Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
SIDDIQUI 1
Abstract — In this experiment, we determine As described by the work of Newton and Galileo, all
the value of the gravitational acceleration close objects irrespective of their mass, experience the same
to the surface of the Earth, g = (9.90 ± 0.13) m constant acceleration close to the surface of the Earth.
s-2 = 9.90 m s-2 ± 1.3% by using a stiff pendulum This has some extremely fundamental consequences –
method. First, we find the moment of inertia of for example, we use this idea to calculate mass on a
the pendulum and then use small angle weighing scale. The same idea can be extended for
approximations to derive an expression for g. We simple problems involving conservation of gravitational
then compare our results to the generally potential energy close to the surface of the Earth.
Lastly, the gravitational acceleration is a term which
accepted value and identify areas of
features in the equations for the time period of the
improvement.
simple and stiff pendulum, as well as the equations
governing simple harmonic motion of an oscillating
spring (see Appendix B).
I. INTRODUCTION
The value of g is also important in problems
where I0 is the known moment of inertia through the Equation 2B.1: The moment of inertia through the centre of mass of a
uniform cylindrical rod of mass M and length L.
centre of mass, m is the mass of the body and d is the
perpendicular distance between the first and second (see Appendix C for derivation) through its centre of
axes [4]. mass, where M is the mass of the rod and L is the length.
We will use a torsion pendulum to calculate the Thus, the dividing the expression for the period of
moment of inertia of the stiff pendulum about its centre oscillation for the pendulum by the period of oscillation
of mass. Then, the parallel axis theorem will be useful for the cylindrical rod yields
in calculating the moment of inertia about the rotation
axis of the pendulum.
= = ⇒𝐼 =𝐼 .
II. THEORY
A. Relating Period of Oscillation to g Equation 2B.2: The expression for the moment of inertia of the
pendulum through its centre of mass, given the moment of inertia of a
For a pendulum of mass m and distance to the uniform rod through its centre of mass, as well as the time period for
centre of mass h, the torque exerted on the pendulum oscillations on the torsion pendulum for the pendulum and cylindrical
rod.
by its weight when it is displaced from the equilibrium
position by an angle φ is equal to 𝜏 = 𝑚𝑔ℎ𝑠𝑖𝑛𝜑 = 𝐼𝜑̈ . It Note, however, that the expression for IP represents that
can be shown (see Appendix D for derivation) that moment of inertia of the pendulum through its centre of
𝑔 = 4𝜋 , mass. To find the moment of inertia of the pendulum
Equation 2A.1: The expression for calculating the value of the through the axis of rotation when the pendulum is
gravitational acceleration, g. vertically oscillating, we use the parallel axis theorem:
where T is the period of oscillation for the pendulum 𝐼 = 𝐼 + 𝑚ℎ = 𝐼 + 𝑚ℎ ,
and I is the moment of inertia about the axis of rotation. Equation 2B.3: Applying the parallel axis theorem adjustment to
Hence, if accurate values of I, m, h and T can be calculate the moment of inertia about the axis of rotation.
acquired, the formula can be used to determine the
where m is the mass of the pendulum and h is the
value of g. Values of m and T can be obtained easily,
distance from the centre of mass to the axis of rotation.
and the value for h can be calculated using a simple
method. However, acquiring the value of I requires using
C. Determining the Centre of Mass
an indirect method.
The centre of mass of an object is said to be the
B. Acquiring the Value of I point at which all of the mass of an object is said to be
concentrated. An alternative definition states that it is
The value for the moment of inertia of the stiff
the point through which a force would not produce an
pendulum about the axis of rotation cannot be easily
angular acceleration [4]. While there are other methods
calculated directly. Instead, we use an indirect torsion
to determine the centre of mass of an object, we will use
pendulum method to first calculate the value of I about
a simple approach. Since
the centre of mass of the stiff pendulum, and then
the centre of mass is the
extend this using the parallel axis theorem to calculate
point through which a
the moment of inertia about the required axis.
force produces no angular
The torsion pendulum is a device in which a rotating
acceleration, the body can
body is suspended from its centre of mass using a torsion
be made to balance by a
wire. When the body is rotated, the torsion wire
single force acting Figure 2C.1: By balancing a rod on
becomes twisted and exerts a rotational torque on the an aluminium prism, the position of
through its centre of the centre of mass can be
body which causes it to accelerate in the opposite
mass. This reaction force determined. For a uniform and
direction to its angular displacement. Again, if the symmetrical body, the centre of
is provided by an mass is always in the geometric
amplitude of the angular displacement is small, air
aluminium prism (see centre of the body.
resistance becomes negligible and the body oscillates
Figure 2C.1).
with simple harmonic motion.
