Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
2, April, 2011
1793-8163
Voltage Sensor
that may cause aliasing. This is performed by an 8 channel,
L ow -pass filter
S ignal processing
Figure 3: The block diagram of the test set-up including the positions of the
sensors [9].
234
International Journal of Computer and Electrical Engineering, Vol. 3, No. 2, April, 2011
1793-8163
at 30% load
turn faults using shorted turn fault frequencies components. -40
30% load
-80
-100
-5 -3 -1 1 3 5
(K)
0
Flux Spectrum : f1[(n/p)(1-s)+/-k)]
-20 Healthy
Faulty(20 ST)
noise level = - 65dB
Amplitude (dB)
at full-load
-40
-80
-100
-5 -3 -1 1 3 5
(K)
Figure 6: Comparison of variation in shorted turn sideband amplitude
versus percent of rated load of healthy motor at 30% load and at full-load.
235
International Journal of Computer and Electrical Engineering, Vol. 3, No. 2, April, 2011
1793-8163
Amplitude (dB)
the different values of k. The results show the maximum -40
variations in the sideband amplitudes for the healthy motor
is less than 4 dB at 30% load, which is not significant and -60
does not affect the accuracy and reliability of the test results phase A phase B
faulty A faulty B
obtained by using the shorted turn fault frequency Load = 30%
-80
components. The faulty motor result is shown for reference. noise level = -90 dB
Fig. 8 shows a comparison of the variations in the
amplitudes of the shorted turn sideband components -100
-5 -3 -1 1 3 5
versus % of rated load for two similar rating (2.2 kW) of K
motors and the variations for any value of k is less than 4
dB, which are not significant. The finding demonstrates the Figure 9: Variations in shorted turn sideband amplitudes for tests on two
reliability of test results. Fig. 9 shows variations in the nominal identical healthy motors. Faulty motor result is shown for
sideband amplitudes between phases A and B for a healthy reference.
-40
and k=±1. It can be concluded that the instantaneous power
signal showed slightly more variations in the amplitude of
-60 noise level = -65 dB negative sideband components at 100% load when
compared to the result for the flux spectra.
test 1 test 2
-80 test 3 faulty However, results obtained at 30 % load showed slight
Load = 30%
variations in the amplitudes of fault frequency components
-100 for the healthy and faulty motor. Therefore, on the basis of
-5 -3 -1 1 3 5 these results, instantaneous power is useful for detecting
K
shorted turn faults at 100% load.
Figure 7: Comparison of variations in flux sideband amplitudes for three Since the instantaneous power signal can detect shorted
tests on the same healthy motor.
turn faults at higher loads, it is important to examine the
0 variability of the instantaneous power signal in order to
Flux Spectrum : f1[(n/p)(1-s)+/-k)] confirm the reliability of the test results to detect shorted
-20
turn fault using instantaneous power signal.
A. Instantaneous Power Variations For Healthy
Amplitude (dB)
-40 Machines
Fig.12, 13 and 14 depict the healthy motor results
-60 noise level = -65dB regarding: repeatability tests on the same motor; differences
between motors; and differences between the motor’s
motor1 motor 2
-80 faulty phases for confirming the reliability of the test results in
Load = 30%
detecting shorted turn faults from the instantaneous power
signal.
-100
-5 -3 -1 1 3 5 Fig.12 summarizes the variation in the sideband
K amplitudes versus different values of k at 100% load and a
set of three tests. The variation was found to be less than 3
Figure 8: Variations in shorted turn sideband amplitudes for tests on two dB, which is very small.
nominal identical healthy motors. The result of faulty motor is shown for
reference. Fig. 13 compares the instantaneous power sideband
amplitudes versus different values of k at 100% load for the
two nominally identical healthy motors and demonstrated a
236
International Journal of Computer and Electrical Engineering, Vol. 3, No. 2, April, 2011
1793-8163
motor. The variation in the amplitudes for both phases is Faulty(20 ST)
Amplitude (dB)
at 30% load
less than 3 dB, which is also very small. -40
It can be concluded from the three different tests on the noise level = - 95 dB
-100
-5 -3 -1 1 3 5
Healthy motor (n=1 and k=-1)
(K)
at full-load
-20
test 1 test 2
faulty test 3
Amplitude (dB)
full- load
-80
noise level = -95 dB
-100
-5 -3 -1 1 3 5
K
Figure 12: Variations in shorted turn sideband amplitudes for three tests on
the same healthy motor at full-load.
