli,(xIl'5 ma~' be mor~' :mr~ml~mu and 5.iFi~~_t ~.M'IJ mttlF viiGio'Us actj,o:n,,, [,~~ b~f~, ;agen~ are' dO'm~IJ!a;k:d, by' '''citr' '\!'i~ '!ilen 'we'y-' ~ wl£Jbd. '~¢kedH;~ ~s' ;a, ~~~ of e'~anu:lt~f" in '~hich rllhe: ;age~~'~ 'w,a:~ ~rwb~lml iSUdb, Vcin1t~ M mti;~' :may :ha~ :and :r~i!il~ ~n :hah~n~iJJI :,atteng, of [e¥lJ ac.~m;I_~" There 3!.Ire e~JtJ:1e:m.e CMeS oJ 'W1I.c::bd)ll;~ ,~Ul 'w:r~i:£~h .,~nrt.s, d~ ~'lot; :inttRly eause ~d, harbir(itWlI~y ;g(i), :ha\'t ,(!b~te:nl ,(tQmi;li~dJ, 'br v.i~~ 'but .1 [gO\ri~~11y and dd_iJlxm~~l~' ,t.~tU\i"ait~ th~ir

ui~"" ,if"" ..... rder 't)""!': ~~'0''ii"l"'"1 ~~~:I ,""'f't:~w;<;,;" ~T"':;' :aUi'i'. ~"'It: .. , !C"',-' ',~ ;:=--;1 1";~'~'·Iii~\Ii:iI,',:,-' '11',1,"'""""0-,; ,",U '!<A1i'U"", l"-l!' !r_,Ii,I,~" ~iIi" ~'!!'.u, 1IU,.,u- • .:,u~i:I., ,~,w: ... !IiI, ~,,,,"g~ ~ ,QlA:iJIr~, Hl'{JI!I_...g_"

Th~' ut~fiit~ [£II '~biltih ia,ptoilS ~ 'WiC'ked~, ~g '~ce~i md pe~'Orm, ,~ ;~tioQ~SI ~s' a. ~u-e~r' Q'f de,~:e, There :is :n~ [deaJlil~' d~_j;'IJa,blt'i, thIife~litg;ld rli!lJji', :if c~d~ '~o1Jlld :m~' an a'CMOll, ~l" ii, Icb~t€f' 'tnJlt. a, Vi~,~ QF ,!liil agent wl.Gudl. CLte_ (;"'Ullii!l, 'M'~;Cli:!",,~J~~u- 'ViI;n","~ ,;o:J;.'n~ ~il"~"""·":l!Q' ~~.,.":i'. 'i'W~'[,;o;~.~.,",,",-- r>."'t-'

_ ~ ~- __ - __ ~ _ -~ _-~_ _~_ _ ~ _ ~ ~~J ;II ~ ~~~~I ~~ "",,!!!J~_ rltbbu!'! __ ~ ~A __ -i:II!l_!l' 'U;~, ~-~U_~,~[!! l~!U}_

:iltifti.-'t, ;,""j11 , e. '!'I!iUI.: .. '!Ij~~ [ .... i;~"'!II', 1ii)Ii~i'i' ~:""",,"UIIo [r~m .. ift'llil".~IIi""'li'~';O; :§~, [~'rr[ I~;I~~~~ ~ii?'~ .. , H~~"'!":I_-_~, ~~ ~~-~ MrII1l~ ~-~~-~ II IL1l~~1 llil._[Ir'!i.!-!'iP.i.I" ~v."l __ r.-I_L~.ur'!i.l'~I'-""'" a.iI,~" ,!Yi ~'1I1t1iiLIIH.11lo JJl7.-.II, rlJ·~~"'I, ,

:p:nr.po~ _~~, tb~, '3J};Um£nt b ~'~llilt '~e :p:r~~nee [of" ilfld'ilHi,pubible ~S' .~n "'hri:~h :a.uiQ~~, 'C3l~ 8eriom;., ll'!lj~tilfiOO 'harm" tke ,dJi~~io;DI 'to :1?£ri'Otm, ;9ut'h at'on~ ,b habit~~iJJI~ Mtd lihc q,m'u,1 cllaracten are dowliF' D!lIi~ed, '~' SlJ.oh. d)ispos:i!ti,~UliS.

'f'iIlIiJlt ,~~, 3;(:ti'oil5 ~ ',~efllt gd, dI~ iliey are 're!,piO.lils.jJj]e :for m:ll,ch


of hii(~nlM ,96""11 b, d~, ":0 m;e· 'r~Ufii1J ofw~1 d'iu ~s ;50" 'tJ.ie obvious ainswer ~s, that :biUJmQiIl, beings are g~t1W!ted 'by ·.eir vi~~ ~m. wbii:dl eviil act!iQ:",~ :fmUn:w;. WillI. wj~, Is :ooinumh]JaJU!ng~ UD.~.t'H ilt i:!§, el:plmlioo 'w:~Y' h:um3lD, Mii,op ~ a/o;d a'Ct on 'ri()e~"

'D:- 7~"lt~iAfib'cal!lf': mMt 'infliu~lri'liaIJ l~x'r..Ianaun:n ls e'M't;~edded ;iJJl 'tile

~. ~~e p~~~~(Ii".". .. [",_-~~ ~~-~~'f ~.~. -'-" -'-'.'- . ,It' - - , .. , - . "... .." ~ ..

Socmtic :pamd'O:x [th~t uoo' ~~e dOes· ,eVi~ know1in,g-iy' hoee h-wl!il :1 g~,':; c'hapt4llf-' :3i ;~d, VJ~t~ l'9~iH~: Chapter ,5), 1',h:e 'th;oulhlt oohitnd, ,~~, :appM~nJll,y ,o1m? OlliS, £ah!bt'Qo(l of ~s dalLm, is il'b~t ~~maJ'il qen.t5 ,.e :nl)~l:r guided :~D, 'tlheirl" a-(t10n$ '~ 'what ~e:ms fQ' 'be ,good [~D [the:m" L'Jl.ie ,apI_a/lion a.f mIJ

~. - '_

,'"' .... i:i .... ~i"'O;: '"r""'1 iIi'.~4i~ ~i'L.""'r.~;I\hr ... ' 'i[,.:~, ,e·I"":i!J.,oeo-[' '~~i!I'''' '"'i~ .. ~O'. ~nrii-E', '"",",,,,"' -lVIltDr:anJi' ;O'1t'illhe g,ood!

"",,u.'Ulil~ ,lJllllu~ I~It'!lo; .C!liu .'!Io.. ~ . Jill!!;""", UII_oI!IO!Io, IJ!!~I!;". ""'iD",",~~l!I"I! @'J! .... ~~~ ~ ~ _~,~ _~ _~~ ~ ~ _

;aJlJiiJ, :ped~tmJ ,evil ,a(:~(ijn~ in illb(l mQ~fii 'bEti,ef>thBl[, m~ ~ good" ,or IrDart

i_£ iio'I!..L 1'..=. Jh .,'L, pOO" ..JI .,'L. _i1-.. '~Il ..:i.~ ;'I-l Ji,'ii", ,;, ,;,

'Ill' iliil.'~:-: li:ji!l':;~-: :--:at 'u..!ifl: '·.i' I.\S ,3!1l1U IIi:U~~' 'Il~",reuiJuele55 U!!), C:~ ~ '~!t'en iii!! ~!il,

, _. ey . @w W -- - ._,. --, . .-,., -,. r ,~,. ,,' ~,...- ~-.- ~ -,' .--- .-'"'~ IlL ~~

'ka~' ~'Cidelllt. 'cQe'tcioth 0:1" :9O:me' :iQ~a-~ity j!i1il~rteK---l ~Iml tlh,tt~F pilIr" ,!nlli~t of 'Wlita!l~ ~~ms to be pOO, to, 'We-lIt. lb.re' Soc__F3itic '~ew ~5, thia;t. Im,owl", 'edge' o:f ~e' g.ood 'Wii~l l~d to ,~lclng it" and il:' ;ilt d1oE!!I, n,o~ dte~. [ID{t,U

,-,~, I ,~:~;i 'ij. .... ,~-:; li--:' -'i-;-;[~i-=-...if~ii""ii!:.ip-=-· ~.'~I\;I 0;'1.. ..... iL~l~l~.FI'-.~, 'C'I;" ,~""'I!r ~"b ... , .. ""'t-~"li'n'.~ L"Ijli-...,. .~~. I;;I'lIl;i ,mllite .m _e-I,I!,~iIi ~n!li..'lt:i ''I''I!,~U~ W_II'G !Jill!l,,,,,"u!l!l<iiUO:,,,",, """1O'I"I!lJlJIill !Ii. _ ,,,,-, B'LW'!.l!'. _ ,. 11.1111,,,,,"

:-~.~-, .. 'I'~·I1'I-·i:·'·,,,, ','~:-_.-, '_~"~l'-' '-'_-'--'1] ';"1 ,II' ,Ji,:ifr,~~,'t 'iTr~,-'-' ~:b(:' In ~~'l(,~ C!fX.P.IiD!~8:Il~ll 01. ~per;:II!iL'('; e'!l1, ;a.otluDS millSt. u!l<ere~@~ e ~ SQ'u:gLl~; ~~ ~a(:~~. !I,M

Mowledg1c Q:F ,lin I~l(;, of ¢h.~rGe:~

'1"'1j-,.~- -=- ,~(~--~ . -,_- .• ,'L, '_:_-,- ,-~' '( -' 'I, 'c' -,: ~:" '.'-', --' :, : .,·;fc : ~ .. ';I-l (see '-r'~;~., 11'~'~ _ 'iF-"rI'. ~'ir-' }i~ ,,:,:t-·· ,!l ,11e:~ ~ !!()l!!U~r a.pJ8iffiliu.ans 0: ;en. . ,see .~!I'i;.e! ,1.:~~"",011 i!' Wlui!lo IU'IM!y M~_I, HOI ..

be dso~, here ooca~ '~ibe-rdili5 h.'il:'K: 5huwn ;11;0 ~ndim;a:ti;o:m [to acc-ept tM~, 1"1il~ ~~d(: 6pl!!Q)atijo:n, bow,_ever-, :is :mo!t; if-lOm.:gemLiJall '~:O :liibel:,ail,lsml. It a!u.rib~res, e~1 ~~O;~ toOl ~O:m!li~' Wld pn)~$ iiIS, a :~m.~d,~' 'tb.e :i!D' -,-,:;::-'---:"-"':_;-;-li' ;:['koow'ltcd(1t!! allil:d! d:u~' :n,ro:te{',it.i£i~ at'" cboik:¢ from iilJuwd!e' :irD'liefl"

pmHme:I'ILu ... -, ---" .. ,!;I!,_.I . --"-r" _. - .. ~.----- ~~ -~.~~.-.- =-= ~-~~~- ~~~~~~

to -- -' - .~ ,- ~;·~.iIlo.l~'-· ,'~ 'll'iL. .. ~_='~ '1=,=-.- ~-~ .~~ ~ .'-~ 'b~ ~ iii' , .. i!- -~ . ., • ....,,~..,..,.' ... ,j>;,....~" ... i!t ~'£ ''''I,~iIi ..... ""." Alm-u. -,

terenee, W~~~C~!h ,~n 1!1!~I~id!I. '~~P~""1lS _~J.I Ute ;lIIU'b~!I,5,1u:~""u~!I!I,~, ul. ;iu!IiJ.,"",I!~"""'~!.·l'

'Ii ,.~II..""~·<I"" ~,~.i!!i~ .. ~!L..",,~I_~ '\'i','O"1Ii'~'~dl '~~, I~I: '~+":_".d! '00 a_c'.i!':ep.,iIt the Ioomtl£ elli!'ip-:-I_a..

LlI~;,dl __ ~ l.~li~·!'p-'1iii'illW~l""l~~ ~_~-~._. ~ = ~,"'L~~ ~-_ ~"._"'="' __ ~ ._.~~ _ ~ ~-~~ .... ~ "-~~ .•. ~ -~"

. .

ti{(JllJ~ :~'Y' bec3iU!:4!' ~t ~s, MWIll w a mc-;l'ap~~l~ aMU1mp'O'JII ~~~ the [I~~~ ,of 're!Jiljl~ ,:and :iLb eft«t 'G:i'l. human ~,pirniti,umrs, 6ait ls :inoompatiib:l'e'

-'~. 'I--'~' ,. d' piI1I1I'~ f' '" , '" , d ~-

'01_. h.,' 1'"1 _~-=--:-l :" ~"I ,""lifO-. I ~." '- ~'~-. ~I'i<';:;' :0' ;, i"t:"', 'l'n,t:"'i"If'Ii<'I'I" ' .... ' , ..... ~,....,,~

WJ! ~ ,_1- ~ .. ~ '_ ~ 15m l!:IIl.U. I c' _ "-'if -, 'LiI~ U . iIi!lliJ , _UIU U~o::IL'" . ~ ,,,,-,",,,'I;i]I.

L'Hwe :m,e~pb~yslcal ~lLm:,ti,cQn 'tlhalt :~ ~gulbleSO:ED.e 'Q:j:' U~~~, is dl~t

~;i-~::_~ 'iJ-I~n,~;O-"1 ,-=--',_:_~"-=-i ,_:_. ",t' '.J'I-:o."~, ,1~ iIi"!"t-,',' . i"': i"'b_, F'II_...,b1""1'~,r: ... 1-.. , ~~~ l!lil),lim~ ~~n~imL~ @.l lln,Cl: W@r: .... i ~i!h~IILe,s '!liD '!Ioue ~~u,~ Q~ u.tc

Soc.nmc ,~l{p:l8lml!tiOmJ!, '~im;e tnowiledlC' of the ;good, olm seems '00 be oofnbi~edJ with deliberate eVil. ~til)m" the' d~~ltostliFes, 'of &X~riti.I}C~' ooub:l "CI!L.: be 0.1' iip.~nnces !mot rea1Iw-, It 'must tlI,ereiQJ"e' be asslJiliD.ed, first

unf .. ".: r--~ , -, -. __ , "-'-}' ,i. ,-~!.--- .~-,,,~.'"'--~ ~. ~~~~~~~~~·l ~~~~~l'

~b~t il!t~uie[l~~q d1:e h~m, ei'(~rien,oe 0:£ We' w.~' 'wo:ri!d! '1iIa:1, ap-pe:arn t~, '~~",;;, m--:. ~,'-'ti(; ,E;:xm'laIli1:8JUtUlJ 'IS 8J.llJI,nliaSC!tlMb:Ie. '~C :reail~fru' 'in 'vihi'eh ;8.

!Q . l:C E .... [,"11 C ·,r···· ,. , .. ·rl .. -~" . __ . ~'-""f =~ -~~~~~~~-

~~~aiI. 'OIrdtet pr~l$ ,.._dJ :~c:{)m.d" tIilJat ,~, nve---.5, for- :Ilutl!martll beinp depe,nd 'G;I'I; uowiln,g :IUld. ~Mng ~iiJ1,eo:nf~ilty tt:g tbi;$ 'Q:~' mtb~r 'i;h~ ~n,g

~·~d'i ~'T,..:I""'~'i<>Ii,"",' 'ii):~WI ~·L by,," ,"'''''''''~niliiii~~ ... , :i<>'nnP_9[...,..II1' ....... ;O'_ 'O"'W1'~' ~f,~,'ii-.'IS, ~p."'''''' "'-li:L.. !le._ ,~~ U"'·"'.I.'10!~"",, ,I!~ ""' .... u u ... _ U_""' .... ·""'r!IIJI;"''''"' Ar."'r~ofII.'I."""'!F.'!;,,'!i..'IlL ~ ~ !t~, L U!IL_,.,~.,"""l __ , I!o __

,. _' '~. _' . ,

S:~n1jpti~~ wc::r-c' bU:e' WO'l~~dJ it :foU~' 'dlrilit evil ,acti.u;m~ ,which iM'~ 'c:O:mJh!r'y

rT, ,~~:_; 1I~ ..... ~I:;-.;4i-=-" ,,"ji';ill;-:lII~'~ ., ..... 11; ..... ;1, ,'"'1'iI" ~\.'';1'~'J~''_' ... '-. .":'"f'r'"""'lfiiClo'" "'xnilaii!ll8 ~~~ ,~O UiL'iri .IlEl'OI.-W al'tiC-I" 01.- ... '-ill ....... "", !Ii.V 1iM", .... W, N~V!""L""i"~I"'" ~~~ @"""'.:!I ~~-r-~--~~ ~ _ ~~1'

we'r-db.re, ,~ a, de.ti,Q:o :ff.-om tbe g-ood (iDE to ~, bJuma ,d!a~t; in :km:owJ.. ~d"~ a dlH~t .i:lIt· 'lnw'lVe!i, 'mi\5tak'i[lO' ,atD'lV"·u.mc.e' 'for :reaiiiifr!w',

••• ~. " •• ;oJ •• __ ._~. __ l~ .. ~ ~.·.l .. __ --·l'~l·-~J'""r·~-- --- ... l"""l •• ~ ~ -~l/~


"jI"ijo.~. ,~~c-p.·~ .. "" ... ,,~ii;:: ... [~. ,;i!!'O~11 ;i":,"jp!II·~.~ b."!!.!' ,.,~~.,. i""'"1~1'''i'C~''''III'ii'''''~l''''''~1 """""'~'.II1'i1iIrn:it:"""~ 'I-.,~ ..... . !l.ld~' c:.x." ~(":LJulat"'"O:u. "",J. ![i.~d ~.lU1'! ;JJ. ",-,\.iii - ~ l- !l~lh.~ ~l.l.&[Ii.Q~.Ulr~*I!o.i""'-, !Q'JI'JI!I,.II-"!~~.F~"L~ ~

--~ --..:.II '~'~.;:,~,-,- 1~"~~I'~~,1i~ :i'b~~,i''Il:"'I"'" '"'rei !F'.·.~ .. -l-I;"';·"', """"'i'fiil I·,'L"..,. ... ~~,'I,,-'IU"\!',·~, : '~,:;;o;.fl:, V ,.;LI·I ,:.·:,··~~I"'ilI!,h:, ,.;if"o:;. .. ~.

p~u J:rom, !I;._ •• ,,~,,~" !l.m;o-u,g~l~ !IL! '",Id ~"'~~'" y;t,..,. .. -", "'''''''!l:!I/ ~!I!~.",.~ ,I y"!,' ~1 ~ Pili ....

'~:"'-; -'ik,.., ,'t£ Sa:i,~ii'A'."ij!l!'noj~~~ "":'":.:1 TI ~h"fioW'''''i<',AAini.I<1iI''''''I~ li"'~b .• fl·""~!I"""'lnll·'1Y ''''~iI'~i~'"i"~"!,,Q, i"\O, WQ:r.,~ lI;)I'I ,'" hili, ~~~iIO.~"" O.:L'U, , ,. fUI,jJIJO;oo;K'! ,0, '""julnj~JRoa.. ~". " _""~ ~""'.,." '~:,. _'!!.I, ~~!I.'I!~!Z! '!IIV

'-(:1 ,,-_,1i~_J1i~..,.~~ ~"rii'~U:.'" ;~~~'\i/J.~~iI.11 ;:o:,'I~'I~4'fI ~..,..'I itl'kj"e' [;",~ .. ,[t~I·'fio'l;1lo "","'~''h","' '"'""'"'1i'f,m;] ""ryiaf' an m!I:'"UI!tlWiI~II,I!'!i:!' iiI!I .. -t"""!I'I!""I"IIIL'I~" .::0 " , ~,~U!U, uvu, !l~!I. "",.~ ",-"!A;. ~ ;Ii-""'!I! •• ,!'eI, [~~ ~~!A-'_ "",,!j '!JIi~

t'bilil pe:Ilm,Calte~, l\ea1~ty" gdJ lit e~m:i1la:irl'l~ th~, p~te~'u~~ 'of cltil by iJJh,c; rpo:r-;., Npli,ng iocIj!)~ctl~-e' [01 'o:rigiQ~1 ~~in. ''iiih:kh ~ea~ 'tw.wmalll kiiini,g-s, ~'O, cb~~ ..... ~eil ~c; ~ -[- ~'1i.. ::_-;-:;:-;-ofI , ...... .,:.Ii "iII;""'if"'i!!'~I' ... ~Iilfou' ]~.~, ""r" '!I''':''!'a'i<I 'I:!' 'p~ 'lit' ,itJ'i'j,o;;.m~ 'se" 'I"~"', ~Q'911'IIll1'Ii<'t' ,.,.VI!, ~F 1I)1Jl~ ~U!'D, 1IU •• U, 1!fi) ..... 1J 'IOi"""f ndU!!I)!" v., ,",,,,,,lUI ~ ~11Ol, !l~!I"", _ " . 1l''!U'i:! ~Oi"~"'l,

Cii@d~I;S, mora] iJU1dter:, ,A1doo'n~h Cbri'ilfa~ d.i~i;jjn{l" aoo~t 'eW~ bia!, d~ejt)~lY

~ D ~-l

Infl 'i,i'"".T!io .... ..,.~1 '~~'~~cil~r'Wf"1 ~ib~~,~a'~,t' 'b.~""~·,.,.~ilfril 'I: .... ;.;, ;f'!'""""e'I~~,' ,.,;;:w~ :""I'ilil..:ll ~:b."'"' nl'\""""""~~'" :i~' ,'II~.~ ~ ~'.u,'!<..x;IJI, ·"'; .. i<IOII_G."IJ,1J III _ JV''''I~lilil' u.;::l;!I!I''L",",~~ !llll, .... Y.I ~"~ ,",Ul.l.& ~_~~u [!I. - "" ,r'."""'~~~['"" ~i!j,

:n;eveRhdf;}~ :(liJIl)jst be ~en~, 1..:u:)~~g' sOIm:e ~m ad ~mmiS of tJ];oo~og:i'c"al

''''0'j"iIl!;'',;o(iIo:~j''i ... t'i''''''"f"1 :"''''' ;""" ,~'~""i'1IIl'r,>~'I'I_":" "",if: 'it:~,o:;. ~~jo,r,>p~'~'~',"''';1 .. .,.,,'Ii"i'f11'"'Aili'!· .... m '!:>!lm:dJ'~1 "'""""" a'!I.oIr:n_I&I!U-'__G)U,.V.'lilJ~1 R.i:Ii o:JoI:l, i:U.J_6.r'~)1I,;- ,.V,I_o11 v.,I- l_iJl~ lIWJlIG~ il~J.'!I.II.I!~-!QI- I ~!I).II~~,rr"-'--'~~~ Q~_.~ ~~

:,1~n~1io~ of eViJ tha;l'~ '6~~ adv,~lIu:ed, by Soc~te:!!i,

Tb.:~-, :'-, ""~."'ItIi'''_~:,-'~'"",,'1 ""1i''"'''I'.,...,''.· '-p.' ."i;~-" ~1.~,Jo>oii"'" .... ;:0:( .... [loryi', 'L.~ T["""!WIln;:o:,'L:-I~' ' __ .. :iif'li-,

,1,1_'_5 m""",I"""r'J: 1i)!5:1 ~O, ~1JjJ_.lU~ ;~_.,v.!,.,~, II ~v ~""" "'''''~~, "",,,,,."111: OJ"-" ~ u..:;: = """'- - ",~QO~~ l' ~l!_g._~

• AI" ~!i... ~~. 'i:..~ ii' 1~1 iil" iik· '" ~ ";1, 'T~ nib' '. be

tail [o'eu, :Ill ~Uje I~j\gll~t; >OJ; Weil~"'~~~ o,q]eC~]ODJj, tD ~~~, _c _:lIe~' [~-tI~otlQI:t~ can ~~'

;!§ta'~~, here M.tbmut. ~lJaJoomMO\n, s~nc~ ~libltl1tls dl~msffl,~·~ 'tend to veiee .,jb."'I';HI· in ,;o,i~"" [;""~.'.'"""",,,"' ..... (0' '[1,;>;aiiilili;jiirruO" i'f'I"'i]igi",.'.i,I; "u·;o,'li.MO"lAl'., '"f,:;:t'~ i'"I .... ~' ;D'Ind.~.l~e:

~~""''''-'l.l = ~~"'" ""''!0!1'~"",", v~ =,,--.-..m'!;'L'1l) ~ ... ! ."; !I;"I'~- -~ Yl~_ - ~~~.f ~ = =- .... !lI!"!"'J' ... ~'" --~ ...... ~

~.~t Day ~, !It.i!L~, i[f~ iN'Of.' of tJme ~tI!PJID'&ed exji.St~itltt· o:f ~, m'o~11 order in a r~Uip~d, S!~,,~~sible r-eaUtr beyo:n:d dle '~(i!illd ;a$, ;i!t ,lppt!m 'to ~~m3!n:

'"'fo:'b..~~"""l\';>;""" ''1"]iI.,.''it. 'L:-~ [..:Il~:rl"'IlJ'""';.'I f .. ryl~ t"'h.", ~i,!:",Ii'!U: :!","" 1"'1' :;;>'P"pe". ~"'I"':i", ,it,~ '1-.'.'.''l'li';O>i"1I' eb .,a:;tI"!lC'~

'!.l!'~., '~'L~,;iI! ,.,III1i'li.";:I!l, U!'C lL'C ","'cu, !I:.,'lJ.lI'o~1I t!l],,,,,, U'V, j!lUi ~ "l, "'" ~. ,0.,,'" !l:v' ,U,!L·UII~JIII.iI;. '!.l!'_ ~.,'"

.___; ~

ers, Sw;;h ,eV:i.de._Q,c"'C". b()~rt eanitlot :r~~tlI~biy 'be ~etl, to ~i~t ,tQi ~"

Si,l!,~~~silb~e (~if4eli' in FCaI~", ibeca-,~' 'the ,m,gst ~'il.lc!h ~"ij,:delmc:c c-arllJ ~n],Ji\ly-' b lbtat '~~ma!J'Ii knowledg'(:' ,o.f the' wotiJd b It a,.pe:llt.$, b, 1hIi.ll~ed, ~d rarullibL~'",

-I"', :'.Iii ~.~"'c"'!I-lllJ ijiljriln.nrr'.iL'iljo;" c.,.,... , ...... .i~·..:.1\,;;,ri ... -.Oii!' :"'~, ;i:'~iiln[1wj~1i,# :iI!'~n,it'~_i!i'''''~~1 "",iIi-"'--"I~'" 'ii:iIi.i'I~"Jlii' .. ~ ,.~ lIr.O.r.~.~_gIJ I].' 1.-~-IIJ_lJr-"""'i:3aI- iDt~ IIuiI. 1l:r'l!'~(L:~l._;:.""_~ ~:u a-WW"",r-"""'~ '!II.-.. _.l.1[~.IIV..IIIIIU-'7UJI! I"~~'!IJII'I.~ -~'~-IUi!Ll

nHlf :I~~ beyond aiVM'laJbl~ (f~,d~l!itC~.

Second, 'if detr~~der'5, of the rn;e:~h}'51cail: as.'J~pttQ~ ~eve·f.el~ss, 'pur.-..' _e: ~e~r: $;pecUb~~(tfiS;J mcitll 'Illiey m~st, !f-e~~e (bat as, uu;!:, e~stefioe of 3, J1llu3:r;al ord~if' ~n iS1U~itJS~IiJ]e r.[GaI'~i,[ty ,IS !IF!I!€ElYrelll :from. o'b5tt~d, :i'[ii5itm!iC~S, of :ilnn!]j;~-;~~ 'aoodm~~ m ~ib~' ~il!!!t~[l(,e !O:f:in ~~'I 'Md~r' 1~ SIlJn~nsl!bl;e

.. c, -r,r~ .. ~IJ. ,!!).~ ... _L .. , __ ~".~._ ._" .• ~-~ .~~.- .. _= -~~ .,~=.~ .~ .• 1'! ~~~ ~'-lI:"'~'--"~~-~~~"

r~a'ity :ltllt:lst be 31n'8!l~El~' j~~fenble fm[f~ (d!)~ned :~Il!St:aillC.e.!!I, o.f ewl. 'There '~ :1'1,'0' :m.ore re;as(m, '~Q i(h:iJik of ,~t as, de.~(1i\1l f"[-o:m, the good :as, thH[ill: ~~, 'to ~i~t, o.f ti1;@' ,a{~d aiS d~ia'ti;(J~ fmFn evil.

[~

'Tb!iIm~, 'eve~ :if it 'Wef\e ~u!m,ed, for the sa'k,e' [of ~me~t iJhalt: 'ta1.e :fi~!iit:

lMo [Oibj~Qti.o:1li5 :fai~~ 'ri:~ :mt=t:a;p:hyskall ,3SSwltl,:pti.o:u WQuld, sl1ln be ,iIll,d.~[~nsi'" bIle':.; MJCau5C ~i: wouild, acl:BUlIflf(; sul\ely ,('Uf' meral ,evii:~! e'aJllI!ed, '~' hfumau. I~~' liI[~n(i¢.1 a1I1d :11'0:1. :fo:r n3Jl:tmral ~rilJ suih as 'rk@' :K:au:iil:y of :n~ms.mry re .. ~U1l'Oe'~i di~te"'i gel). d~~~'~ 'w:m.~ (u~:oufi\e:noo 'c~ Q:illy ~~IP~l)fi~U.y

1i..~" .;l;f.iIi,"""jbY,.,~.d ~.,.., 'b~'Ii'-I""""Ji'Io ~,I;;o,":"Ji;"'IIj'~, l~ !MI-~"I ~ . Ul~l lli.-~ ,_ 1"_'_I::I::I_6_I_oI] ~"ll~Ij-~.J ~

laSlU/Yi the, ~etaJ-p;h~ic.aJj '~m1p~(!tQ, :f~h:, to ,~-(lOIU~~ f{iJ\r ,JnO~, :m.o:nrsfien 'w~o malie ~t a, pollcy fOf' ~e~lVes, to' do ~, :kn,~~gJly' iiliIld, who de:L'il'ber-" ate:liy cldj'~igl~' ~Ce5, in '~£mse:INes, "ll1u:y' d~~) ",ill :Ilot ibeml~' '~ey :m~n.ake i~ :r'O:F ,tJh~ good, 'bt.I~ 'Fn·t~iSCllffiy '~C~~ it is, evil", 'llu~y ,a;r;@' bmu~~ Oil" :tfldi.o@'~ e~~ t(), UU;!!' ,QP~rati'On w :ma;k~' ~i~j~ life' better '[;:at~e:r than, W(iI\~" ,Mo:ra},


:~,Q.~~~n,~ M, be ~~I ~~ :~.~ 'linit t~el;r e:x~stefi(le .is :~rnmc~cl'I!t tn mow tJJat

.. 1.... !Ii'!_._ .' ]". .:il '''i 10. .. , ,;, ~.~ " '~I n.-lIj~-An ~ . .-. .. ii

!IliI;I,ie, ~Fa'bc Ca!fm:-:n'o' lOme 'uoes, 'evI!. Milm'fliID,~)I!i:_____,:.j, 11!0t '!!l:Ilt:y ~i",~I:~,

'but. aho, false,

'I'f "i'I,.."" ~~~'i"',t-:"", ,..,.. ... el .. f"i'"' .. t-:'?io~ .,-..~ .~'-+-, .. p":'~'~~-~-""'e , .... -'" ~l] 4'C";W~lI!_ '~i~"-"i'"1 ~;i!-.~ nu."'. -' , U~l'!G ~_ll[MI·W,~ .... ~,.;rr.' _Ml_ll~-"'~II_11 u;1. U_I~ ~ I ![;-V._~i.~IJ"1Ii. ~ .. !b'~'ll_ 1 IL:M.I_~_~1 L1111~111I! IU_K. ,.~~

'UG:D. 'Gf'wmy' ,evil. is. p~e~,t. :S~ •• :Ube~ ~ a ve~d, lQrret~t, :~g g;..

' .... ':"!in·"'i"!i:7 ,if" ~ __ -i'];"~''''''' ~~J01I;~~' '''J'i~' ,d' I"", ''''0. 't:i"i"!"'::[' 'noi!'i".I·":.,",", ""'l1'..;ii 1"'''i"Qi'i:lit: • ..."., :r:Ii~""";aJ :~n-, II:I-n~ ,.~lI'rJl ,lJl~ [~_m!lil~ ILIII_ili_ .. JI!Ii;i-~ U_lI.-,;' .u ~ 1~_lILIJ_ I r-~iJI- JUT~ RaIlU "~I,.~~ ... Y'1!!\" a.I_II_II_Liil! ~

pear ~o 'be iuoonsUrelll!t. :1'1" e-wi't. ~.81 p~C:H!~ as, ill ils,. ,and ~.f m)ei3ls, :KC ... ."..,.,..mlIif ...... d rt""'" 'm~'il.·~ng' :it '1- 'If!r~el'l't 'as .~' atre ilihen 'h.fiW tJouild th~

I~c'!i!!',.,."'_'_' '_""'-'.:'.. '!I!Y ,_, , ~ - ". ~J~ ~""'"""'" ,r-= :_",i~~~~"~;~,~, ,~_, '!~b~i .~_c., j, ,L-~-~"-',~, .":~.:._,,"'"' ,~.>," "c,", I~~'''''''.t

,amid the o'b'jeclion. dliat, 'lDe:i'[' polimcaili p~ d,e5ip~d, itO' ,e_g'RRO: plu_ra!lum~ f~~Hl-4. ri.g;bl!" eq~'tajilll'!, ~d, .smJbl!ftiveju.$dc:e~ ~,dl. thmlif~ tbem~, ,3IUtOllo:m-,y win :ma'R' leVil more mtme;fi ~u leu, pr~C!i'ilJt by' r~ov-' in;g 'outcbi, on dt~ (",o:i\Ui,tlDt of eVil]d~, u~s, :~' m~r.· 'this, qumunu. ~n Qn,C' 0'1" two ways.,

The ,net. ,!a1DS'Wer attriburwS! '~e p~en'(le '00" evi], :m!DIl'l:r '~ :a!U!tOD,·' Q:mn~ u'o:n~ chat:~ ,~~e rn'Ol3Iy' ,Q$.mlr., Llb~s, oonnniU :lf~~ w th~ ~P'PO~~(f"Il: 't~ait, ~~jl~m' aiR ,~~' poopki 'wh,Q' <of~ml mU~ 'liIinfn:I}('(lld I(bames

:~I" "',"; .,;',:' ···:If",;,,, ::~,"t"~, Ie ;"1 ,"(~,~~"~, Ic,f .~-: "{:-; n, '~I1-. ~~:' --:~~~ dt~ ,~--=liOO;~l ~ ... ~ [~ a:mDll,g ilUtemaMe c;:o-U~ 0'= 3iC lilo= l' W;tiC)' pe~.~~~, _~ -' ac -- ~~ ~~ Ji =~-"-

:fa,romibl;y '~UlaEd aD,d, w:Iil-oK ,sisntifJ£lm~' th~l 'have 'o:ltden:~.ood'j' and their' hiibiJtuaIJ 81[00:11'8 are evil; S'llOC:h. people' 'lD!us, l~,1lowirlilll'y~ lTI!teniu:Oifla11I¥~ a::nd ~.uelllt1ly act :~Q. ml ~. :I:t, i~, an :im,'IlkaCii(tUI 1J)f: Ihb, an~r' dmt.

r:If_.., .... ''''''iIi'',.~, [L- .... 'm, """'"IV' 'I'V, ...... n'I"'!o, ,i'Joif' ~,'L.rl'" iL~J01I;d·'~ '?io~' ........ ~_. ,~'I!:-"", 'mfo~-'ii .... nee ;nf' ... rii

IUlli~I,~ ,.~I::li!u_~ IlK l g_lj~,,. ,rr.-_U.r'I~ Uil ~tl_9.i lM_iI!!I!·._'LlJ ~W~blJp'i!ll!~~' UJI!-~ ,r~II;.'W!~,,=---=~~ '¥!"!l ~,~_

oo~ld ~ot 'be dUe' to IthC'm~

~ "

'~ait could lead, Mtray' dte ag"en~, Q( '~ese :~.i!lto~omo_y evilJ :~ti'Olit~

~_. ~~. ~iJIlE;lir'~ i"-, .,1..._' ,..;,.( ~:.,..~ ;];,~ 'iI'i"~""f"'11 ""'I" ..... ~,.~\iDi~' ,.,,·,~o·,: ,.,..,'1 ...... , ~iIi~"'t .. P""~"1I'n· '1·'0' VJ:lt:i W' ........... iUllIl,~l l!!i !IIlIJG!1 IUI!~l 'IlUJ'" ,n.IUI.AIi ~"L-'!Uu~""'~.ilI'''''I:I,.. ~.~ !<I'A.!.iiIiJI_l!ilM...lIIiI""'" _, , __ ,

caElng scriO'!JUj, iLI~ju.Mi_fiecl. hann 'm QmetJ. 'Dey' may' be :g]iUf-de:t~., ilO1.ilur,~fiS'I' dii'Claito:m., '~Iljmoce~ dJ:j,nes 'w'h,Q doom, dlclir ~climl to Slan!3iOOJ] gdJ d.~~~,~ :m~, slmril~ 'wi~'l!;,w ~ciDl.ems.., n~ mpe' :i)t. a pO~iq ir'Or

i""I:..,~~-::;'I"_""'-, ~l;-ll5!i~il~li,~ iL'i'i~'I·~"" .... ~~II """""dl r~, cheese i"""" :"'''''''': '?io"i1i! 'I·'''·~ Th'I~:"" IUJ!]. . ~i'l!"-lIUt:!i 'L-lO ~,U"'''''' MI,'!UI-D','!Ui~"'" ""dl. ..... "'.11 WI'''. I"-!I ",u" .. -.,. I"", _!I. '!.:.!',"~ ,J!!.;; .e_.1!;".

~'~ol,ogicall, W_(~, ,of m:~ p6~iqr may ~. \iO!]~fi!t lm~,~ ',wjtm~· in,,,, dignatjDn~ ItBlrst .[or power~, ,sel(~Ua!t1hiJl;S:' :pJlGjected, Q"lu;~iJ[\d~, ,~ic~ de~m!.u:~~ :and, ~ :fultb, .~~nd mc~ :fo.~s, 'w- ~.~~~:Vi ~ ~ U'id or i~D'ed ,~njWl!m(:e~ leen~' :r:e'~t !P'!rm;naiI s!bo:noomllt___gs" nfeinTI8 bRuaJ)iHiti:on, Of e_]Un::m~ 8e'I.ifg'h;n~

M~~ m1;)fi_Q~ h.~~r, ~ 5U~~' mR:~ pM'h3i~1~' mrn:t' th.m :m.o:raJ, gnt5, becai~ HKJoDSIten: ~O:t Ckg'~y :m,~ :~ ,;1$ d.~a:F 'viisiQilJ" :gr-c~t ~~, at (;b~~£r, Md, n.updona1I1)1" sttl'O.IlS Siellse of :pur,poK ai, do· sa1n~ 'i:~1!Ijt. m.'Ut. .' :ilIide' Ft-om O't!hen ~e:iiF 'ttue :M'lUt-e, sincce' :vub!Jk; O,iQilQ1iI, :~ :Fft-'

~'i""'lil\l'~''''~Ml ~~ '~"·· ... ~or ''''I!:o~ I~ 'D,,:,,~~Q" i"I] m "I"" '1""""11 m''fIo~''~\iDir~ 'i;~,,,,,~~,,!,",I!!iI;>" 'I· !II' lI.S~iI:IIlIlr 1Il]I~,~I'U1 ~ IllloliJ!~" lD!Ii:r [~~_. '~"_Il_~ Mil __ rV" AI! , __ !u1I_Ml_~ '!II un.", .. ~ILV,lj'~~1 ,_1i:J

'¥elY _c~u[I·t, ~, few :peo:,le' lcan 'be mp:po~ '. ~o.e mQ-j]~ ,..._d


·cnfllllii~~e m. the ~. ~fte. Th~ :~t WOlltild. '~, ~H1ipJ;t.mltlle '00 a~bl!ljte· tJle' p~enoQe of ,e'ril t'O, 1llh~se :f.ew~ ~' :nulrall. rm.o:~sten...

MO'I:1la' poi9fbj~~t¥. :~ 'tlliat ~o:p:lil)· do ~ri~, iaiJiIto:fi£nnomly ~al!iH; 'they .temartieaJliy· suhor.d!inaik :mom to Q'i:her oon1!lB~tme!nj~" These' omer oomrmib~n't.5 .. ~' 'k' t~ll' ~rmrW!, :pOllid~" f1d1gioU!i!, or ~$rJ..~ti'(; pm;" ~otl. Whe~ '.c~r (O'~~tm.eIllLt~ r-eqw$-C' di;eg, w, do, ~Jl' tlhq bowing'~y Dd, ,deU~~' d~, ~t. Tht:ifJu&tificatiolli, is ~t. :1li¥iI__fi_J :~~~I to, melf

............ 'm· ·!I"'--O·; ..... ,i." ''''''''''"1<''''''' !I"' ... in.n-.... ...... ' .;~ .. ~-, ~ .. '""'.I·,·A~"..-D', _,';-'I "iF'i!.'P'V ;0];"'''' ... ,,;111" .......... _.,

~~~__;_:~~~~~_~l ,~ ~_~,~, ~~,r- ~c~ l~,~~, [U__LliUl~ l@e~~'tI~~ [~,~~r. JL H"7.'J' ,~L" ~H~~

'~~~ aDd. :~ti~!, ~ 'th~~l~ ~ ~c· ~~!!!~en,'ts, i(tf 'dle:iir' ~ Of are' antbeltei wh,o, bave ~ cruel 'iil], their indillcfCn,u' ~, bUlnan'IJty" In one' ~'i' th@f',air,e: :liu :m~rail :m~M~~t5, '~ta!~ '"fl. dI)! ~~ Dtcm,Qm.~;'ilSl~ 'but in, MotlJieF waf:! riley ,ate '.wn~jnk~' ~a;lUIe Hl(lraiJ :~~!ilk:n!1 d()J; Ie'YiJ '00-

:"","'iiiiliiii!'; :~I:t~· iiii: ,_fill ~'I[- em<ilii, ,.;I;-~, ~p:'i\;a ,d!,·In. '!I;'iij: ,~"i"' ;DiI'jI."_'_ "!"'''t'l.. ... .,., jI".,.._ ...... ~, ·Thl·l~; 'iP1i"

~.~ I I [1_l1:li !IW'I!'~_IJ_!l' 'n-,ILt. 1. -Moii:I U_:Ii _.. r:..-=-- __ l~ ~IIO.F- ~ ,ILUIJ. ~~IJ"~~IU ~~;I~iII ~,~~-JI~_!l • _ ~ ,

'may' 'be' m0:!:le 'or' l,elS! wlckedj, dcper:ulblg on what 'WI'itll,e5, tbe~' ba~' !iu. !3ddll.." 'gg:,n '~ tbeiJr 'ri'Ce'S!., how '~_¢.'h:' 'vir...nu¢.5. :al~d, 'vio~ ~' 'bal~ilijed~ ,atnd on how :Qli"p.en ,eViJ], they ,~b~~I~y 'e~llSe.,

Th.e fir:si:: lii ... ~~]1 . .• '.,' 'I" ,",,'Ii... n 'i' [",'Ii..!I!' ,"'..... . ~_,'I:~_·. ··Ii· ' ,0'1 :~.. ...iIi .... • .. ~ ~;~ ~.' '-~,;~ ~ ~~,~ ~ :aD~~~ !Jl!!te~j' ~8 Q!lia!~. ~~e ,P:I,'~'!I!~I,CC' 0:1. C1:VI:, ~5 UJM.~ ~:O

[Sw.d'll! pmpl~',. '\that :must be d!on~' ttl, :malk~' ~l l\e~, p~.mt ~~, to' ~t~p'

,~;L.a,om ~'n:1; ,1I:'.!.ib ... ,_:ill·'I'Ii""'iIiiIDQi' ~-.n-1":il 't,'O'1i: :"'iI""'I!r·;r;.If , ... ,"'1ilIJ1;'ifil·~~~i.i""'~iE, ~"I".i 'iE~joi'"fo'nNi;'Ii'Di' ~~~ ~~L!\J!. .. ~ ~K~lllU __ 1~._tutl_1i~~ II_III_LV:" m !I.'~ v.UIHI~1J "'V,Ii_LilI_ [\I~IJ'UlU-'Ul-.II~.::I" DuJ.\i '1:II~,lrlli-IJ,~

'tD,em CCU1U@(; 'be a DlJa!tll§' of Ctodlin,g ~,e~r ,aJl~Il'ti1)n, ~~, ;a Dlli,,~e th~ '~a~ :~! :foOf ,th~, eviJldoen do, [JAlt d~~nli, liIa:t tbey have made ,a :misllal«:'" 11lq Imow' ,an th~, ;m~Jt. :r~t.s~, '~~ ItfiQW ,aoout '~e !m(Jjut~m;CTI,'~ 'Qf 'H1OraitiJW" and, [th~ 'have ded~, lha1t, mm~' :~['IUIiiaLI", ptilJirtiE'aJJ,. :~~igjhJfU5~ 0'1' H-Iti!li!th;; (lolil:siid~tinn J~~II~ mf;m! lilli, ,~tegati~ly vlQlatill'--8' t~e re-

'q""~""'".' .!n'f"_..,.'I\;o; ,nf' "m""--,; <'I~fiV_, ........ ·'_·1 iI''''"V !i\~ "'l~.""" '. ~m "'1~':L."",..". [~'Ik, 'i"'li.i'.: -'''-, .. """'. , .~,~ iIi..j1 ~"~.' .~. '4i'~'. I~ ;-.', ";:'''', ' ,~.,:, ~.'~' _, :~~ "'~"",,""~!Io'lI 'V., , __ ,'V •• I,g "'''''1' ,.,iv """";1 !IIU' IU;I ... " '"U_G''' UI_.r :!<I !I""" U !lU. nD"~, uO 1m ~!i ,ROL,

rg.t:ii",g to ;ailmr Ih.eiir OO'mdE~ beeause ~,~' h3i~' ~n, :(;Mi~~d!, by the ,~11ial, pil'l!tlica'll, r.eligioN" or a~5tDcti~ tt:--uon!!i, they c_ '(;I~' thmi: 'theiir ,eV:ii. ~~ndl!lct :ig.~ti6ed" GiVen ~ 6bemls an! ,c();mmi;t~ [to mWn;g' ,~~ le~ iP~C'41t ,and that. 'the p11ew!1e~c:e of ,e.ViiIJ :~ (blC W :3iN.t'O:m:Olno.ul, ,ia,& '~Of;ij" ,~~be~ mi;ijt, 'be iPrepat.-ed, to, ,CQe1\tle :a\!lwno~o~ ,e:v:i~dben ,iiQ ~, m

~ "1.'1-. ,i, "1 '.

lCU~~ i~ll' 'eYill__ aotl.o:n:I!!.

'[hilS ellr.taiihl1i@f.iIt., h~, :~ :fi01. 'pfi~' ~t ]~k~ looulld, ~~ept get. ~n :R'.~Q :fidtlliWl itoO, theb" po1~liilcal :p~, baMc: 'wb.l.e!l!., 3na, [t~o :m£J'it'a5iing a'lu.'O.FtOim:J'. For:if ,th~ ,,~~nt;~ (ji[ ,~~ ~f¢ d~~' ttIQ' ~y,tgn~mQg ~dQiJji1,.

,.Ii-. ~ ~~ ~ ~J;'~ ~ ~ ..... ~..:il 'i!....;. ......... ..:i - ii - - n.~Jl .. '1' ihu ''''~l· ",'Ii". .• ",'ll.~ ~

'~~~n! 'eYiI__'__ I(lO'YltU. ~' lI!~e ,I,eg, :r.~~, .... ,eHill iilllllil.y 1L".t· ruifta]~l!ng· 'Uie l\QtJo.IHli, 'uiliitt

ca!UK ;i!t;, &a~ iii is!, by ~ypo.tltmi!i" WlllOH,o:molD ac~o:ms di.a~ (ti)i; $Q, '01(iF·' 'laiilift__g' ~J requiJ-es. ,eU'~llti.i!l~~g :pli'tIWiMni, :Hecdo:m~, ,t:"qu]il¥'!, rilblts'J! a~d

d.·'~,'i.,hTii···~Ii"~:n'!'<l' ;·I·· ..... i~A_ ~ .... "", '~~~.i"~' ~'-r-~'t· 'In' .. ,'I e. "":", ,"'. ""'''''''"1''''1'''''' "". '. ""'kLI' ~~.:i(11 :;O;' ... iF~,.,.i;'Iil·S, ,~;r; ... "_

. _~[~~WJ~ .J~!I.Ir'!i .. ,-L.!I !IlJI]~ Y'4ilIIL'WRi...1i:Ii 11._1l_L;:di I g_~ 1R .. ~l~._lI~,L:I!.I.u.u.n,,. ~'",~IJ ~UIU.IJIJ_ ,r=---~IJ

'bJ.e., Th~ cUl't.aiilm~fiilt of .E.K hasi1;; wt1l~5, 'wmJld, :~ M' be ()Qn~~bLe'J given 'illait the :aiutonOJ!JfJOU£ :M:JtioIlS, t'O 'wbkb. ~,e .P:rewJlCDE-e' ,0{' evil Is ~up'

'p.g: .,.s.ed to [L.,,":~~jI~ :'r'iUjlC!~' ;00:1\".1"':, 'Ilf~, .UEp,:po" -~~, ~~I 'Ilf~' i'J"!!;jlii";'O_j!i"'~~iE, 'ifi.oi'iol , ..... ' ' ....... ","",;O;~.'.iO'Noj' . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l~: ~!I"!'!r.' ~.!~", ~ ~ ~ . . .. ,~ I"", ~ ilJ.; ... ~"L'!Ii..(I.'U'·!L'II" 1il!U ~ !l.U ~!IoI'!.O!'!LoIiI~IL,

, . ,_: '~

fM 1JU iP~iiMl~~.


.;Il;. ~.' .' "_~:' '.'). I ,~'~, :.' ','" .. ~ :. " .', . ,~:~.,:,,~:il..,. ;",' " .'. ,'. !itL .: ·,,;,. ' .. ,<11.' ;'. ,e",

rIL!;IC:O.1J U~1lI itO Ule seeona aDS\\"er d.~1J ~ maw Il'Yei!' Ute preYalf:ll'l{)e

""~' ,"'i ,"., ,.;I, . . ·,·"i· 'i' ,~ , C,··,·- i'i,~'''''' ,- -·-_~~i· ';.-, "':h'i.,--r--;-1"b ,~.t..--. ,-·- .i\n.(j-lilj

O~, eVll....l! ,UI: u;ue H'W~~f ~ ,nQnar~~ll.QmnUS, u~on~ . .l'U~iL'Q'QgilU, UI~ ;(lOUI!V " '. ' ,

'tQI dl-e' f~~dGm component ,of ,3itlJt\Ono:l!'N,~'~ 'r1t~, ac~all:J ~ :tl01UliU~O:Il,o.., moUS; 'be~~' thq' viO:I~t:e :~U,Jiu~e;!]l!t ,~o:m~:D,enlt. The [tho'Ug'hil, ~br~lld 'this :iWRe:r," is dma,t 'the 'prege:lil{!e ,O'f e¥cil bime:tv 're!l:ul~ from :~'On8 that

, . ,.1 _. ----r •• --r •• L . __ , _I.- ..•.• l_l~'W'I"7jl~··~J~·-=·~=··=·-'-··~··~~~·~~··~·'

th~' :.iIlI~ :peH:bJlI;\ by' ,eh~~g O:Il~ ~(Jng ~, ait'~aJtiiY~8' iIh:at

'I...; ':'~":" ':' ,1 ~', ~':.' .~..1::"; '~i"i','" b I it' ~b', : .. '" I iii .... , ~,:"~ i'"' I '~7"ii I'~""'!I" it"i"', I , md.· :(1. U:ai~ ,nO' "' .'. '. m J!orio~ all LiI!le~n~ _ .0" " , Ie ~H_ '~JialI~ '1.0 !I;'I'\!M_"", OL ''''"'''' il!I~~e~

8~d, '~e 81gn16c~ce of the aittePl!aU~$, 'dle, :iFr,",' (;'hOO'~. TIIt-q dUI ,~I~

'b' .II~I·: [t:i!-PV~~, 'n~~~ ~ ''''C'''r-l'iit' ~:·h. ':Pv .~~ ,""'~ '''''~~" 'jM..PV see ~'L..""'~r." :g~tiinn;al ~ilnfl~r'

U!Ii; LII_., U.u ,1=1;v.~ .... ,' -nl_~,b,"'!l.l Ii. =s UI'!i;I.! ...... 1 ~Yll_I_'I [llll(-ll ~. l"_[.t~~_, ~H-v.JI::_._~ ~~~I'I!r.-~

.,""m· ... ' """~;L""' ... , .;Il.:.., d,pc+i;" • .", "", .... ..;1 ,~i'IL·_i,.., m' 'I"!spe'" - . _""'jpe;;;;i.tj1liiil'., .. _ ,-'1\00, .... , ,ii ..... '''' 1-~n iii n~

~_I_I~~ ~-~;L~1.IJ, [u-~~ ".s ~1~""'.:.J!~lI,f. 11EI.o.I,I~1 U_lIcE-ioLi. II. _ -. '_. "IJ":"~ ·.U~1.l1.Ia! ,~,I~ UUI~ I!.~ Do .1IkI_lI_lIU. 0;1i.

II t.

€op!l~ 'fa~lU'rlC:.

'Db, ,an~~\ of arU~j; :~ a (JoJ:lltempl~ aDd, a:~fiiiillil!t~, ~mio:n, ,of th,~,

~''f~;' ~.~., ,dl',:·t-I"" ~il:-' ,iii' :":: ,:,":'.', :d~l.: .. ,., ,]. 'il,:"" ',:"".,'i'.,. '1!).-'i"',:,lL,;" , ,; ·,'1 'k,'iI~,

iJVbUuC l'C!L'liJfm, ",ua~, no one .000S eVl, ,l!;n~Blry" ,Ii; ~lI!J.'Fh~ are cme~ ~,liI""

se;e dl~selves, ~ ju.M; they ,~ d~rlflw.Jc bUiI, kli~ m~m~l~ [to ~

... ' ... ' .s. i1i~..:I, ,t'''',· '. ... '.' .. =..:1 'b' .• ' 't, •... .. ' .. ,""" '~'1...·m ., , .. ~.'I'~:n '~i'i-.i!1i f: ,'[[" m~'

Pn,u'(:Jp.lEU" 'liilii!'!'V are !au~'V . l!I"" ~" seems w ~!!c_!_!_; ,M ~:_ ~ ~!!e_l_!:;~ _~~I ' ~ ,,:,,~~,

~ . ~". ~ .l m

th~ ~ ,pU'~iu~~o(f!d 'bu,~ ~p~~ itu lthem~I,~ M, obj@~tl~ ,ailx.nil!l; ~,~jr

*"",'''' ~.Ai .'.iI: 'Ttl: ~'Ii. f:\ It raJ re If t· r.d idi-

'wre'~II~, '",'C@_~; ,[~-_;2ey are.-~, '~i;elIeI~ej' nai H\Q_ .. ~_ :~m;!!L :.c~rs: I~YI~: :mo_ .. ~_ :_~,_,

Q~. ~ ,t:an '00 ~~ wl1!!lit 'm~' iQ~p~ '00 ~i!ll :.,([1, 'wbaJr, "'eJ' wotd~ is@~. if

",'L.." • .;111',..:1 ., .' •. ..:1 ... 1.." ",. ''Tr';'h.'" '" ",", led '£Ii' ~'L.. .i\. ~ _i ..

Ul-m[' '~'C~ 'ulu ]tot CI.O'UU, 'uli.elif W:5I;Qfi .. , 'Jlllll~!!' 115, 'W\LlIlit: ~w ~3!II!H''''tt ~Ji;;;~g!l:

(]:004) to' :S,ped, :~iooult the ~~ty, of' ev.iJ" Thm-e js ll'Q'thr~ng' :ttemi£ aoo~1 [m~ ~Ul~n~ ,of m'OSt eviil :iaClli;Ons': dtpv do nflt :UG'lWt· the maKiim o£ 'M'ilto:n:~s:

. _. ~ . . .• __ - .. .. _ .. ,_ " __ .~ , __ ~,I -_.- .. ,",I _-.=. ,,~·.l ,-_. ------. ~~ ~ ~ •• --"~-~ -"


:e"'i""ijfil": 'E"~""~I iIf;",:, ~:b~'lfI; '-m··.· ,~' ~:'fi''''''-:'I. Y··· b4'~' b.' ~"':",;:o;I:I"'" ,_ii:;f;.""l"~, ~,.:;:~ ''""ryr' afi.,.fI i'l-~j"';""I~";'>;' ~'IlII)!LAIJ~~ liElYlIJJJ,,1 L~ li __ fIUI~ , __ .~ .. ' ~'IUI!L..I.CJ_1'l l I, _ ~~. _ .'!R_I!lioQ __ It L"~I::I~._:JI!~:~ "'~~ l.J~ m~~ l!L..~~~_)

'''I1,.~, 31'-';:> 'moT~~1v'1l~~""'v.nt_ WlI·--l· =.!J~ ~_~I(Y.J" ~11;;rt~_~~~ ~~

Ac-oO',vdiQg t~, iili:is; atn~f! h'~m.an :rn~tirves, ;~' ~~d" gil, :IliUlmaiD, begin~ ,arl~ c{)ml?l~x~ 'Tbcry are MO"~, by both good a/l1d ~\f.lt, Virtue;~, c~i~t atu:l 'CQ:Dillh;:t wllm ~~:s., 'The i~~er lire iI!J£ '!i.e ~~hel~irOl ~~it¥ of: 'hl1;l!fQm:J,

''''''~''miIJi'''' '"I"" ""I GOt .... I~'aQ"I ... , ~'i'1'1 ~h.;'I' ... ; ... ~'111I'::,1I" ... , ...... iI' ......... ;ru·' ..,.lihll'~ Qin>"".:Ii. 'ell·~'. 'b""litI'l""'"11. "'1[1.:1 !.!i!'!i:,;1'''''i1;l!0J! ,..,. ..... ' iiJllUlu~l~ lu,~ n", ,,,,",U, ""'" _1J_'iJl_IJ,Ui!b!i!!'<!!~' '!or[, -''!O..U'I~' !!I!.~~u." _ ., "]~' "_ ..... lIi'Ii .... \.ili~, ""', l~_'

t: =:b. "~I~1 '1,,]1 - - 'I. ~ .~ .-1 .. lib,

,so :1i:Ullui, (lin fitii£ MU~, m~Ui" ,~'~ 'i.ltt~n,q~ pi!t:¥', .lYnilll"2i~, Hi[tu 50 '0:0,,0.]]; 'uiliC

Aiit'h"i"1i" ''':"I~;:O· :~I'!":"" '"'ii...,. iI' ..... l~tii;:OPjl', "'i"f 'iI;~'o;;. ,'Q' .... ~~~~, ,i!'>i""m. ~·e"'· "";~Ii!'>;";~tl[""e' i'". ~'h~. "'", :,·;I~'Ii'i~·,

U~_~~~ ~IUA,;,.~l ~"Ir. UTI~ ~=r.{ll_~ll'~ ~ ~.Il~~ ~~'.J~VL"~_~~I~J Q!.!I~ __ ~. ~.~ !\.rJ~-[]--.t!.~1 _"~.J 1~ __ X.l' ~.j[IPi_'I

"T":I.,~ "~"·'~"r""',·."!'i": ...... .: .. ,i:',' """""',1"1 ~i""'!o ,iI'."'~'''''''1 ~·""',·:.··.Ii"'ii'I""'" """',".,"'~'~';ro.JI, ,.','I··.) .,.,....···w·,,""" '''''".',i!'>','IJ'C,', , ,,"" .... 1i ~,":"'·, .. II il'o-ic,I·'m.·.',·';:;' J.. ~II..... ~u ,,,,",~!<I; 'V,l ",",',,", _, G.I.... o::!"",",l!~ r~'Vf'" ,,,,",, '"'~~~ , __ , ~. _ ,,,,", '!I"n::o..I'~ o.o,.,\JI, H,~ ~,_ _....

C)r(:U!m8~(je-;;;! 'ut'j)Jli.Q:U$ blj, o i)ib,e n;; :peQple' i~l~' JtU)~t 'of '~5, They' ,a:r~' the ageo,'ts o:f eVcil ,atod of ~b,e lood~ :a.!I'u:i, ~b,e.~' a.ct one ''lnra~' '!);f Mot~e:r~ depend-, !I~g on. 'meir ImpEnut knowlcdg~, mrlr2t~d, IliIGtl.ves, 'unclear 3!:Irms,., ad OFru

rIj:I,.., ... ." 'n'r'-"""~iI;"i"!iI', , ....... ,"'i' ... i~d' ,ofio- [iI: ... '"'i'....,.1 I' '~. Iilc ...... 'b,'!I",-;"":" . .ro;i"i;:o,'I. i;Vi;~I!,t:""f~i1i :*"--ilin;--~ 'C'1~111 '!lI;I, .... ,It''' ,,"EiJo.<IoUIIO ""o::! l!W.oIIII~l, !I."",, ","",.1. !l1;1,~,.j.~ ~1 ll;I,,,"" , __ Io>li.v~ I'k~ 'r r~:.IiIJ. l,,",iiI!I~1 !!bU. )L_U],iid!.I~, :aliiIJUi

Ol!lh~F :lUUES, 'to W:hrioc'h 'thq ar~' ;SllJt.j;eot"

Th~~' ~iI~)~ diu It];ot pU~t!I~ ~\11 ,~ a oofisc.l,om alnil. d£iIU;~{iJa~' 'pDrni:q,,, Th~r ,o~lUii'1l1y do ;ff'~]~ b'iilt lb~,. ,ndstaik!(:~ the :m~taI ,stalldi~,g of 'llIe~r ,ae""" ItW:mS·, '1\1] ,!II! :Sell~ ~bif"V llil'dow"w~at ,cV;i~ ~s' b~'{;'F'-~' ttm~:-'M '-I ::::-;:;-;-;,~:L~ ~ ,Rt ;;"'111 ._~, ~=_ .. "-iI"~l _.IL. ~ ~--- .. , I. _ .. _~ .. I_,,!(;. I ,~DglIl;1ll~ I, ilFiI!

odters and fH',~' be brougbt to reWlgMiJz:t= ,~t even :10, tb~~t~:5. M4i)~~~, 'lh~ ch~' iJh£IIF ,~ru iaatiO:I1!$" $iInce 'they pe-.d:o:nm: them 'U!I't:OQef~d, :~n, eir~U'm8t3!U{)es 'ner.e tbey,(O'u;ld 30t ~tJhe~" BUlt; '~ey do not :see' t!herr a.o1i.()~, M evU 'boeCaiU8e oo.jJ],e.b1l:g' ~iif~ltnlde~, betwecn i[h!t~r p[l,~rdJl :krujwl~ ~d,p ,Qf ~l p;d] idle r-oc-.iti,QIn, '$at we~t a(~QiJl~ :fan u~d!e:f' ~t., TIle:i:r'~ CNel;ty lis seen by them] as: hea1!thy ;ambiu!J:ll, :sie~Ii'S'h'I'l;ess as, d,o&llI' 'w~a;l; is, :o,«t;~ 'io 'wtiin ~n th~' oompEiliif1!lan of jik~ :ht~tlioo, ~ w$~f--:meriltred ,con ..

"" ~. ":!rw.;.~~ ". f ~.. [ThJ I n,

'~P~i e~~' as JlU;~ :~pa!tID~~, OJ" :,;gaitt{;L&_~ as, OOImLSlsteillq" . ' .. l,ey !t.U!JW'

'(ball; e:n.nrlJly, ~]tle5hlit~ bal~d~, ~1li\r'Y!~ ailtdJ w~wti:cism H@' ,eW~,., IifUJ1;.It1i@f d-o., Jl<Jt.ltill)W that their' a~tl()ns e'Irre:Iill,piillJ' Ilhese' 1e.'Yili1~, ,~d die!,,' d!o :1:1;01 '~~(!tW

'I"t 'if.~~"".,."""", ~~,~Io.. 1..:i\i>;,nn,:"~"'iIi-:'.,.,,,,, ,~iI~'::~""""'''''If\'.:~iji" _ '1i-- .... ,,,~~I~i"':'i"i"Di'.· :.:;c~ri:~ ..... ·"f'~', ,~;o;('C,.,

,J ~"'_<lII~ '!Io;iIlI ~,1 U"-W ,''I!',III!u.uu~, ~JiIi."U'''''''''''IIU'!LJ!.JJ~!!, 11h !l!lJLllJliI!Lol~~,~ ""xtr-' _"""U"'-=0;1'", ,I~n

'i':::1i!lt'l:!", ',,~ ;i"iDinl"I,:. " .. ,.,. .. n. ',',;,~"'m, : '" _ ""'. 'I"F, "'I, ,..:I~ ... n., ,.,.oDI .......... _ " " ....".:'f.' ~'i'1'I~""·.~""'·"··'r:I""',. ',: '''''.':, r' :"' .. ""noi"'.'. ";"I."".'"',prl',",,, ........ ~ .. ., ~)<', ~f" """'''''~'~''''"!'! Y ~!!I-~~,~ """'~ ~ Y.~r -..!.!~ ",-",.I !!~!IiI!!I;.,.~ ~"'-"'" ~":.r '!.cl!'I'! c;'!l~,r"'-~ i!~ ~"',;!' ,1:"'''''",""~",,"~iIl~

them :from seeing ~be true natlwu, o:f' m~~r ,a-cti:Oj~:S.

S.uClh. :peQ;p~e ar~' ~I'k~' dt~ wh<l' ,s~ooFdJi:Q~re nliO~" :~Ql Q.er oo~side~ tilOlit~ but tb,ey' aft ;.dw ~~~i;k:e' ~beiID beeause du:y -do ~ot do. ,so a!U:~Oll;o..

'''''''''':'''''''i~:_ cThI ',~;if'o \'-"fL~ . .r- ..... ~~;I ~"'.ji\~.'ii";r:c; .......... ""l'i"i1~ 'I~;~o;-:~ ii"UO'--t" ........ ~:lv ~ii-I ud ... , .. ~: ~; ...... "" ~V~""p. 1 j_~ H~llbLi!'! Urv. ~ ~.~_ 1 MlM ~Vl • .i.I~,.~I::I}~,i!'~ _Nil· l~£I}'!UI·I!~ lr~I;JIL\2I11.6!IL. '~. ~!I·~IL 1 n,ll~i'" 1 ... I~l~ ~

:air-e doiIng'~, bUit flh.ese age'o:b d!.o nOot because, dJey' have .made a. :m~stake ~f:i, ~nd.!eDtalil,d~ng 'Of. ~u.ai1i.' dlieiif' own, c:o:ndti.~i" 'f,iJ];ey _ri,!I$, C~~' ,eVi~ ''''o.matUtt>Olu):'''''O'us1,~' 'L.~ ... at·:·~ 'lhM.!' ha~ w;-r.'I""f.)~...:I lib~' j"""'~i)'jf;l;'Jj""ii~[i', :,",Anlii'¥"ii"'liI""fJi'

~~ - ---~ _. ~. ~ -- - ~...cI! - _. --l' ~"""'-~~ --~,l _~_j~!I;,O ~ -~~~ ~=~~ 1.l~!O~~~,]I!~ ~ 'V'V ,~'jj",~!,

~~'~~ll'iIj""'1'A~~: ,1i'!'1'~~, 'f1i;p""IUii'I~ ""'""'.' 'l"'I1 .• '\,..~;o;, '",,",'gj.'!l!' 'b;:o;~~"'it;, ... !,~~, ,EO!".· 11 'mi',,",+,,~"i~'it'I."'~~i"'.'~ ulJ, 11ll.!~~~,1J ... u.-11.~.~:l .• ~".IJ.L~ lli-'"""U,Ii"l ~ ~!U ,. W.I~1l ·"'a, ,_dlIJ.IJ1l!ui:Illl'l taiI,l~l ,rrl, ~,uLOm. ')''-1 o.~U],

~ifS ~I]j'~y tp~dJi~~y" T,h,ce' f(J~e:r ,ar~' wici1i.ed~ the :la~tef aFe _e:r~iIy' :PJ:iOille Ito ;a0t 'wic~m:l~' ~.~ M!n];~' 'r.~rollm®UdJj;C(tS·" 'f.b~, ;~'OOl]Jd I~oornil, ,anNEr, l[b~itt, ~tJtriibl!lOOS, 'm,e :p:~~nm' ,of I~~ 'it]! we [i1U)Ill!~lLd.o:n)omOU$, Wickedn~l of iIh~ ma:n~' ,:'Ii~nils ''liliho h~'if.;ittcJill~' n:r,.,.f:n.rm '!"'vi;1 .o:I; ... .Ii' ............. ,i!'>l~h~,I'O"~ ~!k~' ,....,.~iI!-

~~.~~ ~.~~~~ . ...J~. ~;':""I"_~ _ •• ~~ ~ =~jJ.=r_.~ __ ~{ IrC~ ~'i=.~~ = "ill" • = 1B·1M'-~~~o;;!IJ! ~1!;.~~~.:!J ~ll·~ i-' ~._:.r

ltate ~he ~atDre uf dtte:ir' aotiOIll'5 L'Iliii'"V DOW ~;-;~ ~-;.~r.:a!l ",,"Iliiii[ !!ir","1 i~;--' lr'"'1

__ , ." ._, .. ,.1 ..... "." -,I.- .... liI!,~~I,~, W,_,.v.I,[t5" U.


.JI.. d b ,. ~.'L. 'I~_~' 'Ii...~ ~'ii... '" i~_ "';, ;ilL.

