Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
flexibilities to fit different feedstocks and typically included in feedstock originating or enhances the distinction in
operating cases. In some cases, C4 mixture from cracking processes. Very close boiling volatility between the components,
can be established directly as feedstock— points between singular components— will be used, allowing the paraffins/
e.g., FCC C4 cut as feed for alkylation. e.g., 1-butene (–6.3°C) and isobutene olefins molecules to be separated.
However, in other cases, butanes-butenes (–6.9°C), and azeotrop formations (as Paraffins leave the column top
separation is beneficial or inevitable as in 1-, 3-butadiene and trans-2-butene and solvent with the less-volatile
a process step. Product purification is with n-butane)—result in difficulties of components (olefins) flow to the
mandatory to fulfill certain specifications separation. Those mixtures are not separable bottom of the distillation column,
of downstream chemical synthesis. with conventional distillation methods, and where the extracted components
The complexity of a separation/ additional measures are needed. (olefins) are recovered by a
purification process strongly depends on The available separation techniques subsequent distillation.5 By adjusting
the properties of pure components, as well can be mainly divided into adsorption, the solvent-to-feed ratio, ED
as the interactions between components in membrane processing and extractive processes tolerate better fluctuation of
the mixture (vapor liquid equilibrium). The distillation. olefin content in feedstock.
behavior of fluid mixtures can be calculated • Adsorption, known as molecular Many paraffin/olefin separation
by using thermodynamic models, which sieve technology, is a separation processes are based on ED processes, and
allow the calculation of these properties from process based on the different the selection of the extractive agent is the
available binary experimental data.3 The physical interactions between olefins core know-how of the process design.
complexity of determining thermodynamic and adsorbent. It does not need an For instance, a morpholine-based solvent
properties is enhanced significantly by additional solvent, but it does require mixture is used in a butene concentration
increasing the number of components, a significant amount of electrical process. Such an ED process can be
and it is very important to gain the right energy (caused by high product considered as a standalone butane/butene
thermodynamic knowledge as a function of circulation rates) and a sophisticated separation, as well as a pretreatment step
temperature, pressure and composition. control system. in various synthesis processes for the
Due to their better chemical reactivity, • The application of membrane concentration of reactive olefins in the
butenes are more valuable than butanes. The processes is very sensible to feedstock feedstock. Pretreatment processes are
isolation of butenes from C4 hydrocarbon composition, which contradicts with suitable where the “one-through” conversion
streams is profitable, especially for further the diversity of the petrochemical rate is limited by the concentration of
use in polymer production. Distillation with process, including varying reactive feed components, such as in the case
significant separation effort (stages, reflux feedstocks, since a tight control of of conversion of n-butenes and water to sec-
ratio) for separating components with a very byproducts from an FCCU or SCU butanol (SBA). With the implementation
close boiling point is a traditional technology is difficult. The low tolerance of feed of an upstream feed concentration unit, the
known as super fractionation, and it is used, contaminants would be another recycle stream is reduced (directly reflecting
for example, in C2 and C3 olefin/paraffin limitation of membrane techniques on CAPEX) and the operating expense
splitters. Due to the larger number of isomers for this industrial application.4 (OPEX) is lowered.
in a C4 stream, this system is more complex • The extractive distillation (ED)
compared to C2 and C3 processes. process comprises a simpler process Focus on potential C4 processing
TABLE 1 shows the normal boiling points setup. A solvent that takes advantage routes. Butadiene as an intermediate
(NBP) of C4 components, which are of molecular interaction, and creates product plays a special role in C4 economy.
The recovery of butadiene is accomplished
TABLE 1. Typical composition of SC C4, FCC C4 and field butane feedstock
by using selective solvent via extractive
distillation. Some features, such as the
C4 component NBP, °C SC C4, wt% FCC C4, wt% Field butane, wt% contamination with acetylenes and allenes,
1,3-butadiene –4.4 35–50 0–0.5 – and the risk of self-polymerization, have to
Isobutene –6.9 15–30 10–25 – be taken into account in the process design.
FIG. 2 shows a typical block flow
2-cis-butene 3.7 5–10 10–20 –
diagram of the possible products yielded
2-trans-butene 0.9 5–10 10–20 – from C4 hydrocarbons. However, the
1-butene –6.3 5–20 10–25 – whole scheme would never be applied
Isobutane –11.7 1–5 20–40 in its full range. The focus here is on
100 potential opportunities to understand
N-butane –0.5 1–10 10–20
the C4 hydrocarbon processing routes.
