Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
net/publication/304217914
CITATIONS READS
0 5,318
1 author:
Joel Tan
University of Mindanao
13 PUBLICATIONS 3 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Discovering Shadow Economy: Scavengers in Carmen, Tugbok District, Davao City, Philippines in Focus View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Joel Tan on 22 June 2016.
University of Mindanao
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION
dynamic and demanding today than ever before. The profession is characterized by
beyond.
specialized knowledge, skills, attitude and ethical and moral values after the initial
registration and admission in the profession (PRC, 2008; IES 7, 2006). It is expected
to raise and enhance the professional’s technical skills and competence required and
expected by the stakeholders and the profession (IES 7, 2011; Metz and Tharenou,
activities.
This study is anchored on the idea that CPD is essential to all CPAs in order to
enrich and refine the professional knowledge, skills and ethics earned by the time of
individual who holds a valid certificate issued by the Board of Accountancy (BOA) to
No. 9298, otherwise known as the Philippine Accountancy Act of 2004 provides the
rules and regulations in the implementation of CPD for CPAs in the practice of
accounting.
that participation to CPD courses offered by CPD Council and PRC accredited CPD
standing and globally competitive. The mandate was made following the
liberalization in the trade of services under the fourth Protocol of the General
active member.
Along this thought and direction that many organizations and practitioners
invest money, time and resources to sending their CPA employees to different CPD
activities for their professional productivity, growth and networking (Garavan et al.,
professionals include interest in lifelong learning (Metz and Tharenou, 2001), sense of
CPAs are also expecting that CPD will help them become more valuable and viable
to existing and potential clients or employer, gain advantage in the highly competitive
labor market and have a better career mobility and greater earning potential (Reiling,
iv
2011; Garavan et al., 2004). Simply put it, lifelong education is the heart of
professional development.
does not provide absolute assurance that all members will provide high quality
professional service all the time nor will every person who participates in CPD
programs and activities obtain its full benefits because of variances in personal and
professional efficacy and motivation along with the individual’s commitment and
capacity to learn (IES 7, 2006). Taylor and Francis (2012) also argued that current
complexities and contingent nature of actual practice. Nonetheless, despite its inherent
limits and constraints, CPD requirement, with its objectives and mechanisms, is but
organizations that have direct and potential role, influence and interest on the policy
creation and program implementation of CPD with the end goal of protecting the
prestige and dignity of the profession and the professionals. Researchers can also
METHOD
state of phenomenon and to articulate what variables, conditions and attributes are
present (Orig, 2010). The research instrument used was a self-construct, 3-point
Likert-type survey questionnaire validated by panel of experts. The form and content
v
attainment of purpose of the study. Answers to survey were confirmed and enriched
There were 100 respondents (MacCallum, Widaman, Zhang and Hong, 1999)
objectively distributed as to age, sex, sector connected and years working. The
sampling method used was stratified, purposive random. No incentives were given to
informed CPA-respondents. The study covered periods from 2010-2013. The study
employed statistical tools to include frequency, mean, the Annova and logistical
regression. The frequency and mean analysed the profile of CPAs and level of
The alpha was set at .05 level of significance. The logistical regression examined
Lee & Ingersoll, 2002). It is assumed that the probability of CPD to influence career
advancement increases as the CPD credit units earned increases. The paper used
and quality of this study. The data were carefully tabulated and prudently interpreted
Majority of the respondents aged below 30 years and were relatively fledgling
Accounting professionals. The study was dominated by female. The male class
corresponds to only 38 percent. The four sectors where CPAs may get connected with
were fairly represented in this paper. The government, however, showed the least
distribution at 22 percent. Most of those surveyed have work experiences ranges from
one to five years while few others have been in professional service beyond 20 years.
As with CPD credit units, many respondents have earned a minimum score
oscillating from 3 to 12 points which is far below the required units set by the PRC-
CPD Council. The total CPD credit units for registered Accounting professional shall
be 60 credit units for three years, provided that a minimum of 15 credit units be
Table 1.1
Profile of Respondents
Descriptive variable f %
Age
below 30 50 50
30 to 40 25 25
41 to 50 5 5
above 51 20 20
Total 100 100
Sex
Female 62 62
Male 38 38
Total 100 100
Sector connected
Government 22 22
Academe 26 26
Commerce 26 26
Public 26 26
Total 100 100
Years working
vii
1-5 45 45
6-14 28 28
15-20 8 8
above 20 19 19
Total 100 100
CPD units earned
3-12 49 49
15-24 14 14
27-48 14 14
above 48 23 23
Total 100 100
The study discovered that those novice accountants and those who are yet
establishing their professional careers are more aggressive and committed to CPD as
they yearn for authority, status and self-worth. This is expected as CPD is designed to
enhance professional characteristics and capacities essential for quality service and so
increase professional value (AICPA, 1992; De Lange et al., 2008; Wessels, 2007).