0
Instt.Power Spectrum : fp[(n/p)(1-s)+/-k)]
-20
motor 1
Amplitude (dB)
motor 2
-40 faulty
Faulty motor (n=1 and k=+1) Load = 30%
at full-load -60
-80
noise level = -95 dB
-100
-5 -3 -1 1 3 5
K
Figure 10: indicates variations in the amplitudes of the healthy and faulty Figure 13: Variations in the shorted turn sideband amplitudes for tests on
motor with 20 shorted turns at 100% load tests for n=1 and k=±1. two identical healthy motors at 100% load.
237
International Journal of Computer and Electrical Engineering, Vol. 3, No. 2, April, 2011
1793-8163
0
0
Instt. Power Spectrum : fp[(n/p)(1-s)+/-k)]
Instt.Pow er : f p[(n/p)(1-s)+/-k)]
-20 -20
k=1
Amplitude (dB)
healthy motor
Amplitude (dB)
phase A phase B
-40 faulty B faulty A
-40 faulty motor
Load = 30% -57.83 dB
-60 -60 -59.66 dB
-80 -80
noise level = -95 dB
-100
-100
-5 -3 -1 1 3 5 0 30 60 90 120
K % Rated Load
Figure 14: Variations in shorted turn sideband amplitudes of the healthy
motor between phases A and B at full-load. 0
Com bined Single Signal
Amplitude (dB)
POWER SPECTRA healthy motor
-83.87dB faulty motor
-80
Fig. 15 shows the measured shorted turn sideband
-99.6 dB
amplitudes for healthy and faulty motor (20 shorted turns)
over a wide range of loads from the flux, instantaneous -120
power and single power-flux signal.
The results obtained from the flux signal indicate that
shorted turn causes sideband amplitudes to decrease as the -160
load on the motor increases. However, flux signal proved 0 30 60 90 120
more suitable and in fact preferable for detecting shorted % Rated Load
turn faults at light loads, while the instantaneous power is Figure 15: Variations in the sideband amplitudes for the healthy and faulty
able to detect shorted turn faults at heavy loads. Therefore, motor (with 20 shorted turns). Top row (left) and top row (right) show the
it is difficult to set a threshold between the healthy and flux and instantaneous power. The Bottom (row) represents a single signal.
faulty motors.
To overcome this difficulty, a novel approach has been In summary, the single signal is preferable for detecting
used as a combination of both flux and instantaneous power shorted turn faults over a wide range of loads for the
signals into a single signal called “Power-Flux Signal”. Flux different values of k when compared to the results obtained
signal and instantaneous power signal are used in a from flux and instantaneous power signals separately.
combination of Power-Flux signal. The best feature of the
Power-Flux signal is that the sideband amplitudes between
the shorted turn fault frequency components are generally VI. CONCLUSION
higher as shown in Fig. 15 (bottom row). It is thus easier to Non-invasive multiple sensors for the detection of
set a threshold between the healthy and faulty motors to shorted turns fault using fault frequency components from
determine the shorted turn fault severity using combined flux signal, instantaneous power signal and a single signal
power-flux signal. (combination of flux and instantaneous power signals)
called power-flux over a wide range of loads has been
0 presented in this paper. Using fault frequency components
Flux Spectrum : f1[(n/p)(1-s)+/-k)] to detect the faults and estimate fault severity in the
-20 machines relies heavily on variations in the amplitudes of
-26 dB sideband components. The results for the flux signal
Amplitude (dB)
be used to detect shorted turns fault and showed much Frequency Spectrum Technique”, International Journal of Computer
and Electrical Engineering, IJCEE (Accepted for Publication in Vol.3,
clearer variations between healthy and faulty motors over a Issue 1, Available online in February 2011).
whole range of loads (from no-load to full-load).
