Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
For information on SAE’s full range of Professional Development options, call, email, or visit our website.
or 724-776-4970
The information, representations, opinions, and recommendations contained in the lectures
and hardcopy material are those of the speaker(s) and not of the Society of Automotive
Engineers. This material may be copyright protected. No part of this publication may be
reproduced in any form without the expressed, written permission of the speaker(s).
Please note that SAE policy prohibits the audio or videotaping of any of the presentations.
Fundamentals of Gear Design and Application
I.D. #C0223
Duration: 2 Days
Through informative discussions and detailed explanations, this seminar will provide a solid
and fundamental understanding of gear geometry, types and arrangements, and design
principles. Starting with the basic definitions of gears, conjugate motion, and the Laws of
Gearing, those attending will be given the tools needed to understand the inter-relation and
coordinated motion operating within gear pairs and multi-gear trains. Basic gear system
design process and gear measurement and inspection techniques will also be explained. In
addition, the fundamentals of understanding the step-wise process of working through the
iterative design process required to generate a gear pair will be reviewed, and attendees will
also briefly discuss the steps and issues involved in design refinement and some
manufacturing considerations. Also, an explanation of basic gear measurement techniques,
how measurement equipment and test machines implement these techniques, and how to
interpret the results from these basic measurements will be covered.
Benefits of Attending
By attending this seminar, attendees will be able to:
• Describe the "Law of Gearing," conjugate action and specifically, involute profiles
• Review the various definitions and terms used in gearing
• Identify the function and operation of all gear arrangements
• Appraise preliminary design considerations and the gear system design process
• Explain practical gear measurement and inspection techniques, tools and equipment
• Recognize "Best Practices" in regards to gear system design
• Discuss some of the new and automated gear design systems
Seminar Content
DAY ONE
• Principles of Gears
o Purpose of gears
o Basic concepts -- Law of gearing; common tooth forms
o Classification of gears
o Definitions and terms used in gearing
o Velocity ratio
o Pitch surfaces
• Gear Tooth Action
o Conjugacy
o Profile curves
o Surface of action
o Profile sliding
• Gear Geometry and Nomenclature
o Principle of planes
o Tooth nomenclature
o Blank nomenclature
• Gear Arrangements
o Simple gear train
o Compound gear train -- ratios
o Epicyclic -- configurations (solar, planetary, star); ratios; tooth number
selection and build requirements; application
• Preliminary Design Considerations
o Gear type selection
o Preliminary estimate of size
o Stress formulations
o Gear Drawing Data
DAY TWO
1.3 CEUs
Fundamentals of
Gear Design
and
Application
Introductions
• William Mark McVea, Ph.D., P.E.
– Chief Technical Officer of KBE+, Inc.
– 15+ Years of Geared Product
Design and Development
– Graduate Work:
• Automated Design of Automotive & Off-Highway
Transmissions Using the Techniques of Artificial
Intelligence
1
My Expectations
• #1: I want you to feel confident --
• Able to Understand & Correctly Use Gear
Terminology
• Basic Concepts of;
– Gears
– Path of Motion
– Transfer of Torque
My Expectations
• You Only Get Out of a Course
What You Put Into It
2
Who Is In Attendance?
• Take a Moment & Find Out Who Is Here
ÎI Know, I Know . . .
Nobody Ever Likes Audience Participation
Your Expectations
• Let’s list all the points and topics you want
to cover during the next two days
3
Gears –
Let’s Face It
Ya’ Know Them
Ya’ Love Them
Course Content
• Principles of Gears & Gearing
• Gear Classification
• Tooth Forms & Geometry
• Nomenclature & Definitions
• Design Principles
• Drawing & Layout Techniques / Practices
• Measurement & Inspection
4
Principles of Gears
• Purpose of Gears
• Basic Concepts
– Law of Gearing
– Common Tooth Forms
• Classification of Gears
• Definitions and Terms Used in Gearing
Purpose of Gears
• Transmit Motion Between Shafts
• Transmit Power Between Shafts
• Modify Torque & Speed by Ratio
– Torque Increases as Speed Decreases
– Torque Decreases as Speed Increases
• Change Direction of Power Flow
• Change Axis of Power Flow
• Split Power Among Multiple Shafts
5
Basic Concepts
• Law of Gearing
• Conjugate Action
Law of Gearing
• To transmit uniform rotary motion from one
shaft to another by means of gear teeth
6
Rotary Motion
