Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
A (2016)122:972
DOI 10.1007/s00339-016-0507-8
123
972 Page 2 of 8 M. Abas, K. Rahman
layers, and in between these two layers there is a single bending angles to study repeatability, reliability and degree
resistive layer. By bending, the layers are pushed together of handling. Mahoor et al. [26] fabricated wearable sensor
and as a result resistance decreases [14]. for monitoring and measuring joint angles of the human
Kim et al. [15] developed a high-performance silicon- body. To measure flexion of joints, the sensor is incorpo-
based flexible tactical sensor using dry transfer-printing rated with clothes. The limitation of fabricated sensor is its
method. The fabricated sensor was capable, to sense short life and resistance to high bending angle. Kure et al.
position as well as contact force. Vatani et al. [16] fabri- [27] fabricated flexible displacement sensor by patterning
cated carbon nanotube-based stretchable tactical sensor conductive paste on rubber substrate through ink jetting.
using a novel hybrid manufacturing technique. The pre- By deforming the rubber, a change in electrical resistance
sented technique combines projection-based stereo-lithog- occurs. The basic purpose of it is to pinpoint displacement
raphy and direct print/cure (DPC). The study revealed that of soft actuator. In another study, Kure et al. [28] in their
new technique and material are promising to fabricate study developed displacement sensor for intelligent flexible
tactical sensor for various flexible electronic applications. micro-actuator (FMA) by extruding conductive paste on
Bang et al. [17] introduces the flexible fiber Bragg grating rubber seat. Memoon et al. [29] fabricated the bend sensors
(FBG)-based arrayed sensor system. Fabricated sensor is through roll to roll micro-grave printing system. Activated
used to measure bending deflection and strain of wind carbon with PVDF as binding agent is deposited on PET
turbine tower. In a study of Kang et al. [18], strain of substrate. Fabricated sensor is assimilated with glove to
cantilever beam is measured using a flexible fiber grating study its performance. The result revealed that sensors are
sensor using collimators. Flexible sensor based on PEDOT: stable and have low cost. Gems et al. [30] developed the
PSS polymer was fabricated and reported by Saggio [19]. flexible sensor from conductive carbon-based ink on
Resistance variation is calculated by bending the sensor to polyester plastic substrate. The performance of the sensor
a different radius in two directions either inward or out- is studied under different bending angles from 0 to 90.
ward. More the substrate is subjected to bending, the The study showed that the sensor performance is good in
greater will be resistance. So there is a direct relation case of response time and repeatability. Gentner et al. [31]
between bending and resistance. A design analysis made by integrated carbon-based bend sensor with glove for mea-
Simone et al. [20] on wearable sensor glove specifically suring finger movement for neurophysiological settings.
focuses on bend measure. As compared to commercial The study revealed that its performance is good, and it is
gloves, it is economical and provides good and repeat- more economical compared to commercially available.
able results. Transparent self-sensing deformable surface The present work is intended to optimize printing con-
was fabricated by Rendl et al. [21]. The active sensor dition for DIW system using Taguchi design optimization
material is copolymer P (VDF-TrFE), while electrode technique. Based on optimized parameters, flex sensors of
material is metal nanowire ink. These sensors have great different lengths will be generated from conductive carbon
application in deformable displays. Jurgens et al. [22] paste on flexible PET substrate. The sensor will be sub-
fabricated the flexible sensor based on carbon. Polyester is jected to different bending angles to study its performance
used as a substrate. The sensor can be used for one direc- and stability through electrical characterization.
tion bending because the percentage change in resistance is
too low. Saggio [23] studied the effect of change in elec-
trical resistance when the sensors are exposed to stresses 2 Experimental setup
having two different topologies: (1) by bending it at dif-
ferent radii of curvature such as movement of shoulder, In present work, positive displacement dispensing system,
abdomen, neck and chest and (2) by bending with fixed one of direct ink write technique is designed for the
radius of curvature which is mimic of knee, elbow, ankle printing of flex sensor. The system comprises of X–Y
and finger joints. When the sensor is bent inward, its translation stage controlled through the computer. A 10-cc
resistance decreases; resistance increases when it is bent ink-loaded syringe is attached to a head assembly to gen-
outward. Luo et al. [24] fabricated graphitic sensors on erate patterns with controlled composition and architecture.