Overwhelmingly, female CPAs were seen actively engaged in various CPD activities
initiatives than men. Accounting is more of paper analytics and less of physical
activities which most men find boring and unchallenging. The presence of CPAs in
four sectors indicated the profession’s marketability and importance across all fields.
This further implies that opportunities abound for present and would-be Accounting
practitioners. Salosagcol et al. (2011) accentuated that every CPA, in the exercise of
profession, is duty bound to remain competent and maintain public confidence. This
The result noted that after acquiring meaningful experiences and relevant
skills, respondents preferred to work abroad owing to high work demands and
lucrative remuneration packages and benefits. This explained why the years of
viii
(Salosagcol et al., 2011). A CPD credit is the unit of measuring the extent of CPD
participation. CIPFA (2010) identified two levels of participation, the level one or the
minimum requirement like attending seminars and trainings; and the level two or the
best practice requirement as doing discipline research. CPAs must earn at least 60
units within 3 years so he or she can renew the professional license. However, results
showed that most of the CPAs surveyed earned very low credit units from period
2010 to 2013 and that the participation was overwhelmingly on level one or
minimum. This disconcerting condition can be explained by the fact that many CPAs
still do not understand the objectives of CPD and find no relevance of it to current
work and professional growth. Alejandro (2001) held that intrinsic and extrinsic
expected financial benefit and status while intrinsic motivators include the desire to
transform people and society and win professional identification. Many employers
also thought that engaging their CPAs to CPD is very costly and oftentimes not
spending has increased by eight percent during the recent past years. Few others
believed that CPD is just a waste of time, money, and energy especially when
activities are inapplicable and irrelevant to present and future job (De Lange et al.,
2008). This is a challenge to both PRC-CPD Council and CPD providers to continue
improving the design, programming and delivery of CPD activities to tailor fit it with
what the client needs and wants. New strategies must be explored to inspire and guide
professionals on what CPD activities to participate in. Institutional factors like the
location, time and cost as potential barriers to participation must also be addressed.
ix
Table 1.2 provides the ranking of the CPD activities participated in by the
CPD Council accredited programs, activities and sources vary. Among the hit CPD
studies like masteral and doctoral degrees; organizing self-learning packages and
trainings. None has engaged to writing books, doing research and professional re-
Table 1.2
Ranking of CPD Activities Participated in by Respondents
The results thus, dare the PRC-CPD Council and the CPD regulators and
diverse CPD activities based on the nature of the activity and level of CPAs
of CPAs in terms of career mobility and employment viability. With a mean average
of 1.80, CPD warranted substantial contribution by allowing CPAs to qualify and get
x
and knowledge acquired from various CPD activities, CPAs increase that service
worth, beefs up that credentials and improves that qualification. Thus, make him or
her best fit for greater assignments and authority. It opened many doors to job
opportunities and growth. In the study of Sangsawang (2011), he found out that CPD
had positive effect and influence to Thai accountants' work success. Tames (2012)
however noted that CPD did not have direct impact on the practice of profession but
On matters of career growth and satisfaction, North (2008) pointed out that it
al., (2011) cited that voluntary compliance with CPD is a credible means to ensure
Table 2.1
CPD and Career Development Contribution
Table 2.2 shows that CPD improved the financial condition of CPAs. It
brought in more clients to the practitioners and allowed them to venture into potential
and alternative income sources following that enriched credibility and competence.
xi
The mean average score of 1.81 indicated that CPD has significant impact to
increasing the earning capacities and ensuring fiscal sustainability of CPAs. Through
CPD, professionals increase their eligibility and professional value which normally
translated to higher pay and business opportunities (Reiling, 2011). Most often, salary
increases and demands are driven by and based on qualifications and competencies
driver of income and wealth differences. The human capital model, in contrast to
and developmental courses will have higher chances to get promoted and increased
Table 2.2
CPD and Financial Income Contribution
professional associates that provided each other mutual benefits to include valuable
information and insights for performing better in their current position and in
furthering their careers (Sunseri and Kosteva, 1992; Sweitzer, 2007). Though the
overall level of contribution was deemed negligible at an average mean of 1.66, it was
xii
found that engagements to various CPD endeavours build client referrals and
that widen even more professional contacts and market. Sweitzer (2007) and Hopkins
organizations and establishing mentoring relations and networks can spell a big
difference to survive in a highly competitive labor market. Social network has been
noted, though plausible by default, as career development bias (Metz and Tharenou,
2001).