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to acknowledge their respective
universities for providing adequate resources and
environment for research.
Intesar Ahmed received Phd Electrical Power
Engineering from University of Adelaide, South
REFERENCES Australia and M.Sc. in Electrical Power
Engineering from University of New South Wales,
[1] W. R. Finlay, “Troubleshooting motor problems,” IEEE Trans. Ind.
Sydney, Australia in 2007 and 1994 respectively.
Applicat., vol. 30, pp. 1383–1397, Sept./Oct. 1994.
Dr. Intesar has been involving in various
[2] F. Filippetti and M. Martelli, “Development of Expert System
research projects relating to online condition
Knowledge Base to On-Line Diagnosis of Rotor Electrical Faults of
monitoring of electrical machines, power
Induction Motors,” IEEE Ind. Applicat. Society Annual Meeting, vol.
electronics, and study of multiple faults in electric
1, 1992, pp. 92-99.
machines via signal processing techniques.
[3] A. H. Bonnett and G. C. Soukup, "Cause and Analysis of stator and
Rotor Failures in Three-phase Squirrel-Cage Induction Motors," IEEE
Trans. on Industry Applications, vol. 28, no 4, pp. 921-931,
July/August 1992. Manzar Ahmed received MS in
[4] A.J.M. Cardoso, S.M.A. Cruz, D.S.B. Fonseca, “Inter-turn stator Telecommunication from Asian Institute of
winding fault diagnosis in three-phase induction motors, by Park's Technology, Thailand and B.Sc. in Electrical
Vector approach” IEEE International Electric Machines and Drives Engineering from University of Engineering &
Conference Record, 1997. Digital Object Identifier: Technology, Lahore Pakistan in 2001 and 1991
10.1109/IEMDC.1997.604083 Publication Year: 1997, pp MB1/5.1 - respectively.
MB1/5.3 His current research interests include electric
[5] H.M. Emara, M.E. Ammar, A. Bahgat, H.T. Dorrah, “Stator fault machines and drives, electromagnetic
estimation in induction motors using particle swarm optimization” computational and electromechanical actuation as
IEEE International Electric Machines and Drives Conference, 2003. well as techniques for energy savings.
Volume: 3 Publication Year: 2003, pp 1469 – 1475.
[6] S. Nandi, “Detection of Stator Faults in Induction Machines Using
Residual Saturation Harmonics” IEEE Transactions on Industry
Applications, Volume: 42 , Issue: 5 Digital Object Identifier: Muhammad Shuja Khan received MS degree in
10.1109/TIA.2006.880838 Publication Year: 2006 , pp 1201 – 1208. Electronic Engineering from Ghulam Ishaq Khan
[7] Wang Xu-hong; He Yi-gang, “Fuzzy Model based On-line Stator Institute (G.I.K.I.) of Engineering. Science &
Winding Turn Fault Detection for Induction Motors” Sixth Technology, Swabi Pakistan and B.Sc. Electrical
International Conference on Intelligent Systems Design and (POWER) Engineering from University of
Applications, 2006. Volume: 1 Digital Object Identifier: Engineering & Technology, Lahore Pakistan in
10.1109/ISDA.2006.157, 2006, pp 838 – 843. June 2009 and July 2007 respectively.
[8] J. Cusido, L. Romeral, J.A. Ortega, J.A. Rosero, A.G. Espinosa, “Fault He joined COMSATS Institute, Lahore
Detection in Induction Machines Using Power Spectral Density in Pakistan on August 2009 as Lecturer in
Wavelet Decomposition” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, Department of Electrical Engineering.