The simple harmonic oscillation of the torsion
pendulum is governed by III. EXPERIMENTAL METHOD
𝑇 = 2𝜋 ,
where IP is the moment of inertia of the body and κ is A. Prerequisite Measurements
the torsion coefficient of the torsion wire used [5]. The The centre of mass of the pendulum was determined
value for κ for copper can be relatively easily acquired by carefully balancing the pendulum on the aluminium
from data-books, but it is better to eliminate this value prism as shown in Figure 2C.1. The position of the
altogether by first calculating the period of oscillation centre of mass was marked by placing one edge of a
of a cylindrical rod, whose moment of inertia can be piece of masking tape against the required position.
shown to be Subsequently, the value of h was measured from the
𝐼 = 𝑀𝐿 , knife-edge on the axis of rotation of the pendulum to
the centre of mass using three different metre-rules.
U. SIDDIQUI 3
Lastly, the mass of the pendulum was measured on three measurements in the short time period. Furthermore, it
different precise top-pan balances. was more difficult to concentrate when recording 10
The same process was repeated for the uniform complete oscillations so the standard deviation for the
cylindrical rod. Again, the centre of mass was found time taken for 10 oscillation was significantly larger.
using the aluminium prism and recorded using a piece After displacing the apparatus by a small distance1,
of masking tape. Finally, the theoretical moment of we waited for the apparatus to come to rest at its
inertia of the uniform cylindrical rod was calculated. amplitude to start the timer as this made it easier to
determine when a single oscillation had been completed.
B. Torsion Pendulum We recorded the time taken for 5 oscillations using the
A clamp and retort stand was set-up at the edge of
our work desk with a steel rod inserted through the ring
clamp to give clearance from desk. A copper torsion wire
of thickness approximately (0.71 ± 0.01) mm was
wrapped around the steel rod and held in place with
some masking tape.
The other end of the
torsion wire was
fastened to a pipe
clamp clip and the
uniform rod was
inserted through the Figure 3C.1: The resting block was clamped to the table and the knife-
edge of the pendulum placed in the opening of the resting block. The
pipe clamp clip and pendulum was then displaced slightly and allowed to oscillate.
securely tightened and
the pipe clamp clip lap function on the stopwatch provided, which allowed
positioned on the us to collect a large amount of data in a short time.
Figure 3B.1: A set-up of the torsion
centre of mass so that pendulum apparatus. The retort The data collected was input into a spreadsheet
the rod rested in stand is clamped securely to the desk document and stored as a CSV file before being
equilibrium (see Figure and the cylindrical rod rotates below imported into a Jupyter Notebook and analysed using
the desk. The steel rod was added to Python. The time period for one oscillation was
3B.1). provide greater clearance from the
The torsion desk. determined and Equation 2A.1 was used to calculate the
pendulum was then displaced and the stopwatch was value of g.
started when the pendulum came to rest at its
IV. RESULTS
amplitude position as this made it easy to determine the
end of a single oscillation. The time was recorded for the
pendulum to complete 5 oscillations. The process was A. Prerequisite Measurements
repeated 4 more times to produce a dataset of 5 values The mass and length of the cylindrical rod were
for the time taken to complete 5 oscillations. measured as M = (269.86 ± 0.01) g and L = (78.6 ±
Then, the cylindrical rod was removed from the pipe 0.1) cm, respectively. Hence the theoretical moment of
clamp clip and replaced by the pendulum, again inertia of the cylindrical rod about it centre of mass was
tightening the pipe clamp clip over the centre of mass measured as IR = (13.9 ± 0.1) g m2.
so as to ensure the pendulum was balanced on the
torsion wire. The time taken for 5 oscillations was again Mass Length Table 4A.1: Measurements of the mass
and length of the uniform cylindrical rod.
recorded until we had a dataset of 5 values. /g / cm
For the mass, the first value was discarded
269.57 78.6
Subsequently, the mean value for TR and TP, the due to a systematic error with a faulty
time period for one complete oscillation of the 269.86 78.6 balance. The remaining three values were
269.86 78.6 measured on different balances and were
cylindrical rod and pendulum respectively was consistent to within 0.01g. The lengths
calculated. The moment of inertia of the pendulum 269.86 were measured using different metre-rules
about its centre of mass was calculated using Equation and were each consistent to 0.1cm.
C. Oscillating Pendulum
Next, the apparatus was reconfigured to that shown
in Figure 3C.1. We decided to measure the time taken
for 5 oscillations per measurement because it would be
faster and would therefore allow us to collect more
1
Note: It was necessary to use a small displacement because Equation
2A.1 is only valid if the amplitude of oscillation is small.
