Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Abstract— The sun as the primary source of energy can be tapped versions of power grids as they are implemented typically in
into to light our universities. With the prevailing economic recession local areas having the capacity to disconnect from the main
and global warming, universities can reduce cost of electricity grid and operate in island mode [10]. The aim of the present
through a self-sustaining microgrid. The university is like a separate
entity and can operate as an island with sufficient resources to meet study is to model a UCM at steady state and analyse the
her energy demands. Microgrid has evolved as a major technology performance and cost benefits.
to harness and aggregate available renewable energy sources (RES) The rest of this paper is arranged as follows: section 2
with a view to increasing network reliability, reducing carbon discuss the concept of microgrid, section 3 focuses on
footprint and reducing cost of energy. This paper reviews existing Islanded microgrid as a type of microgrid that could be
university campus microgrids (UCM) around the world, implemented in university campus. A review of university
highlighting their objectives, methods, challenges and results. One
of these objectives is to serve as a test-bed or laboratory in which campus microgrid around the world is presented in section 4
students and faculty staff conduct research to advance modern power highlighting their objectives, configurations and results while
system. Solar Photovoltaic (Rooftop PV) remains the major RES in the final conclusion is drawn in section 5.
the implementation of UCM, however, a hybrid system is also
common. The review shows that UCM if well designed among other
benefits results in a significant reduction in the operation cost of the
university.
1 INTRODUCTION
The drive for alternative energy due to global warming
and environmental pollution as a result of burning fossil fuels
to generate electricity continues to grow in many areas day
by day [1]. Government, utilities, institutions, industries and
businesses are all sourcing for alternatives to cover for future
energy demands to reduce energy cost and reduce the cost of
building high voltage (HV) transmission facilities.
Renewable energy sources (RESs) such as wind, solar, hydro
and biomass have become the major alternatives to
conventional energy sources such as fossil fuel, coal, gas and
oil in meeting the growing energy demand all over the world
[2], [3]. RESs offer in abundance free, readily available,
sustainable and clean energy resources for mankind [4], [5].
Figure 1 shows the annual solar irradiation for South Africa
indicating available potential for solar energy. For efficient Fig 1: Annual Solar irradiation for South Africa [11]
integration of RES to the grid, the microgrid concept has
2 THE MICROGRID CONCEPT
attracted significant interest. For instance, ABB has been
selected by the university of Chester, northwest England to The concept of Microgrid emerged about two decades ago
install a microgrid control system to better integrate to ease and increase the penetration of renewable energy
conventional and renewable energy [6]- [8]. According to [9], sources into the distribution network with higher degree of
microgrid is “a load cluster with a clear geographical reliability and minimal complex algorithm to coordinate all
boundary within a distribution system, which can coordinate the renewables [12]. The main drivers of Microgrid concept
the operation of DERs, and energy storage to supply the local include high level integration of distributed energy resources,
load demand in an economic and reliable manner”. In other increased energy demand, high cost of expanding
words, as the name implies, microgrids are very small transmission facilities to remote areas and instability of the
K. T. Akindeji, Durban University of Technology, P O Box 1334, I. E. Davidson, Department of Electrical Power Engineering, Durban
Durban 400, South Africa (e-mail: kayodea@dut.ac.za). He is a PhD University of Technology, P O Box 1334, Durban 400, South Africa (e-
student at University of Kwa-Zulu Natal and a lecturer at Durban mail: innocentd@dut.ac.za).
University of Technology.
R. Tiako, Department of Electronic, Electrical and Computer
Engineering, University of Kwa-Zulu Natal. (e-mail: tiako@ukzn.ac.za)
grid due to ageing [13]. Microgrid usually comprised 2.1.1 Solar PV
different types of DER such as wind turbine, solar PV, fuel The major source of solar power is by direct or indirect
cells and various distributed energy storage systems in conversion of sunlight to electricity. The direct method is
addition to inverters, smart switches, communication system using photovoltaic (PV) solar cells whereas the indirect
and controllers [14]. Hence, microgrid has become the method uses concentrated solar panel (CSP) [4]. Solar PV
bedrock of smartgrid incorporating information technology is established around the world to generate
communication technology (ICT) into the power distribution electrical power for many stand-alone applications such a
grid. In summary, distribution networks are changing from microgrid. Radiation on a horizontal surface is the only
being passive to active networks with bidirectional power radiation available from most meteorological stations
flows [1]. The main advantage of microgrid from grid point especially in developing world. Other data are estimated
of view is the ability for it to be controlled as a single entity using different models developed for this purpose [20]. The
with respect to the grid [15], [16]. In other words, the solar irradiance for a typical day, 16th January 2019 as
microgrid is treated as a net load or a generator with definite extracted from South African Universities Radiometric
properties [2]. Microgrids operate in two modes, these are Network (SAURAN) [26] showing six provinces; Eastern
grid-connected and islanding modes [3]. Types of microgrids Cape (EC), Kwa-Zulu Natal (KZN), Gauteng (GP), Limpopo
include; campus, community, islanded, nanogrid and hybrid (LP), Northern Cape (NC) and Western Cape (WC) in South
(AC and DC) [17]. However, microgrids cannot be fully Africa is shown in Figure 2.
