Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Kolkata
Annual Report
2014-15
Victoria Memorial Hall
Kolkata
Annual Report
2014-15
22 Victoria Memorial Hall
Annual Report 2014-15 3
Contents
Victoria Memorial Hall 5
The Collection 6
The Galleries 7
Garden 8
Archive 9
Library 10
Board of Trustees 11
Exhibition 12
Educational Activities 13
Activity Club for Young Friends 18
Conservation 23
Restoration 24
Documentation 25
Rajbhasha 26
Seminars and Training 27
Visit of Dignitaries 28
Visitors 29
Revenue Earning, Visitors’ Facilities and Publications 30
Modernization Programme 31
Financial Statements
Balance Sheet 37
Income & Expenditure Account 39
Schedules 41
Statement of Receipts and Payments 73
4 Victoria Memorial Hall
Annual Report 2014-15 5
The Collection
As a museum, the Victoria Memorial Hall’s collection has
28,394 artefact’s displayed Periodically in nine galleries that
encapsulate the history of our nation extending over three
centuries beginning from 1650 A.D. The collection includes
paintings in oil and water colour, sketches and drawings, aquatints,
lithographs, photographs, rare books and manuscripts, stamps and
postal stationery, coins and medals, arms and armour, sculptures,
costumes, personal relics and other miscellaneous archival documents.
The highlight of the museum is a unique collection of paintings by major
European artists of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, such as Johann
Zoffany, Joshua Reynolds, William Hodges, George Chinnery, Robert Holmes,
Thomas Hickey, Tilly Kettle, Baltazar Solvyns, Charles D’Oyly, Emily Eden, John
Fleming and Samuel Davis. It is a repository of the largest number of paintings
by the famous uncle and nephew pair of artists, Thomas and William Daniell. In
the collection of the Memorial is the third largest painting on a single canvas, the
Russian artist Vassili Verestchagin’s The State Procession of the Prince of Wales into
Jaipur in 1876. Other important and interesting artefact’s in the collection of
the Memorial include historic illustrated Persian manuscripts like the Mughal
Emperor Aurangzeb’s hand-written Quran, the Persian translation of the tale
of Nala and Damayanti by Abul Faiz Faizi, Dara Shikoh’s translation of the
Upanishads, a manuscript copy of the Ain-i-Akbari, Kalighat paintings,
Iranian paintings of the Qajar school, Tipu Sultan’s personal war diary,
cannons and cannon balls used in the battle of Plassey, Maharaja Ranjit
Singh’s personal sword, and Tatya Tope’s overcoat. In the recent years
the collection has been further enriched by the acquisition, on enduring
loan from Rabindra Bharati Society, of nearly 5,000 paintings of the Bengal
School of Art, especially many prominent works of Abanindranath Tagore,
Gaganendranath Tagore, Jamini Roy and others
Annual Report 2014-15 7
The Galleries
A large number of artefact’s from the invaluable collections of the
Memorial are on display. They are suitably placed in various gal-
leries.
Garden
Apart from the priceless collection displayed in the galleries, the Memorial has a well-maintained
and picturesque garden with water-bodies, lawns, gravelled pathways, historical busts and statues,
and a rich collection of around 2378 trees.
The original scheme of the garden of Victoria Memorial was drawn in 1915 in consultation with Lord
Redesdale (acknowledged as the greatest amateur authority on the subject of landscape gardening),
Mr. E. White of Messrs. Milner & Co., Landscape Gardeners and Architects and Sir David Prain,
Superintendent, Botanical Gardens, Calcutta and Director of Botanical Survey of India.
Currently, the garden is a major tourist attraction by itself and attracts nearly 3.5 million visitors
annually. It not only offers a visual treat, but is also a place that has over the years become a
favourite with the city’s young and old alike because of its abundant greenery and open space.
Annual Report 2014-15 9
Archive
The VMH archive has rare collections, e.g. Justice John Hyde’s manuscript diary and legal notes, early
colonial documents on Calcutta and Bengal in the 18th and 19th centuries, land records in Urdu and
Persian, a number of old Supreme Court records, as well as the personal memorabilia of historical
personalities – both Indian and British – and miscellaneous other records that constitute an invaluable
source material for scholars working on Indo-British history from the 18th to the 20th century.
10 Victoria Memorial Hall
Library
The Library of the Memorial is a special reference library for Indo-British history, history of Calcutta,
history of art and conservation, museum studies and the management of cultural institutions. It
has 15,006 volumes in its collection and adds to the collection every year. In addition, it subscribes
to several periodicals and newspapers. The library has a sizeable collection of rare books, which
includes important private collections, including those of George Lyell, B.C. Law, and D.C. Ganguly.
It also subscribes to several daily newspapers and periodicals.
A large number of users from outside VMH used the reference library this year. In the Reference
Section, 1900 books were used by researchers.
Acquisition of Books:
175 new books were added to the VMH Library’s collection this year.
