Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Returns
(after tax and increasing with inflation) Inputs: 9.0%
Recognize this model implies that returns are guaranteed Input all the coloured variables. Try cha
each year. A false assumption. You will face (if you see #Div/0 errors change either
Sequential Return risk.
Reduce your withdrawals by about 1% to compensate. Spend $36,500
(after taxes) $ 56,614
This option maintains your nest egg intact in 'real' dollars This depletes your money by the time y
To see what happens with different start years, copy the yellow section and pa
Scroll down column G to see how long the portfolio lasts. Using the default var
1964, 1965, 1966, 1968, and 1969.
To use Canadian stock returns, copy from the TSX column and past overtop th
Portfolio in Stocks
S&P TSX US Yrs since
Year Return Returns Inflation Start Portfolio Income EOY
years, copy the yellow section and paste it overtop the starting year you want.
he portfolio lasts. Using the default variables the only starting years that did not survive 30 years were:
m the TSX column and past overtop the S&P column. Use the UNDO function so you don't lose the US numbers.
Spend
40,000
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
No - Reservoir System - no cash at start, no stock sales unless cash negative, draw = initial
This sheet starts with the Reservoir-With-Dividends sheet and makes some changes
the dividend income in the first year. After than the draws increase with inflati
There is no cash postion to start. The only time stocks are sold is when the cash pos
There is no sales of shares when the portfolio's value exceeds the PLA value.
Taxes must be paid from the $Spend column.
After you copy and past the highlighted line (over the starting year of retirement), you
The default variable = $48,352, the dividend income of year 1938
The results show NO instances of portfolio failure before 2011. The issue for retirees
Simply buying individual stock with a higher yield will change the dynamics of growth.
Variables
Cash Principal Tax % Spend
0 1,000,000 0% 48,352
Portfolio in Stocks
S&P Realized US Yrs since
Year CapGains Yield Inflation Start Portfolio CapGain EOY PLA Portfoli
t and makes some changes to see if the portfolios survive when the original draw is set =
he draws increase with inflation.
re sold is when the cash position become negative.
ceeds the PLA value.
rting year of retirement), you must change the variable for $Spend to equal the dividend income of that year.
of year 1938
2011. The issue for retirees today, is whether they can live on the current 2% yield.
nge the dynamics of growth. It should not be considered equally safe.
To see the results of retirements starting in different years ---- Select and copy the
and past over top of the row of the year before you start retirement
(A)
