Sunteți pe pagina 1din 5

Proceedings of ICEE 2009 3rd International Conference on Energy and Environment,

7-8 December 2009, Malacca, Malaysia

An experimental investigation of unmodified DI


diesel engine with hydrogen addition

R. Adnan H.H.Masjuki, T.M.I. Mahlia


Department of Mechanical Engineering Department of Mechanical Engineering
Universiti Tenaga Nasional University of Malaya
43009 Kajang, Selangor, Malaysia 50603 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
E-mail address: adnanr@uniten.edu.my

Abstract— The consumption of fossil fuels spawns environmental cylinder injection. Such operation, with optimum conversion
considerations in addition to issues of energy demand, national methods, has the potential to provide operational characteristics
security and resource availability. At global level, scientists warn that are comparable of superior to those of the conventional
that the combustion of fossil fuels is significantly changing the diesel engine. This may be achieved while displaying enhanced
world's climate system. Local or regional concerns include smog, emission characteristics, quieter and smoother operation,
acid rain, and health implications of urban air pollution. Due to improved low ambient temperature operation, and reduced
stringent emission norms and depletion of petroleum resources thermal loading. This superior performance may be achieved
there has been a continuous effort to use alternative fuels such as only if sufficiently effective measures can be ensured both for
hydrogen. It has its own benefits and limitations if it is used in
the avoidance of knock, usually at high loads and incomplete
conjunction with conventional fuel in diesel engine. The purpose
gaseous fuel utilization at relatively light loads. Usually, one of
of this article was to investigate the effect of hydrogen addition
on performance and exhaust gas emission of stationary diesel the main aims is to maximize the replacement of the diesel fuel
engine. In this study, hydrogen was used as secondary fuel in a by the gaseous fuel while maintaining acceptable levels of
single cylinder 406 c.c. diesel engine. The hydrogen was injected emissions and engine performance [3].
through intake manifold and diesel was injected directly inside Many researchers have used hydrogen as a fuel in spark
the combustion chamber. Series of experiments were conducted ignition (SI) engine. Caton describes a significant reduction in
and it can be seen the effect of hydrogen addition in the increase
power output was observed while using hydrogen in SI engine
of peak pressure from 5 bar to a maximum 21 bar, IMEP from
and in addition pre-ignition, backfire, and knocking problems
1.0 to 1.7 bar , indicated power from 4%-16%. There were also
increases in NOx and CO emissions from 48-197 ppm and 423-758
were observed at high load. These problems have resulted in
ppm, respectively. Hydrogen addition causes increase in exhaust using hydrogen in SI engine within a limited operation range
gas temperature from 3.1% to 10.2% particularly at 2500 rpm [4]. In the latest series of papers by Saravanan et al. [5,6],
and reduction in O2 emissions from 3.9% to 7.6% (by volume) experimental investigation of H2DE was conducted using timed
throughout all engine speeds. port hydrogen injection and exhaust gas recirculation. They
concluded that hydrogen increases brake power, thermal
Keywords- Exhaust Gas Emissions, Performance Analysis, efficiency, exhaust gas temperature and NOx emissions. Study
Gaseous Hydrogen, Diesel Engine, Alternative Fuel. on H2DE with intake manifold fuel injection system is rare but
it gives a reliable result since both hydrogen and air are
I. INTRODUCTION premixed in the intake manifold. This motivated the study of
the use of hydrogen in diesel engine peculiar on its
performance and emission analyses. The objective of this
Hydrogen, as an energy medium, has some distinct benefits article is to present the experimental results of H2DE. In the
for its high efficiency and convenience in storage, present investigation, intake manifold fuel injection technique
transportation and conversion. Hydrogen has found vast of hydrogen gas was used with hydrogen flow rate of 30±5
applications in fields such as electricity generation, vehicle mg/s injected continuously to intake airstreams before it is
engines and aerospace. Hydrogen engine has both the induced into the combustion chamber.
advantages of the high thermal efficiency of diesel engine and
an excellent operation performance of a petrol engine [1]. The
working process of hydrogen-fueled diesel engine (H2DE) is II. EXPERIMENTAL METHOD
basically the same as other conventional diesel engine. The
most important advantage of hydrogen engine is that it emits The main engine specifications are summarized in Table 1.
fewer pollutants than other engine [2]. Generally, in the gas The engine was installed with hydrogen injector at the intake
fueled dual fuel diesel engine most of energy release comes manifold (near to intake port). In addition to the operation of
from the combustion of the gaseous fuel while a small amount the test engine, an efficient safety measure for operating the
of diesel liquid fuel provides pilot ignition through timed engine need to be developed. A flash back arrestor is a safety

