n sume a
‘hes Sunn Pate or a
von, Sea geet Mon, A ma” a p23
‘ino een tt a dy pon cme
sa cre en) pt son rh pinot ee ow
pon site,» ote ben sen Asn es
reer" in plc, Weasel 24 Hk
a At (29) arn aoe 8
I
A Critical Survey of Modern Studies
on Muhammad’
MAXIME RODINSON
tia constant temptation forthe nonspeit onda for he specials
‘whose expertise in another) 1 imagine that everything as been
‘hid on apolar subject. We ae ll deplorably lacking in magiation
in the facto dlsooveries that romain oe made. However, the perpetual
evolution in histor den even when the docimentaton increases only
ssefodealy) conan sis this wens of ed
st Mn he he sy ote eo. pao on he
subyequent period) by Leone Coetni sppetied 8 Wilan begining in
100S the reearher cou ight fea a sense of discouragement. And
Jets inthe years lowing the pubctig of Catan study, 2 aumber of|
tmoks appezed which have prolly stesed our perspective. Inde,
in recent ears a number of netting biographical states have Been
ube, and at lent some of hem ate of such nature as 1 oer
"eas previo held
"This current fret in the Prophet has causes which at in good mea
sure foritous/The polite! stuation of recent years ha traced he
tenon ofthe general public tothe peoples of Islam an especialy to
howe who, one may 8 erated this elslon, i. the Arabs A French
ook cub involved ia pushing a seis of biographies recently con
dicted kindof pol among reader for the purpose of determining
hich ofthe great men they wished o appear hit Bograph sees
{nin what order of preference. Makamimad was at se ead ofthe fist
»ad bya large margin. I this terest has ited he publication of|
Some good works, one ought paps tobe satised and to overtook the
tars tha are mixed ia with he go00 gran
“The Annal dell Ila of Castano Which reference has lea bse
made, marks both the elimination andthe end of «period of scholars
investigation, Following the ary efforts of K.P. Ludovico Marae”
tho prefaced hs tvansation of the Quran with = biographical study of
Matammad, two centuries enseed during which scolorly ivestiation
nade signiint progres.” European scholars cole! Arabic man
erp, began foe trams, and write commentaries ypon them.
Scholrystues us gradually accumulated. Te historical cuook of
the niacenth century coupled with ciel atitde which had fist
‘en applied in stales on Homer und the Bible mide posible the ist,
Tealy sent works ised on the material which wing poli
investigation had produced"
Following lengthy introduction on pretamie Arabia, Cactany as
sited by his coltborators, compiled and arranged (yearby yer, and
‘reat by eve) all the material which the sources, the Arab Rstrians,
‘ttered. The resultant conclusions based the fat, which Took int
fount the vatant forms in which they were found inthe sures, were
companied by steal alsa that rected the methodol Shep
‘ico eich Lanlos and Seigobos had jot set forth as uboltly nd
Pensible forthe historian. Later generations fee from the poss
eendancy, have opatded this aitude as Ryperercal In ober areas
{oo they were able fo show that it had bec eases, However, he
field under consideration here, there are unfortunatly numerous ex
fimples which poin up the value ofthis esl approach. Numerous
trons in Arab appear each year evidencing nd eoncence in sures
Tot are several centric ater than the events which they report The
counts found in our Muslin soures of events whic occured atthe
etoning of slam do indeed rogue special methodol ty. or
the pone of oral tramisionconsts a robin whose plications
have not ye Ben ful explored
Be thal ay H muy, might have seemed seul 0 go beyond the
quisicthaustive sompiation of Catan Nevertheless while this mon
nena production was coming out, serous facana sn his work became
‘ident presisely inthe aren of the comation of materi from the
ources. Dusiag the same petiod, another team, composed ofthe most
(quliiod Orem, pushed the Pabugit of Ton Satin floes vot
one STUDS ON MUHAMMAD as
umes, # source of capital importance which contained some ofthe most
"als and varied documents that have come dows Tous, But which
{Cactan wtiized only partly
However, stove and beyond the mater of this documentary lacs,
certain scholars were able oso that was pose Lo make prowess n|
‘he fk more by shifting the foes of one's examination of texts lend
known tha by ulinng new documents. Tha te Swed scholar Tor
‘Andrae tempted to explore in greater depth the personality of the
Propet inthe ight ofthe work of tho acy prt ths entry onthe
[ychology of religion? From another vantage point. his Morough
Tnomledge ofthe Syrie Church peated bi to she eatiey now hab
‘on the Custan environment in wick sam developed” Those ives
[ntone were coninsed ty K. Ahers who acted accurate only up 03
Stl pott) thatthe tide of Mohammad toward Css wos
{Ssenialy Christian 'YThe scholars ofthe peti were interested i te
investigation of inflaches. Those works which sited op Christian nr
‘nce were counterislanced by those which emphasized fens nen,
this ater having Bee studies early us 1883 by Rabb Abraham Geiger
in catfully Dalanoed study." The same tendency was subsequently
‘intinued by C. C. Torey and others.” Somewhit more Boal, ious
studies were devoted to Judeo-Chrisian sources Of Quranic mative
fad concepts." Sues ofthis genre are assuredly very necessary. Iam
twas not hoen in sale container in an enironmea zd agaist