Annual Report 2014-15 11
Board of Trustees
1. (a) Shri M. K. Narayanan, Hon’ble Governor of West Chairman
Bengal
(b) Shri Keshari Nath Tripathi, Hon’ble Governor of
West Bengal – since 24.07.2014
2. (a) Shri Arun Mishra, Hon’ble Chief Justice, Calcutta Member
High Court
(b) Smt. Manjula Chellur, Hon’ble Chief Justice,
Calcutta High Court – since 5.08.2014
3. Shri Ravindra Singh, IAS Secretary to the Govt. of Member
India, Ministry of Culture
4. Shri Raghav Chandra, IAS, Additional Secretary & Member
Financial Adviser, Ministry of Culture, Govt. of India
5. Shri Sovan Chatterjee, Hon’ble Mayor, Kolkata Member
Municipal Corporation
6. (a) Shri Stephen Hongray, Accountant General (A&E) Member
West Bengal
(b) Ms. Madhumita Basu, Accountant General (A&E)
West Bengal
(c) Shri M. S. Subrahmanyam, Principal Accountant
General (A&E) West Bengal – since 30.12.2014
7. Shri Vivek Kumar, IAS, Principal Secretary to the Govt. Member
of West Bengal, Higher Education Department
8. Prof. Mahesh Rangarajan, Director, Nehru Memorial Member
Museum & Library
9. Justice (Retd.) Shri Chittatosh Mukherjee Member
10. Dr. P. C. Mahtab Member
11. Prof. Sabyasachi Bhattacharya Member
12. Smt. Shanta Ghosh Member
13. Shri Shuvaprasanna Member
14. Prof. Poonam Chaudhary Member
12 Victoria Memorial Hall
Exhibition
vv A
s VMH’s special offering for children, the the centenary of the First World War on 11
exhibition Wildlife in Africa through the November 2014. Photographs of colonial
eyes of Captain William Cornwallis troops engaged in the First World War were
Harris (1807- 1848) from the collection of displayed in the Portrait Gallery. General
Victoria Memorial Hall was held from 29 April Shankar Roychowdhury, PVMC, COAS
to 1 June 2014. The exhibition featured 30 (Retd), Former Member of the Parliament and
lithographs prints of wild animals of Southern Professor Kaushik Roy, Guru Nanak Professor
Africa. During the exhibition period, films on and Head of the Dept. of History, Jadavpur
wildlife were continuously screened. University were present as guest speakers.
vv A
n exhibition titled Orientalism Revisited vv V
MH organized the exhibition on Folk Archive
– The Creative World of Asit Kumar – Contemporary Popular Art from the UK
Haldar (1890 – 1964) was held in collaboration by Mr. Alan Kane and Mr. Jeremy Deller
with Allahabad Museum. The exhibition curated in collaboration with The British Council. The
by Shri Rajesh Purohit, Director, Allahabad exhibition was inaugurated on 16 December
Museum was inaugurated on 24 June 2014 by 2014 and was on view till 7 January 2015.
eminent artist, Shri Shuvaprasanna. A six page vv A
n exhibition of the Artworks of Samuel
informative folder was brought for the exhibition. Davis (1760-1819) with 32 selected works
The exhibition was on view till 27 July 2014. from the collection of Victoria Memorial Hall
vv V
MH in collaboration with American Center was displayed in the Portrait Gallery on 13
organized the exhibition Beyond Bollywood January 2015.
- Indian Americans shape the Nation, vv An exhibition on The Art of Abanindranath
during 5-9 November 2014. The exhibition Tagore, curated by Professor Ratan
was curated by Dr. Masum Momaya for the Parimoo, Director Lalbhai Dalpatbhai Museum,
Smithsonian Asian Pacific American Center in Ahmedabad, from the collections of Victoria
Washington DC. Memorial Hall and Rabindra Bharati Society,
was inaugurated on 3 March 2015 by eminent
vv V
MH in collaboration with Alliance française
art historian Professor R Siva Kumar,
du Bengale organized the exhibition War
Kala Bhavana, Visva–Bharati University. The
and Colonies 1914-1918 to commemorate
exhibition was display till 19 April 2015.
Educational Activities
Lectures / Seminars/ Panel discussions
vv In the context of India’s 68th Independence Day, Ms Amita Prasad, Modern High School for
a panel discussion on Teaching the History Girls, Ms. Tina Servaia, Calcutta International
of the Freedom Movement to Young School, Ms. Megha Malhotra, Director,
Children was organized on 19 August 2014 Peaceworks Project, Seagull Foundation for the
by involving teachers of different schools from Arts and Mr Anirban Mondal, Netaji Nagar
in and around the city. The panellists were: High School, Durgapur.
• M
s. Devi Kar, Director, Modern High School vv VMH organized an illustrated lecture on Recalling
for Girls, Kolkata moderated the session. Jewish Calcutta by author and Fulbright Nehru
Schools from which teachers participated in the Scholar Dr. Jael Silliman on 1 September
interactive session and shared their classroom 2014. Other Speakers for the day were Mr.
experiences included the Apeejay School, Adam Grotsky, Executive Director, US-India
Park Street, Apeejay School, Salt Lake, Birla Educational Foundation, Mr. G.M. Kapur of
High School, Chowringhee High School, Delhi INTACH, West Bengal Chapter, Professor Amlan
Public School, New Town, Delhi Public School, Dasgupta of the School of Cultural Texts and
Ruby Park, Gokhale Memorial Girls’ School, Records, Jadavpur University and Mrs. Joe Cohen
La Martenelle High School, La Martiniere for representing the Jewish community in Kolkata.
