Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Jafar Morvarid
In this paper, I first mention a statistical survey runs with the Korean TV
series’ audience in Tehran. After that, I study the concepts of “tradition”,
“moderation”, and “justice”, as the main themes of Korean TV series,
from the Islamic and Quranic point of view. I finally make some practical
proposals as to how to model Korean cinema.
Introduction
Moderation is the fruit of such genuine and undying traditions. Such traditions
exhibit a moderate harmony between material, spiritual, and aesthetical aspects of
1
life. Commitment to such tradition brings about inner peace, material happiness
and welfare, and moderation and justice.
Thus, tradition, moderation, and justice constitute the three main themes and
messages of Korean series. Korean series are well received among Iranians for
these themes. These three are Iranians’ ideals. This is why Iranians feel affinity
toward Korean culture through their series.
Moderation and justice are Iranians’ ideals, and it is through tradition and religion
that they can attain this ideal.
The popularity of Korean serials among Iranian people stems from the roots of in
their culture. Iranian culture, like that of Korean, is influenced by an ancient and
deep tradition, and so I will first discuss the analysis and definition of tradition and
traditionalism.
Moderation and justice are two ideals that Iranian culture has from a long time ago
pursued. The religion of Islam and the noble Quran have always enjoined, and,
invited to them, too. Islam and Quran have also bolstered and extended Iranians’
view of these two ideals. Hence, I will analyze the Islamic concepts of moderation
and justice. I will especially discuss about one important constituent of these
concepts, namely rationality. In so doing, I will define reasoning and rationality,
study the application of reasoning in ethics and sociology, and point to the Islamic
idea that there is a close interrelatedness between theory (or theoretical
intellect/reasoning) and practice (or practical intellect/reasoning). This idea
contrasts modern philosophers’ idea to the effect that there is a sharp distinction
between theory and practice.
2
After the conceptual study, I will come back to our first topic and taking the
statistical results, mentioned at the first part of the article, into consideration, I will
make some practical suggestions as to how to promote the Iranian cinema by
modeling the Korean series.
In this study, according to the nature of the case, research objectives, questions and
the extent of its operating, has been used descriptive and survey methods. The
statistical population of the present study includes the 15 to 19 year youth that
living in district 4 of Tehran municipality, which is prepared by social-cultural
assistant of municipality of district 4, based on statistic of year 2009 (1388). This
statistic includes 275465 persons. In this study has been used multistage cluster
sampling method and random sampling. Thus, in population of the present study
includes the 15 to 19 year youth, that living in district 4 of Tehran municipality,
which is prepared by social-cultural assistant of municipality of district the first
stage randomly 4 areas were sampled among the 9 areas of district 4of Tehran
municipality. (Majidi Ghahrevardi, Nasim and Hoshmand, Zohre, 2010)
And in the second stage 2 neighborhoods of each area were chosen randomly.
Then the questionaries were distributed among the 15 to 19 year youths randomly.
The sex ratio of respondents is equal; 50 percent are males and 50 percent are
females.
Research findings
The number of studied sample was 384 persons; 192 persons were male and 192
female. So, 50 percent is male and 50 percent female. From age distribution aspect,
the largest number of studied sample belongs to 15 to 18 years age group which
3
appropriate 27/1 percent of sample. In contrast with, 13 percent of them belong to
27 to 30 year age group. And also, in terms of marital status, 69/3 percent of
studied sample was single and 30/7 percent married. In terms of education, 30/5
percent of respondents had bachelor’s degree, which includes the majority of the
respondents. And 25/8 percent had diploma degree, 20/8 percent pre-diploma and
14/3 percent associate of art, and just 8/4 percent had Master of Science and
doctorate degree. Finally, about the distribution of sample population would say,
25/8 percent was employed, 21/9 percent was the students of primary and high
school, 19/5 percent was unemployed, 17/7 percent was students of university and
15/1 percent was housekeeper.
First hypothesis: it seems that, there is a significant relationship between sex and
the rate of Korean series addressee. For examining this hypothesis, drawing two-
dimensional table for checking the relationship among variables, chi-square non-
parametric tests have been used as well. Frequency distribution of two-dimensional
variables of above hypothesis and the results of chi-square test have shown in the
below table:
The table above shows that the females have watched Korean series more than
males, so that, 44/8 percent of females have watched much the Korean series, in
contract to just 29/7 percent of male have watched them much.