• Transmit rotary motion from one shaft
– The Driver or Driving Member
• To a shaft attached to it
– The Driven or Driven Member
A B
Rotary
Motion Driver Driven
14
7
A B
Rotary
Motion
A B
Driver Driven
15
A B
Rotary
Motion
A B
Driver Driven
Normal to Centerline
of Slot In Arm A
16
8
A B
Rotary
Motion
A B
Normal to Centerline
of Slot In Arm A
17
A B
Rotary
Motion
A B
Normal to Centerline
of Slot In Arm A
18
9
A B
Rotary
Motion
A B
Normal to Centerline
Is Equal
of Slot In Arm A B
A To Zero
Conjugate Action
• Transmit rotary motion from one shaft to a
shaft attached to it
10
Conjugate Action
Conjugate Action
• Transmit rotary motion from one shaft to
a shaft attached to it
11
Involute Profile
Zero Transmission Error Theoretically
23
Conjugacy
• Conjugate Gear Tooth Action: Is the
action between such profiles, which
transmit uniform rotary motion
• In essence the gear tooth surfaces are
cams in which the common normal to both
profiles pass through the
Pitch Point
12
Definitions & Nomenclature
• Classification of Gears
• Velocity Ratio
• Pitch Surfaces
Classification of Gears
• Parallel Axis
– Spur
– Helical
– Double Helical
or Herringbone
13
Gear Type
Definition
STRAIGHT BEVEL
27
Parallel Axis
Spur Gears
14
Parallel Axis
Helical Gears
29
Parallel Axis
Double Helical or Herringbone Gears
15
Classification of Gears
• Parallel Axis
– Spur
– Helical
– Double Helical
or Herringbone
• Nonparallel Axis
– Straight Bevel
– Zerol Bevel
– Spiral Bevel
– Cross-Helical
– Face Gears
Non-Parallel
Axis Gears
32
16
Intersecting Axes
Straight Bevel
Intersecting Axes
Zerol Bevel
34
17
Intersecting Axes
Spiral Bevel
35
Intersecting Axes
Face Gear
36
18
Classification of Gears
• Parallel Axis • Nonintersecting
– Spur Nonparallel Axis
– Helical – Cross-Helical
– Double Helical – Worm
or Herringbone
• Single-enveloping
• Nonparallel Axis • Double-enveloping
– Straight Bevel – Hypoid
– Zerol Bevel – Spiroid
– Spiral Bevel
– Cross-Helical
– Face Gears
Nonintersecting
Nonparallel
Axes
Cross-Helical
19
Nonintersecting
Nonparallel
Axes
Worm
39
Nonintersecting
Nonparallel
Axes
Worm
40
20
Nonintersecting
Nonparallel
Axes
Single
Enveloping
Worm
41
Nonintersecting
Nonparallel
Axes
Double
Enveloping
Worm
42
21
Nonintersecting
Nonparallel
Axes
Hypoid
43
Nonintersecting
Nonparallel
Axes
Hypoid
44
22
Nonintersecting
Nonparallel
Axes
Spiroid
Nonintersecting
Nonparallel
Axes
Spiroid
46
23
Nonintersecting
Nonparallel
Axes
Helicon
47
Classification of Gears
• Parallel Axis • Nonintersecting
– Spur Nonparallel Axis
– Helical – Cross-Helical
– Double Helical – Worm
or Herringbone • Single-enveloping
• Nonparallel Axis • Double-enveloping
24
Nonintersecting
Parallel Axes
Basic Rack
Spur
49
Nonintersecting
Parallel Axes
Basic Rack
Helical
50
25
Specialty Gear Forms
• Square or Rectangular
• Triangular
• Elliptical
• Scroll
• Multiple Sector
Square or Rectangular
Speed
Ratio
Driver Driven
One Revolution of Driver
26
Triangular
Speed
Ratio
Driver Driven
One Revolution of Driver
Elliptical
Speed
Ratio
Driver Driven
27
Scroll
Speed
Ratio Driver Driven
55
One Revolution of Driver One Revolution of Driver
Multiple Sector
Speed Driven
Driver
Ratio
28
Definitions & Nomenclature
• Classification of Gears
29
Creation of an Involute
59
Definition
of
Involute
60
30
Cycloidal
Cycloidal
31
Wildhaber-Novikov
w1
Pinion
r1 f
r2
Gear Lines of
Centers 63
Formate Gearing
Generated Form
Non-Generated Form
32
Gear Geometry & Nomenclature
• Ratio
• Tooth Nomenclature
• Gear Nomenclature
• Blank Nomenclature
• Principle Planes
Ratios
Gears have a
It’s all about ‘radius’
‘Leverage’ Gears rotate ‘in mesh’
Gears are always in ‘pairs’ R
That ‘radius’
R Acts like a lever
Ratio = R / r
You can have multiple
‘gear pairs’ to make
One overall ratio
The difference in the length of the lever
Is the difference in the amount of torque or rotational force it can transmit
Or the ‘ratio’ between the gears
33
Ratio
• Number of Gear Teeth
Number of Pinion Teeth
34
Tooth Numbers
• Based on Ratio
Tooth Numbers
• Pinion Tooth Numbers Based on Application
35
General Guide to Selection of Number of Pinion Teeth
No. Pinion Design Considerations
Teeth
7 Requires at least 25o pressure angle and special design to avoid undercutting.
Poor contact ratio. Use only in fine pitches
If 20o, outside diameter should be reduced in proportion to tooth thickness to
avoid pointed teeth
Subject to high specific sliding and usually have poor wear characteristics
10 Smallest practical number with 20o teeth. Takes about 145 percent long
addendum to avoid undercut. Poor wear characteristics
15 Used where strength is more important than wear. Requires long addendum
25 Good balance between strength and wear for hard steels. Contact kept away
from critical base-circle region.
