Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
The use of point load test for Dubai weak calcareous sandstones
Amr Farouk Elhakim*
Department of Public Works, Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University, Giza, Egypt
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Intact rock is typically described according to its uniaxial compressive strength (UCS). The UCS is
Received 15 December 2014 needed in the design of geotechnical engineering problems including stability of rock slopes and
Received in revised form design of shallow and deep foundations resting on and/or in rocks. Accordingly, a correct measure-
9 April 2015
ment/evaluation of the UCS is essential to a safe and economic design. Typically, the UCS is measured
Accepted 5 June 2015
Available online 25 June 2015
using the unconfined compression tests performed on cylindrical intact specimens with a minimum
length to width ratio of 2. In several cases, especially for weak and very weak rocks, it is not possible to
extract intact specimens with the needed minimum dimensions. Thus, alternative tests (e.g. point load
Keywords:
Point load test
test, Schmidt hammer) are used to measure rock strength. The UCS is computed based on the results of
Uniaxial compressive strength (UCS) these tests through empirical correlations. The literature includes a plethora of these correlations that
Rock characteristic elastic modulus vary widely in estimating rock strength. Thus, it is paramount to validate these correlations to check
Dubai calcareous sandstone their suitability for estimating rock strength for a specific location and geology. A review of the
Calcarenite available correlations used to estimate the UCS from the point load test results is performed and
summarized herein. Results of UCS, point load strength index and Young’s modulus are gathered for
calcareous sandstone specimens extracted from the Dubai area. A correlation for estimating the UCS
from the point load strength index is proposed. Furthermore, the Young’s modulus is correlated to the
UCS.
Ó 2015 Institute of Rock and Soil Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences. Production and hosting by
Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction weathered rock masses. Furthermore, the point load test is simpler
and more economical compared to the UCS test.
The uniaxial compressive strength (UCS) of rock is the most
commonly used parameter in the characterization of intact rock. It
is needed for different applications including the design of foun- 2. The point load test
dations resting on and/or in rocks and the stability of rock slopes.
The UCS is typically determined from the axial loading of uncon- The point load test gradually applies a concentrated compres-
fined intact rock specimens. The uniaxial compression test should sive force using conical platens on the rock specimen until it fails by
be performed on cylindrical specimens with a length to width ratio splitting. The loading system consists of a loading frame, a hy-
of 2e2.5. The standard specimen height should range between draulic jack, and a pressure gauge. The test can be conducted in the
100 mm and 300 mm. The specimen ends perpendicular to the field or in the laboratory. The failure load is recorded and used to
cylinder axis should be flat, smooth and parallel as per ASTM calculate the point load strength index Is, according to the following
(2008a). Alternatively, the UCS may be estimated using the point equation (ASTM, 2008b):
load test, which is conducted on specimens in the form of cores, .
blocks or irregular pieces with a diameter of 30 mm and 85 mm, Is ¼ Pult D2e (1)
respectively (ASTM, 2008b). The point load test is especially useful
when core specimens cannot be extracted from fractured or where Pult is the failure load (N), and De is the equivalent core
diameter (mm).
It has been found that the point load strength index depends on
the specimen size (Thuro and Plinninger, 2001). According to ASTM
* Tel.: þ20 1111921320. (2008b), the standard specimen diameter D is 50 mm. However, it
E-mail address: aelhakim@hotmail.com. may not always be possible to obtain specimens having a 50 mm in
Peer review under responsibility of Institute of Rock and Soil Mechanics, Chi- diameter (Brook, 1980). Therefore, it is common to perform the test
nese Academy of Sciences.
1674-7755 Ó 2015 Institute of Rock and Soil Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sci-
on specimens of different sizes and determine the point load strength
ences. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. index Is. The size is corrected to obtain the value of Is which would
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jrmge.2015.06.003 have been measured by a diametrical test with D ¼ 50 mm and is
A.F. Elhakim / Journal of Rock Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering 7 (2015) 452e457 453
given the symbol Is50 (ASTM, 2008b). Several correction schemes for 4. Mechanical and chemical characteristics of Dubai
size have been developed over the years since the beginning of the calcareous sandstone
point load test (e.g. Broch and Franklin, 1972; Brook, 1985; Thuro and
Plinninger, 2001; ASTM, 2008b). The specimen size correction pro- Boreholes were drilled at a number of sites at Dubai in the
posed by ASTM (2008b) is implemented in this paper. United Arab Emirates. Rock samples were extracted using a double
tube core barrel headed with diamond bit, producing a nominal
3. Geology of Dubai in the United Arab Emirates core diameter of 76 mm. The boreholes extended into the rock at a
depth of approximately 8 m (approximately 13 to 21 DMD
The near-surface geology of the United Arab Emirates can be (Dubai Municipality Datum)). Chemical testing of 21 specimens
divided into two groups: lower formation or ‘Solid Geology’ and shows that the calcium carbonate (CaCO3) contents vary between
upper formation or ‘Superficial Geology’. The Superficial Geology 50.62% and 93.57% with an average of 71.32%.