Volume: 55 , Issue: 2, Digital Object Identifier: He has successfully conducted and taught one Short Certificate Training
10.1109/TIE.2007.911960, Publication Year: 2008 , pp 633 – 643. Course of “Power Distribution System Design” in Spring 2010. His
[9] Ahmed, I., Supangat, R., Grieger, J., Ertugrul, N., and Soong, W.L. "A interests include MEMS Design and Multiple faults in Machines.
Baseline Study for On-Line Condition Monitoring of Induction Engr. Shuja was awarded Higher Education Commission Pakistan
Machines", Australian University Power Engineering Conference, Indigenous Fellowship Award for hid MS program at G.I.K.I. 2007-09. He
Brisbane, Australia, September 2004, ISBN 1864997753, pp. 1-6. was also awarded two International Travel Grants for presenting his
[10] I. Albizu, A. Tapia, J.R. Saenz, A.J. Mazon, I. Zamora, “Stator research paper in ICSCT 2009 and ICMENS 2010 held in South Korea
winding fault diagnosis in induction generators for renewable and China respectively by HEC Pakistan.
generation”, Proceedings of the 12th IEEE Mediterranean
Electrotechnical Conference, 2004. Publication Year: 2004, pp 1017 -
1020 Vol.3.
[11] Ahmed, I., Ahmed, M., "Comparison of Stator Current, Axial Flux and Kashif Imran received his elementary education
Instantaneous Power Used to Detect the Broken Rotor Bar Fault in from England where he obtained GCSEs and
Machines". Australian University Power Engineering Conference, GCEs.He did B.Sc. and M.Sc. in Electrical
Sydney, Australia, 14-17th December 2008, ISBN 978-0-7334-2715-2, Engineering from University of Engineering and
pp. 1-6. Technology (UET), Lahore, Pakistan. His area of
[12] A. Siddique, G.S. Yadava, B. Singh, “A review of stator fault specialization during both degrees was Electrical
monitoring techniques of induction motors” IEEE Transactions on Power. He started his career as a Lecturer at UET
Energy Conversion, Volume: 20 , Issue: 1, Digital Object Identifier: Lahore. Then he moved to SIEMENS where he
10.1109/TEC.2004.837304, 2005 , pp 106 – 114. worked as Engineer on project coordination of
[13] S. Grubic, J.M Aller, B. Lu, T.G. Habetler, “A survey of testing and 132kV grid stations.
monitoring methods for stator insulation systems in induction Later he joined NESPAK, leading engineering consultancy firm of
machines” International Conference on Condition Monitoring and Pakistan, as a Design Engineer in Power Distribution Section. In NESPAK,
Diagnosis, 2008. Digital Object Identifier: his professional experience includes design of overhead and underground
10.1109/CMD.2008.4580262 Publication Year: 2008, pp 196 – 203. power distribution systems for a variety of buildings and installations.
[14] Intesar Ahmed, Manzar Ahmed, M. Shuja Khan, Kashif Imran, Currently, he is Lecturer at COMSATS Institute of IT, Lahore, Pakistan
“Investigation of Multiple Faults Detection in Electric Machine Using where he teaches Electric Machines. His book titled “Power Exchange as a
Broken Rotor Bar and Eccentricity Fault Frequencies Techniques”, Deregulated Electricity Market” has been published by LAP Lambert
International Journal of Electrical and Computer Sciences, Academic Publishing, Germany. His research interests include Power
IJECS/IJENS. Vol. 10, Issue 5, pp 24–31, (2010). System Economics, Restructured Power Systems Simulation, Energy
[15] Intesar Ahmed, Manzar Ahmed, Kashif Imran, M. Shuja Khan, S. Management Systems and Online Condition Monitoring of Electric
Junaid Akhtar, “Detection of Eccentricity Faults in Machine Using Machines.
239