Tooth Numbers
• Pinion Tooth Numbers Based on Application
• Based on Ratio and Center Diameters;
– Calculate Pitch Diameters
– Then Tooth Numbers
36
Numbers of Teeth in Pinion and Gear vs. Pressure
Angle and Center Distance
No. of No. of Teeth in Gear and Pressure Angle
Teeth in 14 1/2 20 20 25
Pinion Coarse Pitch* Coarse Pitch+ Fine Pitch+ Coarse Pitch+
7 42++
8 39++
9 36++
10 25 33 15
11 24 30 14
12 52 23 27 12
13 51 22 25
14 50 21 23
15 49 20 21
16 48 19 19
17 47 18 18
18 46
19 45
37
Tooth Numbers
• Pinion Tooth Numbers Based on Application
• Based on Ratio and Center Diameters;
– Calculate Pitch Diameters
– Then Tooth Numbers
• Spur –
– Integer Diametral Pitch (i.e. 1, 2, 3 / use std. hobs)
• Helical –
– Normal Diametral Pitch to be Integer
38
Ratio Selection Considerations
• Hunting Tooth Ratio
– Number of Teeth in Pinion
– And Number of Teeth in the Gear
– Have No Common Factor
• Example;
– NP = 11
– NG = 41
39
Gear Layout Nomenclature
• Tooth Numbers • Face Width
• Base Circle • Diametral Pitch
• Pressure Angle • Module
• Pitch Circle • Base Pitch
• Line of Action • SAP / EAP
• Center Distance • Contact Ratio
Base Circle
40
Base Circle
• Theoretical Circle
– From which involute tooth profile is derived
Base Circle
82
41
Base Circle
• Theoretical Circle
– From which involute tooth profile is derived
Base Circle
84
42
Base Circle
• Base Circle Diameter is the;
– Pitch Diameter
times
– Cosine of the Pressure Angle
DBaseCircle = DP * cos(θ )
Base Circle
43
Pressure Angle
Tangent to Tooth Surface
at Pitch Line
φ P
Pitch
Circle
Pressure
Line
rB
r φ
Base
Circle
Pressure Angle
• Angle of Tangent to Tooth Surface at Pitch
Point: φ ( phi )
• Typical Angles: 14.5, 20, 22.5, 25, 30
• Selection Based on Available Tooling
• Strength vs. Noise Requirements
– Lower Pressure Angles Generally Quieter
– Higher Pressure Angles are Stronger
44
Pressure Angle
• Select Based on Hob Availability
• Select from Standard Hob PA’s;
– 14.5 degrees (older standard)
– 20 degrees (common standard)
– 25 degrees (for higher strength)
– 30 degrees (special applications)
Pitch Circle
45
Pitch Circle
• Theoretical Surfaces of a Pair of Gears
Which Would Roll without Slipping
Normal
Pitch
92
46
Pitch Diameter
• Pitch Diameter =
– Number of Teeth / Diametral Pitch
• Base Circle Diameter =
– Pitch Diameter * cosine (PA)
• Addendum =
– 1.0 / Dp
• Dedendum =
– 1.25 / Dp
Pitch
Point
94
47
Line of Action
Line of Action
• In Gear Geometry
– Path of Action for Involute Gears
48
Line
of
Action
97
Line of Action
• In Gear Geometry
– Path of Action for Involute Gears
49
Line of
Action
99
Line of Action
• In Gear Geometry
– Path of Action for Involute Gears
50
Center
Distance
Center
Distance
Center Distance
• Distance Between the Centers of Two
Mating Gears
• Distance Between the Center of the
Support Shafts
• Sets Overall Dimension of Gearbox
51
Face Width
103
Face Width
• Width of Gear Tooth at Pitch Circle
• Actual is Measured Width
• Effective is Length of Contact Pattern
• Effective is Less than or Equal Actual
• Face Width is a Function of a Pair
• Effective is Equal for Pinion and Gear
52
Diametral Pitch
• Pd = N / D
(D for Gear, d for Pinion)
Module
• M = D/N (Gear)
• Or M = d/n (Pinion)
• M = 25.4 / Pd
• Inverse Relationship to Diametral Pitch
53
Base Pitch
Base Pitch
• Pitch Along Base Circle
54
SAP / EAP
109
SAP / EAP
55
Active Tooth Profile
• Define Active Tooth Profile
Tooth Action
Pinion
Driver
Angle of Angle of
Approach Recess
Angle of Angle of
Approach Recess
Gear
Driven
56
Tooth Action
• Angle of Approach
– Arc of Pitch Circle
– From Point of First Contact Along Pitch Circle
– To the Pitch Point Between Gear & Pinion
– Used to Calculate
• Length of Contact
• Contact Ratio
Tooth Action
• Angle of Recess
– Arc of Pitch Circle
– From Pitch Point Between Gear & Pinion
– To the Last Point of Contact Along Pitch
Circle
– Used to Calculate
• Length of Contact
• Contact Ratio
57
Contact Ratio
Contact Ratio
• Average Number of Teeth in Contact
• mc = Lab / p * Cos φ
58
Gear Tooth Nomenclature
• Addendum • Chordal Addendum
• Dedendum • Backlash
• Whole Depth • Fillet Radius
• Working Depth • Top Land
• Clearance • Bottom Land
• Circular Thickness • Circular Pitch
• Chordal Thickness • Tooth Flank
Addendum
59
Addendum
• Measured from;
– Pitch Circle
– Top of Tooth
• a = 1.0 / Pd
– Standard Tooth Proportions
