Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Table of Contents
1. INTRODUCTION 4
Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 51
Mechanisms ..................................................................................................................................... 58
4.3.1. Typical mechanisms of alkene hydrogenation ................................................................................. 59
4.3.2. Oxidative addition as a key step in hydrogenation catalysis ........................................................... 64
4.3.2.1. Oxidative addition in Wilkinson's catalyst ................................................................................... 64
4.3.2.2. Vaska's complex............................................................................................................................ 65
4.3.2.3. Oxidative addition of alkyl halides RX to [Pt(PPh3)2] .................................................................. 66
4.3.2.4. Oxidative addition of CH bonds ................................................................................................. 67
4.3.2.5. Digression: σ complexes and agostic interactions ........................................................................ 71
4.3.3. Mechanism of the asymmetric alkene hydrogenation .................................................................... 84
Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 89
6. OXIDATIONS .....................................................................................................................114
7. METATHESIS .....................................................................................................................131
9. POLYMERIZATION ..........................................................................................................163
1. Introduction
Probably the oldest catalysts are metal-containing enzymes, which have existed in nature for
millions of years ( see lecture “Bioinorganic Chemistry”). The ancient Germanic tribes
already used catalysis to produce alcoholic beverages with the help of yeast cells, which they
then consumed with delight. Homogeneous biocatalysis thus was in the cradle of catalysis.
“Catalysis” as a scientific phenomenon was discovered in the 19th century. Already in the 2nd
half of the 18th century, an increasing number of reactions were described that marked the
beginnings of catalytic research.
The establishment of stoichiometry (J. B. Richter 1792/93) and the formulation of the laws
of constant and multiple proportions (J. L. Proust and J. Dalton, 1799 and 1803) provided an
important basis. It was thus possible to realize that substoichiometric quantities of a substance
can induce chemical reactions without the substance being consumed in the reaction.
The word “catalysis” (gr. = dissolution) was coined by Jöns Jakob Berzelius
(1779-1848). In a report to the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, he summarized some of
the observations mentioned above:
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 5
In accordance with the belief at that time, a reaction between two “bodies” required their
“chemical affinity”. Catalysts were therefore seen as “bodies” by Berzelius, which could
"awaken dormant affinities" by their "catalytic force" without themselves having "affinities"
to the reacting substances.
Berzelius uses the term catalysis in a purely descriptive way and brings together phenomena
that could not be explained by the doctrine that reactions are caused by chemical affinity.
Liebig attacked Berzelius several times for his definition of catalysis, with his criticism focusing
on the "creation of a new force through a new word that does not explain the phenomenon
either".
A prerequisite for understanding catalysis in more detail was the development of reaction
kinetics, which allowed to discover and analyze the laws of chemical reactions. This led to the
“kinetic definition of catalysis” by Wilhelm Ostwald (1853-1932; 1932 Nobel Prize in
chemistry). In his experiments on the acid-catalyzed oxidation of hydrogen iodide by bromic
acid, Ostwald detected that the nature of catalysis was not the inducement of a reaction, but
its acceleration.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 6
Catalysis is often not just the "reduction of the energy mountain" but allows for an alternative
reaction path that has a lower activation energy for the rate-determining step.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 7
Wilhelm Ostwald summarized his understanding of catalysis in his lecture on the occasion of
the awarding of the Nobel Prize in 1909. He stated: "…that until a way has been found whereby
a rate of chemical reaction can generally be calculated in advance ..., the catalysis problem
cannot satisfactorily be answered." Not until after Ostwald's death, Henry Eyring (1901-1981)
created an important theoretical basis with his transition-state theory (1935).
Why catalysis?
(Behr, 2008)
1st step: Acylation of isobutylbenzene, same for both processes
2nd step: Heterogeneous catalytic hydrogenation of the ketone group
3rd step: Homogeneous catalytic carbonylation of the hydroxy group with carbon monoxide
After only three steps, ibuprofen is synthesized and all reagents used can be found in the
end product!
This allows, for example, for a direct C-C coupling of various molecules without the need for
any interim steps.
Important processes:
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 9
After Döbereiner, Berzelius, Ostwald and others had detected the basic principles of catalysis,
catalysis developed rapidly as a scientific sub-discipline.
Catalysis is a key driver for investigating organometallic compounds because they are of great
importance as catalytically active species in industrial processes. The driving force for many
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 10
discoveries in catalysis research was "coincidence", fueled by the curiosity of chemists who
were pursuing other objectives.
Examples:
Karl Ziegler set out to produce short-chained olefin oligomers and discovered low-
pressure polymerization of ethene to PE.
Otto Roelen: Discovered aldehydes ("oxo products") in the Fischer-Tropsch reactor in
1938
Overall, four Nobel Prizes have been awarded so far to ten researches altogether for their
outstanding merit in homogeneous transition metal catalysis.
The development of catalysis can be roughly divided into four phases.
Phase 1 (1898-1918): Inorganic basic chemicals
Sulfuric acid contact process (BASF, 1898)
Ammonia synthesis (Fritz Haber, 1903, and Carl Bosch, 1908)
Preparation of nitric acid by catalytic ammonia oxidation (Wilhelm Ostwald, post 1900)
Phase 2 (1919-1945): Synthesis gas and acetylene chemistry
Catalytic refinery processes and works on catalytic synthesis gas and acetylene chemistry
Acetaldehyde as acetylene with HgSO4 as catalyst
Acid-catalyzed synthesis of isopropanol from propene and water
Production of methanol from synthesis gas (CO/H2, Zn/Cr cat., 1923, BASF)
Steam reforming of methane to synthesis gas
Catalytic cracking of hydrocarbons with solid acid catalysts
Fischer-Tropsch synthesis: Reaction of synthesis gas, forming alkanes and alkenes with
heterogeneous iron and cobalt catalysts
Oxosynthesis (= hydroformylation) with cobalt catalysts
Reppe chemistry: Acetylene chemistry, nickel-catalyzed oligomerizations, reaction of
acetylene with CO and H2O or alcohols
Hydroformylation, which was discovered by Otto Roelen, and the C-C coupling reactions by
Reppe are the oldest homogeneous catalytic reactions involving transition metal complexes.
Phase 3 (1945-1970): Major petrochemical products
The great age of petrochemistry where homogeneous transition metal catalysis is
increasingly used - numerous developments in catalytic conversion of alkenes into
chemical base products
The homogeneous transition metal catalysis of 1938-1965:
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 11
(Behr, 2008)
Phase 4 (since 1971): Fine chemicals and special products
The homogeneous transition metal catalysis of 1966-1985:
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 12
(Behr, 2008)
1953, Karl Ziegler (MPI Mülheim), and 1954/55, Gulio Natta (Institute of Technology,
Milan): Alkene polymerization
Karl Ziegler discovered low-pressure polymerization of ethene with organometallic mixed
catalysts at the MPI for Coal Research in Mülheim/Ruhr: Starting point for the development
of the organometallic chemistry of complex catalysis
Natta demonstrated that propene and other olefins are stereoselectively polymerized with
Ziegler's catalysts
1956, Phillips Petroleum: First technical synthesis of high cis 1.4 polybutadiene
time of the transition from acetylene chemistry (coal chemistry) to petrochemistry (ethene
chemistry)
1968, William S. Knowles (Monsanto Co., St. Louis, 2001 Nobel Prize) and L. Horner
(Universität Mainz): Enantioselective hydrogenation of prochiral olefins with Wilkinson-
type complexes with chiral phosphines, use of L-DOPA on an industrial scale
1966, Hitosi Nozaki and Ryori Noyori (Kyoto University, Japan): Asymmetric
cyclopropanation of styrene; first example of an asymmetric catalysis using a structurally
well-defined chiral transition metal complex
M. Kumada, 1972: M = Mg
E.-i. Negishi, 1976/77: M = Zn
A. Suzuki, 1979 (2001 Nobel Prize): M = B
J. K. Stille, 1979: M = Sn
1977, Shell Higher Olefin Process (SHOP), Wilhelm Keim (TU Aachen): Nickel-catalyzed
ethene oligomerization in a liquid-liquid biphasic system
1980, K. Barry Sharpless (Scripps Research Institute, La Jolla, USA, 2001 Nobel Prize):
Asymmetric epoxidation of alcohols
Since 1988, Richard R. Schrock (MIT Cambridge, 2005 Nobel Prize), Robert H. Grubbs
(Caltech, Pasadena, 2005 Nobel Prize): Alkylidene complexes of Mo, W and Ru with a
broad range of applications for olefin metathesis
1997, Jean-Marie Basset (CNRS Lyon): Metathesis of alkanes with a tantalum hybrid
immobilized on a silica gel surface
Principles of catalysis
As a reminder:
Basic principle of catalysis: Catalysts reduce the free enthalpy of the transition state with
the highest energy (i.e. which is rate-determining).
