Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Submitted to
Directorate of Environment & Climate Change
Government of Kerala
December 2015
Managed by
3
4
Table of Contents
5
List of Tables
List of Figures
Figure 1: Sea Level rise along the Indian coast line between 1993 and 2012 ........................ 13
Figure 2: Climate sensitivity of the Kerala Coast ..................................................................... 15
Figure 3: (a) Trends of coastal fish catch from 2006-07 to 2012-13; (b) Trends of landing of
different types of fish across the Kerala Coast ........................................................................ 18
Figure 4: (a) Rice and (b) Coconut production trends in coastal districts of Kerala ............... 20
Figure 5: Institutions managing coastal fisheries in Kerala ..................................................... 23
Figure 6: Agencies governing rice cultivation in coastal Kerala .............................................. 24
Figure 7: Drivers affecting coastal Fisheries in Kerala ............................................................. 26
Figure 8: Multiple drivers impacting coastal rice cultivation .................................................. 31
Figure 9: Schematic diagram of an integrated approach to climate change adaptation in
estuarine-wetland paddy/aquaculture system ....................................................................... 41
6
Abbreviations and Acronyms
ADAK Agency for Development of Aquaculture, Kerala
AGCM Atmospheric General Circulation Models
AIS Automatic Identification System
AVHRR Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer
CATP Catchment Area Treatment Plants
CC Climate Change
CCIP Climate Change Innovation Programme
CDB Coconut Development Board
CMFRI Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute
CPD&M Centre for Product Design & Manufacturing
CRZ Coastal Regulation Zone
CSES Centre for Socio economic and Environmental Studies
CST Centre for Sustainable Technologies
CVI Coastal Vulnerability Index
DFID Department for International Development
DoA Department of Agriculture
DoECC Directorate of Environment and Climate Change
EMI Equated Monthly Instalment
FPO Farmer Producer Organisation
GCM Global Climate Model
GDP Gross Domestic Product
GHG Green House Gas
GoI Government of India
GoK Government of Kerala
GPS Global Positioning System
HIV Human Immunodeficiency Virus
HYV High Yielding Variety
ICSD Inter Cooperation Social Development
ICT Information Communications and Technology
IISc Indian Institute of Science
IIT Indian Institute of Technology
IMD Indian Meteorological Department
IORA Indian Ocean Rim Association
KAU Kerala Agriculture University
KSCDCL Kerala State Coastal Development Corporation Limited
KSHB Kerala State Housing Board
KUFOS Kerala University of Fisheries and Ocean Studies
LRPE Long Range Planning Exercise
MDDT Multi-disciplinary Diagnostic Team
MGNREGA Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act
MNAIS Modified National Agriculture Insurance Scheme
MODIS Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer
MoEF&CC Ministry for Environment Forest and Climate Change
MRI Meteorological Research Institute
7
MSL Mean Sea Level
MWM Municipal Waste Management
NABARD National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development
NCSCM National Centre for Sustainable Coastal Management
NDMA National Disaster Management Authority
NGO Non-Government Organisation
NIFAM National Institute of Fisheries Administration and Management
PRECIS Providing Regional Climates for Impact Studies
RKVY Rashtriya Krishi Vikas Yojana
SAF Society for Assistance to Fisherwoman
SAPCC State Action Plan on Climate Change
SEWA Self Employed Women’s Association
SHG Self-Help Group
SICOM Society for Integrated Coastal Management
SKYMET Weather monitoring and Agri-risk solutions private company
SLR Sea Level Rise
SMS Short Message Service
SPO Small Producers Organisation
SRI System of Rice Intensification
SST Sea Surface Temperature
STP Sewage Treatment Plant
UK United Kingdom
WBCIS Weather Based Crop Insurance Scheme
WP Work Plan
WW Waste Water
8
Executive Summary
This report1 is primarily based on a desk-based study with the main objective of producing a
policy brief highlighting two main areas:
1. An assessment of the policies that are likely to be reformed and/or improved by
having evidence of coastal vulnerability to Climate Change and the relative value of
the evidence; and
2. A preliminary assessment of vulnerability, based on existing evidence, and an
identification of the main steps needed to fill the gaps, taking into account the first
activity.
The report provides an overview of coastal vulnerability and to identify issues for further in
depth assessment, it is supplemented with limited number of discussions with key
stakeholders in government, academic and members of NGOs.
Kerala's current conditions and expected climate change would expose the narrow coastal
strip and its inhabitants to heightened vulnerabilities. Agriculture, fisheries, and mining for
minerals and sand are some of the major economic activities carried out by the people living
in this coastal tract. A large chunk of these inhabitants are the poor and marginalised groups
of artisanal fisher households. Their livelihoods are threatened from the overharvesting of
natural resources, pollution, habitat destruction, invasive species, and climate change.
Projected sea level rise and the collapse of commercial fisheries are putting food supplies and
coastal areas at risk, potentially leading to economic and social upheaval. Moreover, they have
limited access to healthcare and public services and therefore, extremely hard for them to
adaptations. Therefore, in order to address adaptation strategies and adjustment of coastal
management policies to changing circumstances, the report scanned through the policies
governing the coastal systems through a climate change lens.
Fisheries, agriculture and mining for minerals and sand are some of the major economic
activities carried out by the people living in this coastal tract. Considering that multiple drivers
affecting coastal fisheries, the policies that have been analysed are therefore directly or
indirectly supporting the health of the Marine Fisheries in the State. From the policies specific
elements is addressed with suggested approaches and action plans. The analysis has identified
12 elements and has suggested 25 adaptation actions. Agricultural policy encompasses, all
aspects of agriculture including policies on land use, water, soil health, crop husbandry, seeds
and planting material, fertilizer and plant nutrition, pesticides, value addition and processing
of agriculture produce, high tech farming, agriculture intelligence and marketing, minimum
support prices for promoting certain produces, income assurance, crop insurance and credit
policy, and policy on farm producer organisations. It also discusses Climate Change as a key
driver which has the possibility of changing the nature of agriculture in the State. Some of the
salient policy issues have been analysed and gaps identified vis a vis the issue of tackling
climate change. Since coconut continue to be a significant economic driver in Kerala, and since
coconut productivity is more vulnerable to climate variability such as summer droughts rather
1
The report is prepared for ACT by Mr D. Nandakumar (Ph.D) and Ms Sumana Bhattacharya (Ph.D) of Intercooperation Social Development
India (ICSD).