Boy’s, Lakshmipat Singhania Academy, Modern
High School for Girls’, South City International vv As a prelude to the ensuing Durga Puja Festival,
School, The Heritage School, and Techno India a session was organized on the topic Utsaber
School, Garia. Sekal-o-Ekal (Festival: Then and Now) on
20 September 2014. Smt. Krishna Bose
14 Victoria Memorial Hall
Chairperson, Netaji Research Bureau, Kolkata and with Goethe –Institute Max Mueller
Shri Shuvaprasanna, eminent artist were the Bhavan and Kolkata Sukriti Foundation on
speakers on the occasion. 29 November 2014. Panelists were: Ankita
Mukherji, Bhairavi Jani, Dr. Kaarthikeyan,
vv O
rganized a panel discussion on Violence Dr. Mallika Sarabhai, Dr. Mohan Agashe,
against Women and the Role of Media Paranjoy Guha Thakurta, Rakesh Khanna,
on the occasion of UN International Day to Dr. Urvashi Butalia and the Moderator was
end violence against women in collaboration Dr. Kunal Sarkar.
vv V
MH in collaboration with Calcutta Debating India Research Institute Victoria University
Circle and the Kolkata Sukriti Foundation of Wellington, New Zealand and Smt. Ishita
organized a panel discussion on clutter has Banerjee-Dube.
compromised media’s credibility with
internationally renowned media personalities vv An in-house lecture on Presidential
from India and abroad on 13 December 2014. Directives on Reservation Policy held on
22 December 2014. Dr. S. K. Naskar,
vv
VMH in collaboration with Cambridge former Deputy Director, National Commission
University Press jointly organized a panel for SC/ST conducted the programme.
discussion on Modern India: Approaches,
Understandings and Teachings on 18 vv An illustrated talk titled Using Photographs
December 2014. This session was chaired by to illustrate the Nagas: the writings
Shri Sabyasachi Bhattacharya, Tagore and Letters of Reverend Perrine by
National Fellow, National Archives of India, New Ms Geraldine Forbes, Professor Emerita
Delhi and Former Vice-Chancellor, Visva Bharati Department of History, State University of New
University. The panelists were Smt. Tanika York Oswego was held on 23 February 2015.
Sarkar, Professor of History, Centre for The talk was chaired by Shri G S Rautela,
Historical Studies Jawaharlal Nehru University, Director General, National Council of Science
New Delhi, Shri Sekhar Bandyopadhyay, Museums & Director-in-Charge, Anthropological
Professor of History and Director, New Zealand Survey of India.
Annual Report 2014-15 15
vv V
MH celebrated the World Tourism Day on
27 September 2014 with a series of events.
Sri Bratya Basu, Minister in charge, Tourism, • Workshop on Chhau Dance:
Government of West Bengal encouraged the
children and artisans participating in the A workshop on Chhau Dance (folk dance of
programme by his gracious presence. Purulia district of West Bengal) was also
organized for the pre-registered participants.
A sizeable number of visitors including some
foreigners took part in the workshop.
• I
llustrated lecture : “Community led
Heritage Tourism – a Process and Product :
Smt. Sayantani Raychaudhuri, General
Manager, Banglanatak dot com delivered an
illustrated lecture on the above topic marking
the conclusion of the day-long programme.
Some of these events were organized with the
support of Banglanatak dot com.
• W
orkshop for school children: Painting on vv Foundation Day of the Memorial :
clay pots. (Details under Activity Club)
VMH celebrated 110th Foundation Day on 4
• Artisans at work: January 2015 of the Memorial by announcing
rtisans shared the process of making the
A free Son-et-lumiere (Light and Sound) shows
crafts of Patachitra, Wooden Doll, Sitalpati, both Bengali and Hindi for the public.
Kachuripana and Dokra with the audience.
Annual Report 2014-15 17
vv O
n the eve of Earth Day, the Activity Club
Environment Day 2014
for Young Friends of Victoria Memorial Hall
organized a Poster Making Competition on the • Slogan Writing Competition
theme of Global Warming in collaboration with A Slogan Writing Competition based on this
the Narkeldanga Rehnuma e Niswaan on year’s theme “Raise Your Voice, Not
21 April 2014. Approximately 150 students the Sea Level” was organised at VMH. The
in the age group of 13-17 from 23 different competition was held in two categories - Junior
schools in Kolkata participated in the Category (for students from classes V to VIII)
competition. A panel of eminent judges - Shri and Senior Category (for students from classes
Wasim R Kapoor, Smt. Nilima Goel and IX to XII). Students from all over West Bengal
Smt. Bipasha Bhunja – selected the winners. participated in the competition.
Prizes for the best three posters went to Silver The students were asked to write a slogan within
Point School (1st), Modern High School for 10 words in Bengali, Hindi or English, which were
Girls (2nd) and Belgachia Urdu High School for submitted through e-mail. A panel of eminent
Boys (3rd). Two more works of students from judges – Shri Pathik Guha, Smt. Joyashree
Aulad Hussain Islamic Academy and Belgachia Roy, Shri Masood Huq went through all the
Urdu High School for Girls received a special entries and decided on the winners. The winners
mention from the judges. Besides, the team received prizes and certificates.
of special children from All Bengal Women’s
Union got an honourable mention for their vv VMH and The Seagull Foundation for the Arts
efforts. All participants received certificates of in association with Kolkata Police organized a
participation. Golpo Mela – The Peaceworks Storytelling
Festival on the occasion of Children’s Day
on 15 November 2014. About 700-800
underprivileged children attended the festival.
