Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
are, as a species, addicted to story” (xiv). Recog- stroy precariously built structures populated by
nizing this helps explain why narrative takes such green pigs, rests on the central narrative conflict
a prominent role in English classrooms, even as that these pigs have stolen the birds’ eggs. In a
informational and nonfiction texts increase their similar vein, the string of games in the Mario fran-
presence. English teachers seek to help students, chise from Nintendo demonstrates a narrative arc
through a formal study of narrative, learn to in- propelled by Mario’s conflicts with various villains
terpret and extract meaning from the stories they (Bowser, Donkey Kong, and an alternative self
encounter—meanings that shed light on what named Wario) as they seek to kidnap his love in-
it means to be human, what it means to care for terest, Princess Peach, or wreak other havoc in the
another person, what it means to wrestle with Mushroom Kingdom where these characters dwell.
human emotions, what it means to triumph in the These are superficial stories at best, however,
face of adversity. and in games like these the narrative usually serves
Despite the dominant position the traditional as minimal dressing to the reflex challenges or ex-
written narrative has assumed in the modern English ploration tasks at the heart of the game. In other
classroom, we must acknowledge that this is not the types of video games, the narrative arc plays a
only (or even, always, the best) much more integral role, as in the genre of role-
Despite the dominant
medium for telling stories. En playing games. These games, inspired by paper-
position the traditional glish teachers have recognized and-pencil games such as Dungeons & Dragons, cast
written narrative has the value of diverse media and the player in the role of hero and unfold an often-
assumed in the modern content in our English class- complex story in which the hero must accomplish
English classroom, we room, from advertisements tasks (“quests”) to advance the story and resolve the
must acknowledge that (Hobbs) to film (Golden; Tea- central conflict. Many of these games (such as the
sley and Wilder) to pop culture Baldur’s Gate, Elder Scrolls, Fallout, and Mass Effect
this is not the only
(Smith, Smith, and Bobbitt). series) feature extensive dialogue that has players
(or even, always, As new forms of media have reading as much as engaging in virtual combat.
the best) medium for come onto the scene, it’s a tes- While a central focus of these games is character
telling stories. tament to the deep-seated role development—gaining skills and abilities as quests
that story plays in our lives are successfully completed—the entire rationale for
that each new medium—radio, still images, film, playing is provided by the narrative and the prob-
television, and now the Internet and computers— in lems posed within the storyline.
turn has been used to convey narratives. A final genre of video games that relies heav-
ily on narrative elements is the adventure game,
one of the oldest video game genres. Rather than
Video Games as a Narrative Medium
relying on reflexes or developing a virtual char-
To consider the narrative potential of video games, acter’s skills, these games ask the player to solve
we can begin by asking ourselves what we mean by puzzles through in-game research and trial and
the words story and narrative, an exercise I’ve often error, but they rely heavily on story elements to
asked my students to engage in. They reply with provide a context for these challenges. The earli-
answers such as, “It’s got a beginning, middle, and est examples of these games include “interactive
an end” (suggesting that plot matters) or “It’s got a fiction” games that feature no graphics but rather
problem in it” (a nod to conflict) or with comments copious amounts of descriptive text; players inter-
about morals or messages (a reference to theme). act with the game world through simple, typed
This emphasis on literary elements suggests that commands (“go north” or “examine the egg” or
story is a creative work that embodies these ele- “enter the forest”) and often must read the game’s
ments and uses them in a recognizable way. text carefully to pick up on subtle clues to the
With such a definition, we can make an ar- challenges posed within the game. These games
gument that even the simplest video games could (since updated with complex graphics and mouse-
be considered narratives. The popular game Angry driven interfaces) have often featured the most
Birds, focused on launching virtual birds to de- complex storytelling, which is why I focused on
72 July 2013
them as I explored video games and narratives with (free versions of many of these games can be played
my students. online or on mobile devices). Before letting stu-
dents play some of these games in the computer lab,
Studying Video Games in the Classroom I oriented them with a brief tutorial. I have since
found a wonderful resource from Andrew Plotkin,
My efforts to bring video games into the high an accomplished interactive fiction author, that I
school classroom were part of a larger unit on the now use with my university students when we un-
power of storytelling. In this unit, we began by dertake a similar exploration. (See http://pr-if.org/
looking at ancient Greco-Roman and Norse myths doc/play-if-card/ to download a PDF copy.)