Dedendum
60
Dedendum
• Measured from;
– Pitch Circle
– Root of Tooth
• b = 1.25 / Pd
– Standard Tooth Proportions
Whole Depth
61
Whole Depth
• Sum of;
– Addendum
– Dedendum
Working Depth
62
Working Depth
• Sum of;
– Addendum of Gear
– Addendum of Pinion
Clearance
63
Clearance
• Difference Between;
– Whole Depth
– Working Depth
Circular Thickness
64
Circular Thickness
• Arc Tooth Thickness on Pitch Line
Chordal Thickness
65
Circular Thickness
• Arc Tooth Thickness on Pitch Line
Chordal Thickness
• Length of Chord of Circular Thickness
• Used to Measure Tooth Thickness
– With Chordal Addendum
Chordal Addendum
66
Chordal Addendum
• Dimension from;
– Tip
– Center Span of Chordal Thickness
Backlash
67
Backlash
• Clearance Between Tooth Profiles
• Permits Smooth Operation
• Address Manufacturing Tolerance Stack
• Difference Between
– Circular Pitch
– Sum of Circular Thickness of
• Gear
• Pinion
Fillet Radius
136
68
Fillet Radius
• Stress Concentration Reduction
Top Land
138
69
Top Land
• Product of Tooth Thickness and Depth
• Minimum Required to Heat Treat
• Possibly Limits Strength Balance
Bottom Land
• Function of Point Width of Tool
Circular Pitch
140
70
Circular Pitch
• Sum of;
– Tooth Thickness of Pinion
– Tooth Thickness of Gear
– Backlash
• p = π / Pd
71
Tooth Flank
143
144
72
Gear Circle Nomenclature
Helical Gears
146
73
Involute Helicoid
Involute Helicoid
Cylinder
Axis
β
H
2πr
74
Involute Helicoid
Involute
Helicoid r
Helix
λ
Helix
Tangent
75
Involute Helicoid
Involute Helicoid
152
76
Involute Helicoid
Involute Helicoid
154
77
Involute
Helicoid Involute
Curves
rb
• Helical Gear
– Initially a Point
– Becomes a Line as Teeth Engage
– Diagonal across Face of Tooth
78
Helical Gear Contact
• Gradual Engagement of Teeth
• Smooth Transfer of Load Tooth to Tooth
• Transmit Heavy Loads at High Speeds
• Contact Ratio
– Face Contact Ratio
– Transverse Contact Ratio
– Modified (Total Effective) Contact Ratio
Helical Gear
Involute Surface and
Line of Contact
Face Width
t
tac
Con
f
eo
Lin
Normal Length
Base Pitch of
Action
Base Helix
Angle
158
79
Helical Gear Nomenclature
• Hand of Helix • Transverse Pitch
80
Hand of Helix
Plane of Rotation
Pitch Cylinders
Lead Angle Helix
Contact Point
Axis
L.H.
R.H.
Lead – 6”
Lead – 12”
• Helix Angle
81
Helix Angle
Plane of Rotation
Pitch Cylinders
Lead Angle Helix
Contact Point
Axis
L.H.
R.H.
Lead – 6”
Lead – 12”
• Helix Angle
• Lead Angle
82
Lead Angle
Plane of Rotation
Pitch Cylinders
Lead Angle Helix
Contact Point
Axis
L.H.
R.H.
Lead – 6”
Lead – 12”
• Helix Angle
• Lead Angle
• Lead
83
Lead
Plane of Rotation
Pitch Cylinders
Lead Angle Helix
Contact Point
Axis
L.H.
R.H.
Lead – 6”
Lead – 12”
Lead
Plane of Rotation
Pitch Cylinders
Lead Angle Helix
Contact Point
Axis
L.H.
R.H.
Lead – 6”
Lead – 12”
84
Helical Gear Nomenclature
• Hand of Helix • Transverse Pitch
• Helix Angle
• Lead Angle
• Lead
Transverse
Pitch
85
Helical Gear Nomenclature
• Hand of Helix • Transverse Pitch
• Lead Angle
• Lead
Normal
Pitch
86
Helical Gear Nomenclature
• Hand of Helix • Transverse Pitch
Normal
Pressure
Angle
87
Helical Gear Nomenclature
• Hand of Helix • Transverse Pitch
Transverse
Pressure
Angle
88
Helical Gear Nomenclature
• Pitch Helix • Normal Helix
89
Helical Gear Nomenclature
• Normal Plane
90
Helical Gear Nomenclature
• Normal Plane
• Transverse
Pressure Angle
91
Helical Gear Nomenclature
• Normal Plane
• Transverse
Pressure Angle
• Normal
Pressure Angle
92
Helical Gear Nomenclature
• Normal Plane
• Transverse
Pressure Angle
• Normal
Pressure Angle
93
Helical Gear Nomenclature
• Normal
Pressure Angle
94
Helical Gear Nomenclature
95
Helical Gear Nomenclature
96
Internal Gear Nomenclature
97
Bevel Gear
Nomenclature
195
Bevel Gear
Nomenclature
196
98
Bevel Gear Nomenclature
Operating Dimensions
• Theoretical Center Distance
• Operating (Spread) Center Distance
• Operating Pitch Diameter of;
– Pinion
– Gear
99
Center Distance
C
d
100
Operating (Spread) Center Distance
• Common Practice:
– Increase Center Distance Slightly
– Increases Operating Pressure Angle;
• If Operating Center Distance is 1.7116% Larger Operating
Pressure Angle will be 22.5 deg.s
Using 20 deg. Hobs
mG + 1.0
101
Theoretical Pressure Angle
• Given by Design
Pressure Angle
Pitch
Base Circles
Circles
φ
Pressure
Angle
Pitch
Points
102
Operating Pressure Angle
φ = cos-1 (cos φ Theo.)
