Sunteți pe pagina 1din 12

Scandinavian Journal of Occupational Therapy

ISSN: 1103-8128 (Print) 1651-2014 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/iocc20

Community-based participatory research


to promote healthy lifestyles among Latino
immigrant families with youth with disabilities

Yolanda Suarez-Balcazar, Amy Early, Ashley Maldonado, Claudia P. Garcia,


Dalmina Arias, Amalia Zeidman & Alexander Agudelo-Orozco

To cite this article: Yolanda Suarez-Balcazar, Amy Early, Ashley Maldonado, Claudia P.
Garcia, Dalmina Arias, Amalia Zeidman & Alexander Agudelo-Orozco (2018): Community-based
participatory research to promote healthy lifestyles among Latino immigrant families with youth with
disabilities, Scandinavian Journal of Occupational Therapy, DOI: 10.1080/11038128.2018.1502348

To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/11038128.2018.1502348

Published online: 03 Oct 2018.

Submit your article to this journal

View Crossmark data

Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at


http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=iocc20
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY
https://doi.org/10.1080/11038128.2018.1502348

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Community-based participatory research to promote healthy lifestyles


among Latino immigrant families with youth with disabilities
Yolanda Suarez-Balcazar, Amy Early, Ashley Maldonado, Claudia P. Garcia, Dalmina Arias,
Amalia Zeidman and Alexander Agudelo-Orozco
Department of Occupational Therapy, College of Applied Health Sciences, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA

ABSTRACT ARTICLE HISTORY


Background/Aims: Community-based participatory research (CBPR) is an optimal approach that Received 30 November 2017
brings together community stakeholders, researchers and practitioners in an effort to understand Revised 8 February 2018
and address social issues and health disparities experienced by vulnerable populations. Latino immi- Accepted 13 March 2018
grant families in the United States with youth and young families with disabilities have experienced
KEYWORDS
a number of barriers in gaining positive health outcomes. These families face challenges in maintain- Participatory research;
ing a healthy lifestyle, placing them at high risk for obesity, diabetes, and other chronic health condi- Latino; health
tions. The purpose of this study was to develop a healthy lifestyles intervention in collaboration with disparities; disability
Latino immigrant families with youth and young adults with disabilities using a CBPR approach, and
to examine the impact of the intervention from participants’ perspectives.
Methods: Grounded in the principles of CBPR, we developed a partnership with community
stakeholders to create a healthy lifestyles intervention aimed at meeting the needs of Latino
families in the United States. During and following implementation of the intervention, we con-
ducted focus groups with 12 intervention participants to examine the impact of the intervention.
Results: Participants identified the intervention program as meeting a need in the community
and reported specific positive aspects related to health behaviors, social learning, inclusion, com-
munity participation, and peer advocacy.
Discussion: CBPR healthy lifestyle interventions are relevant to the needs of Latino immigrant
families with youth and young adults with disabilities. Health professionals should involve
community residents in the design of healthy lifestyles programming to ensure strategies for
change are relevant and relatable.

Introduction nondisabled peers or those with disabilities from other


Community-based participatory research (CBPR) is an ethnic/racial backgrounds [3]. Latino families with
approach that brings together community stakeholders, youth and young adults with disabilities lack culturally
researchers and practitioners in an effort to understand relevant and family oriented healthy lifestyles program-
and address social issues that matter to the community ming. Immigrant families with members with disabil-
[1]. CBPR has also been proposed as the optimal ities are more likely to experience occupational
approach to address health disparities experienced by deprivation as there are few accessible opportunities for
marginalized communities. Latino immigrant families a healthy and engaging life [4]. Furthermore, they often
in the United States with youth with disabilities is one live in communities that lack health services, public
such group that has experienced a number of gaps in transportation, affordable and inclusive recreational
health outcomes [2]. Specifically, these families face programs, and community social services [2,5].
numerous barriers to maintaining a healthy lifestyle, Interest in addressing health disparities among
placing them at high risk for obesity, diabetes, and other marginalized groups is on the rise among health pro-
chronic health conditions [2]. Strong evidence suggests fessions including occupational therapy. The purpose
obesity rates are higher among Latino youth with dis- of this paper is two-fold: (1) To describe a commu-
abilities and their families when compared to their nity-based participatory approach utilized to develop

CONTACT Yolanda Suarez-Balcazar ysuarez@uic.edu Department of Occupational Therapy, College of Applied Health Sciences, University of
Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL 60612
Present address: Professor, Universidad Del Valle, Cali, Colombia.
ß 2018 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group
2 Y. SUAREZ-BALCAZAR ET AL.

