Comparative Statement for Architectural Design and Engineering Consultancy for Resident Complex for 1,500 Non-Management Staf

Sl. No. Description of Work Qty. in Sf Design Cell Fialka Pronayon Ehsan Khan
Work Rate inTk. Amount in Tk. Work Rate inTk. Amount in Tk. Rate inTk. Amount in Tk. Work Rate inTk. Amount in Tk.
Architectural-
Architectural 20 1,955,100 G. Floor 27 2,639,385 CDA Format 12 1,173,060
Architectural Design and
Engineering Consultancy Architectural-
1 for Resident Complex for 97,755 Structural 8 782,040 Building 15 1,466,325 3D Format 22 2,150,610
1,500 Non-Management 42 4,105,710
Water & Sanitary 4 391,020 Structural 5 488,775
Staf
Electrical 3 293,265 Plumbing 3 293,265
Electrical 3 293,265
Grand Total 35 3,421,425 42 4,105,710 42 4,105,710 45 4,398,975

Name of Consultants
S.L Field of Compare Unit Remarks/
Design cell Fialka Pronayon Recommendation
No of Building / Block High rise building is
1 project Area prefered where the
Nos 12 3 3 land is limited &
Building Storey/Floor price is so high.
2 consider
Floor G+ 4 & G+ 5 G+ 10 G+ 5 Scattered building
service facility is low
3 No of Room 720 780 750 also cost is high also
covered more area
No of Dwellers/ Tenant with huge
4 in each floor each 30 28 100
construction
building Nos activities. As the G+5
Ground Floor Area uses is more efective
5 without lift which
in Sqm Sqm Nill 2912 3045
also leads good
building service with
Common Facilities cost economic
6 (Dining, Kitchen & Prayer In 4-nos block In single place In single place
design. So as above
etc.) Block perspective view &
7 Lift facilities Nos 0 6-nos 0 considering all other
aspects we can
8 Incorporation of water proceed for G+5
body Not incorporated Incorporated Incorporated building to make the
9 Pheripherial Road Used Used Not Used Dormitory more
efficient.
10 Ventilation Provided Provided Provided
11 Building service Medium Medium Good

Area= Area=
G+4=8X60X160=76800 Area= 7,340x3 = 22,020 Sft x10 = 1,015x3X6 =
12 Rough cost estimate idea G+5=4X60X160=38400 = 2,202,000 sft + Misc. = TK. 196,403 Sft X
316,800 Sft X 1,800 + 500,000,000 + Tk.30,000,000 for 1,800 +Misc. =
Miscellineous = TK. piling = Tk. 530,000,000 TK.
590,000,000 380,000,000

13 Area Ten floor=3X10X7340=220200 sft

GF=31300 sft
Common=4X12X160=7680 Total=251500 sft
Total=122880 sft+40% common facilities=172032sft
 Name of Consultants Weitage (In
S.L Field of Compare Unit
Design cell 5 scale)
No of Building / Block
1 project Area 12 1
Nos
Building Storey/Floor
2 consider 5
Floor G+ 4 & G+ 5
3 No of Room 720 1

4 No of Dwellers/ Tenant in 30 1
each floor each building Nos
5 Ground Floor Area uses 1
in Sqm Sqm Nill

Common Facilities
6 (Dining, Kitchen & Prayer In 4-nos block 2
etc.) Block
7 Lift facilities Nos 0 5

8 Incorporation of water 1
body Not incorporated
9 Pheripherial Road Used 5
10 Ventilation Provided 5
11 Building service Medium 3

Area= G+4 (15X160X5) + (G+5

(15X160X6)) = 26,400X12 =
12 Rough cost estimate idea 316,800 Sft X 1,800 + 1
Miscellineous = TK.
590,000,000

Total Weitage = 31
 Name of Consultants Weitage (In
S.L Field of Compare Unit
Fialka 5 scale)
No of Building / Block
1 Nos 3 5
project Area
Building Storey/Floor
2 Floor G+ 10 1
consider
3 No of Room 780 2

No of Dwellers/ Tenant in
4 Nos 28 1
each floor each building

5 Ground Floor Area uses in Sqm 2912 4

Sqm
Common Facilities
6 (Dining, Kitchen & Prayer Block In single place 3
etc.)
7 Lift facilities Nos 6-nos 1
Incorporation of water
8 Incorporated 4
body
9 Pheripherial Road Used 5
10 Ventilation Provided 5
11 Building service Medium 3

Area= 7,340x3 = 22,020 Sft

x10 = 2,202,000 sft + Misc. =
12 Rough cost estimate idea TK. 500,000,000 + 2
Tk.30,000,000 for piling = Tk.
530,000,000

Total Weitage = 36
 Name of Consultants Weitage (In
S.L Field of Compare Unit
Pronayon 5 scale)
No of Building / Block
1 Nos 3 5
project Area
Building Storey/Floor
2 Floor G+ 5 5
consider
3 No of Room 750 2

No of Dwellers/ Tenant in
4 Nos 100 4
each floor each building

5 Ground Floor Area uses in Sqm 3045 2

Sqm

Common Facilities (Dining,

6 Block In single place 3
Kitchen & Prayer etc.)

7 Lift facilities Nos 0 5

Incorporation of water
8 Incorporated 4
body
9 Pheripherial Road Not Used 1
10 Ventilation Provided 5
11 Building service Good 3

Area= 1,015x3X6 = 196,403 Sft X

12 Rough cost estimate idea 5
1,800 +Misc. = TK. 380,000,000

Total Weitage = 44