Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Chapter 1
The Problem
Introduction
reading activities. Male readers may differ their interest so as to the female readers. It
suggested that boy’s motivation may even play a bigger role in their development of
reading skills than in girls. This idea that the difference between boys and girls reading
may stem from biological differences is one proposed by NLT (2012) and supported by
Logan and Johnston (2010), who outlined evidence showing different brain patterns of
activation between the genders when reading and completing language related tasks.
program that aims to develop in Filipino children the literacy and numeracy skills, and
strengthening its reading program through the implementation of early language, literacy,
and numeracy where it is the goal of the K to 12. It widely challenge for teachers to
motivate the learners so as to the interest of the reading materials may affect their attitude
towards reading. As regards to differing attitudes between boys and girls, McGeown et al.
(2015 p.390) and Clark (2012) have all presented data to show that boys generally have
worse attitudes to reading, while it is also claimed that this is evident in the children
2
themselves, with boys willingness to learn to read being self-confessedly lower than girls.
Furthermore, Lundberg et al. (2012) cited in Wolter, Braun and Hannover, 2015 p.2)
explained that these gender differences can exist even before starting school while Casey
(2008; 2009 cited in Sarroub and Pernicek, 2014) claims that a cycle of negative
experience can ensue for struggling readers, resulting in frustration towards teachers,
structures in school and relations at home, leading to further difficulties in reading. This
epitomizes the need to address any problems and ensure that children can engage with
reading.
It has been suggested that an influential impact on reading attitudes may be the
attitude that the child has towards the way in which it is taught (NLT, 2012). It suggest
that boys often prefer different ways of learning, such as challenges, direct
instrumentation and interactive teaching (PLRS, 2015; Heron, 2003 cited in Sarroub and
Pernicek, 2014 p.30; NLT 2012), mainly because they tend to be less organized and less
able to concentrate for as long as girls (NLT, 2012). Therefore, failure to meet these
needs may result in loss of interest from the boy, disengaging him from reading. NLT
(2012) concluded this to be the case, explaining that there is too much focus on the
techniques of reading being taught and on the type of reading done which Sarroub and
Perincek (2014) say is over emphasized by some teachers. Furthermore, Mckool and
Gespass (2009) explained that reluctant and struggling readers, who Logan and Johnston
(2010) say are more likely to be male, tend to receive more intervention regarding skill
whilst their competent reading counterparts are given more time to read for pleasure,
cited by Ofsted (2012) as vital in building a love of reading. The implications of this are
that the child only reads for academic purposes, rarely for pleasure, potentially leading to
3
what Gallagher (2009, p2), termed 'readicide': the focus on progress and standards in
additionally have built a belief that studying isfor girls and therefore choose not to spend
time on it over different activities (NLT, 2012). This stereotype is one explored by
Wolter, Braun and Hannover (2015) who suggested that boys are less motivated in pre-
school and behind in reading competence in year one if their pre-school teacher held
gender stereotypes, whilst girls were found to be unaffected by teacher role. Alarmingly
therefore, It has been found that holding views of this kind can result in children rejecting
reading because of its feminine reputation and interacting through this rejection, a notion
supported by NLT(2012) and Clark, Woodley and Lewis (2011), who highlighted the
negative impact that this has on attainment. The implication is that teaches own views
can heavily influence the development of the boys in their class as NLT (2012) found
strong evidence that those who viewed reading as for girls performed worse than those
It is therefore the purpose of the study is to find out the interest male and female
readers in establishing reading activities if there are differences and relationship when it
Framework
Woodruff (1978) described that social cognitive ability to explain and predict other
people’s actions in terms of the underlying mental states, such as beliefs, intentions, or
4
feelings. Theory of mind is thought to be at the core of any successful social interactions,
and its impairment has been implicated in various neuropsychiatric disorders involving
altered social understanding Gender differences in social cognitive processes are a long-
discussed issue, in particular, those about the theory of mind. This is true in behavioral
studies revealed that female subjects, compared to male, score higher on tests related to
sensitivity, empathy, and emotional intelligence. This theory relates my study on the
gender differences of the male and female affecting their reading attitudes on how gender
This study is anchored on the theory of Realism which defined as the doctrine that
to account for how we experience things which exist in the time and space of the real
world, (Aristotle, 322 BC). It represents the theory that particular things exist
preparation for life, for education equips the child by providing adequate training to face
the crude realities of life with courage. As such, education concerns with problems of life
of the child. A teacher should look at the interest of the child and to teach and set the
This study is anchored on the concept that children need help from teachers in
developing a concrete understanding of the world, Hoxie (2012). To assist our students
effectively, teachers must first observe children and from those observations determine
the types of experiences they maintain and are have an interest in. For Dewey, the path to
5
quality education requires that learning builds on previous knowledge and experiences,
This study is anchored on the concept of learning by doing as the sole strategy for
any kind of learning. He identified education as a kind of experience, and through saying
this he actually means the same equation between what one actually does and the
resultant learning. So if a student learns how to listen and take notes from a lecture, he or
she only learns how to listen and taking notes. If afterwards the student memorizes the
lesson notes, the student learns how to memorize things, Elkan (2013).
