Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Generation and
Management in the
Middle East and North
Africa (MENA) Region:
Algeria as a Case Study
Electronic waste (e-waste) show that high amounts
What Happens to
is one of the fastest grow- of computer and monitor
ing waste streams in the waste were registered for the
Obsolete Equipment
world. Notwithstanding period from 2014 to 2016.
increasing concern world-
(and What Should
wide, e-waste has not yet Introduction
been discussed in depth in Electronic waste, often
Happen to It)?
the Middle East and North called e-waste, is among the
Africa (MENA) region. This study first re- fastest growing waste streams in the world.
views the literature regarding the estimation During the past decades, several developing
of e-waste in the MENA region. It then gives countries have experienced changes in their
an estimate of the past and future trends in lifestyles due to notable economic growth.
the generation of obsolete computers in Al- This situation has driven the use of elec-
geria. For this purpose, the study combines tronic equipment, both in households and
two models: the Carnegie Mellon model in the business sector. An increasing num-
and the market supply (distribution delay) ber of electrical and electronic devices are
model. The Carnegie Mellon model offers entering the market in both developed and
the following options for obsolete computers
and monitors: the device could be reused,
stored, or discarded. The amounts of devices
falling into each category were determined Karima Hamouda
based on these options. The outcomes from
the market supply (distribution delay) model Rachid Adjroudi
6 / Summer 2017 / Environmental Quality Management / DOI 10.1002/tqem Karima Hamouda and Rachid Adjroudi
Exhibit 1. Status of E-Waste Management in Some MENA Countries (Based on Baldé et al. 2015; Madar,
2012)
Algeria Egypt Jordan Morocco Saudi Arabia Tunisia
Electronic Waste Generation and Management in MENA Environmental Quality Management / DOI 10.1002/tqem / Summer 2017 / 7
accurate data about the amounts and types of Data Collection
e-waste generated. Only a few studies about Data regarding imports of computers were
e-wastes were available in respect to the re- collected and analyzed for the period from
gion (Fraige et al., 2012; Ikhlayel & Tasaki, 2000 to 2014. Data on imported desktops
2015; Laissaoui & Rochat, 2008). Providing and laptops were obtained from the Algerian
data on the quantities of e-waste that are gen- National Centre of Informatics and Statis-
erated will help decision makers set the right tics (CNIS), whereas data on CRT and FPD
strategy to: monitors were extracted from the United Na-
tions International Trade Statistics Database
(COMTRADE).
• Collect and treat e-waste,
• Reduce the volume that goes to disposal,
and Questionnaire Survey
• Tackle the informal treatment of e-waste. The useful life and the fate of obsolete
products were the main focus of the ques-
tionnaire. Data on consumer behavior and
This paper is the first study on this topic the fate of obsolete computers and monitors
in Algeria, and it attempts to bridge the gap were obtained primarily through face-to-face
between the lack of interviews and field visits. An initial round of
This paper is the first study on
availability of data mail-based questionnaires and telephone in-
this topic in Algeria, and it
and the need to terviews did not bring any useable results, as
attempts to bridge the gap
assess e-waste. Fur- the response rate was very low. To collect rep-
between the lack of availability
thermore, this study resentative samples, questionnaires were sent
of data and the need to assess
provides an overview to different cities in the country, with an em-
e-waste.
of the e-waste situ- phasis on big cities. Questionnaires were also
ation in the MENA region and proposes sent randomly to different companies.
a methodology to estimate computer In total, 452 questionnaires were com-
and monitor waste generation in Algeria. pleted. The survey questionnaire covered the
life cycle of computers and monitors from
purchase to final disposal.
Materials and Methods
This study focuses only on desktop com-
puters, laptops, cathode ray tube (CRT) mon- Estimates of Computer and Monitor Lifespans
itors, and flat panel display (FPD) monitors Determining lifespan is more compli-
generated in Algeria. Generally, to estimate cated for computers than for other electronic
the amount of e-waste that is generated, sales products. For personal computers, the useful
figures of electronic products are required. lifespan has been decreasing rapidly (Kang &
This approach is not applicable in Algeria, Schoenung, 2006).