comprises beach dune sands, marine sands and silts. The Solid According to ARGEMA classification of carbonate formations
Geology is composed of alternating beds of calcarenite/calcareous shown in Table 1 (Le Tirant and Nauroy, 1994), cemented forma-
sandstone with some carbonate sand bands, gypsiferous sandstone tions with carbonate contents higher than 30% are defined as soft to
with cemented sand layers, and calcisiltite and siltstone, from the hard carbonate rock. For geomaterials with calcium carbonate
top down (Beau et al., 2008). A geological map of the general contents lower than 30%, the material performs as a silicate.
location under investigation is presented in Fig. 1, which shows the Accordingly, it is warranted to describe such materials as “car-
expected stratigraphy of the coastal areas of Dubai (Alsharhan and bonate rock” (Le Tirant and Nauroy, 1994).
Kendall, 2003). It consists of Quaternary marine, aeolian, sabkha The unconfined compressive strength is generally considered as
and fluvial deposits that lie on the top of aeolianite and marine the reference value for the compressive strength which is typically
calcarenite (Ghayathi formation) which overlay the Barzman for- measured using uninstrumented uniaxial compression tests
mation that is comprised of fluvial sediments characterized by (ASTM, 2002a). The recorded values of the unconfined compressive
poorly sorted conglomerates (Macklin et al., 2012). The rocks strengths varied between 0.13 MPa and 15.75 MPa. Thus, the tested
considered in this study belong to the Ghayathi formation rock specimens were classified as weak to very weak ones ac-
described as marine calcarenite. cording to Mayne et al. (2001).
Sharjah
Dubai
Area under study
in this paper
10 km
Fig. 1. Geological map of the United Arab Emirates showing the area under study (Alsharhan and Kendall, 2003).
454 A.F. Elhakim / Journal of Rock Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering 7 (2015) 452e457
Table 2
Correlations between the point load strength index Is and the UCS.
Hard strong rock qu ¼ 24Is50 Broch and Franklin (1972), Gneiss qu ¼ 16.656Is50 þ 21.7 for Cha et al. (2007)
Bieniawski (1975) qu ¼ 29e209.3 MPa
Calcarenites of the qu ¼ 12.2Is50 Beake and Suttcliffe (1980) All rock types qu ¼ 24Is50 ASTM (2008b)
Arabian-Persian Gulf
Calcarenites of the qu ¼ 3.1Is50 Puech et al. (1988) Limestone of Imgye qu ¼ 26Is50 Kim et al. (2012)
Arabian-Persian Gulf area, Korea
All rock types qu ¼ 25Is50 Egyptian Code for Soil Quartzite qu ¼ 22.8Is50 for Singh et al. (2012)
Mechanics, Design, qu ¼ 32.5e98.9 MPa
and Construction of
Foundations (2001)
Mudstones qu ¼ 21.431Is50 for Kahraman (2001) Sandstone qu ¼ 21.9Is50 for
qu ¼ 2e115 MPa qu ¼ 17.6e56.4 MPa
Innsbruck quartz phyllite qu ¼ 19.9Is50 Thuro and Plinninger (2001) Shale qu ¼ 14.4Is50 for
(perpendicular to foliation) qu ¼ 9.9e18.8 MPa
All rock types qu ¼ 18.7Is50 Gabbro qu ¼ 14.4Is50 for
qu ¼ 17.3e137 MPa
Tuffs qu ¼ 22Is50 þ 49 for Kim et al. (2004) Limestone qu ¼ 22.3Is50 for
qu ¼ 80.4e208 MPa qu ¼ 86.9e129.8 MPa
Limestones, marlstones and 1:71
qu ¼ 7:3Is50 Tsiambaos and Sabatakakis Meta-siltstone and qu ¼ (20e21)Is50 Li and Wong (2013)
sandstones (2004) meta-sandstone
Limestones, marlstones and qu ¼ 23Is50 All rock types qu ¼ 9.459Is50 Salah et al. (2014)
sandstones
Sedimentary rocks 1:71
qu ¼ 7:3Is50 Min and Moon (2006) All rock types 0:75
qu ¼ 9:459Is50
for Is50 > 3.5 MPa
and qu ¼ 2.1e254 MPa
Dandot sandstone, Sakkessar qu ¼ 11.076Is50 Akram and Bakar (2007) Very weak rock qu ¼ 5.833sqrt (0.57Is50) Salah et al. (2014)
sandstone, marl
Sandstone, mudstone, qu ¼ 18.11Is50 for Diamantis et al. (2009) Weak rock qu ¼ 5.414exp(0.57Is50)
and shale qu ¼ 23.1e173.9 MPa
Conglomerate qu ¼ 5.4Is50 Elkateb (2009) All crystalline gypsum qu ¼ (11.08e11.24)Is50
Sandstone qu ¼ 6.2Is50 All mudstone qu ¼ 6.05sqrt (Is50)
Siltstone qu ¼ 8.6Is50 Very weak sandstone qu ¼ 5.679sqrt (Is50)
Limestone qu ¼ 6.5Is50
A.F. Elhakim / Journal of Rock Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering 7 (2015) 452e457 455
Fig. 3. Correlation between the point load strength index and UCS for Dubai calcareous
sandstone (linear correlation with zero intercept). Fig. 4. Characteristic elastic modulus versus the UCS of Dubai calcareous sandstone.