It confirms that preferences and interests are not always the same in boys and
girls. As teachers, we must try to uncover the interest of each of our students. We believe
that single sex education might help cater to boy´s and girl´s natural interests and
differences seriously and analyzing current highly gendered practices that competent and
critical readers, of both sexes can be developed. Artola T. et.al (2013). This framework
may further find out the gender differences and effect on the reading attitudes.
This study will find out the gender differences affecting the reading attitudes of
grade seven students. It will further examine the relationship of gender differences
towards reading attitude. This will be conducted in Isulan National High School for the
a. Male readers
b. Female readers
2. Analyze what type of materials, activities and methods can be more useful when it
4. Is there a significant relationship between the male and female readers on their
reading attitude?
Learners. This study will benefit the learners to identify their reading genres by
the various materials given and supported by the school and teachers to motivate their
reading attitude.
Teachers. This study will also benefit the teachers to scaffold and guide learners
according to the differences and needs of the learner in motivating their attitudes towards
reading by the use of various reading materials to a male and female reader.
The School Administrators. This study will make them aware to have a better
understanding, establish support to the teachers and learners to give importance on the
reading attitudes of the learners that will develop their reading comprehension
competences.
The English Language Teaching (ELT) Program. Since the ELT program focuses
technique. This study will serve as a function of reference that will eventually develop
This study will focused on the gender differences and its effects on the reading
attitude to the grade 7 students in Isulan National High School during the first quarter
period of the school year 2018-2019. The research only involve teachers teaching reading
as to assess the gender differences of the learner affecting their reading attitudes.
8
Definition of Terms
which are socially constructed, while sex refers to those which are biologically
determined. People are born female or male but learn to be girls and boys who grow into
women and men. This learned behavior makes up gender identity and determines gender
roles” (World Health Organization, 2002, p. 4). In the study, it refers to gender used in
the study as independent variables to find out the reading attitudes affecting male and
female readers.
Attitude. Attitude in reading are all share the idea of the level of enjoyment shown
towards reading McGeown et al. (2015) .The suggestion is that a good attitude to reading
can be more beneficial than both the amount of reading done (Wang and Guthrie, 2004
cited in Logan and Johnston, 2010 p.177) and having parents with a well-paid career
(OECD, 2002 cited in Lockwood, 2009 p.9). In the study, it refers to attitude is one
variable to be measured by the gender differences both male and female readers.
9
Chapter 2
Review of Literature
This chapter presents the review of literature relevant to the researcher’s study.
Both local and foreign studies that have important bearing in the present study were taken
into consideration. Two major areas of research were reviewed: gender differences; and
reading attitudes.
Gender Differences
Gender differences in reading attitude of male and female learner plays a vital
role in the success of education. This is true in the study conducted by Forshey, (2013) on
the Effects of Reading Attitude on reading achievement of students in grade one through
six where factors that have been noted as affecting a student’s motivation and attitude
toward reading include gender (Coddington & Guthrie, 2009), family history (Conlon et
al., 2006), and early reading failure (Morgan, Fuchs, Compton, Cordray, & Fuchs, 2008).
The following research questions were examined in the study : is there a relationship
between reading attitude and reading achievement of elementary aged students?; What
are the gender differences noted on the Elementary Reading Attitude Survey (ERAS)
(McKenna & Kear, 1990)? ; What are the gender differences noted on the Northwest
quantitative research. The Pearson Correlation was used to determine the relationship
between grade and attitude. Next, an independent t-test was conducted to determine the
10
relationship between gender; male and female. A hierarchical multiple regression was
used to determine how closely related reading attitude was with reading achievement
when factoring out disability, gender, socioeconomic status, and grade level. The
gender) associated with reading attitude. The findings of the study showed that the
examination of the effects of reading attitude on reading achievement revealed that there
student’s attitude toward reading. Further examination of the results also found that in
certain situations there were indications that a significant relationship between the
variables existed. For example, when comparing the reading attitude and reading
attitude. Males tended to have a less positive attitude (lower mean score) toward reading
than their peers who were female. When comparing the reading attitudes of students in
the primary grades versus the intermediate grades a significant difference in mean score
was also noted. The students in the primary grades had a significantly more positive
attitude toward reading than their peers in the intermediate grades .The present study may
use the Elementary Reading Attitude Survey (ERAS) (McKenna & Kear, 1990) to
attitudes.