the germs of other Meolgies ge contemporary Musim authors and ce
tui other frequently imine. Is highly presypaous to bee tat
fone can say the developmeat of naieat Iam by ignoring the reat
World religions whore infucnce, we now know, penetrated all parts of
[Abia atthe bepining of the seventh century, Ths hid of investiga
tho, bowever, had its exces. I an the risk of foreting the dete
vigil of Ilr an he evident fact that study of atvence canoe
fal explain the origin of « new Meologcal phenomenon or is own
Partclardyamivm, One most never ander any circumstances o& i ay
re shun a stactral analysis which takes ito account the fnetional
bocesriy of the new ideology Afterall, Muhammad became neither &
Jew nor & Chris. Ad i tat had happened, it would fave been
nocesnry not only 0 determine the infencs that hd brought about his
onverson but alo 1 explain why it was hat he had allowed himself
be ituenced
‘Wile not having devoted complete work to the fe of Mubarmad in2% runes om La
‘it emtrety foe man domited European stoes on Mobummad during
the fist third of this centry. He was Hens Lammers, This Belgian
Jet, Fronch at hear, a good Arabi though not without hi weakness
in tl regard, was endowed with the power of indtatizabie work and
with «combative temperament wich hs prety profesion channeled in
{he divestion of scholar. He lo possessed remarkable ality oy
bold of those living guilities communicated bythe ancient texts alone
sith crary talent mbih enabled im to convey these to hi eet,
is scholarly and historical expositions (which were aay ile or
‘oral did not distin th wse of thetreal devices: abd ofen in thei
Daring cezndo he made wie of Arabic quotations or rsrtd to hi
favorite French poets sich a Vici Hugo and Hen de Borie. In
ton, he was filed with holy contempt for Iam, fore "delve
ory” and is works, forts casenbliag” and “acvoue” Propet, or
the Arabs of the desert who i his jadgment were cowards a vagger
fs, planderers and destroyers. ASoleted wi the Universite Sat
oweph of Beet, an active enter of Arabi tis, Ne Biterysftcked
{inthe same spt) the Shsiflan woops led by the Meccan Faisal (ad
supported by the Protestant Lawrence) agai the French who were
represented by the pious geneal Gouraud. Turning omar the past be
lashed out agai the caliph “AB, Faas dant ancestor, whom he
haracterzed as obese uly, timid, immoral, gen othe rain of
Is wife, the “dull” and "compisining” Fatima. Taking 8 poston 9p
‘posed to Muti tration, he rehabiltte the Usyad dy whose
Fete ladiference toward slam delighted him, « dynasty which (0
their credit as he saw felled upon Sian Christians to adminis he
ativated lands conquered bythe Aras, and which tempi 0 subs
{he chronic enavchism ofthe “savage” Bedouin. Taking op the iver
tions begun by Tense Goldrher and the eas which he ba st fort,
mens pusod othe extreme the crial analy of Msi triton,
‘smashed without more the later pital tendcsies bind the mt
tives which recounted the deeds an sayings ofthe Prophet and thos of
ik Companions In this entless an desperate pursuit of the apo
hal, be utlized without dcretion the etal tool which the minetenth
etary had wed ga Bis ow lth. "Te only soso acepabl 10
him were those tht reflected unfavorably on Mum and is fay,
His excessive prejudice, his vilton ofthe txt ite ow aten and hi
rors have judy ealed forth severe judgments, However, one mst
ecognige that his colowal efforts at demas also had constructive
opens stuns ox MUNAROAD ”
teh, Thy ave fred wo be much more ih emandig of
Soares With the onli of try ely wet down
‘Sow ates aruling, mower, re 8 We must eatin
‘nts comestom the ear sy bythe Dash sch Frant Bu,
heh spmsntocompreentNe sumoay of Earopesn Schon of
{he pe proto World War I Tht wrk whic peed in Geman
in 980 wan elagenent of ah caker Dons ei pinion 1S,
{ed contain considerable mato formation taken om al of he
{rile sores sd aay eal nthe eho te Sica
om of European Isaniss, of whom he hed an alow exhaustive
Ionedge, With te robet good sense of scarcer, be
Jeced oth the hypeeiicinofceran Arai ao the Dd eon
‘ace of Mastin thir sce. Within the arc of te concer, the
tk has ot ten exceed and reais a npn ol
‘Apa fom tis menemental stneary aed every presplve ad
‘nial ogtsphy of Tor Andre ced above a wl cen oer
Spec wor hs period priced only grog sketch pe
Pete ahr uagatl he deo greta whom Me
fave mentoocd, and numerotsseclinedlnvesigaton in popes”
“Though le apart, we mu eal ataton ote Sogrupy of Maha
ined bY Emile Demengicm.2 «welled mor though wont he
topos of slap eucatinly 9 teary work cen by he
‘ie eae taken In comporton, the eqn eof ge, he
fteence of any srpunenaton on or jain of, Hews. This
tight coal work ceeds ming etm Core mpremion
of the mic in wich the Heo the Pope fled hs seed
trum oeeptn nthe Ara worl
enclose te miner of European sent sues, Ras
sin Kamit ring the poo of tan were cacourage by thio.
Inga eavienment to andenake ses and promote ipo wich
tere fen more tern or th ghey dhe ont ely an
{ore see vale, Tis tempera trend ncn nd of
thw i hoe states sit upon a oft sg) sine the gurtahlar
ten bad the aGvanag one conscientious reeareer, However, (he
Marist method id Tea them cope me Sealy (ough under &
fSnewhat mor mate form) the crcl questions comesed wh he
Socal soodiacs ofthe cei Minion movement, Tho hls wee,
moot, of diferent opm mith there tht here were aed