Benchmark scenarios will be discussed
SC C4 in accordance with their different process
Butadiene Raffinate 1 Isobutene Raffinate 2 complexities. First technical analysis will
removal removal be outlined based on evaluation of three
FCC C4
border cases. Economic evaluations,
including the price development of
FIG. 1. C4 process nomenclatures.
feedstocks and products, and handling
costs, will be carried out as Part 2 in an purification. As FIG. 3 shows only isobutene co-feedstock isobutane for alkylation,
upcoming issue of HP. conversion and further upgrading of the requirements of the gasoline pool,
Raffinate 2 to gasoline, an additive will be and the local market demand, including
Minimization of capital expenditure taken into account. Butadiene removal is transportation fuel specifications.
(Case 1). Usually an olefin containing a only required if butadiene is a problem for
C4 stream is too valuable to be used as fuel downstream processes. Maximization of product diversity
(via total hydrogenation). In some cases, The upgrading of Raffinate 2 can (Case 2). The main objective of this
cutting the mixture into single components be through alkylation, dimerization or case is the maximization of the product
is not the goal, so CAPEX can be kept low oligomerization. The process that is best diversity of C4 intermediate products. By
due to minimized effort for separation and suited depends on the availability of the tailor-made configuration of the process
1-Butene
2-Butenes
2-Butenes
1-Butene
1,3-Butadiene C4 LPG n-Butane 1-Butene Isobutene Isobutane
2-Butenes
2-Butenes
1-Butene
Isobutane
i-/n-Butanes
1-Butene
2-cis/trans 1/2-Butene
butene mixture mixture
1-Butene
Isobutene
1-Butene
Isobutane
2-Butenes
1,3-Butadiene
2-Butenes
n-Butane
Dehydro-
Distillation genation
Isobutane
Butene Distillation
concentration
Isobutane
1-Butene
MTBE/ETBE
1-Butene
2-Butenes 2-Butenes
n-Butane
Distillation
TBA
Isobutene
i-/n-Butanes backcracking
Butene
concentration
To metathesis
i-/n-Butanes
i-/n-Butanes
Raffinate 1
1,3-Butadiene 1,3-Butadiene
extractive Selective Isobutane
hydrogenation Isomerization
distillation
FIG. 2. Block flow diagram of process routes for the separation and conversion of C4 hydrocarbons.
steps, it is possible to isolate almost all C4 Isobutene is used for polymerization 1-/2-butenes and n-/iso butanes. The linear
components derived from an SC/FCC to polyisobutene or butyl rubber; for olefin 1-butene is a desired feedstock for
stream. Only cis/trans-isomers of 2-butene methyl tert-butyl ether (MTBE)/ethyl the production of n-butene polyolefines,
will remain as a mixture. By applying tert-butyl ether (ETBE) synthesis; and for as co-monomer in the production of
polymerization, dimerization, metathesis, tertiary butyl alcohol (TBA) synthesis. polyethylene—low-density polyethylene
oxidation, alkylation, hydration and For isobutene isolation as an intermediate (LDPE) and high-density polyethylene
etherification, these components can be product with high purity, isobutene can be (HDPE)—or as feedstock for propylene
further processed to high-value products. converted to ether (MTBE/ETBE) or to synthesis via metathesis of ethylene and
FIG. 4 represents the link between C4 TBA via direct hydration. Crude TBA can butene.6 The recovery of 1-butene from
intermediates and high-value products. be sold as TBA/water azeotrope or further the cracker-mixed C4 stream is difficult due
With the removal of butadiene via treated to pure TBA (>99.9 wt%) by drying to stringent limitations for isobutene and
extraction or selective hydrogenation, the steps. Alternatively, the azeotropic mixture butadiene in 1-butene product (TABLE 2).7
cracker stream is converted to Raffinate 1. can be decomposed to high-purity isobutene Such separation can be accomplished
It is then routed to isobutene processing (99.98 wt%) at temperatures below 150°C by processing the Raffinate 2 stream in a
where isobutene is removed by chemical and moderate pressure with heterogeneous two-step super fractionation. In the first
reaction from 1-butene (a nearly identical catalyst.6 Etherification and TBA synthesis distillation column, 2-cis/trans-butene
boiling point) and the other butene and are highly selective to isobutene, due to the and n-butane form the bottom product,
butane components. Besides isobutene, inert behavior of all other C4 components at whereas 1-butene and isobutane go
four further products can be derived from such mild reaction conditions. overhead and are separated in the second
Raffinate 1: 1-butene, 2-butene (cis/ By isobutene removal, Raffinate 1 is column. Isobutane, along with some
trans), isobutane and n-butane. transferred into Raffinate 2 containing 1-butene, is recovered as overhead product
and high-purity 1-butene forms the
Crude C4 Butadiene Raffinate 1 Isobutene Raffinate 2 Raffinate II
bottom product. Isobutane can be further
removal Gasoline pool used to produce alkylates via alkylation or
conversion upgrading
(optional)
tertiary butyl hydroperoxid via oxidation.