Catalysts do not lower the energy of reactants nor products! They therefore do not affect
thermodynamics (equilibrium constants, molar ratios of products and educts). However,
catalysts allow reactions to happen faster under mild conditions, which makes a higher
product yield feasible.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 18
1.3.4. Terminology
Catalytic cycle: Series of steps during which the reactants are used up and the products are
formed; starting and finishing points of the reaction are the same.
Example of a catalytic cycle:
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 22
Formation of the active catalyst LnM usually takes place from a precatalyst, in this case LnMX2.
The active catalyst complex binds the substrate while forming the catalyst-substrate adduct
LnMS. The bound substrate is converted to the intermediate LnMI and then to the product
LnMP. The dissociation of the product P leads to the regeneration of the catalyst complex,
coming full circle. The catalyst complex can leave the cycle reversibly by adding a ligand L or
by dimerizing the catalyst-substrate complex LnMS. The species that formed in the process,
Ln+1M and [LnMS]2, can be considered as resting state.
Catalyst complex: All species in the catalytic cycle
Precatalyst: Compounds from which active catalyst complexes can be generated; they are
generally so stable that they can be isolated in substance.
Examples:
Reversible reactions outside of the catalytic cycle may slow down catalytic reactions by
reducing the catalyst concentration
Rate-determining step: Reaction step with the highest activation energy; if there is complex
reaction kinetics, there is not necessarily a rate-determining step, although there is in most
cases.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 24
Solution:
−∆𝐺‡
𝑘𝑏 ∙𝑇
Eyring equation: 𝑘 = 𝑒 𝑅𝑇
ℎ
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 25
‡
−∆𝐺1
𝑘1 𝑒 𝑅𝑇 𝑘 −∆𝐺1‡ −∆𝐺2‡ 𝑘
= ‡ , logarithmizing: 𝑙𝑛
1
= − , transforming 𝑅𝑇𝑙𝑛 𝑘1 = ∆𝐺2‡ − ∆𝐺1‡ = ∆∆𝐺 ‡
𝑘2 −∆𝐺 2 𝑘 2 𝑅𝑇 𝑅𝑇 2
𝑒 𝑅𝑇
𝑘1
= 100 → ∆∆𝐺 ‡ = 11.41 𝑘𝐽 ∙ 𝑚𝑜𝑙 −1
𝑘2
𝑘1
= 1000 → ∆∆𝐺 ‡ = 17.11 𝑘𝐽 ∙ 𝑚𝑜𝑙 −1
𝑘2
Conclusion: Even a comparably small decrease of the activation barrier (compare rotation
barrier around C-C bonds of ethane: 11-13 kJ/mol) causes a high reaction acceleration!
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 26
Metal ion
Formal charge
Results from the formal charge of the ligands and the overall charge of the complex
Examples:
Neutral complex with two mono-anionic ligands oxidation number +II for the metal
atom
Monocationic complex with two mono-anionic ligands oxidation number +III for the
metal ion
Important: The oxidation number is just a formal charge that has no direct reference to
physical reality! Due to the covalent bond components of the metal-ligand bond (in particular
with organometallic compounds), the actual charge of the metal ion is between 1 (= L.
Pauling's principle of electroneutrality).
Why are oxidation numbers useful nevertheless?
Useful to determine the valence electron number of the metal ion (i.e. the number of
electrons in orbitals with a high metal content)
In combination with the valence electron number, the oxidation number allows to make
predictions about the structure and reactivity of complexes
Simple rule:
(n)d shell is filled first, (n+1)s shell remains empty
Cause: Different shielding of s and d orbitals. The 4s orbital is less shielded in the gas phase
than a 3d orbital; therefore, the 4s orbital has a lower energy in the gas phase than the
3d orbital. In a metal complex, in which the metal ion has a partially positive charge, the
difference of the shielding is lower (the orbitals are contracted more in the positively
charged ion).
Number of d-electrons: Number of d-electrons not involved in metal-ligand bonds. For neutral
complexes, the number of d-electrons corresponds to the group number
Examples - jointly compile on the board:
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 27
Change in the stability, basicity and d orbital energies within the transition metals influence
on the reactivity!
Often opposing trends to the main group elements
No continuous trends, but areas with similar characteristics within the transition metals
(e.g. valence electron poor vs. valence electron rich transition metals, first-row vs. second-
and third-row metal, iron group vs. platinum group)
Size trends:
3d metals < 4d metals third-row metals
Question: Why does this trend exist?
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 29
Ligand characteristics
Fundamental classification based on assigning the charges to the ligand or to the oxidation
number of the metal ion:
“Covalent” ligands: “Dative” ligands:
“Charged” ligands “Neutral” ligands
Bonding takes place by metal and ligand Bonding takes place by the ligand donating
sharing an electron each two electrons to the metal ion
If the electrons from the bond are assigned
If the electrons from the bond are assigned to the ligand “neutral” ligand
to the ligand “anionic” ligand
ligands:
Ligands with an even number of C atoms neutral, donate an even number of electrons
when using the neutral counting method
Ligands with an uneven number of C atoms charged, donate an uneven number of
electrons when using the neutral counting method
The number of electrons donated by a cyclic ligand using the ionic counting method
corresponds to the number of electrons in the most stable aromatic system.
Examples:
Metal-ligand bond
The valence electron number is physically measurable, in contrast to the rather arbitrary
formalisms "oxidation number" and "ligand charge" discussed in chapters 2.1.2. and 2.2.1.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 32
This number is important to understand and predict the characteristics and the reaction
behavior of transition organometallic compounds.
