Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
net/publication/272682546
CITATIONS READS
0 1,075
3 authors:
J. D. H. Keatinge
World Vegetable Center
150 PUBLICATIONS 2,677 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Robert Holmer on 24 February 2015.
ABSTRACT
Global production of common and traditional vegetables is steadily increasing, and
traditional vegetables in particular are attracting the attention of farmers, researchers,
policy makers and the public. Nonetheless, many factors constrain vegetable
production, including climate change and extreme climatic events, increased
urbanization and pressure on arable land, ever-present pests and diseases, an aging
farming population, and adverse policies toward horticulture. Families must have
year-round access to affordable and nutritious food for a balanced, healthy diet, which
must include vegetables as a source of many micronutrients. Southeast Asia must
maximize crop productivity while minimizing losses, wastage and the overall impact
on the environment. Solutions to improve productivity, profitability, and human
nutrition include expansion and mechanization of protected agriculture, better
production and environmentally sensitive management technologies, investment in
research to support traditional vegetables, improving all elements along the vegetable
value chain, better engagement of the private sector (including postharvest value
addition, food preservation technologies, and more efficient marketing performance),
better information flow and management, and improved business skills, particularly
for small-scale growers, distributors and marketers. Future initiatives to increase
production must also emphasize consumer education to raise awareness about the
value of vegetables for a well-balanced, healthy diet for all family members.
Keywords
Healthy diets, production, post-harvest, wastage, future perspective
Sustaining Small-Scale Vegetable Production and Marketing Systems for Food and Nutrition Security 1
of 56 kg versus the recommended minimum intake of 146 kg of vegetables and fruits
per capita and year by the World Health Organization and Food and Agriculture
Organization of the United Nations (WHO & FAO 2005). Annual vegetable per
capita intakes, however, vary considerably among countries, from 154.7 kg in Lao
PDR to 33.7 kg in Cambodia and 24.5 kg in Timor-Leste, respectively (FAOSTAT
2014).
With the advent of the ASEAN Economic Community in 2015, the region
now must seek to maximize crop productivity and profitability to ensure sufficient
supply of health-promoting vegetables for its populace while minimizing losses,
wastage and the overall impact of horticultural activities that may impinge upon the
sustainability and resilience of the environment (Holmer 2011).
Many factors currently constrain vegetable production, including climate
change and extreme climatic events, increased urbanization and pressure on arable
land, pests and diseases, an aging farming population, and adverse policies toward
horticulture. Abiotic stresses may have an increasingly potent effect on vegetable
production as horticultural crops are often vulnerable to extreme events of wind and
rain, and global vegetables such as tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) and sweet pepper
(Capsicum spp.) are sensitive to heat damage, waterlogging, drought and increasing
salinity through their individual or combined effects on flowering and fruit set
(Keatinge et al. 2011b). Rising trends in abiotic stresses imposed on horticultural
crops may be inferred to be increasing rapidly in East Asia (Keatinge et al. 2012a),
which will have significant effects on crop production. Biotic stresses are also
expected to respond to these predicted changes in air temperature, precipitation
regime and within-canopy relative humidity, perhaps more rapidly than the general
public and policy makers would expect. For example, the incidence and severity of
bacterial and fungal pathogens responsible for major epidemic diseases in vegetables
such as late blight (Phytophthora infestans), bacterial and Fusarium wilts (Ralstonia
solanacearum and Fusarium oxysporum) are likely to change, probably becoming
more severe, as temperature and rainfall levels increase (Keatinge et al. 2012a).