U. SIDDIQUI 4
of inertia of the pendulum, but further analysis revealed which is a more accurate method of determining h.
that this is likely due to the uncertainty in the value for Note that to further improve the estimate of h, it is
h. possible to plot against d. The gradient of this graph
A strength of the experiment is that it is relatively
simple to execute and does not require any technical or is then equal to . When possible, it is always
advanced apparatus. Considering the simplicity of the advisable to use a graphical method to determine a
equipment used, an error of only ±1.3% is remarkable. value because it is easier to determine outliers from a
However, as mentioned above, the experiment could be graph and errors can be better accounted for in the
improved with a few changes (for example, to the estimate of the gradient.
equipment used to determine centre of mass). A minor source of error was accurately trying to stop
A weakness of the practical was that it makes some the stopwatch when the correct number of oscillations
estimates regarding the experiment that may not be had been completed. Measuring only five oscillations
true. For example, Equation 2A.1 uses the meant that the percentage error in each measurement
approximation that the sine of a small angle is was theoretically larger, but measuring 10 oscillations
approximately equal to the angle. While this meant fewer measurements could be made and it was
approximation holds true for small angles, it is possible more difficult to concentrate for longer periods of time.
that the amplitude of oscillations used during our A better alternative would be to eliminate the error
practical may have been too high for this approximation arising from reaction time and human error altogether
to hold true. Hence, a more accurate approach to by automating the task of taking measurements of the
determining the value of g would take this into period of oscillation. This could be done, for example,
consideration and possibly account for the additional by connecting a laser rangefinder to a datalogger, which
systematic error from the possibility of the amplitude of could record the speed of the pendulum as it was
oscillation being too great. oscillating (see Figure 5.2). When the pendulum was
A source of random error in the experiment arose stationary, it would mean that the pendulum was at an
when using the torsion pendulum, which was extremely amplitude point and the computer could start the timer,
sensitive to nearby air currents. This meant that people stopping the timer after a set number of oscillations
walking past the experiment while the pendulum or rod have been completed. This would be significantly more
were rotating may have influenced the time period, accurate than the method used in this practical, and
which could see a larger error propagating through in
the final value of g. Nevertheless, the biggest problem
with this experiment was in the way that the centre of
mass was determined for the pendulum. The errors in
this arose from the fact that it was based on the
judgement of the scientist to decide if the rod was
balanced on the prism, which is an error that cannot be
easily quantified. Furthermore, it was often easy for the
rod to slip or move off the prism while the masking tape Figure 5.2: Using a laser range-finder to determine the point at which
was being placed on the rod, which made it difficult to the pendulum has reached its amplitude. The data can be passed in
real-time to a computer, which can monitor and record the period of
accurately mark the position of the centre of mass. oscillation automatically and store the data in a CSV file, for example.
The uncertainty in
determining the centre would mean that more measurements could be made
of mass and hence the over a shorter period of time.
value of h can be
significantly reduced VI. REFERENCES
by using the apparatus
in Figure 5.1. Two 1. Grant, E. (1996). The foundations of modern science in the
middle ages. Cambridge [u.a.]: Cambridge Univ. Press.
force-meters are
attached to the 2. Boynton, R. (2001). Precise Measurement of Mass. [online]
Figure 5.1: An apparatus that can be Arlington, TX, p.2. Available at:https://www.space-
pendulum: one is electronics.com/contentAssets/Literature/Precise_Measure
used to determine the centre of mass,
attached to the axis of h, of a body. T1 and T2 are tensions ment_of_Mass.PDF [Accessed 26 Oct. 2017].
rotation of the measured by force-meters a known
pendulum and the distance d apart. 3. Grounds, S. and Kirby, E. (1992). Physics. 1st ed. Essex:
Longman, pp.38-39.
other can be attached
arbitrarily at a known distance d from the first force- 4. Whelan, P. and Hodgson, M. (1989). Essential principles of
meter. Then, by Newton’s 1st Law: physics. 2nd ed. London: John Murray.
𝑇 + 𝑇 = 𝑚𝑔.
Applying the principle of moments about the axis 5. Flegrova, M. and Ward, M. (2017). Calculating g using a
Stiff Pendulum. In: N. Ekins-Daukes and Y. Uchida, ed.,
of rotation gives First Year Laboratory Manual 2017-2018, 1st ed. London:
Imperial College London, pp.41-47.
𝑇 𝑑 = 𝑚𝑔ℎ ⇒ ℎ = = ,
U. SIDDIQUI 6
𝐼 = 2 ∫ 𝑟 𝑑𝑚.