4
test Value Degree of Level of Cramer’s
freedom significance correlation
coefficient
Chi-square 12,456 3 0,006 180,0
The chi-square statistic rate is equal to 12,456, the degree of freedom is equal to 3,
and level of significance is equal to 0,006. Because the level of significance rate is
less than 0,01, therefore the first hypothesis is confirmed by 99 percent confidence
and 1 percent error. So there is a significant relationship between the sex and the
rate of people who watching Korean series.
And also the rate of Cramer’s correlation coefficient of these two variables is equal
to 0.180. This rate of correlation coefficient shows the weak relationship between
two variable of sex and rate of people who watching the Korean series. According
to the above table, females have watched the Korean series more than males.
For examining this hypothesis, drawing two-dimensional table for checking the
relationship among variables, chi-square non-parametric tests have been used as
well. Frequency distribution of two-dimensional variables of above hypothesis and
the results of chi-square test are shown in the below table:
Above table indicates that lower educated persons have watched the Korean series
more that the higher educated persons. So that, 27/5 percent of pre-diploma
persons have watched Korean series “very much”. In contrast to, 9/4 percent of
bachelor’s degree persons have watched the Korean series “much”.
6
in the Korean series stories
expressing the moral message in themes 0/363 0/000
of Korean series stories
presenting the stories with exciting events 0/456 0/000
in Korean series
Well ending in Korean series 0/449 0/000
According to the above two-dimensional table the lower educated people have
watched the Korean series more. Considering to table 5, the rate of significance
level is less than 0/01 in all cases. And correlation relationship between the
dependent variables and independent variables are on average. So the cultural
similarities between Iran and Korea have effect in watching Korean series much
more by Iranian audiences. The others effective factors that could attract the
attention of Iranian audience are hero raising, using clothes with joyful and various
colors, suspension, doubt and hope that occurred in the story, expressing the moral
message in themes, presenting the stories with exciting events and well ending in
the Korean series.
The separation of using of the media and its specific content based on the sex, has
an ancient history. And also in this study the sex variable have been touché upon in
the rate of people who watching the Korean series. The researches that have done
before in genre of radio and television family dramas in America show that women
are the addressee of such series contents more than men. And, this special
attractiveness is not just because of broadcasting in proper time, but due to their
contents that are combination of advice, morality, imagination and symbolic
supporting of the role of women in the house. The results of the present study with
confirmation the previous study, indicate that there is a significant relationship
between sex and the rate of people who watching and watching the Korean series,
and women have watched Korean series more than men. And also, there is a
significant relationship between education and the rate of people who watching and
watching the Korean series. Researches show that lower educated persons have
watched Korean series more than others.
7
Cultural congruity between text and its audience culture is very important. The
audience will leave the series because the series is not understandable for him or
her when the story and narrative is far from him or her culture. This is important
for this factor (this make sense), when a film or series have been made in a country
and broadcasting in another country. So the connection between these two
countries due to cultural and lingual dependent will be very effective. When there
is no cultural coordination between two countries, the audience will not accepted
the imported products and make effective connection with them. This phenomenon
called by Hiskin and Mirus (1988) as “cultural discount”. It means that, whatever
the media products have had a large cultural distance between their audiences, the
demand for those products will be little. So, cultural similarities between Iran and
Korea are another variable that has been studied. Based on researches, cultural
similarities between Iran and Korea have been effective in having Korean series
large audiences.
According to the achieved results, another effective factor that could attracted the
attention of Iranian audience is hero raising, using clothes with joyful and various
colors, suspension, doubt and hope that occurred in the story, expressing the moral
message in themes, presenting the stories with exciting events and well ending in
the Korean series. When we pay attention to east series, we notice that, they are not
so complicated structurally. And the subject of these works is very general and
stereotyped. But this factor is attractiveness, newness and believable for audience.