978-1-4244-5145-6/09/$26.00 ©2009 IEEE 45


device that shuts off gas flow in event of flash back. Flashback fuel without pre-ignition, since high auto-ignition temperature
is the combustion of a flame mixture that can occur within gas of hydrogen (858K) ignites after pilot ignition of diesel [7].
management system and travel back through the line of the The peak pressure's appearance has the tendency to shift to the
gas management system to the gas source. Hydrogen flash right as hydrogen is added into the cylinder charge. This is due
back arrestor is a safety device that shuts off hydrogen flow to high flame speed of hydrogen (3.24-4.40 ms-1) causes fast
and extinguishes the flame before it reach hydrogen storage combustion propagation of the in-cylinder charge which was
tank. Installation of a single-flow valve and water-flame trap only initiated from pilot ignition [8]. It can be observed that
in the hydrogen fuel management system prevents the backfire combustion of H2DE occurs with higher peak pressure
from entering hydrogen tank that causes massive explosion. because of higher heating value (142 MJ/kg) and diffusivity
(0.61cm2/s) of hydrogen [9]. The high diffusivity facilitates
The engine used for the investigation is a 4-stroke, air-
the formation of a uniform mixture of hydrogen with other
cooled, single cylinder, direct-injection vertical diesel engine.
cylinder charge since this contributes greatly to ensure an
Hydrogen is filled into hydrogen storage tank from hydrogen
equal supply of hydrogen to all regions in the cylinder [10].
cell until it reaches 2 bars. Hydrogen is then passes through
single-flow valve before it enter water-flame trap. Then it Additionally, wide range flammability and minimum
passes through flash back arrestor and hydrogen mass flow ignition energy (0.02MJ) of hydrogen promotes complete
meter. Experimental works were conducted at the speeds of combustion of hydrogen throughout the cylinder even within
1000, 1500, 2000, 2500 and 3000 rpm. Data Acquisition the lean mixture regions. With very lean cylinder charge the
System (DAS) interprets the conditioned input signals bulk of the energy release comes from the ignition and
pressure transducer and crank angle encoder. DAS sends data subsequent rapid combustion of the small pilot zone. It comes
to the computer for real-time visualization of P-θ diagram. also from the combustion of part of the charge entrained into
the burning pilot fuel and from the immediate surroundings of
such a zone where higher temperature and relatively richer
Table 1: Test Engine Specifications mixture regions are present [11]. The moment all the mixture
ignites at once, the heat release is much stronger resulting in a
4-stroke, Air-cooled, steep pressure gradient at 20°CA. The strong heat release also
Single Cylinder Compression induces enhanced turbulent mixing due to thermal expansion
Engine Type
Ignition, which contributes toward rapid increase in pressure [12].
Di I j i
Make and Model YANMAR L100-AE 65

60
Diesel Alone-Experiment
Bore x Stroke, mm 86 x 70 55
Diesel + H2-Experiment
50
3
Displacement, cm 406 45

40
Compression ratio 19.3:1
P re s su re (b ar)

35

Combustion System Direct Injection 30

25
Diesel Injection Timing 13°BTDC 20

15
Max. power output, kW 7.4 @ 3600rpm
10

0
III. RESULT AND DISCUSSIONS -180 -170 -160 -150 -140 -130 -120 -110 -100 -90 -80 -70 -60 -50 -40 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180