a healthy lifestyles intervention in collaboration with Literature on accessible and culturally appropriate
Latino families with youth and young adults with dis- health and wellness programs for Latino families with
abilities; and (2) to discuss findings from a qualitative youth and young adults with disabilities is sparse,
study examining the impact of the intervention. particularly interventions that have been designed
Implications for health professionals are discussed. In with the active participation of families in order to
the context of this study, healthy lifestyles refer to
meet their needs [5]. Some evidence-based interven-
opportunities that vulnerable populations have to par-
tions are available, focusing on promoting healthy
ticipate actively in physical and recreational activities,
consume healthy products, and engage in fun activ- lifestyles among youth with disabilities and among
ities with their family members and/or community. adults with developmental disabilities [13,14].
Effective interventions have incorporated physical
activity, nutrition education, and behavior manage-
Latino immigrant families with youth and ment techniques [15]. Family education has also been
young adults with disabilities in the effective in combating obesity among children with
United States neurodevelopmental disorders [16]. Occupational
Latinos are the fastest growing minority group in the therapists have made contributions to health promo-
United States and the group with the highest number of tion by focusing on engagement in meaningful occu-
immigrants coming to the United States. As the number pations and client-focused interventions [17].
of immigrants from Latino backgrounds increases, the However, in order to embrace a CBPR approach and
population of Latinos with disabilities also increases [6]. sustain interventions at the community level, the
Latino families with youth and young adults with disabil- development and implementation of such interven-
ities face many challenges when migrating to the United tions need to include the voices of the community
States including attitudinal and environmental barriers and address cultural nuances and components that
that place them at a higher risk for emotional stress and matter to residents [5]. Many of the available inter-
occupational deprivation [4], as well as other conditions ventions are introduced to vulnerable communities
including obesity and chronic health conditions [3]. without input from them, questioning the inter-
Health disparities experienced by Latino families with vention’s sustainability and cultural fit.
youth with disabilities are a growing concern. Moreover, This research study illustrates the development and
the large body of literature on health disparities has indi- implementation process of a participatory research
cated that Latino youth are at even higher risk to be healthy lifestyles intervention called Healthy Families,
obese—38% higher—than White and Asian youth with for Latino immigrant families with youth and young
and without disabilities [7]. Health disparities refer to adults with Intellectual and Developmental
gaps in health outcomes due, in particular, to race, ethni- Disabilities (IDD). We describe the phases of the par-
city, disability, socio-economic status or other demo- ticipatory approach undertaken to develop the inter-
graphic characteristic. vention in collaboration with the community, then we
One of the barriers Latino families with youth and present the results of a qualitative study designed to
young adults with disabilities have identified to main- examine its impact. We also discuss the process and
taining a healthy lifestyle and active engagement in importance of incorporating participants’ voices into
their communities is a lack of health and wellness the final intervention protocol and implications of
programs available to the whole family that are con- this approach to advance health professions including
sistent with Latino values [8,9]. Moreover, environ- scholarship in occupational therapy. This approach to
mental barriers contribute to the unhealthy lifestyles CBPR is also emancipatory as it is designed to pro-
that fuel obesity in vulnerable populations. For duce knowledge in collaboration with the community,
instance, Latino families with youth and young adults which can benefit the community.
with disabilities are more likely to live in working-
class communities that lack access to accessible play-
CBPR approach: Developing a healthy
grounds and parks and are saturated with fast-food
lifestyles intervention in collaboration with
outlets and convenience stores, in which affordable
Latino families with youth and young adults
healthy alternatives are scarce [10,11]. Furthermore,
with disabilities
occupational therapists have documented the negative
impact of obesity and lack of physical activity on a Grounded in the principles of community-based par-
person’s occupational performance and ability to per- ticipatory research [1] and emancipatory research
form activities of daily life [10,12]. [18], this study was guided by the community of
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY 3

interest’s active participation throughout the develop- development and implementation of the intervention,
ment and advanced refinement of the intervention as well as provide ongoing feedback.
phases. A strong reciprocal partnership with a com- The researchers also partnered with an advocacy
munity-based organization serving people with dis- and education consumer group that provides support
abilities and their families contributed to development to Latino families with youth and young adults with
of the intervention. Collaborative relationships IDD. Through these two organizations, 2 mothers,
between researchers and community members are the both with two youth with IDD each, participated
core of CBPR through coming together to understand actively in the development of the intervention, along
and address issues of interest to the community [19]. with the staff from the agency.
These reciprocal partnerships are grounded in princi-
ples of trust, mutual benefit, respect for diversity and
Identifying and assessing needs from the
the community’s culture, and most importantly,
perspective of participants
respect for the voices of community residents [20].
Informed by frameworks of intervention research Engaging in conversations with community members
in public health and community psychology [20,21], and the target population is central to CBPR and
the Scholarship of Practice Model in Occupational emancipatory research. Thus, in order to determine
Therapy [22], and the Practice Framework in objectives of this project and draft a plan to meet
Occupational Therapy [23], the researchers engaged them, steps were taken to identify issues community
the community in each of the following phases: (1) members faced related to sustaining and maintaining
Developing a community partnership to support par- healthy lifestyles. These steps included conducting: (1)
ticipatory research; (2) identifying and assessing needs focus groups with parents and youth with IDD to
from the perspective of participants; (3) designing the explore their needs; (2) interviews with community
intervention; (4) early pilot-testing of the intervention; stakeholders and agency personnel; and (3) a review
(5) evaluating and further developing the interven- and synthesis of the literature.
tion; and (6) sustaining the evidence-based interven-
tion and utilizing findings. This study was approved Early focus groups with parents and youth with IDD
by the university’s Institutional Review Board before Researchers conducted two separate focus groups early
its onset. Participants’ recruitment and consent to in the development of the intervention phase to hear
participate followed IRB approved protocols. the voice of the community and identify their needs
and barriers in maintaining a healthy lifestyle. Four
Developing a community partnership to support youth with IDD who participated in the focus group
participatory research identified a number of barriers to engaging in healthy
lifestyles including: attitudinal barriers, lack of inclu-
CBPR falls within the context of community settings,
sive, accessible programming that is available to them,
often through partnering with a community-based
lack of community and school staff trained in recre-
organization (CBO). For this project, researchers part-
ation and sports programs, lack of transportation, and
nered with an agency located in a predominately
lack of affordable fresh products available in their com-
Latino neighborhood in a large, dense, urban city in
munities. A separate focus group with 12 parents (6
the United States. The CBO actively pursues its mis-
couples) was conducted in which parents echoed the
sion of assisting individuals with IDD and their fami-
barriers youth had identified. Parents also mentioned
lies to become fully integrated and involved in their
the lack of culturally and linguistically relevant and
communities by offering an array of programs to over
inclusive healthy lifestyles programming available to
1,000 members of this population. The services this
the whole family. For a detailed description of focus
organization offers include vocational evaluations,
group data see Suarez-Balcazar, et al. 2018 [8].
employment services, community residential options,
family respite services, and brain injury case manage-
Interviews and conversations with community
ment, among others. The researchers’ university of
stakeholders and agency personnel
affiliation has had a long history of partnering with
this CBO for education, research and practicum Community partners identified obesity in the Latino
placements of occupational therapy students. The population and the lack of programming available to
CBO provided access to the family participants and them as a significant concern at several community
assigned two agency staff to assist with the meetings. They also discussed the lack of resources
4 Y. SUAREZ-BALCAZAR ET AL.