autonomous without optimal location and sizing of energy
storage devices [18]. Factors or criteria considered in
selecting battery technologies for microgrid are cycle life, Diffuse horizontal irradiance in
cost, safety, round trip efficiency, maintenance requirements,
maximum temperature rating, and environmental impact as [W/m2 ]
well as type of project [19], [20]. The microgrid acts like a 4000
plug-and-play power unit as such it disconnects itself from 3500
the main grid in case of any grid disturbances (e.g. frequency 3000
or voltage violations, short circuit faults), operates in island 2500
mode and reconnects when the main grid is healed [21]. The
2000
transition from grid connected mode to island mode can be
1500
triggered by poor power quality at the main grid such as
voltage or frequency deviations and unscheduled event i.e. 1000
major faults at the main grid [22]. Two IEEE standards, IEEE 500
2030.7(IEEE standard for the specification of microgrid 0
controllers) and IEEE 2030.8 (IEEE standard for the testing
of microgrid) address the control functions of microgrid in
connecting to and disconnecting from the main grid. The
EC KZN GP LP NC WC
following technical requirements must be met for
resynchronization to the main grid. As stated in [13] and [23],
the requirements are; Fig 2: Daily Solar irradiance for Six Provinces South Africa
i. Frequency deviation at the PCC < 0,1 Hz
ii. Voltage angle difference at the PCC < 1º Equations (1) and (2) give the amount of electrical energy that
iii. Voltage magnitude difference at the PCC < 5% can be generated from solar PV using different parameters
Having highlighted the above requirements as well as the [27].
reliability requirement of the concerned consumer, the
institute of electrical and electronic engineer (IEEE) standard 𝐸 = 365 𝑝𝑘 𝑟𝑝 𝐻𝑖 (1)
1547 must be met for islanding and reconnection of all
microgrids [16],[21]. Microgrids are not without challenges E is the annual electricity generation (kWh); Pk is peak power
especially with RESs that are intermittent and climate of solar PV panel (kW); rp is the system performance ratio
dependent in nature. Principal challenge is protection as a and Hi is the annual daily global radiation (Wh).
result of bidirectional flow in the distribution network, the
traditional protection system needs to be redesigned to 𝐸𝑜𝑢𝑡 = 𝐴𝑒 𝐸𝑒 𝐺 (2)
accommodate bidirectional flow considering the dynamics of
the microgrid before, during and after islanding operation Eout is annual electricity production (kWh); Ae is the total
[24]. surface area of solar cells (m2), Ee is the annual mean power
2.1 Distributed energy sources conversion efficiency and G is the annual total global
Non-conventional or RESs used in generating electricity in irradiation (Wh/m2).
microgrid are called distributed energy resources or micro
sources [25]. Prominent among these are solar photovoltaic 2.1.2 Wind energy
(PV) systems, small scale hydro, wind energy conversion The application of wind energy or power started
system (WECS), combined heat and power (CHP) system, thousands of years ago, whereby the energy derived from
micro turbines, fuel cells. A brief description of two major
wind was used to pump water and to grind corn. Also, ancient
DER technologies used in microgrid follows.