Hold Stocks with Yield to match Draws
1,000,000
1938 (1.4%) 31.6% 1,000,000 5.92 174,700 17.47 1,115,545
1939 (0.7%) (1.4%) 1,115,545 5.26 18,630 1.67 1,075,442
1940 1.4% (10.4%) 1,075,442 5.54 (122,063) -11.35 893,802
1941 11.3% (12.0%) 893,802 7.42 (64,264) -7.19 763,200
1942 7.6% 20.8% 763,200 9.36 109,595 14.36 801,387
1943 3.0% 25.4% 801,387 9.17 269,186 33.59 997,051
1944 2.3% 19.5% 997,051 7.54 287,251 28.81 1,209,091
1945 2.2% 36.2% 1,209,091 6.36 501,168 41.45 1,633,357
1946 18.1% (8.4%) 1,633,357 5.56 (173,789) -10.64 1,368,723
1947 10.2% 5.1% 1,368,723 7.32 (37,777) -2.76 1,230,805
1948 1.3% 5.0% 1,230,805 8.24 8,616 0.70 1,138,013
1949 (2.1%) 17.8% 1,138,013 8.73 237,276 20.85 1,275,993
1950 8.1% 30.1% 1,275,993 8.41 377,183 29.56 1,545,852
1951 4.3% 23.8% 1,545,852 7.24 228,168 14.76 1,662,048
1952 0.4% 18.4% 1,662,048 6.76 244,986 14.74 1,794,639
1953 1.1% (1.1%) 1,794,639 6.33 (38,046) -2.12 1,642,931
1954 (0.7%) 52.2% 1,642,931 6.87 740,305 45.06 2,270,419
1955 0.4% 31.6% 2,270,419 4.99 606,656 26.72 2,763,835
1956 3.0% 6.9% 2,763,835 4.22 131,006 4.74 2,778,221
1957 3.6% (10.5%) 2,778,221 4.35 (97,516) -3.51 2,559,861
1958 1.4% 43.6% 2,559,861 4.79 971,979 37.97 3,409,305
1959 1.0% 12.0% 3,409,305 3.63 412,867 12.11 3,698,369
1960 1.7% 0.5% 3,698,369 3.40 266,652 7.21 3,839,106
1961 0.7% 26.8% 3,839,106 3.30 843,068 21.96 4,555,413
1962 1.3% (8.8%) 4,555,413 2.82 (497,907) -10.93 3,929,055
1963 1.6% 22.7% 3,929,055 3.32 510,777 13.00 4,309,269
1964 1.0% 16.4% 4,309,269 3.06 489,102 11.35 4,666,540
1965 1.9% 12.4% 4,666,540 2.88 688,315 14.75 5,220,489
1966 3.5% (10.1%) 5,220,489 2.66 (654,649) -12.54 4,426,825
1967 3.6% 24.0% 4,426,825 3.25 1,119,544 25.29 5,402,285
1968 4.4% 11.0% 5,402,285 2.78 787,113 14.57 6,038,975
1969 6.2% (8.4%) 6,038,975 2.64 (754,872) -12.50 5,124,385
1970 5.3% 3.9% 5,124,385 3.28 (210,100) -4.10 4,746,116
1971 3.3% 14.3% 4,746,116 3.66 407,691 8.59 4,980,146
1972 3.6% 19.0% 4,980,146 3.61 620,028 12.45 5,420,174
1973 9.4% (14.7%) 5,420,174 3.63 (514,374) -9.49 4,708,898
1974 11.8% (26.5%) 4,708,898 4.67 (1,214,425) -25.79 3,274,332
1975 6.7% 37.2% 3,274,332 7.17 1,350,989 41.26 4,390,392
1976 5.2% 23.9% 4,390,392 5.63 1,263,994 28.79 5,407,203
1977 6.8% (7.2%) 5,407,203 4.88 (301,722) -5.58 4,841,396
1978 9.3% 6.6% 4,841,396 5.96 159,282 3.29 4,712,087
1979 13.9% 18.6% 4,712,087 6.98 1,534,255 32.56 5,917,610
1980 11.8% 32.5% 5,917,610 6.21 1,497,747 25.31 7,047,751
1981 8.4% (4.9%) 7,047,751 5.65 (162,098) -2.30 6,487,202
1982 3.7% 21.6% 6,487,202 6.37 1,753,491 27.03 7,827,454
1983 4.2% 22.6% 7,827,454 5.50 2,546,271 32.53 9,943,161
1984 3.5% 6.3% 9,943,161 4.48 817,328 8.22 10,314,714
1985 3.9% 31.7% 10,314,714 4.49 4,381,691 42.48 14,233,306
1986 1.5% 18.7% 14,233,306 3.30 3,236,654 22.74 17,000,101
1987 4.0% 5.3% 17,000,101 2.88 659,604 3.88 17,170,832