Oper.
m`
• Blank Nomenclature
• Gear Nomenclature
• Tooth Nomenclature
103
Principle Planes
• Normal Plane
– Normal to the tooth at the pitch point
– Normal to the pitch plane
Principle Planes
Spur Gears
104
Principle Planes
• Normal Plane
– Normal to the tooth at the pitch point
– Normal to the pitch plane
• Transverse Plane
– Plane perpendicular to both the axial and the
pitch planes
Principle Planes
Helical Gears
105
Basic Rack
• What is the Basic Rack
• How is it used to
– Define Gears
– Design gears
– Design Cutters / Tools
– Why would one use it
Basic Rack
• As the Pitch Circle increases in size,
approaching infinite, it becomes a Rack
106
Principle Planes
Helical Gears
Basic Rack
• As the Pitch Circle increases in size,
approaching infinite, it becomes a Rack
107
Function of a Rack
• A Rack is the Basic Member for a Family
of Gears Conjugate to it
Interchangeable Gears
• Basis for Interchangeability is that the
Basic Member be Complimentary to Itself
108
Design of Gear Cutting Tools
• Hob design derived from the theory of
Basic Rack
• Hobs have Straight Cutting Sides
• Hob Representing the Basic Rack
– Rolls with the Work Piece
– Through a specific Relationship of Motion
– Such that it Generates the Involute Profile
• Motion is both relative Rotation and Translation
Interchangeable Gears
• Basis for Interchangeability is that the
Basic Member be Complimentary to Itself
109
Fillet Curve
• Shape is a Trochoid
– Generated by Radius at Corner of Hob / Tool
– May be Produced With a Protuberance Hob
• Provides Greater Clearance for Shaving / Grinding
Definition of a Trochoid
• Generally -- Trochoid is any curve that is
the locus of a point fixed to a curve A,
while A rolls on another curve B
without slipping
110
Definition of a Trochoid
• Generally -- Trochoid is any curve that is the locus
of a point fixed to a curve A, while A rolls on
another curve B without slipping
Pressure Angle φ 20 o
25 o
20o
Addendum a 1.000 / P 1.000 / P
Dedendum b 1.250 / P 1.200 / P + 0.002
Working Depth hk 2.000 / P 2.000 / P
Whole Depth (minimum) ht 2.250 / P 2.200 / P + 0.002
Circular Tooth Thickness t π / (2 * P) 1.5708 / P
Fillet Radius rf 0.300 / P Not Standardized
(of Basic Rack)
111
Gear Pair Action
• Principle Plane
• Line of Action
• Surface of Action
• Sliding
Velocity Ratio
• Ratio of the Pitch Diameters
• Ratio of Tooth Numbers
• Ratio of Base Circle Diameter
112
Pitch Surfaces
• Imaginary Planes, Cylinders or Cones that
roll together without slipping
X1
Pitch
Element
X2
Pitch
Cylinders
113
Principle Planes
Bevel Gears
Pitch
Element
Pitch
Cones
X2 228
114
Hyperboloid Pitch Surfaces
229
Pitch Circle
Base Circle
Involute
Addendum
Circles
Involute
Pitch
Circle
Base
Circle
Dedendum
Circle
115
Line of Action
231
Line of Action
• In Gear Geometry
– The path of action for involute gears
116
Surface of Action
• Point of Contact is Actually a Line
– Called the Line of Contact
Surface of Action
117
Surface of Action
• Point of Contact is Actually a Line
– Called the Line of Contact
Surface
of Action
118
Sliding
• Efficiency Factor Due to Frictional Loss
• Failure Mechanism:
– Wear / Scoring / Scuffing
– Heat Generation
– Lubricant Film Breakdown
• Two Types:
– Profile
– Length-Wise
Profile Sliding
• Due to the constant change in radius of
involute relative to each gear (as they are
in mesh)
119
Length-Wise
• Sliding along the face length of the tooth
Length-Wise
120
Length-Wise
Contact Lines As
Helix Tangents
Base Cylinder
Helix
Sliding Direction
• Spur Profile only
• Helical Profile only
• Bevel Profile only
• Cross-Helicals Both
• Spiroids Both
• Hypoids Both
• Worm Gears Length-Wise only
121
Preliminary Design Considerations
• Stress Formulations
122
Gear Type Selection
• Why would I select a Bevel Gear
– Transmit Power Through an Angle
• Non-Parallel Shaft Axes
123
Gear Type Selection
• Why would I select a Hypoid Gear
– Transmit Power Through an Angle
– Transmit Power with Off-set Shafts
• Straddle Mount Both Members
• Clearance Design Considerations
• Alignment Design Considerations
124
Other Types of Gears
• Skew Bevel Gears
• Face Gears
• Beveloid Gears
• Cross Axis Helical Gears
• Herringbone Gears
125
Gear Meshing Possibilities
Type Pinion Pinion