And also, audiences pay attention to actions, make-up and the high coloring
clothes of such series. The popularity of a series is dependent on different factors
such as: addressing to characters, accepting the facts or not, and the overall
atmosphere of the series that includes the designing the clothes, make-up and
scene.
It is obvious that, the Korean screenwriter could addressing to and training more
than one hundred character, so that each of these character are involved in flow
cases. In these series, has been addressed to the main character of the story that
usually has a heroic features such as grandee, idealism and financial independence.
And this process has been effective in story attractiveness, and the audiences watch
them.
8
The other reason we could mention that people welcoming the Korean series is the
rhythms and process of the story, the unpredictable events, and because viewer
could not predict what will be happened in the continuation. Sometimes the viewer
enjoys for predicting the next sections and its events, and likes to see his or her
correct predictions. Sometimes his or her prediction is not correct, and this
surprising is attractive for him or her.
Another reason that Korean series have large audiences is confliction between
good and evil. In Legend Jumong, as an example, Jumong is a very gentle with
spiritual traits, and he is the agent of the good and Tzu in the other side is the agent
of the evil. Jumong always remain loyal to his soldiers and he has sense of
patriotism. Generally, this issues have used in religious war and this is attractive
for Iranian audience.
Putting much emphasis on respecting parents and elders and expressing moral
messages is the other reason for these series attractiveness. Denis McQuail in his
book “Audience analysis” says “audiences expect media to conform to certain
norms of good taste and morality, and sometimes also to other values, such as
those of the local community, patriotism and democracy” (Denis McQuai, 1997
(1385): 156). It is obvious that, respect has a special place from Iranian point of
view, and this issue caused the attention of Iranian audiences.
One of the other factors that caused the attention of Iranian audiences to Korean
series is the clothes and colors designing. Despite the traditional form of clothes,
they are very beautiful with various colors. And this is very appropriate for
audience relaxation. The clothes designer would have known the color effect in
making connection within series and viewer, especially in historical works. Using
of blue, green and pink colors in women clothes, and red and white in men shows
the strong feeling of these series, conveniently.
Beside the mentioned cases, bringing up the issues such as kindness, love, anger,
power, fighting and martial arts have a significant effect on inspiriting the interests
sense, attractiveness and watching the series. And also we should mention about
good and accurate dubbed that present for audiences and this factor has effect on
these Korean series attractiveness among the Iranian audiences.
9
Now, I start to study the concepts of “tradition”, “moderation”, and “justice”, as
the main themes of Korean TV series, from the Islamic and Quranic point of view.
To answer these questions, a definition for tradition must be provided and the
history of its development must be taken into consideration. Traditionalism
appeared as a result of the works of such people as Guénon, Coomaraswamy,
Schuon, Lings Burckhardt, and Seyyed Hossein Nasr. This intellectual movement
was developed in the 1910s and 1920s through such traditionalists’ efforts and now
includes about 50 traditionalists of different levels. Seyyed Hssein Nasr is among
those who enthusiastically try to propagate and defend the traditionalist worldview.
10
In his view, tradition is a divine gift. In Nasr’s project, tradition is perennial,
permanent, and conscious, and it is in continuity with God’s tradition which is
referred in Quran as “sunnat al-awalin (tradition of the old), the tradition “which
hath taken course aforetime. Thou wilt not find for the law of Allah aught of power
to change.” (Surah Al-fath, verse 23) It is the very tradition which no alteration
could be made into it, and its arena never ends, and it is live and present in all ages.
Tradition has a divine origin and was revealed to human kind through figures
known as messengers, prophets, Logos, or other transmitter agents. (Nasr, 155-5)
Tradition is at the same time both truth and presence. Nasr holds that tradition is a
science that is too real. (Nasr, 156) Traditionalism is an ideal different from living
a traditional life. Traditionalism has social functions and forms people’s collective
behavior.
