Sunteți pe pagina 1din 12

The Dammam aquifer in Bahrain – Hydrochemical characterization and

alternatives for management of groundwater quality


Waleed K. Zubari

Abstract Over-abstraction of the Dammam aquifer, l’aquifère est alimenté latéralement à partir de l’Arabie
the principal aquifer in Bahrain, by the agricultural and Saoudite orientale. Quatre types de salinisation de
domestic sectors, has led to its salinization by adjacent l’eau souterraine ont été identifiés : une drainance
brackish and saline water bodies. A hydrochemical verticale en provenance d’eaux saumâtres sous-jacentes
study identified the locations of the sources of aquifer dans les régions nord-centrales, ouest et est, une intru-
salinization and delineated their areas of influence. The sion marine dans la région est, une intrusion d’eau de
investigation indicates that the aquifer water quality is sebkha dans la région sud-ouest, et le retour d’irriga-
significantly modified as groundwater flows from the tion dans un secteur localisé de la région sud-ouest.
northwestern parts of Bahrain, where the aquifer Quatre démarches alternatives de gestion de la qualité
receives its water by lateral underflow from eastern des eaux souterraines, acceptables par les services char-
Saudi Arabia, to the southern and southeastern parts. gés de l’eau à Bahreïn, sont discutées et des zones
Four types of salinization of the aquifer are identified: d’action prioritaire sont proposées, selon le type et
brackish-water up-flow from the underlying brackish- l’étendue de chacune des sources de salinisation et en
water zones in north-central, western, and eastern fonction des usages de les eaux souterraines dans
regions; seawater intrusion in the eastern region; intru- chaque secteur. L’efficacité des options de gestion
sion of sabkha water in the southwestern region; and proposées pour le contrôle de la dégradation de la
irrigation return flow in a local area in the western qualité de l’aquifère de Damman devrait être ensuite
region. Four alternatives for the management of évaluée au moyen d’un modèle de simulation.
groundwater quality that are available to the water
authorities in Bahrain are discussed and their priority Resumen El acuífero de Damman, el más importante
areas are proposed, based on the type and extent of de Bahrein, se explota para usos agrícolas y domésticos.
each salinization source, in addition to groundwater use La sobreexplotación del mismo ha provocado su salini-
in that area. The effectiveness of the proposed manage- zación por cuerpos de agua salada y salobre cercanos.
ment options in controlling the degradation of water Un estudio hidroquímico identificó las fuentes de sali-
quality in the Dammam aquifer should be evaluated nización y ayudó a dibujar sus áreas de influencia. La
using simulation modeling. calidad del agua subterránea se modifica significativa-
mente en la dirección del flujo, desde el noroeste del
Résumé La surexploitation de l’aquifère de Damman, país, donde las entradas son laterales y procedentes de
principal aquifère de Bahreïn, du fait des besoins agri- Arabia Saudí, hacia el sur y el sudeste. Se han identifi-
coles et domestiques, a conduit à sa salinisation à partir cado cuatro tipos de salinización: flujo ascendente de
d’eaux voisines saumâtres et salées. Une étude hydro- agua salobre en las regiones norte-central, este y oeste;
chimique a identifié les origines de la salinisation de intrusión de agua marina en la región este; intrusión de
l’aquifère et a délimité leurs zones d’influence. Les agua salobre al sudoeste y, finalmente, retorno de riego
recherches montrent que la qualité de l’eau souterraine en un área local de la región oeste. Se discuten cuatro
est modifiée de façon significative pour les écoulements alternativas para la gestión del agua y se proponen
souterrains dirigés vers les secteurs sud et sud-est et áreas prioritarias basadas en el tipo y la extensión de
provenant de la région nord-ouest de Bahreïn, là où cada fuente de salinización y en los usos de agua
subterránea en cada zona. La efectividad de las
Received: June 1998 opciones de gestión propuestas para controlar la
Revised: November 1998 degradación de la calidad del agua en el acuífero
Accepted: December 1998 Damman deberá evaluarse mediante simulaciones real-
Waleed K. Zubari (Y) izadas con un modelo numérico
Desert and Arid Zones Sciences Program, School of Graduate
Studies, Arabian Gulf University, PO Box 26671
Manama, Bahrain
Key words Bahrain 7 Dammam aquifer 7
Fax: c973 272555 hydrochemistry 7 salinization 7
e-mail: waleed6agu.edu.bh groundwater management