9
than climate change in terms of increase in temperature and decline in rainfall, policies that
are relevant to coconut in terms of climate are analysed.
Our assessment of policies managing the key economic drivers of the coastal Kerala and
vulnerabilities suggest the way forward within the context of the extent of climate gaps and
propose a few long term activities. Some of the proposed activities can even be aligned to
CCIPs work streams identified through the Long Range Planning Exercise (LRPE). Finally, an
integrated approach plan is proposed with a box of activities to ensure sustainability of
estuarine fisheries and wetland rice cultivation is briefly explained.
10
1. The Kerala Coast and its Vulnerabilities
Kerala, the southernmost state of the country lies at the extreme South-West of the Indian
peninsula (between 8o17’and 12o47’N latitudes and 74o52’ and 77o24’ E longitude). It
covers a geographic area of 38,863 km2. On the west is the Arabian sea along its 587.8 km
long coast line2 and in the eastern side of the state lie the mountains of the Western Ghats.
Kerala is divided into highland, midland and lowland. The lowland is the so called Coastal
area, covering 8% of the total geographical area of the state with a density of 2,740 people
per fishing village.3
The coastal area in Kerala comprises of a unique ecosystem - short continental shelf, sandy
beaches, and extensive backwaters having an interface of upstream fresh water system
with brackish water from the sea, chakara formations (mud aggregation) and below Mean
Sea Level (MSL) agriculture system. It is drained by 41 west flowing rivers coming from the
highlands, and flowing through midlands and into the Arabian sea. Elevation of this area
is less than 7.5 m above sea level, however, deltaic areas at river mouths and reclaimed
backwaters are generally at sea level or 1.0 to 1.5 m below MSL. It is dotted by sandy
beaches, mud flats (chakara), mangroves, extensive backwater network having an
interface of upstream fresh water system with brackish water from the sea and estuaries.
Agriculture, fisheries, and mining for minerals and sand are some of the major economic
activities carried out by the people living in this coastal tract.
2 Ramesh R, Purvaraja R and Senthil Vel A. Shoreline Change Assessment for Kerala Coast. National Centre for Sustainable
Coastal Management (NCSCM), Society for Integrated Coastal Management (SICOM) and Ministry for Environment Forest
and Climate Change (MoEF&CC), Government of India.
3 GOI 2010. Marine fisheries census 2010 Kerala, Part II (6). Govt. of India, Ministry of Agriculture, Dept. of Animal
Husbandry, Dairying & Fisheries and Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute, Indian Council of Agricultural Research,
New Delhi, p. 33-48.
4 DFID, 2004. The impact of climate change on the vulnerability of the poor. Key Sheet. Global and Local Environment
Team, Policy Division, DFID, UK.
5 A large chunk of these inhabitants are the poor and marginalised groups of artisanal fisher households. They have
limited access to healthcare and public services and therefore, extremely hard for them to adaptations.
11
precipitation events and extreme drought conditions. Fishing communities are affected by
multiple anthropogenic factors, where climate change is just one of it.
All these affect the entire resource base on which the society is dependent and manifest
differentially across different sections of the populace. It needs to be recognized that the
marginalized sections of the coastal populations, particularly traditional and small scale
fishing communities are much more vulnerable to climate change and they are the primary
vulnerable group. In coastal Kerala, subsistence resources form a large part of people's
life.
A major study was commissioned by the State government in 2007-08 to assess the
vulnerability of the Kerala coast-line. The study was conducted by IIT, Madras and was
funded by the Planning Commission of India under the Tsunami Rehabilitation
Programme. It was noted that how construction of sea-walls indiscriminately is not the
panacea to face disasters from the sea. First, the cost of construction is prohibitive as is
the cost of maintenance. Second, studies have established how constructing a sea-wall in
one area could cause uncalled for repercussions in other parts of the coast. The study,
therefore, recommended a well-considered and scientific mix of civil works and bio-
interventions through planting of mangroves, casuarina, etc. The study mapped the
specific areas that are prone to erosion and those that are experiencing accretion 6.
It is to be noted here that Kerala has a well-established local governance system, and
therefore all climate change adaptation policies need to be integrated within the
governance so as to be successfully implemented all across the coastal region.
Since it is well documented that adaptation to climate change can greatly reduce the
impact of sea-level rise and related coastal changes, it is therefore desirable to address
adaptation strategies and adjustment of coastal management policies to changing
circumstances. Therefore, it is important to scan the policies governing the coastal
systems through a climate change lens in order to build resilience of the most
marginalised coastal communities as well.
This document therefore scans all the policies related to the various economic activities
that would enable climate resilient adaptation in coastal areas through appropriate
responses including governance. For doing so it goes through the literature to ascertain
the extent of climate sensitivity of the coast to present climate trends, future projections,
associated vulnerabilities of key economic activities and associated livelihoods.
6 Sunder V and Murali K. 2007. Planning of Coastal Protection Measures along Kerala Coast - Final Report submitted to Govt
of Kerala. Department of Ocean Engineering. IIT Madras, Chennai
12
2. Climate Sensitivity of the Coast
2.1 Changing trends of Rainfall and Temperature
Rainfall in Kerala varies from 1016 mm to 7620 mm. Temperature ranges between 23.9 oC
and 37.7oC in plains and 10.0 oC to 32.2 oC in the hills. Current observations published by
the IMD7 indicates that between 1951 and 2010, climate parameters have changed. Mean
annual temperatures have risen by 0.01oC/year and the mean annual rainfall has
decreased by 1.43 mm/year. Increasingly, Kerala is experiencing more number of dry days8
and as a result parts of Kerala are becoming vulnerable to drought with direct implications
on its resources and economy associated with agriculture.
13
Altimeter data9 analysis over the 1993–2012 period reveals that the rate of sea-level rise
along the Kerala coast is close to global mean sea-level-rise trend (3.2 mm per year)
estimated over the same period. These recent trends derived from altimeter data are
higher than those estimated from tide-gauge records over longer periods during the 20th
century which peg the sea level rise at 1.81 mm per year10.
9 Altimeter data from TOPEX/Poseidon, Jason-1 and 2 combined observations were processed and redistributed as monthly
mean sea-level anomalies with respect to the seasonal cycle.
