Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
DEMOGRAPHIC TRANSITIONS
Countries
Niaz Ahmed Bhutto, Rizwan Hafeez Dayo, Falahuddin Butt, Rashid Ali Lohach, Neetu Birjani
Abstract
The demographic and economic development literatures are mainly focused on the behavior of
fertility and mortality trends during demographic transitions. One of the school of thoughts
define that the fertility reductions are the consequent of mortality reductions during demographic
transitions. This study analyzes this relationship empirically by examining the low and middle
income countries since 1970. We analyze the impact of infant mortality, life expectancy and
crude mortality on fertility during transitions while controlling other explanatory factors. Our
results show that mortality plays large role in fertility reductions i.e. the major impact is of Infant
mortality, after that there is life expectancy. But on the whole, our study doesn’t support the
impact of crude mortality on fertility reductions; crude death rates are indifferent to fertility in
this regard. We find relatively little support for justifications of the demographic transitions
1. Introduction
In this era of economic development, many of the economies of world have transformed to the
better standards that are of life, education and technology. This is because of the demographic
transitions. Demographic transitions have been occurred in the early advent of 19th century that
is from the later pre-industrialization era to the industrialization and onwards. These transitions
transformed the world economy to the new horizons of growth and prosperity and still the
process is in progress. So, demographic transitions can be defined as the population changes to
levels of economic, education, and health-care development. It can be elaborated from one of the
explanations i.e. as women become better educated and financially independent, the global
fertility rates will continue to decline since women will (1) have fewer children, (2) delay having
them, or (3) forgo having them, so this tradeoff is also known as child quantity/quality tradeoff.
The demographic transition can also be meant the transition from higher birth and death rates to
lower birth and death rates as country develops from a pre-industrial to an industrialized
economy.
Many literatures and theories suggest that those declining mortality rates, decline due to the
transitions that pose some effects over the fertility. So, in this paper we will likely to contribute
by providing some empirical evidences of the effects of mortality reduction on fertility. Going
back in history, earlier this theory of demographic transition was given by Mr. Warren Thomson
in 1929. Traditionally the demographic transition began in eighteenth century in those countries
that are developed now and continues in our current era whereas in less developed countries the
process of demographic transition started later and is still at an earlier stage. Even there are also
those countries that are living below the basic standards of life (poverty line) and those countries
are far away from the process of transition i.e. they haven’t even stepped in the industrial sectors.
Now coming towards the main indicators by which demographic transitions can be observed are
the mortality rates and fertility rates. Many of the theorists and researchers have observed
declining trends in both mortality and fertility rates as the country proceeds towards
demographic transitions. The fertility declines due to the increased awareness, family planning
subsistence agriculture, an increase in status and education of women and the parents’
preferences i.e. child quality (raising the child by providing adequate resources i.e. proper
nutrition, education and proper attention) rather than the quantity. Due to increased life security,
parents prefer to have fewer children so they can raise them with care and proper attention.
Parallel to this scenario, mortality rates also decline due to improvements in food supply and
sanitation, which increase life span and reduce diseases. These improvements are due to new
farming techniques, access to technology, basic health care facilities and education.
For defining demographic transitions we will take the help of unified growth theory. This theory
was modified by Galor and it suggests that the transition from stagnation to growth has been an
inevitable by-product of the process of development. It argues that the inherent Malthusian
interaction between the rate of technological progress and the size and composition of the
population accelerated the pace of technological progress and ultimately raised the importance of
education in coping with the rapidly changing technological environment. The rise in industrial
demand for education brought about significant reductions in fertility rates. It enabled economies
to divert a larger share of the gains from factor accumulation and technological progress to the
enhancement of human capital formation i.e. the quality of child and income per capita, paving
the way for the emergence of sustained economic growth. In this way the transition from higher
birth and mortality rates to lower birth and mortality rates took place.
Due to the demographic transitions, two problems can arise i.e. birth rates may drop to well
below the replacement level and can lead to shrinkage in population that can be a threat to those
industries that rely on population growth. The other problem can be if the birth rates do not fall
corresponding with the fall in mortality rates so there can be a large increase in population that
may cause the issues of food insecurity, unemployment, diseases and many other calamities. So,
the effects of mortality reduction on fertility may vary from the region to region or country to
country according to its position i.e. in which phase of transitions the country is. So, the ample
work has been done in the regard of demographic transitions and the reduction in fertility.