Hydrogeology Journal (1999) 7 : 197–208 Q Springer-Verlag


198

Introduction water bodies. As a direct consequence, encroachment


of these waters into the aquifer has occurred, causing
Bahrain consists of an archipelago of 33 islands located its salinization. The deterioration of groundwater
in the Arabian Gulf, about midway between Saudi quality has restricted the use of this resource from the
Arabia and Qatar. Locations are shown in Figure 1. invaded parts of the aquifer, which are estimated to be
The climate is characterized by high temperatures, more than half the volume of the original groundwater
erratic, often scanty, rainfall (~80 mm/yr), and a high reservoir, under steady-state conditions, in Bahrain
evapotranspiration rate ( 1 1800 mm/yr), which in (Zubari et al. 1993). Unless proper management of
combination create an impossible condition for surface- groundwater quality is implemented, the entire aquifer
water bodies to exist. Water demands are met mainly may be lost to salinization, and remedial measures
by groundwater abstraction and desalination plants. would then be difficult to implement and very expen-
Groundwater abstraction from the Dammam sive.
aquifer, the principal aquifer in Bahrain, accounts for Realizing the present conditions of the groundwater
more than 75% of the total water consumption in the resource and its limited capacity, the Government of
country. However, heavy reliance on the aquifer and its Bahrain has adopted the policy of using groundwater
over-abstraction during the last three decades have mainly for the agricultural sector, and of reducing the
caused a rapid decline in its potentiometric levels and a dependency on groundwater for the domestic sector by
reversal of hydraulic gradients between the relatively constructing additional desalination plants. Further-
fresh-water aquifer and adjacent brackish- and saline- more, treated wastewater is expected to supplement
groundwater used in irrigation and to meet additional
requirements for future agricultural development in the
country.
The management options that are presently avail-
able to the water authorities mainly emphasize the
reduction of groundwater abstraction from the
Dammam aquifer for the agricultural and domestic
sectors, which are the main groundwater consumers
(70% and 27%, respectively). Reduction of ground-
water abstraction in the agricultural sector is planned to
be implemented through the gradual replacement of
groundwater used for irrigation, currently about 153
million cubic meters per year (Mm 3/yr), by tertiary-
treated wastewater. Through an ambitious plan, about
73 Mm 3/yr of these waters would be provided by 2004
(ACE 1990a, 1990b, 1997). Presently, only about
13 Mm 3/yr of these waters is being used in irrigation
(Zubari 1997). On the other hand, reduction of ground-
water abstraction in the domestic sector, currently
about 59 Mm 3/yr, is being planned through the
construction of additional desalination plants at various
locations in Bahrain. At present, Bahrain has three
desalination plants operating on the east coast, with a
total output of 56 Mm 3/yr (Zubari 1997). Desalinated
water is blended with groundwater in a one-to-one
ratio and is used to supply most of the population,
except the northwestern area, which depends princi-
pally on groundwater (Zubari et al. 1996a).
Furthermore, beginning in the 1980s, the water
authorities implemented a management scheme that
consists of prohibiting the industrial sector from using
groundwater from the Dammam aquifer and instead to
meet its water demands from the underlying brackish-
water zones (Amiri Decree No. 12/1980, 1980). The
objective of the scheme is two-fold: (1) to control and
decrease the abstraction rates from the Dammam
aquifer by the ever-expanding industrial sector; and (2)
to lower the potentiometric levels in the brackish-water
Figure 1 Location of Bahrain and sampling sites for hydrochem- zones and decrease the vertical hydraulic gradients
ical survey between the Dammam aquifer and its underlying

Hydrogeology Journal (1999) 7 : 197–208 Q Springer-Verlag


199

brackish-water zones, in order to reduce upward migra- Bahrain, Kuwait, and southern Qatar. The Dammam
tion of brackish water into the aquifer (GDC 1980, aquifer in Bahrain receives its water mainly by under-
1983). flow from this regional aquifer, with additional, insig-
The expansion of tertiary-treatment facilities is still nificant amounts by rainfall recharge, averaging about
in the planning phase, and hence, the majority of waste- 0.5 Mm 3/yr (GDC 1980). According to many
water is being treated only secondarily, due to environ- researchers (Al-Noaimi 1993; Zubari 1987; GDC 1980;
mental considerations, for discharge into the sea. At Wright 1967), the steady-state rate of underflow from
present, secondary-treated wastewater is available in eastern Saudi Arabia to Bahrain ranges from
large quantities, as much as about 44 Mm 3/yr (ACE 100–112 Mm 3/yr. A comparison between the present
1997), which represents about 42% of the present abstraction rates from the Dammam aquifer (218 Mm 3/
groundwater over-drafting rate in Bahrain. The water yr) and the approximate recharge rate by underflow
authorities in Bahrain have considered the possibility indicates that the aquifer is being over-drafted by a rate
of using some of this unused secondary-treated waste- of about 105 Mm 3/yr.
water, and also, future surplus tertiary-treated waste- The Dammam aquifer system in Bahrain islands,
water, to artificially recharge the Dammam aquifer (Al- which is an anticlinal structure, consists of two aquifer
Azawi 1989; GDC 1986). zones, designated the ‘A’ and ‘B’ zones, developed in
In Bahrain, four possible sources of salinization of the Alat (15–25 m thick) and Khobar (40–49 m thick)
the Dammam aquifer exist: seawater invasion, brackish limestone members of the Dammam Formation,
water up-flow from the underlying zones, migration of respectively. Stratigraphic relationships are shown in
sabkha water, and irrigation return flows. The location, the hydrogeologic section of Figure 2. In the core of the
magnitude, and a real extent of each salinization source anticline, at the center of Bahrain main island, the
is the type of information needed by the water authori- rocks of the Dammam Formation are completely
ties (planners and managers) as a first step in the devel- eroded (Figure 1), exposing the rocks of the underlying
opment of a groundwater-quality management plan. Rus Formation (early Eocene). The Dammam aquifer
This information can be used to define the suitability system is confined in most of Bahrain from above by
and the implementation area of each of the above four the claystones of the Neogene Formation (10–60 m
general management alternatives, in order to maximize thick), and from the base by the shale beds of the
their effectiveness in remedying existing degradations Sharks Tooth Shale Member (8–20 m thick) of the
and in preventing future ones. Dammam Formation, in addition to the anhydrite and
In this study, the hydrochemistry of the groundwater shale deposits in the upper part of the Rus Formation.
in the Dammam aquifer in Bahrain is characterized The two aquifer zones are separated by the Orange
using a countrywide hydrochemical survey. The back- Marl Member (9–15 m thick) of the same formation. In
ground major-ion chemistry is identified, and the the western part of Bahrain island, at the locality of
graphical presentation of the hydrochemistry is used to Hamalah, the Neogene claystones and parts of the Alat
identify the locations of the contamination sources indi- limestone are eroded due to a structural high that exists
cated above and to delineate their areas of influence. at that locality, and the aquifer is unconfined (Figures 1
Based on the type and the extent of each contamina- and 2).
tion source, in addition to groundwater use in that area, The ‘A’ aquifer zone has an average transmissivity
alternatives for management of groundwater quality of about 350 m 2/d. The ‘B’ aquifer zone, developed in
are discussed and their priority areas are proposed. highly fractured limestones and dolomites, is the prin-
cipal aquifer in Bahrain, where it provides more than
70% of the total groundwater abstraction. This is due
Hydrogeologic Setting to the high transmissive properties (average transmis-
sivity is about 10,000 m 2/d) of the aquifer. Due to the
The Dammam aquifer, a confined coastal aquifer, is presence of a semi-confining layer between the two
developed in the limestone and dolomite members of zones and to improper well-completion practices, in
the Dammam Formation (early to middle Eocene). The which both aquifers are tapped by most wells, little
aquifer represents the only natural, relatively fresh- variation of water chemistry exists between the ‘A’ and
water source available for Bahrain. Abstraction from ‘B’ aquifer zones (GDC 1980). Therefore, in this hydro-
the aquifer at present (1995/96) is about 218 Mm 3/yr chemical survey, the two are considered together to
and accounts for about 76% of the country’s total represent the Dammam aquifer.
consumption (agricultural, domestic, and industrial A third aquifer zone, termed locally as ‘C’, is devel-
uses), with the remainder provided by desalination oped in the Rus Formation and the upper parts of the
plants and recycled treated wastewater (Zubari 1997). Umm Er Radhuma (UER) Formation (Paleocene to
In Bahrain, the Dammam aquifer is a small part of early Eocene). The Rus Formation is composed princi-
an extensive regional aquifer system, termed the pally of fractured chalky dolomitic limestone, with
eastern Arabian aquifer, that extends from central subsidiary shale and anhydrite intercalations in its
Saudi Arabia, where the aquifer crops out and its main upper section. The Rus Formation in the central and
recharge area is located, to the Arabian Gulf, including eastern parts of Bahrain has undergone extensive solu-