Of Pinion Pinion and Inter- One Pinion of 16
Gear and and Internal change- Tooth of 5 or
Teeth Gear rack Gear ability Pinion Teeth More
Teeth
126
How to Obtain Ratios
127
Gear Design Methodology
• Synthetic K Factor Method
• Proportional to Hertzian Contact Stress
– Based on Roller Bearing Analysis
128
K Factor by Application
• Automotive Transmission
– Steel, 58 HRC…………………………… K = 1.5
• General Purpose Industrial Drive
– Steel 575 BHN / Steel 575 BHN...……. K = 800
• Small Commercial
– Steel 350 BHN / Phenolic……………… K = 75
• Small Gadget
– Steel 200 BHN / Zinc…………………… K = 25
• Small Gadget
– Steel 200 BHN / Brass or Aluminum…. K = 25
Procedure
• For a Given Application
• Assume a K Factor From;
– Use Table 2.15
– On Pg. 2.45
– “Handbook of Practical Gear Design” by
Darle Dudley
129
Derive Base Equation
• Solving for the Face Width and Pinion
Diameter, as one term;
d*F = Wt * ( mG + 1 )
K mG
Best Practices
• Good Practice;
– The Ratio “F / d” Should Not Exceed 1.0
• F – Face Width
• d – Diameter of the smallest diameter member
130
General Design Procedure
for Parallel Axis Gears
• Compare Calculated Face Width, F to;
– Packaging Requirements
– Manufacturability Issues
– Iterate As Required
Next Step
• Once Diameter, Face Width are Selected
131
Pinion Tooth Number Guideline
NPmax
NP / NG
Stress Formulations
• The Synthetic K Factor Method Provides
Preliminary Sizing
• Next Step is to Calculate Bending and
Contact Stress
• Surface Durability
– Approximately 120 to 150 (ksi)
• Dudley Pg.s 13.17 thru 13.24
• Bending
– Approximately 35 to 50 (ksi)
• Dudley Pg.s 13.28 thru 13.38
132
General Survey of Power and Efficiency
Kind of Arrangement Nominal Typical Efficiency, %
Maximum
5:1 50:1 100:1
kW (hp) Ratio Ratio Ratio
Single Reduction:
Spur 2,240 (3,000) 98
Helical 22,400 (30,000) 98
Straight Bevel 370 (500) 98
Zerol bevel 745 (1,000) 98
Spiral Bevel 3,730 (5,000) 98
Hypoid 745 (1,000) 95 80 60
Crossed Helical 75 (100) 95 80 60
Cylindrical Worm 560 (750) 95 80 60
Double-enveloping Worm 745 (1,000) 95 80 60
Ratio Range
Kind of Arrangement 5:1 20:1 50:1 100:1
Single Reduction:
Spur, Helical, Bevel Small
Planoid Small
133
Gearbox Relative Size and Weight
Ratio Range
Kind of Arrangement 5:1 20:1 50:1 100:1
Double Reduction:
Single Power Path, Helical Gears Medium
Size
Multiple Power Path, Helical Gears Small Very
Small
Epicyclic Gears:
• Final Speed;
n6 = N2 N3 N5 n2 (rpm)
N3 N4 N6
134
Gear Arrangements
• Simple Gear Train
• Compound Gear Train
– Ratios
• Epicyclic
– Configurations (Solar, Planetary, Star)
– Ratios
– Tooth Number Selection and Build
Requirements
– Application
Planetaries
135
Epicyclical Trains
• Sun Gear • Single / Simple
• Several Planet Epicyclic Trains
Pinions – Planetary
• Ring Gear – Star
– Solar
• Planet-Pinion Carrier
• Compound Epicyclic
• Input & Output Shafts
– Planetary
– Star
– Solar
Ring Gear
Sun Gear
Planet
Carrier
Planet Pinion
136
Epicyclic Geartrain
Planetary Configuration
Sun Gear
Epicyclic Geartrain
Star Configuration
Planets
Rotate on Spindles
Rotating
Annulus Rotating
Sun Gear
Fixed
Planet Carrier
137
Epicyclic Geartrain
Solar Configuration
Planets
Rotate on Spindles
Rotating
Fixed
Planet Carrier
Sun Gear
Rotating
Annulus
• Planetary
– 3:1 to 12:1
• Star
– 2:1 to 11:1
• Solar
– 1.2:1 to 1.7:1
138
Simple Epicyclical Train
Ratio Equations
Revolution of
Operational
Sun Carrier Ring
Condition
Sun Fixed 0 1 1 + N s / Nr
Carrier Fixed 1 0 - N s / Nr
Ring Fixed 1 + N r / Ns 1 0
139
Compound Planetary Gear
Fixed Annulus
Planet Gear or Ring Gear
Housing
Sun Gear
Rotating Carrier
Rotating Carrier
Housing
Sun Gear
Star Pinion
140
Compound Epicyclical Train
Ratio Ranges
• Planetary
– 6:1 to 25:1
• Star
– 5:1 to 24:1
• Solar
– 1.05:1 to 2.20:1
Revolution of
Operational
Sun Carrier Ring
Condition
1 + Ns * Npr
Sun Fixed 0 1
Nps * Nr
- Ns * Npr
Carrier Fixed 1 0
Nps * Nr
1 + Nps * Nr
Ring Fixed 1 0
Ns * Npr
141
Compound Epicyclical Train
Build Requirements
Epicyclical Design
Considerations
142
Two Common
Compound Epicyclical
• Ravigneaux -- Planetary
– Two Separate Sun Gears
– Two Sets of Planet Gears
– One Planet Carrier
Ravigneaux
Compound Epicyclical
Short Long
Planet Gear Planet Gear
Reverse
Sun Gear
Forward (Input)
Sun Gear
Ring Gear
Rear View (Output)
143