to industry leads and potential business partnerships (Taylor, 2003) and opportunities
for mentoring and coaching relationship. Sweitzer (2007) posited that mentoring
provided career and psychosocial support. Likewise, Garavan et al. (2004) declared
flexibility and visibility in the workplace. He added that Asians make greater use of
contacts within the industry for recruitment and promotion opportunities whereas
Europeans are most likely to utilize external networking for labor market access and
gains. Taylor (2003) commented that professional membership and networks provided
not only sense of value and identity to being (Dobrow and Higgins, 2005) but also
enhance professional life. However, it must be understood that while CPD provided
the platform, the interpersonal attitude and communication skills of the professional
played the greatest role in the process. This attributes will help accountants take full
advantage of the CPD and be able to expand his or her sphere of influence and
Table 2.3
CPD and Contribution to Development of Professional Networks
development program that improves self-awareness and identity, develops talents and
potentials and enriches quality of life and contributes to realization of dreams and
aspirations (Sweitzer, 2007; Metz and Tharenou, 2001). It was observed that personal
The statistical mean average was 1.33 interpreted as negligible. The result
showed that CPD bears no significant impact to personal competencies that could lead
CPAs to acquire new skills and update knowledge in Accounting standards and
practices, it could only make sense and work best in the context of daily work
2000). Further, the significance and appreciation of CPD is affected by many factors
including disposition to learn and interest to the type, design and delivery of CPD
activities (Lam, 2010; IES 7, 2006). In many instances, CPD failed to achieve its
xiv
objectives and rather becomes futile because the motivation behind participation is
plain compliance to regulatory and policy requirement than skills development and
lifelong learning (De Lange et al., 2008; Wessels, 2007). Furthermore, the conduct of
CPD programs and sources do not meet the expectations of the participants and are
incongruent with what the professional needs and wants. Needless to say, the
Table 2.4
CPD and Contribution to Personal Competencies
personal competencies. While it revealed that the collective mean score was 1.65
Accordingly, the result qualified the notion that CPD participation guarantees outright
professional growth and satisfaction (Reiling, 2011). Again, it proposed that the
xv
efficacy and relevance of CPD to every CPA is relative and is affected by many
Table 2.5
Summary of Contribution of CPD
Table 3.1 captures the test of differences of CPD contribution when analyzed
by profile using the Annova. Results clarified that no statistical effectiveness was
noted on the differences of the impact of CPD when analyzed according to the age of
the professional. The recorded F-value of .88 is interpreted as insignificant at .05 level
could result to significant difference within the group. This implied that length of
service and experience does not make substantial impact to the degree of contribution
credit units earned also held no significance with an F-value of .93 insignificant still
at .05 level of significance. Meaning, credit points earned from various CPD
impact to career advancement. The profits of CPD are not instinctive but are gained in
full when it finds relevance and application to current and prospective work
statistical significance on the level of CPD contribution. This can be explained by the
xvi
fact that many CPAs across sectors see CPD participation as mere compliance and
meaningless exercise. Thus, make the impact inconsequential (De Lange et al., 2008).
However, others find CPD indispensable like those in the academe and public practice
where the need to keep abreast of the latest standards and practices is required by the
Table 3.1
Analysis of Variance of Contribution of CPD by Profile of Respondents
Sum of Mean
Variables Comparison Df F Sig.
Squares Square
Age of the between groups 41.03 33 1.24
professional within groups 93.72 66 1.42 0.88 0.66
Total 134.75 99
Sector connected between groups 42.02 33 1.27
with within groups 78.62 66 1.19 1.07 0.40
Total 120.64 99
Number of years between groups 33.85 33 1.03
working within groups 95.14 66 1.44 0.71 0.86
Total 128.99 99
CPD units earned between groups 48.80 33 1.48
within groups 104.99 66 1.59 0.93 0.58
Total 153.79 99
Critical alpha at .05 level of significance
was found out that there was no significant difference of the contribution of CPD
between the male and female group. The statistical variance showed that sex has no
impact over the level of CPD contribution. This result repudiated the idea that sex
influences person’s lifestyle, attitude and rationalities (Allana, Asal and Sherali,
2010). While it is true that majority of the respondents were female; men were found
to have same level of disposition and interest on learning new things and acquiring
new skills through various CPD activities. The recorded t and p values were .97 and
integrate the interests of both sexes in the design and delivery of CPD activities.