Hydrogeology Journal (1999) 7 : 197–208 Q Springer-Verlag


200

Figure 2 Hydrogeologic
section across Bahrain

tion of its anhydrite (Figure 2), which has led to the Mg) and major anions (Cl, SO4, HCO3, CO3), total
collapse of the overlying rocks, and more importantly, alkalinity (as CaCO3), total hardness (as CaCO3), pH,
has reduced the effectiveness of its upper confining electrical conductivity (EC, mmhos/cm), and total
layer, which causes a relatively easier migration of its dissolved solids (TDS, mg/L). The rest of the water
water into the Dammam aquifer in those areas (GDC samples (144) were only analyzed for EC, and their
1983). Groundwater in the ‘C’ aquifer zone occurs in TDS was calculated from an established relationship
the form of a brackish-water lens (8000–15,000 mg/L) in between the TDS and EC measured in the other 110
Bahrain main island (Figure 2), with total water samples.
reserves of about 10,000 Mm 3. Prior to this survey, a general survey on the quality
The salinity of groundwater in the aquifer gradually of groundwater was conducted in 1990 (Raveendran
increases with depth. In central Bahrain island, salinity and Madany 1991a) to investigate the possibility of
increases from about 8000 mg/L at the water table, at groundwater pollution by septic tanks and cesspools in
about 5 m elevation above mean sea level, to about Bahrain. The survey included 57 samples from selected
15,000 mg/L at a depth of about 150 m below mean sea areas in Bahrain, where the chemical species of
level. The brackish-water lens is underlain by brine nitrates, nitrites, ammonia, and phosphates were deter-
with a salinity of more than 40,000 mg/L. Due to its mined in addition to the major cations, major anions,
high salinity, utilization of groundwater from the ‘C’ EC, TDS, and pH. The results indicate that nutrient
aquifer is restricted to industrial purposes in the north- contents are generally low in the Dammam aquifer, and
central region and to supplying desalination plants on thus it was concluded that the aquifer is free from
the eastern coast of Bahrain main island; total abstrac- pollution by nutrients. Some of the results of this
tion is about 30 Mm 3/yr (Zubari and Khater 1995). survey (37 wells) are used to complement the present
study in the statistical analysis section.