To elucidate the concept of tradition, Nasr examines its relation to religion. In his
view, the concept of tradition includes religion as one of its constituents. Any
religion has two dimensions: apparent dimension (Shari’ah) and esoterical
dimension (mysticism). Whereas the apparent dimension of different religions
varies across times and locations, the voice of God can be heard from inside all
religions. (Surah Fatir: 24; Surah Yunus: 47)
Another concept which Nasr tries to elucidate is that of the Sacred. In his view, the
Sacred is the starting point of tradition, and what is traditional is insuperable from
the Sacred. Whoever has no idea of the Sacred cannot comprehend the traditional
view. (Nasr: 168-169)
11
The question arises “who or what guarantees the persistence of tradition? In Nasr’s
view, some traditions have authority and some have a sacred community, which
guarantees the continuation of the message.
According to Islamic thought, moderation results from the close interrelation that
exists between the theoretical and practical intellects. One grasps the close
interrelatedness of the theoretical and practical intellects if one considers the
lexical root of the Arabic term “aql” (i.e. intellect or reasoning). It comes from the
term “oqol” or “iqal”, which are used to refer to the rope Arabs use to fasten the
legs of camels. (Reza Mahyar, Arabic-Persian dictionary, p. 617)
The Quranic concept of aql has a similar content. Derivatives of “aql” used in
Quran do not refer to pure theoretical intellect that has no connection to practice. In
Islamic thought, “aql” is a bond which, like a camel’s bridle, bounds the
theoretical intellect and prevents from disobeying God. Aql is a phenomenon with
which God is worshiped and with which paradise is attained (ma obeda bi hi al-
Rahman wa oktosiba bi hi al-Jinan)"" ماعبد به الرحمن و اکتسب به الجنان.
Under the Quranic verse " َ ُونِليعقَ هم َقوم ال ُنََّ
ِأ“ " بthat is because they are a
folk who know not” it is said that:
َه
ُ َع
َفَا ر
ِنَصحَابض أ ِبع
َ َنِ عِ الجَبّار
َبدد بنِ عِمَّمح
ُ َن ِيسَ ع
ِدر ُ إ
د بنُمََح
" أ
من
ُ َّحِ الرِهد بَُِبما ع ُ َقال
َ َ َقلما العَ ُله
َ َُ ُقلت ِّّللا ع َقال
َبد َب
ِي ع لى أ إ
َِ
َِلكَ تَالَقَ فيةََِاومع
ُ ِيَ فَانِي كلذَّا
ُ فَ ُقلتُ َقال َانِ الجِن ِه
َ بِب
ُسَ اكتو
" َِقلِالع ليسَت ب ِ و
َ َ َقلِالعيهة ب
َ ِِيَ شَب
َ ه ُ و
َةِلكَ الشّيطَن
اء ت
ُ َّكرالن
12
The traditions narrated in the chapter, entitled “Reason and Ignorance”, of Kitab
al-Kafi, indicates the existence of a close interrelation between theory and
knowledge on the one hand and practice and faith on the other. According to these
traditions, aql is not comprehension unconnected from practice, and a
comprehension is sound only if it leads to religious practice and not to Satanic
wrongdoing:
Ahmad the son of Idris narrated from Muhammad the son of Abd al-Jabbar,
and the latter narrated from some companions that “I asked Abi Abdi al-Allah
what aql is. He answered it is what through which God is worshiped and
through which paradise is attained. I asked him what the thing that Mu’aviah
possessed was then. He answered it was artifice and shenanigan; it looked like
aql, but it was not really aql. (al-Kafi, vol. 1, p. 10, tradition 3)
Oh Hisham! God told the story of a pious community who said “Our Lord!
Cause not our hearts to stray after Thou hast guided us, and bestow upon us
mercy from Thy Presence. Lo! Thou, only Thou art the Bestower.” This
community had realized that hearts could go astray, lose their innate light and
gets blind and wicked. Oh Hisham! One does not fear God unless his heart has
been bridled by God and his reasoning (or intellect) has become Godly. And
one’s heart would not obtain and preserve any knowledge and one would not
comprehend the reality of what he knows unless he is sincere.
