Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
m Glossary ...................................................................................................... 17
which in classical Greek poetry is the same as dactylic believable actions that are consistent with their characters.
hexameter, to convey its story. Hexameter refers to the meter,
or pattern of stressed and unstressed syllables, of the poem. Aristotle proposes that the plot in either type should be a
Dactylic describes a poetic foot, referring to the number and unified whole based around the imitation of a central action.
pattern of stressed syllables. A dactyl is one long followed by Plot always requires a beginning, middle, and end, and Aristotle
two short syllables. Hexameter indicates that there will be six emphasizes the importance of each of these parts naturally
feet in each line of the poem: the first five feet are dactyls, and being the cause or the effect of the next part. It is essential
the last foot is a two-syllable foot called a spondee. The that plot develops in an organic way and not as a result of the
rhythm created is something like DUM dah dah | DUM dah dah | poet's forcing events via unlikely character actions or
DUM dah dah | DUM dah dah | DUM dah dah | DUM DUM. This motivations.
informed much of his later writing and theory. the development of criticism. Italian poet Dante Alighieri,
famous during the Middle Ages for The Divine Comedy (c.
Plato saw poetry as of doubtful importance. In fact, he 1308–21), considered Aristotle a master of knowledge. British
proposed that literature was a distraction or misdirection from writer T.S. Eliot, a 20th-century poet and critic, considered
the truth. Aristotle, however, suggests in Poetics that poetry Aristotle a master writer and referenced lines from Poetics in
and art arise from a human desire to imitate and that this his own essays.
desire is connected with the human experience of empathy.
Contemporary Relevance Aristotle stayed at the Academy and studied avidly under Plato
for 20 years. Philosophy experts surmise that many of Plato's
Not only does Poetics give modern readers a sense of the
dialogues written during this period were influenced by the
important elements of poetry and drama in ancient Greece, but
conversations between teacher and pupil. Aristotle was also
it also provides some of the earliest available writing on the art
writing during this period, but only fragments of his work from
of drama in Western culture. Both Plato's writings on poetry
the Academy survive. In one of his earliest works, titled
and Aristotle's response have been used in Western art
Eudemus (c. 352 BCE), of which only small pieces remain,
criticism since they were written.
Aristotle employs his teacher's style of dialogue to reflect on
some of Plato's views. In this work, Aristotle details his theory
In contemporary thought, a common criticism of Poetics is that
that death is the soul returning home, thus making the state of
it tries simply to provide a formula or recipe for art. Part of this
death a happier one than that of life.
criticism results from the way Aristotle elevates the technical
and theoretical construction of drama and poetry above its
Aristotle agreed with and used many of Plato's philosophies
expressive aspects. However, his opinion of certain aspects of
and techniques while at the Academy. However, he eventually
poetry is at times inconsistent in the text and is still a matter of
began to diverge from his teacher's ideas. Aristotle seemed to
much debate.
have remained on good terms with the school and with Plato,
but his writings started to reflect a disagreement with some of
Another aspect of Poetics that is central to the ongoing
Plato's foundational theories. One of the main philosophical
conversation about poetry and criticism is the concept that
points that Aristotle took issue with was Plato's Theory of
both Aristotle and Plato seemed to agree on—that poetry (and
Forms. This theory holds that the real world of physical
art generally) is a form of mimesis, or imitation. This claim is
substance is changeable and, therefore, unreliable. Ideas, on
quite contentious. It has been at the forefront of many
the other hand, are a more accurate representation of reality.
conversations about the relevance of art and creative works.
Aristotle argues against this theory in many of his works, citing
Aristotle's doctrine on poetry and drama has had a huge its implausibility, and proposes alternative possibilities.
influence on Western thought about art, literature, and theater.
At the same time that Aristotle was studying at the Academy in
Aristotle's work has shaped both the development of art and
BCE and united much of Greece. Lyceum. While studying and teaching there, he invented the
concept and system of academic disciplines. This system
helped organize his writings on different scientific and
Travels and Later Life philosophic topics. He grouped the sciences into three
categories: productive, practical, and theoretical.