10 Unnikrishnan A S, A. G. Nidheesh And M. Lengaigne. 2015. Sea-Level-Rise Trends Off The Indian Coasts During The Last
Two Decades. Current science, vol. 108, no. 966 5, 10 march 2015.
11 Abhiya A M, S Minu, and Ramachandran. 2015. Salient Long-Term Observations of SST along Kerala Coast and Its
Comparative Variation with Lakshadweep Coast. Science Direct. Aquatic Procedia 4 (2015 ) 556 – 562.
12 National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA), 2008. Management of Cyclones. National Disaster Management
Authority, GoI
http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INDIAEXTN/Resources/295583-1110791780048/annx-hazards-tsu-na-32005.pdf
14 GoK, 2013. Draft Agriculture Development Policy.
14
Figure 2: Climate sensitivity of the Kerala Coast
15
3. Climate Change Projections
Rainfall projections made using Providing Regional Climates for Impact Studies (PRECIS), a
regional model having 50km x 50km spatial resolution indicates that by 2050s, Kerala
coastal areas would experience increase in annual precipitation by 10-20 per cent with
respect to base line which is the average of annual precipitation between 1961-1990. The
annual temperature is likely to increase by 1.49oC to 1.7oC by 2050s15. District wise
projections are presented in Table 2. Recent studies8 suggest that it is very likely that the
number of extreme warm days are likely to increase all over India, including Kerala.
There is a marked decrease in annual precipitation projected in the 2050s in the northern
districts of Kasaragod, Kannur, Wayanad (see table 2). Recent high resolution modelling
(20km mesh GCM (MRI–AGCM3.2S)) studies17 indicate an overall decrease in monsoon
rainfall by 10-15% in Kerala in keeping with the observed trends. Intensification of extreme
precipitation is projected all over India, but an opposite effect is projected for the western
coast including Kerala. Over the west coast, the drastic reduction of vertical ascent and
weakening of circulation due to upper tropospheric warming effect predominate over the
moisture build-up effect (that causes enhanced rainfall over other parts) in reducing the
rainfall.
15 State Action Plan on Climate Change, Department of Environment and Climate Change, Government of Kerala
16
Gyhathakurta and Rajeevan, 2008. Trends in rainfall pattern over India, Int. Journal of Climatology, 28: 1453–1469.
17 Rajendran K, S. Sajani, C. B. Jayasankarand A. Kitoh. 2013. How dependent is climate change projection of Indian summer
monsoon rainfall and extreme events on model resolution? Current science, vol. 104, no. 10, 25 May 2013.
16
The sea level will continue to rise at the rate of 3.2mm/year and this rate is entirely
dependent on the rate of melting of the glaciers across the world. Some areas across the
coast that are subsiding will encounter flooding due to sea level rise. No direct conclusive
relationship has been established between rise in cyclonic activity with rise in
temperature in the North Indian Ocean, including the Arabian sea bordering south
western part of India.
17
4. The Main Economic drivers of the Coastal Kerala
Fisheries and Agriculture together form the key economic activities of the state that supports
the income of almost half the population in the Coastal region.
Estimated coastal Fishery potential of the state is 5.17 lakh tonnes, which is an aggregate
of pelagic fish, crustaceans, demersals, molluscs and others. Between 2006-07 and 2012-
13, the coastal fisheries sector constitutes of 1.46% of the state GDP. About 31.4% of the
fish catch is exported and the rest consumed domestically in 2012-13. Coastal fisheries
provides livelihood to 0.775 million families across the coast. Of these 55% of families are
below poverty line. Among the 9 coastal districts, the largest proportion of fisher families
below poverty line are in Kasaragod (70%) and Kannur (68%).
In recent years, Kerala has seen an 11% decline in its total fish catch (see Figure 3). Since
2009-2010, Kerala lost its position as the leading producer of marine fish in the country
to Gujarat19. The declining trend is due to declining trend in catch of all types of fish along
the Kerala coast (See Figure 3).
Figure 3: (a) Trends of coastal fish catch from 2006-07 to 2012-13; (b) Trends of landing of
different types of fish across the Kerala Coast
0.00
2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13
18 http://www.fisheries.kerala.gov.in
19 Planning Commission. 2012. Report of the Working Group on Development and Management of Fisheries and Aquaculture.
XIIth Five-Year Plan (2012-2017). GoI, New Delhi.
18
Fish catch in Kerala (million tons)
0.62
0.59806
0.60 0.58628 0.58315
0.58 0.570013
0.560398
0.56 0.553177
0.54 0.530638
0.52
0.50
0.48
2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13
Source of Fig 3a and b : Kerala marine Fisheries Statistics, 2013 and Marine Fisheries Census- Kerala, 2010.
Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute, Kochi. Department of Animal Husbandry, Dairy and Fisheries;
Ministry of Agriculture, GoI
Among the maritime states in India, Kerala has the maximum variety of fishing craft-gear
combinations in use. This richness is due to variety of factors - the high diversity in fish
species, their seasonality, diverse geomorphology of the coast and heterogeneous
oceanographic conditions20. In 2010, Kerala had 21,781 crafts, of which 4,722 were
mechanized, 11,175 motorised and 5884 were non-motorized21,22,23. Between 1973 and
2010, there has been almost 5 times increase in mechanised crafts; no motorised boats
existed in 1973. Today there are less than 30% of the crafts that are non-motorised. This
sudden increase exerted demand for infrastructure development, particularly for fishing
harbours and landing centres.
Among various infrastructure built along harbours, are the landing centres and the ice-
plants which would help store the catch which otherwise would perish fast. Scanning
through various reports and newspaper clippings revealed that none of these ice plants
are functional and fishers are buying ice from private owned ice-plants situated in the
proximity of the fishery harbours.
4.2 Agriculture
The agriculture scenario in Coastal Kerala is dominated by rice and coconut cultivation.
4.2.1 Rice
The low lying coastal area is abundant with submerged wet lands and are suitable for
cultivation of rice in the state. It produces around 0.25 to 0.35 million tons of rice which
amounts to 50-55% of the total rice production of the State. Figure 4 below gives the
trends of rice production between 2003-04 to 2011-12. A clear declining trend is seen
20 Protsahan. 2004. A Status Paper 2003-2004 on Fishery Harbours: Performance, Issues and Management Concerns.
Thiruvananthapuram.
