Sunteți pe pagina 1din 7

The surpluses and shortages in

business-to-business marketing theory


and research
Jagdish N. Sheth
Goizueta Business School, Emory University, Atlanta, Georgia, USA, and
Arun Sharma
School of Business, University of Miami, Coral Gables, Florida, USA

Abstract
Purpose – Business-to-business marketing has come of age in the last three decades and research in this area has been extensive and impressive. This
paper examines the extant body of business-to-business marketing research and identifies surpluses and shortages with the goal of stimulating future
research.
Design/methodology/approach – This paper focuses on two questions regarding future business-to business marketing. First, what has been the
focus of understanding in business-to-business marketing theory and what should be its future focus? Second, what has been the purpose or objective
to study business-to-business marketing and what should be the future objective for research?
Findings – It is found that research in business-to-business marketing is fundamentally changing and will continue to change. The paper identifies
areas of business-to-business marketing research that have received surplus attention and areas that require additional attention.
Practical implications – The paper provides guidelines for future exploration of the business-to-business research domain.
Originality/value – The paper is analogous to the widely cited paper by Sheth (1979) that reviewed the state of consumer behavior research and
identified areas that had been unexplored or under-explored, and in the process provided an impetus for new research in consumer behavor.

Keywords Business-to-business marketing, Research, Marketing theory

Paper type Research paper

Introduction business-to-business marketing expands, it is imperative that a


periodic re-examination of the discipline is conducted
The discipline of business-to-business marketing has come of (Spekman, 2000) to identify surpluses and shortages in
age in the last three decades. Three major academic journals research. Accordingly, the objective of this conceptual paper is
are dedicated to business-to-business marketing (Journal of to identify neglected or under-researched areas so that we can
Business & Industrial Marketing, Industrial Marketing advance the discipline of business-to-business marketing.
Management, Journal of Business-to-Business Marketing) and Nearly three decades ago, Sheth (1979) published a widely
several other journals are dedicated to sub-areas such as accepted paper on surpluses and shortages in consumer
personal selling and sales management (e.g. Journal of Personal behavior that led to research in many new aspects of
Selling and Sales Management). There are also numerous consumer behavior, such as excessive consumption and
books in this area, as indicated by a simple search of emotionally driven behaviors. We find this approach very
Amazon.com that revealed over 500 books with some manner useful in examining the field of business-to-business
of business-to-business marketing content. Finally, there are a marketing.
large number of general and industry-specific business-to- The paper is divided into four sections. The first section
business marketing magazines. Reid and Plank (2000) found reviews the extant literature in business-to-business
both extensive (2,194 articles between 1978 and 1997) and marketing. The second section identifies areas that have
excellent research in these publications. been the focus of understanding in business-to-business
Business-to-business marketing as a discipline has realized marketing theory and suggests areas that should be the future
spectacular growth by borrowing concepts from the focus. The third section examines the purpose of research in
behavioral and quantitative sciences, and by broadening its business-to-business marketing and identifies the future
horizons from traditional industrial product marketing to motivation for continued interest in this area. The final
marketing of business services. As the research domain of section summarizes the paper.

The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at
www.emeraldinsight.com/0885-8624.htm
Extant research in business-to-business
marketing
Danneels and Lilien (1998) highlight the paradox that,
Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing although the dollar value of business-to-business transactions
21/7 (2006) 422– 427
q Emerald Group Publishing Limited [ISSN 0885-8624]
is double that of consumer transactions (Slater, 1999), the
[DOI 10.1108/08858620610708902] bulk of research and teaching in marketing focuses on

422
B2B marketing theory and research Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing
Jagdish N. Sheth and Arun Sharma Volume 21 · Number 7 · 2006 · 422 –427