The incidence and severity of diseases caused by plant viruses is likely to
increase as their vectors become more numerous and more mobile as a result of
increased temperatures. Changing temperatures may also expand the distribution of
viruses, and new viruses may become important in crops in warming areas. For
example, begomoviruses, which infect and cause severe damage to a wide range of
horticultural crops, are likely to become an even more serious constraint to vegetable
production as the number of generations per year of whiteflies (their principal vector,
Bemisia tabaci) increases with warmer temperatures (Hanson et al. 2011). Additional
generations of other highly damaging insect species such as the pod, fruit and shoot
borers (e.g. Leucinoides spp., Maruca spp., and Helicoverpa spp.) may also
potentially mean greater crop losses or additional misuse of insecticides—already a
severe challenge to the safety of vegetables sold in the markets of Southeast Asia that
should not be further exacerbated (Weinberger and Srinivasan 2009; Srinivasan 2012;
Schreinemachers et al. 2012). In addition to the damaging effects of pests and
diseases, the effects of a changing climate on pest natural enemies (e.g. Wolbachia
and Buchnera endosymbionts, two of the major groups of parasitoids or hosts
endosymbionts) and on pollinators are also likely to be severe (Gutierrez et al. 2008;
Hance et al. 2006).
As Asian populations are scheduled to increase markedly in the next 25-50
years and the Asian farming population seems to be starting to follow the Americas
and Europe with a decreasing trend in the size of the agriculturally active population,
2. It will require a substantive reduction in crop losses in both the pre- and
postharvest elements of the vegetable market chain. This will require the adoption of
careful, appropriate harvesting practices and procedures, with produce sorting and
collection at the farm gate. Harvesting at cooler times of the day and rapid cooling of
Sustaining Small-Scale Vegetable Production and Marketing Systems for Food and Nutrition Security 3
many vegetable crops is the key to effective postharvest handling and quality
maintenance (Kader 2013) to minimize the crop losses of 17-42% reported by
Bautista (2001) from Thailand, Indonesia, Malaysia, Vietnam and the Philippines.
This cooling needs to be maintained along the complete market chain. In all cases
sanitary measures should be mandatory to ensure wholesome produce at the market
and food safety. Proper marketing and care of the products while on sale and
ensuring that the product is attractive and safe for the consumer to buy and eat is
required. Better understanding of the need for a clear link between vegetable
production and industrial processing and the adoption of simple or suitable
postharvest technologies such as solar drying, freeze drying, freezing, canning,
bottling, waxing, and modified atmosphere packaging is required (Kitinoja et al.
2011; Saran et al. 2012).
3. It will require the human population to seek effective ways of reducing presently
excessive levels of food wastage, of understanding the need for a balanced diet to
obtain and maintain good health and to adopt ways of vegetable processing and
cooking that maximizes the bioavailability of the essential vitamins and minerals
present in vegetable crops (Keatinge et al. 2012b, Teng and Trethewie 2012). Food
wastage remains an unsolved issue today with wastage occurring at the
producer/farmer, at market, in the supermarkets, in restaurants and hotels, and in the
home.
One technological solution to reduce waste and increase shelf/refrigerator life
is through irradiation. Gamma irradiation can be used to eliminate harmful bacteria,
potentially retard unwanted product maturation, extends shelf life and reduces
spoilage. This technology is employed on 500,000 t of global food products annually
and is accepted in around 50 countries (Farkas et al. 2011; Kume et al. 2009). As
vegetable shelf life can be increased 3-5 times by gamma irradiation, this technology
needs to be considered and introduced more widely in Southeast Asia. Brazil is
currently a leader in this technology, some South Asian countries also accept some
irradiated products and thus there should be no major impediment to its introduction
into Southeast Asian countries other than the need for better consumer education and
understanding.
4. More information, better business skills and job creation will be needed. While
production of vegetables is a widely promoted activity, production of quality
vegetables is a knowledge-intensive occupation. Information is required to ensure
farmers use the most adapted varieties of vegetables, that they are aware of the most
appropriate production technologies (e.g. rain shelters, glasshouses, integrated pest
management) and the optimum methods to ensure their produce reaches the market in
good condition. Business skills for vegetable production increases profitability and
minimizes losses and wastage. Better information for farmers results in increased
bargaining skills to get produce from the farm to the market at the right time for
increased profitability. The increased marketing information flow will also reduce the
opportunities for cheating or excessive profiteering by middlemen. It can also
minimize risk for farmers by enabling them to locate forwards sales contract
opportunities.