Two systems of counting electrons:
1) Covalent model of electron accounting
Neutral central atom and neutral ligands
Valence electron number = group number of the metal atom + number of X ligands + 2x
number of L ligands Overall charge of the complex
2) Ionic model
Charged central ion and charged ligands
Valence electron number = number of d-electrons of the metal ion + 2x number of X ligands
+ 2x number of L ligands
Relationship between charge, oxidation number and ligand charge in the ionic model:
Complex charge = oxidation number + overall charge of the ligands
Number of d-electrons = group number - oxidation number
Examples:
[CpFe(CO)2(C2H5)]
a) Covalent model: b) Ionic model:
1. Iron Group 8 8e- 1. Ligands
2. CO = L type ligand: 2e- per CO 2 x CO: Neutral, 2 x 2e- = 4e-
3. Cp: 5e- Cp-: Anion, 6e-
C2H5: Anion, 2e-
4. C2H5 (ethyl): 1e- electron number of the ligands = 12e-
Overall valence electron number = 2. Metal ion
8 + (2 x 2) + 5 + 1 = 18e-
Oxidation number: Neutral complex, two
anionic ligands Fe2+
3. Number of d-electrons for Fe(II): 6e-
4. Overall valence electron number =
12 + 6 = 18e-
[CpMo(CO)3(H2O)]+
a) Covalent model: b) Ionic model:
1. Molybdenum: Group 6 6e- 1. 3x CO: 6e
2. CO: 3x 2e- 2. H2O: 2e
3. H2O: 2e- 3. Cp-: 6e-
4. Cp: 5e- overall: 14e-
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 33
2.3.2. Structures
IUPAC definition: Coordination number as number of the atoms that are directly bound to the
metal atom
Convention in organometallic chemistry: Coordination number corresponds to the number of
donated electron pairs so that the coordination number in the above mentioned complexes
[Pt(PEt3)2(nBu)2], for example, equals four, in [CpFe(CO)2(C2H5)] and [Ru(NO)(PPh3)2Cl3] equals
six each and in [CpMo(CO)3(H2O)]+ seven.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 34
Electronic effects (overall energy of the occupied orbitals, in particular of the HOMO) can
stabilize a sterically unfavorable structure. Impact of certain d-electron configurations: Four-
fold coordinated complexes of the 2nd and 3rd transition metal series are nearly always
square planar eight d-electrons fill low-lying MOs
Most organometallic complexes have strong donor ligands usually strong crystal-field
splitting, low-spin complexes
Construction of an MO diagram:
Symmetry-adapted linear combinations (SALCs) of metal and ligand orbitals
MOs are formed by combining metal and ligand orbitals
Example: Octahedral complex [PtH6]2-
Ligand orbitals: 6 SALCs, eg, t1u, and a1g
Metal orbitals: t1u for (n+1) p orbitals, a1g for (n+1)s orbital, t2g for three d orbitals and eg
for two additional d orbitals no SALC for three d orbitals (t2g symmetry)
Metal and ligand orbitals of the same symmetry type form binding MOs with lower
energy than the isolated metal and ligand orbitals as well as anti-binding MOs, which
have a higher energy than the isolated orbitals.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 35
• Non-bonding and anti-bonding MOs with high d character often control the reaction
behavior for the octahedral complex, usually t2g and 2eg orbitals. These are usually
considered to be metal d orbitals, which is not really true since they are MOs (with a high
d percentage). Due to the higher energy, the d percentage for 2eg is higher than for t2g
because the energies of the d orbitals are usually higher than those of the ligand orbitals.
18-valence electron rule: 18 electrons fill the 1a1g, eg, t1u and t2g; t2g is the HOMO, 2eg is
the LUMO of the complex. Background of the 18-valence electron rule: A complex of any
symmetry can accept exactly 18 electrons because 9 valence orbitals of the metal are
available, which can form at the most 9 binding and 9 non-binding MOs. When accepting
more than 18 electrons, they must be accepted by anti-binding MOs energetically
unfavorable
delocalization of electron density of the ligand. Delocalization leads to a decrease of the C-O
bond order and compensates the σ donation of the electron density “backbonding”.
Backbonding is physically noticeable by a longer C-O bond length and a lower C-O vibrational
frequency.
Examples:
Despite this convention of counting electrons, the M-C bond differs only slightly. It is, of
course, by no means the case that the negative charge sits on the carbene ligand for
tantalum complexes.
From the perspective of the metal fragment, the symmetry of the border orbitals of carbene
and carbyne ligands are similar:
Carbene ligand: One σ and one orbital
Carbyne ligand: One σ and two orbital
Important distinction between Fischer and Schrock carbene or carbyne complexes:
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 38
Fischer carbenes (e.g. C(OMe)Me, C(NMe2)Me and CPh2): Neutral ligands, two-electron
donors in the covalent and ionic models (see table in section 2.2.1.)
Schrock carbenes: Dianionic ligands, two-electron donors in the covalent model, four-
electron donors in the ionic model
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 39
Solutions:
Dewar-Chatt-Duncanson model, the interaction between σ donor and acceptor again plays
an important role:
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 40
While for CO the acceptor ability is predominant over σ donor characteristics, the relative
σ donor and acceptor strength strongly depends on the metal ion for alkenes:
Metal atoms in high oxidation states (frequently in cationic complexes): Alkenes act as
excellent σ donors resonance structure A
Similar C-C bond length as in the free alkene
Complexes often react as nucleophiles
Electron-rich metal atoms in formal low oxidation states: Alkenes act as excellent
acceptors resonance structure B
Electron density from the metal to the ligand
Significantly longer C-C bond length than in the free alkene
Hybridization increases from sp2 to sp3 angular structure
Examples:
K[PtCl3(2-C2H4)]H2O: Zeise's salt, similar bond length as in the free ethene (1.339 Å)
structure A
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 41
Coordinated polyenes and arenes act in metal complexes as σ donor and donor ligands.
Example: Bis(benzene)chromium
Exercise in the lecture: Draw the orbitals of benzene
MOs of Cr(C6H6)2:
SALCs of the benzene ligands: 2x σ (2x a2u a1g + a2u), 2x (e1g e1g + e1u), 2x (e2u
e2g + e2u), 2x b2g b2g + b2u
Metal orbitals: s, dz2 a1g, pz a2u, px,py e1u, dxz,dyz e1g, dx2-y2,dxy e2g
MOs by overlapping with the following metal orbitals:
a1g + s orbital, dz2 orbitals σ symmetry
a2u + pz σ symmetry
e1u + px,py; e1g + dxz,dyz symmetry
e2g + dxy, dx2-y2 symmetry
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 42
Many other cyclic and acyclic polyenes can also have σ, and interactions with the metal
orbitals. The question whether these are “donor” or “acceptor” interactions cannot be
answered clearly beforehand but is dependent on the formal charge allocated to the ligands
and the occupation of the orbitals in the free ligand.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 43
Alkynes act as four-electron ligands in complexes with less than 18 electrons (see table in
section 2.1.2)
Alkoxides and amides:
Alkoxide ligands: Linear M-O-C angle implies sp hybridization two electron pairs form
a bond with the metal atom
Amide ligands: Planarity implies sp2 hybridization at the nitrogen free electron pair
can form a bond with the metal atom
Other good donor ligands: Halide, oxide and nitride ions
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 41
3. donor ligands
Ligand substitution is an important step in the synthesis of many organometallic bonds. Ligand
substitutions consist of both a ligand dissociation and a ligand addition.
Various mechanisms:
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 42
The ligand dissociation is the first step in many catalytic reactions (see chapter 1.4.4.) - “a
site of coordinative unsaturation is perhaps the most important property of a homogeneous
catalyst” (J. P. Collman, Acc. Chem. Res. 1968, 1, 136).
Associative mechanism, A:
Species formed in the first, associative step is in organometallic reactions in most cases an
intermediate; for SN2 reactions, however, it is a transition state A parallel can be drawn
with base-catalyzed transesterifications, where an intermediate can actually be observed.
Associative and dissociative mechanisms are extremes in a continuum. The truth is often
somewhere in between interchange mechanisms where both a partial bond break and a
partial bond formation take place in the transition state. When the bond formation is more
pronounced in the rate-determining state, it is referred to as associative interchange IA; when
the bond break is more pronounced, it is called dissociative interchange ID.
Exchange mechanisms are particularly widespread in coordination chemistry when charged
complexes react with ligands of opposite charge Formation of an encounter complex where
complex and ligand form an intermediary ion pair.