and discussing the purposes for these stories and I modeled the first steps of playing this game
the influence they have had on Western culture. We by launching one on my computer while students
explored the archetypal hero journey as described observed. I started with Zork, a fantasy-themed
by Joseph Campbell and looked at examples from game that is one of the most popular games of this
these ancient myths as well as modern examples in type (playable online at http://thcnet.net/zork/
such characters as Frodo Baggins, Luke Skywalker, index.php), and I demonstrated how simple com-
and Harry Potter. This exploration of archetypes mands such as “take sack” or “go north” or “read
provided a segue into a unit on film in which we leaflet” allowed us to control the virtual protago-
explored cinematic techniques as we analyzed nar- nist and manipulate the game world. We read to-
rative and dramatic aspects of film, as described gether the descriptions of locations in the game
by Alan B. Teasley and Ann Wilder. Our studies and made choices about where to go, what to pick
of film provided an opportunity to reacquaint my up, and how to get into the strange white house
students with the elements of fiction, and I pushed that features in the beginning of the game. When
students to consider the unique way these elements we tried to enter the dark upstairs of the house, we
were presented in film. were warned about being eaten by a “grue,” and my
The final section of our unit was dedicated to a students then suggested we look for a flashlight or
study of video games as narrative. I began our study perhaps something to defend ourselves with, thus
by asking students to again consider the question demonstrating that the game was already encour-
of how we define story—a question they had richer aging them to make the kinds of inferences we
responses to given our exploration of myths and ar- make when we read conventional stories. I encour-
chetypes and film narratives. Then I brought the aged students to pay close attention to details in
discussion to video games by asking students who the game’s text as those details often came in handy
played them and to name some of the games they when trying to make progress in the game, such as
played, a move that caused some students to perk when we examined the carpet and were told of an
up and sit up straighter in their seats. As we shared “irregularity” beneath it—leading us to a trap door
some titles and experiences with video games, I that starts us on the real adventure.
brought out the central question of this explora- Once students had the hang of the simple
tion: Can video games tell a story, and, if so, how? parsers used in these games and how to interact
While most students reported playing video with the game world, I had them explore this genre
games, not all of them had experience with games on their own; they could either continue with Zork
that go beyond tests of coordination and reflexes. If or choose from a half-dozen other games ported
we were truly to explore the potential storytelling to the Web (available at http://pot.home.xs4all.nl/
power of this new medium, I needed to help my infocom/). My students dove in eagerly, and I en-
students develop a broader sense of the video games joyed watching them become as engaged in the
out there. worlds of these games as they would in books or
films. I was pleased to see some students start
A Historical Beginning sketching maps of the game world on scratch paper
We started with interactive fiction (IF), one of the and others asking me about indirect objects (a re-
earliest forms of storytelling games. This genre has sponse generated sometimes by the game’s parser
the advantage of being low-cost and easy to access when players don’t give enough information in
English Journal 73
74 July 2013
Opening text from a playthrough of the game Dear Esther (published 2012 by thechineseroom).
English Journal 75
compelling teaching activities that could extend wanted students to dig deeper, to start to recognize
students’ critical exploration of consumerism.) the ways that video games can be an expressive me-
A final game I’ve used more recently is Dear dium, one with unique capacities to tell stories in
Esther, a game that eschews some of the traditional ways that other media cannot (Murray).
gaming elements (solving puzzles or completing It’s in pushing students to think in terms of
tasks) and focuses almost ex- the nature of the video game medium that we reach
Once the students
clusively on the exploration of a our most meaningful conclusions (and ask some
begin to see the unique deserted island and the uncov- important questions) about games and their story
affordances of video ering of a rather complex back- telling potential. Once the students begin to see
games, they are on the story. This game emphasizes the unique affordances of video games, they are on
path to becoming more narration and exploration, with the path to becoming more critical about the ways
critical about the ways some beautiful atmospherics media work in their lives—understandings that
and a haunting narrator. Two I hope will bleed over into other media that sur-
media work in their
things about this game appeal round them. Getting to that point isn’t always easy,
lives—understandings to me in terms of classroom though; I summarize here some of the conclusions
that I hope will bleed study: the game is randomized we reached as a result of our exploration, some of
over into other media that so that each “read-through” is which came spontaneously and some of which my
surround them. different, and the lack of some students needed gentle prodding from me to realize.
of the gameplay elements al-
lows us to explore interesting contrasts with the other Participation, Control, and Investment
games we’ve looked at. This game, I think, can do The first comment students make about the unique-
more to help students see the future potential of video ness of the video game medium is that this form of
games as a storytelling medium. storytelling is participatory. They acknowledge that
the main draw of these kinds of games is that you
Reflections and Revelations are the hero, you are the one who makes many of the
Frequently as we explored these games, I paused choices and who drives the plot. I helped students
and discussed with students the narrative nature of connect this to the idea of point of view as we often
the games, asking questions such as: discussed it with traditional written narratives.
