Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
This spreadsheet originated with two live steam locomotive projects, commenced without knowledge
sides of the world. Michael Guy in Toronto, Canada, and myself in Perth, Western Australia, both dec
gauge Garratt locomotives. Both of us decided independently to fit our locomotives with a Lempor ex
The benefits of the Lempor exhaust had been widely described in the printed and electronic media, a
the technology has been subsequently prepared by Michael on his web pages (appendix 1 Ref 1). B
read Ing. L. D. Porta's 1974 paper (appendix 1 Ref 2) describing the theory of the Lempor ejector, an
intimidated by the complexity of the mathematics used. However, a start had to be made somewhere
background in fluid mechanics and experience as an oil and gas pipeline engineer, I ought to make th
work. The result was a primitive combination of hand and spreadsheet based calculations, which gav
Porta's paper and provided chimney throat and nozzle sizes for the Lempor exhaust design on my (R
project.
The decision to develop the spreadsheet into a more user-friendly form was prompted by Michael, wh
by a mutual friend, Russell Dunn. The ensuing cooperation between two live steam enthusiasts who
this workbook.
411525926.xls 1 03/10/2019
INTRODUCTION by Michael Guy
Our intent has been to try to make L.D.Porta's important work on steam locomotive draughting more
model engineer by removing the need to work complex mathematics to achieve a design. This workb
to use and I believe that it is thanks to Richards clear analytical thinking. The user inputs are few and
such as cylinder and wheel dimensions for the most part.
In using it myself, I found that even though an initial set of numbers looked really good, when I actua
go back and tweak the sheet inputs as the reality of heights and clearances made themselves felt. Th
Lempor calc sheet makes it very easy to see the effect of changing the diffuser geometry to suit your
with Porta's instructions, post-installation track testing may require adjustments. The need to do this
method. To prove the sheet works, I built an ejector for my Romulus locomotive. Using the original no
from 57mm water to 126mm, a huge improvement. As time allows I will try different nozzles to swap s
draught for lower cylinder back-pressure.
Go ahead, play with the numbers it can be great fun and the results will more than repay the effort.
IT IS IMPORTANT TO NOTE that this spreadsheet represents one implementation of Porta's theory
that the implementation accurately reflects the great man's intent. The spirit in which the spreadshee
summed up by Porta's introduction to his paper, in which he says:
"It is not a kitchen recipe guaranteeing good results without a good tuning up with measurem
may try, providing that if success crowns his trial and error, the merit is to be credited to the t
expects that the failure is not to be credited to the theory, but to the user."
The spreadsheet will crunch the numbers but the user still has to interpret the results and design the
SPREADSHEET LAYOUT
The workbook is split into the following sheets:
- Introduction.
- Lempor exhaust sizing calculation. (Use this sheet to design the ejector once you know the steam fl
- Steam mass flow rate calculation. (Use this sheet to estimate the steam flow rate of your engine)
- Appendix 1 of explanatory notes, cautions and hyperlinks.
- Appendix 2, tables of locomotive data used in calculation verifications.
CONDITIONS OF USE
Attention is drawn to the disclaimers printed on the Lempor and Steam Rate calculation work
It is considered that others in the live steam community will have the knowledge and experience to m
improvements to the spreadsheet. Such corrections and improvements are welcomed, provided that
spreadsheet are clearly marked to identify changes and avoid confusion between versions, and that
shared within the live steam model engineering community. Initial releases of the workbook will have
passworded to prevent accidental changes. If you wish to try to make improvements or alter the math
please contact us at the address below for an open version.
411525926.xls 2 03/10/2019
CONDITIONS OF USE
Attention is drawn to the disclaimers printed on the Lempor and Steam Rate calculation work
It is considered that others in the live steam community will have the knowledge and experience to m
improvements to the spreadsheet. Such corrections and improvements are welcomed, provided that
spreadsheet are clearly marked to identify changes and avoid confusion between versions, and that
shared within the live steam model engineering community. Initial releases of the workbook will have
passworded to prevent accidental changes. If you wish to try to make improvements or alter the math
please contact us at the address below for an open version.