Around the time of Plato's death in about 348 BCE, Aristotle Much of Aristotle's remaining work is fragmentary. The pieces
left Athens for Assus, a city in Anatolia, which is part of he published during his life are now almost completely lost. The
present-day Turkey. As Plato's student of 20 years, Aristotle works still remaining today are primarily notes from texts and
would likely have been a candidate for taking over as head of treatises that Aristotle wrote to use in his teachings. These
the Academy. Some sources suggest that Aristotle left Athens make up only about a third of his known works. It is known
because he was not given the post as a result of academic through fragments and the writings of others that Aristotle
disputes. Other sources theorize that he left Athens shortly published essays, poetry, and Platonic dialogues, but none of
before Plato died as a result of political tensions between these works remain in their entirety. It is unclear how his
Athens and Macedonia at the time. surviving works were preserved and how they were handed
down. It is widely believed, however, that they were passed
In either case, Aristotle moved to Assus at the invitation of his
between scholars after his death and eventually ended up in
friend Hermias, who was ruler of the city. He could not return
Rome.
to his hometown of Stagira, which had been destroyed
previously by the Macedonian King Philip II. While in Assus, Aristotle researched and wrote on a wide array of subjects.
Aristotle married Pythias, who was the ward or niece of Most of his work falls into three categories: dialogues and
Hermias. It is speculated that she was much younger than popular works, collections of scientific data and research, and
Aristotle, perhaps around the age of 18, while Aristotle was systematic works. He is sometimes called "the founder of
about 37 at the time. They had one child, a daughter, and logic" as the result of some of his writings, including the text
Pythias died after only 10 years of marriage. Prior Analytics (c. 350 BCE). One of his most famous texts still
remaining is his work titled Metaphysics. It is a philosophical
Aristotle was eventually forced to leave Assus when his friend
treatise on being, form, and matter. He also made contributions
Hermias was captured, tortured, and executed by the Persians.
to the fields of astronomy with his studies on comets,
Aristotle wrote his only known poem, "Ode to Virtue," (c.
chemistry and its many processes, and the field of
341–322) as a tribute to Hermias.
meteorology. He was particularly interested in rainbows.
After leaving Assus, during a time of relative peace between
Aristotle was a great student of zoology and biology. He is
Macedonia and Athens, Aristotle was invited by King Philip II to
believed to have performed dissections on several different
return to Macedonia and reside in the court. There, he served
species of animals to study anatomy. He wrote about the
as tutor to Alexander the Great, Philip II's son. Aristotle
internal workings of animals, developed a logical theory of
remained at the court for seven years.
generation and reproduction, and recognized the difference
Aristotle returned to Athens in 335 BCE and formed a school between arteries and veins. While living in Assus, he and his
known as the Lyceum. In 323 BCE, influenced by increasing assistants made a study of biology and marine biology and
anti-Macedonian sentiment in Athens after the death of managed to observe details in different organisms that were
Alexander the Great, Aristotle moved to the house left to him so minute that they were not confirmed until much later when
by his mother's family in Chalcis. A year later he died there of a the microscope was invented. While many of his observations
stomach problem at the age of 62. were flawed for lack of better access to resources and
technology, his studies of medicine and science formed much Poetics ends with a discussion on the role of critics and
of the foundation for what is known today. criticism and a final decisive comparison of epic poetry and
tragedy. Aristotle delineates his argument for why, in the end,
tragedy is actually a higher form of art than the epic poem.
k Plot Summary
Aristotle's Poetics begins with a statement of intention to
discuss poetry in its various forms. Aristotle proposes to
inquire into the workings of the "good" poem and outlines the
various types of poetry he will discuss in his treatise. Much of
his writings on the form of comedy and a few other types of
poetry seem to be lost from the text, however.
Chapter 2 Chapter 5
The object that art aims to imitate is humans in action. There Comedy can be described as an imitation of something that is
are three ways humans may be portrayed: as better than they imperfect or ugly in a way that does not communicate or
are in reality, as worse, or as they actually are. Aristotle create pain. Unlike tragedy, comedy did not pass through the
explains that Homer and Polygnotus both represent people as same extended period of development and originated in Sicily.
better than they really are, Hegemon and Pauson portray their
Epic poetry and tragedy both deal with characters on a higher
characters as less good, and Dionysius and Cleophon draw
moral level. Epic poetry can be distinguished from tragedy by
their characters in the middle. He argues that this division
its restriction to a single kind of meter and its longer length.
illustrates the difference between tragedy and comedy:
tragedy portrays people as better than in reality, and comedy
portrays them as worse.