'1lI1"', U ~ot . ~a '~uat N,t.· ':' .. " .'il: ito KU' !Om 'Ulie n::Iil'1ilt',!U_: aeaens iuiPv

" - ~.l' - '-' . - .. ,,,,, ., ... , ". ' .. " . ..., , ". . r-'_ ... ." ""'---.,-,

'pm.f(i.H:ln"

,OJ

To, gp~' 'fhQ, ~~():1i1J ohtDnrautonomom, ''Rk'~~ftI :mu. e U'i~ oonm~tl;,

(lO:Mid~F :so-m~ faRiiiliair :m:mLt ,0;f 'n!J:llau.W,ftrnnous wi~ke.eg, T-ake, ,a. p:ilf'~c)u'~' ti~d, of dogl!il!l!tUm, :i~ ~p'~ 'w:bo are dopnarti'C :in. Ibis WiI¥' Iha~' a ,.on,1 C'OHlfmllme'-Jlt '00 montil. :,rine~,pl~ :and, ,act 8OCoOfdiftg .' 'lJJi~m:, but, iiieir prln,cip1es, art' mb:ta;k~~," :If ~~' ~~ m~ft :i.nde~n~lt~~d :and. lnqwr.tQI, tbey mi:g;l'n d~~F ~t. dl,(id' pfin¢~pl~s, are fau!l,,~ 'I!mt., as, a

~ -- __ .. -- . -:c' iiI::.. ...• ' ,~''''., ....... ~, .. . . ..... -'Ii' d' ' ... ·iI· . . ·..:il [.;iI..~ .... I '·I~..i '·!I::~'iii £~~~iliv m.~~· h H'ilal!l~r (b, :IC"C~, Ui~ lidiW n.ut.., . ~L.U UP;: req,t:lilr.~ [cn!!l"~ ~1iY""l1'" ,i;JQC,",",

d_opmaWsl![ :may cau.x great cviIJ Jf 'ftey [o~e to 'beii~ '.It :S01'At gnr.wp.t

.~ c ,e--.-i)f'-:-·<:d' ~ ~:,,:,--~, t~. '1'· ['" . I . '.' •.. , .. .'11 ... ,.;,. ... , '[" 'f:'i""L., ... )', "f: ..... ~IL·~",,' .',' i" 1 : . '[Ii'. II" [;,:~ __ :

OF ,l!l1ulVl:· .. . !liWti ,'fl gross ,i':Ulltail.d:::m 0: , I~Jr ml':li~o ,pnO'C-cFLes., ~ 0= u~ey

i,' ~. I· n . _ i""i;,,' _ eh ."; ,;,~. vi " 'il ... "t~ --, ~-.- --'~7"1 ':t.::-:, of'-:-'c~w' ,lITdfense.s, ':ilrnu:I1 de-,

iIDa~ ,W"pose, [UiLCiIl., I,,"Uat. Yi~e .W~rs:Me ,1W!~ty ~~ 8'~!iJ,-~~~~~~~- ~ ,~_. _' __

~~ [dt~ ~ri1(f~ ~ 'tli~.K' dDgilillatol:J, lmowingly [C3.UC du::ml, ~' ,..: ........ ~..- ... ' ,~~;l·, ... ~l ... d .... ,:e that th~ ~ Cli'dBWP' 1mniiI ibn't '~iIl!V' 'ibeJi~' 5.iDii'

l!l.l~.!IftI ~~~T ~~-~.~~~ .... : _ _1 ~~_~j ___}_-'~Jl'" '~_.,:"Ol -·~-~~~~~a ,-,~-'''''f. .>,~_:: '~"_~I :...:-I_il ·:~II "II;

¢'er-.ely god ~. :~'Y" 'that. it b; ljliUlJlil~ :M pun i sh'me nit" (:-nl':RC'.~ R'b!., d~r~n~,. [();F: 'th£ impcWucm, o:f d~pJirFt.~,

,An. oh;n 'r(JlI~nd reason w:l1Iy' ,~~tim 'cQ:~' :00 'h~ld '.e~~ :m~i!i~ 'nfiii)~'~'~'" '.I.I":" .... ~!Ii~··'·,'·;l'I'!'i' ~ ... , "ii'L."'!Ii' i"""'oPV b·~' I'--~,~n 1-.-.~~ln,,'hili' up: [ ~..i'C>[ hol~ d'toio:n.t.

F .... '-' ... ~~~J~ U_.ll1b-II~~~,g _lJ lUI ~::I_1IiII1I! ILl~I_J . __ lIiIIi~~ l~~ u_,u~~_~ _ . ~ _- __ '-= __ ~~~

= ~ .... .

'the &amcC' liS, 'true lot ~~f' LiQ dteir oo~~"~t :~d :~h, doub:~[ ~ ~~y :Iimv:e ,a![C ,alUayedJ by '6e D~o:ri~e-J, w:h;omJ dt~ ~ '~e:H taf.~gblt. 'm ["~

""~" , .. '11' .. , ''''1'J;'~~''I'''1 jk~p,~, .I"j";oi[ ,;"~",.t'· peoc"-~., 'pc'l\.;;; 'ii:iI~' ~Iijo ;ii~~i':~' ~;iji;b.ofl;-II--p .... Iii< .. ib'II=" 'E· ..... [ ;ffiiFi..._~~

01;1' >_" J!!~ ...... J:~~~ !Ill .. " : . ~.iI.'" Oil .... " [ . '.' L ..... Ii~ ........ iI .•. ~ """"",,,_.""'~!lI' ,.~ ... II~I" .... '. r I!;fII/UI!e, !Ii-!!.JI' l.I!I.II"~

I. , II • ~l _

~1~t-Cli(!(11 ,~g rilii~' pre~I~q:' :MoraJ!ity:, 'Tb~' ihaiblt or: .,uati:QJlID[1 need, net

be d.cRm~l~' d_iKo:u:raged~ ~er~ thef\e ~ar be no :5{,l(1Jpe' :for [qu.em(lj'n:'inl, because the m1ota:Utyli w.h!i'(;'h Ito [ou~d$:~, m~:¥ ~ppt'~' ,u· ~mid~l' i$ ilimp:lf tall't!ll; :fM' 11:3!Il:l.rd by dtem, :md by' ~~y who 'COI!Iiil!~, ffuldln__g 'these mi~takeg prin~~ples, gd ,actin:1 :accordin.g '00 flem ~I' an ~nruall

'pan" .. "fl! ,iIi<1.· .L. ,',..1 ..• !'ty. . .,.,i . .. , .. ~:t"i-..-il" "... .' .. ", ,iii""" .' .. -;,.-ty'--' ........... " - -.----i:

' , ~ 0'1: Ullelli lue.n,..." ...... :a.tti!lJl, sense' vl ~~o:nD'lrnQ.es.s '"""" soc.._l:e)", ~ L~' n~:

i J _ ~=or.i~ I. =,r'~''=

'.ey' give :md ~e:lve~, dt~~' :m,o.~ ~IaM pd :.o~ judg,iJFlC;m,U, ,md 'tbti"~r

[0WIji apprmYlli5 o:f themseliYeIl!, :H[e ai~ 'imiK1para:biy 'li'e'd up 'wi~ thdrr' '~t.-

, ... ':,-.--~ _._'~~. ~~ii'ii'li.~.~ Cc~ ... ,t.. ,-".--_ ... 'Il._ ""~:..,...,-~;,;_~ .... '""' .... __ , .NIi',I¥i;..:.,Hi".,l""' ...... ~~ ,i'l!!; .''L. ... ~HJlUl) pn__Q~\R"I, ~U";;lU, ~~.,.' IY:l'l;;' i!I;;.'",,"~~~~~J"""-'!I;ii;l! ":;"1, :1~iI..t.:~.;!' :Walt',.;;;' "","'!UL'!I,'-·lII,!iI',U;I, l\,U~'

, ...... ii< ... 1..~'IiI~~_, ~1'~.1~~·'L. ~I:' :i.r" ... it' ,,,"ii.~,"~,,, """,,",~·v d-1.r.'n"'n:s' ,;,'L. ;a~XJi'''''''n;i.L'''''enriillll''l1 "~.JL~~-f!Ul_il_ .. _1l ~~IlJI1I{j! u";.JJ~!Ir. R!_I.JU-~J", ~·~~'i.l,t'~~TJ [._.~; I .~: U;~~I ~~'~!I!P--~[L[]r"'~-~,__;-_J.~l

:e,u~~ '~k:b. ;t~.~ [of' [~Q, .ugbir;eFifl,g M~I.inu" of' M~11U ~ ---7',-:-' 'hO:l"': war :Qilmiiln:s;t 'll'lII'i'lkls 0:" dl:~ (]latmoiOD5 'M .t.e' inmklti!1)n ,0'F

wa,gmg '. " ... '~-'." .... .. ~[ , .. .... . .r-. .. ". , ... """'

judi~i;aJ 'to:~-.e' ~p :m~di~ 'Ol:ifistrodo:m" and, of n,um~l'iO'LU :N_s and, CQmmiUrfi~ •.

'I''''' .. jL ""..A h." b ..... - .. .-:i .... --.,;[._ .. .:I~ ,",'!;'u--i' .iio'I!...-. ,-"-iFi -- --,- --.ii· ..j~:iI~i!; ... , '~I'ii'llo!. _,."'~- "''''fi''_ ,J,. ~, !I!I~~~i I~ ;ycn~~ [U~a~. [Yle ao~.-O'~!iI' 01, ~~~,.;.....,'~ ,r-""'';'f:ol,.. i!liI~~r '~I!l!i~'

-=-~:;II iti~:-iF [~'If-=-~ir.-::Iog. jjl'i"'IIi~"m -"'.I~'I; ... , J:'~Il"I" ~1f' ... ·i·ft::' ... ~~.,..f~·..:IL~~'I\nPJ· ·m["'m"'. 'f"F' "f~ ... ,

evil II. ,DUll, ule.h !liII.. . .•. IIiiI<I .. I • 'IlO_1i1l;.']! ,1110 ~"."_I) in ".II!ULI[I'!o..!I"""I'~!Ii. U'!i::i,..~"~ . "~~!I. '""= ~"'"

'_' _'

[capadty' w[ cwIlDaite 'their' a.c!li~H:S' :an_d '~dc~d •• ' sipll'Can-eeo. S:in~

,;o;,'I'~';:'i;'!'''l''-~., 'if'6q.-"""",,:,,!,!",I , ...,.lj'fii!''''''~:'lJ·,'' lit,O' i""Ii..I·'e ~~~I.I~i'];"':~"" ,;noI~,.!I1 ~'1'"1"·~'"i>'"r"'-~d.·ii"l"'I·! ["'.I'li-'rt-

;Q!U ... u.~,~U' .. ,.I'.I" ,IJ"" !LI<iil""'''' v.~~Ii,V,~ilLU~., III. lULL ~d:I_y""",,.!'I w-,~ '~"'!lII"'~-":!I!.~" ""'!;tI'~

:. '_ ,: ."

di.tti'QQ~ :~t miU't. be roon,dUd~ ~~t IUCh. ~~ ,~ti(lfl:l and, th~ 'WCt;s[ ,fmm.

wbbr;h ~bc)' SP~8:' an' nonaU!tonoIDOUS •. n~ ~o-mq:ffn '. me:' h~:m,

(~~ i~no-~~:iF;:~',~'ii"ii<A~-i"io~~ b"'llft' ''','Ii:-.~ ,~,~:~Ii'];'''~ ~lIijlllJ·''Ii~d··Qm~~''', ;i'j'\o!'iom'Ii'W'ift~Il!'IIi'. C.OllIiIr-,nt:iilllf!;, 10:1, a. .. 'L ........ iI!!U.~ul ~ !1101Ol, UI_.,!'. ~,L'U\I"l"" no,., _~ 1'" O ••• ~~iI). "'-"U .. ,f"._ ....... ~Ui"


M()~eJ:.. :&'J.F\ID of' 'MC!liOO'llCM, :i~ ;a, 'kind, ,!}'f iInHmslitmJty,,, :1:'1;5, .'~Ilt:s, are t~peramentillY' cdldl, ,aJIld uni~Il~~' ~'oo~t ~c !!Iidc~ilg of oth~;;, 'D.,.'r'bJi!Ii'ftC, ,.i!t1M.!' ,i!liir.,;Iio ~'h. oO!i~,_J1..~"",:,,,: ,;Et;~..,~'I; !~~:O~iI'~'~" ''l:-,~,~,-:~, h,~a;1j. .~~" ,"I 'i:i ,"" ~h"ld ,Ii;'~ ~~""lf"~ !.iIi!l!~,1 !I'IO., """ ,~- ~11i1~11,~ [~ul .... '" '! :a5Geu(;~ ,uave ai, ,_II!i)l~, pa!lD . Fes 0, ~ ~

~d!, not 'be~n.g' pe~'eiP~'i e~_pect 'everyone' 'm be li~e d'l£m., '\Yih,e~ 'lh~' ''Wi~CM' ~igns of :pai~ll" eti'!t'iJt~d by wma't. m.ey' :ftp-d as, ~fiI$U1lJi;(:'~Dt ,carU$e~, 'thq '~!l!t "~m, ~[ i:I~ of' wea_klle.~, to w:htbr:b :peo:ple mO'u:ld not ~.n:,c)lllmb" Their reacltQ!Jl to m~ is 'tBW; o:lJt~n, ,CU[i,'te:m!pt :F:o:r :~U' 'vt(Jiloo" Imag;lBe :~'h 'HeO'.".le :~Il :In;t1mat~' :[\ela!tions!hi~ j~ '~'~~h oth;@im ~XJ~t~, amd U'-c' ~niild.Gd

lIT - Lr ,F--= ~--~

'~.o ~Xi1VTti,~ [b,e~F ~~f.il],!V;, be'~~" ~,d 'UO.d.e~~__m,d'iQ~, ThP\!' nrua~ be '~relilJ~

r--"" _ £'~ 'I ,F' ~l -". 7 .r-

,teacbe",~ ~~U&eS:l' £riendSjo or 'lic}~m. 1Nh~n cnmfrm~md wfuo, ~t dO\n~~ '00

'tb~if' ~ml~DlJa~5\![ '~CY j~gt do ~O't ~' :i.'l. ,g eril B~t i~lel:t~irtiri!~' ,Cain ,also ac,'ti.vely ~' e.viil, because :~t1Ii, ,.~~ do 1101[, Uil1dtiif5tu1d, tIl.ar;; their [(;~I'1,duct

,",,~n .. _ _ 50 ~ '~~ oiO'iI!.._i'!"V un . .;1':- ... ~ _,1l- ....... .ii 'I'-t' ~ii..f"V' tiU'lilflil·..1 ',""'",,. ....'<111111''''''" ,i,il' 'b'l~ t, ~'I..~ "';];ii!Io'.,.·.· •. t' ~~~ [~"'~,~~, .U lU(~i ~~ o.-~W.~l ,J'_jl ~!I,v): ~uu_ ,u] ,1J_~Ull IIi.._G_~1 ,IJI.,.I ·_'.~U~ ~I~.~.' ~~I:~~~!Y!'-~

'u;ode~d ~t bocau.se they'la.elk tfi'E Hiiilsiitivility tD' r.oc~k>e' 'dwa;t ,O'the'x,s ,ime w~fiei"3ibbe' 'where they :~' D~t., And ~, ~h,e~' 'be(';um,~ dto.~ :auib.~ttypal flg~ llf~'; the' :$te:m and ~!L~J':(U;liv.iillg :fadle:r~ the '~.~.Clhe.F Mtm, 'U!~~s6!lJbl\e' de;m3iil.~ 01' '~e :most dian,FroU.~ [h!a!iMr of a'lll~ .~Cl: :i;D.'tiJma'~e cn.cmy 'iJiIiit1;o :know,s and (-Dm;dem~5, ,tii~ '\!Uln,er.alrinti~ 'of 'hi5 (Jr' bet ~lj][ma~:e5.

]i ......... riliol·b"· .. .=iiV [1"'., "'" '''''':''''e 'b.~.~~~~_ ilt, '1"ii"ii!I!'~'~'I~, .. I!I;f. "<lo~r.~.~~ .~~~'~ Dr.,~;j. ';'~, ,:~ ~ ... ~ , ...

.. ~_.~"~)~~;"'~.,,f ~~, ~.""!I!",",, [~~~, '.,''';';'.b!lo_.'o:.'~,I' '~aU5C-,s ~!I., DUiL, ],~ IlS Ul!liJli;;R .non-

(i'~t'(jlDiOm;OU$, '~(;~~~, I~k:e d~3!ii~j' ~t does 'Hilt [(lonfloJ.,m, to tbe ~~!iiJla~' tiun and, '~fid~mta1m.d~ng' ;(iOmdiItifolJils[ ~f a!Y!t<l;mQmlr'~, tintSl viJ"O:lait~IilI' :iJ1:.S .Jltl~,f'

Ji\u~'IfIr~' ... \iI'>.,..,..'I¥\'IlI' .... n't'~ 'T'I....,.. i<'...,.,~'IJ .. :""'~ ,-f" .j';~;o; .(" ... i~ijil_ ,ie' ''"il- '~'~' [Df th~ ::Io[!".'.il>im~'; ____ ~ ~~Il,r. ...... - Ib.~ll~ Illll::lX! ~U~,~IIU 'U , ldI_lI.a! ,ti:L.Ill~L!l;i ,a.:.:.;I! ~lI~ ,F'~-T _ '~' ~ '.: ._ = , __ c'I!r.I [~l"lr.lml~

em'Otiorliall, lives asa :f.'t6ul.t o:fl~n,ctic Ol":ho-:rtt1Q:mrail, (',a.~$ O:f afupbriJJ.i'rlS gd cl~!ii~oes 'WI!I;O!};D/ih.u:iR' tn ~,~ d~]o:pmti:fit i().F 'cim~tef' tncll~ r.eq,~~[led fbr ~nMthdJlf~ ~u,cb as being :imagil~!ltlve~, ~tre~~'~ pe'J1p.epl:i:'!!'f:j, Of [G~~otlvc. 'rei; tbe evil dl3it :in:se~s~ti~ :pe@piJe :111";Y [~a.~ iiS, :0;01, d~ml. i!!!h-~ by W(ilf ~k ,gof g()Q;_I1'Omy"

'btlbl!essn,ess, .is aJlmtl"t~r lunD ,of wi(:bdln~, :1:0, dle ,~o:rm:cd [COWfSe' o:f ~n,~~ [fleDp]e :ti~ ~tteiIr lives, in ,aooor.ru..O(:l 'MJlh :SODl~ ~o:m("cCftio:n~ [ofwh~~ 'would :make' tbem pod" :lljj,m.J~m'I,eS.$, :is; dle vicc' [nC P1LI'8UjM1;g' 't~ese' call;"" cepi)!io:n~ withO'~t repn:t, f.or' die e.~l dllat mAy ,"su'lit. Rtu:hleS$ ~pl~' ¥-e' be'n-be~t 0llI :5UOCe®S., Ttloqr- ml£O~I)jR.F ;Q;~]e:5~ b~t '~qr d~) 'w-hall-Is[ ueces-:w:y 'to '~FC:Om.c' d\~~. & a lie8ldt 'tJhey often [end up ()3r~l!!!inl :~riUM!, iiLI~jiuMUrj"Gd ~~, 'to t~Q\2' WhiO' '~ave 'rae :mild(olrt~fte: '~(ii be [lit"" ol~~'(l~~ liill t]lC~lr 'P~'

:R\Y!tb~IeSlliFi;~ ~ n.uli1i~lU,Ufto;mous, :if' bs iagenirs, :f.l, '~OO ~nd1e'~~.d, ~.e

'ill ru .'£, ~I!' ",'L. '" . .dIi "'T'ib. ..L ,;, • " "'" ..:II

moral .lnfil.!llOO er IUL1Mf '~ ~Oti~J~CL, ~ ~ie,' s-ee iYieJF i:5lilUaball. ilU~ue;['

ttie' dl'~Hp~(}n, of ~rki~1 t'O[ achieve ~I:u~~r guru!!!., Th~ do 'ROIl. h'aJii"end ~ [explo;lt" :bumiJtiar~" maiim" or :FlI!.I~n ~P:~' iiili tbeill" way'~, yet 'when tb~h' :~ ... , tiO'JLS !prodiuu' Eb~5e brP~iU'C~,~ Ithey 'taike' ,Q llildie' iit'i1l,gn~rn;~c of' dleM ~, :a '~'I~r' dtoes, 0:1 [th~ Mld!ILi&, :i,n, ,~~, Wil,y. If' rJJ~~f iitrt~ifido:n is, ¢a1!1~d, tOr '~e evn 'they a~'~ their' :m~!'5po:ll'H' is, a, :5'Iilr~g'. If:mrc~d, to iC'xpiaiiJlh they ~~,


,a;ootl!l; th~ :tm~da:n(l(l: o:f tb.~~f' guill5" Th~y [dol flint set .g·1IJt t~1 h~ oth~Q.'!,

~'h''''-!IJ.' .41."1" rn .... ~· ~~,inv~ .... h,;:Q'. ~, '''''Ii''~' '''''Ifo;i!>'~' , .... l~ 'Iil ""'t'. "'§I~ ~~"i':'-~!I!' ~~J·'lliIo". d .oi'io. '='r§ft ~-.~-"Ir1· ~~ ~L_v" ~lll!l~~ J.' U~~_I"I~ ~!I u-.!IJI!",. ~L~""",l-' UIM' l J IV'-!I. ~H_IJ"" '!W1Ii~~lr'!YlII ill ,lIlll;l,~J.l _ .'II.IIiI!!l1 . IV H~I_o_

~S, :F!;~~'. 'fb~~F $'(A)'ng ~o:mmJiJtm~~~ '10 Ith~ir 8'~ :p.f~d~~ d\~~, wirth a nJ~lulil;iiJlc :Il'o:r 'co:ndU£1tIl11' [1tI:(tl1mselVG5 M, 'mtry' do .. ff paJpl~' dtd [1-01; ,Mil :~FiJ ~ls :mannt:·[~ '~q" cWml, lIl~tld~,g ''WC}wd ~r' '.' i1oco.m(p1i1ShOO." Add to ~I$ dlat the 110ab tiler :p~ftue may' 'k· a;,,~oved ~ th.e~r ~de,,' ;and. that. '.cre ~Y-' I", ,aJ, '~d1~tium of PI!liF!il;lilIog' ' • .em~, afnd then 'tiber' ~U 'be' .e' r.~i~ able c."~CI!i~~ pll.ilticiiJ!tUi~ :$(Jid!~Q~ ~~~ Md. :~ili1etc~ wbm £1\11 :i~itOI '~is Pil!tteni.j",

n~W~j, biige~Sirt1~ityj< ~d, rutl1iL~~n-e1j rate' ~ttJe :rQ:~ [of:n.nnalWtG:ll-

'''-:'''-m' ~ "~""f'~ ~1l'"'1_.=_:~~ ... ;:,.; ·Tl .. I,-~r.['" ,."fi'j.iO; ji'iii'iI,,,,n-li :,,::"~:l,.."";i'iii[ ·(,r ....... ' '!b =_iji;iij> '~~Ui~. 1ti"=_:'I~ =_Iii: '~91M). 1Li!"~ __ ~V!lUa 'I"'.r,.~~~_~;ti~. , ,IJ._~, ~ III,;,I,'~ ~-'U;D;.I-"'l ~Ul,'i:ii~,&I! .. 1~!IYi ,~.~_IIJI ,ll ~"J ,~~1:Ji ,lI.~. "',.1

,md :M·jio 1[984·), Their' ;~igtd6~c;e· il ~t. 'l1lhe ~F :fkey ¢aili :['OF to ·.e' Socr-arut: 'qrue~ull1J of Wih~1'hClt" WJ.clke.d, ,~lmB d.a ,~; 'k;rn:owtfl);.gLy :i5 tt'bt iiill. a, ~firse' me)t d\Q[ tfU1. in anQther KiliiSoe 'flq'do no.to Thef 'blow w-hat evil is,

,;<01.[1.'-'1 ,t]i .. ,~ ~ .. :~; .......... '~11ic'9It 't.1!-;'Ji!>V ...,~ [dl.,.;;;~Oi'. 'b. II~I~· ~:L.."!!I;!'-'I C[ ~ ..... t ["'''?fl;]:-:-"·~t· .. ,I,."""~",, 'iIoI'':'i"''[ in _ tUI l_III---, 19TI~-n '"'.HILn. !tIll..,.!' !A.I! ",. v""_~~,~~ ~l~ Ul~~. u.u ~MlUll !U-~, __ ." .. ~~" ~I~-~ l-tn!!UI

pi'e(;6 of In!JW~edF'' l"hie [taCk of:' ,c.O.mll1iec~o:n i:s 'oofb. ge:o,emi![ mFoctim;g' W,C~f QoOWJ.ed,ge ~f: moC· W~ e~(;lre1f· of thC~f [pa!tt'Cm8 'Qot ~ti~i'I~ gd,

P· "'i"~~""I~IL ... i'"' ,",,""foI":"'.t"~"""'I'f""'.a.' ~}b..o;!!, '~;i"fo;~iI i<'j''''iOji'<j1;>''''Qi' ""'c I~;"'~ :..,~~~ .... , ..... f~:'.;"'ioiOJi;~, ~:t...~'i: ["'if""= 1,,!I'I1I, 1IIiI",",,~_.,JIlAiI~, V."""'I,I!!I.o~I, III!~_U~ 1Ii- .. !V ,1'1_~""",I,,;d;I. !L!'_I\.iI~_III~ 'V.II ,Ill" "',Il".~I!.dlll'" -.'ll.""".!11_'" [LILIJiII: .. """""'u,

stlIru;t,' tth' 1f:UIiiill-.'' Soc-- ~' -, ,.'orb ", [h - ,- f,j' - a - - - ' ", , -. ..1.. 'ii' g,,·u

_..:'..!_cj!l.'e' I.....;_e ,~..:enI:!ii. ,:::..:f3!~~5, ~, 'n.eiL..~!~ •. ~ler-e~,'OJ-e.':i! III !5e.elill~' ~~ !l:b

iL'-""1' .. 'I"i!'..:I\g.,~ I'"", '1"";-_i~'Filj1i·i:J'. ' ~"f"1 ~;L. .... ~9i1''''' I~£' ~_1j1i'9'U:~-ro"f"·"J'l~"'.U': 'II'i'Ni;o;i"I--'..;!':~ . ,~;h:""~:U~ili. ,~. !JiJIII'VHl ~~~ , " .. G!-iliJlill"\b UiIJ !IiJ.I", .... ~ UtI. iIO~,V.UiW Jli!!U,~il.u\IJI'.I.u!U.3; ·!""U!l-iIio"'Jt.li.I:I",","""i!< ,ilDiU:L'u!''"'\l!'!;iliil

"_" "_' _"

h~ did. ny~ see tJb~t ~~to:numgljUli~y wi:c:ktc:d, ;¥~~~ do e::~j wilt'h fbll k_fi~l'-e

edge 'm 'wbat 'tJie:y ,~ dO[I'i_g. Soc.mtt~ h~fer;~ '~ ,ajS() 'WfUfi--8· beesuse he ~Il!p~d tbia!t w, lh;¢ eXJ~it'i1t. b) w(biih ,apnJfS ~55 tnmN\l~d'g~ o:f MII~ it w1Il~ :mf!)~tc' '~em, !IO :a:mid, ~t. ~th ,~ut()~OmOM, ,~d :n(iO:llI~.ool1)1!i;omn1,g 'w.ie'kt:dneM, iQvol,,,"e blowledg;e ,of' evil. iWd, yet ~tte· k_no-wb:4g:c dees !A0't m1)ti~t-e' dic' .-emrl! 'who ~S$ ·~t 'to ,aVO:id, [~Ij, fO'r an a]l:e~31tiiYe' ad, '~mdi~g SQ:llr.;oe ;o-f: motiwti:OIll, 'e~~f:I~, 'w:h/i;c'h :rnde~ the'., d~~ti~, in;Si!n:silti,ve~, ~lth1.e$S~, '0If' ,Wtlcbd :iQ, ,solime othef 'Wtay.

t'h~ fb;rm_s of' ~0:nDto:1itO:JnOU:S wiI.~ked~n~" lind ~r o~.cn ;iIS; weU~ d~Ltop[ :illl. iIh~' rsam~ 'e~'. Lll.ieR ani' age~u 'Mith tr~tiUI'~]~ and. :mnmitly ,:a«e<Pta'ble' [(;Q'o.{)eptio~~ Qf",aJ. g~ :llfe" '{r.n 'w'hjch ,they' ,MI'e ~u~l1g1r >o~mi:t.~ ~~d. 'Th~' ,a!~ :a;lso ,oo:mmrin''sd 't~ ,rihK:m'tll ;(lfrrtariifl. :m.@n'~ :,m:biibhloj]~ tha:t

~. of"· I;' • ,"or,;'; ;i.'1:.. '. ., 'D~ ti ;;11..

'~~e Ol.!llt ~me 'Ways 1_"; '~~!I' tOI iI!~~I!l:e iy'te!l[ (lon.cep:U~~_:!ih ,~cause' 0": 'UlI€:

[ ... .oi'1iIHi.·j.,·.i""·i:J' .. ,.~Hi....-i~: ~~ ,.....:II~~;!f!I'.~ 'C·~~~'.iIol*".""ii'lo."-;~ '"lio;t;1iodl/:"~'V' .. ·'t""'~rr.· ,~ :":"' ...... ,~ ... =' ·;· .... ~ ... :ii\Olio~, [ .... 1 ..... =, ..,v.\I·1 UIL~""'I'I.'!Io-.L~iiI' "'-!II!. L\U", .... ~ """'"~IJ ","iU:l~~",!l;lliU:!loi!lim:l! ,..~~ .' u.. l!I.I!Ii;'1J U"~iI, .... l:td!I.~:L"tii[" U€"

ree~ ~ese two pn& Of·[e~llunJtm.e[li)il8 (jO'JDe ~nm c:O:Jl11~iot. \With eaeh o:t'h.er:, Title ,.0J15 mlust ei~~li" je@cpard~' t!b~iiF :punUlt ef ii, ~, :Ilif-e: '~I' 'wi)Ja!~ 'm,!!lnill p:[\o:h:iJbiiU'OllS and '~' a, g.o;od IU1~ :i'll, :iJmpermiiwbl~ W¥. Th~' fe$Otve' dic' Wfitll~t by aJ1mVini .e~r ;CCf;B\l~~_jtmeBt 'W ~'[tdtiC,tlunre: or ~,~ lif~' 10 overnride ab,C!ir [oG:mmi;tImI.enlt ~D dte :mo;niI. pran[itii!u:ons dll8it ~ta~ujJ_ to, ·~e 'way~ ~d, ~UIe the' oonitingeilll~i.es, that cause dleir' ,ro~~~ots :per8l~ they ·'rio-lark: m'ol"'id pm'hiiihl~O:Il)5 ;ap'ln ,a!nd .irn, Tb.~~1i viiO:latllo;ns fann, pat~m~J I~LDP' irnrW vii{;~!ii, 'In ac:&an:lDee With wJ\l~ph. dlqr ,a(:t ,tweh.


'iiIi'~ ~I!'

~1il1 ~iJ1;u.ai'ti\Q:niS whe~' .e oo~lf1io'b that :£IJ~t :pve ~ 'liD rti,~m f;t0' lO:IllI~[' per.s~., 'These .:eOiU!:, .e~ 'n~tu1i':a!llf 3iitd ~;p6nll31n~ltr~' ao1. :10, dl~ wa/~ ~ITII ~~ilMi('~ ~q' 'WCirC' fi~t ('b~d, by oondn.genel~ W' act.

'~, ."'" ... '":"I:"'~'~"'-':"' ~'"I''' ;-:T:1 "~",C;-::~i~;b.~'~"~'-:Tio,~, ' ... ~~"" 'i!Io~~, '~;j"ioii!lot'·I"I"'I;1i,;!I;,.ol"W~ iC!~m"" .:1, ~iI~1T YlO a""d;il\na. u.L m,'!l;1Ii·iiti.I, pfi1llilil!~I~!lo.,.,.t5(J! ,U'U'!I"I!·!Iiir'!''!G..I" 'II'1'II,,,,", ·'I!'''iv.III'I!!L''!.o!'~!I-~ "io!'.!!. ~=""

of dim Q,~ ntor.d ,cl)mmiil~en'U).. The ,s.elf~O:f:i,dEmf:i:a'O;Il~ ~Il.ch w.oilaitlu:ms ~~iIi,~ii' :i!Io~ 'rP'"li"iI(1ii~"jIi'll :"li""',' '-1i-1i~"I'\ ",'·'1'01'" it,,,]" illio,.,., :ager' ..•.. n:;;·,' :-~f',.oI!Ii'G:i<"'""m" This '~.'"" ;"~tdes

n'IiU"Io,OII,.JL iIIU.~ 1 "B.liIOilil)uli IIIIIH,\JI, '!JI ... . .. . .1eI ~ ,]!!1;""". ., ~'-':!I ~="""",""!Ii"""'~~~" ~ ~~_ _~ ~ "" "" , ,

- [!J '-, "-,.1 ,.",' ,

'tmem, witth aJ,8tt:O:Jlg m'O:tive to, :'J~~~ theh" vim'lJatii()}:~ ~'41;) '~e-mse:l~!Ii if~ a

'-:cC". C"''''''''I~·'~'' 'iilr-iF.·, .... "'pU· :; ,'.II:-II~ ~tg .. ,'h. I. ~H;...";,~.;r,II!ii;i"!..,,, .. ''L..~~.,' ,~ .. ~.·.n' "11eI.'"," " i&:n .. A'i""1f.Ii'I.' g'. ' 'ti"Ii, ~!I! !lth."·'''''' ,m,o.;I- __ ". [~ ~ ,_~~J~ ~_ I~~"!! V",I~ UL~')'!~~~ IUJ,I~ I' ..:i-1~. I ~ LltUoI, U\\J-.IIIJ.L: '. ~ ll_~l III. .; i"II.l

. ,'_' . '_'

:redies£;ri,pli0:1'l1 oJ Ithe mlailU'f'lf! 'of' the.ir ao1iQ~, 'they' see 'tlhemsel've$ ,~ :acltlng

:m;o-t d~!Jiti~rul~ ~~ jiJi :a '~II1~~~led ~I [tot in~Ai!litiv~b~ to ~,(l: swff~ir,ill~

-'=~F~ 1[1 ,[r--"_ IIr- r=r J:J ~l

,o.f ot'ltl;~r:s 'but '~itb dl53i'pro,~ ,of ilheilr selt~[tdua~Cn{lei ~Qit. :~~'e"l~' 'but 'realbticaJly, 'lib.q' m,U! ~m~' w{jCJHd, h'ot m~ do ~at; bw' :ihat :a!OOllJt dleDlSlelves., Sui.h ~OJl~Q!l\'OnQm'O'~ w\icked)[t~ is, J-e~liI~ble :foJ{ ~,:good m.w~~ ,0£' tIiI~ ,ll(;tiulll~ that' ~~~' serious" 'UJtliwU!JuJfic-d, h!ilfIm ud, malbe ,e~i

,- _. - 'J' .. _. _'.. - ---- I .I._I -- "._ ••.• I .... _'. ~J --_1.':iJ!--- -.-- . -_ ~.- == --_.- -'--'~' ~---

.' . -'~I : 'I" pFeV~en,,,.

l'h~-' at!t~ti~jF uf ~b:'rs ~xn'I~fJ1Jart.'!,on of the' 'pre'Mlletl(ie .of:' e:w'l :Me' 'maJn"'",

, ,e. ." 0 1:S ,,'. J " .r . J, 1,,,. ,,' . ,,, " " __... 1 ... .. , .. ..., __ ." ". _ . =" '

I~ :is :psydliu}~'Ca1l~' :,Ia!~bLe; ilt e",])a1!J1!51, how UDeJCic:e.,tl:Q~.al :,eo:,:le·. ,su-ch as (iO:lJI~~;I,eM NaI~ :and, Oo:mJm~n'i®t. :f~('ooariesi em dOl e~cC¢If~tiO';mal evil;

. r" .

it [aceS' '~e. 'ta;C!i; fun ~j, 'is :pre.v,aile:H!t ~t ac.l~owl~s, ~t tt Iq~l)" r.-c.s~'~t5,

r' :,' ' . , 'L. ':; .,,1 ;1 • "i",," ~',..:I '·'l :, .. :"~!, , ~'h'.'. " :'1", '. ,',." ' .• , ~...,.' ".'.',' be" !h.~ '., ., ~(i.., n '.' '. 'It;,'. ' ILro:m, uju.l~ ,;,u:1u,iauls, 3I1lt'u, ,Il, ll'li'Qlu5,~.',e JnC(Ullc5IS"",,!IlCY ." ,,,~ee:1iI! !!Itle l!!e,p~ve

~d We' :posiJti.¥e ,ai~ 'of" Ubenill$~ '6aJt. !I~' or~~d by ai:9triib~m~g' m~' P:[\~

] .. ~ ,,',' " ,(~,', "I~ '. ".,". I~':I': I,' . 'I'~""'" ,', ~",,' :.';" ,: ·:tri··':,'n' ., ,(l:Il;C(: 01, evilil ,malin!." '!I.'O :il!U~Il.O{mOllS :aO!L()u!Ji.

M~5t ~m;e:mrt :Fu(' :p:rreKfii)t pw~s" b.~RT.' :i~ wm.Jt ftJU!ow{5 from, (hilSI

'Il~_· lo..~ 'h ru '" ~~'i\,,·1 I ~"If

e:xpl!~lIIarI:lUJll, iloout ~c:OW LrtCfeDl...ng a!utO~Q:m,r ~es: eVl_._, ~ess:, :pt~.'x-,-e~t., ,j_'

'&~ p~v.a!l~n~~ ()'i: ~Yiili is d!1Jj~ nl!a.IDn'ty to n.OllraJIlJt'Om:o:mUIlS ~.otinI1li5~, ~en!, ~be' 5t1ppos1!tiiG:Il, ~!I!!, :m3jlhll aetlens :m,o;re 3'MIi~:O:llom£!"u, '~i1l1 :ma;kes, 'them less eril'" 'In '~i~ii.olll!lar'" U UliW:'b ev.B s ca~d .~ ~e :~D!)!"nU'f. '[aJil~Fe ,tD e_~'

.• __ P., __ 1 ~jL_ .. '~l • __ . _ .. __ 1 .. _l _ ••• _.-. __ .. __ l ~Jj . lor .• ~I!IP.' l.~L __ •. _ .• - ... __ ~.~_-_

or u_~de:r:slaind the ia!'lreroJa~;s aJmoog '~b;'h ~ey' b~ve 00 C'h,~'i then~~, it iis sllli~d, Mne:r 'evaJhlarti'Om :_d llimdenunuti'IlO '\riU ~mnmve' t'be~1I

,I., ",Ii'"lr~--'i!' .. , .. ,. .. I,. ' .. L .. , ~ " .. , ···r .,., .. ". ,.1

JliIdgm~~~ oo~~t 'thm m~pe~pti<-1iI~ aInd ~, mew fmm, :rn~$tlilcln,g ~~ {:ocr 'D',OQd Mil ,if []tis, is 'nlOl'biL 'cllt~1l d!t~ 'l'riiI1)siJti~ 'ti~ra!I 3Ii'm .of' inereas-

"_ •. ,_.1, ~ .- _ -._ .• , _. ,. I __ . _. ''''--0 _ . "' .. _. , . . ,~-~ _ .;J , _, - • • • .., __ I. - j.

:ml a~j@:no:~y !by' :in¢i'e~iItil fFeed.o:m~ '~,W1!l~ty,~, ri,I~~" :P:I)Um1liMn~, 31f:id di.s-. tribUit1ve J·iud.l_.ee Ii,., :m;ot :itrtc,.n~~~ent with b1!lt aJ, Ue(i~_i_",,' l\'I"lll~iJr.eme~~ o-f

[ . "='~~ I' '='~,

,~a!lb'in.g 't.h~ ~~ati,~,c t~bend, aim, lQ:f :maikmg 1~ll~$S pre_CUlt'. TWoI ;o'b:joo.

'~j)Il~ Fe~d.e:r tb~ Ubernl ~~41 'un.aot:epta!bl~', h~vet:"

~';iii; ,Ell_Iii' , .. " .. r-bf,~"",j;"I"COj;~1 joE! ,"'iIi;",;i' ~-I'ii' ~ .. c:~, nil;-"~' '~-,;"'I'I~-""" ~~i!Oji' "ilL..,. 1I'i~~ll&!i.""I"_' ,I ~Jhi' ,1,1 .• 1,"'" ..... ,i,!I'._' ........ , .... 1IllIO ... UJ:IO!~ ,)1.- ~, ..... .., .. 1.,., ...... 1, ,IJ .... , .1!.:.!''!'1' [h]' .... ,.' •. ~ 'll-'U,,,,," F."""'~'" }"';',.,.,,,,,"}""

" "I"""

I ~ &' I. ,,'''~ L~:·, I 'l ,~, ': . ".' <'I "IIit.r. 't;"lio ' . , :' "I' '1;'.' I 'c' ":,'" I : ' c ,... •.. ,:' , .. ~i"': It"' ~f 'm' ,..". c~~ en:!!:

0.1, evn lu~;JD.I utUe mmml,;r ~ U,OJi)aU!,O,N(l~ll~ ao!-llJ()~ ma ,[!ill, .~()Fe a'CI!j'!!O'\,!~

..."...-, ·m.I",~~·-:I"" """.o(';~' "'"'ilfil;.rio'.· .. "i"i'm· 'f'ii., .... , ~! ...... ~ "iO~~ ,~'A'.!.~ ..... I 'II:-,,:,: i"l"'",""d·,.I ... 'IJ.,;!I';E, 'p.~I~,:"'it. n""~,,,,",~"" ~.~LU.,'" "'I!~"U"~!IjJI,. .u!Ua,ll ~,I,,,,,~~ ",",·!I'·,.I, '!I"I!U''lJlilU ~ ~~W11 ,,,,,," ,l~~ , ~ ""'~lIRIlli;;I.,.,I.

Moor an~, ilt b perf«tlf :possilbL\e' dtcat. ,even if the :~I1J~ 'wh~, a(:~.o:nj talf~'


:Rll;~~'n5~'bl~ f~F tb.e' p~enee of evil eg])Ull.ed and 'lJ1Ilck~t~ tbe~r ,~ 'li,QJ[s alOC\lmtely:, and thus stop~, :m1i~~lWa.g th~r' ~, :m~mi, sta~ '~ey' 'woulld, ,c'Q~dLnue '00 act. d~e sam~ 'way ,3;1 'berfif'e. 'TheIl' [[~eCiio:n 'm the :r1~ill!aUO:n, th3it m~lt ,l!1le d~iJ!tk" ~.~~mli~t1¥ej' and, mlhl~M ndl,~r 'thaD :p:ritu,;:~pl~dJ!, ,disciipl'i~cd" .. id :reailis.tk :~' j!l1$t '", WI 'emlb:~e 'iiibek: '.elll, ~d, tQhe' ~'il.i.~ ~i, fallow '&o:m th,cm. ''I1t~' :M~ dt~ir W£:u ~~

'" '" ,111: r' ...;t_..::: iL..~'I~ It, iL. ~ ,. .... AI '" .'

mm,c' precX!1St1n,g J.eeJI~G'~ I~r~! I~Q~~:! ~~Q~':! (;JF lie,M' lere3!~ 'fell:.f:PUWil¥'

to ~cm. De ~f ;~,~_t:lred 1w,ow:l,edg,~ [that th.(i~r' ,CJh~teF ~U; ~,

'''''''......... .'N t ,.._,,:;:_.' , .. '\..~, -P_~"~' - - - -IL- 'ill... =j'1i " - -, -oJ] c -~..:I . t k. '"_ .. a/if>' .i: '~_

"'!I~'!Wl!" 1Ii~"""',"''''1i I';~~ ;o.j l!!I:f.;;1 : :~,~V"ll);W!~y' UC:-I~~gj' '~~ '(U!li!;, wi :IJ~iIIi: ,m.O!l!l,val~

[lhru:n, 'W ,c:hD~ ~tl'l;oIi!h' ~h"llf~oi!"tl-F;, ~l,'iPV ~;o]i\l'j~·I.'I~t shnli:t 'ad ~ m, m:~'

.. ~ .. ~.~ ~ .. ~.~~~-~.~ ~~~ ~_~9_.119'!r.~i.l'l'l .llll~Ij-~J.. II_Ii_110M, JJ!Ii;IIi!II!Ll - --'~I [_ - ~ J ~tl '_-_' ~~_c _

5ie1ve~ T,Mt is h~ I. amn" And ~Iil 'if me,' wer.-e' rno~b!d iby.' 'tbeilr' nmv' bJ.owl~~ge. to ,cban-lt: dn~iIll5e1wl, 'Iib~ f()r~~ (If '~~t :rnI!lJUve' :~' [Un't:M:' ~~~~It rtQ d~~a;t. the ~Wl!imI;y' :fo:oc¢i!!, of:' dl~ ~.tii.' :mo~ that .ade! '.enll :~e.ptive 'm, ·ltI,e:ll' v.i(ieJ :im, tll~ fi:l::5t p'IJac~~ ~~~i;aN~f no~ lince iIh~f"' vJ~es ~ haibi~u~1 by' '.eir 'very naitmiR. ~iblJtinl :m:cm31!lt'C)ltO:m.D1;I$ aeiClnmlll!, auw:m:O'.mom;, tha,d()J'~" ~' leave ~,,~t g, ~_emit ,as it 'had, beeJil, 'bef-Of.C'",

T-1 ..;il .. ''L.'" iIi=, ·'L~ '1"iL .. ~~.~ , ,t:"._l.. 'L.,_

,itO :m:llu'tit" l!!Iii~!ii, ,~F p.illUi!~ .. e!, ,_~~I~S' 'mid. lm mttr' MlP~' tlliiilil~ a~

rono:my :~ iHooHi(patihle with evil" dlat ,3Intono:muu ~'~fi$ tmd tOI l1le' :g_~;> ,Bld [t_t ml ;aoUOfil5 :a:rl~ u!fua!Uy' d~ w' :bck of' 31UtOJ1O~y,. O,n'_'f if tIl'is ~R' :501 wt"t:li-lil:d, :maiking' iil,o:nau)t-OIlo:m,ou;s, actJIQiJli9i ill!U,Wno:m.o'M ,~~d~r

'.~ 'II' ... , ., 'I"" t,

'ev:J_~ ",eSSI P,feva ,CUll.

:Buit, wltat :q the' f~Jl, :for the ~,PPODtiQIl ~a!t iillf.IItntllOmOtlS Dd mOf:.. ;a!liy' ,~, :Kti.Olli§ 'h;nd WI g'Q roge'~CF ,~d ~at eri~ acmOTI'8 result :millin'ly :~m the' 'bid 'of' ,alUitan.O:OlIY.? Lllu: i[,e.uon, i\5, th~ '_~i~ ~, :if ~,op]e 'weR ;aillowed ~to :mm ~hm~~$, w1IJth~~ OOI"I'U,tiIn~ ~t~a1 iD6!'iienc-e~ willlbO:Uit~ havtn__g' t'h,d___r e\!a'IJua!u\on, alld Uf:ldenb:nd~ng' ~]i)'u~d, by :~'~, dI~rirmJ- . :HJaiti,0'm:~ ,ctime" ~d, [oth~r ~bt!I, ilk;: ,tf they wefC' H@:t: bm)taJ)iz~d" :ilndoom... nakd~ er CIrr,;a;ed, 'by i~jiustia~ :if' tb~' :h:ad, chli' tim~ and 'Q;ppl~hy to

'·~ili1;1\" :i'!IiL~iIi'ilt· '.'1t .. ii"I'I~*Nlilli!, ~i:irn...jl g.p~""'I'I-'ii! i"'1,.~!I\Ii i"':Ii-~ ~U: ild'-I.;lI~1 '~·~l"..;t' 'i!lll ~ .... ~-d! Yl~~~!Ii, AiU'U!~. Ull!!r.~_ll _ j~!!Ir'1l! MII.cCdi.ll !IiH.l .... ,v, __ .... ~ IU~L~~_~ IUL-~J L""'-"U"_I_~ UU Ln,Il~~ ~ ~ liil~' ~~._

d~cy 'wuuld. not do 'w:_t i~ ,~t To, ~n;cf~3R' meJi: a~W'RQfR:f' i~ 'to .~~ Im.eif' ,~mn.eu, W' (;O~pUng' lexte~aJj :i®Jflm::n,cn,r md :iit 15, '~~ ml tome!:fi.i:olm ditC'K' le;xhem a'l: ,lO'filu£nGC:s, dbat '~mmg' mOf-.e ,alltQ:n.o:m.o~, 'will: :mdif!; ,ml, leg, pUVahll!t.. In oth~!I' WQ~ ~i$ ~~r-b ,~ ,p~_ibie by'lh~ ~Jjef thiJit: people an:' ~a!tliJiml~' ~, ;md Qlat: .CY' ,do ~, ' __ ~~, o:f cor.,nl.pt.iln;g' ~x~mal inf].uti_n(;~s. Th~ beillicf:~ 't!he libcraIJ mtb~ ~bout, wtIn:'h, :mtwh 'wil~ be Uiid iI:bJlolllibo!lJlll th,e· 'OOo:k. 1",~ poilll}t; :h~ ;i.$; tb.!lt dt~ iKio~.,ta!hiili)ty ,of 'lh~ pr~~~ ,~F '~nds, on 'illhb, [a,lltb,

nat thi~ 'be'li.cl~;a :maJ!1ter 'Ilf'&i~ is shO'-\imJ by :lts, Hin,g :tmild, :In, 'IilE :tfac~, 'o:f '.,e; ,3.i,d~l'I;OW:I)ed,pdJ fact '~~t; I~I b p~eH:t in :aliI :blown h~man 1Ocietiies., LDe fa£:t :is ,e_l(pWn~ by tIl,eire: ~n,g in!iumch:nril ,illu,ton.o:my. ]cs ,~~ :ficien(f!, h~~! is 'not t~:k~eg, WI :mdi¢a.~:e an,ytihin,g ,adiVCrH iziM.nln'l1mimD


nature. :Erll 'ilsi _,posed, '00. 'be' :Pf1~iiI~ '~GlIiI$' :soci~ti~ :f'ail, 'to :[o,sl\er 'the. aiu;to~OnIr 'M :bitdMdlla'l, 'Who nw' ~n lihEm.'! ''l1iitii lii~' of' b}llman ![iUI1~_re :a;t. th" ,'.' ,C".' ~f' m :. l'iIH:n1! 'f:a~~ is fhm 'dla!t 'b!y'miilin btri_n~ :a1re: '~ dlell' !I1I:liWRli

I .. ~ C'C;lftO e I .. , ,. I, ..... , .1,., L._.= -.- ~!D'~'--- ""','1 -.-

~, ~ua]" mtlo:n'3lJ;, and :moraLIy' :1I'ood. 'They' ai>t. ~1lUO:fiQmQ~y whlt~ th~' expreg, ltieiv ~'I' ;~d, 'nell dt@,),' act ,conhry tol ilru:l1r ,mtw:'e,. it lD~t

L_ iL--'_ .~: .'~'1"'" r"" ..... ,., P'V ,"'''''''', "".;b·~wt', ,i'.A '""'.' """ri,a.I~i;"""ri.'"':i!ri·'"''i~1ii ,~,=,tI'i'i~~oE: o!tI' I..K; l~~ lUl-.,]' [~,~, ~~:JJ!~'~ ~ W ~,~_~~~~~"L-'V'-.II~.,""'_~I ,U;lJ,IJU'!t;i~"""'~~J

''Ill -, nm.ernJ f.~i,th ~~r:. is 'ir.Ulmr~l1islhle 'mr several rea.so:l1Hli- 'tnt· 'DO,

~. __ e .~ ..... '!'!-4' .. !, .". "'. I" .. , .. , ... , , .. ,' . .... I ...... ,_ ... ==-'"'t =~-

~d\ej'u::~ :d t'Ilbtm. to ceunt apiO'5t :IJ1. M'Q![Jj&80ta~(ID_S ,ofboth, 'h~~ ,~ :1ltC'U 3!nd 'wi:('~edmeg, ~' 'talk"(;~, ~ OOIl!6m1iiaJrif .. nli~, of' it~ 'flu: 6'llIlt :['0:1" ,o:1nd,oM :re;UO:il!iii" md 'the ~cQnd ~UK wiC~~'D~ i:s ~d. all 1ev&.rh!O;~' that.

" , t;,hi!liii;;; , '", ',' , , 'n.t ',- tiiii=1iIfi;"-"" ,~~,,= . .-I -,--~,- '[f",. 'hf ... ' ......... - ~',- ... ~.- ~ d' 1.-." ~ ... ' ,: .. In'5y"'~O:IIS m,ml-r"~' !ma!~~'l I~ ,ag~nl~. '. '. ,I 1I,I!U!I~.u, IDmlIl,er--' I " ti ,5'~i!i U. iI;;]I.

'~ .• ~ are ·m:atl.llllll~· ra'oOO" and if'tnP'V do erit dJ~' ~ ,stI~1 n3!ill!i"llill~'

'~-~-~-~----~'- .. """tl" 1 •• "- -_ ,I -i.'TD .. -J._-- _, "_ ~., ._, ... =-=i'!'=--l' .~- --------~-~--:~'~ . .,.

:good.~ ailth(H~lb, 'IDey ba.ve' 'ooen oonu.pten"

I' ~-r~o-.-~ .. ''''9',;"", '''''"'''I'd' I 'iIo'~;;f; r~i"'i ,,"IP,",,, ~1;110 :'" iDOi£<l"'~~""1 '.;if:.,,,,~, :'";0;- ~1fIjI;'" ·rn;;.Ii~;fiii"" hi, ,U~J.[~ ~~-lJ~ .ll~ c_ UI...:II lhiI..It!.IlI. IlU.G lUI_II IIiiIi lr-.....,,..._J ... ,v., .. _1J UUII_RI. [_1111. ~I_~_~~ [Il'~~r'-~~ __

-tfilUn..rl~ rs~_ilaF t~, Ihat· ,0£ 'manv Cbiristimu., .M mam~' Chrrisuans ben~·

9/. ".- ... ~,l(,- .. _ .... ----~ .. [ ]1,' ._I_l._. ~·.·. ~.~.~~ . ._!". --.-.-~--~.~- ~~ ....

rthIt -:-c:"'~ ft'·, dv~ W' 'hrl!l!ma1l bciln~ and mat 'to God MJI 'maiOV l~beraJJs believe'

__' ~, ~_~e 1_ . ' .... .._,."..,..,'" . .. .. ! ' '.' ~ . . _,..

,m-t '.;-:"1 .;.-: dt,-::" to ~',qiru.u~-: [1-: and Ilot ~\()I 11!~al'1 be:inmt., ,As, :many Cbris-

a ew. ,I.!i u~ .... iln!ILQ'c~ .. ~ .. , --- --- ~~. - - ~'!D'"'' . -. ----. J -' .

'Ii an - ~, ,th~i:r' ~1iit":F on whait 'dii~ mke: to be ehe nahlJ.re: of God· Ml' maiv

_ •• __ ~ __ ~ __ ~ __ ._.~-~' ~ •• ~ __ ~_' .~." • ._. ~,,. • __ . _. ••• • _I •• , _ ... , ••. 1 ... _.-~. - . l------'J,'

libe.tms, baH ~e~ belld's; o;n w:~t 'tJbey' ,~, 'tQ; 'be b~~ nam.R·" And ,3$ 'tIlese: G~SI ha~' to IC;(;1)f;\'~nd '~tfh, dl~' prQ:bknl ufm~. ,50 'tta@'Se' lilberab!

'... ' d ';:.iI..,"' , 'Iar" __ " .

,IIi/ave ito IC'OIl:'b!n M'u!!! Ji1!l sec..tI!...: .. ..!- 'VeHWI!1!,

~ :0: ',; d !dJ::,., - - ~I;mii'i~ ::i I d1iat Ililt'f;: pre~leli1(!e af ,e¥j~ 're.m.il,u :om eri'l

,con!1 .~ ~U' cF U,IlI! ....• 1,· .. ·· .L ~ ~_ -. ~ ---- ,-~

irustiIw.tioIt$ i,p;g.T~ fie' ,l)ibVi,(j)~ q'!!l~~QJlJ ~J how i.l1!st.IDt~HO'nl MOOnte ev.it ~e.,~r i~m~u'JO'n~, are I~J depen& '~Il 'the :human, ag~,'ts, who [CFea:~~ ,and :pe~~~ mew .. :[f b~ ~ltits, ~ n3itDraJl,~' ,~~ liu~:n :bow'

".,'1..1 iIo'\., co, .. ~~ .... " ... : .. '.... .........i ';b",,",t,_ 'be .. ~;'ff '~ m' ... - mI!

'C.fiw}i'lI, 'lillie Ul_JIilUJ .. ,dJ:I'J.'!, giey creil~' g~, :pe.rpe'!ii~~; ",_} I~_~ ,~~' Ic.'_C' nu;;u.:

s~~, ,Q( hum. ·~d~.n~ ~pm. on, :~~!!ltj~g :1 tmwJU1JtiO:fliS;, 'lheDl hO'·w' cuuld, pm~xiwn,g ,~n'!t1tm!tiOJ1S be :~mprovedJ, er 'better :~timdnns 'be e.5tabn)lhed? If :biwmMt agyents, :u-e' ,~ lDuc'h :ilJt. !fIle meFCY ,of :in~t1mti:of.i~, as ~bese I~~~ :inl)P~'f. ~~~ bow l(loulld ~i1xrails 'rBemKI;ves, l~ave ,escaped 'bei~K ~nfluen·ced ~' ,eVil 'in~timti"O~s, '00 ,m, e~re-I1!ii: ;mfli:d~nt to 1.4)iOi;"'ifi'~' th~u;

" ,L." ." ,. '~1 ' ~= ="J} __ ~- --- .. ._. - .... -. ... ... .. ~~ ....

evlil? :If :~l .~ :pouiJble toOl escape 'the ,eVi~ :~n6I)jenC'~ ~r ~I, ,~mrltirt~~Qns,. ~.~Ii.i, how' CloiuldJ. 'C'jJ:llti!fI!ued, ad'b.cr.eDce' t~, UU~nl not ba.iVe :m:methilng' 'to ,do, ·wilth.

""I- .,., "'III ..:I! co, co, ~ '..... '" co, '" ~ A.,_ Al

UI;~ 'i"W~X1ISUi""O" ~iIi DlI-1UOin:s 0:1: !bi.'!Il:' iElia.:r"U(;iIi~!tI!liliC!' ::HH'!;mbi. .MJ'IU 1I!ft:R'

l~_I_.:::' ,~,.~--.~--I~_:I.J--e ['.'.''' .. : -r,.;,r._".- -'.,,' .. ".1, .~-" .. It,r. ,,----r----1-D.' ~"""l_J .. ; . '_I.-_, .••..• - .... -.

~~, disml~hi'Ons abo 'me 'pu;d)wrts, 0:£ e'l'iil 'iimtiiltllti'on!i And if: Dev' were·

.... ".-. - ·,r"'-'·· '.' . ' .. , 'I,'" , ,', ,' , ,'.,-" , .. "

how' dild, r~' i_~:sdJtuti1llH;5' beioOlimC ed~'

'T:L,"'_..:II .. 'I- i1t"L..._~,'I' iC..,:~'i.. • 'i' ",_.:I, hu .. 1-. "~ .. -b'~ t"... ....

J!.l.l!l.bil.:li~ Iui;~ ~~~I! iIilI: :b:uiUIi. :1S ,I]:ot :m.e:R.l!f 'U'nsuppo:rU;ul I~,t' ui~' :a_IlA_'_C' :!lLAts

bw~ :incgnsiiil~n:t '~~, 'l!he,m ,a5 '~l[. 'Th~ racu ,~ tJr.lit ml, b p.:~,t in. :alill :tlit~:matn sodetin;; 'the vic:es I~f :!5eLfis't~~ea,~ peed~ ~~~fiI~C'~ ~,vr~,

... ,,'-- ". ~ I·".", I'!.. .". ·1Ii~, . '1'..:1 . I " .I'!. CO!. .•. .,..;;".", '. 'il. "'",... ' ,.1-. ...

agg,I.~SSt,on" pr4l!3WJu:~'i!< ,crn;eil~!!, anu ,!liIrl5PU:IO,ll, mOu,Vtilil,C: peofh,e: ,j~,. as IY;~'

.cO:.[I}ttaiI:y w~es dO', and 'boill, Vittuoes; and '~:.e~ may 'be' Otn:fiom(i;U!!l, UF ,-;-- nac'··liGnOMtl!!H· na('um1i :ad ib.a5i'e or 'lite 'lIX['o(h.!lc!ts of extf:~ inri!D.-

.RQ .1;1:.. ... . !' "." .. ,. , .. "!'" . r"'" ,... .. .... 0 ... _"_._ ~---~


cm:c~s .. It. cw"'ould be' mI, i.m:plau~lb1e' to cliaiml 'lJbal; ehese :r-iu:ts '~~~i~lr to b,~~

_ ~r

• '1",=,.11= _ ,_ b ~''L, iF. ",.:i... L. ~._..;il h T~ ',,",

'~l~Iil~~S5, :as, :~t, :is m . -~' 'Wle :iaii.,.:1i :iQ, ~~~mg M'~.J1ess: 1M, iI:~m.;, ~.~ t.~i,f!'

:b'-'J~',a: W;:';~.'ii;ri-, ""In!\!,' ~'!JIi~.Ii"'l""'(m"""'"'. l'I"t ,: .. ~':r"~ h,. ~1'iWIf"'9i"1" 'L.,,;,:'iijli'a;'C, ""'ii"'!' '-m"lij"~'IIh>' oiIiofwlt,."~~-

--y","" ~. Ql!; ~,!(IIo.I~!I. ~I~,;l' Uili~,,,,,"~ ",""~II,'I;A,:r J ..., IUhI!L ILlIilnalll~, ~u~_ I!IUJ 'Ii;i ~ .. !I;!'.J,iiU'!,)!, ~~l!,:!!~~

ille:nrt.

The 'libe~l faiilh,· 'howf:Ve[' Uatrers hilltma!mi~ '~r nasili'i'tiInQ" ,- tniiW 'C"C~-', ',C~,

~ ~~. ,-,~. L __ ', __ __ 'I "., i!" ,_. . . ""7 ""JI ,r._....·' ~ ~ ~~ ,!l "', """"7 pt'C1XI_Fe

,0;[ WOl!td~n;uw :possiJbj~iIiin,~ whille neg~ee~~,g the' 'haJrd f!Ki~' Ilh~t, iii:, CUUlOI: ,aooO\mDloo3iI~. ]t is ai, :srm:tiIme~taII :iiJil:sifiea'Q(g, tibaIt :s~'bstiliulres mJusii,o;n :['Oli' udqr", It 'Cm.'i:fiQt th~Q:rce :;r~doe' the j~tifica;ti;oD ~bta;t Ub~ml\S need :001"

~1i1"; . " '~iln' ". ':'!Ii~' "".,,.-.' . '.' , "-1 rd ,~:", ,-,-:-.'-_'l"-,,,~ -::. -::.4i.~'-- ,c'-I~' , ..... ,ij,:-, :'. I·" Jt...', .. '" ··I·,_ii ~~~!!:reaL__~g ,!aiU'",-",~!Qln,lP' !iliU., ~,'Ur ~I"Uilng ,1i!1,~uDIiIiI{!< p IUJ,~.aull5m\!i []g!l~'ts!, eq,~

iJi)"" ,Mld dl$triw!lt1ve j_doe as, bgic ~~e9i,

:U~oos, mav dE'D.V 'dniart ,tmPV are CQmm~ilitf!d t'O [llllIis iti'tb, 'l1i~~:' I"-'C-~'-:':"",

~ ~ ~ ,~~~~ ~ '~~,li ~~~~~J _~~~ _~~J=' .... ~ .. , - _. , , ,. .,. - ,.1. • , . .cry' mal ;GOon.

c~d~ tha!t. :5Qme :PJOO¥e Ubetail!i;, ~g 'file pMt. mil" bave' bec~ 'so (;Qlnnl!iittM. 'bu.t,~,o 'On 'ItO c'llaim tt.at ~ibern;I's do, not need ~t iF:- c ,-,d lhsat.'th:~:c_~ : be

~~',Il!I!'~' .·"._1 .1., .~. . ... ,. , ... '. ,QWOO~., .. ~~~~ ~ "ey(:~",

,at ~ibe.d, ,aoout 'the :fac.Q Qf evil all, ,myo;ne else. I:n t'b:a,t ~~ bmW'lfft,i"J liJbemls ,owe a ,reaso:flJ £0:[' i.UppoM~,g ~~t 'by :iIfi(;re~n,g ~\U~~o:my' 'they win. ,SI1'OE.COO 'in. 'mailinl'" e'rililess, 'pre_lent 'If' e\d'i a'Ct!I )IlS '~'';::''::' ,,~,~\,~'~~' '~, no I~:; .

~~. ~ .~ =~ = '" . ~_" ... [.. .... " . ". .. IlL. 'Wen;; _alii[[) , ,aill~~~O--

. " ~

,fIl(l~" !Jjbe~ :i'il(;Fe~.~g ;iliUrn1~o:m.y WO'ul-d, mi(3j'i1ie eldl ,m}il)R :p:ri~~nt" :S()I ~i$

,....,'n]§,nf~rIi"I· .... 1;'1i1 ,;<"'§fnfn .... 'i' ' ..... ~ W" "'l..;li;.( ~~I!';I...~~:lf"i n--:-.,.""dl '~f"'i'- 'nT~'4I __ , '~'f." ,"'"'"I ',;:i1l.. .. · .... ·' ....... 'r'

"'_~rr.' _1HI_1~._A!l-_ JVIlIll III.lO_.~I_I~.iU,.... ~ .. ·II,I_ ... _'U I. ~Il dU . = ,~~U ~ 1t"""~'!I!"L~i!1 '~~;'J ~~=~ ~_~~ Y1Ll_1~~

laiwd. ev.il aotio:n'!, 'wu~ :maiIolr rUfina~~(t:n~JnO~S" th~ :lliJbem1s ~,~I: still ,eltplQliu, W!b.y :1Ifi1;c~~ln,g 9.UtO:jlomy wutiiid :ntaiie ~ViJ1 l~u :PJ~~IlIt. Th.e lib...,· '; ~ 11 '11-'1 "h' t' • ' "it;. -' ··1.,:i," " .]. f· .. "'" ,.,'~, :";1[ :1 "'If,..-, . iii., ~~f .•. '.' , . ,.,,' i~', '~f' "'1;-- .. - '" '1i'-,." ~~L~m__ ~ri1.!il~L ~ tue (Lu e:xp,aocaJtlOIi1iIl' El'UJt Iii ,lh:~lr'iluS gl:5at'!.'OW ,Ijt~ ,iii: ~ey 'iJQ

11;0t belliH,e dli~t buman beojn~ ,atre 'ml~llml!lv'~ if ~tF'~ '~~e.-:~::-: tb~t

~~." ~. -"._"' I_I ..... -, ',!,-r- , .• , ... ' .. 'l ,!5'~~1 ~_,~~_~ - _~:eve ,~)i",

:liiil!llmarn :rn,g~s ,iH~ -b.w,and dtaf( '~~e5, ~d, w(;es, m3!Y ooth be ~t1~.l.lInJJ aDd 'basi£: dJ~n moew I(anuut smtll'i~ that illCrre~~Di' ~-:-ili~',~,:; --:-C'~: ~ -'"n-,'·~:

, ~'"I' -, I,] . . .. r . 'rr~ .' ".~ .. ~ . ~ ,~uu~).~o:m,r 'WiI_~ gwe

pt'.at~if' i(::Q.PC itO '~,""ue-$ uel! ~ailler ;~ope' '00 ''rio~, :11' 'tlbey' n:a'll,y do .Ftot hold, Illhe 'f31irlh '~n 'h'um:an '~,'O!Odliless· tb(li!l~ rb~(~'ll-:-h't to 'lx:t'-=-:~ ,th~t e.:-:. ,;-_ ~~', ~~~~ __ ~ =_~ ~~~ ~~---~'D" .... 1. .. ~ ._, I, '-'~J ···1/·,,·····. l~ve. :II lll'l.(:~~

:i'll@: aiUi~HJlOUl!r 'wUI ~11'Jlt ~n :m.ating' e:~t nu;Of.~ P~~Qt.,

11 'i'i..-.",.;I-" '''"~' '~~'II~ .. ,'II...Il," ~"ii'L. :"" :or".."Ai ~, :L. .... "':!'.,~"(j" '''.'''i''', ;",'IIt,""'i7ffi'ql.";--:-::;~. '~""~l" ' ....... ,-::;.;",

, .... ~~~;,"'" _'i!! ~... Uiil!n;]! L'C'J,!, H ~]ilU. 1M, "'"'iii..,. .,_; '~'"'I'I!!t·""iIO~ li~!u i!!HILGI, ~.~!t....,VC;::![I~, Y'VU!!I, ~~ac,

.. - - .. -" .'1l...'1 ~ '-, - ",'b ~ -~, ~i:., - ~, - ~"- "-, - . "';, " ,,;:1... '. ... '" •

(;-jOfiUiLu.,Cli' ilJr,;)' ''''l~;: 'Y!iI~ can, n"'g'litall~ 'Yllt::lf (lO;mnHjtme.~t Ito :1 B,C['Ieas1Il\'Q" ,a~,

.I"'lr- .~!,. ~

~,.', .... r 'I'.: .. - '"~'''I ..... " '.'.' .. ,.'!;, ..... ' (' ~;L..~, ]:"~ .... ..,....i1i f:"'~~'L ,·J""r;-~'l;, ~_d!1i~ ,~~-I,~I" '\, ,.ib..-. ,~,._"., !IIO;uomlr~ WlI!l.IIi ar: WliU!I,QU" rw~ ,~~!U:I!I, !RI1I"!lIl,. W,nl~n ~I, ![~~!I!~~!rn miC ~!I~~~

bon ,M' ,~,t;;-"'ir 'Iii:~ ... ~''''' <iil'·m. :.'r'~ 'm .. ,..;i\,·i'1l6.' ~~"!ill- ~_, ni""":"f~~I"!i("'liI',: :'C"":' ~;b..~:-: 1C:~'''C

""'-~~ -~ Uh",= =_~~_~ A , U'J, ,---oR"~-b ,,",,'.',~, I~ 1F1i~'!j"m"",u~ ..... ~ ~.ucy Call,

aclt~OW!l~dg~ tbart i.£ll:tullomy _fiSt be {;iiI!Mariled, tQ CiUrt.ai~ ~I!, w:lrui¢'h 'wiU fuurnt :~n the fi:vstnltlo:n ;of tbe.ir ,~m.e ,aim of' inOTi@"asing a'Ull:o:n,gmy' 'by i!rnC:rCMiIII 'iira:do:mii' '~il!Ia;Li)tyi!' ,F1i,lbi)BiJ p-tnF'"aJl~mJ _d d:buiburti.ve ~~ti~'

~ = ~ _ l. lJr.

m'~b m(i~F pnlidcaJ PJ~.

