Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
A new experimental system is presented to investigate the fast pyrolysis of solid fuels, in the
absence of heat- and mass-transfer limitations. It consists of an electrically heated furnace,
where a thin layer of powdered solid is exposed, on both sides, to radiative heating. A PID
temperature controller is programmed for two different working conditions: the usual constant
furnace temperature (A) and a constant sample temperature (B). Cellulose pyrolysis is
investigated in the temperature range 523-699 K. It is shown that significant heat-transfer
limitations cannot be avoided with the modality A, unless very slow heating rates, as in the
classical TGA systems, are applied. In the modality B (global heating rates 19-56 K/s), the
independence of the char yields from the sample thickness, for values of this below a critical
value, indicates negligible spatial temperature gradients and activity of intraparticle secondary
reactions of primary vapors. External heat-transfer limitations, due mainly to endothermic
reaction energetics, are also avoided through proper variation in the intensity of the external
radiative heat flux. Consequently, conversion occurs under exactly determined temperature
conditions. A cold helium flow carries away from the reaction environment volatile products so
that the activity of extra-bed secondary reactions is hindered as well. Cellulose weight loss and
temperature curves are applied to evaluate the global degradation kinetics and to study the
influences of heat- and mass-transfer limitations.
2500 K, is achieved within 3 s, resulting in rather fast of the sample temperature, T, for the computational
reactor heating rates. To avoid interaction between the domain consisting of the half-thickness layer, τ, can be
volatile pyrolysis products and the lamps, a quartz tube described as:
(i.d. 6 × 10-2 m and length 20 × 10-2 m), transparent
to infrared radiation, is located inside the furnace and σS(TL4 - T4)
used as a reaction chamber. A powdered solid sample ∂T
(Fscs + cgFg) ) Qr + (1)
is exposed to thermal radiation by means of a 325 ∂t V
stainless steel mesh screen (4.2 × 10-2 m large and 5.5
× 10-2 m long; Figure 1C), whose sides are wrapped on where Qr and Fc are dependent on temperature and
two steel rods. Accurate temperature measurements, chemical composition. Also, the emissivity may not be
under different heating conditions, have been made to constant, with further effects on the external heat-
define the uniform temperature zone (this corresponds transfer rate. Thus, eq 1 should be formulated and
to an extention of about 2.6 × 10-2 m, in the direction solved in conjunction with chemical species conservation
of the reactor axis, and 2 × 10-2 m, along the other). equations (Di Blasi (1996c)). In the modality A, Qe )
The sample is located at the center of the radiant σSTL4 is constant and the temperature evolution is
chamber and is radiatively heated on both the upper thus the result (eq 1) of the effects of both the external
and bottom sides, this in contact with the sample holder (constant) heating and the variations in the enthalpy
(Figure 1C). Aluminum supports directly connect the and properties caused by chemical reactions.
sample holder to a precision balance (Mettler-Toledo From the mathematical point of view, eq 1 and the
AT400) with an accuracy of order 0.1 mg and a time control equations are applied to determine how Qe
constant of 0.2-0.4 s. should be varied, in order to achieve a chosen sample
The temperature of the reacting solid is measured by temperature evolution in the modality B. According to
a thin (0.1 mm bead) chromel-alumel thermocouple in the classical theory of chemical process control (Seborg
direct physical contact with the powdered sample layer et al. (1989)), eq 1 is linearized, expressed in terms of
(Figure 1C). As pyrolysis takes place, the thermocouple deviation variables, transformed in the Laplace domain
bead moves according to shrinking rate, and, depending and coupled to a PID controller. In the experiments,
on the final solid residual yield, at the completion of the the first step deals with a trial and error procedure
process, it may touch the surface of the sample holder. applied to the empty sample holder for a first estimate
The measured temperature coincides with the sample of the PID controller parameters. Then, prior to each
temperature only if the conversion process occurs in a run, these are adjusted for the presence of the sample
thermally thin regime, that is, if a uniform profile is to be pyrolyzed, again with some trial and error tests,
established along the sample thickness. Therefore, so that the maximum heating rate can be achieved, with
conditions for conversion in a thermally thin regime no deviation from the chosen reaction temperature.