Hydrochemistry
Summary Statistics
Groundwater Sampling A summary of the results of the survey is given in
This paper incorporates results of a countrywide hydro- Table 1, and results are plotted in the percentage
chemical survey of the Dammam aquifer that was frequency diagrams of Figure 3. The relative content of
carried out from August 1990 to May 1992. Ground- a cation or an anion is defined as the percentage of the
water sampling sites (254 wells) are in usable areas of milli-equivalent per liter (meq/L) of total cations or
the aquifer in Bahrain and are shown in Figure 1. total anions, respectively (Sen and Al-Dakheel 1986).
Groundwater samples from the north-central parts of Table 1 indicates that the Dammam aquifer in Bahrain
Bahrain were somewhat limited, because most produc- contains brackish to saline waters (TDS is
tion wells in these parts have been abandoned. Aquifer 2100–6600 mg/L), and Figure 3 illustrates that two ions
salinity had reached about 11,000 mg/L by 1978/79 are dominant in the Dammam water, Na c and Cl –;
(GDC 1980). Out of the total 254 water samples, 110 they are the only ions that extend to the zone of domi-
samples were analyzed for major cations (Na, K, Ca, nance (meq/L% 1 50%). Although not reaching a

Hydrogeology Journal (1999) 7 : 197–208 Q Springer-Verlag


201

Table 1 Statistical summary


Constituent N Mean SD Minimum Maximum
of concentrations of chemical
constituents, Dammam aquifer
TDS, mg/L 291 4611 2639 2120 16,640
EC, mmhos/cm 291 6919 3350 3250 16,460
pH 147 7.20 0.25 6.35 7.76
Total alkalinity, mg/L 147 178 21 115 262
Total hardness, mg/L 147 1296 580 760 3115
Na c, mg/L 147 1005 822 421 5819
K c, mg/L 135 52 36 24 321
Ca 2c, mg/L 147 354 189 177 1172
Mg 2c, mg/L 147 139 86 57 667
Cl –, mg/L 147 1944 1602 788 10,615
HCO3 –, mg/L 147 232 55 104 610
SO4 2–, mg/L 147 787 490 225 3293
CO3, mg/L 147 0.0 - - -

dominance level, the Dammam water contains large Rus Formation. A simple relation exists between the
percentages of Ca 2c and SO4 2– ions, whereas the Mg 2c aquifer potentiometric surface and its salinity: as the
and HCO3 – ions are considerably below the dominance potentiometric head declines, the water quality in the
level (~50%). Groundwater in the Dammam Forma- aquifer degrades. Better quality water (TDS of
tion is thus principally of NaCl facies and has a 2200–2500 mg/L) in the Dammam aquifer flows toward
tendency toward CaSO4 facies. Bahrain from the northwest, where the aquifer is
A general similarity in the above characteristics recharged by lateral underflow from its extension in
exists between the groundwater in the eastern parts of eastern Saudi Arabia. If this relatively fresh water in
Saudi Arabia and that encountered in the northwestern the northwestern and northern parts of Bahrain is
parts of Bahrain. The former has a TDS of considered to be the reference water quality, then
1800–2000 mg/L, and of mainly Na-Cl and Na-Ca-Cl except for the northern and northwestern coastal strip,
facies (Sen and Al-Dakheel 1986; Hassan and Cagatay salinization is widespread in most of Bahrain.
1994). The above hydrochemical characteristics are At the east coast and Sitrah Island, seawater intru-
common features of dolomitic limestone aquifers in sion was recognized as early as the 1940s by many
arid zones and indicate the absence of recent recharge hydrogeologists (Hurry 1940; Gulmon 1941; Steineke
and the old age of the groundwater (Al-Ruwaih 1995a, 1942), when the equilibrium system between the
1995b; Nativ and Nissim 1992; Sen and Al-Dakheel aquifer water and seawater was disturbed by artificial
1986). abstraction. Wright (1967) studied the chemistry of
In order to identify the contamination sources for groundwater in the vicinity of Sitrah Island and
the Dammam aquifer and to delineate their areas of concluded that a saline wedge was developing across
influence, the hydrochemistry was analyzed graphically, the island. He also suggested the possibility of seawater
by means of contour maps of TDS and major ions, Stiff entry through the aquifer outcrops located offshore,
diagrams, trilinear diagrams, distributions of the ratios east of Bahrain islands, and through the offshore
of some major-ion concentrations, and mineral satura- outlets of springs.
tion ratios. In this paper, only the methods most helpful GDC (1980) confirmed Wright’s observations by a
in identifying and delineating the areas of influence of thorough hydrochemical study at Sitrah Island.
the contamination sources are presented. Previous studies of salinization in north-central
Bahrain were reviewed (Wright 1967, 1977; Italconsult
1971;) and here, the aquifer water had reached a
Distribution of Total Dissolved Solids and Sources of salinity of 11,000 mg/L. A detailed study was conducted
Salinization on this degradation mechanism which concluded that
Figure 4 shows the distribution of TDS of groundwater the aquifer was affected by the upward migration of the
in the Dammam aquifer in Bahrain for 1992. In order deeper brackish water from the Rus Formation,
to visualize the spatial distribution of groundwater because the hydraulic gradient between the Dammam
salinity with respect to groundwater flow paths, the aquifer and the underlying Rus Formation had
distribution of elevation of the potentiometric surface reversed due to the reduction of the potentiometric
for the same year is superimposed (Zubari et al. 1993). levels in the Dammam aquifer.
The distribution of potentiometric head indicates that In the southwestern part of Bahrain main island, an
the general groundwater flow direction is from the increase in groundwater salinity was first reported in
northwestern part of Bahrain toward the southern and the 1960s (Hamilton 1965). The increase in salinity was
southeastern parts. In the north-central parts of interpreted to have been caused by the lateral migra-
Bahrain island, potentiometric head is anomalously tion of sabkha saline waters (TDSp10,200 mg/L),
high, about c2.5 m. These contours represent the areas where an extensive sabkha overlies the aquifer (GDC
of active brackish water up-flow from the underlying 1980). (A sabkha is a saline mudflat, or playa.)