8~,po:se, h~[~ d]la!l~ ,tIi~s, :1'iIf:'St ()'~utiDn ~, som,ebDW 'be g~t.. h:.rhill~ 'dt~ t~~FaiIJ t-Q)w :ils :n;OIt, ~nd~en.silbl~'~ '0:1" ~rk3l~ 't&ere is, ,mme ,~tbe,r

lr_' F"'" ,r~

. ~

w~ ;o;f s:bowi[l{r dI~~ die.' 'IlIu~['Ie aU!tof;l{Jmo.U5, iil'C'O'I1lS :arl~, ,th~ 1ii!'D I-:_~-"'I m:,·~:

~·~t .. ~ ~'-""~~'_D< .. __ ., _I, .. , __ --" .. _ -,., " _ .'_' •. ' ~- .~-~

'w,i:JI 'k' .. :E,~ll if tllils were ;50 .. illhErn' lWi}u~d ~~ 'I!)c' _Qth~' lo:\i:eCIti:@~ w ·th.e

'tii'l-. ........ ;i '''"II1I;~:r' ,;i;Ilr-""li ~i'i...,,", p"_~'7",l ... Il1''''''''' lli1"(.',~"~ ~ .. , d. ' "'1"", i"'i"'fi''''~i"1"iko.' ,t,"'I': ,"',"",'iji;~'-'iIi -; -: ;: '-,-~- ,~, ~~~ ~!IL_~~ lI;.!Ih'lO!I., !li.!Ui'Io ~' .,."",l"tidJLlOiI...,"'" v'J. ... ,,,",,1.1, ~il!. ILl,""" niUUiI~ilJ 11100' ... l'l"l' .. ~i!I'U!.:.llnomn'll!

;ru::nUtiI$., !w.'jjm~ fat m,ti' saikj!:', of ~ent ~]U'it Ii:hjs ~F :is OOfl1ect, 1'1:. fo:U~ f~otm ~t dial if IIlO~a!llj[o:m'om'O-Wi!, :3ounl!1is, ~R' ~e a~i©:QI)_gI):U$..


"11~ ~. hi' ffj'E'I.\\U' '

'. ,:,:_:.' ~,:. ' .. ,,,,..' ,'., ,,:,.'~,',;"

. "l ..... l .. ~ ..••

.. 1.,_.; :~:'~';l ~ :T',';I~ 'L.. .... ""\")~~ Il~", .. , 'P'~~'7""~e' ·o:o;t: Y.'hA' ,.r;o:1hi<;'o ~~"""'1'Ii I·'''' 'li'iir.,.' .. , ~1,.",";r-<!l' ,is a

iY:!,'Il:!1IiI, ~VI! W"mll! ,'Ii,LI, I.JGU ,.~~"'" l"",~ ~ .... ""' .... tidJI ,ut. , . '"' Y,U';J w"-"" ••• , oiJ ~!h~I;' 1!loUt~_ ~ ~ _

I',:"",-,-;:or;u . i'iIfii'·tli""" [..;i'I·a;-~_ 't: ,,"~~ ~'h';iIIi !D:fl.,.nltU!JI\o:> ...... '!l'<;'o!"'" ,Ili,;{ th .. , ~ii~~ralI, :£3!i:i:b, ilhari:

[[""'&O ... ~~ "1iuJiL"'" UIJ;~.,.I!W..,.1 , ,I,~ 'V.c.,'~ ""' .='!i.. '!:!iF' ~""'!L"! ~,~~~ .,__~ ~~L",," __ ~~ ~~. ~~ ~ ~ . .

,.".,.~,"'!Ii,;>;... , .. ,'Il. .• ';f; 1 iii''''~ .,.,.;11 .... 1 ~ 1Nrriii'i'i" i ,t:f) n

·1J."IJUIaIL~I:lJ tJ.Illl_~JJ! [I_~~'~ Q_!] ~r',r- ~-~!!l~ .':__.~~!'l'

T~e b~~,~ltd of'thb SUJP1'PO$IIU.Qn IS, :Ii, sode:ty -l'D, whri,eb ~Il is 'p~ lewt 'beCaiDSe' 'lillLalm.:y peo]pb!' iiw~8' in. ~t ,u-e' ,!K:UIQg· nOffi!ault'Omo:moll~~;'. The '_y 'io iJh.e mom]J ~mptuRmltlJ;t, of tlm:tt ,sta't],]!Sl q~o i'S t'@ ~.e d1c'!5e poo;pl1e"s ''''-:'~:'C''if",;f; iI(IiIO""'~' i"'.IIIi· ..... -:-~m'"A'.jIi"'. 'Li-!''i..:,' ... ' .... renuires p,.r~lt~n"'.· ( '~()'~l.:. Ilri :a. 'nA:!ilI,tioiUJ to

O.b!U~~.LL_il! III_II_L-"IU-.II~ A~tV.~ll.I~l __ V.-Ul_~'tiJ '!1r.tl_tOI~lll ~~,~~~-~ 1_,.L~~~l!l!lj ,r-'''!''''l''-,[Pl'''!~ -- - ~- ,F""!"!"~-~~ ~ ~

irnp~ 'their ~LUlai;lll)'.n, ,and uli,~mt.a:nding of dl~' ,al)t~maii.~ :am.u,ug

b'" b ~,,,"" ~ Th rb~~'~1 ]'" Wa1: ';'~I . . dil' '.'' -- -~""h

w,; 10., !OlI:[ey ,Cain cnoese, .rne ~I~]I! ~ ~",u:~r I-'--:'::~~ i Wib ,!ilP:P'~c y :acoompl!5i I I

tibih;, end ,il! no p~d!e mo~ f[,~do:m~ ,eqwal~tr'" :rig'bt5" pl!JilraU~m, 3im;d dJi~,

.iL.. to, '. h '~bffi b..J; ~ ill -'I 'biT f

If,l)u~]lU.ve' ,j'ustic'e iU~ w,;u, aWiii aeee ~~,'Q:fe. :lIDr ':~~e ~it ~:a ~~ll!ty' ,O!,

~~SC: basic Uibera!l '.ues ~i!!i, iii [o!l:nditIion ofareatetr :a1!I.U0'l10:ml1V,_ S~~nl'1iji'ilse 'il1:a'l.

. ,t.... . _ ,_ -.... . . ... _ _ .. , ~~. _ ~ .. ~,. '~ I .• - _ "- .. l - I. _. ,- • ~ •• -._____j,1 ~ ... ·~·r·,r.-·~--·· -- ... ~ ~

.. ,'L. "Ai ''[ ;t'1'L. 'I,"" iii. '" .. I'i.. .' f

!Il;u'IS[ 'WaiS! i!J.@;Il,e"',Iii,l.ia.t WO~~, ~!I:aip'pell L~ ~!!_ait soc~etf'=

,Bc€'O~ tb~, IDii~ralI, ;fill'Liq' 'wa_s, put in place, ,~,ru W3S 'n'rlelrOOcnt. Then t~e

[r~ ~ v- .Ii' Ii'

1Ii·'k.~ 'I ~I· •• 'II .. ,~A ~I ·1A if ""'r~ __ th· " -- tW: 'L.... ,~-.---

d!Eliai, po,ll\Cf :1\91 nmp, ,cmen,'IIIW, U\iI! ~U.oefS,i 0..;' 'Q~~o:m mere m -,--_i ~ g;!J,iIl.y

if ev:ij t~ p~en'~, ,jJJ}C' ,~[!I .cgl~' :fte-ed!Qm~, ,gwe~~~' ~,~iItJ'! :$~~g,~r' l'c"-;--lillSi ,~ '--:-":.~=--:- '--:;ll,[-,-[r~;:f ':;'-p·t"OIl''''' ~~~d '1U@:I'[e reseurees ~M~tlo;h 'i~

ngl· 1:a,.n'C er P }Il,~lro.t ]I~J '0 Gi"" .1.." '5, , ".. - -~... ·~=·'D-- =--

:" ,.,fi . .\I;:'t.,.:i;I~' u", '. ·'usmC." '-I·:" '"Ii ";,,,.j- '-', .. 'b_~~""" , .. iI!..IL.-([ , .. 'b.-::: 'c-:::-,'I"[ - ';"I,:'ld: '~. __ .:L~ ,.,

nr~Y, 'Ill .. nll!oJ!!,I!luU=¥e ~Ic~_.':._ce" ,_~ ,II~. ~O~. OI)V,U;J~ UIi~iL Ui!le irCii!j~ '~' WQiI))il!c. ~ 11,!.l1.~1!.

:r ,.Ii

~ril bscemes mOtt,e '"r::evale!m~;~ "fifu:, 'I~ben~ n{riil1c.~' ;in'!i'nl~ weak!m~r!iQ" exijst:-

.. ,_.~ , __ r.·.l_, .. t .. ,mr.,l. ~. __ r_I'_~.rll'! l l'r .• =L"" .1'_ -~r·"I.'!"'-=---=·J. ~l"!._~_ .•. -_ .•..• ~· .• ---L~ _~=_~

'"0 -;-: ciur,bs, en iiV!\fi:nli@;'s 'COflduct H~w' ;COM I d dl!js: [Dot' 'l!ead '~O ~'IlCl!' ("Te;a/teli'

:I . ,g ., . I IF-~F" .. , . 1. , ,... " .,. . ... L , .. .. [ ., . , ..... ... ,DI'""". __ ~[ Dl, .... ,. U

:' ", ," ,....."., '","1," 'Jb"' c-:~ )lii,,;' "'l'·"""'.l]',·: .. 1'4 -::: ,-=.' --'1-,. ... ':-:::,-::: '--"iO' 'c; ~'"'[i::j :-...-~~- -'IL., :--.~-::::c .. ii. .... , 8lI!:.'O~ ~'IJ evJ.l, ae . ons. ,nlJlmfl, .uou '~!' l!LU.E: CU[[U\:!I, 'WeFe: no ... ,~Il un:ilaI, If 'e..LI!GC~:~"",

befh:j'it.",:, 'b'm,t 'weakcil~i~g' 'them f~rit..b~r 'wiU ~1Jr.e1~' ~O:t aIDt'e1l" '~e ''ri;o~ lihat ]~ad '~O'nil~ eo '~do:r:m eyj'l a.c~O:il5 T~e Hjbe~ ~lk~' w11~ ~ust 'make lIt

,,' , , ,r'~ ',r ' ,. ,r'~' t ... ". ,., , • ,, __ • , ,.~,' .. Ir'~"~' ~ , . .)II .. ·", =.". ~ ."

e~ier ('011" people' W ac~ 'Q(n. rme~!f 'Vi~'es-.., .

'- -iL. ..... ~ t -'I' ,- .-!Ii.' ",'I to, ",b'" • _. 'Tb. ":UII 'h

LlJ~i~~S, 'Wi! j, liili,.:iIil:Jfi'31iliuy r~JE'Ct iU:i]i§, Oft:U£.liSmJ. ,I, ,Ii~r '\4i.Ill~ say It: 'iij,t :11;0 :t:'[t.'fat

~~aJb~e iiibeFal [ever i~Ylp~d thlatt :fir-eed!Q.m" [eql~W~nty,~ :~ImU!~, phu.'a~~m~ :M;~d, disu,jib.~m-e, j'[gue,e sho~ld, be ~O'rided w'i~U!t, ',~Ial~fie;arti~g" T~ey WilUJ ll(li1oJt out ,th~t, '~e Uibe~ ttadl~riQl1I h~ ~~ys beerc. ~~~~y C(Jm-. .

..:I' • • ~~. to, ," to, . .1. "'~! '~II b 'Il",~· u,

[o~rjlU~u notJu!!Il 'WJiUil. ~m;cRasJu,g' :lniiJIIrVilUlm1l~ ,lliuj'ln~')J1lV,y' ~M.t ;j,-!Ij1!3ij' ''WIih~ protect:-·

'~1l8· .,e PQten:iia'll vi€:tiRils, of ~h~' miwse m,auto~~', IrtI~~~tl-i :!"!tiJ1J:O~G\my· 'by j~cf~iiSing the :i:~dGM![ ~CfuUi:lJJ rilbbi,~ plD'mli\sm~ and di!!ltnJbuuve juslice ,egj~d, by' :indiviA)~;ds[ ~~~t.;go '~md, in :~d, 'with preve;o:tlnl '~ndivi;d-, '~J.l!, :flrom hl1:te.ner:in,e:: '~till :t'he exercise of,a'tu,~mo;my by ~Wl.e~, A..D[~O'nQmy~ 'li,~~b[ wiill '~)"" -i'5 ~Qit. ~k¢n'R t@ d.g Wh~~f htdi,~d~b ,Ie~ but tt) pU!~' a re~~a;bl\e Cil~(e,ti:O:ill 'of:a :g'OOd ~~t 1"11 :I, WdlY Ulat dOO$, DOt

L'i";'"..:i.u.if :'i'"~'L.-:-if1". 'f1f""'"m ,Al~ina I:it~'":"wi",oif"_ li!l1t .• ,.,~lI! '!.o!'~IIi!:::~!<!< ~ 'I;.-!'= U~'"-""!D _~ ~. L..~~

Tha~ ilik oo~ce:m h~ b~e'o, ~d '~ an ,abldiQ.g one ;of Ube~5 :is~ 'of. 'e(lJ~'.! ~'" What h~ :P,Q~,~tI, :~aID~-ed :~ 'the ~mf'~I.~Q:n the p~etb5e ,~f[-:::_=':"i~ 'b.a5, 1"0\[' '"it 'mf~~1 ~"5, ~ldtimOWllM'_"d to '~ 'mr.[~V'i.d~~~' lind 'ifdil~ 'Iibenl~

0(, ~. ,. ., ." I .• " .. ,., II , ~,"" ~ .. ,J"" ~., , '-' .. , , .. I~ .. ,~~ .. - .~

:fa!itb ~ :not. '~eld~ th~n :~t m~t ~SO[ !be :aGmowJe,dged, lb.at m.akiim,g flo.n3.Ui"

'''II '" .'11 'k·1 t1h ~;1-. 'I

ml1u}(mou;§[ ~_ a.ott@;[l!s alUitOInQ'm~w 'Yi1J....l mau!.e evl'." H'tOf(:' Fali~eli' ~jg ,teSS,

',~~nt, be(:a~' rut wil~~ :glw' F---{I!t~!t :SCD~ 'liD ,~.I iictjo:n~" 'fo :Pf~veO!t ,~~


ApI, .~ [.;' "Md' lifm"

_. ii _-. . '. .. .. ~. _,.. .

_ ml.'c ... ,',t .'.:"

:from tUlififi¥!n~njj! ~ ~lbem1.8 Mutt 'be: 'n:m~~d to [Clil1'ib both mnO!~nro.n.

l""'! ---,r,~-'W'!!"~~~~!!! . __ ... _--, __ . __ -J l ... ,r "lr-'~-' -_ ... ' _ .. _. __ - . __ .. -_. __ -_.

:m,Olil,'lr ra1iid, auml'u)m~~ ~, ~pil", If'[~ g, ~.e:mit ~, cwdid 'will, :ha~ w[ be ,C'IJ).n!!!li~~'., And l1b~ir :in!iposldGn~ maitl!tenant:e'~ :and, enf:o:~~m;efIlt: amQ,wn~ of' OOU_Qie~ to a polley of' ~lb~~crtfiU~i1Ilg ~Uit()n(nli:f" f~e-

d:orn [~uali'" noih'o ,-p'I\,; ........ r."~-C' :~~~,AI~:!l .. ·~L A';;'_, '·'n;£'~', '('_'" "iJ..;I[_._ -! ,

:: I~, ""oJ,l ... ~I~,~t~ !",,"ti'~~[_!,C-w,~~-gm:li anu U'loHlIHI!UU!IiIi"!!I.JIII;IQiIi;I£,e ,L'llI',r t!ViI~F$.,

If' m~ :is nfi'!~r'il;1i1!nlli'~ [~Ii..;ll_~1l'I' ft;1i1~'.""', '.,.~ '~.l.)~""'~~ii;E, ~~~ ~;~, ' ..... '~"" ,~~~~)-.A _~ _. _ __ r~ =~t~..". __ "':ii '!r.'T"'~!il' ~~"'H'<I'!Io ~ ~.'IiIII)".~~ V'IWI'lI!. .Ii,," !I! !IlIwI' Ill!Ci ex,r""-,",""I

'~i'ir-, ,,'. "i'L. ~""'I" '1:"I!:- .... .."..~, ",,'::':;f!Ij;''':'''~-'.:;~_~~1 ~=: ~[I·~~·~=-=i ,~~,"'~'C, C'("":,,".;L,,,"·' ',,', ". " 1.iI1Ieni!' W.liii!I]i, ,In iii, dAlll"t'i~,m, mcl~L7f Ul_~W~., [~ ai, [lnQ"~~, fliILll:orI!ty ~,!nose acillons

aH;' DlfiWIy' aDC~,tabie gel, fm' who- awittm'omf~ :freiMtom" ~.tl1int:y, :rigl!d~ :plunlLimtI!, and, dl~tf.iilmm jwtkle ~' :paranJt~d, 'Whil~' dlc :1:\0- 'mamr'~mmo:nJ _,~Lri~_~' 'mwt1~-· ,-,~ ""11' tit ~~, ". f"1 " 1 d' ' ",,, : IlIlg I I [' '. ',,: ~,,:jty:! "C:''''~~~ ae)tlQ~__'s[ I.ee ~'!Io!~tMilence 0:', m, ,I!! [~i

wiU 'have their' eW~ [(jo:ndi~t, 'OIJItbed. SU¢n a ~l~' ~~ ,of 'C()~_r:se!' mdiea1~' at. odds, Widll w'hat, li.ix'rall r~tnr:iiC 'n'mmi~ But 'n [~I iii, 'n~t', [iil~"~' -

-. - .~ .- ._- ~. ~ .~- ~. ~- -,", ,- ~ ,' - ,_ .. "., ,. ,r'''' ., ". " ., , .V"~' ~~ -~~'- "" ~ __ e~

~enu to[ 'k' :no r~lila'b]~ aI~~~~'"

If II~mh, 'iiOO'k. th,~ 'A~;mR: 'of eviii scrnO'ua:ro,. ~~' '~wd ha~ [to :!tni'i,

~ -~~"~~ ~.~ -~. ~.~- ,~~ .. ~~ .•. =--=- •••.. -c=. _~ •• · ••• l,. - '.'I·~J _'-'~I .. ... J... _. -_- of

~j~g 'pOiUd~ iIhat, we:a!blll :~theF ~D itr.en;p1i,en. [existing' ~ 'o:n e¥ii ool]Lb.u:L :10 &ot~, l~~~ liberals ¢(J(f~IMJU~ 'flO ~~re' di.eir paUa;!!!!, as :if,~1 were' liot nrevalelil!t. '1be 'il!lldam~n~ r~n 'ror tlrub i"~ '1lih3!~ 'Ilih-:-"'

.. -- .,,- ~ ... ~ .. -~"ir"" --' -,,- ,,-,. ,).. ." .... ,,' '~'.' ~.~~~.~i!j;---~~ --·Cf

:faiil, ItQ R\~ th~, :in,'1)F.i~Ite.ncy '~e:n ilheir' :n~ ~m of'maling' ev:i1.1.6.S5, :p:.[Ievarcn!t. md, 'Ih.eir :pmi~ ,aim, ef i nace...a! ling' autQ:nQilI(f' by' id~n~' freodolBj) ,eq,ua;tl,lf~ .bQ:~, :p.~~!i ,Mtd di~l~·ibutive,jl:mtiu.. ]it. is tnu! diat

1;~~ii~ I ,-:___;~c~. I:, ,-. cllli I, (iii, IE- ',"' iIj~~ ,.,[I~ r- 1~,~_:.Jl·rI'::··I·· ,-,' ,[11 : " .~ ",:':"' ~ ".-.iIII!I'II' " ':"' . " . -. ," '": 'I I·-I-I·t~: -I ," .. ,,·.~l , .. ;~

d!J"l!;;~,~!I! ~ ,po ItA !IO, !IOD !llJnC11" Y!ill.UI)u,Ona, a1iI.u, ~1L'GD;POr.ar.y (iOlnUlil!lM1eOi!l!, ~

oot:h, ailms:., L]bell" ~noonsb.~~1lq;, bOW~VeF! ~I moe' jo.j:n,t rcal!iHtiu, [of' 'ih~iIe ,aiimg, impo$$ii~le.

'1'!b~u' are two furrdlelf' nnes of dereti~, Illh~t :llJbe~s ,may' UJ" [to ~ntaill, ;and, 'wh~ jifii~g,q n.cedi, '. 'be .~, The :fl:m :is [~O cO'J]cm~' Ith:at

, I 'r..... . .... .. . ... . . ".' ' ... ,~, ..I .. i:!=- .. .JJ.=,.dI -, ~ ,.!L._ ,-.- .~ ~'~'f~ ~;'L __ ;ii'· .~, ,_<1·'.· L -~-~--~..:Il ' .. ,

aU"",l!I;omy cann.o" ~ !!iJIE'Hi:DulClO: as, U1i!: l(io.rce (1, 1.!I~K;a q;RI.~ ~~~~Cn, '~ not

m~, ~t ,~iibe"~ ,H1;~t ¢e~' m' 'vailUe' a\lmnomy:~, on;ly ~lDal, ~ [could, no ~,o;.ter :~:ly '0;0: it to p.r.ovi~ th~ lur.ii:lameQJtall Fe~.~ why frceOOm.~ ~1~Uitd!l·'

~sm ri.iphr~·. ,.···~i"~,..'iil·;· r ~ .. , .. ..:ii [d'~l' ... ·ii..~~·;''',·,~ '·I····.·~,· '1'" ","" 'L..~ '- ..... ,. ~,-ill~.~ ~.-, 1"'.,.-:

____ ~, _ '!l!lii--lS~ cq.'~-ty", a:nu."8tnu.l.iI~ ,JIWlLU ilR'i to U'IIi'i ,~'U~, ,!J$ Iyl,~

iI-. ..... ~ ... , ,,,~:I~~"!> .. _ ....... ;pv ~,,,,,!I:!' "i'L.""i"'" r--...Iid "a'''~.''''''''liIi'f'<m.U' ~"!",, :0'1... __ ,-"1..,_-:: b .. c· ... - ... ~ "";c, ,~ ... ,lii:i"~ 11J.lmi.l...,. ~d:lJ!II-II~. Jlll[lr~1 ~""'f !UJ,~LllI. ~-:: I" ~~y.-'-~~'.-'1 ~ U1-~~ ~~§r 1~.___.C, '~~}~I'J

mID [~mtiinp' ~Jt, :rr.nm the nr!iviJle~1 rw.,uO'f] ~t waI[ ~"~ilii!lu '~D11W]!i!t 'Iii)

~ . ~ ~'.~. -~-~'iO---~---- -.~ r--'="'~"';""r~- , .. ,_1 , ,. ··r-"-'·"-~·""_l' ~ ..

OOCiUPY:' They WO!i.dtL tIttorcb)" c;o:nud~ [that m(iI:~iing' a'I!l!OOn(IiR:Y' g~~d [(I,ot ba:ve' 'ifiHn:ft;IV' Th~~co"'~~..:1 ,;:Ii.. . .il._ . -]~"..:I!.-.', .. ''L. ,i' 'ft'II"..'lriiHi;i'V' ._·.lJI '11·" ,-.---~-, ~[- ~~,. -~ ,F'-'-~ ~"-~i" -,~-qr ~~[UlW!, u~e.n acN~,0W, ,~~~ Wila)!. ,L'~~"'6 ~"",I!I, ,l~ p:~

'1~l'li.' .. ,..,..".1,..1 - j _ .. ,~-1l!I-,"- ""i'ii-~:Itan·- .. - - "~ii<""n - m~' '~l~""" i~l" .' .

"", l, [!Io.!uW.(lI, [u,u, ~~IJ~i!I' ,.!'..","1;~. ",.,.' ~~~I~~~'-.g ,aU!!I!H·.,I!!I!O~y" ,II,u,cy Wlbu: aIJlliIl!:

~hat w~ 'hu "pFilcority, is t~ ,(;~te a, SQCiety.' liu whib:!h 'tih,eR':iJ:u :litll~ ~,

' .. ' ... ..1 ,110" ·m·'.'.""'!Il., ""' .... f.· ............. _~ ,~.~,111.~ .. .,.... n'lkr-=iIi"-.--. "~'.D\'b,;i,a, ~ .. ' ~~ .. :i'·tv ~,··.A[ . .lil•. t-.o:i".~~ ,IA.II&!, ~ I , " .u'LiIi~, .. uru,n'U.Ii~,r~~ iU[~~';I;~ rI!Y!I.~~'!!im~ fil.fIi~1IJ!Il;!i,! 'eq~_l,,]~ :1![I,u; uJ8w, liu~

~ juBic~' u ~ble'~ And. they ()ouild, oonwlentrly' hold, dmt 'wnr:king' W .realiK iootb, ~il'Udr' n.t.iVc and tileill' ~J~ ai.~ m.ar wel~ :RqJuire' ~t., :~n..g' ~y Ql\ic' of't\IiI,e buic '\!a1Ues in order 'M inCRaH' ,th~ ,~hanC~I, ~f [th~iT

• • .". all II] .J.

"'":.1] _" .' I l " . ,'-, " n "'I'J l·l.

JGlJ!li( ,lYe. llaJ!!l,[(]Uil.

This vi,~, js: f-.t)a.iOfilable tHld :Ube~ ,e~d, not: ~, it. If tlumnom,f' '~re' r..emcwed, 'ium '~U[ nriviJPQ,ed 'Nl!!!itmn, Iih~n ilKr.ib '~uild n~f"d '-, I: ~~. ~

... -- -~~-~-=--r' "~'!),r.-~L ." '.. . ,,' .",,,.:anew


,~r to d~e q~S'tiQIIl 'tb3it they "revia.' tmswcrm, i'l'll t@ir:rn1S [m' iAutDUi"" 'D:m,y~[ tIlruat b:~, ''Wih,y :re,pd dte 'values th!l!t ~~be~, famr' as, '~L~'~ Th~ pre",'" '(If.u ,~F '~ iQhBi~ 'illq' ~ l1:ec(le~ fQ:f :i:ncFeeL~!J ;iJiu.w~@:rllr Md, lim,a:~tn,!' ;al1t1Ono:m.y mIDI :have :p:finfiqr :in, :Eli, I~benll! ;~ielJ. hil ij":~n(:kc~~g ,aiU't:Oll0nl:Y 111.0 lOI1i,FF !bas pntlfllty, 'Weill wh:r r.-e,pd, ;!il!ukIm~w,y~ he.<Wm" p'lm:il']lsm'j :rig'h'~ equau't¥l ud di~b~Wm: JJllsti~' 'u '~i~ 'vallUE!ilf'

",h~ pP:~or~ iQf 'c:o.~" :~, [i,ot toO' '~.x,'~i$ dou!b~ ,aloout. the importance 0:1:

~; .... ~~ "'7"'~~liI;~, j,.,:IF'i' [i'.n[ "'Yrn~;:;:, ,d!n'iiil'iif;.."'''', 'a~ iL""'ci'iii '~i"r, ...... , 'k~:rn(l' '~IJr. ... ,_~ ,"'l""" .1.."", -"''''~

l!l-_tl~~ ¥Wu~~ ~~I lLy ~~f"",I11~.~ uw.· ... Uy [ 1_LKl-W!1. ~ .. lln.k_~ LP.CIJ,.,--o ~I~ ~"~Ii.1 ~,., IW;"~ [~III'

,ik_~ .. , '"'':'''"I]~ n .. "'~ 1Ii'~'~i\?' ""1!!IIi> [n'l'.lOQV"n·'hi" : ... -.:1 ~<r , ... ~;iI~'it!l;!' '~"''''' '" -::-,,",~i1i~;~~ ~ ~",,:"'c:: ~,~ 11'0;)]:"" "',"'" )U"-'iI!. ""Jiil; ""'~'''''' ,r'.l·'!IJI-r-" ~"~' 'U"~iIO,~, ..,.n',I!liIJ"l~' ,F"""""'I;I,,"~, ,~ ~'I;C~~.:y ~nvwmg-

lfR~"I't, ~e"'i~W !barllllln-"'''' and 'il~,,',~1..:'d· ,'I'nO!1R"";£'1I' nAil ", .. '·I"""'~r.it~ ... , .... ,iI' " .... ' , .. 11., ....... -

I I I .~_.._,.:~~ ~ ~".:__1~~"'~:1:~1! -:_-~,f:[~-~~~~ ~~.-~ ,~~~u~ - lll_;'~r.}./'!Ir.~1 ~~U. 'J ,1Anl! I ~1-lI-~f~ ,lW~lfl~ o;a U_I~

thu~lhlt fA by ~i_raI)s. as ~d' 'The P~F 'C3ln :1't0' :hl~iCF ;appeall '00. dI,c' oo~kibuio;D; 'tniilit, basic I~Km'~ Wbl('!;i!I, m* Itn[ ,Wll!t()jju):my~ ~i; pe:rtha:p' ~t oo~M aippeal to dll~ir (;.:g;m)trilbuti,QfiJ 'ii.D :good, :t),ve!i.

nalt, ,th~ b~(; 1~~nlJ 'q,lues are :i:mpo,11.a!n.t to good lives[ [can:nat be r~ K'umaJbtv ckmied. 'Tb~' proh:t~m :w'F :Ibenll~[ ~~[ ~t '~c same ~ be ;wd. of

lIiIimln,[ otfii~r ~tl.~ iiliat I~~~'II"" .~~~" 'Ij~~. ' ." .'''''i':'' . .fI ~ ,'b~~~,~ 'I: ~. f;i-. ... ,. ~;I::'J .'I';:j I .

~ y ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ _ ~~~ ~ _j~!l! ~ !j,iI!O "",0;1 ,regAII: U 3!i Ui1M,c" , I], U;lLt~, utlfilldng