1988 4.7% 16.6% 17,170,832 2.98 2,005,553 11.68 18,664,695
1989 5.2% 31.7% 18,664,695 2.88 4,727,767 25.33 22,854,152
1990 5.7% (3.1%) 22,854,152 2.49 491,364 2.15 22,776,784
1991 2.6% 30.5% 22,776,784 2.56 9,889,680 43.42 32,082,942
1992 3.3% 7.6% 32,082,942 1.88 384,995 1.20 31,865,402
1993 2.5% 10.1% 31,865,402 1.94 277,229 0.87 31,524,885
1994 2.8% 1.3% 31,524,885 2.01 1,598,312 5.07 32,488,126
1995 2.7% 37.6% 32,488,126 2.01 11,055,709 34.03 42,891,441
1996 3.0% 23.0% 42,891,441 1.57 14,921,932 34.79 57,141,120
1997 1.6% 33.4% 57,141,120 1.19 21,325,066 37.32 77,783,369
1998 1.7% 28.6% 77,783,369 0.89 32,692,350 42.03 109,781,493
1999 2.7% 21.0% 109,781,493 0.65 14,941,261 13.61 124,009,515
2000 3.7% (9.1%) 124,009,515 0.60 8,420,246 6.79 131,689,902
2001 1.1% (11.9%) 131,689,902 0.57 (5,570,483) -4.23 125,371,109
2002 2.6% (22.1%) 125,371,109 0.61 (29,725,490) -23.71 94,877,873
2003 1.9% 28.7% 94,877,873 0.82 28,615,166 30.16 122,710,504
2004 3.0% 10.9% 122,710,504 0.66 13,596,324 11.08 135,501,053
2005 4.0% 4.9% 135,501,053 0.62 14,525,713 10.72 149,188,879
2006 2.1% 15.8% 149,188,879 0.57 (1,745,510) -1.17 146,588,090
2007 4.3% 5.5% 146,588,090 0.61 14,116,433 9.63 159,812,636
2008 0.0% (37.0%) 159,812,636 0.56 (61,192,258) -38.29 97,728,224
2009 2.6% 26.5% 97,728,224 0.94 36,990,133 37.85 133,802,778
2010 1.6% 15.1% 133,802,778 0.70 5,940,843 4.44 138,813,101
2011 2.9% 2.1% 138,813,101 0.69 (14,991,815) -10.80 122,863,547
2012 1.59%
1938
1939
1940
1941
1942
1943
1944
1945
1946
1947
1948
1949
1950
1951
1952
1953
1954
1955
1956
1957
1958
1959
1960
1961
1962
1963
1964
1965
1966
1967
1968
1969
1970
1971
1972
1973
1974
1975
1976
1977
1978
1979
1980
1981
1982
1983
1984
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
1938
1939
1940
1941
1942
1943
1944
1945
1946
1947
1948
1949
1950
1951
1952
1953
1954
1955
1956
1957
1958
1959
1960
1961
1962
1963
1964
1965
1966
1967
1968
1969
1970
1971
1972
1973
1974
1975
1976
1977
1978
1979
1980
1981
1982
1983
1984
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
Variables
Portfolio Start 1,000,000
Withdrawal Rate 6.0%
(B)
Traditional Academic Analysis Using Total Returns
0 60,000 1,000,000
1 59,155 1,000,000 316,300 31.63 1,257,145
2 58,732 1,257,145 (17,977) (1.43) 1,180,436
3 59,577 1,180,436 (122,293) (10.36) 998,565
4 66,338 998,565 (120,028) (12.02) 812,199
5 71,408 812,199 168,531 20.75 909,322
6 73,521 909,322 230,786 25.38 1,066,587
7 75,211 1,066,587 207,878 19.49 1,199,254
8 76,901 1,199,254 434,250 36.21 1,556,602
9 90,845 1,556,602 (131,066) (8.42) 1,334,691
10 100,141 1,334,691 67,402 5.05 1,301,952
11 101,408 1,301,952 64,967 4.99 1,265,511
12 99,296 1,265,511 225,388 17.81 1,391,603
13 107,324 1,391,603 418,177 30.05 1,702,456
14 111,972 1,702,456 405,014 23.79 1,995,498
15 112,394 1,995,498 366,972 18.39 2,250,076
16 113,662 2,250,076 (24,076) (1.07) 2,112,338