however, due to the fact that sales data are
not publically available. In the absence of ■ Carnegie Mellon Model
reliable official statistics, import data were To use the Carnegie Mellon model, de-
considered in this study as an alternative. termining average computer lifespans is re-
The methodology was performed according quired. The average lifespan of the first user
to the steps shown in Exhibit 2. was extracted from the survey. However, no
8 / Summer 2017 / Environmental Quality Management / DOI 10.1002/tqem Karima Hamouda and Rachid Adjroudi
Exhibit 2. A Summary of the Estimation Methodology Used in This Study
data were available on the average lifespan of exist that provide the same value if accurate
the equipment as used by second users. and reliable data are available. In this study,
According to the survey, the substitution normal distribution was used. The obsoles-
of computers is made owing to technological cence rate is described by Equation (1), where
obsolescence rather than functional obso- 𝜇 is the average lifetime and 𝜎 is the standard
lescence. Thus, for purposes of our study, deviation:
we assumed that all computers are reused ( )
1 1 x−𝜇 2
(second use) for at least 2 years and then f (t) = e− (1)
𝜎 (2𝜋) 2 𝜎
stored for 2 years, as well, as computers are
seen as sources of revenue (see the table in Product lifespans using this model are shown
Exhibit 3). In the case of businesses and in- in Exhibit 4.
stitutions, computer equipment was usually
Use of Carnegie Mellon Model
sold through auctions.
The Carnegie Mellon model is applied in
this first part of the study with some modi-
■ Market Supply (Distribution Delay) Model fications as shown in Exhibits 3 and 5. Ac-
For the market supply (distribution delay) cording to the survey, three options are avail-
model, lifespan is variable, and its parame- able to owners who must deal with e-waste
ters are derived from the survey mentioned equipment. First, the owner can sell it to an-
previously. According to the market supply other person to reuse the complete equip-
model, lifespan is defined as the time period ment or working components; second, the
limited to products in use and it does not owner can store it at home (for institutions
include products that are stored unused. Ac- and businesses, they sell them through auc-
cording to the literature, different methods tions after a period a storage). The third pos-
to estimate a product’s lifetime distribution sibility is to discard the equipment. Of these
Electronic Waste Generation and Management in MENA Environmental Quality Management / DOI 10.1002/tqem / Summer 2017 / 9
Exhibit 3. End-of-Life e-Waste Disposal Percentage
Desktop Laptop CRT monitor FPD monitor
options, storage is the most important flow where St equals the total stored devices by
due to the lack of take-back systems. Accord- the first user and the second user, P2 repre-
ing to the available data and the assumptions sents the percentage of stored units that are
above, Equations (2)–(4) are used to calcu- deemed obsolete by the first user, P4 is equal
late the amount of computers to be reused, to the percentage of storage by the second
stored, and discarded. user, and Lr is the average lifespan of reused
computer.
Rut = P1 × (Ot − L Import) (2)
Dat = [P3 × (Ot − L Import)] (4)
where Rut is the total amount of reused items
in the year t, P1 denotes the percentage of ob- + [P2 × P6 × (Ot − L − Lr Import)]
solete, reused devices in the year t. Ot−L Im-
+ [P1 × P5 × (Ot − L − Ls Import)]
port is the number of obsolete items disposed
of in the year t, which were purchased in the + [P1 × P4 × P6 × (Ot − L − Lr
year t-L. L is the average lifespan.
− Ls Import)]
10 / Summer 2017 / Environmental Quality Management / DOI 10.1002/tqem Karima Hamouda and Rachid Adjroudi
Exhibit 5. Schematic Presentation of Generic End-of-Life Model to Predict Computer
Waste in Algeria
Electronic Waste Generation and Management in MENA Environmental Quality Management / DOI 10.1002/tqem / Summer 2017 / 11
Exhibit 6. Amount of Reused, Stored, and Discarded Laptop Computers
Using the Carnegie Mellon Model
12 / Summer 2017 / Environmental Quality Management / DOI 10.1002/tqem Karima Hamouda and Rachid Adjroudi
Exhibit 7. Amount of Reused, Stored, and Discarded Desktop Computers
Using the Carnegie Mellon Model
survey that we carried out in Algeria revealed computer waste is expected to be higher if
that there are some dismantling activities to domestic production is considered. Combin-
extract components from computers and re- ing the modeled lifespan with the imported
sell them. However, Seitz (2014) states that computers gives the number of computers
e-waste management in Algeria is dominated discarded every year. The modeling results of
by the informal sector, and no further infor- computer waste generations are presented in
mation was available. Exhibit 10. The outcomes from the distri-
bution delay model show that high amounts
Use of Market Supply (Distribution Delay) of computer and monitor waste were regis-
Model tered for the period from 2014 to 2016.
