Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
8-14, 2005
ABSTRACT
Traditional flow models for smoke exhaust through horizontal ceiling vent in an atrium fire will be reviewed.
There, buoyancy of the smoke layer is the driving force for extraction. Key equations on calculating the smoke
exhaust rates and required vent area are derived. An atrium is taken as an example to calculate the vent areas
required. Two scenarios for a fire at the atrium floor to give an axisymmetric plume; and a fire at a shop
adjacent to the atrium to give a balcony spill plume are considered. It is found that a balcony spill plume will
give a much higher smoke production rate and so vent with larger area is required for the same design fire in
comparing with an axisymmetric plume.
8
International Journal on Engineering Performance-Based Fire Codes
& e C p (Tg − Ta ) = m
m &
& p C p (Tg − Ta ) = Q (18)
9
International Journal on Engineering Performance-Based Fire Codes
Tg &
Q There had been numerous arguments [15] on
= +1 (19)
selecting suitable plume equations on the above.
Ta m
& p C p Ta
Details on deriving those equations and validation
by experiments or Computational Fluid Dynamics
Substituting into equation (17) gives: appeared in the literature [16,17] and will not be
repeated in this paper.
1/ 2
Q & Q & C 2A 2
+ 1 + 1 + d2 C 2 Examples on calculating the required vent area are
m& p m
& p C p Ta m
& p C p Ta
C A
A
A C =
i
taken on two atria of height 20 m and
&
ρa Cd 2g (H − H g )
Q 30 m respectively. Design fires of heat release
m& p C p Ta rates Q& of 1 MW, 5 MW and 10 MW are
considered. Smoke layer interface height is a key
(20)
design criterion as air entrainment rate of plume
(and hence the smoke production rate) depends on
that. This value has to be agreed while designing a
4. PLUME EQUATIONS natural vent.
In the equation for calculating AC, expressions m
&p Required vent areas are calculated for different
must be determined. But the plume depends on smoke layer interface heights for both
location of the fire. Two smoke plumes are axisymmetric plume and balcony spill plume in
commonly encountered in an atrium: these two atria. The balcony is of width W of 5 m
and height H of 5 m above the atrium floor.
y Axisymmetric plume [1-3,12] due to a fire at Results are shown in Figs. 2 and 3.
the atrium floor as in Fig. 1a, one of the
plume models is: It is observed that higher the smoke layer interface
height, bigger is the required vent area. Effect of
& 1 / 3 H 5 / 3 + 0.0018Q
& p = 0.071Q
m & (21) heat release rate on the vent area is not too
g
significant for 1 MW to 10 MW. Only a slightly
bigger vent might be required for bigger design
y Balcony spill plume [1-3,13] in a shop fires. However, balcony spill plume will require a
adjacent to the atrium as in Fig. 1b, with one much bigger vent area in comparing with an
plume model given by: axisymmetric plume, under the same design fire
and same agreed smoke layer interface height.
m & W 2 ) 13 ( H − 0.75h )
& p = 0.36(Q (22) Therefore, the typical fire scenario in the atrium, i.e.
g
assuming the fire at the atrium floor or the fire in a
where W is the width of the balcony and h is shop adjacent to the atrium, should be decided
its height above the floor. carefully.
C Poo
PC
ρgTg
.
mp
H
ρaTa
Hg
PA
Po A
10
International Journal on Engineering Performance-Based Fire Codes
10 MW
5 MW
1 MW
Required vent area AC / m2
Balcony spill plume
10 MW
5 MW
1 MW
Axisymmetric plume
10 MW
5 MW
1 MW
Required vent area AC / m2
Axisymmetric plume
1/ 2
Performance of the static smoke exhaust system
depends on the smoke temperature and fire size.
2g (H − H g )(φ − 1) (24)
& e = Cdρa A C
m
y Effect of smoke temperature 2 2
φ φ + C d A C
C i A A
2 2
Expressing the smoke temperature in terms of
the ambient air temperature:
Variation of the ventilation capacity with
Tg temperature is shown in Fig. 4.
φ= (23)
Ta
11
International Journal on Engineering Performance-Based Fire Codes
1.0
0.8
me / mmax
0.6
.
0.4
0.2
Ta ∆T / K
1/ 2
C 2A 2 Substituting into equation (27) with equation
φ = 1 + d2 C 2 + 1 (26) (19) gives:
Ci A A
&m
Q & e1 / 2 + m & 1 / 2 (C T ) 1 / 2
& e 3 / 2 C p Ta = A * (H − H g )1 / 2 Q p a
Provided that the area of inlets is large
(29)
compared to the area of the vents, i.e. AA >>
AC,
&e =m
For m & p,
φ≈2
&m
Q & p1 / 2 + m & 1 / 2 (C T ) 1 / 2
& p 3 / 2 C p Ta = A * (H − H g )1 / 2 Q p a
This gives: (30)
12
International Journal on Engineering Performance-Based Fire Codes
Note that the mass flow rate m & p of the plume 3. NFPA 92B, Guide for smoke management systems
in malls, atria and large areas, National Fire
at the interface height is a function of Q& and Protection Association, Quincy, MA, USA (1995).