should be first determined. The procedure applied in A continuous flow of helium is applied to establish
this study is based on the well-known dependence of an inert environment and to reduce the residence time
the residual solid yield on the reaction temperature of vapors inside the reaction chamber. It is distributed
at the entrance of the quartz reactor, at a distance of
(primary char) and the intraparticle residence times of
about 6 × 10-2 m from the sample holder. This is an
primary volatile products (secondary char). Indeed, as
important point. It is generally retained that, under
the temperatures of the primary degradation are in-
conditions of radiative heating (Tabatabaie-Raissi et al.
creased (Shafizadeh et al. (1979), Bradbury et al. (1979))
(1989)), secondary reactions are promptly quenched
or the residence times of primary vapors inside the
because, as soon as volatile products are released from
reacting particle are made shorter (Antal et al. (1990)),
the hot reacting solid, they encounter a zone where the
the char yields decrease. Thus, for chosen heating
temperature is rather low (apart from a narrow gas
conditions, the sample thickness is decreased until the
layer, adjacent to the solid surface, which is heated by
solid residual yield becomes constant.
conduction). However, it is important to reduce the
The radiant heater is made to work according to two residence time of volatile pyrolysis products in the
modalities, here indicated as A and B, which correspond radiant chamber, because it is also well known (Di Blasi
to the emission of a constant flux and to the attainment et al. (1991)) that they can absorb some of the incident
of a certain temperature with an assigned rate, respec- radiation and thus attain temperatures sufficiently high
tively. The modality A, which is the easier one, also for secondary reactions to become active. The continu-
corresponds to a constant temperature of the emitters, ous flow gives rise to very low concentrations of volatiles
after short transients whose duration is successively in the reaction chamber (for the worst case, that is, the
reduced as the intensity of the radiation is increased. highest temperatures, it is estimated that the ratio
The heating modality B can be implemented to impose between volatiles and inert is about 1/1000 mol), thus
a certain time evolution of a temperature, which can keeping gas-phase absorption of radiation to a mini-
be that of the emitters or the specimen, by varying the mum. Furthermore, helium is preferred to argon, given
intensity of the radiant flux. In this study, the con- the higher diffusion coefficient (a factor of about 3) of
trolled variable is the temperature of the sample the high molecular weight volatiles (Varhegyi et al.
surface, after sample sizes for conversion in a thermally (1994)). The flow of inert gas, at ambient temperature,
thin regime are determined. The manipulated variable is also used to cool the residual char, left after complete
is the electric voltage applied to the furnace or, in other solid devolatilization.
words, the intensity of the radiative heat flux Qe. Usually, two runs are required to measure the weight
In the absence of spatial gradients along the sample loss. In the first, the weight loss curve of the degrading
layer, the dynamics of cellulose degradation, for the sample is obtained. The second run is carried out to
heating modality A, are well described by means of the record the so-called “blank” curve, which takes into
mathematical model for a thermally thin regime re- account the effects of spurious weight changes due to
ported by Di Blasi (1996c) (assumptions are listed in temperature effects in the gas phase surrounding the
the same reference). In particular, the time evolution sample while degrading (Tabatabaie-Raissi et al. (1989)).
Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., Vol. 36, No. 3, 1997 545
This curve, obtained with the sample holder left in the
position of the first test and with the final char yield, is
then used to correct the weight loss curve. These cor-
rections are, at the higher temperatures, on the order
of 50% with respect to the measured sample weight. In
order to verify the correctness of the procedure, after
each run, the final char yield is also weighed and com-
pared with that previously determined. Given the rela-
tively large sample mass (20-8 mg) and the very thin
thermocouple, the close contact of this with the sample
does not affect the mechanical inertia of the system and
simultaneous accurate measurements of temperature
and weight are obtained. An acquisition data system,
based on a PC and the software LabView (National Figure 2. Solid mass fraction as function of time (τ ) 50 µm) for
Instruments), allows for continuous monitoring (0.4-1 different system temperatures (heating modality A).
s) and storage of temperature and weight loss values.