Annual Report 2014-15 19
Other Events
vv V
MH in collaboration with Goethe-Institut vv VMH in collaboration with West Bengal Tourism
/ Max Mueller Bhavan Kolkata and Calcutta presented a Story of Songs - a musical
School of Music organized a western classical journey into the evolution of Bengali
music concert –Towards Modernity – songs - conceptualised and directed by Shri
Celebrating the 150th birth anniversary Debojyoti Mishra on 5 February 2015.
of Richard Strauss by Professor Siegfried
Mauser – piano and Amelie Sandmann- vv VMH organised a film based presentation
Mauser -soprano featuring works by Beethoven, -Heritage Music across Borders on
Schönberg, Rihm, Strauss and followed by the remarkable journeys and music
a performance with the Calcutta Chamber collection of ethnomusicologist Deben
Orchestra Camerata on 3 November 2014. Bhattacharya (1921-2001) with introductory
comments by Professor Hari Vasudevan,
Professor of History, University of Calcutta.
This was followed by an interactive session with
Smt. Jharna Bose, wife of Deben Bhattacharya
on 16 February 2015.
vv V
MH and Apeejay Kolkata Literary Festival
(AKLF) organized a segment of the Apeejay
Kolkata Literary Festival 2015 at Victoria
Memorial Hall on 17 January 2015 with a
Literary Afternoon with Celebrated Writers
from India and abroad.
• 5 .15 pm - Fact and Fiction: History as • The festival was attended by large numbers
Literature or Social Science? (with Ramachandra of people on all days. The distinguished
Guha and Supriya Chaudhuri) participants included noted film personalities,
actors, music directors and film makers,
vv VMH jointly organized this year’s Kolkata singers, authors, writers, poets, activists,
Literary Meet (23-27 January 2015) at academicians, media personalities, journalists,
VMH with the following highlights: historians from India and abroad. To mention
a few: Ruskin Bond, Rajdeep Sardesai, Shubha
• The Meet was spread over five days from 23 to Mudgal, Aatish Taseer, Daman Singh, Rita
27 January 2015 with 48 sessions. Bhamani, Arun Shourie, Raj Kamal Jha, Jaya
Bachan, Gautam Bhadra, Rahul Bose, Joanna
• The Kolkata Literary Meet was formally
Rakoff, Vidya Shah, Danish Hussain, Javed
inaugurated by H.E. the Governor of West
Akhtar, Shabana Azmi, Raghu Rai, Jeet Thayil,
Bengal Shri KN Tripathi in presence of Shri
Valmik Thapar, and Amitav Ghosh
Ruskin Bond on 23 January, 2015. The
inaugural session was followed by a conversation
between Ruskin Bond and Jash Sen on the
lifetime of his books.
Outreach Activities
vv VMH participated in the Vibrant India vv V
MH participated in the Sundarban Krishti
Exhibition 2014 and 9th Meri Dilli Utsav Mela O Loko Sanskriti Utsab organised
from 17 - 19 October 2014 at Janak Puri, Dilli by Kultali Milon Tirtha Society at Kultali, P.O.
Haat, New Delhi, with an exhibition of photographs Narayantala, P.S. and Block- Basanti, Dist.
highlighting its activities and achievements. - 24 Parganas (South), West Bengal from
20 - 29 December 2014.
22 Victoria Memorial Hall
Conservation
A. Conserved
Paper objects: 105 (from the Rabindra Bharati Society collection)
Folios from albums: 113 (fumigation, sterilization and conservation)
B. Preventive Conservation :
Weekly visit 8 stores for dusting, cleaning and preventive treatment of art objects
Restoration
1. CURATIVE RESTORATION
Objects from VMH collection:
Oil paintings restored: 11
Frames conserved: 10
Objects of other institutions:
Oil Paintings restored: 2 (Raj Bhavan, Kolkata)
Oil paintings restored: 4 (Presidency University, Kolkata)
Documentation
Physical verification, Documentation and Cataloguing ii) Responded to the enquiries of 51 scholars
from India and abroad during the year
• Physical Verification:
• G
. Nabi, J. Roy & A. Ghosh have attended
i) Physical counting and verification of the RBS various lectures at VMH organized by Hindi
objects continued during the year. 382 objects Unit and Education Unit.
were counted and verified this year.
i) Captions and other details of the displayed
• Documentation and Cataloguing: objects were prepared for the galleries of the
i)
The entry into the collection management Museum as well as for temporary exhibitions
software Jatan continued during the year. A held in the VMH during the year.
total of 3,337 entries were made during the
year.
26 Victoria Memorial Hall
Rajbhasha
For compliance of the Official Language policy, 2. The Memorial observed ‘Hindi Saptah’ from
the Memorial encouraged use of Hindi in day to 14 September to 20 September 2014
day official work and the following programs were and organized a number of events including
undertaken during the year: competitions in Hindi. More than 60 staff
1. The VMH organized Hindi workshops on noting Members / officers participated in the
and drafting for the staff members having working competitions and out of them 37 were given
knowledge of Hindi. Shri Ram Narayan Saroj, prizes for their excellence in the competitions
Dy. Director (O. L.) conducted these workshops including a quiz contest in Hindi.
on 16 June 2014, 22 November 2014 and 16 3. Shri Gholam Nabi, Sr. Technical Assistant,
March 2015. In the workshops, staff members delivered a special lecture Raagmala Chitrakala
acquainted themselves with the Annual Program in Hindi in the Portrait Hall of the VMH on
of Hindi and also practised noting and drafting 15 September, 2015.
in Hindi.
