Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
csandstrom@cellc.co.za
Abstract— The business process industry, especially call as a stressful one and can create burnout for the
centre has been responsible for the growth in job individuals who work in it.
opportunities; however, working in a call centre is not A doctoral study in South Africa suggests that up to one
always a pleasant experience. The call centre fifth of contact centre agents become overly stimu lated
environment is often seen as a stressful one and can when working in a contact centre environ ment. “Contact
create burnout for the individuals who work in it. This centre workers are exposed to high amounts of sensory
research paper hence attempts to explore the degree of bombard ment fro m the office environment – lighted call-
burnout in a South African Call Centre and to explore the boards showing queued calls, ringing phones and
association of mindfulness and burnout by examining a computer screens. Their DNA and brain circu its have an
random sample of 115 Call Centre staff based in the over-intake of sensory information,” Rossier (2014).
South African telecommunications industry. Two research Many contact centre agents cannot maintain a tolerance to
instruments Utrecht Work Engagement Scale (UWES) the environment. This results in high absenteeism,
and the Mindful Attention Awareness Scale (MAAS) were disproportionate sick leave and attrition
used in the study, along with a demographic (Rossier,2014),which are products of
questionnaire. Both these tools have been widely burnout(Ismail,2010). Not only does this cost the
published and have been used within a South African company in train ing, recru it ment and the cost of
context to assess the validity. The research findings operations, this also impacts on the service delivered to
suggest that individuals with higher levels of inherent customers which can ultimately also affect a company’s
mindfulness result in lower levels of burnout. In addition, bottom line.Visser(2007).
the result of the research also varies within the split “The abrasive nature of call centres and how to deal
between call taking versus back office support staff. The effectively within this environment needs to be key focus.
findings of the research study can be utilized by the call There needs to be a focus on providing agents in a contact
centre industry to reduce the burnout of its employees. centre with tools to be able to deal with the harsh
Keywords— Burnout, Mindfulness, Call Centre, Front environment of a call centre to assist in preventing
Office, Back Office. stress.” Braithwaite(2011), thus reducing the level of
burnout prevalent in a call centre environment.Visser
I. INTRODUCTION (2007).
“There is a continuing trend for organisations to use Call “Research conducted with indiv iduals who meditate,
Centres, also referred to as Contact Centres, as a preferred appears to provide evidence that those who med itate
channel to service their customers. The call centre is experience higher quantities of wellbeing and maintained
generally made up of customer service representatives levels of happiness in their lives and reduced levels of
who field calls fro m customers and back office staff who burnout. The results include amplified job satisfaction
provide support and admin istration services. The call levels and improved optimis m and morale as well mo re
centre industry has been responsible for the growth in job disposition to contribute and engage with colleagues.”
opportunities and shows no signs of slowing down.” Puddicombe(2008).
Visser (2007). However, as mentioned by Visser (2007) Mindfulness is one of the results of med itation and a
working in a call centre is not always a pleasant study done by Ismail (2010), stated that individuals with
experience and the call centre environment is often seen higher levels of mindfulness, be it as a result of
www.ijels.com Page | 99
International Journal of English Literature and Social Sciences (IJELS) Vol-4, Issue-1, Jan - Feb, 2019
https://dx.doi.org/10.22161/ijels.4.1.19 ISSN: 2456-7620
med itation or a pred isposition to mindfulness , are less how mindfulness is practiced when comparing Western
likely to experience burnout.“Those practicing meditation and Buddhist perspectives.” Keng, Smoski and Robins
on a regular basis also report that by allo wing the mind to (2011). Keng, Smoski and Robins (2011) further describe
settle, to experience calm, they are able to tap into a mindfulness as having been emp irically and theoretically
previously unknown reservoir of creativity.” connected with the wellbeing of the psyche. ”.
Puddicombe(2008). Mindfulness at the work place is suggested by
This research paper aims to exp lore the degree of burnout Puddicombe (2008) where he cites that Savvy business
of Call Centre Agents working in a business process leaders are starting incorporate more wholesome values
industry in a South African Call Centre and to exp lore the and are increasingly considering meditation or mind
association of mindfulness and burnout. training as the answer.