In this study no extensive investigation on the
dependence of product yields on reaction conditions has
been carried out, as the analysis is focused mainly on
the effects of heat-transfer limitations. However, a
product collection system is being applied, consisting of
a condenser (a 10 × 10-2 m long tube filled in with glass
wool) and a plastic bag for gaseous products.
Results
Thermal degradation of thin cellulosic layers is car-
ried out according to the heating modalities A and B,
by varying the intensity of the radiative heat flux and
the final temperature of the sample, respectively. The
influence of intrabed temperature gradients on the
conversion process (apparent kinetics) is investigated,
by varying the sample thickness. Conditions leading
to a true isothermal process, controlled by (intrinsic)
chemical kinetics, are determined. In all cases, com-
mercial cellulose with lengths of the fibers in the range
20-150 µm (Sigma Aldrich), predried for about 10 h at
a temperature of 388 K, is degraded. Cellulose is chosen
as fuel, given its importance in the field of biomass
thermochemical conversion and the still uncertain
behavior under flash pyrolysis conditions. The helium
flow, at ambient temperature, is equal to 8 × 10-4 m3/
min, which, given a cross section of the quartz reactor
of 28 × 10-4 m2, gives rise to velocities of about 30 ×
10-2 m/min. No variations in the degradation process
are seen with larger mass flow rates (factors of 2-3). Figure 3. Time-temperature curves for cellulose (solid lines) and
Cellulose Degradation under Constant Radia- char (dashed lines) (A) for two different system temperatures (Tf
tive Heat Flux (Heating Modality A). Tests have ) 577 and 633 K) and τ ) 50 µm (heating modality A) and (B) for
been conducted, according to the heating modality A, two different sample half-thicknesses (τ ) 100 and 44 µm) and Tf
for about 10 mg of cellulose powder, uniformly distrib- ) 633 K (heating modality A).
uted along the uniform temperature zone of the sample
holder, to give τ ) 50 µm. As will be shown later, this Examples of the weight loss curves (the solid residual,
sample thickness corresponds, for moderate reaction W, including char and cellulose, expressed as a fraction
temperatures, to conversion in a thermally thin regime. of the initial sample mass, M0) are reported, for system
The steady temperature value, Tf, here indicated as the temperatures in the range 543-622 K, in Figure 2. As
“system temperature”, is used to characterize the dif- expected, preheating times, before significant weight
ferent tests and has been varied in the range 543-699 loss, become successively shorter and the amounts of
K, through different values of Qe. For the sample solid, left as charred residual, decrease as the intensity
thickness given above, the cellulose heating rate (re- of the radiative heat flux (or the system temperature)
ferred to the sample surface and before significant is increased.
weight loss) varies from about 12 to 54 K/s as the system Associated with weight loss curves, the temperature
temperature is varied. As will appear from the experi- of cellulose (recorded in the course of degradation) and
ments, external heat-transfer limitations can hardly be char mass fraction (recorded together with the blank
avoided with this heating modality, so that it is not curve) are available. These can be used to get informa-
applicable to study the intrinsic kinetics of degradation. tion on the thermal history of the sample. Examples of
However, some results have been obtained which can the (char and cellulose) temperature curves are plotted
be of interest from the practical point of view, that is, in Figure 3A,B, for two different system temperatures
in relation to pyrolysis units, where biomass particles (Tf ) 577 and 633 K) and τ ) 50 µm (A) and for two
are exposed to a certain reactor temperature. Also, different sample sizes (τ ) 100 and 40 µm) and Tf )
comparison with previous analyses can be carried out. 633 K (B). In all cases, a region exists where the sample
546 Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., Vol. 36, No. 3, 1997
Figure 5. Solid mass fraction for solid residence times, ts, equal Figure 6. Temperature-time curves of the cellulose sample
to 300 s (Tr ) 573 K) and 10 s (Tr ) 623 K) as a function of the during the initial stage of the process for the heating modality B
sample half-thickness (heating modality B). (τ ) 50 µm).