mariners used wind to sail to distant lands. Wind like solar is stakeholders (distribution system operator, transmission
free and available in an inexhaustible quantity. [20] defines system operator, independent system operator) in deregulated
wind as “the movement of air from high-pressure areas to power system. However, the benefits for the end-users are
low-pressure areas caused by uneven heating of the earth’s improved power quality and reliability, reduction of demand
surface by the sun”. South Africa has fair wind potential, charges and time of use [24]. Apart from providing system
specifically along the coastal area of western and Eastern reliability, ESS can be used to optimize distributed generator
cape. This makes South Africa the highest producers of wind (DG) or on-site generation to reduce the total cost of energy
power in Africa. The average wind speed of selected purchased from the main grid. The ESS stores energy during
provinces in South Africa is shown in table 1. Through the the off-peak period (less expensive tariff) and use it during
peak period (high tariff) [19]. In a microgrid with RES, ESS
Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer’s
provides load capacity and reduces the need for VAR
Procurement programme (REIPPPP), about 19 wind farms
generation from the RESs. In addition, ESSs provide energy
have been established producing 1471 MW. Wind energy is
levelling to source variations, energy buffering to load
converted to electrical energy through a technology called changes and ride-through advantage for microgrid
wind energy conversion systems (WECSs). A WECS mainly application [18]. ESSs are either chemical or mechanical,
consists of a turbine, generator, power electronic converters, common examples include; super-capacitors, batteries of
gear box and a transformer. The amount of energy that can be different types, flywheels and superconducting magnetic
extracted from the wind depends on its speed. From equation energy storage, pumped hydro storage and hydrogen fuel
3, the wind speed is directly proportional to the energy that cells [20].
can be harvested to generate electricity. The power output of
a wind turbine is given by “(3)”; 2.3 Economic benefits of microgrid
With good operation strategy, microgrid can provide varieties
𝑃𝑤 = 0.5𝜌𝐶𝑝 𝐴𝑉 3 (3) of benefits ranging from technical, environmental, social to
economical for every stakeholder. One major challenge of
implementing microgrid is its financial feasibility as a result
Where Pw is the power output, Cp is the power coefficient of
of high capital costs. This problem is addressed by utilities by
turbine, A is the surface area of the turbine, ρ is density and V
providing renewable energy incentive programs such as feed-
is the wind velocity hitting the surface area [20], [28] – [31]. in tariff [35]. This section considers specific economic
benefits of microgrid. From a macro-economic point of view;
Table I. Average wind speed of selected provinces in South Africa microgrid can act as an initiator of local retail and service
[32].
market, acts also as a hedging tool against potential risks of
Month Wind Speed (m/s) price volatility, load growth, outage etc. It is assumed that the
Province NC KZN GP WC overall economic benefits of a microgrid is enjoyed by the
Jan 3.74 1.48 2.41 4.95 end consumers I situation where the consumers own and
Feb 4.12 1.87 2.36 4.80 operate multiple micro source units as an aggregated
Mar 3.87 2.09 1.81 4.13 prosumer entity [16]. Other economic benefits come from the
postponement or deferral of investments in the expansion of
Apr 4.08 2.06 1.71 4.07
generation and transmission systems [25]. Cost is saved also
May 2.89 1.75 1.69 3.44
in transmission and distribution (T&D) through integration of
Jun 3.37 1.91 1.46 3.84 several micro sources (e.g. electric vehicles) as they are
Jul 3.46 2.06 1.69 3.85 operated in plug-and-play mode. Economic benefits also
Aug 3.38 1.89 1.93 3.64 come in terms of unit commitment and economical dispatch
Sept 3.67 2.33 2.80 4.26
of microgrid resources resulting in cost saving. A good
illustration of this cost saving benefit of microgrid is reported
Oct 3.70 2.47 2.63 4.43
in [23], whereby the master controller dispatches the
Nov 3.86 2.43 2.69 5.46 microgrid generation once the electricity price is above 6
Dec 4.24 2.66 2.66 4.93 cents/kWh, charges the battery when the electricity price is as
Ave 3.70 2.08 2.15 4.32 low as 2.8 cents/kWh and discharges the battery storage as
the price of electricity increases to 22.4 cents/kWh. The
economic benefits of microgrid is not limited to saving the
2.2 Significance of energy storage system cost of electricity but also in earnings from feed-in tariff.
Feed-in tariff is a premium rate that is more than the
The power generated by RES such as solar PV and wind electricity rate and is usually guaranteed for a fixed term.
turbines is intermittent in nature and due to sensitivity of Utilities buy back power at premium rate from local
microgrid to change in load or generation, microgrid must generation to encourage investment into RE generation [36].