The associative interchange mechanism does not play a major role in organometallic
reactions, because they usually take place with neutral complexes, non-polar organic solvents
and neutral ligands such as alkenes and CO. Nevertheless, this option needs to be kept in mind.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 43
Oxidative addition: A substrate molecule X-Y is added to a low-valent metal complex after a
bond break occurred increase of the coordination number, the oxidation state and the
valence electron number by two units
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 44
Oxidative additions have a rich mechanistic variety: radical, ionic and concerted
(synchronous) mechanisms, also SN2-type mechanisms are known – more information will
be given below in section 4.3.2. dealing with transition metal-catalyzed hydrogenation
reactions
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 45
Oxidative coupling:
Alkenes or alkynes form metallacycles following complex formation (C-C bond linkage)
Metal makes the transition to an oxidation state that is higher by two units
Reversal: Reductive cleavage or fragmentation
3.4. Migratory insertion and -elimination
The -hydrogen elimination generates either a carbene and a hydrido ligand from an alkyl
ligand, or a carbene and an alkane from two alkyl ligands.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 47
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 48
By coordination to a metal atom, an olefin, for example, is activated so that it can react upon
attack by a nucleophile, producing an alkyl complex. The reverse reaction is called
heterolytic fragmentation.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 50
Oxidized and reduced metal complex merely differ by one electron. The electron injected
upon reduction may populate a metal-centered or a ligand-centered molecular orbital. In case
a metal-centered orbital is populated, the oxidation state of the metal atom decreases by one
unit. When a ligand-centered orbital is involved, the ligand is oxidized or reduced.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 51
4. Homogeneous hydrogenation
4.1. Introduction
One of the most important reactions for the synthesis of bulk and fine chemicals
Heterogeneous reactions (palladium and platinum as catalysts) are advantageous, but
homogeneous reactions are more selective in particular stereoselectivity
Diverse functional groups: Alkynes, aldehydes, ketones, esters, nitroarenes, arenes and
heteroarenes
Multitude of catalysts, in particular neutral and cationic rhodium, ruthenium and iridium
complexes
2001 Nobel Prizes:
W. S. Knowles: Industrial synthesis of the rare amino acid L-DOPA, which can be used to treat
Parkinson's disease. In the key step, a cationic rhodium complex of the chiral diphosphine
DIPAMP catalyzes enantioselectively the hydrogenation of the enamide A (quantitative yield
and 95% ee). A simple acid-catalyzed hydrolysis step leads to L-DOPA.
The Monsanto process was the first commercial catalytic asymmetric synthesis with a chiral
metal complex.
Noyori and Takaya discovered the atropisomeric, chiral diphosphine BINAP in 1981.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 52
4.2.1. Rhodium
Cationic rhodium complexes [RhL2(H)2(S)2]+ (S = polar solvent molecule, e.g. THF or MeOH,
L2 = tertiary phosphine molecule or more commonly bidentate phosphine ligand)
important for the development of enantioselective hydrogenation of alkenes!
Usually more selective than neutral Wilkinson-type ligands - little alkene isomerization
Initial rate constant kinit for hydrogenation of 1-hexene by cationic rhodium complexes
with phosphine ligands (nbd = norbornadiene)
Complex Substrate concentration / kinit × 104 /s-1
mM
[Rh(nbd)(PPh3)2]+ 5.3 0.1
[Rh(nbd)(PPh2Me)2]+ 3.7 3.0
[Rh(nbd)(PPhMe2)2]+ 3.5 6.0
The reaction with H2 forms the cationic dihydride [RhL2(H)2S2]+ with acidic hydride
ligands adding a base such as triethylamine leads to neutral Wilkinson-type ligands
4.2.2. Iridium
Crabtree's catalyst is more reactive than neutral, sterically more hindered rhodium and
ruthenium catalysts
Very high activity with tetra-substituted alkenes
Dramatic influence of the solvent (entries 2 and 3)
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 58
4.2.3. Ruthenium
4.3. Mechanisms
Countless studies (e.g. the legendary studies by Halpern et al. on the mechanism of Rh-
catalyzed hydrogenations) - two very important conclusions:
1. The spectroscopically observable species during catalytic reactions are frequently not
located in the catalytic cycle (unproductive equilibria, off-cycle intermediate or irreversibly
formed, unproductive side products)
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 59
2. Determine rate laws for catalytic sub-steps independently whenever possible and correlate
with the rate law for the overall reaction! Studies examining the influence of countless
variables on the kinetics of the overall reaction are misleading! (too many variables)
Similar mechanisms can be observed with ruthenium and iridium complexes, whereby
modifications may occur, e.g. concerted oxidative addition and migratory insertion or
heterolytic cleavage of H2 with ruthenium acetates.
Another variation is σ-bond metathesis:
Hydrogenation of ketones and imines often does not happen via a reaction path that includes
oxidative addition, migratory insertion and reductive elimination. Instead, an outer-sphere
mechanism can often be observed in such cases, i.e. metal-ligand bifunctional catalysis
(Noyori)
Classical: Chiral, non-racemic diamine complexes [Ru(BINAP)(diamine)(H)2]
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 61
Few years ago, the reaction principle of the Shvo catalyst was transferred to iron:
Kinetic studies:
Oxidative addition either at the starting complex or (104 times faster) at [RhCl(PPh3)2]
Contribution of the two species depends on their relative concentration and thus on the
concentration of free PPh3
In the absence of a high concentration of added PPh 3 this reaction mainly takes place via
the 14e complex [RhCl(PPh3)2], although it exists only in low concentration
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 65
Radical mechanism
The reaction takes place with homolytic cleavage of the R-X bond - Transfer of an electron
(SET - single electron transfer) of Pt(0) to the σ*-C-X orbital Increase of the oxidation state
and coordination number of M by one unit each, subsequently recombination of the radical
pair that formed
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 67
Iridium(I) complexes: A. H. Janowicz, R. G. Bergman, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1982, 104, 352-354.
Activation of methane: J. K. Hoyano, A. D. McMaster, W. A. G. Graham, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1983,
105, 7190-7191.
Rhodium(I) complexes: W. D. Jones, F. J. Feher, Organometallics 1983, 2, 562-563.
The most difficult substrate for CH activation is without doubt methane because it has a very
high CH bond energy (435 kJmol-1), no dipole moment and no functional group.
Recent example: Methane functionalization with ethyl diazoacetate as carbene source in
supercritical CO2 by Peréz et al.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 68
Literature:
A. Caballero, E. Despagnet-Ayoub, M. Mar Díaz-Requejo, A. Díaz-Rodríguez, M. E. González-
Núñez, R. Mello, B. K. Muñoz, W.-S. Ojo, G. Asensio, M. Etienne, P. J. Pérez, Science 2011, 332,
835-838.
V. N. Cavaliere, D. J. Mindiola, Chem. Sci. 2012, 3, 3356-3365. (Review)
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 69
The mechanism of sMMO was investigated on model compounds in quantum chemical studies
and examinations.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 71
Mechanistic steps:
1) Resting state is the form FeIIIFeIII (MMOHox)
2) Reduction by the reductase protein MMOR makes the FeIIFeII (MMOHred) form
3) Reaction with O2 leads to the superoxo intermediate (not yet spectroscopically observed
but plausible based on theoretical and kinetic studies). It is of a mixed-valent FeIIFeIII
structure.
4) Formation of a peroxo intermediate. FeII ion is oxidized to FeIII.
The first step of an oxidative addition is often the formation of a σ complex or an agostic
interaction.
First example of a stable σ complex: Kubas complex
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 72
Reactivity of H2 complexes:
Oxidative addition of H2 ( catalysis)
H2 complexes are frequently at equilibrium with the corresponding hydrido complexes
Energy barrier for the transformation results from structural changes (coordination
geometry, ligands), which must take place when the dihydrido complex is formed
In some cases, H2 complexes were observed as kinetic products when reacting with H2 at
low temperatures before the transformation into dihydride takes place.
Dissociation of the H2 ligand
H2 is usually easily displaced by simple dative ligands, e.g. by N 2, and rarely by H2O and
ether
Example:
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 76
Some anaerobic microorganisms use protons as terminal electron acceptors. Others use H2 as
reducing agent in order to reduce inorganic species such as CO2 (acetogenic, methanogenic
and photosynthetic bacteria), Fe3+ ions, N2, NO3 and SO42 ions.
Most organisms with H2 metabolism are anaerobic prokaryotes. There are also some
eukaryotes and aerobic bacteria that produce energy from the oxidation of H 2 with O2, with
the formation of water.
The production and oxidation of H2 is catalyzed by hydrogenase enzymes (H2ases).
Interestingly, they are one of the most primitive enzymes in biology. Some hydrogenases are
related to subunits of the complex I of mitochondria, an important component of the
respiratory chain. This indicates that these hydrogenases and complex I are evolutionarily
related.