456 A.F. Elhakim / Journal of Rock Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering 7 (2015) 452e457
higher deformation before fracturing compared to rock specimens correlations for different rock types because of the large variation in
with higher modulus ratios (Tziallas et al., 2009). the published correlations. Using “generic” correlations could lead
A best fit linear equation is used to represent the relationship to unrealistic evaluations of rock strength and deformation
between the rock elastic modulus and UCS, as presented in Fig. 5, parameters.
yielding the following relationship:
Kim HG, Koh YK, Oh KH. A study on the mechanical properties of the cretaceous Thuro K, Plinninger RJ. Scale effects in rock properties. Part 2: point load test and
tuffs in Goheung area. The Journal of Engineering Geology 2004;14(3):273e85 point load strength index. In: Rock mechanicsea challenge for society, pro-
(in Korean). ceedings of the ISRM regional symposium EuroRock 2001. CRC Press; 2001.
Kim GM, Kim DH, Kang JS, Kang SS, Baek H. A study of the correlation between p. 175e80.
uniaxial compressive strength and point load strength index of limestone of Tsiambaos G, Sabatakakis N. Considerations on strength of intact sedimentary
Imgye area. Tunnel and Underground Space 2012;22(5):330e8 (in Korean). rocks. Engineering Geology 2004;72(3e4):261e73.
Kulhawy FH, Prakoso WA. Foundations in carbonate rocks and karst. In: Brandon TL, Tziallas GP, Tsiambaos G, Sarglou H. Determination of rock strength and deform-
editor. Foundations and ground improvement. Reston, USA: American Society ability of intact rocks. Electronic Journal of Geotechnical Engineering 2009;14:
of Civil Engineers (ASCE); 2001. p. 1e15. 1e12.
Le Tirant P, Nauroy JF. Design guides for offshore structures: foundations in car-
bonate soils. Technip Editions; 1994.
Li D, Wong LNY. Point load test on meta-sedimentary rocks and correlation to UCS
and BTS. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering 2013;46(4):889e96.
Macklin S, Ellison R, Manning J, Farrant A, Lorenti L. Engineering geological char-
acterisation of the Barzaman Formation, with reference to coastal Dubai, UAE. Dr. Amr Farouk Elhakim is an assistant professor at the
Bulletin of Engineering Geology and the Environment 2012;71(1):1e19. Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University. In July 1995, he
Mayne PW, Christopher BC, DeJong J. Manual on subsurface investigationseNa- earned his B.Sc. in Civil Engineering with honors degree.
tional Highway Institute Publication No. FHWA NHI-01-031. Washington, DC, He worked as a teaching / research assistant in the Soil
USA: Federal Highway Administration; 2001. Mechanics and Foundations Research Laboratory of Cairo
Min TK, Moon JK. A review of strength estimation method on Ulsan sedimentary University. In the same year, he enrolled for a Masters
rocks. Journal of the Korean Geotechnical Society 2006;22(8):63e75 (in Korean). program in Geotechnical Engineering in Cairo University,
Puech A, Beuce JP, Colliat JL. Advances in the design of piles driven into non- where he earned his M.Sc. in July 1998. He then joined the
cemented to weakly cemented carbonate formations. In: Proceedings of the Geosystems Engineering Group at Georgia Tech, where he
International Conference on Calcareous Sediments, Vol. 1; 1988. p. 305e12. worked under the supervision of Prof. Paul W. Mayne. In
Perth, Australia. May 2001, he earned another Masters in Geotechnical
Salah H, Omar M, Shanableh A. Estimating unconfined compressive strength of Engineering from Georgia Tech. He then finished his Ph.D
sedimentary rocks in United Arab Emirates from point load strength index. in Summer 2005 from the same university. He has several
Journal of Applied Mathematics and Physics 2014;2:296e303. publications in the fields of in-situ testing, deep excava-
Singh TN, Kainthola A, Venkatesh A. Correlation between point load index and tions, design of axially and laterally loaded piles, displacements of shallow foundations
uniaxial compressive strength for different rock types. Rock Mechanics and and the use of small strain soil modulus in foundation design. Furthermore, he has
Rock Engineering 2012;45(2):259e64. worked in geotechnical consulting in several projects.