13
ِغتز
ُ بنا ال َّلوا ر ُهم َقا ُنَّ
َ أ ِحِين َال ٍ ص َن َقوم َّّّللا حَكَى ع ِنِشَامُ إ يا ه َ "
اب ه
ُ َّ و ال ت
َ نَأ ك ن إ ة م ح
َ ِّ ً َ َ َ ُ َ ر ك ن د ل ِن
م نا ل ب
َ َ َه و نا ت ي د ه
َ ََ ِ َ َذ إ د ع ب نا وب
َ ُُقل
ِيخَف
َ لم َ ُنه
ِّاها إ َ َ َد َ ر اها و َ مََلى ع ُ إ
َِ ُود تع ُ و
َ َ ِيغ تزَ َ ُوب ُلّ الق َن
ِموا أ َُل َ عحِين
ٍَةِف
معر َ َى َلُ ع ِد َقلبَه يعق َ لم َ ِِّّللا
َنِل ع يعق َ لم َ من َ َ ِِّّللا وَن
ِل ع يعقَ لم َ من َ َّّللا
منَ ِّال
ِكَ إَلَذ
ُ أحَد كَ يكُون َ َ َال ِ
ِي َقلبِه و ها ف َََتِيق د حَق ُِيجَ َ ها و َُِريبص ٍ
ُ َة ِت
َاب ث
لم ه
َ ُُ م اس ك ار
ََ َ َب ت ّللا ّ َ
نَ
ّ ًِ
ْل ا ِق
ف ا و
َُم ِ
ه ِ
ت ِي
ن ّل ِع
ل ه ِر
َ ََ ُّ َ ً َّ ُس و ا ق د ص م ِ
ه ِ
ل ِع
ف ِ
ل ه
ُُل و ق
َ ن ا
َ َ ك
"َُنهٍ ع ِقناط َ َ ُ و ِنه ٍ مِرِظَاه ِّال ب
ِ إ َقلَ الع ِنِي م ِنِالخَف َى البَاط َلّ عدلُيَ
ّ
In the religious view, practical intellect, which is usually called “aql” in Arabic,
comes from light; or rather it is light itself. In this light, good and evil are
recognized. Like a lamp, practical intellect guides one the way. On the other hand,
theoretical intellect, which is usually called “ilm” in Arabic, has been defined as a
light through which good and bad actions are recognized. This indicates the close
interrelatedness of practical and theoretical intellects in the religious ontology:
The holy prophet was asked “out of what did God make aql?” He responded
“when the curtain is lifted a light is cast upon one’s heart, and in this light
religious duties and virtuous acts are recognized and good is distinguished
from bad. Beware that aql in one’s heart is as lamp in one’s house. (Bihar al-
Anwar, vol. 1, p. 99)
Mūsá ibn Ja'far al-Kādhim told Hisham “the illumination of soul is aql” (tohaf al-
Oqul, p. 396)
Amīr al-Mu'minīn quoted the holy prophet “God created aql from a light which
was hidden in His eternal knowledge. Then, He set Ilm as its substance,
understanding as its spirit, and asceticism as its fruit. (khisal, p. 427)
Imam Sadiq told “aql is one’s credit. Sagacity, understanding, remembrance, and
ilm are from aql. So if light is behind one’s aql, one has sagacity, understanding,
14
remembrance, and ilm. Then, one will attain perfection, and aql will be one’s
guide, and aql will give him insight and key to all problems. (Bihar al-Anwar, vol.
1, p. 90)
And it is also narrated that “God created aql out of four things: ilm, power, light,
and providence. (Bihar al-Anwar, vol. 1, p. 98)
The idea that there is a close interrelation between theory and practice is grounded
in the view that there is a graded unity between God, mankind, and nature. In
contrast, the idea that theory is sharply distinct from practice is rooted in the view
that there is a sharp distinction or dichotomy between human as the subject and
nature as the object.