have a storage system both with high power and energy
densities [33]. The utilization of DER in microgrid can be
increased by integrating energy storage system (ESS) [34]. 3 ISLANDED MICROGRID
The purpose or objective of ESS in a microgrid among others Islands and remote areas have complex energy supply
is to achieve balance between energy demand and RE challenges due to geographical and environmental factors
produced or generated especially in islanding mode [3]. In [16]. As a result, they are supplied by diesel generators
essence, any short fall in meeting the load demand would be
having adverse effect on the environment and on the
solved either by discharging the batteries and / or capacitor
reliability of supply. The expansion of the grid to these areas
and /or activating the fuel cell and / or by importing from the
faces many difficulties such as high operational costs and
main grid [14]. ESS has several benefits to different
huge construction investments. The implementation of revolution cannot be overemphasized, specifically, global
microgrid in these areas using RES taking the advantages of system for mobile (GSM). The most energy demanding
the nature to provide among others electricity to local device in the GSM network is the base transceiver station
residents. In the present study, the principle behind islanded (BTS). Close to 90% of the total energy consumed in the
microgrid will be implemented in the UCM model especially mobile network is used by equipment in the BTS. The BTS
during high demand season since the university is billed on provides the frequency interface between the communication
time of use (TOU) tariff to reduce the energy intake from the network and user [43], hence it is a critical load that needs
main grid. In addition, the UCM will comprise nanogrids uninterrupted power supply for quality of service. As at 2012,
inform of building microgrids that can stand alone during the about 40% of BTs in the world are off-grid not connected to
the main electricity grid. As a result, most of the BTS are
period of high demand. Some practical applications of
powered by diesel generators, the operational expenditure
islanded microgrid are discussed below.
(OPEX) of which could be ten times more on a yearly basis
3.1 Remote or rural areas electrification and in addition produces approximately 33.3 tons of carbon
Millions of people still live in darkness especially in remote dioxide (CO2) annually. In recent years, BTS powered by
areas of sub-Sahara Africa while the region has sunshine all RES have gained the attention of GSM service providers [44].
year round. This number is not expected to change soon. For economic and environmental reasons, the power systems
There is a growing trend in informal settlements and it is the for GSM and 4G base stations located in remote areas are now
constitutional right of all citizens to have basic services which designed with RES. In [45], a hybrid RE plant is proposed
include electricity. Most of these informal settlements are not comprising of solar PV, a wind turbine and a fuel cell (with
connected or far from the main grid, as a result, they rely on hydrogen production and storage facility). As reported in
charcoal, firewood for heating and cooking and use paraffin [46], carbon emission can be reduced by over 87.47% while
and kerosene for lighting [37],[38]. Government at all levels the total fuel (diesel) consumption reduced by over 10 400
is therefore looking for solutions to this challenge. Islanded litres per annum using a hybrid of wind turbine and solar PV
microgrid comes as a solution to the challenge of providing as main power supply and a diesel generator as back up for
electricity to rural areas, small island and remote areas that the BTS. The use of RES to power BTS is further justified in
are far from the main grid. An example is a microgrid [47]. Besides the high cost of diesel fuel and cost of its
consisting of a 800 kW wind turbine, 160 kW solar PV and transport to the BTS, the BTS are sources of pollution due to
two battery containers each rated at 1.44 MWh/400 kW being huge green-house gas emissions. Therefore, use of RES
developed in a Greek island through the European reduces energy costs significantly and also improves the
commission [12]. [39] compared the cost of microgrid to cost energy efficiency of the BTS in remote areas.
of grid extension in providing electricity to a rural area in 3.3 University campus microgrid
Ntabankulu Local Municipality, Eastern Cape, South Africa.
The university campus is an idea environment to
The result showed that the costs of electricity using an off-
encourage the development of energy sustainability and
grid microgrid and the main grid were $0.320/kWh and
utilization of RE [48]. Institutional or university campuses
$0.544/kWh respectively. Also, islanded microgrid provides
can be easily transformed to microgrid having many
a good platform to study RES integration. The power
buildings that are closely located. These buildings are
generated can be consumed locally meaning that the
connected electrically within the same network that is
resilience and flexibility of microgrid can be enhanced [40].
connected usually to the main grid through a single point of
Another area where islanded microgrid is deployed is in the
common coupling (PCC), allowing seamless transition
military which can be mobile or base station. In [41], a remote
between islanding mode and grid connected mode [12], [17].