2. Literature Review
As we have discussed in the introduction: those demographic transitions are the changes in the
population that started in the early eighteenth century. Different authors have different
approaches to measure the demographic factors and have shown the impacts of each of them
over mortality and fertility. Many researches are concerned with the impact of infant mortality
reductions on the fertility reductions in the demographic transitions and therefore many
researches are done in this field. Most of the researchers suggest that the impact of mortality on
fertility is positive i.e. as mortality increases the fertility also increases. Apart from that scenario,
there are also other factors that are responsible for fertility reductions during the demographic
transitions. Therefore many of the studies are done. There are many trends in the behavior of
fertility during the demographic transitions. The main reason behind the shift in the trends is the
life expectancy. Due to demographic transitions the life expectancy in different regions has
increased because they have improved in health facilities so the fertility has decreased as authors
have quoted like Soares (2005), Angeles, (2010) & K.A.S. Wickrama Frederick O. Lorenz
(2002) they have shown that as life expectancy has increased, it has brought significant impacts
on reduction on fertility because preferences of women have been shifted towards having fewer
children due to the desire for quality of the children rather than quantity. In this way they can be
brought up in a very good manner and they might be productive in the future like they can make
better decisions about the retirements and savings Bloom et al. (2003, 2007). The decrease in the
mortality rates also decreases the fertility rates because demographic transitions theory suggest
Yet besides the factors described above, population growth has also significant impact on
reducing the fertility. As the fertility has decreased so it has also decreased the population growth
in many regions. There is positive relation between population growth and fertility rate.
Population structure gives significant results on demographic transitions Zheng et al. (2011). As
fertility decreases the youth dependency ratio also decreases quoted by Bloom et al. (2003).
Population growth rates and fertility rates have declined due to demographic transitions.
health facilities, raised social standards, availability of hygiene food in the minds of those people
who lived in rural areas and were unaware about these facilities and it emphasized that more
quantity of children in not good but they should focus on the quality of the children, Borooah
(2003). This is the reason why woman living in the rural areas have more children than of the
urban woman.
Another factor is the health issues that have been faced by the different nations over the different
periods of times. If the woman’s health is not good the chances are of high mortality rates and
high fertility rates because of the hope that few of them will survive. If children are diseased and
are unhealthy then those children will grow up to form sick adults, prone to disease, dampens
economic progress in many ways i.e. it decreases workers’ productivity, and reduces the
enrolment in the schools, and unavailability of the health facilities like vaccinations, doctors etc,
would be a burden because the health related expenditure will increase, world development
Report (1993).
On the other hand provision of information about the contraceptives may be good source to
reduce fertility. As it has been noted that transitions have started in the Asia and Europe, but they
are still in pre-mature phases in African Countries. Unlike other countries, in African Countries
the death rates are high because of the several diseases. Major among them is HIV/AIDS,
(Human Immunodeficiency Virus). Use of contraceptives has somehow impacts that the fertility
has been lowered, like use of contraception has increased from 12.4 percent to 27 percent and
consequently lowering the fertility Robinson (1992). Most writers suggest that by the use of
condoms the threat to HIV/AIDS is lowered and also lowered the fertility in this regard.
HIV/AIDS reduces fertility for infected women but has no effect for unaffected women Fortson
(2009).
Education is yet another factor as Boehmer & Williamson (1996) have used three key indicators
to show the gender specification theory. They are female secondary school enrollment,
contraceptive prevalence and female/male ratio of secondary school enrollment. They have
formed the positive relation between the education and infant mortality rate. Apart from that an
educated mother is more likely to take good care of her child. Educated mothers try to give their
children good nutrition and diet, because they are well aware about the food requirements for
proper and hygienic nutrition of children (Gubhaju, 1986). The more funds spent on education,
the more will be awareness about bringing up the children, so reducing the risk regarding
mortality of their children. Generally it is observed that those educated women are more aware
about the contraception use than illiterate woman (Shah, Makhdoom A. et al, 1998). Educated
women have fewer children as compare to that of the uneducated one. Women with no schooling
have infant mortality rate above 2.5 times. In most cases the educated woman delays marriage
because they want to complete the education first, then they secure their careers and make their
lives stable in this way (Salehi-Isfahani, 2000). When we consider the education, it may be
private or public education. So, the parents who are likely to educate their children in private
schools have higher cost so they prefer few children (Azarnert 2006). The education of the
woman has negative correlation with the mortality rate as one author proposes that 1 percent
increase in the education level decreases mortality by almost 1.9 percent. Falling mortality is
associated with the increase in the life expectancy and it may enable the person to invest in
providing the better education of their children (Ram & Schultz, 1997).