The bottom product of the first column
MTBE or ETBE or TBA of 1-butene separation consists mainly of
n-butane and 2-cis/trans-butene. By using
the butene concentration process, as shown
FIG. 3. C4 process route for minimized CAPEX for C4 processing.
FIG. 4, 2-butene can be separated from
n-butane. The above mentioned process
C4-fraction C4-fraction
FCC steam cracker TABLE 2. Composition of high-purity
1,3-Butadiene Polymerization Synthetic isobutene and 1-butene
1,3-Butadiene
Isobutene rubber
Isobutane Component Pure isobutene Pure 1-butene
N-Butane
1-Butene Alkylation Alkylates Isobutene 99.98 wt% 0.15
2-Butene (c/t) Isobutane
Tertiary butyl 1-butene 0.005 wt% 99.7
Butadiene Butadiene Oxidation
hydro peroxide 2-butene 0.01 wt% 0.01
selective extractive-
hydrogenation distillation
Oxidation Maleic Butane 0.005 wt% 0.15
n-Butane anhydride
1, 3-butadiene < 10 ppm < 10 ppm
Distillation
Raffinate-1:
Isobutene Isobutane Oxidation
Isobutane Octene TBA < 5 ppm < 1 ppm
N-Butane 1-Butene
1-Butene Dimerization Water < 30 ppm < 10 ppm
2-Butene (c/t)
Distillation
1-Butene Raffinate 2
C-2-Butene
T-2-Butene
n-Butane
Hydration
Butene Isobutene Isobutane
MEK
concentration
T-2-Butene 2-Butene Metathesis Propylene TBA N-Butane
C-2-Butene (trans+cis)
Raffinate 1
MTBE or TBA
MTBE 1-Butene
Polymerization Polyisobutylene
TBA or MTBE Isobutene
backcracking Copolymerization ETBE 2-butene
Butyl rubber
with isoprene
FIG. 5. Raffinate 1 and Raffinate 2 secondary
FIG. 4. C4 intermediate products and corresponding final products. products.
route has an advantage compared to the the production of SBA and/or MEK. (C2–C4), resulting in small amounts
conventional process route whereas 1- and A mixture of isobutane and n-butane of propylene and C4 byproducts. As
2-butenes are still in the feedstock. Due to derived from butene concentration can be compensation, propylene and butene on-
the fact that 1-butene was already removed, sold as a liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) purpose technologies have been developed.
the butene concentration unit can
be operated more economically
compared to using Raffinate 2 The upgrading process of C4 hydrocarbon streams
feedstock, including 1/2-butenes.
N-butane can be further processed
is not standardized; a suitable route for each
to maleic anhydride by oxidation refinery must be studied individually. Economic and
with air. 2-butene (-cis/trans) is
forwarded to SBA/methyl ethane environmental issues should be taken into account
ketone (MEK) synthesis, which to achieve the best investment benefit.
will be outlined in the next section.