Ravigneaux
Compound Epicyclical
Long
Ring Gear
Planet Gears
Reverse
Forward Sun Gear
Sun Gear
Short
Planet Gear
Rear
Facing
Output
Two Common
Compound Epicyclical
• Ravigneaux -- Planetary
– Two Separate Sun Gears
– Two Sets of Planet Gears
– One Planet Carrier
• Simpson -- Planetary
– Two Separate Ring Gears
– Two Separate Planet Carriers
– One Common Sun Gear
144
Simpson
Compound Epicyclical
Front
Planet
Gear
Drive Shell
Input
Shell Snap Ring
Thrust
Washer
Sun
Gear
Snap
Ring
145
Gear Selection Considerations
• NVH -- Noise, Vibration & Harshness
• Durability
• Power Density
• Support Requirements
• Lubrication
NVH
• Helical;
– Smoother Operation
– Quieter
• Tooth Contact Ratio;
– Axial Contact ratio
– Transverse Contact Ratio
• Spur Gears;
– Only Transverse of 1.2 to 1.5 Typical
146
Durability
• Bending Stresses & Contact Stresses
Should be Balanced for Application
• Carburized or Carbo-Nitrided
Power Density
• Helical Planetaries Provide Highest PD
• Spur Gears Lowest Cost / Lowest PD
• Helical are More Expensive to Mfg.
• Helical Gears Require More Expensive
Support
• Helical Require Better Control of Mounting
and Positioning
147
Support
• Helical Gears Require Axial & Radial Thrust
Lubrication
• All Gear Teeth Require Lubricant Flow
• Pressure Lubrication;
– 20% - 30% Incoming Mesh (lubrication)
– 70% - 80% Output Mesh (cooling)
• Forced Lubrication;
– Shaft Design to Put Lubrication where Needed
148
Lubricant Cooling
• Internal Lubricant Circulation
• Forced Cooling
– Radiator
– Circulation Pump
Drawing Information
• Gear Data Tabular Information
• Gear Measurement & Inspection
• Tolerances
– Spur
– Helical
– Bevel
• Straight
• Spiral
149
300
150
Lead Tolerance Chart
151
Tooth Profile Crown Note
304
152
Gear Measurement and Inspection
Tooth Thickness
• Gear Tooth Caliper
• Pin Diameter
• Dimension Over Pins
• Modify Pin Diameter and Dimension
Over Pins
• Pin Contact Point
• Span Measurement
153
Drawing Information
• Gear Data Tabular Information
• Gear Measurement & Inspection
Involute
Test
Diameter
Over Pins
Concentricity
360
o Runout Taken
with a Ball
Number of Teeth Checker
154
Tooth Chordal Dimensions
Arc Chordal
Thickness Thicknes
(t) s
(tc)
Gear Tooth
Caliper
310
155
Gear Tooth Caliper
• Used to Measure Gear Tooth Thickness
• At Pitch Line
• Affected by Gear Diameter Variance
– Undersize Blank
• Measure Too Large
– Oversize Blank
• Measure Too Small
• Technique Sensitive
• Affected by;
– Tooth Spacing Errors
– Profile Errors
156
Measurement Over Pins
• Helical Gears
– Use Balls or Dumbbell Pins
– Due to Curvature of Tooth Space
– Critical for Odd Number of Teeth
Measurement
Over Pins
157
Pin Sizes Used to Check the Tooth Thickness of Spur Gears
158
Calculate Dimension Over Pins
• For Standard Pin Diameter
• Internal Spur Gears
• Even Tooth Numbers
– Dudley Practical, Pg. 9.27 – Table &
Method
159
Calculate Dimension Over Pins
• For Standard Pin Diameter
• External Helical Gears
• Even Tooth Numbers
– Dudley Practical, Pg. 9.32 – Table &
Method
160
Span Measurement
M = 3 Pb + tP
BC
Where;
tP = B *ν (for spur gears)
BC
tP = B *ν* sin (θn) (for helical gears)
BC
sin (θt)
ν = tP + Inv (θt)
t
PD
161
Gear Measurement and Inspection
• Involute Chart
• Lead Chart
Involute Chart
o o o
o 6 12 18
0
162
Involute
Chart
Involute Measurement
• Measure of Gear Tooth Profile
• Rolling Gear on Base Circle
• Produces Contact Traces of Profile
• Relation Between Roll Angle / Profile
• Variations in Tooth Geometry
– Deviations from Straight Line on Chart
• Run Out / Gear Wobble Effect Trace
• Measure at Several Axial Positions
163
Involute Measurement Results
True Involute
True Profile
Actual Involute
Form Diameter
Acceptable
Involute
Profiles
164
Equivalent Band Chart 0
-5
True
Involute
Acceptable
Involute
Profiles
-5
329
0
20% of
Total -5
Roll Angle
165
Modified “K” Chart -3 -8
With Tip OD 1
and
Flank Relief 2
PD 3
TIF 5
-3 -8
True Involute
Actual Profile
Actual Involute
Form Diameter
166
Involute Measurement Results
Plus Pressure Angle
Form Diameter
Form Diameter
167
Gear Measurement and Inspection
• Involute Chart
• Lead Chart
Lead
• Axial Advance of a Helix for One Complete
Turn
168
Lead
Plane of Rotation
Pitch Cylinders
Lead Angle Helix
Contact Point
Axis
L.H.