Hydrogeology Journal (1999) 7 : 197–208 Q Springer-Verlag


202

Figure 3 Percentage frequency distribution of TDS and ion Zubari et al. (1997) indicated that in western
concentrations Bahrain, contamination by irrigation return flow and/or
domestic wastewater is possible, due to the presence of
hydraulic conditions that are favorable for surface-

Hydrogeology Journal (1999) 7 : 197–208 Q Springer-Verlag


203

hydrochemical differentiation techniques, in order to


identify the factors responsible for the deterioration in
water quality.

Distribution of Major Ions


The spatial changes in groundwater quality and pattern
changes of the major ions in the Dammam aquifer are
illustrated in Figure 5 by the distribution of Stiff
diagrams (Zaporozec 1972) of some selected sampled
wells. Typical Stiff diagrams of seawater, Rus brackish
water, and agricultural drainage water are also shown.
Analysis of the patterns and their comparison with the
patterns of the salinization sources indicate that most
groundwater in the Dammam aquifer in Bahrain has
been affected by mixing with brackish water from the
Rus Formation, including large parts of the eastern
coastal areas, which were previously known to be
affected by seawater intrusion. Seawater intrusion in
the east coast is also clearly identified in three wells
located in eastern Bahrain main island. Pollution of the
Dammam aquifer by irrigation return flow is difficult to
recognize from the major-ion concentration, because
groundwater from the Dammam aquifer is used for irri-
gation. However, an increase in the TDS (about
5000 mg/L) occurs near the western outcrop areas at
Hamalah locality. Although not conclusive, sabkha
saline-water intrusion, which has characteristics similar
to seawater intrusion, is indicated in one sample in the
southwestern locality of Zallaq.
Figure 4 Distribution of TDS and potentiometric head in the
Dammam aquifer, 1992
Calcium /Magnesium Ratio
Analysis of the data set and relations among various
chemical components indicate that Ca and Mg are good
derived contamination. The Dammam aquifer occurs in indicators of the origin of salinization of the Dammam
most of Bahrain under confining conditions. These aquifer. Figure 6 is a scatter-of the relation between Ca
conditions are assumed to protect the aquifer from and Mg (mg/L) in groundwater. Uncontaminated
surface sources of contamination. However, in west groundwater in the Dammam aquifer evolves in the
Bahrain at the locality of Hamalah, where the ’B’ direction of the Rus Formation brackish waters and the
aquifer crops out, an anomalous increase in salinity of agricultural drainage water, with some tendency toward
groundwater derived from some of the wells, about seawater. The majority of the samples is affected by the
6000 mg/L, has been observed. In this area, intensive Rus brackish water (area within the dotted oval,
agricultural activities are taking place; these include Figure 6).
flood irrigation, frequent washing of soil due to its The relative concentration of Mg in seawater is high
salinization, lack of efficient drainage system due to compared to its Ca concentration; the Ca/Mg ratio in
low surface elevation (~5 m), and heavy application of seawater is about 0.2. In uncontaminated groundwater,
fertilizers. Furthermore, heavy abstraction of the this ratio ranges from 1.45 (Umm Na’asan Island) to
Dammam aquifer in that locality has caused the poten- 1.75 (Manama and west Muharraq Island). In the Rus
tiometric head to decline to mean sea level (Figure 4), Formation brackish water, this ratio ranges from
making the aquifer susceptible to downward migration 1.5–3.7 and increases with depth (GDC 1980, 1983).
of surface water. Thus, the greater the degree of vertical contamination
The determination of the precise origin of saliniza- by the Rus Formation brackish water, the higher is the
tion and its area of influence is difficult using the TDS expected ratio. Therefore, an increase in the ratio indi-
distribution alone, because more than one potential cates mixing with groundwater from the Rus aquifer,
source exists that could increase the salinity level of whereas a decrease in the ratio indicates mixing with
groundwater. Therefore, expert judgment should be seawater and sabkha water.
employed, taking into account the previously known Figure 7 is a contour map of the Ca/Mg ratio for
spatial positions of these sources and aided by other groundwater from the Dammam aquifer in Bahrain.