Crank Angle(degree)

In this study, the performance and emission analyses of Figure 1: In-cylinder Pressure Variations with Crank Angle At 1500RPM
H2DE was carried out experimentally. The rapid compression
of an initially uniform and homogeneous charge of a hydrogen
enriched air soon develops change in the instantaneous values Fig. 2 shows the comparison between in-cylinder
of various properties such as pressure and temperature. These peak pressure of diesel alone and diesel mixed with
changes continue with time as piston moves upwards to TDC. hydrogen. Experimental results showed increase in peak
Fig.1 shows an example of measured in-cylinder pressure pressure from 5 bar to a maximum 21 bar and. At the
curves at 1500 rpm. It can be seen that all curves moves speed of 2500 rpm, the peak pressure was the highest and
upwards with the same pattern before 10° before top dead this can be related to stronger heat release and more
center (BTDC) which indicates normal combustion of pilot

46
complete combustion as the effects from optimum more energy per unit oxygen consumed in the combustion
equivalent ratio of the charge. process. It means with ultra-lean hydrogen/air mixture of
combustion contains more energy as compared to lean
diesel/air mixture, hence the effect of increasing pressure on
90 combustion is stronger in the hydrogen/air flame [13]. In
85
additional, higher flame speed and rate of pressure rise during
combustion of hydrogen leads to rapid increase in in-cylinder
80
charge pressure, consequently contributes towards higher
75 IMEP.
70

7
P re s s u re (ba r)

65

60
6
55

50 5

I n d i c a te d P o w e r(k W )
45
Diesel Alone-Experiment 4
40
Diesel + H2-Experiment
35 3
30
1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 2
Speed (RPM)

Figure 2: In-Cylinder Peak Pressure At All Speed 1 Diesel Alone-Experiment


Diesel + H2-Experiment

6.5 0
1000 1500 2000 2500 3000
6.0 Speed(RPM)
Figure 4: Effects of Engine Speed on Indicated Power
5.5

5.0
The variation of indicated power with engine speed is
4.5 shown in Fig. 4. It shows that indicated power of H2DE
IM EP(b ar)

increases as engine speed increased in the range of 4%-16%.


4.0
The trend is explained as consequence of faster combustion
3.5
propagation and higher heating value of hydrogen that
produces higher energy release during its combustion leads to
3.0 improved engine performance. Basically, the addition of
Diesel Alone-Experiment hydrogen gaseous fuel with engine air gives a significant
2.5
Diesel + H2-Experiment
effect on the cylinder charge during compression and power
2.0
stokes. The combustion zone enveloping a jet diffusion flame
1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 can extend significantly both radially and axially as the
Speed(RPM)
concentration of the gaseous hydrogen fuel in the surrounding
Figure 3: Effects of Engine Speed on Indicated Mean Effective Pressure air is increased until a concentration is reached that would
permit flame propagation to sweep through the entirety of the
jet surroundings. This phenomenon uses the typical properties
The variation of indicated mean effective pressure of hydrogen (such as wide flammability limit and high
(IMEP) with engine speed is shown in Fig.3. IMEP increases diffusivity) to a point of advantage. Moreover, the ignition of
as engine speed increased until 2500 RPM, further increase in the droplets of the direct-injected pilot fuel will be affected
speed drops the IMEP which indicates almost the same pattern similarly by the presence of the hydrogen gaseous fuel and its
as maximum in-cylinder peak pressure. It can be seen the concentration. The reaction time of flame propagation and
effect of hydrogen injection in the increase of IMEP in the associated energy release increases as more concentration of
range of 1.0 to 1.7 bar with respect to engine speeds. Higher gaseous hydrogen fuel in the pilot droplet's surroundings [14].
heating value of hydrogen increases the energy release in its
combustion which has a positive contribution to the increase The variations of experimental NOx emissions and
in-cylinder pressure and leads to the increase of mean exhaust gas temperature with engine speed are shown in Fig.5.
effective pressure in the cylinder. Although hydrogen contains It shows that NOx concentration and temperature increases as
less energy per unit volume than those of diesel, it produces