21 Sathiadhas, R and Raghu, R and Kanakkan, A and Harshan. N K , Marine fish production and export marketing trend in Kerala
- an economic analysis. In: Marine Fisheries Research and Management Pillai V N and Menon, N G,(eds.) CMFRI; Kochi,
Kochi, pp. 876-894. 2000.
22 CMFRI, Marine Fisheries Census, 2010,
23 Directorate of Fisheries, Government of Kerala (2003).
19
with some inter-annual variability in between. This area is subjected to tidal actions or
sea level rise. Area under rice is declining (11% of cropped area in 1990-91 to <4% in 2009-
10), as this land is increasingly being diverted to other cash crops or for housing or other
developments. The trend of area under rice since 1955-till 2010 is shown in figure 4a.
Labour crunch is another issue which results in low area under production. As a result,
production of rice is less than what is required. The estimated requirement of rice in the
state is 35-40 lakhs tons/year however, actual production is 7-8 lakh tons/year. Currently,
91 per cent of the area is under High Yielding Variety (HYV) but the state is not able to
meet the requirement. As a result the deficit amount is procured from Andhra Pradesh
and other nearby states. Irrigation projects in the region have remained incomplete for
decades and this therefore the required water is not available, and the problem is likely
to exacerbate with further changes in climate as drought like situations set in.
Figure 4: (a) Rice24 and (b) Coconut25 production trends in coastal districts of Kerala
million nuts
7000 6054 5941
5641 5802 5667
6000 5287
5000
4000
3000 2026
2000
1000
0
1950-51 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
24 Department of Agriculture (2013). Facts and Figures of Agriculture in Kerala, 2013. Department of Agriculture (DoA),
Gov of Kerala.
25 Coconut Development Board (2013) Concurrent estimation of coconut production in Kerala 2012-13.
20
4.2.2 Coconut
Coconuts are cultivated on nearly 8 lakh ha of land in homesteads along the coast line and
produced 4,886 million nuts in 2014-1526. Predominantly it is grown in small and marginal
holdings. Till a decade ago, coconut trees and coconuts played a vital role in the everyday
life and economy of the state. There was a time when coconuts were traded by
householders for every day provision procuring and the trees acted as bank guarantee for
accessing loans. The produce provides raw material support for the traditional industries
of coir and oil milling and accounts for about 17.29 per cent of the agricultural income of
the state (2008-09). The yield per ha in Kerala was 4,948 nuts in 1950-51 and in 2014-15
it grew to 6,042 nuts per hectare. In between higher yields upto 8,000 per ha also have
been achieved. Decline in production is happening in the districts of Idukki, Kottayam, and
Kollam and a significant increase in yield was found in Alleppey (Alappuzha in Malayalam).
Kozhikode is the highest coconut producing district in the state followed by Malappuram.
Alleppey is the nerve centre of Kerala's famous Coir Industry. Here, one can see coconut
husks being beaten into fibre for making floor mats and other coir products. Both men
and women are actively involved in the production of Coir. The women are mainly
involved in the yarn spinning sector and the men in the product-weaving sector. Coir
Industry enjoys the status as the largest cottage Industry in the state of Kerala, giving
employment to over a million people.
26 http://www.coconutboard.nic.in/stat.htm
21
5. Institutions involved in management of coastal fisheries and rice
cultivation systems in Kerala
5.1 Coastal Fisheries
The institutions supporting fisheries operation in the state are listed below as their
functions:
22
Figure 5: Institutions managing coastal fisheries in Kerala
23
Sl.No. Institutions Functions
5.3 Coconut
Coconut production and coir together are an integral part of the entire coconut
production and related scenario in Kerala. The Coconut Development Board (CDB) is a
statutory body established under the Ministry of Agriculture, Government of India for the
integrated development of coconut cultivation and industry in the country with focus on
productivity increase and product diversification. Various research institutions are there
in Kerala that are focussing on coconut research. The Coconut Board is looking after the
development and marketing of coir products which find numerous use in homes, offices,
gardens, water bodies, fencing, and acoustics.
24
6. Analysing policies governing fisheries and agriculture through a
climate change lens
6.1 Coastal Fisheries
Rising Sea Surface Temperature (SST), storm surges, sea level rise are the drivers that
could change the fishery profile of the state along its coasts. Most fish species can survive
within a narrow range of temperature which is related to their basic metabolism and
availability of food organism. Already some discernible changes have been observed,
namely
o Changes in species composition of phytoplankton at higher temperature in the seas;
o An extension of distributional boundary of small pelagic fish;
o Pelagic fish are now available at deeper waters;
o Phenological changes are occurring amongst pelagic fish; and
o In the estuaries, due to warming of the sea surface, the warm water enters the
backwaters. Coastal waters are getting infested with jelly fish thus limiting crustacean
production27 (prawns and other crustaceans) within backwaters.
With continued rise in SST, some of the long term changes expected are:
o Changes in oceanographic settings may affect fish stocks;
o Shift to higher latitudes if the SST increases in the southern latitudes beyond the
physiological optimum of the fish, and if other oceanographic variables also change
unfavourably;
o Likely entry of species from equatorial regions.
The changing climate along with continued heavy use of pesticides in the upstream
catchments of the rivers that feed into the wetland ecosystem, inappropriate disposal of
waste from back water tourism into the back waters and destruction of mangroves are the
other drives that are changing the pattern of crustacean catch and other types of fish that
have their nurseries in the backwaters and estuaries. Therefore, maintaining the health of
the backwater and estuaries is also of utmost importance. Figure below indicates the
drivers of coastal fisheries that are a function of the marine environment, the beaches,
backwaters, and the communities that survive on this resource.
27 Bijukumar A. (undated). Coastal Environment and Biodiversity Conservation in Kerala in the Context of Climate Change.
Paper documents the impacts of climate change on the coastal and marine ecosystems of Kerala and proposes strategies
and action plans for adaption and mitigation while finalizing State Action Plan on Climate Change (SAPCC).
25
Figure 7: Drivers affecting coastal Fisheries in Kerala
Considering that multiple drivers are affecting coastal fisheries, the policies that have been
analysed are therefore directly or indirectly supporting the health of the Marine Fisheries in
the state. From the policies specific elements is addressed with suggested approached and
action plans. The analysis has identified 12 elements and has suggested 25 adaptation actions.