In this study, only imported computers Using this model in our study, the equip-
in Algeria are considered. The amount of ment lifespan is limited to the length of
Electronic Waste Generation and Management in MENA Environmental Quality Management / DOI 10.1002/tqem / Summer 2017 / 13
Exhibit 9. Amount of Reused, Stored, and Discarded FPD Monitors Using
the Carnegie Mellon Model
Exhibit 10. Computer and Monitor Waste Generation Using the Market Supply,
Distribution Delay Model
time a household or business uses the device results revealed that this change could cause
excluding the storage time. The average lifes- approximately ±15% variation in the annual
pan obtained for computers and monitors is amount of obsolete computers and moni-
presented in the table in Exhibit 3. tors on average compared with the previous
results.
Sensitivity Analysis The choice of these two models consid-
A sensitivity analysis of the model param- ered the market saturation level. Computer
eters was carried out to investigate which pa- use is growing fast with decreasing lifespans.
rameters have an influence on model results. Hence, applying a lifespan distribution is
However, this study tested, in particular, the the right modeling choice for an unsatu-
influence of average equipment lifespan by rated market. However, the Carnegie Mel-
increasing or decreasing it by one unit. The lon model provides insight into the fate of
14 / Summer 2017 / Environmental Quality Management / DOI 10.1002/tqem Karima Hamouda and Rachid Adjroudi
obsolete computers. The lifespan retrieved pans of computers and monitors; thus, a sen-
from the survey appears to be realistic, owing sitivity analysis was performed.
to the fact that the majority of households The outcomes of this study underline the
and businesses tend to replace their comput- demand for further research on e-waste as-
ers in response to the evolution of technol- sessment to acquire more put-on market—or
ogy rather than for functional reasons. sales—data and to define strategies to col-
Based on the findings of this study and lect different types of electronic appliances.
local conditions in Algeria, the following The availability of these data will provide a
points are recommended for enhancing e- platform for an efficient e-waste policy in
waste management in the country: Algeria.
Acknowledgment
• Set specific regulations to collect and
The authors are thankful to the Algerian
manage e-waste; this is a crucial step.
National Center for Informatics and Statistics
• Provide access to data sets, such as sales
(CNIS) for providing data on computer im-
on a national basis, to understand the
ports to the country.
scope of potential e-waste.
• Consider the experiences of other devel-
oping countries in the preparation of a
References
Baldé, C. P., Wang, F., Kuehr, R., & Huisman, J. (2015).
national strategy to address e-waste in Al- The global e-waste monitor-2014. United Nations Uni-
geria (e.g., project set in Morocco) (Seitz, versity, IAS-SCYCLE. Bonn, Germany. Retrieved from
https://unu.edu/news/news/ewaste-2014-unu-report.
2014). html
• Learn from other developed countries Cucchiella, F., D’Adamoa, I., Koh, S. C. L., & Rosa, P.
and implement a take-back system. Vari- (2015). Recycling of WEEEs: An economic assessment of
present and future e-waste streams. Renewable and Sus-
ous stakeholders should work together to tainable Energy Reviews, 51, 263–272. Retrieved from
enforce the system’s regulations. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Paola_Rosa3/publ
ication/277775084_Recycling_of_WEEEs_An_economi
c_assessment_of_present_and_future_e-waste_streams/
Conclusion links/559bbfa008ae898ed6509caf.pdf
In this study, two different methods were Degreif, S., Mehlhart, G., Merz, C., Allam, H., Imam,
used to estimate computer and monitor S., Soliman, F., & Bushra, M. (2014). Global circu-
lar economy of strategic metals—the best-of-two-
waste in Algeria. The results should be taken worlds approach (Bo2W). Retrieved from http://www.
with the consideration that local produc- resourcefever.com/publications/reports/Bo2W_Report_
Egypt_WP2_2_and_2_4_final_2014_07_21.pdf
tion was not included. If all electrical and
Fraige, F. Y., Al-khatib, L. A., Alnawafleh, H. M., Dweirj,
electronic equipment were incorporated, the M. K., & Langston, P. A. (2012). Waste electric and elec-
total amount of e-waste could be notice- tronic equipment in Jordan: Willingness and generation
rates. Journal of Environmental Planning and Manage-
ably higher than the amount estimated by ment, 55(2), 161–175.
this study. Data sets on sales and product Ikhlayel, M., & Tasaki, T. A. Jordanian-MENA re-
gion WEEE input-output and material flow analysis
lifespans are crucial parameters for an effec-
case study: Examining different estimation methods.