polyimide substrate through direct laser writing (DLW) Schematic of designed DIW system is shown in Fig. 1. The
technique. The performance was studied through mechan- design approach relies on generating the desired pattern by
ical test, i.e., under different bending angle and electrical extruding a continuous ink filament. The ink is delivered to
test, resistance changes with respect to time response. substrate under pressure mode. The pressure required for
Saggio [25] developed flex sensor based on carbon paste. dispensing depends on the diameter of nozzle, ink rheology
The sensors were integrated with gloves to perform and printing speed. The minimum feature size and pattern
goniometric semiautomated measurements. The paste is dimensions depend on horizontal (x–y) and vertical
coated on flexible plastic substrate and subjected to various (z) translation distances, resolution and speed. The actual
123
Fabrication of flex sensors through direct ink write technique and its electrical… Page 3 of 8 972
Carbon Particles
DIW is shown in Fig. 2. Conductive carbon paste bought Fig. 4 SEM image of conductive carbon paste
from Guangzhou Print Area Trading Co., Ltd having vis-
cosity of 3500 cps is used for patterns generation. No
modification is done in ink rheology and used as received.
Figure 3 shows dispensing of material through the nozzle
to generate patterns. Figure 4 shows the SEM image of
conductive carbon paste, showing carbon particles at 5 lm
scale. Average size of carbon particle paste is 15 lm. As
shown in Fig. 5 of EDS spectrum, carbon has higher con-
centration in paste due to its high peak energy value.
It is important to optimize printing parameters to achieve Fig. 5 EDX spectrum of carbon paste
better quality and control resolution of patterns. Taguchi
method, a design optimization technique, is adopted to find by analyzing deviation from target values. Depending on
optimal control parameters for printing. The method uses the goal of experiment, there are three categories of S/N
special orthogonal array design to study parameters with ratio, i.e., larger is better, nominal is best, and smaller is
limited experimental runs. The results obtained from better. Each level of control parameters is computed based
experimental runs are converted to signal-to-noise ratio (S/ on S/N analysis. Irrespective of categories, larger S/N ratio
N ratio). S/N ratio is used to measure quality characteristics corresponds to better quality characteristics. So the optimal
123
972 Page 4 of 8 M. Abas, K. Rahman
level of control parameter is the level with highest S/N tip and substrate. If the nozzle is too close to the substrate, it
ratio. Moreover, to identify the significant control param- will affect substrate surface as well as reduce the flow rate of
eter, an analysis of variance (ANOVA) is also performed. ink. If the distance of nozzle is too high, then it will be
Lastly, experimental runs are conducted to validate the difficult to achieve continuous patterns because of the
optimal control parameters from the parameter design. breakup of the ink due to surface tension [32].
Controlling parameters selected for the present study are Three experimental levels are set for each control param-
air pressure, feed rate and standoff distance, while the per- eter as shown in Table 1. Taguchi L27 orthogonal array is
formance measure is the width of pattern. Air pressure is an designed in the present study as depicted in Table 2. Since we
important parameter to control during the dispensing pro- want to achieve minimum width patterns, we selected signal-
cess. It directly affects the flow rate of material through to-noise (S/N) ratio based on ‘‘smaller the better’’ for analysis.
nozzle tip [27]. The feed rate is the distance by which the For each experimental runs, widths of patterns generated were
table carrying substrate moves during dispensing of material. calculated using an optical microscope. All experiments were
It greatly affects continuity of patterns as well as pattern conducted on 200-lm nozzle using conductive carbon paste
width [27]. Standoff distance is the distance between nozzle and PET substrate. The patterns generated were cured at
130 C for 20 min in a dry oven.
Table 1 Factor level for experiments of 200-lm nozzle S/N ratio obtained for experimental runs is shown in
Factors Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Table 2. In Taguchi technique, the word ‘signal’ exem-
plifies desirable value (mean), while ‘noise’ exemplifies
Pressure (P) (psi) 70 80 90 undesirable value (standard deviation) for performance
Feed rate (F) (mm/s) 0.5 1 1.5 measure. Therefore, S/N ratio signifies the amount of
Standoff distance (S) (mm) 0.4 0.6 0.8 variation present in performance measure. As the main
123
Fabrication of flex sensors through direct ink write technique and its electrical… Page 5 of 8 972
Table 3 S/N ratio for width of pattern Table 5 Conformation test for width of pattern
Levels Pressure (psi) Feed rate (mm/s) Standoff distance (mm) Initial control parameters Optimal parameters
123
972 Page 6 of 8 M. Abas, K. Rahman
Fig. 7 Fixture for bending of PET substrate Fig. 10 I–V curve for two flex sensors after first and 100 cycle of
bending
PET substrate
Bending
Protractor
Fig. 8 Actual bending fixture
123
Fabrication of flex sensors through direct ink write technique and its electrical… Page 7 of 8 972
4 Conclusions
References
123
972 Page 8 of 8 M. Abas, K. Rahman
11. L. Dipietro, A.M. Sabatini, P. Dario, Survey of glove-based 23. G. Saggio, Electrical resistance profiling of bend sensors adopted
systems and their applications. IEEE Trans. Syst. Man Cybern. to measure spatial arrangement of the human body, in Proceed-
C Appl. Rev. 38(4), 461–482 (2008) ings of the 4th International Symposium on Applied Sciences in
12. S. Merilampi, T. Laine-Ma, P. Ruuskanen, The characterization Biomedical and Communication Technologies (2011), p. 5
of electrically conductive silver ink patterns on flexible sub- 24. S. Luo, P.T. Hoang, T. Liu, Direct laser writing for creating
strates. Microelectron. Reliab. 49(7), 782–790 (2009) porous graphitic structures and their use for flexible and highly
13. M.A. Zawawi, S. O’Keeffe, E. Lewis, Intensity-modulated fiber sensitive sensor and sensor arrays. Carbon 96, 522–531 (2015)
optic sensor for health monitoring applications: a comparative 25. G. Saggio, A novel array of flex sensors for a goniometric glove.