Further consumer education measures need to be actively pursued amongst
householders, particularly women who need to be further empowered with knowledge
so that they understand the need for good nutrition for all members of their family
from the very young to the very old, as well as other vulnerable members of the
5. Vegetables and their products must be of better quality. The use of Good
Agricultural Practices (GAP) such as those published by the Secretariat of the
Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN 2006) in the field or greenhouse,
with careful harvesting, sanitary preparation for the market, proper marketing and
care of the produce will result in safe, high quality, and attractive products for the
consumer. There are many different consumer target groups: the household, the rural
wet market, urban wet markets, and supermarkets. Within these consumer groups
there are opportunities for niche markets of traditional vegetables, provided seed of
preferred varieties are available to farmers and that the produce can reach the market
efficiently and effectively. Many traditional vegetables are leafy, green vegetables –
these are a challenge for transport to market as they are particularly prone to wilting
and loss of quality and also due to the concurrent loss in weight, bring in less profit.
Vegetables can also be sold as pre-packed washed and prepared vegetables which
meet the needs of busy urban households. Vegetables can also be grown organically,
often with a premium price tag as organic produce, but similarly village or community
quality labels can be used to convey the focus on food safety. There are also many
opportunities for processing and adding value, ensuring that vegetables (and their
nutritional content) remain available throughout the year.
Sustaining Small-Scale Vegetable Production and Marketing Systems for Food and Nutrition Security 5
personal communication). Module farming (and plant factories) are opportunities for
production of vegetables where the environment can be well controlled. There is a
requirement for a reliable power supply for lighting and for use of a conveyor-based
system, and also a ready market for the produce which can be grown year-round.
Examples of such module are indoor vertical farms Farmed Here® in Illinois and
Green Farms A&M in Indiana, USA. Other examples of this futuristic type include
fully hydroponic and artificially lit systems designed for use in public areas or the
home (e.g. AeroGarden® hydroponic, Omega Garden® system); if prices of
installation become reasonable these could be widely adopted in urban environments.
Another opportunity is to utilize gamma irradiation as a mechanism to ensure the
quality of fresh vegetables is retained over a longer period after harvest; it is
comparable to pasteurizing milk, in that the product is left fresh, but is much safer.
Gamma irradiation destroys harmful bacteria, extends shelf life, retards maturation of
vegetables, reduces spoilage by organisms that can grow under refrigeration and can
also be used in place of fumigants and other quarantine procedures. Gamma
irradiation of food is currently permitted by over 50 countries and over 500,000 tons
of food is treated annually worldwide (Farkas et al. 2011; Kume et al. 2009).
Although the cost of developing a Cobalt 60 irradiation facility can be high, the final
costs of irradiating foods would eventually be low (low dose applications such as
disinfestation of fruit range between US$0.02 and US$0.18 per kilo, higher dose
applications can cost as much as US$0.44 per kilo (Corrigan 1993) and the increase in
food safety significant.
7. Biotechnology will need to become a useful tool. Biotechnology will ensure that
the range of molecular tools which can be used to increase the rate of production of
improved, adapted vegetable varieties are available as well as the similar tools to test
for and identify pests and pathogens. A range of molecular markers are currently
available and speed up the development of disease resistant crops. This includes for
tomato, for example, the range of Ty gene markers for chromosome loci that convey
resistance to Tomato yellow leaf curl virus (Verlaan et al. 2013). This means that the
appropriate combination of Ty genes can be combined in one variety to confer
resistance to the current strains of the virus. Molecular markers for other genes such
as those conferring resistance to late blight (Ph genes) or against root knot nematodes
(Mi genes) already exist (Foolad 2007), or for pungency (e.g. in chili, the Pun1 genes,
Steward et al. 2007) but new markers are needed for these and an increasingly wide
range of characteristics, pests and diseases.
Conventional breeding of vegetables has developed many new varieties. The
use of biotechnology to enhance the breeding process is particularly useful where
genes for a particular trait are in a different species and where crossing is not feasible.