Analysis
Aristotle introduces the main topics and concepts of his
Chapter 3
treatise by offering definitions and drawing distinctions
The third type of imitation is the manner in which things are between genres. Epic poetry and tragedy are presented as
imitated. For example, a poet may choose to narrate, using similar forms of art, whereas comedy has a distinct history and
their own voice, or may take on a particular personality in their separate timeline of development. These art forms are all
rooted in the human desire to imitate the surrounding world. "Thought" seems to indicate the intellectual aspects of the
work, and diction the order and meaning of words. Spectacle,
There is a general attitude of disdain toward early comedy, and or the actors and acting, has the power to incite emotion, but
Aristotle draws a distinction between satirical works produced Aristotle considers it the least important of the six elements of
pre-Homer and the genre of comedy that began with Homer's tragedy.
movement away from personal satire into the dramatization of
the absurd. The topic of dithyrambic poetry is introduced but
then fades into the background, shifting the discussion more Chapter 7
fully to the forms of epic poetry, tragedy, and comedy.
Dithyrambic poetry is a form of ecstatic hymn in honor of the Chapter 7 focuses primarily on the structure of tragic plot. The
god Dionysus. plot must have a beginning, middle, and end, each part
naturally causing or following the previous. Aristotle suggests
Aristotle brings up two writers, Sophron and Xenarchus. that a plot gains adequate gravity through length. He argues
Sophron was a writer of mimes, as was his son Xenarchus. that a small thing (or short plot) is not notable, but something
Xenarchus wrote during the reign of Dionysius I. Both spoke that is too large to see the shape of is also problematic. The
and wrote in the Dorian dialect, which Aristotle also mentions plot of a tragedy should be long but have a clear shape and a
in reference to the creation of the genres of tragedy and sense of wholeness.
comedy. The reader should be careful not to confuse
Dionysius, the 5th-century king, with the Greek god Dionysus.
Chapter 8
Aristophanes is another important name mentioned in Chapter
2. Aristophanes was a famous writer of comedy in the early 5th The tragic plot must be built around a single main action. In
and late 4th centuries BCE. He was widely viewed as a regard to the protagonist of the story, only the character's
merciless satirist, and Aristotle probably brings up his name actions that are relevant to the main thread of the plot should
here with Sophocles because he is discussing the be included. If actions or events do not make an impact by their
development of both tragedy and comedy. When Aristotle says inclusion or exclusion from the plot, then those actions are
"Polygnotus depicted men as nobler than they are, Pauson as unnecessary.
less noble, Dionysius drew them true to life," the first two
names are referring to famous Greek artists of the 5th century
BCE, but it is unclear which Dionysius he is referencing. Analysis
Aristotle clearly lays out the ground rules for a successful work
Chapters 6–8 of tragedy. His concept of a tragedy is a drama performed by
actors and incorporating both spoken language as well as
song. However, a good tragedy should also be able to stand
Summary alone as a moving work without needing to be performed by
actors.
only disrupt its unity and thus its effectiveness. He insists that characters experience a reversal in knowledge or emotion—for
"beauty depends on magnitude and order," meaning that length instance, when the protagonist experiences a shift from hate
and unity must work together to create something that may be to love. Combined, reversal and recognition usually inspire pity
considered beautiful. or fear in the audience and are based on the idea of surprise.
