KXGX 6101: Research Methodology

Session 2014-2015, Semester 2

Student Information

Name :

Matric No. :

Rubric for Proposal Presentation Evaluation

Very Poor Poor Satisfactory Good Excellent
Marks Marks
Item Criteria
(Marks: <4) (Marks: In (Marks: 6) (Marks: In (Marks: In Allocated Obtained
between 4 to6) between 6 to 8) between 8 to 10)
Totally irrelevant Poor Overall good Fairly good Comprehensive
background. background. background. background. background.

Problem is not Problem is Problem Problem Problem is very

Background 10
defined and out vaguely defined definition is definition is clear.
of context. and out of moderately clear. clear.
context.

Justification/ Not justified at Poorly justified. Average Good justification. Very well
Content
Problem all. justification. justified. 10
Statement
Vague. Poor. Good but little Fairly good. Very precise and
modification clear.
Too general. Not specific. required. Specific.
Specific.
Scope/ Not achievable. Not achievable. Specific. Achievable but
need Achievable. 10
Objectives
Achievable but modification.
need
modification.

Not relevant at Somewhat Relevant. Fairly relevant. Highly relevant

Proposed all with the relevant with the with the 10
Methodology objectives. objectives. objective.

Not clear at all Little clarity. Clear but can be Fairly clear. Very clear
Clarity improved. No confusion 10

Not well Little organized. Organized but Fairly organized. Very well
Organization organized at all. can be improved. organized. 10

Very poor Moderate Good Very good Extraordinary

presentation. presentation presentation presentation presentation
skill. skill. skill. skill.
Presentation Very poorly
Skill organized. Not well Very well
organized. organized.
Delivery Disjointed 10
presentation Rambled, Very
dwelt too long professional.
on less
important
aspects.

Slides of very Some slides Acceptably clear Well thought Slides

poor quality. are difficult to slides. out slides. outstanding.
read.
Slides 10
Typos and
other errors in
slides.

Exceed 15 min. Within 15 Within 15 min. Within 15 Within 15 min.

Time or less than 7 min. several but rushed min. completed as 10
min. points left out. through. planned.

Unable to answer Had difficulty Able to answer Question(s) Question(s)

Question and question(s). answering question(s) answered with answered with
- question(s). without elaboration. elaboration and 10
Answer
elaboration. able to relate to
project.

TOTAL 100

Name of Moderator :

Signature :