Several genetically-modified vegetables crops are currently available (courgettes and
sweet pepper with virus resistance, eggplant with insect resistance and tomato with
delayed ripening/fruit softening/senescence and insect resistance) and tomato FLAVR
SAVR™ is commercially approved in Canada, Mexico and USA, while chicory Seed
Link™ is commercially approved in USA. In many countries, genetically-modified
vegetables cannot be grown and the products cannot be approved for release to the
public until the necessary country regulations have been approved. (Gupta et al. 2013)
8. Public-private partners must work towards common goals. It is unlikely that in the
near future public sector investment in horticultural research and development will be
sufficient to provide all the seed and technological answers to some of the questions
FUTURE PERSPECTIVE
The perspective of the next 40 years of vegetable production can be viewed
optimistically as the opportunity to render many of the previously intransigent
constraints to on-farm production such as insects and soil-borne diseases can be
considerably diminished if protected horticulture becomes the norm. In addition,
nature has been generous to humankind; copious numbers of digestible nutrient-dense
vegetable species can be valuable in the kitchen if further research can bring them into
the production mainstream.
Influencing populations becomes even more vital, not only influencing what
we eat, but also making sure that different parts of the community interact, that
policy-makers in education, health and agriculture interact to make sure that
vegetables are grown well, that quality produce is available and that the population is
aware that a balanced and diverse diet leads to good health. We also need both a new
generation of agricultural scientists and a new generation of farmers to feed a growing
Sustaining Small-Scale Vegetable Production and Marketing Systems for Food and Nutrition Security 7
population. We also need to influence policy makers so that these needs become a
reality.
And yet, while we are aware of many of the issues, we are still challenged by
inadequate consumer understanding of the need for effective diets, and the difficulty
in changing mindsets to enhance vegetable and fruit consumption among adults.
Disciplinary silos between agriculture, health and education professionals will need to
be overcome if the public are generally to accept the need for better diets and of what
these might consist. If we can link agriculture, health, education and government
policy together effectively and encourage a new generation of scientists and producers
to take up horticulture...then AVRDC believes we have every chance of bringing
“Prosperity to the Poor and Health for All” in the next 40 years in the Southeast Asian
region.
References
Alexandratos A, Bruinsma J, 2012. World Agriculture Towards 2030/2050: The 2012 Revision. ESA Working Paper
No. 12-03 June 2012 Agricultural Development Economics Division. Food and Agriculture Organization of the
United Nations. 147p. http://www.fao.org/docrep/016/ap106e/ap106e.pdf
ASEAN 2006. ASEAN GAP: Good agricultural practices for production of fresh fruit and vegetables in the ASEAN
region. Secretariat of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), Jakarta, Indonesia. 32 p.
http://www.asean.org/images/2012/publications/ASEAN_GAP_Standard.pdf
Corrigan, JP. 1993. Experiences in selling irradiated foods at the retail level. In: Cost-benefit Aspects of Food
Irradiation Processing. Proceedings of an IAEA/FAO/WHO International Symposium. Aix-en-Provence. pp. 447-
453Davis DR, Riordan HD. 2004. Changes in USDA food composition data for 43 garden crops, 1950-1999.
Journal of the American College of Nutrition 23: 669-682
Doucleff M. 2012. Sky-High Vegetables: Vertical Farming Sprouts In Singapore. Extracted on 13 March 2014 from
http://www.npr.org/blogs/thesalt/2012/11/06/164428031/sky-high-vegetables-vertical-farming-sprouts-in-singapore
Ebert, AW. 2011. Vegetable germplasm conservation and utilization at AVRDC – The World Vegetable center. Acta
Horticulturae 898: 89-95
FAOSTAT, 2014. Food and Agricultural Organization Statistical Database: Production. http://faostat.fao.org
(accessed 11 March 2014).
Foolad MR. 2007. Genome Mapping and Molecular Breeding of Tomato. International Journal of Plant Genomics
2007: 1-52.