Hydrogeology Journal (1999) 7 : 197–208 Q Springer-Verlag


204

Figure 5 Stiff diagrams of groundwater samples from selected Anhydrite Saturation Ratio
wells, Dammam aquifer, 1992 The calculated logarithmic anhydrite activity product
(APAnh) of groundwater from the Dammam aquifer
has a mean of –5.045, a minimum of –5.589, a maximum
The low Ca/Mg ratio values (0.3–1.5) in eastern of –4.322, and a standard deviation of 0.265 (Np147).
Bahrain indicate that seawater intrusion is the domi- The logarithmic solubility product value for anhydrite
nant process, whereas in central and western Bahrain (KAnh) is –4.5 (Stumm and Morgan 1970). The degree
high ratio values (1.5–2.0) indicate that contamination of saturation of groundwater with respect to anhydrite
by brackish water up-flow is the dominant process. To was measured by the ratio APAnh/KAnh. If the ratio for
the southwest, the Ca/Mg ratio decreases to about 1.2, anhydrite is greater than 1, the solution is over-satu-
indicating mixing with sabkha water, which has charac- rated and the mineral is being deposited; if the ratio
teristics similar to those of seawater. less than 1, it is under-saturated and the mineral is
In the locality of Hamalah, in northwestern Bahrain, being dissolved; and if it is equal to 1, the solution is in
the Ca/Mg value decreases to about 1.3 and TDS values equilibrium with respect to the mineral.
are greater than 5000 mg/L; these values coincide with Figure 8 shows the anhydrite saturation patterns for
the outcrop areas of the Dammam aquifer. Agricultural groundwater in the Dammam aquifer. The map indi-
drainage water in this locality has a Ca/Mg ratio cates that groundwater approaching Bahrain Islands
ranging from 1.18–1.74, with an average value of about from the northwest is highly under-saturated in anhy-
1.35 (Raveendran and Madany 1991b). The decrease in drite (0.15–0.2). This condition agrees with that
the Ca/Mg ratio is interpreted to be due to downward reported by Hassan and Cagatay (1994) for the
contamination by agricultural drainage water. Dammam aquifer in eastern Saudi Arabia. As this

Hydrogeology Journal (1999) 7 : 197–208 Q Springer-Verlag


205

Figure 6 Relation between calcium and magnesium concentra-


tions, Dammam aquifer

Figure 7 Distribution of Ca/Mg ratio, Dammam aquifer


water moves toward the southeast, it becomes progres-
sively saturated with anhydrite and approaches over-
saturation with anhydrite (reaching a maximum of 1.1) of salinization and their areas of influence. Figure 9
in the central, western, and eastern parts of Bahrain. shows options for various parts of Bahrain. The results
The increase in anhydrite saturation to over-saturation indicate that the brackish Rus Formation is the main
is attributed to the presence of large quantities of anhy- source of contamination of groundwater in the
drite in the Rus aquifer (Figure 2); CaSO4 is being Dammam aquifer in Bahrain. Contamination by
actively introduced to groundwater in the Dammam brackish water occurs over most of north-central
aquifer by upward migration of water from the Rus Bahrain. Efforts at managing groundwater quality,
aquifer. The main areas of upward migration and the therefore, should be concentrated on reducing the
area of influence of this process are delineated from upward migration of the brackish water from the Rus
Figure 8. Formation into the Dammam aquifer; this reduction
The anhydrite saturation decreases in the southeast, can be achieved either by increasing the potentiometric
where seawater is in direct contact with groundwater, head in the Dammam aquifer or by decreasing it in the
and in the southwest, where sabkha water is in direct Rus brackish-water zones.
contact with the groundwater. In the Hamalah locality, This approach suggests that the present policy of
a low value of anhydrite saturation occurs, interrupting supplying the industrial sector with brackish water from
the general trend of increasing anhydrite saturation due the Rus Formation should be continued. This abstrac-
to brackish-water up-flow. This anomaly is interpreted tion should be encouraged in the north-central area,
to be the result of the downward migration of irrigation where maximum upward migration is taking place. The
return flow into the aquifer. extraction would help to lower the potentiometric
levels in the Rus Formation and would consequently
reduce the large vertical gradients that exist between
Alternatives For Management of Groundwater the two aquifers.
Quality Most of the traditional agricultural lands in the
north-central area have been abandoned due to major
The results of this study provide information that can groundwater salinization; TDS is more than 10,000 mg/
be useful for the management of the groundwater L in those areas (Zubari et al. 1996b), and pumping of
resources in Bahrain, especially with respect to sources groundwater has almost completely ceased since the

Hydrogeology Journal (1999) 7 : 197–208 Q Springer-Verlag


206

late 1980s. The first phase in the utilization of tertiary-


treated wastewater for irrigation has concentrated on
some of these areas (ACE 1984), and this has helped in
the reclamation of some of these abandoned lands.
These reclamation efforts should continue in most of
the agriculturally abandoned lands in north-central
Bahrain at later stages of the project for the utilization
of wastewater in irrigation.
Reduction of groundwater abstraction should also
be concentrated in the areas that have shown major
deterioration. The selection of an alternative or supple-
mentary source of water would depend on the main
water use in the area. The western and southwestern
localities, which are affected by the upward migration
of brackish water, intrusion of sabkha water, and
possibly by irrigation return flows, are principally agri-
cultural areas. Tertiary-treated wastewater should be
used in these areas to replace, partially or completely,
groundwater presently used for irrigation. Due to the
marginal quality (4000–7000 mg/L TDS) of ground-
water in these two areas, the acceptance level of treated
wastewater as a substitute for the groundwater is
expected to be relatively high. Moreover, the replace-
ment of groundwater used for irrigation by tertiary-
treated wastewater in these two areas would reduce
groundwater abstraction amounts and help increase the
potentiometric surface, which in turn would reduce the
volumes of irrigation return flows into the aquifer.
In the northern and northwestern areas, which are
affected mainly by brackish-water up-flow, ground-
water is mainly used for agricultural and domestic
Figure 8 Distribution of anhydrite saturation ratio, Dammam purposes. In these areas, new desalination plants
aquifer
should be the alternative source that would replace the

