Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Knowledge also may be considered socially constructed by the fact that public
knowledge -- that is, ideas and information stored and made available for the
general public -- usually goes through some sort of debate amongst people. Groups
of scientists, for example, read each others' articles, write for the same journals and
attend the same conferences. After they have debated ideas about which they have
been investigating in their labs. etc., their collective conclusions get published in
school texts and other records frequented by the public. This is related to the idea of
community of practice (CoP); that is, a group of people with a shared history that
gives them -- among other things -- a shared identity, a repertoire of common
practices and a similar knowledge set. In other words, each of us must admit, 'I am
apart of all of whom I have met' (Tennyson).
(Go to top)
For example, when people try to convince others Teachers must, therefore, take purposeful steps to
that what they see in the above black-and-white gett students to see things in new ways. For
image is the 'right' way to look at it (e.g., a man is example, it would be about getting students to ‘see’
visible), they often fail. Once a person sees it one particular images in the black-and-white photograph
way, however, it’s difficult for them to see it any above. Likewise, it is about getting them to ‘see’
other way! that, as a candle burns, a prevalent explanation is
that wax is combining with oxygen to make carbon
Indeed, students often are emotionally attached to dioxide and water.
their ideas; they don’t even want to hear that
someone may have a ‘better’ explanation. That Because knowledge is so communally-based,
might threaten their self-worth. As a consequence, moreover, learners deserve access to knowledge of
they may not even want to deal with what others different communities. Learning should not be so
(e.g., teachers') recommend! conservative as to ignore knowledge and ways of
knowing of different races, cultures and societies. In
Learners see what they want to see! other words, learning must be pluralist -- rather than
It has been said that ‘observing something tells you conformist.
more about the observer than what is being
observed’. The black-and-white image above is, Students need to know how to learn!
therefore, meaningless without a preconceived Students may not know, even if they have access to
notion about it. ideas and an urge to change, how to change their
thinking. They may lack skills necessary to re-
Observing is, consequently, an active, rather than a consider their ideas. They may not know how to
passive, process. To a great extent, people project think about their own ideas, how to learn new ones
what they already have in their heads onto or how to decide what they believe. Therefore, as
phenomena to be observed. They see what they with conceptual change, students need others (often
‘want’ to see. teachers) to introduce them to new skills; e.g., how
to develop concept maps to exhibit ideas. Some
Learners often are not aware of what they know! approaches to this are provided here: Process
Learning.
Students are frequently not consciously aware of
reasons (e.g., laws and theories) for their actions;
they just ‘innately’ know why they do things a certain Students deserve the right to determine their
way. For example, few stop to think how gravity, beliefs!
wind, surface friction, etc. affect how they walk. For Scientists are never, because of the theory-limited
the reasons cited above, teaching and learning nature of knowledge development, absolutely certain
should begin by encouraging learners to express that their explanations are correct. There always is a
and clarify their pre-instructional conceptions. possibility for change.
Learners may not discover experts' conclusions! Indeed, there have been major paradigm shifts in
Because students will 'see what they want to see', it history (e.g., believing in a flat Earth vs. a round
seems inappropriate for teachers to simply provide one). Furthermore, scientists have been known to
students with experiences and then expect them to be influenced by personal and group biases (e.g., an
'discover' planned conclusions, especially since it interest in fame). Similarly, products of science and
took scientists years to do so. technology -- such as various inventions -- have had
negative side-effects on society and the
environment. Breakdown of nuclear reactors is just
Consequently, familiar ‘inquiry’, ‘discovery’ (and
certain ‘constructivist’) practical activities ('labs.') are one of many examples. Perhaps most importantly,
inappropriate. Students, invariably, ‘discover’ what is much common knowledge is biased and, most
worrisome, controlled by the most powerful
apparent to them; not, necessarily, what would be
members and groups in society.
apparent to a professional scientist or engineer.
Accordingly, it is important for educators to carefully
present ideas, skills, attitudes, etc. to students to Consequently, we could ask whether or not society
which they want them to have access. This policy (through teachers) has the right (or, even, ability!) to
has important ramificatioins for social justice. change a student’s beliefs. While getting students to
Generally, those least likely to 'discover' important understand new ideas may be (is) society’s right and
ideas, skills, etc. from 'inquiry' or 'discovery' responsibility, forcing them to accept certain beliefs
experiences are the most disadvantaged students. may be problematic. Should education be about
Often, this is tied to socio-economic level. Expecting convincing others or about enlightening others?
students to discover important ideas through Perhaps students deserve the right to determine
experiences, therefore, discriminates against the their own beliefs in school settings and beyond. That
poorest children. For this reason alone, educators may occur if students have opportunities to conduct
must work to actively share societies' ideas, skills, scientific investigations and invention projects under
etc. with all students. It is right and just to do so. their control.