The summary of the policies analysed supporting the health of the Marine Fisheries in Kerala
is as given:
An analysis of policies through a climate change lens is presented below for the coastal
fisheries sector.
26
Table 3: Analysis of policies governing Fisheries and Coastal sector in Kerala through
the climate change lens
27
1. Fisheries Sector Development Conservation Policy, 2004
Key Policy Suggested Approach Suggested Climate Adaptation actions
Element
To maintain fish Conservation and 11. Scenarios of future sea level rise, cyclone
landing centres protection of fish landing intensities, probable height of storm surges need
(61) and fish centres vis a vis enhanced to be factored in to the location and design of the
harbours (13) as impacts of climate change fish landing centres and the harbours.
per the not yet factored in. 12. Further, remove existing sea walls and plant
international protective vegetation and reserve the adjacent
Standards beach as buffer for dissipating energy from storm
(Policy 6 page 9) surges.
Stop fishery in Monsoon onset and 13. All fishers should subscribe to weather forecasts
monsoon (Policy 1 cessation not through SMS
page 1) synchronised with actual 14. Strict regulation to disallow any fishing boats to
5-7 day forecasts. exploit the coastal marine waters, and brackish
waters and estuaries. Alternative livelihood
opportunities to compensate for loss of income
during these months should be factored in
Motorisation of It is important to address 15. Renewable energy sources can be tapped such as
traditional crafts the drivers of climate replacing with wind/solar energy, using hydrogen
(Policy 2 page3) change which shape the as fuel, or mixing biofuel with fossil fuel.
vulnerability of the fisher
folk- in this case emission
from motorised fossil fuel
driven crafts.
The Central Government, with a Consult with coastal 1. All efforts should be taken to
view to ensure livelihood communities to seek their consult with the coastal
security to the fisher views on the perceived communities and their
communities and other local impact of climate change, perspectives to be inclusive in
communities, living in the and the sort of responses action plans.
coastal areas, to conserve and that are needed.
protect coastal stretches, its Take into account socio-economic
unique environment and its and other fisheries and non-
marine area and to promote fisheries factors that are locally
development through
28
2. Coastal Regulation Zone Notification, 2011
Key Policy Element Suggested Approach Suggested Climate Adaptation
actions
Area upto 200m to 500m, The housing of fishers also 2. Develop policy framework for re-
construction or reconstruction need to be modified or situating land uses that may
of dwelling units allowed upto a relocated vis a vis the become unsafe or unsuitable in the
height of 9m rising sea level and future. Also develop building
(Page 20) expected higher cyclone standards that can withstand the
frequencies and storm exacerbated situation in a
surges. changing climate scenarios. Land
acquisition of the landward side of
the current dwelling units of
communities living close to the
beach and moving them back may
be factored in.
Environment 1. This does not include fuel spillage 1. Regular monitoring of houseboat
friendly practices into the backwater that spoils the engines and fuel tanks to avoid spillage;
promoted for the environment in the estuaries. fined if detected. Replace all by
backwater and renewables.
other water body
2. Also does not talk about how the 2. Lay out packages of practices that will
tourism
Municipal Social Waste (MSW) ensure MSW and WW management in
(Policy 5.6; Page 7)
and Waste Water (WW) such a way so as to avoid the pollution of
management will be ensured. backwaters.
3. The lighting and other operations 3. The entire operation can be replaced by
in the houseboats are done using renewable energy sources- A study on
diesel the potential of renewable energy use in
the tourism boats can be carried out.
29
4. Environment Policy, 2009
Conservation of Mangroves are the first line of 1. The privately owned mangrove areas
existing mangroves defence from sea level rise, need to be conserved as well and
and restoration cyclones and storm surges. therefore demarcated. Compensation
wherever possible Therefore conservation and for the same may be made to the
through enacting protection of these areas is most owners; like payment for ecosystem
appropriate important. services might be devised here as well.
legislative measures
(Policy 6.4.3; Page 14) The extent of mangrove in Kerala
is 2502 ha out of which 1189 ha
belongs to the state (it is under
conservation) and 1313 ha is
under private ownership.
Mangrove ownership per person
at less than 1 ha can be sold by the
owners.
Prevention of coastal Illegal and clandestine sand 2. Strict enforcement of existing laws,
and riverbank erosion mining continue to erode coast, capacity building of local bodies to
by means of, as far as backwaters and river banks. strategies prevention of illegal mining;
possible, biological Enhance community based coastal
methods. protection/ management.
(Policy 9.2; Page 18)
30
6. Disaster management Policy, 2010
Strengthen the Because of new hi-tech fishery 1. Ascertain areas where women can also
capacities and and high value markets available, access resources and strengthen their
resilience of women have been side lined in resilience. Some of them can be –
vulnerable the entire value chain. women’s participation to be made
communities with mandatory in governance and
special emphasis on management of fishery businesses.
empowerment of Incentivising women to become
women and establish entrepreneurs in fishery businesses.
community level
During extreme weather events 2. Develop community/ cooperative based
systems (Objective 4;
which may continue for several micro-insurance to compensate for
Page 2)
days, earnings of fishers and earnings during these periods,
particularly women in fisheries
are affected
31
In 2013, the Government of Kerala (GoK) has drafted its new Agriculture Development
Policy28. The policy encompasses, all aspects of agriculture including policies on land use,
water, soil health, crop husbandry, seeds and planting material, fertilizer and plant
nutrition, pesticides, value addition and processing of agriculture produce, high tech
farming, agriculture intelligence and marketing, minimum support prices for promoting
certain produces, income assurance, crop insurance and credit policy, and policy on farm
producer organisations. It also discusses Climate Change as a key driver which has the
possibility of changing the nature of agriculture in the state. Some of the salient policy
issues have been analysed below and gaps identifies vis a vis the issue of tackling climate
change.
Suggested Adaptation
Sl.No. Polices
actions (No.)
