12/21/2018 Cognitive dissonance in the occult world -

Experimental Pagan Magic in the Golden Dawn Tradition



You are here Home > magic

Cognitive Dissonance In The Occult World

magic by Nick Farrell - September 5, 2018  4

You would think that occultists would be at the cutting edge of thought and be ready to look and adapt to new ideas. In
fact, new ideas are hard to come by and when introduced are met with a great deal of resistance. Some of this is down
to the idea of preserving traditions, but mostly it is due to what psychologists call cognitive dissonance.

For those who came in late, cognitive dissonance is a simple theory which suggests that we have an inner drive to hold
all our attitudes and behaviour in harmony and avoid disharmony (or dissonance). So, when something appears that is
new, which runs counter to what we thought we knew, we will ignore it just to keep the balance right. My old teacher
once said that people tend to believe the rst thing they are told on a subject and nd it dif cult to let go of, and there
might be some truth behind that (but it was the rst time anyone suggested the idea to me so he might have been
wrong and I refuse to give it up).

TOP

http://www.nickfarrell.it/cognitive-dissonance-in-the-occult-world/ 1/7
12/21/2018 Cognitive dissonance in the occult world -

I rst encountered cognitive dissonance in the occult community nearly 15 years ago when I was doing some research on the banishing ritual of the pentagram. In
Western Magic this little ritual is used before any working. The ritual was developed by the Golden Dawn and was provided to every neophyte.  I looked at the paperwork
given to neophytes throughout the long history of the Golden Dawn it was clear discovered that it was the invoking pentagram which was the main tool to be used to
provide protection and the banishing was just a footnote (for when you were in unsafe space or under attack).

I printed my ndings and expected there to be either a change in the use of the banishing by at least GD types or at least a
general discussion about it. While the idea was accepted amongst some Golden Dawn people, nothing really happened. People
still ask questions about banishing on the various facebook groups. One person recently called into question my ability to teach
because other (non-Golden Dawn) teachers, such as EA Groening insisted on the use of the banishing before any ritual. In short, I
must be wrong because so many others said so. To be fair until I did some research on it, I would have said the same.

I tried to track back when the banishing superseded the invoking and found that it arose with the development of the
psychological model within occultism. People like Israel Regardie favoured the banishing because it meant getting rid of
complexes. The real Golden Dawn had long since passed into obscurity and so a tiny innovation in emphasis went unnoticed and
there was no-one to complain. Regardie was hugely in uential over most of the names of the 20th century magical scene. To
many he was a font of knowledge of all things Golden Dawn. In fact, his Golden Dawn experience was limited and his ideas like
the banishing, the watchtowers and his semi-tantric middle pillar exercise were all his own devising.

Israel Regardie: the Harry Potter

Another example of cognitive dissonance is the amount of emotion placed in defending the Kybalion as “hermetic” or having any
years
real use in magic at all.  As I have written elsewhere, this New Age con trick is responsible for a lot of terrible thinking within the
occult movement. The fact it suckered good minds like Paul Case, David Goddard, and even me for many years is no excuse.

Each of the seven principles that the book is based on can be pulled apart by basic philosophic or scienti c reasoning. The fact it has survived so long is thanks to the lack
of philosophic or scienti c reasoning in the esoteric community and the amount of cognitive dissonance attached to it. Even those who admit it is aky palm off their
dissonance by claiming “there is some truth in it” (truth which they can never provide or if they do it can be soon pulled to bits).

When presented with the fallacy behind the Kybalion you can see people acting in full cognitive dissonance mode. They say:

1. I don’t understand it or have not studied it properly (I do and have).

2. They say it contains principles which have been part of Hermetics and Cabbalah since the beginning (they haven’t. You would think that a book that sums up hermetic
thought might have a basis in existing hermetic thought but nothing).

3. They insist that the universe works like that anyway (it can’t. The Kybalion depends on an early 20th century view of science which has been largely superseded).

4. They claim that magic depends on it (which is odd because no work of magic before the Kybalion uses any of the principles.

5. They say I am stupid and don’t know what I am talking about, and smell of Nintendo (by this point the conversation is normally over).

There are loads of other situations in magic where cognitive dissonance places the brakes on esoteric development.
Issues fought over in esoteric groups often break down to something that my teacher told me that I thought was true
but turned out not to be.  There are many people who swear blind that astral initiation of a neophyte is possible
because their teacher made a buck or two out of them without having to show up for the rite.

People like Jake Stratton-Kent have found it uphill work convincing people that you don’t really need a Tree of Life or a
celestial view of the universe to get things done.

Aaron Leitch has angered those who follow African Traditions for pointing out that some of those traditions exist within the Solomonic tradition (he also may once have
borrowed few of their terms, but it is not my tradition, so I can’t comment on it).

Cognitive dissonance prevents the evolution of magic. In older systems of magic, you can see an evolution of tradition thanks mostly because isolated magicians trained
their students based on their own research. Printing affected that somewhat and enabled more uni ed ideas, but in many ways those systems have become
unchangeable dogmas.

But ironically occult tradition is not about theology or dogmas but research. Because a grimoire has written down a spell, it does not mean it is going to work in the 21st
century.It might have to be adapted. That adaptation needs to be tested to make sure it works.

That process is getting suppressed now as people try and drag systems down to something they are more comfortable and familiar. The internet makes this cognitive
dissonance even worse because it echoes.