pears to cause a reduction in the heat-transfer limita- Indeed, the char yield does not depend on the sample
tions, but this approach is again effective only for thickness only when solid degradation occurs at the
relatively slow heating rates. same temperature, independently of the spatial position,
Cellulose Degradation under Controlled Sample that is, no spatial temperature gradients exist. More-
Temperature (Heating Modality B). The analysis over, these conditions also indicate that intrabed sec-
of the thermal degradation data, obtained through ondary charring reactions do not occur to a significant
modality A, has shown that it is possible to avoid heat- extent. For cellulose and for the chosen heating condi-
transfer limitations only for very thin samples and slow tions, the transition from a thermally thick to a ther-
heating rates (low system temperatures). In the heating mally thin regime occurs for sample half-thicknesses
modality B the temperature of the sample is the result slightly increasing with the temperature, that is, τ )
of a control process. If the proper size of the sample is 70 µm (Tr ) 573 K) and τ ) 60 µm (Tr ) 623 K),
chosen to avoid intrabed gradients, a proper selection respectively. Therefore, conversion of samples with
of control parameters allows degradation to be carried half-thicknesses below 60 µm and reaction temperatures
out under exactly known temperature conditions. There- below 623 K can be assumed to occur in a thermally
fore, some preliminary tests have been conducted to thin regime.
determine the conditions giving rise to a conversion in Examples of the time history of the cellulose temper-
a thermally thin regime for modality B. It should be ature, for the initial stage of the process, are shown in
pointed out that, in relation to intrabed heat- and mass- Figure 6. These have been obtained for different set
transfer limitations, the sample thickness, not the points (reaction temperatures) and τ ) 50 µm (about
sample mass, is the key parameter. Consequently, an 10 mg of cellulose powder). After the first stage of linear
important point is to determine, before all, the size of increase (heating rates from 40 to 78 K/s for the
the sample thickness which does not give rise to temperature range considered), a constant (reaction)
significant spatial gradients of temperature (primary temperature, Tr, is more slowly attained (the time
degradation at different temperatures) and volatile needed to attain this value is indicated as heating time,
residence times (activity of secondary reactions). As th) and maintained for the whole duration of the process,
previously illustrated, the char yields are taken as a with no overshoot in practice. The global heating rates,
measure of the importance of these processes. In for the attainment of the reaction temperature, vary
particular, conditions of char yields not dependent on from about 19 to 56 K/s. For the whole range of reaction
the sample thickness correspond to negligible effects on temperatures tested, the endothermicity of degradation
primary degradation of intrabed transport phenomena reactions is well compensated by increased external heat
and secondary reactions. Given that intrabed space supply. Consequently, no plateau is seen in the time-
gradients and secondary reaction rates are expected to temperature curve, even when fast degradation rates
increase as heating conditions are made more severe, are achieved. Therefore, compared to the curves of
two reaction temperatures have been considered, 573 Figure 3, weight loss curves obtained with the heating
and 623 K. modality B show shorter degradation times (Figure 7)
Tests have been conducted, according to the heating for comparable values of Tf (system temperature of the
modality B (examples of the heating curves will be given modality A) and Tr (the reaction temperature of modal-
in the following), by decreasing the thickness of the ity B).
cellulose layer from about 200 µm. The solid residence The weight loss curves of Figure 7 are obtained under
times are 300 (low temperature) and 10 s (high tem- isothermal sample conditions, apart from the very
perature). After this time, the power is turned off, and beginning of the process. Figure 8 reports the ratio
the sample is promptly moved into a cold zone under a between the conversion time, tc, and the heating time,
continuous helium flow. The solid residual, expressed th, and the solid mass fraction at t ) th as functions of
as a fraction of the initial sample mass, is reported as the reaction temperature. For Tr e 607 K, the conver-
a function of the sample half-thickness in Figure 5. As sion time is significantly longer than the sample heating
expected, it initially decreases with the sample size, time (factors in the range 1000-16), and the conversion
because of the increase in the average reaction temper- level achieved in relation to the heating period is also
ature and the decrease in the volatile residence times, small (0.001-22%) (the factors become 5 and 40%,
and then tends to a constant value. respectively, for Tr ) 623 K).