Annual Report 2014-15 27
Visit of Dignitaries
A large number of dignitaries visited VMH during the year. Notable among them were:
HRH Princess Maha Chakri Sirindhorn of Thailand, on 22.07.2014
Ambassador (Retd.) Kathleen Stephens, US Charge d’ Affaires, on 13.08.2014
H.E. Mr. Joon- Gyu Lee, Ambassador, Republic of Korea, on 28.10.2014
Mr. Andres Barbe, Ambassador of Chile in India, on 24.11.2014
Professor Eric Maskin, Professor of Economics, Harvard University, and Nobel Laureate
(2007), on 8.01.2015
H. E. Mr Nikola Gruevski, Prime Minister of Macedonia, on 13.01.2015
Mr Bernhard Wrabetz, Ambassador of Austria to India, on 24.02.2015
Annual Report 2014-15 29
Visitors
Garden `13,67,472.00
Museum: Indian `19,68,240.00
Museum: Foreigners ` 30,365.00
Son-et-lumiere ` 9714.00
Morning Walkers `1,749.00
Total ` 33,77,540.00
* These figures are exclusive of the number of school students in uniform, military personnel and VIPs.
30 Victoria Memorial Hall
Visitor facilities:
The toilet block for visitors near the VMH Canteen was renovated.
Annual Report 2014-15 31
Modernization Programme
The Victoria Memorial Hall has undertaken – with offices from the VMH building to a renovated office
financial assistance from the Ministry of Culture – block in the southeast corner of the campus, in
a comprehensive programme of modernizing and order to free up space in the museum building for
upgrading its galleries and storage areas. This is the more display. This shifting was completed this year,
first such comprehensive scheme of modernization in which also witnessed the beginning of work on the
the history of the Memorial, and it addresses issues construction of a renovated security enclosure and a
of conservation of the historical monument in terms modern museum shop on either side of the northern
of a long-term building plan; modernization of the entrance of the VMH building.
display systems, the illumination, climate control, The work of this modernization is being carried
security surveillance, the storage systems, the out in phased manner. The work on the renovated
laboratories and the library in tune with international Administrative Block has been completed, and the
best practices; rationalization and optimization renovation of the external facade of the VMH building
of the space within the monument to provide for on the South, North & East sides is in progress. The
an enhanced experience for visitors; branding, installation of a CCTV surveillance system and a
promotion, and sale of merchandise through creation public address system in the gardens with speakers
of a state-of-the-art museum shop, and many others. is also in progress.
One key aspect of the modernization programme
is the shifting of the administrative and accounts
32 Victoria Memorial Hall
Separate Audit Report of the Comptroller & Auditor General of India on the Accounts of
Victoria Memorial Hall, Kolkata for the year ended 31 March 2015.
We have audited the attached Balance Sheet of the Victoria Memorial Hall, Kolkata, as at 31 March 2015,
the Income and Expenditure account and Receipts and Payments Account for the year ended on the date
under Section 20(1) of the Comptroller and Auditor General’s (Duties, Power and Conditions of Service)
Act, 1971 read with Rule 12 of Victoria Memorial (2nd Amendment) Rule 1973 under section 5(2) (e)
of Victoria Memorial Act, 1903. The Audit has been entrusted for the period upto 2017-18. These financial
statements are the responsibility of the Institute’s management. Our responsibility is to express an opinion
on these financial statements based on our audit.
2. This Separate Audit Report contains the comments of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India
(CAG) on the accounting treatment only with regard to classification, conformity with the best accounting
practices, accounting standards and disclosure norms, etc. Audit observation on financial transactions
with regard to compliance with the Law, Rules and Regulations (Propriety and Regularity) and efficiency-
cum-performance aspects, etc., if any, are reported through inspection Reports/CAG’s Audit Reports
separately.
3. We have conducted our audit in accordance with auditing standards generally accepted in India. These
standards require that we plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the
financial statements are free from material misstatements. An audit includes examining, on a test basis,
evidences supporting the amounts and disclosure in the financial statements. An audit also includes
assessing the accounting principles used and significant estimates made by the management, as well as
evaluating the overall presentation of financial statements. We believe that our audit provides a reasonable
basis for our opinion.
4. Based on our audit, we report that:
i. We have obtained all that information and explanations, which to the best of our knowledge and belief
were necessary for the purpose of our audit:
ii. The Balance Sheet, Income and Expenditure Account and Receipts and Payments Account dealt with
by this report have been drawn up in the format prescribed by the Minister of Finance, Government of
India.
iii. In our opinion, proper books of accounts and other relevant records have been maintained by the
Victoria Memorial Hall, Kolkata as required under Rule 12 of Victoria Memorial (2nd Amendment)
Rule 1973 under section 5(2) (e) of Victoria Memorial Act, 1903, in so far as it appears for our
examination of Such books.