The religious view that there is a close interrelation between theory and practice
becomes clear if we contrast it to the modern subjectivist view, which is based on
the sharp distinction between subject and object. The subjectivist view began, in
the modern world, with Descartes and was established in Kant and culminated in
Hegel. Descartes casted his methodic doubt on any doubtable fact. Then, he set
clarity and distinctness as the only criterion of truth. Thus he doubted the truth of
anything except the truth of the very fact that he doubted. So, his doubting was the
only fact that he took as certain. Doubting is a form of thinking. There can be no
thinking unless there is a thinker. The underlying foundation of knowledge thus
was set. The thinking “I” was set as the underlying foundation of knowledge and
ontology. In the pre-modern philosophy, substance was the independent underlying
subject upon which other things, including the thinking “I” depended. In the
modern subjectivism, the relation is conversed: the thinking “I” becomes the
underlying subject, and substance becomes its object of knowledge. This shift was
the starting point of modern subjectivism, and it was then that God and nature,
which were in the pre-modern worldview the ontological and epistemological
foundation, were epistemologically significant only as far as they were the object
of the thinking “I”’s knowledge. For Descartes, the thinking “I” was the foundation
upon which the knowledge of God and nature was based. Whereas, in the religious
thought this is God which is the foundation for knowing other facts. In Descartes’
thought, God has a secondary importance: He is important only because He
guarantees the correctness of clear and distinct beliefs of the thinking “I”. In this
view, man is sharply distinct from nature and God, and his existence is the
foundation of knowledge. In this view, nature and God are significant only because
they are objects of man’s knowledge. For Kant, a prior forms of time and space
constitutes nature, and God merely has a regulative role. God and nature which, in
the religious worldview, are in a graded unity relationship to mankind is, in the
15
modern subjectivist worldview, relegated to mere objects of man’s knowledge.
And in Hegel’s thought, the absolute idea produces, in its historical unfolding, all
ontological phenomenon, and its historical determinism substitutes the free
compassionate God.
In Plato’s view, there are two concepts of truth: the concept of truth which is at
play in his cave metaphor, and the concept of truth as aletheia (a Greek term
meaning unhiddenness or non-concealment). In the cave metaphor, the active role
of man in discovering truth and attaining Ideas is emphasized. In this metaphor,
truth is hidden from man, and this is man who passing the stages of perception
(pestis), imagination (eikasia), and reasoning (noumena), reveals truth. Whereas,
according to the latter concept, truth is non-concealment itself. In this sense, truth
is not hidden from man. Rather this is man who is hidden from truth. Man drank of
the River Lethe (River of Forgetfulness), and the way to reach truth is to hearken
Logos.
One should take the Quranic view on moderation and justice as the standard of
religious form of life. The holy Quran is a source of aspiration for human
philosophical and theological theorizing. Quranic statements are themselves the
best manifestations of moderation. They describe an ontology, an anthropology,
and a sociology, in which moderation is best manifested.
The holy Quran describes an ontology in which the natural world rests on a firm
order, and everything is put, in the appropriate amount, in its proper place. This is
the moderation in ontology. In regard to anthropology, the holy Quran swears by
the moderation of the human soul, and it describes the religious form of life in
terms of the rich concept of “middle nation”. (Surah al-Baqarah, verse, 143) And
with respect to sociology, the holy Quran introduces justice and equity as the
cornerstone of religion and as the main purpose of sending messengers and
revealing Scriptures. To establish equity and justice, people need to reform
themselves by moderating their inner faculties. The outer manifestation of
moderation is social reformation.
16
The holy Quran states that everything was created in a specific pre-determined
proper proportion, and that the world rests on a prior moderation:
“Allah hath set a measure for all things.” (Surah al-Talaq, verse 3)
The noble Quran refers to the Muslim community as the middle nation. (Suarh al-
Baqarah, verse 143) Thus, a society which is guided by Quran avoids extremes and
maintains the golden mean. The holy Quran always guides to the middle way. And
as Shahid Mutahhari pointed out, keeping moderation needs ijtihad (“ijtihad”
means endeavor of a Muslim scholar to derive a rule of divine law from the Quran
and Hadith without relying on the views of other scholars):
Apparently the path moderation is always as a narrow line such that a bit of
carelessness would lead to slipping off the line. What is meant by the remark,
mentioned in religious texts, that “Sirat (i.e. the right path) is more capillary
than hair” is the very point that observing moderation in any deed is so
difficult. Needless to say, human kind always faces new problems, and new
problems calls for new solutions. The term “al-hawadith al-waqi’ah), (i.e.