and lack of inclusive programming available to the CBO also provided regular feedback during the design
whole family. Through these interviews, we learned stage. From this process, a first prototype was devel-
that the CBO was in the process of hiring an outreach oped that included evidence-based components cited
health coordinator to help identify programming to in various health fields including occupational ther-
serve the health needs of people with disabilities and apy, public health, and disability studies. These com-
their families. ponents included a physical activity component
chosen by participants, health education, and family
Review and synthesis of the literature goal setting [29]. Topics of health education covered
In a thorough review of the literature, researchers were those well-documented in the literature to be an
identified several evidence-based programs to pro- essential part of a healthy lifestyles program. These
mote health and wellness among people with disabil- topics included an introduction to healthy lifestyles,
ities, yet none were holistic interventions specifically discussion about healthy eating and healthy routines,
tailored to the multigenerational Latino Family with self-efficacy in planning and preparing meals and gro-
youth and young adults with disabilities. Researchers cery shopping, and the importance of exercising and
have previously highlighted the importance of cultur- active lifestyles. These and other similar topics were
ally and linguistically relevant interventions in order covered across 8 weekly, 2-hour sessions in which the
to maximize their effectiveness [5]. Culturally relevant whole family was invited to participate.
interventions reflect the values, behavioral preferences,
language preference and ways of doing and thinking Early pilot-testing of the healthy families program
of the target population [5]. Examples of effective,
culturally relevant health programming components Conducting an initial trial intervention with the com-
from the literature that have been utilized with the munity of interest in field conditions is an important
Latino population include incorporating dance as a step in beginning to build preliminary evidence for its
form of physical activity [24–26], implementing inter- impact and benefits [30]. One such way to create
active and family-focused physical activities, and early evidence is to conduct a formative evaluation
ensuring that all intervention components and materi- [30], this step of CBPR requires researchers maintain
als are delivered in Spanish and reflect the literacy a stance of openness to further shaping the interven-
level of the population [27]. Additionally, goal setting tion to meet the needs of the community. Seventeen
and goal attainment scaling is a common intervention Latino immigrant families with youth and young
used throughout the literature to promote health and adults with IDD ages 10–25, recruited by the local
weight management among individuals with disabil- CBO, participated in the pilot intervention. Benefits
ities [20,25,28]. of this initial implementation to families’ routines and
goal achievement are described elsewhere [9].

Designing the healthy families intervention


Evaluation and further development of
The starting point of the program development the program
included data compiled from the focus groups, the
interviews and the literature review. The authors also The prototype of the intervention underwent modifi-
adapted components of the previously published cations based on results of previous phases and con-
healthy lifestyles curriculum, ‘Health Matters’ [14]. tinual feedback from participants. The end result was
This evidence-based curriculum was developed for a culturally tailored, healthy lifestyles program
adults with developmental disabilities and has three adapted to meet the expressed needs of its partici-
main components: physical activity, nutrition educa- pants. The resulting protocol included several cultur-
tion, and behavior management. ally tailored adaptations chosen by participants or
During this phase, cultural adaptations were con- developed in collaboration with community stake-
tributed by participants and focused on common per- holders. Examples of further culturally tailored adap-
spectives and behaviors regarding food preparation tations included incorporating foods from
and consumption, ideas about exercise among Latino participants’ culture such as mango, tortillas, beans,
immigrant families, and family routines, among other and salsa; choosing Latin music to dance Zumba and
adaptations. Two mothers participated actively by Salsa; offering the intervention in Spanish; and creat-
providing feedback and helping design the healthy ing a modified version of the MyPlate graphic (avail-
lifestyles intervention, Healthy Families. Staff from the able through the United States Government) that
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY 5