aJ'OOUIt 'U!le8 as basi\(. 'C:Qmml~, '~i'be.~ 'ii.o :h.old!mg' 'i:lhatt w:h.~. '.ey' ~Q'nfllk!!; wiItih, Siili.c1h o~elt wllues M 'm~ n!t:ed ;a!bove Irh~n ~.e' bmi:c U'Ixf\aJj Vi3lhe~'

~~~~~~ _~~_~= ~ ~_~~ ~ ~~ ,~~ ~._~ c. ,~~~,~, l~c , ~~ ~ !' _ ~, ,. ~~" ~ ~ Ui~S

~ib~, 'lA .. ~., "!d' 'l~" . D, , ,t ' ~,'L. ,~ ~ .'1.. .. ~ ~ lid' ~iI!..,"~ 'i!..... ~ ~ ,~, '"I;i,'n. .. ~ ~ ~ ~.~d'~' ~ ~ ~ '''..J!

~.~()ULu, ~r.neiliil.em., uU w,uo/ i5l1ltUlt: 'lili!liIiS ~' Il(K"",lIIY ~~:~~~: ,ill (lG'IlJH.!;i{er'"

able ~H;Cr.-ease' in :~bidi~~e~· not j"iu£ti~ S'OtJiUl:' :[Ied)tl.i:li,{)~ i~, '~Drnili~Hj?'

.,;"!~ I. ~11 F

''Why could the p:re~Mo:n ,0£ ~ac~' :fil)1. be· WQ'nn ~liIn_g' SQ;ITIe :rightsr' '~.y ~(Ji"lld ~Qj~!I:i:_n'iQg ;~ heail1thy [e1rviiro~men,t f:t()t; be m.ur~' :imponant; Ihm!i ~me' :restiioti,o~ of fmedom'~ l.iibeWs h:ave ,III;!) good ,anN~n, ['0 Ith~· qjue~tiofts, because !tBere are ne :go.od, U~H toO[ i);h.em.

,[f th~ U~e 'M d!eiemie' 'were ado,pled b)" ~ibeFaillJ! d!i,~' 'cuTIild, ,SUUC'Ctisnll.ii'ny p~~e meJ!f ~eg~tive. ari'~ oj' mdiJlll erill~M, pr.~l~l!it. PO:I" dll~ ,s:-m.'£icess~. b,~y,e:rio ,tliq 'w(nl~d :hax tl(J, 'pay the 'll1I1aC:c-ejptaiWe :p'ri~e oj ,;a;ban___oo~iJng' ~n, m.~:r' f~fll, ,~~' ,ari_lmlj, w'bkh :is w[ ~sl,('ilill:n ~I~l¥' ill, ,~~Q\f"

,A~_ ,. 'I;} ... \.. \.._~~: ~='I f' Eo ,.:11",- .,.,_iii· • 'L 1 ~'Il

UlMI£e WI!t ., mli! iDD:C 'vwlu~5i 0: ,3!'uJt(Jllo:m.y~, ,.!reegv.~, e',~l!ty'., :rt~[!ftl~, :,)Ub! m .

,~nrt an~, ,~Ii3~'7i1~J~~ J';ir~j:oi';;"';g.:~ iJ,~ ~;'b~'~;I·iI'p'il~,...~, :"U' ~'fio~~m.· ~' '~~m'l '.Ii:''''' .,., ... ,. ..... ~~~_.! ~~~~~ u_ ~ idi,[ll!lil!'~~·I!;; ~ -.:J!!I.I;""",. ilil. !li..u,~l" U~.~. 1Jid .... ·.,_, 0. )l ....... ~!l:... 'J ,11I,'!U ~ u~ .... 'I!,.¥-!.~!

~ ~ ~

the-ill ,they no blln,ger :b.:ave a :r"easan :1'::01" ~fii,g ,lti~~, vall~~, ~ 'b,a,si'Cj, aJilId.

[h,Uj 'liIq' Bo l\lnIcit, have' a .re~n f.of.' de:liimIilng' dt~r' ~JtJ,~~ ,~ Ill, t'C;rm~, ,of: the5e' _ues:,

Th-c ,~gi1i~, :~i'!lC' of dd~ !6ibeuli!i llI'la,' It!ry t~, :matiu.lr.:.Un is m iCU~cede

Illbalt 't!1u: '~revail.:eng' of ~ril ·p.R'SMt&, a ~rl ;;T~ ~~~.c ,;'bl.~ 1~1~1 £' e- tb '''I c, '.~ ) I

,r ~ ~ ~ ',~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ IOU pf(L~eim 1'01 ~. _ .eilf po81 ,o.n

'IllruJt, to ,~. 'that, ;aili, [pQlitilcd :mQ:~i~es, have dJa,t M, ,lin, [~,uaJly ~{)U5'

:,roblem, l'hey :may ai~ 'tDa!t. ;aU 'pO!lIi~cal mo~~~~ :~ '~~ '~.1ive ;aiiDlJ of mwng 'eW~ !~ :~ent , .. d '!lbe positive _m. of 'hinK'O:rMtllJ' :JQCie.~ 'W ooIIJ'hr.m. to 'whai~r hap~m. to be 'tJ..eilr '~i(~ 'v,a]i~,~e!!l. Md an :poliitkaJ, :mq~~('5' QVWjt. :fao~ dJ.e' i:m: mat 'tnei![' ne,ptive aind posiu,\\~ ;a.ims :m:ay' (l():ofl)i:c~ &O[ that. 'Iller oo.!Jl_'__M ~maike' ml, lESS, :p:~~n,rt, [Dnly 'by' £:(Im:~' :mi!!iiing' 'd!.~~r 'b.a!i'(; ~U~~, If 'I;hg 'were righJ~ '~t WQ.'J,dtl be unfair' to dn,gfe


out l~Jbe_mlism; ud 'cn!ticize it :('Or haviin,g' a :p[lobLte;m ,s'biar;ed by' ~~ :po]iiticca], mnra!liIn~.

Tf-lirrlll! '1--]:" jF> "", ;"iiij:' ~",-~~-,_ ~~'e[' ~"'t-;"', .... "1"1 ,"I i"~'Ii<';;> :"'.'''rn:nn-;fiI·''':''l'"'i1" 'jI"I;.,;3!o 'l1l~b~t.,.m-' . ,IJW,IIoil!. __ 1I[1,.~ u.,t UA.r.I~IJ~_~ lI,I,.v.n~·!I!- \ l~ ,IJ ~-;:,~ !\.AIJ_IJ a J.iiU~ I]U,t.\r"'_"~- )U.lUlIJlI.1 ,~,Iil~ .[rI,L~ _ .l~ , _ ,

~5, ;e(f~ly ~Fi.i(l(~ '!lilly :1'01' ,poniiic" mJ)T;WliJu~ '~:h~' ~~ 3lirm, ~m:cWude!!!1 dl~' d~5~rabl~i'ly of~al«(inin,g 'dIe 'CiiLlF10S, 'O\n, 'IWW!wan co:ndiu'et" ,I:t is, onily bec3i~' .~i~Qh~m b~ tltat :as ,p;art, of :~h, :po$iti,ve aim, mat it: i~ opeg 1/0 Ute, C:ba~ tbalt It :mlflu:s I~.~ ma~ mm~f.' ~ rue"M p~en:t.

There aft po];ir~ica] mor,alUues (soch as ~b0se of Ar.,ist:otle' aMid] UGb_s) Wi2it :h.:ax :n,~' faiidi., bit the' :nttmit,a]! :g,oodlft~ of: b~, bei.np" rec:op~' wt :mntl~s ~~ fii3ltl!llFRIly· mix~d~, ,th~t. hl;limp bejn,~ ~ ~Q m.cgfe' pl-Qtu~' w' d~lQiP' vin~e~ 'than 'Vices~, and ,th~t hillman, bei:m;gs shape insti!tutirOus ,jLmt :aB, 'mu£h ~, '~nstiIti)WtJi()iontJ sih~pe' ilie." ~h :pQ'~~ti:ca!l. Hloraruiti~ ''-!!rill [lO~

!t-epd, :It :as, de:!!iirab~e il4ll' Fenlo",e c;urbs, :l"roHll b'U~an, 'wndiu¢'L, On th~, ,co:n-: ~mryj ~h~~' 'wiU. III:u:l it ,ad~s.ar.d~· 't.D strnlf1;ph~~ ,t1l~ :iInStiitytlUDS 'tDat. curb ~I ~d, '~n ~o:t. (.~.mi~ the~hes 'to the ~u~ddJaJ, :pcillicy of:pmi[ljte:eJ~,g ~h~· ~m~' fucdom" ~CfuaIDiIty,. rig;hts~, :p]!UmIlism~, ad, d~$mbntive _j.ti~e :fOF agen:t9! wh,o habituaWlly do- e\-il as ~h,-ey do :['01" dl;~ 'who 'hab~.aJ~' do good.

'Iii'""'[' ,~;., ..... :L,. 'll('ii'I'I"~I· """"",II ,~.".~'I~oIi!.""", ~:L,."'!o n,,:,"~-110li"1"i"'0li' ~;:: ,0l!0'>"11 1I'i'~lil 1"1"""'.1 n-~ .. ~ ... ,jI; :"';0' r'_:;U"t 1 fil!!IA"-.rJl r'~~ _ Jl_ I~IJ ll"I~.,.V.,~_lIHj.;.I""'{iJI!" !IlI1,.~ 1J'~v.-:--.:Il~- ,",,-,-£ v.I- ~"'l.dJ 'ftilllJ, LllI,Uil1 ylJ IIq_~LI,ll ~

i<'o:>''''~'''.i<': ," 'Pro.I.'~]- ~"'i'i'", ~"'. it d .... ...,.,: ~"C",'I;" ~~iL:-~,,:,,<,,"'ll:"""i"Ji1 ,~.~'I,.~ ..... ,..;i""ili:o:.;,",:,,'llI'!!!Oji<" n"i""'""i'"''"''~. -j"i"1 ,"" ~.J lIUU_1i:Ii IR 1_, . IJ). ,.~~_IJ_1l ~ " U~1ai ,ILu~ lb.J~'IIl aJJla.I_lI_~~, L!r'r,l_li!l.T~ U-~LI,~LI~.t1.I~1J ~ rlJ 1U'!U6B.J. ilJlJ,1J [do

Oi)~mtlry 'w,a)!, .. Aood, '~~~~, ~[~f:alI8 d~ Pn:l(~~ i~ ,ii, (;()~~ '~y~ i~. is

!Ilot>;j;, iI]Dif.p1r1'" iI'_"", i4'I'~r::":"'" '.h""'m .. ' r':n]" ,~,L""'I·-I"" "'"","I!1'~~'~""'r:o'~. :::~..",'I,.:II'I·ih!' ~ • ...., .... ..,.,.IH'!' ,-:, .. 1;-1 ~!k~, ~~~.n '!L~~"'~L~ L!Il~ 1~~1!M- !lL~1!M-i __ l ~t~~ .. :lll~ _Il ~~1I11_...,....-,.,1!Lf!"'_.~.1!L-:J ll_1IJII_MlY11 __ i~l ~: .... ~"'r--- '!I""I!,lf!l.i_I:r1 U;;Ij-~

~' '_-

p~e:n:ce of: ~"

The 'upshot of the' ~!In>e~o:ts 'p:re5enft'Cd J~ dd~ ~wr is the: Jjbe~

:n ...... d1tc· 'lIill'!n;o:>'nlit" ;0;/ ....... 'n'~tU .... '1'1·iL.~~1 '!:Io~11IY> """'f:',' ~·~jl-~t"riJIDi' "'-":1 less 'p¥~:I""~~' ~:;fi ~~ lr·~~·~~.:..~b!b!~·~=-~, ~J~' ~!i~~~~.II!!~1 ~UQ'A----=- ~I~'~ [V~l l!_~~_~_~~~ '!I.-·'I!·~_l I"Iw~ = ;,a.'1I.i-!J.'Ml_j-,...~~J~ H ~nJF

oo!jlss~ten:t. 'wiItih, the ,pl~~' lilbe:nrl airm, !Of :,mmQtij~g' the' lilbe~, :pi!ilJi'ticail

b '" ~ d 'If 'I"'L.~~~ iL,~, 1 d1 ",'Il. 'L..=~:

IProgli'alms~ as,u:::: 'H~~I an'· :ilU'tiOfl<lMY"".' ,hLK:iJ.mi5, :aClMIOW $:I~ [ui.~ '()~i'"

'OlD k-ts 'idia/.f; «ri1, is p~-eVt3ilenrt aDd tJiaii ml!2idl o:f lit :i:s ~used by blu~ ,actiQU~ 'tilell 'liiey nlIl1£l; :i:msw;er' 'dl;~ "Illation of bow' ~'WiJl ootiJl~ be mad~' less ,,~~t if evi'ldoeQ ~ ~A(::(r~Faged, 'by n~. :fOJ~tkall .. P~~ i!lb~t inc:r'~ di,~~F frned~_ •. Gql1a'll~tr~. p'lurralhim,. 11 gb,m , and, dmtflhutive

jl~ti£c' :~d, tlWmqh these, dl~r ~lttJ)n,o~f.' .

T~~, 111".'L..·"'~;ll ~f]ll~"""""n'i' ii~, ,,.~j'""i\ilit-~r.ii~, .;t... ... 'i'!ri',--._~:_~;I:::_~, C::::_, (~f-' '':':7c,;l) i,,,,~ .. ~~·-lii-, ~ ~~--~-.,,,n,., Ii ,~Ii "" 'M!I.~Ut."'1; 11;'U ,,"JIOiU ~I!i!'UJI;,,", ~"u"'" t.".,eYdi.I,(liJ1lC~ 0 Ili:iV.ll, ~ 3iUi!li.O]],om'OU:!I,

~' .~

, .. ~~,-.~,- ·-CT'-;-'-;- .. -· ... ---c',.dI ".'~,-"--->----:- .. .jl',-~-,,---_.-_-C'-[ '1.. .... ..,----.-- ,.Ji'j ·c- -,- ,,.'i;.,---c iJ,. .... --- .. A-· '-1,-'-

,~~QJil5 ICaJ'UIQ~, aVOl:ou IU~'~ 'FeUI~«!U _' ,~a!UBe II;V,IlI. 'C::ftl! Yite:1l II,II!:;i iIn~e ,~eMl'

~~.'il - iiu- 'h:u 'bi - '" 'If "'~. __ ~i1i 'L,.

:'~'lI;;~~'C'O.t ;Qn~i ~i· em: (~!Qg aiutQn.omH~ acJ~)lOD~'8i, ,~. le¥l~ lSi p~t!l:;:¥.MeDit;. men

'lb.e c1l!rb5 mmt be (:;(J~spo,H;dlin.gly rncl-ensfiic. Th~ Ubenil] 3!il~r ,co:~s.eq.tie~_' feQjuirn decr-emng :MIther th~ LQueasiIng' d1e' e~te~t 'm wbiu '~.e 'baSit;; Y.Jlru~ and ii1iu'ito.:i],(Jmy ,.e a~la'ble.

:I'f~, O~ the olliher :~d~ 'Ilibe~:s; atltribuJte, '~e p~~n()e o:f ml to IUlI1UI!lJ:o;, 'i!O:fiOmDU!, aCMfi"iB. m~l1 'it.~' :mJust e'xp~~rr.~ :6I"$t, 'w~' ,~litcF--e~n8 auwnO'my'

,- ';-I.!I nO, ,[\,~.~, ;' , "'. . I' ,-,.. ". I' '1-" .' - u ."', " ' , 'L,.-~, -'" ,'" . ,,-' ". '.'

WQ'U__~, ,-;..o~ ~!;"""YlI~ ,In n,onautO:D,oIlMJm if ev:I, adilQ,I'I'5 ~c.o,mlm,g ia.lilitn:nr",",'

matuly' ~, lo1],tES, ud.~, ;~c:{)il.u;l~ w:l:ly :~~~bl~' :~plte, W'~ld ado:p:t. the


~llli(;im'll paUq'" Ilo 'whir:ih. this a~swelr [oo:mmii!ls :I'ilbe:ml1s\i' ([f :ltemovii\ig ~ui~ OitiJ ~oti~OOJfiQtfiOUS'~r ~I, ,a"tions; ~I!~ [Md(tf' '~o jna.~ i'f!llOllum[y" The i~)l~'Y' ,oofioe.i~hI!e exp'~ati:Qn :~ [Il~' :('a:iJlll [~t n' ~pl1i' '~ffi' :a:u!l~luzm'ous , - ,,'d'-] ~'ir ,'i>:- ...... ,- ~·b .... 't"'I'1 ':'-'."j"'- :,~:;-,c-,--~'·lic-.-.A_ :~:~,-.:- ,-::,---"~-;!s n-~-'F'I] ~~:5:S an" "IILe ~.£ ~I!..I'!<;ITii.tlI,V:-dI!UC~ weR l1-=-d-I!_~cu., men pc'(JP3;:: _ =~ii:!U! ,5~~CL ~

~"';I'.jIi 'i'1("'~~I.-'I_ ''1f'II;'''f~' [i.""..,.;i4i:b,'_ ''i-~''- •. "" ~.,-,;,..I\;P;I''''''n' ~:fItf'I"'" :"'~";"'~i>eooo [""'1"", "'-\!i""'~~ .... - i""

"-~U_ Jill] ,r,ll b!t'OI .l .I.lI11_g~1 ll_M.lJl !II .lil"V"n,",,~~lj![ll ill luj .. U,",,-11~ __ ~~, r'!l.r ~IWH~ I~~ 'IW ~ _~!I!~~~ ~

I=,~il, ;: wm '" _'[ :c;: TII'U:j~ir;--""_ 'I': "'1"'_' d,' , '.;~l'" [_III..·;i!!",~""'W"I!j;O' ~:"""",'~~ ,"'{"'d' r- l~",..;!I:;I!U, ,"' ...... ii~"'; .... ~l"" mt(l! ..... ' '!!it;) OO~Ii1!!!; ~."...Q~~ 1]", ~.u! .. ~'I;i I;;lQjl""~I!-I,~¥-- '$ Vl,.,.n"",lIJI, IIIi.U., ~~Dil!l'l 1IIi~1IIi.I.IIlliDl,,""

~d\m1t(:-4ll' ,Cfl:ll!tRdi<;ts ~,t"

Gl~ me' : _ __jlJiFe' ,~f' 'I1l;~ ~~~. '~e UbcraIJ prcdlcame:n.t: ~~.ck. 1'fn;c;

" ' • ,t ,,_' ''-: :i i I ,",'I!:o, ,", . 'II, - , : ',' , "~'_ 'tt"!" I'!-~' ~~, ':' :"[ I' '"iI1,.',' '- ',' " rt ", :h""l!i"ti""'l1_ 'i: iIj\rj'lo ",,'" 'Ilr""d' I, '[' ,Rex" is!II'f,P ~1lIl Y!~e a:~m.em[,", """ I~ [!IoGII..,eo] [1_0 ~;I"e ,o,a" a~_~]! ~S """" C(L~ _c"',

whcthm' it b :~b]e t-o[ e~~t ~, 'tme 'wri~~p, 0:£ :Iliibe'tail, '$iJIJJ11),~,iIJ, ~e

[~!~''r''l!Fr.' ~''"''V of I[-'ji'vh~a ~10[ :Oio'~]'"":;;d' ] 't;l:."" ~;IL..~"i"";1 P"i""..:I1." <;"'c"" fiIIIjO,';>;"-:" [i' uUlilii<, gIRO,,. U , • .:r'-'"~ [L'U ,gi"U'~ ,lll""- I~~~.:..., L ~ ""'U ,,"'-"IIIiIOiIOlc'!loiII!I,~.


·~ WT'~· a Ql~ ~~ W g~ ~PH~d. 'to the bad q,i.W'lti~ that !h.¢ :h!imRlF: ~ge$ ..

C~:fi~ide:r :fi~ iJihe' :pos~ti1Qn of :ti1be'I~b, 'Wb~, ae~QWledJg~ the pI~nt:e' of: ed~ ;attriitul!te :irt, 'to n(ljD~mm;Q~OU:S actiOIl8.~ ,~_il bel1ieve d~ait the w;ay I~n :m.ake .~. :le~, :p:r~~lt b· by .iin-crea.sin.g ;a:\!It'O~0:m)" IthmuJb blt'rc-uiing' :Ffe~do:m" plurr:aJ~sm,! 'eq,IlIP'ty, rigib:ts" ·and d&strilb.~ti~· jJUjti¢'C,~

Th~·,T--;-nm~ni~ in th-, '~F~C~4i~fF,'c'h- ~~~,'_I''b~.,,_~ ~'b~'i' .', "~' •. I' "'I''''I'~,'

_,' ~ ~~. _~~,_te p~e_'e'!;ill~1I (;~~ap~1l" !!l[1~'~' ",,]iU one SO'Uoce OJ. hile

bEiliEr' 'that mWn,g DoO:i1UlfU'tDfi.O:n1(J,u.!i, ~ti~ ~umm;(ij<JiIlJOU$ 'will :~e 'lbem I.eg, evi'll IS the' imd!efe:Il'.!lliJbl!e Iilkm :f:31illl~. Bl(I)t ~~, oolii!f ;a!lm :hm latIlO~.«' so:~rte;: ~lUtt ~n~ ~~~M 'k' :heid, fel,Pl~:d'bie ,o;lil'ty :£0:[" meir' ;a;UIWIlUllmum, aidi([):M, InSQfar ,g ~,-Elig ;Itt MlliautonoOl_ji)'uly" :they'do' IlO't. a-ct as, :res,poll.'" ~b1.e' ag.:ef:JfU! •. To, matt, DiQ:n3l~to:n,Qrnou.s action:91 autonfJ~OUS is thR 'm make thrir .Ilts mo:[\t: ,u5,po:ms.lfu]~'., T,h~ mo:m :~5,POJiH~jM~' ilhot1 ~~, [th~ marie ~,~' wiU be Op~l~ ltD 'tmrt ,~Il!~llh~,flC~ ,of mnrnllitF' ,!Hl,d 'the ~.~ :1:iti-1cY'

[I,' .... :' ~ '·~II [I-..~ Iii< • ,~, ,., ',·:1', ",' ,--:, I!IoU.ey Mill :!.,K; 1110 ,KI, ,In eVi. wa~.

'O~e 1~'fin~u't:l]rCe of"the lib::mJtifiaito:n 'of dl.e dO'mmn. o:f'allllmnomy' wiith, th~, domain 'of' :rces,POIl!!l~b]~i;ty :~ thaJl O'nl~t ;~u·~~~m()'W!i a;cjaM, CalIl :miiJj'k-e~ tb~lr ilg.I~:rl!~, Wi.cik.c.d. On. 'rmu, \!lI~, thf,:l' I~tiimarte ~~ptii)11J 'Qf-wlicbdJH;~

• iIllJa" '" 'b~ ·bl !fi ~' ... , '" '" 11) ·1b.1:

r~qU!I;I~ I_._·_':t. n~ ;qe~~ I~ ~~nuy~e '!.J'Qf Im~;g" M~O:I1i.!, ,~\!IJt. :res;po:n&I.UIi.e

,a,tiioJl; m~i; '~; atUlon.O$(r\.is" and ~Qt~g tt~l lhc' I~boer.aw ;~e:Hlt beeaase the :preglen,C.'e' ,o:f mril. l"eMJ'tts, :from nO:[I;&lutGrrtom,i)'ll, il(~r;nl$;! dt~ir ;agcA~ :!lifu:ould lIl,ot 'be' call1ted, wiJoked.· Sll1'd :mould not 'M' :h~I,d. :rrmPlfli!!l~bl~.

n ~ d ~ ~~ ~~ - ',_ ", ~ ~ ~ " ,';'.'.';~ ~ ~ ~ dJ'~1 ~ ,o.'i..:IL_" ''l..i ..:i' "ik"'d' ,;, ~'i.l., ..:i ._ ,~C:C; '''-~iI!u:Cj' :1i~!IlM~:~ iiIiJ];_ my,~~g ~~~~. 'u~~. U~ :UtLe IPRC-ew

:iIng' ,c'hapte.r ~~ly ca~' ~~,' bllllt lill'CY ~ n,e~meir wl.c;Qd, QQ:F do, they '~ :SU101lciC!i.n~ :atJIlt~fiio:m'f 'to h iliiidd loctocoo.'taJb'Lte r~lF ~C~lF ~ti'O~$." '']bc:

4'6',"

-~ .. .'


']~~i[.. ... ~~ "'iir"(,""''''''O!V ~;col i""·i[-r.· ... 1' ... ;,'1' ·d'~n,'V '.;if.,,,,~ ,_'i[-"", .... ~~ """'iI!~~n, 'iI" :"'iI'@' 'n~-"'fu' 'iI\"lL":"~l;'>;'>ol"io·I~·;o;. ,_'II~!I.!d!I! --.'1111!",".~'1 I'II! IUII'loll'iJl !IIAl!',",-" -'l Uiili"n. u·.lil""u, ""~ilili ,,"-,!IiiIU'. _ " ...... "'"' .. '1oII" .... ,'IiIO_ ,II!!U!'U!U""L'!U,",,~.

th~1l thqr a~~·ty· .re:fl~ot ,~n tbeir .ap1mI1$,. 'lids. Sib.' is 'the d~-Xl'iaII of idle f-dl~j.rity· of levUl• ,an~. ·~t :11 ~e. '~pjc ,of the present c'~~pter;

O'm,e nMM 'who d~nl~!5.lb~' R~l~xMlty of,twij~ js, .AIlMn~ H:DfSta~h.~r:. 'He alf' It ,._,. , .• th ' .. ~.o. f ki ~' If {Is d

.~~~: ,'::-..__I_i~ ~:!ls,'~ho-n ''WIiL me ,~,·!_··~!tlaLIl :t:'m!lli~c' ora ,'D.·,;,o;m.'~ i·len.· 3!1lt1

r·'="'~~ ~i _"

.lI1~""'""'·I\nnm''''''i'''F' ..... (lfil'· .~.e ';t· ,H .,,".'n~ b, .............. ml 'm' Iii."', ~lijm.· ,,",.;I\c iii ....... j,. .... ,;i"(":'i""'f""! ~f··'IF'~""_"_iWi;o;...,.,.

u.:; ,,".~ rUrr." __ ~,,~IW UMI.. ~l ,~. 11i Mi.I=lrUl I _ I~ ~~ _ , .. ~ ~_~_IJ ~1lI !UiJ! lJIlI~ ~1l!I.',"L~ v.: ,1lI!U€lJ.m~_I,I~~f.

;lu,t'On~m·Fi '''Th~ :mural m.m ml1:d.~,g hi! ,~[ujjal iiiJU:JMdiilal~t)?· to 'll11u:: autil:tori~' o:f what he :is (lmt,wftc"Gd ~5. fi,r~lt. ,. ,. '" He .~ ~Q't ~~~pen~d. ~ .. ~y-' '~i!mj):' outs:ide ~ .. ' ~ [to npn'O'nH his actkm ThC!i: fGr(l~ 'that d~ll\filliliill~ 'th;~

- -',I!i)' ., -, .. - , .. ,. • " •. , !r.--'" ,. ,. .. .... _. ,- I" . .... ... .' . . . ,.. . _. ..

~rn'O:nna"· is fh~' :mre~' ,of :Ills ,~ ;~'I' (I:m~: 1.1)-., Aga:ii~t. th~. back-I :~U'llrlj. 'he da~mi!!i' 'dlalt in. ;;itlrut:: :maw. I~~ ,t1lt~ actor ~ ,c:um.rvin~.::iI. ~at ·tlhe mOIm .h;~ ~,O:Iia~~, ~5' m.g~y rigP:t. He :~ iOQn.viii!1;~~ 'i;hr.J!t b~ b, ;~~~I him-· ,se'Lf' ::HI'aill'SI1: what :h.e O'I:U'~:ht W' do, ~llltelil!tilO:llaJjl'V OO~f:1a' 'wbat be o:-,Qiht 'Illjl - - - 9:lt----- - ., -~-~ .. -- - """'fI!;--JJ .. ,.. ..," --" I, - . ,- _ .. - IJ . , ..• ~ . . ..• _., ~!)' .. tL

bl' ~ .. lE,ril 'CatOOlo:t. 'e1[J~t •.•.•.. ;sa'!''C i~ ~d d;ljI'Q'urh 'h~ a¢ti~· oppmi~~Il. ~. w:hat.:~ ·nP.i£-OOived asl ~I. 31Ild 'ri~'hrt"~' t',5-6,~~ He a,'Oe:5, on ee .g~' thaI' ··j'dll~,

---" ---- -- ,F"!""!'- - -~- - - -- I~·'~ -=~.- ~~--- \ ... ··1!'11 l l_ •• ~ ••• - ••• "L_J •• - _, l -- -.

~",ea:l1'v' of wiin u. the ege;_D.'t1a1i fbr.m. ,of evil" ,~81'J; mod that: liliiis· i~W5· ~~R'

£ .. "=" • ~·~-~-';':1· _ ... ~-~~ ~_ ~--- ~--~~ ~~~~ ~-"~~ -,~ ... ~.,I' . :r._J ----, _l __ , -" r,.--.

·wi:·~~~,... .... iF' l~~1 ~ 'T'l...,.. '1' '1'·, ..... ;:'!', :'! 1'1:--, i j"'b'~' ~-~h" ". : .---: ;.' ::: .. :.{ -_-.' .', ~c'L '~. ,', '.=.;-;- ...... ,~JC_~~, ess \.;;;1' ~" ,I •• ne .lmpll~~,O:Il. 15, tn!3Jt , , ~w, ".0 :lr;ts ~~t. UI,C 1-UUU1

n,~~ I\e.aIl~J~g tth.a.t :~t .~ 'Il!he :good. he M~ .!il!l~~st ls ·m;o1. ,evill~" ,(:21)1 because S'Il.ICh. a '£¥'!mOll! 181 not !'~alO evil 'matD ,ac:UD!Q" Dl!allevo·l:entd""· btU: ' .- .- iI ~ -man

-~_---'- ~~ .r"'!""!'----'- -- - _., .,_. _=~ J._ .---~ .-,---. ~.-,,".-l_. -Jl ~ - • I'! I'!. J,el~-~I.--:- _I

~led. ,~, a. maJ~io~nt '~riifidrnl~ ·rD3!t. has, 1~~dJ hl .... '" 'I'UiIiFfc 'D£" rum/'" (.·'~I.

v:,. - ---- - - .r' -- -:r' -- - ~1'IIi..' - If""~~~. ~~-~- .. l.I.~.

I'n , ... ii~ '~Ibl~, ~·c:L."""'4I':,-. 'I II : '. ,.';i[r.:, . I, .",' I.' '.'.' ~ .~ I I'~'_' ... ",,:,.

~__ !iP~ ~LSI' ~ ,"D,I;:IoI.~,uteF aMl!IHlCS 'rN.I!hil.'Qul an-, lupportJng :aqu~nt llI.li3it

evil.is i[IJ, mat~.er of cJl,oi()~~ lm,de~taEd!i·ng!. ,and ~1ua!ti.'O;m~ dlia.t the' 1m theJ1C 1[5; 'M .em'~ Ilbe'l!ess, there' is· of ~ril' tfhart ·~lI\l~· 'GimrRo.l 'M' ~ ~\;'k.~d

.=<_ .. ~,~,-!"'!l ._' •• _I~ __ I •• ,- •• , __ "."." _, -J .",.-iJII. __ -.~r-~·!'II.OPr." ,~ .- 'Wl ._",

unl.~ ·~I'i;.,~, 1IfIiI"'''''fljll i".i01 'b ... ~ :"":n~ ,~'l!i-r'f"" "Ill,.. "'ft· ·it:~·e· 1;:;'''~'''''~~"'~l'I, , ............ , ... 't!li."I'"'i"I""'~ "ilii iL,_..;Ib_

~~ __ ""'..- ""'~.~ J:' ~~""'""~- I,,,",, U'!;" AII!I!!JI. Uh.lI'iJ1 WI_"," .• till; ~~ilIUI[W, !l.1J.LLl(IJIU ...... "1J 'U.I: nil ~W

n,~g, :b: 'ue ;~ta:l:e 11)£" :miind. ·of the' .lent to wh{)!~ wicked~eS8 is leg~t1m_a!teJjy ~~bcd,.

M(Jth~r :~~bcrnJ. 'w:tio de_l1i~es the rdlrexi.rity· iQf' ~1. is, S~~teF' Beflilil. He sa~: !~By '~'!ii.i:Cke~:bu=~!I!-~' llm~u 'wbatm',~' :it is aiberal. i~m.eoRe '~aJt ~~ oWir ca!U~ng' ldm :I. '~c'ed pe.~n,. lit h:. there£~l1e ~. d~re.'ll.t iIII.oti~n fhoJlm

·~,,"it .. ".... .. ;1["""" ""'"("I ; .. ;i['<t-I·~'"l" ;];1":'" ~III~ ...... ..II ·4ccij -(: 1--._~~'II-:l ~.J1 .',~~-~'. [b .. ~.-4I"~' 'I;:wr

,~ __ ,.,." ,~'c!_","~~!i]I ",m., ~ .. I'O.!I~!I "'"".. 'G''''iIOl !U,,,",,lIiiIU, .11.0." i1J], ~I ~eu .may I~ nOIile ~'!'

-.~ "C'~, -.~ -,-. c- ~b.-. ",- ... ~,.,.j. '. ".·-:.·L,· A 'k I .~ ... "'1.0,,, _ii.. .'. t'.: .',.:i" ._..iII'r.~. ·(·lno~. ",n~\ 'jLl'~ so:mflionoe 'Wu,o, lSi nD~. 'Wl,C .... l{l!tiI. lI:'Il.I~ on",]!, 'We~. ~r .~l\g.'e:!;!I. ., .~ ",!,Q:;;I!.. " ~II;!!I)'" ~-~.

di;smn__piiShe!!!, be;~en ~'·~~J~iflJlw.mil< ,cq(tsci~mJti,oll,j, 31IliCl :rnati.8Ji1iDt f:ol'itls 0.£ .0 '~d ,,.. '(~7" 'iC~~~ .:~'!I' ..... c i~'" 'Ii... ~,ir:·.~_"1 ·I"~ .. ·"..!L ~ ,i 'Wl~~~-~~~e~ I"'~:'~I." .~fl'~'W; hi,C' :lii.r!it.lWO'~~, t\1i~(l: :rCi~ [~G ae.!o.iJi:OWiIr

.edLlI. e th.e DtoraJ! ,Sigl1fifie'""ro1O .... ""'· ..... f "",~'I": ,~"!fj"..i'!fc:.,.1 --._ .;--=:-;:.~'i-':Jw-:-~ ·I~ ..... ~, .:;-=

_ ~ _ __ _ _ ~~_ __. _!I!'!;o-,,", ""~ ""' .... ,._ ~ 'IT~lI."b~iI !U'l"~ .III,~I! Ilu,el~_5lI! .I" .. i;lun1il! DI'

" .. '

c:oub:il1:'te---asG:n~]v be lex~c,tf!~ tOI 'mow' as eorils~· 'b:w 'iJibese' ICaseS, 'De w:iJik:e~

. - - . I, I -. . - - - . " ,. . - - llT--. I -. • _- • , - ~. - •• ' ~~~. ~ •• ' _-~ '~-~._' .~_~c_____ _ -~---";'-lil ~~. _- .• ' ~~ ••. ~'

au~ji\;O;!' '.;\_"i:'rii(f-'~'--";~ ii;~, ,~;~[~, -:- ~, - ,~ :~'i;._~;' c·'. .~' •. ;;;14' r .• " •• orb., ,.' . ..,li .." t-

.,·!I"'IU ..-::J! .~ 'I.?lI.r-IiISC---oS ILQ ,51,: ,_, O:[];$ '. .• • ·ue UI.-:e'Jf Q'WI'I" ~!le~·.~ I!lU.C cJu~81JIJWe!mI'j

theIn dt-c' aotj thei~ 1d\'C ~cbd;l:tess'I!' '(~'h ·m(.rtedlfil;~ !pn_ppo_5m a_w, bl~o;~' 'b«a!1l8e '~~,~'ke~~ess ifit a ~rson. :rnqrllli.R'!' lilhat b~ m;Qp.t :an. ·eVil

~ __ ,:to ji.!itfl!'1i Be- ~ ,~ ,. ~ ilh·' 'd'~' f ·.~·I.,~.iI ·~i1i··w 'L.. 'L. .•

. ,' ..•. 1m \I~C ~I. ·.':c,.Ul: I 1~~'JtI.:_~ .-,~ O'~. 'Wl~(!!DeM :l'S< mml~[n~:,!!~ W,r;il~l;il :1:5


w:twat ml):~, IfimStelll, :~~ :~, l,t ~m.ay 'be' :ig;n~red, :iu, the' :p:re.Jefl:t, oonite:xt. '~lnn ;is cenilra1~' to ~e !Il('iii'll't 'h~r ;is ''Ii-.·ihr,,"' 'Beno '1lIi~Il;b 'tihart' "a 'l'KVcb,i,'}-;

, - - . , , , -. .,. - . ) ., .. ~, ., -" l'''~' - - .. ~, ,- , ," ,. I" . ,". ',~" ,,' .. , ... .,. ," ,[,",-,:r' .. .

pmi;(; :pe~i]i~~ty ~' not, ~~iit a.;: 'Wiic.bdlneg ,~t: aUj; ("980)., Sl;u;:::h a ,~

-. ,"'- '4i':,.--, '-:" ';'~ ib:-'ii~' ~'~iL."., ,.ii.",,::.-, 1 " ,·;it ,-: > ,'1;" !-, ,:-',YI ,"" ,.'. :'~' ,.' ,', ih!.,.,.,.."" ,'1"': ',",',' i ,'_ " ...

,SOln uDeS CViI!I ,U!lo u,1I:: u-Oe!!! n.O!LI ,~ ,I!~, as ~VI! I, ex.a\p""1 peFu .. ,,'T""'!' ,m a. c::;o:mve:n

tio:m;aII ~nK;, Thls, ~s' so:me~i~g 'tJhat Il(_~ow :most: peo,le ~lo lOOt '(iib:' bein;g dl):ll,e'~~ ;$0 I: had! beilitei" lel)n,(l~ 'i)lbe body:, B!jI!t ~.e' 'lUnd! of" cQ'.n&:ide~ti!QonS! tbat [mill'tllt l~ti~ and 'mti;ollaJ)i~e IC@:llvenuol'lJail diissf1frn'r,owil ~ ,~t no,

---. --"'0' ,JJ- .. u.,,, '- - .,,_, 1 '.,'- '--r,lj'" ,_ . ,~i= -,.

p~vtbase '(lID, 'hi!!!l, '~H;d~b\mdli~g., .' a a ;8~l'J aJ ~n. eannet 'be' 'wic~edji~ J'""nnl~

'"f~-~."!i'

:Lit~ :~ltad1:~, ~i1!n ~lWn1~!!!' ~w,o.lI.I~ ,!!!.wPlXIiting ~Qleiljt, tb~t ~ t~uo:my u nec-essary' :for wiCkedneJ$. Benn d,~ n~~ [1D~n'k~, dl~g(Jor~1. ~~I!

,-- 'ct~ 'wh; 'Ijo, .. ibi ... ,·· .. :!il:: ,": d 'F' ~~, ~:ifr;i'h.;,.c - -I··~·.-:'t ,-', .;IL"'I "i";k', ':, . ","j, -'-I'" : [peQiPue.~~m ,~~_~,~_y ia1I1_ iP~eJ!;':IL'C_~1 eaase eVI!_, as v.u ene p:FeVlO~,y

d~Fij~d, d~Cicj ~0~1l5~tiiVC!1 ;~,d :flljthJ.e~ OP;~I. ~ be ~aJlled wl(ik.~d, ~f 'dl~ dlQ' ni!)~ j",~t ~~ pri~cl,'t~U' ,at w~i.:c'h tb~~' Iba~' m~ i"by':a :p:r-oc-~g

0.· .'ii!' ~~'~ ..... .,..,·6'~ :~' ~~ .... ,....-t·I·"('io~·n '~'I"'I.";'". ~'=~", .. ~~ .... .,. :~''''''rO, .... , I .... I~":'" .. , '~'''"'''t, !;ro-~'L!!' IIi'I,.,·'U [iClfli ... 1 il''', .. "", .. ,1 11.;fJIiIioI.', .. d;M,I, iii """U""'I!<r .. ,,,,",,11011. ,160 _~ ";I.U:,1_ilI!WU!I£""'~" I.K.lel_U ~ ,~,iI<U," _,. ,",,1;11.1 LUL-lI! I.il ~.

'my ~, it: 'P1ii~tdiei'iJ 'm ~-rirbe Mcbd!H;~ tQI p:o;ple wh~, 'FeJI1J~'w--ly eause ~l bur, baNe' not RfI,@-clm, n,tio:ll!alIl,' on, tlt~ir' ;e-Qfuhl0t arid 'w:hu ~,uno(f.fil"

.~ "'.!L .. 'il. ·1 'h .~ Iii.. _,'i., 1"'" '" n· 1..1'" ~A

CC!l'J1C~, '~wi, '~~e ev:J,--, It_.;~ey i:AO [dut, are ne¥e~, ~e~s.s, m~~:;enltj palt'i:.d_feotti],

,ag~,t.5i?

,1\, dl!ird denim o;f t~e refl,ex'iri~' ,of eri'l: ean, 'k' :fJound, :i'n, Oary' 'W'ailMlfi,"S dlKIlUSlOIJJ 'O'f:R:a1?ert H:amSiI ;8. parti&ul.ully cal!l,ot:U :mJUitlpl~' "Un:lere:F. 'Wat1-

,!IO"-;"'":," ir'i"":'i .... ~i~'~ ..... ,.,., ['--' '.' ;];'~I·:"'~ ,.,li~ •• ,iin'it"""'"!" 1 ... ·£' :~'''''m'; "!IO:i 'm', '"I'i':",~~"" I--:-£'~"'" ~'" '.",'; '- P'"", ~1,11 Ir"~ """"",I,~""" oR In_"",~ ~,'U''!'I!', _u~ a~l, ",r,Y,'U'oI,l, u:l n_""" ".0:1' , __ J!I!IinllI....... w; '._v I ........ Z''''. ,n""

~'b. endes .... ..i' ... ":" .. _ N1f~(.,~~il..r ~'i<>f~i'''~1 nllh!,. 'it,,'" .... h", ro,', '~ ... ;Ijll· _..i , ... i'r~iL ... f ... ","",.:Ii ,0.·,'1Iii' 'it;"',~ Wfl"·r~

[II,; _ I'Ll _ I ~~_IJ.lllJl&O!!l1 ~,,!IWU_I.1 MIlI_IR_I." v.-ulnlll6.fI!]·!l1 l.IIL _. . __ ~_ _ ~ ~-I_I_ .. _LU_[I~ ... t, 1_1J_11li.-r ,,_,,_"U_.

derer, And! :tb:~Ili!' Watson, agollli~; the :mJNNEFeI ,.i,bo., :5ati5fi~§, mlIllll 'Vi,~

Ia;t~ illhc crik.ri.~, '0f ''riotim'hood, :iHiis 'cibildihogmJ 3!b~ ~ a· :mld1lU'iW~~'

'" :in'''...iI '1-.'" ". '.... "'Ill' 'D .. ")'1-. • jI-. b'

IUII.Iil..ote!JI, upon IIil1m ,~D'st ,llill'S 'WIlil1l. ,put ;at ~Iie sa-m,e time , •• ' ., ~li,e iUDa:m,~lW:-

'Ie:nl~t ~mdO'~ sd-Eri;ng" d;~ill:t"' an~, d~'l1'lNoti,O:FiJ~, and '~a!t,:~ '~~at '(,Ol1U!l' [um (d) ~J ls" '. • " ['O~F] 3!miblwil~Ilic.e' f.ie&trJ]U, 'fr.om t!he :fact ~t an ,(.Wt_FailJI, 'wew 5imrl;illl1mii~D1l5Iy' d~mml.ds, ,3lIlO :pr,~'tud~s, :Fe.gatding :b-im, 115, :8.

,·',·~·'·i ,.-'0;' ('ln8C,~':' ?'~i!;;')I. W---';:n h;esi"-----, i-O ,::: .. ;1!1 H'---;---:'-: ,~;<:c'~ ... ..:I1 k",;c--:--_ it:i-o-, VI~hm "'".~.'f~, ,iiIi,~ ..... , •. ~ai~~~ ~~.!LJates: ilL c~ =,~~ WK~ YQcaiU.se !!Ifl-C!

,mftil Im~ 'C3i~d, w.u, ,~I1, :som~ H!m~ t.nIr;~h~' ltD t1t~ ~vii~ 'diial was, dton,~' t~1 'L.· Pi ,;, ., t=f! il 'Il.~~ h L ~ "I Ii~.~m,. ICl:il!mS, 'W'35, Ic;e~...Jl!~y aIlJ ;age~~ iiOOi e.vI~r ~~t per-~a,., L~' 'was not iim! 'C'\Q.."

;.Olt. :8,13 'urFl!r;oi1llHa~ ~i'SO:id, :hrisllOry :~n!~rmpu 'Ih~ progr~,i);i1 Wo:M 'r.alrld@mn~n:g' :llIiis ,~tinn' to, cOlltdemll1'i,t1g him).

"Ru.t 'w;h-,c: hi, me' .;-~~"I, dIal W3;S dDn~ m, h~nl a !f~m foor' :not ,cDfidemn~n~

= -~~ .~~~y ~ ~~ ~ ~~~- .~-~- -~- -~ - ~- ~~-~~ ~~ ~ .. -~- - ~~ --~ ~~- - ~ - ~~- .. ~~~-~t,g

t..1~"'" as c~,...I1.; __ .... i"'!I W.,:,;"'~~·""''''',·· :""!!'ii"Iini"~"""'.:~' "" .... I·,..JII ''''''f'i;":1''!''''d~' ,""j .... , ,~iI;'jI'~' ,i~"" ~ .. ..,..-iI" '~·'L..I· .. 't

,II 1,1 leU """'- '!I'!!',L'!I.-_"~_r.' .. !A.-,I,II ~I,~ . .,.'!I!I",""II~I ..... ,,. !I1Ill"U U,"""'!I'_~",,"iiI! .. ','1 !AOH'iI!H",""",". ,iI. Ih,;. ,"iIM:r!l., 1;.1111_"",.

[Uanis,~':s,]] .' '. '. (fUelty, g, ~ :m,'~emiPble ~fl;PO~' to Ws (~~urn;stati'(;fi gives, a :f'OO::thoid H0:t o~iJ f~ ~:pa!thy'j' bu~ I"or th~, du)~ht that ;itf ll~ad, bee~ :~~~ed to SUQb ciif-ctllm8m:o~s~, 1 migbt :1Iiia:~ 'bcco:m.c, ,0 'YiiL~'", • '" . 'Th~s

.,,\.. 'iI.:'" dl 'il.,'] • ~1 roiL. .:il.:l.~" 1-..,~' .. . rf .,~ ... 1"'·

~ll,O'llllu!t 1ft .. IUI!!8 not O~~,I':em: O'niw.~.o,gtt:~, !f,Ji~~~::rj, wt 31, iSieilil8e '(it;' 'eqtMl~qr

·.'"·: .... ,1 i"'b.-:_ l;;'joi .. :~'~ ... , ~~ '''':;.;:, ,'!io~ ,~l N')' ..... n.,.'t.iiaI ;iE'~~ii'io,.,"",,,,, .. A,..JIli:Wo~~j, .... ~~'I;!'_ 'I·'t' ~!IO, 'lfti"'i"'d' ~"",' 'W'IIU;I IU;l4!i 'U"·UilC(I," J: ",.QI!D _1J11 "'" 1r~'!II!I""'Ui, . ,o:I'_I~II"'I,""'~.... nuU'I:lilii~~ilJ' I' ,I," ,I~ ,I~., , 'IO'U

:k~~ ",!hat, w' do, Wjl\b thJ~ 'ooncl~on;'i (1198,7';' 276).,


.A ~~~~ fe:~~' ,1)f'W~t.mn'~s dJSQussi,omJ is '.alt ~'tm,m;t; Will h.i!!!, ar~L'CIil"'"

,~".<. ',.; ··.C·;:"('·.J·c" ,'jit,~t''''d'I';';I'<Ifi, ·t~;'i-.·,: ',. ",:: .~",,'. ,:~:,: ,L ~"i"",[ .. ,,,,.: ,·,·,~~·.:.I"':"'r~f:, ~Qon, liS (nm:~~Il!I,lIi,;!!IIU;w Oil! W,I!I!8i IIl.Ue: app:mpna ........ ua'C!liilo,u ~ '!O&!' UllC mm~~ 'C~,

H: m:;~:~, '-:I'~ ~'I ~cr-;~~~, :kc- '~ro:b~n(t 10m" ~~uf~bUil~ [UT 'rDc :l'iia:h"~ r~no:nK'"

, e .... mM ,grca, 5UL~C: .. ;'!' !!It ,t'"'= - -~.~ - ~~~ ~ .~~. ~ ~~~;! ~ ~ ~ ~ . r~

B,' • '~,~ , ' ., I ,..:i·/I, ,~.i"i,.~"",' ',.,;..,;l! ',' ,:,",' "',····,·,·"iiI'.a41 :-;~"f"ilijt' ~: ... ~, ~~C7'1 ~:"'ll' , . U~, ,1l:L=i!: ~ nOull!Ilg" ,dII"e,[' UI.e ,m~IJ,~e;r.s, are ,rooO'U..!I1Ii'ION'!..i!j' a~~~, 1!lJ;1.e ~, 'Y;~~

mtllr~rer' caused, ''fW,(); boy8, were bHilm1lly m,U_Id\eT..efll~ tlbiC'iJr :.~liI~' ~n

~ d!.. ,d!..· f:' "1" 'b..:ll it 'l.. ~ 'L. ,..I 'J -~'

,a:wary :ociJm IUJ;~m; 'UI;Elf'~ililG5 ,.aU I~D ttlll;:I1.T..e il:u~ tess, b~e gO'Jry" ~e~1 Slll~q

dJ~, crime, and dltdtr, own, fiecJlllp o.f grief; :ngc',,- ;.d, ~clpl~e~, S~'C~ dttnp happen, o:f~n~ I~n '~n :ti!Mirm, w.~'~s~, alii1;d 'thiey :ma,' hlippe:ml to UJJQSe we' ~ove ;aJlild, W ,o:~hes..., ln, a, '~~eJ;' c~ii1!$list~filt ~iilh, 1~_r.1il, RiDsJ?, biUi[~. '~rll1l5@~ :tlIIO''O:l1'11:es OVf:F tihe criIm~~!I'1 ;!iIlflit, QJii!'i~S a,lO'er Ute ,eri m e,

"llf. .. -- .. - ~ .. '--- _,". l. ••• ·._~ .--~- ~~- .. - - --- --- ~- -_-_-_--

~\,;".. I ~,L"'" t __ ':t,._o. 'L.

g~,ell,~' S()'mel)lljL~Hl' :~ :~'Omliy ;~ ~~eFe.

J~fi~'i 'I~~'"_ ,= ~ 'I'Ii=.it'\ii',~.,..dII~ .. , 'an,_a n'~ .... 'i'!; '~"'l'~,i\il'''''i!N' "';~\I!'.lin"l'!I;"''' .;L.§;t, .,'L. ... , ~POI"t.i'm'!I<i!l;to~, '!':I;;c:!.. , f~~, ,IJ1~ nv_IJ~~_~; [~LI'u, m!G1=1=.=II~, LIf1!'O/~.HIl ,~U_.LIJ_L~.::II lli.J~l~g~J IUJ~ ll!:W~ I!l~U~I~I_~~~ ~

(;ri,pti'O'u 'of'Wiickedtl,e~, depe:n. ,()(Il, m~' ,ailil1tomGlmy' o:f'tlb.e mld,Mif' aftd o,oi; ~', ~''l,-~ ~;'l:1 ,.JI~I~,.;iI;'lil "i:L~"~.~, ...... ~~I" 't't..~ ii1~"f'.'·ifV 14";j\","~. ruf I' 1;11 •. it:; ns ;,' on, ,<tuc:l ~'If.I!, unn,(1;" ,I.'U, IIlUif.'~ ut'lm~ . n~ rtllufJlNjfY.t~:1 w, ~, ~ e¥li...JJ ac~()~~_ ~

n(tn3lU'~Qn,Qntu~, BUt why sibnu!ld, alult.oj~o:m.y 'k' r~utrmJ, fuI' wiicfki.ed'Il;~w

1i;iiilll. .,'" - '"l.,~A ' ".:I,~ .. ".:i,~ . to ",'. - W' . . . . ,;, ", ....... tl:t· " ";'~.4 ..... _ ...... ""m - ..

"~liil!ll'S 'WJ,c~!!<!II_O;ess: ~pen;~nl~'(),Jl w,;~~~""ggeS, Q:1l1 ~~S!,~ '~~~~' I~!~L~~~, rn~ : el'

tb.aiu 00 Ith,e' I~!\i~ dI..J!~' dQ'?' Why d!oes, dt~, ,:a!b!5e'o~'e' of' ,~uito~Oi~' mae i,{ iiU,esiitimai~:e to, ooJlldemn peo:pJe ~ wicked, ;if ~ey' hilb~tl2~any ;~d, :pr~d~c~~ ;~b~, ~' e'ri'lr &r!;tadteif;~ Be~p(~ :.(1, Wa~m do :not aD~!f '~eH' Iflm~'

iIi~.' ",. , 'n'I"t' .:i..., ,. ;., . "_."'" 'd" ;'t" .. ; ,t ... t-.. . ··mil'liiii~ . 'Ii a; .......... '·,[·lllI!tDil

.... 0:1]'5. ,lMlIi'li. 1lI.I.e:re .IS ;& ;"'SWe;r~ all; ' .. ~~ ,P~UOJWI '!I/O ,m, ,as)S.!J~L __ ;,r'~m~~:~~~ aJ~~~...: ~~,.'

,o:oo,~' 31nd mc'Om f!e~;O:!'Isibil~lJ' ~t '~ o:Jl-e' ,Ct£' tn~, deepest sm:ur~es ,of

~li,'L.~"""";I:·""'" W~~IJ d __ ~_I::I_~,IJ_Il.

i::'!Ji.' L' ;' .. ,1.. ~'il... ~·L._~:I ..:Ill '. "t f~' ~jL. ....nIl '"" J:'

:~ittO'Wll_QS: wl.ta:lJ: rs ~ng'Mw~ 'y~e ~~~~~ 'y.~i!li3!. IQ:.:·'iJC fl:;,l-.:exi,ViIty"QiJ,

evil req,uil'e~ 3!, (:l~~r l~ina:tfuo:,I), 0:£ ![~~n&ibi.l~l1·' h~ '~fiOQijj,I~F~ia!l ¢~Ji ,.n~ ~1)ii~ti,<unO!liSly peli'O:FmJ ,N.~ ,actl:OtiilS11 ud m,~' ,a'l:\~ ;riI'brt~f lu~lld l[';es:po;n~i!blc' foOr '~e!]L, The ao1i6ri1i~, meet Ilihe oo~dl~tio(J~:S, ,of' ,~Ujto~o:~' pd, ifViguo.~'C, 'bldl '~iL'j: 'r't~d!G'. arllil! ~t!: iiudj]!jrjili~n't 'comftfflfletmilS (;UI descriibed, ~n

lr~'~' . , -, .... ".,.... . .. " .. ,,[p,. 'Ir;.'!i'~- ..... "'--r~-" Ii .. , ._ ..... ~, .. - ..... ~~

Seoti,og "1,51)" There' 3il!t ~, .~n-CGtlftm~vemaIl .. c~s.1ml.wb~ch. ,age~t5 ha:vt ~d'tJr.mM ~ril actlG'IlS but llGuld '[l,ot ri~'bjtl~ 'be' bel!d '[\~ftAns'ibh~' 'bet:a'~,

,r~"'" - ,. ",'" .• , .,., "I."".. ,." "~I- .Il "" ., ... , " .... T·~'- .. '~·"" - ..... -.--.~,

drley haft' ac-ted Ho:na!~mrtom'01lUJ(y" They d~d ~ot ,db~ the ac~GDS~ ~e

... .'h··:·!"·->-~',' .. ,····,~;~··, ",,~.~ "".{ "I;l..,._;,',' "", 'it.'-r,"':~' •. ,.'I.,~.~ ~;~. ',:':" . ",'i',:' . ,."dl/'::(r' ,.'1[., 10."'" .. !fIoC, 01(~ ~ ilU~'!i!I, om] !Ilu(l;ml~ (lli llllqt lliaClK;\iI!, 1,I:t"f: >Ca:pact!1)' ;cm;'~" iO~ Y!~e -IP,o""

'tUfoJiitr t'0 e~~te 'fir.' ~cle~d ~,e' :~i;nifj(;a:n(:e 'Of 6elrl" aotl.Q:ns.

n~, 'D:l1iooll!trovemd ~s oIJU~s.t 'two :pa1i'1:"l o:f ~:nstinc~OOl ,ce~~aru ta, ,tIIt~ tun"';-~ 'M ;r.lmfif:)ril,-7~b~'r~' 1'h:~ '~r5t i;s be~~ll ~ilS ;8iud, a.o~io:.n~ .. ,.A~eliJ:~

e - Irl,~ . ,,, Ir-, .. 51. 1.1",i!"" ,... .. ,~. ""-;g<--'" _._. ,,, ". --·~~i""~"-

are properly' helld lt~po:E~bl~' fbr 'tke'jJr' ;aotID:H1s., bUll: not. :fol:" ,~1I, th.e~t at-'tiuns\;, On'@' area of c~nlr.O,Ye:mr ahout th.e' ,~ripti:o~ ,ofJ 'res.po~s~bitirty 00'.' cerns, drn~'n-i' the dQlijnctib~11 'betweeli. atltlon!S fOT:' 'w:furiCb 'i!lbE~r agfi;nm ~' :[\espoD'!Ji:blJe ,1iI],d ,acti'OBS< f'O'l' wWch, dleY' ~ not. The' IOc:~;tftd qU'e~t;rm. ito'

'L.':O ~~,;Ej,~""'~d·.1 ~~ '.I!of~,~ ,~''''~il'']t",N'' ~ .. ~ '~'<:I' 'I"t J"'I'I""tiF'!I;IifJl;i1!o r~1 · ... .nJdl :tlli11h'"tI11i~~ '~"~lII1I!!I:iibl~, lKi "_~IJ_II_il!LI§~.bWiill~ ll_II_~, !l_IlI_~ Yll_IHI;rr.-~{I, ~_IJI! • .1_.., J'III 1.~Y_lIll_IQ~.~_.["" l~ .!_'I~~.~ ~i~~~l~ ~·~,r~·~~-=~~~


{'Or the evi~ dlq babi~' ~d, prcclict.a;bty caNUe'~ :if' 'their ;acuions :£'O:now' from, $Orne '\!ices, [c,G],];!I!tibl%lWe' of: their ,dharac~r" blllit I,,~i~~r Irni'!i .~ n(J1' ,th~ par~~ ,Qf ~~~, [that. f~l~ from the~ ate' ;atuUAOl'llOHr

'De' K~jJl _I' oo:nre~ltta11og' '~Q thh~ q,uC'sti;Q~, :l! thail: (as, 'bas ~~11 aif..' ped, :in the pre"d_~JlI' c'bapte![,) the smOflgeM: 'Ii~ra] ~xp]la:liUIOOll, ~e, 'w atJtHibu~, the' ~~~n~~ ,of le"I :~Iy '~ ng~.~uto~~~!JUl, :~m_iS' of' aetlon, Th~ <Jlllestimn naUrns, ,Dot '~C3'" [of;a m~~ib~(;; ~' W, :find, ,a, (:;l!lllpdt" bwrt bec.a~ tbe. :i5UCCe58 o:f :p~)l1ti:c;al p~s dGsign;~, m[ oopE 'MIil, 'mrllI, [*rwo;nru, on, iIt.ow ~r is, ;omswer.~., 'T:t.- ... , 1~\.:-::r'll if~I·~iIi fil"jl. ... :liI ,; .. ' ~'.,,' ,

~ ~ ~~ ~ ,Ie""'" ~ ~ ~ ~~ I~ - ~ ~ ~ - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ - _~ ,u:~ _~I!ijg lt~,1!1l16i;U l.1!oiI' "uOW nnm-

n~n'OmOlldy' evil a:ctio:nil and w,,~s; to ;iit"fIlK~ on '~E :m.onJj ~tmdhl.g'!()f ,th~~ .n~ :~ it :~m~b:l~' 'w h,~JdJ Soueb. ,age~lu Rs.ponsibte,~ 'lhu hilo,dering dte eiffbTUiI 'W :inJj1itu1re :~jticd prognimS ~at 'wou~d :maillti ~~.~ ley, pf.~.enit.

'T!l'r - - - - ~~ dJ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~- ,- 'M~ ~ ~ ~ ii.1S3iI ~~.A ~ ~ ~Il ~ ~ ~ ~·'''':::I~· tv Q ... ~

. , • til' ~CQn; " .. c ~ :.~~.gJ;l,:q ~ _<.:',":,".~I'I, 'e:a~~_,:.., ;31Q~ :m(!J~,~ KlponU~t"l:' ",~p-

,OH:: lihat 'diitR' ~!!I, no dou'bt, ilhat a, pam wi ar' .~:t ~1'f(J~~d!, ,a, pank~d\aI" aotiii!ll~" ''fhe_n! is 'then a, Kille ~n 'which imll~· .nt can, 'k' :wdJ to 'K' :~~~I¥' iSilbl~ fu:r th~ aoc~«Il;. :But [this mUir meg "~pl¥ ilia:t '~~ ;ag,eHlt'~ the'

'n1~ .... iI '111·;nk~' ;I":n; ""'."., "'~I1!11:.~'11 ~1;.I~~111111 ~~~~: i'ri'li0llJ ~~.iI iI'~ ~~L;!:I!' ,i'li""'~"''ft, ,O!I;;!I': "ilL.oI!i' '~"'oiI!!~.' ,rr.~'I!-V~ IJ_ ~._. I _~l.l U~11!I. ~.!R'iJI!~_~ '!IrJ~"'_II_111 ~~I_g_", ~I_...-::II! ~1Ii:iU I~U' Uol[~ ~UVJl";J ~ !11.!.tl,'E ,IJ ~-~~.~l'"

~flil!lak~' is £'0:[' the co'~I~ __ , of:ili hn~, """I' ,th"",. j. .... ,a, '::I(U>n'" .~ ............... ,,'., ... ,i' ... ii.:il_

':...-~~ II....:__:_ '~> __ ...: _._" '_~ . __ ~ _: ...:~_~_~-i .~.:...:. __ ~ I.~_~ .~~, -~ .. - .. :t:t! ~c__; ~~~!I..IUl-~: [~.~~(_~~J!I.. HJ!I ~1I..d-~Y_.~ll~lILr,:

f}o:r ~~ ,action.! ,U Stallilll ;i5 fol" Ime l$lh.t1W'triaib in, the l~, Tbe Mt ;~we b !li'caiL~sal :~s,pon8i!bii~tYi,'i" and the 8e(i~l'td g, U,HlOr.aJi r~m;ili!biiliqr-" ~'l

:Mo~ ~Ipo:miihiill,ty dmn funn ,ca~ :rt'$,tQn$~tJl~ty, :In ~~ _mg ;ap:pJ:\O'jlriaite LQ, '~bl, ease ~o hold ageIl:'ls, liaible to :mo;ra:l j\ll~gmc@1l,lt, ,for thfllir

'". ... ;tI·or;.l(!I,;!I'~ 'I~'P1,..I;-O-~ 'm,. ,..;I.,~",: :'i'i""'1"-r~ ii.I.,A~~"'I"I: ""r~~p.,.ij""f.j"'" '\:1 ["""~: ;:_, mse '~-:- .. '::'"' ft~, _" !!.:Anil!. ",",I;I'\dil, ~ .I!IONC~ ~~~'lZI,'iIIJ"J.J.....,i"U,,,",U!li. O,r;Ii~!U ,~Ul!I'l'" ,III! uD,t;i ~ ~ ~ ~~. ~y,~, ,n<h,.m

'the othe:r':is ~upposcd 'lo be. the :agenu" ,alUilOllOnlIY;, ,AuJIDfito:mlY is, WdJ 'lo :'f'0'l]"~1 "' .... ,!:Iiii!U'i,¥Io~" 1Ii\i['io[ [·:-:--~I·r' """'IIi~~;iI" '"i"''''''!t· .,....,.~,..,.3.uWly b'~~'j;,-,:; """,:1~' -- ~ ~.~~1i~. ~:~:, "'u".~~l.!! •• ""'l, ~~'IU.'La 'l ..... U].'1i:i,. , B'Io.!II.iII",!!,.UI<I' ,~II.U." "';I!a .... ' "'. ~ ~~ .. "~' ~ .. ~~ mQ:~'-'1 g 'We~~., ,!!,~ey

00' :m;ot :merely' :peri'QJln dleir.' aoti.o:~SI 'wt, abo ehoose d'I,cm wlJtbout M],ng fat(lM, and ~~' ,MI)na~' m~m, 3lnd tln~tm1d 'metr' ,siipmciIflce,. It :~ d\ti!iS l,\;JwnOlm¥' '~It dtsli.nguisbes, 'mc'Om res,p;Jn~biiil¥' :[I'OIn [ca!u3ai~ :l1!CSpo.n-,

''' .... ·1'''··

S]~u,',

'Du, 1iI~!ri~'n:Ci~~;::fiJ I~;;'-~' ~'''''':n, '~ .. , [:~<I;'~~ ~Ai, i~c[~ ... :i'~ :~ ''''il-,~ ~·I"",,:,,·~ .. ·:il ,i, .... i. "~"'~

~ ~ __ iIil(L !may lu.~e~ ~ iC'J'tlsteu W IWi:i:ll:lIlu U!le d!.!JICuu !!!tnte,gy 0:1,

d~nyinl ilhat. .'('~t.s, 'wh() ~ ~, '~abin.anf;, :,~~ta!b'ly~ but :~(lt~Wg;.. o:nt1)~y eatl, 'be' :tqj'.~tely' d~Fikd, as, 'wi,IC'.t:d, Such ,agen!u ,aR: nul)"

""'!I1!"":411.J. ~n('iin~·'''I'iL.'II~ ~:"'r' , .. '~,,,,, .... , :,.. .... ·I·.,..'"1"!iIi:~. ',",iil'd·l ! ..... [ :'.: :,~, "-CIO:!i:p-;C_~-;; -,:'''-_, ~;:, ,~,:;]~~ "'-'<R~ .'~'~.T "'-""!r.~~' ..... Jg "'" iIU UlII,,",h -.,~ ''!U.~'''ij; '!lin -... iI!!:. iliI! ,In_~ ~p:IJ'''''',~u;;; ",\0 ,fig, "iii,

d1~m, Iilbl~ 'W ~~, ~~,j~~~t 'th~t. g, ,~D1,tte~, by ,cailU~g them, 'Mciied. If they :b.ad, [ca;~d eril alUito.nmmf.uu'lYIio !Only' dim, 'wmJlkIJ :iJt M jotili:ed, t~, ,sar 'illhart th~' ~ M(!kedJ,~

rli""~ ~~~IJiL.!I ..... '~"",.I!-' ["Ii"'~:;o; ~iii.,..,,",, 'i"i'~ ,!:IIii"O't!ii ....... if"I.C ,'iil ~L,...c ,"., ~'I~ - - ~-, [~~: -"c "C'OLfl"io: ,~-"t~~ . . 11 ,HlM- 1U,'U.. UH::;: '!I'I",I.U1I, UI_ IlIiu!IY' uli, ~,~~u~""'n!l1 ,~ ~., ,I., IU,J.~ ~F !I!I'r'r'l;fl' ,!!!;~~~

mwW, _,Qill,ti~s. Th~' :IQt :b th;a;t ~ora!l, gd] C~'%i3iJ 'Fel,ponsih'iiity €.aRn~t

'Ih-~' [d· 1:_:''''Ql'Iil·_''r-""dl ~;!I', 'f"'I~""'~ as ~:L.""" '11:;'L.;oo"'FI'1 1"'1Ii""':""h!!!O'V '1iit'n~~~ijoi!!!A :r,~' :uH',ii,ii, """'"-c'b!i':

IIl!'t; .I'iI!YH~_.~h:" RiI! ..... ,"_'I!IlI"~J ga '-IL"" ,11!~ldlt M!I'_~I!::I!! '--""J:IJIU~~i!!I' 111, ,~[.".iIiIl~ '4I'ugJI!~

W' be beld, nt'Me 'W mow j~dguienlt, OH'1y :for ,IUitono:mOW!S acliions} '~len :iI~,

:, .. , l'I"III(>'P'O,·:':·r".""-~ ''''Y!' i""~-]:"~ '.~i'li~ •. ' ·~"'i •• , '·'·ilo1i'.~0!1;"'~~'·' 'L.,_' .... ~~, :""~,iI-~'11 """'~' ,di;.,~'-::

,In]!...... . ~ ,"ill'U.'!L, III,U ~iIIJ!u:.... O1:,llll, ~ .,~!L.3 U!lIU~"_l"", ,11\iiI'!!'iE ~~,"" ~!UI'.U,U!ul! 'IUI~'IJ!"_'.II, U.ellJ"

,___; :__.: .. . ~" ~ . ~ . . ~ . ~


:PO~O:Il o:f 'the apacitie.s aJlI,d, Oppot1Il1lD1i:ticS [011, w:hich ilhoCif' auwfiOiTliy' tk1pendls. Oppo;FtW!litii,cl[ ,~ :~dal by' :PQliitit.i'd;, ;~~ ,Hld «OJlj~Mi~ (liltldiJnOOi!,!< whi~h ~.fil!1S canl :i'I1IIi1.:lt'tD;(lt;" :if:';at. ;aillj QllII,~' lDi insipiitlc!ii!'o:l: 'RYS~, ud mpad~ :ucc [c:(il~:ui~p~t O~, rg~~lti(: ,e~d~~I.,! ~ ~.ady [~l1!~n.'"

'.,.,.. .... T;"~ fal ',' '~""""""'b'l~ ~-[ ~'''';iI!oj~1;'' [...;II~'~~'II~nl;'Olli~Jt i"'":"~ ,"I ~ .. ,t, .... , 1::'''', ~I'i:-,,",,;' n~~-", ,,,,,,,,,,,"1'., ,IJLLL~'.I,._,Ill . '!Ir-U-.I,81_ .I.:JU. Il-u !WI_lI~_.,1I ~-(i;LU-rIlLII_L~I~I"-'l MII£IUl Mil ll_M~~~.l l _U~ IWI~I_IW_~ rlj·U~lII~""!iiI ~-!I!~

kxU! fOr 'thei:r [cx~(.;be;. ~ a, remld~ .~I'l!tsl :biave u1Jtimat~lf '(In'ly 'G~~ 're~tmbmty foil' the~ QloQi;-;all ~HISlbl~i1f: .. aDd. d1ru '.in,g an a.l!jtn,n:~, mom .nt tdmmat'dy' ,d~pen. an, flU!XfiiiliUJWJUlKmDW, facton.

ne Imp.licaiion of '~.i:!iil :is '!!halt; :if liM~, vrnm ;rlg;liIIt ;iJ], ~laiming' Ithat, ~)t ~51

~1111.~"'l"""0!I;11<"" I • ..,. ;0!I;"~1..~ '1Ui",",'I"',,",~iMIo;!ll!"", 1Ii~, ::Ii«~[t,,",, til!h· ' .... [ 'h,...'Il-;·I ... ~·_:ill\.!'~ '~T"'..;jl·I~""'t,..ihiiu:~ ~I.I.!. -_, !1.o.a1_III111_L~ ~ ~ ... ,II~ ft·IL~~_~l.I~1iJIil! 'l"V ~~I~.J\iiJ! ~'I_I'U 1_:el~,J!L~_lJl!! riljl~-I'!r.~-~,ll1'

b~t HQ~autonm:HlQ~ji~f ~ [~JI' th~1l :~t. ~UfdJ :£dU~ tb~t. it ie[ ,~, im~j", ma:~ '~:O :ucri!be w1h:,kednr:M, [0;[' B,'OOdneM fJot' 'tlba:t matiter~ [00 .11l~ w:tii:!:~ antl,o:m.'!!, ru"t' wmno:nlGil8.i ~nec' ;autono;nlOl!J~ aetlons '!!.dtirJli1at.ely depem;dJ Q~ fiQl\iltllfOl\.oQlOus. :faCJt~~, :If m~' I;befil! ;~~nt 'RR ,o])rre(l~, dt~ l$C~rip' dun. ,of :RS~MJ!Mlii~' ootddJ n~t!r 'be' l~,tlDDte',.

IF-'_- -,.. ~ l' -""',Qr-

lit Is. :perba;ps Jil'C()~ 'm smess that .~~s[ dim'C~'t~· its[ :not d~c to the :Iltrut~ '~b~ms, :ta1Kt't ~' d~lm"mii'n:i~ ~d the ~ri~dQn. I~ m~[:al1, Fe-

~-~ 1tP.',ll'l!IJI"- l~/' ,r'

s.~nmgbi~~ty' i.fd:~~mliiDi:mlJ 'we:m OOrTlect, 'lbe5e pr<:jb'lem:s present .cul .. ,

'i'~~~ ~~ .. 1I-'7:~'1f, '11~lb'"'T"'I'b ~'i!i;~-:I, ~:~"'~r ,...or1ili'~~,~ ~~'"' ~jl 'I..U\oi"io~,~'lld' '~~ '~I~;!;1ii~,iI;,I!" ~\oi"O[ ~.,,",~ .... I;1i;IV, ue15 lli.o.~ IUU<UIi ,1i1!~1i iIIlGIi _OIly IUt"""., '"'~ ~)"~~I iIlU' I!~, '!!'I''!U!' .... I! . ~ I!Io'I~illi_gu I"" 1_, '!W!'''~1!,1

F~be~ wiitib. them" ~~F th~ tru.th ~uJ dEt£rm~I1!~~ tJ;.i~ :UI~m1, :!!l~k,IW' is l~'Ioon;M!ilkgt ig ~l1'l1' m' :~rilbe ,~~dlo.~ fO:T :nQn~M!li~Il&' :mO'~" ,~Il(;of:i~,~ wjb:jjJC)i 'hin,g 'wii~ti.n.g t.o[ 3Sl;r$H' ~,t for :atUom;n11mWID !lo'tiO:lls(I' if ;~utQ~()):mo~, ~ti()):m;!!i' • ~~, o~t w depend g~ :~Q'~M:fiQ.~ :mtcro~ t::Q ,avoid '~i!il, d"GJjI~!, :~~bc:~ :mj'Us,I; :,fiOVId~ ,a. flJMtrr' upl~a!tiUtl. [of"w'lll,i)!" ;arutuliUiJmllY is oec'elSalY for mQra1J respon8iJbjlUIiy., Their attempt to oo"sQ WiD 'M diK~d ;m, tl!t~ 1~,~xl.SttI,jO:ll.

Th . ih ~iI dA~ifI 1 .• '~ .. L I:;L ... cd~~ of' =~._.._:ere '~j' ~,-owev,el~ ;~so a se(lon~ ~_I_II ~¢lLJ1y 'YfIJ~~ I~~e' id~~.~ :stra~lW' I~,.;

d~m.:yinl'llt~ :~ilc~:~ty o:f'~~'11 i.n dt~ (;~ ~'liiaJbil!uaJ, par*m, 0:£n,()li.iarlli~on,", o:m.O'w aauoos., "[,lite diflCJl.IIt}!":lsi 'that their ~lenia!l, oollJ~i,Ot8 'wiirl!el;f' aarood aud *ongl,r :bc!ld, mo:m.il j.\!Id.gm.co!t8, Consld1e:f' the !mO;M stmdi:B8' of: dil,e d.fuatlc~ ins.ensiuve'~ and, rutbl~ lage~1)j dt'lCnbed, :~n th.~ p~c:ed~ng'

.... ,'L..,g"p., iIi"9ll'~ '~;o;>:;:1l' '""iil'[ ~~~~ I.,'i[-'~m ["0: 'I"',!,>"~iI'''' ,~~ !ii"I'~:::iIf>"i'Ii;lii\,!I .. , ... ..:il '1I'i'~.:il·I'I"t;"'b~'!V~

~:J]_.g~ ~ .. ,. JJJ llJ,~"_,, '1!11 I~1::!I lI~-:UlIl !l-_Ill~ _- _ 1 !IJ. - ~U_1ni.oJ. ~'1!1I_1 lIII_IAIUJ}wlUl_ ~I,~ !PII.I"IIU .r,I~- ,~!Irai_ 11.11

'ltJllllt ]lOt!iarU1ion,omn:lui~y:" 'T'ibq' ~![ '~,E;rn_fO.rn'~ itii,0t; 10 'k' ;~_d~d, a;5, w:i~lmd" aorlc:o:lidiilli' tol 'the 'lifixmt iSh~.'. Th~~r [eWl acmOl1'5 do ll,o;t ~H,cct, on d"teillm

.... \o;~"i'i"' ... I~, ~~.I~';O<~ ~'L.""'t< ""''''-' :""',"!"~\,!l .,..,...·I·_~iIU ~ ... ~-:I "",_Ai,' ~---,...~ll)u ,.,.,... .. nn:-, .. "":ji~'I~ il''''I"['' i:&'U!¥~1J ~IJ,,.' ~~~~ 1lJ]~ f ,:ill! ~ ~,J!-:..-lIl1'l ~_II:iI~IJ_" aJI_lIl1J1, 11=lt-u.L ~_ilJ_LUIm_IJJ .IJ ~-I:],r: ••• ;I!._Ii:t.ID.. ,~ I!lz 1

it'h~ir' a'Ctilo:ns. :NOw COlls:idttr 'th~i'[' COlllm~~ n~ ,th~ o,rosjj~ ~>lt1d [0'£ ilhoe nt1)m, ~~tt",Bm;; ;~tml~ 'w:lt~ ,~ tm~RUitlli;~ iSe~s~iiti~,~ ~d, almili$~lc~ agellb, 'wbQ:!Se' ¥i~e~ ieg, 'them m' benefilt om'eLf:!!l, ha~'b~~all:r ~d, :flWedilOt~ ~'blY!I 'bllit, [dt~ ~ ,~ aodng tm(lmIauJt\(i~():n:u:rQI.y.,

Th" ,. t" .'" '" ~'<~ j"'ii...~~~ ~ • ..i'i-.~ .<'i...~ t: Iii.. 'k:: .... ~~ii "'~ e nn!lllJlca~o:n Oli: tne ~ui;;;i'!t~ ~U"a!. B ~j_a~ '~!I!e ag'en!ts[ m ~~!iI!~~~~ [evIL

ud tooCi ;a.prnilU of' :i:i.'ilbiJtnaJ, g,'OOd, 'ha~ leX'aC!t1, m~' ~~. mnOO. ;si!a1fiding;

N .' i;~ '. f' il.'f ~ .... ,1 '. .:I1.nTn I L.... •. ;,<\!;" '. . ,;, ~

n,.Q~e" ~ ... el!~~er lSi l_Qu~C' 'W mO~:-Jl~~e~~ wC3iUK' ~iU!I!~~er [lSI at.all:K ~UWD-


'O'UlQUi1y. But what :rc~nlb)e :pcrw~ wO!JJ)ld not thifllk that h; is, morally ~U~r ~ be UDd~alti(!i ~Mjlti.~!, ,wrtd ,a;iIU1lri!u¢ [than, _ '~ d();g~jj~~"~

il""i>'~"'I":;:!If''''~ aad .,.~ .. ,1,.1,,"1""~' '1"''r", be :'. !."",[ .. ,~ ,,,'L . .,, ';;>"'~.""""";-riI_""''1''I'" ~""""iI!"i"il""'i!i ""~ ''''':;;-''''''!i'' ,1J~,I,;~:JIol"")IJ.!J..·",~ .. , ~ ... :_ IJLLilJUlJl"___~1i .IL~ IUC ~!I.,;,U,'1or. .. Ul!Lr [~IJI~~IJ"!I;'-JE.lI~~ ~~~~~,~ ~IL "'1i1J1'_~_I;II'

Is ~tur- 'than, d1:eir' :n,ODlf101iailom-oUs, '~£:[\c~', 'buJt '~o wolOOld d~~~ lilbaij 3WJjto:n:llm(iHJS OJ' Itotj viI1lrous. pooplle: aFe mtn:mty ibetter tban. ''WielGus Il'W""nfll!e:? 'Y-tlt the' '!liberal r$tfa:w~' oonlimi~ :~b, defeHid~, t'O 'ui:<;:d. 'lh~ incul1J'"

,r'-~'r I~l-' 1:.1

~s~~le mQ-~l jJiidgiiiJlefilt. \iVh~t ~o~l~ L~~d f,e~:n::~ible' and, rn~Iy' ~cOm-

...:1, 'f in iL.~..:I'. ';I; I . ~<'I... • f '" ke .,

mo.Jtteu! peofLC W _CL~ a!~UJry!Jity,.· '.J: :IS ~~e!1l' ac(;_ep~(le i@;' a :nusta '~'!m. :Pf1lltli'"

'" 'II ,;il_ .. ..iII ,. • .. ,'1...'" '" '" '11- 11'· 'Ii... ~·L~~:It.., ........... 111 '"

,clIiple'" ,~~~, ~,~ '~ ~~~S' '~,e'l' ,~e !PrlI~C.~f"';:' '~ W,~ ... '!£ri: ~~~~~ ap~~ n~

~~I!iit:pti:ng w' :~W~ m(:l' ,'~t _(:l,l]rty :nQot~, ;il!~.

The' :pri___ttdple '~!l whim the ~ibem ~tnJ'. fbI' d1e'Jlyt~g Ute' re-

O '"'·Iv f '"I d~' d.s . 1 ~~.:I, '" ,..'i.. fj' '11~;;.:1-. iii, ~" ''il.", ,;~ '.

,-1e'XWJi .. :t'iQJ ev:!_!." , .. e:pe!rn:'.._"~ cncap!!iU ai~ m dle' 'wrml!!LilA IDa~~O~H:)I"')!I.,~· :!lin-

'~. • , "~ 'J' • ..... :fl"" '.. 't>~.:1 I' ~ ..... :II ' 'J d '. ,;, . ,;, ,;, -..I

p~el .'. ca,: ' U :liS '.~'1 LQltetpre~ ;;U a, ~~~ pfL11Ctp .. e 3([1;'.'_! I_$ ~n~cu;"CQ

md d!de:!'tded, as, ~~cib.!, (See (;Qwa~s, 1:98,7' :f~!:" ~~lD_al ,M1.ide~, and 'Wb~ .. ~:hy:., ~5l, :1004: "-in~, and k~h~F l.tac7:; ,(Jlial,ter: ~n. n~, ~ritid~ b~R' 'p.~pusttd tr[~~ tJh~ :prin£~p:l,e :as, ~, meral O:fi~. I'bji.S'~ ifJ, m~l!tGrllJ' 'YtE.'W of i,ts ~~!l'erpre-ta11o:n (.~'1I 'h~[~, :BrO\'OlJ 19~7';; :~bs, 1986~; Larmere 19a,;':;: ,64-.00,; ,a,n,d V{hhe 197'9)" 'The prinQ],l~' deri,'I'~ {FQQl :~rt~ but 'ilt b~ oome' to, be wiide1y :he]d 'by :!'ll)n·:~ti~ ~ '~Il,,~'

:If ~t IS, true it'b.alt an .en~ iO'u1ht W, aet ,lD a UifUUD 'w\aT~ the :p:riIfl{:~ple' ~ru, 'then ~~ mlUt abo, be true thalt the ;age~~ [could, act :in 'that 'wa!¥,. m ollher 'woIib~ ill ~ a ,cQ'ndlitl.Jln of l:~i~g .otallly rel~S:i,b1e' thti the a(el'llt be' ,a!bl~' '~ 'dl~'h!HI~ tffilJ,e r~~il$1Ihm~., I~ FQnl)~ tl~j~t, ~ :j!t,1l$ ht'i.~lbl~' f'Q:l" ,an, ,.~iillt t'O, fuitfin,~, D;Gra!l fl~~nsih~'lJlty, m~ifi, :~[, ]5, ]llEjJltimat~ 'm~Hi~' tblt, responSibiUty to the .,eo;r., 'lIte prindple' thus pre5lJipposcs tha:t Rte'

~g_TOt b· .... .,"~.Df:: ... i-,;a;..,.t ",,,,,,,.,._ . .,,.'i """"_II!" .. a, .. ,,,, ..... :,,,,,II!'I, In 011'1"''''';::01l!'l' '~l"" 'D'"'·aoa ... ,.,. ....... '-"~~;.) :iIII.:I ~lliEI;hl,';'L'!t..:I~~)' iL~IJLilu,L!L.:I.iJ, l~rI-b • .r ~)~ a~iUk..L.J ,':, '-.ju..'1o.I:au:. lJil. JJ.lI_jJ~ 1.r ... ,l~~ .. lI~~l

,of Si'iiJQh. ~O'j]tFul ,ijs ,n~~~ for :mo.FaiI: ,R5,pon~~I~tr!, w;b,'C!f;eas ~ts, ;"i~R'c~' ,cx'Em,ilS, ~nts from, ,lit., Th~ ~1i1i(ia!tiU~5, of ,~~ r.l~,~IIr:M c~ntt(fl. ;fiU(i), to be spened, out" of (;ourse'~ b~t ~tl.e' [end prodim:t will lank pretty Im'U{:'i~, 'tih' 'the [cO'J1;diti_j)~s, of !il[Uit\o'J1~U]I{y [~b~ Seoti_j)~ 1,.5)" Ought iQ}!pJje~ ea1n~ tibe~~ ~~a'~~ ~~W the d3lirm, that. ii!)~'~' arU!tQliIont1!)~, .~nt~, are mo:rall,y :re!§,punsibl~.

T· he ~;fu'" 'I ,"'11:"...:1 ' •• 1'1"*:0.' ,.··,.~].,.'I'Ii.!' "'fl'\'l'Wi"i""'I~lj1ilQi' .,..:11 "'!!"'I, -jo'Ii1'I"'f~ lends [ ... '""' .... ,.,I·-:iIi"".,..,..I'~II·~ , " _,~ Ir'~ .. ". ~f"!I, -, o.H)U, ["iII!l,. - )u:~ .... ':/ 0r:r·~iUh..,~ LU""O ll~o!l.. ,~~iII,l!JI~ ,",'V',u.'iJI_ ,ttiI'""'~ ""U, ,."

:f'o;rce' '~O ~,e' :prilJ;ciIplc~' is '~,m, 'IJlIi~t. only 'tlA~, .en~ wb,o, :bJare ehe [ClipaC~t¥'

..i .. _.'. ,;", - . - - - ~<~ '. .. ~. . ;L'::~'·. - ~ ~ ' ..... 'f ~ ,.~. ~ "'1 '11: lA"

4U'h,~, o:~po:rw~!I1I~~ 00 meer '~~e![f :K'i!il,~~!ii~~__Ij[ty' ~ ee .. egjlJt!!miillay ".ue~~, ~

be -o-F3iIJy :~~,pl;m~b'l(ii. ']bj$, :i$ 'wby mJait-t!irial! ("bjCi,(;~ :pl!l!Il'b!" !l!D!i;mal~ in,,,, :fa:Il't5" gd dttO:Se '~I~ :me.ntail: dis:curders, lire ,e~.e;mpt.ed (mm, 't~e m.'Orm [Ies.poHisibility, 'to '~~C:h humae ,mUll~ ~ :noffllailjy m'b:J~ct. If Ilibis :~ ~~ men


~~beF3ib '~31n u~ m~ plin:tipaJ 't.D Rsolrn: m~' ·t\¥ol dji£fi~mrtitis, :FRised ,31[, 'the '~Uid 0:(' lit@, :P:n'<loolim:g :~d!o:m",

The fI,r.st d~m.eTI;IJ1f is ~31t :ljjbef.:3!ls, n~cd tnl ,~plaiin. ~hr :ali.U.nfiD:my' l!!i, :ile& ii!"~n!' ~r"m, ..... """'11~ '~N'\'m"'''I'b~ ;11~:.·ifV ~~·''''''I~iI!'''''''''h-~V ,.,.ii"i~i""jO'''''iIi''''''1!... d.·.~",,~~,-I1""""foo'''''' '"-r< "I'r""'I. 'i_,

~~.J 1!v.I. 1 __ ,V,IJ,g_ 1 ,11L~r-~..: _.':iJI_ I_ .-IJ_: _ ;~:r ld~. ~!WII~.v...:.~lt~._~_".1 !U~IJ'j,!.I-~-~-II-AAL-~-~,l . _I~~ ll;!'I!-~ J~.J ~I~.~I, 11::1~~~~!Ur

tf,)nnm((1~ fiwt(J:'f$, Th~ :prin'c~p~e :pr.~de$' '!rthe :r-eq,U~fOdJ e'~J"Jau~.!JiQiJl; 'O:lllr

~il'I'''~'"'''-r<m' , ~I ..... ~i"~, ~,""'"'"I., .. , h. ~, ~1"',;;;., .... ai'n~~~~ltv ,""n ~ ,~i'ri'im""C, ~~,@, [i;~1 'Ij;-",,", 'ifW'io ;: c~ ,'1'111. ,~ : . O~"'!licU',H,V .. "'oI!cIi.ilill ~!YU!I.iJI ,,~'Mf!l'~ ~U"'" '!L~~ .. ""IJ.:, ~.IU,U, ..,,1:"11"' .... ,1, !l!iUn!l~;1' dl Ii,M;: ,U!,O:Fa! ~.I' ,~

s~ttliIbL~'" l'.It~ ,~Oti,d. d.~U!lty :~ il~l) ,~plajn '~" d~e ~~ti(!K1l m: RtOf,aiI r~;po:l1'5:i!bijllilty :b ~m:~PPffl'~W' :l7ur n(jfi~,1J,;l!tQn~m,~w pa:tle~~ of' a~tiQ<it. ']'he' ,ex;pl;matii.o:n :is <ili.e - ~e';: ag~'fl.'ts a;c~~g' :l'IiQ~a!.u'~QDA1)m()gl)l' lacl, 'tJhe ~n'!O~itv :'!O'n~/'~"'I'li'.' ,t'5f:.." ,., 11I1iin.i'\'..,n~'J.,.,j'I'~' 'tf~ '!Il-~, m-:,,~;Iil~' 'r.'~nA"".o:!i'I·b"~· 'rr, "i'''fo.'I~~iii·dji'

~-~~!IIJ" ~~.~~" ~11 ,,_IJlI!~ "~ r",r,r"-.,IJ l"'~_.ll_ 'til} !l~ L~ __ IV II ~_IJ_ 11' [, 1IWr~~~,I~I~_ _ l~[I[ [~_I!~, J!~ -1I11o.:1.!'f1i1ll-"-~l.t.

[[h~ pri!m,¢'i(p!lE:" :ilt is r ~c.'~Gd [lliJat il~Jiij~ 'be~.~ ~ fl!IQ:W :~Iil!~ 'Qin1.~'

'_en 'lhp.v act ~t'"l"n~o"~;c:o~,~ , .. 'I:..'"'"U ~" ... "", f\~....",,~,t~, ~b;'''~\if"''''1 ;];1'I.;-~Cilflo,.iJi~i~l'~ I~.'.~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ '~~'=.l -. - -""'-"'~~~~l!o!I"~~_j,l' YI~~ IY;I~ r,lf·l!o..~II''V'YN.;I'' il,llU'~!!.:a'u ""'~~!O!III! \.lIiIO~,~. ~Ii. ~""'

~Dl!pti!ng' [thrll.'iir' n,([Illa.u)t~n(!"llU~ ,~n{Jt!i~, fffi~ ~(Jm] j~~.e:l1l!t I[U~Ppeli!r5"

If 'Ib.ese diiUicullies 'weR r.ie.m(,W 00 , [m~:tl '~~ ~i'be.if3!l :SIl'1!~ uf d~y&~g' [that :haib~t~laiI, p (U~~, of n.o:~uro~o:mou.s eVil, a{;~o:J'I~ ·~t the' ascrip-

tlon ,,,:,:1' '~"'~'--:--~:n"'~;c:o;I!1 'ti'-r- ~,i..",,~,,!, ,~. '.'"l"~"'! '~II~ll"" If.~, ~.~T;"-rfI~"'''''i\~-fI 'l::~I'b.-=~~I'I;-: c:;-,-;t.41 _ ~ ~~ '!..!',t 'I'!!·~l!w~.cu_U""!0!4 ~ iYJl!I.iu -Oi_illlll;;) ,"",""u_l'U, ~ "·.u,I.lIJ.lI~,",OIJ~" , l!ucl7"lIu,; oO'wu,

th~Jl ~n~$bteo,d~y acb~ledg~' '~e p~,idel1-oe of c:~Jl wildlol!J!t, a~tdb~~l~C' :1)\ t:O wil:'kerlne~; 'Ilbe objeulan !dlJat a:tl)tlUj~fii1'iJ'" [['hoe' basi:e '~ailJ\iies!, :~~, '6e pl'lticaill :p~s, '(ill' :ILiJbemil~sm, .ft.:u'ell" e\!fi:l 'WGillbJ '~ 'w~ab!ll.«~d~ ad 'lit, oou!d be h£ll(j l:Ia~ .e 'best: li,(Jpe m: m~'king ,eriJ les.~ iP~~~.J~l iiS '00 R:ple--

'R1len'i' .. 1.."", '~I·.b":"I!':'];,]~ ,FW"rii'I:'I·!Ii".'....."..'11 'n"'~.·'i·, ~'W'" ""'1''LJ''~''''I.. "'i~m .,,,:!",: ~i""'C:~I"'1Ji"'" ~:b.-:.~c:~ EN'" c·f." =~. ~~'" I~... ~_ 1~I,M, r"'" _ )~ ,'!;.,O;I t"',I"~'I!iI!'" _UL<l!.! H!llbUU. ol~n UI!' ,1~[lor i[i~ ,~ne ~r'" O'J.

auwfifim:y, ,,[b.~ prl!i1i,OjiPl~ mtij ,c~es, a hea"Y 'bur-de~ indeed m, ochc' ,~ef~'Ij~' ,00fUbe~~"

1ib~ IPdncip~' is. :m~smk~iH'j b~j[;, md ~~ ~anno:t ibe:1.U' 'the we~llh~ JjilbeT~'

, .... 11-, 'm= .• ~jt~·. '"""'.~Ii'ii. 1J'IL" 'i;I"Ii"~' ~' he ~. ',m~) ... i",;i" ... , ',I·;C:O· ...... ,\i!'IoV,·.m,lO/'i.".., .. ' '" 'n""'~.i·· ;C:O'I'!m,'~'rn.]~'!"~ '."t" 1·:Il.~·"'!""".·::·:I".''''',.,,,, ~., '," ,~~'~

~ ,F'~ ~ ~'·~HII ~ ~. ~~ IYl~ ~~~~~~ _Q! ~~===:rJ~~;l1 1'.::!i1Ul~ ~ _ , _ ~r-" ""'-'~I I I • _ ~ 1~V.~ l"~ M. 11~ll._~

:placecl. em!'ha3~iiJ3i. 11 dt'te ,e.mpb~5, W~f.~· lllo~ m~5.pla~ed" ih,~ pf1i~QipL~' would, ~Ff,O;r;m. ,3, eG(l~IIJ' and :impoflUJJt EDI'a!lJ tad:., Sooo,d, 'eriiti~iMn ~If ~e ipri!IJ~iple" ,th~Q:~~, m:~'jt.: idmtifY' ij~, pmper :f''Ole by (l!};['mou~ll~ :1;1:5 :mi~ pJ~, ,emp~asl~!, ratlb~f' r!lh3iIl, til' tn, in,yd!lidai~ ~i;., ''I1te pFci~diPLe ~, Ci1l~se-'

'li~'''''n'i:i:V Im~ .i:~t,",,;l'~1!lI; ..,..~;i~'"'."~""""'m· lit' ,:;!I!, 'Ii"~~ ~1f"'an.n~Ii"1r~'~~"""'i'li;t; •. ':'.~I;..~iI"'t w~'-:iiin'~ '''!If·i!ioJl~· ~,"""~~,I' ,~ __ 'I"J!!W'I'~~~ '!'.i!'IHI'~.1"iI[l& J ,u, ~il! ~1!i.iI, ~IJIJ rFIJ '!..!'I;"'I. UII!"""'~J' W,ut""lil[ IJIJI,~!DI~~ ~~~.

~~. :SQm~ c~:m~x,~ :~ts, ~ :is appfflpmoo. The 1~~tlia!1, '~k ,0£ critfc~~ is ~ihiUS, tOI dh;tjjnpidit behVe·eml ,(o;l'lili:el(~· Iu willl.~(~" ~~, '~. IS, :il(ppmprlid.~· and mU5e

" 'IJ.. - 'I... ,', ~ ~, ~

~n W.1:l~"~U u: ~5, 10,0["

h is, ~Ulng :in. ,tlmii:.s: ;{,-Dnn.e:atlnl!lJ tn :r.e'~ec~ (:in :~. ~t:lJ~,ti'OJ~. OOmin1Q:Q, WI :seven'li we'll, .. :kniO'liill ~)tle,m:p~, to id~ntlj' th~ :pf.~i~ fea~Uf~' wh~ :P:f~' e~c:e j~Ul6e~ ~, ;asc!fiptio:u (11: :m,or:al .!i'e]~~~i;b:i~ijl¥ aud whose i1J'bse:l:ttle (i:]'~~J(j]pts age;nts, :Fmm, :i,'I~ The' Db,""ii!l)~. \C_d~dru:e' :t~f 'thrb fe'a~~re i:5, ,d~o:i~'i and am(Jn,g' ,o:tfu:e:~~, e~~tetl:tia_IDbb {see,t. fQ;r' '~ple~ &!_rtwe 1'954·~: espt;-' dall~' 'pan: 4) ma.d~ :mJwdl o:f tb~' iflO~Ojl of ~. ,r-oJiIjDi; [C~D:kE' ~D' be, ::ii, H'i(JFai'1

,ag.fMl'l,. wbic'b. humJOO, ~p t ,e~ther' aeeept '0-,]" evade l~ ba~l rarutlb,." The

..il:~ ... "n~t1io' '~ili;;'il.., [",'LieD' ",.i"""",,, ~., .;L~_~, ,d' 'I' ",~_'I' ... Jh""'I·~iI>'" '''''''';ol;1!l.!' ''''~- ,i.",;-;,.;r""~-.,iI .,..~ io"~.~

'Ull1lnJ~~"'~~I" """:!Jg,~, y;~w "r:!~'nj ~~l 19~!:i:, ~-~ .. .; .... ~~ ''''=-~-=~'...-~~;~ '~.!~.~,:r· ~' [I}~ 1~'I{;i(_'j ~lL"'~;i~[ 'YT

~mJiimiFnl:'Hl~, tad, ~Ji!.lS, :inS'ilImi.ei.eniI :1"01' :m.orail, !f-esp>llIslb:iliity-


¥~t ia, f~nheil" ~",.r~(:l~ :is ~, [iFf ,~o :ld.~nlt1:l1 ",~, el~ml!m)t in, :ft!3.$.Onm d~els10,fJl~, dIal. creates :llia'b'lnt¥' for' bllamc'" YiQI 'Walme Q:e~~ :~ W'Rlgard

.. 11...'-:'''1"1 ,.,,; .. : ~l1rfnrl...,n¥O;];jtj"," 'iE.,.I~iI\;O; ''f.i'1i'[' ~''i'"'' ~"',...~~~, ""'it~!~h:'~""''''=:t''.,.o;,1,.'l"!P;IO 1"~jr.I..:I1 U:l~LllI_~ l~ .. ,lJ"lr .• 'lU"lr:.,iU .... _ ~ ril!U-~~li.1! llJ~, 1 IilIlb ... · MI ~,~~~-!L !W_~~JI.IU~~ Uil 1UU]'~~i~ 1I.u~MI_ 1 U

dIem., These' :remiYe ~tiJtu:des, i!B, '~, ,actic: ~e ,a!PPI-o.pflja:t~ n,o~ :m~fe'iJy' by the ,~nlu!' acti,Qn~, trlll[, ,3150 'bly d1~ .n~,[~ aiU.lI,~llU.i~ ~m, lI;'ho@ir ~, ;:"": ,~'\~·ii:..li~'i:..[, - if-' 'r~:: ~:roi :.41 '~ iti-' !i1I3!UJ-,C -, ,3Ji]-!I,~~if--: ~;~ims.ii'Dt.:es, of'th::'f' :amums..

nons, ~_~I!~iC_ll~ !ai_e =eveMeu ~~,_~e ~~~~~~_FC ~~.IY (:_,'C~ ~~~~ _~ ~-~' _~eL ~~~,_~~~~~,

,''In':~-; •• , ;i ,'~' ~iL..", : ~r" '1!1-~, 111>'1' , ;",~I : -, ,.~ ," i": ~~, i'r-,','il.:l [" ""'f"iiib-o- : ,- :-n.;r. r-- ·ji..'iL~ "'''6~f:lI'''' are UI'uS ... '0 ~ iIIi!'_am~Ui U'!JI, aIDe , ... 0 lIJ)I!I; IlelU Jf1lio;l"m~,7 il'~_WI;!.m;

:li~11' :bavil'l'l 'C'erWD k.ii~. 0:1: Wltiiudes, kr!vatd, th~ at.tiG-c_n~ (BenBe~t 1980;

;£!-"'",(n,'I'oIj'Iiii'" '~1:9'Oi:i!., .... ( .... ..:1 ~~_.,...~.__ ... _ l'i"ii~'.4L .. ,),'~_Dl.;lll~""_LI ., .-00,1 ,1LU;I,OI ~·"\i7.U"-.IIll ... ~ II: ~ .. ~I

Tlile a,u~p~on :t_ha:red b1' ~n these' ~~te~pu, to id.~tify- the :fe:~w-.e .~t :ma'k~ 'lile ~~'MOj], ,0£ m,oIiall :~pomrsi)bnijty lc~gitima~' is 'that it is cw~e~im;g' ;i-nride the .'eAtt~, $Ome$iiti.g that, fle ,agefiJI:$ ~o\l~d d'ol ~F ~


~~":"- 'L...,._,;i,"'"",,.,..,. 1'JiP'-"'''1iiPl[>;1iII',,:,,(lI!' ~'I:~, .... ;n)~'~ .... n '''"1i'f' "'i'!ihii'l"'h '"ii"'-~' '''''1'1''''"' h..,.'fd- 1 'm~~;I~ If""'-

Ur'V'illlr"1..r ~l .. v..IJ·~ r· .... llllliv-..I.~:IJ_IJ_~I!.~1 IU~l~ !QI."-I~,,,~IJ ll~~ ~_ ~=..,.IJ_ WlIJ--l, ~!I!.r -=~-.~ =:.=v~~·7· ~~-

~~bl~'" The prl_IDldpi]e, ,@tl-lbt. b~p'lii~!!l ~,~ :~ ~~~rpJ'!et-ed moeR, ~ ~1a1m.-'

i»Q' '~''''';o:J;ft·, t:H:,p.n''';O;,,;o'';o:J;j~1 ~-, IE!lI;i,(1'. '~"", ~~, m .... ~:III,u, !l'eU\OinsiIJf.1 ... £~'dojmDi' wm.e,thiinCil' 1!_1f.~;1I!:Ii1 1IlJI!!I.."", ~~=!109.1 '!;;~~ I!;!II!; ~.~ """" I~ ~"""~~'i1' ~ ~~!r'''=~~~~~~'''' ;I)"",~. ~~~"1'" ~.~ ~~~~ ~~~~

oldy' if tIil~ ~. dOl 'Wk3i~eveF it. ~, ~at the relpQftlsibl~~~tlQR £e~tw'e :~uim5. 'Tibe' principle Idlius :ma!kei§, ~~U~ ,ur;ripti:o:m o:f mom'~ ,u~ponSiltii~~lf C~Jl'~,r 109 :~'ho:l~k.a!1 ~~~, ~~~rdl~ll_gly~ 'lit i~ a:PpJ:1Q;P~·~ ItOI hob)

:!:IiD'i'i"Oilijll: '''''''"'1ii~!i~ '1!!O!"II!II1iii'i'iI'j!lcil'i,'L.'!ii ... 'iI\ .... r:' I"h· · ... ~r, :!:Io ... ,t'-i ...... f1dll!, Iry"_]~' !ii~ I~'~';:;' ;;:!;;iO''iti;r:01;!i; '~~ ;r:or 1..,~~'!;i1i..:l1 ~,~ _ ..., [IJ"_II~ll[MI_I_II,r ,.J·~r-'Ior."II-II-"_IIU-.l-~ [ltv, 1 l. __ ~II_ ~Y1!i.l.',1J_1I_'" ~.~I-]I ll_1, YllM ~!U~1II_11 "H'MiJI "I..!I 1I.!-V"u_IIU

:have been Ca;~ 'by 'the 're!!l,;afJIMbl~i;ty-~tilQ:1f £e~We' within 'tihem-'

I ........ ''b~~·-I

,~I."",~,

Tl-.""'iIi' "'1 '1:11' G' ~:o;co'"'" 0': f:' ,"t'If:o.<!O ,nn,"""i.<rl1,;1!o is 'm, ·fi",,",;"'-iL-:·~.,.., '11 'Itr-_~ .. ··"'-· ...... m· : '''''ii', ,..,..,..~,.'~"l'ii •. II"" ';0,', "f:i'", .......... '","''''. ,","'.;0;,

til [I~I.:&~ ll._.iIL _~ L~ • 1 ,_IJ_~-~ F, •. ,._I~."_'_IJFJA:r l _~ __ ,La.~IJ_1J ~ .... -u" _ I~~ ~U'W,b ... ~ u._~~ Lilli. 1Ii:1

~ ~

:poiBted, O'~d -that. it iea.ves, Qu:t, 0'£ c-onsidie'mth:;uIJ aIli1! aii)iioliJ,iI,teiy' cmcialJ moraID

'~"""iIi'_ L"I!l'ioil;>, 'II1iin·'"..' ..... i,n'l..,. ... ;O; ... '""~~i<': 'm"1i''''ril '''''''''r!iiii}";'"c;o;i,b·.il'I'JIV iii.,.,. ","",,;01!.'..,.''';O;, "~r ~"L. .... '!IIl":>,~ ~;""I lIL~~1 .iJ.lIlt'!U! ,r~ 1. _.~I~_:IJ,r]'-I.r ~_IJ 1I1.K.-:r. l __ ,.v.,~, ,1l'.u-filI!,r-~lJiILIJI_1J ,lIi_IL '''-:1' ~u ~O~I!.lL::J! ,IJu tlI],~ HdJ,r;,' ~_IIIJ

w'biQ;:'h m~ oome • pedo~ dteb: ,aW(U~~1 b.wt Mt fw the I~Cts 'tiheb' ,acuOcns 'bave ~.~ (uihc"" The :prll_lld:ple is, thius pmOfOCu:pied 'w1;tb d];t~ causes 'M ,actions all; me ~~itH' 0:F: lh~i[ ~fF~ts. The' wUlllL~' is, m1:~t. "~t m~' :,.., ,ch,ob.jlcal ,Ila!~:es ,of ,.nts are :i'r:rellewm,I(; to ~th:eir' nI{Jrid ,i!!itlindiing;J bl!2it, ni!iu~r' that '.iE :1'110:1:'3:1 r~~~c'C ,of 'riie:irr' :psyth.ol~c.al ,!ilmle-s de..~ frQ:m,

ii .... ~ ~. -'~ ;Oil.. . .. .'~'. 'il.,..... I~A, ,.:ii.... Th-' . 1 . ····Ai

me eYl~, ~1ei!!oe ~tare!ill ,~Mve ~w IYJ~'C' agCTIilS 'to eaase, ,,)) l! :,nn'flp. e '1'.91 ''WIftmte.!ilI,

by this :mI5.plac~ '~miPbiWs 'HCaItlM me' m.o.rWll¥ ~iCR~, .:fi):ct :1.1 we' I~I" rcwt the' ~er in ''''ib!ic'h ~iit: :is mNJiS1ed" 'libe _len£t:' oJ !this :mct is, ~i;tly a'Cb.iowJ~d, I~n, 'by .~~, :m~~IUC' 'of' 'th:~ :princi:ple" :wv 'O:Il'~r if ,eVil were'

. ~ 'wo~ld, ~t mate sense 'to seek 'to ~g~ (~L[' wld'lbiO~d :m,o;ral uSPO:llsi7, bi'ljJty :['O:li' ;acti'Ons 'fDait caM@' it,

Kefilectiog O~, ili~' JIlI3iU!.LFe ,of :m~~ll' wlj~ lIeinifoJ'lIe ,this: r:riticBm,;, It is oommuo.n :gwUind amoll.g' Rto:~' '~ho am' ,co:mmh~d '00 D~rWWty :and, ~lnk aoo-~i: ib liatu'lle -that :iit3 u~m~~ ',Ui!:p05e ~d jitl~lc3itloll i!!l, to :p:rl~lruJt ~l land, '~.o. ]H{)JfiDte good. 'n.~n: :De S¢iiOili:l, ~~.-eei'fieni't$.~ of: OO~FSe~, abo~n wh--j' 1-,GOd ad"! ':c:"~ !~',~-, '~,·.,4 'k., ,~' i""'i-.'~:"~jI~'j' .'j .', b ... c. ' .. " :.-i. "d'~I, ~~_ ~ _._ .. ,J~ g __ ~ _~_~ ev:I_.., ue guo .u,OW IY)~-ey O~ .. ~~ ~ I!.n:",: pmm~~ .. Oil'

:pr~n~dJ" blllft: ~jb~K d'iiSalf'~m'EIl,'t.5' :p~up~ ,co:mm~tm~nJt :~o :p1.'Cve:nt?, iillS 1eV.iJ. ~d, 100 ,~~tiIlfIg' ,good., 'The5e' m,oraill ta5'k;s, are basiic", and lever;' ItliIhul' I~I~' dj!,~S) ~,~ mo.ml Ylnl~fi~~~' fmm, ilS wfIIJmbtiMDn, 'W 'iiie:m." It i~ the:~ro~ a ma!ti'er 'Qf,p-ealt :L1iDpe'rUIDa' tn s.haJ_pe du~ ~'Hlra.c.ter- ,0;£0 :m,o;ml

~a,""mrt,iI', ~ ,;o:J;GJ ,to-r< ,dli~~, '~i'!t;>iim. 't'~.'r,d' I iIi·b.·~ ~ ,"'iIlr<.;J1 ~~~"'i;o,.i :",,~II. ~T':;:R ... --: ,--:;. ~'!;,,~_w !<!"!<l!' !Will W-.!I' -"""'lr..~~- 1.iIUI!"", ~ _, !II,V!'I'!!'JI1I;.. !II_ ~ ,"", t!1i,~' ,.;uOllU ~_IJ~iI!!I:. ""'·~·.IJ _" no.l!.,.g ,5{}

":r.~!f,i.Il'" ~qw.~~ ci,lnc~fIl~~d~n, ~jji, tfi-e :~twg:l~~ ,c~~~, ,~ ~bciJ' g~, ac;{i~~', ~t ~)18 ·.al: C_'O'l'fUle:l'JIllnlion, al1id '\idliat e,nd!owtS, ~t( mtb,

'm· ,';-rii,,!,"'1 ,.tl·!l7inJ~~""'"''''''···C·'''''- ''''1 ~-~Of ""~' 't''r·~ ,i)',.·~"f~1 ,"'I"'~ """':;;~I .~~:-: c:;;\~ i''i.·-rit _,..~ "'.-'1 , ~ _ """','A, iiJI~ ~1"_.l.ilIIAog'l" '''''~I IlliU!l'l!"'''''~~" .iU ~ .IiL... ,!)U'UU OLI,'iU, ~~d el~}II,;Cioa !IilIJiIi_... u.~.o:[,,"d,

apnr~, 'C3!~'" This; o:ro~F ~f il~po~c.,e ~ lost Ln fie' priJudrple" fbr :i!t, emphMiz,e~, Ititl.'f,: I~ iimp>:t1amJ~: ;at th~, '~KlMn~ oJ ~(i' :m,urn :impo:ft.a!nt.

'De 'p~~c~pb~' ;~ tth~ m~ asl ~, renkmiO:ll fOJ" the' a;"J:1oprl:crteneM 0:1 nu!~I7dil, responMhilit~f'. ]t mistali.enty ,5ll1fP~S ~a't only :if ~~ :psyc'b~L'ogical s~:!!, oF: mQ:~, ¥11Ji)$ :m~, a ,c.-e:~g ,coRd~ti.o~ if; dgt. '~. d"t-e ;ag,e~~ are' aN.llto:l1omO'~ is. i~ legiltima:te 'to hiol!d 't~e;m, mo:aly Ir~f.l:s:ijhL'e'", Th~ asaip'


~.'. '.':.ii:::.',~,.... Ai...,.·".;I' :t' ~',iI!.~,~,~~

;;}!IIII! ,.,"!6' .... Jml!"U~,

UO:llll of IAlG:r'al res:pan~ijbi;l]i)ty to' ,no:nautnu;olliOUS ,.~ts ~s, :ill:1.qit1ma~i B~~ w:l1y g, ~~~nQmy' hn,poRaiJJ,t? Wh:Y' ,6 Cfuild, :m~m r-e~~~lbmty 'be' Pliadte W, d~~~d, on ,~t :~Il;~F 'tha:n (l11J mil~U.~n('~" oort~t:~oon~ ~., :~ol~ii ~~t+ 'cnc'Cl, 'm:-' wb~d' 'Wb,y doe!!l, i~ matter WbCl\hoe.f' ~mr~, :h;ave :m~' '~n:[un::.d, tib,o.l~5~ ~JU3ittd ~ra~i1r' ,K~tm5J1 ,Mui 'wui~n;tiOOd 'l!h~~1!' Ilpi~ ,cmcci?'

The:rce ~, 'It;eJust ,()[n~ ~c :llt, ~ttef,$, ~~ of. cfi.e' ,evil 'maIt apmrt8 CiUi.I)K'", (1'ht: I'oodj alse rmttte;['[!., of coune'~ 'b1!li'f; ~in£e 'dle ~~~: I~ tn@; :U1:x!IiaJ, iillca,aolty to deaJ, '.tlh, ,eWl" dt~ ,~, ~9, i,p~Fed.,) If that ~" :JQ.\, h~i:"

~:ij-'''"'n~' ,g 'P·'[·I"f:"r. ~r:> ''''''''1i'":",,iiiiu' ,~I~~~ .. ~ , .... n·'I\..., ... OJn~' ,..,vi"I!<,~)D~ for' :g""I'~n'ib~:;;~Qi' 'm, '''''''-r''~ '''"¥,,ni''lm:''oo

Il_IIII-'_'_ _ I lim ." II r'UI ~I ~J 11~.J.I~,IJliAi_I_"J ~r"llol".lj:r. ~_ I, I~~ll inSt _ I ,-"d __ ~ lIJu., ~ I •• _._~~ l __ U't~:.dJI, [I,~~~-~, ,

silhlli",~, ~ame:ty'" me' em ,eff~, 'liiitlt :~O~ qemr~ C~~'., That ilt ~ prior and mona!Uy d~p!r :r~U.mvs £mm, ,it heinl m,o'R' :lmpo:rta!n,[l~ to ,.~ basic

wts, of' Hloraliil.f. ' .

. ']bE if~n, ,foi' hO:ldiGig' .mrts, :m.ornJ1y r-apo:MnlL~ ,~ w' ms~' 'lh~m,

,'C'~ ~AI i~'i..·,,~ '.~' ~AI ,~~:-,:'n~~ ,"~"~~ '"l1'I'''<"j ~ ',; ~~'i" ,~:-C ,--4I~~,AI ti.li(TI-::~: 'c'~C~;/~" t~u me ,I'!..!I!U'!;)I, mu ._~:!t. ev:L, ,1,Uel!lr.~ FeCDj,'~ ann I,UtlllJlfe ,pl'oml&e

in, causing' good Md, ~viJl :is w.~t d;e1e:[[fl!iD~!II, meir.' :m,onil Sb'ndling'. 'Th,e~r

'~:'~'I·ii)Q'i~ .. 1 'iEiIi"'I'i~' i"1"cg~:itl~r:' '~""':0'm[' [t:I!-'~ '""i''''r''..,..i 1'i'iiO~~iIi: , ..... ~ ~Oi~, ik~ ... r,"~.- It:i!-~' lr"', ,._JltlllU!". I~_.~_m, IIl!!lIalE-a! lI_._Wl:l_Il.1Ui I 11J_~ ~ , _ J l_Ij_I~ 11~I_lI~I;,d.!.I, r'l;r"-.,IIJ~ uJJ ')'!llA:P.'I1r l~_~ l_ltl_l·

lt~ ,~, ~iI~¢'t; om, 6£ :m~rnJ, ,qi'iaiUtJ' ~ ,their, 3cJCiinm:s. :Re(i'I~' it foc;;~~ on,

'fK'j;I,"'i,;,,'I~~~;1 !f\iIo""i~: ~;I,..,~, 'm..i, ... , #.il~l_ 'I ... ~-+'''': ,"-r' ..... """ ''"'''Ii''; .... ,"'~J'i~n:iI' ~..,: 'ti'fo: ~"""\iIi!' .lQli";t, ,r-;:r !L"-iI!lfiI', ,~~.=iI:ItI, !<I!liiI!L'.,,,,,,,, ",!;Ii"" Jj'I',~I'liL_~r''''' ,,,,,iIIU~ ULti.lMu; 'nil!l!v ~!Ii:i'r'!I., n, .,U! iI~ ~iI!I,

o:fthc f.~n, why _Q:mll r~ponr5~b$t~ty :m~*Q" ,I~ defel!idc~, .Oll~e '~F '~¢ ,~!i{~~ftt; to' 'wJilii:c'b as~~I~ ~fl.g~_jll ;idG~~ 'Mth ~"~li~~~ ,~'iJ, 'W~~ IdJiey

~Qt~ be ~!l~biJe ,uf ,~p;p~oiatti!fig' :~~~t ~d, h!J!~' ~, 'p:~~f' :~~' of the 'i_,pmt.aince ,m'whail. they are doiLn__g'" In thc' ,c(rJUiI:1e of'writi~18peci'ca'tiOJIS fQr O:te' ftll~niim,_g' (!JF .eQ'U,~ 5OW~ ,defeDde~ of 'ilihe' prl_Q~iiPlc :m~t ~dx",.u: reason whl)! doin:g' :so is DlQm!JIy' Inrnp.:ll'UU1t,i5'

''RIlls, thoof1'igdAlmed rQ:lI,elii!ll~eg ~~l~ :nDt 'be' ~rl~~ if:lDe ,eW] that .e:Iil~' 'C:ailHe' 'wouid ,(lo:il[ld,~le' Mltn '~be~1i 'beiD,g illll, the :[\~pcnl'5ijbili!ty-wa'mmt .. , iog 05ta!te, .~ ailJ agree' '.3[t ,thj~ ,g ~~t 80; .g~ CiliUSC ,eviJ tm~ ~NI!ton&,

'iT!io"~",.,,.: •• :'k!' ~iIO~d' I '~""'~''!io~!t;IIt.i!'i<~'~m.I;o";il.' •• iffi' '~~~~;I,~.i~11o.' ,""Ho, ..:I ,~t:Ii--~....H.iI!i!. '~:Ho,' n .. ,.....,~;oi~~~'II~ .. , "ol~l~ ~". a1.111o. 1I~,v,IJ.UI.!"'~UIJ."'U'i .. ~u:aJI'T· ~l ,Il ~"',r·-.-~-I:DIlJ.-.I,'· l;IU"I;U1 ~L_IJ_I~11 'I'!'!"II_IiJIIIWif. ,11,,11 rllJjJ, U!lwu_lW:

md :p3Yc:bcO~.i€aill ~mtes ,and O'l!.I!l,m '1Item" ,So eveHI if g~m,'O:my~j' f-espon~,·' b~titty", ,and the ri:i,r~lt '~boL~cail smteil, wme :auilhfirilm~I¥' :ii,~ed~ o~ty, ~me' of the eviil, '.ait qeH~ ,ca~ iOol!lldJ thefiCby ~ .~~l,

On~' s;aili,en~, :f-act (tf: :m,om] '~ife ~, th~ pt~alenc:e' of' ¢'ril :Miucb ,of' ~.t :it ~a~ 'by 'human actii..;;uts" 'In-'t, the' ,a¢oons: :aIt-e' 'ootb ,aruton,om,Q'IIQ, pdJ D.([o-'

. 'b' 'b ~,'L. '" h ~~.:AC • ru d

ii'u!~o,QIDOlt~ aet .. ;o~s, OVC::f' 'WdClU mC!IF .e:IlJJts, Lave' 8mi_uCIClOJl. 'Co;flitffJ~ an~ ..

'm~' which ,~ 'beyo~d, 'tb~i!r' eonrrol, :1'1' Q~~ ;m.~n, ~'k, (if :m.orallirty b, to

.. '1 .;ii. ~'i,. 'Ii.~ ~I ', • .-i.., ,~rrll "'1L--..1, ,.

preven!!l: ,evJil; 'y~en 'mi!)~~ljlf i1Dwt ee oo~c:emeY! WlJ~~ ~I! eYI._'j-l'-,,)VQiu(jI~R ae ...

'i'j, .... "i""'. '.,.,., ...... : ,'II~.L , •• ~,i!lFl : ... 'li~'"i" .... ii'O':'""i"'ilioifi ~,-;<~;o; '"'rL""" ,~~~- :"f" ,~'~,"" 'n..i1ilO, ;o;iil'!ii'I .... .; '-r,~'b, ~'!i.U.~~ ,1,liU'~", JU;:!!I1 'I"IUJUI o!U)~""':IIU,il.I'-I'I,U~ ~~~1II. .Ii, !Ill"," ,...t.II;:i!lo;lL, '!IoII_., Ul"" ,1j"'1"I]I'I, ...... ,1j'" "'"~ ,l!lv!l!"F'"

C~,Cl'~ :~ :~o place' niO~3!U!tonOm,0'~, aotW~s, ,ou~de rr:U(1~ oo~£;e.mj' the ~, ~m,tiIm.g' i)h~iF .~,u' :Ff'O:m :m.om] :~~,pon:!iWI~LJ:. lftIat~r' :~~~H!~

Im'l"1i'~ii~iv """.~:no ~!j..""!11110 ,..,Y","[P;\DliIi>, ~oII' ili"L""!NOjku' II""'m, ,~,"'"':"".;i '~n,'I'iI\'Io ' ... .n_'!IIflilft,n,nn~nl!~iII!'h.r __ ~lllldLI_II~~J ~l.. ~~b .. ,.LII '1wJ'i~1 ,'!I.-_~ ,..... "_I~lr"!I.rll,"IwI~" II '!k __ VY-~ ,11IlIUlI_II_1I 11::IJV-.lll_!WM~~I::I~-ILII_..u'UiJl_II)·

a~~illg :ap:ilJiW. Th15'~ '\iI.'i,y the' ,Findplte act~Iy' :fQi!I~n ,~t


Tb~st!; ,crbj~imul apFM [ID[ be ;SQ oWOCl13 gdJ d}arn,~~g' ~t '~e

'III!'i-:il"""n""";",-~ '''''~m!lii"f"'''''~ -~' ~: ... """ ~p""iO:;. .. iiiil"ii'I\ii;" , .. ~""',;: 'O''iliil~' '~i-'i!' "'rl ....... p.<IL .... ;'f''''IF~:O··.n

~·II"-it~ll!;r,ll·~-~' [f¥U:r~r.' ..... _IJ_ •• ll~ ~IL lU~lr~ L IJlU.J.I."_-~'rl~ ~_~.[.~"'J .'.'II.1II]1. JIH'lb.J '1.1.:;.1=1. ~j :.I.W.lI.DLU .. ~'.!Il

There. is mg;b iafl1, ~xpl\anaItiun~ a:md it 'l\1as 'tMJ, IGl~l:r :I'CIJa[md, a5,,e¢1iS: 'iilhe p~Qdplte, h~, 3l, m(1K~Iy' b~1!~~1t ~ mat lis, 'U!flatI~('jt~, 'by tbe [cri)tiC!i~ms, lind a'l:~:ndlon~",g: ~lte ,p:rilitc~ple ;a!ll'08.~tke:r would ha~' m:orn;ny '~IlI~pt~· able ,oonrseq.~en,~, 'n. begin, wirtb dlese (,'O~seq~er1t1e~j if' thee' :,rirtc~ple 'W~~ :abalnduftm, it WU'uld. 'beoo:m.e ~~)ti-Q;t(l' tm hoUI, :pe~ple ~o:ram~y re-