We further report that:
Comments on Accounts
A. Income and Expenditure Account
1.1 Expenditure
1.1.1 Depreciation (Schedule 8) : `938.45 lakh
The above head remained overstated due to charging depreciation on CCTV wrongly capitalized despite
non-receipt of equipment against payment of advance in 2013-14. Despite mention in previous year’s
Annual Report 2014-15 33
Audit Report (2013-14), the Hall had not taken any rectificatory measure. This resulted in understatement
of surplus by `0.98 lakh at the end of 2014-15.
B. General
2.1 An amount of `10.00 lakh was booked under Other Administrative Expenses (Schedule-21) as “Grant
to Rabindra Bharati Society for enduring loan of 5000 paintings and art objects” as per
the agreement between the VMH and Rabindra Bharati Society, Kolkata. Since the Hall had paid
`10.00 lakh to the Society on regular basis for the upkeep of the museum of the Society the amount
should have been shown under Expenditure on Grants and Subsidies (Schedule 22) showing in details
name of the organisation, their activities and utilisation of the amount, etc,.
2.2 The Hall had exhibited total value of Land and Buildings `1015.62 lakh, without segregating the
Land and the Building. It should have been separately disclosed either under ‘Leasehold Land’ or
‘Freehold Land’ as per the guidelines of the Common Format of Accounts. A disclosure should be
made that land was provided free of cost. Despite mention in the previous year’s Management letter
no rectificatory measure was taken by the Hall.
2.3 Despite mention in previous Audit Report the Hall had not provided for the liabilities towards gratuity
and leave encashment for `176.91 lakh and `95.60 lakh respectively in 2014-15 as per actual
valuation.
C. Grant-in-Aid
The Victoria Memorial Hall receives grants from the Govt. of India. In 2014-15 the Hall had received total
grants of `3380.90 lakh (Plan `2746.78 lakh and Non-plan `634.12 lakh including receivable grant of
`62.12 lakh of previous year). Out of the total grants (`3380.90 lakh) the Hall had spent `3405.56 lakh
(Plan `2715.96 lakh and Non-plan `689.60 lakh) leaving net unspent balance of (-) `24.66 lakh (Plan
`30.82 lakh and Non-plan `(-) 55.48 lakh).
The unspent negative balance under Non-plan head was met out of the internal revenue of the Hall.
D. Net Effect
The Net Effect of the comments given in the preceding paragraph is that the Excess of Income over
Expenditure was understated by `0.98 lakh for the year ended 31 March 2015.
34 Victoria Memorial Hall
E. Management Letter
Deficiencies which have not been included in the Audit Report have been brought to the notice of the Victoria
Memorial Hall, Kolkata through a management letter issued separately for remedial/corrective action.
v. Subject to our observations in the preceding paragraphs, we report that the Balance Sheet, Income and
Expenditure Account and Receipts and Payments Account dealt with by this report are in agreement
with the books of accounts.
vi. In our opinion and to the best of our information and according to the explanations given to us, the said
financial statements, read together with the Accounting Policies and Notes on Accounts, and subject to
the significant matters stated above and other matters mentioned in the Annexure to this Separate Audit
Report, give a true and fair view in conformity with accounting principles generally accepted in India.
i. In so far as it relates to the Balance Sheet, of the state of affairs of the Victoria Memorial Hall,
Kolkata as at 31 March 2015 and
ii. In so far as it relates to Income and Expenditure Account of the Surplus for the year ended on that date.
For and on behalf of the C&AG of India
Place : Kolkata
Date : 03.03.2016
Annexure
1. Adequacy of Internal Audit System
There was no Internal Audit Manual in use although internal audit is conducted by a Chartered Accountant
Firm.
2. Adequacy of Internal Control System
Internal Control System was inadequate in view of the following :
i) F
ixed Assets were not covered by any insurance including fire insurance in respect of the buildings.
ii) The VMH had no system of maintaining Journal Vouchers against the Journal Entries passed during
the year.
iii) No Physical Verification of fixed assets was done in 2014-15 and Physical Verification of paintings and
art objects has not been completed.
3. Physical verification of Fixed Assets/Inventory
The Hall had exhibited the Fixed Assets of `563.17 lakh in schedule-8 but no physical verification on
Fixed Assets had been conducted in 2014-15. As such actual existence of all Fixed Assets could not be
verified in audit.
The Hall had also not completed Physical Verification of 5000 paintings and art objects received from
Rabindra Bharati Society, Kolkata.
4. Regularity in payment of statutory dues :
The Hall was regular in payment of Statutory Dues.
VICTORIA MEMORIAL HALL, KOLKATA
Financial Statements for The
Central Autonomous Bodies
Relating to The Year 2014 - 2015
Balance Sheet 37
Income & Expenditure Account 39
Schedules 41
Statement of Receipts and Payments 73
Annexure 1 & 2 76
BALANCE
SHEET
38 Victoria Memorial Hall
(Amount - Rs.)