411525926.xls 3 03/10/2019
The Lempor Ejector Calculator
For the Model Engineer, Live Steamer
and Student of the
Second Generation Steam Locomotive
Beta version 1.1 released November 2005
This workbook is copyright © Richard Stuart & Michael Guy, all rights reserved 2005
This spreadsheet originated with two live steam locomotive projects, commenced without knowledge of each o
sides of the world. Michael Guy in Toronto, Canada, and myself in Perth, Western Australia, both decided to b
gauge Garratt locomotives. Both of us decided independently to fit our locomotives with a Lempor exhaust.
The benefits of the Lempor exhaust had been widely described in the printed and electronic media, and an exc
the technology has been subsequently prepared by Michael on his web pages (appendix 1 Ref 1). Both Micha
read Ing. L. D. Porta's 1974 paper (appendix 1 Ref 2) describing the theory of the Lempor ejector, and both of
intimidated by the complexity of the mathematics used. However, a start had to be made somewhere, and I de
background in fluid mechanics and experience as an oil and gas pipeline engineer, I ought to make the effort to
work. The result was a primitive combination of hand and spreadsheet based calculations, which gave a soluti
Porta's paper and provided chimney throat and nozzle sizes for the Lempor exhaust design on my (Richard St
project.
The decision to develop the spreadsheet into a more user-friendly form was prompted by Michael, who was pu
by a mutual friend, Russell Dunn. The ensuing cooperation between two live steam enthusiasts who have nev
this workbook.
411525926.xls 4 03/10/2019
INTRODUCTION by Michael Guy
Our intent has been to try to make L.D.Porta's important work on steam locomotive draughting more accessibl
model engineer by removing the need to work complex mathematics to achieve a design. This workbook was
to use and I believe that it is thanks to Richards clear analytical thinking. The user inputs are few and are read
such as cylinder and wheel dimensions for the most part.
In using it myself, I found that even though an initial set of numbers looked really good, when I actually drew th
go back and tweak the sheet inputs as the reality of heights and clearances made themselves felt. The graphin
Lempor calc sheet makes it very easy to see the effect of changing the diffuser geometry to suit your own loco
with Porta's instructions, post-installation track testing may require adjustments. The need to do this in no way
method. To prove the sheet works, I built an ejector for my Romulus locomotive. Using the original nozzle size
from 57mm water to 126mm, a huge improvement. As time allows I will try different nozzles to swap some of th
draught for lower cylinder back-pressure.
Go ahead, play with the numbers it can be great fun and the results will more than repay the effort.
IT IS IMPORTANT TO NOTE that this spreadsheet represents one implementation of Porta's theory and no gu
that the implementation accurately reflects the great man's intent. The spirit in which the spreadsheet is made
summed up by Porta's introduction to his paper, in which he says:
"It is not a kitchen recipe guaranteeing good results without a good tuning up with measurements. Ho
may try, providing that if success crowns his trial and error, the merit is to be credited to the theory. If
expects that the failure is not to be credited to the theory, but to the user."
The spreadsheet will crunch the numbers but the user still has to interpret the results and design the ejector.
SPREADSHEET LAYOUT
The workbook is split into the following sheets:
- Introduction.
- Lempor exhaust sizing calculation. (Use this sheet to design the ejector once you know the steam flow rate)
- Steam mass flow rate calculation. (Use this sheet to estimate the steam flow rate of your engine)
- Appendix 1 of explanatory notes, cautions and hyperlinks.
- Appendix 2, tables of locomotive data used in calculation verifications.
CONDITIONS OF USE
Attention is drawn to the disclaimers printed on the Lempor and Steam Rate calculation worksheets.
It is considered that others in the live steam community will have the knowledge and experience to make corre
improvements to the spreadsheet. Such corrections and improvements are welcomed, provided that all revise
spreadsheet are clearly marked to identify changes and avoid confusion between versions, and that all improv
shared within the live steam model engineering community. Initial releases of the workbook will have protection
passworded to prevent accidental changes. If you wish to try to make improvements or alter the math for your
please contact us at the address below for an open version.