“In 2004, Business Week first announced the arrival of
II. LITERATURE REVIEW med itation specifically for the workp lace. So me of the
Ismail (2010) cites three different literary rev iews to first pioneers of this were Google, Apple and Yahoo, as
describe the three dimensions to burnout- overwhelming well as some of the conventional organisations like
emotional exhaustion, depersonalization and reduced McKinsey and Deutsche Bank. Since then there have
personal accomplishment also known as personal been countless other organisations that have followed
efficacy. The study by Carrim (2006) suggests working in suite” Puddicombe(2008). Discussing the benefits of
a call centre is amongst the top three occupations where med itation the study by Melville,Chang, Colag iuri,
people are most unhappy. “Studies conducted have Marshal ,and Cheema (2011) suggests that yoga postures
shown up to 70% of call centre emp loyees display at a and the meditations acutely imp roves the physiological
minimu m, one sympto m of stress. It was also recorded and psychological indicators of stress.
that 61% of these individuals did not experience these Ismail (2010) utilised the Oldenburg Inventory (OLBI) as
stressors prior to being employed within a call centre the measurement for burnout and the Mindful Attention
environment.” Carrim (2006). Visser (2007) states that Awareness Scale (MAAS) to measure mindfulness and
the call centre environment is often seen as a stressful found a moderately significant correlat ion between
one, even receiving the name “electronic sweatshop”. mindfulness and reduced levels of burnout.
A study by Harry and Coet zee (2011) concluded that the Based on the review of the literature across a variety of
wellness climate was risky when co mpared to the national methodologies of study and meditation practice, there is
norm and found a significant correlation between senses strong evidence to support that mindfulness may have a
of higher levels of wellbeing, increased feelings of positive effect on burnout, improved psychological and
coherence and reduced levels of burnout. The problem possibly even physical ailments for contact centre agents.
was further h ighlighted by Simons and Buitendach (2013)
who believes that Call Centre Agents have a sensory III. RESEARCH DESIGN AND
overload with rapid changes in technology, products and METHODOLOGY
high workloads. The consequences of this environment For this study, the data was collected by random samp ling
could result in burnout, anxiety, performance issues, method that involved a structured and specifically
absenteeism and stress. designed questionnaire. The copies of the questionnaire
“Over the last few decades, a lot of focus ,interest and were electronically sent out via a free survey tool called
investigation has been placed on meditation to play a part Survey Monkey to 2170 Contact Centre staff, based in a
in clin ical contributions and interventions.” Keng ,Smoski South African Call Centre in the teleco mmunications
and Robins( 2011).Literature on different techniques of industry in the month of September 2018. The research
med itation suggests that , “Transcendental Meditation was conducted across three locations, two of the locations
(TM) is focusing on a mantra and repeating it for 15 to 20 were based in Johannesburg and the third based in
minutes at a time.” Self Help Robot (2013). “M indfulness Durban. The questionnaires were emailed to all the
is a meditation that involves focusing on the present, to be respondents allowing three days in which to complete the
aware o f thoughts in the present with no judgment.” survey. The total number o f respondents were 153 (7%
Wong (2013). “Gu ided meditation is where the meditator response rate) indiv iduals across the different locations.
is guided through the experience verbally.” Clarke (n.d.). Of the 153 respondents, 115 individuals co mpleted the
“Yoga meditation is systematically, observing, survey; the individuals who did not complete the survey
understanding and accepting, and training the different were removed fro m the survey results. This resulted in, a
levels of being, in order to integrate all parts of one’s self sample size of 115 part icipants, which equates to a total
dwelling in experience and consciousness.” Bharati (n.d.). participation of 5% of the entire group who received the
“With the introduction of mindfulness into Western email to participate in the questionnaire survey.
psychology and medicine, there have been differences on
The maximu m score that an individual could score on the 4.3 Relationship between MAAS and the UWES
15-question MAAS questionnaire was 6; the minimu m Engagement and Burnout Score
score an individual could score was 1. In this study, the Below are the descriptive statistics for MAAS UWES
highest an individual scored was 6 and the lowest score engagement and UWES burnout. The mean for MAAS is
recorded was 1.13. The higher the score, the more 4.52, UWES engagement 3.92 and UWES Burnout 4.04.
mindful an individual is and the lo wer the score the lower
the individuals Mindfulness.