Corpus/Capital Fund And Liabilities Schedule Current Year Previous Year
Corpus / Capital Fund 1 572523178.70 336855007.10
Reserves And Surplus 2 0.00 0.00
Earmarked / Endowment Funds 3 149667802.13 142835690.28
Secured Loans And Borrowings 4 0.00 0.00
Unsecured Loans And Borrowings 5 0.00 0.00
Deferred Credit Liabilities 6 0.00 0.00
Current Liabilities And Provisions 7 13955778.00 6167350.00
General Provident Fund 7A 31895004.27 30232682.27
TOTAL 768041763.10 516090729.65
ASSETS
FIXED ASSETS 8 401381330.29 156346404.29
INVESTMENTS - FROM EARMARKED / ENDOWMENT 9 134511250.13 134699777.28
FUNDS
INVESTMENTS - OTHERS 10 119213730.00 78789247.00
CURRENT ASSETS, LOANS, ADVANCES ETC. 11 81040448.41 116022618.81
MISCELLANEOUS EXPENDITURE 0.00 0.00
(to the extent not written off or adjusted)
GENERAL PROVIDENT FUND 7A 31895004.27 30232682.27
TOTAL 768041763.10 516090729.65
SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES 24
CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND NOTES ON 25
ACCOUNTS
‘Plan’ & ‘Non-Plan’ have been specified in Schedules Figures within bracket indicates minus figures
(Amount - Rs.)
INCOME Schedule Current Year Previous Year
Income from Sales / Services 12 2124.00 1419.00
Grants / Subsidies 13
Plan 49678000.00 0.00
Non-Plan 66200000.00 44120000.00
Fees / Subscriptions 14 33300652.00 30944199.27
Income from Investments (Income on Invest from earmarked/endow. Funds transferred to Funds) 15 0.00 0.00
Income from Royalty, Publication etc. 16 237740.00 326473.00
Interest Earned 17 13464136.00 7184693.00
Other Income 18 1009586.50 697758.00
Decrease in stock of Finished goods and works-in-progress 19 471319.10 (287817.34)
TOTAL (A) 164363557.60 82986724.93
EXPENDITURE
Establishment Expenses 20 70691636.00 62876398.00
Other Administrative Expenses etc. 21 19480417.00 14541040.88
Expenditure on Grants etc. (Plan) 22 54579019.00 0.00
Interest 23 0.00 0.00
Depreciation (Net Total at the year-end-corresponding to Schedule 8) marked (A) in Schedule 8 8169956.00 7630637.00
TOTAL (B) 152921028.00 85048075.88
Balance being excess of Income over Expenditure (A-B) 11442529.60 (2061350.95)
Transfer to Special Reserve (Specify each) 0.00 0.00
Transfer to / from General Reserve 0.00 0.00
BALANCE BEING SURPLUS/(DEFICIT) CARRIED TO CORPUS/CAPITAL FUND 11442529.60 (2061350.95)
SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES 24 0.00 0.00
CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND NOTES ON ACCOUNTS 25 0.00 0.00
Note : Those items where ‘Plan’ has not been indicated relate to ‘Non-Plan’
Figures within bracket indicates minus figures
SCHEDULES
42 Victoria Memorial Hall
Note : Those items where ‘Plan’ has not been indicated relate to ‘Non-Plan’
FORM OF FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (NON-PROFIT ORGANISATIONS)
Name of Entity VICTORIA MEMORIAL HALL, KOLKATA
SCHEDULES FORMING PART OF BALANCE SHEET AS AT 31.03.2015
Lord Curzon Fund for the Office Conservation Fund received Remodelling of Security
Endowment Fund Accom Received From Taj from Central Gallery Fencing Curent Year Previous Year
Govt.
a) Opening balance of the funds 72260278.28 22338013.00 164896.00 0.00 6063987.00 42008516.00 142835690.28 127006139.14
b) Additions to the Funds:
i) Grants 0.00 0.00 60078000.00
ii) Income from investments made 4009545.42 1817510.00 -8208.00 523300.00 3632873.00 9975020.42 15829551.14
on account of funds
iii) Other additions (specify nature) 0.00
c) Deduction to the funds: 0.00
Loss on Foreign Exchange Fluc- 3142908.57 3142908.57
tuation
TOTAL (a+b) 73126915.13 24155523.00 156688.00 0.00 6587287.00 45641389.00 149667802.13 202913690.28
c) Utilisation/Expenditure towards
objectives of funds
i) Capital Expenditure 0.00
- Fixed Assets 0.00 3266809.00
- Others 0.00 11811191.00
Total 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 15078000.00
ii) Revenue Expenditure 0.00 0.00
- Expenditure out of Govt. 0.00 41619387.88
Grants
- Rent 0.00 0.00
- Others 0.00 5081459.00
- Other Administrative expenses 0.00 -1700846.88
Total 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 45000000.00
TOTAL(c) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 60078000.00
NET BALANCE FOR THE
73126915.13 24155523.00 156688.00 0.00 6587287.00 45641389.00 149667802.13 142835690.28
YEAR - END (a + b -c)
Notes
1) Disclosures shall be made under relevant heads based on conditions attaching to the grants.
2) Plan funds received from the Central / State Government are to be shown as separate funds and not to be mixed up with any other Funds.
Note : Those items where ‘Plan’ has not been indicated relate to ‘Non-Plan’
43
44 Victoria Memorial Hall
SCHEduLE 7A
EXPENDITURE Amount (Rs.) Amount (Rs.) INCOME Amount (Rs.) Amount (Rs.)