!U\nln,c!'I"~'I\iI:I;, '~\i!'i;1i i'li1'lll ~;L. ... :jilf rn ..... "1""~II~~ .... i(Ii~of01i'':'f'l~'~;'' ,,,,"~~~>~'iji;~.,"':~: ~[ ,~[;;:~cliiiliii·. ,"'''r:: ~::' '~:';0;'1;;-1 ~!I"~' __ 'iI'_~, ,,," .Ii,v, I ""'], U,Ix.u iIJIl!W!",I'I;g!Il.'II.ilV.,~"'U'JI~~'U'U~ ~!U.i(JJI~:!i., ,~ i), ,[e"5U!I""J; !!;LI!I~ Wluw

;n'I,.FitO;, ... l .211;:£,..-.,...4"".,..;, ""''''' ,_v.ll.. . .". ' ..... -." ... , been 'I;.· ..... '.,I .. ·~II "<ODdl , ........ I~.:II-'l 'I;..~ !Ii,.,.,.'I'..:I """'.·'oN""""I.I.~[~." ,~ ",!~,~o!!,~, ~~~~~~ ~ ~.~ Wl~HI~~ ,I}~~ ~~~ l_JJ ~~~' . ."_, ~-v,!J._l1.=_' uc: Iljll~ rUl ~111_~~.,1& ~,,. ll]''''';''''''

~Jl~b:I:~' fur ~~~F vi~~ :~d, ac~Qon~,t ,eve~ :if' l1heiIr Chn-ltle8 were' flh1r{)ecl,

~'L.jIIi;"'" [oI"\"1i'''.~dl 'n.'fio~: ,.."......IL.r • .,..IIi"!" ,oi'r·;>iiI·Jr' :ofi'.~ cheraceer ,JlI::",;:::Ilcn~I;-::I'I'li: ·~('C,d., ~~""~~'~'~[~'. [!l.Ui'-,J' 'Io.!I!U"U!I.. ,. "'-"'Ii. .... '!I' .... Ii!U'QVLr Ul ...... ,UH,U, _ .... IJ OiLu;o~ U~L{lrlIll('iilil[ ... ~,~ a(:!!i!!O,p~!

alnd the)?' (''O'·!ld:d, :oot. understand, dle nu)~·ai~ ,signific~~ uF: '$cir own, w~,. of Min.g ,and ,:K;tJimg'.

L~ IieY!eniocli1l t~) dll:c: 'oo~ric pm.oliu' of ~mcil :lla.olIDiriJ' WO:l,(I!l(!l, be mOl"" ally ~~Q;attep:ta.le (H~rt :~,'9'1U:: (;'bapt'Cr. ,~, 19i8;b)I. SMRly, ~t 'win bE, ~dj :irt. mUllk~s, ,3, difl~r.~£:~' tf(), the' rn-ond :1"e:5,P'Q~sibni;t:Y 0'£ age~,~ 'wbe*er 'th'tJ oo~l\d, :lmi:vt; ,avaid~d :lliaviing' [b,ejr 'wces ,and ao;]n,g QJiJ 'l&eJ[h wh..::;(il;er' (b~~' had ilIll't; ,ra/pari" and op,ponun;1Ity ,to bE ,an,d, m ~C~ [diiB~~Q!~'~ ;.(i). '~:b~tt.¢.r th~ 'N~ m~y ba~ arllm~i!J1Edly caiilsm was :Ft)):~dJ ()Ql, Illhe~ 'by cir. ... ,

..,....,.I'l"1" .. ;t,,.,.ln~_; '';i!-.f'!'i.!' ~.1~11-:i1 "i"'C"~~":Ail 'I'f,' ~'1,..~ ~p·ijjiitjU":"irii. ,'II::, '~:;:C;: ~ ,~iL .... ""'F'~ryn-:~~)", '~,'C·c'ii').:...., ,,",,!liUlllI:il!-'UI!I.i'-'0 lll_,! ,,",uuLU 'Ii.,u.lOnu.'UJ.". 1!lI11 .... l.c~n~LI:F"l(l ~n;:: ,!l!~ .. .1;!.1~~,!,~, ~ ,!l, (:rI!"",",

ilion orilih.~ "'"'ti"'rin:'i~Oin ofi"1"""'A'_"~ [ ...... ~nan.,!I'cl!j.·I·jl~t!U'" I'·it ,,,,,,,.']oi.,.ilid·.1 [M..,~_~~:: ·i~n.r::tH:il~'l::' ~ ~ ~ ~.~ ~ ~ ~~"". _~ ~1"''Ii'! ~ ~ ~ ~ ~v,l! m ~ ~""!r~,I'I_'" 111.1. ·1I""1~' . J!I., '!I'I!V'!U!I ~o .. ue Iilll,IIt'· __ lL!i[ iI!ii

w[ dl~~IfiiI_ils:h 'ootween, degr:ees of Dl)on~ r.~Jl~ijb:i;I~~'. And ~is, wcruld. u~a~idai'M,~' ~bap~ll, ~if' dl~ ¢'ri~~g:n, gf m-otBli :f:'C'~,pg~!lii;bi!t~ty 'W·Cf~ 'Lh~ ~(:. :fe;r;b,of';,;;.,..,liconE,_ '"i"~'i;-'''''r' "I''i.. ... 1(01 ~:L."").r '~·~·;-:;.]tm·I'l"r~ ,c' ·;];1·'· ...... "' .. 'T·b.'" ,Ji;'~_ •. if"v_.I~~III=-;-'i'

~ "" ~ ~ ~ ~_ ~ ~-'"lI' ~,~y!~~ !!.H.~~ l~t .... ,,_" .r'"~'J ~tlli",""" '_~ ,'!kdiI ,ao~il!. "'" ,,,,," oQIJi.MlJ ... llD .. ~me:n~,

(If 11h~ :,riin:d,lc 'womd ~e ~t iQ]!PJ~~btrc' 'm 'mcog;ll'ille ~ihat: dil:c'Te!llt ~0IJ:'a!l ,jud,gm,'CiDJlS 'I!oay be i1!ppmp:M~ !'Of ar{jull:$ thiaJl. :have i~ifiJllcaJ ef;' :fec;U,., de,~JiI(!)~I't_g (Iii) th~, ¢lt~ine~. [ewiLWliti-onSr. a~d 'u:nderstandi'mg' of dltttir .~:r.s.

Tlfu;aJt d!l~ [O'j);Il~q)~n£.~s, H~' 'OIm;d~s~mblc mot be lticbu;:rwJedged by ,aU

bl 'I A.-. e '" ·'1'" '" • 'L. ... - 'I...

f'Casona ~~e :pcop~e" v~ie' m:ea.su_j\e (h' CiUY.I,JIUJ'!ll,(lUll is it.,iif:' ~xt~mI!tt 1[0 'W,.!I!I£I;iJ

s~i(;t; ,ti~ldjj~]liit¥, b atll~ted 'by ~.e :re(;Qll'd)tig~ gf 'eJC,~'mpti!lit..g' ;md <t~te~~gl\o'


,68

A _~'~,;o.;~~'~'ik~\l,;]~, oiI;~"~l!"l""'!I!! L.;.~

ii~g' ,~C~. ,!If Vttl, :prlndpl~ [~5, hl~d, d1!fcl'lrl 'tDi5, <londido:D 'G,fdv:ilir~ nf~" 'dl~1i1 ]i~$' h~' a very stm:0I' reason, {fir' :o,ot, wanfiiin,g 'W a'b3!11don. :i:t.

:BIlJt dlii5 ~s[ :not [lh~ we ito w:bJJ~l~ the :pw~lple :~ pi!l!t., ]it, i!!l, ~d, as ;a :-~C"'~i~~:~- ,~:; -r,' ~ ... -.,4lhi,""'iQ!' .,....oro-:-'II ~~"'~I~bl'1]~~: """"['~""~~~iIll[lliIm.v'- ,;il;r""t·, is, 'wh-i!l, a:I!~ ~Qi.u..I!O: ~.~ ~~ ioU"" ,~L .• ! .... :Ii d.Ii ~''''"'ur~U-'''- - ~ -01'-1 ~ ,1/"""', !!.·t"",~", c~_n_~~_~~, U~.,., ~_~' ~ _ ~ ~ __

:.~;, :", : . nd I " 'I"· 'il-.il~:·" ~~ , ,~,~~.~i....., 'nFFil '~i- ;:Hsiibj~~I;,V'. 'Il.illi' -riBclli!l:

~,t ciS an B not, "'~!.)tI!IWI!te to asc __ ,~; ,_~O ,~~~,po~ ~-~. - -~ "'l'~ ,_~, ~_ p ~ _ p .~

h_a$, :in()th~' ~: [the o:fie ~3it ~rm-~t.5, tr~itil.GJI; ,0£ e~:emlptinB :and e~-' i(~Il,l1aUU;~' e~.c~, iNihe:~ IDe, :prlndplc Q, '~d, in Ibis (rtQh,$f. wa~~ ~t d~~fi'" m~nes n,ot w:hether 'ilihe ~jDjptio:o of' ma:W, :f'¢sronsibjl~t'¥' ~~, 'lqiiJUllDak 'bUll, :how' :m,tu:h. BlOnd :[t'Clfpo:n!5jbiitiqr- iit b Iegilti!mate t4) ,~'be.

TWQ 'vemg-ns of tbe' :prlfieirpl~ mJust: 'th~~£af;'l¢ be d)~tJrngu1Shed, One ii, 'dle ~.egil~maun:g' 'veniOOi, ~d, th~ '(ijthe'r i~ d~e d~~ipmg' '~~~inn,. ,[80[1], ~i'O~i!I, iUfll: ,SHOO, ,U 'clr,i!te:na :[O:Ii axdbiIns' m~, 're~nMWlhJ. It.wt Qte' ~egiiti'mailill_g' vemo" hI, '~d, w, de~~ine' 'ne'th~F d\~ ucripu,()n [of m~mJ! :~~r,ons.ihl~lty-' is iIIt atl iegilti!rnate " 'ne:lfeilS the, depe~P~Q;I' ve';r'" ,!Ilion !S, used 'l,!) det.e~iine' ~, d~ mf 'Fe~,pon.~binty [that is l~JUma:I~. The le,p~~-n:1 ~n1Ckg l~ '~ to' :0iIari. a 1br~~M 'below w:hic'lll the

,-,~ ,~-c"i-;;,.i:~~; ,-:,"C ....,.~.,..,--JI '~S:bl'"1"iI',:;:-r:::~~f"",.' ~iI', '.' •. 'I'Ii'i'llil,' ·.,·t~;IIi:,~~ ,"'fnA "",ii-.""f,_._~,,' 'lUi,,' 'ir-~ .. iir- '~f' '=;;"J'~~;aii!i-, ~",P.Y-Oll, Ul ~~,~~Ii'~, ,IJ~ .r-'_'''lI~IlJ.JIIJ~l'' 1I_1:!I !l.Ii.I£.~I~'lIl_lll~ MLI~.rUl HU\.I!'r-~ -"'~II_~~~_\I~!I. ~Q'! .r~

flied. Thc' d~~i.p.in,g 've:mo:n 'is '!J15ed, tQ[ m_ad~;, :gra~.iti~~Jii' 'm: m.gm, n:spon_s:ilbiUqr lIi~t :ma:fJUl1~y be ~ri~ ,above' t~.e :rDreShoh:t

'iJ"', "~!l"'-"",(~,,-; ,~,"-c -~~ 'iIoii''''f'',~~.o('o;iiii" 0", ,C t:L..o<Ii' p~n'·i"1"""'I·p'It..;~ .... \ifioIf")iI':'~'~r·""'.-~,.,.;iI"..,...ii',- ["'"" .... ~ ,!I,,'Oi ]l!~~~~.~ 1;lI!I.e~ l,"I!I!!IjJI '~~."i1Ibu ... ~ . ~iI IUI~~, ,n,,,",,~. L,-,", """""1l ..... _LU,I!i;, "Ir'V,IU_~,',,"," __ I!;.,_~=~

[I"i!i~f~.",::"';i':~'"i"'''' >:,"iif.' r'L..;a;, 'n"",,~.",u' ;.I"'1L""",,""f"i"I"".Il~"'Il.. :4'O;gll'i""~:;""~, 'I·m""'n .. ,~~~~,_ ;a.n"lll nlii·i~I""ifiiJ

r"~l~~~~~~~ .~,,~d;, IYl~ ,~=L-"¥1Ii"~ __ ",u."JI""'?I.;IIIJ,IJ_L~'''''''lJl ~I. ',. __ • Mi!Y.!IwJ-l!! 1_.::._"IZ'!Ir_lIl._il:Nl!IIIIi!l'!'!Iii~ fBI::l~l l.l~~~~

al~l1!t::s, disouged, ~ml '~e :p,"[\ea:m~K [cib~pt«;, SliliP,~ ,th~t 'tb~ ~C1i(; alegt g, ~, ;sitx~n:rh""C:e~~ lritt'h. :lIIrtWll!~~1t 'w'h~' taU, 1.5, b) 'fii[l,d;i! l.nrlerro-,

~~"'"~ '1i1i"~""""'J."", """"'d.;- buen ... .;:.~'t;-...., ii"III'_ ,i .. , '''', d ~'i'i~' ~lti~"~~"irio~ ~~~f,,:,"J'i __ .iII1

~[_~!ill ,r~'~~~~l~:~ [~o~c ~~~ ..... T!I!,.~~Il[:b-':'" .£.I_1l.r , ..... I ..... ~·!f.'U.!LiIi ..... ~_Il.IJ.IJII.ilU.IIiIII.I~lr~ ~.II·!'I!·II.lll!'! .. l~

'""t;-'a- ~ ~~..,,'-r;ilioi'\ ~if'i"'" ii'ii"¥lti"o~~",'lII 'ik.J [~''''e ..:I""o"~ll i~!n~ ~..aJ himself":as ,3J h'il:l'!m'hl~' seli-,

'~t 'I.. ,...,,,,I~II!InI! -..J"'" r~~~' iU.1 !.Ill, U'/i;;",,~, !I'B~M "'"""'''''9.' '~ ~~ ~._' ~_ '_. ~. ~_-. __ -~-.

'WtIl:t of' God i~ dOJ-ng wh~t :hc ~ to ~m~~~ tfh~" )h: bas {~l'iID!.ri~ ~~,~",..JI 'b:-~r",-..:.il ,4i~~iffii-, ...... ;iT.' ~m.~~·'f"Ofri;_, Pl~, 'It:-'i!>;a: ' ....... [ ,;l7.1.1~- ;a!oou,t 'bb. belief!,:he:15 amu .1lIi.mGu U.u.rl!lC'.~~!Ii '!<AI HI!.l!'. __ !! .. n. r,-;u;; I!~~ ,UJV 'Y,!(.!I~~!I..::!I ~~_ _ _ _~_ _ __ ~ ~ __ \! ~ _

supported 'iI.mJ hbl, ,a:ctiviltie:s, 'by "tile h.~g'h~t. ,auJmnft!li(i8, and, he i~ :slnc~m'L!' dedicatMJI and, as,jiL!J5~ :IS be ~ 'k' tllli fiollowiIn'S· e.ttle~c '~aw.

Suppose al:so '~ait: '~e i~s.e~ltive ~nrt :~ a f~th~r (If''maIiW,Y ~hrild~n,,, H~

.... , .. .~, ,""'"':"7"'"1=," ~AI ;'~;- 'il~""~ .- '-1.:11 .-. -c'~/. -:.,~~;:..j; ii'io<i<.[fio J·• '~, ;.r:o·n·?~:on:~tm(ll!' "l1!'""'i'Ji't. h;ro',.Ti~'hifllUi ~If".d!

,lIta8< :pr~i!II.U~U, U), 11!I!iE! aIltu aClilil:E.'\!"Gu u'.!l; JI!I, V!7' ,..,1 - ~J!IoIII_ , ---'I::I![ ~~ ""',.,." ~~ ~~-~.r= ~~-

l-ojn,g 'tnn:r.:h _doe ad,vemue8 that WO~iliM '!have (:FW'hed :nto&i 'pe<Iplte. :seJf~en~a1,! dli.scipnn:c~, and 'lline~ilng' ;~pplicati,iO:n bave' become bis s;ec'ORd, :11l!9ituJ[e, :His 'ex,perielll¢.eS; lliave ~aped 'h~ 'vI,:ew Qf'lilFe. ,I'n M~.di. of' lid5, idJ~L*Gl, t'O, beeeme :I1iH' :IriJim" 'he takes, hlnlSelf' w[ be a£iting 'm thcfu; 'kM., 11l'~),Jt., '~, doe.!!i ~ot f~~:e ~t. ,~~, ~.~' :aChrie"'·~m~nM :M,~·e nmde hi~,

" ::' ~: .' [~cf~"ll~c- "'~I-:-;;- :;nft~~,. 'iIi"-l'T"'..:I~S· ~.~ :~, ,t;~,i'Jiil' 'I!:o,i,a; "I"'I'i-'ii:..:I[I'I""I'l" ,""~e [c"'l""~~'ii,.."!'ld-I VIew g.~ ,I!u,e; ,map,'l"Q!r"--~.' ,l"t!i,h u"",,, i.I!I..........~ !ll:bn, IlIi'iI! "'""_iliildU_.,''"', " Mol,', ,I: I~JI,,,,,,,, ~,

'by hi~, demands;: aIfe :s~d, :fOr hils, l~: :fi!m:dJ :h!i;, if!x~tali()n$ ~~J :pojntJ.eu, md :impoS5ibt~ w· :m~et; ;a;nd 'have been :m~med, by' 'h~m :ful' ~lJifc,.

~~' :taJt 'thiJit. th~ fUith'I.e~, .'~Il!r, is :3, ~K- .. ade and. biig1blf' SlUjcel&I)U~ '1tc~1i;E~ti;'i'~;~~'~ ~'~ '~'i!>.c!' ~""I'I..~~~, '1I':,,~ir-"lIfit' h..,. h~*, ,~~Lmnjlj'h, peat, d:edicatiuil,.

I!J.-UI:3,IJ."~.~.II.OI.I,II. n,~ .IJ.I~ ~JJJ~I:!i.I'~'!I.:U 'n!JI~9~ _ ..... ~ lU_~ ~L ~.~~~ _.:~ ~.~._ ~ .. ~ ~~~ ~ ~ .. ~" ~ _ )

'keen oom:peltiJtWem:~., ~d, wwa~rlng ,~nlllidltm.~!l; [lQ ,e:x,~elllq'i :~, is,


mC'Klt~ 'W W ,co~ti.g~, ~Fti(l:e:5, O~~~ w:h~ i! g, o,~~ ,a:nd O'lM~.rm_!!Il, :m,o:nIiIl pro:h,l~ilti.Qn!l!' ,o;nly w:boo, 'thqr' K~ 'h_i:J :p1Bpil)se. ~, ~~ I:'~li! tthJat ~r,lo.U~b 'Ih.e. e::mmnltc- m~i~daflfOO',- am:d ~mm"~ of hb, gthe.rr..

[.1 __ . _l \~~I_' • __ ., ._ -----:r.' ~ ~~.-.- :r.- ,p. . __ J"._. ~.,rr.~"~'-= .,-1":] -~~ .-,.=r~.,-t'

'w-born 'he has, iml'ta!ted, 'tlhr-{J~ghoul h!i~, :lif~',!, H'e ,~ :mQra1J~1f" mefi~h1p~

]1' ,'_ >1 -.~ ~- ,l1tv . -, I ". '-ilI'" I 1-', - '~c~,1- ~'- ol '· .. ·'ir-II " "!Ui,L ,-- I-' 0;,1..'·1 ~'-. :' _1- 'c -,- Jfil1.. .. ~~, .,.-j, .nei!! ml.'!IJI, loy3i '''f] M Kn) im.e:I'I._, IlC)(!!t Ili:!lll!llle5Sn!IJI,Cn !!J.IIJ",P ,go 'WC1U y.~"" ~~os,.

ot~,,~ (d~ta~]~ W' ~o(~~, i!ba-~ r~ni!l'blC!i ~pl~ willI fiU:)t tgJ~ra:i~" :H't\ j..~'ti- . ~-, ~i'j..~j~' ,~i'~rF'~' I~ AI I ~-~ ~~,en~;"'Jl~; ,--, I~ .. 11 '~ci~'~ b~; d :,~"~, and! mo~ ~~eves ~a" i5~'w!'~'1 a:n~, R~K'UlwC: pe;op~e ~ :ao,,;aiI ~~e~~" ~.~~ ~~~~~'

'wb,o, "iJl~(liJ]J hbl, 'beli.m,~ '1)1![]i~:3$)n.!d:il~'I' Wie_ .. OF ;iOslRCER' and ,runrmr~ng'

(ii)M!X'tt_r:s, oying t'o ,~I, '~F Iii~m."

,NIl 'tlhr-cCi :pc(Jpl~' :tl!~bi;tlJia]~f ,~.d pmdi~tilJblly' c.i~~' ;~~u,~, gd. \mj~ti~

,iiI!j,~..:II ~;ol;~1 ~\i'io, '""""~lH;~' "I"'.''t~if!II''_, 7lL-~ji~ i'Io;i!!(~-i,oi"'~iI', ,§;~ ,....;I'il""---l1 ~:] ,i'lon'lil :iI'.~~ '~~m ll~l~ l:...lI_iWIIj ~_~:_Il 1!IL"v.! ll~'_::._!WII~,I· V~~-~Il ~ Ii, ~ll!W.~:_lj ~YI~!I'J_1i! ~!W ~ .. }~ ~'II!'!'t!.: 1 ~~~l ~~~'_:_"J ~,~-~

'~~IiF~~1. __ d ,th~ :.~I~ ~"_l:'~ed.ltU!t '~e~F ~Iii~ ... vi:c-~~ ,and '~Ci~ :nC'U are dtc' '~n-dc~.bie OO~~,~i!!I'l()~ ,of dfiCU~taoc:eSI lbat. aHeokd. '.cm. n~ 'bavt 'liQi,SQugbi thm' cmcums~ee!li' but :h1are been :f~f¢Cd, 'by

.' .... -, , 'd- 'b .. L - , "tl_ - .-:·~'~!"-t-i\lDi· , "I ji..' ., . .' iii' 1'1 ",'I.. - ,I" . 'Ii-., __ ,. iii"..' '~' , . ,,- . ,.AI 1'1,

W.I.em an ." , rfJZ.l l.a.l,~' pO!R." .... 'U!itIi1iIw..1 ~nilile.rnn .. ~n ulelf CIlIJU;aC,Ii.!oii" ILO uspa1l!oil, ~n

me' '~ys, '1l1b~' :liiavc. FM [each~ ee' dooroe ~, 'between lmng acmmi~g' to,

~. ~ - ~ ~ ~ ~ .~_R ~ ~_ ~ f-C' - ~=.= __ .jll iliE'£- .. 'I- ~ .-- .. ,'i., --~ Ii.. - . ..1 'i. .... ~ ~~ ib __ = ~~ .~, ~ ~ ~~ ~ -, - r- "I;.; ~'I;. ... 'i._ ~ ~ ~

,~ 'cO:lliQ~fUfi)1lI Q~, ,a, g.~ ~!lIi]!!: IW~ '~~~. ~~au ~eg loom ~o\.; 'O:__Q}C' '~ W,~I!1'C~1! IUl.-oey

had - - - - - ibil~ ... 1, - . ,. ..I f' "'~" ihu .. 'I.. ·AI~.-.:II_ f .;L

~~_:__. !rnQ a,(l(lepl.a__:_~' ,~wma1Jl:Vej ~g, ~iaililling' 1~~.1' I~' "t.alm~~i~i~' Q~' '~a!t, S3iDl.¢·

c--~ri!i!i:\(Ii~~' Tl.. __ "'!I!I._L_· __ c~,_ £l--~-·--.:II --~ ,,.'l!..,~~~- ,,.t.._~~c 11""""''1.. ..... ..11 ,,.iIl.._~, ~~.~--- c,~ 'fl~''"I!;[H;':_l'--~,r;__Qn • .1,1;1,(;' 1""I__I__OJ,CC l!iaJ ~!CIDCCu O~ u~e_m----\!i 'ulICf ~~U UIII!: meU_i1 ~'O{1r

.. ,'1.. ... , '-I"·.-:'~r~ 1 .... ~I'I .. ,.i"Ii't_.iO. '"l" , ..... f, "i·,:""i,.,. ' ....... "']' ''''''I''"If" . ..Il.,.~ .... "'"'"1"·..11 '.'I'!:-'~' ~.,.il'-!l i"'1~"""·' .l .. ij"·..:III .... ri".

u::i.'!I. ""'.I" J~, !Ii".~"'" /1I!HIIO_Yi ;01., 'V. !WIlt'!i..~1J V HI.;., l!u-'!.:AIJ~Oi~Ei!i 'IRI.I .. U ~_,,.' ... ,uu D, ~l.,'Vl, UIJ~U€iI,

,!!ltDld th.~ isigrdti1l~CE' of' ilh.E~r h.-abiJtm,dl and pFedliciJabl1e ,ao(;tiDn~" 'Thq' '~!' m~f--mof~'" :I':boi[ .a,uI-Oi1IomOI)li8i ,ag~n,'bi"

.;Il;,,=~, 't:ll.~ IL'~' ...... ~~'Iil'i.i' '~i'iiI'-:~r.;,_iE~b·lh !i!i;jtUli!.-·-nii!\r"i; I'~' .. ,'L __ - ~·'·-ffili~-"'CC'~fi~'~:i7' 'i5Jio<--:,nJJ'''''' ,111'".\",~ !l11,v'!!1I''!Ui'l'_.,," ~oJ_.IV'" 'IRII 'J" ,.,I~.I:"' ... ","-id}.- L'e '"""I!l!I"'~I.,~r;'Ii, !.lI11I'i! ll.e~"i!olma~lIm~ ,,,,,,I'"

,!tun, of 'tD~ :pliiim:clipl~' ~~ ,o(r'~otl.' ~~ ~uild, ,fOn~' tba't; k:~~ ,th~, ,ageLIlIJU, laCk ;a:UJw~~m:~tj' ~t 'wouild, be 'g~JL~J.~.1I~led w' UCriil1J,e m.oraill ws,ponsij.. b:iiI~~ tiQ 'them" ~ of !IIe~F ~([.-,c.w~Qj~~c-es" in__Q~te db,pos~ti:OJil~ ;and. :fg~a!ti~ e.x.,m~~re~ mey' I~guld, g,gt ~ :aotcd, ()6eF ·th.3!1\ 'ilihey'd!id. I'f 0'Il1-gb!t; impU(l's can ;an,d, if ~EY' ,c;O'l1Jld. ttott th~Z1i :111.:1$ tIInj~5tiil];m 'tQ ;sa:y m~u i""'i-.~~:,~~----;·hi! 'n'~ :-, ,e, 'i-..~,..., ,Ale--- 'wh~I-' ,....'i~ '~Ii(iijily Ii'--' ,:,', ~'bm .' 1'1- Ii f' ·.4';;i;r .•• ' 1Y,~ey Q.--,g~~~ net to ,H,!A~: Ylme_~ ~~ia!t AI!~ ~iI!~en<le8 on l!ltle~ pmm:plew, u~e_m

to' do", '1b~ ~~c WJIb;'h hrtm)tc:r~ me' :~D~~ :millher" ;_~. the mdl'~~

b.I.:a!liIJIo;i!liil'iI'm. '!!'II""l '!I;I~ "i!L.;i!Ii-';I'~~ '":"".oI'io~~ 'm. , "1i<..,...:I~iI;!' ili":"'iQ"iU-MrI':tiIit'I .... , r~.,. '~'~il .. ":o;,,,J:11 ,':!i;;i"'}i.~ij"S· ~~_~t'~I.~ ..... _ _ _M.Ii_1J ...... L~l '"i.!l,I,~1I ~~fVIJ ~ [.,I~~ , __ ..... ,I,II:UlI,~. ... ~-,F'~~"~~ ~ I,.UIJ WI~IJ,L ~~,I!J, iCl!_~J"'t'I~'IIJ,1J _ "'-,

'ri,~~1. ~d, Wicbd)l\'t~ ,~~: S\LFe~f:r. ,th~t. is an '~OIaa;e.iP·tal\~le mo_ vie.w~,

D, '''£' 111 Iii 'I iL, !L_ .. 11...'·· ~!i ".,1.,

uU!t h: ~ .ijl!!I;!' 'rleali ~ :aCl..:. 'iil!u.t_.()fto:m~' 'til!l~11! mm(i:u,dfllCl' is ,diJ5U '~1l0" 'wtU!I

---,., "-··:l " "I}'._ - I, ..... "'-',l~' , .. , ., ... __ .. -',1:11' ,1_- .. _, ..... -~ ~, .

h_QL\diing .e- ntv~~y r'eS,~nsi!bl¢" ,If ,they ~aU,lt" ~;t;t~lld ,Fi;i;Jt, h.e~,p be'iu.g ~.e

- 0-:.... d-I dOl '" 'L..~; .• iL, ..... "'.... ~ 'Il,!l;" ,.,'Ii-. 'III~ III

'war wi.t:y are ~' .... IOJ~K W,I:Ildit. 'uiliey i!JI.o~, l!l:.Ii.cilil, Ili£huli1l1,g IUii-em ~norali '1' respo;nS:1-

hll~ '11..:11, iL.~ " .... , 'b 'L.~_"::: .~~ , II" 'L.:::~'

,~' 'WOlbu 3i 100 r~mOOl l~, 'ui~ : .' ar.Uii!i~sm b.i :sU'i'Ct ~':a~jil~~

.. , . , - ... , .. , I,. - . - , . - . . ,. - - - , - " .. " 1- - - . '"1"

~t hi: b.efe' ~ 'the ;:5igotifi~(;e ,~ dle' i!iIe:gm~._gm1~ng' ve~~l'IJ 'M die'

Prind~e le;m.e~AL, The ,A~~lic mtdl, 'ltIiU!tll~r.- d:u,~ 'i:nHn:Yiti~ faillll~r ,ad

I~,-,[ __ r. ~ .. _ .• I~I!'"-"Ior.. "_ •. ~II_.LI___ ,,'. _l j ---,._ ~ . __ . ,- _" ---, •• , -----. 'lJ! _ .. 1

t'i'le@ mtlli~ 'll:jI,Hillil!~m-a!n lu.b:ituaU~ ;_d ~pFSdict.ab~ CK~' ~ I.. and :SOl

• - - I ., _"-. _. _ -. ,-. _. _ •• " • l [ •• I • - - - _I~ .. - • 1 L . _ ... - - - 1I1 ... - - ..... 1_ -J.!i • _. l . .

they ,aJ..fe Wicked" l'Ms 'Cg~~()t .be.. aJ, :maFa;li,~' btdifFerent ~lter;, Those who aiR ,c-o:mmi!tmdJ {~, mtomll~ty ,must hi:J]d, dl,tl;m ,Moral!l,y. :rtm;po:m'ijbl~' for' ~~~I" ~~, Q:f being' ,~d aotiQg~ ~n it ~:be1' atf'e n~Di~~WIlQ~~~, !Stilt, dte~F :re-


&po:nsub~lzy' b Bot,~ .-eat as, it WO'u];d, be ~if"~q"we:re ,3;UJtono:m,(Ju,. Au~m)~, :mou:s ,e.vi.il~ '"!£In" ~d, 'Widbdo~.u ,~ wtI~ ~, ~~iF ~([lmia;u{OO~(;f);m~u €"'OlU~te:rn::rfil8- 'The simJ'ifi.UU1oe 'of thc' d~w'o:li1liin'i!r' wtn'.h:~:1ll [of ~I!: nFfjn--.,

-, - - - .. - - ~ r- . -. . , -~I"·-· - . -.. . - - -, - ,., ~'O"'---- --0----"'0 - -, .. ~- '-' -- ,1""-

~iiP-c t.: is, ith~t. it 'm~~ '~t '~ss_~Me b) :I:ie(l~ii~.e bo:tb t'h,CJF Hlond :ri£!iOii"tmI,tbilt..

, .r·~ ~~.-. r-~

iln, gd, d.rt Ih~' ascripliinl1l! !O'fdl~ ,Wnfi1"nnria:~-;::: ~~-;:::-=-, m'-;-;-omI,-,-:-~--:-:; :[~'ilb-'III,

;~J ,-. - -. - ,." -,,' . -- - [~ -, - - - . - ,rlli·'~r -~ ''U''b;fil'" ~- ' ,01_ '_ _ [[~;pot!i,'!!i_ -~-I'

~~ ~.;Il~:l'\PIIi'II,.;IL .. , ,~1IIiI _ :!fIi~NnO'. ,~ .. ~ .. lI!' 1';~~i;li'IiB;C W," ,-h-""i~' ~Iir-;A ~iII'~"";I.iI', i-li<iIf-'I!i' ;H"'~'~;!i,'., .. ..;I1 ,~if'il ~'If-"" ll'Jii.}" ~~-'Il.ur::!! ~.lIJ~, M.II_II_.-U,I"I~I ~1I_1"'~1J U_I_II_.l~"'l . [ _ [~II ~ ~1I~ ~~Ii,IJY ~!E 1iN~~~:~~ ~~_~ lUl1;

oiF'-..nTiiiii"iiri~iU'-~fiI;ri!'iI, 'i,."""Ei~._:rii c~""".:n~l--., .... ~- """",'I\,, ""'r-- 3.- .. ~;i-.""':'''''''m:''t!' ''''i!.,.--ii '~Ii"'ijll'l ~., .. i .... .,. ~~"I'I'~ .... rU-.I_lI)U~i.) - !L111I1_IJ_1l u.c!l~~rl'!ll!!l;;;iIi;i~_lI, 1.:"-~"!!I18{r~~ lI~", ~-~ ... ~~~~~~~.g.__;J~i I~~~' Jl-~~~ lr·4-~~~L"I!.!I~~ IW; J~r.

'The [criddsms, of' -the ~ri_nd~lc' diJsc~d. '~n: '~1llt~· t\IiiIo :~«OOIB:Q1 ,SGCtitnns

,r" ,~- ,""'.I~,

II bee d·, d . ,. ~ .... ,', d m ~

...... "U,'I>' 1 ,',' .•.. '"]" :'; I"1l'"'!' ,.; ..... ; ~~ll' ... "'i' '-Ii'" I ~,Qfllijj.'·'"i""''''·~'ijIi'Di. i "'':''!'ii'ji'''"!'''1 ,-1;-;-, i": I--=--~: 1 ~~;-~'-,~: '," -,-' ,

-"'Ii~'" _ _ _ !Ill _.n! '!iii .,., _ ., ", __ U'iI!l> l'liil! ""~~UIJI'I-"lI!lIlJ"'o """"iii _.uh.IJ~, 3lO. qr- ~~ IlJII-

tnl.u)hed, ilhtli' ~~~i~lnE!' ''VeFSJGll_ 'The mBuse 0'£ thf.:' ii\'lt1indrii'l~ k: Ith,:--=

• '. - ~-,~I""'=~ ~,~I'"-' ,~, ~. -. ~ ~L ~ -- ~--~~~-~ ~~ ~~ ,r\!J~~~, ~,r~' !5 ,~I!:

use 'of'i~, l\pa,iiti1D'ati'n~"\!eBio:n and ,th~ no\"ijoit use [m lit is, ~~, d~'f'ii·!'MKd~:i;niU"

----- -- --- ~'~"'-"'" --~--' ---'-'~'- .. ,!!!iIill!. . , .• ,- - --0;''''''''-"""0'"'"-"

'vef8!iI)tJ .• The' ~cgiti!m~tin;B' 've~i'Q:m of' '.e prindpl1e ~ouild, Hind !'ItLO'\!I~d 'Ix::

,,"['Ii:-_.iji,_'ID-]]~ ... 4i uri~;I,...r>il~I" a ibiiilri-:1of>'lifiliin,u' ~""'-.:I~iiiIw'l;"'1i'Ii-1h1[irlil7' ,..-_....,i,;fl;':' iOIllM_IJ .. U_- .. = I~UI, ~"JU;I~~~ [_ I_U~o~}U~IJIJ,IJ.;~ [.)~ U-:""~~~"~ ~~!!-~~£~.,. !p.l~~I~~~~~~

'The ~1;H~e'$, ,got: dle' dUI:eretl~es 'be~1l 'i:heie' 'i;wQ[ ·VLr.slOJ]lS of '.e pril1lci .... , ple ,a;m~: tb~' di(Df~mllit ql!l~Ii'Olls, m~ aR' illIsei M, ,ask an,d, an~f:; O,ne [qr!l'e~'

I-;-'~ ii, 'w1,. I-j' ,---,-;i",,~~ 'e,' ,,' • .,....."'~ t" ".-:' ~:'r"'~'-I'-,-' 1-'-':' '-','" ;~Il [,'~" II' -"" "'Ii:-~~"',-" '"1""1;.-'~tKL ~s __ ~ila:l, ,maM;S ,pa:rtI,,,",,~la[ ,age:nt5, illliIIlU, ,;e to .m,o.n ,R!!iPOUSiJIliI'J!lIt)'. .. ne

r]'-,h"': 11- 'r:'iJh,:: ~:-'ii-:-cl':- -.fi~,,- ;., .... -- -,:,''''I,;,'it-'' '" ~'I"',,'-I"~'_ :",o;iL. ,·;o'·I'·:"il,.~,

1I"-lP~t 3JIl:~~" _~C one __mp_l'C~, 'V'1 cntl'CIc.SIlnS 0,1, me ,p:nrn:np ,~~ 1!Ii lI.uat.1l ~$ il:no@:

ml, d~cti [i)f d:toGjr ;~ti:on$., 'Dlli ~~ll:m!fWef' 'lis diat the arUi~GMm.y [of'.ilhe as;euits, :ma:'l:es Ill,em :nalile '~O mo:ml.R!!ipouMb:iliit':)". l'hi3it. :is th,~, ~i'bit_1'!d ~ SW~f:~ ;3)l,d, irt.:~ :mj~~l~'(i.:D, '~ca~ ~~ -ak~s ~~ ~.po8$iible 'W ,~, the :rcesQl!l~

!Elf [j1~'tt\i3l~"I--~ bl' :-:~ll~~ ~~'i:-,~, n:::·fi~U·"I~·n·j-m·::I='~·-l 'M·-f~~·-·,.j}:-=.;-~. ~]_:, ~; .. ~- ~'~l·"~~'~· l~~-'~l '~~ ~~~~'"'~~~~li"~~ Ol,iL ~-~ """!.~ ~~!Q~~iilLOO~~!@'~~U:'! ._._~cll'i;:eY1n~ I,r;;o:rn. WI!~L'C1i1 itu,e

p~~.enC'e [r,;-f ~~ :~~ ~I~, The g·dicr ,qrYntbl)~ ~'[ [QiJllY ,aikr me

fiui":c I '[ -'!:~~-(Jl :b-, been . '", - ,~fi _'~'~-~'Ii'" ,t" .: iIii'L.- ~'.' iti: I, :1\,..- ',' ,-,.- .. , ~ i ~,~"';:::' ~~~,~~, qilil~~ ",,(L, "'"-.M neen ~I'Q,!_ •. ,~mJ"'B: '1:. .. '3", pUu.rJlIl!iUI agenl!;;]! are illla?

b:1~' to :m,o.rnill :Fe5cpII1iS~W~~" :for 1i1lt'Cif' wi£k~dGie5$", dt~ ~,Ue"-$tiQliI, b,~ Fnr.' l~ow

'h ral! "'iI.::I::- ,.,'1:..]", ii..'l :? 'T'L.. • ,.,''''~, • rI~· ..:1_

H1IU-'C__;_l ~O~ _.:'I :FeS,~:m~~~' are 1Q!!:ey d~b;U!',~ ·c~,·.t~e M_swcr'lSi Igi_t :11', [~FDw'l

~~ 'paJl't:'- [0:0 'Il\-ow' aiU[~OnOmom, .e~' ia1[,@;- Gmat:er ~Ui~fiJ1,omv (!fi"t',3!la ~~"3!hiir~

~~·'L----""';r.---,·L-_,- .. ,-,_-,-.--- .,--- .. - -'-l .,-,. ---,.-- .- .. -,-,--./.-1- -, 1 .. _ .I~:,!"

:f~~ ,SJ.-eaIter H'lOr.aJj l'~.po~dJWlty~ .. d, l\e$.1e1i ,~lu,m~o:mYi' 'wr ~eMier lmo:m!l m!!ipilnMbi'liity"

'lR: 'kl!(ij' 'd,'~ : j [ ·!rW1rin·,' i""' .... - , . .' - ',-' -·d,: ,', j.' " : '"·-c.·', -1_ : ;1:] , ..... - ',,-. 'I r! ',''''~ -. 'I~ocll-.~'_,..II

._ ¥ ,~_ ~~~g alD,. ~ ~~ __ e.~ ~~g IY!ie. seo.O:Jli.... qU'CStl,QJI!~, 3i" RaMl~a:U"d.': ,h"~,I"'IIi.

eeneerus ;U~' m~l. It is ,mc.i.!z~d Ithat dl,;~' :p:rimd,plle' 'big a ,.cO~ly :lmpg:r(:tllit ,an,d ri,g;b.il, 'u.se:, m-e' Qnc tha!t, fiQ!i~~, fmm, i~ deg;ftee-aQ,igJ'I'iQR '~'on, 1'~hr8!t :1:'ef!.["d;d:Oll~ :ltLuw~r~, ~s, ~-omptnlL~' 'Mrh, :~CX);p!~n,g ,aliso '1li!J:t. '~e' :,riilfl;c~ple' !bas, ,a mo:mJ.Iy' :mj:ualiten WlId, ft"O:l1g' use;: 'me [on..e' that, [UIOM[ ~(if.WD :iJt!i, II .. itiifitUI'~~II' ~niiHIrII. It iis £l1Iirtb~!I"EiIU:~ pu.mb~' '~ ,avo:id w~, 1TI.o:~f lID~~:n:"~;I;h1e OORiU"flilile..nce:!S, [@f ~eve~D(lJ' lo ~triot. tia'b'iUhl!' and 'tD :a!1l 'UillMllk

~- ~ -- !I:" .. ,.......~~ - --~~~-.,,--- ~--- -- --=I!---- ~--~!EIi[-- ,_-~~- - --~-"""t ,_, ,,_I .. L

io1.l'ue:ss '~:O re£_~DiIl!~' e.'X~~, iI:'b!i)~ '£:o'~low 'r!rom abaill1do,~ifL:Q" I[h:-=- ~--::_~"tim~lt?

="§_L , ,~'-.,-' __ ,_ .. , __ ,, __ ,, __ .. ,., ,._ ... __ ,_ ,__I_ .. ~ .e.: •• , . iii ,

:lnl' '¥e~lon, ,of dIe pdlil.¢iple, :F~F dIe' [de,~i .. iin:1 vcnio:n caJlI take :ijn'~.o ~-OuMde;rati:on ,d, dit~ ~Qm:pting' md. ,C'x;tt.~d~g e~Q~ that '~~

~ - - - [ - - 'Ilu ,;, k dJ I!S i~ ... lb'iL~ '" i 11 'b'''i1'W it.'Ii.,~

ll'O'JilalU! -(1j-ll~mo'Wi!",:r' 'Wilc~"e_:__ i¥g__:__ ~~_~' 1,0 ",e!\lli, :mij!)R.!I 1['l~po,n:!Ii_ILllil~T' I~liillt!n

~' ~Eir ,3!Dit'Oll(JUl'U;:rQ15 oo:-.wI!lJt'eFpHirQ..,

SUp'~ that dte legiitim~tirt-l' 've~~o, af the prl_1'l(;~pJe ~ ia!billJIld.~H;ed

~rtd! ~it."~i"'Qi'Ii"P,'""'-c"""""orn"IjID" '~_i'O'io'"l" 'i"': ''''''''''~inI·,....:II_ '~il'!lI,.y ,'liI': ,.,',!--i';o; '·I'mftii'frt't!:lil'il·i) '~H: ''1''-''-'

~~ _ ~_ ~-_Q~ ._~~""_"~,.,~"--'-l_~~ ''!!'I!o.li,!;!!I,:V-,IIiI, =~ """'''''-'!;;-iF~U. .'\111, ,_~ UdIi..., , !I:""'"""" _"ll~, " """'I!I"


..1~~, •. _m . 'il·b~~l';' ) "~,m... . 1..i~'g does i ~,~Iil., '~Th---:- 'i-.~~;:

~;.'!I lit, iiP...Jl'ect ~JJ~,~_I_sm.l!!l~:.a!t: m;~_ um'¢re~c.-e' "".~ u ~.e~' .rne t~C

an~r.' h;, illhat ai~dQni.m,g [the 'le:g;lIU.W!!l!dng ve~lO'o, 'has the 'oon:sequ:e'D.(:C'

...... ·.f·, "ljft_~~p;- ~:i;--.: ',~, ; ...... ,·" .... ,·,·'liIIInltaili .... O, ,~,(" n."i"~,·,',. "'ill·~ .... ··~ ',m, :.''''''''7""";i, " ......... .,."it:-::~I! •. hi',.' I!··O. 1 ""I, d '·'i'I'~ .. ,~~~~"". '.:n, 'Y n,P.L "'~""",~ I~L.... ~ """'I;lI'I"",,,,""" .~ .. y 'I;!I'-1 iF·" ..,.,,,,~I .101"" . ~y~ _1!<!~~~~ "'I _~ _ ~ _.!-. _~Y'''>!'

'~a!t ~!, inromrparti'Itr1].C!i· wlidll~~ntl~. T.he ,~ITijpnmti,fin o:f "[me ,:m(le.,t31D,c~' of 'lillie I egitirm!lit1ng' ~io:n b, iI:b.:M ~umQ;l)my :~';il centnJ '€eaWir.'C' 'I>f' ~(Jfal)~ty

'ntJii-,,;t:lv iL-.~ .~- ':,~' "I'''~ 0fIii""C".,."..11 '"i"", _"if'iifi, '.:' -;<,..~Ii:-~~'jnr.,.' ,...;!l....,~.,...]l., Ii'lL ...... · "IF T['b -::.' :~~n'I'~",,'-~~~:; --: I :;f'·, ,~_I 'l I} 1~!I!I",," ul,.'UiIO .. 1 IJ ""'i!!,r,~J,"~!:i!',lillJ~:l' UiC r~IJ"~ u.u ,lil. ., ~ ,Iu'"r lI ..... a.ullll, 0,

~~dQ:f:i!ilig ~e l~tiJma:d!gg ~~ md Igf' ;H.Wptl~QI the 'depe~iJll·' :irng' 'Yef'SLu;m, :i,s that ,3iUi'4fii];O\ilIlt IS, di!!ip]acm w:m, its pmiJri8:,m iRlor.aIJ posi,~· '~O:Il. The' irmiP~imti,o.llIJ o:f'I'be sbift fOOm. 01lC ~mo:l1. tv!)- UO'tfuf!F is a ,rn\!i~d vi_' of 'Q!I;t. :b moraill, b:mi~~t. If :people 'become 'lia'hle. w· :mo:Fa!J r.e-. r5pongbj~illJ' 'kause' of ~h.e~F iii1.U;O;nomy! [then, ,H;utOfiO:my is; d1:~ ,S~i1i~ Iq:u.a. 'H~ ,Qf ,~ral:ilty,!, '[of' pe()'ple 'OOOOIRe' lia;bl!e' '~:O :mnml :['ft'!piillll!liibiitiJty beeause [of t~eh,;' W.c~5, Md. (lO:~5,PUT!U:tirm.g' :~M.~mJ5 M ,acii'Oi1I~ 'Ulen ilt 1!!j, 'tihn I~I It!JI~ots !O:f ~llu~~F ,ct):ndU(;'t, tlhatl, Q(~~' th~ ~-mtFdiI. ~jtiOD 'ili~t. ~ p:re-' Vci,O'w;sly a~igll,ed, 'm lIut:on.o,nl,Y.· In 'mi~ Iallte:r case, ,aJtI!liOll0m,~' so;ll, :matfti'5j of (li}'tI~'" but it ma1!1~ m,~(Jh L~~ ~~ 'beFore., It ~~, :re_~d, :~-Q~ t~e

'f:!'"'I!!~"'"F of H'P""."...,11i'IV' :""II"~, ,['t .. 'Iii'i"Q'""t,~-fI 'itt--ro: ~i'l....,. ~1"'.['~'f:'""'"~~~""litl;>;O 'no"'j.,~i~~ [~' if....,:',,;<a ~~;<.,;:;.

_ ... __ """"'_ _= """~'~-"l"':l ~~'!JI! = ~~'I:r.""'!liQ.l, !IA!I! W,I,'!o:r ""!I!I!liJlUJi Uilnonu. .• ,r~"_lJmU'J'I. uJ. ~l~,",~ '!WIJi'" .....

,of ~e' :f~b)~; ~:[fit mr~t be ,ooQ!5idemdJ :~n {lSSIIll'i.Qg the' a,ppmprlate depee 'OF 'nI,gr:al! t.~milbiUlty,.

:If!, h~r.~ 8itli~G:l1oMy is !i:iI.em,omdJ in mis, :rn~m:e:r, d'IJ:eJil ]~~~s ~ left. wiJth(H~t ~ !cUlILMef" to llhe [qu.estion. of why alili~.o:fl(Jmy m,(Jo'ld, '00 pl\ac-sd ,air. iih,~' cofii"ti· of dte:li" po-lii)ilcail, :m.o:~ilty, Thce~f P:f1ev.ii(!j!~ gswer-thal~ ~Ui~O'n,·' 'O:lD:~' ~s· th~"~ 'to :~Uiml~~g go 00, ~d. aYO.iiLin.g levit-is. ilia ~onget ,~p1~'

"'1'i,.'It.., A:':"1Jj'"'''''''''O:' m· -v ,i"l ,,,,~- .... , 'rlii''''"' '"''''''' ,a.own~l ~'I""''" ,~[ ... ,A .. ,1-."" ~""r"'_:I'JD""'_' ~£' ..... '!i,'1 ~ .. .iI .. ' .... l~ll.J'l~ .. ", . _" 1 .. ~-.I!lI :: _ ',_ 0 _'/.'- ,~ QI~~~ ,F"'~~. l~~l ~~~~ ~'~~I I~~~' ~lr~ ,tJ;'CV:---'l!r.~.J!~-"I!r I!{Q !I!r.'''·,I_ 1 ~IJ!' UJU!'"

llar.p~f '~O n,o:n:aUIOfii!l:mflrUS ~~iiIJ~U. If '~~be-rnJ!lSm, IS, tmly' oo:mmil~t~d, to i)ihe' b~c wh, m mo:~iit:r--Pmm)1)~~g' gooo, and O\L~~l:ng [evii~-tbeLn It Hli~t d1~ticaJJty revii~Ifi' ilts,'''(!fl'e, The' l\evilsi~~ is urOt ~ll!til, for- k<&i~' :U~f.~ als ha~' m~~nlly :hrll~nmfloo all.U.o:n:o-,·:a5 me' mll~iIy' ,cru.c;iid :~hO:~' [c!iil, ~k gd, '~eh:' :POSilti'OH sl~()u~d, be 'IJIn,'J:I~dJ bY' :ider;ni~,illl dlt~ riribt psyc'boiogiicaiIJ :!!iml~. 'Th,~ rl~.iIJl~rOOJ ~riM~n ~~, dlf'"~ti'(; ~~ fl.c nbctaW :nti~'2ikl~ :15 ~'Q' ,~~ppo~ :m~t. ~' :~h.():t~'Ca:1. ~te ~ cmc~;d W moratiJty,. ~at I'S, ,Cru£'jaJj W n1.oQnlIii!t¥ ;M'~' 'fh~ :good, md I~~ ,d~Clm.,gfh!.wm_ ~t!lJns.;. not 11l1:e:ir.' ~'~o:]~, ~a~.

r~l'·~ "."

If' ~be' legi;timati:DI' ~r.,io.:n ,o:F tb,(li' pr.iJn~iJple ,iI a~dQlJu~:d, aJitd :~b, dq;r~ .

~iping' ~~on m ~Q:e,ted! IJlb~H the' r~fle~ty of evil em he, r-e.c~ii1:ed wilth(1~~ iililicQ'n"i_Qg the' mQml;" 'ur~table COn~UEI!~c'S5' 'gat. 1~~n!l5 :righrJIy ~ ,a_gairnsL If' mu):r:a!l. ,q:e~~ hahi~nlllly' ~dJ predl.otably 'CaiW!'e [evil

'~-ealll8e' ;AI: itth"'lf' \Ii ... """. ',,"II\'I;~ ,~'Il-'"", n'liJI"it,.,..PI;1I;iI', -ro.~ ,"" ..... iti~~ ~·\..""ft 'r., ... "l~,,: r .. II!t.~-, '!llfi"i"''''~ ~._~~._._.~ 'M-~ ~~_~ .~~~ ~~~, Yl~, ~~!I:~!:~_IJ! ~~ ~~.ll W~I_6!1.1 [JIU:111~!ljJ ~dIBI~ ·!r·",~WUi

'~,~1i1l 'tt.i~' ~~ :m,o:ra;IIy-' :~mrs~bL\e ql!ll~te 1iilJde:pendellitJy oJ whethce~ .... th:e:i1I" Wicudnm Q, ~~nQmolU;" 'Tille reason ft.-r dtr.is lt5, 'tha!t. commil,belll;t to 'm,om'lii~ il'Ci'1Illl.liire!S do:i~Q!' 'wha!l ~nu:: li"6aso:nab:lv em ,t~ ~'J ,~~?'~ 'c-,d

~"_'-~~:J' ~"1i ._., ....... -~'~lI!!!'" ... , ... , .... , _. I:; ... 0 .•. " I. ~!, an.

'Wticbd, ag~'Q,~t$, 'ca~ m1.. H~ll(liDI '~em, :mo:raJ~' feSpafi:s:ible ~me.as adlo;pt··


6'~'

[",

...,. . .'~_ d 1" 1',Ii.,_·~.i:~ ,j!iI,p~l,..,n £t!l.J't';!!tY!N.tm·

:iil'lg' '~nw, :measures, 'W ourt.aiil ·thelr COJft4liiCtL Th~· :mesura tnd~' :pUJblK dj~p~ of them gdJ. their:' ~tio~s~. ,~~, :~, 'M ~PKi!Ji~ ~~.

'"i~''"m''' I""",?,'i(-·ii.:ul.,' .r;Ir·:l~II""!'" I'l";ro'ij: '~""" ~.~ 'i'l';i.~, ~ii.;!Im~ '[. ,d'~t_~i~cr'ii~in,Q" '~'t;.""'m' 'rnu-lJI!lL ... ~ilMkU_-"'O .... 1!1!1.!I!IJliIi.~n, .. iii .... '" !1i.'V ~ ,I! ,1'iO'C III.!IJ& .. "~'~""l~~"'iOi Uih.: ..... , ,_, . .\I'.'~.

:Fe:!!i,pcll1l~blC :~tlOT:i~~ ;cm.plloyi'f:tg ~~lla.:Ji([):n~, ~g', Md, ,c~jt:m. to

",,'L. ~ =_ • ,. ",.'1...' ·'1[1..,;,11 • ..,'L. f:' ;o'L

'I1irir=vti!m~ ult'iM lll'w:m (lGll'OO'mtmli!t ~i~~1! arlil! 'C-onUiliKt': 'war:t1im~' 'O'~II~n 0.' iI:.!U~'

lIT"" -'. ) • . .. , •. .1 - . ,. . -, - I. ., ~I ' -, _ . . _ I. _ ,-., ~ •• , .. - _ - ~ ••• _ - ••• I , _ .•

daiftp~ :i;n,v6I~ '~jJJJ ,~~ting Wlith ~~m:, and, '¢'Itahlibhiing ~d, mainlw~,

"i":'l''ilI',:.' ,''"''' ... : •• · •• [l(iI!"'~1"1 ~\oj'i;, 'n-~.,~"'''i: "","I!r""IjjI', 'if-I"'"i"i' "i''L.j "!" 1""-"1i'II'O .• ~. 'I"-""~' .,...~ "i;"L. ... ~r i'"I· .. iIiiiI"lii""';o;_ ,I!~~ ,1! •• ~UdlUUU'JlJliII! [LOU r.PV-'l!lii''!I.1Ii. """UII""'IJ i<t .IJ. U'JliI .. !IiiI!I."",, .... "'-'!',.i.~~""1!"'"'"'.'.~!lI' '!U!',Ii. 1IiJ,11!I." "'_""'Wi!'l!',.'I'il!.

€I L. ~ . .:il~ '~Il ,;, .. tu 'b Ji,'ii-..' ~, " , '.~-t: ~, '.~ ~ii:... ~ ~ '-' ~.' ,

,aHr~il :m.eullIus Me' :mMU;;' '.C,B'J!!Insitc' ~, Iu.;e plterm til; lew~ [u':~' .nts

ha:ve' ¢-a~d, in, ,the ~ ~d, ~' nl~e'lr to ca~ :~n du~' fuil;l~., It; $h(Jllld, •

'~"';, '~w"'m'-~:'IJ;-,,:~4i i""~j=i' i"'b ... , ,...,.~Il'-'i a.rr,-.. 'i'!t""t..liti'F-ili ,'!io~d",' ~"'!,ij;~'I!-]"'" n:l!tili~~;iI! ~""~' ~ ,IJ'!I!-"_IJ_IJ,~ • ~~,~-u, IU_~_"l IU:L~ ~~,.~ [~,~ ,~IUI~m!L-~, illiilllil 'I j' ,,' !Iw~ ... IJ.,..w. lr-',!!","~~~II [I,,~~ ~,Ir'U~

ra're ,episodeSti. ru!lF are '.ey' :m~ pco~adiiU~ but ,tb~ ki[Ji ,m- :~Q~ :~_d '~~;u.stiitied. :h~ th~t. d~flJ]l~di~, :~mrSEJl.IlI~' ,and, IDthl~ ,ag-en!1iI mU!e., ''T~''!rf'-'V ""'''''''''' ~', .~~ .. , ~'h';A~ 'Fe'· · ... ;.1],.... ,,,,_, 'p!hWl:inl~~,-'il '''"iI''~ ~'hn1~,,-:,,"1 ,~~ ...... ,

, liI_" RIO .... IU_g~"_~!I-iI! '!1I'"IV~ ""~"""_)!Io'JI """" ... !.'-~~'¥'~~~~Di""'!;,,~ ,-~Q r = ,,-~~~'I;;I'~~, ~__l!W"_,

,~- ~Ft 'w. cil'i'!io~;'~~ th~r.· 'wc!tlims!' ;(lo:mliif1[ln~d. 'fj~n~otio.n~n~' as 'fj\lt~.o"n,M

~~:s. ill ,.ir~Ut"'"'""''''''1Z . .. .,. . . . . i L .• ••. .! 0 ' , .. . ~ .. ,

hiDmlIm beinl!' Thes;e' :mJeD\!I_l'e~ 0;[ eoune'~ :10 ~Q_s.t '~e lifix:r:jlll,Qiin 'k~~ m~ ;c1LII~1 mf!i' ,aut(ln.o:my ,0£ ag:~I1!t!, 'by' (Jlllrtai'llin,g ~.~, 'Nludl!tI

.. ,'i.... ' _', [;~Itd'~ ...i ,;', ,J!;.,.. '.. ~,1..., . 'il.......... '~I 'L ........ ii ~,;r;;~'" ~', .-J; ,~'il.. .......... ~·> ~- A, .. - .:II ~Bf)

lIi .. Uey ~U. --. lJIeli!r\!'C' iI],'o;m !I;UC' ~K ,J!~],,;jy,y~!!1'e8 OJ! ,P,IiW,'iIlI_I5I'Il-----i!i ~Ji ~eu;Q~[i;

,iYlillliIillitv. rioOl"h!t! and du.bibutive J·mtiice,

~'""111 1r&i:J'JI"&,, _-)il_ ',,-' _,-II_,.,-,-" ;o],::__.' __ ' --.

Th:~ ad.o-ntiCOll of'.~se moffiUU[\~ u'tG!ible to iaiOOse. a!lu~ -the rnn1iD,ad ,ano

, "'. '.. . y." ".-' ,...... ,. -- -- _ ".. _ • ,.. . i!i .•. ,. , !r"~' , . _._ .

Hl,QW, ditl~__ge:r:~, ~~~~d, l~, ~~n} ,af1~ (;(iJn$id~l!ai~l~. 1".h.'¢ :fflL~ IOf' tb~' d~.~'

',' "".' .'" ". ,,--,'''.~ ~ .....ej. ...... ~. '~_,.-!li'~ .. -"',<II-,,'.-,'""'" -~-·.....jl -.--"~~ -i;., .. 'io.,,-,--. diaJiiiItiN!!--' ,,,,_A 'ii';:u:s~gnln,r VC.-slon UI; [~I;J.€'.: Jhl~nC'i~le I.::Ii ~',~_'"l!.!! 'ap!lId11!!1!"" ~~ I.'~ .-'--.I0,,,,g _,...J!!'\OiI!, ~.'tiI!

p~'t 'po~bl~' :~k~' by Pf~'iiWDg a :p:riind,~d, '~¥ of d~idmg what, m~Ul::~.5, and. what ~ri!l¥ ,of m.ca!I!U'[\e! aiR 'tqjitimate to, 't;t'lre im the ease ~f diffe~gl age!lib, 'who ~ ~O-lfIlI~ 'W\ic:kcdJ i~, diiJCr~,t, 'wap., Itp, dIb culllil:eXI iiI. beeomes :i:mpu11ainlt to oded.de: how ,!a!ut'OIUUIWWIi, OT' BonD't'O'no-' HlcQ'Wil, '.c' ;agefl,t$! gd d~eLr aQti-gn~ ,~. HaWA,I,:a pHn.¢i,le b~ of (:iJl,IQe'~~

i"".I·~ m'I~lj';Iiil:li·'''''~ i"'I[-.~r. ~:"'..,.;, ~;n'f"'!i!N"1I'.,· ," ''''''f"·dl ''''~e ... '~:-~iI'"," 'urfO'11: be : ""'1~i;.:i[~~, :a--~l~~' '11'1'" pAln .. ,

MI_lI~Y ~ , .. ~!Ii:i, IUltdil U=I~ tsW!I~~, AIJ. UHI !A~~ nll_lJ_ J .. !PIit'1!u.u.::U1!! 11.J'U~ "_IIIU l. '.1,11_1::11

:By~' 'm- ,~~-engthe;g:mg the cri~~, 'M We' l~t1i~~g ve~oo 1M 'thE prinfip~" ,iir~ '¥I,iU. H' ~rJ[li~ 'to. cOl!lslrlier :so:m.e :imp'liatii.o:ni5, Qwat do ,MId mme' ~ d~ :1101. f"QlUgw :b~, tli.e' p:~c~dmg' krtISSI.Qn., ;So~e :may' lihini, 'thait: because 'dle I egi tim ait1ng' 'vernon. Ib, lbD:~afir ooth 'in ib! QnlJiQ. ,and, ~n, :il" :in~n£e' Ith@t. :mnFaJl :fit'-.5,poni!l~bn~lW ~Il&' loon. ~ul~m.o-m,)' ,Mld 'bc.C3'!IJJK' its·'c[,i1ic__~ ilJivd~ stre~ml' ~e' :mo:raJ. :~potf.ain,~e ,of W, 1~C;,fj ,gf :~U:ons,~ '~e 'Gnrti.c;:i~ :b Idt~O:M 'lh~ :fal111iii iu' mn~";I;1.1~~dailist o'b'j~""· 'mon It:o Ute' ~)ti~ :~pprnaCb to OlOm) q,ue.slluns;., But ihi! (lO'J'tdlWo;n :is :m;o1. OHe that f'oJl~ ~QlJ 'What: ~, '~e-n .td.

The cri'uci5.m, i:s not: ,cn:nseq,u-enlialist;" idtihough ~i!t. is c-ompali!b:le 'M., IO~Q.$eq-!/.I,~ti!8'I~~ ~ ~~ :ii5 wttb IQro.e ~i:gQS of' lh~' ,~tti~p app:~h,


O;Ul~,~¢:mJtiMili!i_ :b (::Qmrnl~tq, tn' ~Uiaiti.ng 'the ,-u~ 5lOO,mng' o:f ~ l~" ii'~,:sol ~'t [k!"':fiIdl~ " ~:n c ~:',,- "." .' ,~"T' :~~~' ilhat It:f]IJow''h. ",; ~doHiiiiiin : mtLJ5 _.:te~y IYl"T .~eR~~t):e w_~e CQnseq!ll'ei1l.c~ ~~_,,,,_~_ .. ,~ _~~~ ,'CL~ ~"~~_~~I

dl~m., The ,o~mun, '1iO 'di~ Icgi!timwtirng' ~i~n 0:£ m~ 'prlnclpl~' :is not

.:il. '" . ". ...:,~I· . L.,~·· lib . '. .A. __ ~ .' ~,.Al::' • h

:Uliat U:, 15, not OOmi.Kq,~m~_J;.!n, l~~ '-,--,-all::n ~ !mot I~ve 8oWnc::relmlt.'WClr!--"~'t [1)0

;ccOn~i~Ii.i(;~S. GJJring th.~, ;S'Il~'h wttiglilrt n~ tn(J~ Wlili\i'(j:lw' gtviln,g dt@m rd~ 'tile 'weigbt.,

'11li~' ()~ti'O:m, i.s that [r1tt' l~giiMma.tln,g '\i'~rsi(jlii, ~Il'C£~~!I, ,(Ill '~~ p.sJF' c'hol~, states '@ftlu: .,el'l:u, in deciding 'wkeller 'llhq' O'ug;bl, '~O 'be bdd :m.o:rnil:ly :FC!lpon:!iitJl~ :fD:F di.eiF aci1iojJ~'I iand, th3~ m~ ~ff«t.!, of [tliteiir' rac,b.Oll!iIi, [nn [iI"i; ..... 'I;-~, gl~ ~Di1:1I;Q' ........ ,,·t ~ ;oi;i'l;!"l""'lI'lI'tin,Q" ~'L"", .;I'''Q':I'\P~H'·lt;1IiIi~nOi' '~IIi'G~n.n~ 'I'RW""Ii-,"'1i;-, ¥~ V~~~i.!JL~ ~j'~ ~~~~!IiZ!;IICUj_r. l""" M.~'~-~,r·H-I~~~ IU_JJ"1r. ~~p 'Ir."'-"~_ ;.,~~_II_IIi~~ ~!!Irll ~VtI::II!I r~';" __ IL~

ltqgJic-all, ;Sl!a'l~ [(;a.1l.$ln;g ,th~ ,~tinn, as wel~ ~ w,e' 1.e-.elS iQ:f' ~e' aoti(!)n~ 'Cg be

[ai~'Ii'" ,i'lIfn'n.....",.nn:";o:>t,",,: ~iU';iht: ·iQ~,b.,...lloait~~,l i"~~."':!' .. , :;0:>,.."" '"'i""i"I~~t' 't'):~":':~'oiIIi~.;"1"lh:'lia· ~.~.!\:;r. .. _ .. ' iPIIllj\r~J'U'r :A_lII~, n!l.;r.-oIJ_IL~"111 .1"·-.1 .... · . ,u.l~,~,.~bd.I. Md_~ 1IIiiII.I.~ .LL~~ ,~·!I!14IiI!.I1IJl, . _~ UE~ .. ,~lIl1lJlJlJl,;I,.~

i)!b~, d~ or m.t)~, :reapoHi!!l~b~IW toO' 'wl~i~'i~ .age[[ll~ ovc:' nca:b'tc,~ while lJ!be ,deQu o~F the~f ~O:fiS, ate' re~~t £0, ;an~R-I' the q,~e.stiun, of 'Whetl~, tbc' ;qe~e aee '(iable '00 UilnraJI :[lespo:miJbi'l;ity., Lest ~,: be dlo~bJt, t;ha~: 'Illbi!!, 'O~rn5, it'lii.~ [o'iJv,io!!U d)i«ERn.c~· 1K;~En eri~ ,eatUR;d by 't1tillm_ ,Mid ~art 'cai~d, 'by ~i1)mih~aIll ;a,g,e~~,. ,lit '~'Iibnuild, 'be' remem'~, that [tnt'; ~B~tI,

w'li'I.nse if-elewnil"l. IS ib-::in~ ;lI!~II""!~~-,~. ;!:I;["'~ 1Ir'!':Iib'ii~'II"~~ '!:Io.dl :nIi'Vi'ldli .... f,,..J ... II~. ~1Iit\PI ... ,.ldll!, ,..,.,f' ..... ~~. __ .~ ~'_~~ .. ~~""'-.". ~. ,~~, ~ !i!."""""'~ !I'i"I'"",",' ~!'-!l'li •. ~~, """'~···Irr.·-··~-!II1[; r----",II.1l! '!W!",'

,eVi~~w:g' :~~~, tiBt, :rceiled the vioos ot their. ;q:eHfa, '~~umim

,Q;CH1t1 do [ilUll :F'GinB a..:mO:118 thrat '(ueell lillis, 8pediCiliriU~., .

Anilth~' «lndl~i.'Qn '!'hail. may be C~j],~OI!W1 tthl)u[~~ w foUuw' '~Ulld

~;yj",'1~ ~''''''' .-I;;d~n,;j'o~tiiI ... ik""':h ..... ""'1IIiI1 ';;"'II!" ·h."""", 'U,'IIi~·I'I'Iol!lill!, ;A'~ ~'i..""', "~I!1' ... ~nl:...,. '~'~ [R]L';O:>.v

H·I! ~ ~~_~, l!bl~ !IIi.I~~_~.:.:i~~-~'-=-.1 1~'~;n'!l.(~~1Il WIr'v ~n-v ·!I'!'1wJ"lII~_ r'U,IJ~_'" '!Uil. 1._I~I!Nw: rlJ IUl'-~"rl~~J .IVll ll~._~:MiJ

be dl,o.ht ~ait wh~t!I, a ,Cittn.alin :limit 15 RH'h.ro..~ :the d~igning '~t-..

;a;~ a,~mlnkr 'iijo;~~"" ;1" I'i'" rI'.iI"Io, 1"1..""" ~PO'irt::m' i'lIft-:;n,a'.' ~o,"iII""1ifIl·. '''Ii'i':-'!' '111',~;;t' ~i"1"1 [i"I'~'"!!"~~""'-- is _~~ --~.r'~!J' lI:i!lill~ 11..'19 ,.~ ... J!P..!I [!I.UI!Io ~~.!I.Ii .. _""'!l.lil'~ T",",~ _"""',,. ..Ii, il:iI ...... I 'I'~in." iIO~~ .,j"'''''''!IiiIU,Ie~ , :a;

RKhtil! 'wh~n ,.n~ ~' 'ca~y :~S,,om~b'lCi for paLttt~sl 'Il! ~ actiAl~i' but '.eir ~hok9(at states prnc~,ude' the ~.itirmai~ aK_r:ipdan uf :ma-ta!l. re~'~Jl~bi!li~ w, thc'g_" Tbi'S ~~Q!y be i:5Ui~d, to hap'pen~ :E'O:1f e:xa:mpl~I~ if ,ag;~nQ, b~~' 'm.~1liIItai dlI~d~ gd dldr ac~~Q~ ;M\e iClIa.~d, by delUiorn!lj. u.,cy :_ve Slu:b, :lDw' :mill£JUgesn.re Ih.at Ilh,q' ~ ;i!fl~bl~' [of ma!kli~g dl~'

, ... \i!'linn ....... iIiiii~n '~~~ ... ..,n ,...!'l;~I.C!jIIoIE, ;!'l;~~ ;If!i~t, .. , "i''L_;O:>ft· ;O:>f~ Kpa' .~' .. '"~'igVi',",-~ Ib)'''. ',I ig;, ",1L.."""iI'i" ';t;~~' .. '._

~-y.~~~~~~ ~l!fc'!!'!-~~I::IJ ~~1Il! ~llf~l 'W_IBli~""'!IriJ! ~ll_~. I MI_ljll!l,i- . .. __ "'Mi'~l " MIl ~_I::IIV<IJ lLl [Ill! .. r-

~ • M

Hail! '0:1" 't'~l'tljpo:ml :~I1!t(',~~ OF 'dJi£f' havc' '~.en .~m:~' b~~~edJ; ~,Ie:r:a1I.

,cbllcl)R.~ :mlgkt haYc' been, :I'll, such, '~ btJtb '~e l~dmiltlll1:g' !a!lld, ~,~, d~iping ~iun ~~ Olll Ithe jn~iij.~ oJ :hOild~ng' m~' .n~ moml~y rCSPfifj_~lb]:e'., 'TiI'u!!:' MO 'venloD!i, ,a![iI!!' tth.us .!ih~ ~:o he :m;Oot :re:il!ly diBcrenJt.

'f,furis ':!MlI,"Pfi:!ittioo~ h~f~ ~is :Qlii~e:n" Thee r'OO't (Jf ~~ [e;:fFOF :b dt~, [(L~I]-

f) .• ' of' m.IJ • bit· d . b 'fiu '" 'bi • tilt

'~.a~Q(n:,.; :gl__,O__; ~_tj R.!!i,POm1!!!~ .. ~ty ~ ... p~D'l.8:.J_me;l'lit, CI~1 ~.:_n_~.I;IMiIU!!A)t. :1' [;'Ii! K~~

,est: :1re~liI. t'O :m.o:ra1, Rspo:msl,b:il~" .. , ,an,d, natlW£'a!lly: .. , ,11IJ1lIIn1iltn;fu I~ ~Hi' rnlOCdrms art;' :po55irbteJl, ~p.ooln, ~tel1t_dl~p~ 'to ~ial! [~ttacl~. ,F~emtote'~ ~n'Jlhrme~t. itself' ~FSI (Kim, m!j~d pem:a!lty m ~Dlipri.50~

W"""I'O'"', [0'[' ,~!U"'Aoi'j"I'"t.:"",,~. '[:,.,,~ ,,,,,,,iii"'';";''i.'I:lft ,;o; .... uiii:'li~, ~"L. ... ,.( ii"i~nii"ill'"" ~. ~~~"L ,~ ... ,1 .. ~:1 djm:-.,., ",.",."""1'1)11. lV\, "",~,,,,,,w,lI.II},,","~,, , l, '~I~-~_ n ~1!lI!I,'U u." '~l,dt:,e; '!lI1J!11l1io iI:-"""F~ WiI"IlQ, '"iII".,.n~,. ~ __ ,[1

AI.......... ~ . . '11 ~ '~'I:..... 'iiI ~_.'i'" .~..i h tool . ' ... ~ • h ..Ii 'B" .. iii.

,~,~, '0:[:" W,__;~O ,~",:_,.:,-,,: ~emll-,-ru~!I~~ mO~~Q, not ~ ~Q_I.!~.'cu." ·.IlU: 'b~e reae-


eA ~

ti.o~ rto :mo~ ~~I'l~hilitlf need! f:U)t take' the :fofll!i. of :pun~~rnenit., "~nII! res.;po:ll's:iJbiliJl¥ IS· ],iamii!W to 'm~rail j~d!prn,e9il :.:~t It:_mwM' true 'that 'the,.;:: peDp]~ b.aibiltnan, :a:nd pmdi:cmbly car~' ~viil; dl~f.' PFGd!i~table ,acdfiniS

" . ~ I;'" " ti ....• ~ ,~. :, ... _ [.: i , r 1 ~. :t~:;C'~~fI 'I[-,~~ 't,:, .. : , .. 'I.., ., . [_ 'Th:'" , :'~. , !li"·~·· ~t,· !In~'_"~IIft.o' 'It .;' ' .. ~;II

€:iiI~ K][UlUS" 00llHYlliQ"" ,I)~,IU, !lin Q,yJ'cf!. =~~'i5; ~_iS ~~a, a ~w.m~.1 ~~euu~

,fa.CJl. atl~' ~Ilot be [co:mmilrtOO l'O FIlOraili!ty amid not dtiJIl'k 'IDat ,m'Cl~, pco-' ple ~1f'.iIiIi' t~"'i'm~'tl~~ '~ ~"I.. ... , ,....n~ ''''~ii!''V h~'!'I;'irf:·,h~ ••• ;iliiV :!:Iilll'o~ lI'\'~d'-li"l"t~b'~ ~'j"-'- ""~Ili ;if r~l .... g_lI,... l-a_-_l!'~l I~J 1 ... _I"It~ ~~I._1 ~l~__".1 ~~-R_~,J'~_'_11J ~::!~, ,rl.li·!!r.'.='!I.:-~U-..J,1 ~~:I! "!r,I·!!P~-,,~ =

[they ,C~jl'n(J-t help, ~lUiIng' it.

'Ii '" ·c,_L.'1 'I..~ .~::..:II b~ h '~~...:'i.. ~ii..·' m'b._:,.. d [lit [(a!nJw:tliu~,:1 K" ~ ,!a!wut sucn peoJL~ '~mt '~~e!Ir wa~ [::~' ~g' ilmi.:.~

aQting ,atie m'orruly' d.e,plo:~bl~: '~!lit, jlt. wootdld be a moraI~' 'Mtlm- woFld, if dler'!: 'wel:l'e D!!) peoplie Uke, d\e:m~ that otters i!lihoo,~lll 'I;~, prore~ted lnlm tbe-Hl_;; d~at UI,'fl' d~taib of thelr actiQ:~s, bomiy :~,d, dii~t ~: ~d, ~ f<tf:tib" To[ w'h!8!t. ~~~ do. :s1lC'h Opifil;[OD5! (:unt~ lhan 3J, :mnr8il.JJll'd.pn~ll!t that inlipUm, ~me d.egre.e of mM,al, respl'ns.ib!l~lf', It 'wouild, 'be' '~~ 'to !puH~s'h :~'h 'ben(g'lu~d .e.n~ bUit ~t :remaiDJJ true that, their"l~~ ,3111<1 c:QrlCiu'Ct ;~ :1iOm:rail1,~' :Fepup~t.

T~' li.itii~' ~ 'i)f .omll, r[~l1is[biil1J~, dti~'.m~f~, is no:t «i~noe' :fmm

;illb' "~"'i'"'L ' ... j.;.f ........ fi'IOl' 1 ,t:Ii~-1 t".., ""''':":''''' """"':~m:nt'e-1l" '~'jlfm~: .. fro ,t:Ii~-i'l'" '["."'ifi'Ioil;>.,...iI!' iI..~ ["""""'''"1''n.,-d' I

H, • _I~,u, ,II!U"H.!nj~ ~~~!.I'" !AiIO '!G "'""_~"" , ~ ~,f"""''!JI_., ,1~iI: ..... ~"",uJ '1~1I1.[!II;]I ~)lI'.'.,,,,,,lIi. !.II{; 1!o,;,,,,,,",,I'.-'IIr~ ~ . ~

f~01J mot:a1l, :~s,,o:nsibjl~ty, (~i' thdr.' 'vi.~~ ,and paJl~m$ of lG"tiO:fi:$. ''Nb~t, :midl~ m-om!l :~J.~IlJMim~~~' in~rn;ble from, 'be i n.'" :1i1i.wman is 'the 'VlN'~ne:ra,,"

llJ-'_- ~:, '-101':,..];"'_ ..... ~

bji~t~r o:f ,O'ther:s, t(J1 the ~I thw;, 't1r,~ma.n ¥i1Ji)$ Ql!D, ca:-~' i]b~m. Wllail, :hrU'man &leD:U, can and ,:!!ihould, be e:lte:mpt'ed :[fODl is :puni5ihIlEUl':JIllt" if' ~b.ey' [e~tIR the' eril 'tbey do ~~ of" i~'b :~k of a~~il;()~Y' g g, W'e' gf'!the :buU,vid~ in 'tihlll @xarm,pts, ,~ll, ,a'OOV'e"

,A, :~e:r :Unp'l~o:n of' it.~, :~edin,g '~D:m, :~btm ro' lthe paint

• ~,~.A L~ ,.,'j:.., ~1 '·b~ ']-'i'~ ~~ 1 'h .. L h ~. b:

Jlm ~~mu,e aiPO"ut, l~i.'t,: ~m0:~J'~' respon_:S1LILlty 'w;' :peo:p~e' 'W'~Q [Y,~~UV~ HO[ :!L~N.lL

:-:-f~''''L"''''''.~~1 ~"~k ;"",,<i"i'",~""'_!lJ'~, "~:n;.~,~, ~;o; i ... ·;jj' :;oc~ .... ;I ..... , ".,. .. ,··'LI·'·",,~iu~.o;>m~ · .... ·n· JI',''i:-~,''''~~'''1 o , Il);t"",~F (h"l!',IIl~ 1 ..... __ 'oI1iIJL"'-!'IiIlV,LU,. .'f.W,~L L'iI! l11li., .,_1Mli ,u, IilII." ... 1liI~r. ._I!<... . _ :~ .. , _ ,!I. ~[!I.,",~",""'-'~

'the ~i;benil! 'tend~ll_q' to ex:em1~t ::rn:¢'h 'iolge~l~ fmm '1fJ"u~:~, r~n$ibn~ty al~ I~thc;r wnd 'd1i~ ~~g ll~,~)ij~' to mp:m ~~m i8$ ImhL~' flo ~~, '~j[l!t; ,n~l; 'to :'UJni5b~{t.. is '~C [qiUe.i5Ii.iOJ] Qfwnol h a, :mDraiL ;¥~t, "bll the' 6Ibe~, 'rl'e'W! '~lC' ],e,ghii~ng ~Q:i,QIilJ (jf ~~, :p:r:iInolipl@' can, 00 e:m;ploy~d as, ii, cri~rio:n :f!l:r :iJfS ;9in~: HlOW agert'tl, aLR those no [C~ a,et g~nQ;m~~'.'ti ,O~, "the nrtcw, 'rie,w;. theroo:reI' ~O~ ;~n.q :~ ~, l~~ mo.raiJ, ;adl!~mc:~t. Th!i.s ~' ~.~~ [0£ oourse~ inmmra.teLJ' [connecmd 'Mth 'the prariUudf' [criJticia~d Qfite' :thl1t, malkes[ lbbiility '~ "~raJ respon~blli. depend O~, '6e ~'bol~~

-~~ ,~lIi"'.c""";o;, ,..,._&' ,.:\-~ ,ap' .. ~~rt;.,.~ ~~ """1"":""n~"'~'lIJ" [".iI': ~'''''''"'~: i"Iflllit, ........ 'O'nf'." ~, ... : ~iI.."", ;i'j"n·ijt,~.no~n LirIlI, 34i.ilI~~ilI vJ, lJI:I~ '. ~~)CI!. .!l, Iii .... "-I1!.l!\.,~. _ 1'Io.. • .,_,u,'U',.!., .~ lIi!U~g,," ""_!II!U\U1UlIi~.~. ,Ill' ",U,.., ""', ~~ !lV,U,

. . , .

of' '"i)!h, meral .nq ,rnnd :morW, :~l~~IIl!:!I~hii~i,tyl 3ifid aU ,ml,d only' mgra1

~ il' 'ii..:1 ~ ...... :I "~iI" ~ 'D ~ "it ~iL '-II ,. ~ '. -, - f

agelllllS arc' IlLau "'~:' 'm [m..o;I:'~, :respoliIg~I~lIty'i ,uut, II iie' , l~tlJ_nDbnl 'VCl'Ilo.il [0",

,~~::. ~p~~ ~'JP~::" ,.,,_ .... ~.1;,~;o;, ,~-~,~J' 'f"~ :iOio'I'I"'''''if''nm1j!' ,;0'0: ..... .:1 'm~ ~·"i'i'.....,.I'I' ,"i'!-'!' .. I'i1iO-..,. ... i1iIl:-',·~.if!!l;!, ,i"If~ i":"l"-, UiI.Cl: L'~ n~CJ:_ J~ d.I,.,g, [lJb., ''I!",L~'!I''I!' "'-AI! illlJU!IlV'~~----I lIIi.UU, , __ ,"'-A.I ""', ,~·I!U<il!,Ir·~'u_~,b"" l11li.,,"'" II '!Ii.'-

" .i'~4i_-, '~'IL .. F~'~~,~ns , .. {I~.-,c,~··d'-I '-C~-"n&" 'th~m-Cm(;; -I m~-~i' d1~~: mlHt 'be"

Jed:e\.ili~, as ~~e ~e!HO~~_ ~~CtL :ag;;u_t. _~e= oo-~,re~,~J~ _~ey ~ ~' "~~,'

'~~~''''''''I' 1 o;II....oi!!' ~.h.-.i;"~.~. ~ ~:· ..... '1'I<J'£ ~--;-...,...iII ag~~ .. ,-. ~''''q-.' ,.'I:-a't ~." :''''1' j~~m,,",~"!'!'lJ'" ,..,;-r.;nll'l.-"i~"': ~ .. 1..

UI~111J liltl,~ ~"U'I.I!.~. . ,~IJ_IJ U~l il_lI_" Uti. W. . .'Gi.~lr.. lial .. -_ "_Il! .tlllJ~ ~ "-"!-u, __ ~ I~"L~ oll ... ::IJ

1 .~ .:. ••

'thieml, 'C_'l!lo-1: eK.~pe' 'beiln,g deck\d!.

'11te ~l[Iimp,tio:n 'ooderlyil'll' aiU!to\ll,omy ;18 a ,m!h:;riuB '00 ~mO'm, :aplilCY 'ils


,'ii", ;t" ·1'" ,AI"" f; 'iIf',~~ 'k~ , " '''111;:--' -, '. ,"""-'il., .' ,- - '.

'Y!ilie :I'amlll~_a'r !:A~Otum o;~; ,~!lt ,3ilNU!t, a'Cti;O'Jl_~ - -.L u~eJf 'WU;n.~!I! !ConM_SU~, n;ot Lilli,

'tme eft~ts, wbicb. re9~t~i~t, from, ~em, ., " " bu,t ~il: moe ,aJU.ii~Ud8 ,of' :milnd "~I " •

wh,.",,'''b ,i'Ii'I:',~ "'e"li~..JI~ in, 1·,'t.1j",' "i""'~' ~\('io, 'm"nif.f"!"'"', ~"b"'~~"'"liil~~' in .. , ...... ~,.".:n~'~ ll.i"·i"'~''':' lGii~iiI~

~~t=~_JI_j-~l ~~~ L.l~~,r = UIL_~ ~~I'" IIlV =~~~~~ l!&i-_~~~~L~-~~ =~ ~~-~ \~~~ ~~~~

.~ lliio'il Q''iI 'Eli' Iii" , ,,'i., " d- _ " " ',-' ,'11" " ,,' "..i '-' ,Ai_ ' O,.,.iIi;t·, ... , • ..i_ '.', ,', ,"'" "., "..i"~' 'I..i .1,'ViiIO.'~,3~1 .. ,IQI!lIi" wl!~l [_ ,_QeS, m,(!T.iib ,agency '!JIe,pefit'!JI, CUill ~l.llWo!ll,e!li, 0,1, B]JJn~, ,allu

:fiot oilJ "the effceU 'w'h-l:d~ reMJt :fI,I),g 'ttitem,''''r :iHow cQ'~d, :it not be :;aid, of '~pl~' '~bO; Lan to :PQ~ the iiii~([f-edi'p;g ,!J!tti!bIlde~ of ~i[id 'but, who, b~bit·,

'·I·-;-o.UU "'i!UI~~ ~)llN\I' '''~a'I~' ~''''''j<;o\f :~~, ~,'"iU~~ :::Ii~iifi;~"'l~ 'i""~[ "c' ...... ~io' ~;!li;i'ilii'i~df; 'n;"--'ii' 'b~",:""_-4i:;i] ~IJI ~-'IWII~ '!t;I"!I'lIt llIEII, l!.Il.-,.. o.lIJ~ ~LI~~\I.m, '-e.;~lJiil)~r ,U\J IU,L~~~ ')i~_uu,LI~1.i.aI ,.,L~'L, _.~~",J

HoW' OO!l.dd '!,}:I'I'@' 'be: ,co;mmitt~d l~) t~~ biWc :In,uml tis'k of :F.1K('~flJtijn:g c~l :md not 'be' w:i~~~~o" '~)} UmD~D:e' dun i;i~~ti~ud~ o:f nlii:mj'~![ 'miiaJt~r ,from ,th~

_I. I .. "~_ ..•.• , .l~ ..... ;.r. Ib _ ,". _~._~. _ ~ .... ', , ,. I ,,_. __ •.•. c_ •

nd . f'· 00 f' n lh' I)' '1llJ· 'b I ii' h ,.,,~

""'".0 'n(\'., ... /iI" "ro' I' '!I'!I""'~ , : :-, ... ;<>1.' .... _"" ofio',' "',', II',.,. ..,..' II "'"c""";:O;,'~ 1'1':"-' [,'I '~".'. ~", 1-lrOiilii'"1 [i'-"""'"i" -"i

~.~'J'1UI 1r,r.~-IJ_I::._j'1 'IUI- .• '''' •• ~'!I'!''!I!' _ ... ~~,~ ~ • . _. "" ~ _ !Ib~'lo:J! '!I!"'I!' j ,1:1i.J _ 1.!L~y_ ~l' _, "_~_IJ!t_ ~ ~I~I_~. r.

Tille muwer' W\h~c!h. [th~' rb~t~:nica'i HiiJ.IesnUIlJS, ,ar~' :m~it '~.O ~ruk~t, 'jjs :l:11!at

ii,

~iili' '·I"'!:"" em: 1~ .. iIo,..,l.",:", ''i~ ',"I'I'n'_~,' •. ' .;, '.~Ia'~' -m,-A..,,-..II ~ii!J!''''''''Ai' d "",~ ... _.,-;J,.., :::-,' !"'-I~.:'1": "'-';;~.,' :k~'~ ....... 11 110', , . ., 'IJII, , _ ~ 1.iI!_~ l"" il!U,r\I;'"'~~~ ll!li l, . u;i,m ~~'"'.'~J _ ,'!L.iIr~uiU" OJ!) ""~!t!.l!',numy,. J.n'UJi~W

ilIfltn£Y is, :11,0:1: an ach.i~lme:i'ic't. 'but ,il £::onrll.~dofi,-'liie hlmJlafi oondttd-'OifI",

Ui.I~1fI"'1 '''"~I [b.~LonO'!':1. _ ' :",,~, '11O'!01·ry..,..iI "'"'0'"""' .... ',, .. , '-r"':"",,,,,.'.;t'- li:l,.-"lil:'!r : ... ..-:i:j.of"i;li'~, i"a ....... •1 ~ .. ,~: ... _. ""'I Itfj--_' "1-;-_ nJ";n.l.~iIO 'UCu,.'l!I~ illllIIO "'"' ,.;.!.,_,..,[:HJ, Gb"".'.'Ul! l!JI!i>,"d_~ LIJ.1t:i ~LL'!U",~i:I i:liIIb!lo!l1 uU],,..!I" ,~llIi.,u~

, . _

lbei!li~wh3!t ~v dB 'hra ~~!IiI,,"/ll'.i"I~~~'~Jle m"",.,......'I[ 'i>'·I!IlJ'n"I~"'''"IIil''''',;e- -y. L.g;1I'1 "I '!I', '~"'i~·;<>[i'

~. ~ '~-'_'D'=' _. - _o~ ~~.~ =i_~ 1-' '_'_ ----' '~_l"!~'~v._!l!Ad~... ~V~ Q~ r;JI_ ~rl."~~I~- j 111..,;', ~ l lll::l_IiiI1il l _~ '!I'!"I!'IHI~_iAl!L-

~ii] themJ :rno:ml agent!! mdl'~i'a'hle ~D nto:nl :[1e3f,K'X08:iJbility. AUJtoI1,j;O:I:n.~' !b~, ,;,I 'bc.rarrWn-l' '~il w:mt 'k~lld [of m,o~ ;.~~ they ru--e .. wb~n: 50rt of mow judgJ!I}etJt is 31p:PJ10prlatle to m.,e of [hrelm" and ',..i~a!t diepee of moral re-

~Q~jbUil~ !C~ 'be' l~lti~~te1ly' ascribed, 'to dteme .

I'E lihi!!l, l!!l, is(j~ ~b~!Ii.i" ~Jt ~Mn 'be ~'k~dl' w:h:v ,M!~ ~b~' vlr05, t~M, ~~~ ,AIDS.!! _a[ll,~~'i~g' '~a5its" and :in.oof!l.~i~H~' :Silw3it:ed acti,;;\e 'mlcanos :Il~l~ ilRP:Cl!1, .eH'~' Md '~iaDl~' lu m,orni~ :r,e~po:ns:i!biHlty?] The ,anS\lf~r U 'rl1:at '~~ D¢ :I!~ot ibea!~ th~~' Me ];lot, h\!l~e, Mo,r:ali)ty is ,an ,liu_emiP~: to avoid, [evil and l'U'

l[nllJlI"",.I;O';:> ~ "'!:Io.III'_'~, ~ 1k~~W'~;I;1i1 ,tIIi~~~if"Ilo'_, '~J'i'~' ''iliY;w;~c'i!i;!'f'ii~~-~Ii'if ~iil;r, 'm'7'",~--= ~~:,,-4i ![""~~~Sl"-!I!!!'!r. !I!!i;"'~~ ~~ I~.'f ~11;!L'IIn_._iIO '""'O!~ill.,~.;I" ,Ii!!iil! ""~~!L'I~i:t.'l-" ~!I:.-::! ,1i,."ou5e mlIu,

Ibl_~" h3 rules,![ id£a1~ valJu~~ :~nim;c~p:le51' ~d, dte~rie~ ;aif-e' :ioJten4ed M ~~llll~nCt'l bWlmaf~ [(\o;ndrtlct. ,~d, ,evellJ if ;$Ome h.~_, beiin.., \Viii :not be I~fl'tl,~nced '~' them,] 'rite :in:fIJallu:(l;' 1 !!I, smn WO:I1D, ~~(l[ing ~.Ri :it. wilru ~a1pe' die' re!il,po~se~ 0:1 'o:lher:s, '~Q those 'who are :n(!t: or [catllU)l; be' af{~ot~d,

ihu, m~ I''''', :"'-,-ii'ifillo,.' __ ~'t' ~~_ [nf': ;i!".n',', ",. ',IIr.-I-~_, '_ "','-,.D;.-".' m;.'."""i;.. '1.1'-' t,i'b, '",,", i'!--fM, I, Ilm_ .. I .... 'l·n:li\jlli"'I"""".~ li,"""[ ,..:II",", ",,~~.[-.[,,~

l~l' ~~t!J ~~'!"Jl ~ ~~ ~f! ¥~ "iIY~~~ ~;;IJ "'-~,' ~_~1Id"I.r_1]1 l _1,,1, 'Ii._ ~ r"Io.! ~llu u_.~ll l _~lIJ..,~l., 1I..l~" "-'"U Uu ~ .. _~_~1Iir"

ithiniV .,.iiJ:.7.f'rt-" ,d'-Ij .. ..".""""'..,,.,- ,n:l',~~~ftt"'1""'f'_ ,gll]'.:1 1.,. .. f".IIIi ..... ;1 ~'I .. r,>!"~""'1;"!<' 'b.-~I~liI" ~iL. .. ,~, ~,~ ' ..... h~~ '.';i.''''Ii;'''I~' =-iDl 115!!!-PJJ!~- .. -Q'l!p~~ ,rr~~~r;]~l g~Ul 1!._IQI';1i:~UJ!PII_l ~Jhll~~Ii:II;.J! ~!I.l iD!I_IiQi_IIIj] ~_iI! ,I!I,V,II. nH_dj!l.,

~',""~".I[-I!·itu,' '1";tO-_ ;to_.l.rrr.-_n.i'i'i_ .... '_.~, if, -" .... ", ", ,.:1;0, __ , Tb' [: _ "" iIjIA,', ';<>"""',"" /I",'b. ~,-,' ~'.,'I~I ;'m-: ;];1"" :tlII~""'I.-"', .... ,. 'ii" - M,'~' '~"'_ .. H,_.t,t:I!f,'i.,.'1 '~i'!-['''=!I!!I!~~~"~"f dl!' ~~,r''',r =~g ~ Yv_ ,~="!.. ~ ",","~_J.I D, ~ 'J! ~!I"'-'I' .. " _GUI '""I1!)~UI.3 '8i.I,~ '""",,llIIl.u llIil.e

do:rnaiiQ. Qf"HlJ1lnd:iity gd ~O]l'h!U'mm ,q;elrn~ Me O:~I!t5i,d,e ~Jt :is :not 't~a't b~mallJ ,age:o,'ts ;~' ~tQ:nQ!m:Q-us aiI1d nQ!nhu~ Q~es ;!iIlre·:tU)~: b~,n ~b...Jait liliwm811l conducti 'C~'!' dllJ!'Htt:Y 'G:r :ind.iit-eotl-r~ be' ,.~fted by' HlQrnllilty:. 'wibere;a:s ~(1!nb!J,·' ~, ,~tiiYilties, ~~~t be"

T,ltte-.: '1Ja.u iI!mp:li,a~O:[l [u be ,co:nstde-rnd tdb3it t:;m~qEs fmlli, d]:e odti,¢i~

'M ~ l~JtilrulJ"':nO!' ~"";''0'n ~f ~'I,..,,", '~n·""_"'I· n'I"" :1""'[",., .... i'lii~~"I~~~~ [""'1""'iO)ili~;""Il_ 'h:'I~JI1-"-~!"!'

- ~ -~~ ~~iC!i"' -~~_;!bL~!I:li' '!!' ..... !'! ~"""=~ """= il-t_,,,,, r= --.,.,~-l,r ,'!Yo iOl! !Q.I~1 g~-!O!IIII '!JI~,1 "-'''-'!'UiI;.JL,,",JU .. il.!U'.1 ,'I!',,"-

ti~w ~f itIiloral imp:__~me~t w, wilicih. defe~den] of ~b:iiS] 've~on 3!J:1e oomOllliJtteti. ,If miOnd agellC)!' m~d' m~mJj :~p(ln5~hilliilty decpend, 'Gn, ~iJ;IJ~~jU)~y~~ .e~ :moml :i'mpKi'leme:ni(; 1!5, fmm, leM, l'O m:o:r[e ,8/uJtuftu.:n,-;., iI[, ,cun:5~1S :~f:iJ

• - - '. "':i ;;. "b :1.. '...,. . ~ • h' dJ

I!Ilcr<!M'LQg oonit'[1O;," over one )5, ;aotl~fai it ,'ri@'lllclil, ~~~bttg' ,(J('rl~lr is ,0 ~ ,uLo(J§ :an


adlio:r;g, :m,oFe' and :lJiInFe' W' tllC' SlOtt, ,of' ,evaill:J.atuOJl, and, un;d\emtwuilin,g :that

~r~I·'~r.I;J'a,~ 1;i!'iFiJ--'I;&)~"'_ ",U~,"'i~.h •• " ![,~, .... II;'''''''-.

C~J1sider.' o,ow' the d.lltatic~ b1sellYi!ti;Ye" and mlbleSi, .nb 'llI5e.d, ItO ~I~m nonauton,QnlOUll, '~CJ~~" '~' :h:abifl~a'fl,f ca~ m~ pM1Jly because €'holc-es, '~R fow~ on th~!' ~n",' 111, lm~bl~ :r~1" 'lb~m lO'

o r~

~u'bj,eot, thc\i:r 'cborea w' :rc:as.o:Il1ili:ble' eva)1u.allivu ,and to, uncl.entand, dlci:[' 1,1,pifican-e,e., Gi",ell the 'new' .of :m,or.al :lmpl"f.Ml:m.enlt, lhat :fO!lltowl, from th~ le,gi~mdn:1 vemo:n ,of lh'C~ :,riinciip:~ ,,:.1. '.,ese ,apillitS Olqf)lJl. to, d,o W, become :m.o:l31~l beuer ,~, to, :i!n,€R~ dt~;)r. :a:uton,o:mr bj' im.'~n,g 'th~~r ~)WI;tion m,d, 'U1IlDentandin;g'" The mQr~ '.,q' ~ d,o thii!i.; ~ i~al~r: '~n th~~' :mo~ iQ'i(pf.~me~t ~, ,~,'~~ dliat. they ;~~ gd ~~jai_ beeeme ID!~ leu dopma!tOC" insrJilLi!l:_~tive~ and, 'ru~less" ,atnd at.UJC :ttaa ,ml, than, ~ore" '1'hq' ~rt '. dleir. (tId, lNap jJ)nly' w'h~m, '.e~ is gtiC'at, ',Fe.' ~~ on, 'them, Of' when, (.l~o~¢a rMC~ 'l!bem 'W aet hmmed!late'fy' ~d, 't.ih~ iha~' :nD time f.of' mo:rafI, :Fetll~c)tign.,

N~ c."Q~tta~t ~~ :~pl~' 'wilth, 'Qd~1i€;,t, :5Cfls:lCiive" and ailtnditk ~nl$ wbfJ; ,3i1'it,jlUl, as :ItOfl«umfi1)M~ as m~iF Wiik., ,()O"~'te~ used 'PJ be. CDese ibem!iln a:g,eml~ have 'Iilbe:ir WmL~ '~ they b~~' '.em, OOM, gd, ~, ig, •• ~' tig_.ht ibenevo:1'eglt, orth.~:" they live, utte~q' een~mltii(1nra1 I~s, 11l1:¢y bar~' lii(Jt '_~n ;~u,wi~y tri~, ,(OCr ,ohd~npd~, ,~h, <]uesuuns aB, mar O(;lCiI.U· ~ d.,em aJ!"e RadUy' ,a:Jl!SWC.mdi by '~e RMd!enti 'iiW:'io.ifi<~;11 "'fi~"'''',"~I~~~: i§li:'lod'i .. t..~,.,: 'hcal;{ifimlli:u ,~"C'';iI '1f!r~..l~i""'=iL'-'I~, ,,,,,,,:,,,~, :";' ~ ,~~~~~Ili, ,nl,'!O;I\I!(IlI! , ... U!~lU'''"IJ~~~" ~I;c l'-1l'qr"~,, ~c I,~,~",T' ,an,\1 ,V'~'~'!!';~!!y ,~~ IH, ,ai, ,HlQ.I,~~.T

good! '''iGJ~ al: l~ast u far' ,35 ~ng 'l!ln;d!opnati.e~, ~nsj~,~, of al1:J'ui5tit, :~ ~Illl~~~.

1:ih L~·,~.,..;iiiu • ' • '. 'r '. ",1-. i'; 'iil'~._ f' ~:i.l., 'I '" ,.

',..;,1I1c:' ,3!~~~,1' CDooiOO~booiU'VC ,c.o;n;C~UIUJ1! !iiI.at :IUUUj[\3 imm, 'UIC "eg)I.'

:maung' 'w.tsiion, ,of Ihe' :princ~pl~ ~s' iIhat, .~, dogiiiau4 :~Ii",!(t" and, m~ le~, ,agent", who :~ve '~de ~~~ :mc;I~' a~~n(QQ,:Qi~5 and, m~ u. :p[\omd au' mmll11ty' ibe'~iI" d-mtn, [Ilt~ 'U!lld~uc~ HiJ)sl~~ ,and idtl'il.Jl!tlc; .~~ who, '~a~ not. LQ1ip1i~dJ at aliI, ~~a!use th~' bave' :renlialned l~ 'illheir :I],Oiil3llliitG;1l0molU Mate~ a 18.tate :lll, w:h!i'th" lit, ,~ihoUJd, be ,re~'~, ,ac:co:[I(i.. mg"w tbQ,ve~on m:me :~lple!, :~tb iJll~ltima. cl!ther' 10, P~' ~r w blam~ th~m" ~f' :mor.d impr~~nlt. d~mdl, jJ)n :m~~ng (tn~,!i", ~U;):n~ Om;Y:i tbe~ the ~~, ~tan.di~1 of' ag~t~, '~() ~ m~,utn--i ,tb~b:' DOOnomy ~i, bo'i.u~.d, t'O, '~ ru,lih~f' than, 'th~ :monIIJ itand.:i.n,g of: mose who mnttnlue in ,3) p~~autonQmo!i.U, state'.,

'Du, l!IllIa(:oOeptabl'e"vimv of:m~rnl imp~nt~.t,~t~~b ~"c~W, facg, One' ,Is that. ;50:me :m.oi'td ,agents, 'have 'got 11II1proved 'beC3~ 'them'

'~ .. : R .... , !M" ..... d' I '~""if ~1Ii', ;I,~~i~''''~ "i"~' 'fiQiY~ !~~~-~U' ,.a..,.;Q~Jtt ~;i"ioo'~.jllllJ' ~1i~ ~'ii'I' ,~"""~ 'ft'iI1WI' ,I,II!U iI'I"~"", ,I,~.. llll'~ _IJ........ !li',I:I,~}, ft'!E'.I,,,,,", mIlO ""iIIkI,1' 1IiJI)U',lililb 11'~'n"~,lCilUiI'l ft '!Ioo-il I, ih.~ ~,u'~E

, ,-,

~c)wa:r ~t, ~~theF is that, me' gdmlhted, hnpt~meDt ,of,~e'

ag,t~lllt5, ma~' m~~ly 'nua'R tnM1l I~ Wi(!~d, lthan, 'liill" 'W~" ud, th~ir 'I.., ~CHt :~' ~tiJlIl~a~ 'th~m, :m a :m,(():nllIy 'WO~ ~ tIgn th~ 'who, bave' :lremWned 'u:niimproved.. ,M.d, yelt, ;an,odter B, that ;a!lthql~, :inc~d


~utoO;o~' :~' l~~ '00 :i!l'l,QAl :im,~ment., b: is ~leaifly not ~uIl,{i~nit, :for it~ ~use 'thl!: [{loj'ujlfi~ .[li1ra1. is ;pilU~~d 'm.ay' be :PUJt '~O ail uses. iPe~l('! w.bo, haft lntoo~d, Ith~l!r' ;auw~Gr-tij" ~. ~Iu.s, once ,agairJilJ" aJltboti@;h rOIl" a, te.

'."''i'!io '~:::C~"''''_I~ E"""I"i;'O!io.-" ,.. ,-~ .. , ,.....,..~""' .. ·.;!II '~"'~"""_ fL-'_'_C , "'fo< ~.jIu'~',' <;., .. ,;;",-~ , .. '11:- - I~'''' ,.. .. h· ~,

I~-.I~, .uJlI1I~lI,~!,I,IJ~l ll .. ~~,1J1l ~_l-. "oI/U~~ ~1Ju.1J ~~ IDe ,1'1 .. ~,lllJlI:r !l!'!f!U!." I:K:n ~o..J,., u:t~ ft.', 0 ~

'have 'persisted :lim, dl,cir l1o;n1it,lllt:o:l!Lo.mou~ be.nigmii;ty:.

= '_' ."

If mii5 i~ a~ iIllilac-(l(f'PtaJh:I~' lili.ew of :nlurall, ;irmp~nleinlt~, t'lll;~ll, ?ib~.t i~ M

,am~pta!blfi' [o:n~? 'Th~' '1iIiD~~ilung ianswu' :is 'tb~ c;omm,0UiKiIls'ioJJ !O:u;~: momiJ :iim:p~~mrt 'O~~ !in, c~~m,g I~ ~l _d m~~ g~ • .Af!i ~.

"[ ,'" c· ".::' ;'·'I'~"""'fl·"'. "",. "n':'~i, ,',."11· .. c, ·'.·'iI',~ .... ,~''L.i··.' ,',' ,,':~ 11.."., ·it,:'!·]i,,,·,···;Oi"r'·,.[ .',' ':',",': '

C~ U], iiI;\!I~~~o;~ cU ~(h, Jreleva!lJ~!I., !Il,V ilj,ulS, prooe5!~ it. U !I., ~I, Ui ~lU!II.JtiI.er lncces--

mni" '"'".' ''''1''P' iI'·lf~.""'i"I""""".'·'~' ,ii:""'1"r 1"'" '~'t' .:;0; ,"1ii"''"!!'!IiJ''!>,\!, 'm"" '~''''jl''l'"'''' 'm'""""""III ~~m' ·'.nr~~ ......... .,..,II!' ,'m''''ti' '---',1/ ,IJ"U.,11 ~_lI],~ ~IJ_ .. ~, JI~,. !.,. JJ ... ~ IYI'-Jl.I,'I;;I "~;I ' "_ ",",,·,I.IJ~~IJ ~__:~v.J,~ ~.--t'__!.F~'~!I!I!'~~~~~~~ , __ I __ ~ __ ~:I'

iL.~, ""~-iI"""dL ·Iff,,:.i' [;o'If:.~"i"!" ",,~, ~"Ii:J.~Ii'jI!_ ""o··d' I i".' !Ii' 'm""" ~~d' I 't:;o-r. lli'i1i';-,;.<-r~ [..,.I! ...... iI;~ ....... ¥:"'d"!i<"'"[. ~ ~~_~}I!..~~. _ 'Ill l!I.~', U_jE~"'lj'" !AlIi ~ ~LI_I~.j,~ MI_ .; I . I ~ •• I :: __ R! .l~... '~I_II_II;U'tlll_, ~~~Il .:UJl.!IIiI~W}\"',lllJ.

M~~ovef;, ml;;):~ ~m~me~[t, :is! ~,o~ a relilab'[e, iQ.ditatgf' gf' :nUl'niI! ~d,-

~n·. '~:lii""i[., [[,":,:,,"'11'·; .'." ··['·,'l,·:",e'· ",". ',: .~',:,'II .... " .'j ,.' .. "', , .... ~'L.-,::.,., ,;Oi'llr .. ·_ [

~K~ ~DjJ lUte li1!U)~ Wi ,tmprmreme:n (ilI.I, some ~pn.: ,ma, mere .. " u.uilll 1.l.I1Ie:m,

il(J[ th~, l~f :~g5, Qf'dccc~qrt a ~ilJio:n. '~~t l~thC:J:1, [~py wilt.hu.~t needi~g 'W im,.rove"

It :ma¥ '~, ~Ojl.{;bldm rJb£~ 'ra~t th.~, ;CrlIiA(:I!!!_ Qf ~e le,g5iiJhtui'~r 'vernon, o.f: ~.e' :,-dfil£~pl~ is :~(jt (;~mmi~t~, '~O CUn;~llj;~:ti:aJJimlI~ d~s :lrtot. 1.m::~oBe ~tfitt 1~b:ilIitr ~F lh~' pP!~hme~t W: pe<Jpl!e 'wbo ~~n.ot help be~n;r WiCked" 31ld ~P:UI th~ 'lJrn,[~~a'hl~' id£lJiUlca:ti'Of!I, of ;mo:f'3!l, .fiq' with th~, ~apadty, foOt' :~utQnom,y~, as, wen :D[ di~' m,posid~n t.ha!t., 'mo:m iQJ(p.j\oveme~t de]Xnds, on '~C:fim~im,g :mOR' :3iJ1UnfiOmOUs.,

''Ij'Ib,,- :'~~(~"I:"~~-"'~>"C ~,",'i!. .. ~.-- ·~~·~'f···:·C.;>,~·~-,- -.-, ;'C . .ll~ ~.ll ... e . .. '~". ~i'~"I,'~'·~ ",' ';'- [ .. 'i!.'.~, Ii,U~ :Imp. !l~allG]]' 'U'..I lU.le~ ~fiIi~{,lsm~ ,83 ,11J;u~~u (h. UlliC ~~imlt. !In Ul~13

~d, '!:be :,~~ftg ~h~,tet;i :~ that lilbeRlliism ~n~~ 'be' oo~sist~Q[tl(y c'{tm·'

'mllir"'~ ~"'i", iJt ... [ 'm:~f;i. ' .• ' ",~ ~·~~'1: [', , ,"~ 'II .• ': .' 1_ '~."iI' ,i ,,~ ~'I iiil!:<"[ ", "i~" '~' = ..:"",'!;,!I!, """'" ~"'" ,~~_~_¥e wm, 0:1l ~lil1lW;.!lng evilili Less prevaIL'eill.!I., an,'!IJ, d) W!1i3 tpM'lu,ye:

tim, of ~nC!f~ili,g al!l!~O'n,()m.¥ 'by InljplerneniliJn,g me' ba8b;: mu'e~ ~d :pOl~ti·, w p~, oflr~raJ!ism. lr:Ul~s"a,1~mpl 'W :rem..ove' dl!~ inoonsislltnq ~' iI~Mndonln,g :auJlI}Jlj@Jn}" as, ,th~ OOu' [Oof n_m!liMm~ m,~n, ~ey :mUI~i!iit :f~~

- - - -

dte q~ue~~(lTI, [of wh,y J'~~~sm! :~~dO'Jlih, Jti~'h~ cq!ll~[ijty'" and dLutrlltnJ/tii,¥e

~Wi.lJtroe are Itn be 're~Tde.d, e 'th;e 'baSic vabl.e5 beeaase 'tt.i~ '~~.o:1D m~~' .

.J.-.-~-.-. __ I. _- .. _ .. "i~_l -" ... _ --_ .. __ . _ .. _--- 1 .. _ -!II ._ .. -._-_.,. F"'] .l ..... _ .... [[~

iIlilat tlIi)~~; H-e~:~- - nJtlail1 i~-[ ,- .,~ ~nC, " ;-- :.,~ '(I; I" C" " 'k, 'Il.:l~,. l:li"t-" . '1f:.,~~~dC: '.' :' , ~~~~ ~~CJ~~' ~ egCL~_ toO ail!l[n::LD;m}?~, ~~O ~o;lllCll' U,oLUO. "'Uili¥ ,5.IJlIOW not,

pe~j [Md.1N~ l~bi, •• ~" :p~rT.itf~ II, h~~'~I1rli1mnm~,'t" ~Ci~flj~~1

: u "d'-I ib. ","[ [ .', '~~, ' .. ', ~~~·:~rjiliu'. OIL,. :~Jl '~] '1'1:' ",',,' 1" ... ·:' ,", . :11; .. :' , jI,.' ", ··dl .'! " ',' ..... "', ',",

all. _ ~~a"p1Deu ~ as Ib.ul~~,l WIWliJl1.I,e., ,!I", 011 tille !l'hLe:r uiain· " an~n;ltomy

oo:mti!n,tI~i5, rt'Ol 'be b-cld, a51 ,th~ OO~' ~r 1bG'r.:.i4J~!!lmi :mm ~ Iq;ue!!l~g:n, ~!!il' b~

~iif:.",:m.!Ii)ll;11I1Io ,"'~1IfI1 '"~nJt- '·;IIr .... ,n'rI .... ~I'I"'"iI1'> ... ."., ~f [...ftru~ 'W,";:~p'I'.'ifng ''";-r.tp, 'at:"I","'itL~P' ;""~:.!Ii"l""~, ~-~~, ~~~, ~~,~ ,r~·!!r.'~~~~l', y~._ ,~~ ~~~~~~~~ ~~ ~'!'tII~~ _'. Viii ._~_ • .:_.~ ll}~'.l ;~. ·_Ml~-ill H~J~I!o"---

0.nlly can'll0t 'M' ,th~ D~f" :far jlt Will gI~ :~3'teF K:-O~ lu, both alillmn~' m~ and fi:Qna'!ltofiii1)m.o~ mJ," :[t W:il~ do, illh.c:' :f~~ef' '~c.a~ p.c:iUet :aU,·' wnom,1,!' '~I (i;cer' 'Ri~n 'm n~l'iLo:m~, 'wi~bdll~M· And 'ft 'will dio [h~

..... ~ .. -_'JJ 1!CIj;r.!"!·'_··, ._l. 1 .. ~_l ... _ ... _ ..... J .. 1 __ .. __ . ~ lr._.· .•. __ . __ P., ,.~ .•• l __ ._-. __ .•

iI.i'">ft··" .... r 'I!:-:- .. """".!._, 'I·'t ~i"!"",.,...JI~~~, ~'I,.."!O- ... ",,~~-~ ..... .t'~t,.. ..... , '~~ ......... -:-:'~ty :'i"'~'[~~:~11 'f'~--:' ~;;I'--'~"f"I'. 1I1111O .. ~ 1lI"II!i""",,~. L, "~,,."'!"VJ,~OiIi 1!l[1~ !(I,,,,,,~,,iIliIlI, U1: ~,"'" ,~''''''I!I~XlVil~1 ..,.1: ~I ![Ql' ",,:Q:~\iI~n-

om.@w, 'wi'cll:iedoe8$~, ~hich plia)t'es, i~ ;age~~ '~~d, mom! relf'O~:d'biILi'ty'

"I!I[Ii'd·1 ,;o:~,u .. , '~Im'~": I""~ ~.'_.4i', il·'m,· 'i~":':" :.; i [~', "'i"':"r'b., ..... ""[. ''':''~I''''I''',""",'''', -!I~:''''ii'. L~ "'?Iy-." ifiEIi ... ·y'-

_~. _ U!I!_ ~'"",,,. ~ ,'!o:l!',!!,""'~ "'" !I'_~",I!..QI, , ... , . . .... , II '!O..U', ~. 1V •• i.1 UI ........ , !Io.<"-"" .... ~J'I!II....... ,.1.11 0.", 'l!'!l'H

,_; .J .:

iO..f' ~jd)ing clh~se ,Qt<J.Fa1ty Ui1UK~~pt.abI:c' (cQn~iuenc:es, ~, (to ~m:pote :R'sttj~·,



"."",A~ ~ 11"'1 ~ ~ ~ ~'i. ~ ~~, 'i.",~~ ~ .... t, ~~ t....'I~t....~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ c~ i''','''r. "~, J,'W.P\iro.!U p_~lu».ep~i~~' ~q"V!Ii' om:~ !.'!.!_~~ a ![l,~ m 'y~. ~

qr.:riri,e! '" .. dliffer.elu; fl'0m, Iii at of ~e ,amci'eflJU!" :In ~ln-er ili1E;e5 " • '", :p'MIOMf'he~, s a a '~~t :~e~Jr h~dJ '00' [~~di"'B]1 .' " ,', ~~" and, :~n~ tb.-e lrbllndlauon, ;Qf' tb~T 'wh~ M~0Jf" " " '" [B.]"In, 'lihi!~ iJ~ me !mean _~, lllllu.st '., ~!' 'that: ~~: ::lfe' e.Ye1J day H~~, ofbbme' and! :pra'isce" 'w:h!w:b, bM\e I~l!ie!&b, ~lldJ 'Oll:' '~nilon .of 'Mill, and 'Cibo:ic:e'~, :a:nrl. .of. w;h,kh h, be:btJ,Vi":!, 'WI,. " u '~~ ~~ ~~Qry ~~,an~ ~i~tlQ~t!,

""""ii), j;'!I.I'I'fII', '~I'I'IilIIE' .JJ ... ,lIi':mJii.·n ~~~ij! ,~:L,"" Pnti~ ... foP ,U",,--,-,"iI'''i'

U.Ii!"ltl·w 1~_!I ,OJ ~~ L. llftli!'-l!ll£iJ!·"'~'rr.u;.JrI· 1!Il'~~r- !!I"~I-~I ~ l e- -.-,-!ly~ ~ lrJ':J;~~

Cou~~ :r~fis~b:iUily :i~ ~Fi~d, ItQ :reo.ple' foOt', ,acfiDfii~ mer

'i;,C",', ~ i 1 ";'i"',""~ 1 ',,' ",..Ii:", ,,(' ~,~ , 1 ',':' 'b', . 'd'~1 ',,': 'I iI": ol ,':,' ','~ I.' Th:;-C'~,', i' ";~ '"I ~~~, ':ft:: i U.\iI,""t:: n,~~~!I~F ,pe;I" .. :o:rnl~!!IJI, nor: .3 COl~Jl[i'J! ,orer.. "'. e :5IWP~"'!I'J'Wl!liilI;lcaw,oJll

for ~15 ~nptli(jul is, t!i'lat :indMd~9, 3IR naihL~' 1m acHOcttl :~r!o:rrmEd by Othl@[' M~Iil1"Mr5 [of ~ otrOllf'i;, t~, whiClh th~ ~lGll«,' Oll~' wtYu'ld ~;ne:ct 'tiibc~:~·

__ ., ---. --_ •.•• ,. - _l~r-' ---r" "._--._l"-r.&I',I'-·· ··'-~rr. [_r •••••• __ r.l~.~. ,_l_- 1

m, ro, ~ ;OIlU~~' :~m;~~bil~ty :~ p!l:thelil[nJ,~ bQ't ,th~ 'u 'by :fiO; :Jn~"~

L, '1;,11' '1'·L_.~it ., '" t II_~, 'Il. ~-ilil .. 'L !l..,~ d b

'tn~ ,t~" .na~' li[~I:'W~' nhili'i~I~' 'C_illUJ' 'to l'itlJU ~!i(!i:m~\Ii~!!![ ,aill !Ot;~"'

. _ . ..- __ -_ !Ill l I_':_ __ ... ,.. ,: I_. 1 __ . ~~~ •. lJ: :_ •.• . .. l_ I. __ _ _. -_ .. ,-. I. 1 .. __ ~." .

~allee~1y 'res,r>n~bl~ :fOF ~tW:m;s, ~"c(lfdld, not ~, :perCQnn~d 'o:r ~Q:~'" 'h"OU,cd, 'OOcaiUR [they 'took, ,lace Ions 'kmre' '.~ were 'born. SUCh is, ~he '~~fiji,A, .. , (,;j.' Am'; ,::c.~': ~i~~·,~-,;il .. ~ ....... -~~ naH ,A;"ccl!m]n~'t:'On ,~ , ~;iHi: b]-,c'u :a!~~~~ o~, ,~~~eJlCiil1Il [!iJ!~~ ~ [~'Y,~~..... ~ Y!1iSCI_~~iiI~ ~~~ ap.I! ~~ ~ ,~~~~_

and, ~m,ce!ll, 'm :~~e o~~ ~ple amonG' ~)\", Mlaltl]~ ~~berail! po'lJjdC';s" ~ong 'd.i~ffl :antJ~Fltf _iii ,~,~ ()p.~rtunilt:¥ ~~,~ q;Ufiw foT' aeade-k admiuin~, _d buiJ1tes.s, ~DD!~b~, iQ:r~~p ,aid, to ~nt:e' OOllllQ1trie!il~, 'i!I!i~ f~8l!Jilrt!l!tiQ:m, ,of·we.MtQh~ and! dtoe 'pu.[el"elliciial i)!f~~tm.:enlt, w: blaet, ,_..d

!tiI\iI"io'm. , ',,""1"" ""Ii"oi'!' 'm.".j~",",~'oiI>dl ~' 1"":'1" .... , "i"", ... i,t, :"" e "I"'.iI>p~,...f.rH""'" ...... ~ , ... ,~]I_~~~, """"~~,,,,:;;ifr.:'I'iii,fv.'~ HV, __ I'!Iii!IUI~ !II_II ~ l __ rVyy."G.M:i'- _ lU,!' IUlbb ~_I!'l ~-b'b _' ~_.ilr~-1Ii,;. ~I. !I..i-U, ~I~ ...... y.~ .. !!IIr.-lI.!r~Jlll-"'W, _1I_.~1'.

TIi.e' :~ritti~(iJ Q"'c6111~otNe r~~~Jbi{liiIF'!, h~rl[ ~$, inC'Qn$"'~,lt, 'wi~, 'th.e [oentral Ii:~ral ~u~r tb~t ~pl~ :s'hOliJl<l, be :h:~I;d, RspcmMbl~' fOr o:n1,' '.~irt ,~ :autnno:rn~ ,~tit)ns., ''Thc: ~tiQD'~' fQr 'W;hi~h. Qlf.:-'Il~Q _ :a

~'-fi ",._ ".~n~=~'..:1 ,i;~ '~IL"",~- "" -'Iil"'",,';h~~-' '_-~WIi;~~t..~IL~fir j."'=~11 ~,'L ... "'~=_,-iI ..... .,... ~~~u.,t": .... '!.:> onJI,r,r'[":KAIi dJ iUI .• R lIjiD,1! ,~~u,ve ,~ .... St.uuSIiUlf.I~;,., 61LUi UI,~' !U'~,'!IA111;1,

i9

,

,


,('II~U· "'L·r 'k .... I .• 'I "'i:...~A r d· "'d("'·

'~~e.otllve re!!l!,pofl~!~h~'ru,' '(;aI]; ~ ~.Iitl'marl:e,,;y ~_y!, to' !I.(I;·.~.,\!I'!ur'

~,'~I~ ~~, ti'~"", ~~ji~~iE, ~~ ,;i?;>"iIi:'~r' '~""'~l'~~~ ~~ ,,:,,~, "' .. ~.,'.fM: II:.~ !UI'h: ~""h'.' .: ... .!!O ~."...;I:i~d: I.!~ ~ &uI' IL_ltl ..... !lD..ut'~U,IJ_II_il! ulL ~UI~ ,1I .. 'L~~_.I.iI.~II,~ v.I. ~LI[~ .-IJ vUl!i_' I.U ft.! __ ~ .... __ 1 U~l~ ~II_IIUIJY.~_ ~

~:il-, "'":"'II~.,.Q' [(.~if .... l'.,..~"' '~;ej;~f:W"" ~"!"'d· I '~.:~ ... , :!'];'n~ '9'-~...,."":r:o '~~'I 'iiI. :lI'!I·I~~'ir' '1J!II'O~~IlN:, ~ tR;LU.11;~1 . ~&"_LLIIJ.K:.!I)! tl. ~ lUll --.J_. RJ;.d~ ~::IUl [0.0;0 ... : ....... ,.. l~'~l 11lr. ~.11, [!). ... ,.~M:~

~ay '~, 'n~Ii:(Jl!i~ ~w.~,! f~gj~, :mtiif»'OOIll~ p~Mi:Q~~ ~d, ~, foftih" '1I[be :fint. ~p 'In [th~ ~~n)t. f·nl:' [tll~ i.qi:tiimaq' of: ,c:o:ncc.d,~ r'~,p~UI5fbil~ "Hi ,"~ m ~.~ ~~'~d~~ ~~~~,~ ii'i~~la!ti~~~ examnl~~ Th"~ w:iJl1 'be ':oll~~"~~d ~'~ ~~ .. ~ ~~. ~~:,. ,Ii!!i,~::' !o~II~~ef iKl!ID'C' IrU~~~~~VC:'.:.::.~.-'~'~:~~i!iI .. ,_,,~'.J~.,.,,~l~~, ~ ~,'.~ ~ ~~~c. l~ ,Ii, m~