Summary
Chapter 12
Chapter 9 Chapter 12 introduces the tangible parts a tragedy may be
divided into. Aristotle outlines these parts as prologue, episode,
The chapter opens with the argument that the poet's job is to exode, and choric song.
write about what may happen, as opposed to what has
happened already. While comedy might invent characters as
well as plot, tragedy usually uses the names of real people to Analysis
give credibility and weight to the story. Aristotle emphasizes
the creation of plot over the use of language, as the poet's job The poet writes about possibility, and the historian records
is to imitate action. The poet and the historian have distinctly events that have come to pass—Aristotle argues that this, and
different jobs: the poet writes about the universal, and the not the style of writing itself, is the difference between the
historian's focus is the specific. Aristotle also insists that plots poet and the historian. Yet the poet can still write about
should not be episodic, as episodes are not connected by historical events without becoming a historian, because they
organic cause and effect. Plots should evoke surprise and can choose to write about events that are relatable to the
emotion in the reader, and those feelings are stronger when audience. In this way, the poet is still writing about the universal
events have clear cause and effect instead of being the result instead of the particular. Chapters 9 through 11 deal primarily
of chance. with the plot devices used in tragedy and detail how these
devices should be used.
multiple times in the text and indicates that some parts of the
Chapter 15
original text are probably missing.
The topic of Chapter 15 is the tragic character. Aristotle argues
that speech or action that can be qualified as "good" is relative
Chapters 13–16 to class and propriety. In order to be more true to real life,
"good" actions should be assigned to characters in which they
would be believable. Characters must be both believable and
Summary consistent. However, Aristotle follows this argument by
insisting that the poet, in writing the character, should mimic a
portrait artist by elevating the character somehow. For
Chapter 13 instance, if the poet is writing a character with flaws, the poet
should preserve the type of character while still painting the
In this chapter Aristotle lays out the aims of a tragic poet and individual as more than a common person.
what the poet should avoid. A tragedy should follow the
complex plot structure instead of the simple and should
prompt pity and fear in the audience. It should avoid overly Chapter 16
simplistic movement such as the complete downfall of the
This chapter details the types of recognition, which is a plot
antagonist, because this type of plot does not evoke emotion
device briefly explained in previous chapters. Aristotle poses
in the audience. Aristotle proposes that a true tragedy involves
that "recognition through signs" is the least skillful of the
a character who is brought from good to bad fortune not
various forms. He explains this form as a situation in which a
through evil or immorality in themselves, but through human
sign or symbol, such as a particular weapon or birthmark,
error. He outlines a few of the major tragic characters, such as
reveal information about a character and cause the
Oedipus and Telephus, and explains that most of the best
recognition. Aristotle argues that recognition in the form of a
tragedies are written about them.
character revealing information because the poet needs it
revealed, and not as a natural progression of the plot, is also
Chapter 14 artless. A third kind of recognition occurs when an object or
experience wakes a feeling in the character. The fourth type of
While pity and fear can be created through the acting and recognition comes about through a process of reasoning. The
production of a tragedy, Aristotle argues that a good poet can best type of recognition, Aristotle insists, is the realization that
create those feelings through the construction of the plot. He occurs through the natural development of events within the
then details the types of actions or situations that cause plot.
people to experience feelings of fear or pity. These feelings
are created, he claims, when a tragic accident happens to
people who have a close relationship—such as a family Analysis
member killing another family member. When such a situation
is set up with "skillful handling," it should incite strong feelings Aristotle makes the case that a tragic plot must not be over
of horror and sympathy in the audience. To handle the tragic simplified, or it will not have the desired effect on the audience.
situation skillfully, the action may be done with conscious Complexity and characters who are relatable and make human
understanding of the relationship between the characters (a errors, as opposed to characters who are without fault or who
mother knowingly murdering her children). There is also the are completely evil, have the power to move an audience.
option that the action may be committed without knowledge of Interestingly, Aristotle classifies "women and slaves" as lower
the relationship, with understanding dawning after the deed is forms of beings to whom certain characteristics such as "valor"
done (Oedipus unknowingly murdering his father). should not be applied, because they would not be believable.
Yet many of the plays he references do contain principal
female characters.
Pity and fear are central concepts to the tragic form, and
generally Aristotle seems to hold the opinion that the goal of complex, the pathetic, the ethical, and the simple. The
tragedy is to awaken these emotions in the reader and that this complex, as discussed in previous chapters, uses both the
should be done through an organic development of events. No reversal and recognition plot devices. In the pathetic the
other emotions seem as integral to the tragic form, and it motive is passion, and in the ethical the motive is
seems that fear and pity must always follow an order: first the correspondingly ethical. The simple type uses only one of the
audience feels fear or horror, and then in the final tragic scene two plot devices.
this fear turns to pity.