consumer markets. This concern is not new. Webster (1978) Plank’s (2000) study to evaluate the state of business-to-
also stated that: business marketing research.
With well over half of America’s economic activity accounted by industrial In order to facilitate our analysis, we have reduced the
marketing, as distinct from the sale of products and services to consumers, it number of areas listed by Reid and Plank (2000) into a more
has been remarkable how little attention, relatively, industrial marketing has
compact list in Table II, based on our own knowledge as well
received in the professional literature and in academic research.
as the wisdom of our colleagues. For example, the
Furthermore, until the early 1970s business-to-business “Organization buying/buyer seller relationships” category
marketing was primarily practice-oriented, with relatively includes articles that address organizational buying and
less academic interest. For example, there were more journals vendor-customer negotiations and relationships. The
specializing in the practice of business buying behavior than in category of “Personal selling and sales management”
includes articles that address issues of personal selling, sales
consumer behavior (Sheth, 1977). One of the reasons for the
training, sales motivation and compensation, and general
low level of academic attention to business-to-business
sales management. Similarly, the category of “Product
marketing is the complexity of studying the business buying
management/new product development” includes articles
behavior. The business buying process normally involves
that address new product development and product
many participants who influence the buying decision
management. As expected, articles on organizational buying
differently. Studies in this area require organizational
and buyer-seller relationships are most frequently addressed
cooperation and intimate knowledge of how the organization
and constitute about a fifth of the research focus in this area.
works, which are not easily attained. We believe this is due to the publication of comprehensive
Fortunately, the research in business-to-business marketing
models of business buying behavior developed by Webster and
since Webster’s call to action has been extensive and
Wind (1972), and by Sheth (1973). While Sheth (1973)
impressive. As mentioned before, Reid and Plank (2000) highlighted the effect of individuals in the buying process,
examined over 2,194 articles that were published on business- Webster and Wind (1972) emphasized the role of the
to-business marketing research between 1978 and 1997. They organization and its environment. Towards the late 1980s
provide excellent summary of the literature, and their and early 1990s, research began to highlight the importance
summary is presented in Table I. We will use Reid and of developing relationships for effective marketing, especially
in the business-to-business context. This led to numerous
Table I Literature summary (1978-1997) academic publications on testing these conceptual frameworks
or in enhancing conceptual foundations. The creation of the
Percentage
Center for Relationship Marketing at Emory University
Topic n of total brought the issue of customer relationship management into
Advertising 58 1.7 the mainstream. Scholarly opinion seemed to converge on a
Sales promotion 50 1.4 pattern of paradigm shift from a transaction-based marketing
Public relations 9 ,1 perspective to a relationship marketing perspective. At the
Promotion 65 1.9 same time, the IMP (Industrial Marketing and Purchasing)
Marketing research 110 3.2 Group in Europe developed a research focus of buyer-seller
Forecasting 38 1.1 relationships in business markets.
New product management and development 225 7.3 The second area of research focus has been personal selling
Personal selling 242 7.0 and sales management. This also constitutes about a fifth of
Sales training 35 1.0
all of the articles published in the business-to-business
Sales motivation and compensation 100 2.9
General sales management 296 8.5 Table II Literature summary by areas (1978-1997)
Purchasing management 253 7.3
Area Number Percentage
Computers in business marketing 29 ,1
Decision support and management science 58 1.7 Organization buying/buyer-seller
Organizational buying behavior 448 12.9 relationships 716 21.49
Product management 89 2.6 Personal selling and sales management 673 20.20
Pricing 73 2.1 Product management/new product
Business services marketing 82 2.4 development 344 10.32
Channel management and administration 135 3.9 Marketing planning and strategy 332 9.96
Logistics and physical distribution 22 ,1 Purchasing management 253 7.59
International business marketing 125 3.6 Communication 182 5.46
Marketing to governments 11 ,1 Channels and supply chain management 157 4.71
Market segmentation 64 1.9 Segmentation and segments 157 4.71
Market planning and strategy 332 9.6 Marketing research and forecasting 148 4.44
Marketing and other functions 67 1.9 International 125 3.75
Ethics in business marketing 18 ,1 Computers/decision support 87 2.61
Buyer-seller relationships 268 7.7 Marketing’s role (functional, ethical) 85 2.55
Other 141 4.0 Pricing 73 2.19

Source: Reid and Plank (2000) Source: based on Reid and Plank (2000)

423
B2B marketing theory and research Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing
Jagdish N. Sheth and Arun Sharma Volume 21 · Number 7 · 2006 · 422 –427