tive assessment. One major limitation of this Proceedings Sardinia, Fifteenth International Waste
Management and Landfill Symposium. S. Margherita di
study was the failure to obtain a greater re-
Pula, Cagliari, Italy (2015). Retrieved from https://www.
turn of completed questionnaires due to the tuhh.de/iue/iwwg/publications/conference-proceeding
s/sardinia-2015.html
unexpectedly low response rate. The accu-
Kahhat, R., Kim, J., Xu, M., Allenby, B., Williams E., &
racy of the summarized results depends on
Zhang, P. (2008). Exploring e-waste management sys-
the representativeness of the modeled lifes- tems in the United States. Resources, Conservation and
Electronic Waste Generation and Management in MENA Environmental Quality Management / DOI 10.1002/tqem / Summer 2017 / 15
Recycling, 52(7), 955–64. Retrieved from https://www. Schluep, M., Hagelueken, C., Kuehr, R., Magalini, F.,
researchgate.net/profile/Eric_Williams15/publication/2 Maurer, C., Meskers, C., … Wang, F. (2009). Sustain-
22143032_Exploring_E-Waste_Management_Systems able innovation and technology transfer industrial sec-
_in_the_United_States/links/54d4de6c0cf25013d02a10 tor studies: Recycling from e-waste to resources. Bonn,
7a/Exploring-E-Waste-Management-Systems-in-the-Uni Germany: United Nations Environment Programme and
ted-States.pdf United Nations University.
Kang, H. Y., & Schoenung, J. M. (2006). Estimation of Seitz, J. (2014). Analysis of existing e-waste practices in
future outflows and infrastructure needed to recycle per- MENA countries. The Regional Solid Waste Exchange
sonal computer systems in California. Journal of Haz- of Information and Expertise Network in Mashreq and
ardous Materials 137(2), 1165–1174. Maghreb Countries, Tunis (SWEEP-Net). Retrieved from
http://www.sweep-net.org/sites/default/files/RA%20E-
Laissaoui, S. E., & Rochat, D. (2008). Techni-
WASTE.pdf
cal report on the assessment of e-waste manage-
ment in Morocco. Casablanca, Morocco: Moroccan StEP Initiative. (2014). One Global Definition of
Cleaner Production Center & Empa. Retrieved from E-waste. United Nations University/Step Initiative.
http://www.ewasteguide.info/Laissaoui_2008_CMPP Retrieved from: http:www.step-initiative.org/files/step/
Lundgren, K. (2012). The global impact of e-waste— _documents/StEP_WP_One%20Global%20Definition
addressing the challenge. International Labour Office, %20of%20E-waste_20140603_amended.pdf
Programme on Safety and Health at Work and the Tarawneh, A., & Saidan, M. (2013). Households aware-
Environment Sectoral Activities Department (SECTOR). ness, behaviors, and willingness to participate in
Geneva: ILO, 2–5. Retrieved from http://www.ilo.org/ e-waste management in Jordan. International Journal of
wcmsp5/groups/public/@ed_dialogue/@sector/docume Ecosystem, 3(5), 124–131. Retrieved from https://www.
nts/publication/wcms_196105.pdf researchgate.net/profile/Motasem_Saidan/Publication/2
74195822_Households_Awareness_Behaviors_and_Will
Madar Research & Development. (2012). Arab ICT use
ingness_to_Participate_in_E-waste_Management_in_Jor
and social networks adoption report. Retrieved from
dan/5518e2690cf29ab36bc50d18.pdf
http://www.unapcict.org/ecohub/arab-ict-use-and-socia
l-networks-adoption-report Widmer, R., Oswald-Krapf, H., Sinha-Khetriwal, D.,
Schnellmann, M., & Böni, H. (2005). Global perspec-
Robinson, B. (2009). E-waste: An assessment of global
production and environmental impacts. Science of the tives on the e-waste. Environmental Impact Assess-
Total Environment, 408(2), 183–191. Retrieved from ment Review, 25(5), 436–458. Retrieved from http://
http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10. ewasteguide.info/system/files/widmer_2005_EIAR.
1.1.452.1498&rep=rep1&type=pdf pdf
Karima Hamouda holds a master degree in industrial engineering from the University of Batna 2. Currently, she is a doctoral
candidate at the same department. Her research interests include electronic waste management, decision support systems,
and circular economy.
Rachid Adjroudi is a PhD researcher teacher in agricultural engineering and evaluating environment at INSVSA, University
of Batna 1. His research interests include wastes and air pollution.
16 / Summer 2017 / Environmental Quality Management / DOI 10.1002/tqem Karima Hamouda and Rachid Adjroudi