Gender differences may affect the learner’s attitude the way they read it. In the
study conducted by Ashcroft (2017) do boys’ attitudes to reading differ to those of girls?
A study into the views of reading within a year three class. Differences in reading
attainment between the genders have been widely reported, while less research has been
11
carried out on gender differences as regards to interest towards reading. Within a sample
of two classes of year three children, information was collected to establish any
differences in the attitudes towards reading that may exist between boys and girls. The
following research questions were examined: It answer their feelings towards reading and
also potential reasons, specifically those relating to gender stereotype, type of books, and
the idea of academic reading as opposed to reading for fun. The study method used are
both quantitative and qualitative (Walliman, 2011) with Greig, Taylor and MacKay
(2012) describing it as suitable for obtaining statistical data as well as opinions. This
research was carried out in the two year three classes of one school in the North of
England at which the proportion of pupils supported by the pupil premium funding is the
almost twice the national average Ofsted (2014) p.3), in order to minimize the impacts of
age and socio-economic background which can have an effect (Clark, Woodley and
Lewis 2011; Clark 2011). The results showed that large support for reading as important
can be linked to the reasons given by the children when asked to explain either their like
or dislike of reading. Although, generally, the quantitative results were positive, the
qualitative data displayed several reoccurring themes. These themes related to viewing
reading as a vehicle to help improve reading and writing, meaning therefore that despite
the responses being generally positive and the question not asking them to do so, the
majority of children linked their view of reading to school. The present study may use the
study mentioned about to find out the gender differences and its effect on the reading
attitude.
12
Reading Attitude
Gender differences in attitudes and their interests towards reading would really
have an impact on the reading development of the learners. In the study conducted by
Artola T. et.al (2013) differences in boys and girls attitudes toward reading. This study is
attitudes toward reading and study of boys and girls from 1st and 2nd grade primary
schools. Some recent studies even speak of “boy´s crisis” in literacy (Stevens, 2011).
Many hypothesis revealed that gender differences between boys and girls reading
and learning styles (Logan & Johnston, 2010) , and mostly gender differences in values,
goals and out of school activities. The research questions were examined on this study:
what kind of attitudes boys and girls have towards reading during their first school years;
explore if reading attitudes and interests differ according to sex; analyze what type of
materials, activities and methods can be more useful when it comes to motivate boys and
girls to read; investigate how well are children able to accurately assess their level of
reading proficiency and if differences can be found between boys and girls when it comes
to estimating their reading competence; analyze if these differences are equally observed
in single sex education schools and coeducation schools or if they differ depending on the
selected pedagogical model considered. The methodology of the study is the adaptation
of the questionnaire used in the Finnish study (Merisuo-Storm & Soininen, 2012) was
employed. The original questionnaire included 22 questions which assessed four different
social reading d 4) feeling of reading competence. The scale used was a Likert type 1-4.
The findings of the study showed that the attitudes towards reading have no significant
differences were found between boys and girls in their general attitude towards reading,
result of the sum of all items of the questionnaire (F = 1.37; p =. 242). No differences
were found either in the global score of the questionnaire when the variable sex and the
variable pedagogical model (coeducation, single sex male and single sex female) were
combined. Therefore, overall scores on the scale are quite similar in boys and girls
= .888) indicating that gender differences in global attitudes towards reading are not
affected by the type of pedagogical model in which the student studies. However
significant differences according to sex were found in some of the dimensions evaluated
significant differences between boys and girls were found in social reading (F = 24.69;
p< 0.001) indicating that girls have a more positive attitude towards reading aloud and
shared reading, while boys are more reluctant to this type of social reading. Also
almost reached significance, (F = 3. 33; p = . 068), pointing out that boys usually have a
better image of themselves as readers and feel they are more proficient readers than girls.
In the present study the researcher conduct a further analysis on the gender differences on
reading attitudes and will adopt and use the questionnaire used in the Finnish study of
(Merisuo-Storm & Soininen, 2012) which allows a better adaptation of the materials to
facilitate promote acquisition and positive attitudes of each male and female readers.
14
Gender differences plays a vital role in reading attitudes between male and
female learners. In the study conducted by Marinak, B. & Gambrell L., (2010) Reading
motivation: exploring the elementary gap that educators agree that motivation plays a
achievement underscore the important role that motivation plays in reading development.