Table 3.2
Test of Difference of Contribution of CPD by Sex
Table 4 displays the result of the logistical regression employed on the data of
the study. The objective of the regression analysis was to estimate the predictive value
of factors that may influence career improvement of CPAs due to CPD. The logistical
regression using MLE revealed that CPD units earned as predictor variable influence
career advancement of CPAs with .43 beta weight. This inferred that frequent
engagement and increased best practice participation to various CPD programs and
sources will help Accounting professional advance, strengthen and sustain his or her
Table 4
Estimating Factors that Influence Improvement due to CPD
Thus, the result established a link between CPD and career advancement of
0.43units_earnedCPD. The model provided four to seven percent fitness to the data;
the residual rate is accounted to stochastic error. The prediction model means that for
xviii
every unit increase in the level of career advancement of CPA, .43 percent is
advancement by not participating to any CPD programs and activities, CPAs must not
be indifferent to and disregard CPD; instead get involved with it more frequently and
aggressively. Only then, the professional can maximize its benefits and gains and so
preclude the risk of career improvement to shrink and diminish over time. The model
factors other than the predictor variable which are not covered in this study.
CONCLUSION
CPAs can be predicted by the credit units earned. As CPD programs, activities and
with CPD to bring about significant benefits and improvement on career mobility and
financial income and to some extent to the development of professional networks and
The link that was established between CPD participation and career
activities both the content and delivery for a more meaningful, enriching and
responsive CPD experience. It must bear significance to the current and dreamed
xix
endeavours of the Accounting professionals. They should also consider and match
programs and approaches on what interests and motivates the professionals so they
can draw in more participants and increase the level of appreciation towards CPD.
The PRC has already provided standardization guidelines and procedures for effective
On the same note, employers and firms should encourage their CPAs to
engage with and be active participants of CPD particularly the young professionals.
Through it, accountants can be well equipped with relevant knowledge, values, ethics
CPD can also be a good measure to check the commitment and zest of CPA to stay
proficient and competitive in the chosen career. Despite inherent limitations, CPD
remains true to its cause of upholding and strengthening the trust and confidence of
REFERENCES
Allana, A., Asad, N. & Sherali, Y. (2010). Gender in academic settings: Role of
teachers. International Journal of Innovation Management and Technology 1(4),
2010-0248.
De Lange, P., Jackling, B. & Suwardy, T. (2008). Access to CPD opportunities and
resources to assist professional accountants to meet their commitment to lifelong
learning: Evidence from the Asia Pacific region. Retrieved February 12, 2013 from
http://www.iaaer.org/research_grants/files/de_Lange_Final_Report.pdf
Eaton, K., Brookes, J., Patel, R., Batchelor, P., Merali, F. & Narain, A. (2011). The
impact of continuing professional development in dentistry: A literature review. The
Faculty of General Dental Practice (UK).
Hopkins, M., O’Neil, D., & Bilimoria, D. (2006). Effective leadership and successful
career advancement: Perspective from woman in health care. Equal Opportunities
International, Vol. 25 Iss:4, pp. 251-271.
MacCallum, Widaman, Zhang and Hong (1999). Rule of 100. Retrieved May 29,
2012 from http://www.rule_of_100_sampling
North, M. A. (2008). The three circles of career advancement: Choices and sacrifices
go hand in hand. Gale Cengage Learning. Retrieved June 30, 2012 from
http://www.threecirclesofcareeradvancement/gale_cengagelearning
Orig, M. (2010). The college mathematical readiness of the senior high school
students of district I in Davao City. Research and Publication Center. University of
Mindanao. Philippines
Peng, C.Y.J, Lee, K.L, & Ingersoll, G.M (2002). An introduction to logistic
regression analysis and reporting. The Journal of Educational Research, 96(1), 3-
14.
Salosagcol, J., Tiu, M. & Hermosilla, R. (2011). Auditing theory: Republic Act No.
9298: The Philippine accountancy Act of 2004. Philippines: Conanan Educational
Supply.