The attainment of a constant value of the char yield Effects of Intrabed Resistances. In order to
corresponds to conversion in a thermally thin regime. understand the influence of intrabed heat- and mass-
548 Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., Vol. 36, No. 3, 1997
( )
proposed. Of course, this theory is not applicable for K1νC -Kt
the heating modality A. The kinetics of primary cel- W ) W∞ + M0 1 - e (12)
lulose degradation are described through a semiglobal K
mechanism:
where W∞ is the final solid residual and can be obtained
K1 νCCHAR + νGGAS
from eq 10 written for t ) 0:
Figure 10. Plots of ln(P) versus time (reduction in the scale as Figure 12. Experimental (symbols) and simulated (dashed lines,
in Figure 7) for several reaction temperatures (τ ) 50 µm, heating one set of kinetic data) solid mass fraction versus time for τ ) 50
modality B). µm (heating modality B).
Lipska, A. E.; Parker, W. J. Kinetics of the pyrolysis of cellulose Shafizadeh, F.; Furneaux, R. H.; Cochran, T. G.; Scholl, J. P.;
in the temperature range 250-300 °C. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. Sakai, Y. Production of Levoglucosan and Glucose from Pyroly-
1966, 10, 1439. sis of Cellulosic Materials. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 1979, 23, 3525.
Madorsky, S. L.; Hart, V. E.; Straus, S. Pyrolysis of cellulose in a Tabatabaie-Raissi, A.; Mok, W. S. L.; Antal, M. J. Cellulose
vacuum. J. Res. Natl. Bur. Stand. 1956, 56, 343. pyrolysis kinetics in a simulated solar environment. Ind. Eng.
Milosavljevic, I.; Suuberg, E. M. Cellulose thermal decomposition Chem. Res. 1989, 28, 856.
kinetics: global mass loss kinetics. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1995, Thurner, F.; Mann, U. Kinetic investigation of wood pyrolysis. Ind.
34, 1081. Eng. Chem. Process Des. Dev. 1981, 20, 482.
Narayan, R.; Antal, M. J. Thermal lag, fusion, and the compensa- Varhegyi, G.; Jakab, E.; Antal, M. J. Is the Broido-Shafizadeh
tion effect during biomass pyrolysis. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1996, model for cellulose true? Energy Fuels 1994, 8, 1345.
35, 1711. Wanzl, W. Techniques for studying and modeling coal pyrolysis
Ozturk, Z.; Merklin, J. Rapid pyrolysis of cellulose with reac- and their relevance to biomass and wastes. Biomass Bioenergy
tive hydrogen gas in a single-pulse shock tube. Fuel 1995, 74, 1994, 7, 131.
1658. Received for review September 9, 1996
Ramiah, M. V. Thermogravimetric and differential thermal analy- Revised manuscript received November 19, 1996
sis of cellulose, hemicellulose, and lignin. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. Accepted November 20, 1996X
1970, 14, 1323.
Scott, D. S.; Piskorz, J.; Bergougnou, M. A.; Graham, R.; Overend, IE960551R
R. P. The role of temperature in the fast pyrolysis of cellulose
and wood. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1988, 27, 8.
Seborg, D. E.; Edgar, T. F.; Millichamp, D. A. Process Dynamics X
Abstract published in Advance ACS Abstracts, January 15,
and Control. Wiley Ser. Chem. Eng. 1989. 1997.