Interest to Members Account 2321386.00 Interest on
Investment
Actual during the 63287.00
year
Bank Charges 818.00
Add: Accrued inter- 2252491.00
est during the year
Adjustment of Liability for 0.00 2315778.00
Previous Year
Surplus Deficit 6426.00
2322204.00 2322204.00
50 Victoria Memorial Hall
schedule 7A
* The value represents the total depreciation charged on disposed assets being adjusted
51
52
FORM OF FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (NON-PROFIT ORGANISATIONS)
Name of Entity VICTORIA MEMORIAL HALL, KOLKATA
SCHEDULES FORMING PART OF BALANCE SHEET AS AT 31.03.2015
Note : Those items where ‘Plan’ has not been indicated relate to ‘Non-Plan’
Annual Report 2014-15 57
Note : Those items where ‘Plan’ has not been indicated relate to ‘Non-Plan’
Annual Report 2014-15 59
Note : Those items where ‘Plan’ has not been indicated relate to ‘Non-Plan’
60 Victoria Memorial Hall
SCHEDULE 15 - INCOME FROM INVESTMENTS Investment from Earmarked Fund Investment - Others
Current Previous
Current Year Previous Year
Year Year
(Income on Investment from Earmarked / Endowment
Funds transferred to Funds)
1. Interest
a) On Govt. Securities - -
b) Other Bonds / Debentures - -
2. Dividends
a) On Shares - -
b) On Mutual Fund Securities - -
3. Rents - -
4. Others (Specify) Interest on TDR 0.00 - -
TOTAL 0.00 0.00 - -
TRANSFERRED TO EARMARKED /
0.00 0.00
ENDOWMENT FUNDS
Note : Those items where ‘Plan’ has not been indicated relate to ‘Non-Plan’
Annual Report 2014-15 61
Note : Those items where ‘Plan’ has not been indicated relate to ‘Non-Plan’ Figures within bracket indicates minus figures
Annual Report 2014-15 63
TOTAL - -
SCHEDULES 23 - INTEREST
Current Year Previous Year
a) On Fixed Loans - -
b) On Other Loans (including Bank Charges) - -
c) Others (specify) - -
TOTAL - -
66 Victoria Memorial Hall
1. ACCOUNTING CONVENTION
The financial statements are prepared on the basis of historical cost convention, unless otherwise stated and on the accrual
method of accounting.
2. INVENTORY VALUATION
2.1. Stores and Spares (including machinery spares) are valued at cost.
2.2. Raw materials, semi-finished goods and finished goods are valued at lower of cost and net realizable value. The costs
are based on weighted average cost. Cost of finished goods and semi-finished goods is determined by considering
material, labour and related overheads.
3. INVESTMENTS
3.1. Investments classified as “long term investments” are carried at cost. Provision for decline, other than temporary, is
made in carrying cost of such investments.
3.2. Investments classified as “Current” are carried at lower of cost and fair value. Provision for shortfall on the value of
such investments is made for each investment considered individually and not on a global basis.
3.3. Cost includes acquisition expenses like brokerage, transfer stamps.
4. EXCISE DUTY
Liability for excise duty in respect of goods produced by the entity, other than for exports, is accounted upon completion of
manufacture and provision is made for excisable manufactured goods as at the year-end.
5. FIXED ASSETS
5.1. Fixed Assets are stated at cost of acquisition inclusive of inward freight, duties and taxes and incidental and direct
expenses related to acquisition. In respect of projects involving construction, related pre-operational expenses
(including interest on loans for specific project prior to its completion), form part of the value of the assets capitalized.
5.2. Art objects 22,789 nos. without any cost price have not been included in Balance Sheet. However category-wise art
objects are quantified in the accession register maintained by the Documentation Section.
5.3. Fixed Assets acquired out of own funds and donations are included in the relevant account from the date of addition.
Annual Report 2014-15 67
6. DEPRECIATION
6.1. Depreciation is provided on Fixed Assets as per the rates prescribed by the Income Tax Act, 1961, as follows:
6.1.1. On the opening balance - at the full rate
6.1.2. On the additions
- if the asset has been acquired / constructed for a period exceeding 180 days, at the full rate
- if the asset has been acquired / constructed for a period not exceeding 180 days, at the half rate
6.2. Gross Block & Net Block of Previous year, rearranged as per prudence of accounting policy.
6.3 Depreciation on addition on fixed assets under plan head has been transferred to other income.
7. MISCELLANEOUS EXPENDITURE
Deferred revenue expenditure is written off over a period of 5 years from the year it is incurred.
11. LEASE
Lease rentals are expensed with reference to lease terms.
68 Victoria Memorial Hall
Income-tax
Sales-tax
Municipal Taxes
1.4. In respect of claims from parties for non-execution of orders, but contested by
the Entity
2. CAPITAL COMMITMENTS
Estimated value of contracts remaining to be executed on capital account and not NIL
provided for (net of advances)
3. LEASE OBLIGATIONS
Future obligations for rentals under finance lease arrangements for plant and NIL
machinery amount to
Annual Report 2014-15 69
8. TAXATION
Surplus for and from the assessment year 1974-75 is exempted from I/Tax as per the Gazette Notification which was
published in Part II Section 3(II) of the Gazette of India dated 10.02.1977.
70 Victoria Memorial Hall
2014-15
Annexure 1
Register of Advance given from Plan Grant
Annexure 2