better reflected families’ eating habits. MyPlate is a promoted the intervention and discussed its effective-
photo of a plate depicting different bright colors rep- ness at town hall meetings with state officials and com-
resentative of veggies (green, yellow, red), protein munity members in order to translate the knowledge of
(brown), and fruits and dairy [31]. effective healthy lifestyles programming gained from
Another cultural adaptation included the introduc- the project to other communities [35].
tion of goal-setting through a traffic light system [29]. The following section describes a focus group quali-
The traditional goal-setting and behavior management tative methodology used to test the impact of the pro-
approach often used in health promotion programs gram during the advanced development phase. The
was adapted for this study. Traditional goal-setting study described below, as well as the participants, is
concepts are rooted in Western values of empower- different from the focus groups conducted during the
ment and self-control [32,33]. However, working class early development phase. The focus groups conducted
Latino immigrants may not necessarily have a history in the first phase of development were designed to
of taking control of their lives and making decisions identify needs. The phases above took two years before
for themselves and are more likely to value collectiv- the impact of the program was actually examined.
ism and family values [34]. When parents expressed
confusion about the goal-setting activity, researchers Qualitative study: Examining the impact of the
quickly introduced a traffic light terminology and vis- intervention
ual aids were used to promote participant engage-
ment. This activity designed by occupational therapy Focus groups are a qualitative methodology often
students was very well received by families. The traffic used with vulnerable populations, deemed as an
light system metaphor helped families identify new appropriate method to bring the voices of marginal-
healthy habits they wanted to start (green light; e.g. ized communities into participatory research [36].
ask youth with disability to help prepare dinner at Consequently, focus groups are particularly well
least 5 times a week) and continue (yellow light; e.g. suited for conducting research with Latino immigrant
continue to walk kids to school) and unhealthy habits families with youth and young adults with disabilities.
they wanted to decrease or stop (red light; e.g. stop Use of qualitative research, such as focus group meth-
eating white bread every day). odology, help educators, researchers, and practitioners
During this phase, researchers transitioned into a examine impact from the perspective of participants
more formal summative evaluation of the intervention and further develop programs that meet the needs of
using a quasi-experimental, mixed methods design. vulnerable populations that are experiencing less than
Periodic assessments were conducted to examine the optimal access to health care and poorer health status
impact of the program on several outcomes. than the majority group [36].

Sustaining the intervention and utilization Method


of findings Participants
Ultimately, the goal for the partnership was to sustain Twenty-four Latino families with youth and young
an evidence-based intervention at the community level adults with IDD ranging in ages from 10 to 25 par-
and to translate knowledge from the project into con- ticipated in the 8-week intervention. The intervention
crete practices and products that support Latino fami- was offered in the community at the local CBO which
lies in sustaining healthy lifestyles. In order to promote had a large meeting room and access to a kitchen.
sustainability of the intervention, researchers kept Some of the parents in this phase of the intervention
detailed field notes of the activities and lessons imple- had participated actively in the initial development of
mented throughout. Additionally, in an effort to trans- the intervention. Two focus groups were conducted
late knowledge, a curriculum was developed at an with 6 parents each. Participants included one father
appropriate literacy level in both English and Spanish and 11 mothers. Focus groups were conducted at the
to be given to the CBO to sustain the intervention same facility where the intervention was offered.
regardless of the researchers’ presence. Findings about
the program’s evidence-based components and effect-
Intervention
iveness have been disseminated throughout the com-
munity through meetings with stakeholders, The intervention was delivered in Spanish at the local
presentations, and publications. Researchers have also CBO and was co-facilitated by mothers from the
6 Y. SUAREZ-BALCAZAR ET AL.

community who volunteered to lead the Zumba ses- qualitative data, by identifying themes and classifying
sions, and assisted youth in the preparation of healthy quotes to reduce the potential for bias and ensure
snacks. The intervention was delivered by bilingual consistency in themes and inter-observer agreement.
occupational therapy and nutrition students along
with the first author of this manuscript. The interven-
Results
tion included 45 minutes of dance chosen by partici-
pants which included Zumba and Salsa; 30 minutes of Focus group results
nutrition education and snack preparation; and
Results are presented according to the questions asked
45 minutes of goal-setting and social learning through
and the themes that emerged from the analysis of the
group discussions. To be consistent with Latino values
focus group data.
regarding family unity, all family members were
invited to participate.
Reasons for participation in the program
All focus group participants alluded to the scarcity of
Design
healthy lifestyles and wellness programming in the
The researchers used a focus group methodology to community. Some also shared difficulties related to
examine participants’ views regarding impact of the being denied access to community programs and the
intervention and enhance its sustainability within the limited number of programs and opportunities avail-
agency. Other pre and post assessments on a number able to them. After one mother said: ‘If I was not
of important outcome measures not described here here with my family [participating in this program],
were also utilized. Such outcomes included measures the kids would be watching TV all day, there aren’t
of self-efficacy, social support, home food inventory, many things for them to do where they learn some-
physical activity, and knowledge about healthy foods. thing and have fun.’ Many parents nodded and
The goal of the focus groups was to examine impact expressed agreement with her statement. Parents also
and benefits from the perspective of the parents and appreciated that the program was offered in Spanish
further improve the intervention in order to prepare
and that the whole family was welcomed. One mother
for long term sustainability and knowledge translation.
said, ‘My children look forward to coming every
Researchers followed a focus group protocol based on
Saturday. They are the ones saying … let’s go, let’s go
the Kruger and Casey (2015) guide to focus group
we don’t want to be late.’
implementation. Focus groups were transcribed verba-
tim and the data was classified based on thematic ana-
Aspects of the program participants liked the most
lysis according to the following themes: (1) Reasons
and perceived impact
for participation in the program; (2) what participants
liked the most about the intervention and how it had Based on focus group data, several themes emerged in
impacted their families; and (3) challenges participants this category. Specifically, themes included (1) healthy
experience in maintaining healthy lifestyles. lifestyles components of the intervention; (2) the
social learning aspect of the intervention; (3) inclu-
Focus group data analysis sion of the whole family and of youth with and with-
Focus group data was analyzed using the analytic out disabilities; (4) participation in the community;
framework of the Constant Comparative method in and (5) peer advocacy.
which the main purpose is to identify patterns in the
data and relationships between concepts, including Healthy lifestyles components of the intervention.
themes, similarities, and differences [37]. Additionally, Participants alluded to enjoying the physical activity/
the data trustworthiness was enhanced through the Zumba class and the fact that this session was led by a
process of establishing credibility and confirmability. mother. They found engaging in Zumba and physical
As such, researchers debriefed with participants on activity to be relaxing. One mother said ‘the exercise
the main issues raised during the focus groups, direct [Zumba session] is a physical relief. So for me, it is
observations during the sessions confirmed many of excellent. I love it. It is fun and now I am trying to do
the statements shared by participants, and participant more of it at home.’ Another mother reported: ‘I have
checks were conducted throughout the focus groups. learned about the importance of having an active life-
Furthermore, two independent coders, one not famil- style, especially when you have kids at home. Being
iar with the study, conducted the analysis of the active makes us all, the whole family, feel good.’
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY 7