This study examined gender differences of third-grade average readers as assessed by the
motivation to read profile. This study was designed as descriptive statistics, a post-test
design and the independent samples tests were generated for the MRP total scores and
subscale scores. The data were analyzed using an electronic statistical package for which
p values are generated. The result of the study showed that third-grade boys and girls who
are average readers are equally self-confident about their reading ability; however, boys
value reading less than girls. The present study may use motivation to read profile
(MRP) if there is a difference between boys and girls students in their reading attitudes.
Reading attitude may vary from various aspects like gender, motivation,
environment and materials suitable for learning. In the study conducted by Asraf, R.M. &
Abdullah, H.(2016) elementary schoolers’ attitudes toward reading in english: how boys
feel relative to girls. It showed that boys have consistently lagged behind girls in reading
Chatterji (2006); from when they were enrolled in kindergarten until the end of first grade
where the gap is the widest. In a broad cross-sectional study of 14,315 students,
McQuillan (2013) found that the girls had more positive attitudes toward reading than the
boys. The study examined primary school students’ reading attitudes in their L2 and the
following research question were examined: What are the students’ attitudes toward
recreational and academic reading in English? Do boys and girls differ in terms of their
15
attitudes? This study was designed as descriptive qualitative and employed to test for the
differences in reading attitudes between boys and girls as this test is the most suitable test
for the given data and assumptions made about the population. The ERAS by McKenna
and Kear (1990) is tailored for English speakers. Hence, to help the Malaysian students—
whose native language is not English—to answer the questions regarding their attitudes
towards reading in English, the researchers modified the The Mann-Whitney U Test
questions by adding “in English” to all the twenty original statements. The random
cluster sampling technique was employed to select the sample because it is the most
appropriate for and best suited to the school context. Random cluster sampling involves
“the random selection of naturally occurring groups or units ,universities, schools, school
districts, classrooms, city blocks, and households” (McMillan, 2008, p. 117). Before data
collection, all the schools in the state of Selangor, Malaysia were listed, and then six
schools were randomly selected from the list. The findings of the study showed that a
significant difference in the academic reading attitude levels of boys and girls. The
distribution of scores on the academic reading attitude measure for girls is also higher
than the boys. The null hypothesis revealed that there is no difference between boys’ and
girls’ academic reading attitude in English was also rejected, in favor of the alternative
hypothesis that girls have a more positive academic reading attitude compared to boys.
The medians of boys’ and girls’ recreational and academic attitudes are quite high, which
demonstrates their positive attitudes toward reading. On the other hand, even both male
and female showed positive reading attitudes, it was found that the girls scored
significantly higher on all the dimensions of reading attitudes compared to boys. The
present study may use to measure the boys’ and girls’ attitudes toward reading.
16
Chapter 3
Methodology
This chapter presents the methods and procedures for this study on gender
differences in reading attitudes. It describes the research design, research ethics, and
Research Design
specifically intended to describe the gender differences of male and female readers. The
gender (male and female) if there is a significant on the effects on male and female
readers on the type of materials, activities and methods to motivate them to read. A
Pearson r will be utilize to test the relationship between the gender differences on the
Research Ethics
The researcher will ask approval and acceptance of the members of the Thesis
Committee on the research instrument to be used in the study. Then, the researcher will
request a written recommendation from the Dean of the Graduate School of Bukidnon
17
State University and a written permission from the school principal of Isulan National
High School to administer the questionnaire to the participants in the school. Upon
approval, the researcher will meet the participants and discuss on their participation in the
study. After the agreement, the researcher will arrange the convenient schedule of the
participants.
Research Locale
The study will be conducted in Isulan National High School during the first
quarter of school year 2018-2019. Isulan National High School the second biggest school
in the division of Sultan Kudarat and popular to be called as bed-rock of Sultan Kudarat’s
finest.
The word Isulan was came in the battle cry of Mofac was the uttering of the word,
“ISU-SILAN” which means “they are there, advance”. This intrepid, although suicidal
show of force and determination , so impressed by UTTO, that in order to save lives on
both sides, he decided to resolve the issue by negotiation, thus placing Mofac and his
principality under his protectorate of Utto, Isulan municipality derived its name from
Participants
The participants of the study are the grade seven students of Isulan National High
School who are enrolled for the school year 2018-2019. They will be selected through
random sampling. The participants in the study will be evaluated based on the
Sampling Procedure
This study will use descriptive random sampling with total sample of 74 students,
37 for males and 37 for females making use of the 10% of the total population out of 745
students population of the grade 7. Using the Slovin’s formula for the sample size with a
5% marginal error .The researcher will use a sample size of 254 participants.