Life expectancy is also a determinant of the fertility of the people. Life expectancy means for
how many years, people are expected to live alive. Life expectancy can reduce fertility by
changing the living standards of people through taking good care of their health and intake of
healthy food. The relation between life expectancy and fertility rate is negative, as life
expectancy increases, it means living standards of people improves that can reduce the fertility
rate that means more people are expected to live alive for longer period of time. Mortality rates
no doubt decrease as it is a general view that when a person thinks that he can live long life
(Soares, 2003). When it is observed that the children are living for a longer period of time
definitely woman will want fewer children and this will reduce the fertility rates.
Generally the researchers believe that well-being of the economy (improved GDP) can have
impact on the mortality reductions like socioeconomic development (Moon, 1991). Whenever an
health and improve the living standard of masses, thus lowering mortality as well as fertility.
This all could be done through increasing the trade, urbanization and education. But in some
countries this is not the case, because there are such countries that have high income but their
infant mortality rate is higher than the countries having low incomes. This is mainly because they
do not make investments in the fields of health and betterment of the society like Oman, Iraq,
In the article of Shen & Williamson (2000) they have shown that among other variables GDP has
always shown positive results in reducing the mortality. However there has been a substantial
impact of GDP over reduction in the infant mortality rates (Brenner, 1979). When economy is in
downturns and there are fewer jobs, people don’t find any job to earn income. So, they may not
be able to take healthier foods and they also fail to invest in health related issues causing more
fatalities. If people want more babies we can take it in terms of economics in which we consider
the income that we forego by working to bring up the every next baby to be born (Becker &
Lewis 1973). A family will send the child to the labor market if, and only if, the family's income
from non-child-labor sources drops very low (Basu & Van 1998).
This article is further divided in three sections. The next section comprises of data and
methodology. Section 4 and 5; sum up the empirical results of the study and conclusions.
revolves around the fact that during the demographic transitions, fertility is influenced by
different variables. In this study the impact of some of those variables on fertility is checked via
running a regression analysis. Considerably this study focuses on the impact of infant mortality
(IMR) on fertility (TFR) during the demographic transitions. The infant mortality rate is taken as
per 1000 infant deaths and the fertility is taken as the births per woman. The rest of the variables
are the control variables that are used in order to reduce the omitted variable bias. Low middle
income countries are still in the process of transition. So, the changing behaviours in fertility can
be observed by analyzing the data of 3 to 4 decades. Confining this study on the low middle
income countries, there are 56 low middle income countries that are taken into account for the
study. Each country is observed for the 40 years from 1970 to 2009. For considering the concept
of demographic transitions health expenditure, GDP per capita and inflation is taken into
account, whereas for the fertility behaviors, the variables: population growth, life expectancy at
birth and crude death rates are taken into account. Infant mortality rate (IMR) remains the main
regressor in this study. Analysis has been done by using a panel regression model on unbalanced
3.2 Methodology:
In this section the econometric model has been run in order to do the empirical analysis
PG = Population Growth
In this econometric model TFR is taken as the dependent variable whereas all other variables are
taken as independent variable. So, basically here in this model the impact of infant mortality is
4. Empirical Results
This paper examines the impact of infant mortality reduction on fertility in the low
middle income countries in order to observe the general behaviour of fertility during the
demographic transitions. The key regressor in this model is Infant mortality rate. The improved
standards of living and increased health and care facilities have reduced the ratio of infant deaths
in these countries and in result the fertility trends are also changing. This model tries to elaborate
those changes and quantifies the findings. In the first basic model the independent variables
explain 70.5% variations in dependent variable. This shows the strong relationship and
significance of the variables that are used. In the first model the relationship between Infant
Mortality Rate and Total Fertility Rate is positive. It means that the infant mortality and fertility
are directly proportional to each other, so when the infant mortality rates increases, the fertility
rates are also likely to increase. As Angeles (2010) concludes in his findings that mortality
reductions have larger impact on fertility reduction and can account for the change characterized
by demographic transitions. This model also gives the same result and the relationship between
IMR and TFR are significant at 1% level. This shows that the relation is very much robust. In the