Participants also enjoyed preparing the snack and started a Zumba class once a week and two of us are
learning about nutrition and how to plan and prepare now walking together when we can.’
healthy meals at home. One participant commented,
‘At my house now there is no more soda. No soda.’ Inclusion of the whole family. Participants particu-
Another participant reported, ‘We eat more vegeta- larly appreciated that the whole family was welcomed
bles, more fruits. At home we now drink more dairy to attend the sessions and that the sessions were
products than we used to. The program has helped facilitated in Spanish. Participants alluded to no other
with our nutrition.’ This was a generally shared senti- program in the community being inclusive to the
ment among all six parents. whole family. They were also pleased that other youth
Parents also alluded to the ways the program has without disabilities were welcome to attend. One
empowered them to address challenges in establishing mother said: ‘It helps the kids without disabilities to
meal preparation routines at home. Although it is learn and feel comfortable being around kids with
hard for families to change their routines, their special needs.’ Another mother said: ‘My son [adoles-
involvement in the program has positively influenced cent with IDD] now feels comfortable coming. At the
their child’s ability to make changes more readily at beginning he drifted around the room and did not
home. Another mother said, ‘It has helped us improve want anyone to touch him or dance with him. Now
our family routines. Now the kids have a role and he likes it, and he is the first one to be ready. It
help out with setting the table and picking up after a helped him to see that everyone is welcome and that
meal.’ Another mother said, ‘It is hard for the kids there are other kids like him and not like him here
when we change the routine, but it is our job to do and other adults as well. He is more comfortable
it.’ Another mother followed, ‘Because a lot of times, around people now.’ All parents agreed that the fact
we are busy with work and with our kids and we go that the whole family was included made it easy for
to what is easiest. We make what is easiest, anything. them to attend and benefit from it.
So it [the sessions] helped me a lot with nutrition and
my son has also helped because he now tells me: ‘we Participation in the community. Several parents
need to buy healthy food, no junk food.’ Other made reference to their youth participating in the
parents affirmed the sessions’ role in promoting posi- community now, including going out on their own.
tive meal routines and nutrition at home overall. One ‘My son has his own bus pass now. He went to watch
mother said, ‘He [referring to son with IDD] never that movie Wonder Woman. He loved it so much
took breakfast before going to school because we did that he had to see it again. From there he went to the
not have time, and now we eat breakfast. Although I mall. Today he went to the city at 6 in the morning
take his breakfast to his school. He takes sliced water- to walk around. He likes to walk [mother shares this
melon, melon, Mexican turnip, whatever fruit there with a sense of pride and happiness].’
is. Or he will simply take an apple or a banana. In Parents alluded to wanting their youth and young
the morning, always, every day, and a bottle of water. adults with disabilities to be active in the community
So that is a change that has surprised me.’ The and get out of the house more than they did before
mother appeared happy while reporting this change participating in the intervention. ‘We want them to
and said this was not the case prior to participating go out and walk and be active. What happens is that
in the program. Another mother said, ‘Not much other people don’t know them. There are people that
soda. Water, water, water, at my home.’ they could get into trouble with, because they could
be mean.’ However, another mother alluded to her
Social learning aspect of the intervention. All focus child feeling comfortable navigating the community.
group participants alluded to enjoying connecting ‘My son has grown up in this neighborhood and a lot
with other parents with youth with disabilities during of the youth around his age know him. They have
the sessions, learning from one another, and not feel- known him since he was small. They all went to
ing alone. A single dad of two adolescents with ASD school together.’ All parents recognized the import-
said ‘I work very hard at two job shifts, so I never get ance of being known in the community and letting
out of the house for socializing and connecting. This youth go out so that they learn, and so in the com-
[program] is the only activity that I engage in at all munity get used to youth with disabilities as well.
with the kids, and we also have fun. I have learned a
lot and feel that we are all healthier now as a family.’ Peer advocacy. Parents also shared stories of their
A mother reported, ‘Out of this program we now youth serving in the role of peer advocacy. One
8 Y. SUAREZ-BALCAZAR ET AL.

