Suite 39, 5th Floor, Katherine & West Building,

114 West Street, Sandton

Tel: 011 072 2600
Fax: 087 220 1075

Postnet Suite 104, Private Bag 9976, Sandton, 2146

Email: info@mkinc.africa
Web: www.mkinc.africa

Our Ref: T Malatji Your Ref: Date: 10 November 2018

Direct Tel: 011 072 2601 Direct Email: tmalatji@mkinc.africa

TO ALL MEDIA HOUSES

Dear Sir/ Madame,

MINISTER PRAVIN GORDHAN AND THE PUBLIC PROTECTOR’S INVESTIGATION

1 We wish to place on record, particular facts about our interactions with the Office of the
Public Protector on behalf of our client, Minister Pravin Gordhan.

2 On 05 February 2018, the Public Protector, Advocate Busisiwe Mkhwebane, sent a letter to
Minister Gordhan. The letter reiterated the very same allegations that were the subject of a
criminal investigation by the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation (“DPCI/the Hawks”),
and subsequent criminal charges by the National Prosecuting Authority (“NPA”) levelled
against Minister Gordhan on 11 October 2016, regarding the early retirement of Mr Ivan
Pillay and his subsequent re-employment by the South African Revenue Service as Deputy
Commissioner in 2010.

3 On 31 October 2016, the criminal charges were withdrawn by the National Director of
Public Prosecution based on, among other considerations, the written submissions by our
Mr Malatji, assisted by senior counsel, to the Hawks that showed that the criminal charges
cannot be sustained on any factual or legal basis.

4 In a subsequent complaint to the Public Protector in November 2016, it was alleged that
the approval by Minister Gordhan of Mr Pillay’s early retirement amounted to
maladministration, dishonest and improper conduct by the Minister in dealing with public
funds.

5 We wrote to the Public Protector on 16 February 2018, expressly stating that we require
that we be provided the particulars and evidence of the alleged dishonesty and impropriety
on the part of Minister Gordhan.

6 To date, such evidence and particulars have not been provided, but for a letter from the
Office of the Public Protector dated 28 February 2018, indicating that the Office was in the
process of conducting a preliminary investigation as contemplated in section 7(1)(a) of the
Public Protector Act, 1994. In the said letter, the Public Protector indicated that her Office
has no evidence implicating Minister Gordhan of any wrongdoing.

7 Subsequent thereto, the investigators in the Office of the Public Protector contacted our
law firm on 3 July 2018 requesting that Minister Gordhan respond to the initial letter of 5
February 2018. They did so despite the fact that no particulars had been provided as
requested. For the sake of cooperating with the Office of the Public Protector, we advised
the Public Protector that we will obtain the Minister’s instructions.

Directors: Tebogo Malatji B Proc LLB Sunelle Eloff B Com LLM Bonang Masia LLB Sayi Nindi LLB LLM
Practising Consultant: Moeti Kanyane B Proc LLB
Associate: Ally Makgopa LLB Reg No: 2018/261984/21
Office Manager: Tummy Seboko Vat no: 4920281922
 -2-

8 These instructions were sought to confirm whether the Minister is obliged to respond to the
Public Protector’s letter of 5 February 2018 in circumstances were the particulars sought
by us on 16 February 2018 were still outstanding.

9 In the intervening period, the Office of the Public Protector proceeded to issue a subpoena
on 01 October 2018 for the Minister to appear before her on 14 November 2018.

10 Any communication that suggests that Minister Gordhan has not responded to the Public
Protector’s enquiries between February and July 2018 – or that “responses were not
forthcoming” - is simply deceptive, false and incorrect. The Minister is yet to receive any
particulars and/or evidence of maladministration, dishonesty or impropriety referred to in
the Public Protector’s initial correspondence of 5 February 2018 and her subpoena of 01
October 2018.

11 Minister Gordhan will nonetheless appear before the Public Protector in response to the
subpoena.

12 For any inquiries, contact Tebogo Malatji at 083 676 6238.

13 Yours faithfully,

MALATJI KANYANE INC

PER: T Malatji
Electronically transmitted and thus unsigned