same basic model there is public health expenditure, which exhibits the positive relationship with
TFR at 1% significance level. One possible explanation of this relation can be: there is less
availability of health facilities like vaccination, availability of doctor and hospital in some of the
low middle income countries, which increase infant mortality. The health expenditure in those
countries becomes a burden on government because it increases the expense so they are less
likely to invest in; (World Development Report, 1993). In response the parents become
concerned about their children’s survival and are likely to prefer the child quantity due to the
uncertainty. In this way the fertility increases with the increase in health expenditure. Apart from
the scenario of infant mortality we have taken the mortality rates at all stages in form of life
expectancy at birth. The relationship is negative and is significant at 10% level. This negative
relationship between life expectancy and TFR describes that higher the life expectancy lower
will be the fertility rates and vice versa. This happens because the parents feel very much secure
about their children, therefore they tend to focus on the quality of their children and prefer fewer
children in order to raise them with good life standards; (Lorenz, 2002) & (Soares, 2005). In the
basic model (a) the other variable is Population growth. The relationship between the population
growth and TFR is positive and 1% significant. Obviously this is the robust relationship because
the increment in fertility rates is considered as the population growth. Borooah (2003) concludes
in his findings that in demographic transitions both population growth and fertility decline due to
the good education, improved health facilities, raised social status and availability of hygiene
food. In model (b) two more variables are included. By the inclusion of these two variables the
R-square has jumped from 70.5% to 75.68% that represents that the additional two variables
have reduced the omitted variable bias and now the independent variables define 75.68% of
variation in dependent variable. First variable is the log of GDP per capita i.e. used in this model
in order to analyze the relationship between total fertility rates and GDP per capita. The relation
is negative and 10% significant. It means that with the every percentage increment in GDP per
capita the fertility rates will decline. This is due to the fact that GDP is considered as the
wellbeing of any economy by many authors. So, the country having higher GDP per capita has
higher living standards which reduces the mortality and in response fertility declines due to the
child quality and quantity trade-off. But this is not always the case; there are many countries
which have still higher infant mortality rates in spite of higher GDP per capita.
(0.066292) (0.066403)
(0.000248) (0.000249)
Log(DR) -0.034845
(0.236096)
This is because of uneven distribution of wealth and the less expenditure over health. That is
why in our model the relation is not that much robust and is aligned with the study of Angeles
(2010) who concludes that GDP per capita and the urban ratio have lesser impact on fertility
than the infant mortality. Apart from that there is another variable that is included in model (b)
is Inflation. This variable is highly insignificant and it doesn’t show any robust relationship
with fertility. By the inclusion of these both variables, life expectancy has become significant
at 1% level.
The final model includes one more variable in the existing variables i.e. Death rate:
crude. In order to observe the overall effect of death rates on fertility, the log of crude death
rate is taken into account. By the inclusion of crude death rates, the significance level of life
expectancy is shifted from 1% to 5%. The results suggest that there is no any significant
relationship between the fertility rate and the death rate. It implies that Total Fertility Rates are
not influenced by the overall crude death rates. This finding is aligned with the finding of
Angeles (2010) in which he suggests that infant mortality have very high and significant
impact on fertility rather than overall mortality. The significance levels of other variables
5.Conclusions
After, all the study and empirical analysis, this paper tries to add to the ongoing literature of
demographic transitions. This study tells about the role of mortality i.e. particularly infant
mortality in fertility reductions, by controlling other obvious factors that are present in the
economic and demographic literature. The main findings of this study can be abridged as
follows:
The findings of this study are inclined with the previous literatures regarding
demographic transitions. Mortality changes that are characterized as infant mortality play
very much significant role and have major impact over fertility reduction in demographic
transitions. We examine this relationship by controlling other variables that influence the
Life expectancy is also taken into account in order to check the effect of mortality rates at
all ages on total fertility. The results are somewhat fuzzy but still statically significant. In
first model it is significant at 10% then in second model the significance level increases
and in third it again decreases. So, this suggests that the infant mortality is very much
influential and has major impact over fertility rather than the mortality at all ages.