mother shared, ‘Someone on Facebook reached out to lights, not giving pedestrians the right-of-way, and
him. She told him: ‘I see you always post about being distracted with their phones while driving. All
autism’ and he said, ‘yes.’ And then the person told focus group participants agreed that traffic and walk-
my son, ‘You know I want to know more about how ability safety was a serious concern. Parents did not
I can learn more about autism because they just diag- feel comfortable having their youth walking around
nosed my son with autism.’ ‘Don’t worry, my mom the community on their own due to their
went through all of that, what you are thinking. Don’t safety concerns.
hit your kid, listen to him. Be patient with him. I rec- Based on the above finding and the realization that
ommend that you go to Grupo Salto [the advocacy walking safely for both parents and their youth and
organization we partnered with for this project]. I am young adults with IDD in their neighborhoods was
in the group and that way you can learn more, so not only a major area of concern, but a barrier to
you can treat your son … ’ and I [the mother] said to physical activity and community engagement,
him: ‘you advised her?’ ‘Yes, I have to … you went researchers added a unit to the Healthy Families cur-
through the same thing, mom. So, I have to help her riculum focused on teaching safe walking habits and
now that she is going through the same thing with the meanings of various traffic signs to youth with
her son.’ disabilities. Once it was implemented in subsequent
replications, high levels of engagement from the youth
Challenges experienced by families in maintaining were apparent throughout the traffic safety activity.
a healthy and active lifestyle The walkability engagement also led to another study
Participants also made reference to experiencing the looking at safety in the community (see Suarez-
greatest challenges when attempting to improve the Balcazar, et al., under review) [39].
diet of their youth with disabilities, changing estab- Despite the challenges families experience in main-
lished routines, and challenges in engaging their taining a healthy lifestyle, overall the focus group data
youth in meaningful leisure and recreational activities. illustrated the views of parents on how they have bene-
Some parents thought other adults—teachers and rela- fited from the intervention. Parents expressed high lev-
tives—contributed to using food as a way to manage els of satisfaction and desire to support its
challenging behaviors of their children with disabil- sustainability at the community level and consistently
ities. Moreover, a few parents shared experiences in alluded to changes in physical activity, consumption of
which they had been denied participation in commu- healthy foods and engagement in community activities.
nity recreational activities because of their child’s dis-
ability. Participants reported that their communities Discussion
did not offer family-oriented, accessible, and afford-
able health and recreational programming for them This study described a participatory process in which
and that the intervention Healthy Families was the the voices of the community were incorporated con-
only program available to them. sistently throughout different phases of a community-
Regarding engaging youth in active lifestyles, one based participatory research study. The active partici-
mother stated, ‘I live in front of the park, but he pation of Latino families with youth and young adults
[referring to son], doesn’t like to go because of the with disabilities in the development of a healthy life-
snow, because of the heat. And now he says … ‘Do styles program resulted in a culturally tailored inter-
you know why I don’t want to go walking?’ I respond, vention that is meeting a need in the community.
‘why son?’ ‘Because there are a lot of dirty people Grounded in principles of emancipatory research and
who leave their dog’s poop on the ground.’ Another the Scholarship of Practice model in Occupational
mother said, ‘I also live close to the park, and the Therapy [18,22], this participatory study provided a
kids always have an excuse. I tell them that they need process to empower participants to take action in
to go and get out and play. I tell them to go. What engaging in healthy lifestyles. Participants shared
happens is that they are not accustomed to going out ideas on how they are doing things differently at
on their own, they don’t go anywhere alone. Someone home to promote healthy eating among their family
has to go with them and then with my work schedule members, how much they have enjoyed the Healthy
it is difficult.’ Families intervention, as well as engagement in phys-
Parents also expressed concerns regarding traffic ical activity outside the program such as walking and
safety in the community. This included drivers not dancing. In terms of challenges to engaging in healthy
obeying traffic laws such as stop signs and traffic lifestyles, they spoke of occupational deprivation and
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY 9