marketing journals. We believe this has been due to three individual factors such as education background, age, and
reasons. First, several academic researchers came with sales gender can further aid an understanding business-to-business
experience and had a managerial affinity. Second, access to marketing. The second dimension is use of decision-making
salespeople and sales management data was easier due to the processes as opposed to non decision-making processes. Once
pervasive nature of sales departments. Third, research was again, more research has been on decision-making processes.
predominantly based on a single unit of analysis (e.g. Figure 1 provides the 2 £ 2 classification.
salesperson, sales manager) in comparison to buyer-seller
relationships that require dyadic and multiple level data Surplus of focus: understanding organization behavior
collection. based on decision-making framework
The third largest area of research addresses product The first area we have identified as having a surplus of focus is
management and new product development and it organizational buying behavior models. There has been
constitutes about 10 percent of the research focus. Product extensive research since the introduction of business buying
management has been less frequently studied when compared models by Webster and Wind (1972) and Sheth (1973). The
to new product development. The research has examined the frameworks are well understood and form the underpinnings
development of products, product lines, and product life cycle of much of the work in the business-to-business marketing
management. In addition, there have been discussions on arena. The second area of surplus is market planning and
organizational adoption and organizational choice frameworks strategy. As Table II demonstrates, about 10 percent of the
specifically relevant to business marketing firms. research focus in the business-to-business area is in marketing
The next area of focus has been marketing planning and planning and strategy. As stated earlier, most of the findings in
strategy, which also constitutes about 10 percent of the this area are relevant for most firms, not just in business-to-
research focus. The majority of research in this area reflects business contexts. The third well-researched area in business-
strategic choices that firms need to make. Although focused to-business marketing is buyer-seller relationships. The
toward business markets, the implications are relevant for all understanding in this area has been considerably enhanced
firms. by the work of the IMP group in Europe as well as by research
Purchasing management is the next largest topic of on relationship marketing.
research, with about 8 percent of research focus. This
research has typically taken the perspective of the buying firm. Need more: organization behavior using non-decision-
Research has examined organizational structures, the supply making framework
management function, partnerships, supplier selection, We identify three areas in business-to-business marketing that
quality processes, and has detailed effective purchasing should address organization behaviors in non-decision making
processes. frameworks. The first area is the impact of organizational
Communication research (advertising, sales promotion, culture on selling or buying behavior. Organizational culture
and public relations) constitutes about 6 percent of the was first introduced to the marketing literature by Deshpande
research focus. Most of the research is empirical, examining and Webster (1989). While there has been some research
details of communication programs with no programmatic regarding organizational culture and business-to-business
basis (Reid and Plank, 2000). All other areas combined markets, we need a lot more to fully understand, for
constitute less than 5 percent of the research focus in example, how an engineering-driven culture impacts
business-to-business marketing. business-to-business marketing differently than a sales-
driven culture.
Examining shortages and surpluses The second area that needs more attention is impact of
As mentioned earlier, we will use the example of Sheth industry structures on business-to-business marketing. While
(1979), who undertook a similar endeavor to identify areas in transaction cost analysis has been utilized in business-to-
consumer behavior that were in shortage of research and business marketing (Rindfleisch and Heide, 1997), there is
theory and those that were researched too much. A large still a lot of potential for additional research. Industry
number of neglected areas identified in the article later structures have also been examined extensively in the
became mainstream consumer behavior research topics, such
as customer satisfaction/dissatisfaction, consumerism and Figure 1 Surpluses and shortages of focus in business-to-business
consumer welfare, search behavior, math choice models, theory
and deviant consumption.
Our expectation is that this paper will generate a similar
shift in research focus from areas of business-to-business
marketing where we have a surplus of both conceptual and
empirical understanding and managerial objectives to those
that have been neglected.

Surpluses and shortages of focus in business-to-


business research and theory
The focus of research in business-to-business theory can be
classified by two dimensions. The first dimension is focus on
individual behavior versus organization behavior. Clearly,
there has been more research on organization behavior than
on individual behavior, although organizational culture,
structure, and processes affect individual decision-making,

424
B2B marketing theory and research Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing
Jagdish N. Sheth and Arun Sharma Volume 21 · Number 7 · 2006 · 422 –427