.. ,'i'li;lui~ ..... _;11 '~~--1" • . ,,' "f 0:,'1..." ,'nd' ii;tii.' ... , fi'·· "i- 1 .. ,·'if,~W"'~-';> , . , .. "' " ti, 'JiI~ '. - ..... :.,1;.,

:Emi.,_1 ~ ~lilUrol1i ~~ !Y:!.e €.'Q~.~ .. ~~lQ'fl_S ~Ql ",!1,0;!1 ,,"e,IP~-~-~ aK.n'~Q~ W,.,IJ.Cn

may IllF ~ 'H1!)'t vmilbre' lhoe Pf~lU e~,le~, :It :~ a '~'bi!JwtQml '~,~ri-' eaee ~~g MCtncan :lbeWs to :Feel [~~jble fm n,dal aAd ,KXJ'la'l diKmmiJ'lJiUli.t)'n., N'u_mao:u catholia [eel, 6~. aibo'lilt du~ Chu.r;c'h,",~ dtl·,

~'.':iI""i' ~""",:,,-,:",,,- . ..:I' ,C, ......... liIi~ .. ~n.i:"'4" \.i"1"~ ".;~~.,.i",,""1". A,'·,"" jDill~iI'.,I~'1;'>1 ~'~'i"I,"'; __ , .... ,~' ,iI':""",'11 '.dl .. .Ii.lI.... 'lU¥r"4ilU .....,I!I!!II.I .. 'I.I ... r~JJ.' !IIIIOIdll, _M.J: .. ,'U'U .. ~" , !a,............... iIr·~,l,~nl!iU!l,.Laol, •• NIo;i!' ,m~1i

il. ,iOOu1. his ~DI~~~j" ~g' 'coluded iQ the in~1iog of pdJti~ di.u'id~nllS :iD psyc;'hihlW~ h.OI,p:LtaJls., blidliAns, ma, :U~ dl~ fsa.m.e :~~lling' ,aoo-~t 'iJ~e r«~iBt religiu:gjl mil&\a(fel in Ilhek ,tQ~nrb1" Am.~, phyai·, cjD.1, :may 'fft~ :iJt( a;bouJt ,th~ rrampan,!t (lomnt~ui.alilm, 'M ~~lr pmf:~Ml0:n" An~ .. 1;.-, o'io... .............. ;i~..".. 'Iln;;]d.s. '~'Iii'1e: o.iiten ,take, nride 'lD '~e' K'tIi~~mu

~c~'-""", y;~ ..:..~~IlI;!I;-"'~ ,~'-.~.'.._~, ='':''-F~':'" '~~)~c:c~1 ~.'_~~" lF~'~·'-.·'_ ,~~~ ,~~.~~ '~~~"~~.:.",.'.,:,c~~"~,-.~

'M 'mhei.r.r" (;~Itry" ~~, :biigh lta.n~, m: 'thl!lf :pmfem.on" th~, :rrrrpu:taIli<!ko of' the t~fa~(>n for .hith '~q" wo;fk" Ilt-u~' wiling:qUl of 'tileiw :p'lidtal p~' tol de:[~ltd, jmtm!:" or tb@' :n,'umoo' ,of Nooo'l PriH~ Win.o,;en at. ~eir ~Il~mlty,!,

Sm;l~ 'e'LJC;,~[l~ ,Hie (Jo:mIDQn and, :s·~ the f~' dial die q;cg~


~- ~-,. "'-'"1'-';'"

',:l',,·',-' " .1 ""'" _,-I

_ . -,.- .\. - . .- ,', ._,.:

., -

Who .aikntwliLlM,p th~ir' f(,';5pfinMb:iU~' do so 'on aeeeuat 'of ac.ti(!U~ dl_q bave' :not. :peri'o:rooed, OF oo~trd]~oo, I~ ~.y (a,.~~S{, itle~ ;ag~n!lS oould ha~ d,o:ne ll'lothims ~, :maib=.: thee.: ,actiOD_$ ka:ppen [QI" IW swp them. :H-QJD h.cappe-1lF

:'--.-;-:- ''I~ •• , ,~,\.,~, ,;t",. .. 'I' .. ',.· ... 1. i"'L._~ ! .. _i.o['i;~';O; "'''1"m' ",,'ii.,~, ,~n~ .. ~, 0'" ,",'~. __ ;,p, ~''''''"''r'ii .. , .... .,.-1"--::1 :tI1lg!' ,!I""'!!;, t!liI.-.;",,., ,~\;;'I;;i~ ~~~., [-'Uliii ~""'''''''Ii~i;!I' ~ - - "",lih;!'" ,L'!Ii.i,U!IYI'I.!Ii. u.~ Uih •• ,u, ~~iI.--U\I,'iIIiI. ,;JYU.I,{if."

:ing'i an,d, 10 lhcy a-c--o¢,pt ~mc' me4U!!.ILI'C .of' bilimte or P~' ,a1Ild dlw W(ii~,

,-:;~:-.nt:l_;:---;;--';l·)·'I!~'ffi,_"~" ", :'L i--M", LTl';~;o;, ,..11". "",.,,;II~ ;o;,ipi·roi .• '1;-''''PiI!V!'D' ~~",'~"" :"!i' ~i;L.-":,,~;1 ""_"''1I11R'II1r.i-,icn.TIi '~,F-~DSlJU]ULi' ,li~I,.J!., IUl~-.I,lIli. Jj. l_lIlI_i:I! ~~b ......... _lUl .1_I1I~ll .I,j_~, 'r~ _ 1 lI_IL U]I~ 1.11l,1li;1 III] ~~--,r'~¥'~~

'were' true '~~t r~;po~Jbm~ (:.lI.Illd be ~"ltim3it~lf 3Kf:'iibGd 'O:Ii1'lr ror- :a1.U.'OIF' Q:mo~ ~l!Ig.:ti~ ~ [1Jl;~ ~nb 'liiav@ '~:o:rm.~, and had some con.Im]]

[~F,

T,hel'e g, ai, ~U~five ~ai,Qgy hen: '~., '6e ~a~ gONefl1;htg' !inib.eri~c:e'., J~t M reciipi'C:ll'l!i, [o£:a beq~~"t !tll';hmt 'ootb, :p~nr' gdJ ~¢ [dainu, :again,t 'liL" :50 the ,p~se-;fJ't memjbe~, ,of a, :gro~p :inb.-e-rit me' :JDt):~ (~diu., ,~d d~b~t.s, ,iil«ru.Gdi WI the Qjr['Oup -, Thi"'V [CaJtl'11I0:t. bdl@11;Q"to'the(lUi.,u;pland1f[eiect,its,

. -._ ._- -" .-. --_. ~.I .. -~,~ . ···-,f ... ----~ ... -. -. =-~ _- .. - __ . "P~·-l.· .-~-.- ~.~ .. - .. --

g],~ra1J :mcold., T~, havc' ,co~ittcd.lllhc~~ ~Qwl~ dlJat dley f~m. fe8pQll;;

, .. ilh~" ~or··· ,,",'If-'"'" 'Q!!I"flUp. ,iii,,., IP,·_'llii':l'}'lIit-ilA.'F;' ,oiji.'f· '"1- '"7"]II;~""- "JI"'Ii.;"I"" :O-!lLnnTli",,~I!---"I~~frv_ iIr-~_

rjJI_1J _- .-.l.1Ii..> Ioti- . lLIJ_L:1j;· 'D~"~;"_: !ill! .1~dI_II6MY·~_".~I. U"L' l~!Ifil! l"tidilJ~k'!il!p. [I. ,I~I __ 'ill !II ~-!lP.r-~I::I-irLMIU, JI_~}Ir!1 ~J 1~1rv.l!1'l~·!I"!~i:'_]~

:l$, ~d~' ~, fJh~il' [~, :~d.~m~ It :in('II;KiI~s, rl~pons~~bi'l!i!lf :fI;ifr ~~, :3.flUOO!!l, of otb,eg, over.' 'wbl\cl~ t!heY' have' no OOgb'ot

This lirfl;~ of ~110'1LLI'bit l~w tol :3. d!n~nnlila fhr liiKraIJs~ [~iJt'ller 'they must. ,abalndon. ,tht:ilf caI!~ to, th~ PH-sen,t. pn:enllln-n, '00 ,a-c~e_,t, r~po:n$:ilb~tity f(>'i'


:sU!~~, 'n31~t ~'iri)~ ;such _, ~da1 and, ~xu:a~ djS(;limin~.{!b;;.n~, Qf ~.~ mrtm,

llrr._,""'''''' llr' ~ "'= l'

a!bari,d,u:n Im.~ Mili.tt dmt r~H.iihmJly at~b~iS on~f 11.'0 r8it.unRO'Di¥'U$ ~

tions '''~''"ft' ,i .. , 'it,"1i: """'~;:;""'","';'; :":"'_.,...,.;: ~;I;.J:I!' ,au~'i\;o; 'I;,......~ ~;I;.i!!'m_.;l~' irN·fif~~;oo...:J1 ~if"''''1 U'll!'.1_ ,"'J Uilol, ,~~ lkl!' IIlIb!ll!l ..... , .. ..., Ui_L U;l~ ~'IEi ... I,.., ,[liiIIf!II'!Ei ",,[l'lEi '""1J: .... ,~ r..,.,II,U,J~ ~~~.~ ~~Yi,

'l.""jIj ~I~ 'Il=_~cc'" ~~-'''~ "~""i~""I'--~~ Tb.- £.~--.-- =. ~--~d'i "JI=-'-'-~~ ~-~-'-- '~"'ib,=~~'1 IIJ'iMlI, "'l, ,K.t5!1o ,5.0:m£ (lo;[i,lIoiiQ, I ~., ,I, ,lilJe 1,'0,1 ,liter W~iI . 'U'!Ilipn,'V1t'i :mit'nl)" 111~iliiI

:,{d~licall, :p:~, of' t1b~~F ji~llt~cartiQn~,! 'wbereu the 13!ttef' w<:H.dtIJ illivalJIdaJ~' IOO,t';' ,of tbe pootaJ as511tnp~fjU]~ un 'wh~c'b, ilh,~' :,~s, :ro:st.

Th~' !liU!uI~ ~ase fot:' (;O;u~~, ra~I'i!S'iJb:~Hlty mlH.S :mamy ~,ue,""

.;:; ..... 11,·,;0;' 'I"i;;= ;,...il~ IV". l,",,'~"p;o;, :'1"h.'"1"f,·k, ~~I~.~'1",!,' ,_;o;po, .• ,iI;]i';o;.;~::;lli,t7f .... "1"'1"1 ~:I;,'~'r' ~"""M"I!o-'"'::-')'

1IiI,I;U, _~. .UU Id.:II .. UUil ~'U""_1I "-'F". ~J,l'Lc~U'!f.~ ,10 ~- ...... _lIJj::lIJUJIJ ... of, IU",IJ,IJ IU~l~;,J, MlMI.~:JILllI~I,r3 •

. -'.' . .i·" - -

How' ,~U'oui!f. ;au,d, bt.J\!W' lutiu~ ;an. ;aU~,h.utc'e i~, r~l1jl[l[trlm, :f'ar €(fll~t1~, re-

~I - -- -~l - - - ~~-- - ,

,Sl;V:iollsl~il~~\';i' \i'Vhiat dioos, th.~, ac.mntulC'tl: o:f (;1)ILocnw' r-l"Wll.'5ibiUbt obl1~

r~l - - - - .. - - ~I". ..,' - - ~ - _. _... ... 'r . -;] .. .. - . .. .. .. .~~._,' - - - - - )"1 . l '~l~

,age~:t5 W' do?' Malt iSI the liia!bi1ilty 'thall, c-'O'leotive I1~FE&ibiil:it¥ ICre:aJt:e,'? Hn.W' c~ le,giiti~oo a1H:d ~lle,giti~ ~riptio:~ [of c:oUecdve r.e~~~bijIliJty bE- djjstiJn,gurim~d)~' Th~ Wne bas, c-ome Ill{} 'CfiMid~F ~.e:se q~ti(),fli!I.

The c:()mdiiiti.nns. fOT' dt~ ,~riIpti.Dn. of c:ollI~otJ've re~fi~bil~" ~t. have

~ '''''11'' ""Di'-I'IQ'._.:II ""f"",,,~ Iilr-lI"'Et. #zl!I'!Ii'IIlfC' ,~,I:.,~i~ ~-rn"J.. '1(i'!C""i'M2CnU~ r/M, ... ~'_~ , •. ii..~.,_ ~ I_Moll. ~IUI_.~.i~~ !IiIII_.l·~ •• 11.1I!il!. _II' "l'.'l!ll-....... [iIi_I!1I:. l,K1(iI;'l ~1[iN+;1 l.L~~I!~~ Juv. ~"~HL;.I!~1 ~

~.'iif momf pmiu fW ~ ~lIW.d~ t1M, ~~ 'Dril1Mt,pmJ~[ mti'W ,~~ (lM"' du ;tif.annanu ~ ,tJitIj [amom fm whim, ~~ ,art ,h,tld' ~.; w;i[\d~, r1w' ~ '~.~ "I ()I1;er' ,~b: • ,~ (It,~,~ IrAe

...... _'"' _.Iii ... 'r! ~,1. _ .n ....... '.·", , .. - .. 1. ._, ........... 1. _iIi_j ,_~[~.Ii.",'~" ,.;;on...i ,1"..;._,_, ...... ,'-, ,;111.. __ ,;Ii." j' ~,_'" ~.....::. ~Irl..:..-KI ~ [~~~~,~ WlW g_l!lOi' na:a .'~rY! .. '.J...~'~ D.IJ_lIU. ,1J,IuIUlI:-l!!.I_lJ1~· ~ ~...;._D ~,

'~'HMli\1hIi m.. .l:.~ [..,.~ __ of' J~[~ •. iL~ [..II:~-- ~,j\iI.~ .... , W'i"'"\' ,~=J.~JI;~ ~'iIi', .,"'~ I! ~!IE"!fiII!""""'~1'j . .j!lll!' IN;W !I.i.t/H!v.Li..... ~. ~,i) tK'J.-Il~1 ./lr-l~'_"_.1 ,,~~ _J_r.-r,a ~'~_'~ iIl~,1i IIIie'

.f4~' grwp.,

.It m.il(y be ("~~k.d that :eve.HJ if 'tihe ~riplio-n, ,00f,ct)'III.eo1ive r.~pombi1!iJty h.as ~mE' ill:tlllttive :,I8:'~lh~lilty i!f iJh.e; loou-iP ~s, a, :[1jati.ofIJ~ CiU~J!JU~',~ :~Li,_O:fi~,

·1 (., 'it-~iI"!;1 '1Ii~" ," r . ",' , '" :. t': .: .• , '.' J .'. :';.", .: " ·;drl ',~~':"; , ;" 'If:o, "·,f ~!"'.". "., :. """ ::',:f . ", 'It-,. :: . : ", '1'1""-,.

~1il'Sw~Uh"lo;ll.~, or ,proJ'f::sss;o\n~ ~"Irapt .. ,r !!JIrmlnili§ue51 , W;I,e g)[aup !~ a iCiILfi'SS e !l!IiU~,

~e' ,,w!C~~~ :iLq a ChatlJie' ICh:ip:Ug :~k:..;aili!k:e c;O'~reS\ Of the' :re.-ed,

'~:f:I~I=: '~1!r'~-,,, ' .... ,.,..,+ mB:lt"t-~'im'-'" , .. ~. ii:''"f'~-'''iji;;,j\'I~'!rE:_ ~ .... ,.-.11il"'" ["'0 .... : "it.. .... ,d·~~"'ifoiii!ii'ji;~, I"" _, .-. ~.Uiji: -~~lI,.'!U!'! !ll'!'v.~ljJAiJ r--=-=-' '""~- - - ~ H~J i"~_L'-'!UI._IIJH'_ r'tlll~' I~J ~I~I~ ...,_I!UI!Ii.'J"'!I.l. W~IXoJ _D.1J,.'!.:r_1I ~-II_II~

'~~~n th.~ 'tMro, ~~ of gmlll!l?S is to ~ :f'B'lDl,d :~11 C:o:nCliQti.~ r~po:lllilb:mty

'~.~!I!, II',·: j '1":1' [~.~" '~'I~' :I!., '," 11".:' j : !'~~J·~:'fWII~.:_.. - .. -~-~ .. -:., .-" :,[':.' , .: ,", c', "1', r 1 l'l~' "::"~["~-r _"'.j ,'~.~~~ I"', / I·_·~·~·~ ~11n,g Imo:m'I,. ,iI,l, IS ,responSiJ~J:II~"'l ,1,O,1i ac~,o.ll'! en a.cOOWillh 0,11, Illll:e:llr ~~n,H: ,g'!J!'UU,

~i;1 ''Eli ""s.k" . f' "" "" ,;, e Wdl ted 'th

'or' "":,~, ~~e' C'XlI_I .. ~C'C" o~ ;so;me ,lP'QuprJ [1_:5,:5SeJ]'_':~y [omnc.,€l. WlLLI mal"-

:~~. ~pmc~t ~~tj~~, wh~f~-{q dl~ at;;~rti.~9, of Q'tb~F :goo.~~ ,atq,~~~' :nlo.~ ,~lpr~fii~m~' (J;lJilf' ~~oldenrtailly'~, :i{,art all" 'n.~ fi~t, ,1ifi),uP' 'wiJ'U, be 'cd"d,

",0 w ." d th d' ,0. 'I .... 'fig'.' ...~ raJ g' .

... ·m,·,·'"'1II·,; ." :iIIoi"'i""., "',";0;. ,"_'~":",.'. ·"~"!"n. , ..... -"I:"'"[.~" : .: , .... ' i""i'"i"'nif'\"i1,....~,~: I I"" ''M";i'"foi"\ .·.il?l";o;o:o",

l __ ~ I 1!i itIiI~_lI. I. _ IIi:r ~'L!-~I,,-I..J 1IiIII~. __ I::I::.,.V.,IJ,~ __ r.. n' "-.LIJ_"r·~1J 11.G.lJ_~'II.. _ ~ 11_1I11.u.'!. , .1I11"_1Ii:r.1~"

sio~ is ['Or dI~' Idie'Jl'tii~' af:a '~U1~ deeends Ion how d,()5i@I~' du~ aCMwri~ 'M

• _. , , .• t.· _c. -. _l ~:". , [~.,,_ .. r .. ~'i_' ••• _J .; •• - •• _ •••••• ,. _. _ I ., .. __ -_, .

'"':"r'"'i!' Q~'1~.'p': ,,,"J._ , ... >rio.Anl ....... t,"",d·j 'M"iil... hiIJ~""""";IJIo ~ir.~I!!0!"~ ~;"' ....... ~~nD!' ,iil~n'O;>il'll; ~ .. , ='~~~.;._'1~,

!LiI1-,. ~.~~.,. ~~ ~-~ ~~~._. ,~~_u~.J _~!I.i!II!_~ ~!I!_ "~_WJ·~!! ~~~~-L~' ~~-_~~ ~_Ii! 'UtUY,ll~uml~.

regn:il.~~ed,~ :iIm it. !i&ng' lOb !l!pJiln, l$, :not. ,iHt.)w' ¢;~~ tile m()raiI, d'iim~nsi.:gn. 1$1,

'''",: ~:~~ ,"" ...... ~.l!iJ~i~i<': IA£" ""I IV' I : ..... ~··Pl ,i!l" '''!i't'iI;''''":"f''1 ."'''!i'''', ·'t"i"""'~~~;I. The "" • .....i,p,iti.oro~ :=:-£' ~n~

!I!.U!'! IUl~ IIM.oJU'1!·IIIU,~~!U" 0. .'UU. ,Ia ~-1t.EIJ_1j !LI-U'-.I;.IU-V.~".""iIiIJ.I_. . _ ~ IIIJ.":I!IIi.:I.I,,1,J . U-UIUI U-.l ~r'UJIJ.

. _

...::.... , II

dive' !r-espo:DS:ilti'li~ g, d~e~ ;al.80 !(lon.~~3lI,. :Out ~u~b OOIllI~~~ p::r~'

:$UtP~' 'dlrat. ~i)$ ~ripi)!io:n, ~s' ~egi!lirma'i1e in prinCiiP~ ,aJ],d foclL1 '00, :~u., I~ti-


'~Q' ,',_;J

~ i[!l, :a :partic;W!\!f;' ¢-~" 'Th~5' ~l)I,~$ts, ttt~, :M'dl. [oan,d:i,~nll:!, :ncam:~l~'~ Iilhart i&,~1 te :roh~'m ,tJtj~' ~ is ~

Erven .I)~, if:Oups~, :ht~i\ :u-e [~ngapd ~iliJ ai, ''Wide' ~~ty-, of di5~

"""'~:;.'~""Ii:i .... "" C"1''l"i'''~, ,~£' ''':~'~m.·' ,""rl~ "i"'I,..,;-O-i':""""'~~~!"1Ii""" ,~£ '''i';"" ii!rt't., '?""I'iI'II. "',!"..:il """"'0!'a0!. -m'l ''''"''1t', iSL!II.!.I.L'Ir.I;:U-~_~1 !iM.l1J_IJL~ OI lEl~'a __ . 0.., ~ ~I~~~.""'~~ ll_3'-1I.!.I"'-' (0- 11111'-1" ~.l U!VIr.~ !PII_.llfU ~"l.gi~~ __ ~.ll I

,. ~~. "... of"C'i1l'~I.· .. ~ FI~' . ·tn·,~· . ~. ~ ~. ~ '" . ~~'.~'" . ~ . ~ ~N"C'~~' ~m1_",'L _r.I_ ~ ~ 'Ul,,'L ~ --

. " . ,-" . _' ',,' ',' .. , - " .' - "',''!l I····· I,' I -,·'i,r I [,," I," .••••.•• .'" _ - ,';. : I I c·_= '_.'

11m, Ic_;~ ~I~I~ g"pan.[~~, ~~ll.e ,rea.so:n, )lU I .. e ,.iil~,' is eD~l!!ce.", eve ,I ~ ~85" . I ~

(:'~Qtcri$tic ac~lim can '1Ixi' e:ani:ed, ,0<11. Oflily-' :if:mrl!llm,ern~ ~flia'bUIl(I' ,ac~·

'it·i_, "'"'1;'Ii'I!' ",,'lin,?, ;;:""f'i;""'d' '.'."" .. ,_-'1. N'" ~ 'm""m' ':L-~_[ iO'i"j.;uz:t 'if..~, '·I! .... ~~i;".,it,~..1. ..,~'if:.,i"'"""""i"'!""""IO"'~, !l-_L-b&li !All ~ !III_GMU ~"'LI!I.j.-. 1WI!'!b~.. l, ·~"'H l:::: ,b __ ]i[IGIJ,!]! !IIJI~~'l ~ [_I!['--'-I!I~_I8!!I.I~p. dY~_IIf~~·~~'~-'!P.!I!ll!l~

" 'I' ;j;,'L._ b~" .,_.:1 " ' .. _.:1 :111' [:11", ... t~ 'L._,I::. ~~ 'l~··f.'-,j"~,,, .. .dI! ~~,~."'."'~ ·,·.oJ1

,m,~~ ~'jg~G:~'~~ ,p:Ii'OOII;'Y.l~~ ,~ .. e~ imUlSi. ~',~'(k1ln'1;I! :;:Ii~Yl ~r.a:, P1!aI!nr~n.egi~,

6'''' 'I-._ ... .:11 d d '1:ih ''' .. 'i..'....'i-. .• -er , '. t:'

.·.·l.UIl.'eS ~et ee s;eiti!~2.~ M1;_I 8i() O~", ',nUllSl 'W'i)'YiIQ, 1Y;t,e' actli\l':t~.es, OJ ,!iii, grQUP~'

it ~, ~~~' toOl w~~~pr~h. 'bet'W~ifi, dl.~teiistU;;!, ~Da'M~~g'~, :.(!1, ip¢i,.·

.-'I,~. ~,~'II : .. ·tr '"rIi':","" "]1".,0",:,,: ·Iit.:, : ',' iiI]; ,I .... " e. ::- " :1[-""i""""'"~rIi .... ·• t~:··:, ;: "': '~' •.. ' :'Ri' :,,<"f' ~,'L....,., 'm··I.·· I' '['1 U/Ii;;!AJI;IU !iK;wi\i1Jw}es., ,ii, ~ ~au_ng _neS5 ~ a !C~l~ aA.,1""lUSW,C; aouw"jl' 0: I [,111;-(: ~om I

grwu:p of phrys.ic~3D~" umnim,g fU!tlW~ pk~i'ciitins, hi, 3D, '~n~hting 'Rtt~,ty~ ,Mtd

d~L .' ~ • ';1.' ·'.:I1~ '"'~~ 1>:\' 'k· &" iii 'i... h fllW!m,g e'xpe.O:S:I,ve (3'111[ lSI !l'DI iUlI:ChK;iIlJ~ one, [l·:['to;m uns :I)O:I~OM[ me 81X)1 ,I

[(la-lldiiltlO:IlJ ~iJr ~,~ :I,{'l,gitim~.tt': aM'ripuoo, ,of c"oI.~~i1~ ;f[e!5pilmr5ijb~I'iltr: ,the ~ limu far whkh, apn~ am ,Ii:dd '~ ~fk dnt pari ftl ,Iht thmtz.uli~' ~t~ rI tAt.' ~al ,~. The r.e~~ :fw this, ooT!ldi!tion, ls, I~t. it ~5 ~bjffiU,g!b :iJm ,dh3i~i!£ruiit a'C~:viibes tli1i3it ,a. ,.o~P pFl~Iy' !lmr~lj'u.ences b~~ wtd)far~ ,!U],d, ~IU.5, ~Ji:(;~u, mooPlJ), au~n,ti.o-~" 'De m;0',W, iDfI)uefl~' 'of

[ ,t, 'bUn ,tiviIit:' . ':. 'x'-:-~-:iI. ·n~' ·f~'.:I;·; .A·I!Ii,t. ~"I..., 1'[ .,t. 11:1;.., '. ,: ~iIi,.! 'io~.:. '~L ','-;: ~._~g ao~~. uees IS c~e~[~ o~~~,,. IlI1Y.IUC.,,}il' 'YIm'llI,g;u, me elll,($C_ 'iliiley .. ~a~

,():n, ",,~, dl:~~~ ~~1~5' Q:£ • .e .g:~, pgup~ ,and.. ;SQ they' h~ve' kg,

Ul'lJ ~II ~'I[~~'. ··.·11·,· ". ,.;ili'""~, ,.;~, ;1, ..."...'I-~"·--;I]'.,III·:- ~"'iif ,L, ;::'-!I.,:.- .".['1 " -:-" ~.L:'·'./.-'C, ,.,~, -:::.:=.-: ~o~ ~ ~p~liCaL~e. ~~"'" U!I;t; !lnnl 'd!I! !S~UI_O! o'li ,I [D£I,u£fill1IIi.'1i. , acllrVLIHm IS ~~~n,

Ht(Jf~' :~nt(Jh!:4y oon~~~d 'wiltib, the :mQ:~, ;~W'1di~g 'of the' :~~p.

Tb,~ 'two' p:RoMing ooudiltiu1l5 b~~p '~D !Specify '01tUR pmd~I!f' 6~ t~n,~'

. '.. €: ID d~1 .''i-. ,', • • I 1~ . ·Jb·'I·'·

i!liIily OJ '~~e grourps: g;~ ~ie' K~1:tes irel!eva11!~ 'tD >OO,J,ectllve' If.lespo;UI". tIJtr;,

But :it is, ~, '1i1~Ai' to, S1V"r:i~' furtbc.r tibc 'Il:a~1JIUi' [of m~ ni:llii'tj~'in1li'rr-1l

... [ J ... .. , . "-'---',1' .. r-'-""'T' , ,.. ,. , ... ... ., .. _ r--"' ~ .. I,r-· ."

'~'indi,ridll1!a!1 .,ent~, :Ln ~uch If.Q\!IpS ~d, :act1¥it1l~. _dlvlid'n~~ ~I!]j~ arre

..,.. ... 'mll :Iff'~""'" ,n.S:' 1I1""""iI"'V !IiI!II';A'>;op'''_ 'I?g;["'1'il'lv. iU"'i\~~I·I'''''D'' [O!i'tlic!"i"I'''''' ..... liiImf'" ,iii"~~"i",""I"''''liIn. !l!1!'~ __ ~!II ~ :v.:~l !IHI~ll,J.' ~~.I'IUI-g ~ .il!r. [iii ['~U~I~_II_ IJ l!! ,~-~I~I_ ~.ll-o~' 1llif.l-_IJ~LIJII_lib ~~ .. ~~._llll~J [UIi,ll'-&IJ_..-u.a_I~IJ_I1r-1!

WQr.:kJ, ht,)'bbi~~ p6tilti,¢$Jj i'(irnigi~n~1 ¢~tk~il!!iih'~p~ :m;~ilh.oot'bood~, gd ~, :r~fiIh

,I : In ,f'"'i'r-. nt, .', '11" 'I., r!)rt ,,!~, ,I ,I,',,' '."1" ,,-~"'r:1... , lilt· .. ·11. IL..~IL-:- .. r. ;me 5O~e o~ ~e ~~ore i( .. L iess ~~a'UJAdll ,gnJu,p,s: ...uwiulCu ,lllM p:o;Ple ~K!l~,gl"

~mber&~p i~ a, gtVtlp[ Ur:Ii~JljMt ba.;ppe_fiS, M' ",~lti;. They :bJa~ !i1i())t ~'ho-'

'.. 6 . 'i 6 ~ ~'il. 'I' 1... • 'Ul~ 'I-.~~''l..'" • b

sen itt'j '~c:ey ,51i11lJl~f ,,~!Q\~, '~~eIiIlse~ve:5, cti_a'VlLliIg lit, ,~"\Km~ .. MIII,':ln ti, ese gifOUpS

rml'f-"~ tri~ 01' hnportanlt. It ii!l, inportiln;'t. :if U, ,Iillft$ ,a. fQnna:tir~ iIlJ!(I~~fi~~ ,nn the cb~tu. 'of :~¢if~ting ;i!lidHiid,.~~;ds. :M'a::m.:J of the' '~il!Ie's iO'f Ithe :gTOIilP then. 'be(;~me' 'tbe 'Vta1J~¢5 of' ii~ m.~m'~!r5], '1b~~ '~~.~ 'MI~~(]¢ i]h~ir t}D:n~o:ru, of a. ilil"ood :tile". de'me so:me of 'liihcirr' 'n(\'uibiiU~e8.' arnd

~"~ ~-~~ - - .-~-=:'F'~ ~ -.~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ - ~ -.~~:Ii ~ ~.~~.-- ~ - - ~ ~ cOO _""' = ,~.~.-.~-.:;-_. ~ .~L'·_' .~--.~

'~im~tB~ ;Slli~ ('r[ltr:na :W:F :mm~' o:ft~h,elrr mOl'a!ljn:dpnenft$" :5'h:a.pe Illheb" aspi,·· ~UI)U~,! and :,~dle :pi)~,~ Ft}'r devclQ!P1~81' 8iOUdiiifJity', feUow fee1l~g'~ ,c(jtln!rad~iiP~ [of' Ju~ ~m,ltl, ,goodwin ~ [on, :miubia!, oo,de~'tall;d'iQg' Wllth Qtn~' ,~~~~~, 'lip .e ,same ~~p.'j' 'DIWi[ indiridTIaJ~ lDay be ~d

iii..,. b:'I'111-' !I<~I'I·~~':"'lt~iC,~~"1!' ''''''~r''J'i ,it:~ ... 1'i'1"""'!~ Of'.".[~,:,.p' . '~~'-rf.'''''~1 ~"': ,",,~'f,,;'t '_~I'I'., .... :"", 'ijW'io'""'~I'L.=r;:". IIi,U I ..... i!I"'.. ,'!.)I",""", !l.ililll~, ''I'I!'~1lI1 !Ll.b .•• i.ilv<I",j;U, ~.' U' ..... ~ ~ '!I'I!'.I!.~"-".U ,.o:t nUo., ,''n~ ,~.,.,,,,,~~~U'Iill'J'~

;~,ibr~p 1o, lit, :lrmpo~,t A. ~1'I:th c'll)ndJi.ti,g~ 'fklf the l!egii~~te, aKri,tiO'J). of' [tlo:1ile~' ~~;p(!m~lbiUty ~ 'theref'QJ:lc 'tha,t t~' ~i$; ~ :i~iiJit:'d :willi; l1le


~,


ities ,@f 'me :~!)If :ar~' ap,roptiale. ,And when o~e mrcm'beF ~.~ g (J<uu::r,s feel, dt~ 'i:!hll;~~~ rs'IlLO:llld, th~~ ~t i~ ~e '~O 'SiaI¥ of'irtbem lIfi.:at dt~ too

.. ". - '1..;1 '~~~~~. ~ .. ~ii\oiiio.~ li;~-'~' _o'];ci'n;'" """i!liV ,~" . ...:1,,·,::11 ,~'Ik, ... _n,,,, ,.w.:L, ...... _ .... '", ... ii~~'. '''' ...... ''''''.l [it'oLL'i"""b. WO'lIIlL~J 1,la~ a.C1~u, !Io1J,IC '1i:tHoI~_~& ""-\H] IfHi QJJg~, g~~ yc~-~~ 1W:IlIIi.yr. ~L~,:.: ,~~,~:r. ~. ~~n

- '

arm,g ,smta1:m ~be' :grn'!!J!p. :[t :is th'fl~tf' sb~d!, ,enduring 1i:ilenr(jic3!tiufl" 'tlb~i1f:'

dediC3!tiDilI, m' '.e' mu~s ,and, 'GhiI!mC~ri5tit. ;actilWties, ~t, bepl, th~ .-0,\1" ,mWi!t" Amerh:a, B 8\UOIiined. if j\m____,Cr1cans, aot ncC:DnlifillF to t!b~, [(b;llsul,u"

,~"""~J" ,. , ... , ... - .. -._ . __ ~'_ ~~,,-._--_ - '---'-"--- '-"-',~ .. -' -, .. -.,----.--, ...

1Ii~.~""1 :""",,,.J j;,L.,~, 'mlill-~ ,~,c ·rm::."}t.,,,., [or_'b["C,-~~,"[~r~, .... ~~yif""'iE, ,:;1" l"':li..n'~i"iIi~~jn,a; l"A/]~, ilih.,. 'IOiI,'!U!',ll~ ...... _~,""", I~~ ~I!.JI, ~ .Ngi!!o!,~!, '!I;.;iiJ1!l':U~:!.ll!I!.Tl ~uu,'IlI1J ""'... ,U ..... _111 ,~_WU.'l' ~V'---"'Y'!'!! ~~"'"

readl;~nn, ,gfJ' ~£oJ M~dici.n,e nouri!~ibes 'if ph~ieigs, ~bide '~~ 'the H~~~J" :.',."=

~- "_ • ~ /..~ ~l~' r.IJ-:"-

cmti,(: o:ath" ;m~, the Law' p~~ W '~U' ;Qm£:~n adm~ni:s~i~-r :iJt ~Hlipartial!ly" ~m;beF5 of' ,3., mond gifOUp aiR thuefoJ1e 'wUeQtively :~n5~bi~ :£u.r Ithe [Ch3iDXl.eri~ti\c aciivities, of the P"OOP-::' '~" wh~C:h. 'rIi~ :h,ye :i:demJti6ed,

_, " I. c!SI'.'

~ir :ml'po.l1J!!ii'bitilW:is on, aeeeunt ,of the good '0.;]" cVi~, ~1TIf~¢U, ,(d" tb@, c'~,

" ., -. -.' " " ;j' ~i1.. .e. .41 ",li. 'f' .. ,I., • '"ii.,.j"!I"'" • '11... "

tensnc ,actwl)tles,01 'lJ!..li.e :RJO!W'. ~uJ, wiC' ,8Qur~~ o_: 'u.~~m:" ,~5p):m51ul~~IJ':~ 'hiiat

" " -

~~:=b::e~~.::=~~~~~o:

p~se Qr 'b~'"

These are 'l:Jme Fea.s;o:ns, theil1r ~a!t rnla.ke me' inJ\'uiJ~ c~ :f:O:F OO:U~()tlvt': ~:spO:u~'l!l~ty' :plm.oobl~., ~t i~, f'Or d~ese irCa5iO~_S, 'tiha!t: America1[l~J! Chrii!l~"~~ 'P:~ysicl3i:ll~, and o:fI)i,a::fS o:f dIe law may 'be' le;giitiim.atel'" p.~d, ,G:t blam,~d, 'GO ac'C:Q.~~~ of ~rulu ~~c)t~rist.ic: a:,Ctil,011,s :penorlIl,ed b'f ,other HlellD!ben, Qf' 'their ~.ral ~llP't even :If 'tbtry' d~~lws, bad, 0,0 ,(O:(ljt1ro~ [!J¥el:' mem .. If ,~~, :Raw:11'S ~.old" h,~~ d1eilil '~e liberal 'ri~, '~i\c~ ~s

tift,:" . ,"'."",,'[", ~':~ ::",1 '~~~":'" ',,"~I~·''''''''~'"""-~~'~iI(1i;d.1 ~iI'l'iV:inC'iii~jl~ih1;~C', n"'oI"I-~". ~iljUJt

,,_ 'C' ~il;Ii;m!lil~C!IUI.o:1!1! ~'L_,",e; .... "'!IlI~'I'li...- .. n.,!" ifHOI,. ,~'!.:i-0l!,f"·~~~~~~~"1 A"! ~~""'''''''''"''= j'j, __ " " ~ _

iM; rig;hit. :8oe:f'OR' pD55ilbte' 'tilberaJ, :res,po~s.eiil, toO' ,tlh~, ~ are dm:;~d!, ;9. &l:iJheF iL~pncatio~ of c:nUeonve J1~po:mi!b:iUrty :m;~'d!!l, '~a 00 ,co:mcsideFect

LJh~ mscl1lllinn has, proceeded SIO far 'O'II, the' ;~m_ptdQD dl;at "e' ~rip ti~"- Df~~n~~, 'us~n5iiblIL~,tv, fur ~ 'and 'eWl ,!:Io;-o ... i ....... ,1Il II'· '~mettii(;a1l

_0111, I.~~ ~--O __ . .:.. ~".~" ... > ,_I :"·--.rr~ 'I.'~,I-_'. ,rl.:1' ,1,"'- I ,~,~ll, ~~.lll • ",1. ~Hj-V.c.~~!JI' ~~ [~,l'~~,b__;~':_'l.___:__. .. ~~'":~ __ ~'

,AoccQJ~g '00 ~i5, aS5umptinllj oo:neclti,lre IresPQusllhiJiity may reswt ill, l~lti,." :marte P~' QJ:' bbmte", l.wt thrb ,~U'mpnfin :is :fiDt o'bviuus'ly true, h rso1llF!l;~ di:!l~~Qtly odd, It) ,say Ithat. ~pl~ are h.~ld tr~ns:ibl,e' ;[01' 'hari_n_g' oon:e !SOm",,1ll!ing :g,'O!Od., "The te:ad,e~q' LQ [l?o:m__mcOIlI, d!~~~ hi, 'iO ,~, '~~ q~' don, ,M :mnmJ, u..,nlih1I~~' OIl1ly w:b~n ~h,ere' g, a, q,~e.!!itiQ~ [of ~l~~mgi. In the IiiO:~ C:()~~ of ~,Its" maW, r.~n'5'i!billiity is ~g t'Ol 'indicate :m,on'l: :f-aib.lH::'., U~~ ~ 'H<'1t; ggGq~ai~ ~n d1!~ :~!!l,peot., 'bu,t it, dlilie!! 'liendi till

,~'''",,-'I~i"':"''-*,iI-:'~~ J·"~iE~: ~"'1",, .:I-

~~ ~~.~-LUU..,lI, -lJIi::I-~ IUI~-~.IE:Ur.

,As ~te~ '~ppe:M,~ '1)!b~~'Ung' ~bo~i '~;e leads to MUll~t'b'ing ~nl1po:~t., [(bljlec~ rapcmMbi!l~~' :is KNUJ.,ded on IdenlL6.€.atllw,.th the ~'h~tcJ''' 'iatlt ~[tiQns, .of ,a moral ~p", BllIit 'dii~R :15 a prei!!il!limptil,O'J'lI" ;a;t.le_t ~~R' ~ts, nlCm'ber8~ .,n dre, ac)tiQ:~ ~, ~!' ~r aJ)~!, tth~ ac.timM H~' (!hanClt~r;. ~tk ~ca~' '~er' f.-epI~fU m(l' '_~ M'th~ group, :NemKi[S, of' 3), gJlQ'Up wi'li, act :In: dnmLCte:n_suc <wa~~, [oth-e~ me, ~Pl '~IlId. disiImimgm~e [0:['

ii'h;toV :. "-~-",,-'IL41 ,'C .~;~' ~.~: ,ii, .... 'iI!t-'''O' ""Iii .. : ~'~i'io"ioii..,",,,",,, '~t, ' •• : [1i'Io .... ~, '1i'Io'-'_*""'JjCI,"",,'i~' tiI!'L.'~'n' '1iIiI ....... 1..-...." ","",~ r WQU .. u !Qe:~ !I;AiI' ~ I~ oIi1i1C:LUIUC'J,i3. Ji! ... ,1:0:1' ,1,L-'U'Iio ,1,liV,R,dl'l!''!o.!'\I, '"'-'11" '!'I',HIJ!;j~~, =.",,"~.~~YII;;'o~ ~


'""'~. ,,'u

lii. __ L_;II~ __ - .,;f;Iip:m .. .-' ' __ . ,_[iIII'i!

·M:iI, .~tlP dQ' 'what :m£mi~m of tJIlat F'lcP ~~' i$u~d. :~g dn", 'Tb~' ~: [conte'xt 'lin w:b-k'h 'qliIClstiO:Jlis[ .m:Ue ;a)OOUlt. res.pomin)ia~ty·~, then" :is: 'wlu:m. a iI!IQ~ :~ vi'(J~ared. Th~s [c~ !happen. I~ l\WQ~: [one' '~al~ the iOme:r' mo:r-' ,alIl¥' s'.pifi,CiUiL

.Memibeg 'm:a :grg~, :may ;sbnp:ly' ~g;late the 'Qiliu~s, of th~ ,IJ-OUPI ~,d. [do ·w:h~t.:I, ev.Ilt. Hi dl~ Ind~d. ha~' am [endUiEirng' iden,ti6~a.cii,o:FiJ wlJtb ·.e' :gH)UP,., ~1Il dtey recogn~' [Ol' Cim 'be 'b1c\.lught '~O re(_~' .a't dlciir ;Kliions '¥m~ ,evIi~" J:t, b, :p:r,.r [1).0 :buld '~ib~m :R~.pon~bl~·~ 'but dt-e1ie :~ :fil:o q'~gtrl.

jj.. - 'f:- U --,;, '-1..:::1'- 'T,i..' ,;, d-'" '·d-·""~~ "Id- 'k ~~iid-I 'i:..~ II L"f:R' Qj ml~ec~ :~.POIlS~~_]t.y:. -Jj,l~j,e' lL~_llYil~. 'ew..~oe~ '!!LCO,~_. ~'

II.:II..-F'""'.-.<'_-"" ·~~r·'"~I!- ... 't [i:'r'~ I;",,~ .... c.-;<~

llJllAIIJI_Z_L'a..lJ ,IL~ "''1!',IIMll-:. U,I ,I.' .,lI_IR'-'I"-~ utj-Ii 1I~.

The .~ (;-o;njtc:x~: ,of [Q'O:nectl:ve :RII,,aJu.imj~ty· Is another 'k~n;d ~'mfdo..' ~ng,· :Nemrbe~ 'm-;~ :If-Qu.,'~' dQ what e, [~I not ~~a~' ~ VioliaiC' the

,~~)liIi~~S,"':'~' ''-I!:'~i! ... ~I!lin iL"'[~.1 '1!f""~ll~~ [I;~~ l'li""'c .~"",~,;o;,.y...:ll':",:"O!' [iI<"": ~: ... ~ Th. iii;!': ,,,"c.oi'ii,c,:II"'1

~,1IJ) .... ~_ U1i, UI~I.iIJ ~"~~llj· ILK!l~ ~ ... _~~ "I~~}. ~!I.Ii ~~u-.l,UU:I~ Ii~ IU~IJ. .• 1 _ [. __ ~ "'I~ULU

iha- ,~;; -0. if ;&0_:- ,00F d. th- l!illt·- -,IS FIr dr~ ,':; u-c- !--,c-,- ~.~tA'iT):mri!S; do; wh-~. ~~_.ppe~~ = ~ _~~iC ~,",_~~e _~rue_ ~ ~_~e ~_p :aH! evI __ ",c~CL~ __ ~_",,--at

&oey :be'~~ g[ ~! b.wt dt~ H-e :mi~c;1il ~~ their' ~U~;, n~y-:~tOOw' dt~

'~~JI .. ~ ... ;o;, ~,,::L... '~"'~~'; ~! .... ~, '-r~~ '1~"liI"'~IIi~FI''''d··.·. ~:I:..l~' '~~~I[iO_ !"':-r..-t, :L.~ ~-~ ~"'": ~"i""=' ... c::: v.\i.U)IJI~_il! "!I!"!f!lIUJI WI_lI_n.-JI_lI, t.J;li~!!- ,1J_m"7."-1IY> I W~IJMliiullll..a of. IUll'G ~_~'U_~ IU_Lilil-:l 1[1_"HIP!G; .... ---!U.,._~ ll~ "IJ_F

for.,m, du:i[' chilfiU:_ter.;. ilhq act iim. c·haimcl.emtK. ''Na)'5i, and, ~lq' ,end IIp' [ta'ID'" i~1 ~I, They :~' OF :~J;,Y' '~~t :rea1lu:~' 'i;b!lt dtr~ 'hg h~ppegcd, :Bu1. th~ ~.egiitimate: .~ri.ptjon of (lGU&~1i,~ ,m,ora'll ,re!.ponsiibilirty, dOie~, n,~t depend' 0.0 'the~r fiC--aJJiim'O:fiil rrot un :meetifll ,th~ :mllO-wtllg' oo.nd~tkml~ u~~r' ~In?' iben, of'dlle :mo:ml :~~(P 'M~h w·Ilat~J~'ll ·the .~~ 'ha¥e M 'G~d'Uirl~fi~' :id~~,1ii6;~,

-~"'"","'[ ' .... I ... ~'- ~..,t~-r'i""'d,· , .... [;o;iII;""I...".. ... iI< .... o;1ii .. tI!~ · .""~._o: ... ..-~ .: ... ..,..~, "l'_"fi'"ii"':~tihJ ·r!iM'W~'"i"~,.

'Ii;.--'III!-lIl!I""-'U .u~·'1!''''' ,t"..,.,:I.lil;;P .... IJIJ....,._. ~ .... I!I~.~~IJ~i;I!!;lII' ~~u. IU~ .... 11i,;U~.,.,." .... l!;!I!:, .""',F".~~~i!!~j~

'II __ f II .:11-.. A"'" , ,,," ,",'L. .. ..'if.. "'£ .. 'L.

mfllC' WD!l.nIil YAdlC8 o:~: 'we :~~,pj, aD!i!I. n :11 true '0'j[ lOOe .nts 'Mar~, ~: 'Ulley'

!had ~Iil! :in tth-e ~illhCF ,agM!ts,~' :poiil~tktn(! they !tOO ·~d. :ha~' d!o.Q~' what. dIe oth,er ,ageD!b., did,. [Given. these oondilio:l'I~, ~DiU 'Can iegitimatelJ"be !held J-e~Mlbfe {Of; at:~O'iU ·tlbey· ha~' peilllbef :ped~. nor' :bJad. ~~nUo~ iiMl't'i[;, .Md, d.,~iIi.i. (h~. :~iilx:i:m iI.mlmpmO:Il: ~t al!li~rmomy' and [~po:Uis_irbiliilJ' .10' band ·~_Ol band :ia; lIililU.lit, !HDw' milbt ~_~ben'~ :~~d. b) tbtl'S ~-' meo'~

:Pet-haps. dt-e 'fint, liNtalJ, :tce$.P'Oms.e 'wi~1 'be .' ~;eot me' ,c_' :for ,c.o.lle'0uve' respo'·IISib:m~-. l~. 'wiil' be said '1Bat 'it. is 'barlbari!C 'm ·llIuiJd. ·nPflp·te

•• _r •••• ~. ' __ 0·, .' . ..: __ ~}.~ lJ •. __ J ", - •• __ ,_.-.llr t_ ~ •.• -_ 1,-, •... l_I. r-"""-- ....

. - - -

r~.mjbt-e fm' 'wh~t 'Il!hey ~ [;I,ot dO'n~ .. 'fto,le (Ju[gh,t to .~ ibie1~Ued, .a"

.3:U!iJ)llomom ~ndll!iidllDi!!!~ net as m~mJbttr:!!!, ·o:I :HJOHPS. 'Th,q' :s'lllOuld .. atI"tM~r :fOF [tb~~r al!i!toooQmo~ fKm~i1iI!, jjtot fnr th~ :a()1io;ns, ,0£ ·O'dJi,en" ,~'F' dt~ In' m:£mMrl, ol,~up!l!,. ~e.n ,they m,O:ullQ 'H' heM us:po;ns:iJhfe :f~r 11u~~r' 1Ml1n;-· '~'h!j.p~ ~d. [ooly fllf 'li1IlIat

]'i':'~ii\~'~-" " . ~,~ tIi\ofi;[ ,,:jl'·l'~·": ~"'po.' ',' '0]10 ' .. , '~I::-~ 'p" ~""'"lllII' ..,..,..~ ['"'AlP' colle tIi':~ '~"po, _. - '.i" !

'....._...., .......... 1!I.lI, ll.'!L.!I !WI].OlI' .1O'!Lo?iI! ..• )1 '" 1.1.1 ..... 11' .... ~-,",'!.:l!''IiII'iI! ~ [IiU,I, "".'!0!1\_"""'-'-'&-1;~''''' ,Il'~ ... 11," ___

_._ ._; _; ._;

'biJUty" If' people :are' ;auJton~mo.w!, f-Jq' ~,o_~ltQ ,c:e~~Iy' be tFeat~ ·ac~~

.' .. ,-11. 'D,[~tI!,,- n ·t,·.. ."- -,.,' [ " '-" ..... , ' .... 111 I:' ... , ,.... 'L.~_'L.'" "_'." ' ... -. . - _ . - .

~.I!f'. ,DU1I. ,9.thOn0.mIY ,IS UIKpQraime fli'iOim, .m,em~mI1llpl ,In Wl]Ji!)W· :p,ups.


Th,ese Rqjtliire:ments, are espe-tiaU.y pr-essiilll' ibea~' tiu~ libeira1 re!po~se pres!iJ),pnses ,it diUbtO'llS, :in:~e;rprretati;(Jl~ [I)'J a'l[I1~O:l,l,omrf';' ]'baJt thi!, iill~ tefPFemth:~I'I, '~ drliljb:kr!ll-~ :is the ,poi~t iQf the [co:m~UlQj!tarim CFbict:!i~Si of it (~e ~ri'O::m. 1.4);, These CcT,i;tkisms, (!(tree a eheiee ibeilWeellll 'two' opuo:ns en :ti:b"",,,,:,,,,[lg ,!iho 'g'IJ'!Ye Illhils, :...,.gPQ,nse_ They .. mtmt: ;Ii>~~~'i...;Ii>r' Fnd, ;3. '~~' ;n'f'~"'-f"'-lI1;dLi'lllg-'-

~~,~ _, ~~ ~ ~ _ ~ ~~~~ ~.",,~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~" ~ ~.~. , ~~~ ~~ ~ .".~~~.".~ ~~~~ ~ ~ .'!'!!'~, "'~~ !IliI!~-"",~~ ~~ ,

I.". ,t', .: ".'

~~, 'C'Ju.mmtl~ impJa;llgbl~ W~ t~iI~t, :indi,ridu. b~tliltrm~ arL!.~~m;Ot!li.i_G!tls a5,

dJey sueeeed iQ id31tBJn_,g' dtc~hl!~ fr-o:m, the vaJue.s[ i!iba~ :p:r~n i~ melr ;sodill oonmJlrl:tl or if' tfllt~ :1~Jk-mlIs, :~j~ot ifl:d:s '~mplaus~ble l!limv" ~~11 i!1hey' m:UM Mlc,ept HabJJli;ty ileO ,c'O:lleotjj_~,e Ir~D~.!hi;liiq;, l;n G't!ler' 'wo~ :.(' iiberal:s ;~pt ~~t -~iiJl]jbc:nhif' h1J ,a g:roup Da;$l, ,Q_ £QTnI:ardive' I~nue~c:e j)Jl. 'Illhe ,aUI" ~nli1;O(mf' of' :iud:r,~dual~ ~bem dlJeY calill~@t ,cO:Il'S:i®ten~ly r(l!pl~' to 'tt.~ tpo:inrt i]bat ;5i;i~h :memibef:~jh~p .ay :mue ]ndI;Vld~s, H!I!ble I~nl 'cml~otl,ve r~po:lii!$i,.,

1:-.;·I~iih:!' 'b.o~, .;n'~·I"i<'~:niQ' "i'Io1I!iI1 ["'.J'l:I;~ILl'I'glt'il!la' ~L;Ii> m· '''i'IoJi''':l;'I-] ,d""i""'~,il!la' ,~~·]·'n·,;i;'I'ui~~;I'l:II;~liI!l ~1!1I;~en.i!"!IlIo., ~ _lI_lI~ll ~!l ._1,,1_"'- _'M.-I_~llD.1 "I..!'!IJIII ~'!'H_ J~!IUI~-,Ij~~ .. _lIll~,.,l' ,_ ,~iII!R_ "l4HIll!!i.l_III_.l~ ~Il , =I~.n i'r.I,U)U_'R_ -~ ~_II_"" r-:..'l II II

deJl'l1v of dl,e, -'Ow i!: Oliu,dJj tt'iIiOi' U'£ iih.e 'i:rnltlit1li 'thaJl. 'mi:"l~fivqc!i)d!11v ~.nl:~~ tl1t-=-iif'

.~ .. ~ ~,' .. ~- - ~~~-~ -~ - -~~'I!:I! ~= ~~. ,I!:)~ ~ ~,f" ~~-". ,E"~ ~~~'1JiI~~_!'!I,!' ... ~O_._!L~

,aiiliJm~g:m!t_

.Ii; - ~.'k ~L"k~~'1 II' ·A .. .'k .. 'It

l'M~'O~_ier 're45,po~s.e ~h~~_E!! may Q~-er 1~E!! 't'O ;Q.Q',n¢-e~e. 1Y;I .. U 'u.::ere ,!aiR eeea-

,E! "I 'of> iifI(i5, ,~ C'w~'i;«~.,.'i,. [I"i,. ... '''"E:r.~lp-ci;~?,n :O~·f'-'",",.-.ji~I~ .. ''''!''!! i""c""!'lHoiIl;a,:O~·lii~;;"., ,'1'.' ]"',"r~~m' ,""J~'" "'-I:, U' t

[iJ_ r"!l.!l1I_1II_1l! ~.~Il .. l[I_:l~[I. 1!l_I]I~ ~1J1.l_ u~.~.,. ~uJ_l~!l_IJ'!f~ ~.~~~. __ ~_.u _1_~"1" ,~ I A.l~"u- , __ aL~~ lUi. ,

'W [claiiw lih3it these eeeaslons !(K:_~Uit;so nJi[le1, 3!nd [ei«;epti,O;lj1!iill~';as t'C)j!l~tifY'

, ...... 1~·,~'f'i:0i.' '~_·o,·'I-]·"i!''''~~':;''''.-,'''' r1~N:'ir":'"("'I·ik';I~:Ii1iJ," ~'"':< "'1;"fil "i""'1 ""M~~"', ,r' '-I":' ;;l""'lc~:,ftIo '-I'J'"_· '"'"i"~c: .. st ,Ii ""'"~~,~~lb"lCl! ... _ .•. -"2"')U;" .... I, !Ei0.r~,I,I ... - )lh~J~l· ili.V l!I.l.... 1J111'lilll~,~,~~~i:I iL1'J, ,111,I,o.1! idi.I_IJ~:! '" ,1101, ,I,I~~.

t~s~, llt:b i~dMdl~aI, ir~po:mr~~bili~ tb~ :mailOOn-", l_.]k~ gl~r oC·Wm. there-

'ii\'Ji<~ 'it:Iic[i!'>i' ~'I...~ ,c' "'cih;O' ''"ry[' ,.-.'(";'I-I~""""'~ ~iI'f;Vi.'"1"",ciili-r-~~'rm' o;.o;oq'-"'"~fIi'O!'~: I~"':" i"'~n ... ~' 't'I!:-I"'Ii_~ ,l'~I"""" lliili""'.... "'-',I.... . ~ ,I!lo!o., ,,"'U _ ,"'"'..-U'-"'-IIY- 110 ""'i:lr~ ... ~-~I!lh",1 .IJ ~ JulilO '!;;,o:t !I~!V UL'U'.I.'!<i .nab

:mblU)f' :~.8ion 'm t.he~r :POSlUOQfiI"

The. W'ubi!e.' wlI~h '~fus, RSPO~s.e i:s Ihat it 'u'IldeustiImLSI';eJ,J, ~;b,e· sl;g~~lic!aiJ;u)e


of, If ., '"b·]'" Co' . l·tK·' ·'m"l" ," '~'".. •

"1"- _..~ ... ",,!!, "-'-';~"''', ,"1: ~k!'. : '-:, ". ~. ,.''li\iI!!' '?","'n;n-r<""',' .. , >'N' I'.: '~', 'ii-'~"".i; ~ ---: !"'-,

""'"U'. """'!IOI"~ ~~-r~'.'.iiU, ·'~"'r·' .--.' .. -,' -.U'I'''''' '~·""",r·~'.~- . 1!""1 1<;10 "_ .. ' l~iI~~~~-_l,.: ~

cribcd, Wh,cD~ 'the cbamcterim!t ;.wtiwtli'cs, o:f a, momll, gtoUIp are' ,~iMIJ 'by

the' Wf-Q~g ~~~. ~Ilt :~ ~~"dJ¥' ~, t~ 00e' ,aJ, mJ)~, ~, ~, d' wb.~ 'vailJue"s, ~ '~n,g ~d ilhe' VOUCP :i;s, Mtai1ily ;O~pL ~III~ :It; ~ :not ~~ ;alli, :~t- ;m, f~~, it.:~ 'gat. :ha~~u, :11Fl0lt m: the' rtime~ that'ihe"! 'HlOnd treden-

cia[1 : ",iii 1"'-:' ...... ~,'I' ~ .' ... , f '1 [ , " I' , ' ' " mi!,-.:I- e"f', '.",' '.!;""'~ I' ," ' " ., .'I,.{t,. ' r- ', '.' , • "

.. _$ 0..1! '''n¢.¥~ue$ iQ'~ .!ai, gm-!II!,P are ~X!;:Y, ,,~·!.,d')lte Yt~~es are n:gu~ SOIn'C: are

~tlg" ood $t)m!~ ,ar~ ~' rlgl:n ~d, ~ '~(J~Ii" 'N'wlO:ID~ ~l'II,O:LMj' irn5ti)wtiCID_s~ 'pFOf'C'AioHJs~, 31I];d iiQ' 'OD :~e-1y have ,Mlly;thirng' but iIj, :ml~:ed :fiC'!C,orcdJ. 'th,clf :m.cm'~~ ~' dl~me lialdt, f>Qi (;cQl~~' :~gdbjlity:. ,~d, :slOtle IJbil ha,penl frequen;t1:y~ (loliecA::ive respmsib:iiii~' [caJlllf'lQ:1, 'be :~n~ ,ably' rel~, '00 m~ :m,arstllls [of· mO'r:aility. The ~,tt1i:OH '00 do so oom,~ :(lto:m th~, m.uguid~ :lioo~l ifoo,d,cmq" ,flQ~~ ij'krui; .. l~' ~m:.~tiima!~ .~, mora) .rtm:oc 'm' :gremhers1Mpl Ln ,BfO'wps 'W the. de.vclop:m,egtt of mt-, tono:my.

A"-'O'~"laof' ]- ;~~pg,~ ~Ql\i'\'n. ',II'.iI;Ii' 'm .... 1V '~":", ,t)"" [~1 ..... 'I'!Ii'!O.!' '~'ii-g;~ [c' ...... 'i[]."i!<C1,..i~~ ~iI'·Di'l'n. · .. tlb· i;Il::hJ.! ,i""

~L . Uil...,.,. 1 l _illJ.E~.A~ ~'~-"""'~i __ ~ , g,ff. [E l..u!" UE~::lll U_~_gJllI v.,IL I~ IUi,,"-'" "'~~r--=' _ ~_ _ ~Ill .. :w, ll.li:l!

~_n~Q:mPl'tU.11e wi!~ DW'Jlomy:, ,ADtOJ1Q-Y :~I1VO:tveS, choioe" m,d, it. 'Mll 'be ~d!, ~~dli\!lldl:E.ah1, ~ nOrMd.y ~ll~ ¥lh.~~' f.o 'h' :~mben; ol',ilJ :gJO~,p. It iis, 'ne ~at binh, :iJHfanq~ ~d, 'childhood m_ail~' it, impouiblc: 'W dl,OOIe

" .. ~"'~"'Il:-,,""," [iI<"'i" '~,~"",,,,,-,,,,,, m·,-··""'_iL.· .. ,-. , .... I.,-- ... j ... 'V'~r.'ft.it .. 1b,.,.;O; ".~If-.- '~n'll-. '_"""l"'b. ~ib.·=, ,"',p~m~;1J ~ ~!I:o~~~l."!:i ,r .I.~~IJ~IJ~~ ~ f:Q: .IL1l1~'~ll· ~~ 4Y!r-'='1Ii U~~, l'!!!·,n~~ol· ,F~r-cl~ ,~L!I1£~~11 ~

age iQf' re~n" ithoey can c:~h~' 'Wh~ex il£J' r.-maiin. :membetm, ~'t Win 'roe ,said, lh~.t ,~m,'¢ gf'lth(! c:undh.i@rtS O'f' c-(flL~d~ '~!Sp(}n~bilitJ' g en.d~rin.g ide:ntifi~ticOH, ~t'tb !1, ,gt.-Qup" w:hrl'(;b i~ 'bu~ ,mtQ~r' oam.~' For ~~W~W1H(!k!;g 'cbOl~e 0:[ 'm.c1ITiJi_fihiip\;,

nl"-' ," :- c; ,Cn-: '~j~1- 'i">r ,';:- -- [1'-- .' '-'_ ~I\- -- _ '~'~';-Il" ;"" '"', ,-e ·iIi.~ ."1'1..;>.-, I :. ~L, ..... ,i!, ,,"_,,18 iI:iC'!i,po __ K ,JlWLI !llO~ ~ ~~n8l, ,!I(~_!f8t" W~!l1! ,e [.Jl ,18 lIO !!i,!I,O'Uu... tn.!Ie IYuu,.

,c.UIllJIlA!lIfUI' m~mJlx.~ip' :io. a, gf'i7iUP" gpcciiaJly ~n ;a monail, gmlll(p,i is mm.~' ~_ma a m~U'er [0£ dtoi\e,ej, :~t lSI ahn fmC flat d~e ~b:intr a.f ~ho!jc:e is ,s~m!pJy' tlllaW1i18J'bltr. for many :~pl~. :Pan ,@f IrIi~ fi¢iI:5011l :['01" this :~ ~ memDe[8'hti'p :in ,mme ,gIFO'UPS, prio]' to dlC' • of :rcuon ma~' in'f];ucllll,tt ~j' :~D,P:I,~"'s, l(;;'biam.ota' MJ' d~~P:ly :3$ m f~,~~re ~xc;~pCjh::u:l!a!1ly ;_-on,g 'CQ!IJ!l'iite~UP_g' :j_ntfl;uc~,ees '00; OVC[-(i(ij,ge !it. :1:1), the a!bsen£'i! of peat. upb,ea~ ' •. ~ri,~w, :~rsonail, €;ris;@s~ ~d. ,suc~, ;socia1J chmp-s ':U 'W3.'fi1, ;and, ~:1~,

co, ]- '. ,...~ii..~ f d"1 .;1.." ., '" ~'L" ~:ii... '" " ~~~.'i

(I@:I"I'.!" :pe~p ,e'J!lI!!~: l~ ~Qf' I~~.·_ meg' [C~~K'A~!iJP~' [eU!Ln~c~t)"j' raee, K:Xj~~

'O'n~[tati;(J~~ :£~~ty, 'Ii~j !JiOd .. t<JI a, I~f' [~I)e:n,t~ :re~igiQ:n ,md (:'~, u wen. l'b'm, g H(>:t. 'r,Q de~~' 'tbat ~piiQ.m;a1l indlwdnab ~ repudiate 'tib,e; groups to, '~Ich, they' ;iiI~ ,D"ut. belo:nging'~, but .. 1[; is ,to der.,y '~iU fOT' 'vel}' man,r ,peopl~' 'ooJog so tis, a, :Iii,¥t o:plion,

A, ;S:-l!Iib~~rial :paronn o:f dll;~ populJajti~n of 811l(y is.ta!b:L~' M)(Jl~t)" d~ as ,Alu2imikm of !flWlll'" o:f 'd\U~~; same 1t00llIPS, !initO wh..ic\h, tO~ were 'boom" and ilU)'t :~' 01' '~£m[ ~ntaiJnl Ute' ,co:mrnlliluir,' 'by chDi.cL~", 'This, is :fiot ~aiU5e mer ;aJ['C eeeeeed bY' tk[iem~ ~t g, ~f' dlat, ,Cltw:l~c reqtlii~ 'OptioHis1, and ~.e' [~illrll?' ~Lra1iln'ing ~e)!" ba~' ,~cceived. aIS, :m em bcts, i!)l vari~~ groU(~ ~I :i:nl])!,(to Ie:P,~~ dtclf' (;'harn.r.t~, ~, '~ :m3i:k;~ Ot.em, '~n~bllc' W ;~' at~~m3iti~' ~~~bi~


~de:Il'i:ii~a:tl:gi1l. with :~r.al ,~~~ i9' 'mg:l, :a ~tt~' [Qf ~h.()jce,. 'Th~s, :tiMml

i . ',', .. ",,' I" .', ,.: , i, t '",;n-~; .. , 1'1 .. 't'Iir"' ., .. i': .. " . ". :' [,.' I' ,," . "'," ,.: :' . '"'11::-.; ·t :' :'~'Ij '''j;' " :"~ . I'l!~"fi . I,ti . n

ireJ;P:>,m:,se ,IS ml!i!.UO..eui!' .I!Le:I}!!11Q;l}e, In S-!J.Ii.ppo510S Uill!ia, e;n~\!ln_QI ,1}!;Jer~lIl'L~ca:M,(L

~~t :mvQl~ the c~~~dsc ~r :~Ul'(lfu:mr.f.

Sup~!, :h~F!, 'that. tJhis, ~adi1mg of ~~. ~i:a!l fam :if m[i~.~tl: ,Mil. . ..1, ru "'dt • fi . "'~ '. ] .. ;1:.. '" J" E ';'f.

CD,y\Uiliml Len'Ui~caftID~ i~~@j~ m,mt¥eS 'Y!~e e~erciLse 0''': ~UilQ-n~m,y" "";;VClm,~,

thg, ~-.e i$Q.~ ilic' ~ :~F ~(;JU~'~' r~PQ:fi5ibi!lllty '~u)d, f~aii~. llD:U\,'

.F....."iij"""il -e:.,.,r ''''''fI:ij ... C~·~u;;, ~-fitJ"i"'E!Iii,.'i~I'I·fi;. ~"" '.", ..... t' ,"'.....,,~~..._"111 r~, ~njt.;;' .f;r.;r- ~'ir'"'+'I''''' .on", .I.L~!II;;;;;;~U,. F.~,., ~~,IlI~.· lll!l, .... -~ [I. ~l[-".-.-.,IJ,~ ~UIJ, ~ )"":/ IAI:I! .1;lrui ~_IJ ~~-'-lil lk.-U r-.-.- ..... I""~l~ lI .. 'ul1I 'L-llL_!Ii:r.. _~. ~~" •.

d~' id~ltifi~1lo:n rtrlllit (()f' ~m,(:!, (;'h'3fl"KlMmti,(l: ~~, aCMum [bilt ;O,th~r' 'mc~'bcn 'M 'theiir' poUPI 'hrave pcnonmlCid. It :~ ~' ~~t [OQ;lIoc~ ~9PJn·' i~~biUty (:~;\'.Il\d :nnt, be l~gjt~HlJatety' a.w:Filbed, I~ Ule' ab&efiOC 'Qf~ndril.lFin,g IdleD,~~ I1jfjmd](J.J:l N'~nhileH Ith~ [O'b~ot "'i1!am~k:. M ~"l aOO~n ~ iJlmd [O;tl~' at 'rIi~

. ., - - .. - _r., •. " ,."\ _. "I' - _. "~J~" • 'lao' _. . - - "l ,y~ . . .. ,... r. -:l _. .1 _ r. ,. ,.

,(';:Q:lltdLi!lirOns ("Qime'ly~ ,emdurios id,en'fi(a!t~ou} of eQ(Uiective' Rs:po:ns'lrb:iU~' nl[!l$t ~ .5tiilllipbJu~d f~m. ,~~!b ,()'th~~~ ~veQ, if' tb~t .0(;:0'- t~Ib~F.

:By '_y of' Mal~'~, ;C:Qmp-e dli~ 'W1jm, l~pl fe5.P'O~iiiiblil;~W :£01';, i~~'~, :f:QJuw·, del:':. Th~' [[lbj~C!t. 'M I~.pl :R's,poIlJsibi~~ty ,is t~h.e· mr~lFd~~ o:fi~ 'C:O:Rdlilfion of' ~£'

~ • _ a, ~' 'I _:1 ,_ ibc _ 'I ,', ,. '1Il.. .. ~ ~ J!: ..J.' .oJl] 'fi'

iI.[fma-~E i~m,enlt. 01:: , '~i,di..., fcm;po:lJJSjju~!I)ty !is, iooiiili,g 0':: ~tln,u, :mlfiu. nlllli:

~'i..-:, ."'<'I·'[dLir~·,·,·,·,,·iIi'.: "··d·. ~~'i,', :', '''',''it,' '>,'1 ",' ., ','" iii ...... : 1,',,·'··· .. · .. ·,'~''I.. .. '·t'W!'r-lt:''. lU];e, "".'!'!.'O ,Mle .. _l!I!e......~n'!O;~ ~, ... _" =50 a gm!ll.esq,u'C e;I:'!I"4l)F """ .s~,p:po,~ ~JIa:.,._IIa:!Io,,IS

'" :i.,,·~.AI· • d·l· . ..1 '" .,'L. 'L. .. '" '" Ii. .~.ii '"

ilM,O~I,~, :I~l :posse SSlIf;t-8' a 8O:~jJJL m)I!ID~, liS, Iui,e' sa-m,;e ia\S W,r.iat :15, n1!ml~~, I'_~

m'jWvd~r:. The ~:f;' ~ej Fl)f' 'tihe ,~m;dUrlJt'ig ide~~6c3ltio:n gd. '~e ,evilW ,actini'l,

ff"ol" w'bri .... 'h .... """'Ilp; .... ,~,_ '.,_'"'riIiilln.,ib~·~~l'tv' ~"" ',,"C!E"ni.~.:I '~ ... .,._ IS n"" II"I' .. U ....... ~"""' '.,..._

~'V_, .. ~._:~=~J '~~cL~·~~~,1W ~-~~,r:~·_!~!;1!- -'. _____}____~,.,: ,~ ~~ ~~or. ~l ~~._~ ~ ~, ~~~ [~-~~,.~~:,,-~ ~-~-

~;p<ll~fb~U,ty 'wiltho.U!t [iC:f:tdufiQg id~i1lihficilitio~ (gd, Ir:t: ~,'Qo;l'iitiii'iJU'C' 'to ~l!iiP"" n.i'l'5@' 'MtMllt tb,e· ~x,@,rd~ air iUIiU:~:1l0mr'tiC~ [~dlwd!twh b~~i': ~ nur

r'-" .. , .. ,. - - . .. I - I., • _. • _ _ ••• _. 1 _ f. __ .,} [II _ • _ • _ . . ,~, [_ r. ,. ., _ t. ,~

'L. ild' I [ .. ·.~'II" .... ~!""''' .... ~. ':' """""po, ~iI"iL:-""" '''";-r..'r' ':i"'" '''i!'ilf end L·,·'n·· .... , '8:'.,' '1·":iI~~I~i~iiif,c·"',· .• ,~ .. ,~ h·"·l.,t '~"'1i'r ~'h, ... ,

[[1 11 ...... """ '1!!io!"''IiIII:~,,, .• I'!v.I! ..... iI"""'UJ"" ,I'Uo" lJIll,,,,,,~, l!U-,~iIc u_, u .. ,iIl.lI,II;;,~iIOlIi.lIl'~OUU''''.' Ul, .Ii,,,,,,", , 'Il_ ""

'. ~ .'

... ·.·I]~' ... ];0:; ,; [', ["1';t.~:' .• 'it.. "[ ..... [ ;i-...,. [, , 'I"'if' rh .. "I [ ... "'.'1 . C '"i"1..: "I [ . 'I ,it, .," .... r .. ['.: ",v, I[ :I'l~ ',iii'

e¥Ii., at:lyOnS "'.1, OUller m,emU'!1;.FS O,L. ["ue~r poup., ,I, u~U" a.lll!!IIDn~mlr OO!ll uno, ..

be a I\eq,w1Rm,e~~. of ,th~, a:etj;O(n~ ~~ spLlmall .an d '~.e:mpo,mil, d~talll£c'

'm ",;i.,~, I~'L .... ·I'r' ~ 1lI;un ii...~ ,.,..., ......... jt· ..... 6"".,.., '1'1' '""j'r1iii!"i ;00"'1 b· 'It.., ,(""~'I']' "" ... ",i "'e ........ Il'iifl ..... ",'Ii.. ~ ~ ·1·tiIl· ,",iii... ""........__ l ~ __ 1Al_~ ULt~ ~ 1 ~nJ~·"-v.I~ll:_lI~~I~I. 1 u,lKIJ_~ _~_~LI r-~~- I_ .l~r. 1IkN, _ ,"_;~~i!l!- . IJ ~1J!,r.,lI-~I1,I,I- J~.i 1JI.j_1,.~IJ~""':

[Qilie n~ed n,ot :~Il~'tve '.c exercise ii!Jf: i~um~LfQ}\",

'Th.e: l~t :l!ifbe,raJ, :~~.roi\l~ t~, ,~, [cgn:$ide:~ ~!ilIlte~ Q:R the q.U~$'tlQn il)f :the 'p~ti:W. i~pnC3!tiDiIJ 0.[ h .. oL{1iin,g [pCo:p]~ 1~(llbre~Iy' .Rs.pDiIlsibile. Sup" :pose :l':cUI' th~ :5altc of iilfgiHm:e.1U, iibat, c~ntem,ve: r.~pct:l]5ijbili", ~s, ,uOd~' :35-' ~~It~d, t{), ~ndMd~, ag~,U. 'What ~ '&e ~:!3.pll\l~bl~~ty, ,req;mFC' tthe-m~ 1t,h!!,i'I;" ~ri'tiC5;, [UT dti;clir'J[u,d,~, w' ~lD'~' ~Sb;ould m~:!C agmiu 'be '~Wlim,ed :101'

.~~i..J ","f~' 'i1ii...,·'''i>'!I:!, ' 'i:.,"_' .~~ 'I'l,~~,~""""",~? 1j~':'i!-~'"' 1.:~:n) .. ~, [~~' 'l!lii· '. ,'-', 'l'iI'''!1-m··, '~'n'"' 'o:ii1"1i'.'.I]·~ '111-~ .. "'j~ 'nllll_lW'~ W~l-,." J' J~M'''-,"", l _ IlUI!II. ~;-'!i.I.'-ill.I~1'l -"'f,Il_M-t-. ll'jj.l .. llU uu; r!U!.II!I- _1i:I_~IUII __ , ~ _ Jll !J.1'!\!I.!U_ J.Jil ~ iAlrr.r-·~

.' r!J ~ ~

:~~' And wliJat :~ :mtx~ :puni •• oe[[llt ~Y'Wta!f? 'i'8 'it ~ythiin--! miOfe' th~

:bav.iIng' d1~,;proving dfuildn~ d~mded ,at oneself?' h~hihme~~ 'M~. teettt

:io ill ~i'b .. , ~m{:; ·c'_ ,Him-nil i~nHi, ,'[, ;t-..~ '~n'~·:~,~" :;'--:;(j'j-'; :-~-, ,,;I: tn:- [e: [~[~ .'"F;.]-!ij _

=~. '~~i ~_~ ~,pJ1~J(L~~U;L~~i __ ~ ~~ 00; 'ut:. m.ap,p:mp~~at:e1' a:nu =CFe mo~iU u_:t-

app~: WD~l11 'k' iiilieff,~t1!la!l n:am.~aI!l~nl!' Urbe:l~ab, may Ithe~t\fie ,arp:e'

[·I!:-·i"Ii't'. ,i, •• ' .. , 'l!-·i"IiiIl.(l' '''00iI: ;iI''"'''''' IL-'~ •• Ij;''''~ ! ........ ~JP· ~~"'fI.' .... :"""f" if" ~ ~It"""l'''~""" ~\i!!ii''i"ifi'r;o-'~I~'~~''1\iLr 'i'':~:I,'ll..:J ~,.,.,. !U,!I-"il! n;"",,~ .. !I/oV' ~'!iiilll,vu ~llIi~ -'~l.;, lIi.lI'!.ZU Y .. ~UIL,""",",!Ui'!l'''''' iT~~,.,._t5_llDJ'IiI"'I ft'U1liIw,


. . .. ". ,. . 'lI"~~ ...21 'h-..nlld~i .' 'L,! ." , ~.·i]~ ... ~ '" .. . ... ··io:: . ~-- .. ·t ,~.L. .., d'l •..

KiI"Ve' 310" ~praCi"~ ena ~~.1~-'~- .perl!dli,p! ~ .. "O'Wil!ll1 !it.l1w(';5[ ~ venl QlI!eu: [~lSa'"

'1M'[0N".:iJ,

Ii·'

The tr!@[Ply' is that the :~ria.l :Iign:itl,€'mc:e· of .m.oni~ :~spons!liidnt)''-----,

'b1""~i~ :'I'i"Ii'~~'~'~i>;o];[1 aad [ ... ,.·.;111..,. ... ·~~'~ ~"'~j;l1 i"~m. ,~'Ifr!'];'" o;ib..,. t:I"'~Il.·:I;·. 'tiJi'h:"",,1 'all'"!'" U'!.!J!W:I. ,!lI."l!JIiI·~·,.~J'I!HIIO, !R~iIo.. I!o..'V ... """'I!u1U,,,"·~ ...... ~ iI·~'!Ir.'" 1 •• 1'''''''' .... , '!I"I!'II""", !.i.!U""", '"'"!I)""''' ,II;;]! "' ... U .. ~ ....

·held. !f~!l~Jbl\c' thoem~~ ~~, [;i,ot hll what i~, dnnc' w, ·.em. ~n1J fie.:s,ponsibl~irlJ' is, u :in.waxd m8in~r mld,~ in ,thY. uspect.~ ~It d)ilff~rs :Fmm I~,pl 'OT' Qm'Cia[I·Fes.pon~hili~,j, for wbicih ~temaiJ. san,(:ll&on~ ~ readil¥' a~ta!blte,.

"j;i!iIi... '" .A·· ".A.,~~iI '1.. d :,~ iliIi·' ·" ... :::11· 1 .. 'I

"~ill!l8it U~uM.wUdJ. :l:pml!liS, Ougld: lo ' n .liIt OOJilb:bWli' :~5pong~.II~~' .. :tI!ma:~~ 'T

'befa!J~ thc~~, b, ito ,~krl(J.wlted.p lit

The' acbowJedgme:ot of oonte~tive rc~~ti~ibiJhf ~ :n.Q egy ~t~f

iIi.·~·~~·~I;t;_ '1~1i' '~'~ .. iIi;t;;o];,'IIIu' [r..Ii .. n'~~tIi.,. l:l!Ii, .;g, ...... ~""'., ... , ini'Ii .... ~~ ,"".M .. i'l!; jlil' ~ ... ~~ .. ::iIi~"tIi., I ..... ,;uI4Ii, l~!~ l}':" ~~:_II"" [.I~~ILlI~ ._~~ 19 ~.j~~~ ~"'ll'UIlm ,..,~ll_,,_8r. I;~ ~~m.ml ';~!II~w. ~'~_"_

boll i~b·~,~~l,:·~,·d1 wr .'~,:,' I,', i~'ha!~ Ib~·. [Ird· I ·tc:;~,···, "ralF;i,:,'c: ,'Il! _it, I L.cm5e ,vcs an .. ne ,gnJ~p it~.!t. ~M ra 31. ",ur:m_atllve ~~_um(le o:~

m~~~ :mtl~ :i.d~Il~. ~ '~~ •. gW.~d. by ,th~ WfDn.g :m,i):~, ~iu('.§ .. T(), ~

iL'~i"~'I..;;."'~~ [.:1:.11• oil' ~ .. , ,"""to: i"1Ii-lfrild': ~oi'1oI,:".:I"':W'Iil··""'.I ~1j1i; o;''L.~i; ... [~ .~ .. _ ""'I(Ii·d· I , ,. J'·.I.' .. t 'iIi"'''li''''

lJiil.l_~UH1IA:l}~'G l_.iIL _-i:I! ~_IJ! ~~ ~_"J~ iJ...!-IY'LI!.rUI'!U,~_IJ,_I_ j [~l ~_~II !WIlb':;'IJ_ll '-IP."~I. -J'.-.~ !Ai_IJ_". _, II::II , .. ::..~!l.l ll!-~,Il

w'b '(>:r' [mall, a OUOifIJ'[ ~l1!t for' pan ,of what .t!hmy ~ [(~~ :Ruroma 1194·).,

,Ollie [mi,g'ht thilllt, 6alt: s:w::tr.l a.ciknowle:dgm.ents wuul{J D,ot [Ott:lllili '~tarU5le' w.(i· .(!I~ wh'(), MaiI.nrr;illlJ aD emdlWr1iH,g' :id~flJMltalt&Dtl. wiJth a :g«J~.P' d~~' ~~r 'va!iIlllGS, :I"ro. '~e: ~~p!, 'flttey ~'bU$ harve n~ other. w1ues, '0\11. 'the '~i3 of wbkh rt'h,ey [could. ()O'Jlcl.e.m1l thee' '_1~e5 0'1 '~e.i!r iP'u;p. But till! iJ8! ~O't :;0 '16;:-;: fWO ''C;:::' --;en'" ~'I-t .t:Ii~IU,\S a'R 'mf:m'ben O'f m~Il'!I;!' O!',OO'Uin.c,.--;on.e ;I!nd the

. UI' .... .~:iISO ... :5: 10, ~,~ . J. ... . ..... , .. - .. . ., .. ... .. 1 ~ J ..... !I:"_ =.... ... " ., ... "

mme peno:f][ [!ElY be 31n ,Am,e:~'i! a, Chr~.thu~:; aJ. phy5idmj, ;md an ,om~eF .()f Ih~· lJa;~d 'tl.itty :may ,cri!li\d~~ .t:h~ va:l!ucs of on.~' o:f ~~, :~~P1ltfi '\'iilrujc'h *ey.' 'k'!qng fmm dl~ :~LQ.t '00 view' [O'f 'the valJue~ ,of ,g,g,the:r' pg:Ujp w' 'wJl1~(:ih ~.ey HL(j)A;g· .. Seool!ld,. b~c~'u.' Wj):ra!l :pUip5 .ar~ ~lldum 111:ojl6;

1ii·~<'L." b' ·m. '. ii..~ •.•• I;' ~~iiI 'I f: ... 'i-.

!llillli!l~C'," it .; e [(JjUCstIlO'DJllllg !mil;)'" LQ.¥Ol¥1!; C11!tI,'(:l!Z!l~g;a, [c,eg~~ ''Y3!_iUC ;()~: iy;,C' PU:P

by a.:PJKilIin:g to oilb~f ·c~n~l v:ildtu!i.s [of [Ili;e ,~m~ F[ouP"

The f~r. '~~m,~i' h~·e'r, '~~t ,a)Jthoqh ~e' ,~bt~~elil!~ ,~14t~'ld, ·ot,(:lJl",. powenw, d,el:~nsive' :('On;;es staDd EIll lilts, ~', Comins '~O q~oti;oJil. ,(OCm,cei'~ :l1IJIond ide!I!Jtilty o.petil 'Illhe door'~ ;~lf~O:fideml!i!il!ti.fin~ .hi~h b a d8IFt;-,

'd'I!'ij'if"i'.'" , ...... t: ~t:-rl ~ ......... lt;:;a1I. ~·~~ ... "i"i"i" .... I·~1Wi!' ""'fi¥;"~q"'~"""1''''''''''!''", ~i: .. , [""1';0];"" .Itr-.~. ,A.""'''''' I~,-.;RIJ V!IIAoi:I! ~!Ir.. '"lr,IJl_.ill r-'·~IJI!Y- _ '.:-,. UIIW!il!U IUl~'_ l~-~ '!UU"lILI_"" ,~~!II!1!~-"iP~ .Ii II_iii_I]! ll:'_._~_A!~ ~ 'V"ll~I"""

,~'UiT..QC iQf' [th~ ~Lu~~~' l'O[ .~bow:lted.p· ~~. I~Wma.q ~f oo'~~~dlvt :~ ,s.pondb'iiU,' •. Be dial: a! ~t, :macl'" 'Ike aikn~Jedg,megt [0£' oon~:clive.' :res.ponri"il~~ f,i:,'(C,;s[ .(h:.; ~11e51i:on '~ibe~ 31f:\"e Ukc:t':: m ill. ;aiOOoUt ins :ncliicall. :M:!.

- ~ ... ~ ~o=ce e ~,~-~--- ~.- --- _= - ---- ~¥ -- -~-. -- - --- -~ iP- --- -- ---- -18

n~'C!llfi(iti.

"11"1.. • Ii' 'i...~, ;o;,L lk!n '1 d' f 11 tu '"hT"

rne .aJt1:5We1! to :lit.. ~1I· tt~t iYie' ac~~w·w=~.'.,pne.fmJt. iQ'"./ [C'ooce..e re~p():n~u:I' ilty

~ilIV(J~ iP~'Ii~nc dl5CL\Q~u~t tdl~ f~lin:g ·M.~~t ~d. :~tI, ~ppm_,-mti£ @Xfl'@~ .si1(}l[~ the [der [gof .~h. oompcngtinn. ,g :h :poM~ble" ;and. the ende~:r' t>Q[

;. ~iI".'; [ ~: .... ~'.[ '[' [ fifl ~..:II~:'~. IL,t 11[~1~ ~ "Il".,..~'1;.. •... ·fil!-·. "', iLo-. . [. ','".' ;·4 .. ,. ;I.,)i .. ", ',' "', ·;..:.~ ... ii mil~rBil lIllil.C .p:oup \!J(;ullIC!M Ii ~~,~ ~ ,~Iill 0: . IolliC!K: ilia!!! (iOnSluCl13mC .P:~~'

sJpl'ifi:ca!lltR'.; The' [d!I~n ,0£ [th~, :ftmeu[ 00f' ,~l~;Iii:QWl~enlt :~J\d""


,C:cl)n:Of~t~· ~xa:mfl~, WihiCJh. are bound Ito 'be' oon~oremiaIJ, Tbe general piJDJl~, :lrtow~r" dees no:l; di!peind, ~~ 31lli¥' fW1i:cularr c;xarmpfe, 'Thox' 'fA3it.

t"':iilil,~.~ :' -!1;-1""',,;1111 ~"" '.~ - I~,""~, ,~- :"~I"'r."'.~I",i, ~~,,' -, ,,-,~:L.:::.~ ·''1'';];1";'" ,,,; .. , ~"fo'ill """'1""1" m, iI'~, '~~f !liQUOW ~!I.!;lII~"IlI. II,lG 'l!.I."",:!1~ ,35 IU~UHI:J;U.oms n£ll}~~ l!lIlIou II!Ia ,.uAl!'<r.;-dlI, '!Or __ "'" ~ __ ~'<!\i ~~,

u~t; of them ®u£:ks ~1iJJ 'the ~~\r. iO~jbers are readily' awi1a'We, 'B'Ult the 'eJ(~ pJes, ailso, serre t~) ~tren~c~ the ~ :folt >ODlJ~~' :1fe~.~~~ibUi!ty 'by $'b.(i'W'B

'I" iO<io a, il'b'.I~"' •• ""'Oj!i;'" ;I·~ '~'''''II·;oI"'''''1 1'1'),.;." '''''oI·:k'I~1~'IL~4Q':r:>';'>''''''''iIi'. :''''1 ,~'I!re 'r'"Q'bt. !"'''''I~ng to do., '~LI~ ~!t;"""'-U,U;II_Ii_1l! l _~1., '!l"II".I~IL I'!I..LI~IJ jlft) ~ _ -" t"V'-n·~~!!I!H~i1!...l.~l' l'_~ u-~. ~I~' U~ ".' _-_ _- __

h'bUc ,iiKlosYil;e b ,a; mOIlle' or 'l~ :fb:~ :~tat-emeJj.'t. 't,. ~me' 3'urthut:IJt,a.,· ,~, tre:pu:se:n~tlve of a. group dll;3!t. the smU(p ~Sl n:sp<JllIslhle ''OF dl~ cviJJ .ail: be, 'K~,1il! (iliu~d" 8lJ.ib ~ 'the ,sU!fieme~t :fo!l in~c<e" iO'f the :R;ugi~. I" ':.- ,', ;,~' :,~. ~'I[-''''~'''''I~- ~ ~j~~~-,-f~ m-:-:--~raII ~jknl!L~,J1 Po~iah [D~iI2-:ts"at K,afft.!i;i'i

;g'OVem~erh, ',rllid!!l. U!le ~e_= seve~ _!I!IJ ~u' - __ ~~._,1J:I!~e:~ - ~~~' -~-~'1'.'"

~, djO:ii\~ 'by d'iiC ~ ,~y" m,t'bcr ~halil1 by the Nuis,j! ~ 'bM been [aL~~' ~~g~d, 'by' ~, s.uc~~nI\l of ,~et 'lJfficds. OJ:;, tOI ~ll~te, dl~' ~e pjirmJt 'by dIe :nu!~:r:ally offeocsi,¥e bCk of pUblic dliscil!l8U1fC"i ,co:uiti,eF the 'm~lI.\·' ,o~b~e r-e~. 'o-! the 'Tlt!lr:kim, g~~eIillt to' adgt m~' T:-lWr~$'h g~cf'(i of hrm,e;nii~m1"~, 'N~dii~g 'CatD. ~~dQ lthe' p~ ,eViJj, 'but :p1!!lhllie ,di;KIQS\n:e i~di:-· ¢a~8' ,a~oepta1i1i~· of f.(iS;J?OIn~ibiUty f~F it. :and, m~ :f'~pr.~n~ mi@' :fi:t::!t iSl~iPl t.-o·~d ~»__g' ame~." The' ;acti;o~ <lf the' :R'U~~ !g,mre:~!m,e!IJit lis· 3), m;o:ral promi5e'~ where~ 'iiic iIriiaoWltlJ '0'£ ~b~' 'Tu__J,':k'i~. ~'~~Il'IlCif~~ C.~Ce-f;'~WiS, ~~ :mD;~l'QuJ~ a!I__rem,y !('J!Jmmttlted;,

Pli.lblk disd~Fe mou!ld. roe' ac-c.--'Om:parmri,e!CI, '~th tbe' :ftt11~tag· of re,gr.et a~ul,

;"Ii'," "''V'n-",,,,;;n-_ 'i'-.~m-' ' .... ~-, ;-r;;(' ,'" iilJ'''o-r<1i~'iIll ~1I!t';-r;;"'I~1 I"i'"lin~ ~'''''LS;''i' 't'~ . .,. ,.,.,,·:IL.' .... "', ,~f ~,'h ... l J!In1I ~~r.-1I ~~-"'V"ll!l._r. ~lr~~. __ J~ll'~ ~'l A ~'_]'~~iC ~~~ML..u. ~IIJ~'~U' IUIl_~~ ,_t~.. ~P~~gI! ~~ l~

gmUiP' h~,~' l'ed :to 'the ,~~ thai has, been dO'me~1 and, :lbe)" sb,auld, say ~l :p,uib'Uclr, '1'1' :memoon! of' tlIe Ameri~atn M~d~tail, ~~tiQ'n g~nu.~nel~· ~-e' 'tEa'r, 'C"@,liIillJtl~M, Am.M,GWi!!l, are 'WiithO'tIIl; :ad~qWl!~~ 1111,~d)i:cM care, Hm. :tlloU,lh. ~b 'Ca:R ~~ availia'lltle, Illhe~ 'they ::~ih~~ll(l ,ex;.ll~:r~ '~cirr' :regret fOf pafli,:cipart·, ing :~p a "ri~e,.Jbd.' nl.:Qnt)plty:i mi)ti:~l~ ~y by 8~"~~ 'w:hikh lis :3. m~jrOF iC'g~mh~t1~I' :fa;ctn:!l' W 'die '~f;t~ 'mat,~ bc~1l1 dg~e, ''The :f:e~i!l!1 ood, £xiPrnssio.n 0:1: :[\¥et ~stab~~h. :3, pc-~na!l C'Omrl1;K;(iGi\[i, 'H~'~fi. i;fi,dM,~, U~I.~fi't5, ~d iIh~' ,~W a;cl1lull~ Ih~t :h:if~ ~~.~ d~~t~lk ~p:~i):n~

f th vall f ~ , Tilt e' M '(I''' '(I 'I

'0': ': I.e 'W:Ffillg ~;' JUleS, '0: '['eif:" :gR"rlilip. ~.I., Ie ~ofi;ll~oUOn R:5 -, '0:0, :I'£t 'l"V1: Jl!I3. .

;:.iUe~;"';' '!w.'If..;n; .... ~m, ',,", r""", '.i.iljil,.;I\-~~ ... ;n...jl ~'j..giii' ~.'j..Ii'1j" 'ito,""'!'-':"" ;·'4e:m1iiJfi; ....... 'wJj"'!"t ~!'L ... W'ri'N:tiit7 ~i""!Il~~ '~'H~ ~~. __ I'" l~ H_Il!ll-~l .. ti!lw:HI~~' ~~~,~ ~_,. IL~~ lorYl. ~~~~y .'~~~~ ~~-'Iirr w·"·~·~~l=~l

wJ!ue:5! md. that tb~ '~.oo' w'O'uild have. beea 'Ilead m (;ai~ e.\i1 h.'ad ~e~' bec~. :m[ me' ;~PPro.~te' $iiJ1iLlaItlu:m,,, 'The e:Xp'Fe'5.'!Ili,oD Qf :~t :~ th~s, on behallf of'

'iiiih-" ... ii,., '0',-- ~"""-~ ;·I·~_mr~~I:v· ,A,:~,.:I ~(k .... iII";IIb,,",'b'~I;a, _ .... O'[I_iII.'i:I'1" ... 1'1'''"' ~iIi' ':~a' ~~-4i [~'i:.., .. ~_ l ~~_.l - -n',IJ.J ~IUIi_.-U!ll,"iII., l "l.iIL ... ~.~. Urwll. ~]!lIl !II:[lr'!i.oJl ~-!IJII_.!IlO~"" ... nn;F'"l' ~-~_.~.=.l ~,I; [lilY ~ ~n~_ITU "'.Ill .....

'~--_-ln'iljo;" oji;or- ":''I,-oi!!~if ,..:It...,.<'F ..... ~4I .. _,i\.. C"W.!l,..ofI;, 'iI[-,..-:-, • .t~ --IF~:'::i' .... 4i I-~Il ;,;,., ""I :i',...,.,,~:;.~I~·_

,F".-.- ..... ,:r-,l~~ .. ~IJ W~I~II_IJ U:~~~~_~, u i.llillLl!O.l!liil! .. , .. '11~lu ,1J.tidL"-tio ~_I/~-II.~!llIl 19'1!"IL UiiJI! o· 1 •• 'tift:IIW_W~~l

A iIi:.,~ ..... L 1]' -.f? ,o.'1i.. ~_;i.,~ 1 dOl ~~. 11 - ,I, lh 'll{ . m

~~J;~[lllCif"-,-atlet Q'~ 'Y!!e ;~!tQW=e!.im,e~~ 'Yl ICOJ_!,ec~' :re:J.PO'II!S~Lily is I~Le

,offer of oom,pcmmti(l~ '~O tb~' viiolilMS, nf Ih,e lJiroup.'~,!!!, 'wrom.;g' ilctioll'S. T.btis is ,a ,~o:m,lL~d, matter {~f' ~~ r.~~~!!!.., ,h :~ ;Qfct~ .~Pl~ble [toO' :rlIndJ Ic'am~Q;_~om that 'wnuld. be CO'c_IiJ1___m,e'll~'I.U!illte with ~,e ~.~de~rvedJ ~~ '~at :~ '~~1fJ! oone, Th:e' ,~WIenQ,p, of th~, Vi,(;ti!m~, of' ~f.~ ~f :irnn~' 'Cie~t :pe~p1e l'"dtl'O' ~gt the be!it'yeag of'thd'r HVCI, • 'C~IIU;le:!]'intio-n, cBm:P'J 'Ooj" the ~'~'~ ,0[' (If illhQ$l!' w'h.,o, :m~-e 'becn dl~M, mild, :litlMIU3i~,


dlro~ltoiUIt. tlIeir 'ti¥cs,'~ ~ f'CD afQm [of' _me' b,l;atk.~ail pn;:j;u.dJoe cat1'not be red~med ~, a swn ,0£' molll~'~ ,es~ial"" not if:' it 'is a!',jveD to,

• I ••• _.. •• _ ••• •• __ ,~,. _ ••• _ _ _ _ .' 1 __ - . _r-';"I!I ."- '-r'~c--- If _ i" ••• I _ I I I ~ I .. _ •

theiill' [~d;JiJ1!tI., Nor d. ::nu;:'h [c~g~~o:n as g[ ofIe~ ~, be

,""",~;r;,j~. [L.~ ... ."",.: ..... , .JL.",,!, '~~~"""IE, ,._.' '~i'i'!!!I"'i~-@'n''''~";'''I~)I': [m"''''' ikl·:·_ ~ .. ["i""!'Il,;,.~",..'"i". 'r~, !IIM..-~I~~-""~ ~~ U],~ '",n.,.~_.:._1riJI! 'U'tl. W_lI~'\L _IJ ~~~~ _ ~_IJ~ 1 __ .81," l~ ,1,L!l!LIJ~:~LI)ll ~

~ ~.~~. ,",'i;...~"ii" '~~~~~·~~~I~"""'~~'· ~~ ~~n~iL"i'itv ""/1' iri' .... ;i... ,<!j; .... t..;iIO~!n noHi....... Th' -:-'. ~~~. ~i!\iO

(:~ l~lC:1i1, ,~iGIC;iiE)u ...... n! ~:r...",; ...... lUl!tll .. s ,I!I'~, :~~u :. ,,,,U~I!I',F !F:iIi :'~~"!' , ,~-.e ~ ~

good RiDOllS '~O Ihiim~ dt«aol!@:J that th@· [Clnm~matiio:n m.olilild. 'bit ~ 'boU:(;, MJ' :appe~ce of DelR-'8' :~d !QfF~, bar.pi~Q'in8' ;Ioout, oonsolenc't' :m.onq~ (J1' (::(J~JtribuQn,g 'm the '(Qrg·eu.il!ll: ;(If' the' [evil 'that ~, '~~n dnQC

... 'ItA ,~','i.. 'ih..' b ... ,~ '.Al~...i ~., •. ~'L·· ii.",.']'i:. " .. . .. " ';;;::" ,~,', 'L .... , ,~:L ....

WOU_m ~ere~,t ~ aml.~!!j,iI!" [~.~JI! ~uv.~.C (lompen&a!lll!on ilia)? ~ 1i!.I~C: ,Ute--

~~ ~.-, ,=r. ~ ...... ,'".; ... _~.'II 'L .... ~i,A~ ... t..~ ,~_ .. ~,~.- =It , ... '_,~·_i,~_ ........ j; '~ .. '--,:il:a.-"l~~ :au:on 'UI a lIiI.dOUU.l:'1iU .D.JuI ....... s» ~' 'iElJ""!G'uon OJ: :"" ,IiIiLOiliil'llJiIJIi.L""lIillL,I' ,0:., ,1J"1~":""""':'.r

Kheduled :meetiinp, oomm.emonUii~n,llh,c' vlrums:., Oir' it. llil'!tay 'H' dI,e :Iteadf :,olitic;a), ,and m(J~ ~pp>ft Qt' th~· pnu:~ ro' wb~ch. tb~· vi~~ '~lotllpd, '~ th~, ~Up' Df 'lb~ mLtd~~ N~~diil!r ~.txJUc 'nor 'actlflii'~ [[;o:mi~"~l1isalljO:fI!

~1 ----_ ,1!!!Ir-"~- ", ... _1 _'_ . , .. _._·.~l[" ,- . - - I.I'I' .... ;.II- -._ •. -._ •. _"J - __ ·-_"'·-10--.-··_-_ ,"_

- - . - .

[t~" ,~f" (;i)~~ re:U~' [~g:IiI~e~ r.~ntiJbiJU,ty" I~t :i!t ~ ,a~l~:[i;DWJedge' '~U;,

'bmdlEn" ,_,d, dmn,g :!O :., .aJ, :mllmi, dE'bt '.31t 'drI£ gn:n!llp itlf ,mlild.MD ~ tOI me' FliP ,of:~u, '~~fm,

Th~ 'nt()!il dVe(;i; pra.Gti~aJ bn~pU~Hlt&Qn, ,of tllt~ at"kll,owl~dgll1(:nlt (iF: ;GQU~

~T~ ~ftffln·."I"~bil]~']i~tv_ b- '~.~r·- ;"I'iC': , .. ,'L.~ ,J3l!I'Od-.-~~"'!IlJ'O!1il" ,t,,,,,,, ~,.~~ ,~,'L..'!!i 8 "i"'1ii',.:ft_ ~~ ..

U:'-!Iii- iI ~'~~i = ::iII_ I • ~ __ illi.}"l!! ~ rVH!!Ir."!'p-!IWri I[_!I! l _!iii !Ii.I1_1~ ~'i.~I,. I'!WlMl'P.'!!II.",ll ~ .. ~JI~lIll~I_II. UlI~ ~.ILV.~r.r.~J ~ 1I]_~~

- ~ - ~

,mqrm!f-a id~nltif}'ln,g 'iliGi. 'HOD,g Vi11uC5 'that, milti¥8i~ ~, ~I ,a(;cinf:l\$. :~

,so.nable refOl':mJ is; e~uemC'~y diMwlt 'OOCai~ the' vail'ue;tlil ,~f ,ai smUiP are' ~! .... ~o;dte'n.i!'!nde:ll!l' oJ' 6""' .. · another- 'Valu:es no:r.malikr f'Ol'Il'l :an 'mteroo:n'"

~~-__'.'-~.T r_1 <_ .:._llt·~,,'I . .:._.:., ~l ,..:._1", .... ~ . ',I,._,-'_I:_=:ol •• , __ ' ,_,:_', ,'.> "":_"1' I .-" ,,~~, ' __ I" 'J __ ':'~'.'-_ I

in . ·~t\il>~ w'h,1.·. ~ . "d :""liIi-.i; ,~iIi~:n .~~',~ iFWiA' ti' ..... n~ .. ~.". '~'~-C_~iblliil ~'k.-~, ---::h,'T'it ~~eel~~, __ ,~~o~ej' ~_, !M~Falll'l!on Y'~ a r""""'''' '",",~~ """'" ~!!i,';~,n~R~ II-Ilmugil'ouli.

m,~' whcQle. W~g '~)U~~!' d1ef.~()-r~, [~~if1(tt, ~ ~m.'lj' ,~e~.d, [or [~

11 _.:i. Ii _. h -C~' ... -~.... '" tb - ~ ..... Ii • ~~ ~ii-. - ~ - ~~ ... , •. ~iliu ,. 'i..~

,cnm.srw ~or :ng_:__:t O~e5, .. ,.jL~~p,----n,g_:,_,-e'!'t!M~ [Yl '~~je' gI1.oup 1~_I!,7':linlVO!!~~S:

,c:JhiJil;t;ifI'i:t\1.T' the: ~nip' AJld tnl'; nUl'5Uon '~:O!II~ w'b;~dtu' ~~R\ WO'1!Il1~ 'N'

.~- - :~-~PJ"" ~ - ,,_ ~"~'~i .\'11 " - '._' - _. ''''_j _, _. -, , ." ~.n'iiiilt1':a! .. , _. -"_, I - [~. ,,_ ,I,.,. _. ..- _'

'en~ugih le.R m the' gIIoup alter' '.e crum,ge.s, 'have beea m_a,de, to OOHitmue' W' :$~p~Ft, di.~ m~, ~~Il'tiJt)'· oJ ~b ~'~. 'Wb~~~r nditro:naJI, Ja;pa-'

~ - 'I!hi!li - ~ - ~ - ,i. .~'I:... iii- ~,L - - ~ ~- - - ~, .. ,1..'" ~ • ..ii... - .. u, ~ - ,.., ... ;i. .... ii" -" --

nese [CAllI!,~n:' ~ ~ Wl:Yllo,\!IlIi, 'Il[~,ie' satmJ\!I1iU '!f:wiilCji wlilleuilCI1' ~uii;O .. L'CBm,

'is, Vciable '~,tho~t dl~· daim. iIhat it. is the o.nly' fioad 'ita ~tJiOth Whether ,an: eilCOOr\!'t ~' can 'be :malD,wned wiilboU!t. t'he mitle ama~rl:@' 'Ilbat

~ ~ ~ dim"" 't . ~ ~ ~

[.~-:-~.-::' I ~.~ .-~ ':-, -:-': -, ~~~. ~,~_~ .. ~ 1 [--:-,-:-c-. I--:-'~-'-,-_~ ,- -~-~: ,,-= -.." _ ["-:::~~ ~-. ["-:- ~,~ -_'-,[!I.-:- - ~, :~. - -~ -;-:--~-~--, - ~ .~-:- -_--:-::-,

i!:',x;(;Jild,ei!il, ~m~~ md gay fn-en ,a!r'Ci~~'-'---~'C~Ut. que~(!kg, 8enou, ruQ:m1i.,

h~~ :Feqmf.~ ~~ling 'widii, Ihem~ :and. [me ;silru,eK~e :d lib'Iy' to bc:' 'p:anicu'llarly '~g ~u.se iii; ~fieDl :in.~l~s, :iln~dlil'll I,gtJ]!U, :w Itn.JW

,ftI· .. ,-' ·1"""" .,1... .. . ..... , ..... : .. 1"" ... ·· ,.!'.,. " ·'·'n:it. . . .. ·'h .. ,,'II., . r' ",'II., . , .~. '11.' .. .,AI '~n' ,

~~lin8' WI,," U~@~~.!!!'U;aJ I:.HCY p11" ~~!i," ¢acr~ [O:g~'C'= I~~'C: ng-,~," ;a~,_~_; "-_;~B

ViaJlIi.in ~a-il 'C-O:H;!;t]tute :lhE~r :rnmF31. WiGti.'U!o/'.

:~r ~~ :~f~rm :b Ml' h~!, d\'C ackB.owJ~d~n[t. of ~~U~~· fOr. '5.l!W'insi'bin~·'~ 'm!l.lcb raRi[' IDO '~l [5'hould 'N'- '(!nl.h!ad [of"~tJlhti~ d!~lMur~

[ ',Ij'-~ .. __ ~J' _. [ , _ t _ - _. " ••• " _ _ _ _ I, ~ _, .. _ .. - ~l, .. _ -,. • [r-' - . I . .:J • - • - • _.. ,. J

.ere' :~ a (lQ'~pil"'3C1 m: s.i1~fl!O~i, :i~dl, of g-e;mfl~He ~m am;dj, i~ a",~

'" • .Ii.. • I'L. _I:: '" '·~,'III·' _I: ~'IL.

Illi'rmt~ ~XprnHlo.n. 'Ulttm 'IS ,31 [nJl0.ni~' !nTefm~ [UJ.' an ilmirt.::li1jUiEtI! '~ ,t.!J. :m~

,r - - - --_- -- _r. 'l!i _. _I I.. ~-- •. _I,,,, r'~"- -_ ..... "-----~~-- .".. . .

[cv!il lQ ',d"dd~ the' ~~," 'pm~:b!l, m(~iVc· ~path~ti~ 'iln~de~dk 'ir~G" ,ud .~, 'wcunu,!1 :!d~riimCft He' ~l~ ~r;. 'iilHtm '0'.f ~l'OOIJi~ or'

, ... ,.._ - I, • , - f.. "_ I ., - - " . _., [. - ;~~' ,.. ~ •• _.... • •• ~. - - - •• _.-.. • • • -.,., •. _. ••• •• "'

mt~j ~g.mpe:~tilO:f:h '~efe' :~ tll!k, o:€' iltieailinB'~' 'Whi~'~ Qfk-J1 me~s m~t 'tJbe


'Tih~' ~e:nt j\l$t ,c:(JQ.-clluded lQt, dl~ de:f'~~' 'm- I(iO!I!I~~ r., :s,poll!ri'bji~ty, :~cl, fof' '~e mm:al, req,mreme:JOO~ Q:j'~. acM~le~(LQ~ may be :fllTiind ~~smg' 'Gn:ming'~ ,~ lit, dac!!!l\!, :£ffim ,a: ,cnllle 'of 'W~be:~. Po:r~ as, :~t :b:im 'kt'.D :H;o:t'e~d ,3;[, 'the: ~n:1ngll :many I~'benil! polimiiiial p~ ,~e ,_{JtI~ted, by ~~l~ti.~, ~Il!il~h~tiity :iO:r ~t; .~~~a~Q:IJJ a :r:e:~,pon~j.. 'billifcv. 'wh~' ,HlatfiW:L't!ld~~emi't.I~~~ 'l!I~~~ ;-'" ~,t .",~~'~'~ be :mr;;c ,sail 'illilt '~e

~~r --- --- -- - ~ -- - - ~-gm- ~ - - -~~~-- ~-~~ - ~ ~ ~ ---.',P'O-- - ~--~~~ ---

,"-~nt ,~nlt, ~~nmJtut~ Wl, e~dO'~e:mrt or th~, plliiCiicai ,'~

"1'1"'.... . . 'I.. •• ... _iL,,_ .11 ~iI_::: .,

'IlItI!"am'i'liJ- ~,iL .Jill.! ,!!ili.l!lmin.t\SltlO'n - Il~r- '~ml5~11I! mu milBil~D!" -t 'RS~ 1--:; (fl ::.Iii

II!).-·--"-_. __ r. ~ I - - _. - - ;r'r-~ _. . - l!! I - .... !!I" - -,. - - - ,I - _. - ,- - -.-~Ql I. . _. 0., _. . I

:faibu:,~' lro ap:~irui:~' dl,~' in1ipnca;ti:QflI~' ,of tb~, ,~~~t. 'Jb m(lW tb~t, ~1:lis, 1.5, 150- '~t is 'nec.e~Ui;np ltD ooncenb,t_~· o:n ;a ~i.ti£ '1rniI\'i'I~rie.aJl 'iI:'\~,1:Gmi - :and

. . tr. ' . I • _. l - r ••• ", ··~·,I . - .". - . - - ,,[... .. - J , J "-r~~- - f •• JI"'_ - . - . r" -~ J . - -~. - ,

Ilb,~' 'P:~~~IUji.ail ~~Iim,MIt. o:f"blaCb md ~mm b, as, :~, ~, l~pJe as, ,artly.

'I,h~ pr~ in, qu:mtino :i! fi),gt ,QilBfmJa~ ~c~():n!, wli-ie'h ~~ toO' ~ .. , ,3!I'I!t~ I~t~ n~1 'qlld6EdI :~~n :~ !E-~~lllI.dcd, :Ff.-QID Ith~ ~1 'of ~d.I~~$, for seme ~l'o;n The '~~~ iis ltD dii5Or:irm~lila~' 'In, 'm:vttr ,of.m-mli: UlI~d'",

,,--, --- ,_, r.-~,,--,_I. , ,_" ,r.'~~."-.-. , ,. - _ , ,, __ ,_,.- i .. , ,'--,- .. I:

,da:~ 'o:n m'C' ~.wnd ~t 'tb~' 'M ;Ofief :mcm'bcn [oof me, po~p 'N 'whJcih, m~ belung b~' ~n, d)i~fijm~n8!t~, .OSI: :io, 'mri ~. One'j~~ti,oil

~;a...;;iit ,': ""~"" ,,' ' .... -_, - ~,'ilibe~:'. -;, I]~' [,iIi';,,", ': ",ii.,. ",,~ ;,', 'It_~""ii ,to:""!" '!i-:.r"';--~"~: ,., "i(i....-~, ': :Ji~ _'_ 'l,iUA1I- ,B Ch~n gI,reml '~," ,II] . ,ms: ,1ID:r SllilCu, p:rll:;,l!e:re:o!llllillll. U "",ii1iull,<!in,,. .l.S ~,u<!i t!OJIe4E

6ve f~;poQiibiitiCJ of th~, :'~Olt p~e~tl~~s of' Am,-eri~~s, r~T: tbe ,eVil 'ca'~d. 1:0 bllacib ~.d, wo:men, '~' th~ dlscnmiruajnu'l, ,~n'5t 'tb~fl'l fl'l pa.5t :p~,~liuns 017' ~ricai'i'.!j. Sim:_Uall' ~m~1iIit15 ,af.-e 'lilad ito j,w.stny' ,B'OliJipo¥r.

,·mtv,' n'd', '-,' '.'.~r'I: '-,' " ,,"-'.-'.-;'t-I-: 'iIV " ,',,',' ,: ".,' '_ , -', !lilli"--', ,.- -" -",~",- .. , f!l-.., "'''',",-~'',--, -, j' ',' "'d' I-.-:'·'~-=-

f:""":r a~ eq~ OP:PO"di.li[L~:1 p~r.atm~, &elliiuilll,1I <JjMIIi-iI.II.':I!!rut a~,i!!mut i!ii1J:Us--

,Hon, ,atnd '1l:tt:W11I;~ IO@;IlI'~~ :fum.,liIJ aid ira :§Om~ ttcO~U~~~S~1 ~:C' :1iC!iI1_iib.

UUO 'M '~rD~ ~d, ,~ fwth., ,BUll l~lt ~ .' wiith pfgef~Q'tia~ ~-ea~it. ,and ,atb~~ -tbat. ---:r 'b]~ ,nd, ~me~ l~~ve wffere:d, RiIi(Jm~, 'Ui.t1J--

co, ·'6e,...i 'L. 'i:..-~ ~£',A'" co, '. "~co, ., 'Il.,

.Jusu, Cu~ ,Illiial[,m, KCaiUSie' 1m: iiaiIKnmllJllaJla;on, ,.-m'll:. 'hiltm~,

Ttl ~ - ~ ~ ~ ~ i1 ~ - '. ~ Wh ~ m - ';'iii' '. ~ ;';, .. ,;;;;:A .:II iii""" 'tit -1..1 - ~ "': iIC' ,~,~:,,:C !f1g~!il.:_J)n D ':~~~e--,-ue:r ~~ ss J~~_eY! ro _,_:_:O~y!, prese.ll;,: :a,ene:~u,ons, CKI;'

~J I. ~

,,~.~ .... :rioi[',,"II1'iC': "".nIll~t;:'-k:' :->'!IiftOn; ... :;;Ih-II"", ~,hp 'P' .. ",.!Ii' ,~i~n"m' ~iOJi;"lt~..-.'"1" -"""ir"d' I '~'-r, ... ",;1 .... = ~____IL'~~L .. ,~~_i0.i ~¥'j-,~w~~-!II~I· !II~~!IP.-r-'.~I_t;y~, r'!l. It"v.-lII, ~AioiJI.' u_~_ I. _ .; .; _~_Ii_II_Ml-!I.I,U-!ll_~"-'I1 ll"'l.ll !l-_1J11IiP ,0 .• ;. ....

:5Wa' i!!l: ,th3it lit IS, :0101: '~l!l:K' ,d!oi~g im, :f3iils, I~j). 'meet :~raJ, ,o.f ldie oo~dr..


'tiQ;IlS r~U_~M :fctr tb,f!' JJ';'eti~, a!K:_rip. ti~1l1 Qf' ~o:Uec~ ~esn.iri,nlibiljj~:. "Ib,e.'

~O~. I _' r-~- ~,fl

fiI.~ il::Dnd~~Dfi rliliat iJt f3jh to 'm~t j~ dla~ ~,~, ;acUun5 :fnr ~w:hk~h .nY ,~

:liLeld, res;p<!1Jl'.!ilbl!e :mJ1i.I5t 'be !~n of dte (l~aJtaCl\eri!!iIi\C ;Kuwltles, of '.e' morail rgmu;p 'wid] 'wbiclh the)" have idJentilfted (tile' ~iXitb OOJltdhiO:ll; d.eKribtdl iu ~Dn, ,4,..:"2l. Ani adiI~t'¥',~~, :mnrni~ :gnl~P ii!l, (i~t~rbli( if i~ ~pr~~, l(im~ ,c~nb!l, '~I1~S, 0:[ 'thE ,glffiUP, and ~t d!if.~tIy :~(dl1iJf!fi~~ mce ~KiiR o.f' the peQ;ple 'who ~' :aI'::~kd by ~t, Nmw' it :~ 'c:cii'Uliin,' ~.Ci thta!t put, d~lim~filiJiIiDf;I, :had: ii, dimCit :~Il!I!lJu.em;o~ ull th.~, ~iJf~ 'm: ~15 viiQtimi!Jl~ but it. i!JI, :0;001. n<e ~at dJi~iDati'O~,:bJu ~pI~d m;e '~~Qi~ ~)UeS,'m,be;rie"l :~~ty., DlS(nn:.~natinn, ,apl!liSl b:Lf.i~b and WQ:m~n h~ ~~, wid~p~adl. bUll. 810, has been. iilJp:posiiilions w, lit. Suih o:ppmltl0:111 :Iruu ,~'h~~ ,a!mO:flS' odte:r tbiH,gs" ~.n, t1l,~, lov.il, 'WM~ m~ ]'!;4'in,~,t~~n~h ,Am~lldf!IU~.llIft m '1Ii.t': (A)n~ti';"J;.I";o'!ii1!'l; i'lIfn·d'·II",'ii.'e ..... im~1 ':m\:B'Ljt,.A~t, !iii'"'''''''' of wL:i..,lh '~uild', 'h~._. ''''~en 'rriinu:ib'~" 'Il!!l."!'!I!l!v.L~,~lj' ''''''lei!.., '-Ill, "'!I~!I'_~ ~DfU!li';ll'~"';> ~~lI!~"'" '.~~ '.~,,~±"""'~ .. ~'.~ C__,,'_, ~~!I'Ii''!r'"'' ~.~~~ ,r'=~~~' ~.""

'."I"ji,'Ir"""'.:'!Ii', "i>'~"i"'"i"J";oo!W,..., narri!":.~i">I" '''''''.:011O'P4i'. ''''.4"'~h!>''''. ~i'i~ 'II¥>"-';oo'" ~r,·1 'iIIJm1il'-' ,!,!" ~IILv!l!l)~ """"'~ilil._~"'" ir-'r'!I!IiliI!U, iil! ..... 11:"''l'' .. _,1, 'Ii.. ,~"~.],"''U~·'''''.l, WII,,,_, ,",".,''!'.A;]!l, r- .... _I ,ii, UI, '-'0-

mCJrnt ued 'by OIppmitCTI'h, of di~rirmiIQa!uon h~ ,~~, been tha~ :it; '¥i~13tcs, tihc' C~~lttail ~g~ of' ,AmieV!lc~ :~lcity g ;c:~r-e~ :t,' 'l!Jhc' 'Cg~sttitQ~(llillJ !~"~ ~ ~)b~, ~:'~~~t"~f~. ,f'!r-!ii'"

3iIiI,u, !IO!IICli ,Din, 0.1:, ~~iI~,

. SUip;po:sejl :how,~I"!, 'that 'this paint is ,nliista'iietl. SUip;po:se: that ,d)i$c'riimitma? 'tJion b~, e_xpreucd ,(deg~, 'gues, of Am,~, ;sorie,Uy., su,~ that those '~~Md 'Vl:'iu~ wh.o ac~ ,A~n;~rican, ,~i~ty as ii, whal~' to£' hairin,g '~~n '1"a'Cls:t and ~st ~tuaJl, ::!I,peal!:;, [the tn.dJb" Th.e iIlSGiH,pti.on of' 'G'O'n~&tift re:s,PQ!!I~blnt¥, .for' ,~t, d~rilHl!iJn~~n '~uld, ~tiill '~ ~~tlied, 'k~~~ :~t w,o]!ilt'es Itlite ,cOim;d'iJticolil 'tmalt the' ~~ts wb~) an:' held, rcspo;lls'iJb'l!e b:9!¥e ~d!en~ mfliSd! MIib, tilfli' mn:mlI, gnlllJl,P 'wh~ m~miM;[5, dimrimina:~~ (dt~ ~nlth (l~!)idiilti.o~ d~ri'ood, in SieotiA!)Q ,4;,.:2h :E~n If' ,J\rn;e'n~an~ 'i~ 'tbe :,.as~ have

'1· ... ""'''1''U-·.c:~~ '~~I·'t;'i:-l , .... \i~..jii"l'l'il·~""'iI!~~':" '~'\~~' 1,...~, i"":Ui"~I''''~;o:'!<': -f· ~i"''''!i_l ,"'~"i1'~~";lii!~~i<!i;, "U,~~_lIJ _lI!I/~U, L!I"!'Ir, I.IJ~ U_~_lj ~_IJ_IJ_I_lI!li:iIIW~I.oll" ·"-~~.l!, ,lIdi. ~i~ lIlIJ!UI_~J~_IJ~"1i:Ii U. !IJ.]_J)\~~"_il_" .... -~IJ 1~_IHltt,r u,u

.~ ",..1:... . 'jf"L jl L~ ~ •. t~ ~. :I.u

net ,~,o ,so en IUl.:e presc..fI!t, !I,"!(lte5e [[.iilJ1'Ie m!JJJn~n are' ~m_~' 'WiP 'lib' :oo,t O-J]~l'

'bl!l~1~:5' ~d, WfiQl(tn, b'U:I: m~ n,unternU$ ,mf;im'~Q (If ~iI~ :':Il~h :~alI~gQ~d! ImUip~ 'wb~t'e ~ei!!l, No:t: legt, ;~O'D~' dJem ,~e whjfle 'maJ)e lJiJ~~ 'buit (l~U'~' to :malgn, rb«(Jrl~ .. , 'Oof ~O~i :pJ:eifJilJ! '~w;bjt~ m~~ ttQf;ili.~r.lll~,

~j -:- JI_~iijO, ,~I~or,,""~iI'i'i':l:t"''''iI!~"'i'-'ifio, 'ru:rta!~ ........ t ~'I"""'I~':"'"' "iilOl··d' I ~or>I"'"'i"'" ;li.";o;, ,~~~ :""", ~fi;'O"~if1i'''' '!U(1U]~,~~lIiIO~" ul.iI!"!Io-.~ 11 ....... ,U.'IRI.IIiIlAl!'<.'., ,~,...I.u . .,.. y !!IM..!~ ""'.1., .. , gv., .. ~ .• ,''!Iiii~'., !Q'l! ~i1 '.'.!lII,7' ;fIIo;I! ""'.'.~,. ,~~_"I!ii'

""~.,... (!!~ ~'... ~,iIfi' d'-'·I""'·n·'m~"""a"=\A.n ....... m ...... ;oo ...... ,A ,,,' ....... "",,"n,.·~,'i ~'~~.I"_' _Ii! ct. _' ........ "'i'lI, ....

~-ll_~. IOU '~'J!-~.~I, .. _IL :.: ~;i, _~_:_lI_~~~_'_ .. vl.lL [~r-,Ij'~~l ,JI~ ~,.lljJUdJ.Il .¥.~~-~ [~J.ltll I~JIJI~_J~-~~1J