occurring events), whose solutions are said, in some traditions, to be upon the
bearers of Islamic knowledge, refers to these novel problems. This is why
there must be in any age some mujtahid (i.e. someone who performs ijtihad),
and this is why people should always refer to some living mujtahid. (Shahid
Mutahhari’s corpus, vol. 21, p.61)
17
“Thus We have appointed you a middle nation, that ye may be witnesses against
mankind. and that the messenger may be a witness against you. And We appointed
the qiblah which ye formerly observed only that We might know him who
followeth the messenger, from him who turneth on his heels. In truth it was a hard
(test) save for those whom Allah guided. But it was not Allah's purpose that your
faith should be in vain, for Allah is full of pity, Merciful toward mankind.” (Surah
al-Bawarah, verse 43)
يكُون
َ َ َ َّاسِ و
َى الن َل
داء ع
َ ه َُنوا ش َُكُولتِ ًَسَطا
ً ومةَُّ
ُم أَلناكِكَ جَع
َذل
َ ك" و
َِّال
َيها إ َل
َ ع ُنتِي ك الت
َّ َ َة
ِبل الق َا َلن َ ما جَع ً و ِيدا َيكُم شَه َلُ ع َّسُول
الر
ة ير ب
ِ
ًَ َ َ َك ل ت ن كا ن إ
ِ َ و ِ
ه يَ َ َلى
ِب
ق ع ع ِبل ق ن ي ن ِم
م
ُ َ َ َّ َ ُ َّ ل و س الر ُ َّ َ َ َ َ َع
عِب ت ي ن م م ل ِ
لن
َِّاس ِالن َََّّّللا ب
ِن نكُم إَِيما َ إ ِيعِيُض
ل ََُّّللا
َ ما كان دىَُّّللا و
َه ِين
َ َ الذ
َّ َى َل
ِالَّ ع
إ
")341 آيه،َحِيم (بقره ُف ر َؤلر
َ
The above-mentioned verse explicitly states that the prophet’s ummah (i.e. nation)
is a nation of moderation,
َسَطا
"ً ً و
مةَُّ
ُم أ
َلناك
ِكَ جَع
َذل
َ ك
" و
and it also mentions some reasons of changing the qiblah in the early years of
Islam.
In the above-mentioned verse, the purpose of making them a middle nation was to
set the prophet’s ummah an example for, and so witnesses against, other people.
ِيدا
"ً َيكُم شَه
َلُ ع
َّسُول
َ الر
يكُون َّاسِ و
َ َ َى الن
َلداء ع
َ ه َُنوا ش
َُكُو
لتِ "
The clause “that ye may be witnesses against mankind. and that the messenger may
be a witness against you” might be meant to point to the fact that the prephet’s
ummah is to be an example for other people, and that the prophet himself was an
example for his ummah. After all, witnesses are selected from among those who
are exemplars. That is, the prophet’s ummah with their deeds witnesses that a
human being can be both a man of religion and a man of this terrestrial world, and
that a human being can live up to his religious and moral values while socializing
with other people in his everyday life. The prophet’s ummah witnesses that not
only religion and this worldly life are not incompatible, but also they can serve and
promote one another.
Some Quran interpreters have commented that the term “wasat” (i.e. middle) refers
to something which is not part of either extremes but rather is between them.
Muslim community is in the same position with regard to followers of past
Abrahamic religions and pagans: pagans are totally on the side of materialism; they
merely try to accumulate their wealth and to maximize their material pleasures.
They neither believe in the hereafter and nor in any kind of resurrection. They have
no care for moral and spiritual values.
18
God made the Muslim community the middle nation. That is to say, He gave them
a religion which leads its followers to the middle way, a way which avoids both
extreme sides. In the middle way, both the means and the goal are considered
important. Man has two dimensions: body and spirit. Therefore, to have a happy
life, he must cultivate both. (Almizan Quran Interpretation, vol. 1, pp. 482-3)
“Allah (Himself) is witness that there is no God save Him. And the angels and the
men of learning (too are witness). Maintaining His creation in justice, there is no
God save Him, the Almighty, the Wise.”