lack of engagement in meaningful occupations [4]. lack of engagement in healthy lifestyles and occupa-
Actively engaging community members and providing tional deprivation.
opportunities for leadership during interventions fur- One of the limitations of this study relates to the
ther promotes program sustainability and offers a measure of impact of the intervention. Despite follow-
sense of individual and group empowerment. ing a rigorous process for analyzing the qualitative
Practitioners also need to engage with diverse com- data, a focus groups methodology is not sufficient for
munities to tailor interventions to meet their needs by examining impact. Future research may consider tri-
listening to views and concerns of families and youth angulating several qualitative and quantitative meas-
with disabilities from diverse backgrounds. ures of impact. Given that the interventions
Families and community stakeholders provided developed and implemented through the use of CBPR
input and expressed their voices throughout the pro- are often tailored to a specific community’s needs and
cess to assist in the development of a culturally tail- preferences, it can be difficult to generalize findings
ored meaningful intervention. For instance, the to broader contexts. Additionally, as CBPR seeks to
component chosen by Latino families, such as danc- understand and address the dynamic needs of com-
ing Zumba and Salsa, is consistent with their culture munity members, researchers are often faced with the
in addition to an enjoyable occupation found to decision to adapt the intervention or maintain con-
impact health and well-being [24,26]. Researchers sistency for the sake of understanding the specific
have stated that dancing is a socially and intellectually intervention’s efficacy and fidelity. Adapting the inter-
demanding physical activity as well as leisure activity vention is a decision the broader research community
[38]. The inclusion of cultural components increases often regards as compromising the study’s rigor due
the likelihood of families relating and enjoying the to lack of standardized intervention protocol.
intervention, increasing its sustainability at the com- Additionally, with a constantly changing intervention,
munity level [5]. it can be difficult to train research personnel as there
Importantly, the qualitative study was critical not is no specific manual that is rigidly followed.
only in understanding the issues Latino families face, However, adapting the intervention in response to
but also capturing parents’ perceptions on impact. community perspectives remains faithful to the core
This participatory study has important implications of CBPR. Finally, given that CBPR is often conducted
for occupational therapists and health professionals. It among marginalized and vulnerable populations,
describes a participatory process and integrates the researchers must consider the challenges the power
voices of Latino families throughout the development dynamic between themselves and participants pose
and implementation of the intervention designed to [18]. This calls for reflections on the role of the inves-
meet a need in the community. Practitioners can lis- tigators in shaping the research agenda and guiding
ten and integrate strategies identified by community the development of the intervention. This power dif-
members for engaging in healthy lifestyles, ensuring ferential may cause participants to be hesitant when
strategies for change are relevant and relatable to the providing feedback on an intervention [18,22]. It is
population involved. It is important for practitioners important that CBPR teams invest substantial time
and researchers to incorporate cultural issues at the into developing rapport with participants and build-
program level and partner closely with the commu- ing a foundation of mutual trust in order to facilitate
nity to enhance program sustainability. a safe environment where participants feel empowered
This study also informs health professionals on the to share challenges they are facing as well as con-
barriers faced by immigrant Latino families with structive feedback regarding interventions that matter
youth and young adults with disabilities to participate to them.
in the community and live healthy and engaging lives. Given the benefits resulting from the social learn-
These barriers may not only apply to Latino immi- ing aspects of the program, researchers enhanced this
grant families entering the United States, but to the component in subsequent program replications
many immigrant families with children with disabil- including the current quasi-experimental design. All
ities migrating to European countries as well. health and nutrition discussions are now followed by
Practitioners can consider how the lack of community open discussions between participants about how
programs inclusive to the entire family impacts the each family handles situations at home, at school or
family system [8]. Future research is needed to exam- in the community. This has resulted in very vibrant
ine these influences on the health and well-being of conversations and sharing of ideas. Based on this, a
the family as a whole and the relationship between Family Navigator was developed and disseminated to
10 Y. SUAREZ-BALCAZAR ET AL.