~~~" :~n ~,~, put Ind, ,~, if.Ain~ri.cms, '~Iill ,th~ put, :mr~ :id~n~~~d Wirth 'the pOI:llp whose 'gue:s, [they weif\e-., 'liihese '~~e~ ,~ [tQ, l'o~ler ,ce~~ io:

'~'I\f'-::' m"!" ..... I' F'-n ,.,L, iX"L.Alr'= .... ~ ... ;li."ijO'." ,iI'~nn ':'11 ~,'I .. , "", '~""'l' ii' 'N",' if'o"'- , .... l~: 'ijOli'.i"""'''''~~.I~;o;, u_IE 1I1111!L!'-,I;:iEIlI. ! .. ; I .ulro l1!.I]a._~ ~~llJ~"lI_~~IJ_lJi:I ,I,U ,[ __ , ,IJ -, U,bl~ Ir,.,'_',",,",~lIjl~~. , .,u; .. uu ,1J_IJ~Ll".~MIIi~~_"

,~ericarns, '~Dl tthoe :'~~It ~dCllitify MID, moe :mmr.lli gnlYioP wh.~ m~m~, m~rim~D!ate,l :in, ch~, :past:., :h; wOU11.d, be unjlutifl,t;d!, 'm~~fuR'~ t~, h;()ldl ,,~~ .be:riCaiIl8, ooll!e£iveiy' :[lespanosible r6f' pa5t dlKri:mil~a!ti_n~"