17 112,817 2,112,338 1,103,274 52.23 3,102,795
18 113,239 3,102,795 981,104 31.62 3,970,660
19 116,620 3,970,660 274,373 6.91 4,128,413
20 120,845 4,128,413 (433,483) (10.50) 3,574,084
21 122,535 3,574,084 1,557,228 43.57 5,008,777
22 123,803 5,008,777 601,554 12.01 5,486,529
23 125,915 5,486,529 25,787 0.47 5,386,400
24 126,761 5,386,400 1,445,710 26.84 6,705,349
25 128,451 6,705,349 (586,718) (8.75) 5,990,180
26 130,563 5,990,180 1,359,771 22.70 7,219,388
27 131,831 7,219,388 1,186,145 16.43 8,273,703
28 134,366 8,273,703 1,024,284 12.38 9,163,621
29 139,014 9,163,621 (921,860) (10.06) 8,102,746
30 144,085 8,102,746 1,943,039 23.98 9,901,700
31 150,423 9,901,700 1,092,158 11.03 10,843,435
32 159,718 10,843,435 (914,102) (8.43) 9,769,616
33 168,169 9,769,616 384,923 3.94 9,986,369
34 173,662 9,986,369 1,428,051 14.30 11,240,758
35 180,000 11,240,758 2,134,620 18.99 13,195,378
36 196,901 13,195,378 (1,938,401) (14.69) 11,060,076
37 220,141 11,060,076 (2,927,602) (26.47) 7,912,333
38 234,930 7,912,333 2,945,762 37.23 10,623,165
39 247,183 10,623,165 2,542,123 23.93 12,918,105
40 264,085 12,918,105 (924,936) (7.16) 11,729,084
41 288,592 11,729,084 770,601 6.57 12,211,094
42 328,732 12,211,094 2,272,485 18.61 14,154,846
43 367,606 14,154,846 4,600,325 32.50 18,387,565
44 398,451 18,387,565 (904,668) (4.92) 17,084,446
45 413,239 17,084,446 3,681,698 21.55 20,352,905
46 430,563 20,352,905 4,591,615 22.56 24,513,956
47 445,775 24,513,956 1,537,025 6.27 25,605,207
48 463,099 25,605,207 8,124,532 31.73 33,266,640
49 469,859 33,266,640 6,210,882 18.67 39,007,663
50 488,873 39,007,663 2,047,902 5.25 40,566,692
51 511,690 40,566,692 6,738,469 16.61 46,793,471
52 538,310 46,793,471 14,829,070 31.69 61,084,231
53 568,732 61,084,231 (1,893,086) (3.10) 58,622,413
54 583,521 58,622,413 17,860,317 30.47 75,899,209
55 602,535 75,899,209 5,786,756 7.62 81,083,431
56 617,746 81,083,431 8,169,278 10.08 88,634,962
57 635,070 88,634,962 1,170,614 1.32 89,170,506
58 652,394 89,170,506 33,510,859 37.58 122,028,971
59 672,254 122,028,971 28,022,326 22.96 149,379,043
60 682,817 149,379,043 49,830,132 33.36 198,526,358
61 694,225 198,526,358 56,736,034 28.58 254,568,167
62 713,239 254,568,167 53,551,074 21.04 307,406,001
63 739,859 307,406,001 (27,971,446) (9.10) 278,694,696
64 748,310 278,694,696 (33,144,290) (11.89) 244,802,096
65 767,746 244,802,096 (54,091,392) (22.10) 189,942,958
66 782,535 189,942,958 54,476,392 28.68 243,636,815
67 805,775 243,636,815 26,516,098 10.88 269,347,138
68 837,887 269,347,138 13,227,700 4.91 281,736,951
69 855,279 281,736,951 44,484,663 15.79 325,366,335
70 891,887 325,366,335 17,861,238 5.49 342,335,685
71 892,154 342,335,685 (126,649,804) (37.00) 214,793,728
72 915,579 214,793,728 56,843,427 26.46 270,721,576
73 930,520 270,721,576 40,778,006 15.06 310,569,063
74 957,739 310,569,063 6,558,660 2.11 316,169,983