economics and strategy literature, but only a small amount of business marketing. For example, Sheth et al. (1999) identify
this knowledge is applied in business-to-business marketing. user, buyer, and payer as three distinct roles in an
For example, what is the impact of consolidation of customer organization.. While we have significant research on how
industries such as telecommunications? different people with specific role responsibilities in a buying
A third area of research is international influences in center make decisions (gatekeeper, user, buyer, decision
business markets. As firms develop a more global orientation, maker, etc.), we really don’t know how these roles are
we need to research such issues as offshore outsourcing and impacted by such non-decision making processes as turf wars
global account management. Another interesting area of and internal politics. Finally, similar to the roles that
research is the effect of the rise of China and India on US organizational employees play, salespeople also play different
buyer-seller relationships. roles, such as consultant, facilitator, or trusted advisor.
Matching of roles to organizational situations and training for
Need more: decision making for individual behavior those roles are areas that need additional research. For
We identify three areas that need more research on individual example, an area of research interest is the effect of
decision making. The first area is organizational influence on compensation on different roles (hunters versus farmers).
individual decision making. While there has been limited
research in this area (Walsh, 1995; Pillai and Sharma, 2003), Surpluses and shortages in the purpose of
what we need to know is how governance policies and
processes impact individual decision making. Specifically, is
business-to-business theory and research
the budget and spending authority decentralized or The purpose of research in business-to-business theory and
centralized? Is the procurement function organized globally research can be divided into two dimensions. The first
or locally? dimension is basis of knowledge – research that is theoretical
The second area of research is schemas, cognition, and in nature versus research that is empirical in nature.
persuasion knowledge. Schemas are knowledge structures that Historically, there has been more empirical research than
individuals utilize to make decisions. These knowledge theoretical research. This may reflect the critical stage of
structures allow individuals to assess cues and to manage growth of the discipline. The second dimension is the type of
persuasion attempts (Friestad and Wright, 1994). While output – research that is managerial versus research that aids
knowledge structures have been extensively examined in discipline development. Similar to the first dimension, more
consumer behavior, they also need to be examined in the research has been for managerial output rather than for
business-to-business context. For example, an area of enhancing the discipline. These two dimensions create a 2 £ 2
research interest may be the effect of an individual’s matrix as presented in Figure 2 and discussed next. As
persuasion knowledge structures on the functioning of the previously stated, while a large number of areas could be
buying center. Similarly, how the style of the decision maker identified, we discuss only three for each cell in the matrix.
(driver, expressive, analytic or amicable) impacts individual
decision marketing is another potential area of research. Surplus: empirical research for managerial benefit
Finally, more research is needed on the decision-making We identify three areas in business-to-business marketing that
process. Business-to-business marketing continues to regard are empirically based and address managerial issues. The first
individual decision-making as a black box. In contrast, area and focus of considerable research interest is personal
research in consumer behavior has considerably enhanced selling and sales management. It constitutes about 20 percent
knowledge of individual decision-making processes. There is a of the research focus in the business-to-business marketing
need to extend this kind of research to business-to-business area (Table II), has a journal dedicated to it, and a large
marketing. An example of research in this area is impact of the number of books on the subject. The broader issues are well
type of message cues on product evaluation in the business-to- understood and recent research has focused on more narrow
business context. issues. The second area of considerable research is new
product development. It constitutes about 7 percent of
Shortage: non-decision marketing for individual research published in the business-to-business marketing area
behavior
As stated earlier, non-decision marketing processes and Figure 2 Surpluses and shortages in the purpose of business-to-
heuristics used by individual decision makers are generally business theory and research
regarded as irrational and unacceptable behavior in business-
to-business marketing. After all, business decisions are
supposed to be based on reason and there is presumed
accountability of managers to make the right decisions.
Unfortunately, research in this area is very limited.
Again we identify three areas that may fill this void. The
first area is impact of situational effects. In consumer
marketing, this topic has been extensively studied (e.g. Belk,
1974), specifically in the context of retail research. The
findings of this research reveal that situational effects impact
consumer behaviors to a large extent. For example, what is
the impact of rising interest rates on Capex decisions in an
organization, or impact of collapse of a company’s market
cap, as has happened with all the major airlines. The next area
of research is the effect of organizational roles in business-to-

425
B2B marketing theory and research Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing
Jagdish N. Sheth and Arun Sharma Volume 21 · Number 7 · 2006 · 422 –427