R.H.
Lead – 6”
Lead – 12”
Lead
• Axial Advance of a Helix for One Complete
Turn
• Lead Tolerance
– Is the total allowable lead variation
• Lead Variation
– Is measured in the Direction Normal to the
Specified Lead of the Gear
169
Lead Chart
• Lead
– Usually Specified Between Points
– Represent 85% of Face Width
Lead Chart
Good Profile
340
170
Lead Chart
Acceptable Profile
341
Lead Chart
Concave Profile
342
171
Lead Chart
Profile with
Protuberance
Lead Chart
Profile with
Protuberance
172
Lead Chart
Profile
Outside Gauge
Lead Chart
• Lead
– Usually Specified Between Points
– Represent 85% of Face Width
• Crest of Crown
– Specifies Position Along Tooth
– Differing Based on Design & Application
173
Crown Tolerance
Crown Tolerance
348
174
Long & Short Lead
Spur Helical
Gear Gear
175
Lead of Tapered Teeth
Spur Helical
Gear Gear
176
Gear Measurement and Inspection
• Involute Chart
• Lead Chart
Red Liner
• Double Flank Tester
• Master Gear
177
Red Liner
Schematic of Gear Rolling Device
Red Liner
• Double Flank Tester
• Master Gear
• Motion of Center of Test Gear
– Recorded (Trace)
– During Roll with Master
178
Red Liner
Typical Chart
357
Red Liner
• Double Flank Tester
• Master Gear
• Motion of Center of Test Gear
– Recorded (Trace)
– During Roll with Master
• Measures Variation of Test Gear
– Composite Test & Master Gear Error
– Master Variation Assumed to be Negligible
179
Red Liner Data
• Total Composite Error
Red Liner
Typical Chart
360
180
Red Liner Data
• Total Composite Error
Red Liner
Typical Chart
362
181
Red Liner Data
• Total Composite Error
• Runout
Red Liner
Typical Chart
364
182
Red Liner Limitations
• Test Run with Zero Backlash
– Not at Operating Pitch Diameter
183
Single Flank Gear Tester
Schematic
367
184
CMM
• Index Variation
• Lead Variation
• Involute Variation
• Topological Plots
Topological Plot
of a Gear Tooth
Surface from an
Automated CMM
370
185
Gear Design Systems and Best
Practices
• Common Proportions
• Interchangeability
• Tooling Considerations
• Mounting Considerations
• Application
186
Gear Seminar Reference List
1. “Gear Handbook” by Darle W. Dudley. First Edition, McGraw-Hill, Inc. 1962.
2. “Dudley’s Gear Handbook, Second Edition” by Dennis P. Townsend. McGraw-Hill, Inc. 1992.
(ISBN: 0-07-017903-4)
7. “The Internal Gear”, by The Fellows Corporation. Seventh Ed, Fellows Corporation. 1978.
8. “Encyclopedic Dictionary of Gears and Gearing” by D.W. South and R.H. Ewert. McGraw-Hill,
Inc., New York, New York. 1994. (ISBN: 0-07-059795-0)
9. “MAAG Gear Book” by MAAG Gear Company Ltd. 1990.
10.“Gleason Fachworter” by The Gleason Works. Alfred Wentzky & Co. 1967.
7. “Mechanical Designs and Systems Handbook”, by Harold Rothbart. Second Edition, McGraw-
Hill Inc. 1985. (ISBN: 0-07-054020-9)
8. “Mark’s Standard Handbook for Mechanical Engineers ” by Eugene Avallone and Theodore
Baumeister. McGraw-Hill Inc. 1978. (ISBN:0-07-004127-X)
187
Gear Seminar Reference List
9. “Rules of Thumb for Mechanical Engineers” by J. Edward Pope. Gulf Publishing Company.
1997.
10.“Mechanisms and Mechanical Devices Sourcebook” by Nicholas Chironis and Neil Sclater.
Second Edition, McGraw-Hill, Inc. 1996. (ISBN: 0-07-011256-4)
11. “Stress Concentration Factors” by R. E. Peterson. John Wiley and Sons, Inc. 1974.
188