When looking at the results from the UW ES engagement When breaking down the MAAS into different scoring
and burnout results versus the MAAS scores, there categories, there is a relationship between lower MAAS
appears to be a strong correlation between engagement scores and higher levels of burnout and higher levels of
and mindfulness and between burnout and reduced levels engagement when comparing against the mean of each
of mindfulness. score.
Individuals scoring higher on the MAAS with a score burnout reduces below the samples mean. Engagement
between 5.00 – 6.00 and an n of 46 (40%) showed an sits at 3.42 versus the mean of 4.04 and burnout sits at
increase in engagement of 4.13 co mpared to the mean of 3.44 versus the mean of 3.92.
3.92 and burnout levels are lower with a score of 4.33 When analysing the MAAS scores between 2.00 – 2.99
compared to the overall mean of 4.04. and an n of 7 (6%) there is a further reduction on
When comparing individuals with a MAAS score engagement and an increase in burnout compared to the
between 4.00 – 4.99 and an n of 38 (33%), there still groups mean. Engagement sits at 3.77 versus the mean of
shows increased levels of engagement with a score of 4.04 and burnout sits at 3.66 versus the mean of 3.92.
4.15 co mpared to the mean of 3.92 and burnout levels are Slightly higher than the MAAS of 3.00-3.99, however, as
lower with a score of 4.32 co mpared to the overall mean the percentage of the sample gets smaller the results could
of 4.04. be less reliable.
However when looking at the MAAS score between 3.00 Individuals who scored 1.00 – 1.99 on the MAAS and
– 3.99 and an n of 20 (17%) the levels of engagement and with an n of 4 (3%) have the lowest engagement and
When categorising MAAS into just two groups those who levels of burnout, with a score of 4.32 versus the mean of
scored between 4.00 – 6.00, with an n of 84 (73%) and 4.04.
individuals who scored 1.00 – 3.99, with an n of 31 (27%) Individuals who scored lower on the MAAS, 1.00 – 3.99
the results show the same trends. Individuals who scored showed lower levels of engagement, 3.31 versus the mean
higher on the MAAS, 4.00 – 6.00 showed higher levels of of 3.92 and higher levels of burnout, with a score of 3.31
engagement, 4.14 versus the mean of 3.92 and lower versus the mean of 4.04.
When categorising MAAS into two groups, with a lower mean o f 3.92 and highest levels of burnout, with a score
MAAS category, those who scored between 3.00 – 6.00, of 2.97 versus the mean of 4.04.
with an n of 104 (90%) and individuals who scored 1.00 –
2.99, with an n of 11 (10%) the results show the same 4.4 Front Office Versus Back Office
trends. Individuals who scored higher on the MAAS, The population was split into Back Office / Support Staff
3.00 – 6.00 showed higher levels of engagement, 4.00 and Call Taking Staff. The Back Office / Support Staff
versus the mean of 3.92 and lo wer levels of burnout, with made up 29% (n = 33) of the total sample group and the
a score of 4.15 versus the mean of 4.04. Call Taking Staff made up the balance of 71% (n = 82) of
Individuals who scored lower on the MAAS, 1.00 – 2.99 the total sample group.
showed the lowest levels of engagement, 3.10 versus the
The Back Office / Support Staff had a MAAS score of significantly lower than the mean of 4.04 and their
4.65, higher than the mean of 4.52 of the entire engagement score was 3.67 significantly lower than the
population. In addition, their UW ES burnout score was mean of 3.92 of the entire population. These scores
4.62 significantly h igher than the mean of 4.04 and their reveal that the Call Taking Staff have lower levels of
engagement score was 4.53 significantly higher than the mindfulness, higher levels of burnout and lower levels of
mean of 3.92 of the entire population. engagement.
The Call Taking Staff had a MAAS score of 4.47, lower
than the mean of 4.52 of the entire population. In V. DISCUSSION ON THE FINDINGS OF THE
addition, their UWES burnout score was 3.80 STUDY