Hg, given by either equation (21) or (22) for 4. H.P. Morgan and J.P. Gardner, Design principles
different configurations. The smoke layer for smoke ventilation in enclosed shopping centers,
interface height in an atrium under a certain Building Research Establishment Report, CI/SIB
fire can be estimated by equation (30) once 34(K3) (1990).
the vent area is known.
5. Fire Services Department, Codes of Practice for
Minimum Fire Service Installations and Equipment
and Inspection and Testing of Installations and
6. CONCLUSION Equipment, Hong Kong (1994).
6. W.Y. Hung and W.K. Chow, “A review on
In this paper, traditional vent flow model for architectural aspects of atrium buildings”,
natural vent was reviewed. Buoyancy is the Architectural Science Review, Vol. 44, No. 3, pp.
driving force and derivation was based on applying 285-295 (2001).
Bernoulli’s theorem. The required vent area is
7. E.W. Marchant, “Effect of wind on smoke
estimated from the derived smoke exhaust rate.
movement and smoke control systems”, Fire Safety
Journal, Vol. 7, pp. 55-63 (1984).
Examples on two atria of heights 20 m and 30 m
were taken to calculate the required vent areas for 1 8. B.S. Kandola, “Effects of atmospheric wind on
MW, 5 MW and 10 MW fires. Both axisymmetric flows through natural convection roof vents”, Fire
Technology, May, pp. 107-120 (1990).
plume and balcony spill plume were considered.
9. C.F. Than, “Smoke venting by gravity roof
It is found that heat release rate would not affect ventilators under windy conditions”, Journal of
the vent area significantly. Perhaps, it is not Fire Protecting Engineering, Vol. 4, No. 1, pp. 1-4
necessary to spend time on arguing the design fire (1992).
size, if static smoke exhaust system is to be 10. H. Ingason and B. Persson, “Effects of wind on
provided. natural fire vents”, Brandforsk Project 055-921,
Swedish National Testing and Research Institute,
However, a balcony spill plume due to a fire in a Fire Technology, SP Report 1995:04, Boras,
shop adjacent to the atrium would give higher air Sweden (1995).
entrainment rate, and so bigger vent area is 11. M. Poreh and S. Trebukov, “Wind effect on smoke
required than the same fire for an axisymmetric motion in building”, Fire Safety Journal, Vol. 35,
plume. The fire scenario must be selected carefully pp. 257-273 (2000).
on designing static smoke exhaust system. Both 12. G. Heskestad, “Engineering relationships for fire
the smoke layer interface height and the fire plumes”, SFPE TR 82-8, Boston, Society of Fire
scenario to give an axisymmetric plume or a Protection Engineers (1982).
balcony spill plume must be discussed and agreed.
13. M. Law, “A note on smoke plumes from fires in
The smoke layer should be kept above the occupied
multi-level shopping malls”, Fire Safety Journal,
zone in order not to emit high radiative heat flux Vol. 10, pp. 197-202 (1986).
for occupants and firefighters staying below.
14. D.H. Sharp, “An overview of Rayleigh-Taylor
instability”, Physica 12D, pp. 3-18 (1984).
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 15. P.H. Thomas, “Some ambiguities in plume and
flame height formulae”, Fire Safety Journal, Vol.
The project is funded jointly by an RGC grant and 34, No. 3, pp. 209-212 (2000).
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University. 16. W.K. Chow and J. Li, “Simulation on natural
smoke filling in atrium with a balcony spill plume”,
Journal of Fire Sciences, Vol. 19, No. 4, pp. 258-
REFERENCES 283 (2001).
17. W.K. Chow and R. Yin, “Discussion on two plume
1. NFPA 204M, Guide for smoke and heat venting, formulae with Computational Fluid Dynamics”,
National Fire protection Association, Quincy, MA, Journal of Fire Sciences, Vol. 20, No. 3, pp. 179-
USA (1991). 201 (2002).
2. J. Klote and J. Milke, Design of smoke 18. “Wind environment around tall buildings”, UK
management systems, ASHRAE Publ. 90022, Building Research Establish, Digest No. 141
American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and (1972).
Air – Conditioning Engineers, Atlanta, USA
(1992). 19. “Assessment of wind loads”, UK Building
Research Establish, Digest No. 119 (1984).
13
International Journal on Engineering Performance-Based Fire Codes
14