(Table I). Most of the research in the new product advertising. However, it would be desirable to test whether
development area has generated findings that are advertising works as a reinforcement of the purchase decision.
generalizable to most firms, not specifically business-to- Thirdly, as companies utilize alternative channels to reach
business marketing firms. The final area of surplus is customers, we need to study their relative efficiency and
company demographic research. For example, some studies effectiveness in generating sales. For example, is telemarketing
have examined the size of the firm and the size of the buying a good lead generator for the sales force or can it generate
center. Other research has examined the number of sales on its own? Similarly, what is the effect of web-based
employees in purchasing departments. There is considerable marketing on traditional channels, for example in the airline
research of this kind, but little additional insights are and travel industry? Finally, internal versus external channels
provided. of sales and distribution are issues of strategic as well as
financial considerations.
Need more: theory-based empirical research
We identify three areas in business-to-business marketing that Shortage: theoretical basis of knowledge and
may generate theory-based empirical research. The first is disciplinary output
organizational satisfaction. There is considerable research on As stated earlier, the confluence of theoretical basis of
customer satisfaction/dissatisfaction in consumer markets and knowledge and disciplinary output is under-researched in
some that addresses both consumer as well as business business-to-business markets. There seems to be an acute
markets (e.g. Gruca and Rego, 2005; Morgan et al., 2005). shortage regarding the theoretical foundations of the
However, the understanding of customer satisfaction/ discipline. While there are several rich hypotheses (e.g.
dissatisfaction in business-to-business marketing is still perceived risk, buyer attitudes) and some good comprehensive
limited. As Reinartz and Kumar (2000) point out, some of theories in business-to-business behavior, most of them are
the fundamental axioms – such as a strong positive customer developed for the managerial perspective. There is a need for
lifetime-profitability relationship, may not be valid in a discipline-oriented theoretical foundation. The first area of
business-to-business markets. research is to develop commonly agreed upon and
The second area that can enhance theory-based empirical scientifically validated laws of business-to-business markets.
research is international and cross-cultural effects on For example, if 20 percent of customers generate 80 percent
business-to-business marketing. The discipline needs to of revenue (20/80 ratio), what is the degree of cross-subsidy
examine this area because business organizations are across accounts? A second area of research is the role of
becoming more international and cross-cultural due to segmentation and profitability analysis in those industries
globalization, and their customers and employees have where the company serves consumers, small businesses and
increasingly varied cultural backgrounds. There is a need to large enterprises. Do large customers subsidize the consumer
examine the antecedents and consequences of international segment? A third area of research is “need versus want”
and cross-cultural shifts in business-to-business markets. For motivation. General business-to-business markets are need-
example, do cross-cultural buying centers make more optimal based. We know very little about the company’s wants and
decisions or do cross-cultural sales teams do a better job of desires and how they get institutionalized differently in
selling to global accounts? different organizations.
A third area of additional research is relational formation,
maintenance, and even dissolution. For example, Wilson
(1995) suggests that the majority of deep relationships such as Conclusion
alliances fail, and he proposes a model of buyer-seller In this paper we have attempted to review the extant research
relationships that will result in structural and social bonding in business-to-business marketing and have suggested
(stickiness). However, there is no empirical study to validate directions for future research. The growth of research in this
this interesting perspective. area was slow until the 1980s, as Haass (1986) states:
Industrial marketing appears to have come of age in the 1980s. After years of
Need more: managerial use of well-accepted marketing languishing in the background of consumer marketing, there are signs that
concepts industrial marketing is taking its rightful place.
We identify three areas in business-to-business marketing that
address managerial use of well-researched marketing The research in business-to-business marketing has been
concepts. The first area is the effect of brand reputation on impressive since then. New areas have been explored in the
business-to-business sales. There is considerable research on business-to-business marketing area. We further aid this
brand equity; however, the majority of this research is on processes by identifying surpluses and shortages in business-
consumer goods. As firms invest heavily in corporate brands, to-business marketing research. Our view is that we have
there is a need to better understand brand effects in business- enough research utilizing decision-making frameworks to
to-business marketing situations. For example, does corporate understand how organizations make buying decisions as well
reputation enhance the effectiveness as well as efficiency of as how we can sell to them. What we need to research is how
the sales organization? individuals in an organization make buying decisions, and
The second area is effect of advertising in business-to- how to sell to a person and make him or her an advocate or
business markets. Business-to-business marketers such as champion for the company. Similarly, we have enough
IBM and Accenture spend considerable resources on research on managerial issues utilizing empirical research
advertising their services in both consumer and business methods. What we need is programmatic research utilizing
media. However, the efficacy of this expenditure has not been large databases similar to PIMS or Computstat.
examined. Reid and Plank (2000) report that the majority of The purpose of identifying new areas of research is to
research in advertising deals with the executional aspects of encourage future researchers to appreciate the exciting