review. Sens. Rev. 33(1), 57–67 (2013) Sens. Actuators 205, 119–125 (2014)
14. H. Yoon, Current trends in sensors based on conducting polymer 26. S. Bakhshi, M.H. Mahoor, Development of a wearable sensor
nanomaterials. Nanomaterials 3(3), 524–549 (2013) system for measuring body joint flexion, in International Con-
15. M.S. Kim, H.J. Shin, Y.K. Park, Design concept of high-perfor- ference on Body Sensor Networks (2011), pp. 35–40
mance flexible tactile sensors with a robust structure. Int. J. Pre- 27. K. Kure, T. Kanda, K. Suzumori, S. Wakimoto, Flexible dis-
cis. Eng. Manuf. 13(11), 1941–1947 (2012) placement sensor using injected conductive paste. Sens. Actua-
16. M. Vatani, Y. Lu, E.D. Engeberg, J.W. Choi, Combined 3D tors 143(2), 272–278 (2008)
printing technologies and material for fabrication of tactile sen- 28. K. Kure, T. Kanda, K. Suzumori, S. Wakimoto, Intelligent FMA
sors. Int. J. Precis. Eng. Manuf. 16(7), 1375–1383 (2015) using flexible displacement sensor with paste injection, in IEEE
17. H.J. Bang, H.I. Kim, K.S. Lee, Measurement of strain and International Conference on Robotics and Automation, ICRA
bending deflection of a wind turbine tower using arrayed FBG (2006), pp. 1012–1017
sensors. Int. J. Precis. Eng. Manuf. 13(12), 2121–2126 (2012) 29. M. Sajid, H.W. Danga, K.H. Na, K.H. Choi, Highly stable flex
18. M.K. Kang, D.J. Park, S.S. Lee, Strain measurements on a can- sensors fabricated through mass production roll-to-roll micro-
tilever beam with fiber bragg grating sensors using a pair of gravure printing system. Sens. Actuators, A 236, 73–81 (2015)
collimators. Int. J. Precis. Eng. Manuf. 13(3), 455–458 (2012) 30. J.J. Gems, P.E. Pattersont, Development and evaluation of an
19. G. Saggio, Mechanical model of flex sensors used to sense finger inexpensive sensor system for use in measuring relative finger
movements. Sens. Actuators A 185, 53–58 (2012) positions. Med. Eng. Phys. 19(1), 1–6 (1997)
20. L.K. Simone, D.G. Kamper, Design considerations for a wearable 31. R. Gentner, J. Classen, Development and evaluation of a low-cost
monitor to measure finger posture. J. Neuro Eng. Rehabil. 2(1), 1 sensor glove for assessment of human finger movements in
(2005) neurophysiological settings. J. Neurosci. Methods 178(1),
21. C. Rendl, D. Kim, S. Fanello, P. Parzer, C. Rhemann, J. Taylor, 138–147 (2009)
M. Zirkl, et al., FlexSense: a transparent self-sensing deformable 32. Z.L. Jiang, Y.Y. Liu, H.P. Chen, Y.N. Zhang, Q.X. Hu, Multi-
surface, in Proceedings of the 27th Annual ACM Symposium on objective optimization of process parameters for biological 3D
User Interface Software and Technology (2014), pp. 129–138 printing composite forming based on SNR and grey correlation
22. J. Jurgens, P.E. Patterson, Development and evaluation of an degree. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 80(1), 549–554 (2015)
inexpensive sensor system for use in measuring relative finger
positions. Med. Eng. Phys. 19(1), 1–6 (1997)
123