411525926.xls 5 03/10/2019
CONDITIONS OF USE
Attention is drawn to the disclaimers printed on the Lempor and Steam Rate calculation worksheets.
It is considered that others in the live steam community will have the knowledge and experience to make corre
improvements to the spreadsheet. Such corrections and improvements are welcomed, provided that all revise
spreadsheet are clearly marked to identify changes and avoid confusion between versions, and that all improv
shared within the live steam model engineering community. Initial releases of the workbook will have protection
passworded to prevent accidental changes. If you wish to try to make improvements or alter the math for your
please contact us at the address below for an open version.
CONTACT INFORMATION
The authors hope that this workbook will be of interest and of use to the model engineering community worldw
build or modify a model or indeed, a full-sized locomotive, we would be interested to hear about it and to see
Your feedback, photographs and suggestions for improvements or corrections are requested and welcomed a
411525926.xls 6 03/10/2019
lemporcalculator@ca.inter.net
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to thank the following people:
Nigel Day for kindly answering a number of emailed questions.
Joe Dunham for MS Excel consulting to Michael Guy.
Trevor Heath for kindly offering to host this work on his Livesteaming.com site
411525926.xls 7 03/10/2019
posite
.25"
mary of
self had
en
with my
Porta's
ion 9 of
ratt
with me
ulted in
411525926.xls 8 03/10/2019
erage
be easy
ood things
had to
of the
nsistent
the
ht went
amount of
are given
s best
e reader
uthor
of the
e freely
and
ses,
411525926.xls 9 03/10/2019
of the
e freely
and
ses,
411525926.xls 10 03/10/2019
Lempor Calculation Spreadsheet Rev 1.1 Date: 1st November 2005
This workbook is copyright © Richard Stuart & Michael Guy, all rights reserved 2005.
Disclaimers:
No warranties or guarantees are given as to the correctness or appropriateness of the calculations in this spreadsheet.
All input data, and all interpretations and applications of the results, are the responsibility of the user.
By using this spreadsheet the user consents to take full responsibility for all costs and consequences arising directly and/or indirectly
from any application of the results.
Notes:
Values in black to be input by user. Bold print indicates principal user input values.
Values in red are calculated by spreadsheet
Input Data column shows terms {ξb, etc} as used by Porta and units (m3/kg) as used in this workbook.
PROJECT DATA
Locomotive Description: 7-1/4" gauge Romulus.
Designer: R. Marsh
Date: November 20th 2005
The objective of the calculation is to determine the chimney throat area, F1 and Tuyere area, F, by trial and error solution of Equation 9.
CALCULATED PARAMETERS
Calculation Steps
Trial value of chimney throat diameter (mm) 38 Vary this by trial and error to maximise Tuyere nozzle size
Chimney throat area, F1 (m2) 0.0011341149 Calculate area from throat diameter
Chimney exit area, Fs, (m2) 0.0079388046 Multiply throat area by exit/throat ratio.
Ideal diffuser outlet area, F0, (m2) 0.0024383845 From Porta's formula
Equation term, λ 0.6081632653 From Porta's formula
D2v 0.0002805751 Porta's equation 9
F1(Draught) Equation 9 denominator term 0.9923505795 Porta's equation 9
Equation 9 denominator term 1.4654405222 Porta's equation 9
Equation 9 denominator term 0.4749996359 Porta's equation 9
Results
Steam tuyere area, F (m2) 0.0001429201 Total area of the Lempor nozzles
Steam tuyere nozzle diameter (mm) 6.745 Diameter of an individual Lempor nozzle - Assumes a 4 nozzle
system.
6.750
6.735
6.730
6.725
6.720
6.715
36.1 37.05 38 38.95 39.9 Tuyere Area
Chimney Throat Diameter (mm) Individual Nozzle Diameter
0.005512 lb/second
3.5 Inch H2O
1.496 inches
0.266 inches
This workbook is copyright © Richard Stuart & Michael Guy, all rights reserved 2005.
Disclaimers:
No warranties or guarantees are given as to the correctness or appropriateness of the calculations in this spreadsheet.
All input data, and all interpretations and applications of the results, are the responsibility of the user.