Aristotle tells the reader that the poet should not try to make
Aristotle references characters from popular plays to support an epic poem into a tragedy. An epic poem has multiple parts,
his opinions about tragedy. Specifically, in Chapter 14 he whereas a tragedy focuses on one plot thread. Aristotle gives
mentions that "Clytemnestra was slain by Orestes and Eriphyle the example of how an unsuccessful tragedy might try to tell
by Alcmaeon." The two plays he's referring to here are the entire story of the entire Iliad, as opposed to just the Fall of
Aeschylus's "Oresteia" and a work that presumably was written Troy.
by Euripides but that no longer exists. Both are examples of
matricide. Aristotle briefly touches on the subject of the chorus,
mentioning that it should be thought of as an actor in the play,
integral to the plot, and not as unrelated interludes.
Chapters 17–19
Chapter 19
Summary Chapter 19 expounds on two of the six parts of tragedy: diction
and thought. Thought encompasses the areas of proof and
refutation, the inspiring of different emotions, and the
Chapter 17 suggestion of importance. Thought pertains mostly to speech
and not the parts of the plot conveyed through action or other
Aristotle discusses the importance of working out the technical means.
details of the acting and setting of any play very carefully. It is
the job of the poet, he explains, to make sure that the whole Diction is the breakdown of how speech is delivered. Aristotle
setting is clear and can be seen in its entirety by the audience. gives examples such as command, prayer, statement, threat,
The poet must also pay attention to the gestures of the and question to illustrate how diction is employed.
characters and make sure that the emotions the actors portray
are natural and realistic.
Analysis
The second part of the chapter describes how the poet should
approach the creation of the plot. A general outline should be One of Aristotle's chief concerns seems to be the natural and
made first, and then the details filled in afterward. After the organic development of the plot. This notion comes back in
outline, what is filled in is called the "episodes," or the actual these chapters multiple times and is connected to the
detailed scenes of the play. audience's response to the tragic play. Aristotle argues that
the plot must develop organically and that the characters'
motives and emotions must be conveyed believably through
Chapter 18 diction and acting.
According to Aristotle, the overall structure of a tragedy can be He also stresses repeatedly the importance of including
classified as the complication and the unravelling. The certain elements in the creation of the tragic plot and also
complication is everything leading up to the climax, whereas insists that a specific order of development be followed when
the unravelling, or denouement, is the rest. the poet writes the tragedy. Many of these ideas are
expansions on ideas that have been discussed repeatedly in
He then goes on to delineate the four types of tragedy: the
earlier chapters.
Summary
Analysis
Chapter 20 These three chapters are slightly tangential to the core topic
of tragic and epic poetry. Aristotle focuses more on the micro
This chapter is likely an aside and focuses primarily on the elements of language and their workings before zooming back
basic elements of language. Aristotle begins with the concept out to poetry. He concerns himself with how language works
of a letter, which he defines as a single sound grouped with on an elementary level to create certain effects in poetry.
other sounds to form syllables and words. He explains
syllables as consonants, or mutes, grouped with a vowel to True to many of Aristotle's other works in classification,
form a single sound. The chapter continues to describe Chapter 20 delves into a method of deconstructing language
connecting words, verbs, and nouns. Sentences and phrases into its most basic elements. Aristotle classifies the "letter" as
are explained as groups of words that contain significant an "indivisible sound, yet not every such sound, but only one
meaning. which can form part of a group of sounds." Letters are the
building blocks of syllables, which in turn are used to build
connecting words, nouns, and verbs, and these build
sentences. Although this chapter is only fragmentary and
probably doesn't impart more than a glimpse of Aristotle's
ideas about linguistic classification, it is an interesting insight
Metaphor is another focal point, and Aristotle gives many Epic poetry is also set apart from tragedy in its length and
examples from Greek texts to illustrate the different ways his scale, which is much longer and broader. It is possible for epic
definition of metaphor can be understood. Aristotle's concept poems to take on events of a much larger scale over a longer
of metaphor seems to be relatively broad and sometimes timespan because they do not have to be conveyed by actors
extends to other literary devices. For instance, he gives the on a stage within a certain timeframe.
example "'Verily ten thousand noble deeds hath Odysseus
wrought'" and calls this a type of metaphor, explaining that "ten Epic poetry also uses heroic meter, whereas tragedy can use a
thousand is a species of large number, and is here used for a variety of meters and aims for a naturalness of speaking.
large number generally." This would be classified in Additionally, Aristotle introduces the idea that epic poetry
contemporary language as hyperbole and not as metaphor. employs the irrational with good effect. Tragedies, he argues,
deal with the wonderful but should leave out the irrational.