  
TOP

http://www.nickfarrell.it/cognitive-dissonance-in-the-occult-world/ 2/7
12/21/2018 Cognitive dissonance in the occult world -

 Share  Tweet  Share  Share  Share  Share

Nick Farrell
http://www.nickfarrell.it

 Previous article
A candidate for the maker of your higher genius

Next article 
It is not your fault

4 thoughts on “Cognitive dissonance in the occult world”

September 5, 2018 at 7:55 pm

Some rare common sense Nick, I think we should all be more concerned with what works for me,now, rather than where did it come from?
Melvin Threadgold

September 5, 2018 at 9:43 pm

I\’m very familiar at meeting with cognitive dissonance when I present my research to the occult community so naturally I completely agree. In the eld of science,
Bethsheba Ashe people are more or less educated to cope with the shocks and surprises of the new. They are taught to question, test and embrace new information and see themselves
as a progressive vanguard. The occult community could do with taking some tips.

September 5, 2018 at 11:14 pm

Thank you for writing this. It is much needed.
Sz

September 11, 2018 at 10:41 am

Thanks Nick, for this post,
Rafael Chiron
I have had similar experiences. In my case, I was told that I would introduce chaotic energies into the group that belonged to the Dion Fortune tradition.

Often, innovative or new ideas are rejected by a teacher, as this does not conform to tradition. For this, text citations of authorities such as e.g. Dion Fortune, who should prove this – but
about personal experiences are not spoken. As a result, innovative resources that a student might bring in are lost and eventually make the tradition sterile. Interestingly, Dion Fortune is
now being discussed as an authority, even though she herself was similarly rejected by Mrs. Mathers with her new ideas. Here, the cat bites its tail, or is it the “hermetic” dragon?

Comments are closed.

Search Content... 

RECENT POSTS

 Standing up to Blavatsky’s racism

 Have you really been initiated into the Golden Dawn?
 Geomancy magical questions
 20 ways in which I am better than Jesus
 It is not your fault 
TOP

http://www.nickfarrell.it/cognitive-dissonance-in-the-occult-world/ 3/7
12/21/2018 Cognitive dissonance in the occult world -

RECENT COMMENTS

 Angelus Inferis on Have you really been initiated into the Golden Dawn? 

 Angelus Inferis on Standing up to Blavatsky’s racism

 Kate on Standing up to Blavatsky’s racism

 jesse Conwell on Standing up to Blavatsky’s racism

 An Ominous One on Standing up to Blavatsky’s racism

ARCHIVES

 December 2018
 November 2018
 October 2018
 September 2018
 August 2018
 June 2018
 April 2018
 March 2018
 February 2018
 January 2018
 December 2017
 October 2017
 September 2017
 August 2017
 June 2017
 May 2017
 April 2017
 March 2017
 February 2017
 January 2017
 November 2016
 October 2016
 September 2016
 August 2016
 July 2016
 June 2016
 April 2016
 March 2016
 January 2016
 December 2015
 November 2015
 October 2015
 September 2015
 August 2015
 July 2015
 June 2015 
TOP

http://www.nickfarrell.it/cognitive-dissonance-in-the-occult-world/ 4/7
12/21/2018 Cognitive dissonance in the occult world -

 May 2015
 April 2015
 February 2015
 January 2015
 December 2014
 November 2014
 October 2014
 September 2014
 August 2014
 July 2014
 June 2014
 May 2014
 April 2014
 March 2014
 February 2014
 January 2014
 December 2013
 November 2013
 October 2013
 September 2013
 August 2013
 July 2013
 June 2013
 May 2013
 April 2013
 March 2013
 February 2013
 January 2013
 December 2012
 November 2012
 October 2012
 September 2012
 August 2012
 July 2012
 June 2012
 May 2012
 April 2012
 March 2012
 February 2012
 January 2012
 December 2011
 November 2011
 October 2011
 September 2011
 August 2011
 July 2011

 June 2011
TOP

http://www.nickfarrell.it/cognitive-dissonance-in-the-occult-world/ 5/7
12/21/2018 Cognitive dissonance in the occult world -

 May 2011
 April 2011
 March 2011
 February 2011
 January 2011
 November 2010
 August 2010
 July 2010
 June 2010
 May 2010
 April 2010
 March 2010
 February 2010
 January 2010
 December 2009
 October 2009
 August 2009
 June 2009
 May 2009
 April 2009
 March 2009

META

 Log in
 Entries RSS
 Comments RSS
 WordPress.org

RECENT COMMENTS

 Angelus Inferis on Have you really been initiated into the Golden Dawn?

 Angelus Inferis on Standing up to Blavatsky’s racism

 Kate on Standing up to Blavatsky’s racism

 jesse Conwell on Standing up to Blavatsky’s racism

 An Ominous One on Standing up to Blavatsky’s racism

NETWORK BLOGS

NetworkedBlogs
Blog:
Nick Farrrell's blog
Topics:
Occult, Golden Dawn,
Magic

Follow my blog

FACEBOOK 
TOP

http://www.nickfarrell.it/cognitive-dissonance-in-the-occult-world/ 6/7
12/21/2018 Cognitive dissonance in the occult world -
[custom-facebook-feed]

© 2018
Powered by WordPress | Theme: AccessPress Mag


TOP

http://www.nickfarrell.it/cognitive-dissonance-in-the-occult-world/ 7/7