Instruments
The study will adapt and modify a questionnaire in gathering the data from
Finnish questionnaire as cited by Artola T. et.al (2013) to be use and evaluate the
student’s reading attitude. This will be subject to review by group of experts in Bukidnon
Administration
19
The participants will be oriented about the questionnaires. They will be given one
Scoring Procedure
This section contains the scoring using Likert Scale type with descriptors and
descriptions. The following scale and limits were used in analyzing the data for the
Table 3
Scoring Scheme in Validating the Questionnaire on the Panel of Experts’ Evaluation
Gender Differences Affecting Reading Attitude
Statistical treatment
Frequency and ranking will be used in this study. Specifically, to answer problem
For problem number three, is there a significant effects of the gender differences
on the reading attitude, the Mann-Whitney U Test will be used to determine the
significant differences between gender (male and female) if there is a significant on the
effects on male and female readers on the type of materials, activities and methods to
motivate them to read. A Pearson r will be utilized to test the relationship between the
gender differences on the reading attitudes of the male and female readers.
21
References
Artola T. et.al (2013) Differences in boys and girls attitudes toward reading. Retrieved
from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/275333670_Difference
s_in_Boys_and_Girls_Attitudes_toward_Reading_A_Comparison_bet
ween_Single_sex_and_Coeducational_Schools
Ashcroft J. (2017). Do boys’ attitudes to reading differ to those of girls? A study into the
views of reading within a year three class. Universityof Cumbria Vol 4 (1) pages
2-14.
Asraf, R.M. & Abdullah, H.(2016) Elementary Schoolers’ Attitudes toward Reading in
English: How Boys Feel Relative to Girls. Canadian Center of Science and
Education.
Chatterji, M. (2006). Reading achievement gaps, correlates, and moderators of early
reading achievement: Evidence from the early childhood longitudinal study
(ECLS) kindergarten to first grade sample. Journal of Educational Psychology,
98(3), 489-507. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0022-0663.98.3.489
Clark, C. (2010) Boys Versus Girls: Why is the Gender Gap in Reading Widening?
Literacy Today, v.64, 2830.
Forshey, (2013). EFFECTS OF READING ATTITUDE ON READING
ACHIEVEMENT OF STUDENTS IN GRADES ONE THROUGH SIX.
Retrieve from http://cardinalscholar.bsu.edu/bitstream/handle/123456789/19
7131 ForsheyA_2013-2_BODY.pdf;sequence=1
Gallagher, K. (2009) Readicide: How Schools Are Killing Reading and What You Can
Do About It. York: Stenhouse.
Logan, S. and Johnston, R. (2010) Investigating Gender Differences in Reading.
Educational Review, v.62 (2), p.175-187. Retrieved from
http://scihub.hk/https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080
/19388070902803795?scroll=top&needAccess=true
Marinak, B. & Gambrell L., (2010) Reading Motivation: Exploring the Elementary
Gender Gap. Literacy Research and Instruction, 49: 129–141, 2010
22
McGeown, S. and Norgate, R. and Warhurst, A (2012) Exploring Intrinsic and Extrinsic
Reading Motivation Among Very Good and Very Poor Readers, Educational
Research, v.54 (3), p.309-322.
McKool, S. and Gespass, S. (2009) Does Johnny's Reading Teacher Love to Read? How
Teachers' Personal Reading Habits Affect Instructional Practices, Literacy
Research and Instruction, v.48 (3), p.264276
Merisuo-Storm, T. &. (2012). Young boy´s opinions about reading, literacy lessons and
their reading competence. Proceedings of the ICERI 2012 Conference, (page.
4109-4118). Madrid, Spain.
National Literacy Trust (2012) Boys' Reading Commission: The report of the All-Party
Parliamentary Literacy Group Commission, London: National Literacy Trust.
Oakhill
Ofsted (2012) Research evidence on reading for pleasure. London: Ofsted.
Sarroub, L. and Pernicek, T. (2014) Boys, Books, and Boredom: A Case of Three High
School Boys and Their Encounters With Literacy. Reading & Writing Quarterly.
v.32, p.27-55.
Stevens, S. (2011). Entering bookworld: How to help both Boys and Girls in Class Read
Aloud. Teacher as Leader, EDU 600, 1-9.
Wolter, I. and Braun, E. and Hannover, B. (2015) Reading is for Girls!? The Negative
Impact of Preschool Teachers' Traditional Gender Role Attitudes on Boys'
Reading Related Motivation and Skills. Frontiers in Psychology,v.6 (1267), p.1-
10.