Three types of hydrogenases are known and were also isolated from sulfate-reducing bacteria
and structurally characterized:
[NiFe] hydrogenase: Heterodinuclear Ni-Fe unit in the active center, usually involved in H2
oxidation
[FeFe] hydrogenase (iron-only hydrogenase): Homodinuclear Fe-Fe unit in the active center,
usually involved in hydrogen production
[Fe] hydrogenase: Only a single iron atom in the active center
All three types are sensitive towards atmospheric oxygen. [NiFe] and [FeFe] hydrogenases
both have similar dinuclear centers but are not evolutionary related.
Example: [NiFe] hydrogenase
The activity of the [NiFe] hydrogenase is lower by one to two times the power of ten than the
[FeFe] hydrogenase. However, H2 binds about 100 times better. [NiFe] hydrogenase is less
sensitive towards O2 and CO.
The structures of a row of [NiFe] hydrogenases were crystallographically determined. The
structures are very similar: Globular heterodimers of 3 nm radius, two subunits with different
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 77
sizes (26 and 63 kDa). The large subunit contains the active center with the dinuclear Ni-Fe
unit. The small subunit contains three iron-sulfur clusters for the electron transport: [4Fe-4S]
cluster at a distance of 1.4 nm from the active center, [3Fe-4S] cluster further away and a [4Fe-
4S] cluster on the surface of the protein. The protein still consists of a large cavity and several
hydrophobic channels.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 78
b) [FeFe] hydrogenase
For the Fe-only hydrogenase, crystal structures of two bacteria (C. pasteurianum and
Desulfovibrio desulficans) are known. Both show the same active center with a dinuclear diiron
complex and terminal CO and CN ligands. The two iron atoms are bridged by a
di(thiomethyl)amine ligand. Similar to the [NiFe] hydrogenases, the protein consists of three
[4Fe4S] clusters, which are located at relatively regular intervals of about 1.2 nm between
the active center and the surface. The [4Fe4S] cluster that is closest to the dinuclear center
is bound to one of the Fe atoms via a thiolate bridge.
The unit from the dinuclear reaction center, the thiolate bridge and the adjacent [4Fe4S]
cluster is also called “H cluster”. Here again, a hydrophobic channel connects the dinuclear
reaction center with the surface.
Crystallographic and IR studies show differences in the oxidized and reduced form of the
[FeFe] hydrogenase of D. desulfuricans. In the oxidized form, a CO molecule bridges the two
iron atoms asymmetrically. Fe1 has six ligands, which are distorted octahedrally coordinated.
Fe2 has five ligands and a free coordination site, which is also free in the reduced form or
which is occupied by a water molecule.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 79
Stable CH complexes are hardly known, but there are indications (isotope effects, NMR
studies)
Example: H-D exchange between hydrido ligands and alkanes almost certainly takes place
via an alkane σ complex (R. G. Bergman)
Unlike CH σ-complexes, there is no “entropic punishment” when coordinating the CH bond.
The strength is specified as 4-40 kJmol-1. The bonding situation may be described in a way
similar to H2complexes. The agostic interaction may be described as “arrested” CH bond
activation.
Different types of agostic interaction:
-agostic interaction: very frequent; interaction with H atom at the carbon atom
Intermediate on the path towards -H elimination
-agostic interactions: In complexes with highly electrophilic metal atoms, also in carbene
complexes with metal atoms in high oxidation states
Agostic interactions between unsaturated metal atoms and ligand-CH bonds, examples:
Kubas‘ H2 complex, [RuCl2(PPh3)3], unsaturated Pd(II) and Rh(I) complexes
Agostic interactions are particularly frequent in cationic complexes. Agostic complexes can
thus be synthesized via protonation of alkene complexes.
Hydrogenations with Wilkinson's catalyst take place stereoselectively in the sense of a syn
addition. If the alkene to be hydrogenated is prochiral, a racemate of two enantiomers forms.
Enantioselective hydrogenations of styrene derivatives were described for the first time by
Leopold Horner and William S. Knowles in 1968 as [RhCl{(S)-(+)-PPhMePr}3]; however, only ee
values up to 15% were obtained.
Enantiomeric excess up to 90% with cationic rhodium complexes [Rh(L2)(S)2] with chiral
diphosphine ligands L2:
Ligands:
No general connection between position of the chirality centers and the catalytic efficiency.
Chirality may be centered at the P atom (DIPAMP), and also at the backbone (DIOP, GLUP;
DuPhos): DIOP was the first efficient P,P chelating ligand (H. Kagan, 1971). Helical chirality with
BINAP. Decisive factors: Form and conformational stability
Olefin mechanism: Acetamido cinnamic acid esters react with cationic rhodium complexes
[Rh(L2)(S)2]+, forming diastereomer complexes.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 86
The Curtin-Hammett principle is the basis for understanding why a conformer present in a low
concentration can be product-determining:
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 87
Metolachlor:
Impressive productivity and activity make the use of iridium catalysts economically viable
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 89
5. Catalytic carbonylations
5.1. Introduction
Linear correlation of the reaction rate with the concentration of rhodium and methyl
iodide, no dependency of the reaction rate from CO pressure and MeOH concentration
Oxidative addition of CH3I as rate-determining step
Mechanism of the oxidative addition of CH3I and the reductive elimination of CH3C(O)I:
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 91
Oxidative addition: SN2 attack by [Rh(CO)2I2] on CH3I (see section 3.2b), reason for good
nucleophilicity: Negative charge of the complex, good donor characteristics of I, 105 times
more reactive than neutral complex [Rh(AsPh3)2(CO)I]
Reductive elimination: Typical reaction path for carboxylic acid derivatives
5.3.1. Introduction
One of the most important homogeneous catalyzed reactions: Approx. 7106 t annually
(approx. 1 kg per person on earth)
Aldehydes: Starting materials for alcohols, carboxylic acids, esters, etc.
Slide: Aldol condensation of n-butyraldehyde and subsequent hydrogenation results in 2-
ethyl-hexane-1-ol Ubiquitous as softener for PVC
Typically high temperatures (120-170 °C) and pressures (syngas H2/CO 1:1, 200-300 atm)
e.g. propene, 1-octene or internal C10 and C12 alkenes SHOP process
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 93
PBu3 in model studies, under technical conditions, phobanes as particularly stable ligands
Stronger Co-CO bond due to stronger backbonding by coordination of the phosphine
ligand More stable complexes; therefore, correspondingly lower CO pressure and
higher temperatures are possible without observing any noteworthy decomposition to
form elementary cobalt.
Higher n:i ratio
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 97
Mechanism: Catalytic system is very complex: Many steps, formation of at least two isomeric
products, many intermediates form several isomers, ...
NMR studies for the reaction with [Rh(CO)2(H)(PPh3)2] as precatalyst (Brown): Two isomers
of [Rh(CO)2(H)(PPh3)2] as resting state (diequatorial:apical-equatorial in the ratio of 85:15);
the equilibrium is reached quickly at room temperature (Berry pseudorotation or turnstile
mechanism)
In situ IR measurements: These two isomers as dominating species under catalysis
conditions for the hydroformylation of 1-octene (60-100 °C, 5-20 bar)
Mechanistic steps are similar to the hydroformylation catalyzed by [Co(H)(CO)4]; however,
there is a larger number of intermediates and of stereoisomers of these intermediates
Migratory alkene insertion, CO insertion and hydrogenolysis of the acyl complex can
proceed both reversibly and irreversibly and controls the stereoselectivity
Kinetically dependent on the reaction conditions
Reaction order under technical conditions (T = 170-210 °C, p(CO/H2) = 5-25 bar, [Rh] 1
M, [alkene] = 0.1-2 M): [Alkene] 1st order, [Rh] zero order, [PR3], [CO] negative reaction
order Conclusion: Migratory insertion of the alkene into the Rh-H bond of
[Rh(alkene)(CO)(H)] as rate-determining step
The ligands have a great influence on selectivity. Consideration: Diphosphines are supposed
to lead to high regioselectivity since [RhH(CO)(PPh3)2] has a high regioselectivity. Simple
diphosphine such as dppe, dppp and dppb, however, are disappointing (n:i 4:1). Better are
selectivities (n:i 5-8:1) with ligands with a large bite angle both P atoms can bind in
equatorial position.