426
B2B marketing theory and research Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing
Jagdish N. Sheth and Arun Sharma Volume 21 · Number 7 · 2006 · 422 –427

opportunities offered by business-to-business marketing for Bennet, P.D. (Eds), Consumer and Industrial Buying
academic research. Behavior, North Holland, New York, NY.
Sheth, J.N. (1979), “The surpluses and shortages in
consumer behavior theory and research”, Journal of the
References Academy of Marketing Science, Vol. 7 No. 4, pp. 414-27.
Belk, R.W. (1974), “An exploratory assessment of situational Sheth, J.N., Mittal, B. and Newman, B. (1999), Customer
effects in buyer behavior”, Journal of Marketing Research, Behavior, Dryden Press, Hinsdale, IL.
Vol. 11 No. 2, pp. 156-63. Slater, C.M. (1999), Business Statistics of the United States,
Danneels, E. and Lilien, G.L. (1998), “Doctoral programs in 5th ed., Bernan Press, Lanham, MD.
business-to-business marketing: status and prospects”, Spekman, R.E. (2000), “A commentary on business
Journal of Business-to-Business Marketing, Vol. 5 Nos 1/2, marketing: a twenty year review and an invitation for
pp. 7-34. continued dialogue”, Journal of Business-to-Business
Deshpande, R. and Webster, F.E. (1989), “Organizational Marketing, Vol. 7 No. 4, pp. 11-35.
culture and marketing: defining the research agenda”, Walsh, J.P. (1995), “Managerial and organizational cognition:
Journal of Marketing, Vol. 53 No. 1, pp. 3-15. notes from a trip down memory lane”, Organization Science,
Friestad, M. and Wright, P. (1994), “The persuasion Vol. 6, May/June, pp. 280-321.
knowledge model: how people cope with persuasion Webster, F.E. (1978), “Management science in industrial
attempts”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 21 No. 1, marketing”, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 42, January, pp. 21-7.
pp. 1-31. Webster, F.E. and Wind, Y. (1972), “A general model for
Gruca, T.S. and Rego, L.L. (2005), “Customer satisfaction, understanding organizational buying behavior”, Journal of
cash flow, and shareholder value”, Journal of Marketing, Marketing, Vol. 36, April, pp. 12-19.
Vol. 69 No. 3, pp. 115-30. Wilson, D.T. (1995), “An integrated model of buyer-seller
Haass, R.W. (1986), Industrial Marketing Management, 3rd relationships”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,
ed., Kent Publishing Co., Boston, MA. Vol. 23 No. 4, pp. 335-45.
Morgan, N.A., Anderson, E.W. and Mittal, V. (2005),
“Understanding firms’ customer satisfaction information Further reading
usage”, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 69 No. 3, pp. 131-51. Dowling, G.R. (1998), “Challenges for B-to-B doctoral
Pillai, K.G. and Sharma, A. (2003), “Mature relationships: programs: a commentary”, Journal of Business-to-Business
why does relational orientation turn into transaction Marketing, Vol. 5 Nos 1/2, pp. 35-40.
orientation?”, Industrial Marketing Management, Vol. 32, Harrison, F. and Pasqualoni, T. (2000), “No gambling with
December, pp. 643-51. health”, Risk Management, Vol. 47 No. 12, pp. 19-22.
Reid, D.A. and Plank, R.E. (2000), “Business marketing Inkpen, A.C. (2001), “Managing balance in career and life:
comes of age: a comprehensive review of the literature”, an interview with champion triathlete Scott Tinley”,
Journal of Business-to-Business Marketing, Vol. 7 Nos 2/3, Journal of Management Inquiry, Vol. 10 No. 1, pp. 76-81.
p. 9. Lichtenthal, J.D. (2005), “Curriculum issues”, AMA/ISBM
Reinartz, W.J. and Kumar, V. (2000), “On the profitability of B2B PhD Summer Camp, San Francisco, CA, July 28-29.
long-life customers in a noncontractual setting: an empirical
investigation and implications for marketing”, Journal of
Marketing, Vol. 64 No. 3, pp. 17-35.
About the authors
Rindfleisch, A. and Heide, J.B. (1997), “Transaction cost Jagdish N. Sheth is Charles H. Kellstadt Professor of
analysis: past, present, and future applications”, Journal of Marketing at the Goizueta Business School at Emory
Marketing, Vol. 61, October, pp. 30-54. University, Atlanta, Georgia, USA.
Sheth, J.N. (1973), “A model of industrial buyer behavior”, Arun Sharma is Professor of Marketing at the University of
Journal of Marketing, Vol. 37, October, pp. 50-6. Miami, School of Business, Coral Gables, Florida, USA.
Sheth, J.N. (1977), “Recent developments in organizational Arun Sharma is the corresponding author and can be
buying behavior”, in Woodside, A.G., Sheth, J.N. and contacted at: asharma@miami.edu

To purchase reprints of this article please e-mail: reprints@emeraldinsight.com


Or visit our web site for further details: www.emeraldinsight.com/reprints

427
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.

S-ar putea să vă placă și