Within Case 2, five C4
intermediate products and three final product. Within the SBA synthesis, all three Field C4 that is separated from natural
products can be processed, beginning with species of butenes form SBA. The variation gas, oil associated gas or shale gas contains
Raffinate 1 (FIG. 5). of feedstock with regard to ratio of 1-butene mainly butanes and no butenes. Butene
and 2-butenes (cis/trans) will have no yielded from such butane feedstock by
Maximize single product yields significant impact on process design; hence, dehydrogenation can also be applied in every
(Case 3). In this case, the focus is on a separation of 1-butene is not considered. butene upgrading processes discussed above,
the maximization of one final product A block flow diagram for the SBA/MEK and is particularly suitable for a process with
based on C4 intermediates. As an production is shown in FIG. 7. a high requirement on feedstock quality.
example, MEK, which is derived from Dehydrogenation is an endothermic
sec-butanol (SBA), is chosen (FIG. 6). Processing field butanes. The change in equilibrium reaction, usually operating in
The challenge is to minimize byproducts the availability of feedstocks over the years is the vapor phase. The paraffin conversion
and to meet the feedstock specification driving the development of petrochemical increases with decreasing pressure and
for SBA/MEK synthesis (TABLE 3). A technologies. In the last decades, ethylene increasing temperature. Obviously,
further objective of this processing route plants/SCUs were often built as gas crackers conversion is limited by the thermodynamic
is to maximize the 1-butene/2-butene
Isobutane
concentration of feedstock for SBA/ Butadiene Raffinate 1: Isobutene Raffinate 2: N-Butane
C4 fraction selective reaction Butane LPG
MEK synthesis up to 97 wt%. FCC Isobutene Isobutene concentration
hydrogenation (to TBA or MTBE)
Technology used for the SBA synthesis Isobutane Isobutane
C-2-Butene
T-2-Butene
SC/FCC-product: N-Butane N-Butane
is a direct hydration process of 1/2-butenes 1-Butene 1-Butene 1-Butene
1,3-Butadiene
in the presence of sulfonic cation exchange Isobutene 2-Butene (cis/trans) 2-Butene (c/t)
resin in the water phase, and the subsequent Isobutane
N-Butane SBA
C4 gas separation from the raw SBA. Of the 1-Butene synthesis
bulk of the SBA produced worldwide, over 2-Butene (cis/trans) SBA SBA
90% is utilized as an intermediate for the Butadiene
C4-fraction MEK
manufacturing of MEK. MEK is mainly steam cracker
extractive
synthesis
MEK
utilized as a solvent in paints, lacquers distillation
TBA or MTBE
and printing inks, as well as an extraction MTBE or TBA
solvent in several industrial sectors (e.g., 1,3-Butadiene
lube oil, plastics and rubber). 1,3-Butadiene Polymerization Synthetic rubber
With regards to byproducts, SC and
FCC feedstocks have to be differentiated. FIG. 6. Processing route for the maximization of single-selected product MEK and minimum
Where an FCC feedstock is available, byproducts.
small contents of 1, 3-butadienes will
be removed by selective hydrogenation. Butenes feed
In the case of SC feedstock, it is
recommended to extract 1, 3-butadienes Raw SBA Pure SBA Raw MEK MEK
SBA SBA MEK MEK
due to a much higher concentration. A synthesis distillation synthesis distillation
97 wt-% 99 wt-% 78 wt-% >99.7 wt-%
summary of this specification is given
in TABLE 3. The limitation for isobutene Pure SBA as product
is important to prevent formation of
additional TBA during SBA synthesis. 99 wt-%
A butene concentration unit Raw TBA
(pretreatment) is able to provide a tailor-
made feedstock, which can be used for FIG. 7. Block diagram of SBA/MEK synthesis and purification.
Hydration
4
Eldridge, R. B., “Olefin/paraffin separation
TBA
technology: A review,” Industrial & Engineering
Isobutane Chemistry Research, 1993.
Dehydrogenation Isobutene Polymerization Polyisobutylene 5
Emmrich G., H. Gehrke and U. Ranke, “Working
Field C4
Etherification MTBE/ETBE with an extractive distillation process,” Krupp Uhde
Distillation
Oil associated GmbH, 2001.
gas, natural Isomerization
(optional)
6
Schulze, J., and M. Homann, C4-hydrocarbons and
gas, shale gas derivatives, Springer-Verlag, 1989.