Figure 9 Proposed schemes


for managing groundwater
quality in Bahrain

Hydrogeology Journal (1999) 7 : 197–208 Q Springer-Verlag


207

wellfields for domestic water supply. Groundwater as groundwater moves from the northwestern parts of
from the Dammam aquifer should be used exclusively Bahrain, where the aquifer receives its water by lateral
for agricultural activities in these areas. This approach underflow from eastern Saudi Arabia, to the southern
is in accordance with the general policy of the govern- and southeastern parts. Degradation of the aquifer
ment. These areas should be given the lowest priority water quality is caused by four sources of contamina-
in the management scheme for the utilization of waste- tion: (1) brackish water up-flow from the Rus aquifer in
water, because they have the best groundwater quality, the north-central, western, and eastern regions; (2)
supplied by underflow from eastern Saudi Arabia. The seawater intrusion in the eastern region; (3) intrusion
presence of groundwater of relatively good quality in of sabkha water in the southwestern region; and (4)
the northern and northwestern coastal strip irrigation drainage water in a local area in western
(~3000 mg/L TDS) makes the use of treated waste- Bahrain. The spatial distribution of TDS, Stiff
water unattractive to farmers in these areas and would diagrams, Ca/Mg ratios, and anhydrite saturation ratios
therefore continue to be one of the constraints on the were used to identify the locations of these four
effective use of treated wastewater in Bahrain (Zubari contamination sources and to delineate their areas of
1997). influence. The study illustrates that the upward migra-
Seawater intrusion is the second major source of tion of brackish water is the main cause of the degrada-
groundwater degradation, and it occurs mainly in the tion of groundwater in the Dammam aquifer in
eastern area. At present, the eastern coast of Bahrain is Bahrain.
an industrial area with some urban settlements and The proposed gradual replacement of abstracted
large, abandoned agricultural lands. The abandonment groundwater used in irrigation by tertiary-treated
of the agricultural lands started in the early 1970s and wastewater should be given top priority in two agricul-
was the direct result of seawater intrusion in the tural areas. These are the western area, which is princi-
eastern coast, where the salinity of the groundwater pally affected by the upward migration of brackish
reached over 15,000 mg/L in that period (Zubari et al. water, and the southwestern area, which is affected by
1994). In this area, industrial activities should continue intrusion of sabkha water. The marginal groundwater
their dependence on the Rus Formation brackish salinity in these two areas (4000–7000 mg/L) results in a
water, and domestic supply should continue its reliance high acceptance level of treated wastewater by the
on desalinated water. In addition, the abandoned agri- farmers. A vast area of agricultural lands has been
cultural lands should be restored and rejuvenated by abandoned in the north-central and eastern parts of
utilizing tertiary-treated wastewater for irrigation. Bahrain due to severe salinization of groundwater. The
Furthermore, at present, about 44 Mm 3/yr of unused introduction of treated wastewater for irrigation should
secondary treated wastewater is being discharged to the be implemented in these two areas in the later stages of
sea along the east coast, where the treatment plant is the management scheme, in order to restore the land
located. As a complementary management option to for agriculture. This utilization should be given the
the ones indicated above, recharging of the Dammam lowest priority in the agricultural lands in the northern
aquifer on the east coast by parts of these unused and northwestern areas, because they have the best
volumes should be considered, in order to form a groundwater quality (~3000 mg/L), making the treated
hydraulic barrier against seawater intrusion. wastewaters unattractive to the farmers and thus
hindering their effective utilization.
The present policy and management scheme of
meeting the industrial-sector water needs with the
Conclusions and Recommendations underlying brackish-water zones should continue. This
utilization should be especially encouraged in the
This paper presents general guidelines and proposes north-central area, where maximum upward migration
priority areas for the effective implementation of four of brackish groundwater is occurring. Furthermore,
groundwater management options available for the artificial recharge of the Dammam aquifer using parts
water authorities in Bahrain by utilizing the hydro- of the unused secondary-treated wastewater should be
chemical characteristics of the Dammam aquifer. These carried out in the eastern coastal area, in order to form
are: (1) reduction of abstraction of groundwater for a hydraulic barrier against seawater intrusion.
agricultural use through its gradual replacement by Considerably more attention should be focused on
tertiary-treated wastewater; (2) reduction of abstrac- the vulnerability and contamination of the Dammam
tion of groundwater for domestic use through its aquifer by return irrigation water and other hazardous
replacement by desalinated water; (3) lowering the substances originating from the surface, in order to
potentiometric levels of the underlying brackish-water prevent further degradation of groundwater quality.
zones through abstraction by the industrial sector; and The concept of protective confining conditions of the
(4) artificial recharge of the Dammam aquifer by aquifer should be examined by undertaking more
unused secondary-treated wastewater. rigorous monitoring and investigation of potential
The hydrochemical investigation indicates that the surface contamination sources for the aquifer at west
Dammam aquifer water quality is significantly modified Bahrain, especially since most of the domestic water