47
speed increased until 2500 rpm, further increase in speed
drops the temperature and consequently NOx emissions. It can Fig. 6 shows the variations of emissions of O2 and CO
be seen that the effect of combustion temperature on the with engine speed. It can be observed that hydrogen fuel in
increase of NOx emissions (from 48 to 197 ppm) with intake unmodified diesel engine causes increase in CO (from 423 to
manifold injection hydrogen system. 758 ppm) and reduction of O2 emissions (3.9% to 7.6% by
volume) as comparable with that of diesel alone operation.
This might be due to the fact that higher compression pressure
500 100
of H2DE during compression stroke pushes cylinder charge
450 90 (containing hydrogen) into the crevices which will return to
the cylinder later in the expansion stroke. The moment exhaust
400 80
port is opened, blowdown of exhaust gases provides less time
350 70 for the newly released fuel (from crevice) to oxide and causes
fuel rich region and overmixing. Additional formation of local
300 60
rich regions in the cylinder at the end of expansion stroke
NOx(ppm)

Texh(°C)
250 50 causes increase of CO emissions due to hydrocarbon
oxidation. Another effect of high in-cylinder pressure is
200 40
NOx-Diesel Alone
dribbling of liquid diesel fuel on the tip of injector nozzle.
150
NOx-Diesel + H2
30 This small amount of liquid diesel evaporates very slowly
100 20
because it is surrounded by a fuel-rich region, and once the
T exhaust-Diesel Alone
injector nozzle closes, there is no pressure pushing it to the
T exhaust- Diesel + H2
50 10 adjacent combustion region which leads to enlargement of
0 0
fuel-rich region nearby the injector [16].
1000 1500 2000 2500 3000
Speed (RPM)

Figure 5: Variation of NOx emissions and exhaust gas temperature with IV. CONCLUSIONS
engine speed

A single cylinder unmodified compression ignition


Hydrogen increases the energy release, which has a engine was researched to study its performance. In the
positive contribution to enhance charge temperature to form experimental works, the engine was installed with hydrogen
NOx (thermal NOx) in both the flame front and the post flame injection system in order to supply constant amount of
of the charge. This can be associated with very high local hydrogen gas into the combustion chamber. From the above
combustion temperature was achieved in the pilot ignition analysis and discussion, the conclusions and recommendations
zone which lengthen the reaction time of nitrogen and oxygen were provided as following:
in the cylinder. Hydrogen addition causes increase in exhaust
gas temperature from 3.1% to 10.2% particularly at 2500 rpm • In-cylinder pressure curves moves upward with the same
due to faster combustion and high combustion temperature in pattern before 10°BTDC which indicates normal
the cylinder [15]. combustion of pilot fuel without pre-ignition.
• The peak pressure's appearance has the tendency to shift
23 to the right as hydrogen is added into the cylinder charge
21
2600 and increases the peak pressure from 5 to 21 bar while the
highest peak pressure occurs at 2500 rpm.
19
2400
• Hydrogen increases the energy release, which has a
positive contribution to increase the IMEP in the range of
17 2200
1.0 to 1.7 bar with respect to engine speeds.
• Indicated power of H2DE increases as engine speed
O2(%vol)

CO(ppm)

15
2000
increased in the range of 4%-16%.
13 • NOx and CO emissions increases from 48-197 ppm and
1800
423-758 ppm, respectively.
11
1600
• Hydrogen addition causes increase in exhaust gas
O2-Diesel Alone
9
O2-Diesel + H2
temperature from 3.1% to 10.2% and reduction in O2
CO-Diesel Alone 1400
emissions from 3.9% to 7.6% (by volume).
7
CO-Diesel + H2
5 1200
The above results suggest that intake manifold
1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 injection of hydrogen increases the performance of
Speed (RPM) unmodified diesel engine. The most significant penalty will
Figure 6: Variation of O2 and CO emissions with engine speed be a slight increase of NOx and CO emissions which requires