Metathesis Propylene 7
Edwards, S. M., S. J. Stanly and M. Shreehan,
“Relative economics of mixed C4 processing routes,”
Dehydrogenation N-butene Polymerization Polyisobutylene ABB Lummus Global, 1998.
n-Butane
Co-polymerization LLDPE
DR. THOMAS STREICH is the head of
the refining and petrochemical
FIG. 8. Processing lines and corresponding products based on field butane. division at thyssenkrupp Uhde
Engineering Services GmbH,
Germany. He has over 25 years of
TABLE 3. Typical specifications for n- reasons behind this indicate the wide engineering and research and
butenes feed within SBA/MEK synthesis diversities of product spectrum and the development (R&D) experience in
possibilities of blending inside of refineries. the fields of refining, hydrocarbon and petrochemical
Component Composition processing, with a special focus on C3 /C4 production
Meaningful economic evaluation is therefore technologies. Dr. Streich holds two degrees in
Isobutene Max. 0.7 wt%
based on the proper understanding and constructional design and process engineering,
N-butane comparison of possible processing routes. as well as a doctorate degree in chemical engineering
Residual
from the Ruhr-University of Bochum in Germany.
Isobutane A simple way for upgrading
1-butene C4 hydrocarbons with minimized HARALD KÖMPEL is the deputy
2-cis-butene Min. 97 wt% intermediate steps can result in high head of the refining, petrochemical
2-trans-butene
octane gasoline components. As a second and technologies department at
thyssenkrupp Uhde Engineering
extreme, the maximization of intermediate Services GmbH, Germany. He has
1,3-butadiene Max. 0.4 wt%
steps to separate the crude C4 mixture into 26 years of experience in the fields
MTBE single components for further upgrading of refining, hydrocarbon and
MeOH Max. 0.2 wt% by chemical synthesis has been reviewed. petrochemical processing, with a focus on light olefins
and their downstream products, including
H2O There is a route with special reflection on the successful commercialization of the methanol to
one selected chemical synthesis, MEK. propylene (MTP) process. Mr. Kömpel holds a degree
equilibrium and requires a recycle of Butenes from field C4 via dehydrogenation in chemical engineering from the Friedrich Alexander
University Erlangen-Nuremberg.
unreacted paraffins. Separation and could cover the gap of high-purity
purification yielding in high-purity butene butene requirements for certain special JIN GENG is a process engineer/
is mandatory for the process. Generally, applications, e.g., polymerization. technologist in the refining,
the hydrogen and light hydrocarbons that Based on the technical possibilities petrochemicals and technologies
department at thyssenkrupp
are the byproducts of dehydrogenation can discussed here, a full economic evaluation Uhde Engineering Services GmbH,
be removed by distillation. will be carried out in a follow-up part to Germany. He earned an MS degree
Either n-butene or isobutene could be this publication. Depending on the feed in chemical engineering with the
focus on separation science and thermodynamics
produced with the butane dehydrogenation composition, a tailor-made process route
from the Friedrich Alexander University Erlangen-
process. FIG. 8 shows the product lines should be chosen to get the best benefit Nuremberg. He has recently exhibited his doctor
based on field butane. Owing to the high from case to case. thesis at the same university.
quality of butenes, polymerization would
MATTHIAS RENGER is a senior
prove to be very beneficial to upgrading. Next month. Part 2 of this article will process engineer within the
appear in July. refining, petrochemical and
Overview and outlook. A comprehensive technologies department at
LITERATURE CITED thyssenkrupp Uhde Engineering
overview on C4 olefin/paraffin-processing 1
Bender, M., “An overview of industrial processes Services GmbH, Germany. He has
and the features of the crude C4 feedstocks, for the production of olefins—C4 hydrocarbons,” over 7 years of experience in
as well as possible product lines, have been ChemBioEng Reviews, 2014. process modelling and the design of chemical
discussed. Engineering companies in 2
Sadeghbeigi, R., Fluid Catalytic Cracking Handbook, processes, including process design packages and
petrochemical industries must steadily face Butterworth-Heinemann, 2012. studies, basic engineering, and commissioning,
3
Gmehling, J., D. D. Liu and J. M. Prausnitz, “High- operation and troubleshooting. He holds a degree in
the challenge that the available feedstock pressure vapour-liquid equilibria for mixtures power and process engineering from the Berlin
will somehow depart from the “desired” containing one or more polar components,” Institute of Technology (TU Berlin, Germany).
compositions and specifications. The Chemical Engineering Science, 1979.
Electronic and single printed copies for distribution with permission to ThyssenKrupp from Hydrocarbon Processing
June © 2016 Gulf Publishing Company