all parents. The Family Navigator is a guide that con- [10] Cahill SM, Suarez-Balcazar Y. Promoting children’s
tains strategies shared by parents on ways to sustain nutrition and fitness in the urban context. Am J
Occup Ther. 2009;63:113–116.
their health and well-being at home, school, and in
[11] Drewnowski A, Specter SE. Poverty and obesity: the
the community. role of energy density and energy costs. Am J Clin
Nutr. 2004;79:6–16.
[12] Nossum R, Johansen A-E, Kjeken I. Occupational
Acknowledgements problems and barriers reported by individuals with
This project was funded by a grant from The Chicago obesity. Scand J Occup Ther. 2018;25:136–144.
Community Trust to the University of Illinois at Chicago, [13] Gephart EF, Loman DG. Use of prevention and pre-
Department of Occupational Therapy. We are grateful to vention plus weight management guidelines for
all the families who participated in this study and to our youth with developmental disabilities living in group
community partner, El Valor Corporation, whose staff homes. J Pediatr Health Care. 2013;27:98–108.
[14] Marks B, Sisirak J, Heller T. Health matters: the
helped in the development and implementation of the
exercise and nutrition health education curriculum
intervention. We are also grateful to parents of Grupo Salto
for people with developmental disabilities. Baltimore
who assisted on this project. Several occupational therapy
(MD): Paul H. Brookes Pub.Co; 2010.
students have been involved in this initiative.
[15] Whitlock EP, O’Connor EA, Williams SB, et al.
Effectiveness of weight management interventions in
children: a targeted systematic review for the
Disclosure statement
USPSTF. Pediatrics. 2010;125:e396–ee41.
The authors report no conflict of interest. The authors alone [16] Irby MB, Kolbash S, Garner-Edwards D, et al.
are responsible for the content and writing of the paper. Pediatric obesity treatment in children with neuro-
developmental disabilities. A case series and review
of the literature. Infant Child Adolesc Nutr.
2012;4:215–221.
References [17] Holmberg V, Ringsberg K. Occupational therapists
as contributors to health promotion. Scan J Occup
[1] Minkler M, Wallerstein N. Community based par-
Ther. 2014;21:82–89.
ticipatory research for health: process to outcomes. [18] Sallah M. Participatory action research with
2nd ed. San Francisco (CA): Jossey Bass; 2008. “minority communities” and the complexities of
[2] Magana S, Parish S, Son E. Have racial and ethnic emancipatory tensions: intersectionality and cultural
disparities in the quality of health care relationships affinity. Res Comp Int Educ. 2014;9:402.
changed for children with developmental disabilities [19] Israel BA, Eng E, Schulz AJ, et al. Methods for com-
and ASD? Am J Intellect Dev Disabil. munity-based participatory research for health. 2nd
2015;120:504–513. ed. San Francisco (CA): Jossey-Bass; 2012.
[3] Rimmer JH, Yamaki K, Davis BM, et al. Obesity and [20] Suarez-Balcazar Y, Mirza MP, Hansen AMW.
overweight prevalence among adolescents with dis- Unpacking University-community partnerships to
abilities. Prev Chronic Dis. 2011;8:A41. advance scholarship of practice. Occup Ther Health
[4] Mirza M. Occupational upheaval during resettlement Care. 2015;29:370–382.
and migration: findings of global ethnography with [21] Fawcett SB, Francisco VT, Schultz JA, et al. The
refugees with disabilities. OTJR (Thoroface N J). community tool box: a web-based resource for
2012;32:S6–S14. building healthier communities. Public Health
[5] Suarez-Balcazar Y, Friesema J, Lukyanova V. Reports. 2000;115:274–278.
Culturally competent interventions to address obesity [22] Hammel J, Magasi S, Mirza MP, et al. A scholarship
among African American and Latino Children and of practice revisited: creating community-engaged
Youth. Occup Ther Health Care. 2013;27:113–128. occupational therapy practitioners, educators, and
[6] Erickson WLC, Von Schrader S. 2012 Disability sta- scholars. Occup Ther Health Care. 2015;29:352–369.
tus report: United States. Ithaca (NY): Employment [23] Occupational therapy practice framework: domain
and Disability Institute, Cornell University; 2014. and process (3rd Edition). Am J Occup Ther.
[7] Krueger PM, Reither EN. Mind the gap: race/ethnic 2017;68:S1–S48.
and socioeconomic disparities in obesity. Curr Diab [24] Flores R. Dance for health: improving fitness in
Rep. 2015;15:95. African American and Hispanic adolescents. Public
[8] Suarez-Balcazar Y, Agudelo Orozco A, Marte M, Health Rep. 1995;110:189–193.
et al. Unpacking barriers to healthy lifestyles from [25] Maga~ na S, Li H, Miranda E, et al. Improving health
the perspective of youth with disabilities and their behaviours of Latina mothers of youths and adults
parents. J Preven Intern Comm. 2018; 46:61–72. with intellectual and developmental disabilities:
[9] Suarez-Balcazar Y, Hoisington M, Orozco AA, et al. health education for Latina mothers. J Intellect
Benefits of a culturally tailored health promotion Disabil Res. 2015;59:397–410.
program for Latino youth with disabilities and their [26] Marquez D, Bustamante E, Agui~ naga S, et al.
families. Am J Occup Ther. 2016; 70:7005180080p1. BAILAMOS#: Development, Pilot Testing, and
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY 11

Future Directions of a Latin Dance Program for [34] Marin G. Influence of acculturation on familialism
Older Latinos. 2015. and self-identification among Hispanics. In: Bernal
[27] Greenwood-Ericksen MB, Chapman CR, Konopken Y, ME, Knight GP, editor. Ethnic identity: formation
et al. Sustainability of a culturally informed communi- and transmission among Hispanics and other
ty–based diabetes prevention program for obese Latino minorities. Albany: State University of New York
youth. J Prim Care Community Health. 2010;1:83–87. Press; 1993. p. 181–196.
[28] Kiresuk TJ, Sherman RE. Goal attainment scaling: a [35] Suarez-Balcazar Y, Singleton C, Perez A, et al.
general method for evaluating comprehensive com- Family navigator. A guide to managing the environ-
munity mental health programs. Community Ment ment to promote health and wellness for families of
Health J. 1968;4:443–453. youth and young adults with and without different
[29] Jason LA, Keys C, Suarez-Balcazar Y, et al., editors. abilities. Department Occupational Therapy. UIC
Participatory community research: theories and 2017.
methods in action. Washington (DC): American [36] Calderon JL, Baker R, Wolk KE. Focus groups: a
Psychological Association; 2004. qualitative method complementing quantitative
[30] McBride N. Intervention research: a practical guide research for studying culturally diverse groups. Educ
for developing evidence-based school prevention Health (Abingdon). 2000;13:91–95.
programmes. Singapore: Springer; 2016. [37] Krueger RA, Casey MA. Focus Groups: A Practical
[31] United States Department of Agriculture. My Plate. Guide for Applied Research. 5th ed. California (CA):
Updated: Jan 11, 2017. Available from https://choo- SAGE; 2015.
semyplate-prod.azureedge.net/sites/default/files/prin- [38] Fallahpour M, Borrel L, Luborsky M, et al. Leisure-
tablematerials/myplate_green.pdf. activity participation to prevent later-life cognitive
[32] Kiresuk TJ, Smith A, Cardillo JE. Goal attainment decline: a systematic review. Scand. J. Occup. Ther.
scaling: applications, theory, and measurement. 2016;23:162–197.
Hillsdale (NJ): L. Erlbaum Associates; 1994. [39] Suarez-Balcazar Y, Early A, Garcia C, et al. Walkability
[33] Riger S. What’s wrong with empowerment? Am J safety and walkability engagement: a health concern.
Community Psychol. 1993;21:279–292. (Under review.)

S-ar putea să vă placă și