Aristotle again mentions the word propriety, but this time he is
referring to a tasteful use of metaphor and unusual language in
a poem, instead of the broader concept of assigning believable Analysis
qualities to certain classes or types of character.
Aristotle continues to laud Homer's writing in these chapters
and uses his Iliad and Odyssey as prime examples of the epic
Chapters 23–24 poem. Within the parameters that Aristotle sets for a
successful epic, The Iliad and The Odyssey work because they
focus on many events that surround one central idea—in the
case of The Odyssey, for example, the story follows
Summary Odysseus's journey and the events surrounding it.
Aristotle also mentions two epics called The Cypria and The
Chapter 23 Little Iliad in comparison to Homer's texts. These two epics are
presumed to have been written around the 7th century BCE,
The topic shifts away from the tragic to epic poetry in this
and they seem to have been well known in Aristotle's time and
chapter. According to Aristotle, epic poetry should follow the
earlier. However, they have been almost completely lost in the
same dramatic principles as tragedy. More specifically, it
time since, and only a handful of lines survive from either. All
should be constructed of a beginning, middle, and end, and the
that is known about both epics has been reconstructed from
plot must be unified. Epic poetry differs from historical writing
references in texts like Poetics, and the surviving lines are
in that the focus of epic poetry is the single action, whereas
those quoted by other authors.
historical writing deals with one time period.
Aristotle argues that epic poetry is freed from much of the
Aristotle illustrates the structure of an epic poem through
constraints of tragedy because it is not expected to be
Homer's handling of the war of Troy. Homer writes about the
performed on stage. Epic poems, therefore, are capable of
war within certain parameters, and he does not try to
handling complex stories over long timespans and can still
encompass the entire war in his epic. Rather, he chooses a
have the power to move the audience. Tragedies face more
single part of the war and writes about multiple episodes that
limitations because they need to translate to the stage, and
take place within that part.
many scenes used in epic poems would look ludicrous if
enacted on stage.
Chapter 24
Epic poetry is similar to tragedy in its requirements of situation
reversal, recognitions, and a need for general unity of plot. It
does not, however, incorporate song and acting or
These are the three ways that poetry may represent humans: reasonable amount of time.
tragedy usually represents them as better and comedy as
worse.
"Beauty depends on magnitude
representing action."
Aristotle argues that something must have a certain
— Narrator, Chapter 3 magnitude, or importance, to be beautiful.
— Narrator, Chapter 8
"Objects which in themselves we
view with pain, we delight to Aristotle explains that having a single protagonist isn't enough
to create a unified plot because the span of a single person's
contemplate when reproduced life and experiences is far too long and complex to create a
single plot.
with minute fidelity."
— Narrator, Chapter 4
"Poetry tends to express the
Here Aristotle discusses the role of imitation in art and how
universal, history the particular."
something that could repulse us in real life (such as a dead
body) could be rendered beautiful through art. — Narrator, Chapter 9
This quotation refers to the plot device of "recognition," which The "they" in this quote are the "good portrait-painters."
is a character having a revelation about his or her relationship Aristotle uses this comparison to explain why imitation works
to another character or some information that has been powerfully in poetry as well as in painting or visual art.
previously unknown or withheld. This device is important in the
tragic plot.
"Poetry implies either a happy gift
— Narrator, Chapter 15
m Glossary
denouement (n) in a story, the part of the plot that follows the
climax and resolves the conflict
hexameter (n) in poetic meter, a line with six feet (the basic
unit of syllabic combinations in poetic meter)
mimesis (n) a Greek term meaning "to imitate" and often used
in the context of philosophy