1. Land Policy 3
2. Climate and Environment Policy 3
3. Water 4
4. Soil 1
5. ICT 1
6. Technology dissemination and management 3
7. Markets and international Trade 3
8. Farmer Producer Organisation 1
9. Income assurance and crop insurance 2
10. Agriculture credit policy 1
11. Crop Husbandry 1
Total 23
Table 4: Analysis of Draft Agriculture policy of Kerala through the climate change lens
Facilitate the possibility of All associated departments 2. Develop and propagate Weather
strategic planning for like irrigation, soil and indexed crop insurance that
systematic Disaster water conservation and compensates for loss in income
Management, as well as for rural development are due to extreme temperatures,
contingency planning at currently not aligning their extreme rainfall, sea level
District, Block and Gram natural resource changes, extreme storm surges
Panchayat levels against all management with the and cyclones
emergencies changing climate
(9.8 Policy 34; Page 58)
Loss in income not factored
in due to extreme climate
Optimize the ecological load Here again potential areas 3. Life cycle assessments may be
on the natural for reducing Green House carried out to identify the
Gas (GHG) emissions from potential areas for reducing GHG
33
Key Policy Element Suggested Approach Suggested Climate Adaptation
actions
systems as well as build up the agriculture sector emissions within the rice
the state’s economy while needs to be looked at production cycle. Introduce low
minimizing environmental carbon strategies wherever
degradation necessary
(9.7 Policy 33; Page 58)
Sub surface dykes are to be The dyke structure has to be 4. Revisit the dyke designs and
constructed at possible places in commensuration with integrate the design element
for the ground water recharge projected recurrence necessary for accommodating
(2.7; Page 21) frequency and intensities of recurrence frequency and
rainfall in the future so that intensity of extreme rain fall
these can catch large events
volumes of rainwater that
may fall within short period
of time
4. Agricultural Policy - Policies related to Soil
Make every effort to reduce Area across the coast will 1. Minimising the coastal
soil erosion on a watershed need different interventions such as breakwater
basis construction, groynes, and sea
34
Key Policy Element Suggested Approach Suggested Climate Adaptation
actions
(8.7 Policy 28; Page 54) interventions to avert soil walls which change the dynamics
erosion of the ocean leading to soil
erosion. Additionally beach
nourishment in and around paddy
wetlands would ensure soil
conservation.
35
Key Policy Element Suggested Approach Suggested Climate Adaptation
actions
The twin goals of ensuring To save farmers from 1. Identification of international
justice to farmers in terms of financial distress mechanisms such as “Fair Trade”
a remunerative price for that provide minimum prices even if
their produce and to the price of the commodity has
consumers in terms fallen or crashed and propagating
of a fair and affordable price this amongst farmers.
(16.6 Policy 73; Page 97)
Actio-Aportum to be Actio-Aportum needs to be 2. In this the “Nidhi” amount can be
introduced for ensuring a legal climate sensitive parked to compensate the farmers
right of share of profit base line income in case of a crop
generated out of farmers farm failure due to climate change.
produce. The additional 3. Apart from supporting weather
amount will be used for based insurance schemes, existing
investment to produce more 137 automated weather stations
and rest will get into “Nidhi” could be upgraded for managing
(20.5 Policy 98; Page 128) climate change induced risks.
8. Agricultural Policy - Policies related to Farmer Producer Organisation (FPO)
Supporting development of Mechanisms to absorb 1. The FPOs should have access to risk
FPOs climate shocks funds to compensate for the losses
(18.2 Policy 18; Page 109) due to climate shocks
9. Agricultural Policy - Policies related to income assurance and crop insurance
Government should adopt An act in the form of 1. However, to have an additional
'Income Guarantee' “MGNREGA” already exists. state specific Act in place, the
programmes for the farmers as Government needs to be clear
the main agricultural support about what activities will be
instrument and an Act in this remunerated in this Act which
line should be passed. should not overlap the activities of
(20.10 Policy 102; Page 133) the Mahatma Gandhi NREGA.
36
Key Policy Element Suggested Approach Suggested Climate Adaptation
actions
lead to opportunities for a
healthy and productive life to
rural families
( 21.4 Policy 103; Page 134)
6.3 Coconut
Coconut and coir industry are dependent on each other, but coconut tree climbers are a
rarity in Kerala and other states now, with very few taking on the traditional profession.
Studies29 point out that increase in temperature, aridity index, number of severe summer
droughts and decline in rainfall and moisture index were the major factors for a marginal
decline or stagnation in coconut productivity, though various developmental schemes were
in operation for sustenance of coconut production in the State of Kerala. The coconut
productivity is more vulnerable to climate variability such as summer droughts rather than
climate change in terms of increase in temperature and decline in rainfall, though there
was a marginal decrease (1.6%) in the decade of 1981-2009 when compared to that of
1951-80.
Some of the policies that are relevant to coconut in terms of climate are discussed below.
29
Krishna Kumar K. N. (2011) ”Coconut Phenology and Yield Response to Climate Variability and Change”, Thesis submitted
in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor Of Philosophy In Atmospheric Science, Department of
Atmospheric Sciences Cochin University of Science and Technology Kochi, India
37
Key Policy Element Suggested Approach Suggested Climate Adaptation
actions
widespread nature causing,
irreparable damages to
palm; Accidental fire,
including forest fire and
bush fire, lightening; Earth
quake, landslide and
tsunami; Severe drought
and consequential total loss
Production and distribution Nominal increase in 2. Agronomic adaptations like soil
of coconut seeds- productivity in the future moisture conservation, summer
The objective of the is estimated due to irrigation, drip irrigation, and
programme is to enhance climate change30. fertilizer application cannot only
the production and supply However, these would minimize losses in majority of
of good quality planting not be sufficient to meet coconut growing regions, but also
materials through following demand in the future. So improve productivity substantially.
component programmes aggressive agronomic Further, genetic adaptation
practices are required. measures like growing improved
local Tall cultivars and hybrids
under improved crop management
is needed for long-term adaptation
of plantation to climate change,
particularly in regions that are
projected to be negatively
impacted by climate change
30 Naresh Kumar, Aggar P K, 2013. Climate change and coconut plantations in India: Impacts and
potential adaptation gains
38
7. Way Forward
Kerala's current conditions and expected climate change would expose the narrow coastal
strip and its inhabitants to heightened vulnerabilities. A large chunk of these inhabitants
are the poor and marginalised groups of artisanal fisher households who depend on
economic activities like agriculture, fisheries, mining etc.,. Their livelihoods are threatened
from the overharvesting of natural resources, pollution, habitat destruction, invasive
species, and climate change. Projected sea level rise and the collapse of commercial
fisheries are putting food supplies and coastal areas at risk, potentially leading to economic
and social upheaval. Moreover, they have limited access to healthcare and public services
and therefore, extremely hard for them to adaptation. Therefore, in order to address
adaptation strategies and adjustment of coastal management policies to changing
circumstances, the report scanned through the policies governing the coastal systems
through a climate change lens.