By using this spreadsheet the user consents to take full responsibility for all costs and consequences arising directly and/or indirectly
from any application of the results.
Notes:
Values in black to be input by user
Values in red are calculated by spreadsheet
PROJECT DATA
Locomotive Description Case 1 is based on SAR modified 25NC, case 2 on SAR 19D. Case 3 for 7-1/4" gauge Romulus miniature loco.
Designer Numerical Calculation Check
Date Nov 16 2005
Steam consumption per minute (kg/min) 358.74084 256.53812 0.7291137 358.74084 Alternative units (kg/min)
Steam consumption per second (kg/s) 5.9790139 4.2756353 0.0121519 5.9790139 Units (kg/s) Enter this value in Lempor sheet cell B36
CONDITIONS OF USE
Attention is drawn to the disclaimers printed on the Lempor and Steam Rate calculation
It is considered that others in the live steam community will have the knowledge and experience
improvements to the spreadsheet. Such corrections and improvements are welcomed, provide
spreadsheet are clearly marked to identify changes and avoid confusion between versions, and
shared within the live steam model engineering community. Initial releases of the sheet will hav
passworded to ensure clean downloads. If you wish to try to make improvements or alter the m
contact us at <lemporcalculator@ca.inter.net> for an open version.
The Lempor Ejector Calculator
This workbook is copyright © Richard Stuart & Michael Guy, all rights reserved
APPENDIX 1
CONDITIONS OF USE
Attention is drawn to the disclaimers printed on the Lempor and Steam Rate calculation workshe
It is considered that others in the live steam community will have the knowledge and experience to make
improvements to the spreadsheet. Such corrections and improvements are welcomed, provided that all
spreadsheet are clearly marked to identify changes and avoid confusion between versions, and that all im
shared within the live steam model engineering community. Initial releases of the sheet will have protectio
passworded to ensure clean downloads. If you wish to try to make improvements or alter the math for yo
contact us at <lemporcalculator@ca.inter.net> for an open version.
The "Lempor Calculation" worksheet determines the following basic dimensions of the exhaust system:
Chimney throat size.
Blast nozzle size.
Note:
Porta's equation expresses these sizes as areas. For the user's convenience, the worksheet converts areas to diameters, o
system comprises a single chimney with four blast nozzles. For a multiple chimney system, the user will need to compute th
nozzle diameters from the area data generated by the worksheet.
Attention is therefore brought to the work of J.J.G. Koopmans (Ref 3) which may provide a method of calculating multiple ch
the values for a single chimney are known.
Note regarding Line 33: Chimney exit area/chimney throat area, Fs/F1.
If room is available for a tall stack (e.g. on a narrow gauge locomotive) this value may exceed 4 to accommodate the recomm
diffuser angle and the available height. Similarly, if headroom is short, the value may be less than 4.
There are various methods of determining the mass flow rate of steam, including the following:
The required smokebox vacuum can similarly be determined by various methods including the following:
Note:
The specific volume of steam is required in two places. These values can be obtained from steam tables or via the web, see
The admission temperature should take into account the superheater if one is fitted.
Caution:
Engine speed, valve-gear cut-off and steam "specific volume" input numbers make a real difference to the sheet output stea
If the "Lempor calculation sheet" results are to be meaningful, these inputs must be realistic and accurate.
Note:
The detail design of the components for an actual Lempor Ejector installation requires several dimensions not calculated by
mathematical explanation of the ejector and the additional dimensions, written to assist the Live Steam enthusiast and Mode
by Michael Guy and is available on the web (Ref 8).
OTHER LINKS
Useful Tools
The authors of this worksheet have no connection with the following companies but have found these pages to be helpful.
please
This workbook is copyright © Richard Stuart & Michael Guy, all rights reserved 2005.
Lempor Calculator
Output
Total chimney choke area, 0.2743 0.1486
F1, m2
Discrepancy, % -1.97 -9.28
Total blast nozzle tip area, 0.0297 0.01688
F, m2
Discrepancy, % -1.82 -4.42
-11% 122%
Not measured, assumed Lower than case 3, but not Above manometer range
to be similar to case 3. quantified during testing. of 178mm water.