military microgrid made up of two diesel generators, solar PV
In other words, due to small distance between DERs, and
panels and hybrid energy storage is used to analyze the
loads in university campuses, the development of a microgrid
performance of energy storage system. The microgrid is
comes handy [13]. A typical campus microgrid could consist
designed such that the critical loads (computers, radars)
of (i) the energy generation (both controllable and RES), (ii)
which are essential for the success of military operation are
the energy storage system (iii) the load (critical and non-
connected such that they received constant power while the
critical) and (iv) controllers for interconnection with the main
non-critical loads can be shed. Due to the increasing
grid. Figure 3 below shows 24-hour (31st October 2018) load
penetration of RESs that are unpredictable and uncertain, the
profile of the Howard College campus of the university of
energy management system in microgrid is complicated. The
kwa-zulu natal (UKZN) as well as the solar irradiance for
battery energy storage system (BESS) is recognized as the
same day. The load data is obtained with permission from the
most favourable approach to smooth out load variations for
UKZN energy management office and the solar irradiance is
increased efficiency of the power supply. In islanded
as measured by the SAURAN weather station equipment
microgrid due to labor and transport costs, it is not
(pyranometer) located on the campus. As it can be seen the
economical to frequently replace the BESS, therefore, there
peak load occurred over the period of high irradiance and with
is need to coordinate and control the BESS in an economical
adequate investment and good technical design of solar PV,
and efficient manner [42]. However, one of the short comings
energy cost of the campus can be reduced. The city of
of BESS is that their lifetime is considerably shorter than that
eThekwini electricity office has designed a solar map that
of other components in a microgrid. The lifetime
calculates and estimate possible costs and potential savings
characteristics of BESS have not been fully studied in many
for residents in the city of Durban, South Africa who want to
RE-based microgrid [20].
install Photovoltaic panels on their roofs [49].
3.2 Base transceiver station/GSM base station
The roles of telecommunication and information
communication technology (ICT) in the fourth industrial
4 UNIVERSITY CAMPUS MICROGRID AROUND 4.1 Objectives
THE WORLD It is important to understand the fundamental reasons
There is no doubt that university campuses around the world where UCM is to be implemented. Among the several
can become sustainable universities by developing microgrid objectives of the microgrid to be implemented at the MCAST
systems, particularly PV systems. An example is found in campus is to serve as pilot projects for demonstrating and
University of Southampton (Highfield campus), where 5 016 implementing novel ideas relating to microgrids and
PV panels are installed to meet about 3.76 % of the annual smartgrids. Also, students and staff are engaged in research
energy demands in the campus with a payback period of 5.6 that will improve energy efficiency on campus [12]. The
years [48]. A typical UCM single line diagram is shown in primary objective of the microgrid at the Jiangan campus of
Figure 4. Sichuan university (SCU) is to investigate the potential of
16000 solar power in building sustainable university [48]. Three
objectives for a UCM according to [14] are;
14000
a) To help the campus avoid peak load in period of
12000 high demand
10000 b) To satisfy part of the residential campus load
8000 c) To charge employees’ electric vehicles
Whereas, the microgrid implemented at the university of
6000
California, San Diego (UCSD) aims to create a self-
4000 sustaining campus and reduce the university’s carbon
2000 footprint [34]. The campus was able to buy gas at an attractive
0 rate thereby reducing the payback period [16]. According to
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 the report in [8], the main objective of ABB microgrid
solution is to demonstrate how DERs would work together to
Campus Load Profile [kW] reduce costs and emissions on a typical grid. A proposed
Solar irradiance Profile [W/m2 ] energy resource management (ERM) in [50] was applied to
distribution network of a university campus in Portugal to test
Fig 3: Typical 24-hour solar irradiance and campus load profiles and validate the hour-ahead and the day-ahead resources
scheduling. The common objective of the microgrids
developed at university of Genoa and Technical University of
Main
Grid Eindhoven is to reduce the usage of fossil-based energy
generation and to improve economic performance as well as
the reliability [51]. The smart polygeneration microgrid
PCC
(SPM) at the Savona campus of Genoa university has two
main objectives: to serve as a test bed for testing, research and
development and to generate clean energy for the university
loads [52], [53]. One of the nine campuses of the Democritus
University of Thrace (DUTH), the Kimneria campus located
in the city of Xanthi in Greece is used as attest case to (i)
minimize electricity costs (ii) design the campus energy
Substation 2
Substation 1