" شهد ّللا انه ال اله اال هو و المّلئکه و اولوا العلم قائما
"بالقسط
“We verily sent Our messengers with clear proofs, and revealed with them the
Scripture and the Balance, that mankind may observe right measure”
"ارسلنا رسلنا بالبينات و انزلنا معهم الکتاب و الميزان ليقوم
".الناس بالقسط
19
Equipped with these three, prophets could raise people for establishing justice.
Interestingly, the holy Quran does not ascribe the establishment of justice to
prophets themselves. Rather, the establishment of justice is assigned to their
followers. In Quran’s view, people should be educated, such that they rise to
establish justice by themselves. The significant point is that the rise should be
spontaneous and not premeditated or forced by external causes. (Javadi Amuli,
Thematic Interpretation of Quran, vol. 3, p. 174)
Here, prophets merely play the role of guides; they do not deprive their followers
of their volition and free will. Prophets were sent to guide people and to waken
what already existed in their intellect but was not awake, so that people rise to
establish justice by themselves. As the holy Quran says “Say: O People of the
Scripture. Come to an agreement between us and you: that we shall worship none
but Allah, and that we shall ascribe no partners unto Him, and that none of us shall
take others for lords beside Allah” (Surah al-Imran, verse 64)
َِكنشر
ُ َ الََّّللا و
َِّال
د إ َ ََّال
َُنعب َكُم أ
بين َنا و
َ َ بين
َ ءٍٍ سَوا
ِمة
ََلِلى ك لوا إَ" تعاا
"44 آيه،آلعمران. ونَِّّللا ِ ُ ِن د
ً مَربابا
ً أ
بعضاَ ُنابعض
َ ََّخِذ
يت َ َ ال ِ شَيئا
ً و ِهب
and “Lo! Allah changeth not the condition of a folk until they (first) change that
which is in their hearts.” (Surah al-Ra’d, verse 11)
ِه
"33 آيه،ِم رعد َنف
ُس ِأُوا ما ب
َيِّر
يغُ َّى
ٍ حَت
َوم
ِقُ ما ب
َيِّر
يغُ ََّّّللا ال
َ
ِن " إ
Finally, it is worth noting that one of the most important social impacts of
observing moderation is that moral deficiencies of society are corrected. God’s
tradition is to enjoin people to maintain moderation, and appealing to the moderate
system of shari’ah is the key to reform the immoral traditions. God enjoin people
to maintain moderation, and thus sets a criterion for distinguishing what really
belongs to religion from what is a tradition of the old and is wrongly ascribed to
religion. The following verses show the critical attitude of shar’ah toward immoral
traditions and costumes of the old, and, as Shahid Mutahhari points out, mentions
the criterion for cleansing religion of what is wrongly ascribed to religion:
20
“And when they do some lewdness they say: We found our fathers doing it and
Allah hath enjoined it on us. Say: Allah, verily, enjoineth not lewdness. Tell ye
concerning Allah that which ye know not? Say: My Lord enjoineth justice.” (Surah
al-A’raf, verses 28-29)
ِهاَنا ب مرََ
َُّّللا أ
اءنا و
َ َ َيها آبَلَجَدنا علوا و ًُ قاُوا فاحِشَةَل
َعِذا فَ إ" و
مر
َ ََ
ُقل أ.َ
مون
َُتعل
َ َِّّللا ما ال
َىَل
َ ع
لون
ُُو
تقَ َ َِحشا
ء أ ِالف
ُ ب
مرُيأ
َ ََّّللا ال
ِن
َّ ُقل إ
" ِِسط
ِالق بي ب ر
َِّ
(Shahid Mutahhari’s corpus, vol. 4, p. 814)
After this conceptual study, I come back to our first topic and I make some
practical suggestions as to how to promote the Iranian cinema by modeling the
Korean series.
21
References
Heidegger, Martin, Plato‘s Doctrine of Truth, Trans. John Barlow, New York:
Random House, 1962.
Heidegger, Martin, Being and Time, Trans. John Maquarrie and Edmund
Robinson, London, 1962.
Saqat al-Islam Quleini, Al-Kafi, vol. 1, Nure Wahy Press, 1428HQ, Qom.
22
Shahid Mutahhari, Shahid Mutahhari’s Corpus, vol. 4 & 7 & 21, Sadra Press,
1368HS Tehran.
23