~!t. :mJIW: be ,-~d!~, ba~F .. , lilIJat ,~t iii, f!UlJt ~ 'tJh3lt diiKl'ljmiin:atinn hal! ever' 'eJC,,~~d, 'c:e~,~, AmerilCa!Il, '~,ru~~, '0:(' .~t ,aJ~, 'O:F mQ$t. ,~e~c:.i'~iiU,

'I,..~ ,j, ........ ~ ... '~£i ... ~ 'iCii1i1;.'f ,.:~~ nro~~ atr'~"t;~~p., 'J,iiJ~~, ~~IlML"","'jI' -i1J.' .... i'"i"' ... ~\OliY-i .. i,~ .... ~I~, [1]_4iiIf'!"'!'~' ,LU~~~~Wol~Ul "n,lI,-t,IIHI, U_I... ._IIL,.,..... ,('I ... ,,,",,,LII ·n~IBI~ [IJ"~~IiL-_.~LKi. .. ,~ ~tl.'iill.iiI,"'L~" .... u.~_I.1"

dUe riD1!iinJaWd, .~Qs.t blJacb md, WQ11DelllJ" 'ro. dC'Df Itmg dOes, g~:7I!¥e' injm.tie~


~ [the m:e:m(1t'ty' ,~ th~ oo:ul1Jil!less Amerle:US\!1 mostly wb:i}t~ 111i.~l\es.!' 'W!mO

'b~" 'IL dJl M bom ~'" w." d eo' • " '~.'

'.:: [ c, 'C ... " ':,:: 'I':: ";"~':-~~, I :~':- ,~, ' ..... ~!;I:''":"~.},"!" ... "'I"'" ~I~)I", 'flf'i"''I'''tl't:lufOi('I':''''Ii'S<'' 'w~~n, 'In.

pll. l:"" Y wn em 1];, " ,_I . 1~liIm_t"l.ftUiI!.l!\U. OUI,.' "''Iia ,r",I,,_l_,!l_i"')I~IIi""'~_, ... ~~_. _,

tn-=-;"-;: 'rnftl~:-m r~:::.' ,C'ili,·'-=:tl" d-=--;e:I1:tlv atlld sn;n;tltaJllwwl!J' IlXtea~d, blacks, and

_~!U'.r __ w.IrW_S!!lq,il!Il:e J'I' ~ -"",.1""- "'r==I--~, '-l'~-'--- - ~- ~~~~~-

'WO_eoc-n 'IIlt.tr' tm:e:rii~~ ,!aJll-d, who, brn!lt'O'ht :a:fu.o~( '~e [l"u',i;i!litt1Ca:l! 3lI'Id HlOrnJ!

", _, (1;" 1 ,I .. 1_, 1 __ , "" _ " ,__ ,.. ~ _ ~ " ~,~ ,_ "'"Q'~ ~ _ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ,~ __ ~~~_ ~~ . .. ~ _

c:_~ge5 ~t h~ve :made' d)i~iim~mra!tiUinJ tma(i&~,ta!b~~.

crtTle ~Fliifl_tJiGn, w- ;[;-tl]~~i1~' :rnsr;~n~siblli,t¥ l'O' dl;~ present 1~~nen'~!};lls 'o:f

r =' ~ "

Aim:eri:e;ms :fQ'F pgt d~~rim:i{:l~tkQn, a;I.$O 'viQila;~ m(i' c.gndii:tiu~ tihatt :d '~e

.-----';, ,- ~--:t;.. I' .... -', ih:,,_'II·d' .:-,.~ill-::_;""i'-=-IL" , .. " .. ··,'_·""I'If-.'I',''l;I''-.,.IIf--~'1 'j" ,tllt,~ 'nll,,"~~;h' .'eJ'Ilts, wum, Irnr~ . tl:~,. " ~Jil~CI.lrVCliliy [,'fl:SPO:IlMlI.!I, ~ 1!~L1.U, ~~Iili lllill:li!lie .F,lac-e 0. ..... '!I-~e

q,enu, who, d~scriHlin~u:ed :in, tlhe :pa~st" meFiJ ~f:t~y wo~ld, bWl~' done what

'_ .'-' -t', '-' "'_~'-,"iI;.,, :~~'d'" i'~,':-- ; ;"i" til:- eend , .... ,,, . eo, , .• ,., " !P:,",,~~:,,".' '4,~',., 'D~s, """litd~'I:.ioI1l!

past, age:I1,!lo:'! \.ill . !I;,l!!J,I,;e IIl.lOitU C.O,I'J,Jld'{p'lal ~, In ;.XlC"",,~Jl ~"!i"1- _ ~~~~ OO'~~_~'""'~ ~~

"':I1'1I;~'f:".;Il'I"'iC': ,~ ~;n;,';jllIi1"~~...t'~'i"h'"",~1 'i";I~I'I'm: I _ "1iI,ri;~ !l!1'1.r'h ... ;1 "ill_Iii, ~I- .~iCol~!v.' mis.lIi~d;ili"' ..

~~JI_III~_ ~~ [AI ~U-U_lIHII~~"IlLl~!\-~_W ~ _IQI -J! Mi_.~lt~1 ~"_IIf""l"-~~ ~@_~"l! !I2I!J,.. ~~.J. ~~.~~.~-~ _~.

~tood. 'De :1iT~hlt il!iMdle-~tllfl,difll~ of th~s, IOO:Il,diltlmn is ['0, :Stlin:IlQ'.~' tIJB,t ~.t:

~.,.I ,rir~-=""

',' I· :~L..lI,r"" I ~~, II _ WI!Ii'h ;oil. ir' 'T. " 'lrnJit'.;j!J ,v.ai~ '5- I~A: inlfit .... rr.onirs - ,and ,p;resenl!l.'"W:Ii,l" ,nmer,u:::tv~s~, ~_ID~_~ ~~e= ,P'=e._~~~!!; -~f _ ~_u¢_" ~_liJlL~_'I!-Y'!e~~_~, ~-~ ~~'

:l~~~fI~~Q:lliS w.I:lh ~U~~, mural :gFO'ups:~ 'werle 1~, rJh.e :place o;f,hme,rl;C:aJ]s :iTI, !!;h~' :~t, Wllili meir ~ues~, 'co:m!m!~tme~~" and ],den~~t3itiQin~" ~lt~Jl, ',~~n,tttday ,Am,cnnlills, wu:wlt(l, bia:\\e (liscri!nlliIn~!l~d ,.ilil:st bla,c~s, and

., L 'Am:. d"d 0" eo, iB"· bW us!l'v

W(!m,elIlJ~t, M :mj'!J.u:~~ M, :past ,~-~~~r'.:1'~;e!ilD._:Si.~ __ ,,',!mce' ag.B.!I~j' '..'!e_I~~ :t;.~ @-,,: ~O,~~~;.-

'fa~ N~, re:asonai~].ti ~FU:in cmii d,e.~~' mart [lhef.\e is 'm~ch I~ss d;iiS~[im~Imla;"

'- ,., .. ,. , ,.. ',. -, . iF~"~~ . , . - ". , . l' . - -., " , " . I - [,. - - , .. , ,,- _. .-

t"'Li1i'1'Ii ,tIIi~l·n'Dit 'li'fl'!11,"";~", ,;g;n~ Wi"'m""n n~ ';oil!rl;nll"'; ,;oib.,.....,;:,; '!II\\8 ii~ t'hjll;, 'DaSL, "fhaJt

~Vi_I~.1 ~rr-- _'_o_L-'i:P!I.. ~J_IIiIII~-~ B~ • _ ~ {W~~ -=~~-'!1'!! W~~~ '-!Il!!~!Ii "ir .. ~ u~ ,_,_.-=i1!r.l ,r= _. ~ ~_~ .-~

m(ia:mrs, 'mart U~R must be :milleh. fi'N~[, J\:m~riC~11I5 .FlUW' wh,o WU1lIl\{J, h~~'

d 1 .... -'1""..:Ii.,.... j.~.,';:OI."':'-+' ~~'I ,o'l.,."!!,, "(jla5.-.t' ''Tr'L~ ascrip .. 'ii~..,. ...... , cifO'l! "'''('i;'lil'''''''<Ii'~!U'''' 'O'I~'pa,.,., n s -1·iki;.I:I'!~"'" t\i'!i; " ..",..~ ~1!~,I~~~II:IOI!_eu, 1I1~ 1][1;1,,,", ',Ib, .Ii, u, .... ,0lM..c1,,1, - .'U!V,~~ "'""~, """",I ! ... uu: ....... ,I,'ot.!a - .',' "U<I'_ JLh! ,j " I.-!V

~- - - - - - J l, l, '_

$,e' ~Ol.'~ :gn.U!P of ,Ame:rl~s, :![P,F p~t. i{U:$Qrim~l'i'atlO:ll, agrdiinst b~ac_b and

~men bJ, tJllu;:refure \lnj~tilied, £0;[' yet ,a tbir-d, F~n.

It :i~ le~lJi~bl~' m oo~cIDude' '~~t ~'I1~ d;elen~ <xf ,cn:l1~cti,~, responsmbil~h¥' ~s, '~DOC. OO~S'i,s-~fUl't 'Wl~b Itlle' re;oct~'on af libera1 N)!l~tfrcal nll'"f'HJ',r,anl'S, mat

',f,"-=" ,,' ':" , _., - _L." ",j ._- ,._, [ ... "-" ,-, ",' -,~" ,_., lr='·~'·'" -~ !F~'~lQF"--- -~,-,' ..

aee m~tiV-d!ted by tic :aclm,(niledJgmc~~ ,mi· ~Ql~~ti¥~, :~!ii,p!.)ffi)~ib~llltY~ '~r' '~~ ~:u;'b~~mt gf: £lQI~~i1\iti, :r'~po:D.lsilhiiljjty :may be m'ii5;mlQ~n, '~n ttil'a]! tfu~

~It-'.iil,·.,i, I ii':" ,.'-'.'I!rI:;~1Ili1 ,,_(,'il~, ... ' .. ~_'I·I~II~II·I',t-:·.'-,,'I·It.. ,,', -: '~I':" '''J~].' ~'11 ,t :,: m -·,t a£~'!,!!]jues ,iIIOI!' WldCill~ tpooPl'@ are ~[I.e. u 00.11 ,ecdve IT Ir~Il!iII!J..!l, e illiI\'I~; !lO mee

one o:it 'm-o~~' ,of mee' iilffim;t:; oofiu:W~iiofi5 lan, wb~,~'JI jim Jl1s~~~d ~rIDpilolli, d:~, ~fJdls· 1'b;~ ~'l!iQ!' Of:dlCli' nUl'ere'mtia;1 ~rle3iQn~nt ftf' ibladk!li;, a~d, VUlmren ~ a,

r~-J·--·P' 1 1 ••• r~'-.J.' ... J I r~ ~ .. _.l'_~. l ._~_.-._.~_.~i" __ . __ -_ . __ ~ == _J_~ --~

c~ :in, :pou~n~ 'hlili: ~mUH' 'C~5, c;ould, be :mad~' apfuf~5t ~~jlilm,fllr.u1il~, ,t}:rJ:ter.'

1,~i~":':~~1 P ·r~.'i ;'iiI"i'""" '·'i'h'II1"'it","Ii'" ,"'r"': ~'h"i!'iji"'J·'·""':4!"fl""""i~'"",--'O"I": ~i"t, """1--1 :'!"-'f:i'~ll'~:'!"tl·~~ -;o;nfi"'1iIi"I·'" I~~~ ... ~ , .,' _~!",_IIJIJI.'a, ,1_u_~I!~I, IRa' ill .• ,""'~I, ,:__ l ..... o::I'I!LI,I~"'"G!l.IIo-V .. ,I!3' IIJ "'-'O::! " V', _, ",",,,-,,.II ""_''''-,!ll~'''-' I, ",,"iJ!,r,~~I~o::! I

biU~"

Tb< a~Q(id, ~'h;e· :m~l,ln.dill::~lfldJi;nl,o:lT :p:r'~~~ ;~Illitfi;~[d~, :1:1:. .s'EU~Ui.!l~d '1iK:: cf'1il1"'

Ph~ed ~ ~he' ,;U;DUme~t ~~l .a!t dii!!Cri__'_~!IIti():1iIJ has, 'OC~YJJ'md. di~t

= 0 -:.= [!tiP =-= r:

'i, ,'" "]~ A ~oL . Ai.........' 'I!., L"""..... 'L"II r. ~ - ,,_I;i!iik . . iIh

Ui :IS, ,3)], ;t;¥.!, '1- ,3Ii,\iJ, iU;I:a:1l .ni!1iI~ir:tC'affil5, ,Iii!aiil.'e: ~Il, :fc~fiQiJ;_5llu ,c' ~,of :11t.1iY ~Iiat ti~lie

,r--'

~~~enlt denies :h~ dl~t me' :m:iII~$, of ~~:5 evil :ha~' be-e.m ~iil,tm1 wlu,~5,

'~I"''Ii., '",ii.'Ifo,~ .... lh 'I!n""~'b~"",, ~',' , .. il!--.,. ~'A'r~~1 P[\,",'Iji;J'n, "'if AlInf':: .... ''''''lOln~ b~";r .. ' ~.:I-;n;ti6 ... d, 'UJil, -T1J!II~ll, R~llll!~ [ . '1.':I~lr'M~ll~J~ ~~, ~1I-,... l!!'~v.~ 41!&! ~J-=-l ~-!l,i_JJ~- Y-..:.l ~ ~_ ~ .l!Ii9~=- ,:.!,H,-_- I!:::r ~~~1!!l.ii; ~~-~~, ~ ~

'.-:; "'-I~·' . 'b,,~r.', iIF'---',' 'I'··""··--:~'--!I-@ ,';l'·,--, '~";-"'.--, T ··,'-'f': .A;,.,...·","!·7-;-·I--; --, I';""j~ .', 'I'~ 'i\i''' ". '1':11 !Ii"11

W:-U£C:G5 .u:al~ ~~~iI p:r:GCiL~,,~ tlltlE ~.c.t!i«Il:s 0:. r:uu,t::n.c~UlS tn8it ,la,~,e \\,l(ii~J~:eu

so:me o:f the ~~tr.aiI 'w.JJue!il. Th,ose -who, ar-c' ~~t?', ,w thc1r 'vi'1!;i~tiQ:mr:!!i ~atVe C:aN~!I, ,ed) :aJnd, ,s~O'uJd, be ~etd, feS!jlQ'Jl.s.lnle fQj" ~t, B~t tbeililr r-e~PQiJl~~ilw~i' d~ :n,g~ ~~ (fc~'e.r tlU, m;Q5~ 'past mull, 'rt'~D,I[, Am,~riCatl'l!~ who, have up'


eosed ,d-li\lU"~mill·n'aili~;o'1iln, :!I;n~ ''''~'r- .... l;1i;~ifi"Ii:'~-r h' _ ~, , ... , ·~r' !I.ihi"ii.~;ll,*, '~,~~ '1i1r~tt:'~~:"'i7..:1, ,"i,

r....:--- _1.'iI!'!i.r_1J II. - - - _~~I- - WA.l!'iI.o_ll iiiill.loIrUI ullJI.v 1I_1I"'~IJUIl~1J __ iJ!~ [.,I~_. "~WU ,I~~ lr[~~-~ ,I~J

.bi! lefi~~ 'iII~n:WFe'~ :Iit. :~' be :wdj, tlh~t :tibegh ~ :ri:~t, tU ooJui__e:m'll, ~,~ Am~ri.rtmi.iiS Wh.OI ba~ m-~d, :pa.!lt and, :p~it ~ 'oot, ar--e ~n.g' bli, lcu'~iliva~~g an :a;tm~s.phel1e 'M pil~ 'wmk:b~ ,K-O(l[\diing bl' dt@';m,jo alI1, A:m,~n., 'catlj o.~ght tf,), :~el The :Ulbe~, eFtOl' :1.$ not to, :su;p~; that, ~t, Day 'k:

JDtifi,ed, '1:0 :hold, :pe-ople' oo'~I;ectivety' :[les,po:ncsiblie ~t t-o audhe looJI~tm,,,,,~ :~~,plJiJsl~i~ wlimo~t ~e' :1)1;~~ j~tifica!li'QH~


Against Liberalism - John Kekes

Încărcat de

Informații document

Titlu original

Drepturi de autor

Formate disponibile

Partajați acest document

Partajați sau inserați document

Opțiuni de partajare

Vi se pare util acest document?

Este necorespunzător acest conținut?

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

Against Liberalism - John Kekes

Încărcat de

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

Copy rig hted m ateri al

S-ar putea să vă placă și

Against Liberalism - John Kekes

Încărcat de

Informații document

Titlu original

Drepturi de autor

Formate disponibile

Partajați acest document

Partajați sau inserați document

Opțiuni de partajare

Vi se pare util acest document?

Este necorespunzător acest conținut?

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

Against Liberalism - John Kekes

Încărcat de

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

﻿Copy rig hted m ateri al

S-ar putea să vă placă și

Copy rig hted m ateri al