High n:i selectivities with diphosphines with large bite angle, well-known e.g. Xantphos (van
Leeuwen et al.)
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 100
Phosphines are easier to oxidize than amines because the oxidation state +V is more stable
for phosphorus than for nitrogen. Due to this reason, many phosphines, in particular alkyl
phosphines, are very sensitive to air. The less electron-rich aryl phosphines and phosphites
are less sensitive to air than are the alkyl phosphines and are often even air-stable. For air
sensitivity, the steric hindrance of the phosphine also plays a role.
The inversion barrier of phosphorus is considerably higher than with amines: Typically, it is in
the range of 2935 kcal mol1. While chiral amines racemize, P chiral phosphines can usually
be isolated as optically active compounds. The P chiral phosphine PMeCy(o-anis) was part of
the first catalyst for enantioselective alkene hydrogenation. (W.S. Knowles et al., J. Chem. Soc.,
Chem. Commun. 1972, 10; Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl. 2002, 41, 1999).
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 103
PtBu3 and PCy3 are the strongest donors, PF3 is the weakest donor in this selection.
Steric properties: Tolman cone angle
In addition to electronic properties, the steric properties frequently control the reactivity of
organometallic compounds. The steric demand, however, is difficult to quantify. Referring to
this, Tolman coined the term “cone angle” in the 1970s.
Tolman cone angle: Angle defined by the outermost edge of the substituents on phosphorus
and the metal center in a space-filling model. Since there were no computer models, geometry
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 105
optimization etc. at that time, the angle used to be determined by using homemade models
made of wood and a protractor.
Literature for further reading: C. A. Tolman, Chem. Rev. 1977, 77, 313.
Big problem: Separation and recycling of the rhodium catalyst, in particular when the
aldehydes need to be distilled because this will destroy the catalyst. Solution by Kuntz (Rhone-
Poulenc): Water-soluble triarylphosphine catalysts. The reaction is done in a two-phase
system the catalyst in the aqueous phase, products in the organic phase. Propene is
sufficiently water-soluble; long-chain alkenes, however, are not sufficiently soluble in order to
be used effectively in the Rhone-Poulenc process.
Enantioselective hydroformylation has been studied for more than 30 years and have great
synthesis potential for the enantioselective formation of CC bonds. Hydroformylation of vinyl
arenes is of particular interest. The aldehydes that form can easily be oxidized to pain-relieving
drugs such as ibuprofen and naproxen.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 109
Challenges:
Usually, linear products are preferred with hydroformylation - vinyl arenes, vinyl acetates
and alkenes with electron-withdrawing substituents, however, have a strong preference
for the formation of the branched product.
Alkene binds exclusively via the system - no two-point interaction as with many
asymmetrical hydrogenations, which could lead to enantioselectivities that are too high
Phosphine ligands in the trigonal bipyramidal catalyst are located further away from
alkene than with square planar hydrogenation catalysts
Hydroformylation must take place faster than the racemization of the enolizable
stereocenter
Breakthrough: Development of phosphite-phosphine ligands by Nozaki, Takaya et al.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 110
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 114
6. Oxidations
Countless studies have dealt with the mechanism of the Wacker oxidation. The sequence of
the elementary steps during the Wacker oxidation seems to depend on the reaction
conditions. Key question: Formation of the C-O bond through nucleophilic attack of H2O on
the coordinated alkene or insertion of the alkene in an M-OH bond??
Two mechanisms, dependent on the Cl- concentration:
Low Cl- (<1 M) and CuCl2 concentration (<1 M, catalysis conditions): Exclusive formation of
aldehydes
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 115
6.2. Epoxidations
The epoxidation of ethene to ethylene oxide is done on an industrial scale by using oxygen as
oxidizing agent. A heterogeneous silver contact catalyst is used.
Already with propene, direct oxidation no longer works because too many side products result
from the oxidation of the methyl group. Instead, the oxirane process is used. During this
process, an alkane, e.g. isobutane, is converted into tert-Butyl hydroperoxide (TBHP) by using
oxygen. It is catalytically converted with propene to propylene oxide and tert-Butyl alcohol.
Propylene oxide is used to produce glycols, glycol ethers, alkanolamines, polyesters and
urethanes. Production of 3.106 t∙a-1 (2003)
Catalysts for the oxirane process:
Heterogeneous Ti(IV)/SiO2 catalyst (Shell)
Homogeneous molybdenum catalyst (ARCO)
The transfer of the oxygen atom to the propene takes place through direct attack of the
alkene on the electrophilic oxygen atom of an alkyl peroxo complex.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 118
The production of 1 t glycidol requires 200 kg titanium isopropanolate, 150 kg tartrate and
400 kg of molecular sieves. Allyl alcohol, catalyst and solvent are tempered in the reactor at -
20 °C. Cumol hydroperoxide is added slowly with stirring. When the reaction is completed, the
molecular sieves are removed by filtration and the glycidol is extracted with water. The
organic phase is treated with a reducing agent to destroy solvent residues. The aqueous phase
is then concentrated and the glycidol is obtained with a purity of 88-90% by vacuum
distillation.
The Sharpless epoxidation has the disadvantage that it can only be done with allyl alcohols
and not with unsubstituted alkenes. Simple alkenes can best be oxidized by Jacobsen-Katsuki
epoxidation. Cationic manganese(III)-salen complexes serve as catalysts.
In order to perform an asymmetrical Jacobsen epoxidation, chiral salen ligands must be used.
One of the most successful catalysts is the “Jacobsen catalyst” with trans-cyclohexane-1,2-
diamine as salen bridge. This “Jacobsen catalyst” is used in the industry preferably with a two-
phase system: The alkene is dissolved in dichloromethane; an aqueous bleach solution (NaOCl)
serves as oxidizing agent.
Sterically demanding groups are important for high selectivity. The sterically more demanding
alkene residue is thus being positioned on the back of the catalyst.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 119
Mechanism: Spectroscopic and kinetic studies as well as quantum chemical calculations show
that the “lock-and-key principle” is at work in these reactions, i.e. the transition state resulting
from the energetically lowest intermediate with the lowest steric repulsion of catalyst and
substrate leads to the product. This is an important distinction to the rhodium-catalyzed
hydrogenation where the diastereomer, which is present at lower concentrations, leads to the
product.
Asymmetric dihydroxylation is done stoichiometrically with potassium permanganate or
catalytically with osmium tetroxide as oxidizing agents. Osmium tetroxide itself reacts slowly
with alkenes. However, already Criegee found that adding amine ligands accelerates these
reactions (ligand-accelerated catalysis, Sharpless). Enantioselective reactions can be induced
with chiral amines.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 120
Mechanism:
Osmium acid ester as an intermediate stage, which is hydrolyzed with the dissociation of the
cis diol and the formation of Os(OH)2O2. The latter one is oxidized with tert-Butyl
hydroperoxide or N-methylmorpholine N-oxide (NMO) to OsO4. In the enantioselective
variation, naturally occurring cinchona alkaloids from cinchona bark are used as auxiliaries.
In nature: Very high substrate specificity, good regioselectivity and stereoselectivity, mild
conditions, O2 as oxidizing agent.
Common characteristic of various oxygenases is the formation of iron(III)-peroxo species as
intermediate. They can either react directly with the substrate or - as takes place in most cases
- form highly oxidized iron-oxo species, which oxidize the substrate. Biomimetic strategies in
oxidation catalysis aim at generating similar intermediates.
