Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Tropical Doctor
0(0) 1–7
! The Author(s) 2018
Effectiveness of treatment regimens Reprints and permissions:
sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
for Typhoid fever in the nalidixic DOI: 10.1177/0049475518758884
journals.sagepub.com/home/tdo
acid-resistant S. typhi (NARST) era in
South India
Abstract
The epidemiology of typhoid fever in South Asia has changed. Multi-drug resistant (MDR) Salmonella typhi (S. typhi) is now
frequently resistant to nalidixic acid and thus labelled NARST. Treatment failure with the use of fluoroquinolones has
been widely noted, forcing clinicians to adopt alternative treatment strategies. In this observational study, we looked at
various treatment regimens and correlated clinical and microbiological outcomes. In 146 hospitalised adults, the median
minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) for ciprofloxacin was 0.38 mg/mL with a median fever clearance time (FCT) of
eight days (range ¼ 2–35 days). Of the regimens used, gatifloxacin and azithromycin had a shorter FCT of six days
compared to ceftriaxone (ten days; P < 0.001). Though mortality and relapse in our cohort was low, NARST seemed
to correlate with mortality (P ¼ 0.006). Gatifloxacin or azithromycin clearly emerge as the drugs of choice for treatment
of typhoid in South India.
Keywords
Typhoid fever, treatment failure, nalidixic acid-resistant S. typhi, gatifloxacin, azithromycin, India
However, present evidence, including meta-analyses,6 owing to a lack of clinical and microbiological correl-
suggests that treatment outcomes are inferior to quin- ation and standardisation of the various
olones owing to higher rates of clinical failure and guidelines (CLSI), British Society of Antimicrobial
relapse with the latter. The ongoing controversy regard- Chemotherapy (BSAC) and European Committee on
ing treatment continues both in the endemic setting and Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing (EUCAST), we
for travellers. Most parts of the world where typhoid is decided to report the ciprofloxacin MIC for S. typhi
endemic also have a pre-existing problem with Gram- as resistant when 0.064 mg/mL according to
negative organisms having extended spectrum and EUCAST guidelines.8 In 2012, CLSI, BSAC and
New Delhi metallo-beta-lactamase (NDM-1) which EUCAST guidelines were standardised and evidence-
are difficult to treat. Evaluation of new and recycled based revision of the ciprofloxacin MIC breakpoints
old therapeutic options is necessary. In order to address and the disc diffusion interpretative criteria specifically
this question, we studied the clinical and microbio- for S. typhi9 were amended as currently followed by our
logical profile of adult patients admitted with NARST microbiology department. This now reports ciprofloxa-
and MDR typhoid fever in our hospital. cin disk diffusion cut-offs > 31 mm as resistant or MIC
breakpoints < 0.06 mg/mL as ‘susceptible’.
Fever clearance time (FCT) was defined as from the
Participants and methods start of appropriate antibiotic therapy to the first
Ours was a five-year retrospective cohort study con- instance when oral temperature dropped below 37.5 C
ducted at the Christian Medical College Hospital and remained below this level continuously for 48 h.
(CMCH), Vellore, a tertiary-care medical centre Complete and sustained resolution of clinical symp-
located in South India. All adult inpatients with cul- toms and signs of fever defined cure, while the persist-
ture-proven typhoid fever, admitted from January 2008 ence of fever > 6 days defined failure. Furthermore,
to December 2012, were included in the study. Cases isolation of S. typhi or S. paratyphi from blood or
were searched from a list of patients with blood or bone bone marrow cultures in patients who had been on
marrow cultures positive for S. enterica serotype typhi treatment for typhoid fever for > 7 days defined true
or S. paratyphi obtained from the Department of microbiological treatment failure. Relapse was defined
Microbiology. Corresponding inpatient charts were as recurrence of clinical symptoms and signs compat-
obtained from Medical Records and the data were rec- ible with typhoid fever < 6 weeks after completion of a
orded on pre-designed proformas. Adults (age >12 course of antibiotics for this disease, after having
years) were recruited for the study. Patient data col- had complete resolution of symptoms and signs
lected included demographic details, presenting symp- during the same treatment episode. Complications dir-
toms, physical and laboratory findings, and ectly attributed to typhoid were noted. An empiric anti-
complications. Response to treatment was assessed in biotic was started based solely on a clinical diagnosis of
terms of time to fever clearance, clinical, microbio- typhoid, before microbiological confirmation. By con-
logical failure and mortality. trast, the original/alternative antibiotic was the one
All isolates from blood culture had been identified used after isolating S. typhi or S. paratyphi in culture
by standard biochemical tests and confirmed by slide and interpretation of susceptibility data. The choice of
agglutination tests using specific Salmonella antiserum antibiotic therapy was at the discretion of the treating
(Murex Diagnostics Ltd., UK). Isolate antibiotic sus- physician.
ceptibility was determined by the disc diffusion method All statistical analyses were done using a software
using a 5-mg disc of ciprofloxacin and a 30-mg disc of package (SPSS for Windows, Version 17.0.1, SPSS
nalidixic acid (HiMedia Laboratories Ltd., India), Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). Continuous variables are pre-
according to the Clinical and Laboratory Standards sented as mean standard deviation (SD) or as median
Institute (CLSI) guidelines and interpretive criteria.7 with interquartile range (IQR). Categorical variables
Isolates were also tested for susceptibility to chloram- are expressed as proportions. The effect of infection
phenicol (30 mg), amoxycillin (10 mg), trimethoprim-sul- with NARST and MDR typhoid (S. typhi or S. para-
famethoxazole (1.25/23.75 mg) and ceftriaxone (30 mg) typhi) and the effect of different treatment regimens on
(HiMedia Laboratories Ltd., India).7 MICs of cipro- FCT were assessed by Kaplan–Meier survival analysis.
floxacin were determined by the E-test method, using The log-rank test was applied to evaluate the equality
commercially available strips (AB Biodisk, Sweden) of fever clearance distributions across treatment regi-
according to the manufacturer’s specifications. mens. We performed a univariate analysis to determine
During our study, we observed discordance between factors associated with adverse outcomes. Multivariate
the clinical response to therapy and the laboratory analyses could not be carried out as the sample size was
interpretation of ciprofloxacin breakpoint susceptibil- too small. All tests were two-sided and a P value < 0.05
ities (MIC and disc diffusion) for S. typhi. However, was considered statistically significant.
Bandyopadhyay et al. 3
Figure 1. Trend of typhoid isolates over the years. (a) Culture-confirmed S. typhi study isolates over the years with ciprofloxacin
MIC. (b) Number of NARST and MDR of typhoid isolates over the years.
Table 1. Baseline characteristics of patients with typhoid fever. Table 2. Patterns of typhoid isolates.
Figure 3. Response of typhoid fever to various antimicrobials. Kaplan–Meier survival plots of time to fever clearance in patients with
blood culture-confirmed Typhoid fever. The y-axis represents the cumulative probability of event-free survival, i.e. remaining febrile.
treated with a single appropriate antibiotic regimen gatifloxacin or azithromycin (median FCT ¼ 6 days)
(P ¼ 0.004). A comparison of median FCT among dif- alone as the final antibiotic compared to those treated
ferent antibiotic combinations is shown in Figure 2. with ceftriaxone alone (median FCT ¼ 10 days;
The median FCT was shorter in patients treated with P < 0.001) (Figure 3).
6 Tropical Doctor 0(0)