Our assessment of policies managing the key economic drivers of the coastal Kerala and
vulnerabilities suggest the way forward for the State of Kerala within the context of the
extent of climate gaps and propose activities to bridge the gaps. The following are the
proposed activities that can be considered by the Government of Kerala:
39
vii. Beach nourishment: Map fast eroding beaches and design beach nourishment
techniques. Also build awareness and capacities of the local self-governments to control
unscientific exploitation of beaches.
2. Strategies and actions for Climate resilient Rice cultivation in Coastal Areas
i. Climate resilient agriculture systems: Life cycle assessments of coastal rice, to initiate
processes that will make climate resilient agriculture systems, i.e from farm inputs
(including appropriate seeds, solar water pumps, organic farming etc) to consumers’
table; A value chain approach leading upto the market along with farming practices
with reduced GHG emissions and increased water use efficiency (like SRI, alternate
drying and wetting etc).
ii. Support to traditional practices: Map the potential coastal wetland areas that can
come under Pokkali and Kaipad cultivation areas, and support traditional practices
keeping in view the changing climate;
iii. Rice wetland protection through women SHGs: Map areas where rice wetlands need
to be protected. Develop a policy that will enable Self Help Groups such as
Kudumbashree to lease the identified land for cultivation. This will ensure that the
owners of such lands are discouraged from selling the land and receive a payment for
eco-system services in the form of the lease money received from SHGs for cultivating
these lands;
iv. Consideration of hydroponics/SRI methods: Considering the constraint of land and
increase in intensity of extreme events in the future, pilots may be carried out to see
the feasibility of cultivating rice in vertical towers through hydroponics technologies
and SRI methods in controlled environment;
v. Water budgeting studies: This may be instituted keeping in view the climate change
scenario and its impact on water available for irrigation when new technologies need
to be instituted;
vi. Weather indexed crop insurance: Develop weather indexed crop insurance to avert
dip in income due to climate shocks and which is not dependent on surveys by
insurance agency but is connected to weather instruments directly;
vii. Artificial recharge of ground water: Explore artificial recharge possibilities of ground
water across the coast;
viii. Strengthening extension services: Strengthen extension services ensuring SMS
transfers on regular basis with key inputs on weather, markets, probable crops to be
sown and inputs required. Popularise dial-in service as well;
ix. Farmer collectivisation and Community risk management: Formation of Small
producer organisations (SPOs) including producer companies and developing an
internal system to manage risks jointly through a value chain approach with a business
model.
40
Some of the proposed activities can even be aligned to CCIP’s work streams identified
through the Long Range Planning Exercise (LRPE).
A Pilot model: An integrated approach to sustain estuarine fisheries and low land paddy
cultivation
The figure below, schematically lists the type of activities that can be undertaken on a pilot
basis by the Government of Kerala to show case how an integrated approach can ensure
sustainability of estuarine fisheries and wetland rice cultivation. The packages of activities
have been briefly explained in Table 6.
Table 6: Package of activities for an integrated approach to sustain estuarine fisheries and
low land paddy cultivation
41
No. Work package (WP) How
physical variables (Geomorphology, slope, relative sea level
change, shoreline erosion and accretion, mean tide range
and mean wave height) to be related in a quantifiable
manner.
5. Hindering pollution This work package will look at how effluents from different
of the system to sources can be best managed to minimise the pollution
sustain productivity seeping into the backwater estuarine /low land paddy
in a climate change cultivation systems.
context
6. Scoping for replacing This will involve replacement of diesel driven boast with
tourism boat solar power, hydrogen, or blending of diesel with biofuel.
operations with Also the lighting and cooling aspects within the boast can
renewable energy be energised by these alternative sources of energy.
technologies
7. New technologies for New technologies such as hydroponics can be explored to
growing rice in a hedge the increasing climate impacts such as droughts,
climate change floods, and extreme rain fall and thus ensure food security.
scenario There are also other farming practices like SRU, alternate
wetting and drying etc which can lead to reduced water use.
8. Abating CH4 Excess fish feed collects at the bottom of the aqua ponds
emission from excess which subsequently get converted into ammonia and nitrite
fish feed in thus affecting fish sustainability. A new technology that
aquaculture ponds would convert this waste material to microbial protein and
created from can be consumed by the fish in the ponds can be
removal of implemented at pilot scale
mangroves
42
No. Work package (WP) How
9. Integrating gender Ascertain areas where women can also access resources
sensitivity into the and strengthen their resilience to climate change. Ensure
fish value chain women’s participation in governance and management of
fishery businesses and explore Incentivising women to
become entrepreneurs in fishery businesses.
It is concluded that when the above mentioned pilot
activities are integrated across the entire coastal Kerala,
adaptation and mitigation strategies would work better as
well as provide a more effective response to climate
change.
43
References
1. Abhiya A M, Minu S, and Ramachandran. 2015. Salient Long-Term Observations of SST
along Kerala Coast and Its Comparative Variation with Lakshadweep Coast. Science Direct.
Aquatic Procedia 4 (2015 ) 556 – 562.
3. Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute, 2010. Marine Fisheries Census, Government of
India.
6. Department of Environment and Climate Change. 2013. Kerala State Action Plan on Climate
Change. Government of Kerala.
8. Government of India. 2010. Marine fisheries census 2010 Kerala, Part II (6). Govt. of India,
Ministry of Agriculture, Dept. of Animal Husbandry, Dairying & Fisheries and Central Marine
Fisheries Research Institute, Indian Council of Agricultural Research, New Delhi, p. 33-48.
10. Gyhathakurta and Rajeevan 2008. Trends in rainfall pattern over India, Int. Journal of
Climatology, 28: 1453–1469.