Many students could recognize first-person and
• Does this game have a setting? What is it? third-person points of view, but few had been ex-
• Who are the characters in this game (includ- posed to a story told in second person. The writing
ing you, the player)? What do we know of the IF games they played allowed them to experi-
about them? ence a story from this perspective, and they com-
• Is there conflict in the game? Describe the mented that this made them more engaged since the
conflict. words were directed at them and their choices made
• Is there a plot in this game? How is it con- an impact on the direction the plot would take.
structed? Will the plot of this story be the The participatory nature of such texts as video
same for every reader-player? games has been explored in literary criticism, most
• How is this story similar to other stories that notably for this context by Espen Aarseth, who ar-
you’ve read/seen? What devices did the game gues that digital texts (or “ergodic texts,” as he la-
authors borrow from these other stories? bels them) such as the video games described here
• How is the story told here different from are unique from other literary texts. While a reader
what we’d normally encounter in a book or of a typical text can become lost in the world of
short story? How about in a movie/film? the book, he or she is ultimately powerless to con-
trol the narrative and can only be a spectator. In
These questions were designed to help students video game narratives, however, effort is required
think more deeply about the experience of playing of the reader—the choices a reader-player makes in
certain kinds of video games and to connect that a video game directly impact the outcomes of the
experience to traditional storytelling. But I also narrative (Aarseth 1–4).
76 July 2013
When I asked students what this participation secting stories of the actual world” (38). My stu-
meant to the nature of the story being told, at first dents saw these multiform stories as entertaining
they focused their comments on the fact that it makes and appreciated the possibilities for replay and ex-
the games more enjoyable than reading from books. ploration provided by them, but they may also have
But with some prodding, they began to suggest that been sensing something meaningful from the world
this participation increased the meaning of certain around them reflected in these virtual worlds.
choices they made. In a story from a book, they sug-
gested, you might become invested in a character Evolving Characters
and his or her choices, but not to the same degree if When we discussed characters as portrayed in video
you are the character making the choices and dealing games, students pointed out that they were often flat
with the outcomes (even if those consequences are or even stereotypes. Villains were often portrayed as
virtual). Such a distinction seemed to give a unique through-and-through bad guys while the player’s
power to video game narratives for my students. character was often heroic or special in some way and
expected to make virtuous and noble choices. Some
Branching Plots girls in my class who played games complained of
More sophisticated observations about this medium sexist depictions of females in some games. The
surfaced after further discussion about the partici- ensuing debate opened up an important discussion
patory nature of games, and one of these centered that helped students think more critically about the
around the branching nature of the plots in this way characters are portrayed in video games and the
game. Many games that students were familiar broader implications of those portrayals.
with (often falling into the first-person shooter cat- Students noted a shift in this, however, as
egory) were examples of games “on rails”—games more recent games allow for more ambiguity in the
that proceed fairly linearly, regardless of a player’s player’s character, and the game’s antagonists are not
actions. Students compared games like this to most always portrayed in such black-and-white terms (as
books they’d read and noted that these games’ at- in the Bioshock games, where the player is allowed
traction rested mostly on being able to solve puzzles to pursue less savory means for moving through
requiring good timing or hand-eye coordination. the game and the villain is not wholly evil). These
The games we explored in class featured more com- shifts—more agency for players and more complex
plex plots in that our actions could directly affect representations of good and evil—show a maturing
certain outcomes in the game. Forgetting to take of the video game genre as it comes to more authen-
the lantern in the early stages of Zork, for example, tically represent the world around us.
would cause difficulties later on when we encoun- Curious about these points, I pushed students
tered dark areas of the game world. to talk about characters in video games and whether
We talked about how each reader-player’s they were more or less “real” to them compared
experience with a game could be conceivably dif- to characters encountered in books. My students
ferent, and then I asked students to consider what struggled with this idea a bit and at first suggested
that meant in terms of the narrative power of these that because our exposure to these characters is so
games. We noted that these possibilities allowed brief in video games (as opposed to the pages and
players to explore alternative choices, to make moral pages a book author gets), we can’t really connect
choices that may not always be easy, and to see the with them in the same sense. I reminded them,
results of those choices. These stories took on a though, that we might feel sympathies toward film
greater power in terms of vicarious experiences than characters and we aren’t exposed to as much about
books ever could—within one “text” we could ex- them as we might be in a book. To help resolve
plore multiple lines of possibility whereas in a single this conundrum, I shared with my students Ken
book there was only likely to be one line. Janet Mur- Perlin’s ideas about how the fact that we give up
ray calls these “multiform” stories (30) and suggests our agency when we enter the narrative stream of a
that they are more compelling for us today given book actually allows us to explore a character more
how aware we are of “alternative possible selves, of fully because “the narrative and point of view lead
alternate possible worlds, and of the limitless inter- us forcefully into [the character’s] vulnerable inner
English Journal 77
landscape” (12). With this idea, we could explore Davenport, Misha. “BioShock.” The Chicago Sun-Times. 24
elements of storytelling that are lost (or perhaps ex- Aug. 2007. Web. 10 Oct. 2012.