48
timed manifold hydrogen injection in order to modify the [6] N. Saravanan, G. Nagarajan, S. Narayanasamy, “An experimental
investigation on DI diesel engine with hydrogen fuel,” Journal of
combustion behavior. After all, there is room for continuous Renewable Energy, vol. 33, 2008, pp. 415- 421.
improvement to optimize the performance, efficiency and [7] F. Schafer , R.V. Basshuysen, Reduce emissions and fuel consumption
emissions through better understanding of combustion in automobile engines. New York: Springer-Verlag Wien, 1995.
processes in diesel running on gaseous hydrogen fuel. [8] L. Hailin, G.A. Karim, A. Sohrabi, “Knock and combustion
characteristics of CH4, CO, H2 and their binary mixtures,” SAE Paper
2003-01-3088, 2003.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT [9] J.B. Heywood, Internal combustion engine fundamentals. International
Editions, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1988.
[10] M.N. Joseph,W.H. James, D.D. Thomas., “Hydrogen fuel for surface
This study was financially supported by Ministry of transport,” Warrendale, U.S.A: Society of Automotive Engineers Inc.,
Science, Technology and Environment of Malaysia. The 1996.
author is grateful to University of Malaya and acknowledges [11] X. Liu, F. Liu, H.J Schock, “Backfire prediction in manifold injection
the technical assistance and advice from both co-authors. hydrogen internal combustion engine,” International Journal of
Hydrogen Energy, vol. 33, 2008, pp. 3847-3855.
[12] G.A. Karim, M.G. Kibriya, R. Lapucha, “Examination of the
combustion of a fuel jet in a homogeneously pre-mixed lean fuel-air
REFERENCES stream,” SAE Paper 1988-01-662, 1988.
[13] D.Z. Chen, Z.M. Weng, X.H. Li, “Theoretical performance evaluation of
hydrogen flames,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, vol.
[1] L.M. Das, “On-board Hydrogen Storage System for Automotive
13(11), 1988, pp. 701-709.
Application,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, vol. 21,
1996, pp. 793-800. [14] G.A. Karim, “Combustion in gas fueled compression ignition engines of
the dual fuel type,” Trans ASME Journal of Engineering Gas Turbines
[2] R. Jorach, “Development of a Low-NOx truck Hydrogen with High
and Power, vol. 125, 2003,pp. 827-836.
Specific Power Output,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, vol.
22, 1997, pp. 423-427. [15] M.S. Kumar, A. Ramesh and B. Nagalingam, “Use of hydrogen to
enhance the performance of a vegetable oil fuelled compression ignition
[3] G..A. Karim, “Combustion in Gas - Fueled Compression Ignition
engine,” Int J Hydrogen Energy, vol.28, 2003, pp.1143-1154.
Engines of the Dual Fuel Type ,” Journal of Engineering for Gas
Turbines and Power, vol. 125, 2003, pp. 827-836. [16] W.W. Pulkrabek, Engineering fundamentals of the internal combustion
engine. 2nd Edition, New Jersey: Pearson Prentice-Hall, 2004
[4] J.A. Caton, “An investigation of cause of backfire and its control due to
creviced volumes in hydrogen fueled engine,” Trans. ASME, vol. 23,
2001, pp. 204–210.
[5] N. Saravanan, G. Nagarajan, K.M. Kalaiselvan, “An experimental
investigation on hydrogen as dual fuel for diesel engine system with
exhaust gas recirculation technique,” Journal of. Renewable Energy,
vol. 33, 2008, pp. 422- 427.

49

S-ar putea să vă placă și