Hydrogeology Journal (1999) 7 : 197–208 Q Springer-Verlag


208

needs in that area are met presently by withdrawal Hassan MH, Cagatay MN (1994) Hydrogeochemistry of Khobar
from the Dammam aquifer. aquifer in Eastern Saudi Arabia. In: Proc Second Gulf Water
Conference: water in the Gulf region – towards an integrated
Simulation modeling should be performed to eval- management, pp 163–178
uate the effectiveness of the proposed management Hurry P (1940) Water resources of Bahrain Island, 1940. Bahrain
options in controlling the degradation of the quality of Petroleum Company, 7 pp
groundwater in the Dammam aquifer, and if possible, Italconsult (1971) Water and agricultural studies in Bahrain.
Bahrain Ministry of Works and Agriculture, 155 pp
in improving its water quality.
Nativ R, Nissim I (1992) Characterization of a desert aquitard
–hydrologic and hydrochemical considerations. Ground Water
30 : 598–606
References Raveendran E, Madany IM (1991a) The quality of groundwater
in Bahrain. Sci Total Environment 103 : 177–183
ACE (Associated Consultant Engineers) (1984) Treated effluent, Raveendran E, Madany IM (1991b) Characteristics of agricultural
sludge, and compost utilization, phase I. Bahrain Ministry of drainage water in Bahrain. Sci Total Environ 104 : 239–247
Works and Agriculture, 268 pp Sen Z, Al-Dakheel A (1986) Hydrochemical facies evaluation in
ACE (1990a) Irrigation master plan. Bahrain Central Munici- Umm Er Radhuma Limestone, Eastern Saudi Arabia. Ground
pality Council, 183 pp Water 21 : 626–636
ACE (1990b) Report on treated effluent utilization, phase II Steineke M (1942) Water resources of Bahrain Island. Bahrain
supplementary report, the economic study. Bahrain Ministry Petroleum Company, 13 pp
of Works and Agriculture, 26 pp Stumm W, Morgan JJ (1970) Aquatic chemistry. John Wiley &
ACE (1997) Production and utilization of treated sewage effluent Sons, New York
– phase II, executive summary. Bahrain Ministry of Works Wright EPW (1967) Report on groundwater resources of Bahrain
and Agriculture, 14 pp Island, Arabian Gulf. Bahrain Ministry of Works and Agricul-
Al-Azawi A (1989) Preliminary study on feeding underground ture, 44 pp
water reservoirs in Bahrain with treated sewage water. Wright EPW (1977) Report on a visit to Bahrain. Bahrain
Bahrain Ministry of Works and Agriculture (Institut Frese- Ministry of Commerce and Agriculture, 24 pp
nius, Chemical and Biological Laboratories Ltd., Taunusstein- Zaporozec A (1972) Graphical interpretation of water-quality
Neuhof, Germany, UNESCO consultancy mission), 30 pp data. Ground Water 10 : 32–43
Al-Noaimi MA (1993) Evaluation of available water resources, Zubari WK (1987) A numerical 3-dimensional flow model for the
present utilization, and consuming sectors’ future needs, Dammam aquifer system, Bahrain and eastern Saudi Arabia.
volume I: evaluation of available water resources and utiliza- MSc Thesis, Ohio University
tion patterns. Bahrain Center for Studies and Research, 292 p Zubari WK (1997) Towards the establishment of total water cycle
(in Arabic) management and reuse program in the GCC countries. In:
Al-Ruwaih FM (1995a) Assessment and management of a desert Proc 3rd Gulf Water Conference, Towards efficient utilization
basin in Kuwait. Water Int 20 : 213–224 of water resources in the Gulf, pp 1–15
Al-Ruwaih FM (1995b) Chemistry of groundwater in the Zubari WK, Khater AR (1995) Brackish groundwater resources
Dammam aquifer, Kuwait. Hydrogeol J 3 : 42–55 in Bahrain: current exploitation, numerical evaluation and
Amiri Decree No. 12/1980 (1980) Concerning the use of ground- prospect for utilization. Water Resour Manage 9 : 1–21
water: Government of Bahrain. Official Gazette 1382 : 3–6 (in Zubari WK, Mubarak AM, Madany IM (1993) Development
Arabic) impacts on groundwater resources in Bahrain. Water Resour
GDC (Groundwater Development Consultants) (1980) Umm Er Dev 9 : 263–279
Radhuma study, Bahrain assignment, vol. III: groundwater Zubari WK, Madany IM, Al-Junaid SS, Al-Manaai S (1994)
resources. Saudi Arabia Ministry of Agriculture and Water, Trends in the quality of groundwater in Bahrain with respect
288 pp to salinity, 1941–1992. Environment Int 20 : 739–746
GDC (1983) Project 25/81, Reverse osmosis desalination, aquifer Zubari WK, Madany IM, Al-Junaid SS, Al-Noaimi MA (1996a)
C investigations. Bahrain Ministry of Power and Water, 79 The applicability of the WHO drinking water guidelines to an
pp arid region. Int J Environ Health Res 6 : 263–276
GDC (1986) Assignment to model treated sewage effluent Zubari WK, Al-Junaid SS, El-Din, MN (1996b) Impacts of deteri-
recharge to the Khobar aquifer, groundwater model studies. orating groundwater quality on desertification of soils in
Bahrain Ministry of Works and Agriculture, 16 pp Bahrain (1956–1992), a case study. In: Proc Int Conf on
Gulmon GW (1941) Water resources of Bahrain Island. Bahrain Desert Development in the Arab Gulf Countries
Petroleum Company, 24 pp Zubari WK, Khater AR, Al-Noaimi MA, Al-Junaid, SS (1997)
Hamilton NJ (1965) Water resources of Bahrain. Bahrain Petro- Spatial and temporal trends in groundwater salinity in
leum Company, 13 pp Bahrain. Arabian J Sci Eng 22 : 81–94

Hydrogeology Journal (1999) 7 : 197–208 Q Springer-Verlag

S-ar putea să vă placă și