Desilets, Brendan J. “Reading, Thinking, and Interactive
perienced differently) when we gain the agency and Fiction.” English Journal 78.3 (1989): 75–77. Print.
control offered by video games. “Essential Facts about the Computer and Video Game
Industry.” Entertainment Software Association. Web.
10 Oct. 2012. <http://www.theesa.com/facts/pdfs/
Awakening Students’ Critical Awareness ESA_EF_2012.pdf>.
Golden, John. Reading in the Dark: Using Film as a Tool in the
I didn’t set out to study video games as a way of English Classroom. Urbana: NCTE, 2001. Print.
motivating reluctant learners or bringing more of Gottschall, Jonathan. The Storytelling Animal: How Stories
Make Us Human. New York: Houghton, 2012. Print.
the students’ culture into the classroom (although Hobbs, Renee. Reading the Media: Media Literacy in High
both things happened, happily, as a result of our School English. New York: Teachers College Press,
exploration). I wanted to help them explore in more 2007. Print.
Jolley, Kristie. “Video Games to Reading: Reaching Out to
critical ways the power and potential of storytelling Reluctant Readers.” English Journal 97.4 (2008):
by looking at a medium that is still growing and 81–86. Print.
evolving. The few days we spent playing together Lenhart, Amanda, Joseph Kane, Ellen Middaugh, Alexan-
facilitated deep and engaging discussions about dra Rankin Mcgill, Chris Evans, and Jessica Vitak.
“Teens, Video Games, and Civics.” Pew Internet &
the power of the video game, its unique strengths American Life Project. 2008. Web. 10 Oct. 2012.
and weaknesses as a storytelling medium, and the <http://www.pewinternet.org/Reports/2008/Teens-
potential future of the genre. While we live and Video-Games-and-Civics.aspx>.
Murray, Janet. Hamlet on the Holodeck: The Future of Narrative
breathe story in the typical En glish classroom, in Cyberspace. Cambridge: MIT Press, 2000. Print.
we don’t often push its boundaries and explore Perlin, Ken. “Can There Be a Form between a Game and a
its frontiers. I have found that doing so, even for Story?” First Person: New Media as Story, Performance,
and Game. Ed. Noah Wardrip-Friun and Pat Harri-
just a short time, awakens a critical awareness for gan. Cambridge: MIT Press, 2004. 12–33. Print.
students of the power and influence of narrative in Sardone, Nancy B., and Roberta Devlin-Scherer. “Keeping
their lives. It Current: Using Technology to Teach about Social
Issues.” English Journal 99.4 (2010): 61–64. Print.
Schiesel, Seth. “Genetics Gone Haywire and Predatory
Works Cited Children in an Undersea Metropolis.” New York
Aarseth, Espen. Cybertext: Perspectives on Ergodic Literature. Times. 8 Sept. 2007. Web. 10 Oct. 2012. <http://
Baltimore: Johns Hopkins UP, 1997. Print. www.nytimes.com/2007/09/08/arts/television/08
Adams, Megan Glover. “Engaging 21st-Century Adoles- shoc.html?_r=0>.
cents: Video Games in the Reading Classroom.” Smith, Allison D., Trixie G. Smith, and Rebecca Bobbitt,
English Journal 98.6 (2009): 56–59. Print. eds. Teaching in the Pop Culture Zone: Using Popular
Bray, Hiawatha. “BioShock Lets Users Take on Fanaticism Culture in the Composition Classroom. Boston: Wads
through Fantasy.” Boston Globe. 27 Aug. 2007. Web. worth, 2009. Print.
10 Oct. 2012. <http://www.boston.com/ae/games/ Teasley, Alan B., and Ann Wilder. Reel Conversations: Read-
articles/2007/08/27/bioshock_lets_users_take_on_ ing Films with Young Adults. Portsmouth: Heine-
fanaticism_through_fantasy/>. mann, 1997. Print.
Jonathan Ostenson taught junior high and high school English for more than ten years and currently teaches in the English
education program at Brigham Young University. He is interested in exploring the intersection of traditional literacy and new
media. Email him at jon_ostenson@byu.edu.
78 July 2013