Whereas the impact of crude death rate on total fertility is concerned, the relationship is
highly insignificant. It means that as a whole, death rates or mortality has nothing to do
Comparable to the other explanatory factors that are responsible for the fertility changes
Proceedings of 2nd International Conference on Business Management (ISBN: 978-969-9368-06-6)
Demographic Transitions 20
during demographic transitions, GDP per capita is less significant. Whereas the effects of
After these findings, turning towards the theoretical literature: we find that our research is very
much aligned with the mortality literature and it emphasizes the role of mortality changes on
fertility in demographic transitions. But it also makes some fuzzy explanations. It weakens one
of the most and equally big part of the literature that is the relationship between GDP per capita
and fertility. In our study we used GDP per capita as the determinant of economic
development. Relationship was significant but somewhat tenuous. There is lesser effect of
GDP per capita on fertility than other main variables. This can be because of many other
factors that are responsible for economic development that influence fertility reduction. In
short, economic development might be the antecedent of mortality reductions and would
References
Fioroni, T. (2010). Child mortality and fertility: Public vs private Education;J Popul Econ
23:73– 97
Ozcan, K.S., and Weil, N.D (2010). Mortality change, the uncertainty effect, and retirement;
Svensson, M., and Krüger, N.A (2010). Mortality and economic fluctuations; J Popul Econ
Ludwig, A., and Vogel, E. (2010). Mortality, fertility, education and capital accumulation in
Akin, S.M. (2005). Education and fertility: A panel data analysis for Middle
Birchenall, A.J. (2007). Escaping high mortality; J Econ Growth (2007) 12:351–387
Galloway, R.P., Hammel, A.E., and Lee, D.R. (1994). Fertility decline in Prussia, 1875-
158
Retherford, D.R. (1985). A theory of marital fertility transition;Population Studies, 39: 249-
268
Shen, C., and Williamson, B.J. (2001). Accounting for cross-national differences in
women’s status, economic dependency, and state strength; Social Indicators Research
53: 257–288
Doepke, M. (2005). Child mortality and fertility decline: Does the Barro-Becker model fit
Holliday, R. (2005). Evolution of human longevity, population pressure and the origins of
warfare;Biogerontology 6:363–368
Zakir, M., and Wunnava, V.P. (1999). Factors affecting infant mortality rates:Evidence
Zheng, H., Yang, Y., and Land, C.K. (2011). Heterogeneity in the Strehler-Mildvangeneral
Soares, R.R. (2003). Mortality Reductions, educational attainment and fertility choice; J
Popul Econ
Gauvreau, D. (2006). Religious diversity and the onset of the fertility transition: Canada,
1870-1900; Religion and the Decline of Fertility in the Western World, 235-258
Legrand, K.T., and Phillips, F.J. (1996). The effect of fertility reductions on infant and child
Hossain, B.M., Phillips, F.J., and Legrand, k.t. (2007).The impact of childhood mortality
Cigno, A. (1998). Fertility decisions when infant survival is endogenous; J Popul Econ 11:
21-28
Palloni, A., and Rafalimanana, H. (1999). The effects of infant mortality on fertility
Mishra, V. Nielsen, L.,and Smyth, R. (2010). On the relationship between female labor
force participation and fertility in G7 countries: Evidence from panel cointegration and
Granger
Gonzalez, F., and Quast, T. (2011). Macroeconomic changes and mortality in Mexico;
Journal of
Bloom, E. D., Canning, D. Fink, G.,and Finlay, E.J.(2009). Fertility, female labor force
Growth 15:177–204
22:540–555
Yucesahin, M.M., Murat E., andOzgur, M.E. (2008). Regional fertility differences in
Turkey persistent high fertility in the Southeast; Population Space and Place Journal
14:135–158
Wickrama, K.A.S., and Lorenz, O.F. (2002). Women’s status, fertility decline, and
women’s health in developing countries: Direct and indirect influences of social status
Grundy, E. (2009). Women’s fertility and mortality in late mid-life: A comparison of three
Neanidis, C.K. (2010). Humanitarian aid, fertility and economic growth; Journal of
Ecomomica, pp.1–35