Fruit Salad Tree. 2012. Extracted on 13 March 2014 from http://www.fruitsaladtrees.comGupta
Gupta SM, Grover A, Nasim M. 2013. Transgenic Technologies in Agriculture: From Lab to Field to Market. CIBTech
Journal of Biotechnology 3(3):20-47.
Gutierrez, Andrew Paul, Kent M. Daane, Luigi Ponti, Vaughn M. Walton, and C. Ken Ellis. 2008. “Prospective
Evaluation of the Biological Control of Vine Mealybug: Refuge Effects and Climate.” Journal of Applied Ecology 45
(2): 524–536. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2664.2007.01356.x.
Hance T., Baaren J., Vernon P., Boivin G. 2007. Impact of Extreme Temperatures on Parasitoids in a Climate
Change Perspective. Annual Review of Entomology 52: 107-126
Hanson P, Gniffke PA, Shieh J, Tan CW. 2011. Solanaceous vegetable breeding at AVRDC – The World Vegetable
Center to meet the challenges of climate change in the tropics. In: Proceedings of the Workshop on Crop breeding
and Management of Agricultural Environment for Coping with Climate Change, Eds. D-H. Wu, M-T. Lu, T-H.
Tseng, Y-T. Wang and C-L. Hsiao, pp. 163-172. Taichung: Taiwan Agricultural Research Institute.
Holmer RJ. 2011. Vegetable gardens benefit the urban poor in the Philippines. Appropriate Technology 38: 49-51
Hughes J. d’A, Keatinge JDH. 2013. The Nourished Millennium: How Vegetables Put Global Goals for Healthy,
Balanced Diets Within Reach. ASEAN Regional Symposium on High Value Vegetables in Southeast Asia:
Production, Supply and Demand (SEAVEG 2012). 24-26 January 2012, Chiang Mai, Thailand. Eds. R. J.
Holmer, G. Linwattana, P. Nath and J.D.H. Keatinge. Shanhua, Taiwan: AVRDC
Jat RA, Wani SP, Sahrawat KL, Singh, P, Dhaka BL. 2011. Fertigation in vegetable crops for higher productivity and
resource use efficiency. Indian Journal of fertilizers 7: 22-37
Kader AA. 2013. Postharvest technology of horticultural crops – An overview from farm to fork. Ethiopian Journal
of Applied Science and Technology Special Issue 1: 1-8
Kahane R, Hodgkin T, Jaenicke H, Hoogendoorn C, Hermann M, Keatinge JDH, Hughes Jd’A, Looney N. 2013.
Diversity for development: the role of opportunity crops and species. Journal of Agronomy for Sustainable
Development. DOI 10.1007/s13593-013-0147-8
Keatinge JDH. 2013. Horticulture – for Nourishing Families, Empowering Women and Commercializing
Smallholders. Agriculture for Development 19: 4-7
Keatinge, JDH, Ledesma D, Keatinge, FJD, Hughes Jd’A. 2012a. Projecting annual air temperature changes to 2025
and beyond: Implications for vegetable horticulture worldwide. Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge vol
152...... doi:10.1017/S0021859612000913 http://journals.cambridge.org/abstract_S0021859612000913
Keatinge JDH, Holmer RJ, Ebert A, Hughes, Jd’A. 2012b. Less visible but yet vital for human health: Nutrient-dense
indigenous vegetables and their need for urgent promotion in balanced diets. Proceedings of the regional
symposium on "Promotion of underutilized indigenous food resources for food security and nutrition in Asia and the
Pacific", 31 May - 2 June, 2012 held at Khon Kaen, Thailand.
Keatinge JDH, Yang R-Y, Hughes Jd’A, Easdown WJ, Holmer R. 2011a. The importance of vegetables in ensuring
both food and nutritional security in attainment of the Millennium Development Goals. Food Security 3:491–501
Sustaining Small-Scale Vegetable Production and Marketing Systems for Food and Nutrition Security 9