Key publication for independent study:
L. Que Jr., W. B. Tolman, „Biologically inspired oxidation catalysis“, Nature 2008, 455, 333 340.
In the lab: The iron salt/H2O2 system to oxidize organic compounds has already been used in
the 19th century. However, mainly highly unselective reactions, e.g.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 122
Fenton reaction:
Oxidation, catalyzed by iron salts (Fenton's reagent), of organic substrates with hydrogen
peroxide in acidic medium, which was discovered at the end of the 19th century by Henry John
Horstman Fenton. In biological systems, Fenton's reaction is seen as the main source of
reactive oxygen species (ROS) in the cell, which lead to oxidative stress. Also on a large
industrial scale, Fenton's reaction and the production of Fenton's reagent are used. In
addition to synthetic applications, it serves as a very strong oxidizing agent, for example to
treat waste water and seepage water from landfills.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 123
The mechanism resembles the one used for cytochrome P450 and for related heme
peroxidases. Selectivity depends on the ring size - cyclopentene and cyclohexene give
significant amounts of allyl alcohol and enone as side products.
Explanation for the formation of side products: Oxygen rebound mechanism
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 125
Complexes with tetradentate N-donor ligands mimic the non-heme peroxidases. Important
for high catalytic activity: Two cis-oriented, labile coordination sites similar to the Rieske
dioxygenase. At the same time, there is an important difference to the heme proteins where
only one free coordination site is available. The mechanism of such reactions was explained
for catalysts of the [Fe(TPA)L2]X2 type.
Methods and findings of the mechanistic studies:
Spectroscopic studies at low temperature
o FeIII-OOH intermediate at 40 °C intercepted in acetonitrile and characterized by
various spectroscopic techniques mechanistic suggestion: Cleavage of FeIII OOH to
FeV(O)(OH), which reacts with the organic substrate
18O labeling at room temperature supports this mechanistic support
The non-heme iron complex [Fe(OTf)2(Me,HPytacn)] catalyzes the hydroxylation of alkanes and
the cis dihydroxylation of alkenes with H2O2 as oxidizing agent functional model of the non-
heme oxygenases. Isotope labeling and DFT calculations allowed to draw the conclusion that
a FeV(O)(OH) species is responsible for the catalytic activity. An iron(V)-oxo species was
observed earlier with the epoxidation of alkenes with peroxides (L. Que Jr., e. L. Bominaar, E.
Münck, T. C. Collins et al., Science 2007, 315, 835-838).
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 127
Jacobsen:
Example for using acetic acid (30 mol%) as additive for efficient alkene epoxidation
Terminal alkenes can be epoxidized with a yield of up to 90% by using only 3 mol% catalyst
(50% excess H2O2).
Beller:
Enantioselective catalyst with high ee's and very high yields
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 130
Generating the catalyst in situ from FeCl3, chiral ligands and two equiv. pyridine-2,5-
dicarboxylic acid
No enlightening insights into the mechanism so far!
Iron catalysts can also be used to hydroxylate hydrocarbons. Classical test systems are
cyclohexane and adamantane, but also complex substrates with tertiary CH bonds can be
selectively hydrated.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 131
Literature
Excellent overview: “Bioinspired Nonheme Iron Catalysts for C−H and C=C Bond
Oxidation: Insights into the Nature of the Metal-Based Oxidants”, W. N. Oloo, L. Que, Jr. Acc.
Chem. Res. 2015, 48, 2612−2621.
7. Metathesis
7.1.1. Introduction
The metathesis of olefins is a catalytic reaction during which a redistribution of the alkylidene
groups takes place by the scission and regeneration of double bonds.
Answer: While preserving orbital symmetry, there is no direct way from the ground state of
the ethene molecules to the ground state of the cyclobutane. For thermal reaction control, a
very high barrier must be overcome due to the symmetry. Thus, the reaction is symmetry
forbidden.
7.1.3. Catalysts
The Hoveyda-Grubbs catalyst was originally developed for immobilization, but has proven to
be particularly successful. Advantages:
Absence of phosphine ligand, which can take part in decomposition reactions
Particularly stable thermally; therefore, higher reaction temperatures are possible
Numerous modifications are possible (works by Blechert, Grela and others)
Immobilized catalysts (Schrock, Coperet, Basset) are also particularly successful:
Isolated metal atoms no dimerization as important deactivation path possible
Asymmetric environment favors higher activity because the electronic requirements of
carbene intermediates and metallacyclic structures are best met low barriers for [2+2]
and retro-[2+2] addition steps
Silica is usually used as carrier material; binding occurs via protonation of reactive alkyl or
pyrrole residue through the OH groups of the carrier material
Up to 10x higher turnover frequencies for the immobilized catalyst
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 138
7.1.4. Mechanism
The mechanism of the alkene metathesis is a result of [2+2] cycloadditions and [2+2]
cycloreversions.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 142
The mechanism of the [2+2] reactions was studied in detail with both Schrock and Grubbs
complexes. In general: At first, there is the coordination of the alkene, then the [2+2]
cycloaddition to the metallacyclobutane, followed by [2+2] cycloreversion and dissociation of
the new alkene.
Mechanism of the [2+2] cycloadditions, taking the Grubbs catalyst as an example:
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 143
Because the [2+2] and retro-[2+2] additions are reversible, the principle of microscopic
reversibility needs to be considered. This principle would be violated if the intermediates and
transition states existed only as square pyramidal complexes. In this hypothetical case, the
[2+2] and retro-[2+2] reactions cannot take place via the same intermediates and transition
states. Therefore, at least one intermediate or transition state must possess a trigonal
bipyramidal structure.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 145
An important “complication”: Intermediates with the alkene in cis position to the carbene
ligand have a similar, sometimes even lower energy as compared to the trans isomers.
The metallacyclobutane intermediates were detected in several studies, and their dynamic
behavior and their reaction behavior were analyzed. Piers and Romero succeeded in
synthesizing a ruthenacyclobutane at low temperature and in doing an NMR spectroscopic
characterization:
Use of 13C marked ethene shows that the C atoms are replaced both in and in position
Energy barriers for the replacement are NMR spectroscopically determined
Replacement is done without dissociation of the alkene
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 146
The mechanism of the alkene metathesis, which is catalyzed by Schrock complexes, was
studied for a complex with perfluorinated tert-butanolate ligands. The reaction mechanism
takes place via [2+2] cycloadditions, which require the coordination of the alkene similar to
the Grubbs complexes. Due to this reason, five or six times coordinated molybdenum and
tungsten complexes are inactive in metathesis. Pseudo-tetrahedral complexes are, however,
active catalysts. The syn isomer is more stable than the anti isomer because the carbene-
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 147
hydrogen atom can form an agostic interaction (hyperconjugation C-H*Mo-N) with the metal
atom in the first case. This also shows in the structure in a larger Mo-C-C bond angle (higher
triple bond character of the Mo=C bond). This stabilization gets lost when the alkene is
coordinated. Therefore, the anti isomer reacts about 1,000 times faster than the syn isomer.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 148
Kinetic studies with Grubbs catalysts lead to additional important mechanistic findings.
Consideration regarding the mechanism:
The starting complex is a 16e complex; however, 14e intermediates play a crucial role
Faster ligand dissociation of the ligand enables a faster reaction rate
Ligand L', which is left behind, is supposed to encourage [2+2] addition and to make it
harder for the dissociated L to coordinate again
Conclusions:
1. Weakly donating and sterically demanding ligands increase the reaction rate because they
dissociate more easily
2. N-heterocyclic carbenes make the dissociation of PCy3 harder by two units, but make [2+2]
cycloaddition easier
3. The k2/k-1 ratio (cycloaddition vs. reassociation) is about four units better than when using
tricyclohexylphosphine or triphenylphosphine. The acceleration of the reaction when
using an N-heterocyclic carbene in the Grubbs II catalyst thus results from the strong
acceleration of the [2+2] cycloaddition.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 149
8. Olefin Oligomerization
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 150
Ziegler and co-workers (MPI for Coal Research, Mülheim/Ruhr) found that the reaction of
triethylaluminium with ethene (90−120 °C, 100 bar) affords long-chain alkyl aluminium
species. β-Hydride elimination occurs at higher temperatures (320 °C) leading to α-olefins and
aluminium hydrides. AlEt3 is regenerated by ethene insertion into Al−H bonds.