11. http://www.coconutboard.nic.in/stat.htm
12. http://www.fisheries.kerala.gov.in
14. Krishna Kumar K. N. (2011) “Coconut Phenology and Yield Response to Climate Variability
and Change”, Thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of
Doctor Of Philosophy In Atmospheric Science, Department of Atmospheric Sciences Cochin
University of Science and Technology Kochi, India
15. Naresh Kumar, Aggar P K, 2013. Climate change and coconut plantations in India: Impacts
and potential adaptation gains
44
16. National Disaster Management Authority. 2008. Management of Cyclones. National
Disaster Management Authority (NDMA), Government of India
17. Planning Commission. 2012. Report of the Working Group on Development and
Management of Fisheries and Aquaculture. XIIth Five-Year Plan (2012-2017). Government
of India, New Delhi.
18. Protsahan. 2004. A Status Paper 2003-2004 on Fishery Harbours: Performance, Issues
and Management Concerns. Thiruvananthapuram.
19. Rajendran K, Sajani S., Jayasankarand C. B,Kitoh A. 2013. How dependent is climate
change projection of Indian summer monsoon rainfall and extreme events on model
resolution? Current science, vol. 104, no. 10, 25 May 2013.
20. Ramesh R, Purvaraja R and Senthil Vel A. (undated) Shoreline Change Assessment for
Kerala Coast”. National Centre for Sustainable Coastal Management (NCSCM), Society for
Integrated Coastal Management (SICOM) and Ministry for Environment Forest and Climate
Change (MoEF&CC), Government of India.
21. Sathiadhas R, Raghu R, Kanakkan A and Harshan, N K. 2000. Marine fish production and
export marketing trend in Kerala - an economic analysis. In: Marine Fisheries Research and
Management Pillai V N and Menon, N G,(eds.) CMFRI; Kochi, Kochi, pp. 876-894.
22. Sunder V and Murali K. 2007. Planning of Coastal Protection Measures along Kerala Coast
- Final Report submitted to Government of Kerala.
23. Unnikrishnan A S, Nidheesh A. G. and Lengaigne M. 2015. Sea-Level-Rise Trends Off The
Indian Coasts During The Last Two Decades. Current science, vol. 108, no. 966 5, 10 march
45
Annexures
Department/Institutions/Boards
Sl.No Name Designation
(SAPCC Implementing Agency)
Counsellor, Head of
1 Ms Sandra Sheard British High Commission
Energy, Climate & growth
British Deputy High
2 Mr Bharat Joshi
Commissioner Chennai
British Deputy High Commission
3 Ms Vidya Soundarajan Senior Regional Adviser
4 Mr Sijoy Thomas Regional Adviser
5 Mr Roger Savage Consultant (BDHC) Atkins
GoI-UNDP Disaster Risk Reduction &
6 Mr Joe John George State Project Officer
Climate Change Adaptation Project
7 Mr P Balachandran General Manager
Assistant General NABARD
8 Mr Patrick Jasper
Manager
Directorate of Environment and Climate
9 Mr C S Yallaki IFS Director (Nodal Officer)
Change
Prof B Madusoodana Kurup Kerala University for Fisheries and
10 Vice Chancellor
(Ph.D) Oceanography Science
Agency for Nonconventional Energy and
11 Mr Prem Kumar K Scientist
Rural Technology (ANERT)
Scientist F & Head
Mr N B Narasimha Prasad Centre for Water Resource Development
12 Hydrogeology &
(Ph.D) and Management (CWRDM)
Geophysics
13 Mr Dinesan Cheruvat (Ph.D) Joint Director Department of Fisheries
Executive engineer
14 Mr Shajatnan Department of Groundwater
(Hydrology
Managing Director,
15 Mr M Raghudasan Department of Tourism
Corporation Bekal resorts
Department of Tourism, Kerala Institute of
16 Ms Rajashree Ajith (Ph.D) Director
Tourism & Travel Studies
Additional Director Health
17 Dr Parvathy A Y Directorate of Health Service
Services
18 Mr Sudevan S Scientist Indian Meteorological Resource Centre
19 Mr Abraham Koshy Executive Engineer Irrigation Department
48
Interim Review Meeting: August 11th, 2015
Department/Institutions/Boards
Sl.No Name Designation
(SAPCC Implementing Agency)
Kerala Coastal Zone Management Authority
20 Mr Kamalakshan Kokkal (Ph.D) Joint Director
(KCZMA)
21 Ms Sreekala S Environmental Engineer Kerala State Pollution Control Board
22 Ms N Preetha (Ph.D) Technical Associate
Kerala State Biodiversity Board
23 Ms Linda John (Ph.D) Principal Scientific Officer
24 Mr Padmakumar G Executive Engineer Kerala State Electricity Board Limited
25 Ms V G Rekha Deputy Chief Engineer
Kerala Water Authority
26 Mr Gokul Satharaj Executive Engineer
National Transportation Planning and
27 M Kalairasan P (Ph.D) Scientist
Research Centre
State Fisheries Resource Management
28 Mr P.Sahadevan Executive Director
Society (FIRMA)
29 Ms Saheena J Asst Director
Department of Agriculture
30 Ms Priya P V Technical Assistant
31 Mr Dharesan Unnithan Director Energy Management Centre (EMC)
32 Dr C. K. Jagadeesan Assistant Director Directorate of Health Service
Institute for Climate Change Studies /
33 Mr Amal Raj M Asst Professor
Institute of Land and Disaster Management
Academy of Climate Change Education and
34 Mr.Kurien E. K (Ph.D) Special Officer
Research, Kerala Agriculture University
Directorate of Environment and Climate
35 Mr Thrideep Kumar Environmental Engineer
Change
India Programme
36 Ms Pamposh Bhat ACT / OPML
Manager
37 Mr Kit Nicholson Core Team member, ACT / OPML
Ms Sumana Bhattacharya Climate Change (CC)
38 ACT / OPML
(Ph.D) expert /ICDS
Public Finance
39
Mr K. K. Krishnakumar Management Expert / ACT / OPML
CSES
Lead consultant for
40 Mr D. Nandakumar (Ph.D) ACT / OPML
Coastal
Technical Expert Kerala,
41 Mr Jerin Thomas Abraham ACT / OPML
DFID-CCIP
Ms. Mariamma Sanu George Team Leader Kerala, DFID-
42 ACT / OPML
(Nirmala) CCIP
49
For more details:
50
www.actiononclimate.today
51