Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
act, which casts dishonor, discredit, or contempt upon another person. The
elements are (1) that the offender performs any act not included in any other
crime against honor, (2) that such act is performed in the presence of other
person or persons, and (3) that such act casts dishonor, discredit or contempt
upon the offended party. Whether a certain slanderous act constitutes slander by
deed of a serious nature or not, depends on the social standing of the offended
party, the circumstances under which the act was committed, the occasion,
etc.[32] It is libel committed by actions rather than words. The most common
examples are slapping someone or spitting on his/her face in front of the public
market, in full view of a crowd, thus casting dishonor, discredit, and contempt
upon the person of another.
The RTC fixed the penalty in this case at 3 months. As already stated, the crime
committed is grave slander by deed, punishable by arresto mayor maximum to
prision correccional minimum, the duration of which is 4 months and 1 day to 2
years and 4 months. Since there is one mitigating circumstance (i.e., voluntary
surrender) and no aggravating circumstance, the penalty should be imposed in
its minimum period. Accordingly, the penalty should be modified.
SO ORDERED.
Prescinding from the foregoing, it would serve the ends of justice better if the
petitioner were sentenced to pay a fine instead of imprisonment. The offense
while considered serious slander by deed was done in the heat of anger[28] and
was in reaction to a perceived provocation. The penalty for serious slander by
deed may be either imprisonment or a fine.[29] We opt to impose a fine.
[28]
Pader vs. People, G. R. No. 139157, February 8, 2000.
[29]
Article 359, Revised Penal Code.
crime
against
honor
which
is
committed
by
performing
any
act
which
casts
dishonor,
discredit,
or
contempt
upon
another
person.
Q:
What
are
the
elements
of
slander
by
deed?
A:
1.
Offender
performs
any
act
not
included
in
any
other
crime
against
honor
2.
Such
act
is
performed
in
the
presence
of
other
person
or
persons
3.
Such
act
casts
dishonor,
discredit
or
contempt
upon
the
offended
party
Q:
What
are
the
kinds
of
slander
by
deed?
A:
1.
Simple
slander
by
deed
performance
of
an
act,
not
use
of
words.
2.
Grave
slander
by
deed
which
is
of
serious
crime.
Q:
What
determines
if
an
act
is
slander
by
deed
or
not?
A:
Whether
certain
slanderous
act
constitutes
slander
by
deed
of
serious
nature
or
not,
depends
on
the
social
standing
of
the
offended
party,
the
circumstances
under
which
the
act
was
committed,
the
occasion,
etc.
Illustration:
Thus,
slapping
a
lady
in
dance
not
for
purpose
of
hurting
her
but
to
cause
her
shame
and
humiliation
for
refusing
to
dance
with
the
accused
is
slander
by
deed.
INCRIMINATORY
MACHINATIONS
INCRMINATING
INNOCENT
PERSON
(Art.
363)
Q:
What
are
the
elements
of
this
crime?
A:
1.
Offender
performs
an
act
2.
By
such
act
he
directly
incriminates
or
imputes
to
an
innocent
person
the
commission
of
crime
3.
Such
act
does
not
constitute
perjury
Note:
The
crime
of
incriminatory
machinations
is
limited
to
planting
evidence
and
the
like,
which
tend
directly
to
cause
false
prosecution.
Q:
What
are
the
distinctions
between
incriminating
an
innocent
person
and
perjury
by
making
false
accusation?
A:
INCRIMINATING