The Aufbau reaction was coupled with an oxidation generating aluminium alcoholates that
were directly converted into fatty alcohols. This process is merely of historical interest
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 151
The dimerization of ethene is also catalyzed by nickel(II) compounds in the presence of alkyl
aluminium co-catalysts. Nickel(II) hydride complexes are the catalytically active species.
Wilke and Bogdanovic investigate the mechanism of nickel(II)-catalyzed olefin dimerization
using nickel(II) allyl halide complexes as precatalysts. Ethen coordination, insertion and β-
hydride elimination afford a nickel(II) hydride chloride species. The selectivity of the reaction
can be modified by the phosphane. The highest selectivity for dimerization was achieved with
PR3 = PMe3. More sterically demanding phosphanes lead to higher oligomers, because
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 152
The catalytic cycle involves coordination and insertion of ethene into an Ni−H bond and β-
hydride elimination. All reaction steps are reversible except for ethene insertion into the Ni−C
bond of a nickel(II) alkyl intermediate. Aluminium alkyl compounds serve as Lewis acid,
forming [AlEtCl2Br]− anions which may serve as hemilabile ligands.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 153
Nickel-catalyzed butene formation may also occur via a nickel(0)-based mechanism involving
metallocyclopentane intermediates. A co-catalyst is not required in this case. However, the
activity of the catalyst is low.
Moreover, Wilke’s nickel(II) catalyst also catalyzes propene dimerization.
The structure of the products is determined by the phosphanes used. Branched dimer
(2,3-dimethylbutene) is favored by sterically highly demanding phosphanes. The catalysts are
extremely active (TOF = 2.1·108 propene / mol Ni · h): 150 t product / g Ni · h can be formed!
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 154
This reaction is important because 1-hexene is needed as a co-monomer for the synthesis of
LLDPE. Titanium and chromium catalysts are used.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 155
Linear α-olefins have various uses. Short chain olefins (C4‒C8) are co-monomers for the
production of polyethylene (LLDPE) and other polymers. α-Olefins with an intermediate chain
length (C8‒C12) are used for producing synthetic lubricants, while those with a chain length of
C12‒C18 are used for the synthesis of detergents and cleaning agents.
The Shell Higher Olefin Process (SHOP) involves the oligomerization of ethylene by
homogeneous nickel catalysts. SHOP is a process for producing linear α-olefins (C12‒C18) from
ethene. This process can be coupled with hydroformylation for the synthesis of aldehydes and
alcohols. SHOP is a combination of oligomerization, isomerization and metathesis.
SHOP involves the oligomerization of ethene by nickel catalysts in solvents such as butane-
1,4-diol at 80‒120 °C and 7‒14 MPa. The resulting linear α-olefins are immiscible with the
solvent. This leads to a biphasic system where the product can be separated conveniently
through a simple phase separation process (biphasic catalysis). The olefins are separated into
three molecular weight ranges by distillation: C4-C8, C10-C18, and >C19. The lighter and the
heavier fractions are then isomerized to a mixture of internal olefins over a heterogeneous
catalyst. The lighter and the heavier fractions of the resulting internal olefins are then
recombined over a heterogeneous olefin metathesis catalyst (MoO3/Al2O3). Linear C4 to C10+
olefins are obtained selectively (99% linear olefins, 1‒2% internal olefins). Anionic nickel
complexes with P,O-ligands are used as catalysts.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 157
relative rates is called Schultz-Flory distribution and obeys the following quantitative
relationship:
K = [Cn+2]/[Cn] = 1/(1 + β)
β…is the relative rate for chain transfer and propagation
Olefin polymerization occurs when when chain transfer is much slower than chain growth.
Olefin oligomerization occurs when chain transfer occurs at rates similar to chain growth.
Olefin dimerization occurs when chain termination occurs after every insertion. Trimerization
typically occurs by a mechanism that is distinct from dimerization, oligomerization, or
polymerization.
Real olefin mixtures from oligomerization reactions mainly contain olefins with short chain
lengths. The longer the olefin chain length the shorter is its molar fraction in the mixture.
Isomerization and olefin metathesis are used to modify the α-olefin product distribution in a
desirable way. These processes afford a mixture of internal olefins (including olefins with an
uneven number of C atoms) with desired chain lengths, that directly converted into
n-aldehydes by hydroformylation. The desired fraction, e.g C10‒C14, can be isolated by
distillation.
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 159
Dimerization is achieved by the presence of a phosphane ligand. The ratio dimer/trimer can
be controlled by the steric properties of the P donor. The ratio COD:DVCB is strongly
influenced by the electronic properties of the ligand on nickel. COD is an important
intermediate in the chemical industry.
The reaction is catalyzed by butadiene complexes of nickel(0) that are void of any other ligands
(‘naked’ nickel). The catalyst are preferably formed by reducing nickel(II) precursors such as
Ni(acac)2 with AlEt2(OEt) in the presence of butadiene, by reductive elimination from nickel(II)
allyl complexes or from nickel(0) precursors such as [Ni(cod)2].
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 161
9. Polymerization
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 164
Herrmann Staudinger developed the basic understanding of synthetic polymers in the 1920s
(Staudinger received the Nobel prize in 1953.) The first industrial processes for polymer
production were developed in the 1930s: synthetic rubber, radical polymerization of vinyl
chloride, vinyl acetate and styrene.
There are four basic mechanisms for polymerizations, which are named according the the
natur of the reactive intermediates:
1) Radical Polymerization are started by a radical initiator.
2) Cationic Polymerizations are initiated by Brønsted or Lewis acids.
3) Anionic polymerizations of dienes or vinyl compounds with acceptor groups are initiated
by by bases such as sodium amide and alkyl lithiums.
4) Coordinative polymerizations. Transition metal complexes serve as catalysts.
Polyethylenes produced from different catalysts can have different structures. Polyethylene
materials can contain branches from side reactions or the incorporation of comonomers. High-
density polyethylene (HPDPE) is strictly linear polyethylene. Low-density polyethylene (LDPE)
contains extensive branching along the polymer chain and “branches on branches”. Linear
low-density polyethylene (LLDPE) is a linear polymer prepared from ethylene and an α-olefin
that creates a material possessing a small number of branches.
crystalline than LDPE. Many transition metal catalysts polymerize ethylene to form HDPE, but
few catalysts match the activity of the heterogeneous titanium systems, particularly
considering the low cost of the Ziegler catalysts.
Titanium catalysts can contain TiIII or TiIV. Classical Ziegler catalysts are based on the formation
of solid TiCl3 via the reduction of TiCl4 with AlEt3 in petroleum. TiCl3 precipitates as a fibery
solid. The co-catalysts AlEt3 alkylates TiCl3 at the surface. Thereby Lewis acidic AlClxEt3-x (x =
0,1,2) are formed. The catalyst is a heterogeneous catalyst with typical organometallic species
on a surface.
Homogeneous catalysts act via a similar mechanism. TiIII or TiIV species are involved. The first
homogeneous system was already presented by Breslow in the late 1950s. The active species
is a TiIV species in this case. Subsequently, investigations on related cationic zirconium species
showed that cationic complexes of type [ZrCp2P]+ (P = polymer chain) are the catalytically
active species. Thus, weakly Lewis basic anions are required that do not interfere with olefin
coordination. Frequently used anions are [B(C6F5)4]- and [MAO-Me]-. The latter is obtained
from the commercially used co-catalyst methylaluminoxane (MAO).
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 168
Isotactic PPP is formed when the alkene always coordinates through the Re and the Si face of
the polymer. Syndiotactic insertion is formed by alternating insertion into the Re and the Si
face. Stereoselective Polymerization requires asymmetric induction. Thereby, either the last
asymmetric C atom form is stereoregulating (chain end control) and/or a chiral catalyst
complex (enantiomorphic site control).
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 170
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 171
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 172
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 173
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 174
Prof. Dr. Robert Wolf, Organotransition Metal Chemistry and Catalysis WS 2017/18 175